Extrapersonal barriers and facilitators to physical activity in rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases: a scoping review Authors: Thomas Davergne, Özgül Öztürk, Mohamed Saadi, David Ueckert, Leti van Bodegom-Vos, Salima van Weely, Özlem Feyzioğlu, Karin Niedermann, Anne-Kathrin Rausch Osthoff Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractObjectivesThis study aims to map patient-perceived extrapersonal determinants influencing physical activity (PA) behaviour among individuals with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases (RMDs).MethodsWe conducted a scoping review in accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidelines, registered in PROSPERO. PubMed, the Cochrane Library, and CINHAL were searched from inception to July 2025. Eligible studies included adults with inflammatory arthritis or osteoarthritis reporting extrapersonal barriers or facilitators of PA from the patient perspective. Determinants were coded using the Theoretical Domains Framework and synthesised inductively into higher-order domains.ResultsForty-two studies (29 qualitative studies and 13 surveys), including 3084 participants from 17 countries, were included. We identified 233 determinants, grouped into 25 themes across 3 domains: social, environmental, and system-level factors. Frequently reported determinants—acting as either barriers or facilitators depending on context—included social support, financial cost, weather conditions, access to adapted PA programmes, and work or family commitments. Several determinants received limited attention in prior reviews, such as habitual family activities, the role of children or grandchildren, pet ownership, proximity to natural environments, patient associations, and active transport.ConclusionsPA behaviour among people with RMDs is influenced by a wide range of contextual determinants that extend beyond individual motivation or disease-related factors. Implementation strategies should therefore address social, environmental, and system-level conditions to improve long-term adherence. Future research should assess the prevalence, perceived impact, and cross-country variability of these determinants. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC •Physical activity (PA) yields substantial benefits in rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases but remains insufficiently implemented. Physical activity (PA) yields substantial benefits in rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases but remains insufficiently implemented. •Previous reviews have mostly focused on individual determinants, with limited attention to extrapersonal factors. Previous reviews have mostly focused on individual determinants, with limited attention to extrapersonal factors. •A comprehensive synthesis of social, environmental and system-level influences was lacking. A comprehensive synthesis of social, environmental and system-level influences was lacking. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS •This review maps 233 determinants of PA across 25 extrapersonal themes using a Theoretical Domains Framework-informed framework. This review maps 233 determinants of PA across 25 extrapersonal themes using a Theoretical Domains Framework-informed framework. •New themes emerged, including family routines, caregiving roles, pet ownership, proximity to nature, patient associations, and active transport. New themes emerged, including family routines, caregiving roles, pet ownership, proximity to nature, patient associations, and active transport. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY •Implementation strategies should explicitly address social, environmental, and structural factors. Implementation strategies should explicitly address social, environmental, and structural factors. •Findings provide a basis for developing survey tools to quantify their prevalence and cross-cultural variability. Findings provide a basis for developing survey tools to quantify their prevalence and cross-cultural variability. Alt-text: Unlabelled box dummy alt text INTRODUCTION Rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases (RMDs), including rheumatoid arthritis (RA), axial spondyloarthritis (SpA), and osteoarthritis (OA), are major causes of global pain and disability [1]. Physical activity (PA) is central to their management, improving pain, function, quality of life and comorbidities [[2], [3], [4], [5]], and is strongly recommended by European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology (EULAR) and American College of Rheumatology (ACR) [6,7]. Yet PA levels remain insufficient in individuals with RMDs [8,9], with only 27% of individuals with RA or SpA meeting PA recommendations [8] and those with OA or RA performing 50 to 200 fewer minutes of PA per week than healthy adults [10]. This gap limits the benefits of PA on symptoms and disease activity [6,11]. Although recent guidelines propose strategies to support PA [6], interventions often fail to sustain long-term engagement [12,13], highlighting the need to incorporate barriers and facilitators into implementation efforts [6,14]. Existing studies have mainly addressed personal determinants, such as symptoms, motivation, and beliefs [[15], [16], [17]], while organizational and system-level influences highlighted by IMPACT-RMD (for IMplementation of Physical Activity into routone Clinical pracTice in Rheumatic Musculoskeletal Disease) remain underexplored [18]. As a result, current PA strategies focus predominantly on individual-level barriers, overlooking social, environmental, and structural factors that may shape behaviour [12,19,20], including healthcare system characteristics, environmental infrastructure, cultural norms, and work or family demands. Identifying extrapersonal determinants is therefore essential to develop context-sensitive strategies that support adherence to PA recommendations [6]. In line with prior work distinguishing intrapersonal from extrapersonal influences on health behaviours [21], and consistent with socioecological and implementation frameworks and previous reviews describing social, environmental, and system-level determinants, we use the term ‘extrapersonal’ as an integrative label to capture contextual factors operating beyond the individual. Previous reviews in OA [[22], [23], [24]], SpA [25], and older adults [26] suggest the relevance