Comparison of smoothening flows for the topological charge in QCD-like theories Preprint: CERN-TH-2025-079 Pietro Butti, Michele Della Morte, Benjamin Jäger, Sofie Martins, J. Tobias Tsang Abstract We investigate properties of the topological charge for several S ​ U ​ ( N C ) SU(N_{C}) gauge field ensembles for N C = 4 , 5 , 6 N_{C}=4,5,6 with a single fermion in the two-index anti-symmetric representation, covering multiple lattice spacings at otherwise approximately constant physical parameters. Comparing the topological charge defined by the Wilson flow and the over-improved DBW2 flow we find that already at small flow times the latter stabilises on discrete values. We provide evidence that as the lattice spacing is lowered the Wilson flow also separates into discrete sectors at earlier flow times. Adopting the DWB2 definition in the remainder of the analysis, we do not see any evidence of fractional topological charges, which could in principle appear at finite lattice spacing. I Introduction and Motivations We recently started exploring the spectrum of SU(N_{C}) orientifold theories with one dynamical quark flavour in the two-index (anti-)symmetric representation Della Morte et al. 2023 ; Della Morte et al. 2025 ; Martins et al. 2024a ; Jäger et al. 2023 ; Ziegler et al. 2022 . In the large N_{C} limit at fixed ’t Hooft coupling, i.e. in the Corrigan-Ramond limit Corrigan and Ramond 1979 , the theory should approach Super-Yang-Mills as first conjectured in Refs. Armoni et al. 2003a ; Armoni et al. 2003b . Predictions for the ratio of masses of the lightest scalar and pseudoscalar mesons have been obtained using either effective field theory or string theory duality approaches Sannino and Shifman 2004 ; Armoni and Imeroni 2005 and such predictions can be compared to lattice results, as done in Ref. Sannino 2024 using our result from Ref. Della Morte et al. 2023 . For N_{C}=3 the two-index anti-symmetric representation coincides with the fundamental representation and hence standard codes optimised for QCD can be used. For N_{C}\neq 3 this is no longer the case, and with increasing N_{C} simulations become more costly. Naively, the cost of a matrix-vector multiplication grows quadratically with N_{C} , while for matrix-matrix multiplications the scaling is cubic. One therefore expects an overall scaling with N_{C} slightly faster than quadratic, assuming that matrix-vector multiplications dominate the cost. This is consistent with our findings in Ref. Martins et al. 2024a . In addition, we are entering a largely unexplored territory concerning the choices of bare (Lagrangian) as well as algorithmic parameters. To the best of our knowledge no other study exists where lattice simulations of the exact same theories considered here are discussed. One of our main concerns, given the cost of the simulations, is critical slowing down, known to become more severe as N_{C} is increased Del Debbio et al. 2002 . This is usually monitored by looking at the Monte-Carlo distribution of a slow (i.e. with long autocorrelation) observable, typically the topological charge. The first goal of this paper is to select a numerical definition of the topological charge which is cheap and stable, in a sense that will be clarified below. Secondly, the study at hand is part of our wider programme to determine the mass spectrum and properties of orientifold theories in the large N_{C} limit. Amongst such properties, here we focus on the behaviour of the topological charge for different choices of N_{C} and investigate the existence of fractional values. Indeed, for the two-index anti-symmetric representation, the winding number (i.e. the topological charge) of a gauge configuration is in general expected to be quantised in units of 1/(N_{C}-2) , see also Ref. Leutwyler and Smilga 1992 for a discussion of a single flavour in the adjoint representation. However, with periodic boundary conditions (as used here) and for sufficiently smooth configurations the