Non-Gibbsian Multivariate Ewens Probability Distributions on Regular Trees F.H.Haydarov, Z.E. Mustafoyeva, U.A. Rozikov Abstract . Ewens’ sampling formula (ESF) provides the probability distribution governing the number of distinct genetic types and their respective frequencies at a selectively neutral locus under the infinitely-many-alleles model of mutation. A natural and significant question arises: “Is the Ewens probability distribution on regular trees Gibbsian?” In this paper, we demonstrate that Ewens probability distributions can be regarded as non-Gibbsian distributions on regular trees and derive a sufficient condition for the consistency condition. This study lays the groundwork for a new direction in the theory of non-Gibbsian probability distributions on trees. Mathematics Subject Classifications (2010). 60K35 (primary); 82B05, 82B20 (secondary) Key words. Ewens’ sampling formula (ESF), regular trees, Gibbsian specifications, Gibbsian and non-Gibbsian distribution. 1. Introduction The rigorous implementation of real-space renormalization group (RG) transformations as mappings on Hamiltonians encountered significant mathematical challenges over three decades ago. These issues were first highlighted by Griffiths and Pearce [ 1 ] and later attributed by van Enter, Fernández, and Sokal to the emergence of non-Gibbsian measures under RG transformations, rendering the mappings ill-defined at the level of Hamiltonians [ 2 ] . This discovery spurred extensive research on non-Gibbsianness and its implications, with notable contributions from van Enter, Fernández, Sokal [ 2 ] , Lörinczi [ 3 ] , van de Velde [ 4 ] , and others [ 5 , 10 , 11 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Subsequent work identified non-Gibbsian measures in transient regimes of interacting particle systems, including stochastic Ising models, where infinite-temperature dynamics were viewed as single-site stochastic RG mappings [ 9 ] . Dobrushin’s program further developed a generalized Gibbsian framework, investigating which traditional Gibbsian properties could persist. Non-Gibbsianness in disordered systems and other contexts was also systematically explored. In 2003, Eurandom (research institute) hosted a landmark workshop on non-Gibbsian measures, featuring Robert Israel, who demonstrated that non-Gibbsianness is a generic property, confirming earlier claims about the Griffiths-Pearce issues [ 12 ] . The Ewens Sampling Formula (ESF) is grounded in Kingman’s coalescent process, which describes genealogical relationships in a sample and connects to partition structures. The ESF arises as a diffusion process capturing the limiting behavior of finite-population models, including the Wright-Fisher, Moran, and Cannings models, as population size grows and time is appropriately scaled. Initially regarded as an approximation in the Wright-Fisher model, the ESF gained further theoretical underpinnings through Ethier and Kurtz, who modeled gene frequencies via diffusion. The Poisson-Dirichlet process, constructed by Kingman, represents the stationary distribution of gene frequencies (see [ 18 , 17 , 15 ] ). Combinatorial aspects, including age-ordered allele frequencies, are detailed in Arratia et al. [ 13 ] . Extensions of the ESF account for allele distributions across time [ 20 , 14 ] . Age distributions of mutations, initially explored by Kimura and Ohta [ 16 ] , have been further investigated through coalescent and diffusion approaches [ 19 , 21 , 22 ] . In this paper, we investigate the Ewens distribution on regular trees and demonstrate that it can be interpreted as a non-Gibbsian distribution. By leveraging established results and methodologies from the theory surrounding the ESF, we highlight its relevance to the broader study of non-Gibbsian measures. Furthermore, this approach represents a novel direction in the ongoing development of non-Gibbs measures theory. 2. Non-Gibbsian measures on regular trees Let \Im^{k}=(V,L) be a k+1 -regular tree, where V and L denote the sets of vertices and edges of the tree, respectively. Consider models in which the spin takes values in a countable set \Phi and is assigned to the vertices of the tree. For a subset A\subset V , a configuration \sigma_{A} on A is defined as an arbitrary function \sigma_{A}:A\to\Phi . The set of all configurations on A is denoted by \Phi^{A} . Two vertices x and y of the k+1 -regular tree are called nearest neighbors if there exists an edge connecting them and we denote \langle x,y\rangle . A configuration \sigma on V is defined as a function x\in V\mapsto\sigma(x)\in\Phi , and the set of all configurations on V is denoted by \Omega:=\Phi^{V} . The restriction of \sigma_{V} to a subset \Lambda\subseteq V is written as \sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda} . For any two mutually disjoint subsets \Lambda_{1},\Lambda_{2}\subseteq V and any configurations \sigma_{\Lambda_{1}}\in\Phi^{\Lambda_{1}} and \sigma_{\Lambda_{2}}\in\Phi^{\Lambda_{2}} , the configuration \tilde{\sigma}\in\Phi^{\Lambda_{1}\cup\Lambda_{2}} , which satisfies \left.