On Serine Octamer Substitution Reactions Brison A Shira, Alana K E Thomas, R Graham Cooks Abstract ABSTRACTRationaleMonomeric amino acids substitute into the ionized serine octamer (Ser8), a magic number cluster that exhibits chiral behavior. Small biomolecules, such as amino acids (AA), substitute into the octamer enantioselectively, giving Ser7AAH+ and Ser6AA2H+ favoring clusters of all L‐ or all D‐chirality. While the formation of Ser8H+ has been well studied, its substitution reactions need further investigation. The fact that water microdroplets readily produce Ser8H+, which undergoes enantiospecific substitution reactions perhaps gives this topic relevance to origins of life chemistry.MethodsThe substitution reactions of several proteogenic AA's (Ala, Leu, isoLeu, Pro, Phe, and Val), along with prebiotically relevant isomers (norVal and isoVal), were investigated using a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer to gain insight into the determinants of the chiral behavior. Rather than using isotopically labeled enantiomers, as in previous work, cluster formation was assessed using samples of variable chiral composition and concentration.ResultsSubstitution enantioselectivity was confirmed, though in the case of some double substitutions and the substitution of nonproteogenic isomers, the homochiral preference was decreased or inverted, an observation which is attributed to the disruption of the highly ordered noncovalent contacts of the parent Ser8 cluster. Additionally, the data suggest that octamer formation is consecutive: Ser8H+ forms first, followed by substitution of AA to form Ser7AAH+, sometimes followed by a second substitution to form Ser6AA2H+.ConclusionsThis investigation illustrates how chiral chemistry using MS must operate through weak but chirality‐sensitive forces while avoiding dominance of stronger but chirality‐insensitive reaction drivers; namely the propensity of a chiral organic base to acquire the charge of a proton affiliated with other chiral molecules. These results are significant because chiral molecular clusters are fundamentally interesting. Understanding the origins of their enantioselectivity contributes to a general understanding of how small molecules may recognize chirality in reaction partners and accumulate enantiomeric excess.Keywords: chiral analysis, ion trap mass spectrometry, molecular clusters, serine octamer Introduction Chiral chemistry accessed with MS is analytically significant, in spite of the fact that MS cannot differentiate enantiomers by mass‐to‐charge ratio (m/z) alone [, ]. Secondary variable(s) allow distinctions arising from interactions with chiral auxiliaries []. Examples include the competitive fragmentations in the kinetic method of chiral analysis [], ion mobility measurements [, ], spectroscopic interrogation [, , , ], and direct ion trap‐based chirality differentiation []. Observing enantiodifferentiating chemical processes in the gas‐phase, though challenging, remains worthwhile because gas‐phase organic molecules may be accessed without any interference from solvent or the constraints of a crystal lattice [, , ], interferences, which dampen the effects of noncovalent interactions []. The reactions of the serine octamer cluster (Ser8) represent one instance of chiral supermolecular chemistry [, ] accessed with MS [, , , ]. Ser8 is known to exhibit chiral preferences in formation [] and substitution reactions in which other small molecules, such as amino acids (AA's), cluster with Ser monomers in a manner that favors clusters of all L‐ or all D‐monomers []. These findings have been taken as evidence that noncovalent interactions between prebiotically relevant chiral molecules represent a potential explanation for how biomolecules accumulated asymmetry on the way, eventually, to biological homochirality [, , , ]. Our investigation uses the systematic variation of chirality and stoichiometry of several AA's to probe the substitution reactions that occur in Ser8 molecular clusters. The previously reported enantioselectivity of substitution [] is confirmed and the data suggest that such reactions proceed sequentially: Ser8H+ first forms, then Ser7AAH+, potentially followed by Ser6AA2H+. Steric and stoichiometric effects were also observed, which had an unusual effect on the enantioselectivity of the substitution reactions, causing decreased chiral preference and a preference against homochirality []. Methods Experiments were designed based on varying reagent concentration, which can be thought of as a fixed‐time kinetic method []. By increasing [AA] (the concentration of AA), a greater degree of reaction will be observed over a fixed time, thus allowing the sampling of a later point on the kinetic coordinate. Because this method assumes that [Ser] is in excess (always 8 mM) and the ratio of AA/Ser is not constant, quantitative measurements cannot be made, but by studying an array of AA's, useful information can be gathered. This approach differs from investigations, which use spectroscopic interrogation of the octamer [, ] and other clusters [, , ]. Though spectroscopic experiments generate data that can be matched with computationally determined structures, their scope and