Quite free p p -groups with trivial duality Thanks: The second author’s research has been supported by a grant from IPM (No. 1403030417). The second author’s work is based upon research funded by Iran National Science Foundation (INSF) under project No. 4027168. The third author research partially supported by the Israel Science Foundation (ISF) grant no: 1838/19, and Israel Science Foundation (ISF) grant no: 2320/23; Research partially supported by the grant “Independent Theories” NSF-BSF, (BSF 3013005232). This is 1045a in Shelah’s list of publications. Mohsen Asgharzadeh, Mohammad Golshani, Saharon Shelah Abstract . We present a class of abelian groups that exhibit a high degree of freeness while possessing no non-trivial homomorphisms to a canonical free object. Unlike prior investigations, which primarily focused on torsion-free groups, our work broadens the scope to include groups with torsion. Our main focus is on reduced separable p p -groups, for which we formulate and prove the Trivial Duality Conjecture . Key tools in our analysis include the multi black-box method and the application of specific homological properties of relative trees. These techniques allow us to navigate the intricate interplay between freeness and duality in a broader class of abelian groups. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 03E75; 20K10, Secondary: 20A15; 13L05; 20K40 1. Introduction This paper addresses the Trivial Duality Conjecture , mainly for torsion abelian groups. Specifically, we are concerned with the following folklore problem and its innovative resolution: Problem 1.1 . Given an infinite cardinal \mu , is there a \mu -free abelian group G such that {\rm Hom}(G,\mathbb{Z})=0 ? We denote this trivial dual property by TDU_{\mu} when \mu>\aleph_{0} . There are a lot of works over abelian groups. Here, is a short list. Recall that much earlier results, like the existence of an \aleph_{1} -free abelian group G of cardinality \aleph_{1} with {\rm Hom}(G,\mathbb{Z})=0 , were established by Eda [ 2 ] and Shelah [ 9 ] . The existence of such groups was known classically for \aleph_{1} -free abelian groups, but remained widely open for many years for \aleph_{n} -free abelian groups, where n>1 . This was finally answered affirmatively in [ 11 ] by Shelah, where examples using n -dimensional black boxes were introduced. Subsequently, these were used for more complicated algebraic relatives in Göbel-Shelah [ 6 ] . In [ 12 ] , Shelah introduced several close approximations to proving in ZFC some almost positive results for \aleph_{\omega} , that is TDU_{\aleph_{\omega}} , using 1-black boxes. In [ 13 ] , Shelah finally proved that TDU_{\aleph_{\omega}} , and indeed TDU_{\aleph_{\omega_{1}\cdot k}} holds for all k<\omega . Furthermore, assuming the existence of large cardinals, he showed that TDU_{\aleph_{\omega_{1}\cdot\omega}} can consistently fail. This demonstrates that \lambda=\aleph_{\omega_{1}\cdot\omega} is the first cardinal for which TDU_{\lambda} cannot be proved in ZFC. Despite a lot of works over abelian groups, the trivial duality problem was largely restricted to torsion-free groups. This inspires us to continue exploring around Problem 1.1. In particular, we address the following natural problem: Problem 1.2 . How can extend TDU_{\aleph_{n}} to not necessarily torsion-free groups? The structure theorem for torsion groups states that every torsion group can be uniquely decomposed into a direct sum of its p -primary components for each prime p , where each p -primary component consists of elements whose orders are powers of p . This means that to understand a torsion group, we can focus on understanding p -groups (groups where each element has an order that is a power of p for different primes p ). Moreover, within each p -group, the theory further simplifies by considering reduced p -groups, where “reduced” typically implies the absence of elements of infinite order in the context of torsion groups. According to the tradition of infinite abelian groups, it is not overly restrictive to assume further that the groups be separable. Hypothesis 1.3 . Assume 0<\mathbf{k}<\omega and let \bar{\partial}=\langle\partial_{\ell}=\partial(\ell):\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle be a sequence of regular cardinals. (a) Let \bar{S}=\langle S_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle , where each S_{m} is a set (of ordinals), (b) \Lambda\subseteq\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]} , (c) \bar{J}=\langle J_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle , where each J_{m} is an ideal on \partial_{m} . To carry out our constructions in {\rm ZFC} , we need some combinatorial principles introduced by Shelah [ 10 ] , known as black boxes, where he showed that they follow from ZFC (here, ZFC means the Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory with the axiom of choice). The first difficulty is to reformulate quite-free for torsion groups. To handle this, we rely extensively on techniques from algebra and set theory, with a particular focus on the use of a version of black-box called the \bar{\chi} -black box. To ensure the paper is self-contained, we review and extend a list of key elements from it, including: • The combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter \mathbf{x}:=(\mathbb{k},\bar{\partial},\bar{S},\Lambda,\bar{J}) . • The \bar{\chi} -black box (see Definition 2.8 ). • The module parameter \mathbf{d} . This consists a tuple \mathbf{d}=\langle R,M^{*},{\mathscr{M}},\theta\rangle=\langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle where R is a ring, M^{*} is a fixed R -module, {\mathscr{M}} is a set or class of R -modules, and \theta\geq\aleph_{0} is a regular cardinal. • The \mathbf{d} -problem \Xi which is a set \Xi of triples of the form (G,H,h) consisting R -modules G and H , and a nonzero homomorphism h\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G,H) . These elements provide a solid foundation for applying Shelah’s method effectively within our proofs and arguments. In Definition 3.14 , we illustrate how to utilize the preceding list to construct a relatively free module with trivial duality, referred to as the (R,\mathbf{x}) -construction {\mathfrak{x}} . The initial step involves employing the black-box method to determine under what conditions \mathbf{x} is equipped with the \theta -fitness. For its definition, see Definition 3.11 . Finally, we offer a solution to the trivial duality problem by extending and simplifying the existing framework [ 13 ] . To this end, it may be worth highlighting the following technical construction. Namely, let G_{*} be an abelian group equipped with a nonzero morphism h\in{\rm Hom}(G_{*},\mathbb{Z}) . Shelah [ 13 ] constructed