A dynamic framework of professional identity formation in trainees for low-resource settings: a qualitative study Authors: Yilin Chen, Peixin Lin, Hengshun Du, Jiaxin Wu, Xuanhua Zheng, Mi Yao, Kai Lin Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundProfessional Identity Formation (PIF) is a dynamic and context-dependent socialisation process; while existing research identifies various influencing factors, there is a paucity of cohesive frameworks that capture the stage-related internalisation of identity elements within practice. This gap is particularly salient in low-resource settings, such as China’s Rural-Streamed Medical Education Programme (RMEP), where substantial turnover and tenuous professional identity among trainees present significant challenges. Drawing upon the Ring Theory of Personhood (RToP) as a theoretical lens, this study aims to construct a dynamic framework for understanding PIF among RMEP trainees, thereby offering insights to enhance PIF for healthcare professionals in low-resource settings.MethodInformed by a pragmatic paradigm, nine focus groups were conducted with 42 RMEP trainees across various training stages in China. Drawing upon the RToP as a sensitising concept, data were analysed using inductive thematic analysis to construct a dynamic framework.ResultsA framework comprising 11 themes was constructed across three dimensions: the Societal Domain, encompassing working conditions, policies, attitudes of others, formal teaching and discipline development; the Relational Domain, including relationships with role models, close ones, patients, and peers; and the Individual Domain, incorporating reflective experience, personal character and values. This framework emphasises the dynamic interaction of these themes and the stage-related shifts of PIF, highlighting a shift from external to internal elements while also acknowledging the prominent influence of early external experiences in low-resource settings.ConclusionsBy proposing a dynamic framework that maps PIF across different training stages, this study extends existing conceptualizations and provides valuable insights for strengthening it among healthcare professionals in low-resource settings.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-10001-7.Keywords: Professional Identity Formation, Low Resource Settings, Focus Groups, Medical Education, General Practitioners Introduction Professional Identity Formation (PIF) is inherently a socialisation-driven process of identity development [1]. Compared with professionalism, professional identity emphasises the internalisation of professional values [2]. During the initial stages of this process, individuals enter the field of medicine with their own unique, pre-existing personal identities. Consistent with Kegan’s theory of the evolving self, through ongoing socialisation, they continuously negotiate between internal self-awareness and external experiences, thereby co-constructing both their personal and professional identities [3–5]. As PIF has increasingly become a focal point within medical education in recent years, educators are actively developing strategies to support PIF throughout medical training. Research into the drivers, components, and impacts of PIF has become increasingly robust, with the factors influencing PIF having been extensively explored and integrated into comprehensive frameworks [3, 6]. Nevertheless, as identity formation is context-dependent and dynamic [6], how individuals perceive these factors and the stage-specific variations in practice remain insufficiently understood, leading to gaps in these frameworks’ ability to effectively guiding practice [7, 8]. Concurrently, PIF research has predominantly focused on developed regions, with a scarcity of exploration in low-resource settings, which have been characterised by nine dimensions of deficiency, including infrastructure, education, and geographical conditions [9, 10]. Healthcare professionals in these regions frequently encounter difficulties, such as inadequate guidance, heavy workloads, and diminished self-esteem, all of which contribute to workforce attrition and the compromised quality of patient care [10, 11]. Amidst ongoing efforts to identify strategies for workforce retention in these settings, the strengthening of PIF is regarded as vital for addressing current challenges [12–14]. In 2010, the Chinese government launched the Rural-Streamed Medical Education Programme (RMEP) to cultivate a substantial workforce of general practitioners (GPs) for service in rural areas [15, 16]. While RMEP trainees (hereafter referred to as trainees in this paper), positioned as the primary workforce in China’s low-resource settings, currently achieve a compliance rate of approximately 70% during the service period, fewer than 20% intend to remain in these positions long-term [17]. An increasing body of evidence suggests that their weak professional identity is closely associated with an increased turnover intention, reflecting significant challenges to their PIF [18, 19]. Current research has explored various factors influencing the PIF of these trainees, including their career cognition, organisational support, and recognition from external groups; however, a comprehensive framework for understanding this process remains elusive [20, 21]. Theoretical framework While research on PIF has expanded, a cohesive theoretical understanding remains underdeveloped, with few studies adequately addressing the contextually grounded perspectives of individual changes along with the sequential transformations [10, 22].Ring Theory of Personhood (RToP), originally applied in palliative care to examine personality changes influenced by familial factors, is particularly relevant to PIF due to its emphasis on the evolving nature of the self and the diverse sources that shape an individual’s self-concept [23, 24]. Emerging studies have applied this theory to PIF research, categorising influences into Individual, Relational, and Societal dimensions, and providing valuable insights into the interrelationships between these factors [6, 10]. By employing the RToP as a theoretical lens, this study aims to develop a framework to explore how individuals in low-resource settings integrate external factors into their identity, and how these perceptions dynamically evolve across different training stages, offering