Sparse Bounds for Discrete Maximal Functions associated with Birch-Magyar averages Ankit Bhojak, Surjeet Singh Choudhary, Siddhartha Samanta, Saurabh Shrivastava Abstract . In this article, we study discrete maximal function associated with the Birch-Magyar averages over sparse sequences. We establish sparse domination principle for such operators. As a consequence, we obtain ℓ p \ell^{p} -estimates for such discrete maximal function over sparse sequences for all p > 1 p>1 . The proof of sparse bounds is based on scale-free ℓ p − \ell^{p}- improving estimates for the single scale Birch-Magyar averages. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 11D72, 42B25, Secondary 11P55, 11L05 1. Introduction Let \sigma be the normalized Lebesgue measure on the unit sphere \mathbb{S}^{n-1}\subset{\mathbb{R}}^{n},n\geq 2 . For a continuous function f:{\mathbb{R}}^{n}\to{\mathbb{C}} , the spherical averages of f is defined by \mathcal{A}_{t}f(x)=\int_{\mathbb{S}^{n-1}}f(x-t\theta)d\sigma(\theta),\;t>0. For n\geq 3 , the full spherical maximal function \mathcal{A}_{\star}f(x)=\sup\limits_{t>0}|\mathcal{A}_{t}f(x)| was shown to be bounded on L^{p}({\mathbb{R}}^{n}) by Stein [ 27 ] if and only if p>\frac{n}{n-1} . Later, Bourgain [ 4 ] proved that the maximal operator \mathcal{A}_{\star} is bounded on L^{p}({\mathbb{R}}^{2}) if and only if p>2 . Further, the lacunary version of the spherical maximal function was considered. Recall that a sequence \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} is called lacunary if there exists c>1 such that \frac{\lambda_{k+1}}{\lambda_{k}}\geq c, for all k\geq 1. The lacunary spherical maximal function corresponding to a lacunary sequence \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} is defined as \mathcal{A}_{lac}f(x)=\sup\limits_{k}|\mathcal{A}_{\lambda_{k}}f(x)|. The maximal function \mathcal{A}_{lac} is known to be bounded on L^{p}(\mathbb{R}^{n}) for 1\frac{n}{n-2} and n\geq 5 ; subsequently Ionescu [ 16 ] established restricted weak-type estimate for M_{\star} at the endpoint \frac{n}{n-2} . Note that unlike the continuous counterpart, the discerte lacunary maximal operator M_{lac} fails to be bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for values of p near 1 . More precisely, a counterexample of Zienkiewicz provides construction of lacunary sequence for which the operator M_{lac} is not bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for p<\frac{n}{n-1} . We refer the interested reader to [ 7 , section 7] for the explicit counstruction of the counterexample. Hughes [ 14 ] showed that M_{lac} is bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for p>\frac{n-1}{n-2} and n\geq 5 . This was further improved by Kesler-Lacey-Mena [ 18 ] for the range p>\frac{n-2}{n-3} and n\geq 5 . However, the question of \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) -estimates of M_{lac} is still open in the range \frac{n}{n-1}\leq p\leq\frac{n-2}{n-3} . It is interesting to know for which sequence of radii \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} , the maximal function \mathcal{M}(f)(x)=\sup\limits_{k\geq 1}|M_{\lambda_{k}}f(y)| extends to a bounded operator on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for all p>1 . This question was addressed by Cook [ 9 ] for a class of sequences, known as sparse sequences, defined as follows. Definition 1.1 . We call a sequence \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} sparse, if there exists \mu_{k} such that \lambda_{k}=\mu_{k}! , with \lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}\frac{\log\mu_{k}}{\log k}=\infty. Cook [ 9 ] showed that the maximal function \mathcal{M}(f)(x)=\sup\limits_{k\geq 1}|M_{\lambda_{k}}f(y)| associated with the sparse sequence \lambda_{k}=2^{k}!,k\in{\mathbb{N}} , is bounded on \ell^{p}(\mathbb{Z}^{n}) for p>1 and n\geq 5 . Later, Kesler-Lacey-Mena [ 18 ] generalized this result further by showing that the operator \mathcal{M} is bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for all p>1 and for any sparse sequence \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} . 1.2. Birch-Magyar averages and associated maximal functions The goal of this article is to extend the results mentioned above regarding the \ell^{p}(\mathbb{Z}^{n}) -boundedness of maximal functions associated with sparse sequences in the setting of Birch-Magyar averages. These discrete averages are defined over more general algebraic hypersurfaces. This framework was developed by Birch [ 3 ] and Magyar [ 25 ] . Let us first briefly recall the notion of Birch-Magyar averages. Note that a homogeneous polynomial with integral coefficients is called an integral form. Let \mathfrak{R}(x) be an integral form of degree d>1 in n variables. The Birch rank of \mathfrak{R} , denoted by \mathcal{B}(\mathfrak{R}), is defined as \mathcal{B}(\mathfrak{R})=n-\text{dim}V(\mathfrak{R}), where V(\mathfrak{R})=\{z\in\mathbb{C}^{n}:\partial_{z_{1}}\mathfrak{R}(z)=\partial_{z_{2}}\mathfrak{R}(z)=\cdots=\partial_{z_{n}}\mathfrak{R}(z)=0\}. We use the following standard notation