Towards Explainable Spoofed Speech Attribution and Detection: a Probabilistic Approach for Characterizing Speech Synthesizer Components Journal: Computer Speech And Language Jagabandhu Mishra, Manasi Chhibber, Hye-jin Shim, Tomi H. Kinnunen Abstract We propose an explainable probabilistic framework for characterizing spoofed speech by decomposing it into probabilistic attribute embeddings. Unlike raw high-dimensional countermeasure embeddings, which lack interpretability, the proposed probabilistic attribute embeddings aim to detect specific speech synthesizer components, represented through high-level attributes and their corresponding values. We use these probabilistic embeddings with four classifier back-ends to address two downstream tasks: spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution. The former is the well-known bonafide-spoof detection task, whereas the latter seeks to identify the source method (generator) of a spoofed utterance. We additionally use Shapley values, a widely used technique in machine learning, to quantify the relative contribution of each attribute value to the decision-making process in each task. Results on the ASVspoof2019 dataset demonstrate the substantial role of waveform generator, conversion model outputs, and inputs in spoofing detection; and inputs, speaker, and duration modeling in spoofing attack attribution. In the detection task, the probabilistic attribute embeddings achieve 99.7 % 99.7\% balanced accuracy and 0.22 % 0.22\% equal error rate (EER), closely matching the performance of raw embeddings ( 99.9 % 99.9\% balanced accuracy and 0.22 % 0.22\% EER). Similarly, in the attribution task, our embeddings achieve 90.23 % 90.23\% balanced accuracy and 2.07 % 2.07\% EER, compared to 90.16 % 90.16\% and 2.11 % 2.11\% with raw embeddings. These results demonstrate that the proposed framework is both inherently explainable by design and capable of achieving performance comparable to raw CM embeddings. 1 Introduction Advances in deep generative modeling [ 1 ] have paved way to flexible generation of high-quality synthetic media . Despite the many useful applications, this ‘ deepfake ’ [ 2 ] technology has raised concerns in its exploitation, whether for misinformation spreading in social media, defaming a targeted person, spoofing biometric systems [ 3 ] or conducting advanced social engineering attacks for financial gains, to name a few. Synthetic media targeted specifically against biometric recognition are forms of presentation attacks ( spoofing attacks ) [ 4 ] . In this study, our focus is on speech. The two well-known technologies of speech synthesis ( text-to-speech , TTS) [ 5 ] and voice conversion (VC) [ 6 ] can be used for controlled generation and speaker identity conversion of speech utterances, respectively. While the past-generation TTS and VC technology was tailored for small and closed-world speaker populations, recent zero-shot [ 7 ] approaches make it possible, in principle, to reproduce speech in anyone’s voice based on a small amount of training data (required at the generation time only). Lately, a number of alarming social engineering attacks that involve the use of these technologies have been reported [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Having recognized the potential risks of TTS and VC to spoof voice biometric (speaker recognition) systems from early on [ 11 , 12 ] , the research community has devised various active defenses (countermeasures) against spoofing attacks. By far, the most common strategy is to detect the presence of spoofing: Spoofing Detection (aka Deepfake Detection or Presentation Attack Detection) Given a speech utterance X , determine whether X is more likely to originate from a bonafide human vocal production system (null hypothesis H_{0} ) or from a spoofing attack algorithm (alternative hypothesis H_{1} ) . Apart from a few exceptions [ 13 , 14 ] , typically no prior knowledge of the speaker identity in X is assumed. Moreover, in the ASVspoof challenges [ 15 ] —a widely adapted benchmark in the field with its fifth edition concluded recently [ 16 ] —both the speakers and the spoofing attacks across the training and test data are, to a large extent, disjoint. Such database design choices are intended to promote the development of speaker- and synthesizer-independent spoofing detection suitable for a range of different applications. As for the detection solutions that have emerged through the past decade, the research focus has shifted from hand-crafting features [ 17 , 18 ] to design of deep neural network architectures [ 19 , 20 ] . To address training data limitations, recent models are typically trained with either data augmentations [ 21 , 22 ] and/or leverage from pre-trained self-supervised feature representations [ 