Effects of rearing system and environmental enrichment on production performance and welfare of slow-growing broilers Authors: Haixuan Deng, Liuting Wu, Yibiao Zhang, Leilei Peng, Kunlong Qi, Yang Liu, Yinuo Wang, Yingjie Wang, Gang Shu, Xiaoling Zhao Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractAlthough consumers place significant emphasis on healthy poultry products, research on welfare-oriented production systems for broilers remains relatively scarce. This study aimed to explore a tailored production system to improve the welfare of slow-growing broilers. Totally 1350 females of Mountain Plum Blossom chickens from Southwest China were randomly allocated into four production systems, each with three replicates per group and 90 chickens per replicate. The systems included plastic net rearing without environmental enrichment (PNR+NEE group), free-range rearing without environmental enrichment (FR+NEE group), plastic net rearing with environmental enrichment (PNR+EE group), and free-range with environmental enrichment (FR+EE group). The environmental enrichment provided in this experiment consisted of sand bathing pool, perches, ramps, platforms, and hide houses. Results showed that the broilers reared in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups had higher final weight than those in the FR+NEE and FR+EE groups (P < 0.05). However, the FR groups, with or without environmental enrichment, showed a higher eviscerated percentage and lower abdominal fat weight and abdominal fat index than the PNR groups without environmental enrichment (P < 0.05). Meanwhile, the FR groups, with or without environmental enrichment, showed higher redness (a*) and yellowness (b*) values in breast muscles than the PNR groups with or without environmental enrichment (P < 0.05). Monounsaturated fatty acids in both breast and thigh muscle from the FR+NEE and FR+EE groups were higher than those from the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups (P < 0.05). Broilers in the FR+EE and PNR+EE groups had better welfare indicators, with lower feather scores and TI duration than the FR+NEE and PNR+NEE groups (P < 0.05). Notably, FR treatment increased serum dopamine levels compared with PNR treatments, regardless of with or without environmental enrichment (P < 0.05). In addition, serum TNF-α levels were lower in the FR+EE and PNR+EE groups than in the FR+NEE and PNR+NEE groups (P < 0.05). These results indicated that the production system with environmental enrichment optimized both animal welfare and meat quality, providing a practical system for broiler production.Keywords: Slow-growing broiler, Environmental enrichment, Rearing system, Animal welfare Introduction The increasing consumer demand for improved animal welfare and high-quality poultry products has prompted the poultry industry to reconsider conventional broiler production system (Campbell et al., 2025). Traditional cage and indoor pen systems are widely used because they maximize space utilization and production efficiency (Jin et al., 2019). However, accumulating evidence suggests that the severe spatial restriction in such systems can limit natural behaviors and locomotor activity, leading to a higher incidence of skeletal disorders and chronic stress in broilers (Kwon et al., 2024; Shields and Greger, 2013). Consequently, alternative rearing systems that better accommodate behavioral needs are gaining increasing attention in poultry production. Among these alternatives, free-range systems have been widely explored for their potential to improve both animal welfare and meat quality (Qiaoxian et al., 2020). Free-range systems allow broilers to express natural behaviors through increased space and environmental complexity, while environmental enrichment further enhances welfare conditions in poultry production (Ventura et al., 2010; Colditz et al., 2024). Environmental enrichment refers to modifications of the captive environment designed to increase behavioral opportunities and stimulate physical and cognitive activity, thereby improving the animals’ physiological and psychological well-being (Tahamtani et al., 2020). Various enrichment strategies have been investigated in broiler production systems. For example, the provision of sand baths and perches has been shown to improve physical condition and reduce undesirable behaviors such as feather pecking (Brantsæter et al., 2017; Yildirim et al., 2021). Moreover, structural enrichments such as ramps, platforms, and barriers can provide additional resting areas and stimulate locomotor activity, thereby reducing stress levels (Kang et al., 2024). Outdoor enrichment structures, including artificial shade and perches, may further enhance environmental complexity and improve thermal comfort for broilers with outdoor access (Chen et al., 2013; Santos et al., 2014). Collectively, these studies highlight the important role of environmental enrichment in promoting behavioral expression and improving the welfare status of broiler chickens. Despite the reported benefits of environmental enrichment, its effectiveness may vary depending on multiple factors, including lighting conditions (Kang, et al., 2024), stocking density (Anderson et al., 2021), and genotype (Mattioli et al., 2024). Moreover, most previous studies have examined enrichment strategies within a single housing system. Systematic evaluations that integrate environmental enrichment across different production systems remain limited. Therefore, a comprehensive assessment combining multiple rearing systems and enrichment strategies is necessary to better understand their combined effects on broiler welfare and productivity. Although free-range systems offer potential welfare benefits, they may also increase the exposure of birds to environmental pathogens and climatic challenges (Jeni et al., 2021), Therefore, chicken breeds with stronger immune capacity and better skeletal integrity are generally considered more suitable for free-range systems. Compared with fast-growing broilers, slow-growing broilers typically exhibit improved locomotor