c_{\mathfrak{R}}=\frac{\mathcal{B}(\mathfrak{R})}{(d-1)2^{d-1}}~~\text{and}~~\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}=\frac{1}{6d}\left(\frac{c_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2}-1\right). Note that d\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}1 in n variables is called \phi- regular if there exists a non-singular solution of \mathfrak{R}(x)=1 in the support of \phi and Birch rank of \mathfrak{R} is greater than (d-1)2^{d} . We note that c_{\mathfrak{R}}>2 if \mathfrak{R} is \phi- regular. Consider the counting function r_{\mathfrak{R},\phi}(\lambda)=\sum\limits_{\mathfrak{R}(x)=\lambda}\phi\left(\frac{x}{\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}}\right) . It is known, see [ 3 , 25 ] , that for a \phi- regular form \mathfrak{R} there is an infinite arithmetic progression \Lambda of regular values \lambda\in\Lambda satisfying r_{\mathfrak{R},\phi}(\lambda)\approx\lambda^{\frac{n}{d}-1} . Henceforth, for a \phi- regular form \mathfrak{R} , let \Lambda denote such an infinite arithmetic progression. We refer the readers to [ 3 ] , [ 25 ] , and [ 7 ] for more details on \phi- regular forms. For a \phi- regular form \mathfrak{R}(x) of degree d>1 in n variables and for \lambda\in\Lambda , the Birch-Magyar average of f is defined by M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)=\frac{1}{r_{\mathfrak{R},\phi}(\lambda)}\sum_{y:\mathfrak{R}(y)=\lambda}\phi\left(\frac{y}{\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}}\right)f(x-y). Note that the definition above encompasses the k- spherical averages studied in [ 24 ] , [ 13 ] , [ 12 ] , and [ 1 ] , see Cook and Hughes [ 7 ] for details. Magyar [ 25 ] proved that the discrete maximal function associated with Birch-Magyar averages M^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}_{*}f(x)=\sup_{\lambda\in\Lambda}|M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)|, is bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) when p=2 . Further, the operator M^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}_{*} is bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for p\leq\frac{n}{n-d} . Later, Hughes [ 15 , Appendix A] showed that the operator M^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}_{*} is not bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) for p>\text{max}\left\{\frac{c_{\mathfrak{R}}}{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1},\frac{2(\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}+1)}{2\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}+1}\right\} . However, the sharp range of p for which the operator M^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}_{*} is bounded on \ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) is not known. For a lacunary sequence \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty}=\mathbb{L}\subset\Lambda , Cook-Hughes [ 7 ] proved that the lacunary maximal function M_{lac}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}f(x)=\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}\in\mathbb{L}}|M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)| is bounded on \ell^{p}(\mathbb{Z}^{n}) for p>\frac{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-2}{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-3} , provided the dimension n is sufficiently large. Moreover, for the range 11 and \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k\in{\mathbb{N}}} be a sparse sequence contained in \Lambda , the set of regular values. Then the maximal function \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}f=\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}}|M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)| is bounded on \ell^{p}(\mathbb{Z}^{n}) for all p>1 . Indeed, we shall prove sparse bounds, Theorem 1.3 , for the operator \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi} . Theorem 1.2 can be obtained as a consequence of sparse bounds. Further, note that Theorem 1.2 is a generalization of the result obtained by Kesler-Lacey-Mena [ 18 ] for the spherical case. In order to state the result concerning sparse bounds for the operator \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi} , let us discuss the preliminaries notion for sparse bounds for discrete operators. 1.3. Sparse bounds for discrete operators The study of sparse bounds for discrete operators is a new topic of research. It is well known that appropriate sparse bounds for an operator imply quantitative weighted \ell^{p} -estimates and vector-valued inequalities for the operator under consideration. We refer the reader to Lacey [ 21 ] for sparse bounds for spherical maximal functions in the continuous case and to [ 19 , 20 ] for the discrete case. \frac{1}{p} \frac{1}{q} Z_{3}=(0,1) Z_{0} Z_{2} Z_{1} P_{2}=\left(\frac{n-1}{n+1},\frac{n-1}{n+1}\right) (1,0) \left(\frac{n}{n+1},\frac{n}{n+1}\right) Figure 1 . Sparse bounds for the discrete spherical maximal function hold for points (\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}) in the interior of the polygon with vertices Z_{0} , Z_{1} , Z_{2} , and Z_{3} . Sparse bounds for \mathcal{M} hold for points (\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}) in