topological charge should take integer values, as first shown in Ref. Lüscher, M. 1982 . When different boundary conditions, such as ’t Hooft twisted boundary conditions, are used fractional charges do instead survive in the continuum limit ’t Hooft 1979 ; Garcia Perez, M. and González-Arroyo, Antonio and Pena, C. 2000 ; González-Arroyo 2020 . In our case we hence expect non-integer charges to appear as cut-off effects, if at all. A similar study was conducted in Ref. Fodor et al. 2009 for the SU(2) case of a single flavour in the two-index symmetric representation (sextet model). The study was quenched, with the topological charge defined through the index-theorem Atiyah and Singer 1968 and the conclusion was indeed that configurations with fractional charge can occur, but disappear as the continuum limit is approached. Here we determine the topological charge using a gluonic definition from smoothened (gradient-flowed) gauge fields. We systematically study the dependence of the charge on the amount of smoothening applied, as well as on the discretisation scheme employed for the flow equations. Ref. Tanizaki et al. 2024 performs a similar study but at a single lattice spacing in pure Yang-Mills for SU(2) . The findings in this work extend beyond that by varying the lattice spacing, including dynamical fermions and exploring different gauge groups. For N_{C}=4 and N_{C}=5 we generated a number of ensembles with approximately tuned spatial extents and connected pseudoscalar ( M_{\pi}^{\mathrm{conn.}} ) masses, but varying lattice spacings. For N_{C}=6 we generated a single ensemble with similar volume and mass and an intermediate lattice spacing. The generation and properties of these ensembles and the smoothening flows are described in more detail in Section II . In Section III we determine the lattice spacings and investigate the topological charge and susceptibility as a function of flow time and the choice of flow. Finally, in Section IV we summarise our findings and provide an outlook. II Computational setup II.1 Ensemble Parameters The gauge configurations were generated using the HiRep code package Del Debbio et al. 2010 ; Martins et al. 2024b ; Martins et al. 2025 ; Drach et al. 2025 . For the gluonic part of the action, we employ the tree-level improved Lüscher-Weisz (LW) gauge action Lüscher and Weisz 1985a . The fermionic part contains a single Dirac flavour in the two-index anti-symmetric representation. We use the Wilson formulation with a tree-level improved clover term, i.e. setting c_{SW}=1 . Since our setup contains a single Dirac flavour, the Rational Hybrid Monte-Carlo (RHMC) algorithm Kennedy et al. 2013 is required. For the numerical integration of the RHMC trajectories, we adopt a 4th-order Omelyan integrator Omelyan et al. 2003 with a trajectory length of \tau=2 molecular dynamic units (MDUs). The number of integration steps in the fermionic force (20 - 26 for N_{C}=4 , 30 - 36 for N_{C}=5 , and 36 for N_{C}=6 ) is tuned to ensure a high acceptance rate. In the gauge sector we also use a 4th-order Omelyan integrator with two steps per fermion update. To reduce autocorrelation, we save every fourth configuration, which results in a separation of 8 MDUs between consecutively saved gauge configurations. For thermalisation, the first 200 trajectories are discarded. All gauge configurations were generated on GPUs (AMD MI250x) using the LUMI-G partition, while all measurements were carried out on CPUs. Table 1 provides an overview of the ensembles generated for this study. The relevant input files are provided in the arXiv submission. Table 1: Parameters of the ensembles used in this study. The temporal extent is fixed to be T=3L for all ensembles. Quoted uncertainties are statistical only. name N_{C} \beta \kappa L/a t_{0}/a^{2} aM_{\pi}^{\mathrm{conn.}} L/\sqrt{t_{0}} M_{\pi}^{\mathrm{conn.