throughput is limited; fitting ab initio computations to an action spectrum acquired at a user facility is laborious [, ]. There is no doubt that chiral molecular clusters, including those beyond Ser8 [, , ], will continue to be an important research area [, , ] but the chemical space of interesting molecular clusters is vast: many clusters derived from Ser8 have been identified (Figure )—privileging experiments that can cover a greater number of combinations faster. Nanoelectrospray ionization (nESI) was used to study substitution by varying the concentration of the substituting AA. Data are presented as scatter plots with n = 3 replicates and error bars representing two sample standard deviations. Experimentally, D‐ or L‐Ser was constituted together in LC–MS water (Fisher Scientific, Fair Lawn, NJ USA) with the AA's (Figure ) also of variable chirality (Millipore Sigma, St. Louis, MO USA). Replicating the results with both L‐ and D‐Ser validates the method. Ser was always 8.00 mM; AA's were used at concentrations from 1.00 to 8.00 mM; sample pH was adjusted to 1.5 using hydrochloric acid. Adjustment of pH ensured that the AA's in solution were in the +1 charge state (Figure ). Peak assignments were confirmed with MS/MS characterization (Figures –). Analyte solutions (4.0 μL aliquots) were loaded into pulled borosilicate capillary emitters with 5‐μm inner tip diameter and positioned 1.5 cm from the inlet (capillaries and P97 puller, Sutter Instrument, Novato, CA, USA). A platinum electrode was used to apply +2.0 kV spray voltage. Measurements used a Thermo LTQ XL linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer with He bath gas. Automatic tuning was used to optimize the ion optics for the Ser8H+ ion, m/z 841. A modified full scan was used: ions were injected until the automatic gain target was met and then trapped with no supplemental activation for 1250 ms before mass analysis, improving the signal‐to‐noise by allowing metaclusters to fragment (Figure ) [, ]. In the case of serine octamers, increasing the droplet flight time by changing the spray distance did not influence the substituted serine octamer formation (Figure ). Representative mass spectra obtained for each AA are arrayed in the Supporting Information (Figures –). Results and Discussion A range of small molecules has been demonstrated to undergo Ser8 substitution reactions (Table ) []. Often these are observed through the protonated clusters: While these reactions are well known, relatively little mechanistic information is available about them, despite several studies concerning ionized forms of Ser8 itself [, , ]. What is known from ion/molecule reactions [] and studies with sonic spray ionization [] is that proton affinity (PA, the negative of the enthalpy of protonation) can drive ligand switching reactions and that homochiral substitutions are generally more favored than substitutions involving mismatched chirality (as confirmed in Figure ). Recent work with hydroxy acids, which have low PA, has identified the importance of α‐ and β‐hydrogen bonding contacts to serine octamer substitution reactions []. Molecules capable of zwitterionic salt bridge interactions exhibit the strongest clustering interactions, but even in the case of nonzwitterionic hydroxy acids, enantioselective reactivity is observed. Besides noncovalent cluster formation processes, another interesting prospect of substitution reactions concerns the possibility of using these clusters for asymmetric bond forming reactions. Past work suggests that Ser8 can direct the asymmetric formation of dipeptides from Pro and Leu []. These prior studies emphasize the need to better understand the mechanism of substitution reactions. Proline Substitution The concentration and chirality of Pro were systematically varied allowing the relative propensity and the chirality of the substitution reactions to be observed (Figure ). By comparing the effects of the concentration of reagents at the start of a reaction (in the bulk sprayed solution) and monitoring the effect on the distribution of products (seen as peaks in the mass spectrum), the effects of chirality and AA identity were studied. In those cases where the chirality of Ser and Pro match (Figure ), the double substituted octamer, Ser6Pro2H+, is the most abundant cluster once [Pro] reached 4 mM in the spray solution. This observation confirms that substitution is enantioselective because when either racemic (DL) or mismatched Pro is used at the same concentration, Ser6Pro2H+ is not as abundant (Figure ). Another detail that confirms the enantioselectivity of the substitution reactions is the predominance of the Ser8H+ peak at the lowest [Pro] when the substituent chirality is mismatched (Figure ), which signals that substitution is not as favorable as in Figure . Further evidence for the enantioselectivity of Pro substitution into the octamer is taken from the intermediate effect observed in the cases with racemic Pro (Figure ). The data also suggest consecutive substitution, in which the first substitution product, Ser7ProH+, is depleted as the second substitution product, Ser6Pro2H+, is generated. This is apparent in the arrayed scatter plots (Figure ), which show first the