Interactive effects of field pea genotypes and Rhizobium Leguminosarum strains on nodulation, yield, and nitrogen fixation in Sinana district, Ethiopia Authors: Tesfahun Kassahun, Habtamu Admas Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractField pea (Pisum sativum L.) is one of the most important food legumes in the highlands of Ethiopia, but its productivity in Sinana District is limited by poor soil fertility and inefficient biological nitrogen fixation (BNF). This study examined the joint effects of field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on nodulation, yield, nutrient uptake, and nitrogen fixation in greenhouse and field experiments. Two strains (EAL 300 and EAL 302), their mixture, and a control were compared for three varieties (local, ‘Wayitu’, and ‘Dadimos’) in a factorial randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replications. Greenhouse experiments showed that EAL 302 had better survival ability on seeds, competitiveness, and symbiotic efficiency than EAL 300. In the field experiment, significant interactions between genotypes and strains were found for nodulation and straw yield. Inoculation with EAL 302 increased nodule dry weight, plant dry matter, grain yield (2900 kg ha⁻¹), straw yield (5633 kg ha⁻¹), total Nitrogen (TN) uptake (169.7 kg N ha⁻¹), and total nitrogen fixed (242 kg N ha⁻¹) significantly compared with the uninoculated control. Among varieties, ‘Wayitu’ had the highest grain yield (2876 kg ha⁻¹) and better nodulation and nutrient uptake. The combination of ‘Wayitu’ and EAL 302 was found to be the most effective symbiotic combination. The results clearly show that genotype-strain interaction is an important factor in improving BNF and yield. Inoculation with EAL 302, especially ‘Wayitu’, is recommended as a promising inoculation strategy to improve field pea yield, nitrogen fixation, and soil nitrogen status in Sinana District.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12870-026-09271-6.Keywords: Field pea, Pisum sativum, Rhizobium leguminosarum, Biological nitrogen fixation, Nodulation Introduction Background One of the most popular and affordable protein sources, field peas provides a sizable household income for farmers. In addition, it is an important break crop in cereal-based agricultural systems, especially in the Bale zone [2]. Due to its widespread use and significance, this crop ranks first in the Bale zone and second nationally among food legume crops [10]. However, inadequate production plans and poor soil physical and chemical characteristics are the main causes of low yield, which is typically unsatisfactory [21]. It is obviously understood that commercial fertilizers have helped to improve yields of some pulse crops. However, farmers are reluctant to use sources of inorganic N fertilizers because of the associated management problems and the higher costs compared with organic N fertilizers. Although the use of mineral N fertilizer in production has increased substantially, its (agronomic) use efficiency is less than 50%. More than one-half of the applied N is lost through various processes, resulting in higher production costs and considerable environmental disturbances [43]. Thus, farmers are now looking for alternatives to these fertilizers. One way to lessen the need for industrially fixed nitrogen is to take advantage of symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Economic and environmental challenges force the reduction of fertilizer use and the maximization of in-situ biological nitrogen fixation, even though intensive agricultural systems are often maintained by the extensive use of industrially fixed nitrogen. The process by which some rhizobium bacteria and legume crops cooperate to extract nitrogen from the soil air surrounding the plant’s roots is known as symbiotic nitrogen fixation. About 78% of the nitrogen in the air contained in the soil’s tiny pores is gaseous (N2). The N cannot be utilized by plants in this form. Nonetheless, gaseous nitrogen can be fixed by rhizobia in the root nodules so that plants can use it. A significant amount of energy is needed for this procedure. The rhizobium in the nodules receives energy, nutrients, and water from the plant and the rhizobium returns the favor by giving the plant nitrogen. The pulse crop, its dry matter production, the amount of accessible soil N, and other environmental factors all affect how much N2 is fixed [11]. As long as Rhizobium leguminosarum, an N-fixing bacteria, has colonized the roots, field pea is a legume that can meet some of its N needs through biological processes. According to production guidelines, biological fixation can provide between 30% and 80% of the N required for field peas [19]. Creating low-input systems that are both sustainable and profitable is now the main obstacle facing research on boosting food production in tropical Africa. Legumes’ primary benefit in this regard is their ability to increase soil organic nitrogen levels to a point where a sufficient quantity is available for crops in the future [6]. Therefore, there are many benefits to inoculating with a persistent and effective strain of rhizobium, including the avoidance of the need to apply nitrogen fertilizers repeatedly [37]. Therefore, when it comes to biological nitrogen fixation, matching host genotypes and rhizobial strains is the most relevant criterion. According to an ICARDA study, strain-cultivar interactions have been noted in faba beans and chickpeas on plant response measures such herbage yield, nodule number, nodule mass, and plant vigour, but they seem to be negligible in lentil, lathyrus, and vetch [4]. Effective inoculation is necessary to sustain a high number of viable bacteria until they are able to nodulate the roots, which is necessary for good nodulation to occur. However, rhizobium strains that can nodulate the host legume must be present in the soil for a symbiosis to establish. Effective rhizobial strains, on the other hand, must be made available to farmers as seed inoculants because they are frequently either absent from soils or present in very little amounts [12]. There is currently relatively little data about BNF research in Ethiopia [25]. Nevertheless the significance of field pea production in Sinana District, there has been limited scientific investigation on the interactive effects of field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains in the area’s agro-ecological conditions. In most previous investigations, the focus was on the evaluation of varieties or inoculation effects, without considering the compatibility of strains and genotypes and its effects on the efficiency of nitrogen fixation. As such, there are no location-specific recommendations on inoculants for the area. This investigation is the first of its kind in Sinana District, aimed at investigating the interactive effects of various field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on nodulation, nitrogen fixation, and yield performance. Objectives of the study General objective The main aim of this study is to assess the interactive effects of field pea genotypes and strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum on nodulation, yield performance, and biological nitrogen fixation in Sinana District, Ethiopia. Specific objectives ✓ To establish the influence of various field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on the nodulation traits. ✓ To establish the influence of various field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on the nodulation traits. ✓ To evaluate the impact of genotype-Rhizobium strain interaction on the growth attributes and grain yield of field pea in the study area. ✓ To evaluate the impact of genotype-Rhizobium strain