}}\sqrt{t_{0}} N_{\mathrm{conf}} N4L12 4 7.1 0.15770 12 0.8691(12) 0.6481(6) 12.8720(90) 0.6042(7) 648 N4L14 4 7.2 0.15651 14 1.3641(17) 0.5101(5) 11.9868(75) 0.5958(7) 677 N4L16 4 7.3 0.15525 16 1.8592(19) 0.4350(4) 11.7344(60) 0.5931(6) 640 N4L18 4 7.4 0.15401 18 2.3885(21) 0.3949(3) 11.6470(51) 0.6103(5) 583 N5L12 5 11.3 0.16089 12 1.1171(11) 0.7571(3) 11.3536(55) 0.8002(5) 1081 N5L14 5 11.4 0.16026 14 1.4800(14) 0.6624(3) 11.5078(53) 0.8058(5) 704 N5L16a 5 11.5 0.15959 16 1.8422(15) 0.5581(3) 11.7884(49) 0.7575(5) 565 N5L16b 5 11.55 0.15929 16 2.0409(21) 0.5922(2) 11.1997(58) 0.8460(5) 469 N6L16 6 16.5 0.16200 16 1.33944(64) 0.8354(1) 13.8248(33) 0.9668(3) 742 Since the simulated masses are rather heavy (see Table 1 ), based on our experience in Ref. Della Morte et al. 2023 , we do not expect these simulations to be affected by a sign problem. In the future we will supplement the ensembles in this work with ensembles at lighter-quark masses and perform extrapolations of observables to the massless limit. In this context we will perform a study of the severity of the sign problem for the lightest simulated quark masses, analogous to that of Ref. Della Morte et al. 2023 . II.2 Flow definitions The gradient flow is a standard tool in Lattice Field Theory, consisting in evolving gauge fields in a fictitious 5th dimension typically referred to as flow time t . This evolution is governed by a gauge-covariant diffusion equation \derivative{B_{\mu,x}(t)}{t}=D_{\nu}G_{\mu\nu,x}(t)\,, (1) with initial conditions B_{\mu,x}(t=0)=A_{\mu}(x) , G_{\mu\nu,x}(t) being the field strength of the field B_{\mu,x}(t) at flow time t . The core idea is that, as shown in the original paper Lüscher 2010 , the flow leads to an effective smearing of the gauge configurations over a length scale \sqrt{8t} , suppressing UV fluctuations and automatically rendering a large class of composite operators renormalised at positive flow times. On the lattice, different discretisations of Eq. ( 1 ) are possible, which can be re-written as a^{2}\quantity(\frac{d}{d t} U_{x,\mu}(t))U_{\mu,x}(t)^{\dagger}=-g_{0}^{2}\partial_{\mu,x}S_{\mathrm{flow}}(U), (2) where \partial_{\mu,x} is the Lie-algebra valued derivative with respect to U_{\mu,x}(t) . S_{\text{flow}} , also referred to as kernel action , represents some discretised version of the gauge action that is used to integrate the flow equations and which, in principle, can be different from the one used to generate the configurations. One possible choice is to consider \order{a^2} -improved actions defined with an appropriate combination of 6-link Wilson loops, beside the usual 4-link (plaquette) loop Lüscher and Weisz 1985b . Considering only 4 and 6-links Wilson loops lying on a plane, we can define the kernel action as S_{\mathrm{flow}}=c_{0}S_{\mathrm{plaquette}}+c_{1}S_{\mathrm{rectangle}}\,, (3) parameterised by 2 coefficients c_{0} and c_{1} constrained to satisfy c_{0}+8c_{1}=1 (4) in order to ensure that in the classical continuum limit, S_{\text{flow}} recovers the standard Yang-Mills action. Among others, popular choices include: c_{1}=0 (the standard plaquette action, commonly referred to as Wilson flow), c_{1}=-0.311 (also called Iwasaki Itoh et al. 1984a ), c_{1}=-1/12 (tree-level improved Lüscher-Weisz (LW) Lüscher and Weisz 1985a ) and c_{1}=-1.4088 (DBW2 de Forcrand et al. 2000 ; de Forcrand et al. 1997 ). In this work, we will consider the case of Wilson and DBW2 flows. A study of all the four mentioned choices for c_{1} in pure SU(2) Yang-Mills appeared recently in Ref. Tanizaki et al. 2024 . In the same reference, the action for a one-instanton configuration is tree-level evaluated to \order{a^2} . The relative correction to the continuum value is given by -(1+12c_{1})/5\times\left(a/\rho\right)^{2} , \rho being the radius of the instanton. As a result, for 1+12c_{1}>0 the flow-action is expected to favour (by lattice artefacts) small size instantons, whereas for 1+12c_{1}<0 larger instantons should be preferred. The latter choice leads to \it{over-improvement} as first discussed along the lines above but in the framework