Comparative assessment of heavy metal accumulation and associated ecological and health risks in citrus orchards under canal and domestic wastewater irrigation Authors: Asma Ashfaq, Rimsha Bashir, Zafar Iqbal Khan, Ahlam Khalofah, Suad AL-Ruzayza Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractSargodha is popularly known as California of Pakistan because of its renowned production of superior quality citrus cultivars. However, the increasing reliance on domestic wastewater for irrigation in this region has raised serious concerns regarding the accumulation of hazardous metals in soil and edible fruit tissues. This may pose a significant risk to food safety and human health. In this study, a field-based comparative sampling strategy was adopted, where irrigation water, soil, and citrus fruit samples were obtained from orchards with canal water irrigation (CW-I) and domestic wastewater irrigation (DWW-II). Samples of water, soil, and fruits were analysed through atomic absorption spectrophotometry to evaluate the accumulation of selected heavy metals in irrigation water, soil, and edible parts of three citrus species grown under CW-I and DWW-II irrigation systems. Zn concentrations ranged from 13.31–51.67 mg L−1 in water, 44–71 mg kg−1 in soil, and 1.08–1.58 mg kg−1 in fruits. Cr levels varied between 1.86–11.66 mg L−1 in water, 9.67–22.70 mg kg−1 in soil, and 0.011–0.10 mg kg−1 in fruits. Ecological risk assessment indicated higher metal accumulation in citrus fruits irrigated with DWW-II compared to CW-I, as indicated by elevated contamination factor (CF) and enrichment factor (EF), with Zn consistently showing the lowest contribution. The pollution load index (PLI) values exceeded 1 under domestic wastewater irrigation (1.53–1.65), suggesting moderate pollution. The estimated daily intake (EDI) values were higher for all metals under domestic wastewater irrigation, particularly for Fe (0.122 mg kg−1day−1) and Zn (0.0604 mg kg−1day−1), yet remained below permissible limits. Health risk assessment revealed that THQ values for all studied metals remained within permissible limits, indicating no significant non-carcinogenic risk associated with the consumption of these citrus fruits. The findings demonstrate that domestic wastewater irrigation significantly increased metal concentrations in soil and fruits. These results highlight the importance of continuous monitoring and the implementation of sustainable irrigation practices to minimize long-term health risks associated with wastewater use in agriculture.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1186/s12870-026-09351-7.Keywords: Heavy metals, Canal water, Domestic wastewater, Potential ecological risk, Citrus Introduction Citrus represents the leading fruit crop worldwide, both in terms of cultivation area and production volume among all fruit-bearing trees. It ranks as the third most widely traded agricultural commodity in the global market. The cultivation of citrus extends across more than 135 countries and regions [1]. Citrus is the genus of the subfamily Aurantioideae in the family Rutaceae. The Rutaceae constitutes a family of flowering plants comprising approximately 160 genera. Among these, the most economically significant are the members of the genus Citrus, which encompass several major fruit species, including sweet orange (Citrus sinensis), sweet lime (Citrus limetta), grapefruit (Citrus paradisi), lime (Citrus aurantifolia), mandarin (Citrus reticulta) and lemon (Citrus limon) [1, 2]. Citrus fruit belongs to the non climacteric group and can be used as a source of valuable macro- and micronutrients for human diets [3]. The main centers of citrus cultivation are in tropical and subtropical regions located between 35°N and 35°S latitude near the equator [4]. Among citrus-producing countries, Pakistan holds a significant position due to its favourable climate and extensive agricultural practices. Pakistan exports over 50% of its fresh Kinnow to five major importers, namely, Russia, Indonesia, Afghanistan, the Philippines, and the United Arab Emirates [5]. Punjab contributes nearly 95% of Pakistan’s total citrus production, with kinnow accounting for approximately 70% of the total citrus fruit output. The average citrus yield in Pakistan is approximately 11.6 tons per hectare [6]. Sargodha, popularly known as California in Pakistan, is renowned for its production of superior-quality citrus cultivars [7]. Pakistan possesses one of the world’s most extensive canal networks. Water from the Indus River, along with other sources, is collected and redirected for irrigation and hydropower generation quality. Irrigation water quality plays a critical role in determining the productivity and sustainability of agricultural systems, particularly in regions facing water scarcity. In arid and semiarid regions, wastewater is widely used for crop and vegetable irrigation due to limited water availability and its cost-effectiveness. Reusing wastewater for agricultural irrigation is a widespread practice globally, with approximately 20 million hectares irrigated in nearly 50 countries [8]. Wastewater is commonly utilized in developing countries such as Pakistan, where agriculture serves as the primary means of economic livelihood and freshwater resources are limited. It is noteworthy that only approximately 3% of the Earth’s total water supply consists of freshwater. Moreover, domestic wastewater originating from household activities such as laundry, bathing, and dishwashing is increasingly being used in North Africa as a water conservation strategy for irrigating crops [8]. The use of domestic wastewater for irrigation provides certain short-term agronomic benefits, as it is often enriched with organic matter, nitrogen, phosphorus, and other nutrients that can enhance soil fertility and reduce the need for chemical fertilizers. However, alongside these benefits, domestic wastewater frequently contains potentially toxic heavy metals such as cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), nickel (Ni), and chromium (Cr), which may accumulate in soils and crops over time [3]. The quality of irrigation water plays a crucial role in controlling the accumulation and mobility of metals in agricultural soils and crops. Continuous application of wastewater introduces elevated concentrations of trace metals, dissolved salts, and organic matter into the soil system, which can alter key physicochemical properties such as pH, cation exchange capacity, and organic matter content. These changes enhance metal solubility and bioavailability, facilitating their uptake by plant roots and subsequent translocation to edible plant parts, including fruits. In contrast, irrigation with relatively canal water generally results in lower metal accumulation due to reduced external inputs. Consequently, long-term wastewater irrigation can lead to the progressive buildup of heavy metals in soil‒plant systems, increasing the likelihood of their entry into the food chain and posing significant ecological and human health risks [6–9]. Heavy metal toxicity refers to the accumulation of metals that are naturally present in the Earth’s crust to levels exceeding safe limits, primarily due to anthropogenic activities [9, 10]. Heavy metal contamination in soils is increasing at an alarming rate as a consequence of rapid industrialization, posing a substantial threat not only to human health but also to ecological stability. Heavy metals indirectly influence soil enzymatic activities by modifying the structure and function of microbial communities responsible for enzyme synthesis [11]. Heavy metals naturally originate from sources such as rock weathering, biological activity, airborne soil particles, and volcanic eruptions. Anthropogenic causes include mining operations, wastewater discharge, industrial and agricultural practices, and vehicle and chimney emissions. Insecticides, textile printing, paint manufacturing, hair dyes, and polyvinyl chloride pipes are the primary sources of metals [12]. Among heavy metals, zinc (Zn) is an essential trace element that plays a multifaceted role in supporting macrophage chemotaxis and immune regulation by modulating leukocyte function, thereby enhancing the body’s resistance to infections. Furthermore, it serves as a vital cofactor for the antioxidant enzyme superoxide dismutase, which facilitates the neutralization of reactive oxygen species, thereby reducing oxidative stress [9]. Iron (Fe) plays a crucial role in various enzymatic pathways involved in cell growth, mitochondrial electron transport, and