Effect of Combined CO₂ Laser Irradiation and Sodium Fluoride Varnish on Enamel Surface Morphology and Surface Elemental Composition: An In Vitro Split-Tooth Study Authors: Sham Mohamad Farouq Alkhateeb, Chaza Nader Kouchaji, Abdulrhman Ahmad Alkhaled, Omar Hamadah, Sanpreet Singh Sachdev, Mays Sameer Tareq, Vikas Singh, Vikas Singh, Sanpreet Singh Sachdev, Sanpreet Singh Sachdev, Abdulrhman Alkhaled, Alhan Ahmed Qasim Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundFluoride administration plays a critical role in the management and prophylaxis of dental caries. Research indicates that laser irradiation can enhance the uptake of fluoride into dental enamel, an effect that is particularly pronounced when used as an adjunct to topical fluoride treatments. The present study aimed to evaluate the impact of CO 2 laser irradiation on fluoride uptake in the enamel of permanent teeth.MethodsSix human upper premolars, extracted for orthodontic reasons, were selected for this study. The roots were separated from the crowns, and each crown was then sectioned mesiodistally to create mesial and distal halves. These halves were assigned to either an experimental or a control group (n = 6 per group). All specimens received an application of 5% sodium fluoride (NaF) varnish. Subsequently, the samples in the experimental group were subjected to irradiation with a 1 W CO 2 laser for a duration of 15 seconds. To assess the effects of the treatments, fluoride uptake was measured and the topographic characteristics of the enamel surface were examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX). The data obtained from the split-tooth design (paired observations from the same tooth) were analyzed using non-parametric methods. The Wilcoxon Signed-Rank Test was employed to compare the chemical element concentrations (F, Ca, P, C) between the experimental (mesial) and control (distal) halves. Effect sizes (r) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated for each paired comparison. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. All analyses were performed using SPSS software version 26 (IBM, USA).ResultsScanning electron microscopy (SEM) structural analysis revealed that the enamel surfaces in the fluoride alone group maintained a typical etched pattern with visible micropores. In contrast, the experimental group subjected to both sodium fluoride varnish and CO 2 laser irradiation demonstrated distinct surface melting, fusing of enamel crystals, and a smoother recrystallized morphology. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometry analysis showed a significant increase in the percentage of fluoride with the application of the laser, The results of the mean ranks showed that the fluoride and CO 2 laser group recorded significantly higher ranks in the fluoride element (8.75 vs. 4.25), reflecting a higher concentration and confirmed statistical significance. Statistically, the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test revealed a significant increase in fluoride concentrations in the laser-treated group compared to the control group (P value = 0.026), which indicates the effectiveness of using CO 2 lasers in enhancing fluoride absorption within the tooth structure.ConclusionThe combination of CO 2 laser irradiation and sodium fluoride varnish resulted in observable enamel surface morphological modifications and increased surface elemental concentrations of fluoride, calcium, and phosphorus in vitro. However, these surface alterations do not constitute direct evidence of enhanced acid resistance, fluorapatite formation, or clinical caries prevention. Further long-term clinical studies are mandatory to validate any potential therapeutic benefit. Introduction Dental caries deserves attention because it has become a chronic disease affecting children worldwide. 1 , 2 Dental caries is a multifactorial disease caused by the simultaneous interaction of various factors— sugar and dental biofilms —in the oral cavity. The introduction of fluoride into dental practice over seventy years ago is widely regarded as the principal reason for the global decline in dental caries. Despite this public health success, the sole confirmed adverse effect of fluoride use in dentistry is dental fluorosis, a condition resulting from excessive fluoride ingestion during tooth development. Recent epidemiological trends indicate a concurrent rise in the prevalence of dental fluorosis and a decline in caries rates. 3 The most common varnish used in dentistry to prevent tooth caries is sodium fluoride (NaF). 4 Topical application of NaF on teeth mitigates enamel demineralization while enhancing the remineralization process. The primary antimicrobial mechanism of fluoride is not direct bacterial destruction, but rather an indirect action through the inhibition of bacterial acid production, which results in a higher pH at the tooth surface. 5 , 6 The combined use of laser irradiation and topical fluoride represents a novel approach to caries prevention by increasing the enamel’s affinity for and incorporation of fluoride. Zancope et al. reported that CO 2 lasers cause morphological changes on the surface of tooth enamel, such as fusion and dissolution. 7 Studies evaluating the effect of carbon dioxide laser on the structure of tooth enamel and dentin have shown high absorption by dental tissue. 8 Specifically, the 10,600 nm CO 2 laser features an absorption coefficient in hydroxyapatite that allows specific depth of penetration and flow to produce the desired thermal effects on caries inhibition. 9 Although topical fluoride applications, such as varnishes, remain the gold standard in caries prevention, their clinical efficacy is often limited by their susceptibility to rapid dissolution in oral fluids, necessitating frequent reapplications. However, repeated high-dose applications raise concerns regarding potential systemic toxicity and fluorosis. 3 To overcome these limitations and enhance the longevity of fluoride retention, modern preventive dentistry has focused on synergistic technologies. The CO 2 laser (10,600 nm) has emerged as a promising modality; when irradiated at specific sub-ablative parameters, it induces microstructural and thermal alterations in the enamel surface. This photothermal effect temporarily increases enamel permeability and promotes the stable conversion of hydroxyapatite into a highly acid-resistant fluorapatite phase. 