Lagrangian split tori in S 2 × S 2 S^{2}\times S^{2} and billiards Joé Brendel, Joontae Kim Abstract . In this paper, we classify up to Hamiltonian isotopy Lagrangian tori that split as a product of circles in S 2 × S 2 S^{2}\times S^{2} , when the latter is equipped with a non-monotone split symplectic form. We show that this classification is equivalent to a problem of mathematical billiards in rectangles. We give many applications, among others: (1) answering a question on Lagrangian packing numbers raised by Polterovich–Shelukhin, (2) studying the topology of the space of Lagrangian tori, and (3) determining which split tori are images under symplectic ball embeddings of Chekanov or product tori in ℝ 4 \mathbb{R}^{4} . 1. Introduction 1.1. Main result The problem of classifying Lagrangian submanifolds up to symplectomorphism or up to Hamiltonian diffeomorphism is very difficult in dimensions greater than two, even in simple spaces. In this paper we restrict our attention to Lagrangian tori that split as a product of circles in S^{2}\times S^{2} equipped with the symplectic form (1) \omega_{\alpha}=2(\alpha+1)\omega_{S^{2}}\oplus 2\alpha\omega_{S^{2}},\text{ for }\alpha>0, where \omega_{S^{2}} is an area form with total area \int_{S^{2}}\omega_{S^{2}}=1 . We denote the resulting space by X_{\alpha}=(S^{2}\times S^{2},\omega_{\alpha}) . Note that up to swapping the factors and rescaling, every non-monotone symplectic form is diffeomorphic to \omega_{\alpha} for some \alpha>0 , see [ 24 ] . Remark 1.4 explains why we make this choice of normalization for the symplectic form. In S^{2}(a)=(S^{2},a\omega_{S^{2}}) , we denote by S^{1}_{h} , for h\in(-\frac{a}{2},\frac{a}{2}) , the circle of constant height such that the annulus bounded by the equator and S^{1}_{h} has (signed) symplectic area h . (x,y) \square_{\alpha} S^{1}_{x} S^{2}(2\alpha+2) x \times S^{1}_{y} S^{2}(2\alpha) y Figure 1 . A split torus T(x,y)\subset X_{\alpha} on the right-hand side and its base point in the rectangle \square_{\alpha}=[-\alpha-1,\alpha+1]\times[-\alpha,\alpha] on the left-hand side. The parameters x and y correspond to the signed areas between the respective circles and equators. Definition 1.1 . A split torus in X_{\alpha} is a torus of the form T(x,y)=S^{1}_{x}\times S^{1}_{y}\subset X_{\alpha} for (x,y)\in(-1-\alpha,1+\alpha)\times(-\alpha,\alpha)\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} . Every Lagrangian torus that splits as a product of circles is Hamiltonian isotopic to a split torus by Hamiltonian isotopies on the S^{2} -factors. Let (2) \square_{\alpha}=[-1-\alpha,1+\alpha]\times[-\alpha,\alpha]\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} for all \alpha>0 . Then the set of split tori in X_{\alpha} is in bijection with the interior \operatorname{int}\square_{\alpha} , and by abuse of terminology, we will refer to a split torus whose base point is in a subset A\subset\operatorname{int}\square_{\alpha} as torus in A . The main result of this paper is a classification of split tori in X_{\alpha} up to Hamiltonian diffeomorphism, which can be seen as studying the corresponding equivalence relation on points in \operatorname{int}\square_{\alpha} . The classification up to symplectomorphism is the same, since, by connectedness of \operatorname{Symp}(X_{\alpha}) - due to Abreu [ 1 ] - and simple connectedness of X_{\alpha} , the group of symplectomorphisms agrees with the group of Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms, \operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) . The analogous classification in the case of monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} was done in [ 7 , Proposition 5.1] . Throughout the paper we say that two Lagrangians L,L^{\prime} are equivalent if they are Hamiltonian isotopic, and we write L\cong L^{\prime} . If they are not Hamiltonian isotopic, we write L\not\cong L^{\prime} . The problem of classifying split tori in X_{\alpha} is equivalent to considering certain billiard trajectories in rectangles. Let (3) \Sigma=\{x=\pm(|y|+1)\}\cup[-1,1]\times\{0\}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2}. Given (x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2} , we view the set \square_{r(x,y)} as a billiard table, where r(x,y)=\max\{|x|-1,|y|\} . Note that (x,y)\in\partial\square_{r(x,y)} and that \partial\square_{r(x,y)}\cap\Sigma consists of the corners of \square_{r(x,y)} . See Figure 2 for a sketch. The reflection law for the billiards is the usual one, where the angle of reflection is equal to the angle of incidence. Definition 1.2 . Let (x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2} . If (x,y)\notin\Sigma , the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) is the unique billiard trajectory in \square_{r(x,y)} that (1) has incidence angle \frac{\pi}{4} with \partial\square_{r(x,y)} , (2) contains (x,y) as bouncing point, (3) is reflected backwards in the same direction when it hits a corner of the billiard table \partial\square_{r(x,y)} . In that case, we call a bouncing point of the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) admissible if it is not in \Sigma , i.e. if it is not a corner point of the corresponding billiard table. If (x,y)\in\Sigma we define the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) as stationary and call its unique bouncing point admissible . (x,y) \Sigma Q \square_{r(x,y)} \square_{\alpha} Figure 2 . A point (x,y)\in\square_{\alpha} , its billiard table \square_{r(x,y)} , part of its good billiard trajectory (dotted line), and corresponding bouncing points (black dots). The set \Sigma is indicated by dashed lines and the set Q as defined in ( 19 ) in grey. This terminology is chosen so that our results can be formulated in a unified way. See Figure 2 for a sketch of a good billiard trajectory. Note that good billiard trajectories can have very few admissible bouncing points, even if (x,y)\notin\Sigma . For example, the good billiard trajectory of (x,y)=(0,1) (in case \alpha>1 ) has a unique admissible bouncing point. Theorem 1.3 . Let T(x,y),T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\subset X_{\alpha} be split tori. Then T(x,y)\cong T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime}) if and only if the good billiard trajectory emanating from (x,y) has any of the points (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime}) as admissible bouncing point. This result is proved in Section 2 along with its refinement Theorem 2.5 . See § 1.4 -§ 1.7 for various applications of this theorem. Remark 1.4. Strikingly, this implies that the classification of split tori is independent of \alpha>0 . Indeed, let (x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2} and let \alpha,\alpha^{\prime}>r(x,y) . Since the statement of Theorem 1.3 depends on the billiard table \square_{r(x,y)} only, two split tori T(x,y),T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\subset X_{\alpha} are equivalent if and only if their counterparts T(x,y),T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\subset X_{\alpha^{\prime}} are equivalent. This is a by-product of the choice of symplectic form in ( 1 ) and explains this convention. Remark 1.5. For every \alpha>0 , there are Lagrangian tori in X_{\alpha} that cannot be mapped to a split torus by a symplectomorphism. This follows for example from [ 9 , Theorem C] . Therefore, this classification result concerns a strict subset of all Lagrangian tori in X_{\alpha} . Remark 1.6. Split tori can be viewed as toric fibres of the standard moment map on X_{\alpha} , which has \square_{\alpha} as image. For some \alpha>0 , certain even Hirzebruch surfaces yield other toric structures on X_{\alpha} , see for example [ 23 ] , and it is natural to ask for a classification of their toric fibres up to Hamiltonian diffeomorphism. Through the use of almost toric fibrations, these toric structures are all related by mutation, see [ 33 , §6.2] . Although this requires some additional work which is beyond the scope of the present paper, this approach proves that the set of toric fibres of even Hirzebruch surfaces coincides with the set of split tori up to Hamiltonian diffeomorphism 1 1 1 In the sense that for every toric fibre of an even Hirzebruch surface, there is a Hamiltonian diffeomorphism which maps it to a split torus. The mutation of the base diagram allows one to identify which split torus it is. . Therefore, our classification yields a classification of toric fibres in these alternative toric structures, too. Similarly, to achieve a classification of all toric fibres of odd Hirzebruch surfaces, it would be sufficient to classify toric fibres in the one-fold blow-up of \mathbb{C}P^{2} for all possible symplectic forms; see Question 7.1 . Remark 1.7. Recall the elementary fact that if the ratio of width and height of a rectangular billiard table is irrational, then the set of bouncing points of any good billiard trajectory is dense in the boundary of that billiard table. By Theorem 1.3 , this implies that there are sets of equivalent tori in X_{\alpha} which are dense in the boundary of certain rectangles in \square_{\alpha} . This will be used repeatedly in applications, for example to produce infinite packings by Lagrangian tori of X_{\alpha} and to exhibit various pathologies of the space of Lagrangian tori. 1.2. Hamiltonian monodromy A question closely related to the classification of split tori is determining their Hamiltonian monodromy group. Definition 1.8 . Let L\subset X be a Lagrangian in a symplectic manifold (X,\omega) . The group (4) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\{(\psi|_{L})_{*}\in\operatorname{Aut}(H_{1}(L))\,|\,\psi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X,\omega),\psi(L)=L\right\} is called the Hamiltonian monodromy group of L . The Hamiltonian monodromy group has been studied quite extensively, see [ 12 , 36 , 22 , 30 , 3 ] . For a thorough discussion of the existing results, we refer to the introduction of [ 3 ] . In [ 7 ] , the first named author has determined the Hamiltonian monodromy groups of all toric fibres in certain simple four-dimensional examples, such as monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} . This extends the earlier result by Ono [ 30 ] for the Clifford torus in monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} to non-monotone split tori. In this paper we study the Hamiltonian monodromy group of split tori in the spaces X_{\alpha} and determine it completely in many cases, though not in all. We find that, in a suitable basis of its first homology, every element in the Hamiltonian monodromy group of a split torus in X_{\alpha} is of the form (5) \begin{pmatrix}\pm 1&0\\ 2k&\pm 1\end{pmatrix} for some k\in\mathbb{Z} . The Hamiltonian monodromy group subtly depends on arithmetic properties of the base point (x,y) of L=T(x,y) , and many different isomorphism types of groups arise in this problem; for example \{1\} , \mathbb{Z}_{2} , but also infinite groups such as \mathbb{Z} and various semi-direct products of \mathbb{Z}_{2} with \mathbb{Z} . Let us point out that in the case of split tori in monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} , only finite groups appear. Our full result is somewhat cumbersome to state; see Theorem 3.5 for more details. 