ability, enhanced disease resistance, and better adaptability to outdoor environments (Abdourhamane İ and Petek, 2024). These characteristics make slow-growing broilers particularly suitable for welfare-oriented production systems. The Mountain Plum Blossom chicken is a slow-growing broiler breed originating from the Qinba Mountain region of Southwest China, reaching a market weight of approximately 2.5 kg at 180 days of age (Ran et al., 2023). In the present study, we evaluated the effects of different production systems on growth performance, carcass traits, meat quality, skeletal development, physiological parameters, and welfare indicators in this breed. The objective of this study was to provide a comprehensive assessment of welfare-oriented production systems and to provide fundamental data for the application of welfare-oriented rearing systems in broiler production. Materials and methods Animals and treatments This study was conducted in Tongjiang County, Sichuan province, P. R. China (latitude 31° 53′ N, longitude 107° 05′ E; elevation 607.5 meters above sea level). A total of 1350 female Mountain Plum Blossom chickens with body weight 1.4 ± 0.25 kg on 105 d were adopted. All of them were vaccinated for Marek’s Disease. The experimental lasted from 105 d to 180 d. Birds were randomly assigned to 4 systems: plastic net rearing (PNR+NEE) system, plastic net rearing with environmental enrichment (PNR+EE) system (Fig. 1A), free-range rearing (FR+NEE) system, and free-range rearing with environmental enrichment (FR+EE) system (Fig. 1B). Each group had three replicates and 90 birds per replicate. Photographs of the two experimental rearing systems with enrichment. (A) Plastic net rearing system with enrichment (PNR+EE); (B) Free-range rearing system with enrichment (FR+EE); (C) Sand bath; (D) Shelter; (E) Platform and ramp. Diet formulation and feeding management Diet. All birds were provided with broiler diets. Its nutritional composition was shown in Table 1, which satisfied with the requirement of Chinese Feeding Standard of Chicken (Ministry of Agriculture PRC, 2004). Chickens had ad libitum access to both feed and water. Table 1Ingredients and nutrient composition of the basal diet.Table 1 dummy alt textIngredientsContentIngredientsContentCorn (%)63.0Soybean meal (%)21.0Wheat bran (%)3.0Limestone (%)8.83Dicalcium phosphate (%)1.07Choline Chloride (%)0.10Salt (%)0.40Premix (%)2.50Metabolizable energy (kcal/kg)2800Lysine (%)0.96Crude protein (%)18.0Available lysine (%)0.83Ether extract (%)4.12Methionine (%)0.4Ash (%)6.63Available methionine (%)0.36Crude fiber (%)3.9Cysteine (%)0.3Ca (%)0.96Methionine + Cysteine (%)0.7Total phosphorus (%)0.64Threonine (%)0.65Available phosphorus (%)0.3Tryptophan (%)0.2The premix provides per kg of diet: Vitamin A 14,300 IU, Vitamin D₃ 2,700 IU, Vitamin E 29 IU, Vitamin K₁ 0.80 mg, Vitamin B₁ 2.25 mg, Vitamin B₂ 8 mg, Vitamin B₆ 1.50 mg, Vitamin B₁₂ 0.03 mg, Niacin 35.75 mg, d-Pantothenic acid 7.00 mg, Folic acid 0.50 mg, Biotin 0.06 mg, Choline chloride 0.47 mg, Magnesium 87.50 mg, Iron 100.00 mg, Copper 5.00 mg, Zinc 75.00 mg, Iodine 350 mg. Ingredients and nutrient composition of the basal diet. The premix provides per kg of diet: Vitamin A 14,300 IU, Vitamin D₃ 2,700 IU, Vitamin E 29 IU, Vitamin K₁ 0.80 mg, Vitamin B₁ 2.25 mg, Vitamin B₂ 8 mg, Vitamin B₆ 1.50 mg, Vitamin B₁₂ 0.03 mg, Niacin 35.75 mg, d-Pantothenic acid 7.00 mg, Folic acid 0.50 mg, Biotin 0.06 mg, Choline chloride 0.47 mg, Magnesium 87.50 mg, Iron 100.00 mg, Copper 5.00 mg, Zinc 75.00 mg, Iodine 350 mg. Rearing System. During the experiment, the mean outdoor temperature and humidity were 25.4 °C and 75%, respectively, while the mean indoor temperature and humidity were 26.2 °C and 60%, respectively. Photoperiod for indoor rearing systems was 16 light:8 dark, with lights turned on at 6:00 and off at 22:00 per day, the same photoperiod was also applied in the houses of the free-range system. The PNR birds were raised in plastic net-floor pens, with pen size 8 m × 2 m, their stocking density was 5.625 birds per square meter. The FR groups were set in a pear orchard with 21,010.5 m². Each replicate unit had a mobile house (8 m × 2 m, stocking density: 5.625 birds/m²) and 20 m × 20 m outdoor areas (stocking density: 0.225 birds/m²) facilitated by fence. The outdoor areas were planted pear trees with a density of approximately 1 tree (height of 2.1 m) per square meter average. Environmental Enrichment. The enrichment facilities comprised a sand bathing pool (dimensions: 140 cm × 100 cm × 5 cm), perches (150 cm × 40 cm), ramps (67 cm × 83 cm × 50 cm), platforms as described by Bailie et al. (2013), and hide houses (140 cm × 100 cm × 55 cm), all constructed from wooden planks and polyethylene composite boards. The PNR+NEE group were not provided with any environmental enrichment. Conversely, the PNR+EE group had the enrichment facilities installed centrally. The FR+NEE group did not fix environmental enrichment outdoor, whereas the FR+EE group had enrichment facilities far away from 5 meters outdoor. Assessment of production performance Growth Performance. Body weight and feed intake were recorded at 105 and 180 days of age to calculate the average daily gain (ADG, g/d/chicken). Feed consumption was determined for each replicate by weighing the residual feed daily, thereby calculating the feed conversion ratio (FCR). Slaughter Performance and Carcass Traits. At 180 days, five hens per replicate were randomly selected from four treatment groups, respectively, and humanely euthanized via intravenous injection of sodium pentobarbital 20% (P0225-5 G, Ekear, Shanghai, China) following cervical dislocation. Carcass traits, including eviscerated weight, semi-eviscerated weight, breast muscle weight, abdominal fat weight, and organs weight, were measured. The organ index was calculated by dividing the organ weight by the body weight to ascertain the respective yields ((Weight of organ / Live weight) × 100). Meat Quality. Samples were collected from the left-side breast and drum muscles to measure pH value, flesh