\tilde{\sigma}\right|_{\Lambda_{1}}=\sigma_{\Lambda_{1}} and \left.\tilde{\sigma}\right|_{\Lambda_{2}}=\sigma_{\Lambda_{2}} is denoted by \sigma_{\Lambda_{1}}\vee\sigma_{\Lambda_{2}} . We denote by \mathcal{N} the set of all finite subsets of V . For each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , define the \sigma -algebra \mathcal{F}^{\Lambda}=\pi_{\Lambda}^{-1}\left(\mathcal{P}\left(\Phi^{\Lambda}\right)\right)\subset\mathcal{P}(\Omega), where \mathcal{P}\left(\Phi^{\Lambda}\right) is the family of all subsets of \Phi^{\Lambda} (Cartesian product of \Phi ) and \mathcal{P}(\Omega) is the family of all subsets of \Omega . The family of such \sigma -algebras satisfies the condition \mathcal{F}^{\Lambda\cup\Delta}=\mathcal{F}^{\Lambda}\vee\mathcal{F}^{\Delta}, for all \Lambda,\Delta\in\mathcal{N} , where \mathcal{F}^{\Lambda}\vee\mathcal{F}^{\Delta}:=\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{F}^{\Lambda}\cup\mathcal{F}^{\Delta}) is the minimal \sigma -algebra containing \mathcal{F}^{\Lambda}\cup\mathcal{F}^{\Delta} . Define \mathcal{A}:=\bigcup_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}}\mathcal{F}^{\Lambda},\quad\mathcal{F}=\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{A}). Then (\Omega,\mathcal{F}) is a measurable space. Now, we define a decreasing family \mathbb{F}=\left\{\mathcal{F}_{\Lambda}\right\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} of sub \sigma -algebras of \mathcal{F} , where \mathcal{F}_{\Lambda}:=\mathcal{S}(\cup_{\Delta\in\mathcal{N},\Delta\in V\setminus\Lambda}\mathcal{F}^{\Delta}). Definition 1 . Let U_{\Lambda}:\Omega\rightarrow\overline{\mathbb{R}}:=\mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty,\infty\} be \mathcal{F}_{\Lambda} -measurable mapping for all \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , then the collection U=\left\{U_{\Lambda}\right\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is called a potential . Also, the following expression (2.1) H_{\Delta,U}(\sigma)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\text{ def }}}{{=}}\sum_{\Delta\cap\Lambda\neq\varnothing,\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}}U_{\Lambda}(\sigma),\quad\forall\sigma\in\Omega. is called Hamiltonian H associated to the potential U . Put r(U)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\text{ def }}}{{=}}\inf\left\{R>0:U_{\Lambda}\equiv 0\text{ for all }\Lambda\text{ with }\operatorname{diam}(\Lambda)>R\right\}. If r(U)<\infty,U has finite range and H_{\Delta;U} is well defined. If r(U)=\infty , U has infinite range and, for the Hamiltonian to be well defined, we will assume that U is absolutely summable in the sense that (2.2) \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\Lambda\in\mathcal{N},x\in\Lambda\end{subarray}}\left\|U_{\Lambda}\right\|_{\infty}<\infty,\quad\forall x\in V, (remember that \left.\|f\|_{\infty}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\text{ def }}}{{=}}\sup_{\omega}|f(\omega)|\right) which ensures that the interaction of a spin with the rest of the system is always bounded, and therefore that \left\|H_{\Delta;U}\right\|_{\infty}<\infty . Let \Lambda^{c}:=V\backslash\Lambda and for any finite \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , any configuration \bar{\sigma}_{V\backslash\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda^{c}} , called a boundary condition, and for any \sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda} consider the relative energy (2.3) \displaystyle H_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}|\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)= \displaystyle\sum_{A\subseteq\Lambda,A\neq\emptyset}U_{A}\left(\sigma_{A}\right)+\sum_{A\in\mathcal{N}:A\cap\Lambda\neq\emptyset,A\cap\Lambda^{c}\neq\emptyset}U_{A}\left(\sigma_{A\cap\Lambda}\vee\bar{\sigma}_{A\cap\Lambda^{c}}\right). The condition ( 2.2 ) ensures the convergence of the series in ( 2.3 ) for all boundary conditions \bar{\sigma}_{V\backslash\Lambda} and configurations \sigma_{\Lambda} . Let (2.4) \zeta_{\Lambda}^{H}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\mid\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)=\frac{\exp\left\{-H_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\mid\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)\right\}}{Z_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)}, where the partition function is given by Z_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)=\sum_{\sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda}}\exp\left\{-H_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\mid\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)\right\}. A probability measure \mu on the measurable space (\Omega,\mathcal{F}) is called consistent with the Gibbs specification \zeta^{H}:=\left\{\zeta_{\Lambda}^{H}\right\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} if for any finite \Lambda\subset\Omega , any measurable function \phi(\sigma_{\Lambda}) of \sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda} , and any subset B\in\mathcal{F}_{\Lambda^{c}} , \int_{B}\phi\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)\mu(d\sigma)=\int_{B}\left(\sum_{\sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Phi^{\Lambda}}\phi\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)\zeta_{\Lambda}^{U}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\mid\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right)\right)\mu_{\Lambda^{c}}\left(d\bar{\sigma}_{\Lambda^{c}}\right), where \mu_{\Lambda^{c}} denotes the restriction of \mu to the \sigma -algebra \mathcal{F}_{\Lambda} . The measure \mu is called non-Gibbsian if there exists no potential U satisfying the condition ( 2.2 ) such that \mu is consistent with the Gibbs specification \zeta^{H} [ 23 ] . 3. Construction of non-Gibbsian multivariate Ewens probability distributions Let us provide a brief overview of Ewens’s sampling formula, introduced by Warren Ewens, which is a key result in population genetics describing the probability distribution of allele counts in a random sample of n alleles, grouped by their frequencies [ 24 , 25 ] . Under certain conditions, if a sample of n gametes is drawn from a population and classified according to the gene at a specific locus, the probability that there are a_{1} alleles represented once, a_{2} alleles represented twice, and so on, is given by: (3.1) P\left(a_{1},\ldots,a_{n};\theta\right)=\frac{n!}{\theta(\theta+1)\cdots(\theta+n-1)}\prod_{j=1}^{n}\left(\frac{\theta}{j}\right)^{a_{j}}\cdot\frac{1}{a_{j}!}, where \theta>0 is a parameter representing the population mutation rate, and a_{1},\ldots,a_{n} are nonnegative integers satisfying the constraint: a_{1}+2a_{2}+3a_{3}+\cdots+na_{n}=n. This formula defines a probability distribution over the set of all partitions of the integer n . In the fields of probability and statistics, it is often referred to as the multivariate Ewens distribution. Define the normalizing constant as Z_{n}(\theta)=\frac{\theta(\theta+1)\cdots(\theta+n-1)}{n!}. Using equation ( 3.1 ), the probability distribution can be expressed as (3.2) P(a_{1},\ldots,a_{n};\theta)=\frac{1}{Z_{n}(\theta)}\prod_{j=1}^{n}\left(\frac{\theta}{j}\right)^{a_{j}}\cdot\frac{1}{a_{j}!}. We now examine equation ( 3.1 ) on a regular tree and, as a natural consequence, it becomes necessary to construct a \sigma -algebra in order to define a measure that is associated with the Ewens distribution. Let \sigma|_{\Lambda}=\tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda} be the cylinder with base \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} and spin values in \mathbb{Z} . We say that \tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda} and \tilde{w}_{\Lambda} are equivalent, denoted \tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda}\sim\tilde{w}_{\Lambda} , if there exists a permutation \pi\in\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|} such that \pi(\tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda})=\tilde{w}_{\Lambda} , where \mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|} denotes the symmetric group of all permutations on \Lambda , with the operation \circ representing composition of permutations. Furthermore, assume that for each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , a probability measure P_{\Lambda} is defined on \mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}) , where \mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}) denotes the minimal \sigma -algebra generated by equivalent classes on \mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|} . Next, we introduce a_{j}:=b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda}) , \sigma_{\Lambda}\in\mathbb{Z}^{\Lambda} that represents the number of distinct spin values that appear exactly j times in \Lambda . Then from ( 3.2 ) we get (3.3) P_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma|_{\Lambda}=\tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda}\right)=\frac{1}{Z_{|\Lambda|}(\theta)}\prod_{j=1}^{|\Lambda|}\left(\frac{\theta}{j}\right)^{b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}\cdot\frac{1}{b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda})!}, where \tilde{\sigma}_{\Lambda}=\{\tilde{\sigma}(x_{1}),\tilde{\sigma}(x_{2}),...,\tilde{\sigma}(x_{|\Lambda|})\} if \Lambda=\{x_{1},x_{2},...,x_{|\Lambda|}\} , |\Lambda| denotes the number of elements in \Lambda and {Z_{|\Lambda|}(\theta)} is the normalizing constant. Lemma 1 . The Hamiltonian corresponding to the probability measure in ( 3.3 ) is uniquely determined by the following expression: (3.4) H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})=\sum_{j=1}^{|\Lambda|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln\big(b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)!\big)\right]. Here, b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda}) represents the multiplicity of the configuration \sigma_{\Lambda} , with \theta and j reflecting system parameters. Proof. The Boltzmann weight refers to the factor used in statistical mechanics to describe the probability of a system being in a particular configuration based on its energy. It is typically expressed in the form: P_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right):=\frac{\exp\{H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}}{{Z_{|\Lambda|}(\theta)}}. From the formula ( 3.3 ) H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})=\ln\left[\prod_{j=1}^{|\Lambda|}\left(\frac{\theta}{j}\right)^{b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}\cdot\frac{1}{b_{j}(\sigma_{\Lambda})!}\right] which is equivalent to ( 3.4 ). ∎ For a given \Delta , the potential corresponding to equation ( 2.1 ) is defined as (3.5) U_{\Lambda}(\sigma)=\begin{cases}b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\dfrac{\theta}{j}-\ln\big(b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\big),&\text{if }\Lambda=\Delta,\\[6.0pt] 0,&\text{otherwise}.\end{cases} Lemma 2 . The condition ( 2.2 ) is not satisfied for the potential given in ( 3.5 ). Specifically, the following divergence holds: \sum_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N},\,x\in\Lambda}\left\|U_{\Lambda}\right\|_{\infty}=\infty,\quad\forall\,x\in V. Proof. To prove this lemma, we consider the following expression: (3.6) \sum_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N},\,x\in\Lambda}\|U_{\Lambda}\|_{\infty}=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sup_{\sigma}\left|U_{\Lambda}(\sigma)\right|=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sup_{b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)}\left|b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln\big(b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)!\big)\right|. It is straightforward to verify that the supremum of the potential is attained when j=1 . In this case, we have b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)=|\Lambda| . Substituting this into the expression, the right-hand side of ( 3.6 ) becomes \sum_{|\Lambda|=1}^{\infty}\left|\ln\frac{\theta^{|\Lambda|}}{|\Lambda|!}\right|. Since \lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\theta^{n}}{n!}=0 for any \theta>0 , it follows that \lim_{n\to\infty}\ln\frac{\theta^{n}}{n!}=-\infty. Therefore, the absolute value diverges as n\to\infty , and by the necessary condition for the convergence of a series, we conclude that \sum_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N},\,x\in\Lambda}\|U_{\Lambda}\|_{\infty}=\infty. This establishes the divergence required by the lemma. ∎ Combining the results from Lemma 1 and Lemma 2 , we obtain the following theorem: Theorem 1 . For each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , the measure associated with the probability measure P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda}) in ( 3.3 ) is non-Gibbsian, provided that it satisfies the consistency condition. For \sigma -algebra \mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right) and \mathcal{B}\left(\overline{\mathbb{R}}_{+}\right) (a Borel \sigma -algebra on \left.