the interior of the triangle with vertices (0,1) , P_{2} , and (1,0) . A collection of cubes \mathcal{S} in \mathbb{Z}^{n} is called \frac{1}{4}- sparse if for each Q\in\mathcal{S} , there is a subset E_{Q}\subset Q such that the sets \{E_{Q}\subset Q:Q\in\mathcal{S}\} are pairwise disjoint and satisfy |E_{Q}|>\frac{1}{4}|Q| . We define the (p,q)- sparse form \Lambda_{\mathcal{S},p,q} , indexed by the sparse collection \mathcal{S} as \Lambda_{\mathcal{S},p,q}(f,g)=\sum_{Q\in\mathcal{S}}|Q|\langle f\rangle_{Q,p}\langle g\rangle_{Q,q}, where \langle f\rangle_{Q,p}=\left(\frac{1}{|Q|}\sum\limits_{m\in Q}|f(m)|^{p}\right)^{\frac{1}{p}} and we set \langle f\rangle_{Q}=\langle f\rangle_{Q,1}. For a sublinear operator T , let \|T\|_{p,q} the (p,q)- sparse norm of T . It is defined as the smallest constant C>0 such that |\langle Tf,g\rangle|\leq C\sup\limits_{\mathcal{S}}\Lambda_{\mathcal{S},p,q}(f,g), where \langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle is the standard inner product on \ell^{2}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n}) . Kesler [ 20 ] proved the sparse bounds for local discrete spherical maximal function. Later Kesler-Lacey-Mena [ 19 ] simplified the proof and extended the sparse bounds for the full discrete spherical maximal function M_{*} . More precisely, they proved that \|M_{\star}\|_{p,q}<\infty whenever \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right) lies in the interior of the polygon with vertices Z_{0}=\left(\frac{n-2}{n},\frac{2}{n}\right),\;Z_{1}=\left(\frac{n-2}{n},\frac{n-2}{n}\right),\;Z_{2}=\left(\frac{n^{3}-4n^{2}+4n+1}{n^{3}-2n^{2}+n-2},\frac{n^{3}-4n^{2}+6n-7}{n^{3}-2n^{2}+n-2}\right),\;\text{and}\;Z_{3}=(0,1) , see Figure 1 . We prove the following sparse bounds for the maximal functions associated with the Birch-Magyar averages. Theorem 1.3 . Let \mathfrak{R} be a \phi- regular integral form of degree d>1 in n variables and \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k\in{\mathbb{N}}} be a sparse sequence contained in the set of regular values \Lambda . Then, the maximal function \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}f(x)=\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}}|M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)| satisfies the following sparse bounds \|\mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi}\|_{p,q}<\infty~\quad\text{for all}\;\left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in S_{n}, where S_{n} is the open triangle with vertices S_{1}=(0,1) , S_{2}=\left(\frac{1+2\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2(1+\eta_{\mathfrak{R}})},\frac{1+2\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2(1+\eta_{\mathfrak{R}})}\right) , and S_{3}=(1,0) . The proof of Theorem 1.3 relies on the method of High-Low analysis of the operator. We exploit the ideas from Kesler-Lacey-Mena [ 19 ] along with the method of estimating the error terms from [ 7 , 25 ] . In order to complete our proof, we require the sparse bounds of the continuous analogue of the discrete maximal operator \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi} . Since, the sparse bounds for the continuous analogue are not written explicitly in the literature, we provide the required details in the Appendix A for the convenience of the reader. Further, we require scale-free sparse bounds for the single averaging operator M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} for all \lambda\in\Lambda . Such estimates are of independent significance. The following result concerns the scale-free bounds for the Birch-Magyar averages. Theorem 1.4 . Let \mathfrak{R} be a \phi- regular form of degree d>1 in n variables and S_{n} be the open triangle with vertices (0,1) , (1,0) , and \left(\frac{1+2\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2(1+\eta_{\mathfrak{R}})},\frac{1+2\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2(1+\eta_{\mathfrak{R}})}\right) . For \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in S_{n} , there exists a constant C_{p,\mathfrak{R}} , independent of \lambda\in\Lambda , such that the following inequality holds \langle M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle\leq C_{p,\mathfrak{R}}|E|\langle f\rangle_{E,p}\langle g\rangle_{E,q}. In particular, for \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in S_{n} , we have \|M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}\|_{\ell^{p}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n})\to\ell^{q^{\prime}}({\mathbb{Z}}^{n})}\lesssim\lambda^{n\left(\frac{1}{q^{\prime}}-\frac{1}{p}\right)}. The \ell^{p} -improving estimates for single scale spherical averages were proved by [ 15 , 17 ] . They used refined Kloosterman sum estimates to improve the range of boundedness. However, we would like to remark here that such refined estimates are not available for the Birch-Magyar setting. An improvement for the Kloosterman sum in the Birch-Magyar case would lead to a better range of indices than those obtained in Theorem 1.4 . Nonetheless, using the estimates in [ 15 ] , we can improve the sparse bounds obtained for the maximal operator in Theorem 1.3 in the spherical case. More precisely, we have the following result. Theorem 1.5 . Let n\geq 5 and P_{n} be the open triangle with vertices P_{1}=(0,1) , P_{2}=\left(\frac{n-1}{n+1},\frac{n-1}{n+1}\right) , and P_{3}=(1,0) . Then for all \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in P_{n} , we have the sparse bound \|\mathcal{M}\|_{p,q}<\infty. 