Access to Ambulatory Cardiology Care: Learning from Families Managing Pediatric Heart Disease Authors: Larissa Wenren, Maria Perez Carballo, Kira Fried, Rebecca Matulsky, Shannon Engstrand, Tiffany Folks, Kathy Jenkins, Sarah de Ferranti, Susan Saleeb, Jean Connor Published: 2026 ABSTRACT ObjectiveMissed ambulatory care visits can lead to worse outcomes and greater use of emergent care for children with complex congenital and acquired heart disease. Through descriptive qualitative inquiry, we explored the barriers to and facilitators of pediatric cardiology ambulatory care for children with complex heart disease.Study designEnglish- and Spanish-speaking caregivers of children with complex heart disease who missed ≥1 clinic visit at a single, free-standing children's hospital were recruited, with purposeful sampling of Black and Hispanic patients. Semistructured interviews explored telehealth, communication, social determinants of health, and perceived impact of race and ethnicity on care. Content analysis summarized information and identified themes.ResultsNineteen interviews were conducted, including caregivers of children of lower socioeconomic status (73%), Hispanic ethnicity (37%), Black race (32%), and primarily Spanish speaking (26%). Overarching themes included barriers to care, facilitators of returning to and staying in care, impact of race and ethnicity, impact of diagnosis, and recommendations for improvement. Barriers to care included appointment access, utilization of telehealth regarding patient-provider communication and missed physical examinations, and social vulnerability regarding housing, transportation, and employment. Each barrier was exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. Facilitators to care included trusted patient-provider relationships, family prioritization of cardiac care, telehealth benefits, and hospital-provided financial resources. Race and ethnicity were not perceived to impact care.ConclusionBarriers to and facilitators of accessing ambulatory cardiology care were multifaceted in a cohort of diverse and socially vulnerable families caring for children with complex heart disease. Understanding their experience can inform actionable areas of improvement to support access and continuity of care. Congenital heart disease (CHD) is the most common birth defect, affecting 1% of US infants.1 CHD severity exists on a spectrum, ranging from mild to complex, the latter necessitating surgical and interventional procedures. Patients with complex congenital and acquired heart disease warrant at least yearly specialized ambulatory cardiology care over their lifetime due to increased lifetime risk of disease progression, risk for heart failure, arrhythmia, prosthesis dysfunction, cardiovascular risk, and noncardiac comorbidities.2 The financial impact of complex heart disease is significant, and delayed or missed ambulatory care can lead to worse outcomes, more emergent care, more urgent interventions, and higher mortality, all of which increase costs.3, 4, 5, 6, 7 Missed ambulatory care is an especially urgent issue within pediatric cardiology, which reported more incomplete telehealth appointments during the COVID-19 pandemic compared with many other pediatric subspecialties.8 Although prior studies have examined factors associated with missed pediatric care such as social drivers (or determinants) of health (SDOH), no study has captured the experience of caregivers whose child with complex heart disease missed ambulatory care.6,9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 In this descriptive qualitative study, we interviewed caregivers of children with complex congenital or acquired heart disease who had missed ambulatory pediatric cardiology visit(s) during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic to better understand the barriers, facilitators, and other aspects impacting access to follow-up care. We purposefully recruited from populations at increased risk for missing ambulatory appointments, including children of lower socioeconomic status (SES), minoritized race and ethnicity, and those with caregivers who primarily spoke Spanish. Methods Clinical Setting This study was conducted at Boston Children's Hospital, a quaternary, academic, pediatric cardiac care center in a free-standing children's hospital. The Heart Center performs >40 000 annual ambulatory visits across the main campus and multiple satellite sites via a combination of ∼70 attending cardiologists, ∼45 advanced practice providers (∼19 practicing independently), and ∼25 cardiology fellows. Characteristics of the patients with completed and incomplete visits during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic and the year prior are fully described in a previous publication.15 Briefly, the clinic population during the first pandemic year was composed of 75% non-Hispanic White, 6% non-Hispanic Black, 10% Hispanic, and 4% Asian patients; 9% spoke a non-English primary language, 30% were publicly insured, and 29% were living in areas of very low or low Child Opportunity Index (COI). Incomplete visits were more common among non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic patients both during and before the pandemic. Families could schedule, reschedule, and cancel appointments in person, by phone, or through the patient portal. During COVID-19, telehealth was adopted within 2 weeks of the pandemic onset by all ambulatory providers and accounted for ∼90% of visits in the first month and ∼50% of visits over the first year of the pandemic (March 13, 2020, to March 12, 2021).15 Inclusion Criteria Participants were recruited among caregivers of children with complex congenital or acquired heart disease, collectively referred to as “complex heart disease” throughout this study. Complex CHD included moderate to severe lesions as defined by the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association guidelines.2 Complex acquired heart disease included cardiomyopathies, inflammatory disease, pulmonary artery hypertension, and connective tissue disorders with associated cardiac findings requiring at least annual cardiology follow-up. Caregivers of a child (<19 years of age) with complex congenital or acquired heart disease experiencing at least one no-show in-person or telehealth visits from March 2020 to March 2021, and who were primarily English or Spanish speaking and Massachusetts residents were included in the study. We purposefully sampled a range of races, ethnicities, and SESs, with a particular focus on sampling children of Black/African American race and Hispanic ethnicity, and those of lower SES, groups known to be disproportionately affected by inequities in pediatric care. This research was approved by the local institutional review board (IRB-P00038667). Recruitment for Participation Caregivers were recruited via phone calls at various times during the day and evening in their documented preferred language to participate in a semistructured interview via Zoom, phone, or in person. Participants were offered travel reimbursements for in-person interviews if a remote interview was not possible. Phone, text, and email reminders were sent, and interviews rescheduled as needed. Participants received a $50 gift card as a token of appreciation. Interview Methods and