color, and shear force, in accordance with the guidelines of Chinese Performance Terms and Measurement Method for Poultry (NY/T 823-2020). The pH value was measured by a portable pH meter (Testo 205, TestoInc, Lenzkirch, Germany), with pH1 recorded at 45 min post-slaughter and pH2 measured after 24 h of storage at 2–8°C. Parameters L*, a*, and b* values were determined through triplicate measurements taken at three sites of each sample via a colorimeter (CR-300, Minolta Camera, Osaka, Japan), which equipped with illuminant D65 and an 8.0-mm diameter aperture, in according to the methodology described by Deng et al. (2022). Samples were grounded and analyzed using a near-infrared analyzer (F4020, Spectrastar, Guangdong, China) to determine moisture, crude protein, and crude fat content, with the methodology described by Prieto et al. (2014). After boiled for five minutes, the meat was carefully stripped of fascia and fat, then sectioned into cubes aligned with the muscle fibers, with a diameter of 12 mm and a length of 3 cm, for further assessment via a tenderness analyzer (TA.XTC-18, Bosin Tech, Shanghai, China). The peak force for each sample was recorded. For amino acid analysis, 0.5 g samples underwent hydrolysis in 6 mol/L HCl at 105°C for 24 h, followed by detection with a Hitachi analyzer (L-8900, Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan). The fatty acid composition was determined according to the procedure described by Suliman et al. (2023). Assessment of animal welfare The Welfare Quality® assessment was carried out on 180 d, with 10 birds per replicate randomly selected from each treatment group. Fearfulness. To avoid disturbing visual assessments on behaviors, tonic immobility (TI) tests were conducted prior to other evaluations. The TI procedure followed Fogelholm's method, birds were laid on their backs in a 50 cm U-shaped wooden cradle. Their chests were gently pressed for 10 s and then released gradually. We repeated the induction if the birds recovered within 30 s, with no more than three attempts per bird. The duration of tonic immobility was recorded once the response occurred, with a maximum duration of 10 min per test (Fogelholm et al., 2019). Appearance Evaluation. Feather coverage was assessed following Pichová's method (Pichová et al., 2017), using a handheld infrared thermography camera (Fotric 348+-L25, Shanghai, China). The EasyIR 1.0.1 software calculated the percentage of exposed skin area (pixels with elevated temperature) at selected abdominal and dorsal regions, with scores assigned as follows: 0 (no exposed skin), 1 ( ≤ 20% exposed), or 2 ( > 20% exposed), according to established criteria. Footpad Dermatitis. Footpad dermatitis (FPD) and hock burn were evaluated using a 5-point scale, where scores ranged from 0 (indicating no lesions) to 4 (indicating ulceration/scabbing, hemorrhage, or deep dermatitis for FPD, and brown/black discoloration with multiple lesions totaling more than 0.5 cm² for hock burn), with the highest score recorded from either foot or leg, as described by Riber et al. (2020). Development of Tibia. The development of the tibia was assessed through the quantification of fluctuating asymmetry (FA), following the methodology outlined by Buijs et al. (2012). Bilateral tibia length and tibia circumference were measured using vernier calipers, and FA values were derived from these measurements. The FA was calculated using the formula |R–L|/((R+L)/2), where R and L denote the measurements from the right and left sides of each bilateral trait (tibia length, tibia circumference), respectively. Serum Biochemical Indices. Before slaughter, blood samples (3.5 mL per bird) were collected from the brachial vein and stored in non-anticoagulant vacuum tubes. Immediately after collection, the blood samples were centrifuged at 4,000 × g for 10 m at 4 °C. The determination of serum biochemical indices was performed using commercially kits (Nanjing Jiancheng Institute of Bioengineering, Nanjing, China). The determined indices included: norepinephrine (NE), 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT), dopamine (DA), total superoxide dismutase (T-SOD), malondialdehyde (MDA), total antioxidant capacity (T-AOC), and tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α), interleukin-2 (IL-2), interleukin-6 (IL-6). Statistical analysis All statistical analyses were conducted utilizing SPSS software version 27.0 (IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA). For datasets exhibiting normal distribution, two-way analysis of variance was employed, followed by Tukey’s post hoc test for multiple comparisons, to assess growth performance, slaughter performance, meat quality, and skeletal characteristics. Conversely, non-normally distributed data pertaining to welfare evaluation were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. A significance threshold was established at P < 0.05. The correlation relationships among welfare indicators, slaughter performance, and meat quality were examined using Spearman’s correlation coefficients for continuous data. Data visualization and correlation analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism software (version 9.4.1, USA). Results Effects of production systems on growth performance Table 2 presents the growth performance parameters of birds from four systems. Final weight was significantly enhanced in the birds of PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups compared to those in FR+NEE and FR+EE groups (P < 0.05). However, no significant differences were observed in BWG, ADG, and FCR among the four groups (P > 0.05). Table 2Effects of the rearing systems on growth performances of birds.Table 2 dummy alt textTraitsPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEInitial weight (g)13981404134913471400.1950.8260.742Final weight (g)19532037192219332650.0340.1100.209BWG (g)55563357358658.70.3130.3530.133ADG (g)7.408.437.637.810.7840.6360.1660.315FCR10.7010.3010.5410.730.9150.5880.3140.096Data represents the means of 90 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; BWG = body weight gain; ADG = average daily gain; FCR = feed conversion ratio.a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on growth performances of birds. Data represents the means of 90 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; BWG = body weight gain; ADG = average daily gain; FCR = feed conversion ratio. a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on carcass trait The rearing system and environmental enrichment had notable impact on carcass traits (Table 3). The birds in the FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments exhibited higher semi-eviscerated weight and eviscerated percentage than those in PNR+NEE treatments (P < 0.05). Furthermore, the breast muscle percentage of chicken was significantly higher in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups than that in the FR+NEE and FR+EE groups (P < 0.05). In PNR systems, the semi-eviscerated weight and eviscerated percentage of chicken was significantly higher in the EE group than that in the NEE group (P < 0.05). Table 3Effects of the rearing systems on carcass traits of birds.Table 3 dummy alt textTraitsPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEDressing weight (g)17441846181917541380.5890.8000.019Semi-eviscerated weight (g)1490b1647a1646a1630a1410.0400.0450.013Eviscerated weight (g)11141209120311961070.1080.1630.062Breast muscle weight (g)20018717818548.60.1960.7480.304Thigh muscle weight (g)23425424523533.90.4540.7630.303Dressing percentage (%)92.093.192.491.31.060.7090.9600.242Semi-eviscerated percentage (%)79.183.383.784.94.230.0050.0130.137Eviscerated percentage (%)58.861.061.162.22.060.0340.0240.498Breast muscle percentage (%)18.0a15.6ab14.7b15.3b2.340.0150.2150.035Thigh muscle percentage (%)21.020.920.319.82.600.0600.3630.417Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on carcass traits of birds. Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on organ indexes Table 4 presents the organ weight and indexes of chickens in the four groups. The spleen weight and index of birds were higher in FR treatments with or without EE than those in PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). The liver weight and index were significantly increased in both FR treatments with or without EE compared with the PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). In addition, the weight and index of gizzard and proventriculus were elevated in FR treatments with or without EE compared with those in PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). Furthermore, the weight and index of abdominal fat were significantly reduced in FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments compared with those in PNR+NEE and PNR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). In PNR systems, the heart weight and index of birds were higher in EE group than those in NEE group (P < 0.05). Table 4Effects of the rearing systems on organ weights and index of birds.Table 4 dummy alt textTraitsPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEHeart weight (g)7.418.828.388.911.420.1490.0100.236Liver weight (g)37.440.944.743.85.350.0030.4220.187Spleen weight (g)2.813.254.816.011.78<0.0010.3690.053Gizzard weight (g)25.623.131.432.33.74<0.0010.4080.109Proventriculus weight (g)6.146.418.418.401.56<0.0010.7430.717Abdominal fat weight (g)91.693.858.644.919.7<0.0010.5100.363Heart index (%)0.3950.4480.4390.4650.0750.1450.0260.648Liver index (%)1.982.072.282.290.3260.0050.5900.638Spleen index (%)0.1510.1760.2550.3010.072<0.0010.4460.116Gizzard index (%)1.36b1.17b1.60a1.68a0.198<0.0010.3250.018Proventriculus index (%)0.3230.3330.4360.4480.084<0.0010.7790.925Abdominal fat index (%)7.537.164.613.582.05<0.0010.2760.611Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on organ weights and index of birds. Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on meat quality The meat quality indicators of the four groups are shown in Table 5, Table 6. The a* and b* value were higher in the breast muscles of chickens in the FR treatments compared to those in the PNR treatments (P < 0.05). The a* value and shear force were higher in the thigh muscles of chickens in the FR treatments with or without EE compared to those in the PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). In FR systems, the b* value and shear force of birds were higher in EE group than those in NEE group (P < 0.05). Table 5Effects of the rearing systems on breast muscle quality of birds.Table 5 dummy alt textBreastPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EECrude Protein (%)24.723.923.423.22.620.1410.4830.667Moisture (%)67.969.370.668.96.340.4940.9260.365Fat (%)3.653.013.563.470.1040.8580.1420.166L* value45.048.548.945.25.360.8730.9580.051a* value1.882.614.314.680.2580.0030.8120.460b* value6.706.517.828.861.010.0170.5560.384pH45min5.725.76.036.070.3670.9600.1030.668pH24h5.615.465.525.500.4990.2520.3890.745Drip loss (%)3.333.514.023.150.8820.1680.5640.116Shear force (N/kg)22.917.322.518.43.090.8600.0510.742Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on breast muscle quality of birds. Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Table 6Effects of the rearing systems on thigh muscle quality of birds.Table 6 dummy alt textThighPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EECrude Protein (%)24.523.323.623.22.700.5010.2310.523Moisture (%)72.471.170.371.21.930.2810.6930.173Fat (%)3.144.253.643.860.3270.0500.7350.543L* value44.345.342.742.34.280.6560.3220.024a* value12.111.812.513.42.240.0220.5600.125b* value6.616.755.177.120.9160.2600.0320.059pH45min6.045.986.146.180.2540.4210.3140.526pH24h5.855.765.885.780.3910.1890.3100.486Drip loss (%)3.533.393.193.540.6710.1280.1840.665Shear force (N/kg)23.927.829.938.02.050.0050.0050.204Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on thigh muscle quality of birds. Data represents the means of 15 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). The amino acid contents of breast and thigh muscle from four groups were shown in Table 7, Table 8, respectively. The cysteine contents were higher in the breast muscles of chickens