23 ] . The above bonafide-spoofed detectors typically produce a single real-valued detection score (such as estimated likelihood ratio P(X|H_{0})/P(X|H_{1}) or posterior probability P(H_{0}|X) ) that reflects the relative strength of evidence towards the two hypotheses. While such scalar score evidence may suffice in applications that involve automated decision making at scale —for instance, authenticating millions of users in call-center or automated phone banking—the approach has limited value in applications that require additional level of detail or explanations relevant to the user of the technology. Audio forensics is one such domain. To this end, in this paper, we consider spoofing attack attribution , also known as source tracing . With the aim to help pinpoint who has generated a specific deepfake, it seeks to identify the specific model or algorithm (source) that was used in generating the spoofing attack: Spoofing Attack Attribution (aka Source Tracing) Given a spoofed speech utterance X , along with a collection of hypothesized attacks \mathcal{A}=\{\mathcal{A}_{1},\dots,\mathcal{A}_{C}\} , determine which attack is the source of X ; or conclude ’none of them’ (unknown attack not included in \mathcal{A} ). When we know that X actually originates from one of the attacks in \mathcal{A} , the spoofing attack attribution is said to have a closed set of spoofing attacks; otherwise an open set . Our study is not the first to address attack attribution, either in general multimedia [ 24 , 25 ] or in speech (related studies are reviewed in Section 2 ). Existing approaches in the literature are primarily focused on predictive performance rather than interpretability. In contrast, we propose a novel probabilistic attribution framework (detailed in Section 3 ) which is designed to be inherently explainable. An initial study this method has been reported in our recent work [ 26 ] , where the study was limited to using a classic decision tree classifier [ 27 ] . While decision trees provided a degree of interpretability, their predictive performance can be constrained. Moreover, the earlier work addressed the spoofing attack attribution task using only two attacks. The present study substantially expands upon [ 26 ] both at the conceptual, theoretical framework, and experimental levels. We incorporate a diverse range of interpretable back-end classifiers, including naive Bayes [ 28 ] (specifically tailored to handle probabilistic attribute features), logistic regression [ 29 ] , and support vector machines (SVM) [ 30 ] . These classifiers bring complementary strengths, such as probabilistic reasoning (naive Bayes), robust classification (logistic regression), and the ability to handle decision boundaries with maximum margin for improved generalizability (SVM). This diversification enhances both the interpretability and predictive performance of the framework. Furthermore, to achieve better generalizability, this study introduces a new custom protocol on the ASVspoof2019 dataset, expanding the scope beyond the earlier focus on two known attack types to include all 17 types of attacks for spoofing attack attribution. The central idea (illustrated in Figure 1 ) is to extract discrete probability distributions over attribute values during the test (inference) phase, which serve as recording-level feature vectors to address the downstream tasks of spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution. These attribute values are derived from a compact set of attributes that characterize various spoofed speech generation methods (see Figure 2 ). For a given test utterance, the explainable design provides insights in the form of probabilities associated with the attributes involved in the spoofed speech generation process. Additionally, while Shapley values [ 31 ] in existing literature have been used to analyze contributing factors in the speech signal or spectrogram for spoofing detection [ 32 ] , our work extends this approach to analyze the contribution of specific attributes towards decision-making. This extension enhances the interpretability of the proposed framework by identifying the key attributes influencing the outcomes for both spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution tasks. Figure 1: Overall pipeline of the proposed architecture. CM: countermeasure, MLP: multilayer perception. Here 1,\ldots,M_{l} represents the predicted attribute values of attribute l . The CM embeddings are extracted from the speech signal and subsequently used with probabilistic attribute extractors to obtain the probabilistic attribute embeddings. The probabilistic attribute embeddings are then used with backend classifiers to perform the downstream tasks: spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution. For comparison, the CM embeddings are also directly used with backend classifiers to perform the downstream tasks (as shown in Figure through dotted arrow). Finally, the explainable probabilistic attribute embeddings, interpretable classifier, and their scores are used to explain the relative contribution of the attributes in decision-making. Figure 2: A tentative structure of spoofed speech generation, VC: voice conversion, E2E: End to End, TTS: text to speech, Waveform Gen.: Waveform Generator . 