an abelian group extension G of G_{*} such that h cannot be extended to {\rm Hom}(G,\mathbb{Z}) , and he implicitly asked the following variation of Problem 1.2 . For a given alelian group G_{*} , is it possible to construct such a group H and a morphism h_{\ast}:G_{*}\to H_{\ast} such that h_{\ast} cannot be extended to the whole group G ? This scenario is precisely described in the text presented as the Main Result of Section 3, which explores the structural constraints that can prevent such extensions. Theorem 1.4 . Let \mathbf{x} be a \mathbf{k} -combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, R=R_{\mathbf{x}} and let (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) be a module problem. Suppose \mathbf{x} \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi),\chi^{+}\geq\theta+|R|^{+} and \mathbf{x} has \chi -black box. The following assertions are valid: (1) There is an (R,\mathbf{x}) -construction {\mathfrak{x}} such that: (a) G=G_{{\mathfrak{x}}} is an R -module of cardinality |\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}| , (b) if (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi, and h_{0}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G_{*},G) is an embedding, then there is no h_{1}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G,H_{*}) such that h_{0}\circ h_{1}=h_{*} : \textstyle{0\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{G_{*}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \scriptstyle{h_{*}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\nexists h_{1}} \textstyle{H_{*}} (2) Suppose in addition to the first item, \mathbf{x} freely \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) . Then we can add the following two properties: (c) G is \sigma -free if \mathbf{x} is \sigma -free, (d) {\rm Hom}_{R}(G,H_{*})=0 , for all H_{*} such that (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi . Our contribution can be summarized as follows: (a) It is preferable to construct G with a predetermined {\rm End}(G) , but we will delay this construction until a forthcoming paper [ 1 ] . (b) There are relatives of the condition “ {\rm Hom}(G,\mathbb{Z})=0 ” that apply to certain classes of abelian groups where the usual notion of freeness does not apply, such as reduced separable abelian p -groups. This class is denoted by \mathbf{K}_{p} , where p is a prime number, and plays a crucial role in this paper. (c) It is desirable to provide proofs in a manner that will be clear to set-theoretically minded algebraists, demonstrating how to apply these results to various algebraic questions. In Definition 3.6 , we present the new concept of relative freeness and almost freeness with respect to a suitable module parameter. We pay special attention to the module parameter \mathbf{d}^{1}_{p}:=\langle R:={\mathbb{Z}},M^{*}:=0,{\mathscr{M}},\theta:=\aleph_{1}\rangle, where {\mathscr{M}}=\{{\mathbb{Z}}/p^{n}{\mathbb{Z}}:n=1,2,\ldots\} . Also, we invent the \mathbf{d}^{1}_{p} -problem \Xi^{1}_{p}, by looking at the class of triples (G_{*},H_{*}:=G_{*},h_{*}:={\rm id}_{G_{*}}) where G_{*} is of the form G_{*}:=\bigoplus\{G^{*}_{m,\alpha}:m<\mathbb{k},\alpha<\omega_{1}\}, and G^{*}_{m,\omega\alpha+n}\cong\mathbb{Z}/p^{n+1}\mathbb{Z} . The main technical task of this paper is to find almost-free frames with respect to \mathbf{K}_{p} . The following is our main result: Theorem 1.5 . Let J=J_{\aleph_{1}}^{{\rm bd}} be the ideal of bounded subsets of \omega_{1} . Then (\aleph_{1},J) fits the triple (\aleph_{1},\mathbf{d}^{1}_{p},\Xi^{1}_{p}) . Section 4 is focused on proving the above central theorem, likely concerning the duality of separable p -groups. Also, we present a pair (\aleph_{0},J) that freely fits the triple \mathbf{d}^{0}_{p}:=\mathbf{d}^{1}_{p} with \Xi^{0}_{p}, be the class of triples (G,H,h) where: - G\in\mathbf{K}_{p} has cardinality \leq 2^{\aleph_{0}} and is not torsion-complete, - H has the form \bigoplus\{G_{n}:n\in{\mathscr{U}}\} where {\mathscr{U}}\subseteq{\mathbb{N}} is infinite and G_{n}\cong{\mathbb{Z}}/p^{n}\mathbb{Z} , - h is a non-small homomorphism from G to H . Namely, we prove that: Theorem 1.6 . Let J=J^{{\rm bd}}_{\aleph_{0}} be the ideal of bounded subsets of \omega . Then (\aleph_{0},J) freely fits the triple (\aleph_{0},\mathbf{d}^{0}_{p},\Xi^{0}_{p}) . The next part of Section 4 is closely linked to Theorem 1.4 . In particular, it applies Theorems 1.5 and 1.6 to explore connections with small morphisms and the concept of almost relative freeness. This part likely provides examples to illustrate how the structural insights from Theorem 1.4 manifest in these specific settings, showing how abstract set-theoretic results translate into concrete algebraic contexts: Corollary 1.7 . There is a group G\in\mathbf{K}_{p} equipped with the following two properties: (a) if (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi^{0}_{p} , then every h\in{\rm Hom}(G,H_{*}) is small. (b) G is \aleph_{\omega\cdot\mathbf{k}} -free with respect to \mathbf{K}_{p} . Following Pierce, a morphism h:G\to H of abelian p -groups is called small if, for a given k>0 , there exists n>0 such that p^{n}G[p^{k}]\leq{\rm Ker}(h) . For more details, see [ 5 , Section 7.3] . Additionally, we recover and extend some interesting results from [ 13 ] : Corollary 1.8 . There is a \aleph_{\omega_{1}\cdot\mathbf{k}} -free abelian group G\in\mathbf{K}_{p} such that {\rm Hom}(G,F)=0 for all indecomposable \mathbf{K}_{p} -free group F . In particular, {\rm Hom}(G,{\mathbb{Z}}/p^{n+1}{\mathbb{Z}})=0 for all n>0 . In this paper all groups are abelian, and all rings are commutative. For all unexplained definitions from set theoretic algebra see the books by Eklof-Mekler [ 3 ] and Göbel-Trlifaj [ 7 ] . Also, for unexplained definitions from the group theory see Fuchs’ book [ 5 ] . 2. Convenience with freeness of trees and black-box In this section, we recall some preliminaries which are needed for the later sections of the paper. The reader may skip this section and return to it as needed. 