of such factors but were not designed to specifically examine them. Only 1 review used the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) [24], without focusing on extrapersonal domains, underscoring the need for a comprehensive synthesis dedicated to these determinants. The review sought to answer the following question: among adults with inflammatory arthritis (IA) or OA (Population), what extrapersonal social, environmental and system-level determinants (Concept) influence engagement in PA (Context)? Thus, the objective of this scoping review was to identify patient-perceived extrapersonal barriers and facilitators influencing PA behaviour among individuals with RMDs. METHOD We conducted a scoping review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses for scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines [27] and methodological frameworks proposed by Arksey and O’Malley [28], further refined by Levac et al [29] and the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Manual for Evidence Synthesis [30]. The protocol was developed according to PRISMA-Protocols [31] and registered in PROSpective REgister of SYstematic REview (PROSPERO) (CRD420251090705). Eligibility criteria Population We included adults (≥18 years) with IA (RA, axial SpA) or hip/knee OA. IA and OA were examined jointly because international PA recommendations frequently address these conditions together [6], and because they share chronic pain, functional limitations, and behavioural challenges related to PA engagement, allowing identification of common extrapersonal determinants while preserving condition-specific nuances. Hip and knee OA were selected because they are the most prevalent and disabling forms of OA and are specifically addressed in current PA and nonpharmacological management guidelines, including those by EULAR [6]. OA affecting the foot and ankle was excluded to ensure greater clinical homogeneity, as evidence and guideline recommendations for these sites are limited and their functional and management characteristics differ from hip and knee OA [32]. Studies including mixed conditions were eligible when IA or OA constituted the majority of participants. Concepts Eligible studies had to identify extrapersonal barriers and/or facilitators to PA behaviour, that is, at social, environmental, and systemic levels from the participant’s perspective. Barriers and facilitators were defined as any participant-reported belief, experience, factor, opinion, reason, or perception that could influence engagement in PA, either by hindering or by supporting PA behaviour. Studies based on the perspective of healthcare professionals were excluded because the review aimed to capture patient-perceived determinants of PA behaviour. Determinants related to professional practice or service implementation from the provider perspective were considered conceptually distinct. PA followed the WHO definition of bodily movement requiring energy expenditure [33] and included all forms of structured or unstructured PA. Context We included qualitative (interviews and focus groups) and quantitative (surveys) studies. Articles focusing exclusively on individual-level barriers and facilitators were excluded since our objective specifically concerned extrapersonal determinants. No restrictions were applied regarding language, country, or publication date. Only peer-reviewed full-text articles were considered eligible. We excluded protocols, abstracts, commentaries, documentary analyses, structured observations, and consensus methods. Randomised controlled trials, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses were also excluded because the objective of this review was to identify patient-perceived determinants of PA behaviour rather than to evaluate intervention effectiveness. While such designs may occasionally report barriers or facilitators, they are not primarily structured to systematically explore behavioural determinants. Information sources and search strategy We searched PubMed, the Cochrane Library, and CINAL from inception to July 2025. Search strategies combined terms related to PA, barriers/facilitators, and RMDs (Table 1). The search strategy was developed iteratively by 2 reviewers with expertise in rheumatology and behavioural research. Search terms and their synonyms were discussed and refined through consensus prior to finalisation. The strategy was pilot-tested in PubMed and adjusted to optimise sensitivity and specificity before being adapted to the other databases. We also performed backward and forward citation searches of included studies and relevant reviews (systematic, scoping, and narrative). Grey literature was not searched as the objective was to synthesise patient-reported determinants derived from empirically designed qualitative and survey studies with sufficient methodological detail to support theory-informed coding. Table 1Search equations used for the 3 databases and corresponding results in July 2025Table 1 dummy alt textDatabaseSearch equationResultsPubMed("barrier*"[Title/Abstract] OR "facilitator*"[Title/Abstract] OR "limit*"[Title/Abstract] OR "determin*"[Title/Abstract] OR "obstacle*"[Title/Abstract]) AND ("physical activity"[Title/Abstract] OR "exercise"[Title/Abstract] OR "training"[Title/Abstract] OR "sport*"[Title/Abstract]) AND ("Osteoarthritis"[Title/Abstract] OR "rheumatoid arthritis"[Title/Abstract] OR "ankylosing spondylitis"[Title/Abstract] OR "psoriatic arthritis"[Title/Abstract] OR "chronic inflammatory arthritis"[Title/Abstract] OR "spondylitis"[Title/Abstract] OR "arthritis"[Title/Abstract] OR "spondylitis, ankylosing"[MeSH Terms] OR "arthritis, rheumatoid"[MeSH Terms] OR "Osteoarthritis"[MeSH Terms])5339The Cochrane Library((barrier*) OR (facilitator*) OR (limit*) OR (determin*) OR (obstacle*)) AND ((physical activity) OR (exercise) OR (training) OR (sport*) OR (Behavior*) AND ((osteoarthritis) OR (rheumatoid arthritis) OR (ankylosing spondylitis) OR (psoriatic arthritis) OR (chronic inflammatory arthritis) OR (spondylitis) OR (arthritis) OR (Spondylitis, Ankylosing) OR (Arthritis; Rheumatoid) OR (Osteoarthritis))4649CINHAL((barrier*) OR (facilitator*) OR (limit*) OR (determin*) OR (obstacle*)) AND ((physical activity) OR (exercise) OR (training) OR (sport*) OR (Behavior*)) AND ((osteoarthritis OR (rheumatoid arthritis) OR (ankylosing spondylitis) OR ( psoriatic arthritis) OR (chronic inflammatory arthritis) OR (spondylitis) OR (arthritis) OR (Spondylitis, Ankylosing) OR (Arthritis; Rheumatoid) OR (Osteoarthritis))3515 Search equations used for the 3 databases and corresponding results in July 2025 Study selection Identified records were imported into Rayyan software (https://www.rayyan.ai/, Rayyan Systems Inc) and duplicates removed [34]. Screening of titles, abstracts, and full texts was performed by 1 reviewer (MS) and checked by a second (TD); disagreements were resolved through discussion or consultation with a third reviewer when required. Data extraction A standardised data extraction form was piloted on 5 studies and used to collect study characteristics and patient-reported extrapersonal determinants. For surveys, determinants were extracted when ≥30% of participants endorsed them, in line with previous scoping work integrating quantitative and qualitative designs. This threshold was used as a pragmatic criterion to identify determinants meaningfully reported within individual studies and did not constitute a quantitative pooling or meta-analytic procedure. No effect sizes were extracted, and no quantitative synthesis was conducted. Synthesis methods We used a framework-informed thematic synthesis. First, study-level themes and quotations were coded using relevant domains of the TDF—including social/professional role and identity, reinforcement, environmental context and resources, social influences, and behavioural regulation [[35], [36], [37]]. Second, we applied inductive refinement to preserve concepts not fully captured within TDF domains. Themes were then consolidated across studies and grouped into 3 higher-order domains reflecting external loci of influence [38,39]: social factors, environmental factors, and system-level factors. Study-level coding and cross-study synthesis were performed independently by 2 reviewers (TD and MS), with disagreements resolved through team discussions. Consistent with scoping review methodology [31], no risk of bias assessment was conducted. RESULTS Study selection and characteristics From 12,304 database records and 26 additional sources, 42 studies met the inclusion criteria (Fig and Table 2) [17,37,[40], [41], [42], [43], [44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52], [53], [54], [55], [56], [57], [58], [59], [60], [61], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68], [69], [70], [71], [72], [73], [74], [75], [76], [77], [78], [79]]. Flow diagram of studies included in the review. Abbreviation: CINHAL, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature. Table 2Study characteristicsTable 2 dummy alt textAuthor, year and countryObjectivesDesignCondition (n=)Barriers and facilitators to PABaxter 2016 (New Zealand) [40]To examine the attitudes and perceived barriers to exercise of women with RASemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 8)Need support from loved ones to exerciseExercise may worry their support personSharing activity makes PA more enjoyableConfusion about the health professional roleToo much information, overwhelmingGP should give exercise recommendationsBad weather as a barrierEnvironment may pose extra risksBell 2022 (United Kingdom) [41]To explore the barriers and facilitators during the transition from a National Health Service-run exercise programme into exercising in the communitySemistructured focus groupsInflammatory arthritis (majority of RA, psoriatic arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis) (n = 13)Work commitment Cost of facilities Accessibility of facilities Transport Available information Family commitment PT national or regional policy Recreation facilities, locations, transportation and cost Importance of peer supportBrittain 2011 (USA) [42]To examine whether the presence of general and arthritis-specific barrier categories and the limitation of these overall categories were significant predictors of participation in moderate PA among women with arthritisCross-sectional surveyOA (n = 248)Outside temperature keeps me from exercisingNo exercise time fits my scheduleWorry about body image around othersDo not feel athletic enough for a groupLong work hours leave me too tiredInsurance does not cover exercise costsHard to schedule exercise with othersWork takes all my exercise timeOther exercisers make me uncomfortableExercise costs too much to participateHard to find a partner with the same skillsTravel to facility takes too much timeNo free facilities in my communityWorkplace lacks exercise spaceInstructors give no arthritis optionsNo arthritis programmes in my communityCrowley 2009 (Ireland) [43]To identify barriers to exercise in RA and to identify facilitators to exercise and methods to increase complianceSemistructured focus groupsRA (n = 12)Lack of professional input Inaccessible facilities Surgery Medications Potential embarrassment Empathetic specialist professional input Correct exercise instruction Common ground Group therapy Heat Having psychological issues addressedDemirulus 2025 (Turkey) [45]To compare PA levels and exercise-related perceptions (benefits and barriers) between patients with radiographic axSpA and nonradiographic axSpA (...)Cross-sectional surveySpA (n = 123)Exercise takes too much of my time Places for my exercise are too far awayEvans 2016 (Canada) [46]To explore the perceptions of patient and public involvement representatives with OA on the facilitators and barriers for their engagement with exerciseSemistructured individualinterviewsOA (n = 7)Information about activity vs exerciseLack of knowledge about OA and exercisePsychological impact of OA and exerciseInfluence and support of othersFisken 2016 (New Zealand) [47]To investigate reasons for ceasing participation in aqua-based exercise among older adults with OASemistructured focus groupsOA (n = 60)Inappropriate classes Instructor was not geared up for my particular disability Cold weather Cost Social interaction with othersFongen 2015 (Norway) [48]To explore barriers and facilitators for being physically active in a group of patients with axSpACross-sectional surveyAxSpA (n = 148)Lack of time Exercise plan Individual adaptation of PAFreid 2020 (USA) [49]To (...) identify exercise barriers and facilitators, and explore patients’ perceptions of interactions with rheumatology providers about exerciseCross-sectional surveyInflammatory arthritis (RA, psoriatic arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis) (n = 108)Cannot afford the exercise I wantNo time to exercise regularlyDoctor’s advice about exerciseWish doctor talked more on exerciseSupport from partner to stay activeGay 2018 (France) [50]To explore the motivators for and barriers to regular PA in people with knee OASemistructured individual interviews and focus groupsKnee OA (n = 27)Lifestyle active family habitsSocial support and others’ viewsEnvironment facility accessibilityEnvironment no rural swimming poolCosts no bike availableSocial body shaming women obeseGreysen 2017 (USA) [51]To explore yoga participation as a symptom management strategy in adults with RA who acknowledged that they participated in yoga at some point in the past yearSemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 17)Influence of others Cost Class difficultyGyurcsik 2009 (Canada) [52]To examine whether barrier frequency, barrier limitation, and efficacy to cope were predictors of planned PA among adult women with arthritis, who are at particular risk for inactivityCross-sectional surveyOA (n = 80)Bad weather Other commitments Icy conditions of sidewalks Employment Family commitmentsHenchoz 2013 (Switzerland) [53]To determine the distribution of exercise stages of change in a RA cohort, and to examine patients’ perceptions of exercise benefits, barriers, and their preferences for exerciseCross-sectional surveyRA (n = 89)Outside temperature keeps me from exercisingDo not feel athletic enough for a groupHard to find a partner with the same skillsHard to schedule exercise with othersExercise costs too much membershipPolicy makers do not support arthritis PADo not know others with arthritis exerciseHendry 2006 (United Kingdom) [54]To examine the views of primary care patients with OA knee towards exercise, explore factors that determine the acceptability and motivation to exercise, and to identify barriers that limit its useSemistructured focus groupsKnee OA (n = 22)Support from healthcare professionalsAdvice referrals supervision from providersSocial support in groups or with partnerFear of other people’s gazeGym bikes are safer than cycling in trafficGyms are safer for women than walking aloneKamwendo 1999 (Sweden) [55]To achieve a better understanding of how patients with RA perceive and relate to PA in their everyday livesSemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 10)Lack of support/Social support Lack of time Cold weather (more clothes/unpleasant outside)/Heat Organised exercises Active transport (biking)Kaptein 2013 (Canada) [56]To examine the perceptions of PA among individuals managing arthritis in addition to employment and other role demandsSemistructured focus groupsOA or inflammatory arthritis (n = 30)Duties at work or with family, kids, house Social supportKing 2022 (Canada) [37]To elucidate strategies to improve OA care in persons with T2DM, we assessed their perceptions of the barriers and enablers to seeking and engaging in OA careSemistructured individualinterviewsOA with T2DM (n = 18)Lack of provider support limits OA careAccess to facilities helps manage OASocial supports keep me engaged in OAListen to peers on OA managementLaw 2010 (United Kingdom) [57]To explore the perceptions of patients regarding the effects of exercise on joint healthSemistructured focus groupsRA (n = 18)Health professionals showing a lack of exercise knowledge (uncertain regarding the specifics of exercise prescription and concerns about exercise and joint health)Lee 2025 (Singapore) [58]To identify facilitators and barriers to PA in patients with RA and AxSpA using the validated Inflammatory arthritis FAcilitators and Barriers (IFAB) questionnaire (...)Cross-sectional surveyRA + AxSpA (n = 222)Weather conditions Presence of support from healthcare professionals Advice from healthcare professionalsLoeppenthin 2014 (Denmark) [59]To describe the experience of PA maintenance in patients with RASemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 16)To experience a community with othersMcKevitt 2022 (United Kingdom) [60]To investigate the attitudes towards, and beliefs about, PA in older adults with OA and comorbidity to understand experiences and seek ways to improve PA participationSemistructured individualinterviewsOlder adults with OA and comorbidity (n = 17)Social support Support by health professional Adapted PA/exercise Social-environmental: lack of exercise partner Limited transportNiedermann 2019 (Switzerland) [17]To explore the barriers and facilitators for vigorous cardiorespiratory training among patients, physiotherapists, and rheumatologistsCross-sectional surveyAxSpA (n = 575)Difficult time planning High time expenditure No possible at work Not possible on way to work Dependence of weather Instructor my not be familiar with diseaseO’Dwyer 2016 (Ireland) [61]To explore the attitudes towards PA and exercise of adults with AxSpASemistructured individualinterviewsAxSpA (n = 17)Lack of resources (time, financial, and access) Misinformation (expertise) Social support network Group exercise Monitoring by healthcare professional Individual programmesGroup exercise resourcesExternal support: Professional expertise Family and friends, Support groups TechnologyPark 2020 (Korea) [62]To identify barriers to and facilitators of PA among Korean female adults with knee OA and comorbidity, such as hypertension, diabetes, and dyslipidaemiaSemistructured individualinterviewsOA (n = 10)Time constraintsAccess appropriate facilitiesPassalent 2022 (Canada) [63]To understand perspectives of the importance of PA in the management of axial SpA; To describe factors associated with PA adherenceSemistructured individualinterviewsAxSpA (n = 12)Social support networks Access to gym Active transport (you can get there on foot, or travel by bike)Petursdottir 2010 (Island) [64]To increase knowledge and understanding of the experience of exercising (...) and to determine what they perceive as facilitators and barriers to exercisingSemistructured individualinterviewsOA (n = 12)Family support Group exercise Physical therapists’ professional care Physician's encouragement Training partners Socioeconomic status Weather Availability of exercise classes Availability of facilities TransportationRasmussen 2020 (Netherlands) [65]To study the association between self-reported PA level and overall attitudes and barriers to and facilitators of PA in people with AxSpACross-sectional surveyAxSpA (n = 445)Exercising together with a friend Great exercise facilities Competent and engaged physiotherapist Short distance to exercise facilities Free exercise My partner supports me in exercisingRausch 2022 (Switzerland) [66]To understand beliefs related to PA in people living with AxSpASemistructured focus groupsAxSpA (n = 24)Group settingInfluence of relatives and healthcare professionals Exercising together with other people Technology supportRodríguez 2017 (Spain) [44]To explore barriers to exercise of patients with spondyloarthritis and to propose facilitatorsSemistructured focus groupsAxSpA (n = 22)No coverage activities costly, limited hoursLack of supportNo reinforcement from the physicianPatient’s circle is not engaged in sportsExercises are too hard or not progressivePoor experiences with supervisionWork-family caregiving responsibilitiesAvoids others, not physical causesHigh cost Lack of exercise informationNo openings or available hoursRole of patient associations reinforcedAdapt the exercise to the individual situationShah 2022 (USA) [67]To explore interrelations between factors related to engagement inPA in inactive adults with knee painSemistructured focus groupsKnee OA (n = 35)Built environment Natural environment (weather, incline) Social perceptions Relationships Kids Exercise as prescription Ambulation or aids for the activities of daily livingsStone 2017 (Canada) [68]To investigate potential facilitators and barriers to PA for adults with OASemistructured individualinterviewsOA (n = 15)Social support Inadequate medical supportSundström 2022 (Sweden) [69]To evaluate exercise habits among patients with ankylosing spondylitis, their clinical status, and what mainly restrains these patients from exercisingCross-sectional surveyAnkylosing spondylitis (n = 189)Economical barriers Distance to facilities as barriersSwärdh 2008 (Sweden) [70]To explore and describe ways of understanding exercise maintenance among individuals with RA who had already started to exerciseSemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 18)External control, monitoring, and support Safety instruction Social support Guidance Collaboration Occasional minor advice (scheduling, type) Shared responsibility (feeling of autonomy) Inspiration Costs Cold climate for performing exerciseTan 2018 (United Kingdom) [71]To investigate factors associated with PA engagement among patients with RA and identify their preference for PA supportCross-sectional surveyRA (n = 96)Outside temperature keeps me from exercisingWorried about body image around othersNo exercise time fits my schedule workNo free facilities in my communityHard to find a partner with same skillsDo not know others with RA who exercisePartner discourages me from exercisingExercise costs too much for a membershipFixed income makes exercise unaffordableInsurance does not cover exercise costsTravel to the facility takes too much timeWorkplace has no exercise spaceUnsafe neighbourhood, no streetlightsPartners or friends do not exercisePartners or friends not supportiveOther exercisers make me uncomfortableChildcare leaves no time to exerciseNo public parks or trails availableBad pavements hinder the RA exerciseNo arthritis programmes in my communityInstructors ignore RA stiffnessInstructors ignore RA pain limitsInstructors give no RA exercise optionsCouncil does not support RA exerciseThomas 2019 (United Kingdom) [72]To explore the perspectives, experiences, and strategies employed by people with RA who successfully engage with regular PASemistructured individualinterviewsRA(n = 15)Hesitant about group activity with the general populationThorstensson 2006 (Sweden) [73]To describe conceptions (...) of exercise as treatment among 16 middle-aged patients with moderate to severe knee OASemistructured individualinterviewsKnee OA (n = 16)Accessibility Moral support, encouragement, and instructions on how to exerciseVidem 2023 (Norway) [74]To investigate associations of the presence of RA and levels of stress and depression with scores for facilitators and barriers to PA, using a new questionnaire (FasBarPAQ)Cross-sectional surveyRA (n = 203)Clear advice I do not have enough time for PA Social interaction Support from friends and family Few available activities and/or long travel timeWang 2015 (United Kingdom) [75]To explore the perceptions and beliefs of people with RA about engaging in exerciseSemistructured individualinterviewsRA (n = 6)Conflict in advice from healthcare professionalsWebber 2020 (Canada) [76]To explore the understanding of PA and sedentary behaviour, including barriers and health influences (...)Semistructured focus groupsKnee OA and knee arthroplasty (n = 22)Weather Availability of exercise facilities/equipment Influences from family members, friends, kids, and petsWilcox 2006 (USA) [77]To examine perceived exercise barriers, benefits, and enablers in exercising and nonexercising adults with arthritisSemistructured focus groupsArthritis (majority of OA and RA) (n = 68)Social support Doctor gave no exercise advice or referralPerson to exercise with Cost Transportation Arthritis specific facilities (water exercise) Programmes for people with arthritis WeatherWithall 2016 (United Kingdom) [78]To explore patient’s views on approaches to delivering PA programmes (…)Semistructured focus groupsRA (n = 19)Support from peers and ‘experts’ Reminder phone calls or text messages Practising in group Accessible location and transportSessions in the community leisure centreZhang 2025 (China) [79]To investigate the awareness, implementation, and factors influencing PA engagement (…)Cross-sectional surveyAxSpA (n = 151)Weather Support from friends and familySupport or advice from professionalsAxSpA, axial spondyloarthritis; OA, osteoarthritis; PA, physical activity; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; SpA, spondyloarthritis; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. Study characteristics AxSpA, axial spondyloarthritis; OA, osteoarthritis; PA, physical activity; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; SpA, spondyloarthritis; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. The 42 included studies, published between 1999 and 2025, were predominantly conducted in high-income countries, most often in the United Kingdom (n = 8), Canada (n = 7), the United States (n = 5), and Sweden (n = 4), with