Enhanced multi-attribute decision-making method to analyze renewable energy sources for sustainable transportation by synergizing the cubic set with picture fuzzy hypersoft sets Authors: Muhammad Sajid, Khuram Ali Khan, Atiqe Ur Rahman, Rostin Matendo Mabela Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractDue to increasing environmental degradation, urban air pollution, and energy instability, the Government of Pakistan is focusing on transitioning to cleaner and more sustainable transportation options. While biofuels have often been seen as a partial substitute, their long-term environmental and economic sustainability is limited. Problems such as land use conflicts, food security concerns, and minimal carbon reduction highlight the need for a systematic shift to renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower. These alternatives offer greater sustainability, lower carbon footprints, and support Pakistan’s national climate goals and energy diversification strategies. This research introduces a new approach to decision-making on green energy options using cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft sets (CPFHSSs), which effectively manage the ambiguity and complexity involved in the evaluation process. The decision-making method applies OR and AND operations of the CPFHSSs to combine expert judgments across multiple criteria, considering both optimistic and pessimistic perspectives in the final evaluation. The methodology is demonstrated through a case study based on recent official guidance to identify and rank the most suitable renewable energy sources for sustainable transportation in Pakistan. Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-50529-8.Keywords: Renewable energy, Sustainable transportation, Aggregation operations, Multi-attribute decision-making, Computational intelligenceSubject terms: Energy science and technology, Engineering, Environmental sciences, Environmental social sciences Introduction The global automobile industry has become a vital sector, significantly influencing both the economy and research and development efforts. The growing number of automobiles on the road has facilitated efficient and rapid transportation. However, the increasing reliance on internal combustion vehicles that operate on conventional, non-renewable fuels has raised concerns about their environmental impact and energy consumption1. Despite this, the rise in conventional vehicles powered by fossil fuels has significantly contributed to increased air pollution in urban areas, as shown by higher levels of pollutants like particulate matter, nitrogen oxides , carbon monoxide (CO), and sulphur dioxide , among others2. A European Union assessment indicates that the transportation sector is responsible for over 28% of total carbon dioxide emissions, with road transport accounting for over 70% of emissions in this sector3. Fossil fuels are the unfortunate source of the necessary energy, which contributes to climate change and greenhouse gas emissions two of the most significant and dangerous problems for environmental sustainability4,5. Therefore, there is a need to drastically cut back on fossil fuel consumption and greenhouse gas emissions in order to maintain environmental stability6. Pakistan is aiming to transition its transportation sector from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources to promote sustainable mobility. This transition involves the adoption of new energy vehicles powered by electricity, hydrogen, or biofuels. However, the decision-making process for renewable energy options is often challenging due to uncertainty and ambiguity. To address this, a new mathematical framework based on the CPFHSS has been introduced. This new decision-support model offers a more adaptable way to assess complicated situations, making it easier to make trustworthy decisions in sustainable transportation planning. In 1965, Zadeh invented fuzzy sets (FSs)7 as a method for managing uncertainty in decision-making processes. The FSs ascertain an object’s degree of membership by mapping the set to the interval [0, 1]. Zadeh subsequently introduced interval-valued fuzzy sets (Iv-FSs)8, which serve as a generalisation of fuzzy sets. Atanassov introduced intuitionistic fuzzy sets (IFSs)9, which extend fuzzy sets by incorporating membership and non-membership functions. He later proposed interval-valued IFSs10 to handle higher uncertainty. Picture fuzzy sets (PFSs)11,12 are an extension of intuitionistic fuzzy sets (IFSs), comprising membership, abstention, and non-membership functions. They must reside within a closed unit interval. Cuong created interval-valued PFSs (Iv-PFSs)13, which describe membership, abstention, and non-membership degrees as closed subintervals of [0, 1]. Iv-PFSs provide a superior framework for the representation and management of fuzzy information in comparison to alternative techniques. Jun et al.14 introduced the concepts of internal and external cubic sets. Additionally, refined definitions of the minimum and maximum between two interval numbers were presented in15. Ashraf et al.16 presented the concept of cubic PFS (CPFS), facilitating the concurrent storing of both definite and indeterminate picture fuzzy information. Abdullah and Ashraf17 devised aggregation algorithms to synthesise confusing information in CPFSs, tackling challenges related to petroleum circulation centre evaluations. Ashraf et al.18 introduced a cleaner production evaluation framework for gold mines utilising a distance measure approach with cubic picture fuzzy numbers. Tehreem et al.19 developed three categories of average aggregation operators derived from CPFSs. The theory of soft sets (SS)20 has greatly advanced since it was founded by Molodtsov, addressing issues in FSs arising from inadequate parameterisation. SSs are parameterised subsets of the universal set, formulated using diverse relations, functions, and methodologies21–23. Maji et al. amalgamated SS theory with the FS framework to develop fuzzy soft sets (FSSs)24. Extensions of SSs encompass interval-valued fuzzy soft sets (25), intuitionistic fuzzy soft sets (26), picture fuzzy soft sets (27), and interval-valued picture fuzzy soft sets (28). Smarandache introduced a novel approach to handling uncertainty by transforming the function into a multi-argument function. This extension led to the development of the hypersoft set (HSS)29 and its various hybrids, including fuzzy