Signatures of Rapidly Rotating Stars with Chemically Homogeneous Evolution in the First Galaxies Boyuan Liu, Yves Sibony, Georges Meynet, Volker Bromm Abstract The James Webb Space Telescope ( JWST ) has revealed an unexpectedly high abundance of UV luminous galaxies at redshifts z ≳ 10 z\gtrsim 10 , challenging ‘standard’ galaxy formation models. This study investigates the role of rapidly rotating (massive) stars undergoing chemically homogeneous evolution (CHE) in reconciling this potential tension. These stars are more compact, hotter, and exhibit enhanced UV emission. We find that the rest-frame UV luminosity of star-forming galaxies can be significantly enhanced by a factor of ∼ 3 − 6 \sim 3-6 when CHE stars above a minimum initial mass of m ⋆ , min CHE ∼ 2 − 10 ​ M ⊙ m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\sim 2-10~\rm M_{\odot} account for more than half of the total stellar mass following a Salpeter initial mass function. As a result, the UV luminosity functions observed at z ∼ 12 − 16 z\sim 12-16 can be reproduced with less extreme values of star formation efficiency and UV luminosity stochastic variability. Our results highlight the potential of CHE in explaining the UV-bright galaxy populations detected by JWST and call for future work to explore the broader astrophysical implications of CHE and its associated phenomena in the early universe, such as gamma-ray bursts, compact object binaries, and metal enrichment. I Introduction Early results from the JWST have challenged the standard model of galaxy formation in the high- z universe [ 7 ] , with the discovery of a surprising abundance of UV bright galaxies at z\gtrsim 10 [ 23 , 24 , 33 , 34 , 43 , 54 , 1 , e.g.,] . Two broad classes of explanations have been discussed, modifications to the underlying \Lambda CDM model of cosmological structure formation [ 55 , 80 , e.g.,] , or models that vary assumptions in the standard picture of star formation. The second (baryonic) category explores scenarios that either increase the stellar mass/star formation rate in a given dark matter host halo, by boosting the star formation efficiency [ 47 , 20 , SFE, e.g.,] or variability/burstiness of UV emission/star formation [ 79 , e.g.,] , or those that enhance the stellar light-to-mass ratio [ 22 , e.g.,] . An example for the latter explores a top-heavy initial mass function [ 47 , 16 , 93 , 96 , IMF; e.g.,] , as predicted for the metal-poor environments in the early universe [ 56 , e.g.,] . UV emission can also be enhanced when strong radiation-pressure driven outflows remove UV dust attenuation during the early evolution of high- z galaxies [ 32 , e.g.,] . Invoking a top-heavy IMF or an increased formation efficiency may, however, only boost star formation locally, but suppress it on galactic scales, by triggering disruptive stellar feedback, such as strong supernova (SN) activity [ 50 , e.g.,] . Here we propose a different (baryonic) solution for the early UV-bright galaxy problem: The stellar light-to-mass ratio is boosted because of a population of stars that undergo chemically homogeneous stellar evolution (CHE), which become more compact and hotter than stars without CHE 1 1 1 Similar but weaker effects can also be achieved by initial helium enhancement [ 51 ] . . Such CHE stage could be realized for rapidly rotating stars, where their structure adapts by triggering strong internal mixing currents [ 59 , 101 , 13 , 100 , 61 , 28 , 29 , 87 , 86 , 30 , 82 , 62 , 19 , 63 , 17 , 2 , 53 , 27 , 73 , 38 , 25 , e.g.,] . Rotation speeds close to the break-up value have been predicted for the first Population III (Pop III) stars, formed in the unique metal-free conditions 2 2 2 Magnetic fields arising from dynamo activity in the primordial protostellar disks could complicate the situation, leading to a possible bifurcation into cases of rapid and slow rotation [ 44 ] . of dark matter minihalos [ 83 , 84 ] . Similarly, metal-poor Population II (Pop II) stars may be able to retain their natal rotation speeds, because of their significantly reduced mass loss due to weakened radiatively-driven stellar winds [ 97 , e.g.,] . Recent direct observations of select O-type stars in nearby metal-poor dwarf galaxies suggest that stellar winds may be even weaker than what was previously predicted by theory [ 78 , 77 , 39 , 90 ] . The impact of a CHE-boost in the ionizing radiation of H, He, and possibly He + from Pop III stars on the early stages of reionization was explored in a previous study [ 81 ] , placing constraints on the fraction of Pop III stars that undergo CHE [see also e.g. 38 , and Liu et al. in prep.] . The reionization modeling, however, is subject to the uncertain escape fraction of ionizing radiation from the galaxy host halos, whereas any constraints from the non-ionizing