in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE treatments than those in the FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). In PNR and FR systems, the glycine content in the thigh muscles of birds were higher in EE group than those in NEE group (P < 0.05). Table 7Effects of the rearing systems on amino acid contents in breast muscle of birds.Table 7 dummy alt textBreastPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEThreonine3.113.323.493.500.4390.4330.7510.781Valine3.673.583.563.900.3240.5050.4200.200Methionine1.741.902.002.050.3330.3560.8140.543Isoleucine3.103.243.333.460.5860.5580.7260.989Leucine5.395.645.886.050.9630.4980.7530.951Phenylalanine2.482.592.672.770.5210.5660.7550.980Lysine6.006.406.686.750.9170.4500.7240.807Histidine2.703.002.852.870.6050.9780.6620.689Aspartic acid6.566.527.047.061.020.4880.9850.974Serine2.732.732.982.950.4470.4350.9510.970Glutamic acid10.910.611.611.91.740.3930.9910.834Glycine3.063.093.113.460.4890.4880.5680.274Alanine4.204.044.094.410.3620.4820.6750.210Cysteine0.4190.3780.2970.3260.0510.0270.8820.315Tryptophan2.302.292.462.500.5020.4740.9590.909Arginine4.494.364.794.770.7410.4450.8850.908Proline2.422.512.672.590.4830.5430.9900.726∑EAA28.229.730.531.45.170.5060.6870.917∑NEAA38.237.540.040.86.400.4350.9990.816∑TAA66.467.170.572.18.130.3640.8090.926EAA/TAA0.4210.4430.4320.4340.1050.6670.0560.217EAA/NEAA0.7730.7970.7630.7750.0140.7680.0650.166Data represents the means of 6 broilers per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on amino acid contents in breast muscle of birds. Data represents the means of 6 broilers per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Table 8Effects of the rearing system on amino acid contents in thigh muscle of birds.Table 8 dummy alt textThighPNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEThreonine3.182.623.342.910.6700.5570.2140.878Valine3.122.543.242.850.6890.6510.3120.837Methionine1.761.301.901.530.4320.5630.2300.886Isoleucine3.032.953.163.030.3820.7890.7900.956Leucine5.394.545.555.280.4980.2210.1370.421Phenylalanine2.581.932.582.450.5470.5380.3620.533Lysine5.675.636.476.080.2840.6360.2980.993Histidine1.881.542.161.700.5130.4890.2360.845Aspartic acid6.445.736.566.680.6320.0760.2890.153Serine2.922.502.962.760.6910.6980.4220.769Glutamic acid11.510.411.810.92.750.6330.3920.786Glycine4.375.984.755.810.7950.7930.0080.489Alanine4.083.823.754.290.6290.8530.6950.293Cysteine0.4430.4240.4290.6020.2060.5310.5640.468Tryptophan2.411.942.642.230.3140.2470.0650.882Arginine4.734.754.604.900.7710.9830.6910.728Proline3.353.613.333.550.3990.8500.3040.930∑EAA26.623.128.425.83.650.0930.2240.789∑NEAA40.239.140.841.75.410.5870.9640.732∑TAA63.855.964.262.010.10.3310.2060.832EAA/TAA0.4200.4190.4440.4220.0040.6700.5080.710EAA/NEAA0.6610.5880.6960.6190.0320.4920.6990.591Data represents the means of 6 broilers per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system;a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing system on amino acid contents in thigh muscle of birds. Data represents the means of 6 broilers per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). The fatty acid contents of breast and thigh muscle from four groups were shown in Table 9, Table 10, respectively. The C16:1 and C20:3n6 content in the breast muscle of chickens was increased in the FR treatments with or without EE compared with the PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). The contents of C14:1 and monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) were affected by the interaction between rearing system and environmental enrichment. Specifically, the C14:1 and MUFA contents in the breast muscle of birds in the FR+EE treatment were higher than those in the PNR+NEE treatment (P < 0.05). The contents of C14:0 in the thigh muscles of chickens were increased in the PNR treatments with or without EE compared with the FR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). However, the contents of C14:1, C16:1, C17:1, C18:1n9 and C22:6n3 in the thigh muscles of chickens were increased in the FR treatments compared with the PNR treatments (P < 0.05). Overall, monounsaturated fatty acids contents in both breast and thigh muscles of chickens were higher in the FR treatments with or without EE than that in the PNR treatments with or without EE (P < 0.05). Table 9Effects of the rearing systems on fatty acid contents in breast muscle of birds.Table 9 dummy alt textBreast(μg/g)PNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEC4:00.0890.0940.1150.1000.0260.1010.9030.248C10:01.582.221.632.190.1570.1930.2380.290C14:06.715.825.723.101.030.3850.5960.052C15:021.824.224.721.34.320.9950.4430.881C16:070.270.371.667.46.540.0550.0980.150C17:00.3010.7950.6551.430.3170.1200.6320.057C22:00.9051.091.081.430.2900.0050.8420.236C23:039.843.048.143.74.680.2510.2910.678C14:10.431b0.775b2.43a2.07a0.2840.0090.3100.041C16:118.922.341.157.13.720.0040.2060.399C17:12.813.814.204.910.4440.1220.8490.265C18:1n923226725729037.20.9010.1870.911C20:1n90.3920.1960.5620.4260.1960.3580.6550.063C18:2n614014415515221.40.4230.8080.977C18:3n61.010.6931.311.180.3970.1180.3260.627C18:3n32.023.153.485.040.6680.3570.1690.578C20:3n61.442.022.973.640.5090.0110.8170.172C20:5n30.7620.5440.7300.6520.2630.8120.6600.364C22:6n30.560.720.760.660.1100.5540.3110.819∑ SFA13414114713714.20.4520.1780.800∑ MUFA255b294ab305ab354a34.90.0110.7790.030∑ PUFA14615116416320.70.3020.8250.889PUFA/SFA1.091.071.121.200.1380.4220.6110.785Data represents the means of 6 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; SFA = saturated fatty acids (C4:0, C10:0, C14:0, C13:0, C14:0, C15:0, C16:0, C17:0, C22:0, C23:0); MUFA = monounsaturated fatty acids (C14:1, C16:1, C17:1, C18:1n9c, C18:1n9); PUFA = polyunsaturated fatty acids (C18:2n6, C18:3n6, C18:3n3, C20:3n6, C22:6n3).a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on fatty acid contents in breast muscle of birds. Data represents the means of 6 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; SFA = saturated fatty acids (C4:0, C10:0, C14:0, C13:0, C14:0, C15:0, C16:0, C17:0, C22:0, C23:0); MUFA = monounsaturated