\overline{\mathbb{R}}_{+}\right) , we define the sets of measurable mappings: \bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right)=\left\{f:\Omega\rightarrow\overline{\mathbb{R}}_{+}\ \mid\ f\text{ is }\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right),\mathcal{B}\left(\overline{\mathbb{R}}_{+}\right)\right)\text{- measurable mapping}\right\} Definition 2 . For each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} let f_{\Lambda}\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right) , the family f=\{f_{\Lambda}\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is said to be additive if for each \Lambda,\Delta\in\mathcal{N} with \Lambda\subset\Delta there exists a mapping f_{\Delta,\Lambda}\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right) such that f_{\Delta}=f_{\Delta,\Lambda}+f_{\Lambda} . If f=\{f_{\Lambda}\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is additive and g_{\Lambda}=\exp(-f_{\Lambda}) , then g=\{g_{\Lambda}\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is clearly multiplicative. Proposition 1 . For each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} , the family \mathcal{H}=\{H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is additive. Proof. It is evident that the potential U_{\Lambda}(\sigma) in ( 3.5 ) is \mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}) -measurable according to the Definition 1 . Since the sum of finite measurable functions will be measurable, we say that the Hamiltonian H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda}) in ( 3.4 ) is measurable, namely for each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right). Consider H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda}),H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})\in\mathcal{H} for \Lambda,\Delta\in\mathcal{N} , where \Lambda\subset\Delta and the case where \Delta=\Lambda\cup\{v\} with \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} . First, we consider a configuration w=\{w(x):x\in V\}\in\mathbb{Z}^{V} such that w(v)\neq\sigma_{\Lambda}(x) for all x\in\Lambda . In this scenario, the following relationships hold: b_{1}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1,\quad b_{i}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\text{ for all }i=2,\ldots,|\Lambda|,\quad\text{and}\quad b_{|\Delta|}(\sigma_{\Delta})=0. Under this condition, we obtain: \displaystyle H_{\Delta}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right) \displaystyle=\sum_{j=1}^{|\Delta|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{1}-\ln b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!+\sum_{j=2}^{|\Delta|-1}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)\ln\theta-\ \ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)!+\sum_{j=2}^{|\Lambda|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=\ln\theta-\ \ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)+\sum_{j=1}^{|\Lambda|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1}+H_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right). Now assume that w(v)\in\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\} . In this case, there exists i_{0}\in\{1,2,\ldots,|\Lambda|\} such that the following relationships hold: b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})-1,\quad b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1,\quad b_{i}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\text{ for all }i\notin\{i_{0},i_{0}+1\}. Under this assumption, we have: H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})=\ln\frac{i_{0}b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}{\left(i_{0}+1\right)\left(b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1\right)}+H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda}), and H_{\Delta,\Lambda}=H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})-H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})=\begin{cases}\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1},&\text{if }w(v)\notin\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\},\\[11.38109pt] \ln\frac{i_{0}b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}{\left(i_{0}+1\right)\left(b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1\right)},&\text{if }w(v)\in\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\}.