1.3. Methods of proof Split tori are toric fibres of the standard toric structure X_{\alpha}\rightarrow\square_{\alpha} and we make extensive use of toric geometry. In particular, based on [ 7 ] , we use symmetric probes to construct Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms realizing equivalences of fibres and given elements of the Hamiltonian monodromy group. Probes were introduced in [ 28 ] and symmetric probes in [ 2 ] for the purpose of displacing toric fibres. The obstructions are derived from Chekanov’s obstructions for product tori in \mathbb{R}^{2n} to be symplectomorphic via a lifting trick from toric geometry; see [ 7 , Section 4] . A key novelty in this paper is the use of properties of billiards to take care of the somewhat involved combinatorics arising in the context of non-monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} . A key insight is that, up to reflections (x,y)\mapsto(\pm x,\pm y) , only iterated symmetric probes realizing billiard trajectories are needed to complete the classification. In [ 7 ] , the first named author has conjectured that two toric fibres in a closed toric symplectic manifold are Hamiltonian isotopic if and only if there is a sequence of symmetric probes between them. Theorem 1.3 confirms this conjecture in the case of non-monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} . Corollary 1.9 . Conjecture 1.3 in [ 7 ] holds for S^{2}\times S^{2} equipped with a non-monotone split symplectic form. Similarly, we suspect that every non-trivial element in the Hamiltonian monodromy group of a split torus is generated by a sequence of symmetric probes starting and ending on the same split torus. Note however that for ( 55 ) and ( 58 ), Theorem 3.5 does not completely determine the monodromy group. Therefore this problem is still open for these cases. 1.4. Application: Space of Lagrangians Let L=T(x,y) with r(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} and (x,y)\notin\Sigma . Since the ratio of width to height of the corresponding billiard table \square_{r(x,y)} is irrational, there is a dense subset of points in \partial\square_{r(x,y)} such that the corresponding tori are Hamiltonian isotopic. Inspired by the recent work of Chassé–Leclercq [ 11 ] , we deduce the following two immediate consequences of Theorem 1.3 , which give counterexamples to Conjectures A and B in [ 11 ] in dimension four. Corollary 1.10 . In every X_{\alpha} , there is a split torus L\subset X_{\alpha} such that every Weinstein neighbourhood of L contains a (and thus infinitely many) split torus L^{\prime} with L\cong L^{\prime} and L\cap L^{\prime}=\varnothing . By the density of bouncing points in \partial\square_{r(x,y)} with r(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} , we can select a sequence of points which converges to a point not in the set of bouncing points to obtain the following. Corollary 1.11 . In every X_{\alpha} , there is a sequence of split tori L_{i}\subset X_{\alpha} which are mutually Hamiltonian isotopic, L_{i}\cong L_{j} , and which converge in the C^{\infty} -topology to a split torus L\subset X_{\alpha} with L\not\cong L_{i} . In particular, the orbit under \operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) of such a torus in the space of Lagrangians is neither C^{\infty} -closed, nor locally path connected. Both these phenomena occur in any symplectic manifold of dimension greater than or equal to six. As was proved in [ 11 ] , this follows from Chekanov’s classification [ 12 ] of product tori in \mathbb{R}^{2n} , see also [ 7 ] for a slightly different point of view. Remark 1.12. Note that the Lebesgue measure on \square_{\alpha}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} induces a natural measure on the set of split tori in X_{\alpha} . The subset of tori having the properties from the Corollaries 1.10 and 1.11 have full measure. Remark 1.13. As was pointed out to us by Felix Schlenk, one can also use [ 14 , Theorem 1.5] to produce results of this type in dimension four. Note however, that their methods work only for small tori contained in a Darboux chart, and, in the special case of X_{\alpha} , only for certain \alpha>0 . 1.5. Application: Lagrangian packing Definition 1.14 . Let L be a Lagrangian in a symplectic manifold (X,\omega) . The packing number of L is defined as (6) \#_{P}(L)=\sup\{N\in\mathbb{N}\,|\,\exists\,\phi_{1},\ldots,\phi_{N}\in\operatorname{Ham}(X,\omega),\,\phi_{i}(L)\cap\phi_{j}(L)=\varnothing,\,\forall i\neq j\}. The following remarkable result is due to Polterovich–Shelukhin, see [ 31 , Theorem C] . It uses ideas introduced by Mak–Smith [ 26 ] , who proved the non-displaceability of certain links of Lagrangian tori in X_{\alpha} by computing Floer homology in the symmetric product. Theorem 1.15 (Polterovich–Shelukhin) . Let \alpha>0 , L=T(x,0)\in X_{\alpha} and k\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 2} . Then (7) |x|<\frac{k-1}{k+1}\quad\Rightarrow\quad\#_{P}(L)\leqslant k. In § 5.1 , we give details on how to adapt [ 31 , Theorem C] to our notational conventions. For any |x|\in\left(\frac{k-2}{k},\frac{k-1}{k+1}\right) , the bound ( 7 ) is optimal for small enough \alpha>0 . Indeed, in that case, a k -packing can be realized by packing the first factor in X_{\alpha}=S^{2}\times S^{2} by k circles. Since \frac{k-1}{k+1}\rightarrow 1 for k\rightarrow+\infty , Theorem 1.15 implies that the packing number of every split torus T(x,0) with |x|<1 is finite. We show that this rigidity breaks down for |x|>1 , answering [ 31 , Question 18] and showing that, up to the critical case |x|=1 , which remains open, the results in [ 31 ] are sharp. Indeed, since distinct split tori are disjoint, Theorem 1.3 yields many interesting packings by split tori. In particular, we find \#_{P}(L)=\infty for split tori L=T(x,0) with x\in(1,1+\alpha)\setminus\mathbb{Q} . This is a special case of the following, which itself follows immediately from Theorem 1.3 and the fact that good billiard trajectories have infinitely many bouncing points whenever the ratio of width and height of the billiard table is irrational. Corollary 1.16 . Let L=T(x,y)\subset X_{\alpha} be a split torus with r(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} . Then (8) \#_{P}(L)=\infty. Note, again, that this shows that generic split tori have this property. As a consequence of Theorem 1.3 , we determine all packing numbers of X_{\alpha} by disjoint split tori , see Corollary 5.2 and Proposition 5.3 . This gives a lower bound on the actual Lagrangian packing number, which is optimal in some cases but not in others, see also the discussion in § 7.2 . Note that even in the case r(x,y)\in\mathbb{Q} , this lower bound tends to be much larger than what one would obtain by a naive packing of circles into one of the sphere factors. There are many open questions surrounding this set of ideas, see Questions 7.3 , 7.4 . 1.6. Application: Late Poincaré recurrence The Lagrangian Poincaré recurrence conjecture can be stated as follows. Conjecture 1.17 (Lagrangian Poincaré recurrence Conjecture) . Let \psi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X,\omega) and let L\subset(X,\omega) be a closed Lagrangian submanifold. Then there exists a sequence k_{i}\rightarrow\infty of natural numbers such that \psi^{k_{i}}(L)\cap L\neq\varnothing . Furthermore, the density of the sequence k_{i} is related to a symplectic capacity of L . We refer to [ 20 , Conjecture 5.6] , where the conjecture is attributed to Ginzburg and Viterbo independently. Recently, Broćić–Shelukhin [ 10 ] have found counterexamples to the LPR Conjecture in all symplectic manifolds of dimensions greater than or equal to six and Schmitz [ 32 ] in some symplectic manifolds of dimension four. None of these results apply to the case of S^{2}\times S^{2} . Using our methods, we prove a related but weaker result: For certain fixed split tori L\subset X_{\alpha} , we find Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms realizing arbitrarily large (but finite) return time. Proposition 1.18 . Let \alpha>0 and let L=T(x,y)\subset X_{\alpha} be a split torus with r(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} . For every N\in\mathbb{N} , there is \psi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) with (9) \psi^{k}(L)\cap L=\varnothing,\quad\text{for all }k\in\{1,\ldots,N\}. This follows straightforwardly from iterated symmetric probes, see the proof in Section 6 . With a bit more work, we can prove a stronger version. For \phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) and N\in\mathbb{N} , let (10) \mathcal{T}_{\phi,N}=\{(x,y)\in\operatorname{int}\square_{\alpha}\,|\,\phi^{k}(T(x,y))\cap T(x,y)=\varnothing,\,\forall k\in\{1,\ldots,N\}\}, i.e. this is the set of all split tori whose images under \phi are disjoint under the N -th iterates. We define a family \{\psi_{\delta}\}_{\delta>0}\subset\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) out of which one can pick an element making this set arbitrarily large for arbitrarily large N . By \lambda we denote Lebesgue measure on \square_{\alpha}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} with normalization \lambda(\square_{\alpha})=1 . Theorem 1.19 . For all \varepsilon>0 and N\in\mathbb{N} , there is \delta>0 such that (11) \lambda(\mathcal{T}_{\psi_{\delta},N})>1-\varepsilon. 