Gamma-Ray Observations of Galaxy Clusters Strongly Constrain Dark Matter Annihilation in Prompt Cusps Milena Crnogorčević, M. Sten Delos, Nadia Kuritzén, Tim Linden Abstract Thermal dark matter models generically include the prompt creation of highly-concentrated dark matter cusps in the early Universe. Recent studies find that these cusps can survive to the present day, as long as they do not fall into extremely dense regions of baryonic structure. In this work, we build models of dark matter annihilation within the prompt cusps that reside in galaxy clusters, showing that they dominate the total γ \gamma -ray annihilation signal. Using 15 years of Fermi -LAT data, we find no evidence for a γ \gamma -ray excess from these sources, and set strong constraints on annihilating dark matter. These constraints generically rule out the thermal annihilation cross-section to the b ​ b ¯ b\bar{b} channel for dark matter masses below ∼ \sim 200 GeV. I Introduction In standard cosmological models, “prompt cusps” of high dark matter density may efficiently form during certain phases in the early Universe [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] — a finding recently supported by novel analytical calculations [ 13 , 14 ] . Intriguingly, studies indicate that these cusps, which follow a \rho_{\text{cusp}}\propto r^{-1.5} radial density profile, form almost instantaneously [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] and survive both halo growth [ 16 ] and clustering [ 18 , 19 ] . Although dense cusps represent only a small fraction of the total dark matter content of the Universe, their high densities lead them to dominate the dark matter annihilation signature in models where dark matter can annihilate [ 20 , 21 , 18 , 22 ] . Consequently, prompt cusps can greatly boost the flux of Standard Model particles, including photons, charged cosmic rays, and neutrinos, produced by dark matter annihilation, while also significantly altering the spatial distribution of this flux. In regions where prompt cusps drive the annihilation rate, the annihilation morphology tracks the number of prompt cusps, effectively tracing the dark matter density, \rho . This contrasts with typical annihilation signals, which scale with the square of dark matter density, \rho^{2} , and instead more closely resembles the signal expected from decaying dark matter. The similarity between annihilation in prompt cusps and dark matter decay motivates \gamma -ray observations of galaxy clusters. As the most massive structures in the Universe, galaxy clusters stand among the best targets for the indirect detection of dark matter decay [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 ] . Notably, galaxy cluster constraints on decaying dark matter can set lower-limits on the dark matter lifetime that exceed 10 27 s [ 29 ] . Figure 1: Upper limits on the dark matter annihilation cross-section to a b\bar{b} final state in the Virgo cluster. Our limits (magenta solid) rule out the thermal annihilation cross-section (black dashed) for dark matter masses below 200 GeV [ 30 ] , exceeding constraints from the stacking of dwarf spheroidal galaxies [ 31 ] (blue dashed) and from the IGRB [ 32 ] (orange dashed). These results are in tension with dark matter explanations for the Galactic Center Excess (green region) [ 33 ] . The light-shaded region indicates the excluded parameter space. Our analysis leverages the enhanced annihilation rate from prompt cusps to improve the sensitivity of \gamma -ray searches for dark matter. Most studies focus on \gamma -ray fluxes that scale with the square of dark matter density, favoring targets with high central densities, such as the Galactic Center [ 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 , 33 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 43 , 44 ] or dwarf spheroidal galaxies (dSphs) [ 45 , 46 , 47 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 , 52 , 53 , 54 , 55 , 56 , 57 , 31 , 58 , 59 ] . However, the annihilation rate from prompt cusps linearly depends on the total dark matter mass, elevating high mass targets ( e.g. , galaxy clusters or the isotropic \gamma -ray background (IGRB) [ 32 ] ), to the most promising candidates. In this paper , we search for dark matter signals in the prompt cusps in galaxy clusters. First, we construct new models for the dark matter flux and morphology from seven nearby clusters, including Virgo, Centaurus, NGC 4636, M 49, Fornax (NGC 1399), Hydra, and Coma, accounting for both the internal density structure and spatial distribution of prompt cusps. We then analyze 15 years of \gamma -ray data from the Fermi Large Area Telescope ( Fermi -LAT), finding no \gamma -ray excesses consistent with prompt cusp models. Figure 1 shows that observations of Virgo alone set a constraint on the dark matter annihilation cross section that is significantly stronger than previous limits from dSphs and the IGRB. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we characterize the annihilation signal from galaxy clusters, including the cosmological distribution of prompt cusps and the impact of tidal stripping. We then apply these models to specific clusters and compute the expected \gamma -ray flux. In Section III , we present our data analysis methodology and the statistical techniques employed to search for the \gamma -ray annihilation signal. We present our results in Section IV and compare our findings with existing constraints. Finally, we conclude in Section V . II Characterizing the annihilation signal The prompt cusps that dominate the annihilation signal form around redshift z\sim 30 [ 18 ] and later accrete onto the galaxy cluster halos that we target. Our calculation of cluster halo annihilation signatures thus proceeds in two parts. First, we describe the average distribution of prompt cusps within an arbitrary volume of dark matter. Next, we specialize to clusters, accounting for their spatial structure and the disruptive effects that occur therein. II.1 Cosmological distribution of prompt cusps Prompt cusps form from local maxima in the initial density field. Each of these density peaks has a collapse time a_{\mathrm{coll}} , which we estimate using the ellipsoidal collapse approximation in Ref. [ 60 ] , and a characteristic comoving size R\equiv|\delta/\nabla^{2}\delta|^{1/2} , where \delta is the height of the peak in the density contrast and \nabla^{2}\delta is the Laplacian of the density contrast with respect to the comoving position. Numerical simulations [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] show that a peak with these parameters collapses to form a power-law cusp with profile \rho=Ar^{-1.5} , where: \displaystyle A \displaystyle\simeq 24\bar{\rho}(a_{\mathrm{coll}})\,(a_{\mathrm{coll}}R)^{1.5}. (1) Here \bar{\rho}(a) is the cosmic mean dark matter density at the scale factor a . This profile initially extends out to the radius \displaystyle r_{\mathrm{cusp}} \displaystyle\simeq 0.11a_{\mathrm{coll}}R. (2) These prompt cusps grow halos around them over time, and the halos also contribute to dark matter annihilation. However, prior halo and subhalo modeling suggests that their contribution to the annihilation rate is only at about the 10 percent level [ 18 ] , so we neglect them. We will revisit this comparison in Section II.2 . Since the annihilation rate arising from a \rho\propto r^{-1.5} density cusp diverges at small radii, it is also important to understand the deep interior structure of a prompt cusp. Analytic arguments [ 16 ] (approximately confirmed in simulations [ 61 ] ) require that the initial thermal motion of the dark matter give rise to a finite-density core of radius \displaystyle r_{\mathrm{core}}\simeq 0.34G^{-2/3}(m_{\mathrm{DM}}/T_{\mathrm{d}})^{-2/3}\bar{\rho}(a_{\mathrm{d}})^{-4/9}A^{-2/9}, (3) where m_{\mathrm{DM}} is the dark matter particle mass, T_{\mathrm{d}} is the temperature at which the dark matter kinetically decouples from the Standard Model plasma, and \bar{\rho}(a_{\mathrm{d}}) is the dark matter density at the time of kinetic decoupling [ 18 ] . Note that typically r_{\mathrm{core}}\sim 10^{-3}r_{\mathrm{cusp}} . Assuming that the \rho=Ar^{-1.5} density profile transitions abruptly into a constant-density core at the radius r_{\mathrm{core}} , the annihilation rate from radii below r_{\mathrm{cusp}} is proportional to the quantity \displaystyle j\equiv\int_{\mathrm{cusp}}\rho^{2}\mathrm{d}V=4\pi A^{2}[1/3+\ln(r_{\mathrm{cusp}}/r_{\mathrm{core}})]. (4) More realistic models of the central core lead to a slightly higher annihilation rate [ 62 ] . The cosmological distribution of prompt cusps follows directly from the distribution of peaks in the initial density field, which is a well understood mathematical problem [ 63 ] . To describe the initial density field, we fix a dark matter power spectrum using the procedure described by Refs. [ 18 , 22 , 32 ] . We begin by evaluating the dark matter power spectrum at z=31 using class [ 64 ] with cosmological parameters from the Planck mission [ 65 ] , and we extrapolate it beyond the code’s numerical resolution limit using the analytic solution of Ref. [ 66 ] that is valid in the small-scale limit. The result is the spectrum of initial density variations for an idealized cold dark matter model, but in practice, the thermal motion of the dark matter suppresses inhomogeneities on smaller scales than the distances that particles randomly stream. The free-streaming scale depends on the dark matter model, namely its mass m_{\mathrm{DM}} and decoupling temperature T_{\mathrm{d}} (which is set by its elastic interactions with the Standard Model). We consider a range of models, and for each one, we evaluate the free-streaming wavenumber k_{\mathrm{fs}} according to Ref. [ 67 ] and scale the power spectrum by \mathrm{e}^{-k^{2}/k_{\mathrm{fs}}^{2}} . Prompt cusps arise from density perturbations with length scales of order k_{\mathrm{fs}}^{-1} . With the power spectrum set, we follow the approach of Ref. [ 18 ] to evaluate the statistics of initial peaks and to translate this into the cosmological abundance and distribution of prompt cusps. The procedure is to evaluate the comoving number density n_{\mathrm{peaks}} of initial peaks and to randomly sample the properties of 10^{7} of them. Any mass M of dark matter contains an average of Mn_{\mathrm{peaks}}/\bar{\rho}_{0} initial peaks, where \bar{\rho}_{0}\simeq 33 M ⊙ kpc -3 is the comoving dark matter density. If we associate each peak with a cusp that contributes some j to the annihilation rate, in accordance with Eq. ( 4 ), then these cusps would contribute in total \displaystyle\int_{\mathrm{cusps}}\rho^{2}\mathrm{d}V=Mn_{\mathrm{peaks}}\langle j\rangle/\bar{\rho}_{0}, (5) where angle brackets indicate the average. The average contribution of the prompt cusps per mass of dark matter is: \langle\rho_{\mathrm{eff}}\rangle_{0}\equiv\frac{\int_{\mathrm{cusps}}\rho^{2}\mathrm{d}V}{M}=n_{\mathrm{peaks}}\langle j\rangle/\bar{\rho}_{0}. (6) For a dark matter particle of mass m_{\mathrm{DM}} and velocity-weighted annihilation cross-section \langle\sigma v\rangle (which we assume to be velocity-independent at lowest order), the cusps would contribute an average annihilation rate \displaystyle\left\langle\frac{\Gamma}{M}\right\rangle_{\!0} \displaystyle=\frac{\langle\sigma v\rangle}{2m_{\mathrm{DM}}^{2}}\langle\rho_{\mathrm{eff}}\rangle_{0} (7) per mass of dark matter. So far, we have assumed that each initial peak can be associated with a prompt cusp with density profile given by Eqs ( 1 - 3 ), which is why we use the subscript ‘0’ in Eqs. ( 6 ) and ( 7 ). This assumption does not fully hold. Some initial peaks do not collapse to form prompt cusps because they accrete into previously formed structures first. Additionally, some of the prompt cusps that do form are destroyed in halo mergers. The approximate picture is that when a small halo accretes onto a much larger halo, the small halo persists as a subhalo, and the central cusps of both halos survive. On the other hand, when halos of comparable mass merge, dynamical friction causes their central cusps to also merge, and this process decreases the number of prompt cusps (and the inner structure of the central cusp of the larger halo is only slightly altered [ 16 ] ). Based on the simulations of Ref. [ 16 ] , Ref. [ 18 ] estimated that due to these effects, only about half of the initial density peaks produce prompt cusps that persist today. These surviving cusps contribute a fraction f_{\mathrm{surv}} of the annihilation signal predicted by Eq. ( 6 ), where f_{\mathrm{surv}}\simeq 0.5\pm 0.1 . We will adopt f_{\mathrm{surv}}=0.5 . II.2 Annihilation in galaxy clusters Now, we consider a cluster halo with density profile \rho(r) . Let \mathrm{d}N_{\gamma}/\mathrm{d}E be the spectrum of \gamma -ray photons produced by each dark matter annihilation event. The differential photon flux (per solid angle) received by an observer is then \displaystyle\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}\Phi}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\mathrm{d}E} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{4\pi}\frac{\mathrm{d}N_{\gamma}}{\mathrm{d}E}\int_{\text{l.o.s.}}\mathrm{d}\ell\,\rho(r)\left\langle\frac{\Gamma}{M}\right\rangle, (8) given in terms of the annihilation rate per mass of dark matter, \langle\Gamma/M\rangle . Here, \ell is the position along the observer’s line of sight, the cluster-centric radius r accordingly depends on \ell , and the line-of-sight integration is performed out to the virial radius of each cluster. We expand the annihilation rate as \displaystyle\left\langle\frac{\Gamma}{M}\right\rangle \displaystyle=\frac{\langle\sigma v\rangle}{2m_{\mathrm{DM}}^{2}}\left[\rho(r)+f_{\mathrm{surv}}f_{\mathrm{tidal}}(r)\langle\rho_{\mathrm{eff}}\rangle_{0}\right]. (9) The first term represents the smooth halo [ 68 ] , which contains almost all of the dark matter, as only about 1% resides in prompt cusps [ 18 ] . The second term accounts for the cusps and is constructed by scaling Eq. ( 7 ) by the cusp survival factor f_{\mathrm{surv}} and by a position-dependent factor f_{\mathrm{tidal}}(r) . Name RA, Dec (deg.) distance (Mpc) \rho_{s} (M ⊙ Mpc -3 ) r_{\mathrm{s}} (Mpc) R_{200} (Mpc) \theta_{200} M_{200} (M ⊙ ) J (GeV 2 cm -5 ) Virgo 187.70, 12.34 15.46 1.22\times 10^{15} 0.335 1.700 6.3^{\circ} 5.6\times 10^{14} 8.88\times 10^{20} NGC 4636 190.71, 2.69 17.18 1.64\times 10^{15} 0.135 0.777 2.6^{\circ} 5.3\times 10^{13} 6.85\times 10^{19} Hydra 139.53, -12.09 47.51 1.3\times 10^{15} 0.264 1.376 1.7^{\circ} 3.0\times 10^{14} 4.99\times 10^{19} Coma 194.95, 27.98 100.24 1.17\times 10^{15} 0.454 2.260 1.3^{\circ} 1.3\times 10^{15} 4.95\times 10^{19} M49 187.44, 8.00 18.91 1.68\times 10^{15} 0.127 0.741 2.2^{\circ} 4.6\times 10^{13} 4.88\times 10^{19} Centaurus 192.20, -41.31 43.16 1.33\times 10^{15} 0.239 1.258 1.7^{\circ} 2.3\times 10^{14} 4.61\times 10^{19} Fornax 54.62, -35.45 21.50 1.65\times 10^{15} 0.132 0.763 2.0^{\circ} 5.1\times 10^{13} 4.12\times 10^{19} Table 1: Clusters considered in our analysis and the properties that we adopt. For each cluster, we adopt a Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) density profile, \rho(r)=\rho_{\mathrm{s}}(r/r_{\mathrm{s}})^{-1}(1+r/r_{\mathrm{s}})^{-2} [ 69 , 70 ] , extending out to the virial radius R_{200} , which encloses mass M_{200} and corresponds to an angle \theta_{200} on the sky. Distances and structural parameters are drawn from Ref. [ 28 ] . We also show the integrated annihilation J factor calculated in accordance with Section II . J depends mildly on the dark matter mass and decoupling temperature; here we fix m_{\mathrm{DM}}=100 GeV and T_{\mathrm{d}}=30 MeV. Figure 2: Spatial extent of each cluster’s annihilation signal. For each angle \theta from the cluster center, we show the fractional contribution to the J factor that comes from angles less than \theta . Inside the halo of a galaxy cluster, prompt cusps are gradually stripped by tidal forces. To account for this effect, we employ the model of Ref. [ 71 ] , which uses the tidal field at a subhalo’s orbital pericenter to predict the density profile of its asymptotic remnant after an arbitrarily long period of tidal stripping. For cusps at a radius r within a cluster, we make a simple approximation that the pericenter radii r_{\mathrm{p}} are uniformly distributed between r_{\mathrm{p}}=0 and r_{\mathrm{p}}=r . Appendix A shows that this is a reasonable approximation. For each cusp sampled in Section II.1 , which had the initial annihilation rate coefficient j given by Eq. ( 4 ), we can evaluate a new coefficient j^{\prime}=\int\tilde{\rho}^{2}\mathrm{d}V associated with the cusp’s tidally evolved density profile \rho^{\prime} . We then define \displaystyle f_{\mathrm{tidal}}(r)=\langle j^{\prime}\rangle/\langle j\rangle, (10) where the brackets average over the pericenter radii r_{\mathrm{p}} 25, as well as all spectral parameters of catalog sources within 7^{\circ} of the RoI center and with TS > 500. The normalization parameters of the diffuse components (Galactic and isotropic) are also left free to vary. To reduce computation time and prevent instability in the fitting procedure, we disable energy dispersion corrections for these diffuse components. This is justified because energy dispersion effects for smooth, extended backgrounds typically result in negligible improvement in fit quality. For the cluster templates and point sources within the analysis region, energy dispersion remains enabled. We then perform a maximum likelihood fit using gta.fit() , which adjusts all the free parameters to best match the data. We extract signal or spectral upper limits using the SED likelihood procedure, gta.sed() . B.1 Dark Matter Analysis We convert the measured \gamma -ray flux limits to dark matter constraints using the expression in Eq. ( 15 ) and then, for each combination of dark matter mass and velocity-weighted annihilation cross-section, we calculate the TS in Eq. ( 16 ). We consider three annihilation channels ( b\bar{b} , \tau^{+}\tau^{-} , and W^{+}W^{-} ) using \gamma -ray spectra from PPPC4DM [ 101 ] with electroweak corrections enabled. TS Map DM Constraints SED Figure 7: Comprehensive analysis results for all seven galaxy clusters. Left column: Test statistic ( \sqrt{\text{TS}} ) maps showing no significant \gamma -ray excesses in any cluster region. The white cross marks each cluster’s dynamical center. Middle column: Dark matter annihilation cross-section constraints as a function of mass for the b\bar{b} channel, with contours showing 68%, 95%, and 99.7% confidence levels. White solid contours indicate the strongest exclusion regions. Right column: Spectral energy distributions showing flux upper limits (black arrows) and likelihood profiles (colored bands) across energy bins from 500 MeV to 500 GeV. The blue curve in Virgo, Fornax, and Coma panels shows the expected spectrum for the best-fit dark matter model. TS Map DM Constraints SED Figure 7 continued: B.2 Fermi -LAT results Figure 7 presents comprehensive Fermi -LAT analysis results for all seven galaxy clusters. All results shown here are computed using the fixed J -factor values listed in Table 1 (this is in contrast to our main results shown in Fig. 5 which account for the m_{\mathrm{DM}} -dependent J -factors shown in Fig. 3 ). We find no statistically significant \gamma -ray sources at cluster locations reported in Table 1 . The way to interpret Fig. 7 is as follows: • Left column (TS Maps): Test statistic ( \sqrt{\text{TS}} ) maps assess \gamma -ray emission significance across each cluster’s RoI. These maps assume a power-law spectral model with fixed photon index ( \Gamma=2.0 ) but free normalization, serving as a proxy for the strength of \gamma -ray emission at each spatial location covered by the DM annihilation map derived in Sec. II.1 . The white cross marks each cluster’s dynamical center, and the color scale indicates the square root of the TS, which approximates the detection significance in units of \sigma . Values above \sqrt{\text{TS}}\gtrsim 3 would indicate potential \gamma -ray sources warranting further investigation. • Middle column (DM Constraints): DM parameter space constraints show the TS as a function of dark matter mass ( m_{\text{DM}} ) and velocity-averaged annihilation cross-section ( \langle\sigma v\rangle ) in Eq. 16 , for the b\bar{b} annihilation channel, computed using each cluster’s specific J -factor from Table 1 . Here, TS follows a \chi^{2} distribution with 2 degrees of freedom (DM mass and velocity-weightet annihilation cross-section), and the contours indicate 68%, 95%, and 99.7% CL. White solid contours delineate the strongest exclusion regions for the assumed J -factor values. • Right column (SEDs): Spectral energy distributions display the differential \gamma -ray flux ( E^{2}\text{d}N/\text{d}E ) as a function of energy from 500 MeV to 500 GeV. Black arrows indicate 95% confidence ULs for energy bins where no significant emission is detected (TS \lesssim 9 ), while error bars show flux measurements with uncertainties for bins with modest evidence (TS \gtrsim 9 ). The pink colored likelihood bands represent \Delta\log\mathcal{L} profiles across energy, where TS (middle column) =-2\Delta\log\mathcal{L} , summed over all energy bins. For clusters showing elevated TS values, the blue curves indicate the best-fit DM annihilation spectra for the assumed J -factor and the b\bar{b} annihilation channel. B.3 Notes on individual clusters Virgo Cluster. The Virgo region contains multiple \gamma -ray components. M87 (4FGL J1230.2+1223) is an established point source with average flux F_{\gamma}\sim 1.6470\times 10^{-9} ph cm -2 s -1 ( 1~\text{GeV} 25 ( \sim 5 \sigma significance) and best-fit mass of \sim 441 GeV. These TS values are not necessarily consistent with a DM interpretation when considered collectively. Instead, they likely originate from known astrophysical processes [ 74 , 110 , 111 , 112 , 113 , 114 , 115 ] : Coma’s signal can correlate with its confirmed radio halo and diffuse emission. Notably, NGC 4636, Virgo, and M49 are all members of the Virgo supercluster, suggesting that any large-scale astrophysical processes affecting one system could extend to the others and provide a common origin for observed \gamma -ray activity. Critically, all putative DM signals from other clusters are excluded by the robust upper limits derived from Virgo—our best characterized system with the largest J -factor and proximity.