HSS30, interval-valued fuzzy HSS31, intuitionistic fuzzy HSS32, interval-valued intuitionistic fuzzy HSS33, picture fuzzy HSS34, and interval-valued picture fuzzy HSS35. Harl et al.36 recently published fresh recommended distances and similarity metrics customised for PFHSSs. Saeed and Harl37 introduced additional operations and features of PFHSS and GPFHSS, validated De Morgan s laws for PFHSS, and proposed an approach with an innovative expectation score function to efficiently rank alternatives in multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) situations. Relevant literature Kumar et al.38 examined the growing application of multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) techniques in energy planning, particularly for rural and remote areas. These methods help decision-makers address the complex interplay of technical, economic, environmental, and social factors by enabling the simultaneous evaluation of multiple, often competing, objectives. Buonocore et al.39 introduced country-level metrics to assess the impact of renewable energy and transportation developments on emissions and public health, revealing disparities in corporate progress toward the Sustainable Development Goals. Işık et al.40 proposed a hybrid model for evaluating Pakistani commercial bank performance using MADM. Alam et al.41 presented a fuzzy MADM framework for the evaluation of Pakistans flood preparedness. Similarly, Ramezanzade et al.42 proposed a hybrid decision-making framework for selecting the most appropriate renewable energy projects at the sub-national level, incorporating environmental, economic, technical, and social criteria. Saeed et al.43 used a dynamic fuzzy HSS-based method to assess the Renewable Energy systems that are currently in place and offer a decision support system for installing new ones based on various geographical, political, social, and natural factors for the best possible resource management. Butkiene and Streimikiene44 employ a MCDM methodology to evaluate sustainable energy development, which is crucial for attaining carbon neutrality, while taking into account both practical and socio-political dimensions of the energy transition in sectors such as power distribution, residential energy, and transportation. Recently, Wang et al.45 integrated“fuzzy analytical hierarchy process” and“technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution” to evaluate and select optimal renewable energy sources for Taiwan’s logistics industry. Reddy et al.3 conducted a comprehensive comparison of four sustainable vehicle technologies: biofuel powered vehicles, fuel cell vehicles, electric vehicles, and solar vehicles, evaluating their development, operational principles, and sustainability based on technical, environmental, economic, and policy factors. Sajid et al.46 recently proposed a novel algorithmic MADM framework for solar panel selection, utilizing modified aggregations of cubic intuitionistic fuzzy hypersoft sets (HSSs). Subsequently, they applied multi-attribute decision-making methods under the single-valued neutrosophic cubic hypersoft set framework to evaluate motorcycle brands47. In another study, Sajid et al.48 employed improved cosine similarity measures for single-valued neutrosophic cubic hypersoft sets in a MADM technique aimed at sustainable supplier selection in the healthcare industry. Additionally, Ali and Yang49 analyzed renewable energy alternatives using circular bipolar complex intuitionistic fuzzy linguistic information, incorporating Frank power aggregation operators and the multi-attribute border approximation area comparison model. However, by combining an Iv-PFS with a PFS, the CPFS is a useful addition to FS theory since it makes it easier to describe ambiguity, imprecision, and uncertainty in decision-making processes. As an extension of SS, HSS can get around restrictions by using the multi-attributes function and can be applied for MADM problems without limiting the attributes of the decision-makers. It provides a more precise model compared to traditional mathematical methods. To develop the CPFHSS, the two frameworks that were previously explained are combined. The offered structure is better than others found in the literature because it uses the flexibility of cubic picture fuzzy structures to address ambiguity and uncertainty in decision analysis while providing access to data parameters as sub-parametric values. Thus, it can be deduced that the objective of creating the CPFHSS is to tackle the subsequent challenges: In PFSs, positive, neutral, and negative grades are typically represented as real numbers. The total of these grades ranges from 0 to 1, which allows for the expression of uncertainties and ambiguities. In this context, decision-makers must rely on one another to select the values necessary for making informed conclusions. When addressing problems, they need to communicate their findings using various fuzzy frameworks; however, fitting a large amount of data into a single fuzzy framework can be challenging. In PFSs, positive, neutral, and negative grades are typically represented as real numbers. The total of these grades ranges from 0 to 1, which allows for the expression of uncertainties and ambiguities. In this context, decision-makers must rely on one another to select the values necessary for making informed conclusions. When addressing problems, they need to communicate their findings using various fuzzy frameworks; however, fitting a large amount of data into a single fuzzy framework can be challenging. It is essential to consider all parameters and their sub-parameters to ensure a reliable, predictable decision-making process. If only a few parameters are considered while ignoring the sub-parameter values associated with them, the validity of the method may be called into question. It is essential to consider all parameters and their sub-parameters to ensure a reliable, predictable decision-making process. If only a few parameters are considered while ignoring the sub-parameter values associated with them, the validity of the method may be called into question. Prominent contribution The suggested-set, CPFHSS’s adaptable approximate function enables it to easily handle these difficulties thanks to its wide range CPFS for managing the first problem and its multi-argument domain (HSS settings) for handling the second. The significant contributions of the study are summarized as follows: The experts have