interaction on the growth attributes and grain yield of field pea in the study area. ✓ To estimate the contribution of biological nitrogen fixation due to various genotype-strain interactions and to determine the most effective symbiotic combinations for enhanced productivity in Sinana district. ✓ To estimate the contribution of biological nitrogen fixation due to various genotype-strain interactions and to determine the most effective symbiotic combinations for enhanced productivity in Sinana district. Materials and methods Description of the study area Location The experiment was conducted on a silty-loam soil at a farmer’s field located approximately 3 km from Sinana Agricultural Research Center during the 2024/2025 ‘Bona’ cropping season. The field had previously been cultivated with wheat under a continuous cereal-based cropping system. It is located at latitudes of 07007′N and 40010′E longitudes with an elevation of 2400 m.a.s.l. referenced from the research station (Fig. 1). The major research station is situated 463 km southeast of the capital, Addis Ababa. The major crops grown in the area are cereals such as wheat, emmer wheat, and barley; pulses such as field pea, faba bean, and lentil, and some oil crops are also grown. However, the natural vegetation cover and the overall ecosystem disturbances have greatly expanded due to mismanagement and illegal exploitation of the resource base [15]. Location of the study area Climate The area is typically characterized by bimodal rainfall having two distinct growing season viz., ‘Ganna’ (March-July) and ‘Bona’ (August–December). The trend of monthly metrological data for the experimental period (2024/2025) and the average data of 20 years (2004–2024/2025) for the main research station are shown in Figs. 2 and 3 and the detail metrological data are presented in appendix Table 1. From the normal route curve as shown in Figs. 2 and 3 about rainfall and temperature respectively, there was a sharp decline in rainfall amount just a month after planting in September 2024 and continued onwards until harvesting in December 2024 and associated with very low temperature which brought about frost damage didn’t favor the growth of field pea. To minimize the effect of moisture stress, supplemental manual irrigation was uniformly applied to all plots at equal intervals and in equal amounts until the pod filling stage, ensuring that no treatment received differential water application. Monthly rainfall during the experimental year (2024) and mean monthly rainfall of past 20 years (2004-2024) Mean monthly maximum and minimum temperatures (0C) during the experimental year (2024) and of past 20 years (2004-2024) Methods Source of inoculants In order to investigate the interaction impact with field pea varieties, carrier peat-based inoculants of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains EAL 300 and EAL 302 were acquired from the National Soil Research Center (NSRC), Addis Ababa’s Soil Microbiology Laboratory. In order to assess the strains’ resistance to antibiotics, pure cultures of the same strains were also gathered. Source of plant seeds The field pea (Pisum sativum L.) genotypes used in this study were obtained from the Sinana Agricultural Research Center (SARC), which operates under the Oromia Agricultural Research Institute, Ethiopia. The seeds were officially released and maintained varieties used for research purposes. The Rhizobium leguminosarum strains were also sourced from the Soil Microbiology Laboratory of SARC. All plant materials were cultivated genotypes; no wild plant samples were collected for this study. Therefore, no special permits were required for plant collection. The experiment was conducted in compliance with institutional research guidelines and national agricultural research regulations of Ethiopia. The identity and purity of the genotypes were confirmed by pulse crop breeders at Sinana Agricultural Research Center prior to planting. The experiment was conducted in accordance with institutional research guidelines and national agricultural research regulations of Ethiopia. Experimental details Experiments on the intrinsic antibiotic resistance of rhizobial strains, rhizobia survival on inoculated seeds of various pea varieties, efficacy in greenhouse soil conditions, and a field trial to examine the interaction effect between rhizobial strains and pea genotypes were carried out. Survival of rhizobia on seeds The ability of two Rhizobium leguminosarum strains EAL 300, EAL 302, and EAL 300 + EAL 302 as well as three field pea varieties local, “Wayitu,” and “Dadimos” to survive on seeds was examined. Equal amounts (7 g/kg seed) of inoculant containing various strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum and their combination were added to the seeds of the three types of field pea. For ten days, the inoculated seeds were incubated at 30 °C. By serially diluting the inoculated seeds and plating 1 ml of the diluted sample on Yeast Extract Mannitol Agar (YEMA), a standard medium used for culturing rhizobia, at intervals of 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, and 10 days, the population of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains was ascertained. The rhizobia count on seeds was expressed as cfu/seed. The combined inoculation treatment (EAL 300 + EAL 302) was prepared by mixing the two peat-based inoculants in equal proportions (1:1 ratio by weight) before seed application at the recommended total rate of 7 g kg⁻¹ seed. Intrinsic antibiotic resistance (IAR) pattern of rhizobial species In order to conduct an intrinsic antibiotic resistance (IAR) investigation, stock solutions of the antibiotics (10 mg/ml) were prepared in the proper solvent (Table 1), filter-sterilized, and kept at 4 °C. 50 ml of YEMA media was dispensed into 100 ml conical flasks, and it was autoclaved for 30 min at 15 lbs pressure. After cooling the medium to between 50 and 60 degrees Celsius, the right amount of antibiotic was applied. While tetracycline was evaluated at 5, 10, 15, and 25 µg/ml, ampicillin and vancomycin were added at doses of 100, 125, 150, and 200 µg/ml. For each concentration, two plates were filled with the melted medium with the corresponding antibiotic concentrations, which were then left to harden. Each strain’s pure cultures were streaked on both the antibiotic-treated and antibiotic-free control plates. At 30 degrees Celsius, the inoculation plates were incubated for 48 to 72 h. Following incubation, control and antibiotic plate growth were compared. For every concentration, growth was recorded as either positive (+++, ++, +) or negative (-). The resistance limit was taken into consideration up to the concentration at which no growth was observed. Table 1Antibiotics and their solventsAntibiotics SolventsAmpicillinDistilled waterVancomycinDistilled waterTetracycline50% ethanol Antibiotics and their solvents Ten nodules were randomly chosen from each treatment, and isolations were made from each to determine the intrinsic antibiotic resistance of the rhizobia isolated from plant root nodules from treatments in which both strains had been utilized. As previously mentioned, each isolate’s pure cultures were examined for antibiotic resistance. The antibiogram (the concentration of each antibiotic at which growth of a rhizobial strain/isolate did not occur) of the pure strain and that of isolates from nodules from each treatment were compared in order to calculate the percentage nodule occupancy. The number of isolates from each treatment’s nodules that matched the antiobiogram of either of the two strains was calculated as the number of nodules out of the ten total nodules that that strain occupied. As a result, each strain’s % nodule occupancy