Procedures A facilitator guide for semistructured interviews was designed to explore several topics around the experience of caregivers, including the accessibility of appointments, telehealth vs in-person care, reasons for missed visits, impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, social impact of having a child with heart disease, health-related social needs, and how medical staff's perception of their child's race and ethnicity have impacted their medical care (Supplemental Figure 1; available at www.jpeds.com). Caregivers were asked to share their child's race and ethnicity during the interview. We consulted the Ambulatory Cardiology and hospital-wide Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion working groups, as well as members of our diverse team to review the proposed questions and process. After obtaining verbal informed consent, caregivers participated in 1 semistructured interview lasting 30-60 minutes conducted by an investigator in the caregiver's documented preferred language. Each interview had 1 researcher primarily conducting the interview, along with 1-2 research personnel providing support. The 2 English- and 1 Spanish-speaking researchers who conducted interviews were not directly involved in the participant's primary cardiology care. The interview team was assembled to represent diverse races, ethnicities, and languages, with the goal of having congruent characteristics of the interviewing research personnel with the interviewed participant. Interviews were recorded via Zoom with an automated transcription that was manually reviewed for accuracy and deidentified. For interviews conducted in Spanish, Zoom produced an automated text transcription in Spanish. The hospital's interpreter services listened to the interview audio recording to ensure the accuracy of the Zoom Spanish transcript, then translated the Spanish transcript into English for analysis; the translations were lastly reviewed by the original interviewer for content accuracy. Interviews with English-speaking caregivers occurred in 2022, with data saturation achieved and confirmed. Interviews with Spanish-speaking caregivers subsequently occurred in 2023, with saturation achieved. Data Analysis Conventional content analysis was used to identify themes and subcategories. The first 5 transcripts were read, reread, and coded individually by 2 team members for emphasis, repetition, significance, or clarity of statement before comparison. A preliminary codebook was constructed after grouping codes into themes and subthemes. All transcripts were imported into a qualitative coding software, NVivo 12 (2017, QSR International, LLC). Coding was continuously reviewed and revised by the team, first for English interviews and then Spanish. Patient demographics derived from the electronic medical record (EMR) included age, sex, race, ethnicity, insurance type, preferred language, maternal education level, street address, missed appointment information, and cardiac diagnosis. SES was assessed using the COI 2.0, a validated census-tract level composite index that integrates 29 weighted indicators across 3 SDOH domains: education, health and environment, and social and economic.17 COI z-scores were normalized at the Massachusetts state level (all participants lived in Massachusetts) and stratified into the following quintiles: very low, low, moderate, high, and very high. Prolonged engagement occurred through saturation of participant language and by broad categories of race and ethnicity. The study team engaged in peer debriefing following the interviews, individually reviewing and coding transcripts, field notes, and then extensive discussion of interpretation. Results Study Population Characteristics Of the 110 patients eligible for recruitment (95 English and 15 Spanish speaking), 19 caregivers were recruited and interviewed, 14 (73.7%) in English and 5 (26.3%) in Spanish (Table I). Most children were of minoritized race and ethnicity (89%), lived in areas of lower COI (73%), or were publicly insured (68%). Caregiver self-reporting of child's race and ethnicity during interviews mostly agreed with the EMR-reported race and ethnicity, although more granularity was obtained during interviews. For example, those of Hispanic ethnicity often shared what country they were from when asked about their ethnicity; 2 individuals listed as “Black/African American” in the EMR were mixed including Black race, 2 individuals listed as “other” in the EMR reported themselves to be Hispanic, and 2 individuals listed as “declined to answer” in the EMR shared their race and ethnicity as White and Mixed Black/White. One-half had no-show rates of >10% for both cardiology and all hospital-system visits, with a median of 1.8 years from their missed cardiology appointment to the interview date. A wide range of complex heart disease was represented. Caregivers were primarily biological mothers, except for 1 father and 1 adoptive mother. Most interviews were conducted via audio-only conference call, with 1 via video conference and 1 in person.Table IDemographic characteristics of children of interviewed caregivers (n = 19)Demographic characteristicsValueComplex heart disease diagnosis Single ventricle disease with Fontan palliation4 (21) D-looped transposition of the great arteries4 (21) Atrioventricular canal defect3 (16) Tetralogy of Fallot2 (11) Truncus arteriosus1 (5) L-looped transposition of the great arteries1 (5) Small left-sided structures1 (5) Anomalous coronary artery from the opposite sinus1 (5) Dilated cardiomyopathy post-heart transplant1 (5) Aortopathy associated with Marfan syndrome1 (5)Female sex7 (37)Age at missed visit (years)9 [0-15] <12 (11) 1-44 (21) 5-126 (32) 13-187 (37)Lapse in time between missed visit and interview date (years)1.8 [0.1-2.7]Caregiver's primary language English14 (74) Spanish5 (26)Child's race and ethnicity (as reported by caregiver) American Indian1 (5) Black6 (32) Hispanic7 (37) Caribbean2 (11) Central American1 (5) South American1 (5) Unspecified3 (16) Mixed3 (16) White2 (11)COI (Massachusetts state normed) Very low9 (47) Low5 (26) Moderate1 (5) High2 (11) Very high2 (11)Public insurance13 (68)Maternal education (as reported during interview or in EMR) Did not complete high school or secondary school1 (5) Completed high school or secondary school7 (37) Attended college or graduate school5 (26) Missing data (not reported in EMR or during interview)6 (32)Driving distance from hospital (miles)15 [2-64]No show rate for all hospital visits∗12% [4%-27%]No show rate for cardiology visits∗8% [5%-28%]Values are number (%) or median [range].