the synthesis of genetic material. Unlike many other minerals, iron lacks a natural excretion mechanism from the body. The normal serum iron level ranges from 60 to 170 µg/dL [13]. Soil contamination by heavy metals constitutes a major environmental challenge with profound consequences for agricultural productivity, food security, and human well-being. The accumulation of these toxic elements in farming soils poses a serious threat to crop yield, food quality, and the long-term sustainability of agricultural systems [14]. Nonetheless, when such fruit are contaminated with hazardous metals, they might have several health impacts, including disruption in cognitive and behavioural function, weakened immune response and loss of important nutrients [15]. Therefore, the present study was conducted to comparatively assess concentration of metals in irrigation water, orchard soils and fruits of selected citrus species under canal water and domestic wastewater irrigation systems. The specific objectives were to: (i) determine the concentrations of selected heavy metals, (ii) evaluate ecological contamination using contamination factors, and (iii) assess potential human health risks associated with fruit consumption. It was hypothesized that domestic wastewater irrigation would increase heavy metal accumulation and associated risks relative to canal water irrigation, with differences among citrus species. Materials and methods Study area The study was conducted in two citrus-producing regions of District Sargodha, Punjab, Pakistan. The first sampling site (CW-I) was located at Chakiyan Phularwan (Tehsil Bhalwal), where Citrus orchards were irrigated exclusively with canal water. The second sampling site (DWW-II) was Chak No. 79 N.B. (Tehsil Sargodha), where citrus orchards were irrigated with domestic wastewater. Due to time and resource constraints, the study was restricted to two irrigation sites. These sites were selected because they represent major citrus-growing areas of Sargodha and supply substantial quantities of citrus fruits to local markets (Fig. 1). Map of the study area for sample collection Samples collection & sampling design Fruit The study was conducted as a field based comparative investigation using a hierarchical sampling framework to evaluate the effects of irrigation water quality on heavy metal accumulation in citrus fruits under semiarid conditions. Two irrigation sites were considered as the main experimental factor: The first irrigation site, comprising orchards irrigated with canal water and located in Tehsil Bhalwal, District Sargodha, was termed as CW-I, whereas the second irrigation site, comprising orchards irrigated with domestic wastewater and located in Tehsil Sargodha, District Sargodha, was referred to as DWW-II. Within each irrigation site, three geographically distinct locations were selected to represent spatial variability. At each irrigation site, sampling was structured across three levels: location, orchards and trees. Specifically, three locations (L= 3) were selected per irrigation regime, within each location three orchards (O= 3) were included, and within each orchard three mature citrus trees (T= 3) were randomly selected. This nested structure resulted in a total of 27 independent biological replicates per irrigation regimes, mathematically expressed as n=L × N × O = 3 × 3 × 3 = 27 trees. Each tree was considered a true biological replicate because it represents an independent physiological unit with distinct root and metal accumulation capacity. Three commercially important citrus varieties, namely C. limetta, C. reticulata, and C. sinensis, were included in the study. These fruits were manually harvested. Fruits were harvested at the edible ripening stage, approximately 6–8 months after fruit set depending on the citrus variety and local climatic conditions. Sampling was carried out during the typical harvesting season (December-January) when fruits reached full maturity. The maturity stage was determined based on surface morphological characteristics, including uniform peel colour development (yellow to orange), attainment of full fruit size, smooth and glossy peel texture, and slight softness indicating optimal ripeness and high juice content [7]. After harvesting, fruits were washed thoroughly with distilled water and peeled, and the edible fruit segments were separated. These separated segments were allowed to air dry for several days until complete drying was achieved, followed by oven drying at 72 °C for 48 h to ensure the removal of any residual moisture [16]. The fully dried samples were then finely ground to obtain a homogeneous powder and stored in a desiccator at room temperature. Subsequently, the samples were subjected to wet acid digestion prior to metal determination of heavy metal concentrations. Soil Soil samples were collected from the root zone (0–25 cm depth) of mature citrus trees corresponding to those selected for fruit sampling. This soil layer was selected because it represents the active zone for nutrient uptake and metal accumulation in orchard soils [9]. After collection, the soil samples were air-dried at room temperature and then oven dried at 70 °C for 48 h using a hot air oven (Memmert UF110, Memmert GmbH, Germany) to achieve constant weight. The dried samples were finely ground and passed through a 2 mm stainless steel sieve (Endecotts Ltd., UK) to obtain a uniform particle size. The processed samples were stored in clean airtight polythene bags prior to heavy metal analysis. Water At each site, three separate irrigation water samples were collected directly from the water channel used for orchard irrigation. Canal water was collected from the irrigation channel in chakiyan Phularwan. Domestic wastewater samples were collected from the wastewater stream entering the orchard at Chak No.79 N.B. For domestic wastewater, samples were collected at three different time intervals (morning, afternoon, and evening) to account for temporal variations in wastewater composition. The collected samples were composited to obtain representative samples. Canal water samples were also collected during the irrigation period from canal outlets supplying the orchards. All water samples were collected in prewashed 500 mL plastic bottles filtered to eliminate suspended particles, stored in an ice box at 5 °C to minimize physical and chemical alterations, and then transported to the laboratory for metal analysis [9]. Sample preparation and digestion For chemical digestion, 1 g of dried soil or fruit powder and 1 mL of irrigation water sample were treated with 10 mL of concentrated HNO3 and allowed to predigest overnight [17]. The samples were subsequently heated on a hot plate at 70 °C until substantial evaporation occurred. After cooling to ambient temperature, 5 mL of concentrated HClO4 (70%) was added, and the mixtures were reheated at 70 °C until the formation of dense white fumes, confirming complete digestion. The digests were cooled, filtered through Whatman No. 42 filter paper, transferred to 50 mL volumetric flasks, and diluted to volume with 0.1 N HNO3 [18]. Heavy metal analysis The concentrations of Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb in the soil, water and fruit samples were quantified using an atomic absorption spectrophotometer (AA-6300, Shimadzu, Japan). Prior to experimental use, all glassware and laboratory equipment were thoroughly washed and dried to prevent contamination. Accurately measured quantities of the required materials were obtained using an analytical balance and subsequently dissolved in deionized water or an appropriate solvent. To facilitate complete dissolution, the mixtures were gently heated on a hot plate. The resulting solutions were then transferred into volumetric flasks to ensure accuracy. After initial mixing, deionized water was added slowly until the meniscus aligned precisely with the calibration mark on the flask. Proper homogenization was achieved by shaking the flasks, and the meniscus level was carefully inspected at eye level to confirm a final volume of 100 mL. The concentrations of heavy metals, including Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb, were determined using a series of standard solutions to enable accurate quantitative analysis. The operating parameters of the instrument are presented in Tables 1 and 2. Table 1Instrumental operating conditions for atomic absorption spectrometric determination of Zn, Cr, Fe, and PbMetalZnCrFePbWavelength (nm)213.9422.7248.2283.2Slit width (nm)0.70.70.20.7Lamp current (mA)22124.5 Instrumental