was determined. Evaluation of effectiveness of rhizobial strains under greenhouse conditions For the purpose of conducting pot trials in the greenhouse under both sterilized and unsterilized soil conditions, the necessary quantity of a bulk soil sample was gathered from the experimental site’s field. For three days in a row, the soil was autoclaved for two hours at 121 degrees Celsius. After cleaning their surfaces with alcohol, the sterilised soil was put into individual plastic pots at a rate of 4 kg per pot. Field pea seeds of the native cultivars “Wayitu” and “Dadimos” were surface sterilized by applying 0.1% HgCl2 solution and 100% alcohol in succession, followed by four to five rinses with sterile water. Different strains and their combination (7 g/kg seed) were inoculated onto surface-sterilized seeds. Under both sterilized and unsterilized soil conditions, the pots were set up in a fully randomized block design with three replications for every treatment. Each pot received a starter dosage of fertilizer consisting of 20 kg N/ha of urea and 46 kg P2O5/ha of TSP. For each replication, three plants were kept in each pot. Six weeks after planting, the plants were carefully removed and their dry matter and nodulation characteristics assessed. Treatments and design for field experiment A field experiment in a silty-loam soil at farmer’s fields near Sinana Agricultural Research Center was laid out in factorial RCBD with 12 treatments and three replications as described below (Table 2): Table 2Inoculant strains and pea varietiesInoculant strainsPea VarietiesA. Uninoculated (control)A. LocalB. EAL 300B. ‘Wayitu’C. EAL 302C. ‘Dadimos’D. EAL 300 + EAL 302 Inoculant strains and pea varieties At planting in the seed row, the treatments received uniform applications of triple super phosphate and urea at rates of 46 kg P2O5/ha and 20 kg N/ha, respectively. Plots were 3 by 4 m in size, with 1 and 1.5 m separating them from blocks, respectively. Seed inoculation Rhizobium leguminosarum strains were injected into seeds at a rate of 7 g/kg using a 1:1 slurry of peat-based inoculants and cool, clean water. To ensure cell viability, all inoculants were sprayed right before planting in a shaded area. Before being planted, the seeds were given a few minutes to air dry. Sowing On August 30, 2024, ten rows of field pea varieties were planted in each plot. 30 cm between rows and 10 cm between plants within rows were used for seeding. The noninoculated plots were planted initially in order to reduce contamination. In order to reduce the possibility of unintentionally contaminating the treatments, all treatments containing the same rhizobia strain or strains were planted one after the other. In order to lessen the spread of bacteria across plots, ridges were also constructed between each plot. Agronomic practices To get rid of any outside competition, the experimental field was weeded twice while it was growing. After 40 days of planting, the first weeding was done, and a month later, the second weeding was completed. To control aphids and ball worms, respectively, the pesticide Karate was sprayed at a rate of 0.4 lit/ha before flowering and at the time when the crop was beginning to form pods. Observation at mid flowering Nodulation Excavating the roots of five randomly selected plants from each plot’s two border rows, leaving the central six rows in the mid-flowering stage of field peas, was how the nodulation sampling was carried out. An undisturbed soil core including the entire root system was collected using a spade. It measured about 20 cm deep and had a radius of about 12 cm extending out from the center stem. After being wrapped in plastic, the undisturbed soil samples were brought to the lab, where tap water was used to gently rinse the soil away from the roots. To guarantee that the roots and nodules were collected undamaged, care was taken. Later, nodules from the crown region and lateral roots were extracted independently of the roots. Nodules were counted overall, and the average number of nodules per plant among five plants was noted. The gathered nodules were submerged in a measuring cylinder filled with water that had already been measured. Nodule volume (ml) was defined as the amount of water that nodules displaced. The collected nodules were dried in an oven to a consistent weight after the nodule volume was determined. This allowed for the measurement of the nodule dry weight per plant. The nodule dry weight per plant was calculated as the average of five plants. The greenhouse investigation used a similar method to determine the quantity and dry weight of nodules. Plant dry matter Plant dry matter was measured from plants sampled for nodulation at the crop’s mid-flowering stage. To ascertain the plant dry matter, the nodules from the roots were removed, and the plant samples were then put in labeled perforated paper bags and oven-dried to a constant weight. To calculate the dry weight per plant, the average dry weight of five plants was measured. Similar approach was utilized for the greenhouse investigation for the assessment of plant dry matter. Agronomic data Plant height For the purpose of measuring plant height at physiological maturity, five plants were chosen at random from the central rows. Plant height was measured by measuring the distance between the apical bud and the soil’s surface. Five plants were selected from each plot, and their average height was measured and reported in centimetres. Number of pods per plant Five plants were chosen at random from each plot’s center rows. Each plant’s pods were gathered individually, and the average number of pods per plant was calculated. Number of grains per pod The amount of grains per plant was determined by separating the grains from the pods after each of the five randomly chosen non-border plants had had its pods counted. By dividing the total number of grains per plant by the number of pods per plant, the number of grains per pod for each plant was determined. Lastly, the quantity of grains per pod was calculated as the average of five plants. Biomass and grain yield and thousand-grain weight Plants from the central six rows of a net plot measuring 1.8 × 4 m (7.2 m2) were manually harvested near the ground when they reached physiological maturity. The above-ground plant biomass yield was calculated by weighing the collected plants after they had been sun-dried outside. Following threshing at the proper moisture level of 10.5%, the grain yield of each plot was calculated. Ultimately, the yield per plot was translated to the yield per hectare. 1000 grain-weight was given as the weight of a random sample of 1000 grains in grams. Straw yield Grain yield was subtracted from the matching total above-ground biomass yield to determine straw yield. Soil and plant sample collection and processing Before planting, ten sampling locations throughout the entire experimental site were used to gather composite surface soil samples (0–30 cm depth) in order to determine the physico-chemical characteristics of the soil. Similarly, five samples were taken at a depth of 0–30 cm from each plot, and they were then composited replication-wise. Following collection, the samples were powdered to fit through a 2 mm sieve and allowed to air dry at ambient temperature. Two rows of non-border plants were harvested at physiological maturity and divided into grain and straw. After being air-dried and oven-dried at 70 °C to a consistent weight, the grain and straw sample materials were crushed to fit through a 1 mm filter and stored for tissue analysis. Physico-chemical analysis of soil Prior to planting, the typical bulk soil sample was examined for the following parameters: base saturation, total nitrogen, accessible P, cation exchange capacity, organic carbon, bulk density, particle size distribution, pH, and exchangeable bases (Na, K, Ca, and Mg). After harvest, total N was measured for every treatment in every replication using the usual protocol. At a soil: water ratio of 1:2.5, the bulk density of the soil was calculated using the core method, and the pH was determined using the potentiometric approach [36]. The 1 M ammonium acetate method at pH 7 was used to determine cation exchange capacity [8], while the dichromate oxidation method [38] and the micro kjeldhal method [17] were used to determine organic carbon and total nitrogen. The Olsen method [28] was used to analyse available P, and the ascorbic acid-molybdate blue method [39]. Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer readings were used to determine the Ca2+ and Mg2+ values, while flame photometers were used to determine the Na+ and K+ values. The hydrometer method was used to determine the size distribution of soil particles [5]. Determination of N uptake in grain and straw A Kjeldahl technique was used to quantitatively measure the total N in grain and straw sub-samples [26]. Grain uptake of nitrogen is calculated by multiplying the grain’s nitrogen content by its yield. In a similar vein, straw nitrogen uptake is calculated by multiplying straw yield by nitrogen content. Grain and straw nitrogen uptake were added together to determine total nitrogen. Determination of P uptake in grain and straw The meta vanadate method [27] was used to determine the phosphorus content of the grain and straw sub-samples. The samples were calcined for 24 h at 450 °C, and the ash was dissolved in 20% nitric acid (HNO3) to liberate organic phosphorus. The phosphorus in solution was measured colorimetrically using molybdate and metavanadate for colour development, and the phosphorus reading was taken at 460 nm in a spectrophotometer. The phosphorus uptake by grain and straw was calculated by multiplying the phosphorus content of the corresponding parts by the grain yield and the straw yield, respectively. The total P uptake was then calculated as the sum of the phosphorus uptake in the grain and straw. Measurement of biological nitrogen fixation N-difference method N2 fixation was estimated in the field by measuring the total amount of N in the legume crop and the nitrogen content in a non-fixing reference crop (barley). The TN yield was estimated using Kjeldahl analysis for the N content of plant dry matter, and the amount of nitrogen that remained in the soil after harvest from the legume field and reference crop field was also examined to determine the amount of nitrogen fixed [4]. The quantity (Q) of N derived from N2 fixation symbiotically was calculated as: Barley was used as the non-N-fixing reference crop for the N-difference method and was not inoculated with Rhizobium strains, since it does not form symbiotic associations with Rhizobium leguminosarum. Statistical analysis [13], used analysis of variance to examine the data, and SAS statistical software was used to compare the treatment means to the control. For mean separation, Least Significant Differences (LSD) was computed. Results and discussion The current study included a number of experiments, such as laboratory tests to ascertain whether rhizobia could survive on seeds of various field pea varieties, tests to ascertain whether pure cultures were resistant to antibiotics, and a greenhouse study in both sterilised and unsterilized soil conditions to assess the fixing ability of rhizobial strains. During the 2024/2025 growing season, rainfall was substantially below the long-term average, creating severe moisture stress that threatened crop establishment and survival. To prevent complete crop failure and ensure the evaluation of genotype-rhizobium interactions, supplemental irrigation was applied uniformly to all experimental plots. Because all treatments received the same amount and timing of irrigation, treatment comparisons remained unaffected. However, the results should be interpreted with caution when extrapolating to strictly rainfed farming conditions, and further evaluation under normal rainfall conditions is recommended. Furthermore, a field experiment was carried out during the main cropping season of ‘Bona’ (Aug-Dec, 2024) to assess the impact of the interaction between field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on nitrogen fixation, nodulation, and grain production. Pure culture and peat-based rhizobium strains were acquired from the National Soil Research Center’s (NSRC) Soil Microbiology Laboratory in Addis Ababa. The findings’ outcomes are displayed as follows: Survival of rhizobial strains on seeds One crucial factor in choosing an efficient commercial strain or strains may be the injected rhizobia’s ability to survive on seed. In his most recent study [40], briefly reported that rhizobial inoculation by seed coating approach more than doubled the establishment rate and frequently greatly boosted seedling growth rates. Thus, rhizobia survival is a crucial factor limiting legume nodulation. In the current investigation, viable live cells on inoculation seeds were measured at different intervals of days. Appendix Tables 2 and Figs. 4 and 5, and 6 present the experiment’s findings. Rhizobia survival on field pea variety seeds revealed differences in the number of rhizobia among the inoculated seeds at various time intervals. On the first day after inoculation, the seeds of the “Wayitu” variety and the local variety showed the greatest number of cells. Variety “Dadimos” was found to be less successful in preserving a higher number of viable cells on seed. Strain EAL 302 inoculated on pea varieties, ‘Wayitu’ and local, recorded the maximum number of rhizobial cells (7 × 104 cfu/seed) immediately after inoculation. On the other hand, combination of strain (EAL 300 + 302) showed maximum number of cell colony (6 × 104 cfu/seed) on seeds of variety ‘Wayitu’. The number of rhizobia on seeds started declining after first day of inoculation. However, it was interesting to note that enough population of strain EAL 302 was maintained on seeds of varieties ‘Wayitu’ and local at the end of 8 days, whereas rhizobia on seeds of ‘Dadimos’ could not be detected after 6th day of incubation. The aforementioned results were consistent with [1], who reported that the safest quality standards needed for inoculated seeds were 105 rhizobia per large seed (soybean, lupin), 104 rhizobia per medium seed (mungbean, pigeonpea), and 103 rhizobia per small seed (clover, sirato) right after inoculation. Thus, all inocula resulted in the safest quality standards required for inoculated seeds. However, the presence of enough number of viable cells for a longer period after inoculation on the seeds of variety like ‘Wayitu’ will ensure better establishment of rhizobia once the seeds are sown. Survival of rhizobia on seeds of local variety Survival of rhizobia on seeds of ‘Wayitu’ variety Survival of rhizobia on seeds of ‘Dadimos' variety Therefore, less number of rhizobial cells observed in case of EAL 300 in comparison to EAL 302 and strain combination (EAL 300 + 302) indicated that EAL 300 survived to lesser extent on seeds after inoculation which may indirectly affect its performance under field conditions [30]., also stated that inadequate nodulation of legumes could result from low symbiotic N2 fixing soil bacterial survival, which would lower their output. Intrinsic antibiotic resistance of rhizobial strains Pure culture strains of EAL 300 and EAL 302 were tested for their resistance to different antibiotics at various levels of concentration. Strain EAL 300 was sensitive, in other words did not show any growth, at 5 µg/ml of tetracycline, 125 µg/ml of ampicillin and 125 µg/ml of vancomycin. Similarly, EAL 302 was sensitive to 25 µg/ml of tetracycline, 125 µg/ml of ampicillin and 125 µg/ml of vancomycin (Table 3). Accordingly following antibiograms of two strains were identified: Table 3Sensitivity of rhizobial pure culture strains to different concentrations of antibioticsStrainsAntibiotics (concentration in mg/ml) Tetracycline Ampicillin Vancomycin5101525100125150200100125150200EAL 300----+---+---EAL 302++++++++-+---+---+++ Good growth, ++ Moderate growth, + Fair growth, - No growth Sensitivity of rhizobial pure culture strains to different concentrations of antibiotics +++ Good growth, ++ Moderate growth, + Fair growth, - No growth EAL → 300 Tetracyclin5Ampicillin125Vancomycin125 EAL 302 → Tetracyclin25Ampicillin125Vancomycin125 Percent nodule occupancy of each strain was then determined by isolating rhizobia from 10 randomly picked nodules from treatments in which combined inoculation of EAL 300 and EAL 302 had been done. The isolates from each treatment were also examined for their antibiotic resistance in similar fashion as described above and their antibiograms were matched with that of pure cultures of EAL 300 and EAL 302. On the basis of number of nodules occupied by each strain, it was observed that strain EAL 302 was highly competitive occupying 40, 50 and 30% nodules in local, ‘Wayitu’ and ‘Dadimos’ varieties of field pea, respectively (Table 4). Compared to other varieties, ‘Wayitu’ seemed to be more responsive to infection by inoculated strain EAL 302. However local variety and ‘Dadimos’ seemed to be more adapted to the infection by native rhizobia in the soil. The strain EAL 300, in terms of nodules occupied in the roots of three varieties of field pea, was less competitive under field conditions than EAL 302 and native rhizobia. Table 4Nodule occupancy as affected by the different strainsVarietyStrainsEAL 300EAL 302OtherLocal20%40%40%Wayitu15%50%35%Dadimos25%30%45% Nodule occupancy as affected by the different strains Effectiveness of rhizobial strains under greenhouse conditions A pot trial was conducted in sterilized and unsterilized soil to study the effectiveness of rhizobial strains on field pea under greenhouse condition. The results of experiment are presented below. Effectiveness in sterilized soil The main effect of rhizobial strains EAL 302 gave the highest nodule number, nodule dry weight and plant dry matter as compared to uninoculated control which did not show any nodule (Table 5). Likewise, variety ‘Wayitu’ significantly showed increased nodule number, nodule dry weight and plant dry matter over local and ‘Dadimos’. Table 5Nodulation and dry matter yield/ plant at mid flowering stage as affected by rhizobium strains and pea varieties in sterilized soil in greenhouse conditionTreatmentNodule no./plantNodule dry wt./plant (mg)Dry matter/plant (g)Uninoculated001.915EAL 3002344.672.257EAL 3022853.172.407EAL 300+ EAL 3021918.502.160LSD (5%)2.814.140.23SE (+)0.91.330.07Local1616.002.041Wayitu2156.382.374Dadimos1515.132.139LSD (5%)2.443.580.19SE (+)0.781.150.06CV (%)12.711.28.3NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Nodulation and dry matter yield/ plant at mid flowering stage as affected by rhizobium strains and pea varieties in sterilized soil in greenhouse condition NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments The interaction effect shown in Tables (6 and 7) affected both nodule number and nodule dry weight. Maximum nodule number was scored when variety ‘Wayitu’ was inoculated with EAL 302 and ‘Wayitu’ with EAL 300 both of which were statistically at par. Similarly, the interaction effect observed in ‘Wayitu’ x EAL 302 and ‘Wayitu’ x EAL 300 resulted in maximum nodule dry weight and was statistically at par. The results indicated that both the strains were capable of nodulating different varieties of field pea in absence of native rhizobia, however, to varying degrees. Similar trend was observed in relation to dry matter of plants where inoculation of EAL 302, as compared to EAL 300, resulted in significantly higher dry matter in different varieties grown in sterilized soil. Table 6Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule number in sterilized soil in greenhouse conditionVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local016 2821Wayitu136 3811Dadimos1 191824LSD (5%) = 2.435CV (%) = 12.7 SE (+) = 1.56 Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule number in sterilized soil in greenhouse condition Table 7Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule dry weight (mg) in sterilized soil in greenhouse conditionVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local01627.520.5Wayitu0.599.5114.511Dadimos0.518.517.524LSD (5%) = 7.163CV (%) = 11.2SE (+) = 2.3 Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule dry weight (mg) in sterilized soil in greenhouse condition Effectiveness in unsterilized soil Pot trial conducted in unsterilized soil condition showed that rhizobial strain and variety didn’t affect nodule number as shown in Table 8. However, the interaction effect of strain and variety significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected nodule number Table 9 [4]. revealed the beneficial relationship between the rhizobium strain and the legume host in Vicia faba for nodulation. Maximum number of nodules was recorded from interaction effect of EAL 302 on local variety which was statistically at par with ‘Wayitu’ inoculated with EAL 302. The least number of nodules were scored due to local variety under uninoculated conditions indicating the need for inoculation. Very low number of nodules in uninoculated plot might be associated with the cropping system (mono cropping) which didn’t allow the actual size of microbial population or less infectivity of native population. On the other hand, the interaction and sole variety effect had marked influence on the plant dry matter but introduced strains didn’t affect plant dry matter (Table 10). Table 8Nodulation and dry matter yield/ plant at mid flowering stage as affected by rhizobium strains and pea varieties in unsterilized soil in greenhouse conditionTreatmentNodule no./plantNodule dry wt./plant (mg)Dry matter/plant (g)Uninoculated2061.832.421EAL 3002143.332.713EAL 3022482.332.865EAL 300+ EAL 3022257.002.530LSD (5%)NS21.9NSSE (+)0.957.050.11Local2258.132.537Wayitu2377.753.234Dadimos2047.502.127LSD (5%)NS19.00.30SE (+)0.826.120.1CV (%)10.828.210.6NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Nodulation and dry matter yield/ plant at mid flowering stage as affected by rhizobium strains and pea varieties in unsterilized soil in greenhouse condition NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Table 9Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule number in unsterilized soil in greenhouse conditionVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local16232722Wayitu20202724Dadimos23201720LSD (5%) = 5.133CV (%) = 10.9SE (+) = 1.65 Interaction effect of strains and varieties on nodule number in unsterilized soil in greenhouse condition Table 10Interaction effects of strains and varieties on plant dry matter (g) in unsterilized soil in greenhouse conditionVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local2.2832.7802.7752.310Wayitu2.9852.6753.8953.380Dadimos1.9952.6851.9251.901SD (5%) = 0.615CV (%) = 10.6SE (+) = 0.2 Interaction effects of strains and varieties on plant dry matter (g) in unsterilized soil in greenhouse condition The present greenhouse study measured the nodule dry weight per plant in unsterilized soil sample. The result of analysis of variance showed strains and varieties significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected nodule dry weight. The highest