The radio afterglow of the ultra-long GRB 220627A Facilities: ATCA, Fermi /GBM, MeerKAT, Swift /XRT, VLA, VLBA James K. Leung, Om Sharan Salafia, Cristiana Spingola, Giancarlo Ghirlanda, Stefano Giarratana, Marcello Giroletti, Cormac Reynolds, Ziteng Wang, Tao An, Adam Deller, Maria R. Drout, Assaf Horesh, David L. Kaplan, Emil Lenc, Tara Murphy, Miguel Perez-Torres, Lauren Rhodes Abstract We present the discovery of the radio afterglow of the most distant ultra-long gamma-ray burst (GRB) detected to date, GRB 220627A at redshift z = 3.084 z=3.084 . Its prompt gamma-ray light curve shows a double-pulse profile, with the pulses separated by a period of quiescence lasting ∼ 15 {\sim}15 min, leading to early speculation it could be a strongly gravitationally lensed GRB. However, our analysis of the Fermi /GBM spectra taken during the time intervals of both pulses show clear differences in their spectral energy distributions, disfavouring the lensing scenario. We observed the radio afterglow from 7 to 456 d post-burst: an initial, steep decay ( F ν ∝ t − 2 F_{\nu}\propto t^{-2} ) is followed by a shallower decline ( F ν ∝ t − 1 / 2 F_{\nu}\propto t^{-1/2} ) after ∼ 20 {\sim}20 d. There are three scenarios that could explain these radio properties: (i) energy injection from an additional, slower ejecta component catching up to the external shock; (ii) a stratified density profile going as n ∝ r − 8 / 3 n\propto r^{-8/3} ; or alternatively, (iii) the presence of a slow, wide ejecta component in addition to a fast, narrow ejecta component. We also conducted an independent test of the lensing hypothesis via Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) observations at ∼ 12 {\sim}12 d post-burst by searching, for the first time, for multiple images of the candidate lensed GRB afterglow. Our experiment highlighted the growing need for developments in real-time correlation capabilities for time-critical VLBI experiments, particularly as we advance towards the SKA and ngVLA era of radio astronomy. I Introduction Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are produced in highly-relativistic jets launched after the core collapse of a massive star [ 136 , 48 , 122 ] or the merger of binary compact objects [ 28 , 69 , 1 , binary neutron star or neutron star-black hole merger;] . A panchromatic synchrotron afterglow [ 88 , 114 , e.g.,] observable from X-ray down to radio frequencies is produced when the jet decelerates into the circumburst medium, giving rise to both a reverse and forward shock at which relativistic electrons are accelerated. Monitoring the radio afterglow up until late times is crucial for constraining the microphysics and energetics of any given event [ 20 , for a review, see] . The radio afterglow may also probe the reverse shock [ 115 , 64 , 3 , 126 , 65 , 14 , e.g.,] with greater observational latency (up to few days post-burst) compared with shorter wavelengths and allow for structure or proper motion on milli-arcsecond scales to be resolved through Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) techniques. However, only a small fraction of GRBs {\sim}12\% have radio follow-up [ 20 , 2 , even fewer {\sim}6\% with radio detections; see the table of GRBs 1 1 1 https://www.mpe.mpg.de/~jcg/grbgen.html maintained by Jochen Greiner and also ] and only a handful of GRBs have been observed with VLBI [ 124 , 84 , 81 , 36 , 40 , 111 , 41 , e.g., GRBs 030329A, 151027A, 170817A, 190829A, 201015A, 221009A ] . Now, with this paper, GRB 220627A joins this small set of events with a comprehensive radio campaign lasting more than 400 d including high angular resolution VLBI follow-up. The most striking feature of GRB 220627A was the presence of two emission episodes, showing similar temporal profiles, separated by {\sim}15\, min in the prompt gamma-ray light curve [ 107 ] . The initial trigger event on the Fermi /Gamma-ray Burst Monitor [ 79 , GBM, 8 keV - 40 MeV; ] occurred at 21:21:00.09 UT on 2022 June 27 [ 32 ] . The detection of this prompt emission was later confirmed by reports of high-energy detections by the Fermi /Large Area Telescope [ 5 , LAT, operating at a higher energy range than Fermi /GBM from 20\, MeV - 300\, GeV; ] [ 27 ] , Swift /Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) via the Gamma-Ray Urgent Archiver for Novel Opportunities (GUANO) programme [ 99 ] , Konus- Wind [ 33 ] , and the AstroSat Cadmium-Zinc-Telluride Imager (CZTI) [ 123 ] . A second trigger event on the Fermi /GBM, localised to the same region of the sky, occurred {\sim}15\, min later; it was shown that this second burst episode had a similar duration 2 2 2 T 90 is a quantity that represents the time interval covering 90% of the total background-subtracted counts detected by the instrument. (T {}_{90}\approx 127\, s) and burst shape to the first episode (T {}_{90}\approx 138\, s). This second episode was also detected across the different energy bands of Konus- Wind ( 20-100\, keV, 100-400\, keV) and AstroSat ( 20-200\, keV) instruments, providing a further spectral constraint on the possible emission mechanisms. The two immediate competing interpretations proposed were either: (i) a gravitationally lensed GRB event, or (ii) an ultra-long GRB event [ 107 ] , which are conventionally characterised as those with durations greater than 1\,000 s . A gravitationally lensed GRB event is expected to have clear signatures imprinted on the prompt light curve: two or more segments of the light curve should show similar temporal and spectral profiles that are indicative of different arrival times for photons from different lensed images due to the different paths traversed [ 73 ] . Given that up to 4 GRBs may be detected on any given day, out to very high redshifts z\sim 9 [ 112 , for a brief review of high-redshift GRBs, see] , a small fraction of them are expected to be gravitationally lensed: approximately 1 in 1000 GRBs [ 73 ] or {\sim}0.3\,\textrm{sky}^{-1}\,\textrm{yr}^{-1} [ 87 ] . To date, five bursts have been claimed to be gravitationally lensed via the identification of feature similarities in different segments of their prompt light curves: GRBs 950830 [ 93 ] , 081126A [ 70 ] , 090717 [ 56 ] , 200716C [ 131 , 137 ] , and 210812A [ 129 ] . However, among them, many of these claims have been disputed on statistical grounds [ 82 , e.g.,] . Lensed GRBs allow the physical properties of the intervening lens to be studied [ 93 , e.g.,] and for time-delay cosmography to be performed, yielding new constraints on cosmological parameters, such as the Hubble parameter [ 104 ] . Recent examples of time-delay cosmography have mainly been through the study of lensed supernovae — e.g., SN Refsdal [ 60 , 59 ] , SN H0pe [ 21 , 95 , 92 ] , and SN Encore [ 96 ] — their effectiveness for doing cosmology will improve with better precision in the time-delay measurements and improved techniques for modelling of the lenses. Despite the initial potential for advancing on this front, the lensing interpretation of the GRB 220627A prompt light curve was later shown to be inconsistent with the higher-energy Fermi /LAT data [ 52 ] . In their analysis of these Fermi /LAT data, Huang et al. [52] showed that the high-energy spectrum of the burst in the first episode was inconsistent with that in the second episode: 49 photons above 100\, MeV were detected by Fermi /LAT in the first episode compared to none in the second. With the lensing interpretation disfavoured, GRB 220627A was instead classified as an ultra-long GRBs, the eighth such event to be confirmed in the literature [see, e.g., 17 , 68 , and references therein] . It should be noted that GRB 220627A belongs to a less common subset of ultra-long GRBs with “interrupted emission” (in contrast to those with “continuous emission”; see Virgili et al. 130 for a discussion): its prompt light curve features two pulses of activity separated by a long period of quiescence, rather than the ‘continuous’ activity (without periods of quiescence) seen in more typical ultra-long GRB prompt light curves. The {\sim}15 min period of quiescence between the two episodes is rather uncommon; only GRB 080407A has been reported in the literature with a longer period of quiescence ( {\sim}1\,400 s) between two observed emission episodes [ 130 ] . It is still unclear whether the ultra-long GRB subpopulation represents the tail of the standard long GRB duration distribution [ 130 ] or a new class of GRBs with fundamentally different properties [ 13 ] . Evidence of properties for this subpopulation differing from standard long GRBs have started to emerge. For example, SN 2011kl, associated with ultra-long GRB 111209A, was found to be three times more luminous compared to Type Ic supernovae associated with standard long GRBs, while also possessing a very distinct supernova spectrum [ 43 ] . The ultra-long GRB 130925A also displayed spectral properties [ 8 , 7 ] seldom observed in the standard long GRB population: the X-ray spectrum transitioned from a softer spectrum (unusual for afterglows) to a harder spectrum (more typical for afterglows), which suggested the presence of either a thermal hot cocoon component [ 97 ] or a dust echo scattering the prompt emission [ 31 , 141 ] ; and the radio spectrum exhibited a sharp cutoff (decline) above 10 GHz [ 50 ] , which could not be explained using an electron spectral index consistent with the values inferred from the wider GRB population ( 1.5
6\times 10^{21}\,
cm
-2
) and softer photon index (
\Gamma>3
) than the normal population; this was interpreted as indications of a turbulent mass-loss history from the progenitor leading to a dusty wind environment or simply the presence of a large stellar progenitor located in a dusty environment
[
76
]
.
