Relative solidity for biexact groups in measure equivalence Changying Ding, Daniel Drimbe Abstract . We demonstrate a relative solidity property for the product of a nonamenable biexact group with an arbitrary infinite group in the measure equivalence setting. Among other applications, we obtain the following unique product decomposition for products of nonamenable biexact groups, strengthening [ Sak09 ] : for any nonamenable biexact groups Γ 1 , ⋯ , Γ n \Gamma_{1},\cdots,\Gamma_{n} , if a product group Λ 1 × Λ 2 \Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} is measure equivalent to × k = 1 n Γ k \times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k} , then there exists a partition T 1 ⊔ T 2 = { 1 , … , n } T_{1}\sqcup T_{2}=\{1,\dots,n\} such that Λ i \Lambda_{i} is measure equivalent to × k ∈ T i Γ k \times_{k\in T_{i}}\Gamma_{k} for i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 . 1. Introduction Two countable groups \Gamma and \Lambda are said to be measure equivalent in the sense of Gromov [ Gro93 ] if there exist commuting free measure preserving actions of \Gamma and \Lambda on a standard \sigma -finite measure space (\Omega,\mu) such that both the actions \Gamma\curvearrowright(\Omega,\mu) and \Lambda\curvearrowright(\Omega,\mu) admit a finite measure fundamental domain. The classification of countable groups up to measure equivalence is a central theme in measured group theory and many spectacular innovations have been made in the last 25 years, see for instance the introduction of [ HHI23 ] . In their seminal work [ MS06 ] , Monod and Shalom used techniques from bounded cohomology theory to obtain the following general unique prime factorization result: if \times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k} is a product of non-elementary torsion-free hyperbolic groups that is measure equivalent to a product \times_{i=1}^{m}\Lambda_{i} of torsion-free groups and m\geq n , then n=m and after a permutation of the indices, \Gamma_{i} is measure equivalent to \Lambda_{i} for any 1\leq i\leq n . Sako then used C ∗ -algebraic techniques from [ Oza04 , OP04 ] , to extend in [ Sak09 ] (see also [ CS13 ] ) the above unique prime factorization results to products of nonamenable biexact groups. For additional such unique prime factorization results, see [ DHI19 , Dri23 ] . In the framework of II 1 factors, Ozawa and Popa obtained in [ OP04 ] a striking analogue to Monod and Shalom’s unique prime factorization result. They showed that if \Gamma_{1},\dots,\Gamma_{n} are i.c.c. (infinite conjugacy class) nonamenable hyperbolic groups (more generally, biexact groups) such that the group von Neumann algebra L(\times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k}) is stably isomorphic to a tensor product of {\rm II}_{1} factors \,\bar{\otimes}\,_{i=1}^{m}N_{i} and m\geq n , then m=n and after a permutation of the indices, L(\Gamma_{i}) is stably isomorphic to L(\Lambda_{i}) for any 1\leq i\leq n . In fact, Ozawa and Popa proved a more general unique prime factorization phenomenon by classifying all tensor product decompositions of L(\times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k}) . More precisely, they showed that if L(\times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k}) is stably isomorphic to a tensor product of {\rm II}_{1} factors N_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,N_{2} , then there exists a partition T_{1}\sqcup T_{2}=\{1,\dots,n\} such that N_{i} is stably isomorphic to L(\times_{k\in T_{i}}\Gamma_{k}) for any 1\leq i\leq 2 . In our first main result we show that a stronger form of Sako’s unique prime factorization result [ Sak09 ] holds by classifying all i.c.c. product groups that are measure equivalent to a product of nonamenable biexact groups. Theorem A . Let \Gamma_{1},\dots,\Gamma_{n} be nonamenable biexact groups. Suppose \times_{k=1}^{n}\Gamma_{k} is measure equivalent to a product \Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} of i.c.c. groups. Then there exists a partition T_{1}\sqcup T_{2}=\{1,\dots,n\} such that \Lambda_{j} is measure equivalent to \times_{i\in T_{j}}\Gamma_{i} for j=1,2 . Note that Theorem A is a consequence of [ DHI19 ] under the stronger assumption that \Gamma_{1},\dots,\Gamma_{n} are non-elementary hyperbolic groups. Results in [ DHI19 ] were achieved by using a combination of tools from Popa’s deformation/rigidity theory including the fundamental work of Popa and Vaes [ PV14b ] which shows that any hyperbolic (more generally, groups that are weakly amenable and biexact) satisfies the following relative strong solidity property : if \Gamma\curvearrowright N is a trace preserving action of a hyperbolic group and P\subset M:=N\rtimes\Gamma is a von Neumann subalgebra that is amenable relative to N inside M , then P\prec_{M}N or \mathcal{N}_{M}(P)^{\prime\prime} is amenable relative to N . An essential ingredient used in [ DHI19 ] is that any group \Gamma with the relative strong solidity property satisfies the following relative solidity property : if \Gamma\curvearrowright N is a trace preserving action of a hyperbolic group and P,Q\subset M:=N\rtimes\Gamma are commuting von Neumann subalgebras, then P\prec_{M}N or Q is amenable relative to N inside M (see [ KV17 , Lemma 5.2] ). Note that the converse is false: there exist groups (e.g. biexact group that are not weakly amenable such as \mathbb{Z}\wr\mathbb{F}_{2} ) that satisfies the relative solidity property, but not the strong relative property. Here, the intertwining is in the sense of Popa [ Pop06a ] and relative amenability is in the sense of Ozawa and Popa [ OP10 ] . It is an open question whether the above relative solidity property is satisfied by general biexact groups, and hence, this leads to the main technical difficulty for proving Theorem A . Conjecture B . Let \Gamma be a biexact group. If \Gamma\curvearrowright N is a trace preserving action and P,Q\subset M:=N\rtimes\Gamma are commuting von Neumann subalgebras, then P\prec_{M}N or Q is amenable relative to N inside M . This problem originates from the pioneering work of Ozawa [ Oza04 , Oza06 ] which states that Conjecture B is true whenever N is a tracial abelian von Neumann algebra. Note that [ PV14b ] shows that Conjecture B is true under the additional assumption that \Gamma is weakly amenable. Also, [ Iso19 , Proposition 7.3] shows that Conjecture B has a positive answer when N satisfies the W ∗ CMAP. Despite the fact that Conjecture B is still open in its full generality, we are able to overcome this difficulty and prove Theorem A by showing a measure equivalence variant of Conjecture B holds true. For simplicity we state here an orbit equivalence version (see also Theorem 4.1 for an equivalent measure theoretical statement). Theorem C . Let \Gamma be a nonamenable biexact group and \Lambda , \Sigma infinite groups. Suppose \Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y,\nu) and \Gamma\times\Sigma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) are orbit equivalent free ergodic p.m.p. actions and denote M=L^{\infty}(X,\mu)\rtimes(\Gamma\times\Sigma)=L^{\infty}(Y,\nu)\rtimes\Lambda . Then for any subgroup \Delta<\Lambda , we have either L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes\Delta\prec_{M}L^{\infty}(X,\mu)\rtimes\Sigma or L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes C_{\Lambda}(\Delta) is amenable relative to L^{\infty}(X,\mu)\rtimes\Sigma in M , where C_{\Lambda}(\Delta) denotes the centralizer of \Delta in \Lambda . A remarkable progress has been obtained in von Neumann algebras and orbit equivalence by the emergence of Popa’s deformation/rigidity theory [ Pop07 ] . For large classes of II 1 factors, many remarkable structural properties have been established, such as primeness, (infinite) unique prime factorization, (infinite) product rigidity, classification of normalizers of algebras, W ∗ -superrigidity, etc. (see the surveys [ Vae10 , Ioa13 , Ioa18 ] ). Numerous of these findings have been achieved for von Neumann algebras that arise from groups that are biexact and weakly amenable by relying on Popa and Vaes’ work [ PV14b ] on the relative (strong) solidity property, see for example [ BV14 , CKI15 , CdSS16 , KV17 , DHI19 , CI18 , CU20 , Iso19 , Iso20 , Dri20 , CDK23 , CDHK24 , CDAD23a , CDAD23b , DP23 , CIOS23 , CFQT24 , DV25 ] . Many of these works do not depend on the relative strong solidity property of the groups, but only on the relative solidity property. Hence, in light of Conjecture B , a natural question is to understand to what extent is weak amenability essential in these results. In this paper, we make progress on this question by applying Theorem C to generalize several rigidity results in the literature as outlined below. Our next main result, Theorem D , concerns orbit equivalence rigidity results for product actions. To put everything into context, note that [ CdSS16 ] shows that the group von Neumann algebra of a product of nonamenable i.c.c. weakly amenable and biexact groups remembers the product structure. The main result of [ Dri20 ] states that a similar phenomenon holds in the equivalence relation setting by showing that the orbit equivalence relation of a product of group actions of infinite weakly amenable, biexact, property (T) groups remembers the product structure. Since the group von Neumann algebra product ridigity from [ CdSS16 ] has been extended in [ CDAD23a ] to the class of nonamenable i.c.c. biexact groups, it remained open to show that the orbit equivalence product rigidity from [ Dri20 ] holds for infinite biexact, property (T) groups which are not necessarily weakly amenable. In the next theorem we affirmatively solve this problem. Theorem D . Let \Gamma_{1},\dots,\Gamma_{n} be infinite biexact, property (T) groups and let \Gamma=\times_{i=1}^{n}\Gamma . For each i=1,\dots,n , let \Gamma_{i}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X_{i},\mu_{i}) be a free ergodic p.m.p. action and \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) denotes the product action \Gamma_{1}\times\cdots\times\Gamma_{n}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X_{1}\times\cdots\times X_{n},\mu_{1}\times\cdots\times\mu_{n}) . Let \Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y,\nu) be a free ergodic p.m.p. action of an i.c.c. groups that is stably orbit equivalent to \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) . Then \Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y is induced from a product action \Lambda_{0}:=\Lambda_{1}\times\cdots\times\Lambda_{n}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y_{1}\times\cdots Y_{n},\nu_{1}\times\cdots\nu_{n}) of a subgroup \Lambda_{0}<\Lambda , such that \Gamma_{i}{\,\curvearrowright\,}X_{i} is stably orbit equivalent to \Lambda_{i}{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y_{i} for each i=1,\dots,n . By using deep results from geometric group theory [ AMO07 , Osi10 ] we point out the following class of biexact, property (T) groups that are not weakly amenable. Example 1.1 . Consider the wreath product H=\mathbb{Z}\wr\mathbb{F}_{n} and notice that H is a finitely generated biexact group [ BO08 , Corollary 15.3.9.] . By [ AMO07 , Theorem 1.1] there is a property (T) group G such that H0 is defined to be M^{t}=p(\mathbb{B}(\ell^{2}(\mathbb{Z}))\bar{\otimes}M)p , for a projection p\in\mathbb{B}(\ell^{2}(\mathbb{Z}))\bar{\otimes}M satisfying ( Tr \otimes\tau)(p)=t . Here Tr denotes the usual trace on \mathbb{B}(\ell^{2}(\mathbb{Z})) . Since M is a II 1 factor, M^{t} is well defined. Note that if M=P_{1}\bar{\otimes}P_{2} , for some II 1 factors P_{1} and P_{2} , then there exists a natural identification M=P_{1}^{t}\bar{\otimes}P_{2}^{1/t} , for every t>0. Finally, let I be a set. For any subset J\subset I we denote its complement by \widehat{J}=I\setminus J . If S=\{i\}, we will simply write \hat{i} instead of \widehat{\{i\}} . Also, given any direct sum group G=\oplus_{i\in I}G_{i} and any tensor product \bar{\otimes}M_{i\in I} , we will denote their subproduct supported on J by G_{J}=\oplus_{j\in J}G_{j} and M_{J}=\bar{\otimes}_{j\in J}M_{j} , respectively. 2.2. Intertwining-by-bimodules We next recall from [ Pop06b , Theorem 2.1 and Corollary 2.3] the powerful intertwining-by-bimodules technique of Sorin Popa. Theorem 2.1 (​​ [ Pop06b ] ) . Let (M,\tau) be a tracial von Neumann algebra and let P\subset pMp,Q\subset qMq be von Neumann subalgebras. Let \mathcal{U}\subset\mathcal{U}(P) be a subgroup such that \mathcal{U}^{\prime\prime}=P . Then the following are equivalent: (1) There exist projections p_{0}\in P,q_{0}\in Q , a * -homomorphism \theta:p_{0}Pp_{0}\rightarrow q_{0}Qq_{0} and a non-zero partial isometry v\in q_{0}Mp_{0} satisfying \theta(x)v=vx , for all x\in p_{0}Pp_{0} . (2) There is no sequence (u_{n})_{n}\subset\mathcal{U} satisfying \|E_{Q}(xu_{n}y)\|_{2}\rightarrow 0 , for all x,y\in M . If one of the equivalent conditions of Theorem 2.1 holds true, we write P\prec_{M}Q , and say that a corner of P embeds into Q inside M . Throughout the paper we will use the following notation. • If Pp^{\prime}\prec_{M}Q for any non-zero projection p^{\prime}\in P^{\prime}\cap pMp , then we write P\prec^{s}_{M}Q . • If P\prec_{M}Qq^{\prime} for any non-zero projection q^{\prime}\in Q^{\prime}\cap qMq , then we write P\prec^{s^{\prime}}_{M}Q . We first recall the following intertwining result which is essentially contained in [ CDAD23a , Section 3] . Lemma 2.2 . Let \Lambda be a nontrivial countable i.c.c. group and denote M=L(\Lambda) . Let \Delta:M\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M be the * -homomorphism given by \Delta(v_{\lambda})=v_{\lambda}\otimes v_{\lambda} , for any \lambda\in\Lambda . Let P\subset pMp be a regular von Neumann subalgebra and \Sigma<\Lambda an infinite subgroup satisfying P\prec_{M}L(\Sigma). If Q\subset qMq is a von Neumann subalgebra such that L(\Sigma)\prec_{M}Q , then \Delta(P)\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q . Proof. We start the proof by considering a Bernoulli action \Lambda\curvearrowright B with tracial abelian base and denote \mathcal{M}=B\rtimes\Lambda . We extend \Delta naturally to a * -homomorphism \Delta:\mathcal{M}\to\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\mathcal{M} by letting \Delta(bv_{\lambda})=bv_{\lambda}\otimes v_{\lambda} for all b\in B and \lambda\in\Lambda . The assumption implies that P\prec_{\mathcal{M}}^{s^{\prime}}B\rtimes\Sigma . By using [ Dri20 , Lemma 2.3] it follows that \Delta(P)\prec_{\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\mathcal{M}}^{s^{\prime}}\Delta(L(\Sigma)) . We further deduce that \Delta(P)\prec_{\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\mathcal{M}}^{s^{\prime}}\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,L(\Sigma) . By using L(\Sigma)\prec_{M}Q , [ Dri20 , Lemma 2.4] implies that \Delta(P)\prec_{\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\mathcal{M}}\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q . By [ CDAD23a , Lemma 3.3] it follows that \Delta(P)\prec_{\mathcal{M}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\mathcal{M}}Q\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q . By [ CDAD23a , Lemma 3.4] it follows that \Delta(P)\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q . ∎ 2.3. Relative amenability A tracial von Neumann algebra (M,\tau) is amenable if there is a positive linear functional \Phi:\mathbb{B}(L^{2}(M))\to\mathbb{C} such that \Phi_{|M}=\tau and \Phi is M - central , meaning \Phi(xT)=\Phi(Tx), for all x\in M and T\in\mathbb{B}(L^{2}(M)) . By Connes’ celebrated work [ Con76 ] , it follows that M is amenable if and only if M is approximately finite dimensional. We continue by recalling the notion of relative amenability introduced by Ozawa and Popa in [ OP10 ] . Let (M,\tau) be a tracial von Neumann algebra. Let p\in M be a projection and P\subset pMp,Q\subset M be von Neumann subalgebras. Following [ OP10 , Definition 2.2] , we say that P is amenable relative to Q inside M if there exists a positive linear functional \Phi:p\langle M,e_{Q}\rangle p\to\mathbb{C} such that \Phi_{|pMp}=\tau and \Phi is P -central. The proof of the following lemma is almost identical to the proof of [ CDD25 , Proposition 2.12] and hence we omit it. Lemma 2.3 . Let \Gamma be a discrete group, \Lambda<\Gamma a subgroup and M a tracial von Neumann algebra with \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}M a trace preserving action. Denote by \Delta:M\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L(\Gamma) the comultiplication map. Then a von Neumann subalgebra B\subset M\rtimes\Gamma is amenable relative to M\rtimes\Lambda if and only if \Delta(B) is amenable relative to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L(\Lambda) . Lemma 2.4 . Given a discrete group \Gamma and a tracial von Neumann algebra (M,\tau) , let \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}^{\sigma}(M,\tau) be a trace preserving action. For a subgroup \Lambda<\Gamma , there exists a (semifinite) trace preserving conditional expectation E:\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda) such that E_{\mid M\rtimes\Gamma} coincides with the conditional expectation from M\rtimes\Gamma to M . Moreover, for any u\in{\mathcal{U}}(M\rtimes\Gamma) for the form u=\sum_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}u_{t_{n}}p_{n} , where \{p_{n}\}_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}} is a partition of unity in {\mathcal{Z}}(M) and \{t_{n}\}_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}\subset\Gamma , we have E is \operatorname{Ad}(u) -equivariant. Proof. Consider the u.c.p. map \phi:{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M\otimes\ell^{2}\Gamma)\to{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M)\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}\Gamma given by \langle(\phi(T))(t)\xi,\eta\rangle=\langle T\xi\otimes\delta_{t},\eta\otimes\delta_{t}\rangle for any T\in{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M\otimes\ell^{2}\Gamma) , t\in\Gamma and \xi,\eta\in L^{2}M . Note that if T\in JMJ^{\prime}\cap{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M\otimes\ell^{2}\Gamma) , then \phi(T)(t)\in M for any t\in\Gamma . A similar computation shows that for any s\in\Gamma and any T\in{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M\otimes\ell^{2}\Gamma) commutes with Ju_{s}J . one has \phi(T)(ts)=\phi(T)(t) for any t\in\Gamma . It follows that E:=\phi_{\mid\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle}:\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda). Realizing \ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda)\subset{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M\otimes\ell^{2}\Gamma) via \delta_{t\Lambda}\mapsto u_{t}e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}u_{t}^{*} for t\in\Gamma , it is routine to check that E_{\mid M\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda)}=\operatorname{id} . One also checks that E(\sum_{t\in F}a_{t}u_{t})=a_{e}\otimes 1_{\Gamma/\Lambda} for any F\subset\Gamma finite, where a_{t}\in M , and the fact E_{\mid M\rtimes\Gamma}=E^{M\rtimes\Gamma}_{M} follows from the normality of E(\cdot)(t) for any t\in\Gamma . To see E is (semifinte) trace preserving, where M\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda) is equipped with \sum_{t\in\Gamma/\Lambda}\langle\cdot\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t},\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t}\rangle , first compute that \operatorname{Tr}(e_{F}Te_{F})=\sum_{t\in F}\langle E(T)\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t},\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t}\rangle for any T=au_{g}e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}bu_{h} , where a,b\in M , g,h\in\Gamma , F\subset\Gamma/\Lambda is a finite set and e_{F}=\sum_{t\in F}u_{t}e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}u_{t}^{*} . It follows that \operatorname{Tr}(e_{F}\cdot e_{F})=\sum_{t\in F}\langle\cdot\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t},\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t}\rangle on \langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle and hence \operatorname{Tr}(T)=\sum_{t\in\Gamma/\Lambda}\langle E(T)\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t},\hat{1}\otimes\delta_{t}\rangle for any T\in\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle . Lastly, for any u\in{\mathcal{U}}(M\rtimes\Gamma) of the form u=\sum_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}u_{t_{n}}p_{n} , T\in\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle , \xi,\eta\in\hat{M} and g\in\Gamma , we compute \displaystyle\langle\phi(u^{*}Tu)\xi\otimes\delta_{g},\eta\otimes\delta_{g}\rangle \displaystyle=\sum_{m,n\in{\mathbb{N}}}\langle T(\sigma_{t_{n}}(p_{n}\xi)\otimes\delta_{t_{n}g}),\sigma_{t_{m}}(p_{m}\eta)\otimes\delta_{t_{m}g}\rangle \displaystyle=\sum_{m,n\in{\mathbb{N}}}\langle T(J\sigma_{g^{-1}}(p_{n})J)(\sigma_{t_{n}}(\xi)\otimes\delta_{t_{n}g}),(J\sigma_{g^{-1}}(p_{m})J)(\sigma_{t_{m}}(\eta)\otimes\delta_{t_{m}g})\rangle \displaystyle=\sum_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}\langle T(\sigma_{t_{n}}(p_{n}\xi)\otimes\delta_{t_{n}g}),\sigma_{t_{n}}(p_{n}\eta)\otimes\delta_{t_{n}g}\rangle \displaystyle=\langle\phi(T)u(\xi\otimes\delta_{g}),u(\eta\otimes\delta_{g})\rangle. ∎ Lemma 2.5 . Let \Gamma be a discrete group with a subgroup \Lambda , (M,\tau) a tracial von Neumann algebra and \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(M,\tau) a trace preserving action and p\in{\mathcal{Z}}(M) a nonzero projection. Suppose {\mathcal{G}}<{\mathcal{N}}_{p(M\rtimes\Gamma)p}(pMp) is a subgroup containing elements of the form \sum_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}u_{t_{n}}p_{n} , where \{p_{n}\}_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}} is a partition of p in {\mathcal{Z}}(M) and \{t_{n}\}_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}}\subset\Gamma . Then N:=\{pMp,{\mathcal{G}}\}^{\prime\prime} is amenable relative to M\rtimes\Lambda in M\rtimes\Gamma if and only if there exists a {\mathcal{G}} -invariant state \varphi on M\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Lambda) with \varphi_{\mid pMp\otimes 1}=\tau_{pMp} . Proof. The only if direction is clear. To see the if direction, consider \omega:=\varphi\circ E:\langle M\rtimes\Gamma,e_{M\rtimes\Lambda}\rangle\to{\mathbb{C}} , where E is from the previous lemma. Note that \omega is {\mathcal{G}} -invariant as E is {\mathcal{G}} -equivariant. Similarly, we have \omega is pMp -central. Since \omega_{\mid p(M\rtimes\Gamma)p}=\tau_{p(M\rtimes\Gamma)p} , a standard argument shows that \omega is indeed N -central. ∎ 2.4. Intertwining and relative amenability via measure equivalence The main goal of this subsection is to discuss an measure equivalence counterpart of the von Neumann algebra intertwining notion [ Pop06b ] and relative amenability one [ OP10 ] . Throughout this subsection, we assume the following notation. Let \Gamma and \Lambda be measure equivalent groups. Then there exists a standard measure space (\Omega,\mu) (called an ME-coupling between \Gamma and \Lambda ) with commuting measure preserving actions of \Gamma and \Lambda such that each action admits a finite measure fundamental domain. Let \Gamma_{0}<\Gamma , \Lambda_{0}<\Lambda be subgroups. Denote by X=\Omega^{\Lambda} and we may identify (\Omega,\mu) with (X\times\Lambda,\mu_{\mid X}\times c) , where c is the counting measure on \Lambda and X is identified with a \Lambda -fundamental domain in \Omega . Note that we may identify \Omega^{\Lambda_{0}} with X\times\Lambda/\Lambda_{0} , equipped with the measure \mu_{\mid X}\times c_{\Lambda/\Lambda_{0}} , which we denote by \mu_{\Lambda_{0}} . We continue by recalling from [ Sak09 , Definition 2] the following intertwining relation in the measure equivalence framework. Definition 2.6 ( [ Sak09 ] ) . We say that \Gamma_{0} intertwines into \Lambda_{0} via the coupling \Omega , denoted by \Gamma_{0}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{0} if there exists a non-null measurable subset E\subset\Omega that is \Gamma_{0}\times\Lambda_{0} -invariant with \mu_{\Lambda_{0}}(E)<\infty . Inspired by [ Hay24 , Theorem 3.5, (ii)] , we are considering the following relative amenability notion in the framework of measure equivalence. Definition 2.7 . We say that \Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to \Lambda_{0} via the coupling \Omega if there exists a \Gamma_{0} -invariant state \nu on L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{0}},\mu_{\Lambda_{0}}) such that \nu_{X}=\mu_{\mid X} , where \nu_{X}(1_{F})=\nu(1_{F\times\Lambda/\Lambda_{0}}) for any measurable subset F\subset X . Continuing in the above setting, by [ Fur99 ] we may assume that X\subset Y and {\mathcal{R}}({\Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}X})={\mathcal{R}}(\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y)\cap(X\times X) by replacing \Lambda with \Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}_{d} and \Omega^{\Gamma} with \Omega^{\Gamma}\times{\mathbb{Z}}_{d} for some d\in{\mathbb{N}} , where Y=\Omega^{\Gamma} . It follows that we have (L^{\infty}(X)\subset L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes\Gamma)=(pL^{\infty}(Y)\subset p(L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes\Lambda)p) with p=1_{X}\in L^{\infty}(Y) . In the following, we denote by \{u_{t}\mid t\in\Gamma\} and \{v_{g}\mid g\in\Lambda\} the canonical unitaries in L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes\Gamma=:A\rtimes\Gamma and L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes\Lambda=:B\rtimes\Lambda=:M associated with \Gamma and \Lambda , respectively. Proposition 2.8 . Using the above notations, the following statements hold. (1) One has \Gamma_{0}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{0} if and only if A\rtimes\Gamma_{0}\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} if and only if L\Gamma_{0}\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} . (2) The subgroup \Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to \Lambda_{0} via \Omega if and only if A\rtimes\Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} in M if and only if L\Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} in M . Proof. We may identify L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{0}})=pL^{\infty}(Y)\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Lambda/\Lambda_{0})\subset p\langle M,e_{B\rtimes\Lambda_{0}}\rangle p and it is not difficult to check that this identification is (semifinite) trace preserving. It follows that \Gamma_{0}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{0} implies A\rtimes\Gamma_{0}\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} , and hence L\Gamma_{0}\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} . If f\in p\langle M,e_{B\rtimes\Lambda_{0}}\rangle p is a nonzero projection with finite trace commuting with L\Gamma_{0} , then apply Lemma 2.4 yields E(f)\in L^{\infty}(X)\,\bar{\otimes}\,\ell^{\infty}(\Lambda/\Lambda_{0})=L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{0}}) a nonzero positive element with finite trace. Moreover, E(f) is \Gamma_{0} -invariant as E is [{\mathcal{R}}({\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y})] -equivariant. Taking an appropriate spectral projection of E(f) yields \Gamma_{0}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{0} . To see ( 2 ), note that the inclusion L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{0}})\subset p\langle M,e_{B\rtimes\Lambda_{0}}\rangle p shows that if L\Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{0} then \Gamma_{0} is amenable relative to \Lambda_{0} via \Omega . The rest follows from Lemma 2.5 . ∎ Finally, we record the following elementary lemma. Lemma 2.9 . Let \Gamma and \Lambda be countable groups that are measure equivalent via an ergodic coupling (\Omega,\mu) . Then the following hold. (1) Suppose \Gamma_{1},\Gamma_{2}<\Gamma and \Sigma<\Lambda are subgroups such that \Gamma_{1} and \Sigma are normal. If \Gamma_{1} and \Gamma_{2} are commuting and \Gamma_{i}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Sigma for i=1,2 , then \Gamma_{1}\Gamma_{2}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Sigma . (2) Suppose \Gamma_{1},\Gamma_{2}<\Gamma and \Sigma<\Lambda are subgroups such that \Gamma_{1} and \Sigma are normal. If \Gamma_{1}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda and \Lambda\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Gamma_{2} , then \Gamma_{1}\subset F\Gamma_{2} for some finite subset F\subset\Gamma . Proof. We follow the proof of [ Sak09 , Lemma 33] . Let e_{i}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega)^{\Gamma_{i}\times\Sigma} be a nonzero projection. By ergodicity of \Omega , we may assume e_{1}e_{2}\neq 0 by replacing e_{1} with t\cdot e_{1}\cdot g for some t\in\Gamma/\Gamma_{1} and g\in\Lambda/\Sigma . To see (1), we may further assume \mu_{\Sigma}(e_{i})<\infty for i=1,2 . Set {\mathcal{C}}={\rm conv}\{t\cdot e_{1}\mid t\in\Gamma_{2}\}\subset L^{2}(L^{\infty}(\Omega)^{\Sigma},\mu_{\Sigma}) and pick f to be the minimal norm element in the closure of {\mathcal{C}} . Since \mu_{\Sigma}((t\cdot e_{1})e_{2})=\mu_{\Sigma}(t\cdot(e_{1}e_{2}))=\mu_{\Sigma}(e_{1}e_{2})>0 , one has f\neq 0 . Moreover, we may assume f is a projection by taking an appropriate spectral projection. It follows that f implements \Gamma_{1}\Gamma_{2}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Sigma . The argument is similar for (2). Indeed, we have \mu_{\Sigma}(e_{1})<\infty and \mu_{\Gamma_{2}}(e_{2})<\infty by assumption. Let p be the minimal norm element in the closure of {\rm conv}\{t\cdot e_{2}\mid t\in\Gamma_{1}\}\subset L^{2}(L^{\infty}(\Omega)^{\Gamma_{2}},\mu_{\Gamma_{2}}) . To see p is nonzero, observe \mu_{\Sigma}(e_{1}(t\cdot