Black holes and covariance in effective quantum gravity: A solution without Cauchy horizons Cong Zhang, Jerzy Lewandowski, Yongge Ma, Jinsong Yang Abstract The issue of general covariance in effective quantum gravity models within the Hamiltonian framework is addressed. The previously proposed equations for the covariance condition in spherically symmetric models are explicitly derived. By solving this equation, a new effective Hamiltonian constraint is obtained, incorporating free functions that can account for quantum gravity effects. The resulting spacetime structure is analyzed by specifying the free functions. Remarkably, in this model, the classical singularity is replaced by a region where the metric asymptotically approaches a Schwarzschild-de Sitter one with negative mass. Thus, this new quantum-corrected black hole model avoids the Cauchy horizons presented typically in previously studied models. The covariant approach is also applicable to matter coupling in the models. I Introduction It is widely believed that Einstein’s general relativity (GR) is not the final theory of spacetime. One significant reason is the inconsistency between the quantum mechanical description of matter and classical spacetime description of gravity [ 1 ] . Another reason is the presence of gravitational singularities, generally appeared in GR [ 2 ] . A significant approach to meet these challenges is search for a consistent theory of quantum gravity (QG) [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . To explore QG effects, one approach is to treat QG semiclassically as an effective field theory [ 7 ] . In this treatment, the effective gravity is still described by a metric tensor, but the equations of motion should be modified to account for quantum effects. Various theories of canonical QG are based on the Hamiltonian formulation (see, e.g., [ 8 ] for the Hamiltonian formulation of general relativity). In the Hamiltonian framework of classical GR, the dynamics are governed by the diffeomorphism and Hamiltonian constraints. Consequently, in a semiclassical theory emerged from certain canonical QG, QG effects are expected to be manifested through some modifications to those constraints. However, if the effective spacetime description was valid, the Hamiltonian formulation would require a 3+1 decomposition of the spacetime. Then the issue of general covariance arises naturally: under what conditions does a given 3+1 model in the Hamiltonian formulation describe a generally covariant spacetime theory. This has been a long-standing issue open to debate, particularly in the context of effective theories derived from symmetry-reduced models of canonical QG [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . General covariance, when translated into the Hamiltonian framework, can be understood by interpreting GR as a totally constrained system with first-class constraints. A system of constraints is of first-class if the constraints form a closed algebra under the Poisson bracket, and the theory is totally constrained if the Hamiltonian is simply a linear combination of these constraints. According to the Dirac-Bergmann theory of constrained Hamiltonian systems [ 20 ] , first-class constraints correspond to the gauge symmetries of the system. More precisely, the Poisson bracket of any linear combination of the constraints with a function on phase space gives rise to an infinitesimal gauge transformation of that function. In the Hamiltonian framework of classical GR, the spacetime metric is a tensor-valued function on the phase space. Therefore, general covariance requires that its infinitesimal gauge transformation generated by the constraints matches its Lie derivative on a spacetime manifold. However, a subtlety arises since the lapse function and shift vector, as the components of spacetime metric, are usually treated as Lagrangian multipliers rather than phase space variables. The meaning of the gauge transformations of the spacetime metric when the lapse function and shift vector are involved will be clarified in Sec. II (see also [ 21 , 22 ] for previous discussions). Despite this subtlety, the overall concept of general covariance remains unaffected. Thus, the concept of general covariance relies on two key elements: the metric and the constraints. To maintain general covariance, these two elements have to be carefully aligned. In this paper, it is assumed that the spacetime metric is modified into an effective one due to the QG effects, while keeping its form fixed. Based on this effective metric, the corresponding expression of the constraints can be restricted to ensure that the effective canonical theory remains covariant. Concretely, we will keep the diffeomorphism constraint in its classical form while leaving the Hamiltonian constraint unknown to incorporate QG effects. This guarantees that the diffeomorphism constraint still generates spatial diffeomorphism transformations. To determine the form of the Hamiltonian constraint, we require the constraint algebra to remain closed, mirroring the classical structure with an additional factor accounting for QG effects. The resulting Hamiltonian constraint will be referred to as the effective Hamiltonian constraint. Since QG effects are expected to resolve the classical singularity, the effective Hamiltonian constraint should lead to the formation of regular black holes (BHs) [ 23 ] . In previous works on effective models of canonical QG [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 14 , 27 , 18 , 28 ] , one usually introduces a specific matter field to partially fix the gauge freedoms of spacetime diffeomorphisms. The Hamiltonian in this preferred gauge is then quantized, yielding an effective Hamiltonian. Thus, the covariance issue is somehow avoided by working within a fixed gauge. However, as discussed in [ 19 ] , several issues arise within this framework. First, if one moved away from the preferred gauge, the effective Hamiltonian had to be modified to ensure that the resulting metric remains diffeomorphically equivalent to the one obtained in the fixed gauge. This modified effective Hamiltonian would no longer be directly derived from the same quantization scheme, suggesting that the quantization strategy depends on the choice of gauge. Additionally, the reliance on the matter fields poses an obstacle to defining a pure-gravity vacuum, as the presence of matter is inherently tied to the gauge-fixing procedure. In this paper, we will focus on the spherically symmetric vacuum gravity, where, classically, the only nontrivial solutions to Einstein’s equations are the Schwarzschild BH and the Kantowski-Sachs universe. By considering the vacuum case, the gauge fixing with matter fields will not be performed, since our aim is to derive effective Hamiltonian constraints that apply uniformly across different gauges. Once the effective Hamiltonian constraints are obtained, matter coupling can be suitably introduced [ 29 ] . This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , the notion of general covariance in the spherically symmetric models of classical theory is discussed in details. Based on this notion, the conditions ensuring covariance for the spherically symmetric effective models of QG are proposed in Sec. III . In Sec. IV , those conditions are formulated into tractable “covariance equations” for the effective Hamiltonian constraint that can describe a covariant model. A new solution to the covariance equations is proposed in Sec. V . In Sec. VI , the free functions of the solution are fixed, and