insights to enhance PIF for healthcare professionals in these settings. Method Study design This study adopted a pragmatic paradigm and employed a qualitative design [25, 26]. Semi-structured focus groups were designed to include 42 RMEP trainees across different stages of training in China (comprising undergraduate students and graduates), organised into nine focus groups. The reporting of this study was guided by the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research (SRQR) to ensure methodological transparency and rigour [27]. Participant recruitment The RMEP in China requires trainees to complete five years of undergraduate education, comprising three years of theoretical study at medical school followed by two years of hospital-based clinical placements. Upon graduation, trainees are required to serve as GPs for six years in designated settings, including three years of standardised residency training in hospitals followed by three years of rural practice. Service locations are allocated based on local needs or academic performance. Participants in this study were recruited via purposive sampling from a university in southern China, where a researcher liaised with the RMEP coordinator to invite trainees across various stages. Specifically, we invited 21 undergraduate students from the university and 21 graduates currently undergoing standardised residency training across different hospital and rural settings. Among them, we approached 10 graduates who, owing to their academic requirements, were able to complete their residency at various locations outside the target university and its affiliated hospitals, with these individuals distributed across the southern, central, and northern regions of China in a ratio of 3:3:4. Depending on geographical proximity, focus groups were convened in either university or clinical settings; additionally, secure online platforms were utilised to accommodate those facing logistical constraints. Ethical approval was granted by the Research Ethics Committee of Shantou University Medical College (Approval No. SUMC-JGLL202205), and all procedures performed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the respective institutions, and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. Prior to discussions, all trainees provided written informed consent, acknowledging their voluntary involvement. All data were anonymised and managed according to institutional protocols. Research team preparation The research team comprised seven members (four men and three women). All members were affiliated with a medical school or its associated hospitals, and were trained in qualitative research. The lead researcher (PhD) was responsible for the overall study design and team training. To ensure procedural rigour and data quality, two core members with prior experience in conducting focus groups within general practice and primary care education served as primary facilitators. Furthermore, all members participated in weekly training sessions on qualitative methodology and focus group facilitation over six months, ensuring a shared understanding of methodological principles. Data collection Data collection was conducted between December 2024 and February 2025. Each focus group lasted 60 to 90 min and comprised two parts: a briefing and the core discussion. Each session was moderated by one primary facilitator, supported by other team members who took field notes and documented the proceedings. No prior relationship existed between the researchers and the trainees, and only the research team and trainees were present during the sessions. Each session commenced with a 10-minute briefing to clarify key concepts, outline the study’s aims and procedures, ensuring that trainees clearly understood their roles. During the core discussion, researchers adopted a facilitatory yet non-directive role to mitigate social desirability bias and power dynamics [28]. The focus group guide (Supplementary Table 1) featured open-ended questions to encourage dialogue, avoiding the constraint of responses within predefined themes. All sessions were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and securely archived. Field notes were documented and summarised in Excel spreadsheets. No further interviews were conducted, in line with the predefined scope of data collection. Data analysis The focus group recordings were transcribed verbatim by two researchers within 24 h. Transcripts were subsequently reviewed by three on-site researchers to ensure the fidelity of the accounts and linguistic integrity. To establish credibility, transcripts were returned to trainees for member reflections; once confirmed, they were imported into Nvivo (Release 1.2) to facilitate analysis. Consistent with a pragmatic approach, an inductive thematic analysis was conducted [26]. The analysis commenced with the lead researcher and the primary facilitator independently engaging in data familiarisation and inductive open coding to identify meaningful units, which were then condensed into codes, interpreted, compared, and iteratively checked against the original transcripts. They subsequently convened to compare their coding, resolving any divergent interpretations through discussion, thereby establishing a codebook. Through an iterative process of comparing, clustering, and synthesising related codes, the research team developed sub‑themes. During the conceptualisation of dimensions and the interpretation of the findings, the RToP was introduced as a sensitising concept by the primary facilitator; concurrently, the lead researcher and the broader research team critically reviewed the thematic structure. This analytical process underwent rigorous review and refinement through iterative team discussions to ensure that the theoretical application remained authentically grounded in the data [29]. Following the analysis, two primary facilitators led a comprehensive review in collaboration with the entire research team to develop the final dynamic framework. Throughout the research process, the research team systematically documented and reviewed reflections on their own positionality and its potential influence on data interpretation. Several members of the research team were familiar with the educational and training context under study, which facilitated rapport and contextual understanding. Meanwhile, the team