more flexibility to incorporate parameterizations of multiple sub-attributes and all three components of cubic picture fuzzy information by combining CPFS and HSS to create CPFHSS. The positive, neutral, and negative grades, along with their interval values, are designed to accommodate large datasets within the picture fuzzy framework. This approach provides a clearer understanding in the first context. In contrast, the latter offers an approximate function capable of managing attribute values across non-overlapping sets with multiple arguments in its domain. Therefore, the integration of these relevant concepts significantly enhances the flexibility of CPFHSS in the decision-making process. The experts have more flexibility to incorporate parameterizations of multiple sub-attributes and all three components of cubic picture fuzzy information by combining CPFS and HSS to create CPFHSS. The positive, neutral, and negative grades, along with their interval values, are designed to accommodate large datasets within the picture fuzzy framework. This approach provides a clearer understanding in the first context. In contrast, the latter offers an approximate function capable of managing attribute values across non-overlapping sets with multiple arguments in its domain. Therefore, the integration of these relevant concepts significantly enhances the flexibility of CPFHSS in the decision-making process. This study suggests that the OR and AND operations in CPFHSSs for MADM can effectively model flexible“OR” and strict“AND” decision strategies. This is achieved by aggregating information through maximum and minimum values, respectively, thereby accommodating both optimistic and conservative evaluations. This study suggests that the OR and AND operations in CPFHSSs for MADM can effectively model flexible“OR” and strict“AND” decision strategies. This is achieved by aggregating information through maximum and minimum values, respectively, thereby accommodating both optimistic and conservative evaluations. Using OR and AND operation algorithms in the CPFHSS framework, a case study examines how the Pakistani government can shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy for sustainable transportation to find the best alternative. Using OR and AND operation algorithms in the CPFHSS framework, a case study examines how the Pakistani government can shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy for sustainable transportation to find the best alternative. The proposed study highlights its practical usefulness through its potential for future development and applicability across various decision-making domains, which are also discussed within the study The proposed study highlights its practical usefulness through its potential for future development and applicability across various decision-making domains, which are also discussed within the study The structure of the study is organized as follows. Section "Preliminaries" introduces a concise set of fundamental definitions necessary for the formulation of CPFHSS. Section "Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft set" formally defines CPFHSS and demonstrates its application through a numerical example. Section "Aggregation strategies: the OR-operation and the AND-operation" presents the aggregation strategies specifically the OR and AND operations, and illustrates them with numerical examples. Section "Ranking green energy sources for sustainable transportation using set-theoretic operations of CPFHSSs" details the practical application of the proposed aggregation operations, outlining a methodology and algorithm based on CPFHSS and their corresponding score values. Finally, Sect. "Conclusion" concludes the study with a summary of key findings and directions for future research. Preliminaries Some basic definitions that are needed to fully understand the idea of this article are included in this part. Let be the initial universe set through out this paper. Definition 1 Reference9 An IFS on is defined by Where the values and obtained respectively from the mappings and satisfy the condition These values are called the membership and non-membership degrees of element u to the IFS . For each u in is known as the degree of indeterminacy of u to . Although Atanassov’s IFS theory has proven effective in a number of domains, it is unable to capture real-world scenarios. PFSs11, an extension of this theory, are an effective tool for cluster analysis and pattern recognition, especially in scenarios with multiple response options such as ’yes,’ ’abstain,’ ’no,’ or ’rejection. Definition 2 Reference11 In the universal set , an object of the form is called PFS where the values , and obtained respectively from the mappings and satisfy the condition . These mappings are from to [0, 1] and the values are called the degrees of positive, neutral and negative membership of u in PFS. Hence, for each u in , the degree of refusal membership in can be computed as . The collection of all picture fuzzy subsets on is denoted by . Jaikumar et al.50 proposed a perfect score function for evaluating picture fuzzy value/number, defined as Definition 3 Reference12 Let ℧ be the collection of all closed subintervals of [0, 1] and , where and are the lower and upper positive degrees of respectively. Let be the universal set, an object of the form is known as the Iv-PFS on . Furthermore, and are respectively called the positive, neutral and negative interval memberships on . Also sum of the values and satisfying the condition The collection of all interval-valued picture fuzzy subsets on is denoted by . Definition 4 Reference15 Consider two interval numbers and . The refined minimum and refined maximum of and , denoted by and , respectively, are defined as follows: By combining an Iv-PFS with a PFS, Ashraf et al.16 proposed a CPFS. The cubic set14 is extended in this way. Definition 5 Reference16 Let be the universal set, an object of the form is a CPFS on Additionally, and For simplicity, CPFS on can be denoted as represents the collection of all cubic picture fuzzy subsets on Molodtsov defined the soft set20 as a parametric representation of FS7. Further theoretical analysis, this concept can be found in Refs. 21–23. Definition 6 Reference20 Let be the set of parameters associated with the universal set is the set of all subsets of . A soft set, over is defined by an approximate mapping In other words, is a parameterized family of subsets of . is a