operating conditions for atomic absorption spectrometric determination of Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb Table 2Regulatory threshold values of selected heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in water (mg L−1), soil (mg kg−1), and fruits (mg kg−1). Superscripts letters indicate different reference sourcesMetalsWater (mg L−1)Soil (mg kg−1)Fruits (mg kg−1)Zn5c300b100dCr0.1c100d2.3fFe5e50,000d20 gPb0.065d200a0.3fSource: (a) Commssion, [19], (b) Ekramul Mahmud et al. [20], (c) Phetxumphou et al. [21], (d) Chiroma et al. [22], (e) Griffiths et al. [23], (f) Rahim et al. [24], (g) Shah et al. [25] Regulatory threshold values of selected heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in water (mg L−1), soil (mg kg−1), and fruits (mg kg−1). Superscripts letters indicate different reference sources Source: (a) Commssion, [19], (b) Ekramul Mahmud et al. [20], (c) Phetxumphou et al. [21], (d) Chiroma et al. [22], (e) Griffiths et al. [23], (f) Rahim et al. [24], (g) Shah et al. [25] Analytical quality control The analytical quality control procedures were strictly followed throughout the study. All glassware was acid-washed with 10% HNO₃ and rinsed three times with ultrapure deionized water prior to use. Reagent blanks and procedural blanks were prepared and analyzed with each batch of samples; blank signals were subtracted from all sample readings and remained below the limit of detection for all four metals. Calibration curves for Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb were constructed using aqueous standard solutions prepared from certified stock standards (1000 mg L−1, Merck, Germany) at five concentration levels. Calibration ranges were 0.05–2.0 mg L−1 for Zn and Pb, 0.10–5.0 mg L−1 for Cr, and 0.50–10.0 mg L−1 for Fe. All calibration curves yielded correlation coefficients (R2) of ≥ 0.999, confirming linearity across the working range. The limits of detection (LOD) and limits of quantification (LOQ) were calculated as LOD = 3σ/m and LOQ = 10σ/m, where σ is the standard deviation of ten replicate blank measurements and m is the slope of the calibration curve. Calculated LOD values were 0.015, 0.030, 0.050, and 0.010 mg/L and LOQ values were 0.050, 0.100, 0.160, and 0.033 mg L−1 for Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb, respectively. All reported concentrations in water (Zn: 18.67–51.67 mg L−1; Cr: 1.86–11.66 mg L−1; Fe: 54.34–195 mg L−1; Pb: 1.75–5.00 mg L−1), soil (Zn: 49–71 mg kg−1; Cr: 9–12 mg kg−1; Fe: 206–300 mg kg−1; Pb: 0.91–3.44 mg kg−1), and citrus fruits (Zn: 1.13–1.50 mg kg−1; Cr: 0.04–0.10 mg kg−1; Fe: 1.96–3.13 mg kg−1; Pb: 0.015–0.03 mg kg−1) exceeded their respective LOQ values, confirming reliable quantification. Method accuracy was assessed by spike-and-recovery experiments at two fortification levels in each matrix; mean recoveries ranged from 85 to 110% for all metals, within the internationally accepted range of 80–120%. Analytical accuracy was further verified using Certified Reference Material NIST SRM 1643f for water and BCR-141R for soil; measured values agreed with certified values within ±5% uncertainty. Each sample was analyzed in triplicate (n = 3) and results are expressed as mean ± SEM. Intra-day precision expressed as percentage relative standard deviation (%RSD) was below 5% for all metals across all matrices, confirming satisfactory repeatability of the AAS measurements. Statistical analysis Data were expressed as mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM). Prior to statistical analysis, the data were checked for normality and homogeneity of variance. A two-factor factorial analysis of variance ANOVA was performed in Python (version 3.12) to evaluate the effects of irrigation source (CWI-I and DWW-II), citrus variety (C. limetta, C. reticulata, C. sinensis), and their interaction on heavy metal concentration in water, soil, and fruit samples. Mean comparisons were conducted Tukey's Honestly Significant Difference (HSD) post hoc test at a significance level of p < 0.05. Significance levels were reported as ns = non significant, *= p < 0.05, **= p < 0.01, and ***= p < 0.001. Pearson correlation analysis was performed using SPSS version 23 to evaluate the relationships among heavy metal concentrations in water, soil, and fruit samples under both irrigation systems. In addition, principal component analysis (PCA) and heatmap analysis were conducted using Minitab version 19 to assess multivariate relationships and distribution patterns of heavy metals among irrigation sources and citrus varieties. Contamination factor The contamination factor (CF) is utilized in examining the contamination of pollutants in sediment [26] (Table 3). Table 3Reference value of selected heavy metals in soil (mg kg−1) based on established environmental guidelinesMetalReference value (mg kg−1)Zn50 dCr9.07aFe56.9ePb8.15aSource: (a) Singh et al. [27], (d) McLaughlin & Smolders, [28], (e) Ahmad et al. [29] Reference value of selected heavy metals in soil (mg kg−1) based on established environmental guidelines Source: (a) Singh et al. [27], (d) McLaughlin & Smolders, [28], (e) Ahmad et al. [29] The contamination factor was calculated using Eq. (1). where, C sample is the concentration of metal in sediment and C Background is the amount of metal from the natural reference. Pollution load index The pollution load index is an easy measure to check the cumulative status of metal pollution in a particular area [26]. The PLI was calculated using Eq. (2). where, CF is the contamination factor of metal in a sample and n is the total number of metals examined. Enrichment factor (EF) The enrichment factor (EF) is a significant index that can be used to measure the degree of accumulation and sources of pollution quantitatively [30] (Table 4). Table 4Standard concentration of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soil and fruits (mg/kg) based on established environmental and food safety guidelinesMetalSoil (mg kg−1)Fruit (mg kg−1)Zn50d60fCr9.07b2.3iFe56.9e20jPb8.15b0.1fSource: (b) Singh et al. [27], (d) McLaughlin & Smolders, [28], (e) Ahmad et al. [29], (f) Ezeilo et al. [31], (i) (Commission, [19], (j) (Shah et al. [25] Standard concentration of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soil and fruits (mg/kg) based on established environmental and food safety guidelines Source: (b) Singh et al. [27], (d) McLaughlin & Smolders, [28], (e) Ahmad et al. [29], (f) Ezeilo et al. [31], (i) (Commission, [19], (j) (Shah et al. [25] The EF was determined using Eq. (3). where, MC represents the metal concentration in soil and fruits. Potential ecological risk index The potential ecological risk index (PERI) is a process of examining environmental risks generated by soil. It is a thorough evaluation of a polluted site to determine the potential ecological risk. The calculation of PER and PERI was performed using Eq. (4 and 5) following the method of Kars & Dengiz [32]. where, PER represents the potential ecological risk of individual metals and PERI represents the potential ecological risk index of combined metals and the comprehensive assessment of ecological hazards [32]. TRF stands for one element’s toxic response factor. The value of TRF for Zn = 1, Cr = 2, Pb = 5, and Fe = 1 [33]. Estimated daily intake The amount of an element in the food that can be taken in a day without constituting a serious hazard to health is called estimated daily intake [34] (Table 5). Table 5Oral reference dose for metals mg/kg/dayMetalOral reference Dose (mg kg⁻1 day⁻1)Zn0.37bCr1.5cFe0.7cPb0.0035aSource: (a) Anyanwu & Onyele, [35], (b) Usepa, [36]. c (Ugulu et al., 2024) [9] Oral reference dose for metals mg/kg/day Source: (a) Anyanwu & Onyele, [35], (b) Usepa, [36]. c (Ugulu et al., 2024) [9] The EDI was calculated based on Eq. (6). where MC represents the concentration of metal in the fruit. F represents the conversion factor, which is 0.085, the daily food intake (DI) is 31.5 g person−1day−1, and the body weight of an adult (BW) is 70 kg [37, 38]. Target hazard quotient To assess the noncarcinogenic health risk of consuming fruits polluted with hazardous metals, the Target Hazard Quotient was used as an evaluation tool [39] (Table 5). The THQ was estimated using Eq. (7). Results Heavy metal concentrations in irrigation water Zn concentrations in irrigation water varied significantly across sites. At CW-I, the mean Zn concentration ranged from 13.33 to 50 mg L−1, while, at DWW-II, it ranged from 18.67 and 51.67 mg L−1. The highest Zn concentration was observed in C. limetta at the DWW-II (Fig. 2). Cr concentrations ranged from 1.86 to 11.66 mg L−1 across both sites, with DWW-II consistently showing higher values. Fe concentrations ranged from 45.5 to 210 mg L−1, with the highest value recorded in C. limetta at DWW-II and the lowest in C. sinensis at CW-I. Pb ranged from 0.93 to 5.2 mg L−1, with maximum accumulation in C. reticulata under DWW-II irrigation. Two-way ANOVA showed that site significantly influenced Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb concentrations (p < 0.001), while varietal and site × variety effects were significant for most metals. These results indicate that irrigation-site conditions were the primary factor affecting heavy metal concentrations in irrigation water. Overall, DWW-II consistently showed higher metal concentrations than CW-I across all metals and varieties (Table 6, Fig. 2). Graphical representation of heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in irrigation water (mg L.