the causal structure of the resulting spacetime is discussed. The issue of matter coupling in the covariant model is discussed in Sec. VII . Finally, our results are summarized in Sec. VIII . The codes for some derivations in this paper are available in [ 30 ] . II General covariance in classical theory Let us start with the Hamiltonian formulation of the spherically symmetric GR in connection formalism. The spatial 3-manifold is denoted as \Sigma=\mathbb{X}\times\mathbb{S}^{2} carrying the {\mathrm{SU(2)}} action, where \mathbb{X} denotes an 1-D manifold and \mathbb{S}^{2} is the 2-sphere. Let (x,\theta,\phi) denote the coordinates of \Sigma adapted to the {\mathrm{SU(2)}} action. The phase space, denoted by \mathcal{P} , comprises of fields (K_{I},E^{I}) (I=1,2) defined on the quotient manifold \Sigma/{\mathrm{SU(2)}}\cong\mathbb{X} (see, e.g., [ 31 , 32 , 33 ] for more details of the kinematical structure). The Ashtekar-Barbero variables (A_{a}^{i},E^{b}_{j}) (see, e.g., [ 34 , 35 ] ) read \displaystyle A_{a}^{i}\tau_{i}\differential x^{a} \displaystyle=K_{a}^{i}\tau_{i}\differential x^{a}+\Gamma_{a}^{i}\tau_{i}\differential x^{a}, (1) \displaystyle E^{a}_{i}\tau^{i}\partial_{a} \displaystyle=E^{1}\sin\theta\tau_{3}\partial_{x}+E^{2}\sin\theta\tau_{1}\partial_{\theta}+E^{2}\tau_{2}\partial_{\phi}, where \Gamma_{a}^{i} is the spin connection compatible with the densitized triad E^{a}_{i} , and K_{a}^{i} is the extrinsic curvature 1-form given by K_{a}^{i}\tau_{i}\differential x^{a}=K_{1}\tau_{3}\differential x+K_{2}\tau_{1}\differential\theta+K_{2}\sin\theta\tau_{2}\differential\phi. (2) Here we adopt the convention \tau_{j}=-i\sigma_{j}/2 with \sigma_{j} being the Pauli matrices. The non-vanishing Poisson brackets between the phase space variables are \displaystyle\{K_{1}(x),E^{1}(y)\}= \displaystyle 2G\delta(x,y), (3) \displaystyle\{K_{2}(x),E^{2}(y)\}= \displaystyle G\delta(x,y), where G is the gravitational constant. This system is totally constrained, so that its dynamics is encoded in a set of first-class constraints: the diffeomorphism constraint H_{x} and the Hamiltonian constraint H . They are expressed as H_{x}=\frac{1}{2G}\left(-K_{1}\partial_{x}E^{1}+2E^{2}\partial_{x}K_{2}\right), (4) and \displaystyle H= \displaystyle-\frac{1}{2G\sqrt{E^{1}}}\Bigg[E^{2}+2E^{1}K_{1}K_{2}+E^{2}(K_{2})^{2} (5) \displaystyle+\frac{3(\partial_{x}E^{1})^{2}}{4E^{2}}-\partial_{x}\left(\frac{E^{1}\partial_{x}E^{1}}{E^{2}}\right)\Big]. The Poisson algebra of the constraints reads \displaystyle\{H_{x}[N^{x}_{1}],H_{x}[N^{x}_{2}]\} \displaystyle=H_{x}[N^{x}_{1}\partial_{x}N^{x}_{2}-N^{x}_{2}\partial_{x}N^{x}_{1}], (6) \displaystyle\{H[N],H_{x}[M^{x}]\} \displaystyle=-H[M^{x}\partial_{x}N], \displaystyle\{H[N_{1}],H[N_{2}]\} \displaystyle=H_{x}[S(N_{1}\partial_{x}N_{2}-N_{2}\partial_{x}N_{1})], with the structure function S given by S=\frac{E^{1}}{(E^{2})^{2}}, (7) where the abbreviation F[g]=\int_{\Sigma}F(x)g(x)\differential x is applied. For a given vector field N^{x}\partial_{x} , it is straightforward to check that \displaystyle\{K_{1}\differential x,H_{x}[N^{x}]\} \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{N^{x}\partial_{x}}(K_{1}\differential x), (8) \displaystyle\{E^{1},H_{x}[N^{x}]\} \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{N^{x}\partial_{x}}E^{1}, \displaystyle\{K_{2},H_{x}[N^{x}]\} \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{N^{x}\partial_{x}}K_{2}, \displaystyle\{E^{2}\differential x,H_{x}[N^{x}]\} \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{N^{x}\partial_{x}}(E^{2}\differential x), where \mathcal{L}_{N^{x}\partial_{x}} denotes the Lie derivative with respect to N^{x}\partial_{x} . Therefore, H_{x}[N^{x}] generates the spatial diffeomorphism transformations along N^{x}\partial_{x} . In addition, K_{1} and E^{2} should be treated as scalar densities with weight 1 on \mathbb{X} , while K_{2} and E^{1} are scalars. II.1 Constructing spacetimes from physical states In the phase space \mathcal{P} , the constraint surface \overline{\mathcal{P}} is defined as the subspace consisting of points of (K_{I},E^{I}) that vanish the constraints H and H_{x} . For an arbitrary scalar field \lambda and an arbitrary vector field \lambda^{x}\partial_{x} on \mathbb{X} , the linear combination H[\lambda]+H_{x}[\lambda^{x}] , as a function on \mathcal{P} , generates a 1-parameter family of canonical transformations. For the first-class constraint system, these canonical transformations preserving \overline{\mathcal{P}} are interpreted as gauge transformations. Applying the gauge transformations associated with all scalar fields \lambda and vector fields \lambda^{x}\partial_{x} on a point (\mathring{K}_{I},\mathring{E}^{I})\in\overline{\mathcal{P}} , one gets a set of points lying in \overline{\mathcal{P}} which is known as the gauge orbit passing through (\mathring{K}_{I},\mathring{E}^{I}) , denoted by [(\mathring{K}_{I},\mathring{E}^{I})] which is a physical state. Now let us consider how to construct the spacetime from a physical state [(\mathring{K}_{I},\mathring{E}^{I})] . The desired 4-manifold M of spacetime should be equipped with a scalar field t corresponding to the time of certain 3+1 decomposition and a vector field T^{\mu}\partial_{\mu} satisfying T^{\sigma}\partial_{\sigma}t=1 , such that the manifold M can be foliated into slices with t= constant and each slice is diffeomorphism to \Sigma . In the corresponding Hamiltonian formulation, one identifies the slices t=t_{1} and t=t_{2} by using the vector flow of T^{\mu}\partial_{\mu} . Let \Psi_{t_{1},t_{2}} be the identification between the two slices. Then, one can introduce a family of embeddings \varphi_{t_{o}}:\Sigma\to M for t_{o}\in\mathbb{R} to map \Sigma to the slice t=t_{o} of M such that \varphi_{t_{1}}=\Psi_{t_{1},t_{2}}\circ\varphi_{t_{2}},\quad\forall\ t_{1},t_{2}. For a given lapse function N and a given shift vector N^{x}\partial_{x} , which are allowed to be phase space dependent, one may solve the Hamilton’s equations \displaystyle\dot{K}_{I}= \displaystyle\{K_{I},H[N]+H_{x}[N^{x}]\}, (9) \displaystyle\dot{E}^{I}= \displaystyle\{E^{I},H[N]+H_{x}[N^{x}]\}, and obtain a curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)) lying in the gauge orbit in \overline{\mathcal{P}} corresponding to a physical state [(\mathring{K}_{I},\mathring{E}^{I})] . Since (K_{I}(t_{o}),E^{I}(t_{o})) for each moment t_{o} are actually fields on \Sigma , they are pushed forward to the slice t=t_{o} of M by the mapping \varphi_{t_{o}} , so do the N(t_{o}) and N^{x}(t_{o})\partial_{x} . Thus, all these fields have become 4-D objects on M . Then we can define the metric g_{\rho\sigma} on M as \displaystyle g_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}= \displaystyle-N^{2}\differential t^{2}+\frac{(E^{2})^{2}}{E^{1}}(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}+E^{1}\differential\Omega^{2}, (10) where \differential\Omega^{2}=\differential\theta^{2}+\sin^{2}\theta\differential\phi^{2} is the standard line element on \mathbb{S}^{2} . It is obvious that the metric ( 10 ) depends on the choice of N and N^{x}\partial_{x} . However, as known from classical GR, different metrics constructed from different N and N^{x}\partial_{x} are the same up to 4-D diffeomorphism transformations on M , implying the covariance of the theory with respect to the metric ( 10 ). We are going to explore the precise meaning of the covariance in the context of the Hamiltonian formulation. II.2 Covariance in Hamiltonian formulation In the procedure described in Sec. II.1 , the solution of K_{I}(t) and