of cooling in Ref. Garcia Perez et al. 1994 . The combination 1+12c_{1} in particular corresponds to the coefficient \epsilon in Ref. Garcia Perez et al. 1994 when only plaquettes and rectangles are considered. We modified the HiRep code to include the rectangle terms in the kernel action. All flow measurements were performed using a third-order Runge-Kutta integration scheme with a fixed step size of 0.01 in lattice units. We tested our HiRep -based implementation of the DBW2 flow by comparing our results to data obtained using the implementation in LatticeGPU Catumba et al. 2025 on a test configuration. The results agree to machine precision. As mentioned above, the length scale over which the configurations are smeared is \sqrt{8t} , also for the case of over-improved actions, as discussed in Appendix B of Ref. Tanizaki et al. 2024 . The flow time t should therefore be chosen to satisfy 2a\ll\sqrt{8t}\ll\frac{L}{2}\,, (5) in order to sufficiently suppress discretisation (left inequality) and finite volume (right inequality) effects. Figure 1: Determination of t_{0}/a^{2} on all ensembles. III Analysis III.1 Scale setting To set the scale of our simulations, we integrate the Wilson flow and compute the expectation value of the flowed energy density \expectationvalue{E_x(t)}=\expectationvalue{\tr G_{\mu\nu,x}(t)G_{\mu\nu,x}(t)} , choosing the plaquette discretisation E_{\text{plaq}} for the action density. The relative lattice scale is usually set by determining t_{0} for which \leftt_{0}^{2} takes a particular value. For the case of N_{C}=3 this value is typically chosen to be 0.3 . Generalising this for N_{C}>3 whilst accounting for the leading N_{C} dependence of \left , and hence staying a fixed ’t Hooft coupling, requires a rescaling by (N_{C}^{2}-1)/N_{C} and so yields \leftt_{0}^{2}=0.3\left(\frac{N_{C}^{2}-1}{N_{C}}\right)\frac{3}{8}\,. (6) This value can then be related to an absolute scale via the determination of a reference t^{\mathrm{ref}}_{0} , obtained from a scale-setting fit. Since (to the best of our knowledge) no such determination exists for a single flavour ( N_{f}=1 ), for concreteness we use the average of the N_{f}=0 Lüscher 2010 and N_{f}=2 Bruno and Sommer 2014 results in QCD obtaining \sqrt{8t_{0}^{\mathrm{ref}}}=0.45\,\mathrm{fm}\,. (7) This yields lattice spacings a\in[0.10,0.17]\,\mathrm{fm} ( [0.11,0.15]\,\mathrm{fm} ) for the N_{C}=4 ( N_{C}=5 ) ensembles and a\sim 0.14\,\mathrm{fm} for N_{C}=6 . We stress that the absolute scale is not essential for this work, but useful to have an approximate estimate of the lattice spacings, masses and volumes under consideration. The values listed in Table 1 contain statistical uncertainties only which are estimated from a bootstrap analysis, not taking autocorrelations into account. Applying the \Gamma -method Wolff 2004 instead leads to somewhat larger uncertainties, possibly indicating the presence of autocorrelations in the data. In the worst case (on the N6L16 ensemble) the uncertainty estimate from the \Gamma -method is a factor 2.5 larger. Since in this work we do not present precision observables this is not expected to have any impact at this stage, but we will carefully investigate this in future studies. III.2 Observables For this work, the main observable of interest is the topological charge Q , defined in the classical continuum limit as the integral of the topological charge density q(x) Q=\int\differential[4]{x}q(x)\,, (8) where q is defined as q(x)=\frac{1}{32\pi^{2}}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\tr\quantity[F_{\mu\nu}F_{\rho\sigma}]\,, (9) and F_{\mu\nu} is the field strength tensor of the unflowed field. On the lattice, several discretisations of the topological charge density can be taken, all leading to Eq. ( 9 ) in the classical a\rightarrow 0 limit. One possible definition is 1 1 1 For simplicity, we adopt the symbol Q to indicate both the continuum topological charge in Eq. ( 8 ) and its lattice discretised