A Neural-Network Extraction of Unpolarised Transverse-Momentum-Dependent Distributions The MAP (Multi-dimensional Analyses of Partonic distributions) Collaboration Preprint: DESY-25-022 Preprint: JLAB-THY-25-4221 Alessandro Bacchetta, Valerio Bertone, Chiara Bissolotti, Matteo Cerutti, Marco Radici, Simone Rodini, Lorenzo Rossi Abstract We present the first extraction of transverse-momentum-dependent distributions of unpolarised quarks from experimental Drell-Yan data using neural networks to parametrise their nonperturbative part. We show that neural networks outperform traditional parametrisations providing a more accurate description of data. This work establishes the feasibility of using neural networks to explore the multi-dimensional partonic structure of hadrons and paves the way for more accurate determinations based on machine-learning techniques. .1 Introduction Transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) distributions provide an important window to investigate the partonic structure of hadrons, enabling a deeper understanding of the three-dimensional dynamics of quarks and gluons within them. TMDs consist of both perturbative and nonperturbative components. While the perturbative part can be calculated from first principles using Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the nonperturbative part, which encapsulates long-distance physics, by definition cannot be evaluated using perturbative methods and must be extracted from experimental data. An accurate parametrisation of the nonperturbative contribution to TMDs is therefore essential for reliable extractions. The abundance of experimental measurements and the development of a robust theoretical framework have favoured a remarkable progress of TMD studies in recent years. Indeed, accurate phenomenological extractions for unpolarised quark TMDs in the proton are now available Bacchetta et al. 2017 ; Scimemi and Vladimirov 2018 ; Bertone et al. 2019 ; Scimemi and Vladimirov 2020 ; Bacchetta et al. 2020 ; Bury et al. 2022 ; Bacchetta et al. 2022 ; Moos et al. 2024 ; Bacchetta et al. 2024 . Despite this active research landscape, explorations of different parametrisations of the TMD nonperturbative part were limited to models based on a small set of functions, such as exponentials and (weighted) Gaussians. While these parametrisations are effective, they carry a significant bias that may limit the accuracy of the models. This rigidity can hinder the ability to fully capture the underlying physics and extract information from experimental data. To overcome these limitations, a promising alternative is given by neural networks (NNs). In this work, we present the first extraction of the unpolarised quark TMD parton distribution functions (PDFs) in the proton using NNs to parametrise their nonperturbative component, achieving next-to-next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic (N 3 LL) accuracy. This constitutes a proof-of-concept extraction, as it is based on Drell-Yan (DY) production data only and neglects flavour dependence of the intrinsic transverse momentum of quarks. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that NN-based TMD extractions outperform traditional nonperturbative parametrisations. Indeed, we provide evidence that current experimental data encode complexities beyond the reach of traditional parametrisations. We remark that NNs have been used in the past to study other partonic distributions (see, e.g. , Refs. Čuić et al. 2020 ; Abdul Khalek et al. 2022 ; Fernando and Keller 2023 ; Bertone et al. 2024 ; Ball et al. 2024 ), but never unpolarised TMDs. Our work paves the way for improved TMD extractions, leveraging the flexibility of NNs to extract information on the multidimensional structure of hadrons using data from current and future experiments. .2 Formalism and parametrisation We consider the DY process h_{A}+h_{B}\rightarrow\ell^{+}+\ell^{-}+X where two hadrons with mass M and four-momenta P_{A} and P_{B} collide with center-of-mass energy squared s=(P_{A}+P_{B})^{2} , and inclusively produce a lepton pair with total four-momentum q and invariant mass Q\gg M . If the transverse momentum component \bm{q}_{T} with respect to the collision axis satisfies the condition |\bm{q}_{T}|\equiv q_{T}\ll Q , the differential cross section can be written as \begin{split}&\frac{d\sigma^{\text{DY}}}{dq_{T}\,dy\,dQ}=\frac{8\pi\alpha^{2}q_{T}}{9Q^{3}}\,{\cal P}\,x_{A}\,x_{B}\,{\cal H}^{\text{DY}}(Q,\mu)\,\sum_{a}c_{a}(Q^{2})\\ &\times\int_{0}^{\infty}\!\!db_{T}\,b_{T}J_{0}\big(b_{T}q_{T}\big)\hat{f}_{1}^{a}(x_{A},b_{T}^{2};\mu,\zeta_{A})\,\hat{f}_{1}^{\bar{a}}(x_{B},b_{T}^{2};\mu,\zeta_{B}),\end{split} (1) where y=\ln\sqrt{(q_{0}+q_{z})/(q_{0}-q_{z})} is the lepton-pair rapidity, \alpha is the electromagnetic coupling, {\cal P} is a phase-space-reduction factor accounting for possible lepton cuts, 1 1 1 See Appendix C of Ref. Bacchetta et al. 2020 for details. x_{A,B}=Qe^{\pm y}/\sqrt{s} are the longitudinal momentum fractions carried by the incoming quarks, {\cal H}^{\text{DY}} is a perturbative hard factor encoding the virtual part of the scattering, and the sum runs over all active quark flavours a with c_{a} the quark electroweak charges. In Eq. ( 1 ), \hat{f}^{a}_{1} is the Fourier transform of the unpolarised TMD PDF of quark flavour a . It depends on the quark longitudinal momentum fraction x and on the variable b_{T}=|\bm{b}_{T}| , where \bm{b}_{T} is Fourier-conjugated to the quark intrinsic transverse momentum \bm{k}_{\perp} . It also depends on the renormalisation scale \mu and on the rapidity scale \zeta (with the constraint \zeta_{A}\zeta_{B}=Q^{4} ). Such dependence arises from the removal of ultraviolet and rapidity divergences Collins 2023 and is controlled by corresponding evolution equations. The complete set of equations (omitting unessential variables and indices) is given by \displaystyle\begin{split}\frac{\partial\hat{f}_{1}}{\partial\ln\mu}&=\gamma(\mu,\zeta)\,,\quad\frac{\partial\hat{f}_{1}}{\partial\ln\sqrt{\zeta}}=K(\mu)\,,\\ \frac{\partial K}{\partial\ln\mu}&=\frac{\partial\gamma}{\partial\ln\sqrt{\zeta}}=-\gamma_{K}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))\,,\end{split} (2) where \gamma and K are the anomalous dimensions of renormalisation group and of Collins–Soper equations, respectively, and \gamma_{K} is the so-called cusp anomalous dimension which relates the cross derivatives of \hat{f}_{1} . Given a set of initial scales ( \mu_{i},\zeta_{i} ), the solution to these differential equations allows us to determine the \hat{f}_{1} at any final scales ( \mu_{f},\zeta_{f} ). In addition, in the region of small transverse separations b_{T} , the TMD PDF \hat{f}_{1} can be matched onto unpolarized collinear PDFs f_{1} through a convolution with perturbatively calculable matching coefficients C . The resulting expression for the TMD PDF at the final scales ( \mu_{f},\zeta_{f} ) is \displaystyle\begin{split}\hat{f}&{}_{1}(x,b_{T};\mu_{f},\zeta_{f})=\big[C\otimes f_{1}\big](x,b_{T};\mu_{i},\zeta_{i})\\ &\times\exp\bigg\{K(\mu_{i})\ln\frac{\sqrt{\zeta_{f}}}{\sqrt{\zeta_{i}}}\\ &\quad+\int_{\mu_{i}}^{\mu_{f}}\frac{d\mu}{\mu}\bigg[\gamma_{F}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))-\gamma_{K}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))\ln\frac{\sqrt{\zeta_{f}}}{\mu}\bigg]\bigg\}\;,\end{split} (3) where \gamma_{F}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))=\gamma(\mu,\mu^{2}) and \otimes indicates the Mellin convolution over the longitudinal momentum fraction x . A convenient choice for the initial scales is \mu_{i}=\sqrt{\zeta_{i}}\equiv\mu_{b}=2e^{-\gamma_{\rm E}}/b_{T} , with \gamma_{\rm E} the Euler constant, in that it avoids the insurgence of large logarithms in the anomalous dimension K and in the matching coefficients C . The TMD PDF in Eq. ( 3 ) includes the resummation of large logarithms of b_{T} to all orders in perturbation theory. A given logarithmic accuracy implies that each ingredient in Eq. ( 3 ) must be computed to the appropriate perturbative accuracy. The present extraction incorporates all the necessary ingredients to reach N 3 LL accuracy Bertone et al. 2019 . The introduction of the scale \mu_{b}\sim 1/b_{T} requires a prescription to avoid integrating in Eq. ( 1 ) over the QCD Landau pole ( \Lambda_{\rm QCD} ) in the large- b_{T} region. To this purpose, we adopt the same choice of Refs. Bacchetta et al. 2017 ; Bacchetta et al. 2022 ; Bacchetta et al. 2024 ; Bacchetta et al. 2020 ; Cerutti et al. 2023 and replace \mu_{b} with \mu_{b_{*}}=2e^{-\gamma_{\rm E}}/b_{*} , where b_{*}(b_{T},b_{\text{min}},b_{\text{max}})=b_{\text{max}}\bigg(\frac{1-e^{-b_{T}^{4}/b_{\text{max}}^{4}}}{1-e^{-b_{T}^{4}/b_{\text{min}}^{4}}}\bigg)^{1/4}, (4) with \displaystyle b_{\text{max}}=2e^{-\gamma_{\rm E}}\text{ GeV}^{-1}\quad b_{\text{min}}=2e^{-\gamma_{\rm E}}/\mu_{f}\,. (5) This choice guarantees that the variable b_{*} rapidly saturates to b_{\text{max}} at large values of b_{T} , preventing \mu_{b_{*}} from reaching \Lambda_{\rm QCD} . However, b_{*} also introduces spurious power corrections that scale like (\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}/q_{T})^{k} Catani et al. 1996 ; Kulesza et al. 2002 ; Laenen et al. 2000 ; Kulesza et al. 2004 , with k>0 . In the region q_{T}\simeq\Lambda_{\text{QCD}} , these power corrections become sizeable and can be modelled by including in Eq. ( 3 ) the nonperturbative function f_{\text{\tiny NP}} as follows: \begin{split}\hat{f}&{}_{1}(x,b_{T};\mu_{f},\zeta_{f})=\big[C\otimes f_{1}\big](x,b_{T};\mu_{b_{*}},\mu_{b_{*}}^{2})\\ &\times\exp\bigg\{K(b_{*},\mu_{b_{*}})\ln\frac{\sqrt{\zeta_{f}}}{\mu_{b_{*}}}\\ &\quad+\int_{\mu_{b_{*}}}^{\mu_{f}}\frac{d\mu}{\mu}\bigg[\gamma_{F}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))-\gamma_{K}(\alpha_{s}(\mu))\ln\frac{\sqrt{\zeta_{f}}}{\mu}\bigg]\bigg\}\\ &\quad\quad\times f_{\text{\tiny NP}}(x,b_{T};\zeta_{f})\,.\end{split} (6) The nonperturbative function must satisfy the condition f_{\text{\tiny NP}}\to 1 for b_{T}\to 0 in order to recover the perturbative regime. It must also grant that the TMD PDF is suppressed for large values of b_{T} and \zeta_{f} . We parametrise f_{\text{\tiny NP}} using a NN but enforcing these physically required constraints. We explored several different NN parametrisations and will report on them in a future work. As a proof of concept, in this work we focus on the following model: f_{\text{\tiny NP}}(x,b_{T};\zeta)=\frac{\mathbb{NN}(x,b_{T})}{\mathbb{NN}(x,0)}\exp\left[-g_{2}^{2}b_{T}^{2}\log\left(\frac{\zeta}{Q_{0}^{2}}\right)\right]\,, (7) where, as customary, we split f_{\text{\tiny NP}} into an “intrinsic” nonperturbative part, entirely parametrised by the NN (denoted as \mathbb{NN} ), and the nonperturbative contribution to the rapidity