2 Related work: inspirations from binary attribution, and studies on explainable deepfake characterization In this study, our intention is to demonstrate how different spoofing attack algorithms can be broken down into their elementary building blocks, represented through a high-level probabilistic feature description. Specifically, our aim is to characterize spoofing attacks through abstract discrete probabilistic attributes . As for the ‘discrete’ , random events that can be named, enumerated, and explained to others are convenient to us as humans. Much of the basic sciences (and everyday communication) seeks to explain complicated concepts through simplifications. As for the ‘probabilistic’ , real-world physical objects, including acoustic speech waveforms, are rarely ‘either-this-or-that’ due to inaccuracies in measuring or observing the relevant cues; probabilities provide a natural way to quantify uncertainty in the features, allowing one to postpone the final classification decision to a later stage. Finally, ‘attribute’ is essentially a synonym for ‘feature’, but intended to emphasize the notion of the features to bear clear semantics to humans. The prior work closest in sentiment to our work includes the use of binary attributes [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] for speaker characterization. By motivations stemming partly from presentation of DNA evidence in forensic contexts [ 36 ] , this approach uses binary-valued (‘on/off’) attributes extracted either through classic statistical GMM [ 33 ] or modern neural autoencoders [ 34 ] to characterize speaker-specific features. We point the interested reader to [ 35 ] for in-depth motivations and interpretation of this binary attribution approach, designed to improve explainability in forensic speaker profiling. These studies provide a valuable foundation for feature-based analysis in speech, highlighting the potential of interpretable representations, especially within domains like forensics that demand explanations along with accuracy. However, the challenge of spoofing detection demands new strategies that can go beyond individual speaker traits. Whereas our study shares the sentiment of [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] in the desire to define explainable attributes, our study is different both in the assumed format of the attributes and the classification tasks. Unlike [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] which rely on binary-valued (‘on/off’) attributes, our method uses multi-class valued attributes and represents feature value uncertainty with probabilities rather than binarized ( 0 or 1 ) versions. This allows such probabilistic features to be easily combined with arbitrary classifiers (as we demonstrate in our experiments). This move to a probabilistic multi-class representation allows capturing rich nuances in spoofing signals, which might otherwise be lost in hard binary decisions. Apart from the subtle technical modeling choice on attribute format, the more critical difference is underlined in the task (speaker characterization in [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] ; deepfake characterization in the present work). Speaker characterization leverages audio data that originates from a biological system—the human vocal production system driven by neural and muscular activities that consists of the lungs, the larynx, and the supralaryngeal vocal tract system. As such, motivation and design of attributes for speaker characterization can benefit from the established speech science that covers domains such as physiology, biomechanics, aerodynamics, acoustics, digital speech modeling, phonetics and phonology. In contrast, deepfakes originate from artificial systems (computer programs that implement specific synthesis or conversion models). What are the relevant attributes of such systems — how should we characterize spoofed and deepfake speech? Whereas the field of speech synthesis has a long history and its established system categorizations (e.g. concatenative, statistical, and neural TTS), there has been little focus towards the attribution task. In short, we require thorough re-thinking of what the explainable attributes for categorizing, classifying and explaining different spoofing attack algorithms should be. With deepfakes being still a relatively recent security threat, and with major focus of defense solutions having been on the binary ’real-fake’ discrimination task, the work in more refined categorization of spoofed speech generators (including their detection) is currently taking only its infant steps. By no means the present work is intended to be a full description of spoofed speech characterization but, rather, a modest conceptual step forward. Besides forensic ‘speaker profiling’, an already established topic [ 37 ] , we expect future forensic speech analysts to benefit from ‘deepfake profiling’ or ‘attack fingerprinting’ methodologies. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, however, no such standardized approaches are available yet. Table 1: Review of speech-based deepfake attribution and detection studies. This table highlights the variety of approaches employed, including the feature extraction and classification methods used by different researchers. Paper Task Dataset Features Classifiers Methodology [ 38 ] Attribution In-house data bicoherence magnitude and phase, first four statistical moments of magnitude and phase logistic regression (linear classifiers) Bispectral analysis was used to extract features highlighting unusual spectral correlations in spoofed speech for classification against human speech. [ 39 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019 short-term and long-term prediction traces (obtained by minimizing prediction error in the time domain) linear SVM, RBF SVM, random forest, GMM A method is proposed that combines short-term and long-term prediction error energies, extracted from a source-filter model of speech, to classify audio as either real or synthetic speech. [ 40 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019 spectrograms, MFCCs, CQCCs, LFCCs, raw waveforms ResNet, RawNet2, GMM Several different audio features were extracted and used with various classifiers (SVM, GMM, and ResNet) to detect synthetic speech in both closed and open-set scenarios, comparing their performance. [ 41 ] Attribution SP Cup challenge (DARPA-Semafor) log-mel spectrograms multi-layer CNNs (used to extract features and classify), self-attention layers (used by transformer in feature extraction) A semi-supervised multi-class ensemble of CNNs was trained using a novel unknown class strategy, data augmentation, and ensemble techniques for synthetic speech attribution. [ 42 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019, DARPA-Semafor mel-spectrograms PSAT A patchout spectrogram attribution transformer (PSAT) architecture, combining a patchout mechanism with a transformer network, was trained to classify synthesized speech samples and attribute them to their respective synthesis algorithms. [ 43 ] Attribution DARPA-Semafor spectrograms compact attribution transformer (CAT) A compact attribution transformer (CAT) was trained to classify speech signals into known synthesizers or an unknown class, utilizing normalized spectrograms as input. [ 44 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019, DARPA-Semafor mel-spectrogram, 768-dim. representation of each region of spectrogram (using pretrained transformer), positional encodings linear layer with SoftMax activation (on top of mean pooled representation from pretrained transformer) A synthetic speech attribution transformer (SSAT) was trained using a pretext task to learn robust representations of speech signals, which were then used for synthesizer attribution in both closed and open set scenarios. [ 45 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019 low-level acoustic features, neural embeddings feed-forward neural network (used for both low-level and learned embedding based signatures) Low-level audio features are extracted and used to train a classifier for attributing audio deepfakes to specific attacks. [ 46 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019, MLAAD raw audio, LFCC (with delta and double delta) ResNet, self-supervised learning (SSL) based model using wav2vec 2.0, Whisper based model A two-stage system is used, first training a model for speaker classification using self-supervised learning and then fine-tuning it for source tracing using a multi-task learning approach. [ 47 ] Detection and Attribution ASVspoof2019 log-FBank, truncated/concatenated signals (for RawNet2), various acoustic features (e.g. LPCC, MFCC - used as inputs, no explicit feature extraction layer) ResNet34, RawNet2 (used as front- end with classification layers) A multi-task learning strategy is employed, combining speaker classification and spoofing detection to improve source tracing performance. [ 48 ] Attribution ADD2023 Challenge Track 3 dataset wav2vec2.0 ECAPA-TDNN A system using wav2vec2.0 for feature