More generally, the following four scenarios have been proposed to explain the long central engine activity required for ultra-long GRBs. (1) core-collapse of low-metallicity blue supergiants with much larger radii than the Wolf-Rayet progenitors of standard long GRBs: they can provide enough mass to power the central engine for thousands of seconds
[
35
,
57
,
83
,
94
, e.g.,]
; (2) tidal disruption of white dwarfs by black holes with mass
<10^{5}\,M_{\odot}
: they can produce accretion timescales of the bound debris and energetics that are consistent with ultra-long GRBs
[
12
,
16
,
138
,
68
,
72
,
54
, e.g.,]
; (3) the spin-down of a newly formed magnetar remnant following the launch of the GRB jet: the ultra-long duration of the GRB can be explained by the extra spin-down energy injection
[
125
,
43
]
; and (4) standard long GRB progenitor (Wolf-Rayet star) in a low-density circumburst environment (e.g.,
<10^{-3}
cm
-3
): the external shock forms further out from the progenitor in a low-density environment, allowing more time for internal shocks to dissipate radiative energy, which leads to both a higher prompt efficiency and a longer duration consistent with ultra-long GRBs
[
31
]
.
An afterglow for GRB 220627A was detected at X-ray
[
45
]
, optical
[
24
,
85
]
, and radio
[
67
,
39
]
wavelengths.
Its localisation enabled the identification of narrow metal absorption lines within the afterglow, placing the spectroscopic redshift measurement of the afterglow at
z=3.084
(making it the most distant ultra-long GRB detected to date), in addition to lines from an intervening system at
z=2.665
[
55
,
25
]
.
In this paper, we present the results from our radio observations of GRB 220627A spanning over 400 days post-burst, which include VLBI observations intended for testing the lensing hypothesis.
While the high-energy spectrum in this case provided sufficient data to disfavour the lensing scenario, VLBI observations offer an independent and direct test of this hypothesis, potentially free from ambiguities from light curve and spectral analysis only.
In the case of strong lensing, these observations would enable us to model the lens, which is an important step for using lensed GRB events for time-delay cosmography.
In Section
II
, we give an overview of our ongoing VLBI program for confirming lensed GRB candidates.
In Section
III
, we present the radio observations of GRB 220627A used in this work.
In Section
IV
, we re-assess the
Fermi
/GBM data originally used to classify GRB 220627A as a candidate lensed GRB,
discuss our physical interpretation of the radio afterglow, and described the outcomes of our VLBI experiment.
We summarise our conclusions in Section
V
.
Throughout this paper, we assume a flat
\Lambda
-CDM cosmology with
H_{0}=~67.7
km s
-1
Mpc
-1
,
\Omega_{\text{M}}=0.310
, and
\Omega_{\Lambda}=0.690
[
98
]
.
II
Imaging Lensed GRB Afterglows with VLBI
GRB 220627A was the first event trigger for our ongoing VLBI programme aimed at verifying candidate lensed GRBs.
In this section, we describe why we triggered VLBI and the companion compact interferometer campaign for GRB 220627A.
In particular, we discuss how we used VLBI to test the gravitational lensing hypothesis of GRB 220627A and the broader scientific implications of confirming a lensed GRB candidate.
II.1
Strongly Lensed Gamma-Ray Bursts
If a GRB is strongly gravitationally lensed, multiple images of the GRB would be produced
[
87
, e.g.,]
.
In the scenario where the observing instrument does not have sufficient angular resolution to resolve the lensed images,
the gravitational lens signature may be superimposed onto the prompt light curve
[
10
]
.
Any flux variation from the GRB would appear at different times in the lensed images because the photons travel different path lengths.
Therefore, in a spatially unresolved light curve there would be two pulses (for two lensed images), where the temporal profile of the second pulse should be similar to the first pulse, albeit weaker in intensity.
The spectral properties of the two pulses in this scenario should also be similar, i.e., the lens signature is consistent across all energy bands.
The time delay between the two pulses can be explained by a combination of both the Shapiro time delay and geometric effects from differing paths traversed by the two rays; it is governed by the relation provided in
Krauss and Small [63]
:
\Delta t=\frac{2GM_{z}}{c^{3}}\bigg[\frac{r-1}{\sqrt{r}}+\textrm{ln}(r)\bigg]\ \textrm{s},
(1)
where
M_{z}=M(1+z_{\textrm{L}})
is the redshifted lens mass (
z_{\textrm{L}}
is the lens redshift),
r
is the brightness ratio of the two lensed images,
G
is the gravitational constant, and
c
is the speed of light.
In the case of lensed GRB candidates reported to date (including GRB 220627A), the time delays between the putative lensed images are usually seconds to minutes
[
129
,
131
,
137
, e.g.,]
.
In this case, using Equation
1
and assuming a range of
r
from 1.5 to 5 and
z
up to
{\sim}9
, we would infer a lens mass of
{\sim}10^{5-7}
M
⊙
.
We note that the optical depth of lenses in this mass range is expected to be an order of magnitude lower than those with more typical “galactic” masses (
{\sim}10^{12}
M
⊙
)
[
71
]
, and that none have been conclusively identified to date.
However, this suggests that lensed GRBs may provide a promising avenue to conclusively identify the first lens within this mass range (see Subsection
II.2
below).
Since high-energy satellites have sub-second temporal resolutions, double-pulse prompt light curves have been the basis of various claims (and disputes) of gravitationally lensed GRBs as discussed in Section
I
.
As an example, we show in Figure
1
the prompt light curve for GRB 220627A (the burst that is the focus of this manuscript) from
Fermi
/GBM.
The presence of two pulses with a flux ratio
r\approx 3
[
107
, this was determined by the ratio of the pulse fluences and is typical of a doubly-imaged strong lensing system; see also]
, which showed similar temporal profiles across more than one energy band, initially provided compelling evidence supporting the strong gravitational lensing scenario.
However, such observations cannot rule out the possibility that the double-pulse profile may be produced by a physical emission mechanism intrinsic to the GRB (rather than by lensing),
or even the possibility that the double-pulse profile does not appear in energy bands outside the observable range of the instrument (e.g., as demonstrated by GRB 220627A, the double-pulse profile was clear in the
Fermi
/GBM data, but was lacking in the
Fermi
/LAT data;
Huang et al. 52
).
The smoking gun for a gravitationally lensed GRB would be the direct detection of two (or more) consistently evolving lensed images of the afterglow with the same surface brightness.
The angular separation of the images is on the order of the Einstein radius:
\theta_{\textrm{E}}=\sqrt{\frac{4GM}{c^{2}}\frac{D_{\textrm{LS}}}{D_{\textrm{L}}D_{\textrm{S}}}}\ \textrm{rad},
(2)
where
D_{\textrm{LS}}
,
D_{\textrm{L}}
and
D_{\textrm{S}}
are the distances between the lens and the GRB, the distance to the lens, and the distance to the GRB, respectively.
For a typical event, with GRB redshift
z_{\textrm{S}}=1
and lens redshift
z_{\textrm{L}}=0.4
, the Einstein radius for a
10^{6}\,M_{\odot}
point mass lens (the typical lens mass inferred from previous claims; see above) is
\theta_{\textrm{E}}\approx 3\,\textrm{mas}\,(M/10^{6}\,M_{\odot})^{1/2}(D/0.6\,\textrm{Gpc})^{-1/2}
, where
D=D_{\textrm{L}}D_{\textrm{LS}}/D_{\textrm{S}}
[
129
]
. As a result, these systems are typically referred to as “milli-lens” systems.