e_{2}))=\mu_{\Sigma}(t\cdot(e_{1}e_{2}))>0 . It follows that there exists a nonzero \Gamma_{1} -invariant projection in \ell^{\infty}(\Gamma/\Gamma_{2}) with finite trace, as desired. ∎ 2.5. From intertwining to measure equivalence All results in this subsection are due to Sako [ Sak09 ] . These results, especially when combined with Popa’s intertwining techniques through Proposition 2.8 , give efficient ways to conclude measure equivalence from intertwining. We present here a streamlined proof for ease of reference and completeness. Notation 2.10 . Let \Gamma and \Lambda be countable groups that are measure equivalent via an ergodic coupling (\Omega,\mu) , assume \Gamma_{1}\lhd\Gamma , \Lambda_{1}\lhd\Lambda are normal subgroups and put \Gamma_{2}=\Gamma/\Gamma_{1} , \Lambda_{2}=\Lambda/\Lambda_{1} . For any projection p\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}},\mu_{\Gamma_{1}}) , we may consider \iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(p) , a \mathbb{N}\cup\{\infty\} -valued measurable function on Y given by \iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(p)(y)=\sum_{t\in\Gamma_{2}}p(t,y) , where (Y,\lambda)=(\Omega^{\Gamma},\mu_{\Gamma}) and (\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}},\mu_{\Gamma_{1}}) is identified with (\Gamma_{2}\times Y,c\times\lambda) . Note that \iota_{\Gamma_{1}} is \Lambda -equivariant as \Gamma_{1} is normal and \mu_{\Gamma_{1}}(p)=\lambda(\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(p)) . Similarly, we consider \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(q) as a \mathbb{N}\cup\{\infty\} -valued measurable function on X for any projection q\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{1}},\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}) . Lemma 2.11 ( [ Sak09 , proof of Theorem 30] , cf. [ DHI19 , Proposition 3.1] ) . With Notation 2.10 , assume in addition that \Gamma=\Gamma_{1}\times\Gamma_{2} and \Lambda=\Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} . If \Gamma_{i}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{i} for i=1,2 , then \Gamma_{i}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{i} for i=1,2 Proof. We denote by e\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and f\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{2}\times\Lambda_{2}}) be nonzero projections with \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)<\infty and \mu_{\Lambda_{2}}(f)<\infty . Since \rho(\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(e))=\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)<\infty , we may assume \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(e) is bounded. Similarly, we may assume \iota_{\Lambda_{2}}(f) is bounded. Moreover by ergodicity of \Gamma\times\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}(\Omega,\mu) , we may assume ef\neq 0 . Observe that \int_{\Omega}efd\mu=\int_{X}\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)\iota_{\Lambda_{2}}(f)d\rho and hence 0<\int_{\Omega}efd\mu=\int_{X}\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)\iota_{\Lambda_{2}}(f)d\rho<\infty. Indeed, this is clear when e=1_{X_{s}\times\Lambda_{1}\times s} and f=1_{X_{t}\times t\times\Lambda_{2}} for s\in\Lambda_{2} , t\in\Lambda_{1} and X_{s},X_{t}\subset X measurable subsets. The general case follows by linearity and normality of the integration. For the same reason, we have 0<\int_{\Omega}efd\mu=\int_{X}\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)\iota_{\Lambda_{2}}(f)d\rho<\infty. Set g:=\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)\iota_{\Gamma_{2}}(f):Y\to\mathbb{N}\cup\{\infty\} and denote by Y_{0} the support of g . Note that \iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)(x)\leq\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)(x)\iota_{\Gamma_{2}}(f)(x)=g(x) for any x\in Y_{0} , as \iota_{\Gamma_{2}}(f)(x)\geq 1 . Moreover, \iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)1_{Y_{0}} is a nonzero function as g is nonzero. Thus 0<\int_{Y_{0}}\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)d\lambda<\infty and there exists some positive integer k with \lambda((\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)1_{Y_{0}})^{-1}(k))>0 . Set Y_{k}=(\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e))^{-1}(k) , which is \Lambda_{1} -invariant, and then \tilde{e}:=e1_{\Gamma_{2}\times Y_{k}}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}}) is \Lambda_{1} -invariant and \int_{\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}}}e1_{\Gamma_{2}\times Y_{k}}d\mu_{\Gamma_{1}}=\int_{Y_{k}}\iota_{\Gamma_{1}}(e)d\lambda\leq k\lambda(Y), i.e., \tilde{e} is finite in both \mu_{\Gamma_{1}} and \mu_{\Lambda_{1}} and hence \Gamma_{1}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{1} . Similarly, we have \Gamma_{2}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{2} . ∎ Lemma 2.12 ( [ Sak09 , Proposition 28] , cf. [ Spa23 , Proposition 3.9] ) . Assume Notation 2.10 . If \Gamma_{1}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{1} and \Lambda_{1}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Gamma_{1} , then \Gamma_{i}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{i} for i=1,2 . Lemma 2.13 . Assume Notation 2.10 . If there exists a nonzero projection e\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) with \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(e)<\infty , then there exists a finite subgroup F<\Lambda_{2} and a nonzero projection f\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) such that \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(f)<\infty , F acts trivially on fL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) , (t\cdot f)f=0 for any t\in\Lambda_{2}\setminus F and \vee_{t\in\Lambda_{2}}t\cdot f=1_{\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}} Proof. Consider \{n\in{\mathbb{N}}_{+}\mid\exists\ \Gamma_{1}\text{-invariant\ projection}\ q\in L^{1}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{1}},\mu_{\Lambda_{1}})\ s.t.\ \rho(\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(q)^{-1}(n))>0\}, which is nonempty by the existence of e and let k be the minimal element in this set. Thus we have a projection p\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) such that k\in{\rm Ran}(\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(p)) . We may replace p with p1_{E\times\Lambda} , which is also \Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1} -invariant, where E\subset X the preimage of k under \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(p) . Denote by \Lambda_{2}^{k} the collection of subsets of \Lambda_{2} of size k . For any K\in\Lambda_{2}^{k} , we consider the measurable subset X_{K}=\{x\in X\mid\sum_{t\in K}p(x,t)=k\} , where we view p\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Lambda_{1}})=L^{\infty}(X\times\Lambda_{2}) . Since {\rm Ran}(\iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(p))=\{0,k\} , we have p=\sum_{K\in\Lambda_{2}^{k}}1_{X_{K}\times\Lambda_{1}\times K} and \rho(X_{K_{1}}\cap X_{K_{2}})=0 for any K_{1},K_{2}\in\Lambda_{2}^{k} with K_{1}\neq K_{2} , and thus \rho(\cup_{K\in\Lambda_{2}^{k}}X_{K})=\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(p)/k . Set {\mathcal{K}}=\{K\in\Lambda_{2}^{k}\mid\rho(X_{K})>0\} . For each K\in{\mathcal{K}} and t\in\Lambda_{2} , we have tK\cap K is either K or \emptyset as \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}((t\cdot p)p)1_{X_{K}}=|tK\cap K|1_{X_{K}} and by the minimality of k one has |tK\cap K|=0 or k . It follows that tK=K if t\in KK^{-1} and tK\cap K=\emptyset otherwise. We may assume there exists some F\in{\mathcal{K}} containing the identity element as we may replace p with t^{-1}\cdot p for some t\in F , and it follows F is a subgroup. Now consider f=\wedge_{t\in F}t\cdot p=\sum_{K\in{\mathcal{K}}}(\wedge_{t\in F}1_{X_{K}\times\Lambda_{1}\times tK}) . For K\in{\mathcal{K}} , one has \wedge_{t\in F}1_{X_{K}\times\Lambda_{1}\times tK}\neq 0 if and only if tK=K for each t\in F , i.e., K=Fs for any s\in K . It follows that we may write f=\sum_{s\in I}1_{X_{Fs}\times\Lambda_{1}\times Fs} for some subset I\subset\Lambda_{2} . Utilizing the minimality of k , one checks that F acts trivially on fL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and (t\cdot f)f=0 for any t\in\Lambda_{2}\setminus F . Since f\leq p , we also have \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(f)<\infty . We claim that there exists a projection \tilde{f}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) with the same aforementioned properties and \vee_{t\in\Lambda_{2}}t\cdot\tilde{f}=1_{\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}} . Indeed, let X_{0}:=\cup_{s\in I}X_{Fs}\subset X , which is \Gamma_{1} -invariant as f is \Gamma_{1} -invariant. If X_{0}\neq X , we may find some g\in\Gamma_{2} such that U=g\cdot X_{0}\cap(X\setminus X_{0}) has positive measure. Set f_{g}=f1_{g^{-1}\cdot U\times\Lambda}=\sum_{s\in I}1_{X_{Fs}\cap g^{-1}\cdot U\times\Lambda_{1}\times Fs}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and \tilde{f}:=f+g\cdot f_{g} . One then checks that \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(\tilde{f})=k1_{X_{0}\cup U} , F acts trivially on f_{g}L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and (t\cdot\tilde{f})\tilde{f}=0 for any t\in\Lambda_{2}\setminus F since (t\cdot f)(g\cdot f_{g})\leq 1_{X_{0}\times\Lambda}1_{U\times\Lambda}=0 . By a maximality argument, we may assume \iota_{\Lambda_{1}}(\tilde{f})=k1_{X} , as desired. ∎ Proof of Lemma 2.12 . By assumption, there exists projections f_{0},e_{0}\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) such that \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(f_{0})<\infty and \mu_{\Gamma_{1}}(e_{0})<\infty . We may assume r:=e_{0}f_{0}\neq 0 by ergodicity of \Omega and hence \mu_{\Gamma_{1}}(r)+\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(r)<\infty , which implies that \Gamma_{1}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{1} via the coupling rL^{\infty}(\Omega) . To see \Gamma_{2}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{2} , note that the above lemma yields from the existence of f_{0} a nonzero projection f\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and a finite subgroup F<\Lambda_{2} such that \mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(f)<\infty , F acts trivially on fL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) , (t\cdot f)f=0 for any t\in\Lambda_{2}\setminus F and \vee_{t\in\Lambda_{2}}t\cdot f=1 . Similarly, we have a nonzero projection e\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) and a finite subgroup E<\Gamma_{2} with corresponding properties. By ergodicity of (\Omega,\mu) , we may assume ef\neq 0 . Consider the Radon-Nikodym derivative d\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}/d\mu_{\Gamma_{1}} , which is \Gamma\times\Lambda -invariant as both \mu_{\Gamma_{1}} and \mu_{\Lambda_{1}} are, and hence must be a constant by ergodicity of \Omega . Moreover as 0<\mu_{\Gamma_{1}}(ef),\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}(ef)<\infty , one has d\mu_{\Lambda_{1}}/d\mu_{\Gamma_{1}} equals to some positive finite constant and thus we may not need to distinguish \mu_{\Gamma_{1}} and \mu_{\Lambda_{1}} as measures on L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) . Let N_{F}<\Lambda_{2} be the normalizer of F in \Lambda_{2} and q=\vee_{t\in N_{F}}t\cdot f and clearly we have an action of N_{F}/F on qL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) with e being a fundamental domain. We claim that q is \Gamma -invariant. Indeed, we observe that q\in L^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) is the maximal projection such that F acts trivially qL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) . This is because for any t\in\Lambda_{2}\setminus N_{F} , we may find some g\in F such that t^{-1}gt\not\in F and hence t^{-1}gt\cdot e is orthogonal to e , which entails that g\cdot(t\cdot e)\perp(t\cdot e) . Then the claim follows directly from this characterization of q . We may thus write q=1_{\Gamma\times Y_{q}} for some Y_{q}\subset Y . Next we show N_{F}<\Lambda_{2} is finite index. Take a transversal \{t_{i}\}_{i\in I}=\Lambda_{2}/N_{F} and notice that t_{i}\cdot q\perp t_{j}\cdot q . It follows that \{t_{i}\cdot Y_{q}\}_{i\in I} is a family of pairwise disjoint subsets of Y with the same measure. As Y is a finite measure space, one has |I|<\infty . In summary, we have an action N_{F}/F{\,\curvearrowright\,}qL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) with a finite measure fundamental domain f , N_{F}<\Lambda_{2} is of finite index and q is a \Gamma\times N_{F} -invariant projection. Replacing e with qe , we may repeat the same argument to conclude that there exists a N_{K}\times N_{F} -invariant projection p\in qL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) such that N_{k}/K{\,\curvearrowright\,}pL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) has a finite measure fundamental domain qe and [\Gamma_{2},N_{K}]<\infty , where N_{k} is the normalizer of K in \Gamma_{2} . Therefore, pL^{\infty}(\Omega^{\Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1}}) is an ME-coupling between N_{F}/F and N_{K}/K with a N_{F}/F -fundamental domain pf and N_{k}/K -fundamental domain qe . It follows that \Gamma_{2}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{2} . ∎ 3. Biexact groups and von Neumann algebras 3.1. The small-at-infinity boundary and boundary pieces The notion of small-at-infinity compatification of a discrete group \Gamma was introduced by Ozawa [ Oza04 , BO08 ] . More precisely, given a discrete group \Gamma , the small-at-infinity compatification \overline{\Gamma}^{s} is described by C(\overline{\Gamma}^{s})=\{f\in\ell^{\infty}\Gamma\mid f-R_{t}f\in c_{0}\Gamma,\ \forall t\in\Gamma\}\subset\ell^{\infty}\Gamma, where R_{t}f(\cdot)=f(\cdot t) is the right translation by \Gamma on \ell^{\infty}\Gamma . The notion of the small-at-infinity boundary for von Neumann algebras developed in [ DKEP23 , DP23 ] , is a noncommutative analogue of the above notion and we recall it now. Let M be a tracial von Neumann algebra. An M -boundary piece {\mathbb{X}} is a hereditary {\rm C}^{*} -subalgebra {\mathbb{X}}\subset{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M) such that M\cap M({\mathbb{X}})\subset M and JMJ\cap M({\mathbb{X}})\subset JMJ are weakly dense, and {\mathbb{X}}\neq\{0\} , where M({\mathbb{X}}) denotes the multiplier algebra of {\mathbb{X}} . For convenience, we will always assume {\mathbb{X}}\neq\{0\} . Given an M -boundary piece {\mathbb{X}} , define {\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}^{L}(M)\subset{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M) to be the \|\cdot\|_{\infty,2} closure of {\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M){\mathbb{X}} , where \|T\|_{\infty,2}=\sup_{a\in(M)_{1}}\|T\hat{a}\| and (M)_{1}=\{a\in M\mid\|a\|\leq 1\} . Set {\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)={\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}^{L}(M)^{*}\cap{\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}^{L}(M) , then {\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) is a {\rm C}^{*} -subalgebra that contains M and JMJ in its multiplier algebra [ DKEP23 , Proposition 3.5] . Put {\mathbb{K}}^{\infty,1}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)=\overline{{\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)}^{{}_{\|\cdot\|_{\infty,1}}}\subset{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M) , where \|T\|_{\infty,1}=\sup_{a,b\in(M)_{1}}\langle T\hat{a},\hat{b}\rangle , and the small-at-infinity boundary for M relative to {\mathbb{X}} is given by {\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)=\{T\in{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M)\mid[T,x]\in{\mathbb{K}}_{\mathbb{X}}^{\infty,1}(M),{\rm\ for\ any\ }x\in M^{\prime}\}. When {\mathbb{X}}={\mathbb{K}}(L^{2}M) , we omit {\mathbb{X}} in the above notations. The following instance of boundary pieces is extensively used in the following. Let M be a finite von Neumann algebra and \{P_{i}\}_{i\in I} a possibly infinite family of von Neumann subalgebras. Recall from [ DP23 , Lemma 6.12] that the M -boundary piece {\mathbb{X}} associated with \{P_{i}\}_{i\in I} is the hereditary {\rm C}^{*} -subalgebra of {\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M) generated by \{xJyJe_{P_{i}}\mid i\in I,\ x,y\in M\} . These notions also accommodate generalizations to the non-tracial setting and we refer to [ DP23 ] for details. 