version in Eq. ( 10 ). Q=\frac{1}{32\pi^{2}}\sum_{x}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\tr\quantity[ \hat C_{\mu\nu}(x) \hat C_{\rho\sigma}(x) ]\,, (10) where for concreteness \hat{C} is the clover discretisation of the field strength which is used in our work. In principle, regardless of the discretisation, the lattice topological charge must be properly renormalised. Alternatively, some smoothening techniques of the gauge configurations can be employed. Among others, popular choices include cooling Berg 1981 ; Iwasaki and Yoshie 1983 ; Itoh et al. 1984b ; Teper 1985 ; Campostrini et al. 1990 ; Alles et al. 2000 , stout-smearing Morningstar and Peardon 2004 and the gradient flow Lüscher 2010 ; Cè et al. 2015 . 2 2 2 Detailed comparisons between these methods can be found, e.g. in Refs. Alles et al. 2000 ; Bonati and D’Elia 2014 ; Alexandrou et al. 2015 ; Alexandrou et al. 2020 . In practice, one also has to control the amount of smoothening applied to the gauge configurations. In the case of the gradient flow one needs to choose the flow time t_{Q} at which Q is computed. Whilst Ref. Lüscher 2010 suggested to use t_{Q}\simeq t_{0} , we will explore the impact of choosing different kernel actions to integrate the flow as in Eq. ( 3 ) as well as the influence of t_{Q} . On the lattice, even after several smoothening steps are applied Q is not expected to take discrete values but rather to be distributed over real numbers clustered around peaks. 3 3 3 This can be corrected for using rounded definitions, see e.g. Refs. Del Debbio et al. 2002 ; Bonati et al. 2016 . The cumulants of the distribution of Q can be used to compute physical quantities, such as the topological susceptibility \chi , defined as \chi=\lim_{a\rightarrow 0}\lim_{V_{4}\rightarrow\infty}\frac{\expectationvalue{Q^2}}{V_{4}}\,, (11) where V_{4}=L^{3}T is the 4-volume in physical units. Another observable that we will consider is the so-called smoothness parameter defined in Refs. Lüscher, M. 1982 ; Lüscher 2010 and adapted to our case as h(p)=\mathrm{Re}\,\mathrm{Tr}\left(\mathds{1}-\prod_{(x,\mu)\in p}U_{x,\mu}(t)\right)\,, (12) p being a given plaquette. We distinguish between \displaystyle h_{\mathrm{max}} \displaystyle=\underset{p}{\mathrm{max}}\,(h)\,, (13) \displaystyle h_{\mathrm{avg}} \displaystyle=\underset{p}{\mathrm{avg}}\,(h)\,. Since the flow is a smoothening procedure, h_{\mathrm{avg}} should monotonically decrease as a function of flow time. However, as we will see, h_{\mathrm{max}} is a local object and doesn’t necessarily have a monotonic behaviour. The smoothness parameter h_{\mathrm{max}} can be used to characterise configurations between topological sectors. For those, h_{\mathrm{max}} has to be larger than a critical value of order 10^{-1} for the theories considered here Lüscher, M. 1982 ; Lüscher 2010 . However, as discussed in Ref. Lüscher 2010 , the occurrence of such configurations decreases proportionally to a^{6} , which leads to the problem of topological freezing as the lattice spacing is reduced. This makes clear that studies of topological properties of a lattice gauge theory suffer a window problem. On the one side the lattice spacing should be fine enough such that configurations are sufficiently smooth to be classified according to a lattice version of the topological charge, while on the other side topological freezing should be avoided in order to have an adequate sampling of all the sectors. III.3 Determination of the topological charge Figure 2: Topological charge determined using the Wilson flow (top) and the DBW2 flow (bottom) on the coarsest N_{C}=4 ensemble. Figure 3: Topological charge determined using the Wilson flow (top) and the DBW2 flow (bottom) on the finest N_{C}=4 ensemble. At each positive flow time t we compute the topological charge for the Wilson-flowed and the DBW2-flowed configurations. Since we want to investigate the existence (or absence) of fractional topological charges, on a given configuration