10 Therefore, the integration of laser therapy is proposed not to replace fluoride, but to optimize its chemical binding and depth of penetration, thereby potentially offering prolonged cariostatic protection with lower effective fluoride doses. This study aimed to evaluate and compare the efficacy of CO 2 laser irradiation versus a CO 2 application in enhancing fluoride uptake by the surfaces of permanent teeth following treatment with NaF varnish. Materials and methods Source of teeth specimens The six human upper premolars were obtained from the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery in College of Dentistry, University of Damascus after routine extractions for orthodontic reasons and not specifically for this study. Teeth were stored in distilled water at 4 °C until use. Teeth were examined to ensure they were free of any caries, abrasions or fractures. They were divided into two sections, a mesial section and a distal section, so that each treatment was applied to a section of the tooth. The root was cut from the Cementoenamel junction and the crown were stored in distilled water to prevent dehydration ( Figure 1). A picture of the teeth used in the research before and after the section. Mesial section was used as the experimental specimen and the distal as the control. All specimens were first dried and treated with 5% NaF varnish (VOCO®, Germany). A distinction was then made between the groups: the experimental specimens were laser irradiated, while the control specimens were not. Sodium fluoride varnish (5% NaF varnish (VOCO, Germany, Product Code: [190/10]) was applied to the mesial section of the tooth with a carbon dioxide laser with a wavelength of 10600 nm (power 1 W – pulse duration 15 ms) while the control sample was in the distal section and sodium fluoride varnish alone was applied ( Figure 2). A picture of the sodium fluoride varnish used by VOCO and how it is applied. The varnish was applied using a small brush according to the manufacturer’s instructions by applying a thin layer over the entire occlusal surface of the tooth. The sample in the mesial section was exposed to CO 2 laser radiation (10600 nm wavelength, 1 W power, pulsed mode, 15 ms pulse duration) with a wavelength of 10600 nm and a power of 1 W for 15 seconds with a pulsed mode and a pulse duration of 15 ms 11 at a distance of 1 cm. Irradiation was performed in a continuous scanning motion that allowed the entire surface to be irradiated and we re-preserved it with distilled water ( Figure 3). Image of the parameters used. The test of the effect of the laser on the varnish was evaluated using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) (T-Scan company VEGA II XMU, Czech Republic). Prior to SEM and EDX analyses, the remaining fluoride varnish was thoroughly and systematically removed from the enamel surfaces. Each specimen was gently wiped for 30 seconds using fresh cotton pellets saturated with pure acetone to dissolve the organic matrix of the varnish, followed by an immersion in an ultrasonic bath of distilled water for 5 minutes to eliminate any remaining chemical residues. Finally, the surfaces were thoroughly rinsed with a continuous stream of distilled water for 60 seconds and dried using a oil-free air syringe. The amount of fluoride, calcium, phosphorus, and carbon remaining on the specimens was tested using energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) (Oxford Instruments, UK) attached to the microscope located in the Atomic Energy Commission ( Figure 4). To ensure reproducibility and eliminate bias, examiner blinding was implemented during the microscopic evaluation. All specimens were assigned coded identification numbers by a primary investigator, completely masking the group assignment (experimental vs. control) from the SEM and EDX operators. Furthermore, the EDX acquisition protocol was standardized utilizing an accelerating voltage of 20 kV with a fixed working distance across all analyzed specimens. The samples were analyzed by SEM to observe the topographic properties of the enamel surface after different treatments, and images of the central region were taken using two different detectors: Secondary Electrons (SE) and Backscattered Electrons (BSE). EDX analysis provided non-destructive quantitative data on the chemical composition and elemental distribution over the surface area. 12 The response variables evaluated were changes in the concentrations of fluoride, carbonate, calcium, and phosphorus that constitute the hydroxyapatite structure. Image of the sample after preparation for entry into the scanning electron microscope. Ethical approval and informed consent This in vitro study utilized extracted human teeth collected from patients who underwent orthodontic treatment. This study was from 24/8/2025 to 27/9/2025. The study protocol was reviewed and approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of College of Dentistry, University of Damascus On August 21, 2025 under reference number (DN-210-125-3-9-1/21/8/2025). All participants (or their guardians) provided written informed consent for the use of their extracted teeth for research purposes, in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. Patient identifiers were removed to ensure confidentiality. Results The results were evaluated according to the surface shape in electron microscope images and according to the concentration of fluoride, calcium, phosphorus and carbon. In this study, SEM images showed that CO 2 laser irradiation fuses the surface, creating a smooth, recrystallized side. Fusion between enamel surface crystals was also observed after carbon dioxide laser treatment ( Figures 5 and 6). SEM micrographs of enamel surfaces. (A) Mesial section (fluoride + laser) using SE detector (×1000): Black arrows indicate zones of superficial enamel melting and crystal fusion. (B) Distal section (fluoride only) using SE detector (×1000): White arrows point to typical patent micropores. (C) Mesial section (fluoride + laser) at ×500 magnification: Black arrows highlight the smooth, recrystallized surface topography. (D) Distal section (fluoride only) at ×500 magnification showing unaltered surface morphology. SEM micrographs of enamel surfaces using BSE detector. (A) Mesial section (fluoride + laser) at ×200 : Black arrows indicate the boundary of thermal modification and fused mineral deposits. (B) Lateral section (fluoride only) at ×200 showing baseline surface characteristics. (C) Medial section (fluoride + laser) at ×500 : Black arrows mark the homogeneous recrystallized hydroxyapatite lattice. (D) Lateral section (fluoride only) at ×500 displaying micro-roughness without melting features. Comparing the apparent differences in the mean of the measured items between the two groups ( Table 1) and the descriptive statistics for fluoride, calcium, phosphorus, and carbon ratios in both study groups ( Tables 2– 5). Table 1. The comparison between elements using the mean.ElementFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laserThe difference between averagesCommentsFluoride0.351.73+1.38Obvious apparent increase in fluoride with laser applicationCalcium1.623.72+2.10Significant apparent increase in calciumPhosphorus0.990.65−0.34Slight decrease in phosphorusCarbon72.8967.30−5.59Slight carbon reduction Table 1. The comparison between elements using the mean.ElementFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laserThe difference between averagesCommentsFluoride0.351.73+1.38Obvious apparent increase in fluoride with laser applicationCalcium1.623.72+2.10Significant apparent increase in calciumPhosphorus0.990.65−0.34Slight decrease in phosphorusCarbon72.8967.30−5.59Slight carbon reduction The comparison between elements using the mean. Table 2. The descriptive statistics of fluoride ratios.FluorideFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laser group Mean 0.41.7 Std. Deviation 0.31.4 Median 0.21.4 Minimum 0.10.2 Maximum 1.04.3 The descriptive statistics of fluoride ratios. Table 3. The descriptive statistics of calcium ratios.CalciumFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laser groupMean1.623.72Std. Deviation1.566.28Median1.101.28Minimum0.500.60Maximum4.6516.50 The descriptive statistics of calcium ratios. Table 4. The descriptive statistics of phosphorus ratios.PhosphorusFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laser groupMean0.990.65Std. Deviation1.130.92Median0.390.35Minimum0.110.00Maximum2.442.50 The descriptive statistics of phosphorus ratios. Table 5. The descriptive statistics of carbon ratios.CarbonFluoride groupFluoride + CO 2 laser groupMean72.8967.29Std. Deviation8.977.42Median74.2468.75Minimum57.1357.80Maximum84.1277.56 The descriptive statistics of carbon ratios. Test values represent Wilcoxon signed-rank Z-scores. Negative Z-values indicate the direction of the difference between paired observations (laser-treated mesial halves vs. control distal halves). Effect sizes (r) were calculated as r = |Z|/√n, where n = 6 paired observations. All comparisons were based on paired data from the same tooth (split-tooth design). The Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test revealed a statistically significant increase in fluoride, calcium, and phosphorus weight percentages in the laser-treated group compared to the control group (p < 0.05). Conversely, carbon demonstrated a significant reduction following treatment. Detailed paired differences, effect sizes (r), and 95% confidence intervals are summarized in ( Table 6). Table 6. Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test results. Fluoride Calcium PhosphorusCarbonvalue-Z-2.201-2.201-2.207-2.201P value<0.0010.0120.0280.008Comparison with significance levelLess than 0.05Less than 0.05Less than 0.05Less than 0.05ResultThere is a statistically significant difference between the two groupsThere is a statistically significant difference between the two groupsThere is a statistically significant difference between the two groupsThere is a statistically significant difference between the two groups Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test results. Discussion This study evaluated the efficacy of a CO 2 laser for enhancing fluoride uptake in dental enamel. According to existing literature, the combined application of a CO 2 laser with fluoride varnishes or gels can potentially quadruple fluoride absorption, which may significantly improve caries prevention and reduce the required fluoride dosage or frequency of clinical applications. 13 While our current laboratory findings support this positive synergistic trend by demonstrating a statistically significant increase in surface fluoride concentrations (p < 0.001) via EDX analysis using the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test, these results must be interpreted within specific boundaries. Due to the small sample size utilized in this investigation (n = 6 permanent teeth sectioned to create 12 experimental halves), this work should be appropriately characterized as a pilot study. In advanced microstructural and surface examinations using SEM and EDX, small sample sizes are frequently employed because the focus is on highly precise, localized topographic and elemental changes rather than biological variance. Furthermore, our study utilized a split-tooth design—where each tooth served as its own internal control (mesial half treated with laser + fluoride, distal half with fluoride alone)—which effectively eliminated inter-individual biological variability and enhanced the statistical power of the comparison. Nevertheless, we acknowledge the small sample size as a limitation of this laboratory model, and future large-scale quantitative trials are required to fully validate the clinical extent of this laser-induced enhancement. In order to obtain a protective effect, a laser was used to raise the temperature of the tooth enamel to the melting point of its inorganic components or to the decomposition point of its organic components. On the other hand, non-thermal laser radiation was used after tooth fluoridation to achieve a slow fluoride release effect. This type of reaction is called laser-activated fluoride treatment. 11 Carbon dioxide laser irradiation of tooth enamel, within certain parameters, results in a specific temperature increase above the irreversible pulpitis threshold of 5.5 °C, 14 which changes the chemical composition of the tooth enamel surface and the morphological structure 15 and the increase may lead to permanent damage to the tooth pulp. Excessive temperature elevation during laser application poses a risk of injury to the dental pulp. A study addressing this risk compared the thermal effects of two laser systems: a CO 2 laser (at 1 and 2 W) and a diode laser (at 5 and 7 W). The results indicated that the mean temperature rise remained below the 5.5 °C critical threshold for pulp damage. Based on this evidence, the authors determined that both lasers could be used safely without compromising pulp health. 16 The absorption depth of port and ivory is 12 μm, compared to the absorption depth of water of 15 μm. 17 The absorption effects of tooth enamel and dentin at these depths depend on how the laser energy affects them and the laser energy depends on laser parameters such as power, mode of operation (continuous or pulsed wave mode), flow (energy density) and dose. The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonization, dissolution and cracking of the enamel and the development of the pulse mode allowed variations by frequency and pulse duration in milliseconds (ms) and microseconds (μs). This improved the thermal control of the laser in tissue. The dose depends on the radiation method: spot radiation or sweeping motion, the number of repeated radiations. 9 Several hypotheses have been advanced to explain the mechanisms by which combined laser and fluoride treatment enhances resistance to enamel demineralization. A principal theory posits that laser irradiation creates micro-spaces within the enamel structure, which subsequently serve to retain fluoride ions more effectively. 18 These structural alterations are also believed to contribute directly to reducing enamel solubility. 19 The observed morphological changes on the enamel surface following the sequential application of topical fluoride and CO 2 laser irradiation provide a rationale for the superior protective effect compared to fluoride treatment alone. 20 This synergistic effect is further attributed to the laser-induced conversion of hydroxyapatite to the more acid-resistant fluorapatite phase, a process accompanied by the melting and recrystallization of hydroxyapatite crystals. 21 The results of previous studies showed that treating the surface of tooth enamel using a carbon dioxide laser reduces demineralization of tooth enamel compared to the control group. Studies have shown that wavelengths from 9 to 11 micrometers of CO 2 lasers are effectively absorbed by dental hydroxyapatite, causing loss of carbonate mineral, which in turn reduces acid reactivity. 