UV continuum are more direct indications of the underlying stellar populations. We note that there have been recent indications for the metal enrichment from rapidly rotating stars in the first galaxies, inferred from their chemical abundance patterns with deep JWST spectroscopy. Prominent among them are high nitrogen-to-oxgen abundance ratios, e.g., in GN-z11 and RXCJ2248-ID [ 11 , 92 ] , which may be explained with models of rapidly rotating, massive stars [ 94 , 69 , e.g.,] . Another nucleosynthetic signature of rapidly rotating stars is the proposed boost in carbon production [ 57 , 49 ] , providing a possible explanation for strong carbon emission lines detected in z\gtrsim 12 galaxies [ 21 , e.g.,] and carbon-enhanced extremely metal-poor stars in the Milky Way [ 104 , e.g.,] . As the extreme outcome of rotational mixing, CHE leads to the maximal enhancement of carbon production [ 49 ] , although it is unclear whether nitrogen enhancement can be achieved by stars with CHE, which presumably depends on how the CHE phase starts and ends. We will therefore explore in the following whether a rapidly rotating subset of stars under CHE within the first galaxies can account for the emerging JWST phenomenology of UV bright galaxies in the first few hundred million years of cosmic history. II Chemically Homogeneous Evolution II.1 Stellar Evolution Figure 1: Rest-frame UV light curve: evolution of UV luminosity normalized by the total stellar mass for a single-age stellar population. The left (right) panel shows the results for a Salpeter (top-heavy) IMF, dN/dm_{\star}\propto m_{\star}^{-\alpha} , with a slope \alpha=2.35 (1) and a mass range m_{\star}\in[1.7,300]~\rm M_{\odot} for both non-rotating and CHE stars. The mass fraction of CHE stars f_{\rm CHE} is varied between 0 and 1, with lighter colors denoting larger f_{\rm CHE} . The stellar evolution models for stars evolving homogeneously are based on n=3 polytropes with a time-varying mass fraction of hydrogen, as detailed in Sibony et al. [81] . In that work Pop III stars with initial masses ( m_{\star} ) between 9 and 300 M ⊙ were computed. Here we complement our previous grid by adding tracks for lower initial mass stars with masses between 1.7 and 7 M ⊙ . As a comparison sample, we use the stellar tracks for non-rotating Pop III stars in the same mass range ( 1.7-300~\rm M_{\odot} ) from Murphy et al. [66] . Here, we only consider initially metal-free stellar evolution models for simplicity, while freely varying the IMF parameters (see Sec. II.2 below). We focus on the Main-Sequence (MS) phase where most UV photons are produced and ignore mass loss from stellar winds, which is minor for metal-poor stars [ 41 , 53 , e.g.,] . For metal-rich massive stars where winds are strong, the UV emission will be overestimated in our models. This renders our results as optimistic estimates. In fact, for non-rotating stars, the difference in rest-frame UV ( \lambda\sim 1500~\rm\AA ) luminosity made by changing the initial metallicity from Z=0 to Z=0.02 under a fixed Kroupa [52] IMF is small (within a factor of \sim 2 ) for a typical star formation timescale \sim 100 Myr, according to the Yggdrasil stellar population synthesis models [ 103 ] . For CHE stars, Kubátová et al. [53] found that changing the wind parameters (mass loss rate and clumping factor) has negligible effects on the UV spectrum around \lambda\sim 1000-3000\ \rm\AA during MS with helium mass fractions Y\lesssim 0.98 for m_{\star}\sim 20-130\ \rm M_{\odot} in the metal-poor regime ( Z=0.0002 ), although the impact of winds can be stronger at higher metallicities. However, the impact is expected to be smaller than the case of non-rotating stars since the strong surface enhancement of helium is the dominant factor in CHE, as implied by the smaller effects of metallicity on the properties of pure helium stars [ 48 , see, e.g., figs. 5 and 6 in] . Homogeneous evolution requires that the timescale for chemical mixing is much smaller than the nuclear timescale during the MS phase. The mixing timescale scales as R^{2}/D_{\rm mix} , where R is the stellar radius, and D_{\rm mix} the diffusion coefficient describing the transport of the chemical elements. Maeder & Meynet [60, see their paragraph 3.1] showed that the ratio of the mixing timescale to MS lifetime approximately varies as 1/m_{\star} for stars more massive than 15~\rm M_{\odot} . This indicates that when the mass decreases, the mixing timescale increases faster than the MS lifetime. Thus, we can expect to reach a lower initial mass limit, m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} , below which homogeneous evolution will not be obtained. The precise limit depends on the initial rotation and metallicity, with lower values when the initial rotation increases