1.4. Organization of the paper The proofs of Theorem 1.3 and Theorem 1.5 are given in Section 3 . Section 2 contains the proof of Theorem 1.4 . Appendix A is devoted to proving sparse bounds for the continuous analogue of the operator \mathcal{M}^{\mathfrak{R},\phi} . 1.5. Notations We use the following notation throughout the paper. (1) We write 1_{A} to denote the characteristic function of the set A. (2) For a ring K , we use the notation a\cdot b (for vectors a,b\in K^{n} ) to denote the sum \sum\limits_{1\leq j\leq n}a_{j}b_{j} . (3) The notation \star denotes convolution on any group G , provided it is well defined. (4) The torus (\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^{n} identified with the cube [-\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}]^{n} and it is denoted by \mathbb{T}^{n} . (5) For a function f defined on \mathbb{Z}^{n}(\text{ or }\mathbb{R}^{n}) , we denote its \mathbb{Z}^{n}(\text{ or }\mathbb{R}^{n}) -Fourier transform by \widehat{f}(\xi) for \xi\in\mathbb{T}^{n}(\text{ or }\mathbb{R}^{n}) . (6) The notation M\lesssim_{a}N or N\gtrsim_{a}M means that there exists an absolute constant 0N\}}M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f. We set M_{1,1}f:=1_{\{\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}\leq N\}}M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f . For \lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}\geq N , by following the approach of Magyar [ 25 , Lemma 1] , we decompose the operator further as M_{\lambda,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}=C_{\lambda}+M_{2,1} , where the multiplier m_{2,1} of the error term given by the convolution operator M_{2,1} satisfies (2.3) \displaystyle\sup\limits_{\xi}|m_{2,1}(\xi)|\lesssim_{\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}\lambda^{-\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}, and the multiplier corresponding to the operator C_{\lambda} is given by c_{\lambda}(\xi)=\sum_{1\leq q\leq\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{q}}\sum_{a\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{\times}}e_{q}(-a\lambda)F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right). Here in the expression above, \zeta is a radial Schwartz function on \mathbb{R}^{n} such that \widehat{\zeta}(\xi) is identically 1 for |\xi|\leq\frac{1}{2} and 0 if |\xi|\geq 1 with \widehat{\zeta}_{q}(\xi)=\widehat{\zeta}(q\xi) . The measure d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}} is defined by d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}(y)=\phi(y)\frac{d\mu(y)}{|\nabla\mathfrak{R}(y)|}, where d\mu is euclidean surface measure on the hypersurface \{x\in\mathbb{R}^{n}:\mathfrak{R}(x)=1\} . Let F_{q}(a,b) denote the normalized Weyl sum defined as F_{q}(a,b)=\frac{1}{q^{n}}\sum_{m\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}e\left(\mathfrak{R}(m)\frac{a}{q}+\frac{m\cdot b}{q}\right), where a\in\mathbb{Z}_{q} and b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n} . We have the following estimate [ 7 , p. 3862] for the quantity F_{q}(a,b) : |F_{q}(a,b)|\lesssim q^{-c_{\mathfrak{R}}},\quad\text{for}\quad(a,q)=1. We will require to decompose the operator C_{\lambda} further as follows, C_{\lambda}=M_{1,2}+M_{2,2}+M_{2,3}, where the operators M_{1,2} , M_{2,2} , and M_{2,3} correspond to the multipliers m_{1,2} , m_{2,2} , and m_{2,3} respectively. These are given by \displaystyle m_{1,2}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{1\leq q\leq N}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{q}}\sum_{a\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{\times}}e_{q}(-a\lambda)F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{\frac{q\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}}{N}}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right), \displaystyle m_{2,2}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{1\leq q\leq N}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{q}}\sum_{a\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{\times}}e_{q}(-a\lambda)F_{q}(a,b)\left(\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)-\widehat{\zeta_{\frac{q\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}}{N}}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right), \displaystyle m_{2,3}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{NC\langle f\rangle_{3Q} for a large constant C . Recall the definition of admissible stopping time for a given dyadic cube. For a dyadic cube Q and f=1_{F} with support inside Q , a map \tau:Q\rightarrow\{\lambda_{k}\} is called an admissible stopping time if for any subcube P\subset Q and some large constant C with \langle f\rangle_{P}>C\langle f\rangle_{Q} we have \min\limits_{x\in P}\tau(x)>\ell(P). Observe