Specifically for GRB 220627A, given its redshift and that of the intervening system (which we interpret here as a potential lens), the expected Einstein radius would be
\theta_{\textrm{E}}\approx 1.8
mas.
Considering this typical angular scale expected from lensed GRB systems, direct detection of the two images in the prompt gamma-rays or through standard X-ray/optical/radio afterglow observations would be infeasible.
VLBI is currently the only way of reaching the necessary angular resolution for confirming a strongly lensed GRB event.
To confirm a strongly lensed GRB event with VLBI observations, the detection of spatially resolved components would be required.
Ideally, these detections are made in at least two epochs, with at least one epoch featuring quasi-simultaneous observations at two or more frequencies.
These allow for a confirmation of lensing by checking:
•
for consistency between the spectra of two lensed images
[
58
, e.g., figure 6 of]
;
3
3
3
In this case, we note that the time delays observed in many putative lensed GRBs – seconds to minutes – are much shorter than the
timescale on which the typical radio afterglow spectrum undergoes significant change (
\sim
days).
•
for surface brightness preservation between the two lensed images (a necessary signature of gravitational lensing);
•
that the two lensed images preserve their brightness ratio as they evolve and, aided by complementary low-resolution radio observations, evolve in accordance with known GRB closure relations
[
114
, e.g.,]
; and
•
that the brightness ratio of the afterglow images matches the ratio of the pulse fluences from the GRB prompt light curve (although there are certain scenarios where this may not hold, e.g., if there are significant wavelength-dependent absorption and scattering effects caused by the lens galaxy, or if the prompt emission comes from an emitting region with a large displacement from the radio emitting region – see
Mittal et al. 80
,
Cheung et al. 22
).
The combination of all these checks makes a confirmation robust against potential ambiguities that arise from using one or two checks, such as the possibility of chance spatial association with non-afterglow related sources (e.g., a background host galaxy nucleus).
II.2
Broader Scientific Implications
The confirmation of a strongly lensed GRB candidate has scientific implications for time-delay cosmography, the physics of the lens, and our understanding of GRBs.
A confirmation would provide a new example of gravitational lensing to test Einstein’s general relativity, checking for consistency in both the temporal and spatial data.
Like other strong gravitationally lensed explosive transients, lensed GRBs have important applications in time-delay cosmography; the measured time delay can be used alongside a well-constrained Einstein radius to constrain the Hubble parameter
H_{0}
[
104
]
.
This is a direct consequence of the time delay between the lensed GRB images being dependent on the mass distribution of the lens, which can be modelled from the morphology and distribution of detected components in high-resolution VLBI images, as well as geometric effects from different paths in space-time, which is determined by the Hubble parameter – for a comprehensive review of time-delay cosmography for transients, see
Oguri [87]
.
As GRBs are found at high redshifts up to
z\sim 9
[
112
, e.g.,]
and their prompt light curves (and any time delays) can be sampled accurately down to sub-second temporal resolution
[
79
, e.g.,]
, strongly lensed GRBs can potentially probe for lens mass and distance ranges that cannot be probed by strongly lensed quasars and supernovae (since the temporal resolution of the time delay determines the redshifted lens mass range your probe is sensitive to as shown in Equation
1
).
Accompanying previous claims of lensed GRs were suggestions of using them to study the population statistics and physics of their lenses
[
93
, e.g.,]
.
In fact, a confirmation of a lensed GRB (with an observed time delay on the order of seconds to minutes) could also lead to the first confirmation of a milli-lens object, which implies the presence of massive compact objects, such as intermediate-mass black holes (IMBH) and dark matter halos expected in some dark matter models
[
135
,
121
,
19
, e.g.,]
.
On the other hand, a conclusive rejection of a lensing explanation for a GRB with a double-pulse profile would put extra constraints on the physics of GRB central engines.
For example, current GRB models that can explain multiple pulses in the prompt emission would need to be extended to explain how their emission mechanism in some GRBs can produce repeated pulses with similar temporal and spectral profiles.
In the specific case of GRB 220627A, the comparison of the
Fermi
/GBM and
Fermi
/LAT data that ultimately disfavoured the lensing hypothesis
[
52
]
indicated that the GRB belonged to the subpopulation of ultra-long GRBs.
Motivated by these broader scientific implications for confirming and characterising a lensed GRB event, we began our radio campaign to independently test the lensing hypothesis for GRB 220627A through VLBI shortly after the GRB was detected; this campaign is described in the following section.
Figure 1:
Background subtracted light curve of GRB 220627A from the
Fermi
/GBM NaI#3 and BGO#0 detectors showing the count rate obtained integrating the signal in the
10-900\,
keV and
300-30\,000\,
keV energy range, respectively.
The shaded pink and green regions show the time intervals selected for the spectral analysis.
III
Observations and Data Analysis
Here, we outline our radio observations triggered for GRB 220627A as part of the VLBI programme, which aimed to provide an independent test of the lensing hypothesis to verify the conclusions from the analysis of high-energy spectra.
The Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA), MeerKAT, and the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) observations led to the discovery of the radio afterglow and contributed to the monitoring of its evolution over a span of
{\sim}400
d.
This set of observations informed our trigger of the high-resolution Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) observations.
III.1
ATCA Observations
Table 1:
Radio flux-density measurements for GRB 220627A.
Columns 1 through 4 show the number of days
in the observer frame
since the
Fermi
/GBM trigger (21:21:00.09 UT on 2022 June 27), the observing telescope, the central observing frequency of the radio image, and the flux-density measurements for the observation.
We report the
3\sigma
limit for all non-detections
, where
\sigma
here is simply the rms noise.
The only exception is for the VLBA observation, where a more conservative
5\sigma
limit is provided instead.
The reported uncertainties
include both the statistical and systematic components added together in quadrature.
Here, the systematic errors arising from flux-density scale calibration are typically
\lesssim 5
per cent for the ATCA, MeerKAT, and VLA, and
\lesssim 15
per cent for the VLBA (which is higher because it relies on system temperatures and gain curves for flux-density calibration, rather than an observation of a dedicated flux-density calibrator).
t
(d)
Telescope
\nu
(GHz)
F_{\nu}
(µJy)
0
7.5
ATCA
0
5.5
<98
0
7.5
ATCA
0
9.0
<91
0
7.5
ATCA
16.9
373\pm{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}74}\phantom{0}
0
8.9
MeerKAT
0
1.3
<28
11.7
VLBA
15.2
<293
15.2
VLA
10.0
<60
15.2
VLA
15.0
74\pm{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}18}
27.4
ATCA
0
5.5
{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}<63}
27.4
ATCA
0
9.0
{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}<41}
27.4
ATCA
17.7
63\pm{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}19}
35.7
MeerKAT
0
1.3
{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}<44}
39.0
VLA
0
6.0
{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}<41}
45.1
VLA
15.1
44\pm{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}8}\phantom{0}
455.7
ATCA
16.9
{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}<19}
We observed the field of GRB 220627A with the ATCA, using the coordinates of the reported optical afterglow
[
24
]
as the phase tracking centre.
We conducted four epochs of ATCA observations, observing the first epoch on 2022 July 5 for 10 h
(7.5 d post-burst)
, the second epoch on 2022 July 25 for 12.5 h
(27.4 d post-burst)
, the third epoch on 2023 September 22 for 12 h
(452.2 d post-burst)
, and the fourth epoch on 2023 September 29 for 12 h
(459.2 d post-burst)
, all under project C3478 (PI: J. Leung).
For the first two epochs, the observations were observed at multiple bands, centred on 5.5, 9, 17 and 19 GHz, each with a bandwidth of 2 GHz, while for the final two epochs, the observations were observed only at 17 and 19 GHz, each with a bandwidth of 2 GHz.
The array was in H214 configuration for the first two observations and in H168 configuration for the final two epochs.
4
4
4
https://www.narrabri.atnf.csiro.au/operations/array_configurations/configurations.html
In these configurations, the maximum baselines are
247
and
192\,
m, respectively. The values do not consider baselines involving antenna CA06 (all of which exceed
4\,
km) since they were flagged in our data reduction process as discussed below.
We reduced the visibility data using standard
Miriad
procedures
[
116
]
.