additional studies from 12 other countries (n = 18). Most used qualitative designs (n = 29), including semistructured interviews (n = 16), focus groups (n = 12) or both (n = 1), whereas 13 employed cross-sectional surveys. The conditions studied ranged broadly across RMDs: OA (n = 14), RA (n = 13), and SpA (n = 10), with 3 studies addressing IA more generally and 2 including mixed OA/IA populations. Across all studies, 3084 participants were included, with sample sizes ranging from 6 to 575 (median 35), reflecting the predominance of qualitative interview-based research. Synthesis of results Across the 42 studies, 233 determinants were identified and consolidated into 25 themes across 3 domains (Table 3). Table 3Summary of barriers and facilitators to physical activity from the perspective of individuals with RMDs and the number of supporting referencesTable 3 dummy alt textCategoryExplanationSocial factorn = 33 Social support of personal networkSupport from relatives, friends, or colleagues; encouragement facilitates, lack of support hinders.26 Social support of healthcare professionalsSupport from healthcare providers through guidance and monitoring; absent or conflicting advice hinders.24 Social interaction during activityEffect of social pressure, comparison, and group exercise; may motivate or discourage participation.16 Planned and habitual family activitiesPlanned activities and exercise habits within the family; shared routines encourage activity, absence limits it.6 Body image comparisonComparing one’s body with others; may motivate change but can discourage through negative self-perception.5 Children or grandchildrenChildren or grandchildren influence PA through active play or caregiving constraints.4 Pet ownershipPet ownership, especially a dog, promotes activity via regular walks and play.1Environmental factorsn = 40 Adapted and supervised programsTailored, supervised exercise programmes increase safety and effectiveness; absence may hinder activity.16 Weather conditionsWeather conditions influence PA; mild climate supports, extreme heat or icy conditions hinder.16 Proximity to sport facilitiesNearby sports facilities, including workplace access, reduce time and travel barriers.15 Qualified and supportive instructorsInstructors with RMDs expertise ensure safety and adaptation; poor guidance can discourage.13 Transport to sports facilitiesConvenient transport, parking, and travel times support PA; poor access is a barrier.10 Digital access and other support resourcesAvailability of digital and nondigital means to access information, guidance, monitoring, and motivation for physical activity.9 Accessibility to convenient settingConvenient access to gyms, community centres, hospitals, and flexible opening hours supports participation.9 Safety of the environmentAdequate lighting, traffic, and hazard control encourage PA; unsafe conditions deter participation.5 Living environmentFeatures such as stairs, gardens, or infrastructure influence daily PA opportunities.3 Proximity to natureAccess to green spaces and fresh air motivates and enhances PA.2 Active transportCycling or stair climbing integrates PA into daily routines.2 Self-directed exercise programsPrescribed home-based exercises foster autonomy but may raise issues of safety or adherence.2 Walking and mobility aidsWalking or daily living aids support participation by improving mobility; lack of aids can be a barrier.2 Patient associationsAssociations promote PA via peer support, advocacy, and organised programs; absence limits opportunities.1System factorsn = 26 Costs and financial resourcesFinancial factors such as fees, and equipment; coverage facilitates, costs hinder.18 Work and family responsibilitiesWork, caregiving, and family obligations limit time for PA; exercise may be seen as conflicting with duties.16 Health insurance coverageReimbursement of exercise costs or supervised programmes facilitates participation; lack of coverage hinders.3 SurgeryScheduled or past surgery can be an encouragement, while the absence of surgery can be a disincentive if it is hoped for.1PA, physical activity; RMD, rheumatic and musculoskeletal disease. Summary of barriers and facilitators to physical activity from the perspective of individuals with RMDs and the number of supporting references PA, physical activity; RMD, rheumatic and musculoskeletal disease. Social factors Social influences were among the most prominent barriers and facilitators for PA behaviour and were identified in a total of 33 studies [17,37,[41], [42], [43], [44],46,47,[49], [50], [51],53,55,56,[58], [59], [60], [61],[63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68],[70], [71], [72], [73], [74],[76], [77], [78], [79]]. Social support from the personal network (family, friends, and colleagues), identified in 26 studies, promoted participation through encouragement and shared involvement, while its absence or negative encouragement hindered engagement. Similarly, social support of healthcare professionals was described as a facilitator when clear guidance, safety monitoring, and encouragement were provided, but as a barrier when advice was absent or contradictory. Social interaction during activity not only fosters motivation, enjoyment, and a sense of belonging in group settings, but also discourages participation when individuals feel mismatched in skills or excluded. Planned family activities and habits acted as facilitators through shared routines. Body image comparison emerged as a barrier when negative self-perception led to withdrawal from activity. Finally, the presence of children or grandchildren and pet ownership influenced PA behaviour both positively (active play, walking a dog) and negatively (time constraints from caregiving). Environmental factors Environmental barriers and facilitators of PA behaviour were frequently emphasised across studies (in n = 40 studies overall) [17,25,37,[41], [42], [43], [44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52], [53], [54], [55],57,58,[60], [61], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68], [69], [70], [71], [72], [73], [74], [75], [76],78,79]. Several factors related to the outdoor environment were consistently described. Weather conditions, for example, were among the most common influences (n = 16 studies), with favourable climates facilitating PA, although extremes such as icy sidewalks or excessive heat