E^{I}(t) plays two roles. First, it gives a curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)) in the phase space \mathcal{P} . Second, it is mapped onto the 4-D manifold M as 4-D fields. Treating them as 4-D fields on M , the Hamilton’s equation ( 9 ) can be written in terms of Lie derivative as \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}E^{1} \displaystyle=\{E^{1},H[N]\}, (11) \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(E^{2}\differential x\wedge\differential t) \displaystyle=\{E^{2},H[N]\}\differential x\wedge\differential t, \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(K_{1}\differential x\wedge\differential t) \displaystyle=\{K_{1},H[N]\}\differential x\wedge\differential t, \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}K_{2} \displaystyle=\{K_{2},H[N]\}, with \mathfrak{N}^{\rho}\partial_{\rho}\equiv T^{\rho}\partial_{\rho}-N^{x}\partial_{x} . Note that in Eq. ( 11 ) E^{2} and K_{1} are lifted as 2-forms E^{2}\differential x\wedge\differential t and K_{1}\differential x\wedge\differential t on M , respectively. Equivalently, they can be interpreted as scalar densities of weight 1 on the 2-D manifold M/{\mathrm{SU(2)}}\ni(t,x) . Shall we treat E^{2} and K_{1} as 1-forms E^{2}\differential x and K_{1}\differential x on M , their Poisson brackets with H[N] would not be the desired Lie derivatives. Next, we consider an infinitesimal gauge transformation generated by H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}] , where \alpha is a scalar field and \beta^{x}\partial_{x} is a vector field. It will transform the curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)) into another curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t)+\epsilon\delta K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)+\epsilon\delta E^{I}(t)), (12) where \displaystyle\delta K_{I}:= \displaystyle\{K_{I},H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}, (13) \displaystyle\delta E^{I}:= \displaystyle\{E^{I},H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}. The curve ( 12 ) satisfies also the Hamilton’s equation ( 11 ) with respect to some new lapse function N+\epsilon\delta N and shift vector (N^{x}+\epsilon\delta N^{x})\partial_{x} , and hence we get \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\delta X+\mathcal{L}_{\delta\mathfrak{N}}X (14) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{X,H[\delta N]\}+\{\{X,H[N]\},H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}, with the abbreviation X\equiv K_{I},E^{I} . By direct calculations, we have \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\delta X= \displaystyle\{\{X,H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\},H[N]\} (15) \displaystyle+\left\{X,H\big[\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(\alpha N)-\{\alpha N,H[N]\}\big]\right\} \displaystyle+\left\{X,H_{x}\big[(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\beta)^{x}-\{\beta^{x},H[N]\}\big]\right\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\{\{H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}],H[N]\},X\} \displaystyle+\{\{X,H[N]\},H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}\} \displaystyle+\left\{X,H\big[\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(\alpha N)-\{\alpha N,H[N]\}\big]\right\} \displaystyle+\left\{X,H_{x}\big[(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\beta)^{x}-\{\beta^{x},H[N]\}\big]\right\}, where \alpha , \beta^{x} , N and N^{x} could be phase space dependent. Note that in the second equality of Eq. ( 15 ), the term \{\{X,H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\},H[N]\} gives the Lie derivatives of the phase-space variables in \{X,H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\} while the Lie derivatives of the phase-space-independent quantities are included in the other terms. By using the constraint algebra ( 6 ), we get \displaystyle\{H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}],H[N]\} (16) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-H_{x}[SN^{2}\partial_{x}\alpha]+H\big[\{\alpha N,H[N]\}\big] \displaystyle+H[\beta^{x}\partial_{x}N]+H_{x}\big[\{\beta^{x},H[N]\}\big]. Substituting Eq. ( 16 ) into Eq. ( 15 ) results in \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\delta X-\{\{X,H[N]\},H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}\} (17) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{H_{x}[SN^{2}\partial_{x}\alpha],X\}-\{H[\beta^{x}\partial_{x}N],X\} \displaystyle+\left\{X,H\big[\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(\alpha N)\big]\right\}+\left\{X,H_{x}\big[(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\beta)^{x}\big]\right\}. Thus, Eq. ( 14 ) can be simplified as \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\delta\mathfrak{N}}X+\{H_{x}[SN^{2}\partial_{x}\alpha],X\}-\{H[\beta^{x}\partial_{x}N],X\} (18) \displaystyle+\left\{X,H\big[\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(\alpha N)\big]\right\}+\left\{X,H_{x}\big[(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\beta)^{x}\big]\right\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{X,H[\delta N]\}. The definition \mathfrak{N}^{\sigma}\partial_{\sigma}=T^{\sigma}\partial_{\sigma}-N^{x}\partial_{x} implies \delta\mathfrak{N}^{\sigma}\partial_{\sigma}t=0 . Hence we obtain \mathcal{L}_{\delta\mathfrak{N}}X=\{X,H_{x}[\delta\mathfrak{N}^{x}]\}-H_{x}\big[\{X,\delta\mathfrak{N}^{x}\}\big]. (19) Plugging Eq. ( 19 ) into Eq. ( 18 ), we have \displaystyle\left\{X,H_{x}\Big[\delta\mathfrak{N}^{x}-E^{1}(E^{2})^{-2}N^{2}\partial_{x}\alpha+(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\beta)^{x}\Big]\right\} (20) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left\{X,H\Big[\delta N-\beta^{x}\partial_{x}N-\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}(\alpha N)\Big]\right\}+H_{x}\big[\{X,\delta\mathfrak{N}^{x}\}\big]. Thus implies \displaystyle\delta N^{x}\approx \displaystyle-N^{2}S\partial_{x}\alpha-(\mathcal{L}_{\beta}\mathfrak{N})^{x}, (21) \displaystyle\delta N\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}N+N\mathfrak{N}^{\rho}\partial_{\rho}\alpha, where the equality \delta N^{x}=-\delta\mathfrak{N}^{x} is used, and the convention A\approx B indicates that A is equal to B on the constraint surface \overline{\cal P} . Since the Hamiltonian constraint H in Eq. ( 5 ) is independent of the derivatives of K_{I} , it is easy to obtain \{E^{I}(x),H[\alpha N]\}\approx\alpha(x)\{E^{I}(x),H[N]\}. (22) Plugging Eq. ( 22 ) into Eq. ( 13 ), we get \displaystyle\delta E^{1}\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}E^{1}, (23) \displaystyle\delta E^{2}\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}E^{2}-E^{2}\mathfrak{N}^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}\alpha, where E^{1} is a scalar while E^{2} is a scalar density of weight 1 . By Eqs. ( 21 ) and ( 23 ), the infinitesimal gauge transformation for g_{\rho\sigma} generated by H[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}] reads \displaystyle\delta g_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}\approx\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}(g_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}), (24) which corresponds to its diffeomorphism transformation generated by the vector field \alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta . This verifies the covariance of the theory with respect to the metric g_{\rho\sigma} . III Conditions of general covariance for effective models Consider an arbitrary spherically symmetric effective model of some canonical QG theory. We