We used PKS B1934
-
638 to set the flux-density scale and calibrate the bandpass response, and PKS B1313
-
333 (J1316
-
3338) to calibrate the complex gains.
Prior to imaging, we flagged out all the baselines involving antenna CA06.
This was because the large gap in (
u,v
)-coverage between these longer baselines and the other much shorter baselines in the array created difficulties in the imaging process (due to the highly irregular shape of the resulting dirty beam).
We produced images using the multi-frequency synthesis CLEAN algorithm
[
49
,
23
,
117
]
and extracted flux densities in the case of a detection by fitting a point-source model in the image plane.
For the 2022 July 5
(7.5 d post-burst)
, 2023 September 22
(452.2 d post-burst)
, and 2023 September 29
(459.2 d post-burst)
observations, we did not use the 19 GHz band as it was either severely affected by poor weather conditions or radio frequency interference.
However, both the 17 and 19 GHz frequency bands provided reliable data for the 2022 July 25
(27.4 d post-burst)
observations so we could image them together, providing a contiguous bandwidth of 4 GHz centred on approximately 18 GHz.
In order to obtain a deep late-time image of the field, we also imaged the 2023 September 22 and 29 observations
(mean epoch of 455.7 d post-burst)
at 17 GHz together, providing an effective total integration time of 15 h.
The flux densities (and
3\sigma
upper limits for non-detections) are reported in Table
1
.
The rms noise in all bands was higher in the first observation, compared to the second, due to poor weather conditions.
III.2
MeerKAT Observations
We observed the field of GRB 220627A with the MeerKAT telescope on 2022 July 6
(8.9 d post-burst)
and 2022 August 2
(35.7 d post-burst)
under project DDT-20220705-SG-01 (PI: S. Giarratana) for 2 h each.
These observations were centred on 1.28 GHz (L band) with a bandwidth of 0.78 GHz.
We used PKS B1934
-
638 for bandpass and flux-density scale calibration, J1311
-
2216 for phase calibration.
The archived raw visibilities were converted to the Measurement Set format with the KAT Data Access Library (
katdal
5
5
5
https://github.com/ska-sa/katdal
) for continuum imaging.
We reduced the data using
oxkat
6
6
6
https://github.com/IanHeywood/oxkat
[
47
, v0.3;]
, where: the Common Astronomy Software Applications
[
78
,
18
,
CASA
;]
and
Tricolour
7
7
7
https://github.com/ska-sa/tricolour
[
53
]
packages were used for measurement set splitting, cross-calibration, flagging;
CubiCal
8
8
8
https://github.com/ratt-ru/CubiCal
[
62
]
was used for self-calibration; and
WSClean
[
86
]
was used for continuum imaging. All processes were executed with
oxkat
L-band default settings.
We do not detect any radio emission at the source location in both observations.
The
3\sigma
non-detection limits are given in Table
1
.
III.3
VLA Observations
We obtained observations for GRB 220627A with the VLA at three separate epochs, with 1 h of observation time per epoch, under project VLA/22B-031 (Legacy ID: AL1245; PI: J. Leung).
The first epoch of observations occurred on 2022 July 13
(15.2 d post-burst)
, at the 10 and 15 GHz (X and Ku) frequency bands, with the array in A
\rightarrow
D configuration.
9
9
9
This observation occurred during a reconfiguration, where the VLA antennas were transitioning from the A configuration (with a maximum baseline of 36 km) to the D configuration (with a maximum baseline of 1 km). For more information on VLA configurations, see:
https://public.nrao.edu/vla-configurations/
We then obtained a second epoch at the 6 GHz (C band) frequency band on 2022 August 5
(39.0 d post-burst)
and a third epoch at the 15 GHz (Ku band) frequency band on 2022 August 11
(45.1 d post-burst)
; the array was in D configuration for both the second and third epoch of observations.
For each observation, we used 3C 286 to calibrate the bandpass response and flux-density scale; we also used PKS B1313
-
333 (J1316
-
3338) to calibrate the complex gains.
Prior to imaging, we obtained the pipeline-calibrated
10
10
10
All VLA data is calibrated by an automated
CASA
pipeline
[
61
]
. For more information, see:
https://science.nrao.edu/facilities/vla/data-processing/pipeline
visibility data from the data archives (see Data Availability section).
We used
CASA
to verify the quality of the pipeline-calibrated data and also to image the field using the wide-field, multi-frequency synthesis CLEAN algorithm.
For the 2022 July 13
(15.2 d post-burst)
observation, due to problems associated with the unbalanced
(u,v)
-coverage of the hybrid array, we were only able to obtain reliable data by using just the antennas that had already moved to the D configuration (i.e., we flagged all antennas located more than 2 km from the centre of the array).
After further accounting for antennas under maintenance and antennas flagged by the automated pipeline, the imaging process for the 10 and 15 GHz observations on 2022 July 13
(15.2 d post-burst)
used data from only 12 and 13 antennas, respectively; for the 2022 August 5
(39.0 d post-burst)
observation (at 6 GHz), the imaging process used data from 21 antennas; and for the 2022 August 11 observation
(45.1 d post-burst)
at 15 GHz, the imaging process used data from 22 antennas.
Further self-calibration was not performed for all observations since weak field sources in addition to the presence of poorly-modelled extended sources led to limited improvements in the gain solutions.
Due to the presence of imaging artefacts caused by the sidelobes of a bright, extended source outside the primary beam, PKS J1325
-
3236, we phase rotated the 2022 August 5 (6-GHz band) visibility data to J2000 13:25:32.8,
-
32:30:45 before imaging so we could deconvolve both the target and PKS J1325
-
3236 in our CLEAN cycles.
For each observation, we imaged using the full bandwidth; i.e., 4 GHz for the observations centred on 6 and 10 GHz and 6 GHz for the observations centred on 15 GHz.
In the case of a detection, we extracted the flux densities by fitting a point-source model in the image plane and report them in Table
1
(for non-detections, we give the
3\sigma
upper limit).
III.4
VLBA Observations
We obtained high-resolution observations for GRB 220627A with the VLBA on two consecutive days under project VLBA/22B-032 (Legacy ID: BL296; PI: J. Leung).
These observations were 6 h in duration, starting at 22:30 UT on both 2022 July 8 and 9
(corresponding to a mean epoch of 11.7 d post-burst)
.
All standard VLBA antennas,
11
11
11
The standard array of antennas consists of 10 stations, see:
https://science.nrao.edu/facilities/vlba/docs/manuals/oss/sites
with the exception of the Kitt Peak station which was out due to wildfires, were available for both observations.
The longest baseline was from Mauna Kea to Saint Croix, giving a projected baseline of
{\sim}8\,600
km or
{\sim}430
M
\lambda
.
For these observations, the VLBA was configured to use the digital downconverter (DDC) observing system, observing at the central frequency of 15.168 GHz (Ku band), with a total bandwidth of 512 MHz (split into four 128 MHz sub-bands) in two circular polarisations (right- and left-circular polarisations).
Using a 2-bit sampler, the resulting data rate was 4 Gbps.
The data were correlated after the observations using DiFX
[
26
]
with an integration time of 1 s and a spectral resolution of 1 MHz at Socorro, New Mexico, USA.
We carried out standard reduction procedures on the correlated datasets from both observations simultaneously using
AIPS
[
44
]
.
We applied standard
a-priori
amplitude calibration using the provided system temperature and gain curve tables.
The instrumental delays were determined using the fringe finders J0555
+
3948 and J1642
+
3948.
The latter was also used for solving the bandpass.
Since the expected flux density of our target, GRB 220627A, was
<0.5\,
mJy as informed by our earlier ATCA observations, we phase-referenced our experiment using the calibrator J1324
-
3235, which was observed in 45 s scans as part of 100 s duty cycle.
Although this calibrator had a low unresolved flux-density measurement at 8.6 GHz (50 mJy), it was chosen due to its close separation (
0.32\arcdeg
) from the target position, which was particularly important given the low elevation of the source with respect to the VLBA antenna stations.
To attain better signal-to-noise, we combined all the sub-bands during our global fringe fitting process on the fringe finders and phase-reference calibrators in order to solve for the residual phases, delays, and rates.
The solutions from the phase-reference calibrator were interpolated to both the target and our check source, PKS B1313
-
333 (J1316
-
3338), located
1.75\arcdeg
away from the target.
Finally, we used
Difmap
[
119
]
with a natural weighting scheme (after trying several other robust weighting schemes to search for sources in the field of interest) to obtain the final images of both the target and the check source.
The resulting image had a beam size of
0.49\,\textrm{mas}\times 1.51\,\textrm{mas}
with a position angle of
-5.4\arcdeg
.
In our VLBA observations, we were unable to identify any sources that were related to the GRB 220627A event within the optical
12
12
12
Optical position:
\alpha=13
:25:28.49,
\delta=-32
:25:33.31, uncertainty of 0.1
\arcsec
for each coordinate
[
24
]
.
and radio
13
13
13
Radio position:
\alpha=13
:25:28.57,
\delta=-32
:25:33.31, uncertainty of 0.1
\arcsec
on
\alpha
and 0.2
\arcsec
on
\delta
(from our highest signal-to-noise VLA detection).
positional uncertainties.
The final target image achieved an rms sensitivity of
51\,
µJy beam
-1
and no noise peaks exceeded the
5\sigma
level (i.e.,
{\sim}250
µJy beam
-1
).
After performing self-calibration iterations on the check source (located further from the phase-reference calibrator than the target), we found that the phase errors were no more than
{\sim}10\arcdeg
for most antennas, suggesting that possible problems with phase transfer were not responsible for the non-detection.
The
5\sigma
upper limit is reported in Table
1
.
We verified this result in an independent calibration of the data (as a blind test) using standard reduction procedures in
CASA
; we attained a similar rms sensitivity (and upper limit), arriving at the same conclusions.
IV
Results and Discussion
IV.1
Re-analysis of
Fermi
/GBM Observations and Classification as an Ultra-long GRB
Interval
log(L)
E_{\rm peak}
\alpha
\beta
factor
PG-stat(dof)
(sec)
(erg/s)
(keV)
[-6,300]
52.37^{+0.04}_{-0.04}
282.8^{+33.1}_{-29.6}
0.95^{+0.06}_{-0.06}
2.7{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}4}^{+0.39}_{-0.28}
1.10^{+0.16}_{-0.13}
704(219)
[910,1096]
52.17^{+0.09}_{-0.09}
366.1^{+803.6}_{-143.6}
1.31^{+0.10}_{-0.14}
2.56^{+2.03}_{-0.51}
0.67^{+0.31}_{-0.22}
337(219)
Table 2:
Spectral parameters of the fit of the prompt emission spectrum of the two emission episodes. Errors represent the 95% confidence interval for each parameter value.
Figure 2:
Posterior distributions of the parameters of the spectral fit to the two time intervals (violet and green for interval 1 and 2 respectively, see Table
2
). The median and 95% confidence intervals are marked by the dashed vertical lines in the histograms.
Figure 3:
Spectra energy distribution of the prompt emission spectrum. The two time intervals analysed are shown. The shaded regions represent the 68% confidence interval on the best fit model (solid lines).
GRB 220627A was originally proposed as a candidate lensed GRB based on similar pulse profiles observed in the
Fermi
/GBM data
[
107
]
.
While this interpretation was later disfavoured after assessing the spectra inferred for both pulses using data from
Fermi
/LAT
[
52
]
, we check to see whether a similar conclusion could have been drawn from the
Fermi
/GBM data alone.
In particular, we analyse the
Fermi
/GBM data of both the NaI#3 and BGO#0 detectors.
We used the
Fermi
Science Tools
v.2.2.0 to analyse the
Fermi
/GBM data following the standard procedure
14
14
14
https://fermi.gsfc.nasa.gov/ssc/data/analysis/software/
[
100
,
102
, e.g.,]
. We extracted the light curves of NaI#3 in the
10-900
keV energy range and of BG#0 in the
300-30\,000
keV energy range.
The background subtracted light curve of these two detectors is shown in the top and bottom panels, respectively, of Figure
1
.
The prompt emission shows two distinct emission episodes, each lasting few hundred seconds, separated by a much longer period of quiescence.
The two emission episodes have quite different temporal structures, with the first one being more variable and the second one apparently composed by two sub-pulses.
We extracted the time integrated spectrum of the two emission episodes by selecting two time intervals, [
-6
,300] and [910,1096] seconds, shown by the shaded regions in Figure
1
.
Given the large separation of the two time intervals, the background spectrum was estimated by considering four intervals bracketing the two emission episodes: [
-450
,
-200
], [400,500], [700,850], and [1200,1300] seconds.
A third order polynomial was fit to the spectra contained in these time intervals and then interpolated to the time region selected for the spectral analysis.
We performed the spectral analysis with
Xspec
v.12.14.0
[
4
]
. We considered the energy range between 10 and 900 keV for the NaI spectrum and excluded the
30
to
40\,
keV range due to the contamination by the Iodine K-edge at such energies. The energy range 300 keV to 30 MeV was considered for the BGO spectrum. We allowed for a free inter-calibration constant factor between the NaI and BGO spectra.
We adopted the PG-stat, i.e., Poisson statistic for the source counts and Gaussian statistic for the background counts, in performing the fit.
The spectral model adopted is a smoothly broken power law:
\frac{dN}{dE}=AE_{\rm break}^{-\alpha}\left[\left(\frac{E}{E_{\rm break}}\right)^{\alpha n}+\left(\frac{E}{E_{\rm break}}\right)^{\beta n}\right]^{-\frac{1}{n}}
(3)
in photons cm
-2
s
-1
keV
-1
units.
\alpha
and
\beta
are the spectral index of the power laws below and above, respectively, the characteristic break energy
E_{\rm break}
. The model parameter
n
sets the curvature between the two power laws. We assume
n=2
which resembles the curvature of the typical Band function which has been fitted to GRB spectra (
Band et al. 6
, see also
Ravasio et al. 101
).
The normalization constant in Equation
3
is defined as:
A={{L}\over{4\pi d_{L}(z)^{2}\int_{1\,{\rm keV}/(1+z)}^{10\,{\rm MeV}/(1+z)}E\times{{dN}\over{dE}}{dE}}}
(4)
where
L
is the luminosity in units of [erg/s] in the 1 keV
-
10 MeV rest frame energy range and
d_{L}(z)
is the luminosity distance corresponding to the redshift
z
of the source. Therefore, the luminosity
L
is one of the four free parameters of the spectral model.
The peak energy of the spectral energy distribution (SED), i.e., the energy where
E^{2}\times dN/dE
peaks, is:
E_{\rm peak}={{E_{\rm break}}\over{\left({{\alpha-2}\over{2-\beta}}\right)^{{1}\over{n(\alpha-\beta)}}}}
(5)
We report the fit results for the two time intervals in Table
2
.
The posterior distributions of the fit parameters are shown in Figure
2
and the resulting fits are shown in Figure
3
.
In addition to the aforementioned differences in temporal structures between the first and second episodes (as shown in Figure
1
), the spectra taken at the two time intervals are clearly distinct from each other, e.g., the
\alpha
slope parameter differs between the two intervals with a significance
>5\sigma
.
It is likely that the initial lensing hypothesis proposed in
Roberts et al. [107]
was based off the analysis of the
Fermi
/GBM data with lower-resolution binning, where the temporal structures between the two episodes are more similar.
Therefore, based on the re-analysis of the
Fermi
/GBM data alone – without requiring the additional information from
Fermi
/LAT as in
Huang et al. [52]
– we can reject the lensed GRB hypothesis and verify the ultra-long GRB classification.
IV.2
Phenomenology and Interpretation of the Radio Afterglow
In addition to informing our VLBI observations, our broadband radio light curves provide a detailed view of the afterglow of GRB 220627A between
\sim
4 and 450 days post-burst.
Here we assess implications of these observations on the properties of the afterglow and the progenitors of ultra-long GRBs.
Figure 4:
Left
:
Radio light curves for GRB 220627A.
Radio detections are represented with circular markers.
3\sigma
upper limits, represented using downward-pointing triangular markers, are used for all non-detections, with the exception of the VLBA observation (
t=11.7
d,
\nu=15.2
GHz), where a
5\sigma
upper limit is used instead.
The grey dotted and dashed lines show a
t^{-2}
and a
t^{-1/2}
slope, respectively, for reference.
Right:
Radio spectra for GRB 220627A.
The plot shows different spectral snapshots centred around 3 different times as indicated in the legend.
Markers carry the same meaning as those in the light curves plot.
The grey dotted and dashed lines show a
\nu^{2}
and a
\nu^{1/3}
slope, respectively, for reference.
IV.2.1
Basic Properties of the Radio Afterglow
Radio frequency light curves and spectra of the GRB 220627A afterglow at 7.5, 15, and 27 d post-burst are shown in Figure
4
.
Our ATCA observations 7.5 post-trigger (light blue spectrum in the
right
panel of Figure
4
) indicate a positive spectral slope
\alpha>1.5
between 9 and 17 GHz, where
F_{\nu}\propto\nu^{\alpha}
and we quote a 3-sigma lower limit.
Assuming synchrotron emission, this is a strong indication of self-absorption at these frequencies and at this epoch, with the self-absorption frequency
\nu_{\mathrm{a}}>17
GHz. At later times, our observations still indicate a rising spectrum, but the available limits can also accommodate a shallower slope of
F_{\nu}\propto\nu^{1/3}
(Figure
4
,
right
). Due to a lack of detections, we cannot constrain the temporal evolution at
\nu<15
GHz. The
15-17
GHz light curves, on the other hand, reveal an unexpected flattening in the decay of the radio flux density at
t\gtrsim 15
d (Figure
4
,
left
): while the evolution between
7.5 and 15 d is consistent with a steep
F_{\nu}\propto
t^{-2}
decay, the subsequent detections indicate a shallower
F_{\nu}\propto
t^{-1/2}
.
IV.2.2
Comparison to the Afterglow Model of
de Wet et al. [25]
Previously,
de Wet et al. [25,
DW23
hereafter]
presented a best-fit model for the afterglow of GRB 220627A.
Specifically, they used the
ScaleFit
software package
[
109
]
to model a set of X-ray, optical, and radio afterglow data (their radio data points are a preliminary subset of what we present in this paper).
Overall, their modelling favoured a homogeneous circumburst medium and converged to the following afterglow model parameters:
slope of the electron energy distribution
p=2.00^{+0.08}_{-0.06}
,
the isotropic-equivalent kinetic energy of the outflow
E_{\textrm{iso}}=9^{+65.1}_{-7.4}\times 10^{53}
erg,
circumburst medium density
n_{0}=19^{+133}_{-16}
cm
-3
the microphysical shock parameters relating to the fractional internal energy in accelerated electrons and magnetic fields
\bar{\epsilon}_{\textrm{e}}~=~\frac{p-2}{p-1}\epsilon_{\textrm{e}}~=~1.5^{+8.1}_{-1.3}\times 10^{-3}
and
\epsilon_{\mathrm{B}}=4.6^{+30.7}_{-4.3}\times 10^{-3}
,
jet half-opening angle
\theta_{\textrm{j}}=4.5^{+1.2}_{-0.3}\arcdeg
,
and host galaxy extinction
A_{\textrm{V,host}}=0.09\pm 0.03
mag.
In Figure
5
, we plot the radio data from Table
1
, optical data from
25
, and the X-ray data from the
Swift
Burst Analyser
15
15
15
https://www.swift.ac.uk/burst_analyser/00021506/
[
30
]
.
Also shown are model light curves and spectra obtained with
BOXFIT
16
16
16
The use of
BOXFIT
should ensure that the predictions closely match those from
ScaleFit
(i.e., the code employed by
25
), as the latter is based on the former.
v. 2.0
[
127
]
, with the same parameters as the best-fit model of
25
.
Our 7.5 d radio spectrum (epoch 4 in Figure
5
) is in tension with the predictions from the
25
model, which over-predicts the flux density at
10
GHz by at least a factor of
{\sim}2
at this time.
Moreover, the temporal evolution revealed by our
15-17
GHz observations does not match that predicted by the model: the relatively early jet break in the
25
model causes the radio light curve to drop steeply as
F_{\nu}\propto t^{-p}
(where
p=2.0
in their model) after
{\sim}5-7
days (corresponding to the time in their model after which both the injection frequency,
\nu_{\mathrm{m}}
, and the self-absorption frequency,
\nu_{\mathrm{a}}
, cross the observing band).
While this is consistent with the observed decay between 7.5 and 15 days, the subsequent flatter evolution remains unexplained.
We note that we found a similar disagreement also with the alternative model presented in appendix A of
25
, which assumes a wind-like external medium.
Figure 5:
Left
:
Multi-wavelength light curves for GRB 220627A and forward shock synchrotron model from
25
.
The radio data points are represented with circular markers, the near-infrared and optical data points with star markers, and the X-ray data points with square markers.
3\sigma
upper limits, represented using downward-pointing triangular markers, are used for all non-detections, with the exception of the VLBA observation (highlighted with a red square), where a
5\sigma
upper limit is used instead.
The dashed lines represent the
5\sigma
sensitivity thresholds expected for the VLBA+HSA and SKA-VLBI/ngVLA-LBA arrays (in 10 and 1 h of integration, respectively).
Right:
Multi-wavelength SED snapshots for GRB 220627A, from radio frequencies through to X-ray energies.
The plot shows different spectral snapshots of the afterglow centred around 6 different times as indicated in the legend.
The temporal window for data points included in each SED snapshot is indicated by the shaded vertical bands in the light curve plot.
Markers in the SED snapshots plot carry the same meaning as those in the light curves plot.
The residual plots on the bottom, showing the difference between the data and the model for all detections in logarithmic space, highlight the discrepancy between the shallow radio evolution after 15 d post-burst and the synchrotron model from
25
.
Given that the flux density at 17 GHz is seen to vary, with a decay at least as steep as
F_{\nu}\propto t^{-1/2}
from 27 to 445 d (see Figure
4
,
left
), and given the positive spectral slope implied by our upper limits at lower frequency, we can exclude that the excess emission with respect to the
25
model is due to star formation in the host galaxy.
Figure 6:
Model with additional wider jet component
better explains the shallow radio evolution observed in the afterglow after 15 d post-burst
. The fast, narrow jet model of
25
features an isotropic-equivalent energy of
E_{\mathrm{iso}}=9\times 10^{53}
erg and a half-opening angle
\theta_{\mathrm{j}}=4.5\arcdeg
. The additional wide jet component has
E_{\mathrm{iso,w}}=3\times 10^{53}
erg,
\theta_{\mathrm{j,w}}=15\arcdeg
, and an initial bulk Lorentz factor
\Gamma_{\mathrm{0,w}}=3
. The shock microphysical parameters are the same for the two components, namely
\epsilon_{\mathrm{e}}=0.076
,
\epsilon_{\mathrm{B}}=4.6\times 10^{-3}
and
p=2.02
.
In addition, at least two of our upper limits below
17
GHz (at 7.5 and 15 d) are inconsistent with the
25
model. However, given the good match between the model and higher-frequency observations at these epochs, a possible explanation of such inconsistency could be traced back to the simplified description of the electron population in the afterglow model: the energy distribution of electrons in GRB afterglow models
[
114
,
89
,
127
, e.g.]
is described as a non-thermal power law, but physically we expect a lower-energy thermal population to be present in these relativistic outflows
[
37
,
120
,
134
,
34
,
106
, e.g.,]
. Even in the case in which the latter electrons constitute a non-dominant fraction over the total, with a negligible contribution to the radiated power, they could still affect the low-energy spectrum by increasing the self-absorption optical depth
[
29
,
105
,
132
,
133
,
74
,
75
]
. For that reason, we do not consider these inconsistencies as severe.
IV.2.3
Explaining the Shallow Radio Decay
We discuss below three scenarios that can explain the shallow decay observed in radio at
t>15\,\mathrm{d}
. For each scenario, we describe the modelling choices and the implications on our understanding of the source.