set known as the ε-approximate elements in the soft set, for any parameter . Thus, over can be expressed as a collection of ordered pairs As a development of soft sets, Smarandache introduced HSSs29. In complex systems, HSSs offer a flexible and sophisticated framework for decision-making and problem-solving. It permits many parameter sets to have an impact on element membership. Definition 7 Reference29 Let is a set of n well-defined attributes, with corresponding attributive values contained in the sets Then, HSS, on is defined as Here, is cardinality of any subset of Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft set In this section we introduce the definition of CPFHSS and the basic concept that goes along with it. As seen in Fig. 1, the CPFHSS is an HSS with CPFS as the value of its approximate function. Frame diagram of CuHSS . Definition 8 Let is a set of n well-defined attributes, with corresponding attributive values contained in the sets For any , the CPFHSS, is characterized by approximate mapping such that . It can be written as: Where and be the collections of Iv-PFSs and PFSs over respectively. Moreover, is an Iv-PF grade over with regard to such that ⊆ [0,1] and ⊆ [0,1] are positive, neutral and negative membership intervals respectively such that In the same way and represent the upper and lower ends of refusal grades, respectively. is an Iv-PF grade over with regard to such that ⊆ [0,1] and ⊆ [0,1] are positive, neutral and negative membership intervals respectively such that In the same way and represent the upper and lower ends of refusal grades, respectively. is a PF number over with regard to such that and are positive, neutral and negative grades respectively, such that and grade of refusal membership is is a PF number over with regard to such that and are positive, neutral and negative grades respectively, such that and grade of refusal membership is A CPFHSS is a simultaneous multi-argument parameterized family of PFS and Iv-PFS. For ease of use, a CPFHSS, may be denoted as , and their collection is denoted by . Example 1 A family wants to buy onetouch washing machine. Suppose be the set of washing machine of different brands and features under consideration. Parameters affecting the best choice of machine are , and Sub-parameters valued sets corresponding to these parameters are: Now, we define Each element for i=1,...,6, is a 6-tuple consisting of sub-parametric values given as follows: Consider a subset of and define an approximate function for a CPFHSS, . For simplicity, is defined over a subset of as follows: This set can be written in tabular form as displayed in Table 1. Table 1Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Aggregation strategies: the OR-operation and the AND-operation In MADM problems, complex and uncertain data such as evaluating renewable energy options for sustainable transportation, is involved. It is essential to combine individual opinions or expert evaluations in a meaningful and robust way. Since each decision-maker might view options differently based on various factors, we need a good way to combine these opinions into one clear decision-making framework. To address this, we introduce two aggregation strategies OR-operation and AND-operation on CPFHSSs. These operations help capture the optimistic and pessimistic perspectives of the evaluators, allowing for a more comprehensive and flexible analysis in uncertain environments. Definition 9 For any two CPFHSSs, and on , the operation OR between them is defined and represented as follows: where Example 2 Reconsider the CPFHSS, from Example 1 and let be another CPFHSS, defined as over , whose tabular representation is shown in Table 2. Then, the operation OR of two CPFHSSs, given by is presented in Table 3. Table 2Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Table 3Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Definition 10 For any two CPFHSSs, and on , the operation AND between them is defined and represented as follows: where Example 3 Reconsider the CPFHSSs, and from Examples 1 and 2 respectively. Then, the operation AND of two CPFHSSs, given by is presented in Table 4. Table 4Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Tabular form of CPFHSS, . Following definition is the modified version of the Definition 12 presented by Naeem et al51. Definition 11 For each IVPFN, the score function is defined by Ranking green energy sources for sustainable transportation using set-theoretic operations of CPFHSSs This section presents four alternative green energy solutions for sustainable transportation in developing countries. We evaluate these alternatives based on four distinct criteria, which are further broken down into ten smaller criteria using set-theoretic operations of CPFHSS . Algorithm and methodology We propose a novel MADM framework for evaluating green energy alternatives using a committee of decision-makers and a structured set of attributes and sub-attributes using the OR and AND operations of CPFHSSs. A set of k committees, denoted as is formed, with each committee consisting of three decision-makers responsible for evaluating various green energy alternatives. The evaluation is based on multiple green energy attributes, denoted as , which include key aspects such as environmental impact, financial considerations, sustainability and resilience, and governance policies. Each attribute is further characterized by a set of distinct sub-attributes, represented as . Additionally, the set of green energy alternatives under evaluation is denoted by , where represents the n potential energy options being considered. The procedure is presented in Fig. 2 and its different stages are explained as given below: Methodology for choose the green energy source. Input: 1.1For MADM problem, let denote a finite collection of viable green energy alternatives from which experts must choose. The symbols signify q clearly defined attributes (criteria), further delineated by the sets of distinct sub-attributes used to evaluate alternative performance. Additionally, let represents a collection of committees. Input: 1.1For MADM problem, let denote a finite collection of viable green energy alternatives from which experts must choose. The symbols signify q clearly defined attributes (criteria), further delineated by the sets of distinct sub-attributes used to evaluate alternative performance. Additionally, let represents a collection of committees. 