assume that the diffeomorphism constraint keeps the same as the classical expression ( 4 ), such that it still generates spatial diffeomorphism transformations. However, due to QG effects, the effective Hamiltonian constraint {H_{\rm eff}} may deviate from the classical one. In addition, the constraint algebra is assumed to be \displaystyle\{H_{x}[N^{x}_{1}],H_{x}[N^{x}_{2}]\} \displaystyle=H_{x}[N^{x}_{1}\partial_{x}N^{x}_{2}-{N^{x}_{2}\partial_{x}N^{x}_{1}}], (25) \displaystyle\{{H_{\rm eff}}[N],H_{x}[M^{x}]\} \displaystyle=-{H_{\rm eff}}[M^{x}\partial_{x}N], \displaystyle\{{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{1}],{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{2}]\} \displaystyle=H_{x}[\mu S(N_{1}\partial_{x}N_{2}-N_{2}\partial_{x}N_{1})], where the modification factor \mu , as some function of K_{I} and E^{I} , comes from QG effects. It is then nature to ask the question whether the effective model is still covariant with respect to the metric ( 10 ). If it is not, is it possible to find an effective metric with respect to which the effective model is covariant? Since the effective model is still a totally constrainted system, we can follow the procedure described in Sec. II.1 to check its covariance. As done in Eq. ( 11 ), the Hamilton’s equation ( 9 ), with replacing H[N] by {H_{\rm eff}}[N] , can be written in terms of Lie derivative as \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}E^{1} \displaystyle=\{E^{1},{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}, (26) \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}E^{2} \displaystyle=\{E^{2},{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}, \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}K_{1} \displaystyle=\{K_{1},{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}, \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}K_{2} \displaystyle=\{K_{2},{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}, by the computation on the 2-D manifold M/{\mathrm{SU(2)}} . Next, as shown in Sec. II.1 , the infinitesimal gauge transformation generated by {H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}] transforms the curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)) into another curve t\mapsto(K_{I}(t)+\epsilon\delta K_{I}(t),E^{I}(t)+\epsilon\delta E^{I}(t)), (27) with \displaystyle\delta K_{I}:= \displaystyle\{K_{I},{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}, (28) \displaystyle\delta E^{I}:= \displaystyle\{E^{I},{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}. The curve ( 27 ) satisfies the Hamilton’s equation ( 26 ) with respect to some new lapse function N+\epsilon\delta N and shift vector (N^{x}+\epsilon\delta N^{x})\partial_{x} . Following the derivations for ( 21 ), we get \displaystyle\delta N^{x}\approx \displaystyle-N^{2}\mu S\partial_{x}\alpha-(\mathcal{L}_{\beta}\mathfrak{N})^{x}, (29) \displaystyle\delta N\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}N+N\mathfrak{N}^{\rho}\partial_{\rho}\alpha, where, in comparison with Eq. ( 21 ), the factor \mu is involved in the expression of \delta N^{x} . Since in the effective model {H_{\rm eff}} could depends on derivatives of K_{1} , we have \displaystyle\{E^{1}(x),{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]\} (30) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\alpha(x)\{E^{1}(x),{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}-\Delta_{1} \displaystyle+\int\differential y{H_{\rm eff}}(y)N(y)\{E^{1}(x),\alpha(y)\}, where \Delta_{1}=\sum_{n\geq 1}(-1)^{n}\sum_{m=1}^{n}\binom{n}{m}(\partial_{x}^{m}\alpha)\frac{\partial^{n}\left(N(x)\frac{\partial{H_{\rm eff}}(x)}{\partial(\partial_{x}^{n}K_{1}(x))}\right)}{\partial x^{n-m}}. Equation ( 30 ) indicates \delta E^{1}\approx\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}E^{1}-\Delta_{1}. (31) Similarly, we have \displaystyle\delta E^{2}\approx \displaystyle\alpha\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}E^{2}+\mathcal{L}_{\beta}E^{2}-\Delta_{2} (32) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}E^{2}-E^{2}\mathfrak{N}^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}\alpha-\Delta_{2}, where \displaystyle\Delta_{2}= \displaystyle\alpha(x)\{E^{2}(x),{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}-\{E^{2}(x),{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{n\geq 1}(-1)^{n}\left[\sum_{m=1}^{n}\binom{n}{m}(\partial_{x}^{m}\alpha)\frac{\partial^{n}\left(N(x)\frac{\partial{H_{\rm eff}}(x)}{\partial(\partial_{x}^{n}K_{2}(x))}\right)}{\partial x^{n-m}}\right]. By Eqs. ( 29 ), ( 31 ) and ( 32 ), the infinitesimal gauge transformation for g_{\rho\sigma} generated by {H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}] reads \displaystyle\delta g_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma} (33) \displaystyle\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}(g_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}) \displaystyle+\left(\frac{\Delta_{1}}{(E^{1})^{2}}-\frac{2\Delta_{2}}{E^{1}E^{2}}\right)(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}-\Delta_{1}\differential\Omega^{2} \displaystyle+N^{2}(1-\mu)(\partial_{x}\alpha)(2\differential x\differential t+2N^{x}(\differential t)^{2}), where the metric g_{\rho\sigma} is given by Eq. ( 10 ). Therefore, in general the theory is no longer covariant with respect to g_{\rho\sigma} . Comparing Eq. ( 33 ) with Eq. ( 24 ), three terms arise to break the desired covariance. While the terms proportional to \Delta_{1} and \Delta_{2} could be eliminated by requiring that {H_{\rm eff}} is independent of the derivatives of K_{I} as in the classical case, to remove the term proportional to 1-\mu is challenging. This motivates us to modify g_{\rho\sigma} into some effective metric g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} , with respect to which the theory is expected to restore its covariance. Following the arguments in [ 36 , 29 ] , it is assumed that the effective metric takes the form \displaystyle g^{(\mu)}_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}= \displaystyle-N^{2}\differential t^{2}+\frac{(E^{2})^{2}}{\mu E^{1}}(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}+E^{1}\differential\Omega^{2}. (34) Here, by taking the structure function \mu S in ( 25 ) as the (x,x) -components of the inverse spatial effective metric, the algebra ( 25 ) continues to describe hyper-surface deformations in the same way as in the classical case. Then, by Eqs. ( 29 ), ( 30 ) and ( 32 ), we get \displaystyle\delta g^{(\mu)}_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma} (35) \displaystyle\approx \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}(g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}) \displaystyle+\frac{\Delta_{1}}{\mu(E^{1})^{2}}(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}-\Delta_{1}\differential\Omega^{2} \displaystyle+\frac{1}{\mu^{2}E^{1}}\left(\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}\mu-\delta\mu-\frac{2\mu\Delta_{2}}{E^{2}}\right)(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}. It should be noted that the weak equality \approx in the above equation would be replaced by the strong equality = if \alpha , \beta , N and N^{x} were phase space independent. Reversely, the derivations of Eqs. ( 29 ), ( 31 ) and ( 32 ) indicates that, if one had the identity \displaystyle\delta g^{(\mu)}_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma} (36) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}(g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}) \displaystyle+\frac{\Delta_{1}}{\mu(E^{1})^{2}}(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2}-\Delta_{1}\differential\Omega^{2} \displaystyle+\frac{1}{\mu^{2}E^{1}}\left(\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}\mu-\delta\mu-\frac{2\mu\Delta_{2}}{E^{2}}\right)(\differential x+N^{x}\differential t)^{2} for all phase space independent quantities of \alpha , \beta , N and N^{x} , Eq. ( 35 ) would be satisfied automatically. Therefore, rather than Eq. ( 35 ), we only need to consider Eq. ( 36 ) for all phase space independent quantities of \alpha , \beta , N and N^{x} . Therefore, in order to restore the covariance, i.e., \delta g^{(\mu)}_{\rho\sigma}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}=\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}(g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)}\differential x^{\rho}\differential x^{\sigma}) , the necessary and sufficient conditions are figured out as follows: (i) \Delta_{1}=0 for all phase space independent \alpha and N , which is equivalent to require that {H_{\rm eff}} is independent of the derivatives of K_{1} ; (ii) the following equation is satisfied for all phase space independent \alpha , \beta , N and N^{x} : \mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}\mu-\delta\mu-\frac{2\mu\Delta_{2}}{E^{2}}=0. (37) In Eq. ( 37 ), the strong equality = is used instead of the weak equality because the resulting \mu is expected to remain valid for models with matter coupling. More explicitly, if one uses the weak equality \approx here, the expression for \mu could be different for different matter coupling models, because the total constraints for different models with matter coupling are different. The Hamilton’s equation indicates \mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{N}}\mu=\{\mu,{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}. (38) Hence, taking account of the fact that \mu is a spacetime scalar, one has \mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}\mu=\alpha\{\mu,{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\}+\{\mu,H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}. (39) Since \delta\mu is defined by \delta\mu=\{\mu,{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]+H_{x}[\beta^{x}]\}, (40) Eq. ( 37 ) can be simplified as \alpha\left\{\frac{\mu}{(E^{2})^{2}},{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\right\}=\left\{\frac{\mu}{(E^{2})^{2}},{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]\right\}. (41) Since \Delta_{1}=0 , Eq. ( 41 ) is equivalent to \alpha\left\{\mu S,{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\right\}=\left\{\mu S,{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]\right\}, (42) where \mu S is the structure function appearing in ( 25 ). We now reach the following proposition 1 1 1 While finalizing this paper, we became aware that Eq. ( 43 ) was independently derived in Ref. [ 37 ] , though with an on-shell condition that we deliberately omit in Eq. ( 43 ). It should be noted that the on-shell condition in the vacuum case differs from that in scenarios with matter coupling. To ensure that the resulting effective Hamiltonian constraint remains applicable when matter is coupled, the on-shell condition is not considered not only in this proposition but also throughout the other derivations in this paper. : Proposition 1 . The totally constrained Hamiltonian theory with the constraint algebra ( 25 ) is covariant with respect to the metric g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} given in ( 34 ), namely equation \delta g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)}=\mathcal{L}_{\alpha\mathfrak{N}+\beta}g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} holds for all smeared functions \alpha and smeared vector fields \beta^{x}\partial_{x} if and only if (i) {H_{\rm eff}} is independent of \partial_{x}^{n}K_{1} for all n\geq 1 ; (ii) The following equation is satisfied for all phase space independent functions \alpha and N : \alpha\left\{\mu S,{H_{\rm eff}}[N]\right\}=\left\{\mu S,{H_{\rm eff}}[\alpha N]\right\}. (43) Notably, the derivation of this proposition relies solely on the constraint algebra ( 25 ) and the equations of motion ( 26 ). Consequently, the proposition can be easily generalized to models with matter coupling by replacing {H_{\rm eff}} with the effective total Hamiltonian constraint. IV Covariance equations While Proposition 1 provides a necessary and sufficient condition for covariance, it remains unclear whether an effective Hamiltonian constraint {H_{\rm eff}} satisfying this condition exists and, if so, whether it is unique. In this section, we will show in details that under several physical assumptions, {H_{\rm eff}} is determined by a mass function M_{\rm eff} satisfying some differential equations, along with an arbitrarily chosen function \mathcal{R} . Since the Hamiltonian constraint is a scalar density of weight 1 , it can be expressed in the form of {H_{\rm eff}}=E^{2}F, where F is a scalar field and can be written as a function of basic scalars given by K_{I} , E^{I} and their derivatives. As discussed in [ 29 ] , by excluding the derivatives of K_{2} in the expression of F , the condition (i) and the behaviors of the the Poisson bracket between {H_{\rm eff}}[N_{1}] and {H_{\rm eff}}[N_{2}] as shown in Eq. ( 25 ) restrict the basic scalars to the following choices: \displaystyle s_{1}=E^{1},s_{2}=K_{2},s_{3}=\frac{K_{1}}{E^{2}},s_{4}=\frac{\partial_{x}E^{1}}{E^{2}}, (44) \displaystyle s_{5}=\frac{\partial_{x}s_{4}}{E^{2}},s_{6}=\frac{\partial_{x}E^{1}}{K_{1}},s_{7}=\frac{\partial_{x}s_{4}}{K_{1}}. In addition, as pointed in [ 29 ] , in the Schwarzschild solutions of classical GR, there exist 3+1 decompositions such that K_{I} or the derivatives of E^{I} vanish throughout the entire t -slices. Thus the basic scalars s_{6} and s_{7} would be ill-defined for such cases. Hence we also exclude s_{6} and s_{7} in the expression of F in order to accommodate solutions analogous to the Schwarzschild solutions. To summarize, {H_{\rm eff}} now can be written as {H_{\rm eff}}=E^{2}F(\vec{s}), (45) where \vec{s} denotes the set of \{s_{a}\,|\,a=1,2,\cdots,5\} . Then, we can compute the Poisson bracket \displaystyle\{{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{1}],{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{2}]\} (46) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\iint\differential x\differential y\big[N_{1}(x)N_{2}(y)-N_{1}(y)N_{2}(x)\big] \displaystyle\times F(\vec{s}(x))E^{2}(y)\left\{E^{2}(x),F(\vec{s}(y))\right\} \displaystyle+\iint\differential x\differential yN_{1}(x)N_{2}(y)E^{2}(x)E^{2}(y) \displaystyle\times\{F(\vec{s}(x)),F(\vec{s}(y))\}. Since \partial_{x}K_{I} are not involved in s_{a} , we get \left\{E^{2}(x),F(\vec{s}(y))\right\}\propto\delta(x,y), (47) which implies that the first term in Eq. ( 46 ) vanishes. Thus, we have \displaystyle\{{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{1}],{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{2}]\} (48) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}a,b=1\\ am_{o} . In our convention, the shaded regions S are not considered as part of either B or W . The diagram contains asymptotically flat regions A , the BH region B , the WH region W , and the Schwarzschild-de Sitter-like regions S . VI.1 Spacetime structure for GMx_{\rm min} . To extend the spacetime beyond x=x_{\rm min} , we introduce a new coordinate z(x) , as suggested in [ 40 ] for a similar context, defined by \left(\frac{\differential z}{\differential x}\right)^{2}=\mu_{3}^{-1}. (110) In the coordinates (t,z,\theta,\phi) , the metric reads \differential s_{(3)}^{2}=-\bar{f}_{3}^{(0)}(z)\differential t^{2}+\big(\bar{f}_{3}^{(0)}(z)\big)^{-1}\differential z^{2}+x(z)^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, (111) where \bar{f}_{3}^{(0)}(z):=\bar{f}_{3}^{(0)}(x(z)) and x(z) denotes the inverse function of z(x) determined by Eq. ( 110 ). The metric ( 111 ) is well defined at x(z)=x_{\rm min} . Since x=x_{\rm min} is a root of \mu_{3}(x) , the function x(z) exhibits a turning point at x(z)=x_{\rm min} . This implies that the extension beyond x=x_{\rm min} turns back to x>x_{\rm min} . However, it should be noted that, due to the arcsine function in \bar{f}_{3}^{(n)} , after the turning point, the line element should transition to the branch of the arcsine function corresponding to n=1 . Then the metric, after the turning point, becomes \displaystyle\differential s^{2}_{(3)}= \displaystyle-\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}(z)\differential t^{2}+\big(\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}(z)\big)^{-1}\differential z^{2}+x(z)^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}. (112) The choice in Eq. ( 112 ) ensures the smoothness of the metric, i.e., \lim_{z\to z_{o}^{+}}\frac{\differential^{n}}{\differential z^{n}}f_{\rm eff,III}^{(0)}=\lim_{z\to z_{o}^{-}}\frac{\differential^{n}}{\differential z^{n}}f_{\rm eff,III}^{(1)}. (113) It is obvious that, for GMx_{\rm min} . Hence, there is a horizon in the spacetime region associated with \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)} . The expression of \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)} in Eq. ( 105 ) indicates that, as x\to\infty , the spacetime region associated with \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)} asymptotically approaches to a de-Sitter spacetime. Thus, by gluing the spacetime regions associated with \bar{f}_{3}^{(0)} and \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)} , we get the Penrose diagram of the spacetime \differential s_{(3)}^{2} as shown in Fig. 3 , where A is the region associated with \bar{f}_{3}^{(0)} , and A^{\prime}\cup B and A^{\prime}\cup W are those associated with \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)} . For the region B\cup A^{\prime} or W\cup A^{\prime} , the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates, denoted by (t_{\pm},x,\theta,\phi) , can be employed to cover it. The line element in the region B\cup A^{\prime} is \displaystyle\differential s_{(3)}^{2}= \displaystyle-\differential t_{+}^{2}+\mu_{3}^{-1}\left(\differential x+\sqrt{\mu_{3}\big(1-\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}\big)}\differential t_{+}\right)^{2} (114) \displaystyle+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}. and in the region W\cup A^{\prime} is \displaystyle\differential s_{(3)}^{2}= \displaystyle-\differential t_{-}^{2}+\mu_{3}^{-1}\left(\differential x-\sqrt{\mu_{3}\big(1-\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}\big)}\differential t_{-}\right)^{2} (115) \displaystyle+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}. Besides the coordinates (t,z,\theta,\phi) introduced in Eq. ( 112 ), to cover the entire wormhole region A\cup A^{\prime} , we can also introduce the new coordinates (t,X,\theta,\phi) as follows: x^{3}=\frac{2GM\zeta^{2}}{\sin(X)}, (116) and hence \differential X=\mp\frac{6\zeta^{2}GM}{x^{4}}\frac{\differential x}{\sqrt{\bar{\mu}_{3}}}. (117) Thus the metric in the new coordinates becomes \displaystyle\differential s_{(3)}^{2}= \displaystyle-\Phi(X)\differential t^{2}+\frac{\Xi(X)^{2}}{9\Phi(X)\sin^{2}(X)}\differential X^{2} (118) \displaystyle+\Xi(X)^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, with \displaystyle\Xi(X)= \displaystyle\left[\frac{2GM\zeta^{2}}{\sin(X)}\right]^{1/3},\quad (119) \displaystyle\Phi(X)= \displaystyle 1-\left[\frac{2GM}{\zeta\sin(X)}\right]^{2/3}X. The wormhole throat is located at X=\pi/2 , and the horizon appears at X=X_{o} , where X_{o} , greater than \pi/2 , is the root of \Phi(X) . The range of X reads 0m_{o} In this case, \bar{f}_{3}^{(0)} has a real root denoted by x_{h} where the horizons form. The Penrose diagram, as shown in Fig. 3 , consists of the asymptotically flat regions A , the BH region B , the WH region W and the Schwarzschild-de Sitter-like region S . In the current scenario, the surface x=x_{\rm min} occurs inside the horizon and is spacelike. In either the region A\cup B or the region A\cup W , one can choose the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates (t_{\pm},x,\theta,\phi) to cover it. Then, the line element reads \displaystyle\differential s_{(3)}^{2}= \displaystyle-\differential t_{\pm}^{2}+\frac{1}{\bar{\mu}_{3}}\left(\differential x+\sqrt{\bar{\mu}_{3}(1-\bar{f}_{3}^{(0)})}\differential t_{\pm}\right)^{2} (124) \displaystyle+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, where as in Eqs. ( 114 ) and ( 115 ), the signs \pm correspond to the regions A\cup B and A\cup W respectively. In the shadow region S , the Schwarzschild-like coordinate can be chosen, in which the line element reads \differential s_{(3)}^{2}=-\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}\differential t^{2}+\bar{\mu}_{3}^{-1}(\bar{f}_{3}^{(1)})^{-1}\differential x^{2}+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}. (125) It is easy to see that \bar{f}_{3}^{(1)}<0 for all x>x_{\rm min} in the current case. Moreover, the metric in region S asymptotically approaches the Schwarzschild-de Sitter one with negative mass in the far future. To define the coordinates covering the entire region A\cup B\cup S or A\cup W\cup S , we again use the coordinates (t_{\pm},z,\theta,\phi) with z define by Eq. ( 110 ), or the coordinates (t_{\pm},X,\theta,\phi) with X given by Eq. ( 116 ). Then, the metric in these two coordinate systems will take the same forms as those in Eq. ( 122 ) and Eq. ( 123 ) respectively. VII Matter coupling The approach for covariant effective models discussed in previous sections can be extended to include matter coupling, such as a dust fields [ 41 ] . In the canonical formulation, the dust fields in the spherically symmetric model can be described by the canonical pairs (T(x),P_{T}(x)) and (X(x),P_{X}(x)) , where P_{T} represents the dust density and X is related to the comoving dust frame. The dust part of the diffeomorphism constraint reads H_{x}^{\rm d}=P_{T}\partial_{x}T+P_{X}\partial_{x}X. (126) Replacing E^{1}/(E^{2})^{2} in the classical dust Hamiltonian by \mu E^{1}/(E^{2})^{2} , we get a possible expression for the effective dust Hamiltonian as H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}=\sqrt{P_{T}^{2}+\frac{\mu E^{1}}{(E^{2})^{2}}(H_{x}^{\rm d})^{2}}. (127) Using the fact that \mu is a function of s_{1} and M_{\rm eff} as indicated by Eq. ( 81 ), it is easy to show that \{H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[N_{1}],H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[N_{2}]\}=H_{x}^{\rm d}[\mu S(N_{1}\partial_{x}N_{2}-N_{2}\partial_{x}N_{1})]. (128) Let H_{x}^{\rm tot}=H_{x}+H_{x}^{\rm d} and H_{\rm eff}^{\rm tot}={H_{\rm eff}}+H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d} denote the total diffeomorphism and Hamiltonian constraints, respectively. Taking account of Eq. ( 82 ), one can further show \{H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[N_{1}],{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{2}]\}+\{{H_{\rm eff}}[N_{1}],H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[N_{2}]\}=0. (129) Consequently, the constraint algebra for H_{\rm eff}^{\rm tot} keeps the same form as given by Eq. ( 25 ). Since H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d} does not contain the derivatives of K_{1} , the covariance condition (i) is met by H_{\rm eff}^{\rm tot} . Moreover, a straightforward calculation shows that \left\{\mu(x),\frac{\mu(y)E^{1}(y)}{E^{2}(y)^{2}}\right\}\propto\delta(x,y). (130) As a result, we have \alpha(x)\{\mu(x),H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[N]\}=\{\mu(x),H_{\rm eff}^{\rm d}[\alpha N]\}. (131) Furthermore, since the derivatives of K_{2} is not contained in H_{\rm eff}^{\rm tot} either, Eq. ( 131 ) implies that H_{\rm eff}^{\rm tot} fulfills the covariance condition (ii). In the model described by H_{\rm eff}^{(3)} , the corresponding value of \mu\equiv\mu_{3} is given by Eq. ( 86 ). Thus, the dust Hamiltonian reads, H_{\rm eff}^{{\rm d},3}=\sqrt{P_{T}^{2}+\mu_{3}\frac{E^{1}}{(E^{2})^{2}}(H_{x}^{\rm d})^{2}}, (132) and thus the total Hamiltonian constraint reads H_{\rm eff}^{{\rm tot},3}=H_{\rm eff}^{(3)}+H_{\rm eff}^{{\rm d},3}. (133) VIII Summary The issue of maintaining general covariance in the spherically symmetric effective models of QG has been studied in previous sections. We retain the kinematical variables (E^{I},K_{I}) , with I=1,2 , and the classical form of the diffeomorphism constraint H_{x} , while leave the effective Hamiltonian constraint {H_{\rm eff}} undetermined to accommodate QG effects. The diffeomorphism constraint and the effective Hamiltonian constraint are assumed to obey the Poisson relation ( 25 ), where a free factor \mu is introduced to account for QG effects. To ensure general covariance, the classical metric is modified into the effective one g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} by incorporating \mu into its expression, which ensures that the algebra ( 25 ) continues to describe hypersurface deformations as in the classical case. Then, by requiring that the gauge transformation of g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} coincides with its corresponding diffeomorphism transformation, the sufficient and necessary conditions for the covariance are derived. Based on the covariance conditions, we ultimately arrive at Eq. ( 82 ), which links {H_{\rm eff}} and M_{\rm eff} , with M_{\rm eff} satisfying Eqs. ( 78 ) and ( 81 ). Note that {H_{\rm eff}} includes a free function \mathcal{R} , and by setting \mathcal{R}=0 M_{\rm eff} becomes a Dirac observable representing the BH mass. Solving Eqs. ( 78 ) and ( 81 ), we have obtained three families of M_{\rm eff} , denoted by M_{\rm eff}^{(i)} with i=1,2,3 , which involve some free functions as the constants of integration. Note that in [ 29 ] , the properties of the models resulting from M_{\rm eff}^{(1)} and M_{\rm eff}^{(2)} were studied with these integration constants fixed by adopting the \bar{\mu} -scheme within the context of loop quantum BH models. In the current paper, we focus on the new solution M_{\rm eff}^{(3)} . In the resulting spacetime, the classical singularity is resolved, and the spacetime is extended beyond the singularity into a Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetime. Notably, the new quantum-corrected spacetime does not contain any Cauchy horizons, which might imply its stability under perturbations (see, e.g., [ 42 , 43 , 44 ] for further discussion on Cauchy horizon in effective quantum BH models). It should be noted that, from the perspective of a Taylor expansion of the sine function in ( 85 ) and ( 87 ), the appearance of higher-order derivatives of E^{1} is expected. However, the sine function involving the spatial derivative of E^{1} does not introduce additional degrees of freedom, as it contains only spatial derivatives and hence does not lead to any ghost fields. Furthermore, the absence of higher-order derivatives of E^{2} in our construction is not an arbitrary assumption, but rather a consequence of the requirement of general covariance, which strongly constrains the form of the effective Hamiltonian. Why general covariance permits higher-order derivatives of E^{1} while excluding them for E^{2} is an interesting issue that deserves further investigation. By proposing the effective dust Hamiltonian ( 127 ), the effective model of gravity coupled to the dust fields has been obtained. Thus our covariant approach establishes a fundamental platform for future research involving matter couplings. This would allow for the study of BH formation through the collapse of a dust ball, which is left for our future study. Furthermore, it is desirable to generalize the framework developed in this paper to models with different symmetries, such as the axially symmetric case. Acknowledgements. C.Z. acknowledges the valuable discussions with Luca Cafaro, Kristina Giesel, Hongguang Liu, Chun-Yen Lin, Dongxue Qu, Farshid Soltani, Edward Wilson-Ewing, and Stefan Andreas Weigl. This work is supported by the NSFC Grant Nos. 12275022 and 12165005, “the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities”, and the National Science Centre, Poland as part of the OPUS 24 Grant No. 2022/47/B/ST2/02735. Appendix A The metrics associated with M_{\rm eff}^{(1)} and M_{\rm eff}^{(2)} A.1 The metric associated with M_{\rm eff}^{(1)} The first solution, as proposed in [ 29 ] , is obtained by considering the polymerization of M_{\rm cl} in Eq. ( 84 ). We introduce \displaystyle M_{\rm eff}^{(1)}= \displaystyle\frac{g(s_{1})}{2G}+\mathcal{F}(s_{1})\left[\frac{\sqrt{s_{1}}}{2G\lambda(s_{1})^{2}}\sin^{2}\Big(\lambda(s_{1})[s_{2}+\psi(s_{1})]\Big)-\frac{\sqrt{s_{1}}(s_{4})^{2}}{8G}\exp\Big(2i\lambda(s_1)[s_2+\psi(s_1)] \Big)\right], (134) with arbitrary functions g , \mathcal{F} , \lambda and \psi . Substituting this expression into Eq. ( 78 ) and ( 81 ), we have \mu\equiv\mu_{1}=\mathcal{F}(s_{1})^{2}. (135) The resulting Hamiltonian constraint reads \displaystyle H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}= \displaystyle-\frac{\mathcal{F}(E^{1})\sqrt{E^{1}}}{2G\lambda(E^{1})^{2}}\left[K_{1}\lambda(E^{1})+2E^{2}\frac{\partial\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}\right]\sin(2 \mathfrak P(E^1)) (136) \displaystyle-\frac{E^{2}}{G}\frac{\partial}{\partial E^{1}}\left[\frac{\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})}{\lambda(E^{1})^{2}}\right]\sin^{2}(\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})) \displaystyle+\left[\frac{(\partial_{x}E^{1})^{2}}{4GE^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial E^{1}}\Big(\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})\Big)+\frac{\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})}{2G}\partial_{x}\left(\frac{\partial_{x}E^{1}}{E^{2}}\right)\right]e^{2i\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})} \displaystyle+\frac{i\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})(\partial_{x}E^{1})^{2}}{2GE^{2}}\left[\frac{\lambda(E^{1})K_{1}}{2E^{2}}+\frac{\partial\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}\right]e^{2i\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})} \displaystyle-\frac{E^{2}}{G}\frac{\partial g(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}+E^{2}\mathcal{R}(E^{1},M_{\rm eff}^{(1)}), where we introduced the abbreviation \mathfrak{P}\equiv\lambda(E^{1})\Big[K_{2}+\psi(E^{1})\Big] (137) to denote the polymerization of K_{2} . In what follows, we focus on the case of \mathcal{R}=0 . Substituting the gauge fixing condition ( 90 ) and ( 91 ) into H_{\rm eff}^{(1)} , we get \displaystyle H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}(x)=-\frac{E^{2}(x)}{x}\partial_{x}\hat{M}_{\rm eff}^{(1)}(x), (138) where \hat{M}_{\rm eff}^{(1)}(x) denotes M_{\rm eff}^{(1)}(x) with Eqs. ( 90 ) and ( 91 ) substituted. We are interested in the stationary solution, in which N and N^{x} should be chosen so that \dot{E}^{I}=0 , i.e., \displaystyle 0= \displaystyle\{E^{1}(x),H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}[N]+H_{x}[N^{x}]\}, (139) \displaystyle 0= \displaystyle\{E^{2}(x),H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}[N]+H_{x}[N^{x}]\}, leading to \displaystyle N(x)= \displaystyle\frac{x}{E^{2}(x)}, (140) \displaystyle\frac{N^{x}(x)}{N(x)}= \displaystyle\frac{\mathcal{F}\left(x^{2}\right)}{2\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)E^{2}(x)^{2}}\Bigg[-E^{2}(x)^{2}\sin\left(2\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)\left[K_{2}(x)+\psi\left(x^{2}\right)\right]\right) \displaystyle+2ix^{2}\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)^{2}e^{2i\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)\left(K_{2}(x)+\psi\left(x^{2}\right)\right)}\Bigg]. To write down the metric in the Schwarzschild-like coordinates (t,x,\theta,\phi) , we choose the Schwarzschild gauge such that N^{x}=0. (141) This condition, together with the constraint H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}=0 , results in \displaystyle E^{2}(x) \displaystyle=\pm\frac{x^{2}\mathcal{F}(x^{2})}{\sqrt{\left[g\left(x^{2}\right)-2GM\right]\left(xf\left(x^{2}\right)+\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)^{2}\left(g\left(x^{2}\right)-2GM\right)\right)}}. (142) We thus get the metric \displaystyle\differential s_{(1)}^{2}=-f_{1}\differential t^{2}+\mu_{1}^{-1}f_{1}^{-1}\differential x^{2}+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, (143) with f_{1}(x)=\frac{g\left(x^{2}\right)-2GM}{x\mathcal{F}\left(x^{2}\right)}\left[1+\frac{\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)^{2}\left(g\left(x^{2}\right)-2GM\right)}{x\mathcal{F}\left(x^{2}\right)}\right], (144) and \mu_{1}(x)=\mathcal{F}(x^{2})^{2}. (145) To write down the metric in the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates (t_{p},x,\theta,\phi) , we choose the gauge E^{2}(x)=x, (146) leading to N=1 . This condition, together with the constraint H_{\rm eff}^{(1)}=0 , gives N^{x}(x)=\pm\sqrt{\mu_{1}(1-f_{1}(x))}. (147) Thus, the metric in the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates (t_{\pm},x,\theta,\phi) is \displaystyle\differential s_{(1)}^{2}=-\differential t_{\pm}^{2}+\mu_{1}^{-1}\left(\differential x\pm\sqrt{\mu_{1}(1-f_{1}})\differential t_{\pm}\right)^{2}+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, (148) where the sign of + corresponds to the ingoing Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates and the sign of - corresponds to the outgoing Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates. It is easy to check that the metric ( 148 ) is the same as the one in Eq. ( 142 ) up to a coordinate transformation. This fact is compatible with fact that the theory described by H_{\rm eff}^{(1)} is covariant. A.2 The spacetime metric associated with M_{\rm eff}^{(2)} The second solution is obtained by choosing \displaystyle M_{\rm eff}^{(2)}= \displaystyle\frac{g(s_{1})}{2G}+\mathcal{F}(s_{1})\left[\frac{\sqrt{s_{1}}}{2G\lambda(s_{1})^{2}}\sin^{2}\left(\lambda(s_{1})[s_{2}+\psi(s_{1})]\right)-\frac{\sqrt{s_{1}}s_{4}^{2}}{8G}\cos^{2}\left(\lambda(s_{1})[s_{2}+\psi(s_{1})]\right)\right], (149) for arbitrary functions g , \mathcal{F} , \lambda and \psi . Substituting M_{\rm eff}^{(2)} into Eqs. ( 78 ) and ( 81 ) leads to \mu\equiv\mu_{2}=\mathcal{F}(s_{1})\left[\mathcal{F}(s_{1})+\frac{\lambda(s_{1})^{2}}{\sqrt{s_{1}}}\left(g(s_{1})-2GM_{\rm eff}^{(2)}\right)\right]. (150) The resulting Hamiltonian constraint H_{\rm eff}^{(2)} reads \displaystyle H_{\rm eff}^{(2)}= \displaystyle-\frac{\mathcal{F}(E^{1})\sqrt{E^{1}}}{2G\lambda(E^{1})^{2}}\left[K_{1}\lambda(E^{1})+2E^{2}\frac{\partial\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}\right]\sin(2 \mathfrak P(E^1)) (151) \displaystyle-\frac{E^{2}}{G}\frac{\partial}{\partial E^{1}}\left[\frac{\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})}{\lambda(E^{1})^{2}}\right]\sin^{2}(\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})) \displaystyle+\left[\frac{(\partial_{x}E^{1})^{2}}{4GE^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial E^{1}}\Big(\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})\Big)+\frac{\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})}{2G}\partial_{x}\left(\frac{\partial_{x}E^{1}}{E^{2}}\right)\right]\cos^{2}(\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})) \displaystyle-\frac{\sqrt{E^{1}}\mathcal{F}(E^{1})(\partial_{x}E^{1})^{2}}{4GE^{2}}\left[\frac{\lambda(E^{1})K_{1}}{2E^{2}}+\frac{\partial\mathfrak{P}(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}\right]\sin(2\mathfrak P(E^1)) \displaystyle-\frac{E^{2}}{G}\frac{\partial g(E^{1})}{\partial E^{1}}+E^{2}\mathcal{R}(E^{1},M_{\rm eff}^{(1)}), with \mathfrak{P} given by Eq. ( 137 ). In what follows, we again focus on the case of \mathcal{R}=0 . We still choose the areal gauge to solve the dynamics. Substituting the gauge fixing conditions ( 90 ) and ( 91 ) into H_{\rm eff}^{(2)} , we have H_{\rm eff}^{(2)}(x)=-\frac{E^{2}(x)}{x}\partial_{x}\hat{M}_{\rm eff}^{(2)}, (152) where \hat{M}_{\rm eff}^{(2)}(x) is the value of M_{\rm eff}^{(2)} with the conditions ( 90 ) and ( 91 ) substituted. Since the stationary solution is still focused on, we apply the similar procedure as in Eq. ( 139 ), obtaining \displaystyle N(x) \displaystyle=\frac{x}{E^{2}(x)}, (153) \displaystyle\frac{N^{x}(x)}{N(x)} \displaystyle=-\frac{\mathcal{F}\left(x^{2}\right)}{2E^{2}(x)^{2}\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)}\left(E^{2}(x)^{2}+x^{2}\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)^{2}\right)\sin\Big(2 \lambda(x^2) \left[K_2(x)+\psi\left(x^2\right)\right]\Big). Then, the Schwarzschild gauge ( 141 ), together with the constraint equation H_{\rm eff}^{(2)}=0 , results in \displaystyle E^{2}(x)=\pm\frac{\sqrt{x}^{3}\sqrt{\mathcal{F}(x^{2})}}{\sqrt{g(x^{2})-2GM}}, (154) \displaystyle\sin\left(\lambda\left(x^{2}\right)\left[K_{2}(x)+\psi\left(x^{2}\right)\right]\right)=0. Consequently, the value of \mu_{2} is \mu_{2}=\mathcal{F}(x^{2})^{2}\left(1+\frac{\lambda(x^{2})^{2}\left(g(x^{2})-2GM\right)}{x\mathcal{F}(x^{2})}\right). (155) Substituting the above results into the expression g_{\rho\sigma}^{(\mu)} , we get the metric \differential s_{(2)}^{2}=-f_{2}\differential t^{2}+\mu_{2}^{-1}f_{2}^{-1}\differential x^{2}+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, (156) with f_{2}=\frac{g\left(x^{2}\right)-2GM}{x\mathcal{F}\left(x^{2}\right)}. (157) To write the metric in the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates, we again need the gauge ( 146 ) which, together with the constraint H_{\rm eff}^{(2)}=0 , results in N^{x}(x)=\pm\sqrt{\mu_{2}(1-f_{2})}. (158) Thus, the metric in the Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates (t_{p},x,\theta,\phi) is \differential s^{2}=-\differential t_{\pm}^{2}+\mu_{2}^{-1}\left[\differential x\pm\sqrt{\mu_{2}(1-f_{2})}\differential t_{\pm}\right]^{2}+x^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}, (159) where the sign of + corresponds to the ingoing Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates and the sign of - corresponds to the outgoing Painlevé-Gullstrand-like coordinates. It can be easily checked that the metric ( 156 ) is the same as the one given in Eq. ( 159 ), as a consequence of the fact that the theory described by H_{\rm eff}^{(2)} is covariant.