also included researchers with diverse academic and international backgrounds, including two bilingual researchers with extensive cross-cultural experience who completed their doctoral training in Australia and the United Kingdom, respectively. To capitalise on this diversity, ensure analytical rigour, regular peer-debriefing sessions were convened. These sessions facilitated collaborative sense-making and critical dialogue, allowing the team to examine underlying assumptions and explore alternative interpretations. Ultimately, these practices promoted transparency and team reflexivity, ensuring that potential biases were critically acknowledged and that final interpretations remained authentically grounded in the trainees’ experiences [30]. Saturation was assessed by systematically monitoring the emergence of new codes following each session and updating the codebook accordingly. Furthermore, given the inclusion of trainees at different stages, saturation was evaluated both across the entire dataset and within each training stage. By the conclusion of the sixth focus group, we observed that no further themes emerged. The final three sessions (FG3, FG8, FG9) served as confirmatory groups; they provided additional contextual nuance without generating novel themes or substantive codes, at which point thematic saturation was deemed achieved [31]. During the translation of findings from Chinese into English, key cultural and linguistic nuances were carefully negotiated to enhance fidelity to the original data. Where culturally specific expressions and highly contextualised terms emerged, they were systematically deliberated. The research team prioritised conceptual equivalence over literal translation to ensure that the socio-cultural weight of these terms was accurately reflected within the English themes. To maintain conceptual consistency, the translated segments were back-translated into Chinese for cross-verification. Trustworthiness was further enhanced through the involvement of the aforementioned bilingual team members, with the lead researcher was responsible for final adjudications. This team composition and collaborative translation process facilitated the identification and critical reflection upon taken-for-granted cultural assumptions, thereby preserving the participants’ authentic meanings as much as possible during theme development. Results Focus groups profile All 42 invited trainees agreed to participate. Each participant was assigned to one of nine focus groups (FGs), which were purposefully formed based on their stage of learning and comparable age. Detailed demographic characteristics of the participants are presented in Table 1. Analysis indicated that trainees’ clinical involvement played a pivotal role in their responses, with clinical trainees articulating relatively concrete and consolidated conceptualisations of professional identity, while pre-clinical trainees without clinical involvement primarily shared aspirational projections or uncertainties regarding their professional futures, with their reflections appearing more abstract. Given these thematic differences between the two cohorts, a stratified exploration was adopted, whereby FG1-3 represent pre-clinical trainees and FG4-9 comprise clinical trainees. Table 1Characteristics of the traineesTraining PhaseStage of StudyYear of StudyFocus GroupNo. of ParticipantsRange of AgeResearch BackgroundPre-clinical StageUndergraduateYear 2FG1519∼21NUndergraduateYear 3FG2620∼21NUndergraduateYear 3FG3619∼21NClinical StageUndergraduateYear 4 & 5FG4421∼24NGraduateYear 1FG5523∼26NGraduateYear 2FG6624∼41NGraduateYear 1FG7424∼30YGraduateYear 1FG8322∼26YGraduateYear 2 & 3FG9332∼38Y Characteristics of the trainees Themes in PIF within general practice Qualitative analysis identified 11 themes. Qualitative analysis identified 11 themes. Descriptions and representative quotes for each theme are presented below. Additional illustrative quotes are provided in Table 2. Table 2Themes with representative quotesThemesQuotes from pre-clinical traineesQuotes from clinical traineesWorking Conditions“I think salary is really important, as it reflects the hospital’s valuation of you, the perks, and whether promotion opportunities are on par with those of other doctors.” (FG2, P4) [employment benefits]“During my last visit, the doctors appeared rushed and careless. I worry that my future workplace may encounter similar issues, which I find quite demoralising.” (FG2, P1) [work environment]“If the job mainly involves tasks like guiding patients, I don’t think I’d feel a sense of accomplishment in that role.” (FG2, P2) [work content]“Honestly, GPs don’t earn as much as most specialists. It might be better in some areas, but it’s not the place we will go in the future.” (FG8, P1) [employment benefits]“Some of the medications were unavailable…The team there also couldn’t compare to the one in the CCU.” (FG9, P1) [work environment]Policies“The government is really focused on us and has provided substantial support, including waiving tuition fees, accommodation fees, and even offering a monthly stipend.” (FG1, P1)“Many well-intentioned policies often fail in smaller cities due to a lack of funding, turning into tick-box exercises.” (FG6, P2)“The policy seems focused on quickly meeting government targets by bringing people from other industries into general practice. It feels unfair, as others can easily obtain certification through alternative routes.” (FG6, P4)“The job satisfaction for GPs in big cities is definitely higher than in rural areas because the perks are better, and the work is more diverse… In rural areas, though, you end up doing less, and everything feels much slower. " (FG9, P2)Attitude of others“I often scroll through social media and see GPs sharing their experiences…There are pros and cons.” (FG1, P1)“Some professors may favour specialty students, viewing general practice as too broad and shallow in content.” (FG8, P3)“We’re both graduates, but I’m a GP working in primary care, while other clinical students have better opportunities. This is somewhat disappointing to me.” (FG6, P2)Formal Teaching“I like the practical courses arranged by the school now, such as animal surgeries. I enjoy the feeling of doing things myself.” (FG3, P5)“You only understand and know if you love general practice after working in the community or related institutions.” (FG8, P2)Discipline Development“It seems like there are more and more candidates applying for our specialised programme these days, and we can see that the scores keep going up every year.” (FG1, P1)“I think the future of general practice looks promising, especially with China’s aging population.” (FG4, P3)“General practice needs a stronger disciplinary system. Both the public and even GPs don’t fully understand it currently.” (FG7, P4)Relationship with Role Models“There’s a GP on the volunteer team who spoke about visiting homebound patients… Their ability to provide such care is truly inspiring to me.” (FG1, P5)“My tutor has been pivotal in shaping my professional identity, with his patience and care for patients deeply impacting me.” (FG6, P1)Relationship with Close Ones“My family has quite traditional and simple views, and they think it’s good enough for me to be a generalist in all subjects. " (FG3, P2)“My relatives and friends often say, ‘As a GP, you learn a lot, but you never truly specialize.” (FG1, P4)“My family sees it as a great opportunity because it offers a stable job with no tuition. At the time, I had just finished the college entrance exam and was unsure about my options, but I found it appealing, so I applied.” (FG6, P3)Relationship with Patients“Real interactions, such as taking blood pressure for elderly patients or visiting the palliative care centre, are far more valuable than merely observing activities.” (FG3, P3)“The strong rapport GPs had with the villagers left a lasting impression, inspiring me to continue in this profession.” (FG6, P2)“Hospital patients often show appreciation for doctors’ efforts, but GPs in rural areas rarely get such feedback and are often overlooked. " (FG7, P2)Relationship with Peers“Maybe comparing myself to students in higher-paying majors, like dentistry, makes me feel a bit down.” (FG1, G4)“I find the discussions between GPs really interesting. It’s something I’ve personally experienced in the general practice department.” (FG6, P5)“At academic conferences, I meet like-minded people, reinforcing that this profession is worth pursuing.” (FG7, P2)“I have classmates who don’t put in much effort, and when they underperform, people label them as ‘just a GP…If I’m next, they might apply the same preconceived notions to me.” (FG9, P1)Reflective Experience“Negative experiences with community healthcare, like high fees… If I become a GP, I will make sure to avoid that.” (FG2, P1)“I envision my future career in a small clinic, like the one downstairs from my house. It’s closely connected to my life, and I can work in a stable environment.” (FG1, P4)“I believe that with some clinical experience and a solid understanding of textbooks and guidelines, you’ll have a much clearer grasp of general practice.” (FG7, P3)“Overcoming the challenges I encounter in practice inspires me to consider research, and seeing other GPs succeed boosts my confidence.” (FG9, P1)Personal Character and Values“To be honest, I don’t quite get what GP is yet.” (FG2, P2)“I used to be impatient, but becoming a GP has taught me patience and calmness.” (FG6, P1) Themes with representative quotes “I think salary is really important, as it reflects the hospital’s valuation of you, the perks, and whether promotion opportunities are on par with those of other doctors.” (FG2, P4) [employment benefits] “During my last visit, the doctors appeared rushed and careless. I worry that my future workplace may encounter similar issues, which I find quite demoralising.” (FG2, P1) [work environment] “If the job mainly involves tasks like guiding patients, I don’t think I’d feel a sense of accomplishment in that role.” (FG2, P2) [work content] “Honestly, GPs don’t earn as much as most specialists. It might be better in some areas, but it’s not the place we will go in the future.” (FG8, P1) [employment benefits] “Some of the medications were unavailable…The team there also couldn’t compare to the one in the CCU.” (FG9, P1) [work environment] “Many well-intentioned policies often fail in smaller cities due to a lack of funding, turning into tick-box exercises.” (FG6, P2) “The policy seems focused on quickly meeting government targets by bringing people from other industries into general practice. It feels unfair, as others can easily obtain certification through alternative routes.” (FG6, P4) “The job satisfaction for GPs in big cities is definitely higher than in rural areas because the perks are better, and the work is more diverse… In rural areas, though, you end up doing less, and everything feels much slower. " (FG9, P2) “Some professors may favour specialty students, viewing general practice as too broad and shallow in content.” (FG8, P3) “We’re both graduates, but I’m a GP working in primary care, while other clinical students have better opportunities. This is somewhat disappointing to me.” (FG6, P2) “I think the future of general practice looks promising, especially with China’s aging population.” (FG4, P3) “General practice needs a stronger disciplinary system. Both the public and even GPs don’t fully understand it currently.” (FG7, P4) “My family has quite traditional and simple views, and they think it’s good enough for me to be a generalist in all subjects. " (FG3, P2) “My relatives and friends often say, ‘As a GP, you learn a lot, but you never truly specialize.” (FG1, P4) “The strong rapport GPs had with the villagers left a lasting impression, inspiring me to continue in this profession.” (FG6, P2) “Hospital patients often show appreciation for doctors’ efforts, but GPs in rural areas rarely get such feedback and are often overlooked. " (FG7, P2) “I find the discussions between GPs really interesting. It’s something I’ve personally experienced in the general practice department.” (FG6, P5) “At academic conferences, I meet like-minded people, reinforcing that this profession is worth pursuing.” (FG7, P2) “I have classmates who don’t put in much effort, and when they underperform, people label them as ‘just a GP…If I’m next, they might apply the same preconceived notions to me.” (FG9, P1) “Negative experiences with community healthcare, like high fees… If I become a GP, I will make sure to avoid that.” (FG2, P1) “I envision my future career in a small clinic, like the one downstairs from my house. It’s closely connected to my life, and I can work in a stable environment.” (FG1, P4) “I believe that with some clinical experience and a solid understanding of textbooks and guidelines, you’ll have a much clearer grasp of general practice.” (FG7, P3) “Overcoming the challenges I encounter in practice inspires me to consider research, and seeing other GPs succeed boosts my confidence.” (FG9, P1) Working conditions Trainees articulated how perceived working conditions shaped their professional identity, focusing on three primary areas: employment benefits, work environment, and work content. Regarding employment benefits, trainees highlighted salary, promotion opportunities, and external exchange opportunities. There was a perception that these benefits were not comparable to those available to hospital-based specialists, which left them feeling that general practice was undervalued. “GPs lack good opportunities for further study. Unlike specialists, whom hospitals will send out for exchange and learning, such opportunities are exceedingly rare at the primary care level… It makes you feel that general practice is undervalued.“(FG6, P4). The work environment encompassed both the working atmosphere and the objective environment. The former was valued for its suitability for learning and professional development; however, trainees also expressed concerns about potential ideological and behavioural conflicts with older generations of GPs in their future workplaces, given the current realities of primary care in China. Meanwhile, the latter pertained to aspects such as the availability of medical equipment and medications, the lack of which restricted their sense of clinical autonomy, cultivating a sense of professional inadequacy that hindered their capacity to conceptualise themselves as competent, autonomous practitioners. The majority of trainees’ concerns were informed by prior negative experiences or observations. “If you think a certain medication could help a patient recover, but you can’t prescribe it because you don’t have the authority…That really undermines one’s professional identity.” (FG1, P2). Finally, concerning work content, while pre-clinical trainees expressed a desire for more challenging tasks, clinical trainees found that a significant proportion of GPs’ work comprised routine, repetitive administrative tasks, leading to feelings of disappointment stemming from a perceived inability to deliver impactful patient care. “I’ve heard of places where GPs focus on paper work and have no patient-facing opportunities…What’s the point of being in a place like that?” (FG6, P1). Policies Irrespective of whether trainees had entered clinical practice, they generally expressed a positive attitude towards the policy formulation, both in relation to the RMEP specifically and to the broader context of general practice. However, several trainees indicated that certain aspects of the current policy, such as the compulsory six-year service requirement, led to perceptions that their future development was constrained. They described a sense of being tied to a contract rather than pursuing a career they had actively chosen. " I have to stay there for six years. I feel like, after finishing, my age will make it harder for me to develop elsewhere.” (FG2, P6). Furthermore, they reported a sense of inequity, particularly in comparison to other trainees who received less specialised training yet benefitted from supportive policies for career mobility. Additionally, clinical trainees observed regional and urban-rural disparities in policy implementation, noting that the discrepancy between policy mandates and local execution notably affected their professional motivation. Attitude of others This theme encompassed evaluations of the status of GPs within society and the healthcare system from various sources, including online media, career lectures and social interactions. Pre-clinical trainees reported that their understanding of GPs’ status was primarily shaped by perceptions encountered through media and social interactions. A notable aspect of their experience was interacting with colleagues from other disciplines in social settings, where comparisons between general practice and other fields frequently led to a sense of disparity and a diminished sense of professional identity, and even active resistance towards their identity as future GPs. “Although I am currently training in general practice, I still wish to pursue a career in surgery. Everyone says that GPs lack in-depth expertise.” (FG3, P4). Comparatively, clinical trainees often indicated that such appraisals had a limited influence on them. “In this field, you’ll hear a lot of different opinions…While they can have some impact, they don’t affect me much.” (FG8, P2). Formal teaching Formal teaching referred to the courses organised by medical schools and hospitals, encompassing both theoretical and practical components. While trainees acknowledged that theoretical courses provided foundational knowledge, they perceived practical training as playing a more central role. Pre-clinical trainees regarded the practical one as novel, while clinical trainees recognised the value of GPs through direct exposure to their work, an experience that facilitated a transition in their roles from observers to active participants. “Take the clinical skills course for example… It’s more hands-on. When you actually get to practice, you feel a sense of accomplishment and excitement. " (FG1, P2). Discipline development Discipline development encompassed the current state and future prospects of general practice in China. As clinical trainees gained clinical experience, they frequently engaged in in-depth reflections on these issues, recognising the field as both vibrant and challenging. Some participants internalised these macro-level challenges as part of their professional narratives, positioning themselves as potential agents of change within a developing discipline, rather than as passive employees. “General practice needs a stronger disciplinary system. Both the public and even GPs don’t fully understand it currently.” (FG7, P4). Role models Interactions with role models within general practice had a profound influence on trainees at both pre- and clinical stages. Comparatively, clinical trainees provided more nuanced descriptions, including guidance from their mentors on general practice knowledge and skills, career progression, and even aspects of