−1) collected from CW-I and DWW-II sites of Sargodha, with values expressed as the mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM; n = 3 per site per species) Table 6Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg L−1) in irrigation water samples collected from CW-I and DWW-II sites in SargodhaSource of variationDFZnCrFePbSites1242***298.49***100,501***61.79***Water21940.17***1.79**260**0.56***Sites × Water271.17**4.11***21 ns0.07*Error126.320.21290.01DF degree of freedom, ns non significant*** = significant at 0.001, ** = significant at 0.01, * = significant at 0.05 Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg L−1) in irrigation water samples collected from CW-I and DWW-II sites in Sargodha DF degree of freedom, ns non significant *** = significant at 0.001, ** = significant at 0.01, * = significant at 0.05 Concentration of Heavy metals in the Soil Samples Soil Zn concentrations ranged from 44 to 71 mg kg−1, with the highest value recorded in C. sinensis at DWW-II. Cr ranged from 9.67 to 22.7 mg kg−1, with the highest accumulation in C. limetta under DWW-II. Fe concentrations at DWW-II ranged from 296.67 to 310 mg kg−1, with C. reticulata showing the peak value. Pb under CW-I raged from 0.91 to 1.10 mg kg−1, while DWW-II soils showed substantially higher concentrations of 2.94 to 3.44 mg kg−1. Two-way ANOVA confirmed that site was the dominant source of variation for Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb concentrations (p < 0.001), while varietal effects were significant for Cr and Pb, whereas Zn and Fe were not significantly affected by variety. A significant site × variety interaction was observed only for Zn, indicating differential accumulation among citrus varieties across irrigation-site conditions (Table 7, Fig. 3). Table 7Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg kg−1) in irrigation soil samples from citrus orchard irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in SargodhaSource of variationDFZnCrFePbSites11963.56***496.12***41,088.9***21.67***Soil of Varieties23.17 ns9.57*301.4 ns0.17*Sites × Soil of Varieties247.06*1.08 ns51.4 ns0.04 nsError127.331.6083.30.04ns non significant* = significant at 0.05, ** = significant at 0.01, *** = significant at 0.001 Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg kg−1) in irrigation soil samples from citrus orchard irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha ns non significant * = significant at 0.05, ** = significant at 0.01, *** = significant at 0.001 Bar graph representing heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) measured on a dry weight basis and expressed in mg kg.−1 in soil samples collected from citrus orchards irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha, with values presented as the mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM; n = 3 per site per species) Heavy metals in citrus fruits The concentration of Zn in fruits of citrus plants was found between 1.08±0.04 mg kg−1 to 1.58±0.07 mg kg−1 and the highest concentration was recorded in C. limetta at DWW-II. The concentrations of Cr ranged from 0.011 to 0.10 mg kg−1, which were the lowest in CW-I and highest in C. sinensis in DWW-II, respectively. However, Fe was in the range of 1.96 to 3.2 mg kg−1 respectively with the highest value observed in C. limetta in DWW-II. The lowest concentration of the all the metals was observed for Pb with C. reticulata under DWW-II having the highest concentration ranging from 0.010 to 0.031 mg kg−1. Two-way ANOVA revealed that site had a significant effects on Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb concentrations (p < 0.001), whereas varietal differences were significant only for Cr. No significant site × variety interactions were detected for any metal, suggesting a relatively consistent response of citrus varieties across irrigation-site conditions. All concentrations of metal in fruit were found to be below the permissible levels. At the irrigation sites, the fruits contain the highest level of Fe, followed by Zn, Cr and Pb, with Fe > Zn > Cr > Pb (Table 8, Fig. 4). Table 8Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg kg−1) in edible fruit tissues of C. limetta, C. reticulata, and C. sinensis under canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) irrigation in SargodhaSource of variationDFZnCrFePbSites10.7854***0.0089***5.3356***0.0014***Varieties20.0051 ns0.0042***0.00389 ns0.000003 nsSites × Varieties20.0031 ns0.0002 ns0.0239 ns0.00001 nsError120.01550.00020.04560.00001ns non significant* = significant at 0.05, ** = significant at 0.01, *** = significant at 0.001 Analysis of variance of heavy metal concentrations (mg kg−1) in edible fruit tissues of C. limetta, C. reticulata, and C. sinensis under canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) irrigation in Sargodha ns non significant * = significant at 0.05, ** = significant at 0.01, *** = significant at 0.001 Bar graph demonstrating heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb) measured on a dry weight basis and expressed in mg kg-1 in fruits of C. limetta, C. reticulata, and C. sinensis cultivated under canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) irrigation in the semiarid region of Sargodha, with values expressed as the mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM; n = 3 per site per species) Indices evaluating heavy metal contamination in water, soil and fruit samples Contamination factor CF values indicated that Fe showed the highest contamination (3.48–5.44), particularly in C. reticulata at the DWW-II site, reflecting moderate to considerable pollution. Cr concentration ranged from 1.06–2.50, with the maximum value observed in C. limetta irrigated with DWW-II. Similarly, the highest Zn CF (1.42) was recorded in C. sinensis at DWW-II, whereas Pb exhibited the lowest contamination overall (0.11–0.42), although its maximum value also occurred in C. limetta at DWW-II. In contrast, the lowest CF values for most metals were detected at CW-I, especially in C. reticulata and C. sinensis. Overall, CF values consistently followed the order DWW-II > CW-I, while metal contamination trend was Fe > Cr > Zn > Pb (Fig. 5). Contamination factor of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils from citrus orchard irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha, indicating the relative degree of soil contamination at each site Pollution load index PLI values showed clear variation between CW-I and DWW-II. At CW-I, all citrus varieties had PLI below 1, indicating low metal pollution and safe environmental conditions. In contrast, all varieties at DWW-II showed PLI values above 1, confirming significant contamination due DWW-II to irrigation. The highest PLI was recorded in C. limetta (1.65), followed by C. sinensis and C. reticulata, indicating greater metal accumulation in C. limetta. Overall, DWW-II was more contaminated than CW-I and may pose environmental and food safety risks (Table 9). Table 9Pollution Load Index values for heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils of citrus orchards irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha VarietiesCW-IDWW-IIC. limetta0.881.65C. reticulate0.821.53C. sinensis0.801.61 Pollution Load Index values for heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils of citrus orchards irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha Enrichment factor The highest enrichment of Zn (0.0215) was observed in C. sinensis at CW-I, whereas the lowest Zn enrichment factor (0.0176) was recorded in C. sinensis at DWW-II. The maximum EF for Cr was observed in C. reticulata (0.020) at CW-I, whereas the lowest EF (0.003) was recorded in C. limetta at CW-I. The EF of Fe spanned from 0.026 to 0.0306, with the highest enrichment observed in C. limetta at the DWW-II irrigated site, whereas the lowest Fe enrichment was found in C. limetta at CW-I. The enrichment factor of Pb ranged from 0.68–1.11, with the maximum value observed in C. limetta at CW-I and the minimum at DWW-II. Overall, the enrichment factor was consistently higher at DWW-II compared to CW-I, with the metal enrichment pattern following Pb > Fe > Zn > Cr (Fig. 6). Enrichment factor of selected heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, and Pb) in soils from citrus growing areas irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II), reflecting the degree of anthropogenic influence Potential ecological risk The potential ecological risk (PER) values varied among metals and irrigation sites. Fe showed the highest PER (3.485–5.448), with the maximum value recorded in C. reticulata at DWW-II, while the lowest was observed in C. sinensis at CW-I. Cr ranged from 2.132 to 5.005and showed the highest PER in C. limetta at DWW-II. Zn exhibited comparatively lower PER values (0.88 to 1.42), with the maximum recorded at DWW-II, whereas Pb showed the lowest ecological risk (0.558–2.11), although its highest value was also observed in C. limetta at DWW-II. Overall, PER values were consistently higher at DWW-II than CW-I, following the order Fe > Cr > Pb > Zn (Fig. 7). Variation in the potential ecological risk of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) at canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) irrigated sites in Sargodha Potential ecological risk index At CW-I, the PERI values ranged from 7.26 to 7.79, with C. limetta showing the highest risk index (7.79), followed by C. reticulata (7.48), while C. sinensis exhibited the lowest value (7.26). This suggested minor variation among citrus varieties, but all values remained well within the low-risk category (Table 10). Table 10Assessing the potential ecological risk index for heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils of citrus orchards irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in SargodhaVarietiesCW-IDWW-IIC. limetta7.7913.70C. reticulate7.4812.85C. sinensis7.2613.27 Assessing the potential ecological risk index for heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils of citrus orchards irrigated with canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) in Sargodha In contrast, at DWW-II, PERI values were comparatively higher, ranging from 12.85 to 13.70. The highest ecological risk was observed in C. limetta (13.70), followed by C. sinensis (13.27), whereas C. reticulata showed the lowest value (12.85). Although these values were higher than those at CW-I, they still indicated low potential ecological risk. Estimated daily intake of metals EDI values were consistently higher at DWW-II than CW-I for all studied metals. Fe showed the highest EDI (0.075–0.1224 mg kg−1 day−1), with the maximum value recorded in C. limetta at DWW-II, whereas Pb exhibited the lowest (0.0003–0.0011 mg kg−1 day−1), highest in C. reticulata at DWW-II. The highest Zn intake was observed in C. limetta (0.0604) at DWW-II, while Cr showed the maximum value in C. sinensis (0.0038) at the same site. Overall, EDI values followed the order CW-I < DWW-II, while the metal intake trend was Fe > Zn > Cr > Pb (Fig. 8). All EDI values remained below the internationally recommended tolerable daily intake limits. Variation in estimated daily intake (mg kg−1 body weight day−1) of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) through consumption of citrus fruits grown under canal water-irrigation (CW-I ) and domestic wastewater-irrigation (DWW-II) in Sargodha Target hazard quotient THQ values for all four metals remained below 1 across all citrus varieties and both irrigation sites, indicating no non-carcinogenic health risk from consumption of citrus fruits grown under either irrigation regime. THQ value for Zn (0.112–0.116), Pb (0.109–0.338), Cr (0.000281–0.002550), and Fe (0.1071–0.1749) all remained below the safety threshold of 1. Fe is an essential micronutrient, and its presence in citrus fruits may contribute positively to dietary intake of consumers. The ascending THQ order was Cr < Zn < Pb < Fe, and all fruits are confirmed safe for human consumption under both irrigation conditions (Fig. 9). Fluctuation in Target Hazard Quotient of heavy metals (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in Fruits at CW-I and DWW-II Pearson correlation coefficient The Pearson correlation coefficient was used to determine the association between metal concentrations. A positive and statistically significant correlation (p < 0.05) of Zn was found from water to soil at CW-I (Table 11), while a weak and non significant relation of soil-fruit (p > 0.05) was observed at CW-I. In DWW-II, a negative and non significant correlation was observed between water-soil; in contrast, a positive and non significant relationship was observed in the soil and fruit samples of DWW-II. A positive significant correlation of Cr between water and soil was present at the CW-I site. In contrast, negative and non significant correlations were found between water and soil at CW-I and between water‒soil and soil-fruit at DWW-II. A positive and non significant correlation of Fe (p > 0.05) was noted in water, soil and soil-fruit in both irrigation types (CW-I and DWW-II). DWW-II showed a weaker correlation than CW-I. At CW-I, a positive and statistically non significant correlation (p > 0.05) of Pb was observed between water and soil (Table 11). The correlation between soil and fruit was statistically positive and significant (p < 0.01) at CW-I, while Pb at DWW-II displayed a positive and non significant correlation of water to soil and soil to fruit. Table 11Pearson correlation coefficients for heavy metal concentrations among among water, soil, and citrus fruit samples at CW-I and DWW-II in SargodhaSITESCW-IDWW-IIMetalsWater- SoilSoil-FruitWater-SoilSoil-FruitZn0.670*0.349ns−0.420ns0.620nsCr0.858**−0.183ns−0.217ns−0.413Fe0.648ns0.646ns0.186ns0.600nsPb0.634ns0.825**0.504ns0.299nsns non significant, *significant at 0.05, **significant at 0.01 Pearson correlation coefficients for heavy metal concentrations among among water, soil, and citrus fruit samples at CW-I and DWW-II in Sargodha ns non significant, *significant at 0.05, **significant at 0.01 PCA analysis for water The results of the two irrigation regimes in the separation of citrus varieties are clearly shown by the PCA scatter plot (Fig. 10). The first principal component (F1) explained 96.28% of the total variance, indicating that the major variability among the measured parameters was strongly associated with irrigation–site conditions. Samples linked with CW-I clustered on the negative side of the F1 axis, whereas samples associated with DWW-II) were distributed on the positive side, reflecting pronounced irrigation site associated differentiation. The second component (F2), which determined 3.70% of the variance, represented comparatively minor variation and mainly reflected varietal differences within the irrigation-site groups. C. sinensis presented a comparatively specific distribution pattern compared to C. limetta and C. reticulata, suggesting possible differences in physiological or biochemical responses under the studied conditions. Overall, the PCA findings suggest that the observed variability in water-related heavy metal parameters was primarily associated with irrigation-site conditions, whereas varietal effects contributed comparatively less to the total variation. However, because the sampling sites were distributed across different cities, the contribution of site-specific environmental conditions cannot be completely excluded (Figs. 10 and 11). Scatter plot depicting the distribution of heavy metals in water samples using PCA Heatmap depicting the variation in heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in irrigation water linked to different citrus species (C. limetta, C. reticulata, C. sinensis) under canal water-irrigated (CW-I) and domestic wastewater-irrigated (DWW-II) conditions in Sargodha PCA analysis for water and soil As seen in the PCA scatter plot of soil parameters (Fig. 12), there was an obvious distinction between the samples of the two irrigation regimes. The first principal component (F1) had a variability value of 99.62, indicating that the most of the variation in the soil properties was associated with the