1.1For MADM problem, let denote a finite collection of viable green energy alternatives from which experts must choose. The symbols signify q clearly defined attributes (criteria), further delineated by the sets of distinct sub-attributes used to evaluate alternative performance. Additionally, let represents a collection of committees. For MADM problem, let denote a finite collection of viable green energy alternatives from which experts must choose. The symbols signify q clearly defined attributes (criteria), further delineated by the sets of distinct sub-attributes used to evaluate alternative performance. Additionally, let represents a collection of committees. Construction:2.1Make the Cartesian product and pick a subset of that has d multi-attribute sub-parametric tuples.2.2Construct the k decision matrices (as presented in Fig. 3) where each energy source is evaluated under each criterion using cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft values (CPFHV): Here represents the CPFHS value evaluated on the alternative concerning the criterion established by the kth committee. The sub-attribute valued tuples are arranged in the rows and the alternatives are arranged in the columns. In this way, the order of each matrix is d × n. Construction:2.1Make the Cartesian product and pick a subset of that has d multi-attribute sub-parametric tuples.2.2Construct the k decision matrices (as presented in Fig. 3) where each energy source is evaluated under each criterion using cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft values (CPFHV): Here represents the CPFHS value evaluated on the alternative concerning the criterion established by the kth committee. The sub-attribute valued tuples are arranged in the rows and the alternatives are arranged in the columns. In this way, the order of each matrix is d × n. 2.1Make the Cartesian product and pick a subset of that has d multi-attribute sub-parametric tuples. Make the Cartesian product and pick a subset of that has d multi-attribute sub-parametric tuples. 2.2Construct the k decision matrices (as presented in Fig. 3) where each energy source is evaluated under each criterion using cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft values (CPFHV): Construct the k decision matrices (as presented in Fig. 3) where each energy source is evaluated under each criterion using cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft values (CPFHV): Computation: 3.1Apply the OR-operation (AND-operation) to the k decision matrices to obtain the overall decision matrix of order .3.2Convert the overall decision matrix into a reduced form with fuzzy numerical grades by applying Equation 1 for picture fuzzy values and Equation 4 for Iv-PF values (Iv-PFVs). Then, highlight the highest numerical Iv-PF grade in each row of the matrix.3.3Sum the products of the highest numerical grade of Iv-PFV and the corresponding numerical grade of picture fuzzy values to calculate the score for each green energy alternative.3.4Rank the energy sources based on the . Computation: 3.1Apply the OR-operation (AND-operation) to the k decision matrices to obtain the overall decision matrix of order .3.2Convert the overall decision matrix into a reduced form with fuzzy numerical grades by applying Equation 1 for picture fuzzy values and Equation 4 for Iv-PF values (Iv-PFVs). Then, highlight the highest numerical Iv-PF grade in each row of the matrix.3.3Sum the products of the highest numerical grade of Iv-PFV and the corresponding numerical grade of picture fuzzy values to calculate the score for each green energy alternative.3.4Rank the energy sources based on the . 3.1Apply the OR-operation (AND-operation) to the k decision matrices to obtain the overall decision matrix of order . Apply the OR-operation (AND-operation) to the k decision matrices to obtain the overall decision matrix of order . 3.2Convert the overall decision matrix into a reduced form with fuzzy numerical grades by applying Equation 1 for picture fuzzy values and Equation 4 for Iv-PF values (Iv-PFVs). Then, highlight the highest numerical Iv-PF grade in each row of the matrix. Convert the overall decision matrix into a reduced form with fuzzy numerical grades by applying Equation 1 for picture fuzzy values and Equation 4 for Iv-PF values (Iv-PFVs). Then, highlight the highest numerical Iv-PF grade in each row of the matrix. 3.3Sum the products of the highest numerical grade of Iv-PFV and the corresponding numerical grade of picture fuzzy values to calculate the score for each green energy alternative. Sum the products of the highest numerical grade of Iv-PFV and the corresponding numerical grade of picture fuzzy values to calculate the score for each green energy alternative. 3.4Rank the energy sources based on the . Rank the energy sources based on the . Output: 4.1The green energy source with the highest scoring is the best appropriate for sustainable mobility. Output: 4.1The green energy source with the highest scoring is the best appropriate for sustainable mobility. 4.1The green energy source with the highest scoring is the best appropriate for sustainable mobility. The green energy source with the highest scoring is the best appropriate for sustainable mobility. Decision matrices to based on CPFHVs. Problem statement In recent years, energy has become a crucial global resource. Many sectors worldwide face challenges such as energy shortages, inefficient resource utilization, and sustainability risks52. The transportation industry, in particular, is one of the most affected by these issues. As a vital link in the global business and social ecosystem, the transportation sector relies heavily on energy. Technological advancements have enabled the adoption of various methodologies to enhance energy supply within this industry . These option are electric vehicle battery and fuel-cell engine technologies in lieu of gasoline engines53. Simultaneously, these technologies serve as effective alternatives for efficient energy utilization and environmental sustainability. Nevertheless, these technological advancements cannot independently resolve the entire issue. In examining the energy usage procedures within the transportation sector, it becomes evident that the primary issues related to resources are associated with the energy generation components. For instance, while utilizing electric vehicles and battery technology to mitigate carbon emissions, it is imperative to investigate the source of the