∗Denotes lifetime appointments within hospital system through the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, including testing and laboratory appointments. Table IDemographic characteristics of children of interviewed caregivers (n = 19)Demographic characteristicsValueComplex heart disease diagnosis Single ventricle disease with Fontan palliation4 (21) D-looped transposition of the great arteries4 (21) Atrioventricular canal defect3 (16) Tetralogy of Fallot2 (11) Truncus arteriosus1 (5) L-looped transposition of the great arteries1 (5) Small left-sided structures1 (5) Anomalous coronary artery from the opposite sinus1 (5) Dilated cardiomyopathy post-heart transplant1 (5) Aortopathy associated with Marfan syndrome1 (5)Female sex7 (37)Age at missed visit (years)9 [0-15] <12 (11) 1-44 (21) 5-126 (32) 13-187 (37)Lapse in time between missed visit and interview date (years)1.8 [0.1-2.7]Caregiver's primary language English14 (74) Spanish5 (26)Child's race and ethnicity (as reported by caregiver) American Indian1 (5) Black6 (32) Hispanic7 (37) Caribbean2 (11) Central American1 (5) South American1 (5) Unspecified3 (16) Mixed3 (16) White2 (11)COI (Massachusetts state normed) Very low9 (47) Low5 (26) Moderate1 (5) High2 (11) Very high2 (11)Public insurance13 (68)Maternal education (as reported during interview or in EMR) Did not complete high school or secondary school1 (5) Completed high school or secondary school7 (37) Attended college or graduate school5 (26) Missing data (not reported in EMR or during interview)6 (32)Driving distance from hospital (miles)15 [2-64]No show rate for all hospital visits∗12% [4%-27%]No show rate for cardiology visits∗8% [5%-28%]Values are number (%) or median [range].∗Denotes lifetime appointments within hospital system through the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, including testing and laboratory appointments. Demographic characteristics of children of interviewed caregivers (n = 19) Values are number (%) or median [range]. Denotes lifetime appointments within hospital system through the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, including testing and laboratory appointments. Themes From the 19 interviews, 5 overarching themes were identified: barriers to accessing care, facilitators of returning to and staying in care, impact of race and ethnicity, impact of heart disease diagnosis, and caregiver recommendations for improvement (Table II). Detailed, representative quotations representing each theme are included in Table III.Table IIThemes and subthemes identified from content analysis of semistructured interviewsThemesNo. of interviews (%)No. of quotesBarriers to accessing care19 (100)103 Hospital systems including appointment scheduling14 (74)29 Difficulties with parking and traffic8 (42)9 Challenges with rescheduling (provider availability, long phone wait time), late policy, and difficulty of using patient portal5 (26)7 Insufficient accessibility via phone, nursing calls4 (21)5 Inconvenient appointment times and locations3 (16)4 Length of appointment related to scheduling multiple visit components (echocardiogram, other)3 (16)4 Feeling rushed at appointments1 (5)2 Telehealth14 (74)24 Lack of in-person physical examination, laboratory test, imaging11 (58)14 Lack of comfort asking questions by telehealth vs in-person3 (16)4 Logistics of telehealth visits (eg internet connection, web link)2 (11)2 COVID-19 pandemic10 (53)20 COVID restrictions impeding access to care6 (32)6 Infectious risk with coming to hospital4 (21)4 Delayed care due to patient/caregiver COVID infection3 (16)6 Social vulnerability exacerbated by pandemic (finances, housing, employment, transportation)3 (16)4 Social vulnerability (existent prior to pandemic)10 (53)19 Transportation7 (37)8 Finances5 (26)6 Taking time off work3 (16)3 Housing1 (5)2 Language barrier∗6 (32)11 Interpreter adding additional time to visit∗4 (21)6 Insufficient information from provider; caregiver hesitation to ask for clarification∗3 (16)4Facilitators of returning and staying in care15 (79)37 Trusting relationship with multidisciplinary medical team11 (58)17 Perception of cardiology as a top priority8 (42)10 Convenience of staying home for telehealth visits5 (26)6 Financial resources provided by hospital∗2 (11)4Impact of race and ethnicity on care19 (100)19 No perceived impact19 (100)19Impact of cardiac disease diagnosis18 (95)66 Caregiver's physical and mental health9 (47)12 Need for flexibility/accessibility due to child's health needs8 (42)8 Stunting parent's professional growth: employment and education7 (37)9 Concern about child's health: activity restriction, reducing contacts7 (37)9 Finances7 (37)7 Impact on school for child6 (32)7 Strength from faith/religion4 (21)6 Child's physical and mental health3 (16)4 Lack of family support2 (11)2 Filtering online information1 (5)2 Difficulty sharing news initially1 (5)1Families' recommendations for improvement13 (68)23 Additional appointment times5 (26)5 More thorough medical explanations from providers; teach-back techniques to confirm caregiver's understanding∗4 (21)6 Having cardiac resources readily available for patients/families and noncardiac providers2 (11)3 Transportation resources3 (16)3 Different types of appointment reminders2 (11)2 Different care models for different ages2 (11)2 Mental health resources for patients/families1 (5)2 Patient-centered language for adolescents1 (5)1∗Only present in interviews with Spanish-speaking caregivers.Table IIIRepresentative quotations from identified themesBarriers to accessing care Hospital systems including appointment scheduling I hate getting there and then I'm driving all the way around [the patient parking garage]. They had to cancel it [the appointment], and then when I tried to reschedule it, they told me that they were booking way far out and I would have to call back at a later time. The way to make an appointment right now is kind of ridiculous. I was able to get through to the cardiology office through a phone call, but a lot of times they won't even let you call. You have to do it through the portal, and then they give you 2 dates to pick from. They gave me a 2:15 appointment. That's a nightmare. I don't know how I am gonna do that. I must have had no choice. I'm gonna have to figure out childcare and the whole thing. I'm gonna get stuck in traffic. I wind up spending my whole day in the hospital, which is very exhausting. It just felt really rushed… I didn't really feel like I had enough time to work through all of the questions that I wanted to address. Telehealth I didn't feel like a virtual visit was going to be really enough to address those concerns that I had. So I actually ended up canceling that appointment and asking for a later appointment where we could have an in-person examination. By observing the child and parents [in-person], you get a better sense of what's going on than you can over a 30 minute phone call when we're both sitting in front of a computer. they can really check exactly what's going on in his body and make sure everything is okay. The only thing that's easier [about virtual visits] is that you're not actually there. But I prefer to be there personally, because I feel like I can tell you everything, even though you can see her through the screen. Cardiology is a specialty where you really, really have to have hands on [the patient]. I like to have that stethoscope touching her chest to actually hear. I like them to get that real, live time O2 oximeter on her. We have an oximeter in our house, but there's nothing like the doctor's perspective. Now that he's getting older and learning to start to speak for himself, he has some questions as well that we've been talking about as a family. So I want to be able to have that in person, that way he can really address those questions and not have that awkward virtual discomfort. My cell phone connection was glitchy. The app would glitch. [There were] just so many other issues that made it [telehealth] frustrating. COVID-19 pandemic It [our appointment] got pushed back and rescheduled because there were so many other kids that had more pressing needs. I have to be very careful, because she's a kid that has heart problems. She's just always washing her hand. She wears 2 masks. It really did affect me because I didn't want her to get sick, because at the time she was getting sick a lot. When I was suffering from long COVID, I did miss a couple of appointments for her. We had a really, really hard time. We had no help from anyone. Nothing, nothing, nothing… Honestly, I am surprised because I don't know how we went through it, but we pulled through with work that I did because my husband got fired. It was very difficult during the pandemic since we had no papers, no social… We had nothing, nothing! Social vulnerability (existent prior to pandemic) I'm unemployed, so it's hard to get around. I'm taking public transportation, but I don't have the money to get on public transportation, so how am I gonna get around to appointments? It's difficult. It's very difficult. We run into many, many, many roadblocks. (Did it impact your ability to keep a job?) Yeah, absolutely, honestly, he's like 24 hours monitored, all the time, with me. We recently were homeless in the last 2 years, so we were in a shelter. Language barrier When I was younger and less experienced, there were times when the doctors explained to me what my child had, and when I didn't understand very well through the interpreter, I wouldn't ask anymore questions. There comes a time when you feel like, for the sake of not bothering the doctor or not feeling confident enough to ask anything you want, even the slightest thing, you may limit yourself.Facilitators of returning and staying in care I know that if there's any concerns that I bring up, he [primary cardiologist] takes it seriously. So I'm really thankful for that.If we're late for an appointment, they will call me right away like, ‘Is everything okay? Is there anything you need?’ That's not being intrusive, it's being supportive.When we talk about the hospital, for me it is life. It is salvation. It is gratitude. It is respect. It is knowing that people treat you with dignity and knowing that the doctors can hear your voice. If, God forbid, there's something wrong and had we just gone to that 7:30 echo they offered us and the doctors could have seen something and prevented something from happening.When they [cardiology] tell me to do something, I do it. When they tell me to be there, I'm there. I don't care what's going on on the outside, but I rearrange everything and I present my child because I can sleep better. I feel better. I'm like, okay, my doctor saw her. The convenience in your home. You don't drive. You don't looking for parking. They gave me meal vouchers. Since I was a newcomer, I had no money, I lived off the help I was given. For the cabs, they paid me because at that time I didn't have a car, I didn't drive.Impact of race and ethnicity It [race or ethnicity] hasn't impacted [care/treatment] at all. They treat her the same as they would with any other baby of a different race.Impact of cardiac disease diagnosis When she was first diagnosed, I was extremely anxious about it. It took me at least 6 months to have it all register and really realize that she was going to be okay. I couldn't sleep at night, crying and crying, while thinking about what I was going to do, what I could do. Me and my husband were pretty much traumatized. The beginning was really difficult. I remember every day [feeling] like I don't know how this child's future is going to be. I had to really alter my schedule and really make a whole lot of adjustments with my schedule and my personal life. I actually took some time off to really arrange my schedule so that I can get the best support for him in terms of physical therapy, occupational therapy, and all those other things to help him. [You] just need to be very flexible in this type of situation, and if your employer can't honor that then it's gonna be extremely challenging. They ended up letting me go, which it is what it is, but I had so many appointments that I had to go to for him, for my daughter, and for myself.It has impacted me being able to stay in school because I do have to work on top of school, and there's times where she does get sick and I do have to miss out many times in school to the point where I fail a class because I missed a test or something. Even to this day, it's hard for me to focus on a career. She wants to do so many things, but her condition kind of limits a lot of the things that she can do. I was so stressed that he might not [be able to] catch his breath a lot, or he might be too exhausted or overwhelmed because of his surgery. It [CHD diagnosis] changes your life economically, because I had money that I was saving to buy my first car and then I used it all, I spent it on my son. Sometimes I have it [money] and sometimes I don't, so I have to go out and borrow the money to get the medicine. [We would] not be able to pay for utilities sometimes in winter [due to medical expenses] when the electricity and gas bills are expensive. Early on it [impact on school] was an issue, but thankfully through a lot of intensive therapy, he's doing so much better. I was able to get him in some really good schools with lots of support with smaller classrooms where there were really lots of hands-on support. I told myself, God is gonna help us! As a family, we believe in God strongly. It definitely had a big impact on him, just feeling very ill in a lot of ways, very different from his peers. He takes off his shirt, and people would be like whoa, what's that? I think he's definitely gone through bouts of self-consciousness and self-esteem issues. There's support, but I can't fully depend on those supports, 100 percent, because I know with life being the way it is, everybody has a load of their own responsibilities. I had to stay away from the Internet. For some reason the Internet only shows you the worst case scenario. They don't tell you the great success rates and all the wonderful things that can happen. It was kind of hard to even share with some of my extended family because I didn't know how they would take it [impact of CHD diagnosis].Recommendations for improvement Even if the dad or mom is nervous, is sleepless and all that stuff, [since] they are not going to fully understand it, but they [care team] should always ask again, “Did you understand? There's no problem, we can repeat it because we know you are nervous…” I think using emails, voicemails, and especially text reminders for the appointments is pretty good. Now he's at the age where he's asking these questions and he wants to have a more concrete understanding and, from a parent perspective, it's a different kind of message when I tell him something vs when someone who might be a social worker says, “Hey, you know, it's part of what Marfan patients go through, and let's work through the emotional feelings that you're going through.” … I wish I had a social worker to work through and process some of that and the emotional stuff that comes with it. I think it's good to have resources where as a family I can gather more information, either on a website or different literature or different