we desire a definition of Q which admits a window in flow time for which Q is insensitive of the exact choice of t_{Q} whilst adhering to the bounds in Eq. ( 5 ). The top (bottom) panel of Fig. 2 shows the topological charge as defined by the Wilson (DBW2) flow as a function of flow time for our coarsest ensemble ( N4L12 ). Each line corresponds to a different configuration. We observe that for this ensemble the Wilson flow does not admit such a definition, and instead find that even for large t_{Q} the topological charge fluctuates as a function of flow time. In contrast to this, the DBW2 flow does admit such an assignment. When instead considering our finest ensemble ( N4L18 ), as shown in Fig. 3 , we note that the rate of jumps between topological sectors decreases for both flows. For the Wilson flow, several configurations maintain an asymptotically stable value, but some jumps can still be seen even for the largest plotted flow times. For the DBW2 flow, the configurations quickly stabilise into discrete topological sectors. Figure 4: Topological charge (top) as well as h_{\mathrm{avg}} and h_{\mathrm{max}} (bottom) for the Wilson flow (red, dashed and dotted) and the DBW2 flow (cyan, solid and dash-dotted) as a function of very long flow times and on a single configuration of the N4L12 ensemble. The vertical dotted lines correspond to the location of local maxima in h_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mathrm{Wilson}} . When rewriting the upper bound on t_{Q} in Eq. ( 5 ) above in terms of t_{Q}/t_{0} we find \frac{t_{Q}}{t_{0}}\ll\frac{1}{32}\frac{L^{2}}{t_{0}}\,. (14) Substituting the corresponding numbers from Table 1 we find the expected bounds to be t_{Q}/t_{0}\ll 5.18 for N4L12 and t_{Q}/t_{0}\ll 4.24 for N4L18 . The rate of transitions between topological sectors defined by the Wilson flow on a given configuration seems to decrease with flow time. In the following we explore the behaviour as the flow time is increased further towards and beyond the upper bound in Eq. ( 14 ). Whilst we are aware that this eventually introduces non-localities, we are curious about the qualitative features this induces. Figure 4 shows the topological charge Q , h_{\mathrm{max}} and h_{\mathrm{avg}} as defined in Eq. ( 13 ) as a function of t_{Q}/t_{0} for very long flow times on a representative configuration of the N4L12 ensemble. As expected for a smoothening flow, the value of h_{\mathrm{avg}} monotonically decreases as a function of flow time for both choices of flow. For the DBW2 flow, this also holds for h_{\mathrm{max}} , indicating an approximately uniform smoothening, whilst for the Wilson flow this is not the case. Instead there are several occurrences where h_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mathrm{Wilson}} suddenly increases before dropping again (note the logarithmic scale in the bottom panel). Since the average of h still decreases, this must be a local (at the lattice scale) effect. This observation is consistent with the expectation for non-over-improved actions, as they do not suppress small instantons, as discussed in Sec. II.2 and Ref. Garcia Perez et al. 1994 . Turning our attention to the topological charge we find that Q^{\mathrm{DBW2}} quickly becomes largely independent of flow time and slowly approaches an asymptotic value. We will discuss the fact that this value does not appear to be an integer in due course. The topological charge Q^{\mathrm{Wilson}} instead displays meta-stable plateaus over some time scales, but continues to jump between different topological sectors even for very late times. In order to assess the existence of fractional topological charges, we hence prefer the DBW2 flow. From a closer look at the spikes in h_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mathrm{Wilson}} , we find that they correlate with jumps in Q^{\mathrm{Wilson}}(t_{Q}) (as indicated by the vertical lines). Figure 5: Topological charge determination with the DBW2 flow for