irrigation-site conditions. Samples linked with CW-) clustered distinctly on the negative side of the F1 axis, whereas samples associated with DWW-II were positioned on the positive side, demonstrating strong irrigation-site associated differentiation. Scatter plot depicting the distribution of heavy metals in soil samples using PCA The second principal component (F2) explained only 0.28% of the total variance and reflected relatively small varietal differences within irrigation-site groups. The limited contribution of (F2) suggests that varietal effects on soil characteristics were comparatively minor. In general, the PCA results indicate that irrigation-site conditions exerted a substantial influence on soil-related heavy metal variability, while varietal differences contributed less prominently to the observed patterns. Nevertheless, as the sampling sites were located in different geographical areas, the influence of site-specific environment variability cannot be entirely ruled out (Figs. 12 and 13). Heatmap showing variation in heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in soils of citrus species collected from CW-I and DWW-II The PCA scatter plot for fruits The PCA scatter plot of fruit characteristics revealed a strong segregation of samples associated with different irrigation-site conditions (Fig. 14). F1 account for 98.95% of the total variance, indicating that the major variability in fruit associated with heavy metal was strongly linked with irrigation site conditions. Samples associated CW-I clustered toward the negative side of F1 axis, whereas samples linked with DWW-II were grouped on the positive side, indicating pronounced irrigation-site associated differentiation. The second component (F2), which explained only 0.91% of the variance, had little contribution and was mostly based on trivial varietal disparity within irrigation-site groups. Among the varieties, C. limetta exhibited the most pronounced shift between CW-I and DWW-II conditions, suggesting comparatively greater sensitivity to the studied irrigation site conditions, while C. reticulata and C. sinensis exhibited relatively moderate responses. In general, the PCA indicates that the most important sources of variation in fruit heavy metal characteristics were the irrigation-site conditions, while the variation in heavy metal characteristics of different varieties was comparatively small. However, because the experimental sites were distributed across different cities, some influence of site-specific environmental factors may also have contributed to the observed clustering patterns (Figs. 14 and 15). Scatter plot depicting the distribution of heavy metals in fruit samples using PCA Heatmap illustrating the distribution of heavy metal concentrations (Zn, Cr, Fe, Pb) in different citrus species (C. limetta, C. reticulata, C. sinensis) under canal water (CW-I) and domestic wastewater (DWW-II) irrigation conditions in Sargodha Discussion Water analysis from citrus field The present study revealed that the concentration of Zn in both irrigation water sources ranged from 13.33 to 51.67 mg L−1. The observed value of Zn in water was above the permitted limit of 5 mg L−1, as reported by Phetxumphou et al. [21]. The consistently higher Zn at DWW-II compared to CW-I, suggests that DWW-II serves as the primary input pathway, likely driven by household discharge containing galvanized pipe, corrosion products, and agricultural runoff [40]. These values were markedly higher than those reported by Li et al. [30] and Ahmad et al. [29] in comparable irrigation water studies, indicating a relatively greater contamination burden in the present study area. The significant site effect confirmed by ANOVA (p < 0.01) further supports than Zn loading is predominantly site-driven rather than variety-dependent. The present study revealed that the Cr concentration in water samples varied from 1.86 to 11.66 mg L−1. The chromium concentration in both irrigation sites was beyond the maximum acceptable limit of 0.55 mg L−1, as reported by Chiroma et al. [22]. A comparison of the results with the other research showed that the amount of Cr in the present research was significantly higher than that described by Khan et al. [40], where the Cr concentration in the water sample fell within the range of 0.18–0.686 mg L−1. This is due to the cleaning of clothes by various detergents, utilization of soaps, and leathery items that contain a high content of Cr, which then enter into household waste. The cumulative usage of these products makes DWW-II more contaminated. Moreover, a shortage of pretreatment enables Cr to infiltrate freely in the irrigation system [41]. This demonstrated an elevated amount of Cr in DWW-II. The Fe content in water at two different locations ranged from 45.5 to 210 mg L−1. When compared with the findings of Ugulu et al. [9], who reported Fe concentrations in fresh and sewage water ranging from 5.45–11.32 mg L−1, the values observed in the present study were considerably higher. The reason behind this is the overuse of old water pipes in households. As water passes through old iron pipes, corrosion occurs, causing rusted iron to mix with the water [42]. The allowable safe range of Fe in water is 5 mg L−1, indicating that the Fe concentration observed in the present study was markedly higher than the permissible level and higher than that reported by Griffiths et al. [23]. The non-significant site × variety interaction for Fe in ANOVA indicates that Fe loading from water is largely site-controlled, with minimal varietal influence on initial water phase concentration. The Pb concentration in various water samples ranged from 0.93 to 5.2 mg L−1. The current value of Pb in water exceeded the permitted value of 0.065 mg L−1 reported by Chiroma et al. [22]. The current findings are higher than those of Khan et al. [40], who observed lead concentrations from different irrigation sources within the range of 0.062 to 0.128 mg L−1. The higher Pb at DWW-II reflects the cumulative input of battery waste, laundry effluents, vehicle emissions, and cosmetic effluents entering the domestic wastewater stream [41]. The significant site effect (p < 0.001) with a relatively small interaction term indicates that Pb levels in water are primarily determined by irrigation source characteristics rather than citrus variety. Soil analysis from citrus fields In the present study, Zn concentrations in soil ranged from 44 to 71 mg kg−1. According to Khan et al. [40], the level of Zn in the soil of C. reticulata (28.7–67.88 mg kg−1) was within the range observed in the present study. Hashem and Qi [43] reported a Zn concentration of 53.03 mg kg−1 in treated wastewater-irrigated soil, which was slightly lower than the upper range observed in the current study. The greater Zn retention capacity of the alluvial loam soil at DWW-II relative to the sandy alluvial soil at CW-I may have independently contributed to higher soil Zn at that site. These elevated Zn concentrations may be attributed to the loamy nature of the soil, which has a moderate Zn-binding capability, along with various agronomic practices. A continuous supply of domestic wastewater saturates the soil, resulting in additional Zn leaching in the topsoil [44]. The significant site × variety interaction effects in ANOVA (p < 0.001 and p < 0.05) confirm that Zn accumulation is associated with the combined influence of irrigation-site conditions and citrus variety. According to the findings, the average contamination of Cr in soil ranged from 9.67–22.7 mg kg−1. C. limetta contained the maximum level of Cr in DWW-II, while the minimum concentration of Cr was found in the soil of C. reticulata and remained below the permissible limit reported by Chiroma et al. [22]. Duan et al. [45] also indicated a higher concentration of Cr (111.54 mg kg−1) in Taiyuan, China. Continuous irrigation with domestic wastewater results in Cr accumulation in soils due to its absorption onto soil particles and organic matter. Plants generally restrict Cr uptake as a defence mechanism against toxicity; therefore, its translocation to edible plant parts is often limited compared with essential micronutrients. The higher Cr accumulation at DWW-II site suggests that soil at the wastewater irrigated site may be accumulating metals at a comparatively faster rate, though site-specific soil characteristics also contribute to this pattern. The Fe range in CW-I and DWW-II irrigated soil varied from 198.33 to 310 mg kg−1. When compared with the findings of Ugulu et al. [9], who reported Fe concentrations ranging from 21.93 mg/kg to 26.32 mg kg−1 in soils under C. limetta and C. sinensis, the values observed in the present study were considerably higher. The dominant site effect (p < 0.001) with non-significant variety and interaction terms confirms that Fe accumulation is strongly associated with irrigation-site conditions. Fe dynamics in soil are fundamentally governed by the Fe (II)/Fe (III) redox couple: periodic waterlogging and the high organic load of wastewater create transient reducing conditions that promote Fe3+ reduction to soluble Fe2+ by iron-reducing bacteria (Qui & Primo-millo, 2015) [46]. According to the current study, Pb concentrations in the soil varied between 0.91 and 3.44 mg/kg. As reported by Wahid et al. [47], Pb contamination in soil ranged from 1.17–1.79 mg/kg, which is closely related to the present findings. Pb concentrations in all soil samples remained well below the safe limit of 200 mg kg−1 [19]. These results suggest that the application of domestic wastewater may have enriched soils with heavy metals [48].However, the stronger Pb-binding capacity of the alluvial loam soil at DWW-II relative to sandy alluvial soil at CW-I means that difference in soil texture may also contribute to differential Pb retention between sites. Comparative analysis across environmental media showed that metal concentrations were highest in soil compared to irrigation water and fruit samples, indicating that soils act as a major reservoir for heavy metals. The elevated levels under domestic wastewater irrigation suggest continuous deposition and accumulation over time. Heavy metals in fruits Zn is absorbed by roots through ZIP transporter (ZIP1/ZIP4), but its movement is tightly regulated. When Zn levels are high, the plant sequesters excess Zn into vacuoles in roots and leaves via CDF transporters to prevent toxicity. As a result, only a small portion of Zn is loaded into the phloem and transported to fruits (Xie et al., 2025) [49]. The mean Zn level in citrus fruits varied from 1.08 to 1.58 mg kg−1, with the maximum value found in C. limetta irrigated with domestic wastewater. This level was below the recommended limit of 100 mg kg−1 in fruits as set by Chiroma et al. [22]. The concentration of Zn in the present research was closely related to the study reported by Saleem et al. [50], which was 0.20–1.60 mg kg−1. Although Zn availability in soil and water was elevated, low concentrations were observed in citrus fruits because most Zn is absorbed by nonedible parts, such as leaves. In edible parts, Zn is present due to its abundance in wastewater and because it is an essential mineral for plant growth [51]. The current investigation indicated that the Cr concentration in all citrus varieties fluctuated between 0.011 and 0.10 mg kg−1. Similar observations were reported by Rasool [52], with mean concentrations ranging from 0.063 to 0.15 mg kg−1 in juice of various orange varieties in the Sargodha district. These findings are closely aligned with the current investigation. Rahim et al. [24] suggested a safe limit of 2.3 mg kg−1 for fruits. Likewise, the present concentration was comfortably under the safety limit. In contrast, Abdel-Shafy and El-Khateeb [53] found a Cr level of 0.45 mg kg−1 in C. sinensis, which exceeds the range observed in the present study. The Fe level in the edible parts of citrus fruits ranged from 1.96 to 3.2 mg kg−1 in the present study. C. limetta showed an elevated Fe level (3.2 mg kg−1) of Fe at domestic wastewater sites; however, this value was lower than the permissible limit of 20 mg kg−1 for fruits given by Shah et al. [25]. Rasool [52] evaluated the level of Fe in citrus cultivars in different tehsils of Sargodha and found that their concentrations varied according to their origin. In the Silanwali region, Fe concentrations were 2.90 mg kg−1 in grapefruit, 2.88 mg/kg in mandarin and highest in sweet lime (5.23 mg kg−1). The dominant site effect (p < 0.001) with non-significant variety and interaction effects confirms that fruit Fe is strongly associated with irrigation-site conditions. In the current area of study, Pb concentrations at both irrigation sites ranged from 0.010–0.031 mg kg−1. These findings are consistent with Khan et al. [40], who reported Pb concentrations in sewage water ranging from 0.031 to 0.095 mg kg−1, indicating that domestic wastewater is a significant source of heavy metals. The Pb levels observed in the present study were below the acceptable limit of 0.3 mg kg−1 for fruits reported by Rahim et al. [24]. Owing to the low Pb concentrations in citrus fruits, their consumption is unlikely to pose any health risk to humans. The significant site effect (p < 0.001) with non-significant variety interaction terms confirms site-level control over fruit Pb patterns. The low-fruit Pb correlations at DWW-II are consistent with strong Pb immobilization in both soil types, though the greater binding capacity of alluvial loam soil at DWW-II may further restrict Pb bioavailability at that site relative to the sandy alluvial soil at CW-I. A comparison among citrus species indicated noticeable variation in metal accumulation patterns. C. limetta showed relatively higher concentrations of metals than C. sinensis and C. reticulata, suggesting species-specific differences in uptake and translocation mechanisms. Additionally, metal concentrations in fruits are lower than those observed in soils, reflecting selective uptake and internal regulation by plants. Among the metals, Fe and Zn exhibited comparatively higher accumulation, whereas Cr and Pb remained at lower levels, consistent with their mobility and physiological roles. Integration of PCA with Metal Accumulation Patterns The PCA analysis across irrigation water, soil, and fruit compartments revealed consistent irrigation-site associated differentiation across all three matrices, with F1 explaining 96.28–99.62%, and 98.95% of total of variance in water, soil, and fruit samples respectively. Since irrigation regime and sampling site were not independently varied in this comparative field based study, and given the contrasting soil types, sandy alluvial soil at CW-I and alluvial loam at DWW-II. These patterns reflect combined irrigation-site-associated influences rather than irrigation source alone. The F2 components (0.28–3.70% of variance) captured minor varietal differences, with C. sinensis showed a distinct physiological response in the water PCA, consistent with its significantly different Cr accumulation pattern in the ANOVA (varieties significant for Cr: p < 0.01, Table 8). C. limetta exhibited the greatest displacement between sites in the fruit scatter plot (Fig. 14), aligned with its highest PLI (1.6535), The heatmap visualisations (Figs. 11, 13, 15) revealed that Fe and Zn consistently generated the highest intensity signal across all compartments, while Cr and Pb produced comparatively lower signals. Despite higher Fe and Zn signals, all fruit metal concentrations remained well below permissible limits. Furthermore, THQ values for all metals remained below 1, confirming that citrus fruits from both irrigation-site conditions are safe for human consumption The concentration factor (CF) The CF in soil samples was highest for Fe (5.44) in C. reticulata at DWW-II, while the lowest CF (0.12) for Pb was observed in C. sinensis at CW-I. The CF of Cr and Zn ranged from 1.06–2.29 and 0.88–1.42, respectively, indicating moderate soil pollution. According to Khan et al. [40], the CF values of Fe (0.1345–0.7595) were lower and Zn were to the current study. The CF of Pb was less than 1, indicating minimal Pb accumulation in soil and negligible soil pollution. The increasing metal contamination trend is Pb < Zn < Cr < Fe. CF values were consistently higher at DWW-II than CW-I across all metals and varieties, may partly reflect the greater metal retention capacity of loam soil alongside irrigation-site-associated metal input rather than irrigation water quality alone. Pollution load index A PLI value less than 1 indicates no pollution or baseline levels, whereas values greater than 1 signify progressive deterioration of soil quality and anthropogenic contamination [54]. PLI values at CW-I ranged from 0.8091 to 0.8802, remaining below unity for all citrus varieties and confirming acceptable soil metal levels under CW-I. At DWW-II, PLI values ranged from 1.5325–1.6535, indicating moderate pollution status. The highest PLI was recorded in C. limetta (1.6535), followed by C. sinensis (1.6155) and C. reticulata (1.5325). Elevated PLI values under wastewater irrigation are consistent with previous studies, however, soil texture differences between sites may independently contribute to differential metal retention and should be considered when interpreting site-level PLI difference. Enrichment factor (EF) EF values for Zn (0.0176–0.0215), Cr (0.003–0.020), and Fe (0.026–0.0306) remained below 1 at all sites, indicating predominantly natural geogenic sources for these metals. Pb showed a marginally elevated EF of 1.11 in C. limetta at CW-I, suggesting a minor anthropogenic contribution at CW-I irrigated site that warrants monitoring. The increasing order of the metal enrichment factor followed Cr < Zn < Fe < Pb, consistent with Ali et al. [55], and Khan et al. [40] who reported comparable EF ranges for these metals in similar agricultural soils. Ecological risk factor The results showed that the metals had a high level of potential ecological risk in C. limetta compared to C. sinensis and C. reticulata grown under canal and domestic wastewater irrigation. The PER values for Zn, Pb, and Cr spanned from 0.88-1.42, 0.558-2.11 and 2.132-5.005, respectively, indicating a low potential ecological risk of these metals to public safety. Akoto and Anning [33] reported a PER value for Fe of 8.3, which is consistent with the current PER value. The present investigation of ecological risk for Pb (2.11) and Zn (1.373) also agrees with the findings of Saha et al. [56], who reported Pb (2.11) and Zn (1.37) in soils from Shanxi, a province of China, and found very low potential risk. The PER followed the trend Fe > Cr > Pb > Zn. The current results show PER values below 40, indicating that the soil is protected from potential health risks [56]. Estimated daily intake EDI values were consistently higher at DWW-II than CW-I for all metals following the order Fe > Zn > Cr > Pb. Fe recorded the highest EDI (0.075–0.122 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1), followed by Zn (0.0414–0.0604 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1), Cr (0.0004–0.0038 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1), and Pb the lowest (0.0003–0.0011 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1), with maximum values for all metals recorded at DWW-II. Amjad et al. [57] reported lower EDI values for Fe ranging from 0.0025–0.019 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1 than the current study. This suggests greater iron availability or exposure in our study area. The EDI of Cr (0.0064 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1) reported by Ugulu et al. [9] was higher than that in our study. According to Khan et al. [40], the EDI values of Pb and Cr were 1.1858 × 10−6 and 7.4970 × 10−6 mg kg⁻1 day⁻1), respectively, which were much lower than those in our study. All EDI values remained below internationally recommended tolerable daily intake limits, confirming no immediate dietary hazard from fruit consumption under either irrigation-site condition. Target hazard quotient The THQ values of all four metals remained below 1 across all varieties under both irrigation-site conditions, indicating no significant non-carcinogenic health risk associated with fruit consumption. According to USEPA [36], THQ value below 1 suggests that consumers are unlikely to experience any immediate health effects. The THQ levels for Zn and Pb ranged from 0.112–0.163 and 0.109–0.338, respectively, with all values remaining below 1. These values were consistent with Khan et al. [40] and Saleem et al. [50] Although domestic wastewater irrigation resulted in higher metal concentrations in fruits, the corresponding THQ values remained well below the critical limit of 1. The corrected ascending THQ order was Cr < Zn < Pb < Fe. Study limitations The present study was designed as comparative field based study examining heavy metal distribution across two irrigation-site condition in Sargodha. It is important to acknowledge that irrigation source and sites were not independently varied in this study, as only one site per irrigation was included. In addition, the two study sites were located approximately 56.6 km apart, which may have introduced spatial variability in soil characteristics, local sources of heavy metals, and background metal concentrations. Consequently, the observed differences in heavy metal concentration between CW-I and DWW-II reflect not only differences in irrigation water quality but also site-specific factors including differences in soil texture and composition. The sandy alluvial soil at CW-I and the alluvial loam soil at DWW-II differ in their metal binding capacities, cation exchange capacity, and organic matter content, all of which independently influence metal retention, mobility and plant bioavailability. Therefore, all findings in this study are presented as irrigation-site conditions rather than definitive evidence of causation by irrigation source alone. Conclusion This comparative field based study showed higher heavy metal accumulation and ecological risk indices (CF, PLI, PERI, and EDI) at DWW-II than at CW-I, with Fe and Zn showing comparatively greater accumulation. However, THQ values for all studied metals remained below 1, indicating no significant non-carcinogenic health risk associated with citrus fruit consumption. Because only one site was examined under each irrigation condition, the observed variations between CW-I and DWW-II may also have been influenced by site-specific characteristics, including differences in soil texture, composition, and metal retention capacity. Therefore, the findings should be interpreted as irrigation-site associated patterns rather than definitive effects of irrigation source alone. Overall, the study provides baseline information for citrus growing regions of Sargodha and emphasizes the need for continued monitoring and irrigation management practices in domestic wastewater associated agricultural systems. Furthermore, the study captures inter-compartmental linkages and variability among citrus species. Future research should focus on long-term field assessments, metal speciation, and bioavailability, as well as the development of mitigation strategies such as improved domestic wastewater treatment, controlled irrigation practices, and phytoremediation approaches to reduce metal accumulation in edible crops. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Acknowledgements The authors extend their appreciation to all those who contributed to the manuscript and express special thanks to Dr. Kafeel Ahmad for his support. Voucher specimens The plant samples were identified by Dr. Iftikhar Ahmad, an associate professor at Botany, University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan, and Dr. Mansoor Hameed, a Professor at the University of Agriculture, Faisalabad. Herbarium sheets (number R2-D123-134) are deposited at the Department of Botany (Muhammad Ali Contact +923036200205), University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan. Clinical trial number Not applicable. Authors’ contributions A.A., collected and analyzed the samples; R.B., reviewed the manuscript, prepared the graphs and tables; Z.I.K., supervised the study; A.K. and S.A.R., reviewed the article, prepared the graphs and tables, revised the manuscript and worked on methodology. All authors contributed to the manuscript. Funding No Funding. Data availability Data are provided within the manuscript or supplementary information files. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate The plants were collected from Sargodha, Pakistan (public land), and the governing body of the Higher Education Commission, Pakistan, and University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Pakistan, gave their approval for the collection of samples as per the Ethics and Guideline Committee of the University of Sargodha (Approval No. 23ES-27/2024 UOS). All the experimental methods used in this study followed all the appropriate guidance and regulations. All the protocols and experimental procedures used in this investigation were approved by the Board of Studies of the University of Sargodha, Pakistan, and the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan. Consent for publication All subjects gave their “informed consent” for the publication of details within the text (“informed consent”) to be published in the above Journal and Article. Written “informed consent” was obtained from all authors for the publication of this manuscript. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Data Availability Statement Data are provided within the manuscript or supplementary information files.