1.7. Application: Lagrangian tori from symplectic ball embeddings For any Lagrangian torus L\subset X , one can ask whether L is the image of a Lagrangian torus under a symplectic ball embedding and, if so, which Hamiltonian isotopy type of torus in the ball it corresponds to. Definition 1.20 . We call a Lagrangian torus L\subset(X,\omega) ball-embeddable if there is a symplectic ball embedding \varphi\colon B^{2n}(r)\hookrightarrow X with L\subset\operatorname{im}\varphi . By B^{2n}(r)=\{x_{1}^{2}+y_{1}^{2}+\ldots+x_{n}^{2}+y_{n}^{2}\leqslant\pi r^{2}\}\subset(\mathbb{R}^{2n},\omega_{0}) , we denote the closed 2n -ball of capacity r . In dimension four, we consider three types of Lagrangian tori in \mathbb{R}^{4} , namely nonmonotone product tori , i.e. tori of the form \Theta(a_{1},a_{2})=S^{1}(a_{1})\times S^{1}(a_{2}) with a_{1}\neq a_{2} , Clifford tori , i.e. product tori of the form T_{\rm Cl}(a)=\Theta(a,a) , and Chekanov tori , T_{\rm Ch}(a) , for which we give a definition in Section 4 . Definition 1.21 . Let L\subset X^{4} be a ball-embeddable torus. We say that L is ball-Clifford if it is contained in the image of a symplectic ball embedding \varphi into X such that \varphi^{-1}(L)\subset\mathbb{R}^{4} is a Clifford torus. The terms ball-Chekanov and ball-nonmonotone are defined analogously. A priori, a ball-embeddable torus may be of none of these three types; or of several types simultaneously. In fact, we will see that the latter occurs in the case of X=X_{\alpha} . We first note the following. Theorem 1.22 . For every symplectic ball embedding \varphi\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} and a<\frac{r}{2} , we have (12) \varphi(T_{\rm{Ch}}(a))\cong T(\alpha-a-1,\alpha-a). In other words, ball-Chekanov tori in X_{\alpha} are not exotic . Note that this stands in contrast with the case of monotone S^{2}\times S^{2} , where ball-Chekanov tori are exotic, i.e. not Hamiltonian isotopic to a split torus. For the monotone Chekanov torus (though it is not ball embeddable), this was proved by Chekanov–Schlenk [ 13 ] . For the those non-monotone Chekanov tori that are ball-embeddable, this is a recent result by Lou [ 25 ] . Our main result about ball-embeddability is completely determining which split tori are ball-Clifford, which are ball-Chekanov and which are ball-nonmonotone. Theorem 1.23 . A split torus L=T(x,y)\subset X_{\alpha} is (1) ball-Clifford if and only if 2 2 2 Recall the definition of \Sigma from ( 3 ), see also Figure 2 . (x,y)\in\Sigma with y\neq 0 ; (2) ball-Chekanov if and only if (x,y)\notin\Sigma and the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) contains a corner of the billiard table \square_{r(x,y)} as bouncing point; (3) ball-nonmonotone if and only if (x,y) is contained in the complement of the set \Sigma\cup{\mathcal{D}} , where (13) {\mathcal{D}}=\left\{\left.\left(\frac{k-2l-1}{k},\pm\frac{1}{k}\right)\right|k\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 1},l\in\{0,\ldots,k-1\}\right\}. \square_{\alpha} Figure 3 . Illustration of Theorem 1.23 . The set of ball-Clifford split tori is indicated by dashed lines. The dots represent the second set in the union ( 13 ) i.e. the tori which are ball-Chekanov but not ball-nonmonotone. The central segment drawn by a solid line consists of the points which are of neither of the three types in Definition 1.21 . The set of ball-nonmonotone tori is the complement of the union of dashed lines, the central segment and the dots. The set of ball-Chekanov tori is dense in \square_{\alpha} and hence cannot be meaningfully represented. See Figure 3 for an illustration. The proof of Theorem 1.23 heavily relies on the fact that the space of symplectic ball embeddings into X_{\alpha} is connected, which goes back to McDuff [ 27 ] ; see also Lemma 4.1 . Theorem 1.23 has interesting consequences. First note that, among split tori, being ball-Chekanov and ball-Clifford are mutually exclusive. The same holds for ball-nonmonotone and ball-Clifford. However the sets of ball-Chekanov tori and ball-nonmonotone tori intersect non-trivially. More precisely, we find the following. Corollary 1.24 . Let \varphi\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} be a symplectic ball embedding and T_{\rm Ch}(a)\subset B^{4}(r) . There is a product torus \Theta(b,c)\subset B^{4}(r) with (14) \varphi(T_{\rm{Ch}}(a))\cong\varphi(\Theta(b,c)), if and only if a\notin\left\{\alpha-\frac{1}{k}\,|\,k\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 1}\right\} . In this case, the torus \Theta(b,c) is nonmonotone, i.e. b\neq c . Since the Chekanov torus is exotic in \mathbb{R}^{4} , an isotopy as in ( 14 ) cannot be supported in any extension of the symplectic ball embedding to a larger domain in \mathbb{R}^{4} . Hence any such Hamiltonian isotopy in X_{\alpha} has to intersect a divisor at infinity. Another consequence of Theorem 1.23 is that the split tori which are of neither of the three types in Definition 1.21 are exactly those over the central segment [-1,1]\times\{0\} ; see Figure 3 . We do not know, in general, if these tori are ball-embeddable or not. For a discussion of this and other open questions surrounding Lagrangian tori coming from ball embeddings, we refer to § 7.3 . 1.8. Structure of the paper The heart of this paper is Section 2 , where we review symmetric probes, introduce methods from billiards, and prove our main result, Theorem 1.3 . In Section 3 we explore the relationship between billiards and the Hamiltonian monodromy group of split tori, prove Theorem 3.5 and discuss why our methods are insufficient in some special cases. In Section 4 , we prove the results about ball-embeddable tori outlined in § 1.7 . In Section 5 , we prove the results in § 1.5 and in Section 6 , we prove the results in § 1.6 . Section 7 contains open questions surrounding our results and a discussion thereof. 2. Main theorem This section is dedicated to proving Theorem 1.3 and its refinement Theorem 2.5 . 2.1. Symmetric probes For the construction of equivalences of split tori, we make use of the standard toric structure X_{\alpha}\rightarrow\square_{\alpha} for which split tori appear as toric fibres. This allows us to use symmetric probes first used for the purpose of constructing Hamiltonian isotopies between fibres. Let us recall the basics of this technique for the reader’s convenience. For details, we refer to [ 7 ] . A symmetric probe \sigma\subset\Delta in the Delzant polytope arising as moment map image \Delta\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} of a toric symplectic manifold is a segment intersecting \partial\Delta integrally transversely in two points. Integral transversality means that \sigma has a rational direction and that its primitive directional vector can be completed to a basis of the lattice by vectors parallel to the facet the probe intersects. This condition implies that one can perform symplectic T^{n-1} -reduction by a subgroup of the toric action and obtain a smooth copy of S^{2} as quotient. Toric fibres corresponding to points lying on the symmetric probe map to circles in the reduced space, and Hamiltonian isotopies of these circles lift to Hamiltonian isotopies of the corresponding fibres. This yields [ 7 , Theorem A] . Theorem 2.1 . Let X be a toric symplectic manifold with moment polytope \Delta and \sigma\subset\Delta a symmetric probe. If p,q\in\sigma lie at equal distance to the boundary \partial\Delta , then T(p)\cong T(q) . Let us now discuss the case X=X_{\alpha} , where we have \Delta=\square_{\alpha}=[-\alpha-1,\alpha+1]\times[-\alpha,\alpha]\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} . The symmetric probes in \square_{\alpha} are easy to understand, see Figure 4 . Every line \ell with slope (1,0) or (0,1) that intersects \square_{\alpha} in its interior yields a symmetric probe. We call these probes horizontal and vertical , respectively. Every segment with slope (1,1) and (-1,1) which intersects \square_{\alpha} but none of its vertices yields a symmetric probe. The latter two types of probes will play a crucial role for us, as they generate Hamiltonian equivalences corresponding to billiards. Note that for small \alpha\in\mathbb{R}_{>0} , there are other symmetric probes, namely those of slope (k,-1) for k\in\mathbb{Z} , which intersect only horizontal edges of \square_{\alpha} . However, for |k|>2 these probes are redundant for the classification of toric fibres and determining their Hamiltonian monodromy group and will not be used in the paper. \sigma_{-1} \sigma_{0} \sigma_{1} \sigma_{2} \sigma_{3} \sigma \square_{\alpha} Figure 4 . Some examples and one non-example of symmetric probes in \square_{\alpha} . The segments \sigma_{k} have slope (k,-1) for k\in\{-1,0,1,2,3\} and \sigma has slope (1,0) . The dashed segment \sigma_{3} is not a symmetric probe, since its intersection with the the vertical edge is not integrally transverse. 