Microbe-biochar interaction in improving plant growth and water reuse in a green wall system Authors: Atefeh Zarei, Zahra Karimian, Zahra Meghdari, Ava Heidari Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Given the increasing scarcity of potable water and the rising generation of domestic and industrial wastewater, the reuse of greywater to meet part of plant water requirements, along with its environmentally friendly approach, has gained increasing attention. The present study was conducted in 2023 to investigate the effects of microorganisms and biochar on the establishment and growth of Crassula capitella Thunb., as well as on greywater treatment. Cyanobacteria (C0, C0.4, and C0.8 g), mycorrhiza (M0, M5, and M10 g), and biochar (B0, B5, and B10 g) were evaluated under two irrigation regimes including municipal water (MW) and greywater (GW) within a green wall system in Mashhad, Iran. The results indicated that the combined treatments and irrigation water type had statistically significant effects on most of the measured traits. The C0.4–M10–B0 treatment increased chlorophyll content by more than 97% (from 4.93 to 9.74 µg g⁻¹ FW), while the C0–M10–B5 treatment increased RFW and RDW by 189 and 298%, respectively (from 2.530 to 7.309 g and from 0.353 to 1.407 g), compared to their respective minimum values. The initial wastewater COD (376 mg/L) was 118% greater than the COD measured after treatment with C0.4–M10–B0 (173 mg/L). Overall, the C0–M10–B5 and C0.4–M10–B0 treatments showed superior performance in improving plant establishment and growth of C. capitella in the green wall system, while the C0.4–M10–B0 and C0.4–M5–B5 treatments were more effective in greywater treatment. Based on these findings, the integrated use of cyanobacteria, mycorrhizae, and biochar may contribute to the establishment of Crassula in green wall systems and to urban water resource management under the conditions tested in Mashhad, Iran. However, further studies are needed to assess the applicability of these results to other cities or environmental conditions.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-51657-x. Introduction Rapid urbanization over recent decades, combined with changing patterns of water consumption and increasing volumes of domestic wastewater, has posed significant challenges to sustainable urban water management. These developments have contributed to declining water quality, greater pressure on wastewater collection and treatment infrastructure, and increased pollutant loads entering the environment1. In many regions, limited renewable water resources and decreasing precipitation have made the reuse of urban wastewater not merely an option but a necessity. According to reports by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and UN-Habitat, approximately 90% of wastewater generated in developing countries in 2010 was discharged into nearby water bodies without adequate treatment, largely due to insufficient treatment facilities2. More recent assessments, however, indicate substantial progress, with an estimated 56% of domestic wastewater being safely treated worldwide by 2020 (WHO71). Among the various wastewater streams, domestic wastewater and particularly greywater accounts for a considerable proportion. Compared with blackwater, greywater contains a relatively low pathogenic load, while its composition of organic matter, surfactants, oils, and nitrogen and phosphorus compounds makes it well suited for biological treatment and reuse3. Greywater originates from activities such as handwashing, bathing, laundry, and kitchen use, and represents a significant share of household wastewater generation4. Its reuse can enhance the flexibility and resilience of local water systems while reducing demand on freshwater supplies and lowering wastewater conveyance and treatment costs5. In recent years, treated greywater has therefore attracted growing interest for applications such as urban agriculture6 and the irrigation of urban green spaces7. In line with these emerging needs, decentralized nature-based solutions that integrate vegetation into built environments have gained attention as practical systems for onsite greywater treatment, providing a logical transition from broader water challenges to building-scale applications. An innovative approach to wastewater reuse that simultaneously enhances urban environmental quality is the integration of green walls and plant-based treatment systems. Green walls, as vertical vegetation systems, not only improve the aesthetic and microclimatic conditions of urban areas but also contribute to wastewater treatment, pollutant filtration, mitigation of the urban heat island effect, and improvement of air quality8. Numerous studies have demonstrated that plant species used in green wall systems can absorb and immobilize a portion of the chemical contaminants present in greywater, thereby improving the quality of reclaimed water9, 10, 11. Research further suggests that green walls function as a form of constructed wetland and represent an environmentally friendly technology capable of effectively treating greywater, with demonstrated potential for treating wastewater with relatively high organic loads12. In such systems, the selection of suitable plant species, along with optimized substrate composition and operational conditions, plays a critical role in achieving high treatment efficiency13. Additionally, outdoor green wall systems have been shown to maintain high pollutant removal efficiency even under winter conditions when treating synthetic greywater4. Beyond the role of plants, microorganisms are essential contributors to biological treatment processes and can substantially enhance the performance of plant-based systems. Cyanobacteria, for instance, are capable of fixing atmospheric nitrogen and producing extracellular polysaccharides14, which improve photosynthetic efficiency15, enhance soil structure, and increase the adsorption capacity for various organic and inorganic pollutants. Through these mechanisms, cyanobacteria can improve substrate quality and overall system performance16, while also reducing biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), chemical oxygen demand (COD), and other key water quality parameters17. Mycorrhizal fungi, as one of the most important plant-associated symbiotic microorganisms, also play a fundamental role in wastewater treatment systems. By expanding the effective root absorption area, enhancing nutrient transfer, improving plant tolerance to salinity and pollution stress, and immobilizing contaminants in the rhizosphere, mycorrhiza significantly contribute to treatment efficiency18,19;. Improved uptake of nitrogen, phosphorus, and micronutrients further promotes plant growth in low-quality or contaminated substrates20, 21. Evidence suggests that the combined presence of plants, cyanobacteria, and mycorrhiza can reduce chemical pollutant concentrations, enhance plant performance, and improve the stability of treatment systems22. Biochar represents another complementary component with the potential to enhance plant-based wastewater treatment systems. Owing to its porous structure, high specific surface area, and abundance of functional groups, biochar is capable of adsorbing and stabilizing a wide range of pollutants, including heavy metals, organic compounds, and nitrogen and phosphorus containing substances23, 24, 25. In addition, biochar provides a favorable habitat for microbial communities, thereby increasing the biological efficiency of treatment