that, for a suitable choice of constant C , we have \sum_{P\in\mathcal{Q}_{Q}}|P|\leq\frac{1}{4}|Q|, and for an appropriate choice of admissible stopping time \tau , we get that (3.1) \displaystyle\left\langle\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}\leq\ell(Q)}M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\right\rangle\leq\left\langle M_{\tau,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\right\rangle+\sum_{P\in\mathcal{Q}_{Q}}\left\langle\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}\leq\ell(P)}M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}(f1_{3P}),(g1_{P})\right\rangle. Therefore, the desired sparse bounds follow from the following estimate (3.2) \displaystyle\frac{1}{|Q|}\langle M_{\tau,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle\lesssim\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{p}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{q}}, along with a recursive argument on the second term in the equation ( 3.1 ). This will prove the theorem for characteristic functions. Thereafter, we can conclude the result for general class of functions using the interpolation of sparse bounds as in [ 19 , Lemma 4.1] . Therefore, in order to prove Theorem 1.3 , we need to establish the estimate ( 3.2 ) for a suitable stopping time \tau with a large cube Q such that f=1_{F} is supported on 3Q and g=1_{G} is supported on Q and \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in S_{n} . In this proof, we use a continuous sparse bound estimate that we prove in the last section. Let us fix a point \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in S_{n} . From the definition of \mu_{l} it is clear that \mu_{l}\approx l^{\alpha(l)} where \alpha(l)\rightarrow\infty as l\rightarrow\infty . Therefore, for a constant N_{\circ}>0 we have that \mu_{N^{\epsilon}}>N^{d} for N>N_{\circ} and d>1 . We claim that for sufficiently small \epsilon\in(0,1) , stopping time \tau taking values in \left\{\lambda_{k}\in\Lambda:\lambda_{k}\text{ is a sparse sequence}\right\} , and a large natural number N , we can decompose the operator as M_{\tau,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f\leq\mathcal{T}_{1}f+\mathcal{T}_{2}f such that (3.3) \displaystyle\langle\mathcal{T}_{1}f,g\rangle\lesssim N^{\epsilon}|Q|\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{p}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{q}}, (3.4) \displaystyle\langle\mathcal{T}_{2}f,g\rangle\lesssim N^{-c_{\mathfrak{R}}+2}|Q|\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{2}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{2}}. Note that the constants in the inequalities above depend on p , q , and \epsilon . Likewise the previous section, estimates ( 3.3 ) and ( 3.4 ) imply that (3.5) \displaystyle|Q|^{-1}\langle M_{\tau,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle\lesssim N^{\epsilon}\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{p}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{q}}+N^{-c_{\mathfrak{R}}+2}\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{2}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{2}}. Observe that the choice N=\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{p-2}{2p(c_{\mathfrak{R}}-2+\epsilon)}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{q-2}{2q(c_{\mathfrak{R}}-2+\epsilon)}} optimize the right hand side of ( 3.5 ). Therefore, substituting the value of N in ( 3.5 ) and taking \epsilon very small, we get the desired estimate |Q|^{-1}\langle M_{\tau,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle\lesssim\langle f\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{p}}\langle g\rangle_{Q}^{\frac{1}{q}}. 3.1. Decomposition of M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} : For each k\in{\mathbb{N}} , we decompose the average in the following way \displaystyle M_{\tau(\cdot),\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x) \displaystyle=1_{\{\tau(\cdot)\leq\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}\}}(x)M_{\tau(\cdot),\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x)+1_{\{\tau(\cdot)>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}\}}(x)M_{\tau(\cdot),\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x). We set M_{1,1}f=1_{\{\tau(\cdot)\leq\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}\}}(x)M_{\tau(\cdot),\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x) . For a fixed \lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]} , let M^{k}_{1,2} be the operator associated with the multiplier \Omega_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi)=\sum_{0\leq a\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}\}}(x)M_{\tau(\cdot),\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x) \displaystyle\leq \displaystyle\sup_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}|M^{k}_{1,2}f(x)|+\sup_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}|M^{k}_{2,1}f(x)|+\sup_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}|M^{k}_{2,2}f(x)|+\sup_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}|M^{k}_{2,3}f(x)| \displaystyle:= \displaystyle