2.2. Billiards Let \alpha>0 and let (x,y)\in\square_{\alpha} . Recall that we have set r(x,y)=\max\{|x|-1,|y|\} and that the billiard table corresponding to (x,y) is \square_{r(x,y)} equipped with the equal angles reflection law. In the corner of the billiard table, the trajectory is reflected backwards. The good billiard trajectory of (x,y) was defined in Definition 1.2 . Recall that a bouncing point of the good billiard trajectory of (x,y)\in\square_{\alpha} is called admissible if it does not coincide with a corner of the billiard table. In case (x,y)\in\Sigma , its good billiard trajectory is by definition stationary and has (x,y) as single bouncing point, which we call admissible. We introduce some further notation. For any k\in\mathbb{Z} let (x,y)_{(k)}\in\partial\square_{r(x,y)} be the k -th admissible bouncing point of the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) with (1) (x,y)_{(0)}=(x,y) , (2) The clockwise branch of the billiard trajectory starting at (x,y)_{(0)}=(x,y) corresponds to k\geqslant 0 , the counterclockwise branch to negative k\leqslant 0 . See also the right-hand side of Figure 5 . For all (x,y)\in\square_{\alpha} , let \displaystyle B(x,y) \displaystyle=\{\text{admissible bouncing points of the good billiard trajectory of }(x,y)\} \displaystyle=\{(x,y)_{(k)}\,|\,k\in\mathbb{Z}\}\subset\square_{r(x,y)}. The following proves the construction part of Theorem 1.3 . Lemma 2.2 . If some (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime})\in B(x,y) then T(x,y)\cong T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime}) . Furthermore, this equivalence can be realized by a sequence of symmetric probes. Proof. All maps of the form (x,y)\mapsto(\pm x,\pm y) can be realized by at most one horizontal and one vertical probe. If (x,y)\in\Sigma , there is nothing further to show, since (x,y)_{(k)}=(x,y) for all k . Let (x,y)\in\square_{\alpha}\setminus\Sigma . We restrict our attention to the case of k\geqslant 0 . The case k\leqslant 0 is similar. Let n>0 be the smallest index such that the good billiard trajectory has hit a corner of \partial\square_{r(x,y)} between (x,y) and (x,y)_{(n)} . If such an index does not exist, set n=+\infty . Let k0 , the folding map is defined as (15) F_{r}\colon\mathbb{R}^{2}\rightarrow\square_{r}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2},\quad(x,y)\mapsto((-1)^{m}(x-2m(r+1)),(-1)^{n}(y-2nr)), where (m,n)\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} is chosen such that F_{r}(x,y)\in\square_{r} . Although the pair (m,n)\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} is not unique whenever x=(2l+1)(1+r) or y=(2l+1)r , the map is still well-defined. For later use, we also define, for (m,n)\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} , the following maps (16) A^{r}_{m,n}\colon\mathbb{R}^{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{2},\quad(x,y)\mapsto((-1)^{m}x+2m(r+1),(-1)^{n}y+2nr). Note that (17) (F_{r}\circ A^{r}_{m,n})|_{\square_{\alpha}}=\operatorname{id}_{\square_{\alpha}}, for all m,n\in\mathbb{Z} . Under the folding map, the line l_{(x,y)}=\{(x,y)+t(1,1)\,|\,t\in\mathbb{R}\}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} is mapped to the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) in \square_{r} . The set of admissible bouncing points B(x,y) is given by (18) B(x,y)=F_{r}\left(l_{(x,y)}\cap F_{r}^{-1}(\partial\square_{r})\setminus F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r)\right). Note that F_{r}^{-1}(\partial\square_{r}) is the grid \{x=(2l_{1}+1)(1+r)\,|\,l_{1}\in\mathbb{Z}\}\cup\{y=(2l_{2}+1)r\,|\,l_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}\}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} and F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r) is the set of intersection points of the horizontal and vertical lines of that grid. These correspond to the corners of the billiard table, which is why we remove them. See Figure 5 for a sketch of the folding map. Note that ( 18 ) holds, although l_{(x,y)}\setminus F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r) may have several connected components (this happens exactly in case the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) hits a corner of \square_{r} ). Indeed, the images of different connected components of l_{(x,y)}\setminus F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r) under F_{r} coincide. For \alpha>0 , let (19) Q=\{(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\,|\,y>0,y>|x|-1\}, see also Figure 2 . It is enough to classify split tori in (Q\cup\Sigma)\cap\square_{\alpha}\subset\square_{\alpha} . Indeed, any split torus in the complement of this set is equivalent by a single symmetric probe to a split torus in Q . We thus restrict our attention to Q to simplify the statement of the following lemma. Without this restriction, there would be a distinction of cases in ( 20 ) according to which expression realizes the maximum r(x,y)=\max\{|x|-1,|y|\} . Lemma 2.4 . Let \alpha>0 and (x,y),(x^{\prime},y)\in Q . If there are k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} and \delta\in\{0,1\} with (20) x=(-1)^{\delta}x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y, then there are \delta_{1},\delta_{2}\in\{0,1\} such that ((-1)^{\delta_{1}}x^{\prime},(-1)^{\delta_{2}}y)\in B(x,y) . Note that if (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in\Sigma , then, for some choice of signs, we have (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime})\in B(x,y)=\{(x,y)\} . Proof of Lemma 2.4 . Since (x,y)\in Q , the billiard table is \square_{r} for r=y . We use the folding construction to prove the statement. In particular, recall from ( 18 ) that points in B(x,y) lift to intersection points of the grid F_{r}^{-1}(\partial\square_{r}) with l_{(x,y)} under the unfolding. Since (x,y),(x^{\prime},y) are not on the corner of \square_{r} , their lifts are not in F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r) . Furthermore, since (x,y),(x^{\prime},y)\in Q we can restrict our attention to intersection points of l_{(x,y)} with horizontal lines of the grid. These are given by the set (21) \{(x,y)+2kr(1,1)\,|\,k\in\mathbb{Z}\}. By Lemma 2.2 , the image F_{r}(x^{\prime\prime},y^{\prime\prime}) under the folding map of every (x^{\prime\prime},y^{\prime\prime})\in\mathbb{R}^{2} which is in the set ( 21 ) but not in F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r) satisfies T(x,y)\cong T(F_{r}(x^{\prime\prime},y^{\prime\prime})) by applying a billiard trajectory of symmetric probes. On the other hand, the set of points in \mathbb{R}^{2} which map to (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y) under the folding map is equal to (22) F_{r}^{-1}(\pm x^{\prime},\pm y)=\left\{A_{m,n}^{r}((-1)^{\delta_{1}}x^{\prime},(-1)^{\delta_{2}}y)\,|\,(m,n)\in\mathbb{Z}^{2},\delta_{1},\delta_{2}\in\{0,1\}\right\}, where we have used ( 17 ). Therefore, to prove the statement it is sufficient to prove that the intersection of the sets ( 21 ) and ( 22 ) is non-empty. A computation shows that setting m=k_{1} , k=n=k_{1}-k_{2} and taking \delta_{1},\delta_{2} such that \delta_{1}\equiv\delta+m\mod 2 and \delta_{2}\equiv n\mod 2 yields a point lying in both sets. \Box 2.3. Proof of main theorem Theorem 1.3 is a consequence of the following. Theorem 2.5 . Let \alpha>0 and let (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in Q\cup\Sigma , then the following are equivalent: (1) One of the points (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime}) is in the set B(x,y) of admissible bouncing points of the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) ; (2) The split tori T(x,y) and T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime}) are Hamiltonian isotopic; (3) If (x,y)\in\Sigma , then (x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in\Sigma and (x,y) is equal to some (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime}) . If (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in Q , then (23) y^{\prime}=y,\quad x=\pm x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y,\quad\text{for some }k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}. Lemma 2.2 shows (1) \Rightarrow (2) and Lemma 2.4 shows (3) \Rightarrow (1). To complete, we need to show (2) \Rightarrow (3), which is Lemma 2.7 . To prepare its proof, let us discuss some of its ingredients. We use obstructions from [ 7 ] , which apply to toric fibres in general compact toric manifolds. Let X be a compact toric symplectic manifold with moment polytope \Delta\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} and denote by \ell_{i}(p) for 1\leqslant i\leqslant N=\#\{\text{facets of }\Delta\} the integral affine distance of a point p\in\operatorname{int}\Delta to the i -th facet of \Delta . The following is [ 7 , Theorem B] . Theorem 2.6 . Let X be a compact toric symplectic manifold with moment polytope \Delta . If T(p)\cong T(q) for p,q\in\operatorname{int}\Delta , then (1) d(p)=d(q) , where d(p)=\min_{i}\{\ell_{i}(p)\} , (2) \#_{d}(p)=\#_{d}(q) , where \#_{d}(p)=\{i\,|\,\ell_{i}(p)=d(p)\} , (3) \Gamma(p)=\Gamma(q) , where \Gamma(p)=\mathbb{Z}\langle\ell_{1}(p)-d(p),\ldots,\ell_{N}(p)-d(p)\rangle\subset\mathbb{R} . Here, we denote by \mathbb{Z}\langle a_{1},\ldots,a_{n}\rangle\subset\mathbb{R} the subgroup of linear combinations with integer coefficients of a_{1},\ldots,a_{n}\in\mathbb{R} . These invariants are derived, via Delzant’s construction, from the invariants for product tori from [ 12 ] , which is why we call them Chekanov invariants . We refer to Sections 1.2 and 4.1 in [ 7 ] for a thorough discussion. Though these invariants are not complete, we will use the first and second Chekanov invariant in the proof of Lemma 2.7 . For \Delta=\square_{\alpha} , the functions \ell_{i} for i\in\{1,2,3,4\} are given by (24) \ell_{1}(x,y)=\alpha-y,\quad\ell_{2}(x,y)=1+\alpha-x,\quad\ell_{3}(x,y)=\alpha+y,\quad\ell_{4}(x,y)=1+\alpha+x. We also use [ 7 , Theorem 4.7] , which yields constraints on the map \phi_{*}\colon H_{2}(X,T(p))\rightarrow H_{2}(X,T(q)) induced on relative homology by \phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X) mapping a toric fibre T(p) to another toric fibre T(q) . We refer to [ 7 , Section 4.2] for details. Lemma 2.7 . Let \alpha>0 . If (x,y)\in\Sigma\subset\square_{\alpha} , and T(x,y)\cong T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime}) then (x,y)=(\pm x^{\prime},\pm y^{\prime}) . If (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in Q and T(x,y)\cong T(x^{\prime},y^{\prime}) then (25) y=y^{\prime}\text{ and }x=\pm x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y\text{ for some }k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}. Proof. Note that \Sigma\subset\square_{\alpha} is the subset where the second Chekanov invariant is strictly greater than one. In particular, split tori in \Sigma can only be equivalent to split tori in \Sigma , which allows us to treat this case separately. The only points having \#_{d}(x,y)=3 are (0,1) and (0,-1) , which proves the claim for these. Let (x,y) be any other point of \Sigma , then d(x,y)=\alpha-|y| and \#_{d}(x,y)=2 . In case |y|>0 , this allows us to conclude, since the first Chekanov invariant yields |y|=|y^{\prime}| and thus |x|=|x^{\prime}| . In case y=0 (this corresponds to the segment [-1,1]\times\{0\} ), we cannot yet conclude and it will be treated similarly to the case of (x,y)\in Q , see the end of the proof. Alternatively, it can be settled by appealing to [ 19 ] , as these product tori are distinguished by their displacement energy. Now let (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in Q . Then y=y^{\prime} follows from the first Chekanov invariant, d(x,y)=\alpha-y . The second Chekanov invariant is constant equal to one on Q and therefore of no further use. The third Chekanov invariant is not complete and we use [ 7 , Theorem 4.7] instead. Assume there is \phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) mapping L=T(x,y) to L^{\prime}=T(x^{\prime},y) . Then we have the following commutative diagram (26) {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{2}(X_{\alpha})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{1}(L)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{2}(X_{\alpha})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L^{\prime})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces H_{1}(L^{\prime})} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0.} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\operatorname{id}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\partial} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\phi_{*}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces(\phi|_{L})_{*}} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\partial^{\prime}} As the inclusion L\subset X_{\alpha} yields the zero map in homology, this diagram can be easily extracted from the long exact sequences on relative homology. On H_{2}(X_{\alpha}) the Hamiltonian diffeomorphism \phi induces the identity since \phi is isotopic to the identity. We use [ 7 , Theorem 4.7] to determine which isomorphisms H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L)\rightarrow H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L^{\prime}) can be induced by the Hamiltonian diffeomorphism \phi . Let D_{1},D_{2},D_{3},D_{4}\in H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L) be the classes defined by the obvious disks bounding the circles in the product S^{2}\times S^{2} , labelled such that D_{1} and D_{3} contain the north and south poles of the smaller sphere, respectively, and D_{2} and D_{4} the north and south poles of the larger sphere, respectively. This notation is coherent with the one used in [ 7 , Proposition 2.9] for the general toric case. All of the classes D_{i} are represented by topological disks of Maslov index 2 and have symplectic area equal to the integral affine distance of (x,y)\in\operatorname{int}\square_{\alpha} to the corresponding facet of \square_{\alpha} , i.e. \int_{D_{i}}\omega_{\alpha}=\ell_{i}(x,y) . In our case, we have, (27) \int_{D_{1}}\omega_{\alpha}=\alpha-y,\quad\int_{D_{2}}\omega_{\alpha}=1+\alpha-x,\quad\int_{D_{3}}\omega_{\alpha}=\alpha+y,\quad\int_{D_{4}}\omega_{\alpha}=1+\alpha+x. Similarly, we denote by D_{i}^{\prime} the corresponding classes in H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L^{\prime}) . Recall from [ 7 , Definition 4.6] that the set of distinguished classes {\mathcal{D}}(x,y)\subset H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L) is formed by the D_{i} for which the integral affine distance to the boundary \partial\square_{\alpha} is minimal. Since both base points are in Q , we have {\mathcal{D}}(x,y)=\{D_{1}\} and {\mathcal{D}}(x^{\prime},y)=\{D_{1}^{\prime}\} , meaning that \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{1}^{\prime} by [ 7 , Theorem 4.7] . Now set (28) \phi_{*}D_{2}=a_{1}D_{1}^{\prime}+a_{2}D_{2}^{\prime}+a_{3}D_{3}^{\prime}+a_{4}D_{4}^{\prime},\quad a_{i}\in\mathbb{Z}. The integers a_{i} determine \phi_{*} . Indeed, note that D_{1}+D_{3},D_{2}+D_{4}\in H_{2}(X_{\alpha}) and therefore \phi_{*}(D_{1}+D_{3})=D_{1}^{\prime}+D_{3}^{\prime} and \phi_{*}(D_{2}+D_{4})=D_{2}^{\prime}+D_{4}^{\prime} . We deduce that \phi_{*}D_{3}=D_{3}^{\prime} and \phi_{*}D_{4}=-a_{1}D_{1}^{\prime}+(1-a_{2})D_{2}^{\prime}-a_{3}D_{3}^{\prime}+(1-a_{4})D_{4}^{\prime} . Since \phi_{*} is an isomorphism, we obtain (29) \det\phi_{*}=a_{2}-a_{4}=\pm 1. Let us first treat the case \det\phi_{*}=+1 . Then a_{4}=a_{2}-1 . Since \phi_{*} preserves the Maslov class, ( 28 ) yields a_{3}=2-a_{1}-2a_{2} . Since it preserves the area class, we find \displaystyle 1+\alpha-x \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{D_{2}}\omega_{\alpha} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{\phi_{*}D_{2}}\omega_{\alpha} \displaystyle= \displaystyle a_{1}(\alpha-y)+a_{2}(1+\alpha-x^{\prime})+(2-a_{1}-2a_{2})(\alpha+y)+(a_{2}-1)(1+\alpha+x^{\prime}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle 2a_{2}+2(1-a_{1}-a_{2})y-1+\alpha-x^{\prime}, from which we deduce (30) x=x^{\prime}+2(1-a_{2})+2(a_{1}+a_{2}-1)y=x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y, for k_{1}=1-a_{2} and k_{2}=a_{1}+a_{2}-1 . In case \det\phi_{*}=-1 , an analoguous computation shows (31) x=-x^{\prime}-2a_{2}+2(a_{1}+a_{2})y=-x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y, for k_{1}=-a_{2} and k_{2}=a_{1}+a_{2} . This proves the statement for (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in Q . It remains to show the statement for (x,y),(x^{\prime},y^{\prime})\in[-1,1]\times\{0\} , in which case {\mathcal{D}}(x,0)=\{D_{1},D_{3}\} , and {\mathcal{D}}(x^{\prime},0)=\{D_{1}^{\prime},D_{3}^{\prime}\} . This means that either \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{1}^{\prime} or \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{3}^{\prime} . In the former case, the same computation as in the case of Q can be carried out. In the case \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{3}^{\prime} , a similar argument applies, up to a change in sign in ( 29 ). This means that in both cases we also obtain equations ( 30 ) and ( 31 ). Since y=0 in this case, this completes the proof. \Box 3. Hamiltonian monodromy The goal of this section is to discuss the Hamiltonian monodromy group of split tori in X_{\alpha} and prove our main result in that direction, Theorem 3.5 . 3.1. Preparations The Hamiltonian monodromy group is defined in ( 4 ). Note that it is a symplectic invariant up to conjugacy in the sense that for all \phi\in\operatorname{Symp}(X,\omega) , we have (32) {\mathcal{H}}_{\phi(L)}=(\phi|_{L})_{*}\circ{\mathcal{H}}_{L}\circ(\phi|_{L})_{*}^{-1}. Thus it is enough to determine {\mathcal{H}}_{L} for a representative of a Hamiltonian orbit in the space of split tori. Let \sigma\subset\square_{\alpha} be a symmetric probe with primitive directional vector v\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} intersecting facets defined by normal vectors \xi,\xi^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} . Here we choose \xi,\xi^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z}^{2} to be primitive and pointing into the interior of \square_{\alpha} with the convention that v points from the facet defined by \xi to the one defined by \xi^{\prime} . Let L,L^{\prime}\subset X_{\alpha} split tori lying on \sigma at equal distance to the boundary. By Theorem 2.1 , the symmetric probe induces a Hamiltonian diffeomorphism \phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) with \phi(L)=L^{\prime} . Via the toric group action, there is a natural way to identify H_{1}(L)\cong H_{1}(L^{\prime}) , which we will use tacitly from now on, and to interpret v\in H^{1}(L) and \xi,\xi^{\prime}\in H_{1}(L) . With this interpretation, the Hamiltonian diffeomorphism \phi induces the following map on the first homology, (33) (\phi|_{L})_{*}\colon H_{1}(L)\rightarrow H_{1}(L^{\prime}),\quad a\mapsto a+\langle v,a\rangle(\xi^{\prime}-\xi). For details, we refer to [ 7 , Section 3] , in particular to Theorem 3.2 and Figure 4 therein. In the remainder of this section, we express automorphisms of the first homology of split tori by two-by-two matrices expressed in the basis on H_{1}(L) induced by the Hamiltonian T^{2}=\mathbb{R}^{2}/\mathbb{Z}^{2} -action on X_{\alpha} via the moment map X_{\alpha}\rightarrow\square_{\alpha} . Up to choosing adequate orientations, this is the same basis as the natural one obtained from viewing a split torus T(x,y)=S^{1}_{x}\times S^{1}_{y}\subset S^{2}\times S^{2} as product of circles and taking as basis the elements S^{1}_{x}\times\{*\} and \{*\}\times S^{1}_{y} . Recall that, in this paper, we only use symmetric probes with directional vectors (1,0),(0,1),(1,1),(-1,1) and, by ( 33 ), these yield the six matrices (34) \begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ \pm 2&-1\end{pmatrix},\pm\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ 1&0\end{pmatrix} in the above basis. The first two matrices come from the horizontal and vertical probe, respectively. The following pair of matrices comes up in the case of symmetric probes (-1,1) and (1,1) having endpoints on two horizontal edges. The latter pair of matrices comes up in case the same symmetric probes have endpoints on one horizontal and one vertical edge. 3.2. Obstructions We prove the following upgrade of Lemma 2.7 . Lemma 3.1 . Let L=T(x,y) and L^{\prime}=T(x^{\prime},y) for (x,y),(x^{\prime},y)\in Q . If there is \phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) with \phi(L)=L^{\prime} then the map (\phi|_{L})_{*}\colon H_{1}(L)\rightarrow H_{1}(L^{\prime}) has the form (35) (\phi|_{L})_{*}=\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{\delta}&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix} for some \delta\in\{0,1\} and k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} satisfying (36) x=(-1)^{\delta}x^{\prime}+2k_{1}+2k_{2}y. Proof. This follows from the proof of Lemma 2.7 . Indeed, consider the map \phi_{*}\colon H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L)\rightarrow H_{2}(X_{\alpha},L^{\prime}) induced on relative second homology and let \phi_{*}D_{2}=\sum_{i}a_{i}D_{i}^{\prime} . Furthermore let \delta\in\{0,1\} such that \det\phi_{*}=(-1)^{\delta} . For \delta=0 , we obtain x=x^{\prime}+2(1-a_{2})+2(a_{1}+a_{2}-1)y as in ( 30 ). Setting k_{1}=1-a_{2} and k_{2}=a_{1}+a_{2}-1 and using \partial\circ\phi_{*}=(\phi|_{L})_{*}\circ\partial as in ( 26 ), we find (37) \begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}. The case \delta=1 is treated similarly using ( 31 ) and yields (38) \begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}. \Box Note that for \delta=1 , ( 35 ) yields an involution, whereas for \delta=0 , it yields an element of infinite order. 