and when the metallicity decreases [ 10 , see, e.g., fig 4 in] , which is due at least in part to the fact that at lower metallicities, stars are more compact. This limit also depends on the physics used for chemical mixing and for the transport of angular momentum. These two transport mechanisms are intimately related since the gradients of chemical composition impact angular momentum transfer, which in turn influences the transport of the chemical elements. For this work, since we do not use a peculiar physical mechanism to obtain the homogeneous tracks, we simply consider the value of this limit as a free parameter. Most of the stellar models computed so far have focused on the massive stellar mass range down to lower masses between 4 and 10 M ⊙ [ 102 , 10 , 87 , 73 , see, e.g.,] , so we may wonder if it is justified here to extend this limit further. As indicated above, the limit depends on the physics of mixing which is still not yet fully understood. On the other hand, fast rotation is likely not the only process that may lead to homogeneous stars. For instance, grazing collisions have been found to result in nearly completely mixed stars producing blue stragglers, as observed in globular clusters [ 5 , e.g.,] . II.2 UV Emission and stellar populations As in Sibony et al. [81] , we consider stars to radiate as black bodies and compute their average spectral luminosity L_{\star,\nu}(t,m_{\star}) in a 100 Å window around the typical rest-frame UV wavelength of 1500 Å along their evolutionary tracks. We have verified using detailed stellar atmosphere models computed by the code tlusty [ 45 , 46 ] that the relative errors in L_{\star,\nu}(t,m_{\star}) introduced by the back-body assumption are within 30 % for most CHE and non-rotating stars with m_{\star}\sim 3-300\rm~M_{\odot} , surface gravities g\sim 10^{4.1-5.1}~\rm cm~s^{-2} , and effective temperatures T_{\rm eff}\sim 10^{4.3}-10^{5}~\rm K , that dominate the overall rest-frame UV emission. We also compare our results with those from Kubátová et al. [53] for CHE stars with Z=0.0002 and m_{\star}\sim 20-130\ \rm M_{\odot} , whose spectra are calculated using the atmosphere code powr [ 76 , e.g.,] from the evolutionary tracks computed by Szécsi et al. [87] . The discrepancy is also within 30% during MS ( Y\lesssim 0.98 ), mainly resulting from the different evolutionary tracks. When T_{\rm eff} is controlled, the difference caused by the black-body assumption alone is within 7%. It is shown below that our conclusions are robust despite these uncertainties. We consider a mixed stellar population containing both CHE and non-rotating stars as a single-age starburst. This population is defined by two parameters, the mass fraction f_{\mathrm{CHE}}\in[0,1] of CHE stars, and the minimal stellar mass m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\in~[1.7,20]\rm~M_{\odot} for CHE to occur. For a given choice of (f_{\mathrm{CHE}},m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}) , we first generate two stellar populations following a power-law IMF, dN/dm_{\star}\propto m_{\star}^{-\alpha} , with a slope of \alpha=2.35 [ 75 ] or \alpha=1 (top-heavy). The population of CHE stars is generated between m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} and m_{\star,\max}=~300\rm~M_{\odot} , while non-rotating stars span a fixed mass range from m_{\star,\min}=1.7~\rm M_{\odot} to m_{\star,\max}=300\ \rm M_{\odot} . For each population, we compute the total luminosity L_{\nu}(t) by summing up the L_{\star,\nu}(t,m_{\star}) for all stars that are still alive at time t , up to t=1~ Gyr, which is then normalized by the total initial stellar mass M_{\star} as \mathcal{L}_{\nu}(t)\equiv L_{\nu}(t)/M_{\star} . Finally, we combine the CHE and non-rotating populations so that the mass fraction of CHE stars is f_{\mathrm{CHE}} . For illustration, Figure 1 shows the resulting rest-frame UV light curves for m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=~1.7\rm~M_{\odot} and varying f_{\mathrm{CHE}} . Note that in the aforementioned default model, the overall IMF of the mixed population is no longer a strict power-law when f_{\rm CHE}>0 and m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}>m_{\star,\min}=1.7~\rm M_{\odot} as the CHE component is more top-heavy than the non-rotating component. An alternative approach is to turn a fraction of the stars above m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} into CHE stars while keeping the overall IMF fixed to the chosen power-law form. In this case, the mass fraction of CHE stars has an upper limit f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}=[\int_{m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}}^{m_{\star,\max}}m_{\star}(dN/dm_{\star})dm_{\star}]/[\int_{m_{\star,\min}}^{m_{\star,\max}}m_{\star}(dN/dm_{\star})dm_{\star}] as