3.2. Biexactness Following Ozawa [ Oza04 , BO08 ] , one says a discrete group \Gamma is biexact if \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}\overline{\Gamma}^{s} is topologically amenable. The corresponding notion for von Neumann algebras was introduced in [ DP23 ] and we recall it in the following. Let M be a von Neumann algebra, {\mathbb{X}}\subset{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}M) an M -boundary piece and {\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) the corresponding small-at-infinity boundary for M . We may equip S:={\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) with the M -topology, which is given by the family of seminorms s^{\rho}_{\omega}(x)=\inf\{\rho(a^{*}a)^{1/2}\|y\|\omega(b^{*}b)^{1/2}\mid x=a^{*}yb,\ a,b\in M,y\in S\}, where \rho,\omega range over all normal positive functionals on M . By an equivalent characterization [ DP23 , Lemma 3.4] , we say a net \{x_{i}\}\subset S converging to 0 in the M -topology if there exists a net of projections p_{i}\in M such that p_{i}\to 1 strongly and \|p_{i}x_{i}p_{i}\|\to 0 . We also have the weak M -topology on S , which is described by {\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)^{\sharp}=\{\varphi\in{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)^{*}\mid M\times M\ni(a,b)\mapsto\varphi(aTb)\in{\mathbb{C}}\text{\ is\ separately\ normal}\ \forall T\in{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M)\}, i.e., \{x_{i}\}\subset S converges to 0 in the weak M -topology if \varphi(x_{i})\to 0 for any \varphi\in{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}}(M)^{\sharp} . We say M\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) is M -nuclear if there exist nets of u.c.p. maps \phi_{i}:M\to{\mathbb{M}}_{n(i)}({\mathbb{C}}) and \psi_{i}:{\mathbb{M}}_{n(i)}({\mathbb{C}})\to{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) such that \psi_{i}\circ\phi_{i}(x)\to x in the M -topology of {\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) , or equivalently, in the weak M -topology (see [ DP23 , Section 4] for details). And we say M is biexact relative to {\mathbb{X}} if M\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}(M) is M -nuclear. When {\mathbb{X}} is the M -boundary piece associated with a family of von Neumann subalgebras \{P_{i}\}_{i\in I} of M , we say M is biexact relative to \{P_{i}\}_{i\in I} , and when {\mathbb{X}}={\mathbb{K}}^{\infty,1}(M) , we simply say M is biexact. These notions coincide with the corresponding notions of groups if we consider group von Neumann algebras: a discrete group \Gamma is biexact relative to a family of subgroups \{\Lambda_{i}\}_{i\in I} if and only if L\Gamma is biexact relative to \{L\Lambda_{i}\}_{i\in I} [ DP23 , Theorem 6.2] . Lemma 3.1 . Let M be a finite von Neumann algebra and P\subset pMp , Q\subset M von Neumann subalgebras. Suppose P\not\prec_{M}Q . Then there exists a P^{\prime}\cap pMp -central state on \varphi:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{Q}}(M)\to{\mathbb{C}} such that \varphi_{\mid pMp} coincides with its trace. Equivalently, there exists a conditional expectation \phi:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{Q}}(M)\to P^{\prime}\cap pMp such that \phi_{\mid pMp} coincides with the canonical expectation onto P^{\prime}\cap pMp . Proof. From P\not\prec_{M}Q we obtain a net of unitaries \{u_{n}\}\subset{\mathcal{U}}(P) such that \|E_{Q}(au_{n}b)\|_{2}\to 0 for any a,b\in M , which in turns implies that \|u_{n}Ku_{n}^{*}\|_{\infty,2}\to 0 for any K\in{\mathbb{K}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{Q}}^{\infty,1}(M) by the same proof of [ DP23 , Lemma 6.12] . The desired \varphi\in{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{Q}}(M)^{*} is then obtained by taking a limit point of \{\langle\cdot\hat{u}_{n},\hat{u}_{n}\rangle/\tau(p)\}_{n} . To see the existence of \phi , consider \phi:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{Q}}(M)\to{\mathbb{B}}(L^{2}(B)) given by \langle\phi(T)\hat{a},\hat{b}\rangle=\varphi(b^{*}Ta) for any a,b\in B , where B=P^{\prime}\cap pMp . Since \varphi is B -central, we have [\phi(T),JxJ]=0 for any x\in B . The fact \phi_{\mid pMp}=E^{pMp}_{P^{\prime}\cap pMp} follows from \varphi_{\mid pMp}=\tau . ∎ Proposition 3.2 . Given an index set I , let M_{i} be a von Neumann algebra with a faithful normal state \varphi_{i} for each i\in I . Set {\mathcal{M}}=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{i\in I}(M_{i},\varphi_{i}) and M_{\widehat{i}}=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{j\in I,j\neq i}(M_{j},\varphi_{j}) for each i\in I . If each M_{i} is biexact, then {\mathcal{M}} is biexact relative to \{M_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} . In particular, if \{\Gamma_{i}\}_{i\in I} is a family of biexact groups, then \oplus_{i\in I}\Gamma_{i} is biexact relative to \{\oplus_{j\neq i}\Gamma_{j}\}_{i\in I} . Proof. We may assume I is infinite as the finite case is covered by [ DP23 , Proposition 6.14] . For any finite set F\subset I , denote by {\mathcal{M}}_{F}=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{i\in F}M_{i} and E_{F}:{\mathcal{M}}\to{\mathcal{M}}_{F} the conditional expectation. Note {\mathcal{M}}_{F} is biexact relative to \{E_{F}(M_{\widehat{i}})\}_{i\in F} as E_{F}(M_{\widehat{i}})=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{j\in F\setminus\{i\}}M_{j} and thus we have the following diagram {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathcal{M}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathcal{M}}_{F}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{F}}({\mathcal{M}}_{F})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}}({\mathcal{M}}),} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathbb{M}}_{n(k)}({\mathbb{C}})} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces E_{F}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\phi_{k}^{F}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\iota} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\psi_{k}^{F}} where {\mathbb{X}}_{F} denotes the {\mathcal{M}}_{F} -boundary piece associated with \{E_{F}(M_{\widehat{i}})\}_{i\in F} , {\mathbb{X}} denotes the {\mathcal{M}} -boundary piece associated with \{M_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} , \phi_{k}^{F} , \psi_{k}^{F} are u.c.p. maps such that \theta_{k}^{F}:=\psi_{k}^{F}\circ\phi_{k}^{F}\to\operatorname{id}_{{\mathcal{M}}_{F}} in the point- {\mathcal{M}}_{F} -topology, and \iota is the restriction of the embedding {\mathbb{B}}(\otimes_{i\in F}L^{2}(M_{i},\varphi_{i}))\otimes 1\subset{\mathbb{B}}(\otimes_{i\in I}L^{2}(M_{i},\varphi_{i})) to {\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{F}}({\mathcal{M}}_{F}) . For any \varphi\in{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}({\mathcal{M}})^{\sharp} , note that \varphi\circ\iota\in{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{F}}({\mathcal{M}}_{F})^{\sharp} . For any x\in{\mathcal{M}} , one checks that \lim_{k}\langle(\iota\circ\theta_{k}^{F})(E_{F}(x)),\varphi\rangle=\lim_{k}\langle\theta_{k}^{F}(E_{F}(x)),\varphi\circ\iota\rangle=\langle E_{F}(x),\varphi\rangle. Since \varphi_{\mid{\mathcal{M}}} is normal, we further have \lim_{F}\varphi(E_{F}(x))=\varphi(x) . It follows that {\mathcal{M}} is biexact relative to {\mathbb{X}} . The moreover part is a consequence of [ DP23 , Theorem 6.2] . ∎ Remark 3.3 . Note that one may prove directly, without using [ DP23 ] , that \Gamma=\oplus_{i\in I}\Gamma_{i} is biexact relative to {\mathcal{G}}:=\{\Gamma_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} if each \Gamma_{i} is biexact, following the same idea. Indeed, for each finite F\subset I denote by \pi_{F}:\Gamma\to\times_{i\in F}\Gamma_{i}=:\Gamma_{F} the quotient map and {\mathcal{G}}_{F}=\{\pi_{F}(\Gamma_{\widehat{i}})\}_{i\in F} . Following the notation of [ BO08 , Chapter 15] , one checks that c_{0}(\Gamma_{F},{\mathcal{G}}_{F})\subset c_{0}(\Gamma,{\mathcal{G}}) under the embedding \ell^{\infty}(\Gamma_{F})=\ell^{\infty}(\Gamma_{F})\otimes 1_{\otimes_{i\in I\setminus F}}\ell^{2}\Gamma_{i}\subset\ell^{\infty}\Gamma . Then a similar argument as above shows that \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}\{f\in\ell^{\infty}\Gamma\mid f-R_{t}f\in c_{0}(\Gamma,{\mathcal{G}})\} is topologically ameanble, i.e., \Gamma is biexact relative to {\mathcal{G}} . Corollary 3.4 (cf. [ HI16 , Theorem 5.1] ) . Given an index set I , let M_{i} be a von Neumann algebra with a faithful normal state \varphi_{i} for each i\in I and M_{0} an amenable von Neumann algebra (possibly trivial). Set {\mathcal{M}}=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{i\in I}(M_{i},\varphi_{i}) and M_{\widehat{i}}=\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{j\in I,j\neq i}(M_{j},\varphi_{j}) for each i\in I . If P\subset M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}} is a finite von Neumann subalgebra with expectation, then either P^{\prime}\cap(M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}}) is amenable or P\prec_{M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}}}M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{i}} for some i\in I . Proof. Set \widetilde{\mathcal{M}}=M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}} and \widetilde{M}_{\widehat{i}}=M_{0}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{i}} . Suppose P\not\prec_{\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}}\widetilde{M_{\widehat{i}}} for any i\in I . By [ DP23 , Lemma 6.12] and its following paragraph, one obtains a u.c.p. map \Theta:{\mathbb{S}}_{\widetilde{\mathbb{X}}}(\widetilde{\mathcal{M}})\to\widetilde{\mathcal{M}} such that \Theta_{\mid Q}=\operatorname{id}_{Q} , where Q=P^{\prime}\cap\widetilde{\mathcal{M}} and \widetilde{\mathbb{X}} denotes the \tilde{\mathcal{M}} -boundary piece associated with \{\widetilde{M}_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} . Denote by {\mathbb{X}} the {\mathcal{M}} -boundary piece associated with \{M_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} . As {\mathcal{M}} is biexact relative to {\mathbb{X}} by Proposition 3.2 , the {\mathcal{M}} -boundary piece associated with \{M_{\widehat{i}}\}_{i\in I} , we have nets of u.c.p. maps \phi_{j}:{\mathcal{M}}\to{\mathbb{M}}_{n(j)}({\mathbb{C}}) and \psi_{j}:{\mathbb{M}}_{n(j)}({\mathbb{C}})\to{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}({\mathcal{M}}) such that \psi_{j}\circ\phi_{j}\to\operatorname{id}_{\mathcal{M}} in the point {\mathcal{M}} -topology. Moreover, since M_{0} is semidiscrete, we also have u.c.p. maps \alpha_{\ell}:M_{0}\to{\mathbb{M}}_{n(\ell)}({\mathbb{C}}) and \beta_{\ell}:{\mathbb{M}}_{n(\ell)}({\mathbb{C}})\to M_{0} such that \beta_{\ell}\circ\alpha_{\ell}\to\operatorname{id}_{M_{0}} in the point-weak ∗ topology. Consider {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{0}\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathcal{M}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces M_{0}\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}({\mathcal{M}})\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{\widetilde{\mathbb{X}}}(\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}).} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\mathbb{M}}_{n(\ell)}({\mathbb{C}})\otimes{\mathbb{M}}_{n(j)}({\mathbb{C}})} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\alpha_{\ell}\otimes\phi_{j}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\beta_{\ell}\otimes\psi_{j}} One checks that (\beta_{\ell}\otimes\psi_{j})\circ(\alpha_{\ell}\otimes\phi_{j})(x)\to x for any x\in M_{0}\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathcal{M}} in the (M_{0}\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathcal{M}}\subset\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}) -topology, from which we obtain that \widetilde{\mathcal{M}}\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{\widetilde{X}}(\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}) is {\mathcal{M}} -nuclear by [ DP23 , Corollary 4.9] . Finally, note that there exists a normal faithful conditional expectation E:\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}\to Q=P^{\prime}\cap\widetilde{\mathcal{M}} since P\subset\widetilde{M} is with expectation. It follows that Q\subset\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{\widetilde{X}}(\widetilde{\mathcal{M}})\xrightarrow{\Theta}\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}\xrightarrow{E}Q is a weakly nuclear map, i.e., Q is semidiscrete. ∎ As a consequence, we obtain the corresponding result of [ HI16 ] in the infinite tensor product setting. This also removes the weak amenability assumption in [ Iso19 ] [ Iso20 , Theorem D] , as we do not rely on strong primeness. Corollary 3.5 . Let I and J be index sets and (M_{i},\varphi_{i}) , (N_{j},\psi_{j}) be nonamenable factors for each i\in I and j\in J with faithful normal states. Set M=(\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{i\in I}(M_{i},\varphi_{i}))\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{0} and N=(\,\bar{\otimes}\,_{j\in J}(N_{j},\psi_{j}))\,\bar{\otimes}\,N_{0} , where M_{0} and N_{0} are amenable factors. If each M_{i} is biexact and (N_{j},\psi_{j}) is prime with large centralizer, then M=N implies that there exists a bijection \sigma:J\to I such that M_{\sigma(j)} is stably isomorphic to N_{j} for all j\in J . Proof. This is similar to [ DP23 , Corollary 6.15] . Following the exact same proof of [ HI16 , Lemma 5.2] using Corollary 3.4 in replacement of [ HI16 , Theorem 5.1] , one has that for any j\in J , there exists some \sigma(j)\in I such that M_{\sigma(j)}\prec_{M}N_{j} . Combining with primeness of N_{j} , we further have the stable isomorphism between M_{\sigma(j)} and N_{j} . The fact that \sigma is a bijection follows from the same proof of [ Iso19 , Theorem A] . ∎ 4. Relative solidity in measure equivalence This section is devoted to prove Theorem C and its more technical versions, which are needed for later use. We first show the following measure equivalence version of Theorem C . Theorem 4.1 . Let \Gamma and \Lambda=\Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} be countable groups with \Gamma\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda via a coupling \Omega . Suppose \Lambda_{1} is nonamenable and biexact, and \Sigma<\Gamma is subgroup. If \Sigma\not\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{2} , then C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma) is amenable relative to \Lambda_{2} via \Omega . Moreover, denote by \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) and \Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}},\nu\times c) the associated stably orbit equivalent free ergodic m.p. actions with (X,\mu) realized as a measurable subset of (Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}},\nu\times c) , and set B=L^{\infty}(Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}},\nu\times c) and M=B\rtimes(\Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}) . We then have either zL(\Sigma)\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} or zL(C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)) is amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} in M , for any nonzero \Sigma C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma) -invariant projection z\in L^{\infty}(X) . Proof. Replacing \Lambda_{1} with \Lambda_{1}\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}} and setting Y_{1}=Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}} , we have {\mathcal{R}}({\Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}X})={\mathcal{R}}({\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y_{1}})\cap(X\times X) . Denote by p:=1_{X}\in B=L^{\infty}(Y_{1}) , A:=L^{\infty}(X)=pB , M=B\rtimes\Lambda , \{u_{t}\mid t\in\Gamma\}\subset A\rtimes\Gamma and \{v_{g}\mid g\in\Lambda\}\subset M the canonical unitaries and c:\Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}X\to\Lambda the Zimmer cocycle. We will only show the moreover part, as the first assertion follows by setting z=1_{X} and using Lemma 2.8 . View L\Gamma as a von Neumann subalgebra of pMp and set \Delta:M\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda to be the comultiplication map given by \Delta(bu_{g})=bu_{g}\otimes u_{g} for b\in B and g\in\Lambda . Since zL\Sigma\not\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} , one has (z\otimes 1)\Delta(L\Sigma)\not\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2} . Lemma 3.1 yields conditional expectation E:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda)\to P with E_{\mid M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda} coinciding with the canonical conditional expectation from M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda to P , where P=\Delta(zL\Sigma)^{\prime}\cap(zMz\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda) contains \Delta(zL(C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)) . We follow the idea of [ Din25 , Proposition 3.1] . As \Lambda_{1} is biexact, there exists sequences of u.c.p. maps \alpha_{n}:{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\to{\mathbb{M}}_{k(n)}({\mathbb{C}}) and \beta_{n}:{\mathbb{M}}_{k(n)}({\mathbb{C}})\to{\mathbb{S}}(L\Lambda_{1}) such that \beta_{n}\circ\alpha_{n}\to\operatorname{id}_{L\Lambda_{1}} in the L\Lambda_{1} -topology. Moreover, we may assume \alpha_{n} is normal [ DP23 , Lemma 4.1] . It follows that we have \phi_{n}=:(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\to(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathbb{S}}(L\Lambda_{1})\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda), where \phi_{n}=(\operatorname{id}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}\otimes\beta_{n})\circ(\operatorname{id}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}\otimes\alpha_{n}) , such that \phi_{n}{\mid_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}=\operatorname{id} and \phi_{n}(x)\to x in the M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda -topology for any x\in L\Lambda_{1} , which implies that \phi_{n}(x)\to x in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda -topology for any x\in(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Lambda_{1} (N.B. we do not conclude convergence for all x\in(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{1} ). Here, we have (M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes_{\rm min}{\mathbb{S}}(L\Lambda_{1})\subset{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda) as (M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes{\mathbb{K}}(L\Lambda_{1})\subset{\mathbb{K}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda) . Using the embedding of L\Gamma\subset pMp is given by u_{t}\mapsto\sum_{g\in\Lambda}v_{g}p_{g}^{t} , where p_{g}^{t}\in L^{\infty}(X) is the characteristic function of \{x\in X\mid c(t,x)=g\} , we may produce a sequence of projections \{p_{n}\}\in L^{\infty}(X) that increases to p strongly such that for any t\in\Gamma , there exists some N_{t}\in{\mathbb{N}} with p_{n}u_{t}p_{n}\in B\rtimes_{\rm alg}\Lambda for all n\geq N_{t} . Indeed, for any t\in\Gamma and \varepsilon>0 , we may find a finite subset F_{t,\varepsilon}\subset\Lambda such that \tau(p-\sum_{g\in F_{t,\varepsilon}}p_{g}^{t})<\varepsilon and we set q_{t,\varepsilon}=\sum_{g\in F_{t,\varepsilon}}p_{g}^{t} . After enumerating elements in \Gamma by \{t_{n}\}_{n\in{\mathbb{N}}} , we set p_{n}=\wedge_{i\leq n}q_{t_{i},2^{-n}} . Note that \tau(p-p_{n})\leq n2^{-n} and for any i\leq n , we have p_{n}u_{t_{i}}p_{n}=p_{n}(\sum_{g\in F_{t_{i},2^{-n}}}v_{g}p_{g}^{t})p_{n}\in B\rtimes_{\rm alg}\Lambda . Set \psi_{n}^{0}:pMp\to pMp to be \psi_{n}^{0}(x)=p_{n}xp_{n}+\tau(x)(p-p_{n})/\tau(p) and \psi_{n}=\psi_{n}^{0}\otimes\operatorname{id}_{B(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}} . Then for any t\in\Gamma\setminus\{e\} and n\geq N_{t} , we have \psi_{n}(\Delta(u_{t}))=\sum_{g\in\Lambda}\operatorname{Ad}(p_{n})(v_{g}p_{g}^{t})\otimes v_{g}=\sum_{g\in F}\operatorname{Ad}(p_{n})(v_{g}p_{g}^{t})\otimes v_{g}\in M\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Lambda , for some finite subset F\subset\Lambda depending on n and t . Thus it follows that for any t\in\Gamma and m\geq N_{t} , we have \phi_{n}(\psi_{m}(\Delta(zu_{t})))\to\psi_{m}(\Delta(zu_{t})) in the M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda -topology as \psi_{m}(\Delta(zu_{t}))\in(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Lambda_{1} . Next, notice that \psi_{m}\to\operatorname{id}_{pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda} in the pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,\Lambda -topology as s^{\rho}_{\omega}(p_{n}xp_{n}-x)\leq\rho(p-p_{n})+\omega(p-p_{n}) for any x\in(pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda)_{1} and normal states \rho,\omega\in(pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda)_{*} . We also observe that E:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}}}(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda)\to P is continuous from the weak pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda -topology to the weak P -topology as E_{\mid pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda} is the conditional expectation to P . Now consider the u.c.p. map \theta_{n,m}:=E\circ\phi_{n}\circ\psi_{m}:pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\to P . For any t\in C_{\Gamma}({\Sigma}) , the above argument shows that \lim_{m}\lim_{n}E(\phi_{n}(\psi_{m}(\Delta(zu_{t}))))=\lim_{m}E(\psi_{m}(\Delta(zu_{t}))=E(\Delta(zu_{t}))=\Delta(zu_{t}) in the ultraweak topology of P (equivalently, the weak P -topology of P ). Moreover, for any a\in A , we have E(\phi_{n}(\psi_{m}(a)))=E(\psi_{m}(a))\to E(a) ultraweakly in P . Therefore, if we denote by \theta a limit point of \{\theta_{n,m}\} in the point-weak ∗ topology, then we obtain a state \tau_{P}\circ\theta:pMp\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}\to{\mathbb{C}} that is \{\Delta(zu_{t})\mid t\in C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)\} -central and (\tau\circ\theta)_{\mid zB\otimes 1} coincides with its trace. Regarding M\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Lambda_{1})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}=\langle B\rtimes(\Lambda\times\Lambda),e_{B\rtimes(\Lambda\times\Lambda_{2})}\rangle , where \{e\}\times\Lambda acts trivially on B , we may apply Lemma 2.5 to conclude that \Delta(zL(C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma))) is amenable relative to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2} in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda , which implies that zL(C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)) is amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} in M by Lemma 2.3 . ∎ Remark 4.2 . Note that from the biexactness assumption, we derive a sequence of u.c.p. maps \phi_{n} that only converges to identity on (M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2})\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Lambda_{1} . This is exactly the technical issue in [ Din25 , Proposition 3.1] and [ Iso20 , Proposition 7.3] , which was overcame by the extra assumption of weak amenability. However, the measure equivalence setting here allows us to construct approximation maps \psi_{n} from above to circumvent this issue. Corollary 4.3 . Let \Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) and \Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y,\nu) be p.m.p. free ergodic actions of countable groups and denote by {\mathcal{R}}={\mathcal{R}}(\Gamma{\,\curvearrowright\,}X) , {\mathcal{S}}={\mathcal{R}}(\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y) . Suppose L({\mathcal{R}}) and L({\mathcal{S}}) are full. If \Gamma is biexact, then {\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{R}}\times{\mathcal{S}})={\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{R}}){\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{S}}) . Proof. Suppose t\in{\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{R}}\times{\mathcal{S}}) and we have {\mathcal{R}}\times{\mathcal{S}}=({\mathcal{R}}\times{\mathcal{S}})^{t}={\mathcal{R}}\times{\mathcal{S}}^{t}=:{\mathcal{K}}\times{\mathcal{L}} , and we further denote {\mathcal{K}}=L^{\infty}(X_{1})\rtimes\Gamma_{1} , {\mathcal{L}}=L^{\infty}(Y_{1})\rtimes\Lambda_{1} and by \Omega the ME coupling between \Gamma\times\Lambda and \Gamma_{1}\times\Lambda_{1} . Following [ Iso20 ] , we claim that one has \Lambda\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{1} , or \Gamma_{1}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda . Indeed, if \Lambda\not\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{1} and \Gamma_{1}\not\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda , we then have L\Gamma is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Lambda_{1} , as well as A\rtimes\Lambda_{1} is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Lambda by Theorem 4.1 and Lemma 2.8 , where A=L^{\infty}(X\times Y)=L^{\infty}(X_{1}\times Y_{1}) . By [ OP10 ] , we have L\Gamma is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Lambda in A\rtimes(\Gamma\times\Lambda)=:M , which implies \Gamma is amenable. In the case of \Lambda\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{1} , we have 1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}})\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Lambda_{1} by Lemma 2.8 . Using the fact that L({\mathcal{S}}) is full, we have 1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}})\prec_{M}1\otimes L({\mathcal{L}}) by [ Hof16 , Proposition 6.3] and hence u^{*}(1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}}))u\subset 1\otimes L({\mathcal{L}})^{s}\subset L({\mathcal{K}})^{1/s}\,\bar{\otimes}\,L({\mathcal{L}})^{s} for some s>0 and u\in{\mathcal{U}}(M) . It follows that L({\mathcal{L}})^{s}=u^{*}(1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}}))u\,\bar{\otimes}\,P and u^{*}(L({\mathcal{R}})\otimes 1)u=P\,\bar{\otimes}\,L({\mathcal{K}})^{1/s} , where P=(u^{*}(1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}}))u)^{\prime}\cap L({\mathcal{L}})^{s} . Since L({\mathcal{R}}) is solid [ Oza06 ] , one has P={\mathbb{M}}_{n}({\mathbb{C}}) for some n\in{\mathbb{N}} . Lastly, notice from above one has u^{*}(1\otimes L^{\infty}(Y))u\prec_{1\otimes L({\mathcal{L}})^{s}}L^{\infty}(Y_{1})^{s} and L^{\infty}(X_{1})^{1/s}\prec_{u^{*}(L({\mathcal{R}})\otimes 1)u}u^{*}(L^{\infty}(X)\otimes 1)u . It then follows from [ Pop06a ] that {\mathcal{R}}={\mathcal{K}}^{n/s}={\mathcal{R}}^{n/s} and {\mathcal{S}}^{n}={\mathcal{L}}^{s}={\mathcal{S}}^{ts} , i.e, n/s\in{\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{R}}) and ts/n\in{\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{S}}) , as desired. If \Gamma_{1}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda , by a similar argument we have v^{*}(L({\mathcal{K}})\otimes 1)v\subset 1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}})^{k} for some k>0 and v\in{\mathcal{U}}(M) and hence 1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}})^{k}=v^{*}(L({\mathcal{K}})\otimes 1)v\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q and v^{*}(1\otimes L({\mathcal{L}}))v=L({\mathcal{R}})^{1/k}\,\bar{\otimes}\,Q , where Q=(v^{*}(L({\mathcal{K}})\otimes q)v)^{\prime}\cap(1\otimes L({\mathcal{S}})^{k})={\mathbb{M}}_{m}({\mathbb{C}}) for some m\in{\mathbb{N}} by fullness of L({\mathcal{L}}) . The same argument as above then shows {\mathcal{S}}^{k}={\mathcal{K}}^{m}={\mathcal{R}}^{m} and {\mathcal{S}}^{t}={\mathcal{L}}={\mathcal{R}}^{m/k} and hence t\in{\mathcal{F}}({\mathcal{S}}) . ∎ 4.1. Technical variants In this section, we prove technical variants of Theorem 4.1 for later use. We will assume the following notation throughout. Notation 4.4 . Let \Lambda be a countable i.c.c. group that is measure equivalent to a group \Gamma . By using [ Fur99 , Lemma 3.2] , there exist positive integers d\leq\ell , free ergodic p.m.p. actions \Gamma\curvearrowright(X,\mu) and \Lambda\curvearrowright(Y,\nu) such that \mathcal{R}(\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y)=\mathcal{R}(\Gamma\times\mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z}\curvearrowright