2(A). Freeness of relative trees In this subsection, we introduce a series of definitions and results with a set-theoretic emphasis. All of these will be utilized in the subsequent discussion. Notation 2.1 . Let 0<\mathbf{k}<\omega . Suppose \bar{\partial}=\langle\partial_{\ell}=\partial(\ell):\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle is a sequence of regular cardinals or just limit ordinals and \bar{S}=\langle S_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle is a sequence of sets. We allow \bar{\partial} to be constant, i.e. \partial_{\ell}=\partial for some \partial and all \ell<\mathbb{k} . Suppose {\mathscr{F}}\subseteq\prod\limits_{\ell<\mathbb{k}}{}^{S_{\ell}}X_{\ell} is a family of \mathbb{k} -sequences of functions. We say {\mathscr{F}} is weakly ordinary if for each \bar{\eta}=\langle\eta_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle\in{\mathscr{F}} , each \eta_{\ell} is a one-to-one function. In the case that the sets S_{\ell} and X_{\ell} are sets of ordinals, we say {\mathscr{F}} is ordinary if each \eta_{\ell} as above is an increasing function. Definition 2.2 . ( [ 13 , Definition 0.7] ). Suppose {\mathscr{F}}\subseteq{}^{S}X is a family of functions from S into X , J is an ideal on S , and \theta is a cardinal. (1) We say {\mathscr{F}} is (\theta,J) -free if for every {\mathscr{F}}^{\prime}\subseteq{\mathscr{F}} of cardinality <\theta , there is a sequence \langle w_{\eta}:\eta\in{\mathscr{F}}^{\prime}\rangle such that: (a) \eta\in{\mathscr{F}}^{\prime}\Rightarrow w_{\eta}\in J , and (b) if \eta_{1}\neq\eta_{2}\in{\mathscr{F}}^{\prime} and s\in S\setminus(w_{\eta_{1}}\cup w_{\eta_{2}}) , then \eta_{1}(s)\neq\eta_{2}(s) . (2) We say {\mathscr{F}} is \theta -free if it is (\theta,J) -free where S\subseteq{\rm Ord} and J=J^{{\rm bd}}_{S} , the ideal of bounded subsets of S . Definition 2.3 . ( [ 13 , Notation 1.2] ). Let \bar{\partial}=\langle\partial_{\ell}=\partial(\ell):\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle and \bar{S}=\langle S_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle be as described above. (1) Let \bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]}=\prod\limits_{\ell<\mathbb{k}}{}^{\partial(\ell)}S_{\ell} and for u\subseteq\{0,\dotsc,\mathbb{k}-1\} set \bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial},u]}=\prod\limits_{\ell\in u}{}^{\partial(\ell)}S_{\ell} . Furthermore, if each S_{\ell} is a set of ordinals, then let \bar{S}^{<\bar{\partial}>}=\{\bar{\eta}\in\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]} : each \eta_{\ell} is increasing \} and \bar{S}^{<\bar{\partial},u>}=\{\bar{\eta}\in\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial},u]} : each \eta_{\ell} is increasing \} . (2) Suppose \bar{\eta}\in\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]},m<\mathbb{k} and i<\partial_{m} . Then (a) for w\subseteq\partial_{m},\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,=w) is defined as \langle\eta^{\prime}_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle where \eta^{\prime}_{\ell}=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\eta_{\ell}&\mbox{if }\ell<\mathbb{k}\wedge\ell\neq m,\\ \eta_{\ell}{\restriction}w&\mbox{if }\ell=m.\end{array}\right. (b) \bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i)=\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,=\{i\}) . (c) \bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m)=\langle\eta_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\wedge\ell\neq m\rangle . (3) Suppose \Lambda\subseteq\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]},m<\mathbb{k} , w\subseteq\partial_{m} and u\subseteq\{0,\dotsc,\mathbb{k}-1\} . Then (a) Set \Lambda\upharpoonleft(m,=w)=\{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,=w):\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda\} . (b) for i\leq\partial_{m} set \Lambda\upharpoonleft(m,} is normal if whenever \bar{\eta},\bar{\nu}\in\Lambda,m<\mathbb{k},i,j<\partial_{m} and \eta_{m}(i)=\nu_{m}(j) , then i=j . We now recall the notion of combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter from [ 13 , Definition 1.3] : Definition 2.4 . We say \mathbb{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, when \mathbb{x}=(\mathbb{k},\bar{\partial},\bar{S},\Lambda,\bar{J})=(\mathbb{k}_{\mathbb{x}},\bar{\partial}_{\mathbb{x}},\bar{S}_{\mathbb{x}},\Lambda_{\mathbb{x}},\bar{J}_{\mathbb{x}}) and it satisfies: (a) \mathbb{k}\in\{1,2,\ldots\} . Let k=k_{\mathbb{x}}=\mathbb{k}-1 , (b) \bar{\partial}=\langle\partial_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle is a sequence of limit ordinals, (c) \bar{S}=\langle S_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle , where each S_{m} is a set (of ordinals), (d) \Lambda\subseteq\bar{S}^{[\bar{\partial}]} , (e) \bar{J}=\langle J_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle , where each J_{m} is an ideal on \partial_{m} . Convention 2.5 . Suppose that \mathbb{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter as above. (1) If for each \ell<\mathbb{k} , we have \partial_{\ell}=\partial , then we may write \partial instead of \bar{\partial} , and call \mathbb{x} a combinatorial (\partial,\mathbb{k}) -parameter. This may be abbreviated as (\partial,\mathbb{k}) -c.p. (2) We may say \mathbb{x} is a \mathbb{k} -c.p. if it is an (\aleph_{0},\mathbb{k}) -c.p. (3) Similarly, if all S_{\ell} ’s are equal to a set S , then we may write S instead of \bar{S} . Suppose that \mathbb{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter. Then \mathbb{x} is called (weakly) ordinary if \Lambda_{\mathbb{x}} is (weakly) ordinary. Furthermore, if \Lambda_{\mathbb{x}}=\{\langle\eta_{\mathbb{x},\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}_{\mathbb{x}}\rangle: each \eta_{\mathbb{x},\ell}\in{}^{\partial_{\mathbb{x},\ell}}S_{\mathbb{x},\ell} is increasing (one-to-one) \} , then we call \mathbb{x} is (weakly) ordinary full . Also, \mathbb{x} is disjoint , if \langle S_{\mathbb{x},\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}_{\mathbb{x}}\rangle is a sequence of pairwise disjoint sets. Similarly, we say \mathbb{x} is free , when \Lambda_{\mathbb{x}} is free. 2(B). Multi black-boxes We now intend to define the kind of black box that is required for our purpose. We start by defining the notion of a pre-black box. Definition 2.6 . ( [ 13 , Definition 1.7] ). Assume \mathbb{x}=(\mathbb{k},\bar{\partial},\bar{S},\Lambda,\bar{J}) is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, and \bar{\chi}=\langle\chi_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle is a sequence of cardinals. (1) \bar{\alpha} is a (\mathbb{x},\bar{\chi}) -pre-black box, if (a) \bar{\alpha}=\langle\bar{\alpha}_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda\rangle (b) \bar{\alpha}_{\bar{\eta}}=\langle\alpha_{\bar{\eta},m,i}:m<\mathbb{k},i<\partial_{m}\rangle and \alpha_{\bar{\eta},m,i}<\chi_{m} (c) if \langle h_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle\in\prod\limits_{m<\mathbb{k}}{}^{\Lambda_{m}}\chi_{m} , then there exists some \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda such that for all m<\mathbb{k} and i<\partial_{m} we have h_{m}(\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i))=\alpha_{\bar{\eta},m,i} . We may also replace \mathbb{x} by \Lambda and say \bar{\alpha} is a (\Lambda,\bar{\chi}) -pre-black box. (2) We say \mathbb{x} has \bar{\chi} -pre-black box, if some \bar{\alpha} is a (\mathbb{x},\bar{\chi}) -pre-black box. (3) Given \bar{\alpha} as