M_{1,2}f(x)+M_{2,1}f(x)+M_{2,2}f(x)+M_{2,3}f(x), where the operators M^{k}_{2,1} , M^{k}_{2,2} and M^{k}_{2,3} are associated with the multipliers m^{k}_{2,1} , m^{k}_{2,2} and m^{k}_{2,3} respectively, defined as \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,1}(\xi) \displaystyle=\widehat{w}_{\mathfrak{R},\lambda_{k}}(\xi)-\sum_{q=1}^{\infty}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}e_{q}(-\lambda_{k}a)F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right), \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,2}(\xi) \displaystyle=\Omega_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi)-\sum_{q=1}^{N}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right),\;\text{and} \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,3}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{q>N}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}e_{q}(-\lambda_{k}a)F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}.\right)\right) The rest of the proof is devoted to establishing the estimate ( 3.3 ) for terms M_{1,1} and M_{1,2} and the estimate ( 3.4 ) for terms M_{2,1} , M_{2,2} , and M_{2,3} . 3.2. Estimate for M_{1,1} Note that by the estimate for single averages from Theorem 1.4 we have that \langle M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle\lesssim|Q|\langle f\rangle_{Q,p}\langle g\rangle_{Q,q},\quad k\in{\mathbb{N}}. Therefore, \displaystyle\langle M_{1,1}f,g\rangle \displaystyle\leq\langle\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}\leq\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle \displaystyle\leq\sum_{k\leq[N^{\epsilon}]}\langle M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f,g\rangle \displaystyle\leq N^{\epsilon}|Q|\langle f\rangle_{Q,p}\langle g\rangle_{Q,q}. 3.3. Estimate for M_{1,2} We write the multiplier \Omega_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi)=v_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi)s(\xi) , where \displaystyle v_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{L}}\widehat{\zeta_{L}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{L}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left({\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{L}\right)\right), \displaystyle\text{and}\quad s(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq a2^{d}(d-1) . Then, \frac{1}{L^{n-1}}\sum_{x\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{L}}1_{\{\mathfrak{R}(x)\equiv 0\text{ mod }L\}}(x)\lesssim 1. We shall prove the claimed \ell^{p} estimate at p=1 and p=\infty. The general case follows by standard interpolation argument. Note that it is enough to show \|s^{\vee}\|_{1}\lesssim 1 . Consider \displaystyle s^{\vee}(-x) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq a\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}\lambda_{k}^{-\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}\Big)\|f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\lambda_{N^{\epsilon}}^{-\eta_{\mathfrak{R}}}\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}\lesssim N^{-(c_{\mathfrak{R}}-2)}\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}. 3.6. Estimate for M_{2,2} We have, \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,2}(\xi) \displaystyle=\Omega_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi)-\sum_{q=1}^{N}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}N\end{subarray}}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}g\left(\frac{a}{q}\right). Using the identity as above, we write the multiplier as m^{k}_{2,2}=m^{k}_{2,2,1}+m^{k}_{2,2,2} , where \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,2,1}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}N\end{subarray}}F_{L}(\bar{a},\bar{b})\widehat{\zeta_{2L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\right), with the index \nu=\text{gcd}(\bar{a},\bar{b},L) for which we have F_{L}(\bar{a},\bar{b})=F_{\frac{L}{\nu}}(\frac{\bar{a}}{\nu},\frac{\bar{b}}{\nu}) . Thus we have M_{2,2}f(x)\leq M_{2,2,1}f(x)+M_{2,2,2}f(x), where M_{2,2,1} and M_{2,2,2} are the operators defined as M_{2,2,j}f(x)=\sup_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]}}|(m^{k}_{2,2,j})^{\vee}\star f(x)|,\;j=1,2. 3.7. Estimate for M_{2,2,1} : Observe that \widehat{\zeta_{2L}}(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L})-\widehat{\zeta_{\frac{L}{\nu}}}(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}) is supported for |2L(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L})|\geq\frac{1}{2} ; i.e., |\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}|\geq\frac{1}{4L} . Therefore, in the support of \widehat{\zeta_{2L}}(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L})-\widehat{\zeta_{\frac{L}{\nu}}}(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}) the term |\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}(\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}_{k}(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}))| is bounded by \left(\frac{L}{\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}}\right)^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1} . Also, for k>N_{\circ} , \lambda_{k}>N^{d}!>(N!)