personality. However, a proportion of trainees reported feeling marginalised due to a lack of dedicated mentorship or encountering dismissive attitudes from hospital specialists. Alarmingly, some highly regarded GPs even encouraged trainees to leave the specialty, leaving them feeling uncertain about their professional legitimacy within the broader medical hierarchy. ‘There was a highly experienced GP told me straight away to run away, saying it didn’t matter how much the penalty for breaking the contract would be…They understand so much more about this profession than we do, and yet they say things like this…’ (FG4, P4). Close ones Regarding close relationships, most trainees reported that their initial decision to pursue general practice was influenced by their parents, who held the belief that one should seek a stable and relatively less strenuous job, rather than stemming from a genuine interest in the field. Additionally, some trainees noted that their family members did not view general practice favourably due to limited opportunities for career progression. However, owing to their limited early professional exposure, the majority of trainees passively deferred to their parents’ opinions and arrangements. As trainees’ understanding of general practice deepened, clinical trainees reported that the influence of close ones gradually diminished, with some even describing instances where they, in turn, reshaped the perspectives of those around them. “After learning more about general practice from me, my family now sees it as the right path. I’ve truly changed their perspective.” (FG7, P2). Patients Pre-clinical trainees mainly interacted with patients through volunteer outreach, such as community clinics. However, these opportunities were limited by time and settings, and only those who engaged in meaningful interactions found them beneficial to their professional identity. Clinical trainees noted that positive interactions between GPs and patients fostered professional aspirations and increased their willingness to establish similar connections as future GPs. In contrast, some clinical trainees indicated that the professional identity could be undermined by the variability in health literacy and the reasons for consultation among primary care patients. Moreover, they expressed concerns that they might face greater challenges in managing doctor–patient relationships when navigating clinical uncertainty without the structured knowledge framework typical of specialist fields. “GPs may lack the specialised skills to treat certain illnesses due to the large number of cases they handle, leading to frustration. Meanwhile, this can cause patients to perceive the doctor as incompetent, which may result in a lack of respect.” (FG8, P3). Peers This theme addressed daily communication with peers, as well as giving and receiving support during critical moments. Clinical trainees provided more extensive descriptions related to the relationships with peers, particularly emphasising the deeper insights they gained into general practice and a stronger sense of group belonging, which they attributed to discussions and exchanges with their colleagues. However, one trainee mentioned that if the peers performed poorly, it would affect how others in their local area perceived them, thereby prompting them to distance their personal self-concept from a potentially devalued group identity. “I have classmates who don’t put in much effort, and when they underperform, people label them as ‘just a GP…If I’m next, they might apply the same preconceived notions to me.” (FG9, P1). Reflective experience Reflective experiences catalysed trainees’ contemplation of their future roles as GPs. These insights were derived from clinical encounters, involvement in research, various educational activities, and their personal experiences as patients seeking care. For pre-clinical trainees, observational placements in community hospitals and their experiences as patients had a notable influence in aiding the formation of an initial understanding of GPs. For clinical trainees, clinical experience had a more immediate and profound impact on the development of their professional identity. Additionally, clinical trainees demonstrated a more sophisticated understanding and greater critical thinking regarding general practice, actively exploring solutions to current issues in the field. Consequently, their engagement in academic research served as a pivotal influence in shaping their professional identity. Personal character and values While pre-clinical trainees appeared to have a limited awareness of how their character and values influenced their professional identity, the majority of clinical trainees engaged in active reflection within this theme. They contemplated whether their inherent characteristics were compatible with the role of a GP and how their character had been shaped or transformed during their training. Furthermore, they developed a deeper understanding of the values and principles underlying general practice. “I used to work in the CCU, which was much more fast-paced, but I consider myself a laid-back person. This experience made me want to be a doctor who takes the time to communicate with patients and provide warmth.” (FG9, P1). The dynamic framework of PIF Inter-thematic relationships within the same stage As illustrated in Fig. 1, at any specific juncture, the elements within the three domains are not independent; rather, they exist in a nested hierarchy, operating within distinct focal domains while maintaining interdimensional connectivity. The Dynamic Framework of PIF In this study, the Individual domain emphasises subjective, agentic behaviours, which are frequently informed by experiences derived from themes within the Societal and Relational domains. The Relational domain highlights the influence of close personal relationships on the individual, where perspectives are often mediated by themes within the Societal domain. The Societal domain focuses on broader relationships and the effects of the perceived environment. Notably, the Relational domain often serves as a conduit for individuals’ understanding of and engagement with this societal environment. Consequently, the specific emphasis of each domain varies according to these distinct focal points, collectively contributing to the professional identity of each