above, we may identify it with a function \mathbb{b} with domain \{(\bar{\eta},m,i):\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda,m<\mathbb{k},i<\partial_{m}\} such that \mathbb{b}_{\bar{\eta}}(m,i)=\mathbb{b}(\bar{\eta},m,i)=\alpha_{\bar{\eta},m,i}. Notation 2.7 . In Definition 2.6 , we may replace \bar{\chi} by \chi , if \bar{\chi}=\langle\chi:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle , or by \bar{C}=\langle C_{\ell}:\ell<\mathbb{k}\rangle when |C_{\ell}|=\chi_{\ell} and {\rm Im}(h_{\ell})\subseteq C_{\ell} . Definition 2.8 . ( [ 13 , Definition 1.7] ). Assume \mathbb{x} and \bar{\chi} are as in Definition 2.6 . We say \mathbb{x} has a \bar{\chi} -black box , if there exist a partition \bar{\Lambda}=\langle\Lambda_{\alpha}:\alpha<|\Lambda|\rangle of \Lambda and a sequence \mathbb{n}=\langle\bar{\nu}_{\alpha}:\alpha<|\Lambda|\rangle such that: (1) each \mathbb{x}{\restriction}\Lambda_{\alpha} has \bar{\chi} -pre-black box, (2) \Lambda=\{\bar{\nu}_{\alpha}:\alpha<|\Lambda|\}, (3) if \mu is the maximal cardinal satisfying (\forall\ell<\mathbb{k})2^{<\mu}\leq\chi_{\ell} , then \alpha<\beta<\alpha+\mu\Rightarrow\bar{\nu}_{\alpha}=\bar{\nu}_{\beta}, (4) if \alpha\leq\beta<|\Lambda| , (\alpha,\beta)\neq(0,0) and \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\beta} , then \nu_{\alpha,\mathbb{k}-1}<\eta_{\mathbb{k}-1}\mod J_{\mathbb{k}-1} . We now recall freeness for a combinatorial parameter from [ 13 , Definition 1.11] . Definition 2.9 . Suppose \mathbb{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, and \Lambda_{*}\subseteq\bar{S}_{\mathbb{x}}^{[\bar{\partial}_{\mathbb{x}}]} . (1) We say \mathbb{x} is \theta -free over \Lambda_{*} , if it is weakly ordinary and for every \Lambda\subseteq\Lambda_{\mathbb{x}}\backslash\Lambda_{*} of cardinality <\theta , there is a list \langle\bar{\eta}_{\alpha}:\alpha<\alpha_{*}\rangle of \Lambda such that for every \alpha , for some m<\mathbb{k}_{\mathbb{x}} and w\in J_{\mathbb{x},m} , if \bar{\nu}\in\{\bar{\eta}_{\beta}:\beta<\alpha\}\cup\Lambda_{*}\quad and\quad\bar{\nu}\upharpoonleft(m)=\bar{\eta}_{\alpha}\upharpoonleft(m), then we can deduce that \nu_{m}(j)\neq\eta_{\alpha,m}(i) for all j<\partial_{\mathbb{x},m} and i\in\partial_{\mathbb{x},m}\setminus w . If \Lambda_{\mathbb{x}} is normal, we can restrict ourselves to i=j and this is the usual case. (2) Suppose \bar{\Lambda}=\langle\Lambda_{\bar{\nu}}:\bar{\nu}\in\Lambda_{\mathbb{x}}\rangle where each \Lambda_{\bar{\nu}}\subseteq\Lambda_{\mathbb{x}} . We say \mathbb{x} is \theta -free over \Lambda_{*} respecting \bar{\Lambda} if for every \Lambda\subseteq\Lambda_{\mathbb{x}}\setminus\Lambda_{*} of cardinality <\theta , there is a list \langle\bar{\eta}_{\alpha}:\alpha<\alpha_{*}\rangle of \Lambda witnessing \mathbb{x} is \theta -free over \Lambda_{*} such that for every \alpha<\alpha_{*} , \bar{\eta}_{\alpha}\in\Lambda_{\bar{\nu}}\implies\bar{\nu}\in\{\bar{\eta}_{\beta}:\beta<\alpha\}\cup\Lambda_{*}. Discussion 2.10 . The existing problem of \bar{\chi} -black boxes, equipped with the above freeness properties, is the subject of [ 13 , 1.20 + 1.25] . 3. The relative notions of freeness and module parameters The main result of this section is Theorem 3.15 . In [ 13 ] , Shelah constructs abelian groups and modules which are, on the one hand, quite free and, on the other hand, have a small dual. The results in [ 13 ] do not apply directly, e.g., to the class \mathbf{K}_{p} of separable reduced abelian p -groups, as the relevant notion of freeness is different (see Definition 3.3 (2) below). For information about such groups, see [ 5 ] and [ 7 ] . In this section, we extend the results stated in the above-cited work of Shelah and also obtain similar results for separable reduced abelian p -groups which are not covered there. Notation 3.1 . If G is an abelian group and n\in\mathbb{N} , then set: (1) nG:=\{ng:g\in G\} , (2) G[n]:=\{g\in G:ng=0\} , (3) {\rm ord}(g) means the order of an element g , (4) \textbf{ht}_{p}(g) stands for transfinite height of the element g at prime p . Definition 3.2 . Let p be a prime number. By a p -group is meant a group the orders of whose elements are powers of p . Recall that p -groups without elements of infinite heights is called separable. A reduced group means a group with no nonzero divisible subgroup. Definition 3.3 . Let p be a prime number. (1) Let \mathbf{K}_{p} be the class of abelian p -groups G which are reduced and separable. (2) Suppose G,H\in\mathbf{K}_{p} . Recall that a map g\in{\rm Hom}(H,G) is called small , if for every k>0 , there exists n>0 such that {\rm ord}(a)\leq p^{k} and \textbf{ht}_{p}(a)\geq n imply that g(a)=0 . In other words, the Pierce condition p^{n}H[p^{k}]\subseteq{\rm Ker}(g) holds, with the convenience that p^{n}H[p^{k}]=p^{n}H\cap H[p^{k}] . (3) An abelian group G is called \mathbf{K}_{p} -free , provided it is the direct sum of finite cyclic p -groups. (4) An abelian group G is called (\theta,\mathbf{K}_{p}) -free , if every H\subseteq G of cardinality <\theta is \mathbf{K}_{p} -free. We now give, in a series of definitions, a more general notion, that we will work with. Definition 3.4 . A module parameter is a tuple \mathbf{d}=\langle R,M^{*},{\mathscr{M}},\theta\rangle=\langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle where: (a) R is a ring, (b) M^{*} is a fixed R -module, (c) {\mathscr{M}} is a set or class of R -modules, (d) \theta\geq\aleph_{0} is a regular cardinal. Given a module parameter \mathbf{d} , we define some classes of R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules as follows. Definition 3.5 . Suppose \mathbf{d}=\langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle is a module parameter. (1) Let \mathbf{K}_{\mathbf{d}} be the class of R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules. (2) Let \mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d}} be the class of R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules G which are \mathbf{d} -free , i.e., G=\bigoplus\{M_{s}:s\in I\}\oplus M where M\cong M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} and each M_{s} is isomorphic to some member of {\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}} ; here {\rm fr} stands for free. (3) Let \mathbf{K}^{{\rm sfr}}_{\mathbf{d}} be the class of R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules G which are semi- \mathbf{d} -free , i.e., G=\bigoplus\{M_{s}:s\in I\} where each M_{s} is isomorphic to some member of {\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}} ; here {\rm sfr} stands for semi-free. We also define the notion of freeness of one R -module over another with respect to a module parameter. Definition 3.6 . Suppose \mathbf{d} is a module parameter. For R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules M_{1},M_{2} , we say that M_{2} is \mathbf{d} -free over M_{1} , when M_{1}\subseteq M_{2} are from \mathbf{K}_{\mathbf{d}} and for some N\in\mathbf{K}_{\mathbf{d}}^{{\rm sfr}} we have M_{2}=M_{1}\oplus N . In the case \mathbf{d} is clear from the context, we may say M_{2} is free over M_{1} . Note that an R_{\mathbf{d}} -module is \mathbf{d} -free if and only if it is \mathbf{d} -free over some M\cong M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} . Definition 3.7 . Suppose \mathbf{d}=\langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle is a module parameter and \theta is an infinite cardinal. (1) Let \mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\theta}=\mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d},\theta} be the class of R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules M which are (\mathbf{d},\theta) -free , this means that there are \bar{M},I such that: (a) I is a \theta -directed partial order, (b) \bar{M} is a sequence \langle M_{s}:s\in I\rangle of members of \mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d}} , (c) I has a minimal member \min(I) such that M_{\min(I)}\cong M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} , (d) s<_{I}t\Rightarrow M_{t} is free over M_{s} , (e) M=\bigcup\{M_{s}:s\in I\} , (f) each M_{s} has cardinality <\theta . If \mathbf{d} is clear from the context, we may say M is \theta -free. (2) We say M_{2} is (\mathbf{d},\theta) -free over M_{1} if M_{1} is a sub-module of M_{2} and there are \bar{M},I as in clause (1) with M_{\min(I)}=M_{1} and M=M_{2}. If \mathbf{d} is clear from the context, we say M_{2} is \theta -free over M_{1} . We also define another variant of the above classes of modules. Definition 3.8 . Suppose \mathbf{d} is a module parameter. The class \mathbf{K}^{\text{g}}_{\mathbf{d}} is defined as the class of all M\in\mathbf{K}_{\mathbf{d}} extended by the individual constants c^{M} for c\in M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*} such that c\mapsto c^{M} is an embedding of M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*} into M . The classes \mathbf{K}^{{\rm gr}}_{\mathbf{d}},\mathbf{K}^{{\rm gr}}_{\mathbf{d},\theta} and \mathbf{K}^{{\rm sgr}}_{\mathbf{d}} are defined in a similar way using the classes \mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d}},\mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d},\theta} and \mathbf{K}^{{\rm sfr}}_{\mathbf{d}} respectively. So, \mathbf{K}^{{\rm sgr}}_{\mathbf{d}}=\{(M,c_{a})_{a\in M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}}}:M\in\mathbf{K}^{{\rm sfr}}_{\mathbf{d}}\emph{with}c_{a}=0\} . In the sequel, we aim to generalize [ 13 , Definition 2.11] of \theta -fitness to the more general context of module parameters. Definition 3.9 . Suppose \mathbf{d} is a module-parameter. A \mathbf{d} -problem is a set \Xi of triples of the form (G,H,h) satisfying: (\alpha) G and H are R_{\mathbf{d}} -modules, (\beta) h is a nonzero homomorphism from G to H as an R_{\mathbf{d}} -module homomorphism. Definition 3.10 . We say (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) is a module problem , when (1) \chi is an infinite cardinal, (2) \mathbf{d}:=\langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle is a module parameter, (3) \Xi is a \mathbf{d} -problem, (4) if (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi , then |H_{*}|+|G_{*}|\leq\chi , (5) \Xi has cardinality \leq\chi , (6) {\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}} and each M\in{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}} have cardinality \leq\chi , (7) M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} has cardinality \leq\chi . The following gives the promised generalization of [ 13 , Definition 2.11] . Definition 3.11 . Suppose \chi is an infinite cardinal, \mathbf{d} is a module-parameter and \Xi is a \mathbf{d} -problem such that (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) is a module problem and set \theta=\theta_{\mathbf{d}} . Also, assume \mathbf{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter. (1) We say (\bar{\partial},\bar{J}) \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) , when the following conditions (A) and (B) are satisfied, where R=R_{\mathbf{d}} : (A) (a) \bar{\partial}=\langle\partial_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle is a sequence of limit ordinals, and \bar{J}=\langle J_{m}:m<\mathbb{k}\rangle , where each J_{m} is an ideal on \partial_{m} , (b) (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) is a module problem, (B) Suppose that (a) (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi , (b) M_{*}\in K^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d}} and M_{*}=M^{*}\oplus N for some N\in K^{{\rm sfr}}_{\mathbf{d}} , (c) h_{0}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G_{*},M_{*}) , (d) \bar{M}=\langle M_{m,i}:m<\mathbf{k},i<\partial_{m}\rangle is such that M_{m,i}\in K^{{\rm sfr}}_{\mathbf{d}} for m<\mathbf{k},i<\partial_{m} and \sum\limits_{m,i}\|M_{m,i}\|<\theta , (e) G_{0}=\bigoplus\{M_{m,i}:m<\mathbf{k},i<\partial_{m}\}\oplus M_{*} , so G_{0}\in\mathbf{K}^{{\rm fr}}_{\mathbf{d}} , (f) h_{1}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G_{0},H_{*}) is such that h_{0}\circ h_{1}:G_{*}\rightarrow H_{*} is equal to h_{*} , i.e., the following diagram commutes: \textstyle{G_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \scriptstyle{h_{\ast}} \textstyle{M_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \textstyle{G_{0}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{1}} \textstyle{H_{\ast}} Then there is G_{1} such that: (\alpha) G_{1} is an R -module extending G_{0} , (\beta) G_{1} has cardinality <\theta , (\gamma) there is no R -homomorphism f from G_{1} into H_{*} extending h_{1} . We say (\partial,J) \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) , when the sequences \bar{\partial},\bar{J} are fixed. The definition is neatly summarized in the accompanying diagram: \textstyle{G_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \scriptstyle{h_{\ast}} \textstyle{M_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \textstyle{G_{0}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \scriptstyle{h_{1}} \textstyle{G_{1}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\nexists f} \textstyle{H_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{=} \textstyle{H_{\ast}} (2) We say (\bar{\partial},\bar{J}) freely \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) , if in addition it satisfies: (\delta) if m<\mathbf{k} and u\in J_{m} , then G_{1} is \mathbf{d} -free over \bigoplus_{\ell<\mathbf{k}}\{M_{\ell,i}:i<\partial_{\ell}\emph{and}\ell=m\Rightarrow i\in u\}\oplus M_{*}. (3) If \mathbf{x} has a \chi -black box, then we say \mathbf{x} (freely) \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) , when (\bar{\partial}_{\mathbf{x}},\bar{J}_{\mathbf{x}}) (freely) \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) . (4) In the above definitions, we may omit \theta when \theta=|R|^{+}+\max\{\partial^{+}_{\mathbf{x},m}:m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}}\} . Also, we may say the paring fits H_{\ast} . The next definition extends [ 13 , Definition 2.4] . Definition 3.12 . Suppose \mathbb{x} is a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, the triple (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) is a module problem and R=R_{\mathbb{d}} . (1) An R -module G is (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -derived from \mathbf{x} , when there is a tuple \langle X_{*},G_{*},\langle G_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\rangle,\langle Z_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\rangle\rangle such that: (a) X_{*}=\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i)}:m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}},i<\partial_{m} and \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\}\cup\{M^{*}_{\mathbb{d}}\}, where each M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i)} is semi- \mathbb{d} -free, (b) G_{*}=\bigoplus\limits_{M\in X_{*}}M , (c) the R -module G is generated by \bigcup\{G_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\}\cup G_{*} , so G_{*}\subseteq G , (d) G/G_{*} is the direct sum of \langle(G_{\bar{\eta}}+G_{*})/G_{*}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\rangle , (e) Z_{\bar{\eta}}\subseteq X_{*} for \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} , (f) if \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} , then the R -submodule G_{\bar{\eta}}\cap G_{*} of G is equal to the R -submodule generated by \bigcup\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i)}:m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}}\emph{and}i<\partial_{\mathbf{x},m}\}\cup\bigcup\{M:M\in Z_{\bar{\eta}}\}. (2) By an (R,\mathbf{x},\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -construction , we mean a tuple {\mathfrak{x}}=\langle\mathbf{x},R,G_{*},G,\langle M_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x},<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}}}\rangle,\langle G_{\bar{\eta}},Z_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\rangle\rangle defined as above, and we may say {\mathfrak{x}} is (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -derived from \mathbf{x} . Notation 3.13 . Given an (R,\mathbf{x},\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -construction {\mathfrak{x}} , we shall write G^{{\mathfrak{x}}}_{*} for G_{*} , G_{{\mathfrak{x}}} for G , G_{{\mathfrak{x}},\bar{\eta}} for G_{\bar{\eta}} , and etc. Furthermore, we may remove the index {\mathfrak{x}} , when it is clear from the context. The following definition presents several variants of the above concept and can be viewed as a generalization of [ 13 , Definition 2.4] . Definition 3.14 . Suppose \mathbf{x} , (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) , G and {\mathfrak{x}} are as in Definition 3.12 . (1) We say G is simple when Z_{\bar{\eta}}=\{M^{*}_{\mathbb{d}}\} for every \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} . (2) We say {\mathfrak{x}} is almost simple , when for each \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}, we have |Z_{\bar{\eta}}\backslash\{M^{*}_{\mathbb{d}}\}|\leq 1 . (3) We say G is (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -freely derived from \mathbf{x} , if in addition to items (a)-(f) of Definition 3.12 (1) we have (g) if \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}},m<\mathbf{k} and w\in J_{\mathbf{x},m} , then there exists some R -module G^{\perp}_{\bar{\eta},m,\omega} such that G_{\bar{\eta}}=G_{\bar{\eta},m,w}\oplus G^{\perp}_{\bar{\eta},m,w} is a free R -module where G_{\bar{\eta},m,w} is the R -submodule of G generated by \bigcup\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m_{1},i_{1})}:m_{1}<\mathbb{k}_{\mathbb{x}},i_{1}<\partial_{m_{1}},\emph{and}(m_{1}=m\Rightarrow i_{1}\in w)\}\cup\bigcup\{M:M\in Z_{\bar{\eta}}\}. (4) We say {\mathfrak{x}} is a canonical (R,\mathbb{x},\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) -construction , if we have Z_{\bar{\eta}}=0 for all \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{{\mathfrak{x}}} . (5) We say {\mathfrak{x}} is (<\theta) -locally free , if in addition, the following two properties are valid: (h) it satisfies clause (3)(g), furthermore the quotient G^{\perp}_{\bar{\eta},n,w} is \theta -free, (i) \mathbf{x} is \theta -free. Also, we may call {\mathfrak{x}} is a free (<\theta) -derivation . (6) {\mathfrak{x}} is called well orderable, when we can find \bar{\Lambda} so that: (\alpha) \bar{\Lambda}=\langle\Lambda_{\alpha}:\alpha\leq\alpha_{*}\rangle is \subseteq -increasing and continuous, (\beta) \Lambda_{\alpha_{*}}=\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} and \Lambda_{0}=\emptyset , (\gamma) if \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\alpha+1}\setminus\Lambda_{\alpha} and m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbb{x}} then \big\{i<\partial_{m}:(\exists\bar{\nu}\in\Lambda_{\alpha})(\bar{\eta}\upharpoonleft(m,i)=\bar{\nu}\upharpoonleft(m,i)\big\}\in J_{\mathbf{x},m}, (\delta) if \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\alpha+1}\setminus\Lambda_{\alpha} then \bigcup\{M:M\in Z_{\bar{\eta}}\}\subseteq\langle\bigcup\{G_{\bar{\nu}}:\bar{\nu}\in\Lambda_{\alpha}\}\rangle_{G} . Recall that [ 13 , Claim 2.12] provides a situation in which \textstyle{0\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{Rz\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \scriptstyle{h_{\ast}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\nexists h} \textstyle{R,} where h_{\ast}:Rz\to R is given by the assignment z\to 1\in R , where z is the distinguished linearly independent element requests additional examples. Here, we extend it: Theorem 3.15 . Assume 0<\mathbf{k}<\omega and \bar{\partial} of length \mathbf{k} are given. Let \mathbf{x} be a \mathbf{k} -combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter, R=R_{\mathbf{x}} and let (\chi,\mathbb{d},\Xi) be a module problem. Suppose \mathbf{x} \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi),\chi^{+}\geq\theta+|R|^{+} and \mathbf{x} has \chi -black box. The following assertions are valid: (1) There is {\mathfrak{x}} such that: (a) {\mathfrak{x}} is an (R,\mathbf{x}) -construction, (b) G=G_{{\mathfrak{x}}} is an R -module of cardinality |\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}| , (c) if (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi, and