X\times\mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z})\cap(Y\times Y), {\mathcal{R}}(\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})={\mathcal{R}}(\Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}})\cap((X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})\times(X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})). Here, we considered that \mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z}\curvearrowright(\mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z},c) acts by addition and c is the counting measure and similarly for \ell . We also identified X\times\mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z} as a measurable subset of Y\times\mathbb{Z}/\ell\mathbb{Z} . Y=Y\times\{0\} as a measurable subset of X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}} . Denote p=1_{Y}\in L^{\infty}(X\times\mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z}) and q=1_{X}\in L^{\infty}(Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}}) . Letting B=L^{\infty}(Y) , A=L^{\infty}(X)\otimes{\mathbb{M}}_{d}(\mathbb{C}) , B_{1}=L^{\infty}(Y)\otimes{\mathbb{M}}_{\ell}({\mathbb{C}}) and M=A\rtimes\Gamma , we have pMp=B\rtimes\Lambda and B\subset pAp , as well as M=q(B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda)q and A\subset qB_{1}q . Denote by \{u_{g}\}_{g\in\Gamma} and \{v_{\lambda}\}_{\lambda\in\Lambda} the canonical unitaries implementing the actions \Gamma\curvearrowright A and \Lambda\curvearrowright B , respectively. Following [ PV10 ] we define the * -homomorphism \Delta:B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda\to(B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda)\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda) by \Delta(bv_{\lambda})=bv_{\lambda}\otimes v_{\lambda} , for all b\in B_{1},\lambda\in\Lambda . We may then restrict \Delta to a * -homomorphism \Delta:q(B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda)q=M\to M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda) and verify that \Delta(M)^{\prime}\cap M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda)=\mathbb{C}1 since \Lambda is i.c.c. Theorem 4.5 . With Notation 4.4 , suppose \Gamma=\Gamma_{1}\times\Gamma_{2} with \Gamma_{1} nonamenable and biexact. Then for any \Sigma<\Gamma and any nonzero \Delta(\Sigma C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)) -invariant projection z\in L^{\infty}(X\times X) we have either z\Delta(L(\Sigma))\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes\Gamma_{2} or z\Delta(L(C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma)) is amenable relative to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M . Proof. Consider \Psi^{0}:A\rtimes\Gamma\ni au_{t}\mapsto au_{t}\otimes u_{t}\in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma and its extension \Psi:=\operatorname{id}_{M}\otimes\Psi^{0}:M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma)\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma). Denote by {\mathcal{M}}=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma and {\mathbb{X}} the {\mathcal{M}} -boundary piece associated with M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} . Since \Gamma_{1} is biexact, we have a sequence of u.c.p. maps \phi_{n}:{\mathcal{P}}:=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Gamma_{1})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2}\to{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}}({\mathcal{M}}) with {\phi_{n}}_{\mid M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2}}=\operatorname{id} and \phi_{n}(x)\to x in the {\mathcal{M}} -topology for any x\in L\Gamma_{1} . Set N=z\Delta(L\Sigma) and N_{1}=\Psi(z\Delta(L\Sigma)) . Assuming N\not\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) , we have N_{1}\not\prec_{{\mathcal{M}}}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} and hence there exists an N_{2} -central state \varphi:{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}}({\mathcal{M}})\to{\mathbb{C}} such that \varphi_{\mid\tilde{z}{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{z}}=\tau by Lemma 3.1 , where N_{2}=N_{1}^{\prime}\cap\tilde{z}{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{z} and \tilde{z}=\Psi(z)=z\otimes 1_{L\Gamma} . We claim that we may find a sequence of u.c.p. maps \theta_{i}:{\mathcal{P}}\to{\mathcal{P}} such that for any x\in\Psi\big(z\Delta({\mathbb{C}}\Gamma)\big) we have \theta_{i}(x)\in(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M)\otimes_{{\operatorname{alg}}}L\Gamma for large enough i and \theta_{i}(x)\to x in the point {\mathcal{M}} -topology, similar to the argument in Theorem 4.1 . Proceeds as in Theorem 4.1 , we then obtain a \Psi(\Delta(\Sigma^{c})) -invariant state \psi on {\mathcal{P}} that restricts to the trace on zL^{\infty}(X\times X) , where \Sigma^{c}=C_{\Gamma}(\Sigma) . It then follows from Lemma 2.5 that \Psi(z\Delta(L\Sigma^{c})) is amenable relative to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} in {\mathcal{M}} , which in turns implies z\Delta(L\Sigma^{c}) is amenable relative to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M by Lemma 2.3 . To see the existence of such \theta_{i} , we first analyze z\Delta(u_{t})\in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M for t\in\Gamma . Set X_{1}=X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}} , \tilde{\Gamma}=\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}} , Y_{1}=Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}} and \tilde{\Lambda}=\Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}} . For each t\in\Gamma , we have u_{t}=\sum_{g\in\tilde{\Lambda}}q_{g}^{t}v_{g} , where q_{g}^{t}\in L^{\infty}(Y_{1}) forms a partition of q=1_{X_{1}}\in L^{\infty}(Y_{1}) . Similarly, we have v_{g}=\sum_{t\in\tilde{\Gamma}}p_{t}^{g}u_{t} for each g\in\Lambda , where p_{t}^{g}\in L^{\infty}(Y) forms a partition of p=1_{Y}\in L^{\infty}(X_{1}) . It follows that \Delta(u_{t})=\sum_{(g,h)\in\tilde{\Lambda}}q_{(g,h)}^{t}v_{(g,h)}\otimes v_{g} and \Psi(\Delta(u_{t}))=\sum_{(g,h)\in\tilde{\Lambda}}\sum_{(s,r)\in\tilde{\Gamma}}q_{(g,h)}^{t}v_{g}\otimes p_{(s,r)}^{g}u_{(s,r)}\otimes u_{s}. The same argument as in Theorem 4.1 produces two sequences of projections \{q_{n}\},\{p_{m}\}\subset L^{\infty}(X_{1}) strongly increasing to q and p , respectively. And for each t\in\Gamma (resp. g\in\Lambda ), there exists N_{t}\in{\mathbb{N}} (resp. M_{g}\in{\mathbb{N}} ) such that q_{n}\sum_{g\in\Lambda_{1}}q_{g}^{t}=q_{n}\sum_{g\in F}q_{g}^{t} (resp. p_{m}\sum_{s\in\Gamma}p_{s}^{g}=p_{m}\sum_{s\in E}p_{s}^{g} ) for any n\geq N_{t} (resp. m\geq M_{g} ), where F\subset\Lambda_{1} and E\subset\Gamma_{1} are some finite sets. Now we view p_{n}\in L^{\infty}(X_{1})\rtimes\tilde{\Gamma}=M and consider \alpha_{n}(q)=\operatorname{Ad}(q_{n})(x)+\tau_{M}(x)q_{n}^{\perp} as a u.c.p. map on M . Similarly, we consider \beta_{m}^{0}(x)=\operatorname{Ad}(p_{m})(x)+\tau_{M}(x)p_{m}^{\perp} for x\in M and set \beta_{m}=\beta_{m}^{0}\otimes\operatorname{id}_{{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Gamma_{1})\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2}} . Put \theta_{n,m}:=\alpha_{n}\otimes\beta_{m}\in UCP({\mathcal{P}}) and enumerate \Gamma=\{t_{i}\}_{i\in{\mathbb{N}}} . For each i\in{\mathbb{N}} , set n_{i}:=\max_{j\leq i}\{N_{t_{j}}\} , F_{i}\subset\Lambda_{1} to be a finite such that q_{n_{i}}\sum_{g\in\Lambda_{1}}q_{g}^{t_{j}}=q_{n_{i}}\sum_{g\in F_{i}}q_{g}^{t_{j}} for all j\leq i , and m_{i}:=\max_{g\in\pi(F_{i})}\{M_{g}\} , where \pi:\Lambda_{1}\to\Lambda is the quotient. It follows that \theta_{i}(\Psi(\Delta(u_{t_{j}})))=\sum_{(g,h)\in F_{i}}\sum_{{(s,r)}\in E}q_{n_{i}}(q_{(g,h)}^{t}v_{(g,h)})q_{n_{i}}\otimes p_{m_{i}}(p_{(s,r)}^{g}u_{(s,r)})p_{m_{i}}\otimes u_{s}\in M\otimes_{\rm alg}M\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Gamma for all j\leq i , where \theta_{i}:=\theta_{(n_{i},m_{i})} and E\subset\Gamma_{1} is some finite subset. Finally, since z\in L^{\infty}(X\times X) is in the multiplicative domain of \theta_{i}\circ\Psi , we have \theta_{i}(\Psi(z\Delta(u_{t_{j}})))=(z\otimes 1_{L\Gamma})\theta_{i}(\Psi(\Delta(u_{t_{j}})))\in(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M)\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Gamma, as desired. ∎ The following is another variation of Theorem 4.1 . Although it is more involved, the proof follows the same ideas as in Theorem 4.1 and Theorem 4.5 . Theorem 4.6 . With Notation 4.4 , we assume in addition that \Lambda=\Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} . Set {\mathcal{M}}=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(L\Lambda_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda_{2}) , \tilde{\mathcal{M}}=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M and \sigma\in\operatorname{Aut}({\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}}) given by \sigma((x\otimes v_{g}\otimes v_{h})\otimes(y\otimes v_{g^{\prime}}\otimes v_{h^{\prime}}))=(x\otimes v_{g^{\prime}}\otimes v_{h})\otimes(y\otimes v_{g}\otimes v_{h^{\prime}}) , where x,y\in M , g,g^{\prime}\in\Lambda_{1} and h,h^{\prime}\in\Lambda_{2} . Suppose that \Gamma=\Gamma_{1}\times\Gamma_{2} with \Gamma_{1} nonamenable and biexact, \Sigma<\Gamma is a subgroup and \Sigma^{c} denotes the centralizer of \Sigma in \Gamma . Then we have either \sigma\big(\Delta(L(\Sigma))\,\bar{\otimes}\,\Delta({L(\Gamma)})\big)z\prec_{{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) or \sigma\big((\Delta(L(\Sigma^{c}))\otimes 1)\big)z is amenable relative to {\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) in {\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}} , for any nonzero projection z\in(A\otimes 1_{L(\Lambda)})\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\,\bar{\otimes}\,A)\subset{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}} that is \sigma\big(\Delta(\Sigma\Sigma^{c})\otimes\Delta(\Gamma)\big) -invariant. Similarly, we have either \sigma\big(\Delta({L(\Gamma)})\otimes\Delta(L(\Sigma))\big)z\prec_{{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) or \sigma\big(1\otimes\Delta(L(\Sigma^{c}))\big)z is amenable relative to {\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) in {\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}} , for any nonzero projection z\in(A\otimes 1_{L(\Lambda)})\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\,\bar{\otimes}\,A)\subset{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}} that is \sigma\big(\Delta(\Sigma\Sigma^{c})\otimes\Delta(\Gamma)\big) -invariant. Proof. Consider \Theta_{0}:A\rtimes\Gamma\ni au_{t}\mapsto au_{t}\otimes u_{t}\in M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma and its extension \Theta:=\operatorname{id}_{\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}\otimes\Theta_{0}:(\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M)\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma)\to(\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M)\,\bar{\otimes}\,(M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma). Denote by {\mathcal{M}}_{1}=\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M , {\mathcal{M}}_{2}={\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma and {\mathbb{X}} the {\mathcal{M}}_{2} -boundary piece associated with the subalgebra {\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} . Since \Gamma_{1} is biexact, we have a sequence of u.c.p. maps \phi_{n}:{\mathcal{P}}:={\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Gamma_{1})\to{\mathbb{S}}_{{\mathbb{X}}}({\mathcal{M}}_{2}) with {\phi_{n}}_{\mid{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2}}=\operatorname{id} and \phi_{n}(x)\to x in the {\mathcal{M}}_{2} -topology for any x\in L\Gamma_{1} . In particular, we have \phi_{n}(x)\to x in the {\mathcal{M}}_{2} -topology for any x\in({\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2})\otimes_{\rm alg}L\Gamma_{1} . Set N=\sigma\big((\Delta(L\Sigma)\,\bar{\otimes}\,\Delta(L\Gamma)\big)z\subset z({\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}})z and N_{1}=\Theta(N)\subset z{\mathcal{M}}_{2}z , where we view z=z\otimes 1_{L\Gamma}\in{\mathcal{M}}_{2} . By assumption we have N\not\prec_{{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) , then we have N_{1}\not\prec_{{\mathcal{M}}_{2}}{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} . It follows that there exists a N_{2} -central state \varphi:{\mathbb{S}}_{\mathbb{X}}({\mathcal{M}}_{2})\to{\mathbb{C}} with \varphi_{\mid z{\mathcal{M}}_{2}z}=\tau , where N_{2}=N_{1}^{\prime}\cap z{\mathcal{M}}_{2}z . We claim that we may find a sequence of u.c.p. maps \theta_{i}:{\mathcal{P}}\to{\mathcal{P}} such that for any x\in\Theta\big(\sigma\big(\Delta({\mathbb{C}}\Gamma)\otimes 1)\big)z\big) we have \theta_{m}(x)\in({\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M)\otimes_{{\operatorname{alg}}}{\mathbb{C}}\Gamma for large enough m and \theta_{i}\to\operatorname{id}_{{\mathcal{M}}_{2}} in the point {\mathcal{M}}_{2} -topology. Similar to the proof of Theorem 4.1 , this then yields a \Theta(\sigma\big((\Delta(\Sigma^{c})\otimes 1)\big)z\big) -central state \psi on {\mathcal{P}} that restrict to the trace on z({\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}})z . We may view {\mathcal{M}}_{2}=(A\,\bar{\otimes}\,1\,\bar{\otimes}\,A\,\bar{\otimes}\,A)\rtimes((\Gamma\times\Lambda\times\Gamma\times\Gamma)\times\Gamma) , where \{e\}\times\Gamma acts trivially, and {\mathcal{P}}=\langle{\mathcal{M}}_{2},e_{{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{1}}\rangle=\langle\mathcal{A}\rtimes(\Upsilon\times\Gamma),e_{\mathcal{A}\rtimes(\Upsilon\times\Gamma_{1})}\rangle, where \mathcal{A}=A\,\bar{\otimes}\,1\,\bar{\otimes}\,A\,\bar{\otimes}\,A and \Upsilon=\Gamma\times\Lambda\times\Gamma\times\Gamma . Thus we are in the situation of Lemma 2.5 and hence {\Theta\big(\sigma\big(\Delta(L\Sigma^{c})\otimes 1\big)z\big)} is amenable relative to {\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Gamma_{2} in {\mathcal{P}} , which in turns implies \sigma(\Delta(L\Sigma^{c})\otimes 1)z is amenable relative to M_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,(A\rtimes\Gamma_{2}) in \tilde{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,\tilde{\mathcal{M}} . To see the existence of such \theta_{i} , we first analyze \sigma(\Delta(u_{t})\otimes 1))\in{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathcal{M}} for t\in\Gamma . For each t\in\Gamma , we have u_{t}=\sum_{g\in\Lambda}p_{g}^{t}v_{g} , where p_{g}^{t}\in B_{1} forms a partition of q=1_{X} . Similarly, we have v_{g}=\sum_{t\in\Gamma}q_{t}^{g}u_{t} for each g\in\Lambda , where \{q_{t}^{g}\}_{t\in\Gamma}\subset A forms a partition of p=1_{Y} . Writing g=(g_{1},g_{2})\in\Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2} , we have \sigma(\Delta(u_{t})\otimes 1)=\sum_{g\in\Lambda}(p_{g}^{t}v_{g}\otimes v_{e}\otimes v_{g_{2}})\otimes(1_{M}\otimes v_{g_{1}}\otimes v_{e}), and hence \Theta(\sigma(\Delta(u_{t})\otimes 1))=\sum_{g\in\Lambda}\sum_{s\in\Gamma}(p_{g}^{t}v_{g}\otimes