a function of m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} . Although we do not model this case explicitly, its outcomes can be estimated from the results of the default model via f_{\rm CHE}^{\max} , which do not change our conclusions made with the default model. Figure 2: Rest-frame UV luminosity per unit SFR \eta_{\rm UV} for a top-hat star formation history within a timescale t_{\rm SF}=100~\rm Myr . As in Fig. 1 , the left and right panel show the results for Salpeter and top-heavy IMFs, with \alpha=2.35 and 1 , respectively. While the mass range of non-rotating stars is fixed as m_{\star}\in[1.7,300]~\rm M_{\odot} , we plot \eta_{\rm UV} as a function of m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} for f_{\rm CHE}\in[0,1] , where f_{\rm CHE} increases for lighter colors (from bottom to top). The dotted curve with errorbars shows the maximum \eta_{\rm UV} in the alternative population model with a fixed overall IMF (corresponding to the maximum CHE mass fraction f_{\rm CHE}^{\max} ), which is estimated to be in between \eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}=f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}) and f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}\eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}=1) . We also show the reference value \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq 8.70~\times~10^{27} from Madau & Dickinson [58] with the dashed line, which is very close to our result for f_{\rm CHE}=0 given \alpha=2.35 . The shaded regions show the results for Pop III stars with extremely top-heavy IMFs from Inayoshi et al. [47] . III Impact on First Galaxy UV Emission To predict the UV magnitudes of high- z galaxies and make direct comparisons with observations, we focus on the UV emission efficiency \eta_{\rm UV}\equiv\kappa_{\rm UV}^{-1} defined as the inverse of the conversion factor \kappa_{\rm UV} between star formation rate (SFR) and rest-frame UV luminosity L_{\nu}(\rm UV) : {\rm SFR/(M_{\odot}~yr^{-1})}=\kappa_{\rm UV}L_{\nu}(\rm UV)/(erg~s^{-1}~Hz^{-1})~. (1) A reference value from local calibrations adopted by Madau & Dickinson [58] is \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq 8.70\times 10^{27} , corresponding to \kappa_{\rm UV}=1.15\times~10^{-28} . Given the single-age starburst results (see Fig. 1 ), we calculate \eta_{\rm UV} as a function of the CHE fraction f_{\rm CHE} and minimum mass m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} under different IMFs by integrating the stellar mass-normalized light curve \mathcal{L}_{\nu}(t) over a simple top-hat star formation history with a constant SFR for a period of t_{\rm SF} : \eta_{\rm UV}=\int_{0}^{t_{\rm SF}}\mathcal{L}_{\nu}(t)dt\times\rm M_{\odot}~yr^{-1}/(erg~s^{-1}~Hz^{-1})~. (2) We adopt t_{\rm SF}=100 Myr by default (see Appendix A for the results for t_{\rm SF}=10 and 1000 Myr) as the typical timescale of star formation probed by rest-frame UV emission, which is also close to the halo dynamical timescale and baryon cycle timescale at z\sim 10 [ 3 , 35 , 89 , e.g.,] . We have ignored the contribution of nebular emission and dust attenuation. As discussed in Appendix B , for moderately metal-enriched ( Z\gtrsim 0.0004 ) luminous high- z galaxies observable by JWST , the enhancement of rest-frame UV emission by CHE with t_{\rm SF}\gtrsim 10 Myr can be underestimated by up to a factor of \sim 2 in the absence of nebular emission, which is also expected to be enhanced for CHE stars due to their strong ionizing power [ 53 , 81 ] , and the effect is stronger for more metal-poor systems [ 103 ] . Therefore, our results without nebular contributions should be regarded as conservative estimates. The effect of dust attenuation can be effectively absorbed into the UV variability parameter [ 79 , see below and] . The results are shown in Fig. 2 . We obtain \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq~8.17~\times~10^{27} in the canonical case of Salpeter IMF without CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=0 ), which is very close to the reference value \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq 8.70~\times~10^{27} [ 58 ] . This further justifies our choice of t_{\rm SF}=100 Myr (as well as m_{\star,\min}=1.7~\rm M_{\odot} ). Interestingly, the enhancement of UV emission by CHE peaks at m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=4~(3)~\rm M_{\odot} for the Salpeter (top-heavy) IMF, reaching \eta_{\rm UV}\sim 5.14~(2.73)~\times~10^{28} for f_{\rm CHE}=1 , which is higher than the reference value by a factor of \sim 6 (3). Here, \eta_{\rm UV} does not increase monotonically with m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} because the (lifetime-integrated) rest-frame UV emission