Energy injection from an additional, slower ejecta component
the decay of the radio light curve could become shallower due to the energy injection occurring when a slower ejecta component catches up to the external shock
[
90
,
113
]
. First, we can estimate the Lorentz factor of such ejecta for the collision to happen at an observed time
t_{\mathrm{coll}}\sim 15\,\mathrm{d}
, assuming a similar ejection time as the main ejecta that caused the peak of the afterglow emission. Assuming the dynamics of the blast wave to be described, before the collision, by the
Blandford and McKee [11]
self-similar solution in a homogeneous external medium, at an observer time
t
the part of the blast wave closest to the observer is located
[
114
]
at a radius
r(t)\sim(17E_{\mathrm{iso}}t/(1+z)4\pi m_{\mathrm{p}}cn_{0})^{1/4}
from the central engine, where
m_{\mathrm{p}}
here is the proton mass. The radius of the slower ejecta component is instead
r_{\mathrm{sl-ej}}(t)\sim\Gamma_{\mathrm{sl-ej}}^{2}ct/(1+z)
. Equating these two radii and setting
t=t_{\mathrm{coll}}
, we obtain the required ejecta Lorentz factor:
\displaystyle\Gamma_{\mathrm{sl-ej}}
\displaystyle\sim\left(\frac{17(1+z)^{3}E_{\mathrm{iso}}}{4\pi m_{\mathrm{p}}c^{5}n_{0}t_{\mathrm{coll}}^{3}}\right)^{1/8}
(6)
\displaystyle\approx 10\,E_{\mathrm{iso,54}}^{1/8}n_{0}^{-1/8}\left(\frac{1+z}{4.084}\right)^{3/8}\left(\frac{t_{\mathrm{coll}}}{15\,\mathrm{d}}\right)^{-3/8}.
In words, ejecta as fast as
\Gamma_{\mathrm{sl-ej}}\sim 10
catch up with the blast wave as late as
t\sim 15\,\mathrm{d}
. We describe the energy injection as an increase in the isotropic-equivalent blast wave energy with observer time
17
17
17
The reason why it makes sense to parametrize the blast wave energy as a function of the observer-frame time is because the arrival time of a photon emitted at a lab-frame time
t_{\mathrm{lab}}
and at a typical latitude
\theta=1/\Gamma
,
t=t_{\mathrm{lab}}-\beta r/c
, is almost identical to the ‘retarded’ time
t_{\mathrm{r}}=t_{\mathrm{lab}}-\beta_{\mathrm{ej}}r/c
that represents the ejection time of relativistic ejecta travelling at
\beta_{\mathrm{ej}}
that catch up with the blast wave at a radius
r
.
at
t>t_{\mathrm{coll}}
, parametrized as
E_{\mathrm{iso}}(t)=E_{\mathrm{iso}}\times(t/t_{\mathrm{coll}})^{\delta}
. This modifies the blast wave Lorentz factor evolution such that the shock downstream Lorentz factor scales as
\Gamma(t)\propto t^{(4\delta-3)/8}
and the blast wave radius as
r\propto t^{(\delta+1)/4}
. In the post-jet-break phase, neglecting sideways expansion of the shock and focussing on the
\nu_{\mathrm{a}},\nu_{\mathrm{m}}<\nu<\nu_{\mathrm{c}}
spectral regime, the flux density is proportional to
F_{\nu}\propto\Gamma^{2(p+1)}r^{3}
, which leads to a light curve scaling
F_{\nu}\propto t^{((7+4p)\delta-3p)/4}
. With
p\sim 2
, a scaling
F_{\nu}\propto t^{-1/2}
can be reproduced by setting
\delta\sim 4/15\approx 0.27
. This scaling is expected
[
90
,
113
,
139
]
if the slow ejecta features a velocity profile such that their mass above a Lorentz factor
\Gamma
is
M(>\Gamma)\propto\Gamma^{-s}
with
s=(7\delta+3)/(3-\delta)\sim 73/41\approx 1.8
. Since the observer time increases fourfold during the shallow decay phase, the energy increase due to injection is just
\sim 4^{4/15}\approx 145\%
.
These calculations show that a relatively slow shell ejected shortly after the main ejecta and containing about half as much energy, could produce the observed flattening in the radio light curve. The presence of a tail of slower ejecta carrying a substantial energy is a common expectation from the unsteady central engines behind leading GRB jet prompt emission scenarios, such as the internal shocks scenario
[
103
]
and the internal-collision-induced magnetic reconnection and turbulence
[
140
, ICMART;]
scenario.
Unfortunately, model predictions are not yet sufficiently detailed as to answer the question whether the requirements found here are easily satisfied in a typical central engine.
Changing external density profile
the flattening in the radio light curve decay could stem from a steepening in the external density profile, which could signal, for example, the fact that the blast wave is emerging from the molecular cloud where the progenitor has formed. Assuming the external density to scale as
n\propto r^{-k}
, the Lorentz factor in the shock downstream then evolves
[
11
]
as
\Gamma\propto r^{-(3-k)/2}
. In terms of observer frame time, we then have
r\propto t^{1/(4-k)}
and
\Gamma\propto t^{-(3-k)/2(4+k)}
. In the post-jet-break phase the flux density evolves as
F_{\nu}\propto\Gamma^{2(p+1)}r^{3-k}
(the
3-k
exponent here reflects the slower increase in the number of shocked electrons with radius when
k>0
), so that
F_{\nu}\propto t^{-(3-k)p/(4-k)}
. This shows that the
t^{-1/2}
decay can be reproduced, assuming
p\sim 2
, if the external density decreases with a slope
k=(6p-4)/(2p-1)\sim 8/3
.
An additional, wider ejecta component
as an alternative scenario, we consider the possibility of a
wider and slower component in the ejecta, on top of the fast and narrow component whose afterglow emission is described by the
25
model. These ejecta decelerate at a larger radius with respect to the narrow jet, enhancing the observed radio flux density. We model the dynamics and emission of such an additional component following
Panaitescu and Kumar [89]
, including the ejecta coasting phase, the trans-relativistic deceleration of the blastwave, the effect of synchrotron self-absorption on the emission (but still neglecting thermal electrons), and photon propagation effects. In Figure
6
, we show the model light curve obtained by adding the flux densities predicted by such a model to those of the
25
model, keeping the microphysical parameters fixed to values similar
18
18
18
In
25
, the best fit value of the slope of the relativistic electron energy distribution is
p=2.0
. Since the model assumes that the electron energy distribution power law extends to infinity, this parameter choice is formally unphysical. Nevertheless, we find that by setting
p=2.02
we can reproduce the same results as
25
.
to
25
, that is,
\epsilon_{\mathrm{e}}=0.076
,
\epsilon_{\mathrm{B}}=4.6\times 10^{-3}
and
p=2.02
. The wide jet component is assigned an isotropic-equivalent energy of
E_{\mathrm{iso,w}}=3\times 10^{53}
erg, an initial bulk Lorentz factor of
\Gamma_{0,\mathrm{w}}=3
, and a half-opening angle of
\theta_{\mathrm{j,w}}=15\arcdeg
. Its collimation-corrected energy is therefore
E_{\mathrm{w}}=(1-\cos\theta_{\mathrm{j,w}})E_{\mathrm{iso,w}}\approx 10^{52}
erg. For comparison, the narrow
25
jet has
E_{\mathrm{iso}}=9\times 10^{53}
erg and
\theta_{\mathrm{j}}=4.5\arcdeg
(and a formally infinite initial bulk Lorentz factor), hence a collimation-corrected energy of
E=(1-\cos\theta_{\mathrm{j}})\approx 3\times 10^{51}
erg. The addition of the wide component therefore increases the energy budget by about a factor of four.
The inclusion of this wider component leads to a clear improvement in the modelling of the late flattening in the radio light curves, as shown in the comparisons of the residuals in Figures
5
and
6
.
The presence of a slow, wide ejecta component that carries a similar (or even somewhat larger) collimation-corrected energy as the inner, narrow jet is expected in the case where the jet spends a large fraction of its total energy in breaking out of the progenitor star
[
77
,
15
,
46
,
42
]
.
In such a scenario,
the energy is channelled to a hot cocoon that shrouds the jet during the propagation. After the jet breakout, the cocoon blows out producing a slow, wide ejecta component
[
110
]
, which could explain the scenario behind our proposed modelling. For the cocoon to contain a large fraction of the total energy, the jet head must have propagated at a Newtonian velocity for most of its journey through the progenitor envelope
[
77
,
15
,
110
,
42
]
. In such a regime, the time for the jet head to break out can be estimated based on the numerically-calibrated model of
Harrison et al. [46, their equation 16]
, that gives a breakout time (relative to the birth time of the jet):
t_{\mathrm{bkt}}\sim 37\,E_{\mathrm{tot,52}}^{-1/3}\,T_{3}^{1/3}\theta_{\mathrm{base,10^{\circ}}}^{4/3}\,R_{11}^{2/3}\,M_{10}^{1/3}\,\mathrm{s},
(7)
where
E_{\mathrm{tot,52}}
is the total energy in the ejecta (narrow plus wide) in units of
10^{52}
erg,
T_{3}
is the total jet duration in units of
1\,000
s,
\theta_{\mathrm{base,10^{\circ}}}
is the half-opening angle of the jet at its base (i.e., at launch, before propagating through the stellar envelope) in units of
10\arcdeg
,
R_{11}
is the stellar radius in units of
10^{11}
cm, and
M_{10}
is the stellar mass in units of
10\,\mathrm{M_{\odot}}
.