\end{cases} Since 0\leq b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\leq|\Lambda| and due to the properties of compositions of measurable functions, the function f(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda}))=\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1} is Borel measurable. For any B\in\mathcal{B}(\mathbb{R}) , we write: f^{-1}(B)=\left\{b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\in\{0,1,\ldots,|\Lambda|\}:f(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda}))\in B\right\}\subset\{0,1,\ldots,|\Lambda|\}. For instance, f^{-1}(\{1\})=|\Lambda| , which indicates that the spins in \Lambda are all distinct. The measurability of the second function, \ln\frac{i_{0}b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}{\left(i_{0}+1\right)\left(b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1\right)}, can be established by employing an argument analogous to the one used in the preceding case. ∎ Define a finite-dimensional distribution of probability measure P_{\Lambda} in the set \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} as (3.7) P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda}):=Z_{\Lambda}^{-1}\exp\left\{-\beta H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+\sum_{x\in\partial\Lambda}h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x),x}\right\} where \beta=\frac{1}{T} , T>0 - temperature, Z_{\Lambda}^{-1} is the normalizing factor, \textbf{h}:=\{h_{t,x}\}_{x\in V} is a family of measurable functions. Definition 3 . A family of measures \phi=\{\phi_{\Lambda}\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is said to be multiplicative if, for every pair of sets \Lambda,\Delta\in\mathcal{N} with \Lambda\subset\Delta , there exists a measure \phi_{\Delta,\Lambda}\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right) such that \phi_{\Delta}=\phi_{\Delta,\Lambda}\,\phi_{\Lambda}. It is important to note that if a given family of kernels satisfies both the specification and multiplicativity conditions, this provides a framework in which theorems concerning the existence of Gibbs and non-Gibbs measures on regular trees can be effectively applied. Theorem 2 . The family of measures \{P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} in ( 3.7 ) is multiplicative for each \Lambda,\Delta\in\mathcal{N} with \Lambda\subset\Delta . Proof. Repeating as above, we consider the case \Delta=\Lambda\cup\{v\} with \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} . According to the Definition 3 and ( 3.7 ) we write the following: P_{\Delta,\Lambda}=\frac{P_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})}{P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}=\frac{Z_{\Lambda}}{Z_{\Delta}}\frac{e^{-\beta H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})+\sum_{x\in\partial\Delta}h_{\sigma_{\Delta}(x),x}}}{e^{-\beta H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+\sum_{x\in\partial\Lambda}h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x),x}}}. Since \partial\Lambda=\{u,x_{1},\ldots,x_{m}\} and \partial\Delta=\{v,x_{1},\ldots,x_{m}\} , where \langle u,v\rangle\in L , we rewrite P_{\Delta,\Lambda}=\frac{Z_{\Lambda}}{Z_{\Delta}}e^{-\beta H_{\Delta,\Lambda}}\cdot e^{h_{\sigma_{\Delta}(v),v}-h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u),u}}. By Proposition 1 , \exp\{-\beta H_{\Delta,\Lambda}\}\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|})\right) and \frac{Z_{\Lambda}}{Z_{\Delta}}=\frac{|\Lambda|+1}{|\Lambda|+\theta} is Borel measurable, then we conclude that P_{\Delta,\Lambda}\in\bar{M}\left(\mathcal{B}\left(\mathcal{S}_{|\Lambda|}\right)\right). ∎ Definition 4 . The family of measures \{\mu_{\Lambda}\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is said to be consistent (compatible) if \mu_{\Lambda}(F_{\Lambda})=\mu_{\Delta}(F_{\Delta}) for all F_{\Lambda}=F_{\Delta}\in\mathcal{B}_{\Lambda} whenever \Lambda\subset\Delta . Theorem 3 . Let \{P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} be the family of probability distributions defined by equation ( 3.7 ). For each \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} and \Delta:=\Lambda\cup\{v\}(v\in V\setminus\Lambda) , if the family of measurable functions h satisfies the following equation: (3.8) \displaystyle\frac{Z_{\Delta}}{Z_{\Lambda}}=\sum_{w(v)\notin\left\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\right\}}\exp\left\{-\beta\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1}+h_{w(v),v}-h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u),u}\right\}+ \displaystyle\sum_{w(v)\in\left\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\right\}}\exp\left\{-\beta\ln\frac{\alpha_{\Lambda}(w)b_{\alpha_{\Lambda}(w)}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)}{\left(\alpha_{\Lambda}(w)+1\right)\left(b_{\alpha_{\Lambda}(w)+1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1\right)}+h_{w(v),v}-h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u),u}\right\}, then the family \{P_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}_{\Lambda\in\mathcal{N}} is consistent. In this