fatty acids (C14:1, C16:1, C17:1, C18:1n9c, C18:1n9); PUFA = polyunsaturated fatty acids (C18:2n6, C18:3n6, C18:3n3, C20:3n6, C22:6n3). a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Table 10Effects of the rearing systems on fatty acid profiles of thigh muscle in birds.Table 10 dummy alt textThigh(μg/g)PNRFRSEMP valueNEEEENEEEERSEERS × EEC4:00.0630.0630.0440.0320.0150.0340.4860.743C10:00.5430.9650.5250.5880.2260.1860.1170.210C14:018.419.917.217.21.630.0060.1700.166C15:024.927.628.024.52.390.9970.6240.107C16:033733237736230.10.0540.5550.764C17:02.852.802.192.470.8430.2470.7740.685C22:01.562.102.161.590.6650.9500.9710.210C23:07681.677.472.610.60.4940.9670.382C14:12.132.203.063.490.353<0.0010.2330.366C16:166.563.9126.91318.25<0.0010.8920.464C17:15.085.185.915.630.3240.0300.7090.457C18:1n946455366465551.10.0020.2670.181C20:1n90.4530.4900.4390.4970.1060.9580.4740.873C18:2n630931430630217.00.4330.9300.606C18:3n62.643.242.393.590.6190.8720.0690.369C18:3n310.512.512.712.11.400.3910.5010.258C20:3n65.965.516.606.680.8560.1000.7150.606C20:5n30.8261.101.370.9490.3980.3750.7310.138C22:6n311.110.812.413.01.710.0260.8210.522∑ SFA44244748646334.70.1320.6390.476∑ MUFA53862580079554.3<0.0010.2160.168∑ PUFA34034734133818.80.7070.8070.572PUFA/SFA0.7690.7820.7050.7340.0620.1950.6310.872Data represents the means of 6 broiler chickens per treatment.PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; SFA = saturated fatty acids (C4:0, C10:0, C14:0, C13:0, C14:0, C15:0, C16:0, C17:0, C22:0, C23:0); MUFA = monounsaturated fatty acids (C14:1, C16:1, C17:1, C18:1n9c, C18:1n9); PUFA = polyunsaturated fatty acids (C18:2n6, C18:3n6, C18:3n3, C20:3n6, C22:6n3).a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on fatty acid profiles of thigh muscle in birds. Data represents the means of 6 broiler chickens per treatment. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; RS = rearing system; SFA = saturated fatty acids (C4:0, C10:0, C14:0, C13:0, C14:0, C15:0, C16:0, C17:0, C22:0, C23:0); MUFA = monounsaturated fatty acids (C14:1, C16:1, C17:1, C18:1n9c, C18:1n9); PUFA = polyunsaturated fatty acids (C18:2n6, C18:3n6, C18:3n3, C20:3n6, C22:6n3). a-c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on welfare indicators Fig. 2 presents the welfare indicators of broiler from the four groups. Feather score was higher in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups than that in the FR+NEE and FR+EE groups, and PNR+NEE and FR+NEE groups was higher than that in the PNR+EE and FR+EE groups (P < 0.05). The footpad score and hock burn score were also increased in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE groups compared with the FR+NEE and FR+EE groups (P < 0.05). Compared with the PNR treatments with or without EE, the TI duration of broilers in the FR treatments with or without EE were decreased. Compared with the NEE treatments, the TI duration of broilers in the EE treatments were decreased, (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on welfare status of birds. Column presents welfare indicators for birds from different rearing systems on 180 days of age. Higher value indicates poorer welfare conditions. PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range rearing system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; Data were shown as means ± SEM (n = 15). a–c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on skeletal development of tibia The tibial skeletal development of chickens in the 4 groups were shown in Fig. 3. The tibia length FA value was affected by the interaction between rearing system and environmental enrichment. Specifically, the tibia length FA value of birds in the PNR+NEE treatment were higher than those in the PNR+EE, FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). In addition, the tibia circumference was affected by the interaction between rearing system and environmental enrichment. Specifically, the tibia circumference of birds in the PNR+NEE treatment were higher than those in the PNR+EE treatment (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on the tibia development of birds. Column presents tibia and ulna indicators for birds from different rearing systems on 180 days of age. FA: fluctuating asymmetry; PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range rearing system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; Data were expressed as means ± SEM (n = 15). a–c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Effects of production systems on serum biochemical indices Fig. 4 shows the serum biochemical parameters of broilers among the four groups. The PNR treatments exhibited higher MDA content of chicken than the FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). In contrast, T-AOC levels were higher in FR treatments than in the PNR treatments, and higher in the EE treatments than in the NEE treatments (P < 0.05). Furthermore, the PNR+NEE and FR+NEE treatments exhibited higher serum NE levels in chickens than the PNR+EE and FR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). In addition, DA levels were higher in the FR+NEE and FR+EE treatments than in the PNR+NEE and PNR+EE treatments (P < 0.05). Serum DA levels were significantly higher in the EE treatments than in the NEE treatments under both the FR and PNR systems (P < 0.05). The TNF-α level in broilers was lower in the EE treatments than in the NEE treatments under both the FR and PNR systems (P < 0.05). The IL-2 level was increased in the EE treatments than in the NEE treatments under both the FR and PNR systems (P < 0.05). Effects of the rearing systems on serum biochemistry of birds. Column presents serum biochemistry indicators for birds from different rearing systems on 180 days of age. NE: norepinephrine; 5-HT: 5-hydroxytryptamine; DA: dopamine; T-SOD: total superoxide dismutase; MDA: malondialdehyde; T-AOC: total antioxidant capacity; TNF-α: tumor necrosis factor-α; IL-2: Interleukin-2; IL-6: Interleukin-6; PNR = plastic net rearing system; FR = free-range rearing system; NEE = no-environment enrichment; EE = environment enrichment; Data