In this regime, the energy in the cocoon (and hence in the wide ejecta) is approximately
E_{\mathrm{w}}\sim E_{\mathrm{tot}}t_{\mathrm{bkt}}/T
. The total jet duration
T
can be estimated as the sum of the breakout time plus the GRB duration,
T\sim t_{\mathrm{bkt}}+T_{\mathrm{90}}/(1+z)
. Using
E_{\mathrm{tot}}=E+E_{\mathrm{w}}
, these relations yield:
\begin{split}&T\sim\frac{T_{90}}{1+z}\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{w}}}{E}+1\right)\approx 1.2\times 10^{3}\,\left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{90}}}{1100\,\mathrm{s}}\right)\left(\frac{1+z}{4.08}\right)^{-1}\\
&\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\indent\times\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{w}}/E+1}{4.3}\right)\,\mathrm{s},\end{split}
(8)
t_{\mathrm{bkt}}\sim\frac{T_{90}E_{\mathrm{w}}}{(1+z)E}\approx 9.0\times 10^{2}\,\left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{90}}}{1100\,\mathrm{s}}\right)\left(\frac{1+z}{4.08}\right)^{-1}\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{w}}/E}{3.3}\right)\,\mathrm{s},
(9)
and
\begin{split}&R\approx 1.3\times 10^{13}\,M_{10}^{-1/2}\left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{90}}}{1100\,\mathrm{s}}\right)\left(\frac{1+z}{4.08}\right)^{-1}\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{w}}}{10^{52}\,\mathrm{erg}}\right)^{3/2}\\
&\indent\indent\times\left(\frac{E}{3\times 10^{51}\,\mathrm{erg}}\right)^{-1}\theta_{\mathrm{base,10^{\circ}}}^{-2}\,\mathrm{cm}.\end{split}
(10)
Here we used
E_{\mathrm{w}}
and
E
from the proposed modelling,
T_{\mathrm{90}}\sim 1100
s from
25
, and we kept the initial half-opening angle at
10\arcdeg
(the jet is then expected to be collimated during propagation, see e.g.,
Bromberg et al. 15
,
Salafia and Ghirlanda 110
).
If indeed the wide component in our proposed modelling originates from a cocoon,
the long jet duration and large stellar radius obtained from these arguments
are then consistent with expectations for
the blue supergiant progenitor scenario proposed for ultra-long GRBs
[
35
,
54
,
94
, e.g.,]
.
In particular, we note that typical Wolf-Rayet stars have radii of only
\sim
1 R
⊙
compared to tens to a few hundred of R
⊙
for blue supergiants.
This is similar to the conclusion reached by
Piro et al. [97]
in their study of ultra-long GRB 130925A (with gamma-ray activity lasting for at least
{\sim}7
ks); they found evidence for the presence of a hot cocoon which supported the blue supergiant progenitor scenario.
More recently, by conducting simulations of evolutionary pathways for different possible progenitor scenarios, the findings in
Ror et al. [108]
similarly support blue supergiant stars as a plausible progenitor for ultra-long GRBs, including GRB 221009A which was the focus of their work.
IV.3
Testing the GRB 220627A Lensing Scenario with VLBI: Proof of Concept and Future Prospects
The aim of our VLBA experiment was to provide a test of the lensing scenario for GRB 220627A that was independent of the conclusions drawn from the analysis of the high-energy spectra (see Subsection
IV.1
, see also
Huang et al. 52
).
From the light curve evolution shown in Figure
6
(
left
), we estimate the unresolved flux density at the time and frequency of our VLBA observation (15 GHz, 11.7 d post-burst) to be
{\sim}150
µJy.
This suggests that in the ultra-long GRB (non-lensing) scenario, we should expect a compact radio source at
{\sim}150
µJy, and in the lensing scenario, two compact sources at even dimmer flux-density levels of
{\sim}40
and
{\sim}110
µJy (as determined by their gamma-ray fluence brightness ratio
r~\approx~3
).
Our VLBA observations yielded a non-detection down to a
5\sigma
limit of
{\sim}0.3
mJy beam
-1
.
Within the uncertainty region of lower-resolution optical and radio detections (see Subsection
III.4
), there were a few noise peaks exceeding
3\sigma
level, but none above the
5\sigma
level.
This means we were unable to claim a detection or a non-detection of an afterglow source (or any source) at the
{\sim}0.3
mJy
level; the lensing and ultra-long GRB scenarios could not be distinguished so our VLBI experiment yielded a non-conclusive result.
This experiment was the first time VLBI was used to search for the multiple images of a candidate strongly gravitationally lensed GRB afterglow.
The only lensed GRB candidate that had VLBI follow-up prior to this event was GRB 200716C
[
38
]
.
For that event, as the afterglow had faded by the time of the observation, the European VLBI Network (EVN) and
e
-Merlin were used to search the candidate host galaxy for a possible IMBH that could act as the lens, rather than directly for the multiple images of the afterglow.
Their non-detection (
5\sigma
upper limit of
<50\,
µJy beam
-1
) also yielded an inconclusive result, unable to confirm the presence of a possible IMBH lens in the candidate host galaxy.
These results highlight the difficulty of such an experiment and the need for improvements in future programmes.
Below, we evaluate the outcomes of our VLBI campaign for GRB 220627A and discuss the possible improvements that can be implemented in the areas of angular resolution, sensitivity, and trigger timing (including real-time correlation capabilities).
Figure 7:
The Einstein radius
\theta_{\textrm{E}}
as a function of the lens redshift
z_{\textrm{L}}
for GRB 220627A is represented by the blue solid line.
The expected Einstein radius for a lens located at the redshift
z=2.665
, which was the redshift of the intervening system identified in the optical spectrum
[
55
,
25
]
, is plotted with an orange starred marker.
These are compared against our VLBA major-axis beam size
\theta_{\textrm{maj}}
represented here by the red dashed line.
The part of the parameter space that cannot be probed by the angular limit of our observation is shown by the red hatched region.
The Einstein radius as a function of lens redshift for a typical GRB at redshift
z=1.5
, given different, random (but possible) combinations of brightness ratios
r
and time delays
\Delta t
are also shown using grey solid lines.
IV.3.1
Angular Resolution: probing different lens configurations
Our resulting VLBA image had a synthesised beam size of
0.49\,\textrm{mas}~\times~1.51\,\textrm{mas}
.
In Figure
7
, we show the expected Einstein radius for GRB 220627A in the lensing scenario as a function of the lens redshift, calculated using Equations
1
and
2
, compared to our major-axis beam size.
With the major-axis beam size being smaller than the expected Einstein radius out to
z\approx 2.8
(n.b.,
z_{\textrm{GRB}}=3.084
), our VLBA observations had sufficient angular resolution to resolve the lensed images for much of the lens redshift parameter space.
As an intervening absorber was identified at
z=2.665
via the presence of S
iv
, Si
ii
, C
iv
, Fe
ii
, Al
ii
lines in the optical spectrum
[
55
,
25
]
, we considered this system the likely location of the lens during our radio campaign.
At this redshift, the Einstein radius would be
\theta_{\textrm{E}}\approx 1.8
mas, so the two distinct lensed images of the afterglow (in the lensing scenario) would have been resolved by our VLBA observations.
However, in the extreme scenarios, where the lens redshift is greater than
z_{\textrm{L}}\approx 2.8
, the lensed images may be unresolved.
In this scenario – if detected – the lensed event could potentially still be confirmed by modelling a multi-component source, but this may be at the expense of accuracy in both the astrometry and source structure, which are critical for modelling of the lens (and by extension, time-delay cosmography).
In Figure
7
we also plot 100 possible Einstein radii functions (i.e., as Einstein radius as a function of lens redshift) for a typical GRB at redshift
z=1.5
(the redshift where star formation and long GRB production is expected to be dominant).
Each different Einstein radii function is produced by assuming different, random combinations of brightness ratio (selected from
1.1