of CHE stars has a peak around m_{\star}\sim 2~\rm M_{\odot} and decreases for more massive stars, dropping even below the values for non-rotating stars at m_{\star}\gtrsim 100~\rm M_{\odot} . Here, massive stars become too hot under CHE, producing primarily more energetic (ionizing) photons [ 81 , Liu et al. in prep.] . For the same reason, the effect of CHE is generally stronger at m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\lesssim 10~\rm M_{\odot} when \alpha or t_{\rm SF} increase (see Appendix A ) or with a smaller IMF upper mass limit m_{\star,\max} . Without CHE, we obtain \eta_{\rm UV}=1.42~\times~10^{28} under our top-heavy IMF (that extends down to m_{\star,\min}=1.7~\rm M_{\odot} with \alpha=1 ), moderately increased by \sim 74 (63)% compared with the Salpeter (reference) case. It is shown in Inayoshi et al. [47, see their table. 1] that considering extremely top-heavy IMFs ( m_{\star}\gtrsim 10~\rm M_{\odot} ) for Pop III stars further increases the UV emission efficiency to \eta_{\rm UV}\sim 2.68-3.57~\times~10^{28} [ 8 , see also] . Comparable and higher values of \eta_{\rm UV} can be achieved by CHE with f_{\rm CHE}\gtrsim 0.5 and m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\sim 2-10~\rm M_{\odot} under a Salpeter IMF. Given the results of \eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}) in the default model, the maximum UV efficiency in the alternative case of a fixed overall IMF should be in between \eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}=f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}) (with optimistic contributions from non-rotating stars below m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} ) and f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}\eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}=1) (ignoring non-rotating stars below m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} ). The resulting values are very close to \eta_{\rm UV}(f_{\rm CHE}=1) for the top-heavy IMF ( \alpha=1 ) as f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}>0.94 . For the Salpeter IMF with f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}\sim 0.3-1 , the maximum UV emission efficiency peaks around m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\sim 3-4~\rm M_{\odot} given f_{\rm CHE}^{\max}\sim 0.7-0.8 , reaching \eta_{\rm UV}\sim 3.6-3.8~\times~10^{28} , which is still a factor of \sim 4 larger than the reference value. Once \eta_{\rm UV} is known, we derive the UV luminosity function (UVLF) using the model in Shen et al. [79] . First, we calculate the median UV magnitude M_{\rm UV} as a function of halo mass M_{\rm h} from the median {\rm SFR}=~\epsilon_{\star}f_{\rm b}\dot{M}_{\rm h} estimated by the median halo accretion rate [ 31 ] \begin{split}\dot{M}_{\rm h}&\simeq 25.3~{\rm M_{\odot}~yr^{-1}}\left(\frac{M_{\rm h}}{10^{12}{\rm M_{\odot}}}\right)^{1.1}\\ &\times(1+1.65z)\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm m}(1+z)^{3}+\Omega_{\Lambda}}~,\end{split} (3) and SFE [ 88 , 42 , e.g.,] \epsilon_{\star}=\frac{2\epsilon_{0}}{(M_{\rm h}/M_{0})^{-\gamma}+(M_{\rm h}/M_{0})^{\xi}}~. (4) Here f_{\rm b}\equiv\Omega_{\rm b}/\Omega_{\rm m}\simeq 0.16 is the cosmic baryon fraction, and we adopt \epsilon_{0}=0.1 , \gamma=0.6 , and \xi=0.5 based on Behroozi et al. [4, for the normalization and low-mass slope, matching the SFR - M h relation at = z 7 ] and Harikane et al. [42, for the high-mass slope] . Next, this median M_{\rm UV} - M_{\rm h} relation is combined with the halo mass function 3 3 3 We use the hmf package [ 67 ] to calculate the halo mass function with the Tinker et al. [91] model and real-space top-hat window function for a flat \Lambda CDM cosmology. The relevant cosmological parameters are based on Planck Collaboration et al. [72] results: H_{0}=67.66~\rm km~s^{-1}~Mpc^{-1} , \Omega_{\rm m}=0.30966 , n_{\rm s}=0.9667 , \sigma_{8}=0.8159 , and \Omega_{\rm b}=0.04897 . dn/d\log M_{\rm h} to derive the median UVLF dn_{\rm median}/dM_{\rm UV}=(dn/d\log M_{\rm h})|\frac{d\log M_{\rm h}}{dM_{\rm UV}}| , which is then convolved with a Gaussian kernel of width \sigma_{\rm UV} (mag) to predict the observable UVLF \Phi\equiv dn/dM_{\rm UV} . The last step captures the stochastic scatter in the scaling relations used above into the UV variability parameter \sigma_{\rm UV} . Figure 3: Constraints on UV emission efficiency and variability from JWST data. The colored curves show the values of \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} and \sigma_{\rm UV} required to reproduce \log(\Phi(M_{\rm UV}=~-20.5)~[\rm mag^{-1}~cMpc^{-3}])=-5 and -5.3 at z=10 (solid) and 12 (dash-dotted) based on spectroscopy, and \log(\Phi(M_{\rm UV}=-20.5)~[\rm mag^{-1}~cMpc^{-3}])=-4.5 , -5 , and -5.2 at z=10 (dashed), 12 (dotted), and 