the N4L12 (left) and N4L18 (right) ensembles at 4 flow times (from top to bottom t_{Q}=t_{0} , 2t_{0} , 4t_{0} and 8t_{0} ) plotted configuration by configuration. In Figure 5 we depict the topological charge determined by the DBW2 flow configuration-by-configuration for flow times t_{Q}=t_{0} , 2t_{0} , 4t_{0} and 8t_{0} . As discussed before, we notice that discrete topological sectors form, but that they do not exactly coincide with integer values. Instead they appear to be multiples of a number close to, but slightly smaller than, unity. We observed in Figures 2 and 3 , that (within a given discrete sector) the topological charge continues to slowly grow in magnitude as a function of flow time. In Figure 4 we saw that this trend continues even for very large flow times but still not reaching integer values. When comparing the N4L12 and the N4L18 ensembles in Figure 5 , we notice that with decreasing lattice spacing, the topological sectors approach integer values. Both of these effects contribute to the unit of discretisation being smaller than one. In order to faithfully capture the discrete sectors when representing the data in histograms, in the following we use bin widths that reproduce this feature. In particular we will define the bin width \epsilon such that 2\epsilon to a good approximation corresponds to the separation between adjacent topological sectors. Figure 6: Histograms of the topological charge for the Wilson flow (top) and the DBW2 flow (bottom) evaluated at flow time t_{Q}=2t_{0} (left), t_{Q}=4t_{0} (middle) and t_{Q}=8t_{0} (right) on the N4L12 ensemble. Figure 6 shows histograms of the topological charge evaluated at different flow times for the Wilson and the DBW2 flow on the N4L12 ensemble. The bin width is chosen to account for the quantised units of Q being different from one. In the left panel the histogram of Q is shown at t_{Q}=2t_{0} . As can be inferred from Fig. 2 at this time the Wilson flow has not settled into any asymptotic value yet, leading to all bins in the central region being populated. The same figure indicates that for the DBW2 flow, the asymptotic sectors have been reached, i.e. on this ensemble no crossings between topological sectors occur for later flow times than t_{Q}=2t_{0} . However, several configurations still slowly flow to those discrete values, leading to some contamination between the main bins. For the DBW2 flow this rapidly improves as the flow time is increased to t_{Q}=4t_{0} (middle) and t_{Q}=8t_{0} (right). Contrary to this, even for this large flow time the Wilson flow displays results in the intermediate bins. Figure 7: Histograms of the topological charge defined via the DBW2 flow at t=4t_{0} for all ensembles considered in this study. From top to bottom N_{C} is increased from 4 to 6 and within each row the lattice spacing is reduced from left to right. In Figure 7 we present the histograms of the topological charge for all ensembles considered in this work. In each case the value of \epsilon was tuned to ensure that the discrete bins are correctly captured. We find that Q does take discrete near-integer values in all cases and hence do not observe any fractional topological charges. We further find that the unit of discretisation approaches 1 as the lattice spacing is reduced. III.4 Dependence of gauge averages on flow smoothening We now turn to assessing the impact of the effects discussed in the previous section on physical observables such as the topological susceptibility and related quantities. Similar studies of systematic effects associated with the smoothening radius – particularly in the context of comparisons between cooling and gradient flow – can be found in Refs. Bonati and D’Elia 2014 ; Bonanno 2024 ; Alexandrou et al. 2015 ; Alexandrou et al. 2020 . In the same spirit, our goal is to investigate whether variations in the flow time t_{Q} or the choice of kernel action introduce significant artefacts on physical observables. On our ensembles, i.e. at