22, 23 The integration of lasers in preventive dentistry reflects a modern paradigm shift within the field, moving away from a traditional focus on restorative treatment and toward a philosophy of disease prevention. This approach is consistent with the recommendations of major professional bodies and is part of a wider scientific consensus advocating for less invasive caries management strategies, 24 Which aims to preserve tissues to the maximum extent, and in this new approach, prevention has acquired an important role that it has not played before in the past. 11 All experiments combining CO 2 and fluoride laser radiation have shown better results in preventing tooth caries when compared to a single treatment. Therefore, this ‘combination therapy’ may be clinically effective, and at the same time, it may only involve moderate daily doses of fluoride and low levels of laser radiation energy, which is consistent with our current study. A critical limitation of this study is that SEM and EDX analyses provide topographic and compositional data only. While we observed increased surface fluoride and calcium concentrations, along with surface melting and recrystallization patterns, these findings cannot be directly interpreted as evidence of fluorapatite formation, reduced enamel solubility, or enhanced acid resistance. The measured elemental changes reflect surface modifications rather than functional resistance to demineralization. Future investigations should incorporate direct acid resistance assays (e.g., pH cycling models, microhardness testing, or polarized light microscopy) to confirm whether these surface alterations translate into clinically meaningful protection against dental caries. Conclusion Within the limitations of this in vitro study, the combined application of CO 2 laser and sodium fluoride varnish resulted in observable surface morphological changes (surface melting and recrystallization) and increased surface elemental concentrations of fluoride, calcium, and phosphorus compared to varnish alone. However, these topographic and compositional alterations do not constitute direct evidence of enhanced acid resistance, reduced enamel solubility, or clinical caries prevention. Long-term clinical trials incorporating direct acid resistance tests (e.g., pH cycling or microhardness testing) are mandatory to validate any potential therapeutic benefit. Recommendations Although these results are very promising, more studies should be developed in order to test these radiation conditions under different challenges, and simulate other clinical variables and therefore, future clinical studies are recommended to confirm these results. The subsections of figures are not labelled and described. The redundant full forms of SEM and EDX are mentioned repeatedly still. Ethical approval section reveals all details about the authors' university, which is against the jurnals policy of anonymity. Tables are still not merged and presented separately. They should be merged to improve readability of the mansucript helping readers to understand the results at a glance. There is a lot of redundancy btween the methods, results and discussion sections Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? No If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? I cannot comment. A qualified statistician is required. Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? No Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? No Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? No Reviewer Expertise: Oral Pathology, Dental Materials, Dental Innovations, Dental Anatomy, Dentistry I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to state that I do not consider it to be of an acceptable scientific standard, for reasons outlined above. The Reviewer's Comments Recommendation: Accept with major revision. Summary: The manuscript contains various grammatical mistakes and typos. A comprehensive linguistic editing is necessary. Weaknesses and Suggestions: Abstract Some experimental data need to be included in this section to give a clear insight on the results and their discussions instead of some general statements and unnecessary comparisons. Introduction In the introduction, if abbreviations are used, they should be consistently applied throughout the text. Also, include similar research related to your work and briefly compare their results. When stating the objective of the study, clearly mention the variable parameters. At the end of the introduction, introduce the upcoming sections: In the next section, we consider materials and methods applied to the experiment. Section 3 shows the …. In Section 4, we present the results and discussion. Section 5 illustrates the …. In the final section, acknowledgements and author contribution are mentioned.The research objective should be written in a more concise and objective manner. In the introduction, if abbreviations are used, they should be consistently applied throughout the text. Also, include similar research related to your work and briefly compare their results. When stating the objective of the study, clearly mention the variable parameters. At the end of the introduction, introduce the upcoming sections: In the next section, we consider materials and methods applied to the experiment. Section 3 shows the …. In Section 4, we present the results and discussion. Section 5 illustrates the …. In the final section, acknowledgements and author contribution are mentioned. In the introduction, if abbreviations are used, they should be consistently applied throughout the text. Also, include similar research related to your work and briefly compare their results. When stating the objective of the study, clearly mention the variable parameters. At the end of the introduction, introduce the upcoming sections: In the next section, we consider materials and methods applied to the experiment. Section 3 shows the …. In Section 4, we present the results and discussion. Section 5 illustrates the …. In the final section, acknowledgements and author contribution are mentioned. The research objective should be written in a more concise and objective manner. The research objective should be written in a more concise and objective manner. Experimental Methodology, results, and discussion: What is the novelty of this work?The article describes a split-tooth approach, using the mesial and distal half of the same tooth as paired experimental and control groups. This is a strong design that takes into account interindividual variability. The statistical analysis was performed with Mann-Whitney U test, which is for independent samples. Why not use a paired test (e.g. Wilcoxon signed rank test)? The principal finding of the study (p=0.026 for fluoride) may not be legitimate because of the use of an incorrect statistical test. “It is absolutely essential to re-analyze with the proper test. The study used just six teeth (n=6 per group). The authors say in the response to reviewers that this is a “pilot study”. However, the abstract and conclusions describe the finding as if it is final. Was a formal power analysis done a prior to establish that a sample size of six was adequate to detect a clinically relevant difference? But if so, why can this study be recognized as anything more than a preliminary pilot research and why was this not clearly indicated in the title and abstract? The Abstract mentions teeth halves were "randomly assigned" to groups, however the Methods section indicates that the mesial half was always allocated to the laser+fluoride group and the distal half to the fluoride-only group. What is correct? If allocation was not randomised there is considerable possibility of systematic bias. For example, is there a structural difference between the mesial and distal surfaces that confounds the results? Please explain exactly how the allocation was made and argue why the use (or absence) of randomisation does not undermine the validity of the study.The title and findings of the study boldly assert a “protective effect” and the possibility of “long-term enamel protection”. However, only the surface elemental composition was evaluated using SEM/EDX in the research, showing a rise of fluoride, calcium and phosphorus on the surface. This does not directly evaluate fluoride absorption into the enamel, or fluorapatite production or resistance to acid demineralisation. Your findings do not include a test of acid resistance (e.g., a pH cycling model). How can you make such broad claims regarding clinical effectiveness and caries prevention from this in vitro trial alone?How was the varnish removed from