16 (long dashed) from photometry. Three representative cases of different \eta_{\rm UV} with fixed \epsilon_{0}=0.1 are shown by the thick vertical lines: the top-heavy models with no CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=0 , dashed) and optimal CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=1 , m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=3~\rm M_{\odot} , dash-dotted) and the Salpeter model with optimal CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=1 , m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=4~\rm M_{\odot} , dotted). The thin solid and dashed horizontal lines show the minimum and maximum UV variability estimated by Shen et al. [79] . Figure 4: UVLF for select degenerate models that meet the photometric constraints from JWST at z=12 , i.e., \log(\Phi(M_{\rm UV}=-20.5)~[\rm mag^{-1}~cMpc^{-3}])=-5 . These include the reference case with \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq 8.70~\times~10^{27} (solid) and the three representative models with enhanced UV emission from CHE and/or a top-heavy IMF considered in Fig. 3 . For comparison, the observational data for z\sim 11-13 [ 68 , 6 , 43 , 71 , 1 , 14 , 23 , 24 , 34 , 64 , 74 , 99 ] are shown using CoReCon [ 37 ] , among which the data points with arrows are upper limits. We also plot the results for constant SFE \epsilon_{\star}=0.03 , 0.1, 0.3, and 1 (from bottom to top) without UV variability as the thick solid lines. As illustrated in Shen et al. [79, see their fig. 3] , the UVLFs inferred from JWST observations place constraints on \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} and \sigma_{\rm UV} , which can be estimated by considering the value of \Phi at a typical magnitude M_{\rm UV}=-20.5 . Here, we require \log(\Phi(M_{\rm UV}=~-20.5)~[\rm mag^{-1}~cMpc^{-3}])=-5 and -5.3 at z=10 and 12 according to spectroscopic observations, and \log(\Phi(M_{\rm UV}=-20.5)\rm~[mag^{-1}~cMpc^{-3}])=-4.5 , -5 , and -5.2 at z=10 , 12, and 16 from photometric results, using the observational data compiled by the python package CoReCon 4 4 4 https://corecon.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.html [ 37 ] . The corresponding values of \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} and \sigma_{\rm UV} are shown in Fig. 3 , where larger \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} and/or \sigma_{\rm UV} are required to explain observations at higher z , and a smaller \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} can be compensated with a larger \sigma_{\mathrm{UV}} . To appreciate the trend and the degeneracy, we focus on 3 representative cases with boosted UV emission efficiency and fixed \epsilon_{0}=0.1 : the top-heavy ( \alpha=1 ) models with no CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=0 ) and optimal CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=1 , m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=4~\rm M_{\odot} ), and the Salpeter ( \alpha=2.35 ) model with optimal CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=1 , m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=3~\rm M_{\odot} ). The corresponding UV variability parameters inferred from the photometric constraints at z\sim 12 (16) are \sigma_{\rm UV}=1.75 , 1.40, and 0.98 (2.55, 2.31, and 2.06), respectively, while the reference value \eta_{\rm UV}\simeq 8.70~\times~10^{27} requires \sigma_{\rm UV}=1.98 (2.72). Clearly, with enhanced \eta_{\rm UV} from CHE, smaller (less extreme) values of \epsilon_{0} and \sigma_{\rm UV} are required to explain JWST results. In particular, only for the Salpeter model with optimal CHE ( f_{\rm CHE}=1 , m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=3~\rm M_{\odot} , \alpha=2.35 ) the \sigma_{\rm UV} needed at z\sim 16 remains below the maximum value 2.2 estimated by Shen et al. [79] . Fig. 4 shows the UVLFs of the (degenerate) models at z\sim 12 , which all agree well with current observations, but differ slightly in shape: The evolution of \Phi with M_{\rm UV} is stronger for larger (smaller) \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} ( \sigma_{\rm UV} ), especially at the luminous end. Therefore, high precision measurements of UVLFs (in larger survey volumes) can potentially break the degeneracy between \epsilon_{0}\eta_{\rm UV} and \sigma_{\rm UV} . Additional constraints from galaxy clustering properties are also useful [ 65 , 85 ] . IV Summary and Discussion We explore the contribution of rapidly rotating stars under chemically homogeneous evolution (CHE) to the rest-frame UV ( \lambda\sim 1500~\rm\AA ) emission of the first galaxies. By incorporating CHE into a simple population synthesis model under the assumptions of black-body spectrum and negligible nebular emission , we predict the UV emission