processes26. Its incorporation into soil or growth substrates has also been shown to improve plant growth, enhance physiological performance27, increase water-holding capacity, and reduce heavy metal uptake from reclaimed wastewater (Kamran et al.,72). In studies examining plant responses to alternative irrigation sources such as greywater, physiological and biochemical indicators are commonly evaluated to better understand plant tolerance mechanisms. Traits such as RWC, plant weight, and photosynthetic pigments are widely used to assess plant water status28, growth performance (Anangadan et al.,73), and photosynthetic efficiency73 under stress conditions. Biochemical markers, including ascorbic acid and enzyme activity, are frequently measured as indicators of antioxidant defense responses to oxidative stress29, 30. In addition, determining leaf nutrient concentrations helps evaluate plant nutritional status and nutrient uptake efficiency, particularly in studies involving soil amendments and beneficial microorganisms that influence nutrient availability21. Integrative indices such as APTI are also used to assess overall plant tolerance to environmental stress31. Meanwhile, changes in greywater quality parameters (e.g., EC, BOD, COD, and pH) are commonly analyzed to determine the potential role of plant-based systems in wastewater improvement (Aylan et al., 205232;. Therefore, these indicators were evaluated in the present study to assess both plant tolerance and the contribution of treated plants to greywater purification under the combined application of biochar, cyanobacteria, and mycorrhiza. Increasing water scarcity and the growing production of urban wastewater highlight the urgent need for sustainable and cost-effective solutions for water treatment and reuse. Among emerging approaches, engineered systems such as green walls offer a promising strategy for integrating nature-based solutions in urban environments. This study investigates the interactions among Crassula capitella, microorganisms (cyanobacteria and mycorrhiza), and biochar within a green wall irrigated with greywater. Crassula capitella was selected due to its succulent nature and Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (CAM), which enhances water-use efficiency and tolerance to water stress by enabling nocturnal stomatal opening. These traits make it well-suited for green wall systems irrigated with greywater, where water availability and quality may vary33. Previous studies have documented the individual contributions of biochar, cyanobacteria, and mycorrhizal fungi in improving soil quality, promoting plant growth, and enhancing water treatment. However, knowledge about their synergistic interactions, particularly in confined and engineered settings like green walls, remains limited. Biochar provides a favorable habitat for microbial colonization, potentially enhancing microbial activity, while the co-existence of cyanobacteria and mycorrhiza may improve nutrient cycling in complementary ways. Here, we systematically examine the combined effects of biochar, cyanobacteria, and mycorrhizal fungi in a greywater-irrigated green wall, addressing a critical gap in our understanding of integrated nature-based solutions for urban water management. Materials and methods Study area This study was conducted in Mashhad, Razavi Khorasan Province, Iran, located at 36°59′ N latitude and 59°36′ E longitude in northeastern Iran. The city experiences maximum summer temperatures of up to 43 °C and minimum winter temperatures as low as − 23 °C. The mean annual precipitation is approximately 253 mm, and the elevation is 995 m above sea level (Salahi et al., 2016). Mashhad is the second-largest city in Iran, with an estimated population of about 3.5 million. As the country’s most important religious and pilgrimage destination, it is estimated to receive approximately 27 million religious tourists annually. The experiment was conducted over a five-month period, from early June to mid-November 2023, on the eastern side of the Faculty of Natural Resources and Environment at Ferdowsi University of Mashhad (Fig. 1). Fig. 1Location of study sites (3) in Mashhad city/Razavi Khorasan Province (2), Iran (1) (Source: Google map, 2025). Green wall (4) and the materials of green wastewater (5), (Source: Authors, 2025). Location of study sites (3) in Mashhad city/Razavi Khorasan Province (2), Iran (1) (Source: Google map, 2025). Green wall (4) and the materials of green wastewater (5), (Source: Authors, 2025). Preparation of cyanobacteria, mycorrhizae, and biochar For cyanobacterial propagation, a culture medium containing BG11 powder was used. The cultures were transferred to a growth chamber under controlled conditions with a 16 h light/8 h dark photoperiod, light intensity of 1600 lx (fluorescent lamps), and a temperature of 30 ± 2 °C. A light microscope (Echo UM-210 BD) was used to determine the morphological characteristics of the cyanobacteria (Desikachary,75). Cyanobacterial inoculation into the soil was carried out following the method reported by Zanganeh et al.74. Initially, fresh and dry weights were measured, with dry weight determined after oven-drying for 24 h at 105 °C. Subsequently, the required amount of cyanobacterial biomass was mixed with 50 cc of distilled water and placed on a magnetic stirrer at 0 °C for 24 h. Finally, the resulting suspension was applied to the soil surface in three stages using a sterile syringe. Cyanobacteria were applied after successful plant establishment, approximately one month after planting, at rates of 0, 0.4, and 0.8 g per pot, distributed in three stages over the soil surface. Based on light microscopic observations, the cyanobacterium used in this study was identified as Oscillatoria sp., characterized by filamentous, straight, unbranched trichomes, lacking heterocysts, with slightly curved apical cells and occasionally surrounded by a thin mucilaginous sheath34, 35. The mycorrhizal fungus used in this study was purchased from Zist Fanavaran Touran Company (Shahroud, Semnan Province, Iran). Mycorrhizawere applied at rates of 0, 5, and 10 g per pot and incorporated into the soil in layers at the center of the pots to facilitate symbiosis with plant roots. Biochar was obtained from Tarbiat Modares University, Mazandaran Branch, Noor County, Iran. The biochar was produced via pyrolysis of wood residues from three plant species including Parrotia persica, Populus spp., and Eucalyptus spp. at 600 °C with a heating rate of 10 min⁻¹ under an argon atmosphere for 1 h. The physicochemical properties of the biochar used in this study are presented in Table 1. Biochar treatments were applied at rates of 0, 5, and 10 g per pot were incorporated into the potting soil and thoroughly mixed prior to planting. Preparation of greywater The materials used for the preparation of synthetic greywater were adopted from the study by Diaper et al.36 and are listed in Table 2. Secondary treated wastewater was obtained from the Mashhad Industrial Town (Kalat) wastewater treatment plant. To prepare the irrigation treatments, 2 L of the treated effluent was thoroughly mixed in a container and then diluted with 100 L of municipal water. The chemical oxygen demand (COD) of the final greywater was 376 mg/L, determined using the method described by APHA81,. The pH was measured using a Testo 230 pH meter as 8.98, and the electrical conductivity (EC) was measured using an EC meter as 1593 µS/cm. Table 1Analysis of important biochar and soil compounds in Crassula capitella.ParametersBiocharSoilpH7.868.83EC (µS/cm)316.3343Carbon (%)73.41-Hydrogen (%)2.71-Nitrogen (%)0.37-Sulfur (%)0.00-Oxygen (%)23.51-Clay (%)-40Silt (%)-40Sand (%)-20WHC (%)84 Table 1Analysis of important biochar and soil compounds in Crassula capitella.ParametersBiocharSoilpH7.868.83EC (µS/cm)316.3343Carbon (%)73.41-Hydrogen (%)2.71-Nitrogen (%)0.37-Sulfur (%)0.00-Oxygen (%)23.51-Clay (%)-40Silt (%)-40Sand (%)-20WHC (%)84 Analysis of important biochar and soil compounds in Crassula capitella. Table 2Recipe of synthetic gray water.