v_{e}\otimes v_{g_{2}})\otimes(1_{M}\otimes q_{s}^{(g_{1},e)}u_{s}\otimes u_{s}). The same argument as in Theorem 4.1 produces two sequences of projections \{p_{n}\}\subset B and \{q_{m}\}\subset A such that they increase to 1 strongly and for each t\in\Gamma (resp. g\in\Lambda ), there exists N_{t}\in{\mathbb{N}} (resp. M_{g}\in{\mathbb{N}} ) such that p_{n}\sum_{g\in\Lambda}p_{g}^{t}=p_{n}\sum_{g\in F}p_{g}^{t} (resp. q_{m}\sum_{s\in\Gamma}q_{s}^{g}=q_{m}\sum_{s\in E}q_{s}^{g} ) for any n\geq N_{t} (resp. m\geq M_{g} ), where F\subset\Lambda and E\subset\Gamma are some finite sets. Now we view p_{n}=p_{n}\otimes 1_{L\Lambda\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}=M\,\bar{\otimes}\,L\Lambda\otimes 1_{M}\subset{\mathcal{M}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M={\mathcal{M}}_{1} and consider \alpha_{n}(x)=\operatorname{Ad}(p_{n})(x)+\tau_{{\mathcal{M}}_{1}}(x)p_{n}^{\perp} as a u.c.p. map on {\mathcal{M}}_{1} . Similarly, we consider \beta_{m}^{0}(x)=\operatorname{Ad}(q_{m})(x)+\tau_{M}(x)q_{m}^{\perp} for x\in M and set \beta_{m}=\beta_{m}^{0}\otimes\operatorname{id}_{L\Gamma_{2}\,\bar{\otimes}\,{\mathbb{B}}(\ell^{2}\Gamma_{1})} . Put \theta_{n,m}:=\alpha_{n}\otimes\beta_{m}\in UCP({\mathcal{P}}) and enumerate \Gamma=\{t_{i}\}_{i\in{\mathbb{N}}} . For each i\in{\mathbb{N}} , set n_{i}:=\max_{j\leq i}\{N_{t_{i}}\} , F_{i}\subset\Lambda to be a finite such that p_{n_{i}}\sum_{g\in\Lambda}p_{g}^{t_{j}}=p_{n_{i}}\sum_{g\in F_{i}}p_{g}^{t_{j}} for all i\leq j , and m_{i}:=\max_{g\in F_{i}}\{M_{(g_{1},e)}\} , where g=(g_{1},g_{2}) . It follows that \theta_{i}(\Theta(\sigma(\Delta(u_{t_{j}})\otimes 1)))=\sum_{g\in F_{i}}\sum_{s\in E}(p_{n_{i}}(p_{g}^{t}v_{g})p_{n}\otimes v_{e}\otimes v_{g_{2}})\otimes(1_{M}\otimes q_{m_{i}}q_{s}^{(g_{1},e)}u_{s}q_{m_{i}}\otimes u_{s})\in{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\otimes_{\rm alg}{\mathbb{C}}\Gamma for all j\leq i , where \theta_{i}:=\theta_{(n_{i},m_{i})} and E\subset\Gamma is some finite subset. Lastly, note that \theta_{i} is \mathcal{A} -bimodular and \Theta(z)=z\otimes 1_{L\Gamma} and hence \theta_{i}\Big(\Theta\big(\sigma\big(\Delta(u_{t_{j}})\otimes 1\big)z\big)\Big)=\theta_{i}\Big(\Theta\big(\sigma\big(\Delta(u_{t_{j}}\otimes 1\big)\big)\Big)(z\otimes 1_{L\Gamma})\in{\mathcal{M}}_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M\otimes_{\rm alg}{\mathbb{C}}\Gamma, as desired. ∎ 5. Proofs of Theorem A and Theorem D Throughout this section we assume Notation 4.4 that will be used in the proofs of Theorem A and Theorem D . Lemma 5.1 . Assume that \Gamma=\times_{i=1}^{n}\Gamma_{i} and \Gamma_{1},\dots,\Gamma_{n} are nonamenable biexact. Let \Sigma_{1},\Sigma_{2} be commuting subgroups of \Lambda satisfying [\Lambda:\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}]<\infty . Then there exist a non-zero projection e\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} and disjoint subsets T_{1},T_{2}\subset\{1,\dots,n\} such that L(\Sigma_{i})e is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{i}} inside M for any i\in\{1,2\} . Moreover, note that for any non-zero projection r\in B one can choose e\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} with re\neq 0 . Proof. We only prove the moreover part. Since B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} is completely atomic, let e\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} be a projection such that B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}}e=\mathbb{C}e and re\neq 0 . By [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] for any i\in\{1,2\} there exists a minimal subset T_{i}\subset\{1,\dots,n\} such that L(\Sigma_{i})e is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{i}} . Assume by contradiction that there is j\in T_{1}\cap T_{2} . By Theorem 4.1 , we get that L(\Sigma_{1})e\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}} or L(\Sigma_{2})e is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}} . By [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] the second possibility contradicts the minimality of T_{2} . Assume now that L(\Sigma_{1})e\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}} holds. Since \Lambda is i.c.c., we get that \mathcal{N}_{pMp}(L(\Sigma_{1}))^{\prime}\cap pMp\subset B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} . Since B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}}e=\mathbb{C}e we further deduce that L(\Sigma_{1})e\prec_{M}^{s}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}} . This would imply by [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.6(3)] that L(\Sigma_{1})e is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}} , which contradicts the minimality of T_{1} . ∎ 5.1. Proof of Theorem A We first define a relative version of the flip automorphism from [ IM22 ] (see also [ Dri23 ] ). Define \mathcal{M}=M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda) and let \sigma\in{\rm Aut}(\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M}) be defined by \sigma((m\otimes v_{h_{1}}\otimes v_{h_{2}})\otimes(m^{\prime}\otimes v_{h^{\prime}_{1}}\otimes v_{h^{\prime}_{2}}))=(m\otimes v_{h^{\prime}_{1}}\otimes v_{h_{2}})\otimes(m^{\prime}\otimes v_{h_{1}}\otimes v_{h^{\prime}_{2}}) for all m,m^{\prime}\in M , h_{1},h_{1}^{\prime}\in\Lambda_{1} and h_{2},h_{2}^{\prime}\in\Lambda_{2} . Define \Delta:M\to\mathcal{M} by letting \Delta(av_{h})=av_{h}\otimes v_{h} , for all a\in A and h\in\Lambda . Note that there are 2n commuting subalgebras in \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma))\otimes\Delta(L(\Gamma)))\subset\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M} denoted R_{1},\dots,R_{2n} . More precisely, R_{i}=\sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma_{i}))\otimes 1) if 1\leq i\leq n and R_{i}=\sigma(1\otimes\Delta(L(\Gamma_{i}))) if n+1\leq i\leq 2n . Denote \tilde{p}=1\otimes p , \tilde{\mathcal{M}}=M\bar{\otimes}M and note that \mathcal{M}\subset\tilde{p}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{p} . Since \Lambda is i.c.c., note that \mathcal{N}_{{\mathcal{M}}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{p}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{p}}(R_{i})^{\prime}\cap{\mathcal{M}}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{p}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{p}\subset\sigma(\Delta(M)\bar{\otimes}\Delta(M))^{\prime}\cap{\mathcal{M}}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{p}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}\tilde{p}=:\mathcal{B}\subset A\bar{\otimes}1\bar{\otimes}A\bar{\otimes}B , for any 1\leq i\leq 2n . By applying Theorem 4.6 , we get that for any non-zero projection z\in\mathcal{B} and for all 1\leq k\leq 2n and 1\leq j\leq n , we have R_{\hat{k}}z\prec_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{j}}) or R_{k}z is amenable relative to \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{j}}) inside \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}} . Note that it is not possible to find 1\leq k\leq n such that R_{k}z and R_{k+n}z are both amenable relative to \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{j}}) for all 1\leq j\leq n . Indeed, if there would exist such k , then [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] implies that R_{k}z and R_{k+n}z are both amenable relative to \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\otimes 1 . By letting z_{0}\in R_{\hat{k}}^{\prime}\cap\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M} be the support projection of E_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M}}(z) , it follows by [ Dri23 , Lemma 2.4] that R_{k}z_{0} and R_{k+n}z_{0} are both amenable relative to \mathcal{M}\otimes 1 inside \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M} . Since E_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M}}(z)\in A\otimes 1\otimes A\otimes 1 , it follows that \sigma(z_{0})=z_{0} . By considering the flip automorphism \sigma , we derive that (\Delta(L(\Gamma_{k}))\otimes 1)z_{0} is amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda_{2})\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda_{1}) , but also amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda_{1})\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda_{2}) inside \mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M} . By using once again [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] , we get that (\Delta(L(\Gamma_{k}))\otimes 1)z_{0} is amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}1\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}1 , which implies by [ Dri23 , Lemma 2.4] and [ IPV13 , Lemma 10.2] that \Gamma_{k} is amenable, contradiction. Hence, by [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.4] it follows that any non-zero projection z\in\mathcal{B} and for any 1\leq k\leq n , there exist a non-zero projection z_{1}\in\mathcal{B} with z\geq z_{1} and 1\leq j\leq n satisfying R_{\hat{k}}z_{1}\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{j}}) or R_{\widehat{k+n}}z_{1}\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{j}}) . Using this observation finitely many times, one can construct a function f:\{1,\dots,n\}\to\{1,\dots,n\} and a decreasing sequence of non-zero projections z_{1}\geq z_{2}\geq\dots\geq z_{n} from \mathcal{B} with the property that R_{\hat{k}}z_{k}\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{f(k)}}) or R_{\widehat{k+n}}z_{k}\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{f(k)}}) for any 1\leq k\leq n . Put s=z_{n} . Next, note that f is bijective. Otherwise, by [ CDAD23b , Proposition 4.4] there is 1\leq\ell\leq n such that \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma)))\prec_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{\ell}}). Since \sigma_{|(A\otimes 1)\bar{\otimes}(A\otimes 1)}={\rm id}_{|(A\otimes 1)\bar{\otimes}(A\otimes 1)}, [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] implies that \sigma(\Delta(M)\bar{\otimes}\Delta(M))\prec_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{\ell}}). Using the definition of \sigma , this further implies that \Delta(M)\prec_{M\bar{\otimes}M}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{\ell}}) . By [ IPV13 , Lemma 10.2] we deduce that L(\Lambda)\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{\ell}} , which contradicts the fact that \Gamma_{\ell} is an infinite group. This shows that f is bijective. Next, one can define a partition \{1,\dots,n\}=T_{1}\sqcup T_{2} by \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma_{\widehat{k}})))s\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{f(k)}}),\text{ for all }k\in T_{2}, and \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma_{\widehat{k}}))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma)))s\prec^{s}_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{f(k)}}),\text{ for all }k\in T_{1}. By [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.8(2)] this further implies that \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{2}}}))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{1}}})))\prec_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\tilde{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}A Since \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{2}}}))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{1}}})))\subset\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}\mathcal{M} , we further deduce that \sigma(\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{2}}}))\bar{\otimes}\Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{1}}})))\prec_{\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}{\mathcal{M}}}\mathcal{M}\bar{\otimes}M\bar{\otimes}1. By applying the flip autmorphism \sigma to the above intertwining, it follows that \Delta(L(\Gamma_{{T_{i}}}))\prec_{\mathcal{M}}M\bar{\otimes}L(\Lambda_{i}) for any 1\leq i\leq 2 . This implies that L(\Gamma_{T_{i}})\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Lambda_{i} for any 1\leq i\leq 2 . By Lemma 2.11 and Lemma 2.8 we get the conclusion of the proof. \square Remark 5.2 . There is an alternative way to end the proof of Theorem A by avoiding the use of Lemma 2.11 : Let k\in T_{2} . Then by Theorem 4.1 , we get that L(\Lambda_{1})\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{k}} or L(\Lambda_{2}) is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{k}} . If the second possibility holds, then by [ Ber15 , Lemma 2.11] , we get that B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{k}} . Together with A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{2}} being amenable relative to B\rtimes\Lambda_{2} , we get by [ OP10 ] that \Gamma_{k} is amenable, contradiction. Hence, L(\Lambda_{1})\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{k}} for any k\in T_{2} . This implies that L(\Lambda_{1})\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{1}}, and consequently, B\rtimes\Lambda_{1}\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{1}} . The proof now concludes by using either Lemma 2.12 or by [ DHI19 , Proposition 3.1] . 