kinds of materials that we can digest later on… There's still more education that needs to be done, even for other medical professionals who are still learning. Table IIThemes and subthemes identified from content analysis of semistructured interviewsThemesNo. of interviews (%)No. of quotesBarriers to accessing care19 (100)103 Hospital systems including appointment scheduling14 (74)29 Difficulties with parking and traffic8 (42)9 Challenges with rescheduling (provider availability, long phone wait time), late policy, and difficulty of using patient portal5 (26)7 Insufficient accessibility via phone, nursing calls4 (21)5 Inconvenient appointment times and locations3 (16)4 Length of appointment related to scheduling multiple visit components (echocardiogram, other)3 (16)4 Feeling rushed at appointments1 (5)2 Telehealth14 (74)24 Lack of in-person physical examination, laboratory test, imaging11 (58)14 Lack of comfort asking questions by telehealth vs in-person3 (16)4 Logistics of telehealth visits (eg internet connection, web link)2 (11)2 COVID-19 pandemic10 (53)20 COVID restrictions impeding access to care6 (32)6 Infectious risk with coming to hospital4 (21)4 Delayed care due to patient/caregiver COVID infection3 (16)6 Social vulnerability exacerbated by pandemic (finances, housing, employment, transportation)3 (16)4 Social vulnerability (existent prior to pandemic)10 (53)19 Transportation7 (37)8 Finances5 (26)6 Taking time off work3 (16)3 Housing1 (5)2 Language barrier∗6 (32)11 Interpreter adding additional time to visit∗4 (21)6 Insufficient information from provider; caregiver hesitation to ask for clarification∗3 (16)4Facilitators of returning and staying in care15 (79)37 Trusting relationship with multidisciplinary medical team11 (58)17 Perception of cardiology as a top priority8 (42)10 Convenience of staying home for telehealth visits5 (26)6 Financial resources provided by hospital∗2 (11)4Impact of race and ethnicity on care19 (100)19 No perceived impact19 (100)19Impact of cardiac disease diagnosis18 (95)66 Caregiver's physical and mental health9 (47)12 Need for flexibility/accessibility due to child's health needs8 (42)8 Stunting parent's professional growth: employment and education7 (37)9 Concern about child's health: activity restriction, reducing contacts7 (37)9 Finances7 (37)7 Impact on school for child6 (32)7 Strength from faith/religion4 (21)6 Child's physical and mental health3 (16)4 Lack of family support2 (11)2 Filtering online information1 (5)2 Difficulty sharing news initially1 (5)1Families' recommendations for improvement13 (68)23 Additional appointment times5 (26)5 More thorough medical explanations from providers; teach-back techniques to confirm caregiver's understanding∗4 (21)6 Having cardiac resources readily available for patients/families and noncardiac providers2 (11)3 Transportation resources3 (16)3 Different types of appointment reminders2 (11)2 Different care models for different ages2 (11)2 Mental health resources for patients/families1 (5)2 Patient-centered language for adolescents1 (5)1∗Only present in interviews with Spanish-speaking caregivers. Themes and subthemes identified from content analysis of semistructured interviews Only present in interviews with Spanish-speaking caregivers. Table IIIRepresentative quotations from identified themesBarriers to accessing care Hospital systems including appointment scheduling I hate getting there and then I'm driving all the way around [the patient parking garage]. They had to cancel it [the appointment], and then when I tried to reschedule it, they told me that they were booking way far out and I would have to call back at a later time. The way to make an appointment right now is kind of ridiculous. I was able to get through to the cardiology office through a phone call, but a lot of times they won't even let you call. You have to do it through the portal, and then they give you 2 dates to pick from. They gave me a 2:15 appointment. That's a nightmare. I don't know how I am gonna do that. I must have had no choice. I'm gonna have to figure out childcare and the whole thing. I'm gonna get stuck in traffic. I wind up spending my whole day in the hospital, which is very exhausting. It just felt really rushed… I didn't really feel like I had enough time to work through all of the questions that I wanted to address. Telehealth I didn't feel like a virtual visit was going to be really enough to address those concerns that I had. So I actually ended up canceling that appointment and asking for a later appointment where we could have an in-person examination. By observing the child and parents [in-person], you get a better sense of what's going on than you can over a 30 minute phone call when we're both sitting in front of a computer. they can really check exactly what's going on in his body and make sure everything is okay. The only thing that's easier [about virtual visits] is that you're not actually there. But I prefer to be there personally, because I feel like I can tell you everything, even though you can see her through the screen. Cardiology is a specialty where you really, really have to have hands on [the patient]. I like to have that stethoscope touching her chest to actually hear. I like them to get that real, live time O2 oximeter on her. We have an oximeter in our house, but there's nothing like the doctor's perspective. Now that he's getting older and learning to start to speak for himself, he has some questions as well that we've been talking about as a family. So I want to be able to have that in person, that way he can really address those questions and not have that awkward virtual discomfort. My cell phone connection was glitchy. The app would glitch. [There were] just so many other issues that made it [telehealth] frustrating. COVID-19 pandemic It [our appointment] got pushed back and rescheduled because there were so many other kids that had more pressing needs. I have to be very careful, because she's a kid that has heart problems. She's just always washing her hand. She wears 2 masks. It really did affect me because I didn't want her to get sick, because at the time she was getting sick a lot. When I was suffering from long COVID, I did miss a couple of appointments for her. We had a really, really hard time. We had no help from anyone. Nothing, nothing, nothing… Honestly, I am surprised because I don't know how we went through it, but we pulled through with work that I did because my husband got fired. It was very difficult during the pandemic since we had no papers, no social… We had nothing, nothing! Social vulnerability (existent prior to pandemic) I'm unemployed, so it's hard to get around. I'm taking public transportation, but I don't have the money to get on public transportation, so how am I gonna get around to appointments? It's difficult. It's very difficult. We run into many, many, many roadblocks. (Did it impact your ability to keep a job?) Yeah, absolutely, honestly, he's like 24 hours monitored, all the time, with me. We recently were homeless in the last 2 years, so we were in a shelter. Language barrier When I was younger and less experienced, there were times when the doctors explained to me what my child had, and when I didn't understand very well through the interpreter, I wouldn't ask anymore questions. There comes a time when you feel like, for the sake of not bothering the doctor or not feeling confident enough to ask anything you want, even the slightest thing, you may limit yourself.Facilitators of returning and staying in care I know that if there's any concerns that I bring up, he [primary cardiologist] takes it seriously. So I'm really thankful for that.If we're late for an appointment, they will call me right away like, ‘Is everything okay? Is there anything you need?’ That's not being intrusive, it's being supportive.When we talk about the hospital, for me it is life. It is salvation. It is gratitude. It is respect. It is knowing that people treat you with dignity and knowing that the doctors can hear your voice. If, God forbid, there's something wrong and had we just gone to that 7:30 echo they offered us and the doctors could have seen something and prevented something from happening.When they [cardiology] tell me to do something, I do it. When they tell me to be there, I'm there. I don't care what's going on on the outside, but I rearrange everything and I present my child because I can sleep better. I feel better. I'm like, okay, my doctor saw her. The convenience in your home. You don't drive. You don't looking for parking. They gave me meal vouchers. Since I was a newcomer, I had no money, I lived off the help I was given. For the cabs, they paid me because at that time I didn't have a car, I didn't drive.Impact of race and ethnicity It [race or ethnicity] hasn't impacted [care/treatment] at all. They treat her the same as they would with any other baby of a different race.Impact of cardiac disease diagnosis When she was first diagnosed, I was extremely anxious about it. It took me at least 6 months to have it all register and really realize that she was going to be okay. I couldn't sleep at night, crying and crying, while thinking about what I was going to do, what I could do. Me and my husband were pretty much traumatized. The beginning was really difficult. I remember every day [feeling] like I don't know how this child's future is going to be. I had to really alter my schedule and really make a whole lot of adjustments with my schedule and my personal life. I actually took some time off to really arrange my schedule so that I can get the best support for him in terms of physical therapy, occupational therapy, and all those other things to help him. [You] just need to be very flexible in this type of situation, and if your employer can't honor that then it's gonna be extremely challenging. They ended up letting me go, which it is what it is, but I had so many appointments that I had to go to for him, for my daughter, and for myself.It has impacted me being able to stay in school because I do have to work on top of school, and there's times where she does get sick and I do have to miss out many times in school to the point where I fail a class because I missed a test or something. Even to this day, it's hard for me to focus on a career. She wants to do so many things, but her condition kind of limits a lot of the things that she can do. I was so stressed that he might not [be able to] catch his breath a lot, or he might be too exhausted or overwhelmed because of his surgery. It [CHD diagnosis] changes your life economically, because I had money that I was saving to buy my first car and then I used it all, I spent it on my son. Sometimes I have it [money] and sometimes I don't, so I have to go out and borrow the money to get the medicine. [We would] not be able to pay for utilities sometimes in winter [due to medical expenses] when the electricity and gas bills are expensive. Early on it [impact on school] was an issue, but thankfully through a lot of intensive therapy, he's doing so much better. I was able to get him in some really good schools with lots of support with smaller classrooms where there were really lots of hands-on support. I told myself, God is gonna help us! As a family, we believe in God strongly. It definitely had a big impact on him, just feeling very ill in a lot of ways, very different from his peers. He takes off his shirt, and people would be like whoa, what's that? I think he's definitely gone through bouts of self-consciousness and self-esteem issues. There's support, but I can't fully depend on those supports, 100 percent, because I know with life being the way it is, everybody has a load of their own responsibilities. I had to stay away from the Internet. For some reason the Internet only shows you the worst case scenario. They don't tell you the great success rates and all the wonderful things that can happen. It was kind of hard to even share with some of my extended family because I didn't know how they would take it [impact of CHD diagnosis].Recommendations for improvement Even if the dad or mom is nervous, is sleepless and all that stuff, [since] they are not going to fully understand it, but they [care team] should always ask again, “Did you understand? There's no problem, we can repeat it because we know you are nervous…” I think using emails, voicemails, and especially text reminders for the appointments is pretty good. Now he's at the age where he's asking these questions and he wants to have a more concrete understanding and, from a parent perspective, it's a different kind of message when I tell him something vs when someone who might be a social worker says, “Hey, you know, it's part of what Marfan patients go through, and let's work through the emotional feelings that you're going through.” … I wish I had a social worker to work through and process some of that and the emotional stuff that comes with it. I think it's good to have resources where as a family I can gather more information, either on a website or different literature or different kinds of materials that we can digest later on… There's still more education that needs to be done, even for other medical professionals who are still learning. Representative quotations from identified themes Barriers to Accessing Care Hospital Systems Including Appointment Scheduling Difficulties with navigating hospital systems were raised by 74% of caregivers. Scheduling or rescheduling appointments was challenging, with one caregiver noting that the process is “kind of ridiculous,” with the onus often on the family to make appointments via long phone wait times and limited patient portal scheduling at inconvenient appointment times. Timely nursing or provider communication was difficult to obtain, with several caregivers reporting “it's not easy to reach them [the clinic] by phone.” Telehealth Challenges and limitations with telehealth visits compared with in-person visits were reported by 74% of caregivers. In-person communication, physical examinations, laboratory tests, and imaging such as echocardiograms were perceived as essential components of the cardiac assessment of their child. In-person visits were seen as more useful and preferred, with several caregivers rationalizing, “I'm there and I can elaborate more.” Some caregivers expressed they or their children were less comfortable asking questions virtually, especially with an interpreter. Logistically, telehealth was frustrating when issues around internet connectivity arose. COVID-19 Pandemic About one-half (53%) of the caregivers cited the COVID-19 