(Source36:.IngredientAmount in 100 L (g) unless otherwise statedProduct usedSunscreen OR1.5UV TripleGuardMoisturiser1.0DoveToothpaste3.25Colgate Maximum Cavity Protection (regular)Deodorant1.0MumNa₂SO₄3.5Analytical gradeNaHCO₃2.5Analytical gradeNa₂PO₄3.9Analytical gradeClay (Unimin)¹5.0Industrial gradeVegetable Oil0.7Coles Own brandShampoo/hand wash72PalmoliveLaundry15Omo High Performance/Omomatic concentrateBoric acid0.14Analytical gradeLactic acid2.8Analytical gradeSecondary effluent2 LEastern Treatment Plant at Carrum (from secondary clarifier) Table 2Recipe of synthetic gray water.(Source36:.IngredientAmount in 100 L (g) unless otherwise statedProduct usedSunscreen OR1.5UV TripleGuardMoisturiser1.0DoveToothpaste3.25Colgate Maximum Cavity Protection (regular)Deodorant1.0MumNa₂SO₄3.5Analytical gradeNaHCO₃2.5Analytical gradeNa₂PO₄3.9Analytical gradeClay (Unimin)¹5.0Industrial gradeVegetable Oil0.7Coles Own brandShampoo/hand wash72PalmoliveLaundry15Omo High Performance/Omomatic concentrateBoric acid0.14Analytical gradeLactic acid2.8Analytical gradeSecondary effluent2 LEastern Treatment Plant at Carrum (from secondary clarifier) Recipe of synthetic gray water. (Source36:. Table 3Abbreviations of treatments, and their rate in Crassula capitella.Irrigation and combined treatmentsMunicipal water (MW)Gray water (GW)1C0.4–M5–B5C0.4–M5–B52C0.4–M10–B0C0.4–M10–B03C0.0–M5–B0C0.0–M5–B04C0.4–M10–B10C0.4–M10–B105C0.8–M0–B5C0.8–M0–B56C0.0–M10–B5C0.0–M10–B57C0.8–M5–B10C0.8–M5–B108C0.8–M10–B5C0.8–M10–B59C0.4–M0–B0C0.4–M0–B010C0.0–M5–B10C0.0–M5–B1011C0.0–M0–B5C0.0–M0–B512C0.8–M5–B0C0.8–M5–B013C0.4–M0–B10C0.4–M0–B10C: Cyanobacteria, M: Mycorrhiza and B: Bochar treatments.The numbers represent the amounts of treatments in each pot. Table 3Abbreviations of treatments, and their rate in Crassula capitella.Irrigation and combined treatmentsMunicipal water (MW)Gray water (GW)1C0.4–M5–B5C0.4–M5–B52C0.4–M10–B0C0.4–M10–B03C0.0–M5–B0C0.0–M5–B04C0.4–M10–B10C0.4–M10–B105C0.8–M0–B5C0.8–M0–B56C0.0–M10–B5C0.0–M10–B57C0.8–M5–B10C0.8–M5–B108C0.8–M10–B5C0.8–M10–B59C0.4–M0–B0C0.4–M0–B010C0.0–M5–B10C0.0–M5–B1011C0.0–M0–B5C0.0–M0–B512C0.8–M5–B0C0.8–M5–B013C0.4–M0–B10C0.4–M0–B10C: Cyanobacteria, M: Mycorrhiza and B: Bochar treatments.The numbers represent the amounts of treatments in each pot. Abbreviations of treatments, and their rate in Crassula capitella. C: Cyanobacteria, M: Mycorrhiza and B: Bochar treatments. The numbers represent the amounts of treatments in each pot. Green wall setup, plant material, and growth substrate The green wall was constructed from wood with dimensions of 80 cm in length, 15 cm in width, and 15 cm in height, arranged in five vertical tiers, and installed at the study site. The soil was obtained from the research greenhouses of the Faculty of Agriculture, FUM, Mashhad. Pots and soil with a clay loam texture were sterilized using an autoclave at 121 °C for 60 min, and each pot was filled with 1 kg of soil (Table 1). Additionally, no chemical fertilizers or pesticides were applied during the experiment to avoid interference with the microbial treatments. The planted plants were also irrigated with NPK fertilizer (20-20-20, g/l) every two weeks. After soil inoculation with mycorrhiza (M) and the addition of biochar (B) and cyanobacteria (C), cuttings of Crassula capitella containing young and healthy roots were obtained from the greenhouse of the Faculty of Agriculture, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran. The plant species (Crassula capitella Thunb, family: Crassulaceae) were identified and authenticated by at Ferdowsi University of Mashhad Herbarium (FUMH, Taxonomist: Mr. Mohammad Reza Joharchi), Mashhad, Iran. A voucher specimen (Code: E-1718 FUMH) has been deposited in the herbarium. The pots were labeled according to the experimental treatments and randomly arranged on the green wall. According to the experimental design, half of the pots on one side of the green wall were irrigated with municipal water (MW), while the pots on the opposite side were irrigated with greywater (GW) (Fig. 1). Measurement of leaf relative water content (RWC) Leaf relative water content (RWC) was determined according to the method described by Ritchie et al.76. Fresh weight (FW) of the leaves was measured immediately after sampling. To determine turgid weight (TW), each leaf was immersed in 50 mL of distilled water in a sealed container and kept at 4 °C for 24 h. The leaves were then oven-dried at 70 °C for 48 h to determine dry weight (DW). Finally, leaf relative water content was calculated using the following equation: \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{RWC}}=\left[ {\left( {{\mathrm{FW}}--{\mathrm{DW}}} \right)/\left( {{\mathrm{TW}}-{\mathrm{DW}}} \right)} \right]\; \times \;100$$\end{document} Measurement of fresh and dry weight of shoot and root To determine the fresh weight of the shoot, the plant was cut at the soil surface and weighed using a balance with 0.001 g precision. Roots were gently removed from the soil, washed with water to remove adhering particles, blotted with paper towels to remove excess water, and then weighed using the same balance. Both shoots and roots were oven-dried at 70 °C for 48 h, and the dry weight was recorded afterward (Beets et al.,82). Electrolyte leakage (EC) and pH of plant and soil To measure tissue electrolyte leakage, approximately 1 g of young leaf tissue was added to 20 mL of distilled water and kept at 24 °C for 24 h. The electrical conductivity of the solution was recorded as initial leakage (EC1) using an EC meter. Samples were then autoclaved at 120 °C for 15 min, allowed to cool, and the final leakage (EC2) was measured. Electrolyte leakage (µS·cm⁻¹) was calculated using the following formula (Whitlow et al.,83): \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{EC}}=\left( {{\mathrm{E}}{{\mathrm{C}}_{\mathrm{1}}}/{\mathrm{E}}{{\mathrm{C}}_{\mathrm{2}}}} \right)\; \times \;{\mathrm{1}}00$$\end{document} For plant pH measurement, 4 g of leaf tissue was ground with 40 mL of distilled water in a porcelain mortar, centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min, and the pH of the supernatant was measured using a pH meter (Chen et al.,77). Soil pH was determined by preparing a 1:25 soil-to-distilled water suspension, shaking it at room temperature for 30 min, and then measuring the pH using a pH meter. Determination of photosynthetic pigment content The total chlorophyll content of the samples was determined using the Lichtenthaler method (1978). In this method, 1 g of fresh leaf tissue was homogenized with 44 mL of 80% acetone. The homogenate was centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min. The absorbance of the supernatant was measured at wavelengths of 470, 645, and 663 nm using a spectrophotometer. Chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, and carotenoid contents were calculated using the following formulas: \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\text{ChloropHyll a}}\left[ {{\mathrm{mg}}/} \right]=\left( {{\mathrm{19}}.