emergence of Ser7ProH+ then, as [Pro] increases, Ser6Pro2H+, with the intensity of Ser8H+ decreasing throughout. An interesting feature is that at the highest [Pro] (8 mM), the octamer products have similar distributions, regardless of their chirality. Under these conditions it is likely that competitive ionization effects dominate. The essence of this argument is similar in its logic to ion suppression effects [, ]. While the most kinetically advantaged homochiral substitution reactions are observed when [Pro] is lower, when [Pro] is higher, these are overcome by the favorable thermodynamics (viz. Le Chatelier's principle) that vary less strongly with chirality. With an abundance of Pro monomers available, the charge of Ser8H+ is susceptible to reaction with the more basic Pro, which has a secondary amine with a high PA of 921 kJ/mol []. This observation highlights the fact that in order to accomplish asymmetric chemistry in the gas‐phase, the two competing forces of chirally sensitive kinetics and chirally insensitive thermochemistry need to be balanced. Charge–charge interactions, quantified through thermochemical quantities such as PA, are usually much stronger but less selective than hydrogen bonding and steric effects which have more susceptibility to chirality. Leucine and Isoleucine Substitution The substitution of Leu shares some features with that of Pro (Figure ). Here, as with Pro, when the chirality of Leu does not match Ser and [Leu] is low (Figure ), Ser8H+ has higher relative abundance than when the chirality is matched (Figure ). Additionally, when [Leu] is highest (6 mM), the distribution of serine octamers generated is similar, regardless of the sample's chiral composition, and the double substitution to give Ser6Leu2H+ predominates. The same effect, though to a lesser extent, is observed for isoLeu (Figure ). The main difference between the serine octamers obtained from Leu substitution and isoLeu substitution is that the Leu‐substituted octamers are more abundant than the parent Ser8H+ cluster. The abundance of Ser8H+ is greater when measured against the isoLeu substitution products, implying that branching on the β‐carbon may disrupt the accommodation of this AA into the cluster. The difference between the Leu and Pro substitutions centers on the second substitution (compare Figures and ). At low [Leu], substitution is more prominent in the homochiral cases but at higher [Leu], the usual enantioselective behavior of serine octamer substitution does not hold. It is possible that the steric profiles of Leu and isoLeu, which have bulky sidechains, disrupt the octamer's tightly packed structure and lessen or even invert the chiral preference of the substitution reaction, a phenomenon which has been observed in other molecular clusters [, ]. On the other hand, the structure of Pro is more rigid, locking in the polar moieties about the chiral center. Indeed, in biology Pro‐containing moieties are associated with tight turn structures [], which may be similar to the close contacts exhibited within serine octamers. While Leu has a bulky sidechain that may disrupt the cluster's structure, Pro better maintains the contacts between the protonated amine and deprotonated carboxylic acid. Alanine Substitution In the case of Ala (Figure ), only Ser8H+ and Ser7AlaH+ were observed. It appears that Ser7AlaH+ is less favorable than Ser8H+, as even in the case of 8.00 mM, where the concentrations of the Ser and Ala are equal, Ser7AlaH+ is not abundant, making any measured differences due to chirality small. This likely follows from Ala's reduced ability to participate in intermolecular hydrogen bonding/ion‐dipole interactions: It does not have a polar sidechain and has a slightly lower PA than Ser, 902 versus 907 kJ/mol []. Nevertheless, these data also confirm the enantioselectivity as previously discussed for Leu and Pro; more Ser7AlaH+ was observed when the chirality of Ala and Ser matched. Unlike the other AA's, the abundance of the substituted octamer did not always increase with [Ala]. For the chirally mismatched substitution, Ser7AlaH+ is most abundant at 4.00 mM and less so at 8.00 mM. It is possible that alternative avenues consume the Ala (such as self‐aggregation by formation of proton‐bound clusters of Ala [, ]) preventing it from appearing as a substitution product. Valine, Isovaline, and Norvaline Substitution The steric bulk of Leu and isoLeu's alkyl R‐groups may explain the increased abundance of the double substitution when chirality is not matched (Figures and ). Val and its isomers, isoVal and norVal, provide further evidence for this explanation. While the single substitution to form Ser7ValH+ exhibits the expected enantioselective behavior (Figure ), the double substitution exhibits an inverted preference, making it a more abundant species at 4 and 6 mM [Val] in the case where Ser and Val have opposite chirality (Figure ). The same trend is reproduced with the isomer norVal, which has a straight chain, not a branched alkyl substituent (Figure ). For isoVal (Figure ), which has a methyl group added to its α‐carbon where a hydrogen would be in a proteogenic AA, substitution does not appear to be consecutive because both substitutions