the surface of the tooth before the SEM/EDX analysis? If it wasn't removed, are you measuring fluoride in the varnish residue and not the enamel? The conclusion suggests that the combination treatment is “clinically translating to enhanced enamel surface resistance to acid challenges”. No acid challenge or demineralisation test was performed in this research. This is a little exaggeration of your findings. How can you square this finding with the fact that your study didn’t truly test acid resistance?There is an unnecessary paragraph on the mechanisms of action in the manuscript (pages 9 and 10). More crucially, the statement "The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonisation, dissolution and cracking of the enamel... " is referenced without citation and is opposed to your own pulsed-mode laser technique. If you did not employ continuous wave mode in your study, why is this subject relevant? Please elaborate and cite.Discuss the limitations of their study that they had observed during conducting this study. For future work, it is suggested that the authors explore whether the proposed system can be applied to other types of materials, or how it can be combined with other advanced technologies to improve overall performance. What is the novelty of this work? What is the novelty of this work? The article describes a split-tooth approach, using the mesial and distal half of the same tooth as paired experimental and control groups. This is a strong design that takes into account interindividual variability. The statistical analysis was performed with Mann-Whitney U test, which is for independent samples. Why not use a paired test (e.g. Wilcoxon signed rank test)? The principal finding of the study (p=0.026 for fluoride) may not be legitimate because of the use of an incorrect statistical test. “It is absolutely essential to re-analyze with the proper test. The article describes a split-tooth approach, using the mesial and distal half of the same tooth as paired experimental and control groups. This is a strong design that takes into account interindividual variability. The statistical analysis was performed with Mann-Whitney U test, which is for independent samples. Why not use a paired test (e.g. Wilcoxon signed rank test)? The principal finding of the study (p=0.026 for fluoride) may not be legitimate because of the use of an incorrect statistical test. “It is absolutely essential to re-analyze with the proper test. The study used just six teeth (n=6 per group). The authors say in the response to reviewers that this is a “pilot study”. However, the abstract and conclusions describe the finding as if it is final. Was a formal power analysis done a prior to establish that a sample size of six was adequate to detect a clinically relevant difference? But if so, why can this study be recognized as anything more than a preliminary pilot research and why was this not clearly indicated in the title and abstract? The study used just six teeth (n=6 per group). The authors say in the response to reviewers that this is a “pilot study”. However, the abstract and conclusions describe the finding as if it is final. Was a formal power analysis done a prior to establish that a sample size of six was adequate to detect a clinically relevant difference? But if so, why can this study be recognized as anything more than a preliminary pilot research and why was this not clearly indicated in the title and abstract? The Abstract mentions teeth halves were "randomly assigned" to groups, however the Methods section indicates that the mesial half was always allocated to the laser+fluoride group and the distal half to the fluoride-only group. What is correct? If allocation was not randomised there is considerable possibility of systematic bias. For example, is there a structural difference between the mesial and distal surfaces that confounds the results? Please explain exactly how the allocation was made and argue why the use (or absence) of randomisation does not undermine the validity of the study. The Abstract mentions teeth halves were "randomly assigned" to groups, however the Methods section indicates that the mesial half was always allocated to the laser+fluoride group and the distal half to the fluoride-only group. What is correct? If allocation was not randomised there is considerable possibility of systematic bias. For example, is there a structural difference between the mesial and distal surfaces that confounds the results? Please explain exactly how the allocation was made and argue why the use (or absence) of randomisation does not undermine the validity of the study. The title and findings of the study boldly assert a “protective effect” and the possibility of “long-term enamel protection”. However, only the surface elemental composition was evaluated using SEM/EDX in the research, showing a rise of fluoride, calcium and phosphorus on the surface. This does not directly evaluate fluoride absorption into the enamel, or fluorapatite production or resistance to acid demineralisation. Your findings do not include a test of acid resistance (e.g., a pH cycling model). How can you make such broad claims regarding clinical effectiveness and caries prevention from this in vitro trial alone? The title and findings of the study boldly assert a “protective effect” and the possibility of “long-term enamel protection”. However, only the surface elemental composition was evaluated using SEM/EDX in the research, showing a rise of fluoride, calcium and phosphorus on the surface. This does not directly evaluate fluoride absorption into the enamel, or fluorapatite production or resistance to acid demineralisation. Your findings do not include a test of acid resistance (e.g., a pH cycling model). How can you make such broad claims regarding clinical effectiveness and caries prevention from this in vitro trial alone? How was the varnish removed from the surface of the tooth before the SEM/EDX analysis? If it wasn't removed, are you measuring fluoride in the varnish residue and not the enamel? How was the varnish removed from the surface of the tooth before the SEM/EDX analysis? If it wasn't removed, are you measuring fluoride in the varnish residue and not the enamel? The conclusion suggests that the combination treatment is “clinically translating to enhanced enamel surface resistance to acid challenges”. No acid challenge or demineralisation test was performed in this research. This is a little exaggeration of your findings. How can you square this finding with the fact that your study didn’t truly test acid resistance? The conclusion suggests that the combination treatment is “clinically translating to enhanced enamel surface resistance to acid challenges”. No acid challenge or demineralisation test was performed in this research. This is a little exaggeration of your findings. How can you square this finding with the fact that your study didn’t truly test acid resistance? There is an unnecessary paragraph on the mechanisms of action in the manuscript (pages 9 and 10). More crucially, the statement "The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonisation, dissolution and cracking of the enamel... " is referenced without citation and is opposed to your own pulsed-mode laser technique. If you did not employ continuous wave mode in your study, why is this subject relevant? Please elaborate and cite. There is an unnecessary paragraph on the mechanisms of action in the manuscript (pages 9 and 10). More crucially, the statement "The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonisation, dissolution and cracking of the enamel... " is referenced without citation and is opposed to your own pulsed-mode laser technique. If you did not employ continuous wave mode in your study, why is this subject relevant? Please elaborate and cite. Discuss the limitations of their study that they had observed during conducting this study. Discuss the limitations of their study that they had observed during conducting this study. For future work, it is suggested that the authors explore whether the proposed system can be applied to other types of materials, or how it can be combined with other advanced technologies to improve overall performance. For future work, it is suggested that the authors explore whether the proposed system can be applied to other types of materials, or how it can be combined with other advanced technologies to improve overall performance. Conclusions The conclusion section should be rewritten, briefly summarize and mention the main findings of all analyses, highlight the novelty of the work, and suggest potential ideas for future studies. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Yes If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Partly Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? Yes Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? Yes Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? Partly Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Partly Reviewer Expertise: laser-tissue interaction. laser ablation, laser medical applications, nanotechnology. and lasers in dentistry I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. The authors have made substantial efforts to address the methodological and interpretational concerns raised during the previous round of peer review. The revised manuscript demonstrates clear improvements in statistical methodology, methodological transparency, and interpretation of the findings. Most of the major concerns identified in my previous review have been satisfactorily addressed. In particular, replacing the Mann-Whitney U test with the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test appropriately reflects the paired split-tooth design, where each tooth serves as its own control. The inconsistency regarding specimen allocation has also been resolved, and the manuscript now clearly describes the mesial halves as the experimental specimens and the distal halves as the controls. The addition of methodological details regarding fluoride varnish removal, examiner blinding, and EDX acquisition parameters has improved the reproducibility of the experimental procedures. Furthermore, the Discussion and Conclusion have been revised to appropriately acknowledge that SEM and EDX provide only topographic and elemental information and do not directly demonstrate fluorapatite formation, enhanced acid resistance, or clinical caries prevention. The inclusion of a dedicated limitations section is also appreciated. Although the manuscript has improved substantially, several issues remain that would further strengthen the scientific presentation. First, the statistical reporting remains incomplete. The Methods indicate that effect sizes (r) and 95% confidence intervals were calculated, yet these values are not fully presented in Table 6, which currently reports only Z-statistics and P-values. Reporting the actual effect sizes together with their corresponding confidence intervals would allow readers to better appreciate the magnitude and precision of the observed differences. Wherever possible, exact P-values should also be reported instead of threshold values such as "<0.001." Second, despite the improved discussion of limitations, the study remains based on a very small sample of six teeth (twelve paired specimens). While the split-tooth design appropriately controls for inter-individual variability and increases the efficiency of paired comparisons, the findings should continue to be interpreted as exploratory laboratory observations. The Discussion should consistently avoid language implying broader clinical effectiveness beyond what can reasonably be concluded from this pilot in vitro investigation. Third, although the authors have appropriately clarified that EDX measures elemental composition rather than fluorapatite formation, several statements continue to imply that increased elemental fluoride necessarily reflects enhanced fluoride uptake within enamel. Since EDX is primarily a surface elemental analysis technique and cannot distinguish between loosely retained surface fluoride, chemically incorporated fluoride, or fluorapatite formation, the manuscript would benefit from consistently referring to increased surface fluoride concentration rather than enhanced fluoride uptake unless supported by additional analytical methods. Finally, while statistically significant differences in elemental composition are reported, the biological significance of these differences remains uncertain. The Discussion would be strengthened by placing the magnitude of the observed elemental changes into context through comparison with previous quantitative studies and by discussing whether the observed differences are likely to be clinically meaningful. Overall, the revised manuscript is substantially stronger than the previous version. The principal methodological concerns raised during the earlier review-including the statistical analysis, clarification of specimen allocation, methodological transparency, examiner blinding, specimen preparation, and more cautious interpretation of the findings-have been satisfactorily addressed. The remaining issues relate primarily to reporting completeness and scientific presentation rather than fundamental methodological flaws. In its current form, I consider the manuscript scientifically acceptable as a pilot in vitro investigation, provided that the remaining reporting and presentation issues outlined above are addressed. I therefore support indexing with following minor revisions. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Partly If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? No Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? Partly Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? No Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? No Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Partly Reviewer Expertise: Public Health Dentistry, Preventive Dentistry, Oral Epidemiology, Clinical Research Methodology, Biostatistics, Evidence-Based Dentistry, Dental Materials I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. This manuscript investigates the effect of CO₂ laser irradiation combined with topical fluoride on enamel morphology using an in vitro split-tooth design. The topic is relevant and the study has potential as an exploratory laboratory investigation. However, several major methodological and interpretational concerns substantially reduce confidence in the validity of the findings. The most important concern relates to the statistical analysis. The study is described as a split-tooth design in which paired observations are obtained from the same tooth, yet the analysis was performed using the Mann-Whitney U test, which assumes independent samples. This approach requires clear justification or reanalysis using an appropriate paired statistical method. In addition, the manuscript contains contradictory descriptions of specimen allocation. The Abstract states that tooth halves were randomly assigned to the experimental