trainee. Thematic variations across stages Figure 1 illustrates stage‑related differences in the salience of themes across distinct training phases. Notably, the third stage representing ‘healthcare professionals’ does not signify a static or predefined endpoint. Instead, it denotes a dynamic process where trainees increasingly align with the professional identity of their specific field as their identities mature. Our findings suggest that clinical trainees reported a limited influence from the attitudes of others and the opinions of close individuals, contrasting with pre-clinical trainees, for whom these themes were central to their PIF during the initial stages of their training. Concurrently, themes such as discipline development, relationships with peers and patients, as well as personal characteristics and values became more pronounced among clinical cohorts, whereas pre-clinical trainees demonstrated limited awareness of these themes. Moreover, as clinical trainees recognised the increasing importance of discipline development and relationships with peers and patients in shaping their PIF, they often associated this shift with an enhanced awareness of their values and characteristics. This observed pattern may suggest that as clinical training progresses, elements within the Individual domain assume an increasingly central role in the PIF process. Early community involvement as the prominent influence Initially, we anticipated that clinical experience would diversify with increasing seniority, assuming that hospital-based placements would exert the primary influence on trainees’ PIF. However, during the discussions, trainees consistently emphasised the formative impact of their two-week community involvement on shaping their professional identity, which nearly all had completed at accredited primary care institutions prior to their hospital placements. “Those two weeks gave me a real sense of what being a GP is all about… I thought GPs are amazing, and at that moment, I knew I wanted to become a GP like that in the future.” (FG6, P3). In contrast, while hospital placements such as weekly half-day attendances during pre-clinical years and full-time hospital placements may be beneficial for doctors’ professional identity, they appear to have a minimal effect on GP PIF. This distinction underscores that structured community involvement, rather than traditional hospital placements, serves as the prominent influence for GP PIF. Discussions This study employed focus groups with 42 trainees to construct a dynamic framework for the PIF in low-resource settings. The findings elucidate how specific themes influence PIF at various stages of training, while also emphasising the Individual domain and key formative events that warrant attention, offering insights to foster PIF for healthcare professionals in low-resource settings. The results revealed that the influence of themes varied across different stages, aligning with the dynamic nature emphasised in Kegan’s framework and the evolutionary character of the RToP [3, 23, 24]. This suggests that the stages of PIF are dynamic, with each stage prioritising different attributes and challenges. Our study found that, while the themes from the Relational and Societal domains may initially dominate trainees’ identity negotiation, themes within the Individual domain become increasingly prominent as clinical immersion deepens [24, 32]. This shift potentially accompanies the development of personal awareness, suggesting that educational interventions focused on value guidance and reflective environments are essential to accelerate the maturation of these themes [33]. Although the trainees in our study did not report undergoing specific reflective training, an observable trend was noted: those with a more mature professional identity were more likely to describe their reflections on practice and demonstrate insights into their personal characteristics and values. This aligns with previous studies emphasising narrative reflection, as it deepens the processing of experiences and fosters critical thinking, thereby providing space for identity development [4]. Guiding such behaviours may be an effective method for accelerating the formation of the themes within the Individual domain, a notion further supported by the Krishna Model of Reflective Writing [23, 34]. Beyond the Individual domain, creating an environment during the early stages of PIF conducive to reflection through the Relational and Societal domains are also critical. While previous research has identified the provision of role models and clinical experiences as two of the most significant factors in facilitating PIF [3, 4], our study suggests that, in low-resource settings, the challenges associated with implementing these factors may be more complex than anticipated. The influence of role models, traditionally regarded as positive, has recently come under scrutiny in studies documenting their negative impacts and the burden placed on trainees in their absence [1]. In our study, most trainees lacked dedicated mentors and sought guidance from other groups. Unfortunately, these “role models” were often perceived to have a negative effect, trainees reported that some specialists treated them with indifference compared with specialty-track students. Furthermore, during case discussions, GPs often assumed a secondary role. While the situation may be more pronounced in certain groups including GPs and psychiatrists, and has been previously characterised in the literature as “stigmatisation”, the common lack of mentorship in low-resource might lead to a fragmented construction of professional identity, ultimately leaving students uncertain regarding their future roles during the critical early stages of their training [35, 36]. Additionally, we identified early community involvement provided by formal teaching as a prominent influence for trainees in our study. Unlike the standard Chinese curriculum where community engagement commences in the eighth year, the innovative two-week experience at the end of their third year facilitated significant reflective practice. Trainees utilised these early encounters to navigate their perceptions of GPs before their re-entry into the field. Previous studies have characterised these significant transformations as pivotal transitions in PIF [7, 37]. Regrettably, many low-resource