increase in a monotonic way, nor does substitution appear to be strongly enantioselective. Varying the chirality of Ser and isoVal does not significantly influence the observed abundance of the substituted octamers. This result shows that the method used in this study can distinguish enantioselective and nonenantioselective substitutions. Studying nonproteogenic AA's and the differences of their behavior in abiotic processes, such as molecular cluster formation, may help elucidate the chemical evolution that selected the proteogenic AA's. Findings from simulated prebiotic chemistry and meteorites have resulted in a consensus view that life must have evolved in a chemical space that contained a variety of organic monomers, including the proteogenic amino acids, but also related hydroxy acids, and other “noncanonical” chemicals [, ]. Val, norVal, isoVal, and isoLeu are especially germane in this context because these have been identified in meteorite samples in a chirally enriched form [, , , ]. It is interesting then that isoVal, which is not a proteogenic AA, is unable to participate in a proposed enantio‐amplification scheme []. Phenylalanine Substitution Of the AA's studied, Phe exhibits the most abundant single substitution at low [AA]. In the cases in which Ser and Phe have matching chirality (Figure ), Ser7PheH+ is the most abundant octamer. Here, as with Val and Leu, the double substitution is most abundant when the chirality of Ser and Phe are mismatched (Figure ). The favorable and enantiospecific formation of Ser7PheH+ represents the goldilocks condition where thermochemistry (the enthalpic drive of an organic base to acquire a charged proton) is relatively less important than the chiral noncovalent contacts, which give Ser8 its enantiospecificity. The PA of Phe is 906 kJ/mol, which is close to that of Ser, 907 kJ/mol []. Because the exchange of a Ser monomer for a Phe in the cluster has only small thermochemical consequence, the relative importance of the chiral noncovalent contacts increases, a factor compounded by the steric bulk of Phe. Conclusions These data indicate (i) the basic fact of enantiomeric control of substitution, at least in cases where excessive concentrations do not overwhelm the delicate gas‐phase intermolecular interactions through which the chiral effect is observable; (ii) homochiral serine octamer substitutions are consecutive; (iii) charge stabilization may influence the observed abundance of a given substitution; and (iv) the substitution of AA's with sterically bulky groups (e.g., double substitution of Leu, Val, and norVal) can in some cases decrease or even invert the homochiral preference of octamer substitutions, while the addition of a nonhydrogen function on the α‐carbon can dampen enantioselection. A sequence of reactivity was measured in which the AA's most likely to engage in substitution are: Phe > Pro > Leu > Val > isoLeu > isoVal > norVal > Ala, with Phe, Pro, and Val exhibiting the strongest enantiodifferentiation. Microdroplets, the medium from which serine octamers were generated, exhibit many interesting and useful properties. Indeed, droplets and related chemical environments have long been hypothesized to play a role in life's origin and chiral chemistry [, , ]. The octamer likely forms during the evaporation of the microdroplets that deliver analyte from the nESI emitter to the vacuum chamber [, ]. Because microdroplets are a unique chemical environment and potentially are “abiotic reactors” [] where acid/base chemistry is different than in bulk, examining the effect of thermochemical drivers like PA on chiral cluster formation is reasonable. Therefore, spray ionization MS is an advantaged experiment for the examination of chiral clusters because it offers ready access to the products of (chiral) droplet chemistry [, , ]. MS‐based chiral analysis matters because MS provides an avenue for simple and rapid exploration [] of chirality and how chiral effects manifest biologically [, , ]. Though the understanding of the role of charge in the reactions of the octamer is not complete, it is interesting to consider the suggestion that neutral Ser8, not Ser8H+, is the underlying magic cluster [] although the aqueous microdroplets have strongly acidic (or in the opposite polarity, basic) interfaces and ionic forms might have been directly involved in the prebiotic process of chiral selection. The structure of Ser8H+ does not feature higher order symmetry as protonation disrupts the hydrogen bonding/ion‐dipole interactions []. However, the dichloride octamer, which has more polarizable chloride ions [], features D4 symmetry [], raising the question of whether neutral clusters have such symmetry and exhibit even better enantioselectivity. In either case, the serine octamer cluster provides an avenue through which enantioselected material can be transported differently than nonselected material, a potential enrichment scheme [, ]. The importance of this phenomenon motivated this investigation's illustration of the fact that gas‐phase chiral chemistry involves two competing chemical forces weak but chirality sensitive sterics and hydrogen bonding and on the other hand strong but chirality insensitive drivers such as PA.