discouraged it. Similarly, perceived safety of the environment (n = 5) shaped opportunities for facilitating PA, highlighting the importance of adequate lighting, traffic control, and hazard-free surroundings. In terms of accessibility, the proximity to sports facilities played a central role (n = 15). Easy access to sports centres, gyms, or community venues, together with reliable transport and flexible opening hours, were repeatedly mentioned as facilitators, while distance, parking problems, or long travel times were identified as barriers. Everyday opportunities to integrate movement were also noted, such as the presence of stairs, gardens, or active transport routines, as well as access to natural environments that enhanced PA. Beyond physical access, several studies underlined the significance of the resources and quality of exercise opportunities. Adapted and supervised programmes (n = 16), particularly those adapted for individuals with RMDs, together with guidance from qualified instructors (n = 13), were seen as strong facilitators of safe and effective PA behaviour. By contrast, a lack of adapted options or inconsistent advice discouraged engagement. Although digital tools, patient associations, and mobility aids were mentioned less often, they nevertheless appeared as additional levers to support PA behaviour, whether through remote guidance, peer support, or walking aids. System-level factors System-level barriers and facilitators, included in 26 studies, showed how PA behaviour is embedded in broader structural, organisational, and policy environments [17,25,37,41,42,44,45,[47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52], [53],55,56,61,62,64,65,[69], [70], [71], [72],74,77]. Financial aspects were the most consistently reported barrier of facilitator (n = 18), with costs related to memberships, equipment, or transport shaping opportunities for engagement. Work and family responsibilities were also salient (n = 18), highlighting how professional demands, caregiving, and domestic duties reduce the time and energy available for exercise. Less frequently, other system-level barriers and facilitators were noted. Health insurance coverage (n = 3), although rarely discussed, pointed to the role of institutional policies in facilitating access to supervised or prescribed PA programs. Surgery was mentioned only once, yet it illustrates how medical events intersect with systemic factors, potentially not only restricting activity in the short term but also restoring function and enabling participation in the longer term. DISCUSSION Principal findings This review provides the first dedicated synthesis of extrapersonal determinants of PA in individuals with RMDs. Social, environmental, and system-level factors frequently acted as both barriers and facilitators depending on context. Several determinants not identified in previous reviews emerged, including family routines, caregiving roles, pet ownership, proximity to nature, active transport, and patient associations. Comparison with prior literature Most determinants in this review acted as both barriers and facilitators depending on context. For example, healthcare professional support could enable PA when present but hinder it when absent. This supports our choice to present determinants holistically, as recommended elsewhere [26]. Compared with previous reviews that addressed PA barriers and facilitators without focusing on extrapersonal factors, our findings revealed several additional themes, including planned family activities, children or grandchildren, pet ownership, proximity to nature, active transport, patient associations, and surgery. Furthermore, none of the themes reported previously were missing from our synthesis, suggesting a more comprehensive mapping. Some reviews proposed alternative classifications or greater granularity (eg, on digital tools, time constraints, social interactions, or the role of professionals), such as those by Giardulli et al [22] and others focusing on specific determinants. Overall, earlier work emphasised social support, facility access, and safety but did not systematically examine extrapersonal domains. By adopting a TDF-informed approach, our synthesis offers a more complete and nuanced understanding and consolidates and extends prior evidence. Strengths and limitations A limitation of this review is that study selection and data extraction were initially conducted by a single author. However, all steps were subsequently verified by a second reviewer, and consensus was sought in cases of disagreement, which helped to enhance reliability. In addition, the research team was consulted on several occasions regarding extraction and classification choices. Furthermore, grey literature was not searched. To compensate for this, the electronic search strategy implemented sought to be as sensitive as possible, with 12,304 articles initially identified. Moreover, we excluded certain study designs (eg, randomised trials and systematic reviews) as our objective was to synthesise patient-perceived determinants derived from empirically designed qualitative and survey studies. While this approach ensured methodological consistency and sufficient detail for theory-informed coding, it may have limited the comprehensiveness of the mapping and potentially excluded additional contextual determinants reported in other sources. In addition, the predominance of qualitative interview-based studies in the included literature may partly reflect our eligibility criteria. By excluding intervention studies, randomised trials, and other quantitative designs, we may have favoured research methodologies more commonly used to explore behavioural and contextual influences. While this approach was consistent with our objective of mapping patient-reported extrapersonal determinants, it may have influenced the observed distribution of study designs. The development of themes and domains was informed by the TDF and refined through input from the research team. Data synthesis was further peer-reviewed by a multidisciplinary group, strengthening credibility, although alternative groupings of barriers and facilitators could have been possible. Another limitation is the absence of a formal quality appraisal of the included studies. This decision reflects the exploratory aim of a scoping review, which is to provide a comprehensive mapping of existing