finite lattice spacing and volume, we compute the topological susceptibility \chi , as defined in Eq. ( 11 ) and compare results obtained for the two flows. For each case, we consider several values of the flow time t_{Q}\in\{t_{0},2t_{0},4t_{0},8t_{0}\} to assess the impact on the extracted values of \chi . We also determine the ratio of susceptibilities computed with different flows, defining R=\frac{\chi^{\text{DBW2}}}{\chi^{\text{Wilson}}}\,, (15) which we expect to be less sensitive to slight mistunings of volumes and masses. Figure 8: Ratios of susceptibilities computed with Wilson and DBW2 as a function of the lattice spacings for N_{C}=4 (upper panel) and N_{C}=5 (lower panel). As in the caption, the colour code reflects a different choice for t_{Q} . Point markers are slightly shifted in the x -axis to improve visibility. Figure 9: Same as in Fig. 8 , but in log-log scales. Dashed lines are linear fits to the rescaled points, in the caption, the exponents of a represent the fitted slopes of the lines. In Fig. 8 we plot this ratio as a function of the lattice spacing in units of \sqrt{8t_{0}} for our ensembles with N_{C}=4 and N_{C}=5 . We observe that the ratio approaches unity as the lattice spacing is reduced, in line with our expectations. However, given the coarseness of our lattice spacings, a linear extrapolation in a is not sufficient, suggesting that higher powers of a are required to describe the scaling behaviour. To investigate this, we present the same data in a log-log plot in Fig. 9 , allowing us to extract the dominant power-law behaviour in the parameter range covered in this work. A linear fit in this representation yields an effective scaling exponent between 3 and 4 for both choices of N_{C} , consistent across all t_{Q} . IV Conclusions and Outlook We generated ensembles with different lattice spacings but approximately tuned spatial extents for SU(4) , SU(5) and SU(6) , with one fermion in the two-index anti-symmetric representation. On these ensembles we studied the behaviour of different gradient-flows in the context of the topological charge. In order to investigate the presence of fractional topological charges we advocate the use of an over-improved action for the gradient flow as it quickly and unambiguously settles into discrete topological sectors. With such a prescription, the flow-time bounds defined in Eq. ( 5 ) can be satisfied and a topological charge (and functions of it, such as the topological susceptibly) can easily be defined. Whilst we do not observe any fractional topological charges, at finite lattice spacing we find the unit of discretisation to be slightly below one. We expect the ratio of topological susceptibilities defined though the Wilson and the over-improved DBW2 flow to differ from unity by discretisation effects. Our data confirm this and that the ratio approaches one as the lattice spacing is reduced. We expect these findings to be independent of the choice of fermion representation used in this work. Having gained experience in the largely unexplored parameter space for these theories and defined and determined the topological charge on the ensembles at hand, we are continuing to generate a suite of ensembles for N_{C}>3 which allows the computation of the mesonic spectrum as well as its extrapolation to the massless limit. This will provide further non-perturbative insight into the conjectured connection of these theories to Super-Yang-Mills. One crucial step to achieving this is to define a cost-efficient measurement strategy for the computation of disconnected diagrams in higher representations, which is ongoing work. Furthermore, the large- N_{C} limit of \mathcal{N}=1 SUSY Yang-Mills has been explored for very large N_{C} using twisted volume reduction techniques Butti et al. 2022 ; Bonanno et al. 2024 ; Bonanno et al. 2025a ; Bonanno et al. 2025b . In the future we plan to explore comparisons between such an approach and the method presented in this work.