{\text{3 }} \times {\text{ A663}}-0.{\text{86 }} \times {\text{ A645}}} \right){\text{ V}}/{\mathrm{1}}00{\text{ W}}$$\end{document} \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\text{ChloropHyll b}}\left[ {{\mathrm{mg}}} \right]=\left( {{\mathrm{19}}.{\mathrm{3}} \times {\mathrm{A645}}\;-{\mathrm{3}}.{\mathrm{6}} \times {\mathrm{A663}}} \right){\text{ V}}/{\mathrm{1}}00{\text{ W}}$$\end{document} \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{Carotenoids}}\left[ {{\mathrm{mg}}} \right]\,\;=\,\;{\mathrm{1}}00\left( {{\mathrm{A47}}0} \right)\,\; - \,{\mathrm{3}}.{\text{27 }}\left( {{\text{mg Chl}}.{\text{ a}}} \right)-{\mathrm{1}}0{\text{4 }}\left( {{\text{mg Chl}}.{\text{ b}}} \right)/{\mathrm{227}}$$\end{document} Measurement of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) To determine leaf hydrogen peroxide content, 0.07 g of leaf tissue was homogenized in an ice bath with 5 mL of 1% trichloroacetic acid (TCA). The resulting suspension was centrifuged at 12,000 rpm for 15 min at 4 °C. Then, 0.5 mL of the supernatant was mixed with 0.5 mL of 10 mM potassium phosphate buffer and 1 mL of 1 M potassium iodide (KI). The absorbance of the reaction mixture was measured at 390 nm using a spectrophotometer. The H₂O₂ content in the sample was determined by comparison with a standard curve prepared with known concentrations of H₂O₂37. Measurement of polyphenol oxidase (PPO) enzyme activity For enzyme extraction, 0.1 g of leaf tissue was selected and powdered using liquid nitrogen. The powdered tissue was mixed with a suitable buffer solution and centrifuged for 15 min to separate the enzyme extract from the solid material. From the resulting extract, 300 µL was collected and stored in a microtube at − 20 °C. These extracts were stable and usable for up to 45 days. To assess polyphenol oxidase (PPO) activity, a reaction mixture containing phosphate buffer, pyrogallol, and the enzyme extract was prepared according to the method of J. Raymond (1993). The absorbance change due to the formation of purpurogallin was measured every 5 s at 420 nm for one minute using a spectrophotometer. PPO activity was expressed as enzyme units (U mg⁻¹ protein). Determination of ascorbic acid content in plants To measure the ascorbic acid content, 1 g of leaf tissue from each plant was homogenized with 20 mL of an extracting solution containing 5% metaphosphoric acid and centrifuged at 8000 rpm for 20 min at 4 °C. Then, 1 mL of the clear supernatant was mixed with 0.5 mL of DCIP to oxidize ascorbic acid to dehydroascorbic acid. To measure the oxidized ascorbic acid, 0.5 mL of distilled water was added to 1 mL of the centrifuged solution. For the blank solution, 1 mL of 5% metaphosphoric acid was combined with 0.5 mL of DCIP. Subsequently, 1 mL of 1% thiourea was added to the samples in three final steps. Then, 1 mL of 20% sulfuric acid was added to the blank solution and 1 mL of 10 mM DNPH solution was added to the remaining samples. The samples were incubated in a 50 °C water bath for 1 h and then placed in an ice bath for 20 min. Next, 2.5 mL of 85% sulfuric acid was added, and the test tubes were again kept in an ice bath for 30 min. The absorbance of each sample was measured at 520 nm using a UV–VIS spectrophotometer, compared to the blank. Finally, ascorbic acid content was calculated based on the standard curve prepared from the measured absorbance values38. Measurement of sodium, potassium, phosphorus, nitrogen, and protein in plants To determine sodium (Na) and potassium (K) contents and prepare extracts for ICP analysis, 0.3 g of ground plant sample was weighed and placed in a crucible for 4 h in a muffle furnace at 450 °C. After cooling, the resulting ash was mixed with 10 mL of 0.1 N hydrochloric acid and heated on a hot plate at 80 °C for 10 min. Sodium and potassium concentrations in the plant extract were measured using a flame photometer, and the percentage of Na and K in the plant sample was calculated39. For phosphorus (P) determination, the same procedure was followed for ashing and extracting the sample. Then, 0.5 mL of the extract was mixed with 4 mL of solution B (a combination of specific chemicals), and the absorbance was measured at 660 nm using a spectrophotometer. The phosphorus content was calculated based on the measured absorbance40. Total nitrogen (N) and protein content were determined using the macro-Kjeldahl method. Briefly, 0.3 g of ground plant sample was weighed and mixed with 1.1 g of catalyst (a mixture of potassium sulfate, copper sulfate, and selenium powder) and 5 mL of concentrated sulfuric acid. The mixture was digested at 500 °C for 1 h. After cooling, 20 mL of 10 N sodium hydroxide and boric acid solution were added. Nitrogen was distilled and titrated with 0.005 N sulfuric acid. Nitrogen and protein contents were calculated using the following formulas41: \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{ppm}}\,=\,{\mathrm{V}} \times 0.00{\mathrm{5}} \times {\mathrm{5}}0 \times {\mathrm{14}} \times {\mathrm{1}}000\left( {0.{\mathrm{3}} \times {\mathrm{2}}0} \right),{\text{ V}}=\% {\mathrm{N}}\,=\,{\text{ppm }}/{\mathrm{1}}0000$$\end{document} Where V is the volume of acid (mL) used for titration Protein%= %N×6.25. Calculation of anticipated performance index (APTI) The Anticipated Performance Index (APTI) is an empirical index used to evaluate plant tolerance to air pollutants. Based on this index, plants are categorized into sensitive, moderate, and tolerant groups in response to air pollution. Higher APTI values indicate greater tolerance of plants to air pollutants31. To calculate APTI, the values of specific traits, including leaf chlorophyll content, leaf pH, relative water content (RWC), and ascorbic acid content, are required. The measurement methods for these traits have been described in the previous sections. Finally, the APTI value, which reflects the plant’s tolerance to air pollution, was calculated using the following formula42: \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{APTI}}\,\;=\;\,{\text{Acid ascorbic }}\left( {{\mathrm{Chlorophyll}}\,+\,{\mathrm{pH}}} \right)\,+\,{\mathrm{RWC}}/{\mathrm{1}}0$$\end{document} Experimental design and data analysis In this study, four factors including mycorrhiza, cyanobacteria, biochar, and irrigation type were considered. A full factorial design based on three levels for each factor (3 × 3 × 3) would result in 27 treatment combinations. However, to reduce the number of experimental runs while maintaining adequate representation of the experimental domain and factor interactions, a Response Surface Methodology (RSM)-based optimal design was generated using Design-Expert software (Version 13.0.5.0) (Montgomery et al.,78). The software-generated design matrix selected 13 treatment combinations as representative and well-distributed points within the factor space. This approach allowed efficient exploration of the main effects and interactions among factors while minimizing the total number of experimental runs. It should be noted that the application of RSM in this study was primarily aimed at optimizing the selection of treatment combinations rather than performing full response surface modeling. Due to the nature of the optimal design, the experimental matrix does not strictly follow a full factorial structure and does not necessarily include a single complete control treatment (C0, M0, B0). Instead, treatments with zero or low levels of individual factors were included, providing a relative baseline for comparison and enabling the evaluation of interaction effects within the experimental domain. The selected treatments (Table 3) were applied under two irrigation regimes, municipal water (MW) and greywater (GW), each with three replicates, resulting in a total of 78 experimental units. This level of replication provided sufficient statistical comparison while considering greenhouse space and resource limitations. However, we acknowledge that a higher number of replicates could further reduce variability and strengthen the robustness of the results, and this limitation has been noted in the revised manuscript. At the end of the experiment, the collected data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) to evaluate the effects of treatments. In addition, relationships among measured variables were examined using correlation analysis in Minitab 22 software, and only correlation coefficients greater than 0.6 were considered significant. Furthermore, Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was performed to investigate the multivariate relationships among variables and to better understand the combined effects of treatments on plant physiological traits and water quality parameters (The results of the PCA analysis are available in the supplementary file). Results The results of this study showed that the combined treatments had significant effects on the COD, pH, and EC of the outlet wastewater at the 1% probability level. In addition, the effects of these treatments were statistically significant (p ≤ 0.05) for all measured traits except RWC, SFW, RDW, and soil EC. The irrigation type also showed significant effects on most traits at least at the 5% level, except for SFW, RDW, total chlorophyll, and plant EC. The interaction effects between combined treatments and irrigation type were significant at the 1% level for RFW and RDW, soil EC and pH, PPO activity, H₂O₂ content, and ascorbic acid concentration (Table 4). Effects on graywater quality parameters (COD, pH, and EC) The mean comparison among the combined treatments showed that the highest COD value (475.67 mg L⁻¹) in the C0.4–M0–B10 treatment significantly differed from the lowest value (172.67 mg L⁻¹) observed in the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment. In contrast, most of the other treatments showed no significant differences from one another. The highest COD concentration was recorded under C0.4–M0–B10 (475.67 mg O₂ L⁻¹), which was about 175% higher than the minimum observed value. Conversely, C0.4–M10–B0 produced the lowest COD (172.67 mg O₂ L⁻¹), about 64% lower than the maximum (Table 5). Table 4ANOVA of plant and soil traits of Crassula capitella under treatments. * and ** indicate significance at the 5 and 1% probability levels, respectively, and ns indicates non-significance.SourcesDFEC-plant(µS/cm)EC-soil (µS/cm)pH-PlantpH-soilPPO)U/mg(APTICombined treatments12189.87**189,828 ns0.19816**0.24951**2620.0**60.3*Water type1121.77ns46,055,628**4.87000**1.31482**4314.3*313.27*Sample×Water type1270.820ns736,703**0.11892ns0.21106**2098.0*43.5nsError5247.730153,9130.068040.07579974.3030.81Total77------SourcesDFRWC(%)SFW(g)RFW(g)RDW(g)Chl.)µg/g fw(H2O2)µmol/g fw(Ascorbic acid) mg/g fw(Combined treatments1277.89 ns1340.7 ns4.099*0.15299 ns12.103**0.01037*48.500**Water type1995.97**280.0 ns12.146**0.15101ns8.225 ns0.02565*196.69**Sample×Water type1228.42 ns2301.1ns6.355**0.28851**9.429 ns0.01146**54.730**Error5252.221303.71.9610.096095.14800.0046320.050Total77------- Table 4ANOVA of plant and soil traits of Crassula capitella under treatments. * and ** indicate significance at the 5 and 1% probability levels, respectively, and ns indicates non-significance.SourcesDFEC-plant(µS/cm)EC-soil (µS/cm)pH-PlantpH-soilPPO)U/mg(APTICombined treatments12189.87**189,828 ns0.19816**0.24951**2620.0**60.3*Water type1121.77ns46,055,628**4.87000**1.31482**4314.3*313.27*Sample×Water type1270.820ns736,703**0.11892ns0.21106**2098.0*43.5nsError5247.730153,9130.068040.07579974.3030.81Total77------SourcesDFRWC(%)SFW(g)RFW(g)RDW(g)Chl.)µg/g fw(H2O2)µmol/g fw(Ascorbic acid) mg/g fw(Combined treatments1277.89 ns1340.7 ns4.099*0.15299 ns12.103**0.01037*48.500**Water type1995.97**280.0 ns12.146**0.15101ns8.225 ns0.02565*196.69**Sample×Water type1228.42 ns2301.1ns6.355**0.28851**9.429 ns0.01146**54.730**Error5252.221303.71.9610.096095.14800.0046320.050Total77------- ANOVA of plant and soil traits of Crassula capitella under treatments. * and ** indicate significance at the 5 and 1% probability levels, respectively, and ns indicates non-significance. RWC (%) SFW (g) RFW (g) RDW (g) Chl. )µg/g fw( H2O2 )µmol/g fw( Ascorbic acid ) mg/g fw( The highest pH value of the outlet wastewater in C. capitella was observed in the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment (9.45), whereas the lowest pH value (8.45) occurred in the C0.4–M10–B10 treatment. Overall, most pH values ranged between 8.45 and 8.92. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, the outlet wastewater pH exhibited a variation of approximately 11.9% across treatments. Additionally, the treatment showing the minimum pH did not differ significantly from the pH of the influent wastewater (Table 5). The mean comparison of EC values among treatments indicated that the highest EC (11286.7 µS cm⁻¹) was recorded in the C0.4–M5–B5 treatment, whereas the lowest EC (4180.3 µS cm⁻¹) was observed in the C0–M10–B5 treatment. Most EC values ranged between 4704.3 and 8760 µS cm⁻¹. Based on the minimum and maximum observed values, EC showed an overall variation of approximately 170% among the treatments. The treatment with the minimum EC did not show a noticeable difference compared with the EC of the influent wastewater (1593 µS cm⁻¹) (Table 5). Effects on plant growth and biomass (shoot and root fresh and dry weight) Although no statistically significant differences were detected among treatments, the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment under graywater irrigation exhibited the highest shoot fresh weight (137.35 g), whereas the lowest value (48.68 g) was recorded in the C0.8–M5–B10 treatment under municipal water. Based on the minimum and maximum observed values, SFW showed an overall variation of approximately 182% across treatments. The highest root fresh weight (RFW) value (7.31 g) was observed in the C0–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with municipal water, whereas the lowest RFW (2.53 g) occurred in the C0.8–M5–B10 treatment under the same irrigation source. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, RFW showed an overall variation of approximately 189% across treatments. Similarly, root dry weight (RDW) ranged from 0.353 g in the C0.8–M5–B10 treatment to 1.407 g in the C0–M10–B5 treatment, corresponding to a variation of about 299% between the minimum and maximum values. On average, plants irrigated with municipal water produced slightly higher RFW (15%) and RDW (10%) than those irrigated with graywater (Table 6). According to the correlation analysis (Table 7), RDW showed a strong positive correlation with RFW (r = 0.801) and shoot fresh weight (SFW; r = 0.679). In addition, RFW was positively correlated with SFW (r = 0.657). All correlations were statistically significant at the 1% level. These results indicate that increases in RDW were associated with higher RFW and SFW, and increasing RFW also resulted in improved SFW. Table 5Mean comparison between measured traits in gray water effluent under combined treatments.Combined treatmentsCOD (mg O2/l)EC (µS/cm)pHC0.4–M5–B5195.000b11286.7a8.49667bC0.4–M10–B0172.667b7153.3ab9.45433aC0.0–M5–B0289.000ab4704.3b8.52667bC0.4–M10–B10278.100b8760.0ab8.45000bC0.8–M0–B5334.767ab6893.3ab8.70333abC0–M10–B5254.000b4180.3b8.92667abC0.8–M5–B10319.000ab7160.0ab8.54333bC0.8–M10–B5332.333ab6581.3ab8.77000abC0.4–M0–B0222.333b7663.3ab8.55333bC0–M5–B10245.667b5470.0b8.78667abC0–M0–B5195.333b5740.0b8.77000abC0.8–M5–B0304.667ab6826.7ab8.47000bC0.4–M0–B10475.667a8373.3ab8.45000b Table 5Mean comparison between measured traits in gray water effluent under combined treatments.Combined treatmentsCOD (mg O2/l)EC (µS/cm)pHC0.4–M5–B5195.000b11286.7a8.49667bC0.4–M10–B0172.667b7153.3ab9.45433aC0.0–M5–B0289.000ab4704.3b8.52667bC0.4–M10–B10278.100b8760.0ab8.45000bC0.8–M0–B5334.767ab6893.3ab8.70333abC0–M10–B5254.000b4180.3b8.92667abC0.8–M5–B10319.000ab7160.0ab8.54333bC0.8–M10–B5332.333ab6581.3ab8.77000abC0.4–M0–B0222.333b7663.3ab8.55333bC0–M5–B10245.667b5470.0b8.78667abC0–M0–B5195.333b5740.0b8.77000abC0.8–M5–B0304.667ab6826.7ab8.47000bC0.4–M0–B10475.667a8373.3ab8.45000b Mean comparison between measured traits in gray water effluent under combined treatments. Effects on plant water status and photosynthetic pigments (RWC and chlorophyll content) Mean comparison among the combined treatments showed that the highest relative water content (RWC) was obtained in the C0.4–M0–B10 treatment under municipal water irrigation (90.46%), whereas the lowest RWC (70.28%) was recorded in the C0.8–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with graywater. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, RWC varied by approximately 28.7% across treatments. On average, irrigation with municipal water resulted in higher RWC compared with graywater irrigation (Fig. 2E). The highest chlorophyll content was recorded in the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment irrigated with graywater (11.366 µg g⁻¹ FW), whereas the lowest value (3.508 µg g⁻¹ FW) was observed in the C0.8–M5–B10 treatment irrigated with municipal water. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, chlorophyll content varied by approximately 224% across treatments. Overall, plants irrigated with graywater exhibited slightly higher chlorophyll levels compared with those irrigated with municipal water (Table 8). Table 6Means comparison between measured traits in Crassula capitella for the interaction of combined treatment×water type (municipal water (MW) and graywater (GW)).Combined treatmentsWater typeRFW (g)RDW (g)EC soil (µS/cm)pH soilC0.4–M5–B5MW5.789abc0.949ab718.77abc8.37abcdGW4.802abc0.861ab812.67abc8.56abcdC0.4–M10–B0MW5.918abc0.770ab1536.00abc8.23abcdGW6.817abc1.102ab437.17bc9.06aC0.0–M5–B0MW7.263a1.204ab1545.67abc7.780dGW4.963abc0.781ab535.23bc8.73abC0.4–M10–B10MW5.702abc0.855ab812.00abc8.35abcdGW4.363abc0.692ab1006.00abc8.33abcdC0.8–M0–B5MW5.951abc1.053ab1342.00abc8.29abcdGW5.598abc0.994ab324.07c8.57abcdC0–M10–B5MW7.309a1.407a1405.33abc7.75dGW4.438abc0.755ab1095.00abc8.16bcdC0.8–M5–B10MW2.530c0.353b1410.33abc8.21abcdGW7.283a1.296ab844.33abc8.70abcC0.8–M10–B5MW6.931abc1.370a861.57abc8.39abcdGW4.127abc0.781ab782.33abc8.07bcdC0.4–M0–B0MW5.609abc0.813ab1634.00ab8.06bcdGW2.643bc0.479ab1002.00abc7.85cdC0–M5–B10MW4.782abc0.713ab1039.67abc8.27abcdGW4.348abc0.551ab636.67abc8.51abcdC0–M0–B5MW7.089a0.730ab1242.00abc8.35abcdGW5.954abc1.114ab887.67abc8.47abcdC0.8–M5–B0MW6.745abc1.324ab1857.33a8.10bcdGW5.780abc0.960ab576.33bc8.59abcdC0.4–M0–B10MW6.833abc0.940ab925.00abc8.12bcdGW7.072ab0.971ab1072.33abc8.06bcd Table 6Means comparison between measured traits in Crassula capitella for the interaction of combined treatment×water type (municipal water (MW) and graywater (GW)).Combined treatmentsWater typeRFW (g)RDW (g)EC soil (µS/cm)pH soilC0.4–M5–B5MW5.789abc0.949ab718.77abc8.37abcdGW4.802abc0.861ab812.67abc8.56abcdC0.4–M10–B0MW5.918abc0.770ab1536.00abc8.23abcdGW6.817abc1.102ab437.17bc9.06aC0.0–M5–B0MW7.263a1.204ab1545.67abc7.780dGW4.963abc0.781ab535.23bc8.73abC0.4–M10–B10MW5.702abc0.855ab812.00abc8.35abcdGW4.363abc0.692ab1006.00abc8.33abcdC0.8–M0–B5MW5.951abc1.053ab1342.00abc8.29abcdGW5.598abc0.994ab324.07c8.57abcdC0–M10–B5MW7.309a1.407a1405.33abc7.75dGW4.438abc0.755ab1095.00abc8.16bcdC0.8–M5–B10MW2.530c0.353b1410.33abc8.21abcdGW7.283a1.296ab844.33abc8.70abcC0.8–M10–B5MW6.931abc1.370a861.57abc8.39abcdGW4.127abc0.781ab782.33abc8.07bcdC0.4–M0–B0MW5.609abc0.813ab1634.00ab8.06bcdGW2.643bc0.479ab1002.00abc7.85cdC0–M5–B10MW4.782abc0.713ab1039.67abc8.27abcdGW4.348abc0.551ab636.67abc8.51abcdC0–M0–B5MW7.089a0.730ab1242.00abc8.35abcdGW5.954abc1.114ab887.67abc8.47abcdC0.8–M5–B0MW6.745abc1.324ab1857.33a8.10bcdGW5.780abc0.960ab576.33bc8.59abcdC0.4–M0–B10MW6.833abc0.940ab925.00abc8.12bcdGW7.072ab0.971ab1072.33abc8.06bcd Means comparison between measured traits in Crassula capitella for the interaction of combined treatment×water type (municipal water (MW) and graywater (GW)). Effects on oxidative stress and membrane stability (H₂O₂ content and EC) Based on the mean comparison test, the highest hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) content was observed in the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment (0.387 µmol g⁻¹ FW), whereas the lowest value (0.0913 µmol g⁻¹ FW) was recorded in the C0.4–M0–B0 treatment. Both treatments were irrigated with municipal water. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, H₂O₂ content varied by approximately 324% across treatments. Overall, plants irrigated with municipal water exhibited higher H₂O₂ concentrations than those irrigated with graywater (Fig. 2D). The highest plant EC value (105.25 µS/cm) was recorded in the C0.4–M0–B10 treatment, whereas the lowest value (77.91 µS/cm) occurred in the C0.4–M5–B5 treatment; both were irrigated with graywater. Across all treatments, plant EC values ranged from 77.91 to 105.25 µS/cm, showing no significant differences among most treatments. Based on the minimum and maximum values, plant EC varied by approximately 35.1% across treatments. The overall effect of graywater irrigation on plant EC, compared with municipal water, was negligible (Table 8). Table 7Correlation coefficients (r > 0.30) among the measured traits of Crassula capitella under treated irrigated by municipal water and gray water (n = 78, P < 0.000).Sample 1Sample 2CorrelationP-ValueAPTIAscorbic acid0.880.000RDWRFW0.8010.000RDWSFW0.6790.000RFWSFW0.6570.000Ascorbic acidH2O20.4230.000RWCpH Plant0.410.000APTIH2O20.3970.000ChlorophyllpH Soil0.3540.002EC SoilpH Plant0.3430.002Ascorbic acidEC Soil0.3370.003PPOpH Plant0.3350.003Ascorbic acidSFW−0.3010.008RWCpH Soil−0.3140.005Ascorbic acidRDW−0.3180.005EC SoilpH Soil−0.6550.000 Table 7Correlation coefficients (r > 0.30) among the measured traits of Crassula capitella under treated irrigated by municipal water and gray water (n = 78, P < 0.000).Sample 1Sample 2CorrelationP-ValueAPTIAscorbic acid0.880.000RDWRFW0.8010.000RDWSFW0.6790.000RFWSFW0.6570.000Ascorbic acidH2O20.4230.000RWCpH Plant0.410.000APTIH2O20.3970.000ChlorophyllpH Soil0.3540.002EC SoilpH Plant0.3430.002Ascorbic acidEC Soil0.3370.003PPOpH Plant0.3350.003Ascorbic acidSFW−0.3010.008RWCpH Soil−0.3140.005Ascorbic acidRDW−0.3180.005EC SoilpH Soil−0.6550.000 Correlation coefficients (r > 0.30) among the measured traits of Crassula capitella under treated irrigated by municipal water and gray water (n = 78, P < 0.000). Mean comparison among the combined treatments showed that the highest soil EC was recorded in the C0.8–M5–B0 treatment (1857.33 µS/cm), whereas the lowest value (324.07 µS/cm) occurred in the C0.8–M0–B5 treatment; both received graywater irrigation. Across the remaining treatments, soil EC values generally ranged from 437.17 to 1634 µS/cm, without distinct significant differences among most of them. Based on the minimum and maximum values, soil EC varied by approximately 473% across treatments. Overall, graywater irrigation tended to increase soil EC compared with municipal water irrigation (Table 6). Table 8Means comparison of some traits in Crassula capitella under main effect of combined treatments.Combined treatmentsEC-plantpH-plantChlorophylC0.4–M5–B582.79bc5.32b4.19bC0.4–M10–B092.06abc5.44b9.74aC0.0–M5–B089.96abc5.62ab7.56abC0.4–M10–B1095.13ab5.55ab5.96abC0.8–M0–B592.64abc5.81ab5.35abC0–M10–B596.30ab5.99a5.27abC0.8–M5–B1083.30bc5.58ab5.85abC0.8–M10–B580.70c5.44b7.00abC0.4–M0–B095.79ab5.51ab5.49abC0–M5–B1090.13abc5.72ab6.60abC0–M0–B595.13ab5.75ab4.93bC0.8–M5–B094.97ab5.48ab6.90abC0.4–M0–B1098.42a5.66ab5.37ab Table 8Means comparison of some traits in Crassula capitella under main effect of combined treatments.Combined treatmentsEC-plantpH-plantChlorophylC0.4–M5–B582.79bc5.32b4.19bC0.4–M10–B092.06abc5.44b9.74aC0.0–M5–B089.96abc5.62ab7.56abC0.4–M10–B1095.13ab5.55ab5.96abC0.8–M0–B592.64abc5.81ab5.35abC0–M10–B596.30ab5.99a5.27abC0.8–M5–B1083.30bc5.58ab5.85abC0.8–M10–B580.70c5.44b7.00abC0.4–M0–B095.79ab5.51ab5.49abC0–M5–B1090.13abc5.72ab6.60abC0–M0–B595.13ab5.75ab4.93bC0.8–M5–B094.97ab5.48ab6.90abC0.4–M0–B1098.42a5.66ab5.37ab Means comparison of some traits in Crassula capitella under main effect of combined treatments. Effects on antioxidant metabolism (ascorbic acid content and PPO activity) The combined treatments showed significant differences in ascorbic acid content. The highest ascorbic acid concentration (22.64 mg g⁻¹ FW) was observed in the C0.8–M5–B10 treatment irrigated with municipal water, whereas the lowest value (1.87 mg g⁻¹ FW) occurred in the C0–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with graywater. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, ascorbic acid content varied by approximately 1111% across treatments. In general, plants irrigated with municipal water exhibited higher ascorbic acid levels than those irrigated with graywater (Fig. 2A). Based on the mean comparison test, the highest polyphenol oxidase (PPO) activity (180.53 U mg⁻¹ protein) was recorded in the C0–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with municipal water, whereas the lowest value (33.87 U mg⁻¹ protein) occurred in the C0–M0–B5 treatment irrigated with graywater. Based on the minimum and maximum recorded values, PPO activity varied by approximately 433% across treatments. In general, plants irrigated with municipal water exhibited higher PPO activity than those irrigated with graywater (Fig. 2B). Air pollution tolerance index (APTI) The highest Air Pollution Tolerance Index (APTI) value (30.94) was observed in the C0.4–M10–B0 treatment irrigated with municipal water, whereas the lowest value (9.36) occurred in the C0–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with graywater. Based on the minimum and maximum values, APTI varied by approximately 230% across treatments. On average, plants irrigated with graywater exhibited lower APTI values than those irrigated with municipal water. According to the correlation analysis, APTI showed a strong positive correlation with ascorbic acid content (r = 0.88), indicating that increases in ascorbic acid were associated with higher APTI values (Fig. 2C). Effects on plant nutrient uptake (N, P and K content) As shown in Fig. 3, which illustrates the effects of combined treatments on nutrient concentrations in plant tissues, the highest nitrogen content (26,519 ppm) was observed in the C0.8–M0–B5 treatment irrigated with gray water. In contrast, the lowest nitrogen content (6,183 ppm) was recorded in the C0–M0–B5 treatment irrigated with municipal water. The highest phosphorus concentration (0.47 ppm) was found in the C0–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with gray water, while the lowest value (0.12 ppm) occurred in the C0.8–M10–B5 treatment irrigated with municipal water. The maximum (70,622 ppm) and minimum (20,382.2 ppm) potassium concentrations were observed in the C0–M5–B10 and C0.8–M0–B5 treatments irrigated with municipal water, respectively (Fig. 3). Fig. 2Ascorbic acid (A), PPO (B), APTI (C), and H₂O₂ (D) under the combined treatment×water type interaction, and RWC and plant pH (E) under the main effect of water type in Crassula capitella. Ascorbic acid (A), PPO (B), APTI (C), and H₂O₂ (D) under the combined treatment×water type interaction, and RWC and plant pH (E) under the main effect of water type in Crassula capitella. Fig. 3Concentration of Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Potassium (combined treatment in Crassula capitella under UW and GW. Concentration of Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Potassium (combined treatment in Crassula capitella under UW and GW. Discussion The findings of this study clearly demonstrate that the combined application of cyanobacteria, mycorrhiza, and biochar exerts significant influence on both the growth performance of Crassula capitella in a gray water–irrigated green wall system and the quality of the treated wastewater. The results collectively suggest that plant physiological responses, substrate modifications induced by microbial and organic amendments, and the chemical characteristics of gray water interact to shape plant performance and treatment efficiency. The high water-holding capacity of the biochar used in this study (84%) reflects its inherently porous structure, which likely contributed to improved moisture retention in the growth medium and enhanced water availability to plants. This is consistent with previous reports highlighting the role of porous biochar in improving substrate physical properties43, 44. Graywater quality parameters One of the most notable outcomes was the substantial variation in COD removal efficiency among treatments. The C0.4–M10–B0 treatment yielded the lowest COD concentration (172.67 mg L⁻¹), corresponding to a purification efficiency more than 2.75 fold higher than the treatment with the highest COD value. This enhanced performance aligns with literature demonstrating that mycorrhiza and cyanobacteria have strong biodegradation capacities, contributing to COD reductions of up to 74.4% (Dou et al.,84) and 77%32, respectively. The pH of the treated gray water remained alkaline (8.45–9.45), with the highest value occurring in C0.4–M10–B0. Because the biochar applied in this experiment was derived from woody biomass (Parrotia persica, poplar, eucalyptus), its buffering capacity and tendency to shift soil and effluent pH toward neutral to alkaline levels (Lievens et al.,85) likely contributed to these results. The observed pH shift is also consistent with the alkalinizing effects reported for cyanobacteria45, biochar, and mycorrhiza (Vaast and Zasoski86). Substantial differences in outlet EC up to 2.7 fold indicated marked treatment-dependent variation in salinity. Although all EC values remained within the saline range, these differences likely reflect ion release from biochar, mineralization by cyanobacteria, and rhizosphere-driven nutrient mobilization under mycorrhizal colonization. Similar impacts of gray water irrigation on soil EC and nutrient dynamics have been reported by Sulayman et al.46. Plant water status and growth performance The highest RWC (90.46%) was obtained under C0.4–M0–B10 (municipal water), approximately 1.3 times higher than the lowest RWC recorded under gray water irrigation. These differences suggest that gray water–induced osmotic stress reduced leaf RWC, consistent with prior studies47. The enhanced RWC in treatments with higher biochar content supports previous findings that biochar improves water-holding capacity and reduces plant water stress28. In terms of biomass production, SFW was highest in C0.4–M10–B0, 2.8 times greater than the lowest value. The growth-promoting effects of cyanobacteria on shoot biomass48 and the positive influence of gray water irrigation reported in other species49 (Anangadan et al.,73) help explain this response. Conversely, excessive cyanobacterial concentrations can suppress growth50, which may clarify variation among treatments. Root biomass (RFW and RDW) reached its maximum in the C0–M10–B5 treatment under municipal water irrigation—about 3–4 times higher than the minimum. This outcome is consistent with the known capacity of mycorrhiza18 and biochar51 to enhance root architecture, substrate porosity, and nutrient uptake21; (Kamran et al.,72). Photosynthetic pigments, oxidative stress and membrane stability Chlorophyll content peaked in C0.4–M10–B0 (a 3.2-fold increase over the lowest value). The stimulation of chlorophyll by mycorrhiza under both optimal and stressful conditions52, along with reduced heavy metal uptake mediated by mycorrhiza53, likely contributed to these results. Cyanobacterial treatments are also known to increase chlorophyll and delay senescence54. The mixed effects of gray water on chlorophyll reported in earlier studies73 are consistent with the variable responses observed here. H₂O₂ levels showed a clear trend: the lowest value (in C0.4–M0–B0) was more than four times lower than the maximum. Cyanobacterial extracts are known to reduce oxidative stress by limiting H₂O₂ accumulation (Abdelaziz et al.,79), although in this experiment, neither biochar nor mycorrhiza effectively decreased H₂O₂. Plant EC and soil EC varied substantially among treatments, with soil EC showing a 5.7-fold range. Biochar’s ability to enhance membrane stability55 and reduce soil EC over time56, along with cyanobacterial and mycorrhizal effects on membrane integrity57, 58, helps explain these patterns. Variations in plant and soil pH also corresponded with known pH-modulating effects of mycorrhiza59, 60 and gray water irrigation73, as well as the alkalinity of biochar61. Antioxidant metabolism Ascorbic acid content exhibited more than a twelvefold difference among treatments, with the highest levels recorded in C0.8–M15–B10. The increase aligns with the well-established role of mycorrhiza in improving plant antioxidant capacity under stress30, the stimulatory effects of acidified biochar on nutrient uptake and ascorbic acid accumulation62, and the positive influence of cyanobacteria on antioxidant levels (Gashash et al.,80). Improved nutrient accessibility is known to enhance antioxidant responses63, which likely contributed to these findings. APTI values exhibited strong treatment dependence, with C0.4–M10–B0 showing the highest value (30.94), more than three times the minimum. Higher APTI is closely linked to elevated ascorbic acid content and reduced oxidative stress31, suggesting that treatments enhancing physiological resilience also improved air pollution tolerance. Similarly, PPO activity varied by more than fivefold, peaking in C0–M10–B5. Increases in PPO activity mediated by biochar and mycorrhiza have been widely reported as part of plant defense responses64, and gray water irrigation itself can stimulate PPO29, consistent with the patterns observed here. Plant nutrient uptake (N, P and K content) Under gray water irrigation, nitrogen content peaked in C0.8–M0–B5, while phosphorus was highest in C0–M10–B5 and potassium in C0–M5–B10 (municipal water), each showing 214%, 53% and 245% than minimum value, respectively. These results reflect the functional roles of the applied amendments: cyanobacteria fix nitrogen and solubilize phosphorus (Kollmen and Strieth, 2022), thereby enhancing plant nutrient status65; biochar improves nutrient retention and availability, including increases in K uptake55, 66; and mycorrhiza facilitate organic nitrogen decomposition67, P uptake58, d transport68. Although gray water provides nutrients such as N and P and may reduce fertilizer demand, excessive concentrations can lead to leaching and eutrophication69. In green wall systems, gray water irrigation has been associated with increased soil mineral content and biomass73, consistent with the responses observed here. Taken together, the integrated responses observed across physiological, biochemical, and substrate-related traits point toward a shared mechanistic pathway through which cyanobacteria, mycorrhiza, and biochar collectively enhance pollutant tolerance and graywater purification performance. Specifically, the simultaneous increase in antioxidant metabolites (ascorbic acid), enzymatic defenses (PPO), and APTI together with reduced oxidative pressure (lower H₂O₂) and improved water status (higher RWC) indicates that these amendments stabilized cellular redox balance and membrane integrity under graywater-induced osmotic and chemical stress. Such stabilization is well known to increase plant tolerance to complex pollutants and to maintain photosynthetic and metabolic activity under stressful wastewater conditions (Ahsan et al.,70). Furthermore, the porosity, adsorption capacity, and ion-buffering properties of biochar, combined with nutrient mobilization by mycorrhiza and nitrogen/phosphorus provision by cyanobacteria, likely optimized rhizosphere conditions for microbial degradation processes, thereby contributing directly to enhanced COD removal. These converging physiological and substrate-mediated processes provide a coherent mechanistic explanation for why treatments that supported higher antioxidant activity, better membrane stability, and improved water balance also corresponded to the highest graywater purification efficiency. Conclusion The results of this study indicate that, among the tested treatments, C0.4–M10–B0 and C0.8–M0–B5 were associated with relatively improved establishment and growth of Crassula capitella irrigated with greywater in a green wall system. This response was reflected in higher values of growth and stress-related parameters, including fresh and dry biomass, relative water content, PPO activity, APTI, chlorophyll content, and H₂O₂ concentration. With respect to greywater treatment, C0.4–M10–B0 achieved the lowest COD and C0.4–M5–B5 also showed low COD, indicating effective organic matter removal, although it resulted in higher EC values. In the context of increasing water scarcity in semi-arid and densely populated cities such as Mashhad, Iran, these findings suggest that greywater reuse, combined with selected microorganisms and biochar, can serve as a supplementary water source for irrigating green wall systems. The integrated application of phytoremediation and bioremediation may help reduce environmental risks associated with untreated wastewater while supporting building-scale green infrastructure. Overall, this study provides evidence that the combined use of cyanobacteria, mycorrhizae, and biochar – particularly the treatments C0.4–M10–B0 and C0–M10–B5 for plant growth, and C0.4–M10–B0 and C0.4–M5–B5 for greywater treatment – has potential to support greywater-irrigated green wall systems. However, as the findings are based on a specific experimental scale and local conditions, further long-term studies under diverse environmental and operational settings are. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 1