evidence and identify potential barriers and facilitators, rather than to assess methodological rigour or the strength of association [31]. This is also coherent with current methodological guidance. In this context, including all relevant studies regardless of quality was considered appropriate to capture the full range of patient perspectives, as proposed in another review [24]. However, the absence of quality assessment limits our ability to evaluate the robustness or credibility of individual determinants and to distinguish findings derived from methodologically stronger vs weaker studies. Although many of the determinants identified, such as social support, environmental accessibility, or nature-based opportunities, have been described in other fields, including occupational therapy and primary care, our contribution lies in explicitly framing and synthesizing these influences as extrapersonal determinants within the context of RMDs. This conceptual positioning, informed by socioecological approaches and the TDF, was motivated by the relative underrepresentation of such factors in previous RMD-focused reviews Finally, the threshold of ≥30% for surveys applied for extracting quantitative data was based on a previous scoping review that integrated qualitative and quantitative evidence [80]. Although this cut-off may have led to the omission of certain barriers and facilitators, it is likely that many of these were captured through other studies and therefore remained represented in the overall synthesis. Implications for research The 25 themes identified were supported by between 1 and 26 studies, yet, as noted by Bouma et al [80], the frequency with which determinants are reported does not necessarily reflect their true importance. Patient perceptions may be shaped by availability bias, whereby salient or easily recalled factors are more likely to be mentioned while others of equal or greater relevance remain underreported [81]. This highlights the need for future research to systematically explore all domains and to build survey tools capable of assessing the prevalence, perceived influence, and cross-country variability of these determinants more efficiently than qualitative approaches. Because the included studies spanned 17 countries, including 10 in Europe, it is likely that the relevance of specific determinants varies across settings due to differences in climate, cultural norms, infrastructure, and exercise-related costs or insurance coverage [82]. However, this review did not permit cross-country comparisons, and only 2 studies originated from lower-income contexts (China, Türkiye) [45,79], underscoring the need for research in diverse socioeconomic settings and in underrepresented groups such as those with low health literacy. Similarly, we did not stratify determinants by population subgroup (eg, disease type, age [47], or comorbidities [60,62]), although previous work shows that RMDs may differ in PA-related influences. This can concern joint deformities or psoriasis, or variation in professionals’ promotion of PA guidelines [25]. Future studies should therefore identify disease- or population-specific determinants and explore their relative impact, which could not be quantified here given the predominance of interview and survey designs. Overall, the determinants identified suggest that PA implementation in RMDs may benefit from the involvement of multiple stakeholders and healthcare professionals equipped with appropriate training and resources, potentially including digital tools [83,84]. Approaches such as participatory cocreation and attention to environmental factors may also contribute. These findings provide a foundation to help clinicians and other stakeholders support sustained PA engagement among individuals with RMDs. CONCLUSION This scoping review identified 233 extrapersonal determinants of PA in RMDs, synthesised into 25 themes across social, environmental, and system domains. PA behaviour is shaped by diverse contextual influences that extend beyond the individual. Addressing these determinants through coordinated, context-sensitive strategies may enhance long-term PA engagement. Further research should clarify how these determinants vary across countries, cultures, PA types, and RMD conditions. CRediT authorship contribution statement Thomas Davergne: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Validation, Resources, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Özgül Öztürk: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Validation, Supervision, Resources, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Mohamed Saadi: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Investigation, Formal analysis. David Ueckert: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Resources, Project administration, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation. Leti van Bodegom-Vos: Writing – review & editing, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Data curation, Conceptualization. Salima van Weely: Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Özlem Feyzioğlu: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Investigation, Formal analysis. Karin Niedermann: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Validation, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Formal analysis. Anne-Kathrin Rausch Osthoff: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Resources, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Competing interests All authors declare they have no competing interests. Acknowledgments Funding This work was supported by EULAR, not exceeding 50,000 euros (grant HPR061). The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not represent the official views of EULAR. Patient consent for publication Not applicable. Ethics approval Not applicable (scoping review). Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed. Data availability statement All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary material. Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the manuscript preparation process During the preparation of this work, the authors used ChatGPT 5.2 in order to assist with writing. After using this tool/service, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the published article. Footnotes Handling editor Gerd Burmester. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary material.