3.3. Hamiltonian monodromy and billiards Returning to the folding construction of billiards, we show the following refinement of Lemma 2.4 . Contrary to Lemma 2.2 and Lemma 2.4 , we cannot circumvent the fact that some trajectories hit corners of the billiard table, see Section 3.5 . Lemma 3.2 . Let 00 and thus 0\leqslant m=k_{1}\leqslant n=k_{1}-k_{2} , whence k_{2}\leqslant 0 . Here we have used m\leqslant n , which can be easily deduced from the folding picture of billiards. . Since the matrix of the first type is -\operatorname{id} , it commutes with every other matrix and we can write (45) (\chi|_{L})_{*}=(-\operatorname{id})^{k_{1}}\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ (-1)^{k_{2}}2k_{2}&(-1)^{k_{2}}\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{k_{1}}&0\\ (-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}}2k_{2}&(-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}}\end{pmatrix}, where the first factor in the product comes from applying the matrix of first type k_{1} times and the second factor from applying matrices of the second type -k_{2} times. To compute the matrix (\phi|_{L})_{*} , we post-compose \chi with swaps of the sphere factors to compensate for the signs in \chi(L)=T((-1)^{\delta_{1}}x^{\prime},(-1)^{\delta_{2}}y) . This yields (\phi|_{L})_{*}=\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{\delta_{1}}&0\\ 0&(-1)^{\delta_{2}}\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{k_{1}}&0\\ (-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}}2k_{2}&(-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}}\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{k_{1}+\delta_{1}}&0\\ (-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}+\delta_{2}}2k_{2}&(-1)^{k_{1}+k_{2}+\delta_{2}}\end{pmatrix}. By the above choices, we find k_{1}+\delta_{1}=m+\delta_{1}\equiv\delta\mod 2 and \delta_{2}\equiv n=k_{1}-k_{2}\equiv k_{1}+k_{2}\mod 2 and thus ( 40 ) follows. The case k_{1}-k_{2}<0 is proved similarly, since ( 45 ) holds in that case, too. \Box The condition that the billiard trajectory between (x,y) and (\pm x^{\prime},\pm y) does not hit a corner of the billiard table \square_{r} is difficult to get a handle on. For simplicity, we restrict our attention to the set of points whose billiard trajectory never hits a corner point. Definition 3.3 . By S_{r}\subset\partial\square_{r} we denote the set of points whose billiard trajectory eventually hits a corner. In the notation of Section 2.2 , (46) S_{r}=\left\{(x,y)\in\partial\square_{r}\,|\,l_{(x,y)}\cap F_{r}^{-1}(\pm(1+r),\pm r)\neq\varnothing\right\}. Together with Lemma 3.1 , Lemma 3.2 has the following immediate consequence. Corollary 3.4 . Let 01\} . We recall that the obstruction from Lemma 3.1 only holds for (x,y)\in Q , meaning there is no contradiction with the fact that the Hamiltonian monodromy group for some (x,y)\in\Sigma is larger. Theorem 3.5 . For (x,y)\in\Sigma the Hamiltonian monodromy group of L=T(x,y) is given by (49) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\left.\begin{pmatrix}\pm 1&0\\ 2k&\pm 1\end{pmatrix}\right|k\in\mathbb{Z}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}\ltimes\mathbb{Z}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}, if (x,y)=(0,0) , by (50) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\left.\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2k&\pm 1\end{pmatrix}\right|k\in\mathbb{Z}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}\ltimes\mathbb{Z}, if (x,y)\in\Sigma_{1} , by (51) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&\pm 1\end{pmatrix}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}. if (x,y)=(\pm 1,0) , and by (52) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ 1&0\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ 1&0\end{pmatrix}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}, if (x,y)\in\Sigma_{2} . For the remainder of the statement, let (x,y)\in Q . First, we treat the case where y is irrational. If furthermore x\notin\mathbb{Z}\langle 1,y\rangle , then the Hamiltonian monodromy group of L=T(x,y) is trivial, (53) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\{1\}. If on the other hand y is irrational and x\in\mathbb{Z}\langle 1,y\rangle , then let k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} be the unique pair with x=k_{1}+k_{2}y . We have (54) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}, if least one of the coefficients k_{1},k_{2} is even. If both k_{1},k_{2} are odd 4 4 4 This is the case where (x,y)\in S_{y} , see ( 48 ) in which the billiard construction fails. Therefore we only get an inclusion. , then (55) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}\subseteq\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2k_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle\cong\mathbb{Z}_{2}. Let y be rational and write y=\frac{p}{q} with q\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 1},p\in\mathbb{Z} coprime. If x\notin\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} , then (56) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2q&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\left.\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2kq&1\end{pmatrix}\right|k\in\mathbb{Z}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}. If x\in\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} , write x=\frac{p^{\prime}}{q} and p^{\prime}=m_{1}q+m_{2}p , where the pair m_{1},m_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} is chosen such that m_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geqslant 0} is minimal 5 5 5 Since p,q are coprime, such a pair m_{1},m_{2} exists. . Then the Hamiltonian monodromy group of L is (57) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}=\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2q&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2m_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\left.\begin{pmatrix}(-1)^{\delta}&0\\ 2(\delta m_{2}+kq)&1\end{pmatrix}\right|k\in\mathbb{Z},\delta\in\{0,1\}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}, if p^{\prime}\not\equiv p+q\mod 2 , and it satisfies (58) {\mathcal{H}}_{L}\subseteq\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2q&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2m_{2}&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle, if p^{\prime}\equiv p+q\mod 2 . Proof. We use the same notation as in the proof of Theorem 1.3 . First suppose (x,y)\in\Sigma_{2} . Then {\mathcal{D}}(x,y)=\{D_{1},D_{2}\} and the map \phi_{*}\in\operatorname{Aut}H_{2}(X_{\alpha},T(x,y)) either acts by the identity on {\mathcal{D}}(x,y) or permutes its elements by [ 7 , Theorem 4.7] . In the former case, the induced monodromy on H_{1}(T(x,y)) is the identity and in the latter, it is the swap of basis vectors e_{1}=\partial D_{2},e_{2}=\partial D_{1} . This proves the inclusion \subseteq in ( 52 ). To prove equality, consider the symmetric probe with direction vector (1,-1) passing through (x,y) together with ( 33 ). In the case (x,y)=(1,0) , we have {\mathcal{D}}(1,0)=\{D_{1},D_{2},D_{3}\} . Since \phi is a Hamiltonian diffeomorphism it preserves the element D_{1}+D_{3} which is in the image of the natural map H_{2}(X_{\alpha})\rightarrow H_{2}(X_{\alpha},T(1,0)) . Therefore the only admissible permutations of the elements in {\mathcal{D}}(1,0) are the identity and (D_{1},D_{2},D_{3})\mapsto(D_{3},D_{2},D_{1}) . The former induces the identity on H_{1}(T(x,y)) and the latter the map e_{1}\mapsto e_{1},e_{2}\mapsto-e_{2} , proving the inclusion \subseteq in ( 51 ). To prove equality, consider the vertical probe passing through (1,0) , or a lift to S^{2}\times S^{2} of an appropriate rotation of the second factor in S^{2}\times S^{2} . The case (x,y)=(-1,0) follows analogously. Let us now turn to the remaining case where (x,y)\in\Sigma_{1}\cup\{(0,0)\} , meaning we prove ( 50 ) and ( 49 ). Note that Lemma 3.1 does not apply, since (x,y)\notin Q . The difference with the case (x,y)\in Q is that now {\mathcal{D}}(x,y)=\{D_{1},D_{3}\} , but the idea of proof is the same. We first treat the case \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{1} , for which we obtain ( 35 ) by the same arguments. Since y=0 , the equation in ( 36 ) has no solution for \delta=1 , except if x=0 , which is precisely the case ( 49 ). Second, suppose that \phi_{*}D_{1}=D_{3} . Similar arguments as in the proof of Lemmata 2.7 and 3.1 yield the following cases. For \det\phi_{*}=+1 , we obtain (59) (\phi|_{L})_{*}=\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 2l_{2}&-1\end{pmatrix},\quad l_{1}+l_{2}y=x,\quad l_{1},l_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}, and for \det\phi_{*}=-1 , we obtain (60) (\phi|_{L})_{*}=\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ -2k_{2}&-1\end{pmatrix},\quad k_{1}+k_{2}y=0,\quad k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}. Again, in \Sigma_{1}\cup\{(0,0)\} , the second equation in ( 59 ) has no solution except if x=0 . This proves the inclusions \subseteq in equations ( 50 ) and ( 49 ). All of these monodromy matrices can be realized by noting that every (x,y)\in\Sigma_{1} lies on the midpoint of a vertical symmetric probe and a symmetric probe with directional vector (1,-1) . By ( 34 ), these probes yield the elements \begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\end{pmatrix}\text{ and }\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2&-1\end{pmatrix}, respectively. The point (0,0) additionally lies on the midpoint of a horizontal symmetric probe, yielding the additional generator \begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix}. Let (x,y)\in Q , meaning we can use Lemmata 3.1 , 3.2 and Corollary 3.4 with x^{\prime}=x . First let y\notin\mathbb{Q} . Then there is no non-trivial pair k_{1},k_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} which solves ( 36 ) with \delta=0 , meaning that there is