were expressed as means ± SEM (n = 15). a–c Mean within a row lacking a common superscript differ significantly (P < 0.05). Correlation analysis between slaughter performance and welfare indicators Fig. 5A shows the correlation analysis between slaughter performance and welfare indicators. Feather score and tibia length FA value were positively correlated with the breast muscle percentage (P < 0.05). Hock burn and tibia length FA value were negatively correlated with eviscerated yield (P < 0.05). Moreover, hock burn score, TI duration, tibia length FA value were negative correlated with heart index in chickens (P < 0.05). Correlation heatmap of slaughter performance (A), meat quality (B) and welfare indicators in birds. The heatmap illustrates the relationships between welfare indicators and slaughter performance and meat quality with varying abundance, where the vertical axis representing slaughter indicators, horizontal axis representing welfare indicators, each cell indicates the correlation coefficients and their strength, with darker shades indicating stronger inter-indicator correlations. *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01. Correlation analysis between meat quality and welfare indicators Fig. 5B shows the correlation analysis between meat quality and welfare indicators. Hock burn score was negatively correlated with thigh muscle shear force (P < 0.05), and TI duration was negatively correlated with thigh muscle a* value (P < 0.05). Tibia breaking strength and tibia index were positively correlated with breast muscle a* value, and tibia index was negatively correlated with pH24h in the breast muscle (P < 0.05). Discussion The present study systematically evaluated the effects of several production systems on production performance and welfare indicators in slow-growing broilers. The results indicated that incorporating environmental enrichment in free-range rearing systems can further improve broiler welfare and meat quality, providing a practical model for broiler production. Growth performance is a key indicator for evaluating production efficiency in poultry systems (Li et al., 2017). In the current study, welfare-oriented system slightly decreased body weights but increased the eviscerated yield, which is directly associated with improved economic return due to its close relationship with meat yield (Zhao et al., 2024). In contrast, the plastic net rearing system resulted in a higher abdominal fat percentage, possibly indicating that restricted movement limits energy expenditure and promotes lipid deposition in broilers (Chen et al., 2023). These finding are consistent with the previous studies reporting greater abdominal fat accumulation in caged broilers compared with birds raised in alternative production system (Yan et al., 2021; Song et al., 2022). Organ indices are widely used as indicators of organ development and physiological function in poultry (Zhang et al., 2025a). In the present study, free-range broilers exhibited larger gizzard and proventriculus indices compared with plastic net rearing birds. A prior research has demonstrated that the ingestion of fibrous materials, grit, and other natural particles in outdoor environments stimulates mechanical digestion and promotes the development of digestive organs in broilers (González-Alvarado et al., 2008). In the present experiment, liver weight and liver index increased while abdominal fat rate decreased in free-range broilers, suggesting that free rearing strengthened liver metabolism and reduced fat accumulation (Niamat et al., 2025). In addition, our results showed that welfare-oriented production systems increased both the heart weight and heart index of broilers. Increased locomotor activity in free-range environments has been shown to stimulate cardiovascular development and elevate heart index in broilers (Wang et al., 2021). Similarly, higher activity levels can enhance energy expenditure and reduce lipid deposition (Li et al., 2025). Therefore, the increased heart index and reduced abdominal fat percentage of broilers in free-range systems are likely associated with increased physical activity facilitated by environmental enrichment and outdoor access. Indicators of meat quality are essential for assessing the quality of poultry meat. Meat color is primarily determined by myoglobin concentration in muscle tissue and strongly influences consumer purchasing decisions (Majdi Abdelfaraj et al., 2023). In the present study, broilers raised in welfare-oriented systems exhibited higher redness (a*) and yellowness (b*) values, which is consistent with previous reports on free-range chickens (Wang et al., 2009). It is hypothesized that increased physical activity in free-range environments promotes the development of oxidative muscle fibers and elevates myoglobin content, which may contribute to the observed changes in meat color (Altmann et al., 2023). The elevated shear force observed in FR and EE treatments reflects a increase in chewiness, which may be attributed to enhanced muscle fiber development induced by higher physical activity in free-range and enriched systems. Flavor is another critical determinant of consumer acceptance of meat products and results from complex interactions between taste and aroma compounds (Sitz et al., 2005). Amino acid and fatty acid composition are important contributors to meat flavor characteristics (Liu et al., 2023b). Amino acids such as glutamic acid, alanine, aspartic acid, and glycine are recognized as key contributors to umami flavor in chicken meat (Zhang et al., 2022). In the present study, broilers raised in enrichment systems exhibited higher glycine content in thigh muscle compared with normal broilers, although total amino acid contents did not differ significantly among groups. These results potentially suggest that enrichment conditions may promote the deposition of certain flavor-related amino acids without substantially altering overall amino acid. Free-range rearing also improved external welfare indicators and skeletal integrity, which may be associated with