settings fail to provide the necessary conditions for such transitions, which consequently impedes early integration and a sense of belonging, both of which are essential for PIF [7]. Given that current PIF research predominantly originates from developed regions, this study’s framework provides a vital pathway for educational reforms in low-resource contexts, facilitating targeted interventions across various stages [10, 38, 39]. Given the current lack of evidence for instruments that can effectively and reliably assess medical students’ PIF [40], we propose the use of flexible assessment tools to capture shifts in the attributes and challenges prioritised at each stage. For example, Tagawa’s stage-specific attribute scale, grounded in Kegan’s framework, targets professionals at four distinct developmental stages [5, 39], offering valuable insights into longitudinal research regarding the evolution of focal dimensions and their relative weightings. The framework developed in this study also possesses the potential to be operationalised into quantitative assessment instruments. Its flexibility allows it to guide educational reforms in general practice, while offering interdisciplinary applicability to monitor trainees’ PIF in low-resource regions and provide constructive feedback for continuous improvement. While the long-term impact of early interventions on retention remains unclear, proactively addressing these themes may alleviate uncertainty and foster a robust professional identity; this is a process that necessitates ongoing collaboration between educators, practitioners, and researchers to effectively capture the multifaceted nature of PIF across diverse clinical contexts. Limitations Several limitations warrant acknowledgement. Firstly, given the cross-sectional design of this study, while baseline consistency was noted across the RMEP institutions at entry, longitudinal research is required to fully clarify the trajectory of PIF. Secondly, the study focused on trainees within the RMEP pathway, which represents a structured and policy-driven training model. Consequently, the findings may not fully capture the experiences of other training pathways or independent healthcare professionals. Thirdly, while the use of RToP as a sensitizing concept facilitated the exploration of individual and sequential transformations, its application may have constrained interpretations from alternative theoretical perspectives. Future research should consider employing diverse lens to capture a broader perspective of PIF in low-resource settings. Additionally, the perspectives of educators and key stakeholders within low-resource settings—particularly rural supervisors, frontline general practitioners, and policymakers—were not included. Given their critical role in shaping training environments and PIF, future research incorporating multi-stakeholder perspectives is needed to enhance the ecological credibility of the framework. Finally, although participants were recruited from multiple regions, the study was not designed to systematically compare geographic or healthcare settings. Importantly, thematic saturation was achieved, and no substantial divergence in core themes was observed across participants, suggesting relative conceptual consistency. However, further studies are warranted to explore how specific contextual factors may shape PIF in greater depth, thereby further assessing the and adaptability of the proposed framework. Conclusion This study constructs a dynamic framework comprising 11 themes across three interconnected domains, providing a nuanced understanding of PIF in low-resource settings. The findings reveal cross‑stage thematic patterns that are consistent with a shift from externally mediated influences towards internally integrated identity elements, while underscoring the critical role of early contextual experiences as prominent influence. These insights extend existing conceptualisations of PIF, offering a context-sensitive framework to inform the design of targeted educational strategies for low-resource settings. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Acknowledgements The authors would like to express their sincere gratitude to all members of the focus groups for their valuable contributions. Abbreviations Professional Identity Formation General Practitioners Rural-Streamed Medical Education Programme Ring Theory of Personhood Authors’ contributions Y.C. and P.L. led the study design and data collection. K.L. secured funding and ethical approval. P.L., H.D. and J.W. handled the initial transcription of audio recordings, while Y.C. and X.Z. reviewed the accuracy of the transcription. K.L., Y.C., P.L. and X.Z. contributed to the data analysis. M.Y. provided expertise in the development of the group guide, data analysis, and framework. M.Y. and K.L. coordinated the overall research project, overseeing data analysis and guiding the interpretation of findings. Y.C. and P.L. drafted the manuscript. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript. Funding This study was supported by the Teaching Reform Project for “New Medical Sciences” (Notice on the Announcement of the 2023 Teaching Reform Project List by the Guangdong Provincial “New Medical Sciences” Construction Steering Committee-No. 126), the Teaching Reform and Research Project of Shantou University Medical College (SUMC [2025] No. SUMC-JG202529 and No. SUMC-JG202553), and the Medical Science and Technology Research Fund Project of Guangdong Province (A2023422). Data availability No datasets were generated or analysed during the current study. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Ethical approval for this study was granted by the Research Ethics Committee of Shantou University Medical College (Approval No. SUMC-JGLL202205). All procedures performed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the respective institutions, and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. Informed consent was obtained from all participates. Data were anonymised and managed according to institutional protocols. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contributor Information Mi Yao, Email: mi.yao@bjmu.edu.cn. Kai Lin, Email: klin2@stu.edu.cn. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Data Availability Statement No datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.