^{d}=L^{d} . \displaystyle\|M_{2,2,1}f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\sum_{\lambda_{k}>\lambda_{N^{\epsilon}}}\left(\sup_{\xi}|m^{k}_{2,2,1}(\xi)|\right)\|f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}\lambda_{N^{\epsilon}}}\left(\frac{L}{\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}}\right)^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}\frac{1}{L^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}}} \displaystyle\lesssim\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}N\end{subarray}}F_{L}(\bar{a},\bar{b})\widehat{\zeta_{2L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\right) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}N\end{subarray}}F_{L}(\bar{a},\bar{b})\widehat{\zeta_{2L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\widehat{\zeta_{L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\right). Since \widehat{\zeta_{L}}\left(\xi-\frac{b_{1}}{L}\right) and \widehat{\zeta_{2L}}\left(\xi-\frac{b_{2}}{L}\right) have disjoint supports for b_{1}\neq b_{2} , we can write M^{k}_{2,2,2}=V_{\lambda_{k}}\circ S, where V_{\lambda_{k}} and S are the operators corresponding to the multipliers v_{\lambda_{k}} and s respectively given by \displaystyle s(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}N\end{subarray}}F_{L}(\bar{a},\bar{b})\widehat{\zeta_{2L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\quad\text{and} \displaystyle v_{\lambda_{k}}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\bar{b}\in\mathbb{Z}^{n}_{L}\\ \frac{L}{\nu}>N\end{subarray}}\widehat{\zeta_{L}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left({\lambda^{\frac{1}{d}}_{k}}\left(\xi-\frac{\bar{b}}{L}\right)\right). Invoking Proposition 3.6 and Theorem A.1 , we get that \|\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}}|V_{\lambda_{k}}f|\|_{\ell^{p}}\lesssim\|f\|_{\ell^{p}} for p>1 ; in particular, note that the inequality as above holds true for p=2 . This gives us \displaystyle\|M_{2,2,2}f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\|Sf\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\sup\limits_{\xi}|s(\xi)|\|f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\sum_{0\leq\bar{a}\lambda_{[N^{\epsilon}]} and q>N , we write the multiplier m^{k}_{2,3} as \displaystyle m^{k}_{2,3}(\xi) \displaystyle=\sum_{q>N}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}\sum_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{q}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}\left(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}\left(\xi-\frac{b}{q}\right)\right), \displaystyle=\left(\sum\limits_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}\widehat{\zeta_{q}}(\xi-\frac{b}{q})\widehat{d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R}}}(\lambda_{k}^{\frac{1}{d}}(\xi-\frac{b}{q}))\right)\left(\sum\limits_{a\in U_{q}}\sum\limits_{b\in\mathbb{Z}_{q}^{n}}F_{q}(a,b)\widehat{\zeta_{2q}}(\xi-\frac{b}{q})\right). Using Proposition 3.6 and Theorem A.1 , we get that the maximal operator corresponding to the first term in the expression above is bounded on \ell^{2} . Hence, \displaystyle\|M_{2,3}f\|_{\ell^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}\sum_{q>N}\sum_{a\in U_{q}}|F_{q}(a,b)| \displaystyle\lesssim\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}\sum_{q>N}\frac{1}{q^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}} \displaystyle\lesssim\frac{1}{N^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}}\|f\|_{\ell^{2}}. This concludes the proof of Theorem 1.3 . Proof of Theorem 1.5 : . The proof is similar to that of Theorem 1.3 with the exception that we use the following bound for the single scale average instead of Theorem 1.4 . For any \delta>0 , \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right)\in P_{n} and any cube Q\subset{\mathbb{Z}}^{n} , there exists C>0 , independent of \lambda , such that \langle M_{\lambda}f,g\rangle\leq C\lambda^{\delta}\langle f\rangle_{Q,p}\langle g\rangle_{Q,q}|Q|,\;\forall\;f,g\;\text{supported in }Q. The estimate above is a direct consequence of the following \ell^{p}- improving property of M_{\lambda} obtained in [ 15 ] , Lemma 3.9 ( [ 15 ] ) . Let n\geq 5 and \frac{n+1}{n-1}\leq p\leq 2 . Then for each \delta>0 there exists a constant C_{p,\delta} such that for all \lambda\in{\mathbb{N}} , we have the following estimate \|M_{\lambda}f\|_{\ell^{p^{\prime}}}\lesssim_{p,\delta}\lambda^{\delta-n\left(\frac{2}{p}-1\right)}\|f\|_{\ell^{p}}. ∎ Appendix A Sparse bounds for a continuous maximal operator In this section we discuss the continuous analogue of the lacunary maximal function associated with the average M_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} . As mentioned previously, due to non-availability of results in the desired framework in the literature; we present the proofs here. Let \{\lambda_{k}\}_{k=1}^{\infty} be a lacunary sequence in the set of regular values \Lambda . Consider the lacunary maximal function defined by \mathcal{A}_{\mathfrak{R},*}f(x)=\sup\limits_{\lambda_{k}}\mathcal{A}_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x), where \mathcal{A}_{\lambda_{k},\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f(x):=\frac{1}{\lambda_{k}^{\frac{n}{d}-1}}f*d\sigma_{\mathfrak{R},\lambda_{k}}(x)=f*d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},\lambda_{k}}(x), where \phi and \mathfrak{R} are as in Section 1 . We have the following sparse bound for the operator \mathcal{A}_{\mathfrak{R},*} , which were used to prove Theorem 1.3 . Theorem A.1 . The sparse bound \|\mathcal{A}_{\mathfrak{R},*}\|_{p,q} holds for all points \left(\frac{1}{p},\frac{1}{q}\right) belonging to the interior of the triangle V_{n} with vertices (1,0) , \left(\frac{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}},\frac{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}}\right) , and (0,1) . The sparse bounds as above are indeed a consequence of the L^{p} -improving properties of single scale avarages . This observation was obtained in the work of [ 21 ] and further used by Oberlin [ 26 ] to obtain certain endpoint sparse bounds for Radon transforms. We also refer the readers to [ 2 ] . We use the following result Lemma A.2 . [ 26 , Theorem 1.3] Suppose \sigma is a finite measure supported on the unit ball with |\widehat{\sigma}(\xi)|\lesssim|\xi|^{-\beta}, for some \beta>0 , and 10 . Suppose that \{T_{j}\} is a sequence of linear (or sublinear) operators such that for some 1\leq p_{1},p_{2}<\infty , and 1\leq q_{1},q_{2}<\infty , \|T_{j}(f)\|_{L^{q_{1}}}\leq M_{1}2^{\epsilon_{1}j}\|f\|_{L^{p_{1}}},~~\|T_{j}(f)\|_{L^{q_{2}}}\leq M_{2}2^{-\epsilon_{2}j}\|f\|_{L^{p_{2}}}. Then T=\sum_{j}T_{j} is bounded from L^{p,1} to L^{q,\infty} , i.e. \|T(f)\|_{L^{q,\infty}}\lesssim M^{\theta}_{1}M^{1-\theta}_{2}\|f\|_{L^{p,1}}, where \theta=\frac{\epsilon_{2}}{\epsilon_{1}+\epsilon_{2}} , \frac{1}{q}=\frac{\theta}{q_{1}}+\frac{1-\theta}{q_{2}} and \frac{1}{p}=\frac{\theta}{p_{1}}+\frac{1-\theta}{p_{2}} . Proof of Proposition A.3 . Since \|d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}\|_{1}\lesssim 1 , it follows that the operator \mathcal{A}_{1,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} is bounded in L^{p} for p=1 and p=\infty . Next, we prove that \mathcal{A}_{1,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} is bounded from L^{\frac{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1},1} to L^{2c_{\mathfrak{R}},\infty} . Note that the desired L^{p}\rightarrow L^{q} -boundedness of \mathcal{A}_{1,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}} in the interior of the triangle D_{n} follows by interpolation. Let \psi be a Schwartz function such that \widehat{\psi}(\xi)=\begin{cases}1,&\text{if}\hskip 5.69054pt|\xi|\leq 1,\\ 0,&\text{if}\hskip 5.69054pt|\xi|\geq 2.\end{cases} Define \widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi)=\widehat{\psi}\left(\frac{\xi}{N}\right) and write \widehat{f}(\xi)\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi) as \widehat{f}(\xi)\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi)=\widehat{f}(\xi)\widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi)\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi)+\widehat{f}(\xi)(1-\widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi))\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi). Notice that, \psi_{N^{-1}}*{d\bar{\sigma}}_{\mathfrak{R},1}(x) is bounded by \frac{N}{(1+|x|)^{M}} . If \mathfrak{R}(x):=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n}|x_{i}|^{2} , a proof of this can be found in [ 11 , Lemma 6.5.3] . Further, since the proof depends on the dimensionality of the measure, this estimate is valid for the measure \bar{d\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1} over the variety \{x\in{\mathbb{R}}^{n}:\mathfrak{R}(x)=1\} , where \mathfrak{R} is any integral form of degree d . We refer to [ 15 , p 970] , where this estimate is used to bound the averages. Consider, \displaystyle\|f*\psi_{N^{-1}}*{d\bar{\sigma}}_{\mathfrak{R},1}\|_{L^{\infty}} \displaystyle\lesssim\|\psi_{N^{-1}}*{d\bar{\sigma}}_{\mathfrak{R},1}\|_{L^{\infty}}\|f\|_{L^{1}} \displaystyle\lesssim N\|f\|_{L^{1}}. Next, using the support of \widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi) and the bound of \widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi) mentioned earlier, we get that \displaystyle\|f*(1-\psi_{N^{-1}})*d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}\|_{L^{2}} \displaystyle=\|\widehat{f}(\xi)(1-\widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi))\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi)\|_{L^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\sup\limits_{\xi}|(1-\widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi))\widehat{d\bar{\sigma}_{\mathfrak{R},1}}(\xi)|\|f\|_{L^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim\frac{1}{(1+|\xi|)^{c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1}}|1-\widehat{\psi_{N^{-1}}}(\xi)|\|f\|_{L^{2}} \displaystyle\lesssim N^{1-c_{\mathfrak{R}}}\|f\|_{L^{2}}. Using Lemma A.4 , it follows that \|\mathcal{A}_{1,\phi}^{\mathfrak{R}}f\|_{L^{2c_{\mathfrak{R}},\infty}}\lesssim\|f\|_{L^{\frac{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}}{2c_{\mathfrak{R}}-1},1}}. This completes the proof. ∎