no element with positive determinant in {\mathcal{H}}_{L} . For \delta=1 , ( 36 ) becomes x=k_{1}+k_{2}y , which has a solution only if x\in\mathbb{Z}\langle 1,y\rangle . This proves ( 53 ). Note that (x,y)\in S_{y}\cap Q if and only if x=l_{1}+l_{2}y for some l_{1},l_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} odd. Therefore, ( 54 ) follows from Corollary 3.4 . This also explains why we do not obtain equality in ( 55 ). Now let y=\frac{p}{q}\in\mathbb{Q} . Again, recall that (x,y)\in S_{y}\cap Q if and only if x=l_{1}+l_{2}y for some l_{1},l_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} odd. Note that in that case x\in\mathbb{Z}\langle 1,\frac{p}{q}\rangle=\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} . Let x\notin\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} . Then (x,y)\notin S_{y} . Furthermore, let \delta,k_{1},k_{2} be a triple satisfying ( 36 ) with x=x^{\prime} in Lemma 3.1 . Then \delta=0 because in the case \delta=1 , ( 36 ) yields qx=qk_{1}+pk_{2} which would imply x\in\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} . In the case \delta=0 , we find qk_{1}+pk_{2}=0 and thus (k_{1},k_{2})=k(-p,q) for some k\in\mathbb{Z} . This proves ( 56 ) by Corollary 3.4 . Let x=\frac{p^{\prime}}{q}\in\frac{1}{q}\mathbb{Z} for some p^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z} . Write p^{\prime}=m_{1}q+m_{2}p with m_{2}\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geqslant 0} minimal among all m_{2} for which there is m_{1}\in\mathbb{Z} solving this equation. Let \delta,k_{1},k_{2} be a triple satisfying ( 36 ) with x=x^{\prime} . As above, if \delta=0 , then k_{2}=kq for some k\in\mathbb{Z} . If \delta=1 , then we obtain the equation m_{1}q+m_{2}p=k_{1}q+k_{2}p from ( 36 ). Since p,q are coprime, this implies that k_{2}\equiv m_{2}\mod q , proving ( 58 ) and the inclusion \subseteq in ( 57 ). We now need to prove that (x,y)\in S_{y} if and only if p^{\prime}\equiv p+q\mod 2 . Recall from ( 48 ) that for (x,y)\in Q , we have (x,y)\in S_{y} if and only if there are l_{1},l_{2}\in\mathbb{Z} such that x=2l_{1}+1+(2l_{2}+1)y . Setting y=\frac{p}{q} and x=\frac{p^{\prime}}{q} , we find p^{\prime}=(2l_{1}+1)q+(2l_{2}+1)p . Since p,q are coprime there are l_{1},l_{2} satisfying the latter equation if and only if p^{\prime}\equiv p+q\mod 2 . This proves ( 57 ) and shows that we cannot improve the inclusion ( 58 ) by our methods. \Box 3.5. Cautionary example Let \alpha>1 and consider the torus L=T(0,1)\subset X_{\alpha} . The methods used in this paper are insufficient to determine the Hamiltonian monodromy group {\mathcal{H}}_{L}\subset\operatorname{Aut}H_{1}(L) , as we will discuss now. This illustrates that the hypothesis in Lemma 3.2 of the billiard trajectory not hitting any corners of the billiard table is necessary. In terms of obstructions, note that we are in the case of ( 58 ) of Theorem 3.5 with p=q=1 and p^{\prime}=m_{2}=0 and thus (61) {\mathcal{H}}_{T(0,1)}\subseteq\left\langle\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\ 2&1\end{pmatrix},\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix}\right\rangle=\left\{\begin{pmatrix}\pm 1&0\\ 2k&1\end{pmatrix}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}. Alternatively, this special case follows straightforwardly from Lemma 3.1 by noting that every pair \delta,k_{2} solves ( 36 ) with y=1 and x=x^{\prime}=0 by setting k_{1}=-k_{2} . The second generator e_{1}\mapsto-e_{1},e_{2}\mapsto e_{2} in ( 61 ) can be realized by a horizontal probe or lifting to S^{2}\times S^{2} an appropriate rotation of the first factor in S^{2}\times S^{2} , in which the circle factor of T(0,1) sits as the equator. We obtain (62) \mathbb{Z}_{2}\cong\left\{\begin{pmatrix}\pm 1&0\\ 0&1\end{pmatrix}\right\}\subseteq{\mathcal{H}}_{T(0,1)}\subseteq\left\{\begin{pmatrix}\pm 1&0\\ 2k&1\end{pmatrix}\right\}\cong\mathbb{Z}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}, which cannot be improved by the methods of this paper. Indeed, the only admissible symmetric probes containing (0,1) are horizontal and vertical. There are no symmetric probes with directional vectors (\pm 1,-1) , since both segments hit the vertices of \square_{1} . Equivalently, the good billiard trajectory of (0,1) has one single admissible bouncing point in the sense of Definition 1.2 . 4. Lagrangian tori from ball embeddings The main goal of this section is proving the results discussed in § 1.7 . We start by giving some background material on ball embeddings into X_{\alpha} in § 4.1 . Before proving Theorems 1.22 and 1.23 in § 4.3 and § 4.4 , respectively, we define and discuss the Chekanov torus in § 4.2 . 4.1. Ball embeddings into X_{\alpha} Recall that we consider symplectic embeddings \varphi\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} of the standard closed ball of capacity r into X_{\alpha} . By Gromov’s nonsqueezing theorem [ 21 ] , the Gromov width of X_{\alpha} is 2\alpha and hence such an embedding exists only if r<2\alpha . See also [ 5 , Section 5] . A crucial ingredient for the results of this section is the connectedness of the space of ball embeddings into X_{\alpha} , which goes back to McDuff [ 27 ] . The formulation we will use is as follows. Lemma 4.1 (McDuff) . Let \varphi,\varphi^{\prime}\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} be symplectic ball embeddings. Then there is \psi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) with \varphi^{\prime}=\psi\circ\varphi . This follows from [ 27 ] . Indeed, by the connectedness of the space of ball embeddings, there is a smooth family of ball embeddings interpolating between \varphi,\varphi^{\prime} . This isotopy can be extended to an isotopy of slightly larger balls, see for example [ 29 , Theorem 3.3.1] . Since the ball is simply connected, the symplectic vector field of the isotopy is induced by a globally defined Hamiltonian vector field obtained by performing a cut-off in the larger ball. By the connectedness of ball embeddings, we can use a reference ball embedding. Let (63) \varphi_{0}\colon\operatorname{int}B^{4}(2\alpha)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} be a T^{2} -equivariant symplectic embedding of the open ball at the lower left vertex of the moment map image \square_{\alpha} , see also the left-hand side of Figure 6 . Throughout the section, we will use its restrictions to smaller closed balls, \varphi_{0}\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} for all r<2\alpha as reference symplectic ball embeddings. By abuse of notation, we denote them by \varphi_{0} , as well. By equivariance, the embedding \varphi_{0} maps product tori \Theta(b,c)=S^{1}(b)\times S^{1}(c) in \mathbb{R}^{4} to split tori in X_{\alpha} . More precisely, for \varphi_{0}\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} , we find (64) \varphi_{0}(\Theta(b,c))=T(b-\alpha-1,c-\alpha) for all b,c>0 with b+c\leqslant r . Recall from Definition 1.21 that a Lagrangian torus L\subset X^{4} is called ball-Clifford , ball-Chekanov or ball-nonmonotone if it is the image of a Clifford , Chekanov or nonmonotone product torus in B^{4}(r)\subset\mathbb{R}^{4} under some ball embedding. Lemma 4.2 . For any Lagrangian torus L\subset X_{\alpha} we have that L is ball- \tau for \tau one of the types (Clifford, Chekanov or nonmonotone) if and only if there is a Lagrangian torus T\subset B^{4}(r) for some 00 . Since area preserving isotopies of \mathbb{C}^{\times} lift to Hamiltonian isotopies in \mathbb{C}^{2} , every closed curve isotopic to some S^{1}(a) lifts to a Lagrangian torus which is Hamiltonian isotopic to T_{\rm Cl}(a) . On the other hand, it turns out that any curve which is not isotopic to any S^{1}(a) in \mathbb{C}^{\times} lifts to a copy of the Chekanov torus. Definition 4.3 . For every a>0 , let \gamma_{a}\subset\mathbb{C}^{\times} be a curve bounding a topological disk of area a in \mathbb{C}^{\times} . Then we call its lift T_{\rm Ch}(a)=\pi_{0}^{-1}(\gamma_{a})\subset\mathbb{C}^{2} a Chekanov torus . This yields a monotone Lagrangian torus which is well-defined up to Hamiltonian isotopy. By choosing a suitable curve, one can show that the symplectic ball B^{4}(r) contains a representative of T_{\rm Ch}(a) for all a<\frac{r}{2} . In particular, given a symplectic ball embedding \varphi\colon B^{4}(r)\hookrightarrow X , we can consider the Lagrangian torus \varphi(T_{\rm Ch}(a))\subset X for every a<\frac{r}{2} . 4.3. Proof of Theorem 1.22 \varphi_{0}(\operatorname{int}B^{4}(2\alpha)) \square_{\alpha} \sigma \mu(p_{\rm sing}) s \gamma_{a} C(a) S^{2}(2\alpha) Figure 6 . The main idea of the proof of Theorem 1.22 . Symplectic S^{1} -reduction on \sigma yields the punctured spere on the right-hand side. Any Hamiltonian isotopy mapping \gamma_{a} to C(a) lifts to a Hamiltonian isotopy in X_{\alpha} which maps T_{\rm Ch}(a) to a split torus. Recall that r<2\alpha . By Lemma 4.1 , we can assume that \varphi=\varphi_{0} , where \varphi_{0} is the reference ball embedding ( 63 ). Let \mu=(\mu_{1},\mu_{2})\colon X_{\alpha}\rightarrow[-\alpha-1,\alpha+1] be the standard moment map on X_{\alpha} . The T^{2} -equivariance of \varphi_{0} translates to \varphi_{0}^{*}(\mu+(\alpha+1,\alpha))=(\pi|z_{1}|^{2},\pi|z_{2}|^{2}) , where the latter is the standard moment map on \mathbb{C}^{2} . In particular, the Hamiltonian G=\mu_{1}-\mu_{2}+1 on X_{\alpha} pulls back to H under \varphi_{0} . We perform symplectic reduction at G=0 . The level \{G=0\} contains one singular point, namely p_{\rm sing}=\mu^{-1}\{(-1-\alpha,-\alpha)\} and maps to the segment \sigma=\{x-y+1=0\}\cap\square_{\alpha} under \mu , see Figure 6 . Crucially, the S^{1} -action generated by G is free elsewhere and in particular on the fibre of \mu over the endpoint (\alpha-1,\alpha) of \sigma . This follows from the fact that \sigma intersects the corresponding edge integrally transversely at that point. We deduce that we can perform symplectic reduction on G^{-1}(0)\setminus\{p_{\rm sing}\} . The reduced space carries a residual Hamiltonian S^{1} -action induced by the T^{2} -action on X_{\alpha} and can be equivariantly identified with the punctured two-sphere S^{2}(2\alpha)\setminus\{s\} (where s\in S^{2} denotes the south pole) equipped with the standard area form of total area 2\alpha and the Hamiltonian S^{1} -action by rotation. Note that under this identification, the fibre \mu^{-1}(\alpha-1,\alpha) maps to the north pole of S^{2} . We denote the projection map by \pi\colon G^{-1}(0)\setminus\{p_{\rm sing}\}\rightarrow S^{2}(2\alpha)\setminus\{s\} . Since split tori are T^{2} -invariant, they project to the circles of constant height in S^{2}(2\alpha)\setminus\{s\} . For every 00\} . The claim for split tori which are not contained in Q follows from applying a symmetric probe mapping that point into Q . \Box Proof of Corollary 1.24 . By Theorem 1.22 , we have \varphi(T_{\rm Ch}(a))\cong T(\alpha-a-1,\alpha-a) . By Theorem 1.23 (1) and (3), there is a ball embedding \varphi^{\prime}\colon B^{4}(r^{\prime})\hookrightarrow X_{\alpha} and a product torus \Theta(b,c)\subset B^{4}(r^{\prime}) with \varphi^{\prime}(\Theta(b,c))=T(\alpha-a-1,\alpha-a) if and only if a\notin\left\{\alpha-\frac{1}{k}\,|\,k\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 1}\right\} . By Lemma 4.1 we find \varphi^{\prime}(\Theta(b,c))\cong\varphi(\Theta(b,c)) and thus the claim follows. \Box 5. Lagrangian packing In this section, we prove and discuss the results from § 1.5 . For the reader’s convenience, we start by proving that Theorem 1.15 is a reformulation of [ 31 , Theorem C] by adapting its statement to our notational conventions. 5.1. Discussion of Theorem 1.15 In [ 31 ] , S^{2}\times S^{2} is equipped with the symplectic form \omega_{S^{2}}\oplus 2a\omega_{S^{2}} for 0<2a<1 and the torus they consider is L=S^{1}(B)\times S^{1}_{\rm eq} , where S^{1}(B) is an embedded circle bounding a disk of area B>0 and S^{1}_{\rm eq} is the equator. For any k\in\mathbb{N}_{\geqslant 2} , it follows from [ 31 , §3.4-3.6] that \#_{P}(L)\leqslant k whenever (69) B-C>a,\quad\text{ where }\quad C=\frac{1-2B}{k-1}. Switching back to our notation, let \alpha>0 and T(x,0)\subset X_{\alpha} for x\in(-1,1) . By scaling the symplectic form \omega_{\alpha} of X_{\alpha} by a factor of \frac{1}{2(1+\alpha)} and substituting (70) a=\frac{\alpha}{2(1+\alpha)},\quad B=\frac{1}{2}-\frac{|x|}{2(1+\alpha)}, we see that ( 69 ) implies ( 7 ). 5.2. Packing by split tori Definition 5.1 . For (x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus\Sigma , let b(x,y)\in\mathbb{N}\cup\{\infty\} be the cardinality of the set of admissible bouncing points of the good billiard trajectory of at least one of the points (\pm x,\pm y) . Theorem 1.3 immediately implies the following. Corollary 5.2 . Let L=T(x,y)\subset X_{\alpha} be a split torus. Then, (71) b(x,y)=\#_{TP}(L)\leqslant\#_{P}(L). Here, \#_{TP}(L) denotes the packing number by disjoint split tori of X_{\alpha} . Note that it makes sense for general toric symplectic manifolds to ask what the packing number by disjoint toric fibres is, see the discussion surrounding Question 7.4 . Using the same notation as in § 3.4 , we can determine b(x,y) for all (x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2} . The distinction of cases follows a similar pattern as in Theorem 3.5 . Proposition 5.3 . Let L=T(x,y) by a split torus. If (x,y)\in\Sigma then (72) b(x,y)=\begin{cases}1&\text{if }(x,y)=(0,0),\\ 2&\text{if }(x,y)\in\Sigma_{1}\cup\{(\pm 1,0)\},\\ 4&\text{if }(x,y)\in\Sigma_{2}.\end{cases} If (x,y)\notin\Sigma , we suppose without loss of generality that (x,y)\in Q . In that case, if y\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} , then (73) b(x,y)=\infty. If y\in\mathbb{Q} , we write y=\frac{p}{q} for p,q coprime and have (74) b(x,y)=\begin{cases}4p+2q-4,&x=\frac{p^{\prime}}{q}\text{ for some }p^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z}\text{ with }p^{\prime}\equiv p+q\mod 2,\\ 4p+2q,&x=\frac{p^{\prime}}{q}\text{ for some }p^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z}\text{ with }p^{\prime}\not\equiv p+q\mod 2,\\ 8p+4q,&\text{else.}\end{cases} Proof. The cases in ( 72 ) are an immediate consequence of our definition of admissible bouncing points of a good billiard trajectory in the case (x,y)\in\Sigma , see Definition 1.2 . The case ( 73 ) follows from the elementary fact that good billiard trajectories on rectangular billiard tables are not periodic and thus have infinitely many bouncing points. Note that such a good billiard trajectory hits a corner of the billiard table at most once and hence always has infinitely many admissible bouncing points. Let us turn to the case ( 74 ). Recall from Theorem 2.5 that points (x,y),(x^{\prime},y)\in Q correspond to equivalent tori if and only if x^{\prime}\pm x\in\mathbb{Z}\langle 2,2y\rangle . Here, we have \mathbb{Z}\langle 2,2y\rangle=\frac{2}{q}\mathbb{Z} . This means that the orbit in Q\cap\square_{y} is generated by x\mapsto-x and translations by \frac{2}{q} . In other words, the segment [0,\frac{1}{q}] contains exactly one admissible bouncing point of every good billiard trajectory in \square_{y} . The endpoints 0 and \frac{1}{q} correspond to the first two cases in ( 74 ) depending on the parity of p+q and the points in the interior of [0,\frac{1}{q}] to the last case in ( 74 ). The perimeter of \square_{y} for y=\frac{p}{q} is 4\left(\frac{2p+q}{q}\right) , which implies the last equality in ( 74 ) by dividing by the length \frac{1}{q} of [0,\frac{1}{q}] . For the other two equalities we a priori take half of 4(2p+q) because the corresponding representatives in [0,\frac{1}{q}] are boundary points. Additionally, we need to take the case into account where the good billiard trajectory hits the corner points of the billiard table. By ( 48 ), as in the proof of Theorem 3.5 , this happens if and only if p^{\prime}\equiv p+q in which case we remove four bouncing points to obtain the count of admissible bouncing points. \Box U_{14} U_{12} U_{23} U_{34} U_{36} U_{16} U_{56} U_{45} U_{25} \square_{\alpha} U_{6} U_{4} U_{2} U_{3} U_{1} U_{5} S_{1}^{\delta} S_{2}^{\delta} S_{3}^{\delta} S_{4}^{\delta} Figure 7 . The subsets U_{i}\subset\square_{\alpha} with dashed boundaries and their intersections U_{ij} . Arrows indicate the direction of the billiard trajectories realized by \psi_{\delta} in the respective U_{i} . The cut-off region P_{\delta} is dark grey. 6. Late Lagrangian recurrence In this section, we provide proofs of Proposition 1.18 and Theorem 1.19 . Proof of Proposition 1.18 . Let L=L_{1},L_{2},L_{3},\ldots be the split tori which have as footpoints the admissible bouncing points of the good billiard trajectory of (x,y) with L=T(x,y) . Since r(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\mathbb{Q} , we can assume that L_{i}\neq L_{j} for i\neq j . Indeed, if the billiard trajectory hits a corner point of \square_{r} in one direction, then it does not hit one in the other direction. Now let N\in\mathbb{N} and define \psi\in\operatorname{Ham}(X_{\alpha}) as the Hamiltonian diffeomorphism obtained by concatenation of the first N-1 symmetric probes corresponding to that billiard trajectory with supports chosen small enough so that the supports of the Hamiltonians of probes intersect if and only if the probes intersect. Since the Hamiltonian diffeomorphism associated with the i -th probe swaps L_{i} and L_{i+1} , we obtain (75) \psi(L_{1})=L_{N},\quad\psi(L_{i})=L_{i-1}\quad\forall i\in\{2,\ldots,N\}. Since the L_{i} are pairwise disjoint, this proves the claim. \Box We now turn to the proof of Theorem 1.19 , which requires some preparations. Let \alpha>0,\delta>0 and define the following line segments in \square_{\alpha} \displaystyle S_{1}=\{y-x-1=0\}\cap\square_{\alpha},\quad S_{2}=\{y-x+1=0\}\cap\square_{\alpha}, \displaystyle S_{3}=\{y+x-1=0\}\cap\square_{\alpha},\quad S_{4}=\{y+x+1=0\}\cap\square_{\alpha}. For every i , denote by S_{i}^{\delta} the set of points in \square_{\alpha} which are at integral affine distance <\delta from S_{i} . The complement of S_{1}^{\delta}\cup S_{2}^{\delta} consists of three connected components which we denote by U_{5},U_{1},U_{3} from left to right. Similarly, we denote the three connected components of the complement of S_{3}^{\delta}\cup S_{4}^{\delta} by U_{6},U_{4},U_{2} from left to right. See also Figure 7 . For every i , let U_{i}^{\delta} be the set of points in \square_{\alpha} which are at integral affine distance <\delta from U_{i} . For every i\in\{1,\ldots,6\} , we define a Hamiltonian diffeomorphism \varphi_{i}^{\delta} which has support in \mu^{-1}(U_{i}^{\delta}) and which realizes a part of a billiard trajectory for all toric fibres in \mu^{-1}(U_{i}) . Heuristically, every \varphi_{i}^{\delta} comes from a certain symmetric probe which has been thickened to have as large a support as is permitted by \square_{\alpha} with a cut-off region of width \delta . For the reader’s convenience, we give an explicit definition of the \varphi_{i}^{\delta} . We introduce model spaces M_{1},M_{2} and Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms on them. Let M_{1}=Z\times S^{2} , where Z denotes the cylinder Z=\{(\theta,p)\in T^{*}S^{1}\,|\,-1k\,|\,M_{k^{\prime}}\neq M_{k}\}. We show that for all such k , the triple x_{k_{*}},x_{k},x_{k^{*}} of corresponding base points realizes a billiard bounce in \square_{\alpha} . Since the subsequences obtained for kk_{\rm fin} are constant, this proves that the full sequence \{M_{k}\} traces out a (forward or backward) billiard trajectory of L ; with possible repetitions of the form M_{k}=M_{k+1} . Since \{\psi^{k}_{\delta}(L)\}_{0\leqslant k\leqslant N} is a subsequence of \{M_{k}\} , this proves the claim. To prove that the triple x_{k_{*}},x_{k},x_{k^{*}} is obtained by performing a billiard bounce at x_{k} , note that x_{k} is contained in a unique U_{ij} . It follows that (82) M_{k}=\varphi^{\delta}_{i_{1}}(M_{k_{*}}),\quad M_{k^{*}}=\varphi^{\delta}_{i_{2}}(M_{k}). for some i_{1},i_{2}\in\{i,j\} with i_{1}\neq i_{2} . Indeed, by Proposition 6.2 every \varphi_{k}^{\delta} with k\notin\{i,j\} equals the identity on U_{ij} and therefore i_{1},i_{2}\in\{i,j\} . The claim i_{1}\neq i_{2} follows from the fact that the maps \varphi_{i}^{\delta} are applied cyclically and by increasing order of i . This implies that the sequence i_{k} in ( 79 ) is strictly increasing or strictly decreasing, where the former corresponds to the case i=i_{1}