nodule dry weight per plant was recorded in strain EAL 302 and variety ‘Wayitu’. In general, the results of greenhouse experiment under sterilized and unsterilized conditions indicated the higher N fixing capacity (as reflected by more nodulation and dry matter of plants) and competitiveness (as reflected by more nodulation in unsterilized soil and also by percentage nodule occupancy) of strain EAL 302 as compared to EAL 300 and native rhizobia. Field experiment Properties of soil of the experimental site Some of the selected physico-chemical properties of the experimental site are shown in Table 11 below. The nutrient class range identified by [22] indicated that soils containing less than 10 ppm were considered as low in available P, those grouped in the range of 10–20 ppm are considered as medium and the rest containing greater than 20 ppm are classified as high in available P. Thus, the experimental soil was low in available P, which indicated the need for phosphorus application. Such soil conditions therefore may have apparently influenced the microbial activity since phosphorus plays important role in several energy requiring biochemical reactions including biological nitrogen fixation. According to [16], soils having 0.05–0.125% N are grouped as low in nitrogen and this also holds true for the experimental site [32] found that the majority of Ethiopian soils are generally poor in accessible phosphorus (P) and nitrogen (N), much like the agricultural soils of other tropical nations. As such these two nutrients are often limiting crop production in Ethiopia. Considering other parameters, the experimental site has very high in cat ion exchange capacity, medium in organic carbon content, and very high in base saturation. The base- forming component (exchangeable base) was very low in exchangeable Na+ in particular and the exchange site is highly dominated by Ca2+ [16]. Table 11Some physical and chemical properties of the experimental surface soil (0-30cm)ParametersValuepH in water (1:2.5)7.7Organic carbon (%)1.87Total N (%)0.12Available P (ppm), Olsen7.4CEC (cmolc/kg of soil)51Na+ (cmolc/kg of soil)0.12K+ (cmolc/kg of soil)2.4Ca++ (cmolc/kg of soil)30.9Mg++ (cmolc/kg of soil)8.2Base saturation (%)82Bulk density (g/cm3)1.07Sand (%)43.60Silt (%)45.48Clay (%)10.92Textural classSilty-loam Some physical and chemical properties of the experimental surface soil (0-30cm) Effects of pea genotypes and rhizobial strains on nodulation and plant dry matter at mid flowering The results of analysis of variance showing interaction effects of pea genotypes and inoculation of rhizobial strains are presented in the tables given below. Yield and components of yield were found to be significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected by different treatments with respect to the majority of parameters. Only parameters like pods per plant and seeds per pod showed non-significant differences due to any of the applied treatments or their interaction. Effect on nodulation of field pea The response of field pea to inoculation in terms of nodulation was, in general, poor probably due to the insufficient moisture prevailing in the cropping season in the area [23]. According to reports, fixation is highly susceptible to moisture stress, which might impact the growth of nodules that were started with a sufficient water supply. Both inoculated and uninoculated plants had pink nodules, which suggested that the soil had beneficial native rhizobia. However, the native population declines to the point that it can no longer compete with the introduced strains due to poor soil conditions brought on by improper land usage for crop cultivation [30]. According to the material currently in publication, rhizobia alone is not always enough. In order to fix a sufficient amount of nitrogen, it needs also be successful in colonizing the rhizosphere. As a result, a number of factors, such as the host cultivar and rhizobial strain matching, affect the legumes’ ability to succeed. Therefore, the significance of the host legume and cropping history in sustaining the rhizobia population is relevant as a fundamental paradigm [24]. Number of nodules per plant The data on nodule number (Table 12) showed that the interaction effect (strain x variety) was significant (p≤ 0.05). Inoculation of variety ‘wayitu’ with EAL 302 alone or with (EAL 300 + EAL 302) recorded 17 and 15 nodules per plant, respectively which were at par with each other but were significantly higher than the rest of treatment interactions. An ICARDA study on the response of chickpea and faba bean with regard to nodule number found a similar interaction effect [4]. Table 12Interaction effects of strains and pea varieties on nodule number per plant at mid flowering stageVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local911128Wayitu1171517Dadimos912108LSD (5%) = 3.873CV (%) = 21.2SE (+) = 1.32 Interaction effects of strains and pea varieties on nodule number per plant at mid flowering stage Response of varieties to rhizobia for nodulation is ultimately reflected on their contribution to biological nitrogen fixation [20]., shown that legumes have a great deal of potential for nodulation. In the current study, variety “Wayitu” had the most nodules per plant when compared to the other two pea types. In most cases studied so far in greenhouse as well as in field, ‘Wayitu’, the recently released variety from Sinana Agricultural Research Center, has out-performed the rest. Nodule dry weight F-test values indicated significant differences between treatments and interactions with respect to nodule dry weight. EAL 302 recorded the highest nodule dry weight (92.11 mg/plant) followed by uninoculated treatment (68.89 mg/plant) which was significantly higher than strain combination (EAL 300 + EAL 302) (Table 13). Table 13Interaction effects of strains and varieties on nodule dry weight (mg/plant) at mid flowering stageVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local52.6777.3394.0044.00Wayitu92.0051.00101.782.67Dadimos62.0064.0080.6741.33LSD (5%) = 12.9CV (%) = 10.8SE (+) = 4.4 Interaction effects of strains and varieties on nodule dry weight (mg/plant) at mid flowering stage With respect to response of varieties in terms of nodule dry weight, variety ‘Wayitu’ responded significantly (Table 13) [35]., found that Bradyrhyzobium japonicum’s nodulation causes genotypic diversity in the host soybean. Variety “Wayitu” had the highest nodule dry weight (81.83 mg/plant), whereas the other two variants were statistically equivalent. Interaction effect of strain-variety on nodule dry weight showed (Table 14) promising response of ‘Wayitu’ and local variety inoculated with EAL 302. The lowest nodule dry weight was recorded with uninoculated local variety (52.67 mg/plant). In agreement of these results, Studies conducted at ICARDA have also demonstrated the effects of strain-cultivar interactions on chickpea and faba bean nodule mass [4]. Table 14Main effects of rhizobial strains and pea genotypes on nodulation and plant dry weightTreatmentNoduleno./plantNodule drywt./plant (mg)Nodule vol.(ml)Dry matter/plant(g)Uninoculated1068.890.09420.97EAL 3001064.110.10222.91EAL 3021292.110.24128.37EAL 300+ EAL 3021156.000.08825.13LSD (5%)NS7.440.043.10SE (+)0.762.540.011.06Local1067.000.11922.64Wayitu1381.830.17526.20Dadimos1062.000.01024.06LSD (5%)1.936.450.032.69SE (+)0.662.20.010.92CV (%)21.110.823.613.0NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Main effects of rhizobial strains and pea genotypes on nodulation and plant dry weight NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Nodule volume Nodule volume was significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected by strain and variety and their interactions. The highest nodule volume (0.241 ml) was recorded due to inoculation of strain EAL 302. Regarding pea genotypes, variety ‘Wayitu’ showed increased nodule volume compared to local variety presented in Table (13). The interaction effect in terms of nodule volume was also significant (p≤ 0.05). Maximum nodule volume was registered in variety ‘Wayitu’ x EAL 302 followed by local x EAL 302. The interaction effect of ‘Wayitu’ with rhizobial strain EAL 302 in terms of nodulation was excellent indicating the importance of genetic-strain compatibility. Plant dry matter at mid flowering Analysis of results clearly indicated marked differences in terms of plant dry matter at mid flowering stage. It was observed that both strain and variety independently affected (p≤ 0.05) the plant dry matter. On comparing main effect of inoculation of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains, it was observed that EAL 302 gave the maximum dry matter (28.37 mg/plant) over uninoculated (20.79 mg/plant) [42]., in his Research on field peas in the Sinana region also revealed that Rhizobium leguminosarum inoculation alone caused a 22.4% increase in dry matter compared to the control. Similarly [18], also shown that the inoculation of bean genotypes resulted in higher grain production, dry matter, and nitrogen content. The present study also reflected differences among field pea varieties on plant dry matter. Variety ‘Wayitu’ gave the maximum plant dry matter (26.20 mg/plant). The increase in dry matter may have been caused due to difference in genetic potential of the different varieties of pea. Effect of pea genotypes and rhizobial strains on plant height, yield and yield attributes Plant height ANOVA test indicated significant statistical difference existed due to main effects of pea varieties in relation to plant height at physiological maturity. Varietal differences in nutrient absorption, nitrogen fixation, and accumulation of other pertinent nutrients support the idea that the rise in plant height was solely due to these changes [1]. Variety ‘Wayitu’ showing a height of 155.6 cm was, however, statistically at par with the local variety (155.5 cm) (Table 15). Experiments with Trifolium species by [29] have verified that the overall symbiotic competency of plants varies, leading to a respectable degree of nitrogen fixation and plant development. Table 15Main effects of rhizobial strains and pea genotypes on plant height, pod per plant and seeds per podTreatmentPlant height (cm)Pods/plantGrains/podUninoculated154.8196EAL 300147.0206EAL 302151.5206EAL 300 + EAL 302153.4206LSD (5%)NSNSNSSE (+)3.590.840.17Local155.5196Wayitu155.6216Dadimos144.0195LSD (5%)9.13NSNSSE (+)3.110.720.15CV (%)7.112.79.0NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Main effects of rhizobial strains and pea genotypes on plant height, pod per plant and seeds per pod NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Pod number and number of seeds per pod The variation among treatments on number of pods/plant and seeds per pod showed non- significant differences in Table 15. This was in agreement with the findings of [31] who stated that seed/pod or pods/plant were unaffected by cultivar or rhizobial inoculation. Effect on grain yield and thousand grain weight Results (Table 16) showed that grain yield was significantly affected due to Rhizobium leguminosarum strain and variety. However, the combined interaction effect of strain and variety did not affect the grain yield. Table 16Straw yield, grain yield and thousand-grain weight of field pea as influenced by rhizobium strain and pea varietiesTreatment1000 grainweight (g)Straw yield(kg/ha)Grain yield(kg/ha)Uninoculated18447842772EAL 30017047842550EAL 30218456332900EAL 300 + EAL 30217449002826LSD (5%)NS367.4247.5SE (+)7.5125.384.4Local13648902840Wayitu19052082876Dadimos20949772570LSD (5%)19.0NS214.4SE (+)6.5108.573.1CV (%)12.67.49.1NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Straw yield, grain yield and thousand-grain weight of field pea as influenced by rhizobium strain and pea varieties NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Studies done by [41] have demonstrated that inoculation increases field pea seed output. The results of present study showed that inoculation of rhizobium strain EAL 302 out yielded (2900 kg/ha) all other inoculated treatments and then it was followed by EAL (300 + 302) recording a yield of 2826 kg/ha, which was statistically at par with EAL 302. These two inocula showed significant (p≤ 0.05) increase in grain yield over EAL 300 which recorded the least grain yield (2550 kg/ha). Other studies have also shown that there was no any additive effect of introduced strains when applied in combination (Asfaw H/Mariam, personal communication). In greenhouse study, under sterilized soil condition, EAL 300 was comparable in several of the nodulation parameters with EAL 302 but it was not so under unsterilized soil conditions. Thus, the results of field study also show that EAL 302 is more competitive than native rhizobia as well as inoculated strain EAL 300. Research conducted in South Vietnam on soybean inoculation has demonstrated that the soybeans responded well to the inoculation by increasing their grain yields. Yields were increased by 38% on average (59% in the Mekong River Delta and 16% in the Eastern part of South Vietnam) [34]. In the present study indicated a yield increment due to inoculation of rhizobium strain EAL 302 by 44% over uninoculated control, the difference was significant. This narrow gap in yield between inoculated and uninoculated treatment may perhaps be due to low rainfall in the area during the cropping season. Grain yield was also significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected due to varieties. Maximum grain yield was recorded from variety ‘Wayitu’ (2876 kg/ha) followed by local variety (2840 kg/ha) which was statistically at par. Thousand-grain weight was only affected by field pea varieties. Neither strain effect nor interaction of strain and variety caused variation in thousand-grain weight of field pea. The finding was in agreement with [42] who demonstrated the negligible impact of rhizobium strains on field pea thousand-grain weight. However, the highest thousand-grain weight was recorded from variety ‘Dadimos’ which was statistically at par with variety ‘Wayitu’. Effect on straw yield The effects of various treatments on straw yield are presented in Tables (16 and 17). Rhizobium strain and interaction effect of variety and strain significantly (p≤ 0.05) increased straw yield. Higher fixation capability, according to published research, makes nutrients available and encourages crop development in response to inoculation on straw yield [1]. The maximum straw yield (5633 kg/ha) was achieved due to inoculation of EAL 302. Table 17Interaction effect of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains and pea varieties on straw yield (kg/ha) of field peaVarietiesRhizobium strainsUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local4514451459034630Wayitu4630532460194861Dadimos5208451449775208LSD (5%) = 636.4CV (%) = 7.5SE (+) = 217 Interaction effect of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains and pea varieties on straw yield (kg/ha) of field pea However, the effect was more pronounced due to interaction effect of strain and variety. As a result, the highest straw yield (6019 kg/ha) was recorded by strain EAL 302 with ‘Wayitu’ followed by local + EAL 302 (5903 kg/ha) however both were statistically at par. Similar research conducted at ICARDA demonstrated that strain-cultivar relationships positively impacted herbage yield [4]. Effect on nitrogen uptake Grain nitrogen It is evident from the data presented