energy employed for charging the battery. Furthermore, while employing fuel-cell technology that is entirely hydrogen-based, it is imperative to ascertain the energy sources utilized in the hydrogen generation process54. As a result, compared to earlier times, the countries’ energy production resources and methods have become increasingly significant. The use of traditional fossil fuel resources as a base for energy creation is a major problem for the world because they are outdated, inefficient, and unsustainable, yet they have a large producing capacity in comparison to other options. One example of the region’s heavy reliance on coal for electricity generation is Asia Pacific, where coal-fired power plants provide about 56% of the region’s electricity52. Therefore, there are significant health and environmental dangers associated with air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions55. It’s also no secret that leaders of both wealthy and emerging nations have a responsibility to make decisions about their countries’ future, including formulating policies surrounding their energy infrastructures. However, it is important to acknowledge that pricing and costing factors can lead to hesitancy, particularly in underdeveloped nations56. The transportation sector’s high reliance on fossil fuels is a major contributor to economic instability, energy insecurity, and carbon emissions. For transportation, an effective and sustainable alternative energy source is required. Case study and numerical example of renewable energy in sustainable transportation This study focuses on modeling the decision-making process for new energy investments in transportation infrastructure in a developing nation reliant on fossil fuels. Using a Multi-Attribute Decision-Making (MADM) model, it evaluates green energy sources for sustainable transportation. Transitioning to renewable energy is vital for these countries, offering economic, environmental, and social benefits, enhancing energy security, and lowering transportation costs. It also reduces carbon emissions and air pollution, supporting public health and climate goals. Investments in clean energy are essential for economic growth, job creation, and innovation. However, developing countries like Nigeria, Pakistan, India, and Indonesia face challenges in adopting sustainable mobility due to inadequate green energy infrastructure, leading to significant environmental and energy security concerns. Energy system of these nations mostly depend on fossil fuel. For example, Nigeria boasts the largest economy and the most abundant oil resources on the African continent, leading to fluctuations in energy supply and pollution issues. It continues to be the biggest producer and consumer of petrol in West Africa. Nigeria is undergoing significant power sector reforms, including electrification plans. In Pakistan, the majority of main energy supply is derived from oil and natural gas. The nation’s primary renewable energy source is hydropower, however the shares of wind and solar photovoltaic are gradually increasing. India’s energy demand is rising quickly, which has significant ramifications for the world energy market. This increasing need is met by a variety of energy sources, with coal continuing to be the dominant source. As the Indian government meets its lofty renewable energy targets and lowers local air pollution, it remains committed to providing safe, affordable, and sustainable electricity. In recent years, Indonesia’s oil imports have grown significantly. This resource-rich country is the leading supplier of gas in Southeast Asia and the fourth-largest producer of coal worldwide. The Indonesian government has presented multifaceted ideas that include expanding the current infrastructure, encouraging off-grid solar and micro-hydro technologies, as well as isolated diesel generators and solar-diesel hybrids. As these countries strive to transition to more environmentally friendly energy sources, lowering their dependency on fossil fuels will be essential to achieving sustainable development goals. We examine a scenario with four alternatives, emphasising the increasing need for sustainable options, as presented in Table 5 taken from Ref.57 with minor modifications. Table 5Description of alternatives.AlternativesDescriptionConcentrate on developing current infrastructure and adopting biofuels (ethanol and biodiesel) as a viable alternative to fossil fuels.The strategy calls for the full shutdown of the current system after investing in and utilising electric vehicles powered by renewable electricity.By using engine and turbine technologies, investing in renewable energy systems, and improving the efficiency of energy infrastructure, the current system will be partially decreased.Invests in renewable energy sources and hydrogen-based energy production technologies in order to make the shift gradually. Description of alternatives. Three Pakistani experts (decision-makers) are selected to assess the case scenario, all of whom belong to the technology, transportation, and environmental sectors. The first expert has over twenty-five years of experience, having served as both a politician in the National Assembly of Pakistan and the Ministry of Communications of Pakistan. The second expert has over twenty years of experience, having served as both a politician in the National Assembly of Pakistan and the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources of Pakistan. The third expert possesses more than twenty years of academic experience in civil engineering and transportation, having served as an environmental social director in the mining and transportation industries within the private sector. He also has more than ten years of experience in the data centre, information technology, and transportation industries. To determine the best green energy alternative, we utilize an MADM approach. This approach encompasses four main attributes “environmental, financial, sustainability and resilience, and governance and policy” all comprising 10 distinct sub-attributes, as outlined in the Table 6 and illustrated pictorially in Fig. 4. Table 6Attributes and sub-attributes with brief descriptions for ranking renewable energy for sustainable transportation.SymbolSub-attributesBriefly descriptionsEnvironmentalEssential Material ManufacturingRaw material extraction poses significant environmental and social challenges, including pollution, habitat