and control groups, whereas the Methods indicate that the mesial half was consistently assigned to the experimental group and the distal half to the control group. This inconsistency must be resolved because it directly affects the validity of the experimental design. The conclusions also extend beyond the evidence generated by the study. SEM and EDX analyses demonstrate changes in enamel surface morphology and elemental composition, but they do not directly demonstrate fluoride uptake, fluorapatite formation, increased acid resistance, or clinical caries prevention. The conclusions should therefore be restricted to the measured outcomes. Additional methodological details required for reproducibility should be provided, including the EDX acquisition protocol, specimen preparation, varnish removal before analysis, examiner blinding, and measurement standardization. The Discussion should better acknowledge the limitations of this pilot in vitro study and avoid claims that are not directly supported by the experimental findings. Minor revisions include improving the title to better reflect the measured outcomes, reducing repetition in the Results section, reporting effect sizes and confidence intervals where appropriate, consolidating descriptive tables where feasible, and correcting the formatting of several references and remaining language issues. Overall, although the research question is scientifically relevant, the combination of methodological inconsistencies, apparently inappropriate statistical analysis, contradictory specimen allocation, and conclusions that exceed the available evidence means that the manuscript does not currently meet the standard required for approval. Major methodological issues would need to be addressed before the work could be considered scientifically sound. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Partly If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? No Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? Partly Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? No Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? No Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Partly Reviewer Expertise: Public Health Dentistry, Preventive Dentistry, Oral Epidemiology, Clinical Research Methodology, Biostatistics, Evidence-Based Dentistry, Dental Materials I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to state that I do not consider it to be of an acceptable scientific standard, for reasons outlined above. The study title is scientifically inappropriate. Also, the word pilot study should be included in the title given that the sample size is vastly deficient to be considered as proper original research. The study aim itself is incorrect. The authors are advised to use a simple language that is easy to understand by the readers.Brand, city, country of the materials are required only at the first instance of mentionWhy were the root halves not randomly distributed? The manuscript discusses it as a split-tooth design where each tooth serves as its own control, but each group had the fixed root that could have confounded the results owing to differences in the anatomy.Expansions of the abbreviations are only needed at the first instance.Label both parts of the figures as a) and b) and described what is to be seen in themTables are better combined in a single table for ease of readers.last paragraph of discussion is unclear. whether the authors are talking about a previous study or describing their overall findings? the phrase consistent with our current study, implies that earlier sentences are referring to earlier studies. References are required for those.The claim made in the discussion that 'The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonization, dissolution and cracking of the enamel and the development of the pulse mode allowed variations by frequency and pulse duration in milliseconds (ms) and microseconds (μs). ' Is unsubstantiated and scientifically inaccurate. Authors must review carefully all claims made when discussing the findings. The study aim itself is incorrect. The authors are advised to use a simple language that is easy to understand by the readers. The study aim itself is incorrect. The authors are advised to use a simple language that is easy to understand by the readers. Brand, city, country of the materials are required only at the first instance of mention Brand, city, country of the materials are required only at the first instance of mention Why were the root halves not randomly distributed? The manuscript discusses it as a split-tooth design where each tooth serves as its own control, but each group had the fixed root that could have confounded the results owing to differences in the anatomy. Why were the root halves not randomly distributed? The manuscript discusses it as a split-tooth design where each tooth serves as its own control, but each group had the fixed root that could have confounded the results owing to differences in the anatomy. Expansions of the abbreviations are only needed at the first instance. Expansions of the abbreviations are only needed at the first instance. Label both parts of the figures as a) and b) and described what is to be seen in them Label both parts of the figures as a) and b) and described what is to be seen in them Tables are better combined in a single table for ease of readers. Tables are better combined in a single table for ease of readers. last paragraph of discussion is unclear. whether the authors are talking about a previous study or describing their overall findings? the phrase consistent with our current study, implies that earlier sentences are referring to earlier studies. References are required for those. last paragraph of discussion is unclear. whether the authors are talking about a previous study or describing their overall findings? the phrase consistent with our current study, implies that earlier sentences are referring to earlier studies. References are required for those. The claim made in the discussion that 'The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonization, dissolution and cracking of the enamel and the development of the pulse mode allowed variations by frequency and pulse duration in milliseconds (ms) and microseconds (μs). ' Is unsubstantiated and scientifically inaccurate. Authors must review carefully all claims made when discussing the findings. The claim made in the discussion that 'The continuous wave mode resulted in carbonization, dissolution and cracking of the enamel and the development of the pulse mode allowed variations by frequency and pulse duration in milliseconds (ms) and microseconds (μs). ' Is unsubstantiated and scientifically inaccurate. Authors must review carefully all claims made when discussing the findings. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? No If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? I cannot comment. A qualified statistician is required. Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? No Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? No Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? No Reviewer Expertise: Oral Pathology, Dental Materials, Dental Innovations, Dental Anatomy, Dentistry I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to state that I do not consider it to be of an acceptable scientific standard, for reasons outlined above. The introduction states the importance of fluoride, then abruptly moves to the harmful effects of fluoride, followed by the enhancement using a laser. Nowhere is the need for the application of lasers specified. Is the normal fluoride application insufficient such that additional laser application is required? The introduction is majorly unformatted and needs proper structuring in paragraphs. Needs better flow of the content. Table 1 not required. Non-contributory to manuscript. Authors can just cite the justification for their range. SEM and EDX full forms are repeated. The AI generated placeholder [“Not applicable as the study used discarded biological material”] has got retained in the manuscript after the ethical approval number. The authors probably forgot to remove it. So currently there is a reference ethical approval number and 'not applicable' statement at the same time, which are contradicting each other. Indicate by arrows what is to be seen in the SEM images, and also mention that in the legends. Include SEM results in the abstract too. Discussion makes a strong claim 'The combined application of a CO 2 laser with fluoride varnishes or gels, which can quadruple fluoride absorption, may significantly improve caries prevention. ' The authors need to specify that such a claim is based on their results or from existing literature. If existing literature, cite the references accordingly. But in this case, the present study is not required, if it is already established that lasers enhance the binding four-fold. If based on the present study's findings, it is too strong a claim based on an in vitro study on 12 samples. Justification for the sample size is required, otherwise the study is just a pilot study with a small sample. Citations for all the mechanisms stated for action of laser are required. Currently, only one reference is cited at the end of the paragraph discussing the mechanisms. The discussion flow is abrupt and inconsistent, requiring overall re-writing. Conclusion must have a modest tone, and organized as a paragraph rather than bulleted list. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? No If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? I cannot comment. A qualified statistician is required. Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? No Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? No Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? No Reviewer Expertise: Oral Pathology, Dental Materials, Dental Innovations, Dental Anatomy, Dentistry I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to state that I do not consider it to be of an acceptable scientific standard, for reasons outlined above. تاResponse: We sincerely thank the reviewer for this constructive critique. We agree that the rationale for introducing laser therapy was not sufficiently justified. In the revised manuscript (Introduction, Paragraph X), we have restructured the text to bridge this gap. We have clearly specified that while conventional fluoride application is highly effective, its clinical longevity is limited due to dissolution in oral fluids and sub-optimal deep-tissue uptake. CO2 laser irradiation is introduced not because normal fluoride is "insufficient," but as a synergistic modality to alter the enamel surface topography and thermal properties, thereby enhancing the retention, conversion, and depth of fluoride penetration into fluorapatite. The Introduction has been thoroughly rewritten and restructured into logical, well-demarcated paragraphs to ensure a smoother transition from the background of dental caries prevention to the specific objective of this study. Table 1 has been removed from the manuscript, and the laser parameters have been integrated textually within the Methodology section along with the appropriate justification and references. Additionally, all redundant full forms of SEM and EDX have been corrected, keeping the full term only upon first mention. The contradictory placeholder was inadvertently left during the final drafting process. It has been completely removed in Version 2. The official ethical approval number [Insert Number] stands alone as the correct authorization for this study. In the revised manuscript, we have added distinct arrows to the SEM micrographs to explicitly point out structural changes (e.g., enamel melting, micro-cracks, and crystal precipitation). The figure legends have been updated to explain these indicators. Furthermore, a concise summary of the SEM and EDX findings has been incorporated into the Abstract. This specific statement ("quadruple fluoride absorption") was cited from existing literature to highlight the maximum potential described in historical protocols, rather than being a direct finding of our study. We agree that extrapolating this as a definitive claim based on our in vitro sample size (n=12 treatment sites) is scientifically overreached. In Version 2, we have rephrased this section to adopt a more modest and objective tone, clearly differentiating between historical literature findings and our own current laboratory observations. Proper citations have been added In in vitro studies employing advanced surface analyses like SEM and EDX, small sample sizes are frequently utilized due to the high precision, micro-destructive nature, and qualitative depth of the evaluation, which focus on structural topography rather than biological variance. However, we acknowledge the reviewer's perspective that without a formal prior power analysis, this work should be characterized appropriately. We have now included a paragraph in the Discussion acknowledging this as a pilot investigation and have explicitly listed the sample size as a limitation, which paves the way for future large-scale quantitative evaluations. Response: We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. We have thoroughly revised the Discussion section to ensure a logical and scholarly flow. Multiple missing citations validating the photothermal and structural mechanisms of the 10,600\text{ nm} CO_2 laser on dental enamel have been integrated into the relevant paragraph. The entire section has been streamlined to prevent abrupt transitions. The bulleted conclusion has been transformed into a cohesive, well-structured paragraph. The tone has also been modulated to be highly conservative and strictly reflective of our in vitro findings, using hedging verbs such as "suggests" and "within the limitations of this laboratory study." Greetings : 1. Introduction: It needs to highlight the important of enamel protection role against acid dissolution. paragraph 3 " Recent epidemiological trends indicate .............." the reference is old ; attention should be paid to this. 2. Discussion: the results of this study need further clarification and comparison with other studies, and it is preferable recent. The authors did not mention the limitations of this study. 3. Conclusion: second point" Laser therapy can be an alternative or synergistic to topical fluoridation to prevent tooth enamel caries with a longer-lasting effect" according to the result of this study laser is synergistic to topical fluoride application to increase fluoride uptake by enamel surface. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Partly If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Yes Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? Yes Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? Yes Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? Partly Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Yes Reviewer Expertise: Preventive Dentistry I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard.