Leptogenesis in the presence of density perturbations Kenta Hotokezaka 1, Ryusuke Jinno 2, Rin Takada 1 Abstract We point out a new effect on the freeze-out process of heavy particles induced by density perturbations in the early universe, which we call “acoustically driven freeze-out.” This beyond-linear effect is caused by the exponential decoupling of heavy particles from the thermal bath in the presence of density perturbations, and already at moderately large values δ ​ T / T ¯ = 𝒪 ⁡ ( 10 − 2 ) \delta T/\bar{T}=\mathcal{O}(10^{-2}) it cannot be captured by linear perturbation theory. We illustrate this effect with leptogenesis taking the decay and inverse decay of heavy neutrinos into account, and discuss its phenomenological implications. We found that perturbations always enhance the (spatially averaged) values of the final lepton asymmetry, and as a result, constraints on the mass of heavy neutrinos are found to be relaxed in the presence of perturbations. Preprint: RESCEU-1/25 Preprint: KOBE-COSMO-25-01 I Introduction Inflation provides a successful explanation for the homogeneity, isotropy, and flatness of the universe [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] as well as the origin of the large-scale structure [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] . One of its characteristic predictions is that it generates density perturbations over different scales. While density perturbations are well constrained at large-scales from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) [ 10 ] and large-scale structure observations [ 11 ] , those at small scales are yet to be explored. These scalar fluctuations re-enter the Hubble horizon after inflation, driving acoustic oscillation of density and temperature. Out-of-equilibrium phenomena play central roles in the history of the universe. One of the prominent examples is the production of baryon asymmetry, which requires out-of-equilibrium interactions among the Sakharov’s three conditions [ 12 ] . Other examples include preheating after inflation [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] and freeze-out/freeze-in of dark matter [ 16 , 17 ] , as well as Standard Model (SM) processes such as big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) and recombination. Among these out-of-equilibrium processes, the effect we point out occurs when heavy particles decouple from the thermal bath. In the presence of temperature fluctuation \delta T , the Boltzmann factor for the equilibrium abundance of such particles with mass M is given by \displaystyle\exp(-E/T) \displaystyle=\exp[-E/(\bar{T}+\delta T)] \displaystyle=\exp(-E/\bar{T})\exp(E\delta T/\bar{T}^{2}). (1) When E\simeq M is much larger than \bar{T} , the exponent of the second factor in the right-hand side of equation ( 1 ) is not necessarily smaller than unity, invalidating truncation of the system at the first order in perturbation. The actual abundance of this particle species also closely follows this equilibrium value around the decoupling time, and hence the final abundance of this species itself or its decay product cannot also be predicted with truncation at the first order. Baryogenesis is one of the phenomena in which this beyond-linear effect can potentially play an important role, and in this paper we illustrate the effect with one the simplest baryogenesis scenarios. Leptogenesis [ 18 ] is among the most successful scenarios, in which the Sakharov’s three conditions are satisfied by the CP-violating decay of right-handed neutrinos together with the sphaleron process in the SM. These right-handed neutrinos naturally exist in the UV completion of the SM such as grand unification theories, and can also naturally explain the masses of light neutrinos through the seesaw mechanism [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . The masses, mixing angles, and CP phase(s) of these light neutrinos are being explored with solar, reactor, atmospheric and accelerator neutrino oscillation experiments (see e.g., Ref. [ 23 ] ), while their Dirac or Majorana nature may be determined in the current or future 0\nu\beta\beta decay experiments (see e.g., Ref. [ 24 ] ). Density perturbations at small scales, on the other hand, are gaining interest in view of gravitational-wave (GW) observations [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] . They give rise to multipole structures in the matter distribution, and for sufficiently large amplitude they produce secondary GWs [ 31 , 32 ] and lead to the formation of primordial black holes [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] . Part of the motivations of the current paper is re-assessing the effect of inhomogeneous universe on particle physics processes, demonstrating the interplay of micro- and macro-physics. In this perspective, we investigate the influence of density perturbations on the lepton and baryon asymmetries within the simplest leptogensis scenarios. As we see in the following, sound waves induce a sudden freeze-out of heavy particles, resulting in a net enhancement in the particle abundance after freeze-out even after spatial average. 1 1 1 The effects of density perturbations on baryon asymmetry is partially studied in Ref. [ 36 ] , where the authors consider perturbations of the same order of magnitude as CMB and find the effect to be negligibly small. The present analysis is different from theirs in that we calculate the spatial average of the resulting baryon asymmetry, which should be the relevant quantity for the observed baryon asymmetry. Another difference is that we consider relatively large density perturbations, which we will find to have a net effect on the final averaged baryon abundance. We call this process “acoustically driven freeze-out.” This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we derive the Boltzmann equations for the heavy neutrino N_{1} and for the baryon-minus-lepton number B-L , in the presence of density perturbations. We also review various parameters related to the neutrino masses. In Section III , we discuss the intuitive picture for the acoustically driven freeze-out, and then present the time evolution of the right-handed neutrino and B-L as well as the parameter space for successful baryogenesis. Finally in Section IV we discuss the implications of our results and present possible future directions. II Leptogenesis in the presence of cosmological perturbations II.1 Prerequisites for leptogenesis Leptogenesis [ 18 ] is a scenario in which the CP-violating decays of heavy right-handed neutrinos, together with the sphaleron process in the SM, generate the baryon asymmetry of the universe. In leptogenesis, the SM is extended with right-handed neutrinos with heavy Majorana masses that violate the lepton number. These right-handed neutrinos have Yukawa interactions with the Higgs and light leptons, whose complex phases give rise to CP violation. Their CP-violating decays produce lepton asymmetry, part of which is then converted into baryon asymmetry through the SM sphaleron process. The Majorana masses of the right-handed neutrinos at the same time explain the observed light masses for left-handed neutrinos via the seesaw mechanism. Leptogenesis scenarios can be classified into two classes: thermal and non-thermal (see, e.g., [ 37 , 38 ] ). The former assumes thermal abundance for the right-handed neutrinos as one of the initial conditions, while in the latter the right-handed neutrinos are produced via various non-thermal processes. One of the attractive features of the former class is its robust predictivity: the number of free parameters is significantly smaller, thereby allowing for more robust experimental predictions. For this reason we focus on thermal leptogenesis in this paper. We consider a simple model so-called vanilla leptogenesis, in which heavy right-handed neutrinos N_{1} , N_{2} , and N_{3} with masses in the order M_{1}m_{\ast} and \tilde{m}_{1}m_{2}^{2}-m_{1}^{2} or m_{3}^{2}-m_{2}^{2}0 , and that it increases monotonically for 0\leqslant|\mathcal{R}_{i}|\lesssim 0.3 . Figures with other values of \bar{z}_{H} are shown in Appendix A . III.3 Parameter regions for successful leptogenesis Figure 4: Allowed regions for successful leptogenesis. The normal hierarchy and zero initial abundance for N_{N_{1}} are assumed. The curves show (\tilde{m}_{1},M_{1}) where \eta_{b}^{\rm max}=(\eta^{\rm CMB}_{b})_{\rm low}=6.0\times 10^{-10} is satisfied for \overline{m}=(0.051,\,0.078,\,0.15,\,0.19)\,{\rm eV} . For a given \overline{m} , the region above the curves is the one for successful leptogenesis. The blue and orange curves represent the case with and without temperature fluctuations \delta_{T} , respectively. The primordial curvature perturbation is taken to be |\mathcal{R}_{i}|=0.2 . We can see that the allowed region in (\tilde{m}_{1},M_{1}) is expanded by the effect of \delta_{T} . The solid lines correspond to m_{1}=0 such that \overline{m}=\overline{m}_{\rm min}=0.051\,{\rm eV} . The dash-dot lines are for \overline{m}=0.078\,{\rm eV} , corresponding to the upper limit from CMB and BAO observations [ 11 ] . The dashed lines are for \overline{m}=0.15\,{\rm eV} , corresponding to the upper limit from CMB alone [ 10 ] . The dot-dot-dashed lines correspond to \overline{m}=0.19\,{\rm eV} . If scatterings are included, the upper boundary appears, and the allowed region would disappear for \overline{m}>0.19\,{\rm eV} [ 46 ] . Figure 4 shows the parameter regions for successful leptogenesis on the (\tilde{m}_{1},M_{1}) plane. For a given value of \bar{m} , there are two curves with (blue) and without (orange) density fluctuations. The primordial curvature perturbation is taken to be |\mathcal{R}_{i}|=0.2 . In the region above each curve, the produced amount of baryons exceeds the lower limit given by the CMB data ( 40 ). In the previous subsection, we considered the case of K=100 , 1 , and 0.01 corresponding to \tilde{m}_{1}\simeq 0.1 , 10^{-3} , and 10^{-5}\,{\rm eV} , respectively. While the contours are not closed in this plot, it is known that upper limits on M_{1} arise once \Delta L=2 scatterings are taken into account (see e.g., Ref. [ 37 ] ). The reason we do not take account of these scatterings is simply to illustrate the effect of acoustically driven freeze-out in the simplest setup (see also discussion in Section IV ). In the case of m_{1}=0 , the absolute mass ( 42 ) takes its minimum value \overline{m}=0.051\,{\rm eV} . The resulting constraint is shown in the solid lines. In the weak washout regime \tilde{m}_{1}\lesssim 10^{-3}\,{\rm eV} , the constraint with temperature fluctuations is almost identical to the one without temperature fluctuations. In the strong washout regime \tilde{m}_{1}\gtrsim 10^{-3}\,{\rm eV} , the allowed region with fluctuations gets slightly extended from that without fluctuations due to the enhancement by the acoustically driven freeze-out. The allowed parameter space shrinks as \overline{m} increases, as discussed in Ref. [ 46 ] . For instance, in the case of \overline{m}=0.078\,{\rm eV} , the region for \tilde{m}_{1}\gtrsim 0.03\,{\rm eV} is ruled out as shown in the dot-dashed lines. As in the case of \bar{m}=0.051\,{\rm eV} , including fluctuations enlarges the allowed region. Similar behavior is observed for \overline{m}=0.15\,{\rm eV} (dashed lines) and \overline{m}_{\rm max}=0.19\,{\rm eV} (dot-dot-dashed lines). We thus conclude that the beyond-linear effect can enlarge the parameter space for successful leptogenesis if the amplitudes of primordial density fluctuations are sufficiently large. The effect of perturbations is important in the strong washout regime 8.7\times 10^{-3}\,{\rm eV}\lesssim\tilde{m}_{1}\lesssim 5.0\times 10^{-2}\,{\rm eV}. (55) The dependence on the primordial curvature perturbation |\mathcal{R}_{i}| can be inferred from Figure 3 . Note that the neutrino oscillation experiments suggest that the masses of light neutrinos likely lie in this range, see equation ( 45 ). In the future, as neutrinoless double beta decay experiments such as CANDLES [ 48 ] , CUORE [ 49 ] , EXO [ 50 ] , KamLAND-Zen [ 51 ] , LEGEND [ 52 ] , NEMO-3 and SuperNEMO [ 53 , 54 ] (see also Ref. [ 24 ] and references therein) achieve better sensitivities, not only will the upper limits on the mass eigenvalues of the light neutrinos improve, but the absolute mass scale \overline{m} may finally be determined. If the determined mass scale falls within the ballpark of \overline{m}\gtrsim 0.1\,{\rm eV} , the effect discussed in the present paper turns out to be relevant, as seen from Figure 4 . IV Discussion and conclusions In this paper, we studied the effect of primordial density fluctuations on the freeze-out of heavy particles. Primordial density fluctuations within the Hubble horizon propagate as sound waves during the freeze-out of these particles. Sound waves cause temperature oscillation at each spatial point, driving oscillation in the abundance of massive particles with respect to radiation. Using leptogenesis as an illustrative framework, we have derived the governing equations that describe the evolution of these heavy particles in the presence of fluctuations, and found that the exponential dependence of the abundance of heavy particles on the local temperature causes a beyond-linear effect in the system, see equations ( 51 ) and ( 52 ). As a proof of concept, we applied the formulation to the scenario of vanilla leptogenesis and demonstrated how temperature fluctuations affect the abundance of the right-handed neutrino and the resulting B-L asymmetry. We indeed observed oscillations in the equilibrium abundance of the right-handed neutrino N_{1} and in the baryon-minus-lepton number N_{B-L} (Figure 2 ). Interestingly, the density fluctuations always increase the final baryon-to-photon ratio compared to the case without fluctuations, even after taking spatial average (Figure 3 ). This suggests that the effect of oscillations cannot be captured within linear perturbation. Qualitatively, the equilibrium value of the right-handed neutrino is governed by the Boltzmann factor \exp(-E/T)\simeq\exp(-E/\bar{T})\exp(E\delta T/\bar{T}^{2}) , and the fast temperature oscillation makes it harder for the non-equilibrium abundance of N_{1} to follow this equilibrium value. If the temperature oscillation occurs with the right phase, the freeze-out of N_{1} is dominantly driven by the oscillation, not by the slow decrease in the average temperature, and the resulting |N_{B-L}| is enhanced (top panel of Figure 3 , around \bar{z}\simeq 15 ). We call this effect “acoustically driven freeze-out”. Of course, each spatial point has its own oscillation phase, and thus the enhancement in |N_{B-L}| does not occur uniformly. However, the exponential enhancement of |N_{B-L}| in some regions cannot be fully canceled out by the contributions from other regions. As a result, we get a net enhancement of the baryon asymmetry even after spatial average. From the consideration above, the allowed parameter space for leptogenesis gets enlarged in the presence of fluctuations. We presented the allowed regions \eta_{b}\geq(\eta^{\rm CMB}_{b})_{\rm low} in the (\tilde{m}_{1},M_{1}) plane for a given absolute neutrino mass scale \overline{m}=\sqrt{m_{1}^{2}+m_{2}^{2}+m_{3}^{2}} (Figure 4 ). The effective neutrino mass \tilde{m}_{1} is linearly proportional to the decay parameter K and thus characterizes the weak and strong washout regimes (Figure 4 , \tilde{m}\lesssim 10^{-3}\,{\rm eV} and \tilde{m}\gtrsim 10^{-3}\,{\rm eV} , respectively). When temperature fluctuations are included, we indeed found an enlarged allowed regions. The difference arises mainly in the strong washout regime, because in the weak washout regime the actual N_{1} abundance is almost unaffected by its oscillating equilibrium value (bottom panel of Figure 3 ). While the quantitative difference is not dramatically large, given that the neutrino oscillation experiments point toward the strong washout regime [ 47 ] , our findings will be relevant when we find relatively large \bar{m} from cosmological observations [ 11 , 10 ] . We conclude by mentioning several possible future directions. For the microphysics side, we took only decay and inverse decay into account in this study. However, it is well known that \Delta L=2 scattering imposes an ( \overline{m} -dependent) upper bound on M_{1} and thus closes the allowed region in the (M_{1},\tilde{m}_{1}) plane [ 46 ] . Such scattering processes will not bring qualitative changes in the behavior of acoustically driven freeze-out since they do not affect the oscillating equilibrium abundance itself, which is the main reason for the net enhancement in the asymmetry. Nevertheless, identifying the allowed parameter space including all the known microphysical effect will be important in preparing for future precision measurements. For the macrophysics side, in this paper we injected monochromatic sound waves for simplicity. In reality, however, fluctuations are a superposition of waves with various wavenumbers characterized by the power spectrum of the primordial curvature perturbation. Thus the effect of fluctuations on freeze-out will ultimately be described by the power spectrum, and it would be interesting to construct analytical formulations for it. In addition, it has been pointed that the sound waves can evolve to shock waves in the long run [ 55 ] . Shock waves by definition have discontinuities in thermodynamic parameters and hence are expected to enhance the sudden freeze-out of heavy particles. Incorporating all these aspects will be important and interesting future steps, to which we will come back elsewhere. Acknowledgements. The work of K.H. is supported by the JST FOREST Program (JPMJFR2136) and the JSPS Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (20H05639, 20H00158, 23H01169, 23H04900). The work of R.J. is supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers 23K17687, 23K19048, and 24K07013. Appendix A Time evolution for different values of \bar{z}_{H} In this Appendix, we plot the time evolution of N_{1} and B-L , the freeze-out values of B-L , and their dependence on |\mathcal{R}_{i}| for \bar{z}_{H}=0.5 and 2 . Figures 5 and 6 show the time evolution of N_{1} and B-L , Figures 7 and 8 show the freeze-out values of B-L , and Figures 9 and 10 show the dependence on |\mathcal{R}_{i}| for \bar{z}_{H}=0.5 and 2 . These figures correspond to Figures 1 – 3 in the main text, in which \bar{z}_{H}=1 is adopted. Figure 5: Time evolution of N_{N_{1}} and |N_{B-L}| . Parameter values are the same as Figure 1 except for \bar{z}_{H}=0.5 . Figure 6: Time evolution of N_{N_{1}} and |N_{B-L}| . Parameter values are the same as Figure 1 except for \bar{z}_{H}=2 . Figure 7: Freeze-out value of |N_{B-L}| for different values of \delta . Parameter values are the same as Figure 2 except for \bar{z}_{H}=0.5 . Figure 8: Freeze-out value of |N_{B-L}| for different values of \delta . Parameter values are the same as Figure 2 except for \bar{z}_{H}=2 . Figure 9: Ratio between the spatially averaged freeze-out value \langle|N_{B-L}^{\rm f}|\rangle_{\rm space} with and without perturbations. Parameter values are the same as Figure 3 except for \bar{z}_{H}=0.5 . Figure 10: Ratio between the spatially averaged freeze-out value \langle|N_{B-L}^{\rm f}|\rangle_{\rm space} with and without perturbations. Parameter values are the same as Figure 3 except for \bar{z}_{H}=2 . Appendix B Derivation of the Boltzmann equation B.1 The Boltzmann equation We begin with the Boltzmann equation [ 45 ] : \dfrac{df}{d\lambda}=C[f]\quad\Rightarrow\quad P^{0}\dfrac{df}{d\eta}=C[f], (56) where f is the distribution function, \lambda is the affine parameter, C[f] is the collision term, and P^{0} is the zeroth component of the energy-momentum 4-vector P^{\mu} . We integrate the former equation using the integral measure in momentum space defined as \pi=g_{\rm deg}\dfrac{d^{3}p}{E}, (57) where g_{\rm deg} represents the internal degrees of freedom of the species, and E and p^{i} are the energy and 3-momentum of the particle evaluated in the local inertial frame, respectively. B.2 Equivalence of integral measures The integral measure ( 57 ) evaluated in an arbitrary coordinate system is given by [ 45 ] \pi\equiv g_{\rm deg}\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}\,d^{3}P}{P_{0}}=g_{\rm deg}\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P^{0}\sqrt{-g}}. (58) To check this, note that the relation between the 4-momenta evaluated in the general coordinate system and in the local inertial system is P^{\mu}={e^{\mu}}_{\nu^{\prime}}p^{\nu^{\prime}}, (59) where {e^{\mu}}_{\nu^{\prime}} is the tetrad, and p^{0}=-p_{0}=E is the instantaneous energy of the particle with respect to the local observer. The tetrad satisfies {e^{\mu}}_{\alpha^{\prime}}{e^{\nu}}_{\beta^{\prime}}g_{\mu\nu}=\eta_{\alpha^{\prime}\beta^{\prime}} . Using ( 59 ) and E\;dE=p_{j}\;dp^{j} , we may rewrite dP as \displaystyle dP^{i} \displaystyle={e^{i}}_{0}\dfrac{\partial p^{0}}{\partial p^{j}}\;dp^{j}+{e^{i}}_{k}\dfrac{\partial p^{k}}{\partial p^{j}}\;dp^{j} \displaystyle={e^{i}}_{0}\dfrac{p_{j}}{E}\;dp^{j}+{e^{i}}_{j}\;dp^{j}=\left({e^{i}}_{0}\dfrac{p_{j}}{E}+{e^{i}}_{j}\right)dp^{j}. (60) Substituting this into dP in ( 58 ) and using P_{0}=g_{0\mu}{e^{\mu}}_{\nu^{\prime}}p^{\nu^{\prime}}=\eta_{\nu^{\prime}\sigma^{\prime}}{(e^{-1})^{\sigma^{\prime}}}_{0}p^{\nu^{\prime}}, (61) the integral measure indeed reduces to \pi=g_{\rm deg}\dfrac{d^{3}p}{E}. (62) B.3 Equivalence of ( 17 ) and the integral of ( 56 ) In this subsection we show the equivalence of equation ( 17 ) and the integral of ( 56 ) following Ref. [ 56 ] . The momentum integral of the Boltzmann equation ( 56 ) is \dfrac{g_{\rm deg}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}\;d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\;\dfrac{df}{d\lambda}=\dfrac{g_{\rm deg}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p}{E}\;C[f], (63) where we used the equivalence of the integral measures ( 58 ) and ( 62 ). We aim to show that this equation is equivalent to equation ( 17 ). For this purpose it is sufficient to consider the collisionless Boltzmann equation, since the collision terms are already identical. Let f denote the distribution function, and consider \dfrac{df}{d\lambda}=\dfrac{dx^{\mu}}{d\lambda}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial x^{\mu}}+\dfrac{dP^{i}}{d\lambda}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial P^{i}}=0, (64) that is P^{\mu}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial x^{\mu}}-{\Gamma^{i}}_{\mu\nu}P^{\mu}P^{\nu}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial P^{i}}=0. (65) Integrating both sides of equation ( 65 ) with the integral measure (\sqrt{-g}^{2}/P_{0})\;d^{3}P\;d^{4}x gives \displaystyle\int\left(P^{\mu}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial x^{\mu}}-{\Gamma^{i}}_{\mu\nu}P^{\mu}P^{\nu}\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial P^{i}}\right)\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}^{2}}{P_{0}}\;d^{3}P\;d^{4}x \displaystyle=\int\dfrac{\partial}{\partial x^{\mu}}\left(P^{\mu}f\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}^{2}}{P_{0}}\right)\;d^{3}P\;d^{4}x \displaystyle\quad-\int\dfrac{\partial}{\partial P^{i}}\left({\Gamma^{i}}_{\mu\nu}P^{\mu}P^{\nu}f\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}^{2}}{P_{0}}\right)\;d^{3}P\;d^{4}x=0. (66) The second line of equation ( 66 ) can be rewritten as \displaystyle\int\dfrac{\partial}{\partial x^{\mu}}\left(P^{\mu}f\dfrac{\sqrt{-g}^{2}}{P_{0}}\right)\;d^{3}P\;d^{4}x \displaystyle=\int\biggl[\dfrac{\partial}{\partial x^{\mu}}\left(\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\right) \displaystyle\hskip 30.00005pt+{\Gamma^{\kappa}}_{\mu\kappa}\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\biggr]\sqrt{-g}\;d^{4}x \displaystyle=\int\left(\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\right)_{;\mu}\sqrt{-g}\;d^{4}x, (67) where we used \displaystyle{A^{\mu}}_{;\mu} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\partial A^{\mu}}{\partial x^{\mu}}+{\Gamma^{\mu}}_{\mu\sigma}A^{\sigma} (68) \displaystyle=\dfrac{\partial A^{\mu}}{\partial x^{\mu}}+\dfrac{\partial\ln\sqrt{-g}}{\partial x^{\mu}}A^{\mu}=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{-g}}\dfrac{\partial(\sqrt{-g}\,A^{\mu})}{\partial x^{\mu}}, (69) which follows from {\Gamma^{\nu}}_{\mu\nu}=\dfrac{1}{2}g^{\nu\sigma}\dfrac{\partial g_{\nu\sigma}}{\partial x^{\mu}}=\dfrac{\partial\ln\sqrt{-g}}{\partial x^{\mu}}. (70) Also, the left-hand side in the third line of equation ( 66 ) vanishes because the volume integral in momentum space can be rewritten as a surface term at infinity where the distribution function f approaches zero. Thus, equation ( 66 ) can be simplified as \int\left(\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\right)_{;\mu}\sqrt{-g}\;d^{4}x=0. (71) Since this holds for any integral over spacetime, the integrand must vanish. Thus we get \left(\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}\right)_{;\mu}=0. (72) On the other hand, number density current \mathcal{N}^{\mu}=nU^{\mu} is defined as \mathcal{N}^{\mu}\equiv\dfrac{g_{\rm deg}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int P^{\mu}f\sqrt{-g}\;\dfrac{d^{3}P}{P_{0}}, (73) and hence the momentum integral of the collisionless Boltzmann equation ( 64 ) becomes {\mathcal{N}^{\mu}}_{;\mu}=0. (74) In other words, the left-hand side of equation ( 63 ) can be replaced with {\mathcal{N}^{\mu}}_{;\mu} , which yields the Boltzmann equation in the form of equation ( 17 ). B.4 Calculation of the covariant derivative of the number density current In this subsection we calculate equation ( 18 ) in detail. In the following we omit the index N_{1} in n_{N_{1}} . By using equation ( 19 ) and formulas in Appendix C , \displaystyle(nU^{\mu})_{;\mu} \displaystyle=(nU^{\mu})_{,\mu}+{\Gamma^{\mu}}_{\mu\nu}(nU^{\nu}) \displaystyle=(nU^{0})_{,0}+{\Gamma^{0}}_{0\nu}(nU^{\nu})+(nU^{i})_{,i}+{\Gamma^{i}}_{i\nu}(nU^{i}) \displaystyle=\left[\dfrac{n}{a}(1-A)\right]^{\prime}+{\Gamma^{0}}_{00}(nU^{0})+{\Gamma^{0}}_{0i}(nU^{i}) \displaystyle\quad+\left(\dfrac{n}{a}v^{i}\right)_{,i}+{\Gamma^{i}}_{i0}(nU^{0})+{\Gamma^{i}}_{ij}(nU^{j}) \displaystyle=\dfrac{n^{\prime}}{a}(1-A)-\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a^{2}}n(1-A)-\dfrac{n}{a}A^{\prime} \displaystyle\quad+\left(\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}+A^{\prime}\right)\dfrac{n}{a}(1-A)-\left(A_{,i}-\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}B_{,i}\right)\dfrac{n}{a}v^{i}+\dfrac{n}{a}{v^{i}}_{,i} \displaystyle\quad+\left[\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}{\delta^{i}}_{i}+C^{\prime}{\delta^{i}}_{i}+\left({E^{,i}}_{,i}-\dfrac{1}{3}{\delta^{i}}_{i}\nabla^{2}E\right)^{\prime}\right]\dfrac{n}{a}(1-A) \displaystyle\quad+(\mbox{1st-order})\times(\mbox{1st-order}). (75) Dropping the terms of second or higher order in perturbations, \displaystyle(nU^{\mu})_{;\mu} \displaystyle\simeq\dfrac{n^{\prime}}{a}(1-A)-\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a^{2}}n(1-A)-\dfrac{n}{a}A^{\prime} \displaystyle\hskip 45.00006pt\,+\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}\dfrac{n}{a}(1-A)+A^{\prime}\dfrac{n}{a}+2\dfrac{n}{a}{v^{i}}_{,i} \displaystyle\hskip 45.00006pt\,+3\left(\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}+C^{\prime}\right)\dfrac{n}{a}-3\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}A\dfrac{n}{a} \displaystyle=\dfrac{n^{\prime}}{a}(1-A)+\dfrac{n}{a}{v^{i}}_{,i}+3\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}\dfrac{n}{a}+3C^{\prime}\dfrac{n}{a}-3\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}A\dfrac{n}{a} \displaystyle=(1-A)\biggl(a^{-1}n^{\prime}+3\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a^{2}}n\biggr)+\dfrac{n}{a}({v^{i}}_{,i}+3C^{\prime}) \displaystyle=\bar{z}H(1-A)\biggl(\dfrac{dn}{d\bar{z}}+\dfrac{3}{\bar{z}}n\biggr)+\dfrac{n}{a}({v^{i}}_{,i}+3C^{\prime}), (76) is obtained. Here we used \displaystyle\dfrac{d}{d\eta} \displaystyle=a\dfrac{d}{dt}=a\bar{z}H\dfrac{d}{d\bar{z}}, (77) that follows from entropy conservation. B.5 Calculation of the collision term In this subsection we calculate equation ( 20 ) in detail. The distribution function of right-handed neutrinos, defined with the normalization constant \mathcal{C} , is given by f_{N_{1}}=\mathcal{C}\exp\left[-\dfrac{(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2}-\mu_{N_{1}}}{\bar{T}+\delta T}\right]. (78) By integrating this equation over the entire momentum space, we obtain the particle number density \displaystyle n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z}) \displaystyle=\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}\mathcal{C}}{2\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dp_{N_{1}}\;p_{N_{1}}^{2} \displaystyle\quad\times\exp\left[-\dfrac{(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2}-\mu_{N_{1}}}{\bar{T}+\delta T}\right]. (79) Changing the variable to p_{N_{1}}=M_{1}\sinh\theta on the right-hand side, and introducing z_{T}(\bar{z})=\bar{z}/(1+\delta_{T}) , the integral reduces to \displaystyle n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})=\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}\mathcal{C}}{8\pi^{2}}M_{1}^{3}\int_{0}^{\infty}d\theta\;(\cosh 3\theta-\cosh\theta)\,\mathrm{e}^{-z_{T}\cosh\theta}. (80) Here note that the modified Bessel function of the second kind K_{\nu} is given by the integral K_{\nu}(z)=\int_{0}^{\infty}d\theta\;\cosh(\nu\theta)\,\mathrm{e}^{-z\cosh\theta}, (81) from which follows K_{\nu+1}(z)-K_{\nu-1}(z)=\dfrac{2\nu}{z}K_{\nu}(z). (82) Then the normalization constant is determined to be \mathcal{C}=\dfrac{2\pi^{2}z_{T}}{g_{N_{1}}M_{1}^{3}K_{2}(z_{T})}\,n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})\,\mathrm{e}^{-\mu_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}, (83) and the distribution function of right-handed neutrinos becomes f_{N_{1}}=\dfrac{2\pi^{2}z_{T}n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})}{g_{N_{1}}M_{1}^{3}K_{2}(z_{T})}\exp\left[-\dfrac{(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2}}{\bar{T}+\delta T}\right], (84) which rewrite as f_{N_{1}}=\mathcal{C}^{\prime}n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)} . On the other hand, assuming that lepton l and Higgs \phi are in thermal equilibrium and denoting their distribution functions by f_{l}^{\rm eq} and f_{\phi}^{\rm eq} , respectively, the momentum integral of the collision term in the Boltzmann equation for N_{1} is \displaystyle\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{E_{N_{1}}}\;C[f_{N_{1}}] \displaystyle=\int d\Pi_{N_{1}}\int d\Pi_{l}\int d\Pi_{\phi}\;(2\pi)^{4}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\delta^{4}(p_{N_{1}}-p_{l}-p_{\phi}) \displaystyle\quad\times(f_{l}^{\rm eq}f_{\phi}^{\rm eq}-f_{N_{1}}) \displaystyle=-\int d\Pi_{N_{1}}\int d\Pi_{l}\int d\Pi_{\phi}\;(2\pi)^{4}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\delta^{4}(p_{N_{1}}-p_{l}-p_{\phi}) \displaystyle\quad\times\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\left[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}-n_{l}^{\rm eq}n_{\phi}^{\rm eq}\,\mathrm{e}^{-(E_{l}+E_{\phi})/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}\right] \displaystyle\simeq-\int d\Pi_{N_{1}}\int d\Pi_{l}\int d\Pi_{\phi}\;(2\pi)^{4}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\delta^{4}(p_{N_{1}}-p_{l}-p_{\phi}) \displaystyle\quad\times\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr], (85) where we used the energy conservation law E_{N_{1}}=E_{l}+E_{\phi} and detailed balance at high temperatures n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}\simeq n_{l}^{\rm eq}n_{\phi}^{\rm eq} . Note that the matrix elements for N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi and N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast} do not depend on p_{N_{1}} , p_{l} , and p_{\phi} at the tree level. Let us proceed to perform the integrals over d\Pi_{\phi} , d\Pi_{l} , and d\Pi_{N_{1}} sequentially. First, for the d\Pi_{\phi} integral we get \displaystyle\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{E_{N_{1}}}\;C[f_{N_{1}}] \displaystyle=-8\pi^{2}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\;\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{2E_{N_{1}}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{l}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\;\dfrac{g_{l}}{2p_{l}}\dfrac{g_{\phi}}{2(E_{N_{1}}-p_{l})} \displaystyle\times\delta(E_{N_{1}}-p_{l}-p_{\phi})\,\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr]. (86) Here we approximated the lepton l and Higgs \phi to be massless, assuming that their masses are sufficiently smaller than that of the right-handed neutrino N_{1} . Thus, performing the integral over d^{3}p_{l}=4\pi p_{l}^{2}\;dp_{l} we get \displaystyle\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{E_{N_{1}}}\;C[f_{N_{1}}] \displaystyle=-|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\;\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{2E_{N_{1}}}\dfrac{g_{l}g_{\phi}(E_{N_{1}}-p_{\phi})}{E_{N_{1}}-p_{l}} \displaystyle\quad\times\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr]. (87) Recalling that l and \phi are in thermal equilibrium, we take thermal average over these species. Since both l and \phi are massless we can set \langle p_{l}\rangle=\langle p_{\phi}\rangle , which yields \displaystyle\left\langle\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{E_{N_{1}}}\;C[f_{N_{1}}]\right\rangle \displaystyle=-g_{N_{1}}g_{l}g_{\phi}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}} \displaystyle\quad\times\dfrac{\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\,\mathrm{e}^{-E_{N_{1}}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)}}{2E_{N_{1}}}\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr]. (88) By changing the variable to p_{N_{1}}=M_{1}\sinh\theta , equation ( 88 ) becomes \displaystyle\mathcal{C}^{\prime}\int_{0}^{\infty}\dfrac{4\pi p_{N_{1}}^{2}\;dp_{N_{1}}}{2(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2}}\,\mathrm{e}^{-(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2}/(\bar{T}+\delta T)} \displaystyle=2\pi\mathcal{C}^{\prime}M_{1}^{2}\int_{0}^{\infty}d\theta\;\sinh^{2}\theta\,\mathrm{e}^{-z_{T}\cosh\theta} \displaystyle=\dfrac{4\pi^{3}}{g_{N_{1}}M_{1}}\dfrac{K_{1}(z_{T})}{K_{2}(z_{T})}, (89) where we used equations ( 81 ) and ( 82 ). Substituting equation ( 89 ) into equation ( 88 ), we obtain \displaystyle\left\langle\dfrac{g_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{E_{N_{1}}}\;C\right\rangle \displaystyle=-\dfrac{4\pi^{3}g_{l}g_{\phi}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}}{M_{1}}\dfrac{K_{1}(z_{T})}{K_{2}(z_{T})}\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr] \displaystyle\equiv-\Gamma_{D}(\bar{z}=\infty)\biggl\langle\dfrac{1}{\gamma}\biggr\rangle(z_{T})\bigl[n_{N_{1}}(\bar{z})-n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\bigr]. (90) B.6 Derivation of N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq} In this subsection we discuss several expression of N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T}) which holds for different ranges of z_{T} . Approximating with the Boltzmann distribution, the number density n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T}) can be approximated using the Boltzmann factor as