Selectivity in Tip-Induced Skeletal Editing via Heteroatom Substitution Shantanu Mishra, Rasmus Svensson, Valentina Malave, Florian Albrecht, Manuel Vilas-Varela, Henrik Grönbeck, Leo Gross, Diego Peña Abstract Skeletal editing enables precise structural modifications of molecules at late stages of a synthetic sequence. We recently demonstrated skeletal editing on a single-molecule scale. Voltage pulses applied by the tip of a scanning probe microscope to an oxygen-containing seven-membered heterocycle led to both oxygen deletion and ring-contraction rearrangement reactions. An open question is whether selective skeletal editing of a heterocyclic core can be achieved by the choice of heteroatom. Here we show that tip-induced reactions of an analogous sulfur-containing seven-membered ring mainly result in sulfur deletion. Our results demonstrate that the combination of tip-induced chemistry and heteroatom selection in the molecular design is a powerful strategy for single-molecule skeletal editing, potentially enabling diverse structural transformations of heterocyclic frameworks. [ja6c12567_0005.webp] Skeletal editing refers to the late-stage modification of a molecular skeleton through insertion, deletion, or exchange of individual atoms (a). The field has received considerable attention as a means of reducing the need for de novo synthesis, and precise structural transformation of molecules, , with potential applications in drug discovery, green chemistry, and materials science. − In particular, deletion of a strategically placed heteroatom from a carbon-based cyclic skeleton can provide access to diverse carbocyclic motifs. While conventionally performed via solution-phase chemistry (with demonstrated examples of boron, nitrogen, − oxygen, , and sulfur deletion), extension of atom deletion to the single-molecule scale via tip-induced chemistry , could enable the synthesis of elusive molecules. In pursuit of single-molecule skeletal editing, we recently explored tip-induced reactions of individual dinaphtho­[1,8-bc:1′,8′-ef]­oxepine (DNO) molecules adsorbed on NaCl (b). Voltage pulses applied by the tip of a combined scanning tunneling microscope (STM) and atomic force microscope (AFM) to individual DNO molecules led to multiple reactions. Among all reacted molecules, nearly 50% corresponded to 1-perylenoxy radical resulting from ring-contraction rearrangement, whereas 33% corresponded to molecules generated via oxygen deletion, of which perylene was the major species (14% of all reacted molecules). The remaining molecules resulted from undesired side reactions. An open question is to what extent the selectivity of skeletal editing in a heterocyclic core can be directed toward a specific reaction by the choice of the heteroatom. In the present work we explore if heteroatom deletion can be favored over ring-contraction rearrangement by replacing oxygen with sulfur, hypothesizing that the lower C–S bond dissociation energy relative to the C–O bond would promote heteroatom deletion. We show that tip-induced reactions of dinaphtho­[1,8-bc:1′,8′-ef]­thiepine (DNT), which shares the same molecular structure as DNO but with sulfur replacing the oxygen atom, result in heteroatom deletion in virtually all cases, with perylene as the predominant product (c). DNT was synthesized via solution-phase chemistry (Scheme S1 and Figures S1 and S2) and deposited onto a single-crystal Cu(111) surface partially covered by two monolayer-thick (denoted bilayer) NaCl films (Figure S3). Similar to DNO, individual DNT molecules adsorbed on both Cu(111) and NaCl adopt a geometry where the sulfur atom points toward the surface. a–c shows STM and AFM images of a DNT molecule adsorbed on Cu(111). Related to the nonplanar geometry of DNT, two diagonally opposite benzenoid rings appear bright in AFM imaging due to their upward tilt. The remaining two benzenoid rings, which exhibit a downward tilt, appear notably dark, while the sulfur atom is not visible. d–f shows STM and AFM images of a DNT molecule adsorbed on NaCl, which exhibits stronger nonplanarity because of weaker molecule–surface interaction on NaCl compared to Cu(111) (see also Figure S4). The streaks in AFM images of DNT/NaCl (highlighted in e) likely result from conformational switching of the molecule due to interaction with the tip. The adsorption geometry inferred from AFM imaging is in line with the density functional theory (DFT) calculation of the adsorption geometry of DNT (g,h). Further measurements on DNT are shown in Figures S5 and S6. We applied voltage pulses to individual DNT molecules adsorbed on NaCl to trigger skeletal editing reactions (we did not observe skeletal editing on Cu(111), see Figure S7). Briefly, we first positioned the tip above a DNT molecule at set-point conditions of V = 0.2 V and I = 0.5 pA (V and I denote bias voltage and tunneling current, respectively). Then, we opened the feedback loop and retracted the tip by 9.5–12.0 Å to limit the current (typically, I < 30 pA at the final voltage). Finally, we increased the voltage to 4.7–5.0 V for 140 ms. If subsequent STM imaging indicated a change in the appearance of the molecule (Figure S8), we conducted AFM imaging to obtain the molecular structure. Upon application of voltage pulses to molecules adsorbed on a defect-free region on bilayer NaCl, we never found those molecules in a 200 Å × 200 Å scan frame. We presume that the molecules were picked up by the tip or displaced from NaCl islands onto Cu(111). Therefore, we applied voltage pulses to molecules adsorbed on bilayer NaCl at the step edges of third-layer NaCl islands, where the adsorption is stabilized. From 47 voltage pulses applied to 28 DNT molecules, we observed 