efficiency \eta_{\rm UV}\propto L_{\nu}(\rm UV)/SFR as a function of the mass fraction f_{\rm CHE} and minimum mass m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE} of CHE stars with two power-law initial mass function (IMF) models ( dN/dm_{\star}\propto m_{\star}^{-\alpha} , \alpha=2.35 and 1, m_{\star}<300~\rm M_{\odot} ). We then adopt the model in Shen et al. [79] to calculate the relevant UV luminosity function (UVLF). We find that CHE can significantly enhance the rest-frame UV emission of star-forming galaxies, as efficient as alternative scenarios of enhanced star formation efficiency and top-heavy IMFs. Compared with the canonical value from local calibrations [ 58 ] , \eta_{\rm UV} is increased by a factor of \sim 3-6 for f_{\rm CHE}\gtrsim 0.5 and m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}\sim 2-10~\rm M_{\odot} with a Salpeter IMF ( \alpha=2.35 ) at the typical star-formation timescale t_{\rm SF}\sim 100 Myr. The effect of CHE is generally stronger for larger t_{\rm SF} or IMF slope \alpha . The enhanced UV emission from CHE can reproduce the UVLFs inferred from observations at z\sim 12-16 with less extreme values of star formation efficiency (SFE) and stochastic variability of UV luminosity, within the range of current theoretical predictions. Taking into account nebular emission can further enhance the effect of CHE by up to a factor of \sim 2 for Z\gtrsim 0.0004 (see Appendix B ). Moreover, compared with top-heavy IMFs, a potential advantage of the CHE scenario is that the enhancement of SN feedback is likely weaker, making it less vulnerable to the global suppression of star formation by such feedback [ 50 ] . We estimate the (IMF-averaged) SN energy per unit stellar mass \mathcal{E}_{\rm SN} for our pure CHE and non-rotating populations using the SN models in Goswami et al. [40] , assuming that the SN explosion of a star undergoing CHE is identical to that of the (pre-SN) helium core with the same mass (ignoring mass loss) 5 5 5 We have ignored two competing effects possibly associated with CHE: the enhancement of SN energy by fast rotation [ 12 , 61 , 15 , 36 , e.g.,] , and the reduction of core mass by strong Wolf-Rayet-like winds during post MS or near the end of MS [ 100 , 53 , 73 , 95 , e.g.,] . Taking them into account in a detailed investigation of the SN feedback from CHE stars is deferred to future work. . In the metal-poor regime ( Z\lesssim 0.01 ) of high- z galaxies, \mathcal{E}_{\rm SN} is enhanced by a factor of \sim 25-34 in the top-heavy ( \alpha=1 ) model of non-rotating stars compared with the canonical case of Salpeter IMF ( \alpha=2.35 ). On the other hand, in the optimal CHE model with \alpha=2.35 and m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=4~\rm M_{\odot} , \mathcal{E}_{\rm SN} is only boosted by a factor of \sim 8-11 , comparable to the increase of \eta_{\rm UV} . This means that the effects of CHE on UV emission and SN feedback can be similar to those of increasing the SFE. However, unlike the latter, CHE is not limited by the baryon mass budget. Besides, stellar UV spectra become harder under CHE [see also 81 , Liu et al. in prep.] which may play a role in the decrease of UV continuum slope \beta (from the fit L_{\lambda}\propto\lambda^{\beta} for \lambda\sim 1270-2600\ \rm\AA ) with redshift and extremely blue galaxies with \beta\lesssim-2.6 in observations [ 26 , e.g.,] . In our top-heavy (Salpeter) IMF models, for CHE stars with m_{\star,\min}^{\rm CHE}=1.7\ \rm M_{\odot} , we obtain \beta\sim-3 ( -2.4 ) and -2.3 ( -2 ) at 10 and 100 Myr after the starburst, respectively, while non-rotating stars give larger values, \beta\sim-2.7 ( -2.2 ) and -1.2 ( -1 ), under the same condition 6 6 6 Note that these results do not consider nebular enmission and treat stars as black bodies. According to the tlusty stellar atmosphere models, the spectral shape of UV continuum at \lambda\sim 1270-2600\ \rm\AA does not deviate much from that of black bodies for hot stars. Besides, the nebular contributions can be small in extremely blue galaxies due to high escape fractions and/or bursty star formation [ 26 ] . . Although this work focuses on the UV continuum, stellar and nebular lines are also affected by CHE and fast rotation in general [ 53 , 70 , e.g.,] . In addition to boosting the UV emission [as well as ionizing power, see, e.g., 81 , Liu et al. in prep.] of galaxies, populations of chemically homogeneous stars may have consequences for the nature of transients and for stellar nucleosynthesis. If homogeneous evolution is triggered by fast rotation, those stars (at least the massive ones) may produce long soft gamma ray bursts (GRBs), via the collapsar mechanism [ 101 , 102 , 13 , 100 , e.g.,] . With the extension to high redshifts considered here, GRBs may then also