5.2. Proof of Theorem D For any 1\leq i\leq n since \Gamma_{i} is biexact, Theorem 4.5 implies that \Delta(L(\Gamma_{n})) is amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{i}}) or \Delta(L(\Gamma_{\hat{n}}))\prec_{M\bar{\otimes}M}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{i}}) . Note that if \Delta(L(\Gamma_{n})) is amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{i}}) for any i , it follows from [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] that \Delta(L(\Gamma_{n})) is amenable relative to M\bar{\otimes}1 . This implies by [ IPV13 , Lemma 10.2] that \Gamma_{n} is amenable, contradiction. Therefore, there is j such that \Delta(L(\Gamma_{\hat{n}}))\prec_{M\bar{\otimes}M}M\bar{\otimes}(A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}}) . Since \Gamma_{\widehat{n}} has property (T), it follows that \Delta(L(\Gamma_{\hat{n}}))\prec_{M\bar{\otimes}M}M\bar{\otimes}(A_{\hat{j}}\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{j}}) . By using Ioana’s ultrapower technique [ Ioa12 , Theorem 3.1] (see also [ CdSS16 , Theorem 3.3] , [ KV17 , Lemma 5.6] and [ DHI19 , Theorem 4.1] ), it follows that there is a subgroup \Sigma<\Lambda with non-amenable centralizer C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma) such that L(\Gamma_{\widehat{n}})\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Sigma . By applying [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] , we deduce that A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Sigma . By using [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.4(2)] there is a non-zero projection r\in\mathcal{N}_{pMp}(B\rtimes\Sigma)^{\prime}\cap pMp\subset B^{\Sigma C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma)} such that (1) A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma)s\text{ for any non-zero projection }s\in B^{\Sigma}r. Next, we claim that (B\rtimes\Sigma)r\prec_{M}^{s}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\hat{n}} . Let s be a non-zero projection in B^{\Sigma C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma)} . By Theorem 4.1 and [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] , it follows that for any i\in\{1,\dots,n-1\} we have (A\rtimes\Sigma)s\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{i}} or L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma))s is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{i}} . The first possibility together with ( 1 ) and [ Dri20 , Lemma 2.4] imply that A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{i}} , which implies that \Gamma_{i} is not infinite, contradiction. Hence, L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma))s is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{i}} for any i\in\{1,\dots,n-1\} , which implies by [ PV14a , Proposition 2.7] that L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma))s is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{n} . Since C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma) is nonamenable, we deduce that L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma))s is not amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}} . By using once again By Theorem 4.1 and [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] , we get that (A\rtimes\Sigma)s\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}} , proving the claim. By [ DHI19 , Proposition 3.1] , \Sigma is measure equivalent to \Gamma_{\hat{n}} , and hence by [ Fur99 , Corollary 1.4] , it follows that \Sigma has property (T). It thus implies that L(\Sigma)e\prec_{M}^{s}M_{\hat{n}} . Note that \Delta:=\{\lambda\in\Lambda\;|\;\mathcal{O}_{\Sigma}(\lambda)\text{ is finite}\} is normalized by \Sigma , where \mathcal{O}_{\Sigma}(\lambda)=\{\eta\lambda\eta^{-1}\;|\;\eta\in\Sigma\} . Let f\in B^{\Delta\Sigma}e be a non-zero projection. By passing twice to relative commutants we note that M_{n}\prec(B\rtimes\Delta\Sigma)f , and thus, B^{\Delta\Sigma}f\prec_{M}M_{\hat{n}} . Also, by passing to relative commutants in ( 1 ), we get that B^{\Delta\Sigma}f\prec_{M}M_{n} . Since \mathcal{N}_{pMp}(B^{\Delta\Sigma})^{\prime}\cap pMp\subset B^{\Delta\Sigma} it follows from [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.4] that B^{\Delta\Sigma}e\prec_{M}^{s}M_{\hat{n}} and B^{\Delta\Sigma}e\prec_{M}^{s}M_{n} . By [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.8(2)] it follows that B^{\Delta\Sigma}e\prec_{M}^{s}\mathbb{C}1 , which implies that there is a non-zero projection f_{0}\in B^{\Delta\Sigma}e such that B^{\Delta\Sigma}f_{0}=\mathbb{C}f_{0} . Since M_{n}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Delta\Sigma)f_{0} and M_{\hat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Delta\Sigma)f_{0} , it follows from [ Dri20 , Lemma 2.6] that M\prec_{M}B\rtimes\Delta\Sigma , and hence, [\Lambda:\Delta\Sigma]<\infty . Next, since \Lambda has property (T), the group \Delta\Sigma has property (T) as well. Note that \lambda\in\Delta if and only if there is a finite index subgroup \Omega<\Sigma with \lambda\in C_{\Lambda}(\Omega) . It thus follows that there is a decreasing sequence \{\Omega_{n}\}_{n\geq 1} of finite index subgroups of \Sigma for which \Delta=\cup_{n\geq 1}C_{\Lambda}(\Omega_{n}) . Since \Delta\Sigma has property (T) it therefore follows that there is n\geq 1 for which [\Lambda:\Omega_{n}C_{\Lambda}(\Omega_{n})]<\infty. Denote \Sigma_{1}=\Omega_{n} and \Sigma_{2}=C_{\Lambda}(\Omega_{n}) . Since \Lambda is i.c.c., it follows that \Sigma_{1},\Sigma_{2} have property (T). By using Lemma 5.1 there exist a non-zero projection e\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} and a partition \{1,\dots,n\}=T_{1}\sqcup T_{2} such that L(\Sigma_{i})e is amenable relative to A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{i}} inside M for any i\in\{1,2\} . Therefore, by [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.6(1)] we get that L(\Sigma_{i})e\prec_{M}^{s}A_{T_{i}}\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{i}} for any i\in\{1,2\} . Thus, we can apply [ Dri20 , Theorem 3.1] and obtain that there exist commuting subgroups \Lambda_{1},\Lambda_{2}<\Lambda and free ergodic pmp actions \Lambda_{i}\curvearrowright Y_{i} for i\in\{1,2\} such that \Lambda\curvearrowright Y is induced from \Lambda_{1}\times\Lambda_{2}\curvearrowright Y_{1}\times Y_{2} and \Gamma_{T_{i}}\curvearrowright X_{T_{i}} is stably orbit equivalent to \Lambda_{i}\curvearrowright Y_{i} . The proof ends by repeating the argument finitely many times. Remark 5.3 . In the above proof, one can show that T_{1} can be taken to be \hat{n} and T_{2}=\{n\} . Indeed, since A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma)r and [\Sigma:\Sigma_{1}] , we get A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma_{1})r . By [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.4(4)] there is a non-zero projection r_{1}\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}}r for which (2) A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma_{1})s\text{ for any non-zero projection }s\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}}r_{1}. By using the moreover part of Lemma 5.1 one may assume that e\in B^{\Sigma_{1}\Sigma_{2}} satisfies er_{1}\neq 0 . From ( 2 ) we get A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma_{1})er_{1} and by using [ Vae08 , Lemma 3.4] , we deduce A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}(B\rtimes\Sigma_{1})e . By [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] we have (B\rtimes\Sigma_{1})e\prec_{M}^{s}A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{1}} , and hence, by using [ Vae08 , Lemma 3.7] , we derive A\rtimes\Gamma_{\widehat{n}}\prec_{M}A\rtimes\Gamma_{T_{1}} , which shows that T_{1}=\hat{n} and T_{2}=\{n\} . 6. Rigidities for infinite direct sum groups Proof of Theorem E . Let \{\Gamma_{i}\}_{i\in I} and \{\Lambda_{j}\}_{j\in J} be families of nonamenable biexact groups and suppose \Gamma:=\oplus_{i\in I}\Gamma_{i}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(X,\mu) and \Lambda:=\oplus_{j\in J}\Lambda_{j}{\,\curvearrowright\,}(Y,\nu) are stable orbit equivalent free ergodic p.m.p. actions. It follows that we may find d,\ell\in{\mathbb{N}} such that Y=Y\times\{0\}\subset X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}\subset Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}} and {\mathcal{R}}(\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})\cap(Y\times Y)={\mathcal{R}}(\Lambda{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y), {\mathcal{R}}(\Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}Y\times Z/\ell{\mathbb{Z}})\cap((X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})\times(X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}))={\mathcal{R}}(\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}{\,\curvearrowright\,}X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}). Put A=L^{\infty}(X) , A_{1}=L^{\infty}(X)\otimes{\mathbb{M}}_{d}({\mathbb{C}}) , B=L^{\infty}(Y) , B_{1}=L^{\infty}(Y)\otimes{\mathbb{M}}_{\ell}({\mathbb{C}}) , p=1_{A_{1}}\in B_{1} , q=1_{B}\in A_{1} and M=B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda . By Proposition 3.2 and [ DP23 , Proposition 8.3] , we have M is biexact relative to \{B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\}_{j\in J} and hence for each i\in I , there exists \sigma(i)\in J such that L\Gamma_{\widehat{i}}\prec_{M}B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda_{\widehat{\sigma(i)}} . By Lemma 2.8 , we have \Gamma_{\widehat{i}}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{\widehat{\sigma(i)}}\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}} and thus \Gamma_{\widehat{i}}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{\widehat{\sigma(i)}} , where \Omega=(X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})\times(\Lambda\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}})=(Y\times{\mathbb{Z}}/\ell{\mathbb{Z}})\times(\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}) is the ME coupling arising from the stable orbit equivalent actions [ Fur99 , Theorem 3.3] . Note that \sigma:I\to J is injective as otherwise Lemma 2.9 shows that \Lambda_{j} is finite, contradicting the nonamenable assumption. Reversing the roles of \Gamma_{i} ’s and \Lambda_{j} ’s, we obtain an injection \rho:J\to I such that L\Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\prec_{pMp}A_{1}\rtimes{\Gamma_{\widehat{\rho(j)}}} . The same argument as above yields that \Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega_{0}}\Gamma_{\widehat{\rho(j)}} , where \Omega_{0}=(X\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}})\times\Lambda=Y\times(\Gamma\times{\mathbb{Z}}/d{\mathbb{Z}}) , and this in turn implies that \Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Gamma_{\widehat{\rho(j)}} . We claim that \rho\circ\sigma=\operatorname{id}_{I} . Otherwise, there would exist some i\in I such that \Gamma_{i}\preccurlyeq_{\Omega}\Lambda_{\widehat{j}} and \Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\prec_{\Omega}\Gamma_{\widehat{i}} , which implies that \Gamma_{i} would be finite by Lemma 2.9 . Similarly, we have \sigma\circ\rho=\operatorname{id}_{J} . It then follows from Lemma 2.12 that \Gamma_{i}\sim_{\rm ME}\Lambda_{\sigma(i)} for all i\in I . ∎ Remark 6.1 . Observe that the conclusion of Theorem E holds whenever one has L\Gamma_{\widehat{i}}\prec_{M}B_{1}\rtimes\Lambda_{\widehat{\sigma(i)}} and L\Lambda_{\widehat{j}}\prec_{pMp}A_{1}\rtimes{\Gamma_{\widehat{\rho(j)}}} as above. Thus the same conclusion holds if each \Gamma_{i} and \Lambda_{j} are groups with positive first \ell^{2} -Betti number, and more generally, in class {\mathscr{M}} as in [ Dri23 ] . Proof of Corollary F . Let A\wr\Gamma\curvearrowright(X,\mu) and B\wr\Lambda\curvearrowright(Y,\nu) be free ergodic pmp actions for which we have the identifications p(L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes A\wr\Gamma)p=L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes B\wr\Lambda and L^{\infty}(X)p=L^{\infty}(Y) for a non-zero projection p\in L^{\infty}(X) . Denote M=L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes A\wr\Gamma . Note that it is enough to show L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes A^{(\Gamma)}\prec_{M}L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes B^{(\Lambda)} and L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes B^{(\Lambda)}\prec_{M}L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes A^{(\Gamma)} by Lemma 2.8 , Lemma 2.12 and Theorem E . Because of symmetry reasons, we only prove L^{\infty}(X)\rtimes A^{(\Gamma)}\prec_{M}L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes B^{(\Lambda)} . Using [ BV14 , Lemma 2.3] it is enough to show L(A^{(\Gamma)})\prec_{M}L^{\infty}(Y)\rtimes B^{(\Lambda)} . We make the following notation. For any i\in\Gamma , denote by A^{i}0 and a unitary u\in M such that uM_{1}^{t}u^{*}=L(\Lambda_{1}) and uM_{\widehat{1}}^{1/t}u^{*}=L(\Lambda_{\widehat{1}}) . Proof. Let \Delta:M\to M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M be the * -homomorphism given by \Delta(v_{\lambda})=v_{\lambda}\otimes v_{\lambda} , for any \lambda\in\Lambda . By using Corollary 3.4 there exists k\in\mathbb{N} such that \Delta(M_{\widehat{1}})\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{k}} or \Delta(M_{\widehat{1}})\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M_{\widehat{k}}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M . By using the symmetry of the operator \Delta , we can assume that (3) \Delta(M_{\widehat{1}})\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{k}}. Next, we apply Ioana’s ultrapower technique [ DHI19 , Theorem 4.1] (see also [ Ioa12 , Theorem 3.1] ) to deduce that there exists a decreasing sequence \{\Sigma_{i}\}_{i\in\mathbb{N}} of subgroups of \Lambda such that M_{\widehat{1}}\prec_{M}L(\Sigma_{i}) for any i\in\mathbb{N} and M_{k}\prec_{M}L(\cup_{i\in\mathbb{N}}L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma_{i}))) . Since M_{k} has property (T), we may find some j\in{\mathbb{N}} such that M_{k}\prec_{M}L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma_{j})) . Thus there exist two nonamenable commuting subgroups \Sigma:=\Sigma_{j},\Theta:=C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma_{j}) of \Lambda such that (4) M_{\widehat{1}}\prec_{M}L(\Sigma)\text{ and }M_{k}\prec L(\Theta). By passing to relative commutants in ( 4 ) it follows that (5) L(\Theta)\prec_{M}M_{1}\text{ and }L(\Sigma)\prec M_{\widehat{k}}. We continue by showing that L(\Sigma)\prec^{s}_{M}M_{\widehat{k}} and k=1 . To this end, let z\in\mathcal{N}_{M}(L(\Sigma))^{\prime}\cap M\subset L(\Sigma\Theta)^{\prime}\cap M be a nonzero projection. Since L(\Theta)z is non-amenable, then Corollary 3.4 implies that there exists j\in\mathbb{N} such that L(\Sigma)z\prec_{M}M_{\widehat{j}} . We assume by contradiction that j\neq k . By Lemma 2.2 it follows that \Delta(M_{\widehat{1}})\prec^{s}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{j}} . Together with ( 3 ), it follows from [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.8] that \Delta(M_{\widehat{1}})\prec^{s}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{\widehat{\{j,k\}}} . By applying again [ DHI19 , Theorem 4.1] , there exists a subgroup \Sigma_{0}<\Lambda such that M_{\widehat{1}}\prec_{M}L(\Sigma_{0}) and M_{\{j,k\}}\prec_{m}L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma_{0})) . By passing to relative commutants, it follows that L(C_{\Lambda}(\Sigma_{0}))\prec_{M}M_{1} . By using Lemma 2.2 it follows that \Delta(M_{\{j,k\}})\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{1} , and hence, \Delta(M_{\{j,k\}})\prec^{s}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{1} since M_{\{j,k\}} is regular in M . By applying the flip automorphism on M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M , it follows that \Delta(M_{\{j,k\}})\prec^{s}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M as well. By applying [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.8] it follows that \Delta(M_{\{j,k\}})\prec^{s}_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M_{1}\,\bar{\otimes}\,M_{1} . By using Corollary 3.4 it is not hard to get that \Delta(M_{j})\prec_{M\,\bar{\otimes}\,M}M\otimes 1 , which contradicts the fact that M_{j} is a II 1 factor. Thus, L(\Sigma)z\prec_{M}M_{\widehat{k}} , which implies by [ DHI19 , Lemma 2.4] that L(\Sigma)\prec_{M}^{s}M_{\widehat{k}} . Together with ( 5 ) it follows from [ Vae07 , Lemma 3.7] that M_{\widehat{1}}\prec_{M}M_{\widehat{k}} . This implies that k=1 . To summarize, we proved that M_{\widehat{1}}\prec_{M}L(\Sigma) , L(\Sigma)\prec_{M}^{s}M_{\widehat{1}} , M_{1}\prec L(\Theta) and L(\Theta)\prec_{M}M_{1} . The conclusion of the theorem follows now by applying [ Dri21 , Theorem 2.3] (see also [ DHI19 , Theorem 6.1] ). ∎