extraction, ECAPA-TDNN for algorithm classification, and data augmentation techniques. [ 49 ] Attribution ADD2023 Challenge Track 3 dataset LFCC, Raw Waveform, HuBERT rawnet2, SE-Res2Net50, HuBERT Multi-model fusion using manifold distance and feature-level fusion. [ 50 ] Attribution ADD2023 Challenge Track 3 dataset STFT, Wav2Vec2 SENet, LCNN-LSTM, TDNN, kNN-based OOD Detection kNN with cosine similarity for OOD detection, combined with data augmentation and model fusion. [ 51 ] Detection PartialSpoof dataset, ASVspoof 2019 LA dataset log-mel spectrograms SSL-gMLPs, SSL-Res1D Grad-CAM visualization and a novel quantitative analysis metric (RCQ) were used to interpret the decision-making process of countermeasures trained on partially spoofed audio. [ 52 ] Detection LJSpeech dataset, AI-generated voice data using Tacotron2 and FastSpeech2 with HiFiGAN waveform generator mel-spectrogram CNN14 PDSM discretizes saliency maps using phoneme boundaries from an ASR model for explainable spoofed speech detection. [ 47 ] Detection and Attribution ASVspoof2019 raw audio Resnet34, Rawnet2 A multitask framework is introduced to jointly train spoofing detection and attribute value classification. [ 53 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019 and FAD 2023 features from pre-trained models CNN, FusIon through ReNyi DivERgence (FINDER) FINDER framework is proposed for optimally combine the features from speech-pre-trained models [ 54 ] Attribution ASVspoof2019, DARPA SemaFor, and CFAD Sub-band time-frequency feature Transformer Proposed sub-band time-frequency feature and shown the effectiveness of class-dependent threshold for openset attribution task. [ 55 ] Attribution ST-Codecfake raw audio, mel spectrogram Wav2vec ASSIST, ASSIST, LCNN Introduced a source tracing Codecfake dataset, and analyzed the performance with frequently used classifiers. This work Detection and Attribution ASVspoof2019 probabilistic attribute embeddings derived from countermeasure systems Naive Bayes, Decision Tree, Logistic Regression, Support Vector Machine Spoofed speech is characterized by a set of high- level probabilistic attributes extracted from CM embeddings and used with several classifiers, including Shapley value analysis for explainability. With the stage set above for explainability and the relevance of probabilistic attributes in speech tasks, we now review related explainability studies specifically within the context of spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution, as summarized in Table 1 . These studies are examined through the lens of their focus on feature analysis, detection or attribution, and modeling techniques. Prior works on explainability in this domain can be broadly categorized into two approaches. The first category focuses on identifying regions within the spectrogram or speech signal that contribute to predictions in spoofing detection. For instance, [ 51 ] employs gradient-weighted class activation mapping (Grad-CAM), while [ 52 ] uses saliency maps to highlight the regions of speech waveforms and spectrograms contributing to predictions. Although these approaches provide a degree of explainability, they are not explicitly linked to the underlying process of spoofed speech generation. The second category attempts to explain spoofed speech by tracing its source of generation, commonly referred to as spoofing attack attribution or source tracing , as mentioned in Section 1 . One of the earliest investigations in this direction [ 38 ] utilized bispectral magnitude and phase features to differentiate between spoofed and bonafide speech sources. Building on this, [ 39 ] explored long-term and short-term parameterization using linear prediction (LP) residuals and their periodicity to detect spoofing attributes, highlighting the importance of time-domain feature analysis. Open-set attribution was investigated in [ 40 ] through a one-class thresholding approach combined with a support vector machine (SVM). Similarly, [ 41 ] addressed open-set attribution using an ensemble semi-supervised multi-class strategy based on convolutional neural networks (CNNs). Further advances in spoofing attack attribution include approaches based on the popular Transformer models. For instance, [ 42 ] proposed a patchout spectrogram-based Transformer framework, while [ 43 ] introduced a compact attribution transformer with a poly-1 loss function [ 56 ] to enhance open-set performance. Extending this direction, [ 44 ] explored self-supervised Transformer models for spoofing attack attribution. Another study [ 45 ] examined low-level acoustic features such as fundamental frequency, distortion, shimmer, and speaker gender, combined with neural embeddings to improve attack attribution. Moreover, [ 53 ] demonstrated the role of prosodic signatures captured in speech pre-trained models, while [ 54 ] explored sub-band time-frequency features with Transformers for spoofing attack attribution. Recently, [ 46 ] employed Rawnet [ 57 ] , Whisper [ 58 ] , and self-supervised learning techniques [ 59 ] to trace spoofed speech sources, focusing on attributes such as input type, acoustic model, and waveform generator [ 59 ] . Another approach in [ 47 ] utilized Rawnet and ResNet34 architectures with multi-task learning (joint attribute value classification and spoofing detection) to address source tracing alongside spoofing detection. Furthermore, [ 55 ] introduced neural codec source tracing and demonstrated its effectiveness in both open-set and closed-set scenarios, leveraging mel light CNNs (mel-LCNN) [ 60 ] , audio anti-spoofing using integrated spectro-temporal graph attention network (AASIST) [ 61 ] , and wav2vec-AASIST [ 62 ] architectures. The growing interest in this field is evident from the upcoming special session on Source tracing: The origins of synthetic or manipulated speech 1 1 1 https://www.interspeech2025.org/special-sessions at Interspeech 2025, which aims to bring together researchers working on spoofing attribution techniques. Additionally, as summarized in Table 1 , most prior works utilized publicly available datasets such as ASVspoof2019 [ 63 ] , Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency Semantic Forensics (DARPA SemaFor) [ 64 ] , TIMIT-TTS [ 65 ] , Open Dataset of Synthetic Speech (ODSS) [ 66 ] , Fake or Real (FoR) [ 67 ] , Chinese fake audio detection (CFAD) [ 68 ] and Multi-Language Audio Anti-Spoof (MLAAD) [ 69 ] for evaluating the performance of their methods. Unlike speaker profiling, which focuses on analyzing speaker traits, most existing techniques prioritize predictive performance in either detecting spoofed speech or attributing attacks but offer a limited explanation of the spoofing traits that contribute to the predictions. In contrast, our approach characterizes spoofed speech using discrete probabilistic attributes derived from its generation process. These attributes are leveraged to perform both spoofing detection and spoofing attack attribution. By design, the proposed framework provides explainability for a given utterance by associating probabilities with the attributes involved in the spoofed speech generation process, offering insights into both tasks simultaneously. 3 Proposed Probabilistic Attribute Characterization In our approach, a CM embedding ( \vec{e}_{\text{cm}} ) is first extracted from a speech utterance ( \vec{x} ), as illustrated in Figure 1 . These CM embeddings are then utilized to characterize the attributes through probabilistic attribute extractors. The outputs of each attribute extracted are stacked to form a probabilistic attribute embedding, denoted as \vec{\rho} . These embeddings are subsequently used with backend classifiers to perform downstream tasks here, either of spoofing detection or spoofing attack attribution. To enhance explainability, the attributes that contribute significantly to the predictions are analyzed using Shapley values [ 70 ] . For a fair performance comparison, the downstream tasks are also conducted using raw CM embeddings as baselines. The design of attributes, their probabilistic characterization, the use of backend classifiers for downstream tasks, and the use of Shapley values to explain attribute contributions to decision-making are briefly discussed in the following subsections. 3.1 Attributes of spoofed speech generators We aim to characterize spoofed speech using explainable probabilistic attribute embeddings, drawing inspiration from the processes involved in its generation. To this end, we decompose spoofed speech generation to its underlying attributes hierarchically, as illustrated in Figure 2 . First, note that spoofed utterances are typically produced through voice conversion (VC) or text-to-speech (TTS) approaches, or their hybrids (TTS followed by VC) [ 47 , 46 , 63 ] . These methods are generally designed and implemented through one of the two main approaches. The first approach combines a number of clearly identified sub-components—such as an intermediate acoustic feature predictor and a waveform generator—in a cascade. Since the individual sub-components (modules) and their functions are clearly understood and known at the training and inference (speech generation) stages, we refer to spoofed speech generators in this category modular . This is in contrast to the second approach based on end-to-end (E2E) [ 65 ] models that map either a text passage (in TTS) or a source speaker utterance (in VC) directly to a predicted waveform. The design philosophy of E2E approaches is to use a model optimized ‘in one go’, as opposed to constructing it from separately-optimized