pandemic as a barrier due to restrictions impeding medical care access, new infectious risk visiting the hospital, delayed care from active COVID-19 infection, and exacerbated social vulnerability. Some shared how “we really haven't been able to follow up since COVID” and that they were “afraid” or “nervous” to come in. Appointments got pushed back by clinical team triage of urgency. One mother cited how their entire family contracting COVID-19 led to significant delays in a cardiac procedure her child needed. Some shared how the pandemic made their lives extremely difficult, particularly from a financial and social support standpoint. Social Vulnerability About one-half (53%) of the participants felt that unmet health-related social needs remained a barrier during the pandemic or were further exacerbated, particularly for transportation (37%), finances (26%), taking time off work (16%), and housing (5%). Transportation barriers included access to a car, need for rides to the clinic, distance to care, and gas prices. One caregiver shared, “I didn't have a car at the time, so the challenges were finding other people to drive me there.” Finances contributed to whether caregivers decided to travel to the clinic or save that money for more emergent needs; for example, one caregiver shared, “Let me save my gas, let me not leave my house for a couple of days to save the gas in my car for more of an emergency, like if I had to go grocery shopping.” Caregivers expressed concerns maintaining job security when needing to take time off for medical appointments. One caregiver shared that, during the pandemic, they became homeless and lived in a shelter far from the city without a car, which impacted their ability to keep appointments. Language Barrier All five Spanish-speaking caregivers, plus one English-speaking caregiver who reported Spanish as her primary language, cited language as a barrier to accessing care. Caregivers perceived that providers may not look favorably on the added time needed for interpreter use, with one caregiver sharing, “I imagine if a doctor is going to talk to you, he would prefer not to have to use an interpreter because it takes more time to translate.” They also voiced a lack of confidence or fear of bothering providers as barriers to asking questions or receiving clarification on information. Separately, one caregiver voiced that calling the clinic to request an interpreter could be stressful due to difficulty getting in touch and limited or delayed availability of interpreters. Facilitators of Returning to and Staying in Care Many caregivers (79%) shared facilitators that promoted returning to and staying in cardiology care centered on trusting patient-provider relationships (58%), cardiology care as a top priority (42%), convenience of telehealth visits (26%), and financial resources provided by the hospital (11%). With increased telehealth availability, some caregivers liked the convenience of staying at home without driving and parking. One Spanish-speaking caregiver shared how the financial resources that the hospital provided her family (including meal vouchers, food, and cab rides) positively impacted her ability to make her child's frequent appointments. Impact of Race and Ethnicity on Care Universally, when asked, “How have other people's perception of your child's race and ethnicity impacted your medical care?”, participants reported no effect on the care they received. One caregiver stated, “They treat her the same as they would with any other baby of a different race.” Other sentiments from caregivers included “he wasn't treated any differently” and “I feel like it didn't, it had nothing to do with that.” Impact of Cardiac Disease Diagnosis Caregivers (95%) recounted the dramatic impact on their own lives by the child's heart disease diagnosis, impacting caregiver physical and mental health, educational and employment opportunities, family finances, and support systems. Caregivers noted needing to remain flexible with their schedules to obtain care for their child, resulting in several caregivers sharing the sentiment of putting “a lot of things on the back burner,” needing to quit their jobs or being let go because of their children's appointments, hospital stays, or sick days. Consequently, the cardiac diagnosis substantially impacted some families' finances, with one caregiver sharing that it was “a challenge having to juggle with very little resources.” Caregivers noted “problems paying for lots of things” and a lack of reliable social support. Some caregivers reported drawing strength from God and their faith. Recommendations for Improvement Most caregivers (68%) shared recommendations for improving access to care, including more patient-centered communication for families and noncardiac providers, mental health resources, and patient-centered, educational language during visits. Caregivers desired additional appointment times on more days of the week and reminders across email, voicemail, and text. Spanish-speaking caregivers desired more thorough explanations and teach-back. Discussion These data offer a rich description of caregiver experience managing a child with complex heart disease. Hearing from a diverse racial, ethnic, and sociodemographic group, who missed cardiac care in the early pandemic, allowed for the emergence of important barriers to and facilitators of accessing pediatric ambulatory cardiology care. Perceived barriers to care included hospital systems such as challenging appointment scheduling, concerns with the completeness of telehealth, complicating factors from the COVID-19 pandemic, language barriers, and social vulnerability. Facilitators of care included trusted patient-provider relationships, family prioritization of cardiac care, benefits of telehealth, and financial support from the hospital. We found that English- and Spanish-speaking caregivers echoed similar barriers, with perhaps the most profound being social vulnerability for some families, sparked by their child's cardiac diagnosis and again exacerbated by the pandemic. Caregivers shared how their child's diagnosis complicated their lives through tighter finances and fragile employment or stunted education, with secondary effects on transportation availability and housing stability. They described worsening mental health for both caregivers and children. Our qualitative findings align with and expand upon the existing literature of quantitative studies that have established that factors including increased driving distance to clinic, disease severity, living in areas of lower COI, non-White race, lower maternal education, and public insurance status correlate with gaps in care.6,11,12,15,16,18 Their dynamic, evolving experiences underscore the need for regular, ongoing SDOH assessment during routine cardiology care and the provision of adequate and timely support through social work and patient navigator resources. Vouchers or gift cards for transportation, parking, gas, and food can enhance patient engagement and continuity of care by offsetting financial pressures. Despite the potential of telehealth to ease travel burden and time away from work, most caregivers preferred in-person care for the physical examination, concurrent diagnostic testing, and interpersonal connection with providers. Although telehealth also offered benefits to families through contactless continuity with their care team, it also brought many challenges, including technological difficulties, the need for broadband service, and communication difficulty. In our small cohort, telehealth preference depended on what caregivers felt their child needed at that moment and was not related to patient demographics, congruent with other studies during the early pandemic.19,20 Of note, caregivers did not perceive that their child's race or ethnicity impacted the care they received. Although it is possible that our center provided equitable care to children of all races and ethnicities, many studies have repeatedly demonstrated that racial and ethnic disparities exist in pediatric cardiology care outcomes, including disparate access to our own ambulatory clinic.11,15,21, 22, 23, 24, 25 Although we aimed to use bias-conscious wording during interviews, caregivers may not have fully shared their beliefs with interviewers, particularly if their races and ethnicities were not congruent or if they felt discomfort answering over phone. Specifically, for the Spanish-speaking caregivers of Hispanic children who universally felt that language was a barrier to care, there may have been cultural hesitancy in sharing honestly with medical professionals or a belief that their child was still receiving excellent medical care despite the language barrier. Health insurance was not mentioned as a barrier, despite the high cost of medical care for complex heart disease. This may be because all participants lived in Massachusetts, which offers universal government-funded healthcare for qualifying residents (MassHealth). Nonetheless, racial and SES disparities exist. Nearly one-half of US Medicaid-covered children with complex CHD did not receive recommended cardiology follow-up, with Black Medicaid-covered children less likely to have yearly follow-up compared with White Medicaid-covered children.23 Our findings identified actionable areas for improvement to facilitate ambulatory engagement, which we have pursued within the larger efforts of our heart center to reduce disparities. To reduce gaps-in-care, we initiated a Return-to-Care, Remain-in-Care working group to implement individual and population health interventions. We developed a dashboard of patients with complex heart disease with gaps-in-care to personalize outreach through phone calls and portal messaging and to reduce future gaps. We recruited additional members to our family advisory council to increase the racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic diversity. To address difficulties with navigating hospital systems around scheduling and rescheduling appointments, and timely communication with nurses and providers, the family advisory council developed a communication toolkit for families. Heart center-wide efforts are ongoing to increase awareness of disparities for non-English speaking families, ensuring timely interpreter services and encouraging family communication and education through visual tools and translated materials. To proactively identify and respond to health-related social needs, we collaborated with our ambulatory social workers and leadership to screen all families coming to our ambulatory clinics, developed a library of multilingual resource sheets with QR codes, and implemented a process for non-urgent and same-day social work consult based on need. To provide heart center-wide education on implicit bias and disparities in care in the clinical setting, we instituted Health Equity Rounds to raise awareness and disseminate strategies for equitable care.26,27 Although we have begun tackling many issues at an institutional level, much more work and advocacy are needed on the community and legislative levels to facilitate equitable healthcare for children with CHD, including government-funded insurance and assistance programs.11 Qualitative studies by design are foundational; therefore, limitations exist and findings may not be generalizable to other settings. Our intended participants missed appointments and thus were inherently difficult to contact and engage in research. This partially contributed to a long median of 1.8 years lapse between their missed appointment and the interview and could have led to recall bias. Further, we had incomplete capture of the lost-to-care population, since our recruitment relied on children missing scheduled appointments and answering our phone calls; we were unable to capture patients entirely lost-to-care. Interviews were largely conducted only with audio due to technological issues, which may have affected caregiver-interviewer interaction. Although we matched Hispanic, Spanish-speaking participants and interviewers, these caregivers may have experienced cultural hesitancy around research and sharing honestly with medical professionals. Last, the interviews occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic and may be particularly reflective of circumstances during that unique time, which may have changed since then. In conclusion, barriers to and facilitators of accessing ambulatory cardiology care were multifaceted in a cohort of diverse and socially vulnerable families caring for children with complex heart disease. Social vulnerability can be dynamic in nature; having a child with complex heart disease may increase pre-existing social vulnerability for a family. Understanding their experience can inform actionable areas of improvement to support access and continuity of care. Future work will include increasing awareness of disparities among staff, aligning efforts with our Family Advisory Council, using electronic patient dashboards to identify gaps in care, and screening for health-related social needs in our population. CRediT authorship contribution statement Larissa Wenren: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Validation, Software, Resources, Project administration, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Maria Perez Carballo: Writing – review & editing, Validation, Methodology, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Kira Fried: Writing – review & editing, Validation, Software, Project administration, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation. Rebecca Matulsky: Writing – review & editing, Software, Project administration, Data curation. Shannon Engstrand: Writing – review & editing, Software, Project administration, Investigation, Data curation. Tiffany Folks: Writing – review & editing, Investigation, Formal analysis, Conceptualization. Kathy Jenkins: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Conceptualization. Sarah de Ferranti: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Conceptualization. Susan Saleeb: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Supervision, Methodology, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Conceptualization. Jean Connor: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Visualization, Validation, Supervision, Resources, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Conceptualization. Declaration of Competing Interest LW was supported by the Boston Children's Hospital Fred Lovejoy House-staff Research and Education Fund. Potential, Perceived, or Real Conflicts of Interest: None.