increased locomotor activity. Feather condition is a recognized indicator of broiler welfare status (Saraiva et al., 2016), and improved feather coverage observed in free-range birds may be attributed to greater space allowance and reduced feather pecking associated with lower stocking density (Baxter et al., 2018). Environmental enrichment can further stimulate behavioral activity and promote adaptive behavioral responses in poultry (Bonnefous et al., 2022). We found that environmental enrichment exerted a more remarkable improving effect on feather condition of broilers in plastic net rearing systems than in free-range systems. FA is regarded a measure of developmental stability, with higher asymmetry values resulting in worse skeletal functional morphology (Carla et al., 2015). We found that the free-range system and environmental enrichment had positive effects on reducing tibia length FA in broiler chickens. These findings support the conclusion that rearing systems restricting movement can negatively affect skeletal health and overall welfare. Physiological and immunological responses further indicated that welfare-oriented systems promoted improved biological resilience. Serum biochemical parameters are sensitive indicators of physiological status (Liu et al., 2023a; Zhang et al., 2025b), and elevated dopamine levels in the EE groups suggest enhanced positive affective states and greater engagement in natural foraging behavior (Kang et al., 2020; Moe et al., 2014). Outdoor systems and environmental enrichment were also associated with enhanced antioxidant capacity, as reflected by higher T-AOC, a comprehensive indicator of systemic redox balance (Han et al., 2020). Although free-range exposure increased serum TNF-α levels and spleen index, indicating greater immune activation likely due to environmental antigen challenge (Tong et al., 2015), enrichment appeared to modulate this response by reducing TNF-α and increasing IL-2 levels, thereby promoting a more balanced immune regulation (Stefanetti et al., 2023). Collectively, these results may suggest that production systems encouraging activity and behavioral expression could enhance skeletal robustness, antioxidant defense, and immune adaptability in broilers. The eviscerated yield serves as a crucial metric reflecting poultry meat production, with direct implications for economic efficiency (Yushanaji et al., 2025). In this study, broilers exhibiting lower hock burn scores and tibia length FA value had higher eviscerated yield. This indicates that improving animal welfare conditions may promote economic benefits. Additionally, the heart index was found to be significantly negative correlated with hock burn score, TI duration, and tibia length FA value in broilers, indicating that a higher heart index may be associated with improved animal welfare status. High heart index is likely due to increased physical activity (Ren et al., 2024), which concurrently elevates overall welfare levels. Increased exercise levels raise myoglobin content, thereby enhancing the a* value of meat (Özbek et al., 2020). Our study identified a significant correlation between the a* value of meat and the TI duration, tibia breaking strength, and tibia index in broilers, which suggests that improving broiler welfare may be linked to enhancing both skeletal development and meat quality. Generally, the welfare-oriented production systems improved carcass traits and meat quality of broilers, which may be associated with elevated locomotor activity. In the present study, the free-range area was large and covered with dense vegetation, which prevented us from systematically recording the behaviors and physical activity of broilers. Consequently, we failed to obtain intuitive data on their exercise indicators. While the indoor lighting regime was standardized, free-range birds were also exposed to natural daylight. Differences in photoperiod therefore served as a potential confounding factor. Additionally, all experimental data were collected from female chickens only. In future research, we will include broilers of both sexes for comparative measurements and strive to acquire behavioral and activity data of chickens reared in different systems. Conclusion The welfare-oriented production systems effectively enhanced the welfare status and meat quality of slow-growing broilers. The free-range conditions with environmental enrichment system significantly improved the meat color, skeletal development and immunity of chickens, while reducing abdominal fat deposition and fearfulness response. These findings indicate that environmental enrichment can optimize broilers’ immune function and welfare status, which may be associated with increased locomotor activity. Ethics approval and consent to participate All experimental animals were applied in agreement with requirements for experimental animal operation and animal welfare proposed by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Sichuan Agricultural University, China (Approval No. 20240516; Chengdu, Sichuan, China). Author contribution Haixuan Deng and Liuting Wu carried out all animal trials and sample detection, analyzed experimental data, and finished the draft of this manuscript. Gang Shu assisted in optimizing the experimental design and polishing the language of this paper. Xiaoling Zhao designed this project, supervised the whole progress of this study, revised and improved the manuscript. Research funding We would like to thank the National Key R&D Program (Grant number 2025YFF1000102) and Sichuan Provincial Natural Science Foundation Outstanding Youth Science Fund Project (Grant No. 24NSFJQ0121) and Municipal-University Cooperation Project from Bazhong City for their financial support. Disclosures The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper. Acknowledgements Yibiao Zhang, Leilei Peng, and Kunlong Qi participated in animal feeding and sample collection work, and assisted in sorting out partial experimental data. Yang Liu, Yinuo Wang, and Yingjie Wang took part in sample collection and drawing charts. References