evolution, encoded in the exponential function. The NN is taken with architecture [2,10,1] , i.e. with two inputs corresponding to x and b_{T} , 10 hidden nodes, and one output node. The activation function associated to the nodes of the hidden layer is \sigma(z)=\frac{1}{2}\left(1+\frac{z}{1+|z|}\right)\,, (8) which resembles the more traditional sigmoid function but offers a significant reduction of computational burden while granting an excellent quality of the final result. The activation function for the outer layer is instead chosen to be quadratic. The reference scale for the rapidity evolution is set to Q_{0}=1 GeV. The parametrisation of the function f_{\text{\tiny NP}} in Eq. ( 7 ) is engineered to match the constraints mentioned above, namely f_{\text{\tiny NP}}\to 1 for b_{T}\to 0 and f_{\text{\tiny NP}}\ll 1 for large b_{T} and \zeta_{f} . With this setup, we have a total of 42 free parameters, 41 associated to the NN and one ( g_{2} ) to the evolution. The values of the best-fit parameters are obtained by minimising a \chi^{2} that accounts for all sources of experimental uncertainties. The minimisation is performed using the Levenberg–Marquardt algorithm as implemented in the Ceres-Solver package Agarwal et al. 2023 . An important aspect of our analysis is that the gradient of the \chi^{2} with respect to the free parameters is evaluated analytically by exploiting the ability to compute the derivatives of the NN with respect to its parameters in a closed form Abdul Khalek and Bertone 2020 . This feature is crucial to ensure a fast and stable convergence of the minimisation procedure. Finally, overfitting is a well known problem of phenomenological analyses based on NNs Ball et al. 2017 ; Ball et al. 2022 . We avoid it by using the cross-validation method Del Debbio et al. 2007 . Specifically, the data set is split into two subsets: one for training and one for validation. The training set is used to determine the best-fit parameters, while the validation set is used to monitor the quality of the fit. The best-fit set of parameters is determined by requiring the \chi^{2} of the validation set to be minimal. In our analysis, we divided the data set into validation and training sets of the same size. .3 Results In this section, we discuss the results for the fit of f_{\text{\tiny NP}} in Eq. ( 7 ) to the DY experimental data included in the most recent analyses of the MAP Collaboration (see Refs. Bacchetta et al. 2022 ; Bacchetta et al. 2024 for more details). We consider fixed-target data from Fermilab (E605 Moreno et al. 1991 , E288 Ito et al. 1981 , and E772 McGaughey et al. 1994 ) and collider data from Tevatron (CDF Affolder et al. 2000 ; Aaltonen et al. 2012 , D0 Abbott et al. 2000 ; Abazov et al. 2008 ; Abazov et al. 2010 ), RHIC (STAR Collaboration 2024 ), and the LHC (LHCb Aaij et al. 2015 ; Aaij et al. 2016a ; Aaij et al. 2016b , CMS Chatrchyan et al. 2012 ; Khachatryan et al. 2017 ; Sirunyan et al. 2019 , ATLAS Aad et al. 2014 ; Aad et al. 2016 ; Aad et al. 2020 ). The collinear PDFs f_{1} in Eq. ( 6 ) are taken from the MSHT2020 set Bailey et al. 2021 of the LHAPDF library Buckley et al. 2015 at next-to-next-to-leading-order, which is necessary to achieve N 3 LL. The strong coupling \alpha_{s} is obtained from the same PDF set. We propagate the uncertainties of collinear PDFs into TMD PDFs as in Refs. Bacchetta et al. 2022 ; Cerutti et al. 2023 . In order to ensure applicability of TMD factorisation, we impose the kinematic cut q_{T}/Q<0.2 . We exclude all experimental data in the energy range of the \Upsilon resonance (9 GeV