destruction, and community displacement, despite precautionary measures.58,59.Environmental Impact of Energy ProductionPollution from energy production, mainly due to fossil fuel reliance, leads to air, water, and soil contamination60. It contributes to climate change, respiratory issues, water pollution, habitat destruction, and soil degradation, threatening biodiversity and public health61,62.Efficient Energy UtilizationEfficient energy use maximizes sustainability and reduces costs by adopting energy-efficient technologies, renewable sources, and advanced battery systems63,64. Behavioral changes, energy audits, and supportive policies further enhance efficiency, lowering environmental impact and promoting a sustainable energy future65.FinancialGreen Energy Investment PotentialInternational Financial Institutions (IFIs) and Export-Import Banks (Eximbanks) support economic growth by providing tailored credit, especially for renewable energy66. They enhance access through targeted financing, risk mitigation, local partnerships, and green financing initiatives, aligning credit with sustainability goals67,68.Rising Energy Production Costs with Green EnergyThe transition to green energy initially increases production costs due to high infrastructure, installation, and grid integration expenses. Market fluctuations and shifting subsidies from fossil fuels to renewables further impact prices69.Strong Reliance on ExportsThe growing demand for energy storage has increased reliance on lithium, essential for lithium-ion batteries. This dependency creates challenges for exporters like Australia and Chile due to market and geopolitical risks, while importers face supply chain instability70. To mitigate these issues, investing in alternative battery technologies and improving recycling processes is crucial for a sustainable, circular economy71.Governance and PolicyAlignment with Climate Change RequirementsIntegrating climate change considerations into energy projects in developing countries is essential for sustainable development and resilience. This involves prioritizing renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower to cut emissions and enhance energy security72. Conducting climate risk assessments helps design resilient energy systems, while involving local communities ensures projects align with both development and climate goals73,74.Carbon FootprintThe high carbon footprint of energy projects in developing countries remains a concern as they expand infrastructure while addressing climate change75. Many still rely on fossil fuels, especially coal, leading to significant emissions. Transitioning to renewable energy sources can help reduce emissions, while carbon accounting systems and energy efficiency measures are crucial for effective emission management76.Sustainability and ResilienceAlignment with Global AgreementsAdapting to international energy agreements is vital for developing countries to achieve sustainability and energy access while addressing climate change. Aligning with global targets like the Paris Agreement and SDGs involves integrating renewables and improving energy efficiency77. Support through capacity building, technical assistance, and climate finance, such as the Green Climate Fund, is essential for successful implementation72.Regulatory Needs for Infrastructure PoliciesNew infrastructure policies for energy projects in developing countries should promote sustainable energy access and efficiency. Key requirements include comprehensive energy planning, investment in renewable technologies, capacity-building programs, and clear regulatory frameworks to attract investment78. Additionally, policies should support innovative technologies to enhance energy efficiency79. Attributes and sub-attributes with brief descriptions for ranking renewable energy for sustainable transportation. Available alternatives with their attributes and related sub-attributes. Numerical example This example, which was modified from reference57, is explained as follows: From the four viable options (, and ) listed in Table 5, the Pakistani government wants to choose a renewable energy source for environmentally friendly transportation. Two committees, each comprising of three distinct professionals from the transportation, technology, and environmental domains, are constituted for the evaluation of four viable options and selecting the most suitable green energy alternative. The assessment of the alternatives takes into account the following attributes: The first is the environmental aspect, the second is the financial aspect, the third is the sustainability and resilience aspect, and the fourth is the governance and policy aspect. . This cartesian product contains sub-parametric 4-tuples. For the computational purpose, we take where and which contains just 4 sub-parametric tuples preferred for further approximations. Next, we implement the proposed approach from Sect. IV to address the green energy selection problem for sustainable transportation. Obtain the cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrices as provided by the decision makers. Here, represents the approximate value of the ith attribute for the jth alternative, as evaluated by the kth decision maker. The cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrices are presented in Tables 7 and 8. The OR operation between two CPFHSSs, and , is represented as . This operation is performed according to Definition 9 and is illustrated in the corresponding tables (Table 9). Table 7Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrix , provided by Committee 1. Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrix , provided by Committee 1. Table 8Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrix , provided by Committee 2. Cubic picture fuzzy hypersoft decision matrix , provided by Committee 2. Table 9The OR operation, between and . The OR operation, between and . Using Eq. (1) for picture fuzzy values and Eq. (4) for interval-valued picture fuzzy values, we get the reduced fuzzy numerical values of as shown in Table 10. The bolded values in the table represent the highest values in their respective rows. Table 11 presents the reduced fuzzy numerical grades for all interval-valued picture fuzzy numbers and picture fuzzy numbers as listed in the Table 10. Since both parameters remain identical for the pairs where i=1,2,3,4, the values of and are considered to be 0. Table 10Reduced fuzzy numerical values for OR operation. Reduced fuzzy numerical values for OR operation. Table 11Grade-wise table based on OR operation.Highest interval-valued picture fuzzy valuesRelevant picture fuzzy values000.690.570.710.640.690.550.690.53000.710.640.690.520.680.520.670.58000.690.520.720.580.720.580.730.6400 Grade-wise table based on OR operation. Final score of all available alternatives are given as Green energy alternative is selected as it has the highest score. Using AND operation The identical input and construction procedures are applicable when analysing the data in numerical example Numerical example. But our steps for computation and output are different. Currently, is presented in the Table 12. Table 12The AND operation, between and . The AND operation, between and . Using Eq. (1) for picture fuzzy values and Eq. (4) for interval-valued picture fuzzy values, we get the reduced fuzzy numerical values of as shown in Table 10. The bolded values in the table represent the highest values in their respective rows. Table 11 presents the reduced fuzzy numerical grades for all interval-valued picture fuzzy numbers and picture fuzzy numbers as listed in the Table 10. Since both parameters remain identical for the pairs where i=1,2,3,4, the values of and are considered to be 0. Final score of all available alternatives by using the AND operation are given as Green energy alternative is selected as it has the highest score. The robustness of the proposed algorithm is assessed through the computational complexity which is determined as: As in the case study, number of green energy alternatives , number of assessment criteria, number of sub-attribute valued tuples , and number of experts committees are, respectively, 4 (four), 4 (four), 4 (four) and 2 (two). The total computational complexity of the proposed algorithm is , i.e. 16 + 2.4080 = 18.4080 and . The constant value shows that the proposed algorithm consistently requires the same amount of time to process, regardless of the input size. Furthermore, the framework is designed to scale effectively to accommodate larger datasets, whether in size, dimensions, or complexity, without causing significant increases in computation time, memory usage, or performance issues. Result discussion and comparative analysis The evaluation of renewable energy alternatives for sustainable transportation involves a complex decision-making process that must account for multiple criteria such as environmental sustainability, financial feasibility, resilience, and governance policies. In this study, we consider four green energy alternatives, denoted as and , and evaluate them using a MADM method that incorporates multiple sub-criteria. The evaluation employs two distinct aggregation strategies: the OR-operation and the AND-operation. Each alternative s performance is measured using CPFHV, derived from two decision matrices formed based on expert evaluations. The final score for each alternative is calculated by multiplying the highest interval-valued picture fuzzy value with the corresponding picture fuzzy value, and summing the resulting products. Under the OR-operation, the alternative clearly stands out with the highest score of 54%, indicating superior performance across key sub-attributes. Alternatives and exhibit significantly lower scores, reflecting either low or inconsistent evaluations. The alternative achieves a moderate score but still falls well below . Even when evaluated using the more conservative AND-operation, maintains its lead, achieving a slightly higher score of 57.5%. This consistency demonstrates not only its high potential but also its reliability and stable performance across all considered dimensions. In contrast, the remaining alternatives continue to rank lower, with again emerging as the second-best option. The comparative score values obtained from both OR and AND strategies for all alternatives are visually represented in Fig. 5, providing a clearer understanding of the ranking outcomes. Renewable energy selection using the OR & AND operations. Conclusion In this study, we introduced a new mathematical framework called the CPFHSS to address the confusion, uncertainty, and unclear aspects often encountered in MADM problems. The CPFHSS framework enhances traditional decision models by incorporating the advantages of cubic picture fuzzy sets and hypersoft set theory, making it particularly effective for complex evaluations, such as assessing renewable energy sources for sustainable transportation. To effectively aggregate expert opinions and evaluate various attributes, we developed and implemented two aggregation strategies: the OR-operation and the AND-operation on CPFHSSs. These operations offer flexible and comprehensive methods for evaluating alternatives in both optimistic and pessimistic decision-making environments. Building on this theoretical foundation, we designed a practical algorithm capable of solving MADM problems by utilizing the CPFHSS model along with the OR and AND operations. The algorithm systematically processes complex decision matrices and identifies the most suitable alternative based on clearly defined scoring rules. To validate the applicability and robustness of the proposed method, we applied the algorithm to a real-world case study in which the Pakistani government seeks to identify the most appropriate renewable energy source for sustainable transportation. The results highlighted the superiority and consistency of one alternative across both aggregation strategies, thus demonstrating the method s effectiveness in realistic policy-making scenarios. The flexibility and adaptability of the proposed framework make it applicable to a broad range of other decision-making domains such as supply chain management, healthcare systems, environmental planning, and financial investment analysis. Future research can explore further extensions of this model to include hybrid aggregation operators and dynamic decision-making environments. Supplementary Information Supplementary Information. Author contributions Conceptualization, M.S., and A.U.R.; methodology, M. S., K.A.K., and A.U.R.; software, M. S., and A.U.R.; validation, M. S., K.A.K., and R.M.M.; formal analysis, K.A.K., and R.M.M.; investigation, K.A.K., A.U.R., and R.M.M.; visualization, M.S., and A.U.R.; supervision, K.A.K., and A.U.R. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Data availability The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.