originate in the first galaxies [ 9 , e.g.,] , and their associated bright afterglows could act as background sources to probe the early intergalactic medium with absorption spectroscopy [ 98 ] . The latter would be an ideal target for the upcoming suite of extremely large telescopes (ELTs). CHE can play important roles in post-MS and binary stellar evolution, regulating the properties of evolved stars and binary products, such as Wolf-Rayet stars, X-ray binaries, and binary black hole mergers [ 29 , 100 , 62 , 19 , 63 , 53 , 27 , 73 , 95 , 18 , e.g.,] . Moreover, those stars, if they lose mass, may enrich their surroundings in helium, hydrogen-burning products, and possibly also some helium-burning products, while being depleted in lithium. This material could furthermore exhibit strong carbon over-abundances, thus leading to the formation of next-generation carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars [ 57 , 49 ] . All these aspects would deserve to be explored in future studies, illustrating the various manifestations of rapid rotation in the early universe. BL gratefully acknowledges funding from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Germany’s Excellence Strategy EXC 2181/1 - 390900948 (the Heidelberg STRUCTURES Excellence Cluster). YS and GM have received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement No. 833925, project STAREX). Appendix A SFR-UV conversion factors for different star-formation timescales Figs. 5 and 6 show the results of \eta_{\rm UV} for t_{\rm SF}=10 and 1000 Myr, respectively, complementing the results for t_{\rm SF}=100 Myr in Fig. 2 . Figure 5: Same as Fig. 2 but for a star-formation timescale t_{\rm SF}=10 Myr. Figure 6: Same as Fig. 2 but for a star-formation timescale t_{\rm SF}=1000 Myr. Appendix B Contribution of nebular emission We use the Yggdrasil models [ 103 ] to estimate the possible contribution of nebular emission in rest-frame UV. As shown in Fig. 7 , nebular emission is strongest for very young star-forming clouds, reaching up to \sim 40\% of the stellar luminosity in moderately metal-enriched environments with Z\geq 0.0004 . However, it decays with time and becomes negligible ( \lesssim 10\% of the stellar contribution) shortly ( \sim a few Myr \ll t_{\rm SF} ) after the starburst. Besides, for continuous star formation with a constant SFR over the past t_{\rm SF}=100~(10)\rm~Myr , the nebular luminosity is below 10~(20)\% of the stellar luminosity. Note that Zackrisson et al. [103] only consider non-rotatings stars without CHE and adopt a Kroupa [52] IMF in the mass range m_{\star}\in[0.1,100]~\rm M_{\odot} for Z\geq 0.0004 . The nebular emission is stronger at lower metallicities and when the stellar ionizing radiation is enhanced. In the Yggdrasil models of metal-free clouds hosting non-rotating Pop III stars, nebular emission can dominate the rest-frame UV luminosity in the first few Myr and remain comparable to stellar emission for up to \sim 20 Myr after a starburst or continuous star formation with t_{\rm SF}\sim 10-100 Myr. Here, the nebular contribution is approximately proportional to the stellar ionizing flux. If this trend holds for moderately metal-enriched ( Z\gtrsim 0.0004 ) galaxies most relevant for JWST observations, nebular emission can become comparable to stellar emission in rest-frame UV under CHE, since the production of ionizing photons is boosted by up to a factor of a few by CHE [ 81 , Liu et al. in prep.] . Figure 7: Ratio between nebular and stellar luminosities in rest-frame UV ( 1500\pm 50~\rm\AA ) from an instantaneous starburst and continuous star formation (starting at t=0 ) with a constant rate over timescales t_{\rm SF}=10 , 30, and 100 Myr (clockwise) for the Yggdrasil models [ 103 ] , assuming no leakage of ionizing photons (optimistic nebular emission). Among these are two models for Pop III stars with top-heavy IMFs: a Salpeter-like power-law ( dN/dm_{\star}\propto m_{\star}^{-2.35} ) in the range m_{\star}\in[50,500]~\rm M_{\odot} (Pop III.1, solid) and a log-normal distribution with characteristic mass m_{\star,\rm c}=10~\rm M_{\odot} and dispersion (in \ln m_{\star} ) \sigma=1 for m_{\star}\in[1,500]\ \rm M_{\odot} (Pop III.2, dashed), one Pop III model with a Kroupa [52] IMF in m_{\star}\in[0.1,100]\ \rm M_{\odot} (dash-dotted), three Pop II models with the same Kroupa [52] IMF and different metallicities: Z=0.0004 (dotted), 0.004 (long-dashed), 0.008 (dash-dot-dotted), and a Population I (Pop I, densely-dashed) model with the same Kroupa [52] IMF and Z=0.02 . For the cases with continuous star formation, we are mainly interested in the results at t=t_{\rm SF} (labeled with vertical lines), which denotes the moment of observation, i.e., when the galaxy has been forming stars for a duration of t_{\rm SF} .