n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\mathcal{C}_{0}\int\dfrac{d^{3}p_{N_{1}}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\;\exp\biggl(-\dfrac{E_{N_{1}}}{\bar{T}+\delta T}\biggr), (91) where \mathcal{C}_{0} is a normalization constant. After changing the variable using E_{N_{1}}=(p_{N_{1}}^{2}+M_{1}^{2})^{1/2} and t=E_{N_{1}}/M_{1} , integration by parts yields n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\mathcal{C}_{0}\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}z_{T}}{3}\int_{1}^{\infty}dt\;(t^{2}-1)^{3/2}\mathrm{e}^{-z_{T}t}. (92) By using the integral expression for the modified Bessel function of the second kind K_{\nu}(z)=\dfrac{\sqrt{\pi}\,(z/2)^{\nu}}{\varGamma\bigl(\nu+\frac{1}{2}\bigr)}\int_{1}^{\infty}dt\;(t^{2}-1)^{\nu-\frac{1}{2}}\mathrm{e}^{-zt}, (93) equation ( 92 ) becomes n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\mathcal{C}_{0}\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}z_{T}}{3}\cdot\dfrac{3}{z_{T}^{2}}K_{2}(z_{T})=\mathcal{C}_{0}\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}}{z_{T}}K_{2}(z_{T}). (94) If the photon number density is normalized n_{\gamma}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})\propto(\bar{T}+\delta T)^{3} , N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\dfrac{n_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})}{n_{\gamma}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})}=\mathcal{C}_{0}^{\prime}z_{T}^{2}K_{2}(z_{T}). (95) with some normalization constant \mathcal{C}_{0}^{\prime} . For equation ( 95 ) to hold in the relativistic limit z_{T}\ll 1 , it must reduce to ( 6 ) in this limit. Since K_{2}(z)\simeq\dfrac{2}{z}K_{1}(z)\simeq\dfrac{2}{z^{2}},\qquad z\ll 1, (96) the normalization constant is fixed from \dfrac{3}{4}=N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T}\ll 1)\simeq\mathcal{C}_{0}^{\prime}z_{T}^{2}\cdot\dfrac{2}{z_{T}^{2}}=2\mathcal{C}_{0}^{\prime}, (97) as \mathcal{C}_{0}^{\prime}=3/8 . From this and equation ( 95 ), we obtain N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\dfrac{3}{8}z_{T}^{2}K_{2}(z_{T}). (98) B.7 Derivation of the washout factor W_{\rm ID} In this subsection we derive the expression for the washout factor W_{\rm ID} . The decay rate of N_{1} is given by \Gamma_{\rm D}(z)=\tilde{\Gamma}_{\rm D}\biggl\langle\dfrac{1}{\gamma}\biggr\rangle=\tilde{\Gamma}_{\rm D}\dfrac{K_{1}(z_{T})}{K_{2}(z_{T})}, (99) where \tilde{\Gamma}_{\rm D}=\Gamma_{\rm D}(z=\infty) from \lim_{z\to\infty}K_{1}(z)/K_{2}(z)=1 . The inverse decay rate \Gamma_{\rm ID} is related to the decay rate \Gamma_{\rm D} through detailed balance \Gamma_{\rm ID}(z)=\Gamma_{\rm D}(z)\dfrac{N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})}{N_{l}^{\rm eq}N_{\phi}^{\rm eq}}. (100) The equilibrium number densities of heavy neutrinos, lepton doublets, and Higgs doublets are, as already derived, N_{N_{1}}^{\rm eq}(z_{T})=\dfrac{3}{8}z_{T}^{2}K_{2}(z_{T}),\quad N_{l}^{\rm eq}=\dfrac{3}{4},\quad N_{\phi}^{\rm eq}=1. (101) Hence the contribution of inverse decays to the washout term W_{\rm ID} is W_{\rm ID}(z_{T})\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\dfrac{\Gamma_{\rm ID}(z_{T})}{\bar{z}H(\bar{z})}=\dfrac{1}{4}z_{T}^{2}K_{2}(z_{T})\dfrac{\Gamma_{\rm D}(z_{T})}{\bar{z}H(\bar{z})}. (102) Substituting equation ( 99 ) and K\equiv\tilde{\Gamma}_{\rm D}/\bar{z}^{2}H(\bar{z}) into equation ( 102 ), the washout factor is found to be \displaystyle W_{\rm ID}(z_{T}) \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{4}z_{T}^{2}K_{2}(z_{T})\dfrac{\tilde{\Gamma}_{\rm D}}{\bar{z}H(\bar{z})}\cdot\dfrac{K_{1}(z_{T})}{K_{2}(z_{T})} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{4}K\bar{z}z_{T}^{2}K_{1}(z_{T}). (103) Appendix C Perturbative Christoffel symbols In this appendix we summarize the metric ( 11 )–( 13 ) and its inverse, together with the Christoffel symbols. The metric and its inverse are given by \displaystyle g_{00} \displaystyle=-a^{2}(1+2A),\qquad g^{00}=-a^{-2}(1-2A), (104) \displaystyle g_{0i} \displaystyle=-a^{2}B_{,i},\hskip 45.00006ptg^{0i}=-a^{-2}B^{,i}, (105) \displaystyle g_{ij} \displaystyle=a^{2}\biggl[(1+2C)\delta_{ij}+2\biggl(E_{,ij}-\dfrac{1}{3}\delta_{ij}\nabla^{2}E\biggr)\biggr], (106) \displaystyle g^{ij} \displaystyle=a^{-2}\biggl[(1-2C)\delta^{ij}-2\biggl(E^{,ij}-\dfrac{1}{3}\delta^{ij}\nabla^{2}E\biggr)\biggr]. (107) The Christoffel symbols up to first order in perturbations are given by \displaystyle{\Gamma^{0}}_{00} \displaystyle=\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}+A^{\prime}, (108) \displaystyle{\Gamma^{0}}_{0i} \displaystyle=A_{,i}-\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}B_{,i}, (109) \displaystyle{\Gamma^{0}}_{ij} \displaystyle=\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}\delta_{ij}+\biggl[-2\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}A+\dfrac{(a^{2}C)^{\prime}}{a^{2}}\biggr]\delta_{ij} \displaystyle\quad+B_{,ij}+\dfrac{1}{a^{2}}\biggl[a^{2}\biggl(E_{,ij}-\frac{1}{3}\delta_{ij}\nabla^{2}E\biggr)\biggr]^{\prime}, (110) \displaystyle{\Gamma^{i}}_{00} \displaystyle=A^{,i}-\biggl(B^{\prime}+\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}B\biggr)^{,i}, (111) \displaystyle{\Gamma^{i}}_{0j} \displaystyle=\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}{\delta^{i}}_{j}+C^{\prime}{\delta^{i}}_{j}+\biggl({E^{,i}}_{,j}-\dfrac{1}{3}{\delta^{i}}_{j}\nabla^{2}E\biggr)^{\prime}, (112) \displaystyle{\Gamma^{i}}_{jk} \displaystyle=\left(C_{,k}{\delta^{i}}_{j}+C_{,j}{\delta^{i}}_{k}-C^{,i}\delta_{jk}\right)+\dfrac{a^{\prime}}{a}\delta_{jk}B^{,i} \displaystyle\quad+{E^{,i}}_{,jk}-\dfrac{1}{3}\nabla^{2}\bigl({\delta^{i}}_{j}E_{,k}+{\delta^{i}}_{k}E_{,j}-\delta_{jk}E^{,i}\bigr). (113) Appendix D Calculation of CP asymmetry \varepsilon_{1} In this appendix we calculate the CP asymmetry \varepsilon_{1} from the interference between tree and one-loop diagrams in the decay of N_{1} . D.1 Prerequisites The relevant Yukawa terms in the Lagrangian are \displaystyle\mathcal{L} \displaystyle\supset-y_{\alpha\beta}^{(e)}(\bar{l}_{\rm L})_{\alpha}\phi(e_{\rm R})_{\beta}-y_{\alpha\beta}^{(\nu)}[(\bar{l}_{\rm L})_{\alpha}\circ\phi^{\dagger}]N_{\beta}+{\rm h.c.}, (114) where \alpha,\beta=1,2,3 denote the lepton flavor, and repeated indices are implicitly summed over. In addition, the indices L and R represent the left-chiral and right-chiral eigenvectors of the eigenspace ( 181 ) of chirality ( 178 ). Left-chiral field l_{\rm L} and Higgs field \phi form \mathrm{SU}(2) doublets as l_{\rm L}=\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\ e_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)},\qquad\phi=\begin{pmatrix}\phi^{+}\\ \phi^{0}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}. (115) The Dirac conjugate of the former is defined as \bar{l}_{\rm L}=\begin{pmatrix}\bar{\nu}_{\rm L}&\bar{e}_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}, (116) where \nu_{\rm L} , \nu_{\rm R} , e_{\rm L} , e_{\rm R} are all Weyl fields. The Dirac conjugates for them are defined by promoting to Dirac fields and then projecting them onto the eigenspaces of the chirality \gamma_{5} . To do so we introduce dummy fields \nu_{\rm R}^{\prime} and e_{\rm R}^{\prime} as \nu=\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\[2.5pt] \nu_{\rm R}^{\prime}\end{pmatrix}_{\rm Dirac},\qquad e=\begin{pmatrix}e_{\rm L}\\[2.5pt] e_{\rm R}^{\prime}\end{pmatrix}_{\rm Dirac}, (117) and then \bar{\nu}_{\rm L} and \bar{e}_{\rm L} satisfy \displaystyle\bar{\nu}_{\rm L} \displaystyle=\overline{P_{\rm L}\nu}=(P_{\rm L}\nu)^{\dagger}\gamma^{0}=\nu^{\dagger}P_{\rm L}\gamma^{0}=\nu^{\dagger}\gamma^{0}P_{\rm R}, (118) \displaystyle\bar{e}_{\rm L} \displaystyle=\overline{P_{\rm L}e}=(P_{\rm L}e)^{\dagger}\gamma^{0}=e^{\dagger}P_{\rm L}\gamma^{0}=e^{\dagger}\gamma^{0}P_{\rm R}, (119) where P_{\rm L} and P_{\rm R} are projection operators of chirality defined in equation ( 180 ). These definitions give \displaystyle l \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}\nu\\ e\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}=\begin{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\[2.5pt] \nu_{\rm R}^{\prime}\end{pmatrix}_{\rm Dirac}\\[10.00002pt] \begin{pmatrix}e_{\rm L}\\[2.5pt] e_{\rm R}^{\prime}\end{pmatrix}_{\rm Dirac}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)} \displaystyle\Rightarrow\quad l_{\rm L} \displaystyle=P_{\rm L}l=\begin{pmatrix}P_{\rm L}\nu\\ P_{\rm L}e\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}=\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\ e_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}. (120) The product \bar{l}_{\rm L}\circ\phi^{\dagger} is defined so that it is invariant under \mathrm{SU}(2) [Note that \mathrm{i}\sigma^{2}=\bigl(\begin{smallmatrix}0&1\\ -1&0\end{smallmatrix}\bigr) ]: \displaystyle\bar{l}_{\rm L}\circ\phi^{\dagger} \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}\bar{\nu}_{\rm L}&\bar{e}_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}\circ\begin{pmatrix}(\phi^{+})^{\dagger}\\ (\phi^{0})^{\dagger}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)} \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}\bar{\nu}_{\rm L}&\bar{e}_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ -1&0\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}(\phi^{+})^{\dagger}\\ (\phi^{0})^{\dagger}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)} \displaystyle=\bar{\nu}_{\rm L}(\phi^{0})^{\dagger}-\bar{e}_{\rm L}(\phi^{+})^{\dagger}, (121) which can be rewritten as \bar{l}_{\rm L}\circ\phi^{\dagger}=\overline{P_{\rm L}l}\circ\phi^{\dagger}=(\bar{l}P_{\rm R})\circ\phi^{\dagger}=(\bar{l}\circ\phi^{\dagger})P_{\rm R}. (122) The conjugate of the above gives \phi\circ l_{\rm L} : \displaystyle\phi\circ l_{\rm L} \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}\phi^{+}&\phi^{0}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}\circ\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\ e_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)} \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}\phi^{+}&\phi^{0}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)}\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ -1&0\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}\nu_{\rm L}\\ e_{\rm L}\end{pmatrix}_{\mathrm{SU}(2)} \displaystyle=\nu_{\rm L}\phi^{0}-e_{\rm L}\phi^{+}, (123) which can be rewritten as \phi\circ l_{\rm L}=P_{\rm L}(\phi\circ l). (124) Note that the sign of the operation \circ changes depending on whether the fields are \mathrm{SU}(2) fundamental or \mathrm{SU}(2) anti-fundamental. The Majorana field N is the Majorana representation of the right-chiral Weyl field \nu_{\rm R} given by N=\begin{pmatrix}(\nu_{\rm R})^{c}\\ \nu_{\rm R}\end{pmatrix}_{\rm Dirac}, (125) where the charge conjugation operator c is defined as \begin{array}[]{l}(\mbox{left-chiral})^{c}=\mathrm{i}\sigma^{2}(\mbox{left-chiral})^{\dagger},\\[7.5pt] (\mbox{right-chiral})^{c}=-\mathrm{i}\sigma^{2}(\mbox{right-chiral})^{\dagger},\end{array} (126) thereby (\nu_{\rm R})^{c}=-\mathrm{i}\sigma^{2}\nu_{\rm R}^{\dagger} . Thus the relevant Yukawa couplings become \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\rm int} \displaystyle=-y_{\alpha\beta}^{(\nu)}[(\bar{l}_{\rm L})_{\alpha}\circ\phi^{\dagger}]N_{\beta}+{\rm h.c.} \displaystyle=-y_{\alpha\beta}^{(\nu)}(\bar{l}_{\alpha}\circ\phi^{\dagger})P_{\rm R}N_{\beta}-y_{\alpha\beta}^{(\nu)\ast}\bar{N}_{\beta}P_{\rm L}(\phi\circ l_{\alpha}). (127) Henceforth, we denote y_{\alpha\beta}^{(\nu)} by y_{\alpha\beta} . D.2 Feynman diagrams We list the Feynman diagrams that appear in the one-loop calculation of \varepsilon_{1} . For the Feynman rules for Majorana fermions, refer to Refs. [ 57 , 58 ] . D.2.1 Tree diagrams y_{\alpha 1}P_{\rm R} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1} l_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1} \bar{l}_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi^{\ast} D.2.2 Vertex diagrams y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\alpha\gamma}P_{\rm R} y_{\beta\gamma}P_{\rm R} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1} l_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi -p_{1}+q \phi p_{2}+q \bar{l}_{\beta} q N_{\gamma} y_{\beta 1}P_{\rm R} y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1} \bar{l}_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi^{\ast} -p_{1}+q \phi^{\ast} p_{2}+q l_{\beta} q N_{\gamma} D.2.3 Wavefunction diagrams I y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\alpha\gamma}P_{\rm R} y_{\beta\gamma}P_{\rm R} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{\gamma} p_{1} l_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi p_{1}+p_{2}+q \phi^{\ast} -q \bar{l}_{\beta} y_{\beta 1}P_{\rm R} y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{\gamma} p_{1} \bar{l}_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi^{\ast} p_{1}+p_{2}+q \phi -q l_{\beta} D.2.4 Wavefunction diagrams II y_{\beta 1}P_{\rm R} y_{\alpha\gamma}P_{\rm R} y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{\gamma} p_{1} l_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi p_{1}+p_{2}+q \phi -q l_{\beta} y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}P_{\rm L} y_{\beta\gamma}P_{\rm R} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{1} p_{1}+p_{2} N_{\gamma} p_{1} \bar{l}_{\alpha} p_{2} \phi^{\ast} p_{1}+p_{2}+q \phi^{\ast} -q \bar{l}_{\beta} D.3 Calculation of tree diagrams In this subsection we calculate the tree diagrams. Hereafter we assume that the masses of the leptons and the Higgs boson are negligible compared to the mass of the heavy neutrino M_{1} . We often use p_{1}^{2}=p_{2}^{2}=0,\qquad p_{1}\cdot p_{2}=\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{2}, (128) for the momenta of the lepton p_{1} and the Higgs boson p_{2} . Here the second equation is derived from (p_{1}+p_{2})^{2}=M_{1}^{2} . First we consider N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi . Let s and t be the spins of the initial and final states of N_{1} and l_{\alpha} , respectively. The Lagrangian in equation ( 127 ) can be written as \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\rm int} \displaystyle\supset-y_{\alpha\beta}[\bar{\nu}_{\alpha}(\phi^{0})^{\dagger}-\bar{e}_{\alpha}(\phi^{+})^{\dagger}]P_{\rm R}N_{\beta}. (129) Thus there are two possibilities for the final state: \nu_{\alpha}\phi^{0} and e_{\alpha}\phi^{+} , originating from the \mathrm{SU}(2) doublet. Here the matrix element \mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{(s,t)} is defined for each channel, and hence the result obtained below must be multiplied by a factor of two when calculating the total decay rate. The total matrix element is the sum of the tree and the one-loop: \mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}(s,t)}=\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}+\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}. (130) The squared magnitude of the matrix element at the tree level is obtained by taking the sum over spins s and t and then averaging over the spin s of the initial state \displaystyle\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}|\bar{u}_{l_{\alpha}}^{t}(p_{1})(-\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}P_{\rm R})u_{N_{1}}^{s}(p_{1}+p_{2})|^{2} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{2}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}\tr[(\not{p}_{1}+\not{p}_{2}+M_{1})P_{\rm L}\not{p}_{1}P_{\rm R}] \displaystyle=|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}(p_{1}\cdot p_{2})=\dfrac{1}{2}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}M_{1}^{2}, (131) where we used the spin sum formula ( 199 ), the trace formulas ( 186 ), ( 187 ), ( 190 ), and ( 179 ), as well as the approximation in equation ( 128 ). Next, for N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast} , a similar calculation yields \displaystyle\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}|\bar{v}_{l_{\alpha}}^{t}(p_{1})(-\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}P_{\rm L})u_{N_{1}}^{s}(p_{1}+p_{2})|^{2} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{2}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}\tr[(\not{p}_{1}+\not{p}_{2}-M_{1})P_{\rm R}\not{p}_{1}P_{\rm L}] \displaystyle=|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}(p_{1}\cdot p_{2})=\dfrac{1}{2}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}M_{1}^{2}. (132) D.4 Calculation of vertex diagrams In this subsection we calculate vertex diagrams and the resulting interference with the tree-level diagrams. We first consider N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi . The combined contribution of the tree and one-loop diagrams is \displaystyle\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}}\Bigr|^{2}\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle\simeq\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr|^{2} \displaystyle\quad+\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl[\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr)^{\ast}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr)+{\rm c.c.}\Bigr]. (133) The interference part is \displaystyle I_{\rm vertex} \displaystyle\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr)^{\ast}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr) \displaystyle=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma} \displaystyle\quad\times\int\!\!\dfrac{d^{4}q}{(2\pi)^{4}}\;\dfrac{-\frac{1}{2}M_{1}^{3}M_{\gamma}-M_{1}M_{\gamma}(p_{1}\cdot q)}{(q^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2})(-p_{2}-q)^{2}(-p_{1}+q)^{2}} \displaystyle\equiv y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}D_{\rm vertex}, (134) where we used equation ( 182 ), the spin sum formula ( 199 ), and the trace formulas ( 186 ), ( 187 ), ( 189 ). Furthermore, performing the q -integration using Feynman parametrization ( 202 ) and the dimensional regularization formulas ( 203 ) and ( 204 ), we get \displaystyle D_{\rm vertex}=\dfrac{1}{2}\int\!\!\dfrac{d^{4}q}{\mathrm{i}(2\pi)^{4}} \displaystyle\quad\times\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}M_{\gamma}+2M_{1}M_{\gamma}(p_{1}\cdot q)}{(q^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}+\mathrm{i}\epsilon)(-p_{2}-q+\mathrm{i}\epsilon)^{2}(-p_{1}+q+\mathrm{i}\epsilon)^{2}} \displaystyle=\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\int_{0}^{1-x}dy\;\dfrac{M_{1}M_{\gamma}(1-y)}{M_{\gamma}^{2}(1-x-y)-M_{1}^{2}xy-\mathrm{i}\epsilon}, (135) where -\mathrm{i}\epsilon in the denominator comes from the \mathrm{i}\epsilon prescription. We define m\equiv M_{1}/M_{\gamma} and perform the integration over y in equation ( 135 ). Considering the complex y -plane, there exists a pole at y=(1-x)/(1+m^{2}x)\equiv a within the range 0\leqslant y\leqslant 1-x on the real axis, which we avoid by taking an upper semicircle. We divide the integration range of y into three intervals [0,a-\epsilon^{\prime}] , [a-\epsilon^{\prime},a+\epsilon^{\prime}] , and [a+\epsilon^{\prime},1] . Figure 11: Contour of D_{\rm vertex} . In the middle interval [a-\epsilon^{\prime},a+\epsilon^{\prime}] , we perform the variable transformation y=a+\epsilon^{\prime}\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}\theta} (where \epsilon^{\prime}>0 is a small quantity and 0\leqslant\theta\leqslant\pi ). The imaginary part of D_{\rm vertex} is evaluated as \displaystyle\mathrm{i}\Im(D_{\rm vertex}) \displaystyle=\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\int_{a-\epsilon^{\prime}}^{a+\epsilon^{\prime}}dy\;\dfrac{m(1-y)}{1-x-y-m^{2}xy-\mathrm{i}\epsilon} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\;\dfrac{m}{1+m^{2}x}\int_{a-\epsilon^{\prime}}^{a+\epsilon^{\prime}}dy\;\dfrac{y-1}{y-\frac{1-x}{1+m^{2}x}+\mathrm{i}\epsilon} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\;\dfrac{m}{1+m^{2}x}\int_{\pi}^{0}\mathrm{i}\epsilon^{\prime}\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}\theta}\;d\theta\;\dfrac{a-1+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{\prime})}{\epsilon^{\prime}\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}\theta}} \displaystyle\xrightarrow[\epsilon^{\prime}\downarrow 0]{}-\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\;(-\mathrm{i}\pi)\dfrac{m}{1+m^{2}x}\biggl(\dfrac{1-x}{1+m^{2}x}-1\biggr), (136) where the +\mathrm{i}\epsilon in the denominator specifies that the integration contour lies in the upper half-plane. Upon performing the x -integration, we find \Im(D_{\rm vertex})=\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi}\biggl\{\dfrac{1}{m}\biggl[1-\biggl(1+\dfrac{1}{m^{2}}\biggr)\ln(1+m^{2})\biggr]\biggr\}. (137) Thus equation ( 134 ) becomes \displaystyle I_{\rm vertex} \displaystyle=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}\Im(D_{\rm vertex}). (138) We next consider N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast} . Similar calculation as above gives \displaystyle I^{\prime}_{\rm vertex} \displaystyle\equiv\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr)^{\ast}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr) \displaystyle=\cdots \displaystyle=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi}\biggl\{\dfrac{1}{m}\biggl[1-\biggl(1+\dfrac{1}{m^{2}}\biggr)\ln(1+m^{2})\biggr]\biggr\}. (139) Regarding the external lines, while the anti-lepton part changed from u_{l_{\alpha}}^{t} to v_{\bar{l}_{\alpha}}^{t} , the N_{1} part remained as u_{N_{1}}^{s} . This is due to the Majorana nature of N_{1} . Combining above results, the CP asymmetry (\varepsilon_{1})_{\rm vertex} is given by \displaystyle(\varepsilon_{1})_{\rm vertex} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\sum_{\alpha}\Bigl(\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}}\Bigr|^{2}-\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}}\Bigr|^{2}\Bigr)}{\sum_{\alpha}\Bigl(\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2}+\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2}\Bigr)} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}F(m),\qquad m\equiv\dfrac{M_{1}}{M_{\gamma}}, \displaystyle F(m) \displaystyle\equiv\dfrac{1}{m}\biggl[1-\biggl(1+\dfrac{1}{m^{2}}\biggr)\ln(1+m^{2})\biggr]. (140) As seen from this expression, in order for \varepsilon_{1} to be non-zero, D_{\rm vertex} must have an imaginary part. D.5 Calculation of wavefunction diagrams Regarding the wavefunction diagrams, there appears two types of contributions: wavefunction I and wavefunction II. However, only the former contributes to the CP asymmetry (this will be verified later). Additionally, be mindful of the factor two which appears below. This arises when two different particle species belonging to the \mathrm{SU}(2) group appear in the loop. For example, when fix the decay channel to N_{\alpha}\to\nu_{\alpha}\phi^{0} , the particles appearing in the triangular loop in the vertex diagrams are fixed to \phi^{0} and \nu_{\beta} , since the vertex is connected to the final state. On the other hand, in the wavefunction diagrams, there is no constraint on the particles entering the loop from the final state, and hence both \nu_{\alpha}\phi^{0} and e_{\alpha}\phi^{+} contribute. The interference term of the wavefunction diagram I is \displaystyle I_{\rm wave}^{(1)} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr)^{\ast}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr) \displaystyle=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}\dfrac{2M_{1}M_{\gamma}}{M_{1}^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}}\int\!\!\dfrac{d^{4}q}{(2\pi)^{4}}\;\dfrac{p_{1}\cdot q}{q^{2}(p_{1}+p_{2}+q)^{2}} \displaystyle\equiv y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}D_{\rm wave}^{(1)}, (141) where we used ( 182 ), the spin sum formula ( 199 ), and the trace formulas ( 186 ), ( 187 ) and ( 190 ). Furthermore, applying Feynman parametrization ( 201 ) and the dimensional regularization formula ( 204 ), we perform the q -integration and extract the imaginary part, obtaining \displaystyle D_{\rm wave}^{(1)} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{2M_{1}M_{\gamma}}{M_{1}^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}}\int\!\!\dfrac{d^{4}q}{\mathrm{i}(2\pi)^{4}}\;\dfrac{p_{1}\cdot q}{q^{2}(q+p_{1}+p_{2})^{2}} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}M_{\gamma}}{M_{1}^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}}\int_{0}^{1}dx\;x\log\bigl[-M_{1}^{2}x(1-x)-\mathrm{i}\epsilon\bigr], (142) i.e., \Im(D_{\rm wave}^{(1)})=\dfrac{1}{32\pi}\dfrac{M_{1}^{3}M_{\gamma}}{M_{1}^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}}. (143) Here note that \log\bigl[-M_{1}^{2}x(1-x)-\mathrm{i}\epsilon\bigr] is specified with the integration contour lying in the lower half-plane, thus yielding -\mathrm{i}\pi instead of +\mathrm{i}\pi . From this and equation ( 142 ), we obtain I_{\rm wave}^{(1)}=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi}\dfrac{m}{m^{2}-1},\quad m\equiv\dfrac{M_{1}}{M_{\gamma}}. (144) The interference term of the wavefunction diagram II is \displaystyle I_{\rm wave}^{(2)}=\dfrac{1}{2}\sum_{s,t}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}(s,t)}\Bigr)^{\ast}\Bigl(\mathrm{i}\mathcal{M}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(1-loop)}(s,t)}\Bigr) \displaystyle=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}\dfrac{2M_{1}^{2}}{M_{1}^{2}-M_{\gamma}^{2}}\int\!\!\dfrac{d^{4}q}{(2\pi)^{4}}\;\dfrac{p_{2}\cdot q}{q^{2}(p_{1}+p_{2}+q)^{2}}, (145) where we have taken into account equation ( 182 ), the spin sum formula ( 199 ) and the trace formulas ( 188 ) and ( 191 ). Applying Feynman parametrization ( 201 ) and the dimensional regularization formula ( 204 ), we perform the q -integration in a similar way to those in equation ( 144 ), obtaining I_{\rm wave}^{(2)}=\mathrm{i}y_{\alpha 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}\dfrac{M_{1}^{2}}{32\pi}\dfrac{m^{2}}{m^{2}-1},\quad m\equiv\dfrac{M_{1}}{M_{\gamma}}. (146) By summing equations ( 144 ) and ( 146 ), similarly to equation ( 140 ), we find \displaystyle(\varepsilon_{1})_{\rm wave} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\sum_{\alpha}\Bigl(\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}}\Bigr|^{2}-\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree+1-loop)}}\Bigr|^{2}\Bigr)}{\sum_{\alpha}\Bigl(\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to l_{\alpha}\phi}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2}+\Bigl|\mathrm{i}\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{N_{1}\to\bar{l}_{\alpha}\phi^{\ast}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize(tree)}}\Bigr|^{2}\Bigr)} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}\cdot\dfrac{m}{m^{2}-1} \displaystyle\quad+\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}\cdot\dfrac{m^{2}}{m^{2}-1}. (147) Here note that \displaystyle\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}) \displaystyle=\Im\Biggl[\sum_{\alpha}(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast})\sum_{\beta}(y_{\beta 1}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma})\Biggr] \displaystyle=\Im\Biggl(\biggl|\sum_{\alpha}y_{\alpha 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}\biggr|^{2}\Biggr)=0, (148) from which follows that the contribution from wavefunction diagram II is zero. Thus we find (\varepsilon_{1})_{\rm wave}=\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}\cdot\dfrac{m}{m^{2}-1},\qquad m\equiv\dfrac{M_{1}}{M_{\gamma}}. (149) D.6 Final result and approximate expression By combining equations ( 140 ) and ( 149 ), the expression for the CP asymmetry is obtained as \displaystyle\varepsilon_{1} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}} \displaystyle\quad\times\dfrac{1}{m}\biggl[1+\dfrac{m^{2}}{m^{2}-1}-\biggl(1+\dfrac{1}{m^{2}}\biggr)\ln(1+m^{2})\biggr]. (150) At this point we switch to x\equiv M_{\gamma}^{2}/M_{1}^{2} in place of m\equiv M_{1}/M_{\gamma} to match the literature \displaystyle\varepsilon_{1} \displaystyle=\dfrac{\Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})}{8\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}f(x),\qquad x\equiv\dfrac{M_{\gamma}^{2}}{M_{1}^{2}}, \displaystyle f(x) \displaystyle\equiv\sqrt{x}\,\biggl[1+\dfrac{1}{1-x}-(1+x)\ln\biggl(1+\dfrac{1}{x}\biggr)\biggr]. (151) Note that \Im(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\beta 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast})=0 and hence \varepsilon_{1}=0 for \gamma=1 . Thus the contributions from the second and third generations are necessary to generate nonzero \varepsilon_{1} . When the magnitude of the CP asymmetry \varepsilon_{1} is much smaller than one, x=M_{\gamma}^{2}/M_{1}^{2} is expected to be much larger than unity. In this case, we perform a Taylor expansion of f(x) for 1/x\ll 1 : f(x)=-\biggl[\dfrac{3}{2\sqrt{x}}+\dfrac{5}{6x^{3/2}}+\mathcal{O}\biggl(\dfrac{1}{x^{5/2}}\biggr)\biggr], (152) from which we define \tilde{f} taking the leading term \tilde{f}(x)\equiv-\dfrac{3}{2\sqrt{x}}. (153) The plots for f(x) and \tilde{f}(x) are shown in Figure 12 . When approximating f(x) with \tilde{f}(x) , the CP asymmetry ( 151 ) is approximated as \varepsilon_{1}\simeq-\dfrac{3M_{1}}{16\pi\sum_{\alpha}|y_{\alpha 1}|^{2}}\Im\biggl(y_{\alpha 1}y_{\alpha\gamma}^{\ast}\dfrac{1}{M_{\gamma}}y_{\beta 1}y_{\beta\gamma}^{\ast}\biggr). (154) Figure 12: Functions f(x) (blue) and \tilde{f}(x)\equiv-3/(2\sqrt{x}) (magenta). Appendix E Derivation of the maximal CP asymmetry |\varepsilon_{1}|^{\rm max} From the Lagrangian ( 2 ), the neutrino masses are given by [ 59 ] \mathcal{L}_{m}=-\dfrac{M_{\alpha\beta}}{2}\bar{N}_{\alpha}^{c}N_{\beta}-y_{\alpha\beta}\phi^{\ast}\bar{l}_{\alpha}\bar{N}_{\beta}+{\rm h.c.}, (155) where M is the heavy neutrino mass matrix. Here (m_{\rm D})_{\alpha\beta}=y_{\alpha\beta}v from the Higgs mechanism, where m_{\rm D} is the Dirac mass matrix, y_{\alpha\beta} is the Yukawa coupling, and v=\langle\phi\rangle is the VEV of the Higgs field \phi . We adopt the mass eigenstate basis for the heavy neutrinos, in which M is diagonal with real positive eigenvalues M_{1}\leqslant M_{2}\leqslant M_{3} . Through the seesaw mechanism, the light neutrino mass matrix m_{\nu} can be expressed in terms of m_{\rm D} and the inverse of M , m_{\nu}=-m_{\rm D}\dfrac{1}{M}m_{\rm D}^{\intercal}, (156) where higher order terms in 1/M are neglected. m_{\nu} can be diagonalized by a unitary matrix U^{(\nu)} U^{(\nu)\dagger}m_{\nu}U^{(\nu)\ast}=-\begin{pmatrix}m_{1}&0&0\\ 0&m_{2}&0\\ 0&0&m_{3}\end{pmatrix}\equiv-D_{m}, (157) with real positive eigenvalues m_{1}\leqslant m_{2}\leqslant m_{3} . Substituting equation ( 156 ) into equation ( 157 ), we get \displaystyle U^{(\nu)\dagger}\bigl(-m_{\rm D}M^{-1}m_{\rm D}^{\intercal}\bigr)U^{(\nu)\ast} \displaystyle=-U^{(\nu)\dagger}(yv)D_{M}^{-1}(yv)^{\intercal}U^{(\nu)\ast} \displaystyle=-v^{2}U^{(\nu)\dagger}yD_{M}^{-1}y^{\intercal}U^{(\nu)\ast}=-D_{m}, (158) where D_{M} is the diagonalized heavy mass matrix M . Equation ( 158 ) means that \Omega\equiv vD_{m}^{-1/2}U^{(\nu)\dagger}yD_{M}^{-1/2} (159) is an orthogonal matrix \Omega\Omega^{\intercal}=\bm{1} . This implies that \Im(\Omega^{\intercal}\Omega)_{11}=0 , which yields \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=\Im(\Omega^{\intercal}\Omega)_{11} \displaystyle=\Im\bigl(vD_{M}^{-1/2}y^{\intercal}U^{(\nu)\ast}D_{m}^{-1/2}\cdot vD_{m}^{-1/2}U^{(\nu)\dagger}yD_{M}^{-1/2}\bigr)_{11} \displaystyle=v^{2}\dfrac{1}{M_{1}}\Im\bigl(D_{m}^{-1}y^{\intercal}U^{(\nu)\ast}\cdot U^{(\nu)\dagger}y\bigr)_{11} \displaystyle=v^{2}\dfrac{1}{M_{1}}\sum_{\alpha=1,2,3}\dfrac{1}{m_{\alpha}}\Im\bigl(U^{(\nu)\dagger}y\bigr)_{\alpha 1}^{2}, (160) that is, \dfrac{1}{m_{1}}\Im\bigl(U^{(\nu)\dagger}y\bigr)_{11}^{2}=-\sum_{\alpha\neq 1}\dfrac{1}{m_{\alpha}}\Im\bigl(U^{(\nu)\dagger}y\bigr)_{\alpha 1}^{2}. (161) On the other hand, the CP asymmetry \varepsilon_{1} is obtained from equation ( 154 ) \varepsilon_{1}\simeq-\dfrac{3}{16\pi}\dfrac{M_{1}}{(y^{\dagger}y)_{11}}\Im\biggl(y^{\dagger}y\dfrac{1}{M}y^{\intercal}y^{\ast}\biggr)_{11}, (162) where M is the heavy neutrino mass matrix. Substituting equation ( 157 ) and equation ( 161 ) into ( 162 ), and expressing it in terms of \tilde{y}=U^{(\nu)\dagger}y (163) instead of y , we obtain \displaystyle\Im\biggl(\tilde{y}^{\dagger}\tilde{y}\dfrac{1}{M}\tilde{y}^{\intercal}\tilde{y}^{\ast}\biggr)_{11} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{1}{v^{2}}\Im\biggl(\tilde{y}^{\dagger}U^{(\nu)\dagger}m_{\nu}U^{(\nu)\ast}\tilde{y}^{\ast}\biggr)_{11} \displaystyle=-\dfrac{m_{1}}{v^{2}}\Im(\tilde{y}_{11}^{2})-\sum_{\alpha\neq 1}\dfrac{m_{\alpha}}{v^{2}}\Im(\tilde{y}_{\alpha 1}^{2}) \displaystyle=-\dfrac{1}{v^{2}}\sum_{\alpha\neq 1}\dfrac{\Delta m_{\alpha 1}^{2}}{m_{\alpha}}\Im(\tilde{y}_{\alpha 1}^{2}), (164) that translates into \varepsilon_{1}=\dfrac{3}{16\pi}\dfrac{M_{1}}{v^{2}}\sum_{\alpha\neq 1}\dfrac{\Delta m_{\alpha 1}^{2}}{m_{\alpha}}\dfrac{\Im(\tilde{y}_{\alpha 1}^{2})}{(\tilde{y}^{\dagger}\tilde{y})_{11}}, (165) where \Delta m_{\alpha 1}^{2}\equiv m_{\alpha}^{2}-m_{1}^{2} . Now, consider the normalized Yukawa couplings [ 46 ] z_{\alpha}=\dfrac{\tilde{y}_{\alpha 1}^{2}}{(\tilde{y}^{\dagger}\tilde{y})_{11}}=X_{\alpha}+\mathrm{i}Y_{\alpha}, (166) which follow 0\leqslant|z_{\alpha}|\leqslant 1,\qquad\sum_{\alpha}|z_{\alpha}|=1. (167) From the orthogonality condition (\Omega^{\intercal}\Omega)_{11}=1 , the additional constraint is given by \sum_{\alpha}\dfrac{\tilde{m}_{1}}{m_{\alpha}}z_{\alpha}=1, (168) where \tilde{m}_{1} is the effective neutrino mass ( 37 ). From equation ( 165 ), the CP asymmetry reads in the new variables \varepsilon_{1}=\dfrac{3}{16\pi}\dfrac{M_{1}}{v^{2}}\biggl(\dfrac{\Delta m_{21}^{2}}{m_{2}}Y_{2}+\dfrac{\Delta m_{31}^{2}}{m_{3}}Y_{3}\biggr). (169) Since m_{3}>m_{2} , \displaystyle\dfrac{\Delta m_{31}^{2}}{m_{3}}-\dfrac{\Delta m_{21}^{2}}{m_{2}} \displaystyle=\dfrac{m_{3}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}}{m_{3}}-\dfrac{m_{2}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}}{m_{2}} \displaystyle=\dfrac{(m_{3}-m_{2})(m_{1}^{2}+m_{2}m_{3})}{m_{2}m_{3}}>0 \displaystyle\Rightarrow\quad\dfrac{\Delta m_{31}^{2}}{m_{3}} \displaystyle>\dfrac{\Delta m_{21}^{2}}{m_{2}}. (170) From this, we can presume that the maximal CP asymmetry is achieved when |Y_{3}| is maximal. The additional condition ( 168 ) yields \displaystyle\dfrac{Y_{1}}{m_{1}}+\dfrac{Y_{2}}{m_{2}}+\dfrac{Y_{3}}{m_{3}}=0, (171) \displaystyle\dfrac{\tilde{m}_{1}}{m_{1}}X_{1}+\dfrac{\tilde{m}_{1}}{m_{2}}X_{2}+\dfrac{\tilde{m}_{1}}{m_{3}}X_{3}=1. (172) Since m_{3}>m_{2}>m_{1} , we can set X_{2}=X_{3}=Y_{2}=0 for maximal |Y_{3}| . Then, it follows that Y_{1}=-\dfrac{m_{1}}{m_{3}}Y_{3},\qquad X_{1}=\dfrac{m_{1}}{\tilde{m}_{1}}. (173) The second equation in ( 167 ) gives \sqrt{X_{1}^{2}+Y_{1}^{2}}+|Y_{3}|=1. (174) The conditions ( 173 ) and ( 174 ) determine |Y_{3}| as a function of m_{1} , m_{3} , and \tilde{m}_{1} : \displaystyle\biggl(1-\dfrac{m_{1}^{2}}{m_{3}^{2}}\biggr)|Y_{3}|^{2}-2|Y_{3}|+1-\dfrac{m_{1}^{2}}{\tilde{m}_{1}^{2}}=0 \displaystyle\Rightarrow\quad|Y_{3}|=1-\dfrac{m_{1}}{m_{3}}\sqrt{1+\dfrac{m_{3}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}}{\tilde{m}_{1}^{2}}}, (175) where |Y_{3}|<1 is taken into account. Substituting Y_{2}=0 and equation ( 175 ) into equation ( 169 ) yields |\varepsilon_{1}|^{\rm max}=\dfrac{3}{16\pi}\dfrac{M_{1}m_{3}}{v^{2}}\Biggl[1-\dfrac{m_{1}}{m_{3}}\biggl(1+\dfrac{m_{3}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}}{\tilde{m}_{1}^{2}}\biggr)^{1/2}\Biggr], (176) where m_{3}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}