17 molecules that underwent a reaction on the surface. In unsuccessful cases, the molecules were either displaced on NaCl without any reaction or not found. Sulfur deletion was the predominant reaction in successful cases (), accounting for 16/17 reacted molecules (94%) and resulting in the generation of perylene (14/17 cases, ∼82%) and, in a minority of cases, the perylenyl radical (compound 1, 2/17 cases). In one case, we observed the generation of compound 2 resulting from a side reaction. Notably, there was no ring-contraction rearrangement observed for DNT, in contrast to DNO where it was the dominant reaction. a shows an AFM image of a perylene molecule generated via tip-induced removal of the sulfur atom from DNT (see also Figure S9). STM imaging of the molecule at V = 2 V revealed the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) density (b), which agreed well with the calculated LUMO of perylene (Figure S10). This reinforced the assignment of the molecule as perylene. In a minority of cases, we also observed the generation of compound 1, which exhibited charge-state bistability between neutral (denoted 1 0 ) and anionic (denoted 1 – ) states (c). AFM imaging revealed that whereas 1 0 is planar (d), the trivalent carbon atom in 1 – binds to the surface, leading to a nonplanar adsorption geometry of 1 – (e). The assignment of charge states of 1 is supported by the absence (presence) of NaCl/Cu(111) interface-state scattering , by the neutral (charged) species (Figure S11). Finally, in one case, we observed the generation of compound 2 resulting from a ring-opening and cyclization side reaction. f,g shows the AFM image and chemical structure of 2, which consists of a fluoranthenyl core along with a functional group that we tentatively assign as buta-1,3-diene-1-thione. To elucidate the key experimental observations, namely, the predominance of atom deletion and the absence of ring-contraction rearrangement in skeletal editing of DNT relative to DNO, we performed DFT calculations of the reaction landscape of DNT and compared the results with our previous findings for DNO. a,b shows the reaction paths and energy barriers toward the generation of perylene and P1 in the gas phase. See Figure S12 for calculations on bilayer NaCl/Cu(111). Perylene results from atom deletion and is the predominant product of tip-induced reactions of DNT. P1, which results from ring-contraction rearrangement, was not observed in the present study but was the major product of tip-induced reactions of DNO. Starting from DNT (a), the first step involves migration of the sulfur atom to a C–C bridge site and formation of a central six-membered ring. The formation of the intermediate Int1­(S) is exothermic and associated with an activation energy ΔE ⧧ = 1.70 eV (the corresponding reaction DNO → Int1­(O) is endothermic and has ΔE ⧧ = 2.70 eV; see b). From Int1­(S), three reaction paths are possible, as for the case of Int1­(O). First, the sulfur atom can be directly eliminated, resulting in the generation of perylene. The associated ΔE ⧧ for Int1­(S) → perylene is 2.08 eV, substantially lower than ΔE ⧧ = 3.85 eV for Int1­(O) → perylene. Second, the sulfur atom can migrate to a neighboring bridge site, resulting in the intermediate Int2­(S) (ΔE ⧧ = 0.54 eV), from where it can again be eliminated to generate perylene, associated with ΔE ⧧ = 1.80 eV (for Int2­(O) → perylene, ΔE ⧧ = 3.44 eV). Third, a rearrangement reaction Int1 → Int3 can occur, which exhibits similar ΔE ⧧ values of 1.03 and 1.20 eV for the sulfur and oxygen cases, respectively, and is exothermic. From Int3, removal of the hydrogen atom bonded to the chalcogen results in the generation of the ring-contraction-rearrangement product P1, which exhibits similar ΔE ⧧ values of 3.16 and 3.28 eV for the sulfur and oxygen cases, respectively. The substantially lowered ΔE ⧧ (by more than 1.60 eV) for chalcogen elimination from Int1 and Int2 for sulfur compared to oxygen, along with the similar ΔE ⧧ values for the reaction Int3 → P1 for sulfur and oxygen (the difference being only 0.12 eV), results in the high selectivity for atom deletion in DNT. In conclusion, we demonstrate selectivity in skeletal editing of a heterocyclic core by the choice of the heteroatom. Combining single-molecule scanning probe experiments and density functional theory calculations, we show that tip-induced reactions of dinaphtho­[1,8-bc:1′,8′-ef]­thiepine adsorbed on NaCl predominantly lead to atom deletion. This is in contrast to our previous study on the oxygen-containing analogue dinaphtho­[1,8-bc:1′,8′-ef]­oxepine, where both ring-contraction rearrangement and atom deletion were observed as the majority and minority reactions, respectively. Our results demonstrate selective skeletal editing for a specific molecular system, and future directions could thus involve exploring the influence of molecular geometry, insulating surface, and molecular charge state on the reaction selectivity. Establishing control over atom deletion and ring-contraction rearrangement pathways could enable diverse applications in on-surface chemistry, such as the synthesis of elusive molecules (polyradicals or molecules with strained rings) by atom extrusion or imprinting electronic functionalities in graphene nanoribbons by edge functionalization. , The Supporting Information is available free of charge at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/jacs.6c12567. - Experimental and theoretical methods, solution-phase synthesis of DNT, NMR characterization of DNT, STM and AFM data, and DFT calculations of molecules adsorbed on bilayer NaCl/Cu(111) (PDF) R.S. and V.M. contributed equally. The authors declare no competing financial interest.