h_{0}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G_{*},G) is an embedding, then there is no h_{1}\in{\rm Hom}_{R}(G,H_{*}) such that h_{0}\circ h_{1}=h_{*} : \textstyle{0\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{G_{*}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \scriptstyle{h_{*}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\nexists h_{1}} \textstyle{H_{*}} (d) {\mathfrak{x}} is simple. (2) Suppose in addition to the first item, \mathbf{x} freely \theta -fits the triple (\chi,\mathbf{d},\Xi) . Then we can add the following two properties: (e) G is \sigma -free if \mathbf{x} is \sigma -free, (f) {\rm Hom}_{R}(G,H_{*})=0 , for all H_{*} such that (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi . Proof. (1) We are going to define {\mathfrak{x}}=\langle R,X_{*},G_{*},G,\langle M_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x},X_{*},<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}}}\rangle,\langle G_{\bar{\eta}},Z_{\bar{\eta}}:\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\rangle\rangle, equipped with the requested property. Recall that the module parameter \mathbf{d} is of the form \langle R_{\mathbf{d}},M_{\mathbf{d}}^{*},{\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}},\theta_{\mathbf{d}}\rangle . For every \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} , we set Z_{\bar{\eta}}:=\{M^{*}_{\mathbb{d}}\} and R:=R_{\mathbf{x}} . Let \langle M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha}:\alpha<\alpha_{\mathbf{d}}\leq\chi\rangle enumerate {\mathscr{M}}_{\mathbf{d}} . For \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} , m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}} , and i<\partial_{m} , set M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i)}:=\bigoplus\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha}:\alpha<\alpha_{\mathbf{x}}\}, where for each \alpha as above, M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha}\cong M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha} . Let also f_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha} be an isomorphism from M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha} onto M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha} . Define: • X_{*}=\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i)}:m<\mathbf{k}_{\mathbf{x}},i<\partial_{m},\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}}\}\cup\{M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}}\}, • G_{*}=\bigoplus\{M_{\bar{\eta},\alpha}:\alpha<\alpha_{\mathbf{d}},\bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x},<\mathbf{k}}\}\oplus M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}}. Let the collection \{(\alpha_{\varepsilon},G_{\varepsilon},H_{\varepsilon},h_{\varepsilon},g_{\varepsilon},f_{\varepsilon}):\varepsilon<\chi\} list, possibly with repetitions, all tuples (\alpha,\mathbb{G},\mathbb{H},h,g,f) satisfying: (i) \alpha<\alpha_{\mathbf{d}}, (ii) (\mathbb{G},\mathbb{H},h)\in\Xi, (iii) g\in\text{Hom}_{R}(M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha},\mathbb{H}), (iv) f\in\text{Hom}_{R}(\mathbb{G},M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}}). Let \mathbf{b} be a \chi -black box for \mathbf{x} (see Definition 2.6 ). Define \mathbf{b}^{\prime} and \mathbf{b}^{\prime\prime} such that: \mathbf{b}_{\bar{\eta}}(m,\ell)={\rm pr}(\mathbf{b}^{\prime}_{\eta}(m,i),\mathbf{b}^{\prime\prime}_{\bar{\eta}}(m,i)), where {\rm pr}(-,-) denotes a pairing function. For \bar{\eta}\in\Lambda_{\mathbf{x}} and \alpha<\alpha_{\mathbf{d}} , set G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha}=\sum\{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha}:m<\mathbf{k},i<\partial_{m}\}\oplus M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}}\subseteq G_{*}. Now, suppose \varepsilon<\chi . Define F_{\bar{\eta},\varepsilon}:G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\to H_{\varepsilon} such that for each m<\mathbf{k} and i<\partial_{m} , y\in M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\Rightarrow h_{\bar{\eta}}(F_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha_{\varepsilon}}(y))=g_{\varepsilon}(y)\in H_{\varepsilon}. We apply the property supported by Definition 3.11 to the data (G_{\varepsilon},H_{\varepsilon},h_{\varepsilon}) , together with f_{\varepsilon} , G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} , and F_{\varepsilon} . This allows us to conclude that, assuming F_{\varepsilon}\circ f_{\varepsilon}=h_{\varepsilon} , there exists some G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} extending G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} such that no homomorphism from G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} into H_{\varepsilon} extends F_{\varepsilon} : \textstyle{G_{\varepsilon}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{f_{\varepsilon}} \scriptstyle{h_{\varepsilon}} \textstyle{M^{*}_{\mathbb{d}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \textstyle{G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \scriptstyle{F_{\bar{\eta},\varepsilon}} \textstyle{G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\nexists} \textstyle{H_{\varepsilon}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{=} \textstyle{H_{\varepsilon}} Finally, let G_{\bar{\eta}} be freely generated by \bigcup\limits_{\varepsilon<\chi}G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} excepted with relations coming from them. These define the (R,\mathbf{x}) -construction {\mathfrak{x}} . It remains to show that it is as required. Suppose not. Then we can find some (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi and an embedding h_{0}\in\text{Hom}_{R}(G_{*},G) such that there exists h_{1}:G\to H_{*} satisfying h_{1}\circ h_{0}=h_{*} : \textstyle{0\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{G_{*}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \scriptstyle{h_{*}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\exists h_{1}} \textstyle{H_{*}} Thanks to the black box, we can find \bar{\eta} , m , and i such that if we set \varepsilon=\mathbf{b}_{\bar{\eta}(m,i)} , then (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*},g,f):=(G_{\varepsilon},H_{\varepsilon},h_{\varepsilon},g_{\varepsilon},f_{\varepsilon}), where g_{\varepsilon},f_{\varepsilon} are chosen so that h_{1}{\restriction}\circ f_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha_{\varepsilon}}=g_{\varepsilon} and f_{\varepsilon}=\pi\circ h_{0} with the convenience that \pi:G\to M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} is the projection map. Let us summarize these with diagrams: \textstyle{M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{f_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha_{\varepsilon}}} \scriptstyle{g_{\varepsilon}} \textstyle{M_{\bar{\eta}\upharpoonright(m,i),\alpha}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \textstyle{H_{*}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{1}} \textstyle{G_{\varepsilon}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{=} \scriptstyle{g_{\varepsilon}} \textstyle{G_{*}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{0}} \textstyle{M_{\mathbf{d},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\pi} Therefore, h_{1}\restriction G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} extends F_{\bar{\eta},\varepsilon} : \textstyle{G^{0}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{F_{\bar{\eta},\varepsilon}} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \textstyle{H_{\ast}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{=} \textstyle{G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{h_{1}\restriction} \textstyle{H_{\ast}} This is in contradiction with the definition of G^{1}_{\bar{\eta},\alpha_{\varepsilon}} . (2) Clause (e) is essentially [ 13 , Claim 2.12] , so we only show (f) . Recall \theta={\rm cf}(\theta) is >\|G_{*}\| whenever (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi . By induction on i\leq\theta , we choose an increasing and continuous chain \langle M_{i}:i\leq\theta\rangle of elements of \mathbf{K}_{\mathbf{d}} as follows: (i) For i=0 , let M_{0} be the expansion of M^{*}_{\mathbf{d}} by c^{M}=c for c\in M^{*} . (ii) For i a limit ordinal, let M_{i}=\bigcup\{M_{j}:j}2\} freely except the equations: (*)^{1}_{\alpha,n} \quad\quad\quad py^{1}_{\rho_{\alpha},n+1}=y^{1}_{\rho_{\alpha},n}-y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}{\restriction}n}-\sum\limits_{m<\mathbf{k}}x_{m,\omega\cdot\alpha+n}, (*)^{2}_{\alpha,n} \quad\quad\quad p^{n+1}y^{1}_{\rho_{\alpha},n}=0=p^{n+1}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction n} , where \alpha<\omega_{1},n<\omega with the convenience that {\rm ord}(y^{1}_{\rho_{\alpha},n})={\rm ord}(y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction n})=p^{n+1} . In particular, p^{n}y^{1}_{\rho_{\alpha},n}\neq 0\neq p^{n}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction n} . According to its definition, H_{*} and G_{*} are free in the sense of \mathbf{K}_{p} . Here, we are going to show G_{*}\subseteq G , and G is \aleph_{1} -free. Indeed, let X\subseteq G be countable. Let \alpha<\omega_{1} be such that X\subseteq\langle\{x_{m,\beta}:m<\mathbb{k},\beta<\omega\cdot\alpha\}\cup\{y^{1}_{\beta,n}:\beta<\omega\cdot\alpha,n<\omega\}\rangle_{G}. Let g:\beta<\omega\cdot\alpha\rightarrow\omega be such that \langle\rho_{\beta}\upharpoonright g(\beta):\beta<\omega\cdot\alpha\rangle are pairwise \unlhd -incomparable. We can find a basis of X . In other words, G is \aleph_{1} -free. In the same vein we observe that G/G_{*} is \aleph_{1} -free. Therefore, tings are reduced to showing that there is no homeomorphism h\in{\rm Hom}(G,H_{*}) , extending h_{*}={\rm id}_{G_{*}} . Suppose on the way of contradiction that there is an \hat{h}\in{\rm Hom}(G,G_{*}) such that \textstyle{0\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{G_{*}\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\subseteq} \scriptstyle{=} \textstyle{G\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\exists\hat{h}} \textstyle{G_{*}} For each ordinal \beta , we look at L_{\beta}:=\bigoplus\{\mathbb{Z}x_{m,\beta+n}:m<\mathbb{k},n<\omega\}. Then L_{\beta} is countable, and there is a projection \pi_{\beta} from H_{*}=G_{*} onto L_{\beta}. For each countable ordinal \beta set \tilde{h}_{\beta}=\pi_{\beta}\circ\hat{h}, and recall for these ordinals that L_{\beta} is of countable size. For every n<\omega and \alpha<\omega_{1} , we bring the following claim (\ast) y^{1}_{\alpha,0}=p^{n}y^{1}_{\alpha,n+1}+\sum_{i\leq n}p^{i}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction i}+\sum_{i\leq n}\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}p^{i}x_{m,\omega\alpha+i}. Indeed, we proceed by induction on n . For n=0 this is clear. Assume it holds for n , then we have \begin{array}[]{ll}y^{1}_{\alpha,0}&=p^{n+1}y^{1}_{\alpha,n+1}+\sum_{i\leq n}p^{i}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction i}+\sum_{i\leq n}\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}p^{i}x_{m,\omega\alpha+i}\\ &=p^{n+1}[py^{1}_{\alpha,n+2}+y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction n+1}+\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}x_{m,\omega\alpha+n+1}]\\ &\quad+\sum_{i\leq n}p^{i}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction i}+\sum_{\leq n}\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}p^{i}x_{m,\omega\alpha+i}\\ &=p^{n+2}y^{1}_{\alpha,n+2}+\sum_{i\leq n+1}p^{i}y^{2}_{\rho_{\alpha}\restriction i}+\sum_{i\leq n+1}\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}p^{i}x_{m,\omega\alpha+i},\end{array} as claimed by (\ast) . Applying \tilde{h}_{\beta} on both sides of (\ast) , and noting that \tilde{h}_{\beta} is identity on x_{m,\omega\beta+i} ’s, we lead to: (*)_{1} For every ordinal \beta<\omega_{1}, n<\omega \tilde{h}_{\beta}(y^{1}_{\beta,0})=p^{n+1}\tilde{h}_{\beta}(y^{1}_{\beta,n+1})+\sum_{i\leq n}p^{i}\tilde{h}_{\beta}(y^{2}_{\rho_{\beta}\restriction i})+\sum_{i\leq n}\sum_{m<\mathbb{k}}p^{i}x_{m,\omega\beta+i}. Note that for each \beta<\omega_{1}, there is some n_{\beta}<\omega such that \tilde{h}_{\beta}(y^{1}_{\beta,0})\in L_{\beta}\restriction n_{\beta}=\bigoplus\{\mathbb{Z}x_{m,\beta+n}:m<\mathbb{k},n0 . Proof. Given \mathbf{k} , we use Discussion 2.10 to find a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter \mathbf{x} which is \aleph_{\omega_{1}\cdot\mathbf{k}} -free and equipped with a \chi -black box, where \chi:=|R|+\aleph_{1} and J:=J_{\aleph_{1}}^{{\rm bd}} . In view of Theorem 4.8 , \mathbf{x} \aleph_{1} -fits the triple (\aleph_{1},\mathbb{d}^{1}_{p},\Xi^{1}_{p}) . In order to get the desired conclusion, it remains to apply Theorem 3.15 . ∎ Corollary 4.10 . Let 0<\mathbf{k}<\omega and let p be a prime number. Then there is a group G\in\mathbf{K}_{p} equipped with the following two properties: (a) if (G_{*},H_{*},h_{*})\in\Xi^{0}_{p} , then every h\in{\rm Hom}(G,H_{*}) is small. (b) G is \aleph_{\omega\cdot\mathbf{k}} -free with respect to \mathbf{K}_{p} . Proof. Recall that we can find a combinatorial \bar{\partial} -parameter \mathbf{x} which is \aleph_{\omega\cdot\mathbf{k}} -free and equipped with a \chi -black box, where \bar{\partial} is the constant sequence \aleph_{0} of length \mathbb{k} , \chi:=\aleph_{1} and J:=J_{\aleph_{0}}^{{\rm bd}} . Thanks to Theorem 4.4 , \mathbf{x} freely \aleph_{1} -fits the triple (\aleph_{0},\mathbb{d}^{0}_{p},\Xi^{0}_{p}) . This allows us to use Theorem 3.15 to get the required group G . ∎