sub-components. Note that while E2E models also consist of cascaded components—namely, the layers in a deep neural network that pass intermediate latent feature representations to the next layer(s)—the key distinction here is whether the individual sub-components have a clearly-identified, explainable meaning to their function or not. A ’WaveNet waveform generator’, for instance, might be argued to be more meaningful than ‘layer number 26’. The modules used in constructing a complete TTS or VC system themselves can further be characterized with a number of pre-defined high-level design choices, or attributes . The values of attributes determine the design choices used. For instance, the intermediate acoustic feature predictor operates on specific type of input data (text or speech) and produces particular type of outputs (type of predicted features) expected by the subsequent waveform generator module. The intermediate acoustic feature predictor may use a specific duration model or a particular target speaker representation (such as one-hot vector or an external speaker embedding vector for zero-shot type of TTS). Assigning specific values for both the feature predictor and the waveform generator attributes defines a particular TTS or VC system design. As a concrete example, consider one of the widely used modular TTS approaches described in [ 71 ] . This approach consists of a so-called ‘Tacotron2’ acoustic feature predictor and a ‘WaveNet’ waveform generator [ 72 ] . The former assumes character embedding inputs that are passed through layers of convolutional neural network, long-short term memory (LSTM), and bidirectional LSTM layers to predict a mel-spectrogram. A WaveNet waveform generator conditioned on the mel-spectrogram is then used for generating the audio waveform. This approach can further be extended, as reported in [ 73 ] , to support multiple speakers by conditioning the mel-spectrogram generation by speaker embeddings. Hence, based on the structure shown in Figure 2 , the ‘Tacotron2+WaveNet’ TTS system can be characterized using the following attribute-value pairs: input = text input processor(character encoder) = 1-hot duration = None conversion = CNN+LSTM speaker = x-vector outputs = mel-spectrogram waveform generator = waveNet This way, we can characterize the spoofed speech generation methods using information available at the training time. Whereas the majority of source tracing (attack attribution) approaches aim at fingerprinting the full model, our approach seeks to detect partial traits by estimating the attribute values. In practice, each attribute is presented using a categorical random variable over its possible values. While these values are known at the training time (presented through 1-hot encoding), their values are uncertain at the test time. We hypothesize that variations in the attribute values may leave detectable traces in the generated spoofed speech. Compared to the typical high-dimensional CM embeddings, the characterization of spoofed speech with clearly-defined attributes and their values has better explainability. 3.2 Probabilistic attributes Let \bm{\mathrm{x}} denote a speech waveform. We use {\bm{\rho}}_{\ell}(\vec{x})=[\rho_{\ell,1},\dots,\rho_{\ell,M_{\ell}}]^{\mathsf{T}} to denote a discrete probability distribution over the values of attribute \ell ; the probabilities are \rho_{\ell,m}(\vec{x}) , where 1\leq m\leq M_{\ell} . For a given utterance, we extract L such distributions. In our approach, we first extract a CM embedding {\bf e}_{\text{cm}}(\vec{x})\in\mathbb{R}^{D} using a suitable spoofing CM system. The CM embeddings are then used to train a bank of L probabilistic attribute extractors , \{\mathcal{F}^{\text{pae}}_{{\bm{\rho}}_{\ell}}:\ell=1,\dots,L\} , each specific to an attribute as follows, \mathcal{F}^{\text{pae}}_{{\bm{\rho}}_{\ell}}:{\bf e}_{\text{cm}}(\vec{x})\mapsto{\bm{\rho}}_{\ell}(\vec{x})\in\mathbf{P}^{M_{\ell}}, (1) where \mathbf{P}^{K}\triangleq\{(r_{1},\dots,r_{K}):r_{k}\geq 0\;\sum_{k=1}^{K}r_{k}=1\} denotes a probability simplex. The L stacked (concatenated) attribute probability distributions, \bm{\mathrm{\rho}}(\bm{\mathrm{x}})\triangleq[\bm{\mathrm{\rho}}_{1}(\bm{\mathrm{x}}),\bm{\mathrm{\rho}}_{2}(\bm{\mathrm{x}}),\ldots,\bm{\mathrm{\rho}}_{L}(\bm{\mathrm{x}})]^{\mathsf{T}}\in\mathbf{P}^{M_{1}}\times\dots\times\mathbf{P}^{M_{L}}, (2) of dimensionality M=\sum_{\ell=1}^{L}M_{\ell} , will be referred to as the probabilistic attribute embedding of the utterance \bm{\mathrm{x}} . Labeled collections of these embeddings can then be treated like any generic features to train the back-end classifier for relevant downstream tasks. Compared to the original (raw) CM embedding, the dimensionality of the probabilistic attribute embedding is usually lower (i.e. M