context, \alpha_{\Lambda}(w) is the number of distinct elements in \Lambda that appear exactly as many times as w(v) does. Proof. We consider the condition of consistency for the case \Delta=\Lambda\cup\{v\} with \Lambda\in\mathcal{N} and \Phi=\mathbb{Z} . Firstly, assume that w(v)\neq\sigma_{\Lambda}(x) for all x\in\Lambda . Under this assumption, the following relations hold: b_{1}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1,\quad b_{i}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\quad\text{for all }i=2,...,|\Lambda|,\quad\text{and}\quad b_{|\Delta|}(\sigma_{\Delta})=0. In this case, we have: \displaystyle H_{\Delta}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right) \displaystyle=\sum_{j=1}^{|\Delta|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{1}-\ln b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!+\sum_{j=2}^{|\Delta|-1}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)\ln\theta-\ \ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)!+\sum_{j=2}^{|\Lambda|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]= \displaystyle=(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)\ln\theta-\ \ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)!+\sum_{j=2}^{|\Lambda|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)!\right]= From \ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1)!=\ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda}))!+\ln(b_{1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1) one gets (3.9) H_{\Delta}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)=\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1}+H_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right). Now we consider the second case, i.e., there exists x\in\Lambda such that w(v)=\sigma_{\Lambda}(x) . In this case, there exists i_{0}\in\{1,2,\ldots,|\Lambda|\} such that the following relations hold: b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})-1,\quad b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1,\quad\text{and}\quad b_{i}(\sigma_{\Delta})=b_{i}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\quad\text{for all } i\notin\{i_{0},i_{0}+1\}. Then, we have (3.10) H_{\Delta}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)=\sum_{j=1}^{|\Delta|}\left[b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)\ln\frac{\theta}{j}-\ln b_{j}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\right)!\right]=\ln\frac{i_{0}b_{i_{0}}(\sigma_{\Lambda})}{(i_{0}+1)\left(b_{i_{0}+1}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+1\right)}+H_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right). Thus, the consistency condition can be expressed as: \sum_{w(v)\in\Phi^{\{v\}}}P_{\Delta}\left(\sigma_{\Delta}\vee w(v)\right)=P_{\Lambda}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right), for all \sigma_{\Lambda}\in\Omega^{\Lambda} . Namely, we can rewrite as follows: \frac{Z_{\Delta}}{Z_{\Lambda}}=\sum_{{w(v)}\in\Phi^{\{v\}}}\exp\{-\beta H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})+\beta H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})\}\times \times\exp\left\{\sum_{x\in\partial\Delta}h_{\sigma_{\Delta}(x),x}-\sum_{x\in\partial\Lambda}h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x),x}\right\}. Given that \partial\Lambda=\{u,x_{1},\ldots,x_{m}\} and \partial\Delta=\{v,x_{1},\ldots,x_{m}\} , where \langle u,v\rangle\in L , the following relationship holds: (3.11) \frac{Z_{\Delta}}{Z_{\Lambda}}=\sum_{{w(v)}\in\Phi^{\{v\}}}\exp\{-\beta H_{\Delta}(\sigma_{\Delta})+\beta H_{\Lambda}(\sigma_{\Lambda})+h_{{w(v)},v}-h_{{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u)},u}\}. Using ( 3.9 ) and ( 3.10 ), we can write \displaystyle\frac{Z_{\Delta}}{Z_{\Lambda}}=\sum_{w(v)\notin\left\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\right\}}\exp\left\{-\beta\ln\frac{\theta}{b_{1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1}+h_{w(v),v}-h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u),u}\right\}+ \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\sum_{w(v)\in\left\{\sigma_{\Lambda}(x)\mid x\in\Lambda\right\}}\exp\left\{-\beta\ln\frac{i_{0}b_{i_{0}}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)}{\left(i_{0}+1\right)\left(b_{i_{0}+1}\left(\sigma_{\Lambda}\right)+1\right)}+h_{w(v),v}-h_{\sigma_{\Lambda}(u),u}\right\}. From i_{0}=\alpha_{\Lambda}(w) one gets ( 3.8 ). ∎ Statements and Declarations Conflict of interest statement: The author states that there is no conflict of interest. Data availability statements The datasets generated during and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.