in Table 18 that significant variation in grain N uptake exists due to rhizobial strains and pea varieties. Inoculation of Rhizobium leguminosarum strain EAL 302 showed significantly (p≤ 0.05) higher grain N uptake as compared to EAL 300. Table 18Uptake of nitrogen as influenced by pea genotypes and rhizobium strainsTreatment Nitrogen uptake (kg/ha)Total uptake (kg/ha)StrawGrainUninoculated58.791.53150.2EAL 30063.467.15130.6EAL 30270.799.04169.7EAL 300+ EAL 30261.689.05150.7LSD (5%)NS10.716.8SE (+)3.543.635.79Local68.086.97154.9Wayitu59.495.04154.4Dadimos63.578.06141.5LSD (5%)NS9.2NSSE (+)3.073.155.01CV (%)16.712.611.6NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Uptake of nitrogen as influenced by pea genotypes and rhizobium strains NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments EAL 302 resulted in the highest grain nitrogen uptake (99.04 kg N/ha) followed by uninoculated and strain combination which all were statistically at par. This might attributed to the effectiveness of native population in colonizing the root to fix nitrogen. Field pea genotypes also affected significantly grain nitrogen uptake. Among three varieties tested, the variety ‘Wayitu’ recorded 95.04 kg N/ha in grains which was significantly higher than ‘Dadimos’ (78.06 kg N/ha). The local variety was also found efficient in uptake of N in grain (86.97 kg N/ha) and was statistically at par with ‘Wayitu’, an improved variety. Straw nitrogen Interaction effect of rhizobial strains and varieties showed significant variation in straw nitrogen uptake as presented in Table 19. Uptake of N in straw increased significantly due to interaction effect of strain EAL 302 and local variety. This might be attributed to the high nitrogen fixing ability of the introduced strain and the assimilation by the crop to increase the total biomass for the available nutrient [1]. Uptake of nitrogen in straw was not affected due to main effect of different varieties as well as strains. Table 19Uptake of nitrogen in straw (kg/ha) as influenced by genotype-rhizobium interactionVarietiesRhizobium strains UninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300 + EAL 302Local56.3865.0285.2965.12Wayitu47.969.7969.450.47Dadimos71.8255.4157.3769.25LSD (5%) = 17.98 CV (%) = 16.7 SE (+) = 6.13 Uptake of nitrogen in straw (kg/ha) as influenced by genotype-rhizobium interaction Total nitrogen uptake In principle total nitrogen implies the sum of N uptake in grain and straw yield. Analysis of results revealed that only rhizobial inoculation significantly (p≤ 0.05) affected the total nitrogen uptake of field pea (Table 18) [42]., stated that Rhizobium leguminosarum inoculation alone was the cause of the increase in total nitrogen absorption. Accordingly, inoculation with EAL 302 resulted in the maximum total nitrogen uptake (169.7 kg N/ha) of field pea, which was significantly high over uninoculated control. The increase in total nitrogen uptake by rhizobial inoculation could be the result of an increase in nitrogen fixation. The present study showed the increase in total nitrogen uptake from inoculation of EAL 302 by 11.5% in excess of uninoculated control. On the other hand, varieties and interaction effects didn’t affect the total nitrogen uptake. Effect on P uptake Grain phosphorus In comparison with the control, inoculation of rhizobium strain EAL 302 significantly (p≤ 0.05) influenced grain P uptake. It was evident that inoculation of EAL 302 showing uptake of 6.67 kg P/ha was superior in grain uptake of P. However, all other inocula were at par with uninoculated control in terms of P uptake in grain. Research on P requirements for N2-fixation in legumes, such as peas (Pisum sativum), revealed that P requirements are typically higher for N2-fixation [7]. As far as response of varieties on grain P uptake was concerned, variety ‘Wayitu’ (6.62 kg P/ha) outperformed the rest. An increment of 17% in grain P uptake was observed in ‘Wayitu’ as compared to ‘Dadimos’. It may be due to fact that the variety was highly effective in nitrogen fixation resulting better growth and, hence, more uptake of P as well [3]. Straw phosphorus Similarly P uptake in straw was affected both by rhizobium strains and field pea genotypes. Results presented in Table 20 clearly indicate that P uptake in the straw significantly (p≤ 0.05) increased due to inoculation of EAL 302 as compared to uninoculated control. The highest straw P uptake on the other hand, was observed in variety ‘Wayitu’ (3.45 kg P/ha) which was comparable in statistical terms to the uptake of P due to variety ‘Dadimos’ (3.14 kg P/ha). There was no any interaction effect for straw P uptake between varieties and strains. Table 20Phosphorus uptake as influenced by pea genotypes and rhizobium strainTreatmentPhosphorus uptake (kg/ha) Total uptake (kg/ha)UninoculatedStrawGrain2.885.818.68EAL 3002.825.468.28EAL 3024.206.6710.87EAL 300+ EAL 3022.836.289.10LSD (5%)0.430.850.92SE (+)0.150.290.31Local2.966.048.99Wayitu3.456.6210.07Dadimos3.145.518.65LSD (5%)0.370.740.8SE (+)0.130.250.27CV (%)13.714.410.2NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Phosphorus uptake as influenced by pea genotypes and rhizobium strain NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Total phosphorus uptake It was markedly affected due to strains and varieties (Table 20). The maximum total phosphorus uptake was observed in strain EAL 302 (10.87 kg P/ha) which was significantly higher as compared to uninoculated control. Varietal response to total P uptake showed the highest total P with variety ‘Wayitu‘ which was 11% higher over local variety [44]., since symbiotic nitrogen fixation is an energetically costly process, nitrogen-dependent legumes are more likely to be impacted by reported phosphorus. Generally, in the present study that total P uptake was comparable with the total amount of N fixed which indicated that microbial activity in terms of N fixation was highly dependent on the availability of P. Effect on residual nitrogen after harvest The contribution of any N2 fixing plant to the sustainability of agricultural system depends on how much of the fixed N is harvested and removed from the system. For grain legumes the amount of N contributed is the amount of N2 fixed less the amount of harvested in the seed [33]. The post-harvest total nitrogen soil analysis showed that both the introduced strains and varieties markedly affected (p≤ 0.05) nitrogen in soil (Table 21). The highest total nitrogen was recorded due to EAL 302 (0.16%) and uninoculated control (0.14%) which was significantly higher than EAL 300 (Table 22). It showed that indigenous rhizobia in the soil were also contributing N to the soil. Table 21Amount of symbiotically fixed N (kg/ha) left in the soilVarietiesRhizobium strainsMeanUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300+302Local71.3-9.26120.1960.1960.61Wayitu118.3460.19129.63100102.04Dadimos61.4855.5671.4860.1962.18Mean83.7135.5107.173.46 74.94 StrainVarietyInteractionSE (+)10.479.0618.14LSD (0.05%)30.7126.6NSCV (%)14.92* Total soil N in reference crop, barley at physiological maturity = 111.11 kg/ha NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Amount of symbiotically fixed N (kg/ha) left in the soil * Total soil N in reference crop, barley at physiological maturity = 111.11 kg/ha NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Table 22Total nitrogen content of the soil after harvest as affected by rhizobium strain and pea genotypesTreatmentTotal N (%)Uninoculated0.14EAL 3000.11EAL 3020.16EAL 300+ EAL 3020.13LSD (5%)0.03SE (+)0.0075Local0.12Wayitu0.15Dadimos0.13LSD (5%)0.03SE (+)0.0065CV (%)10.7NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Total nitrogen content of the soil after harvest as affected by rhizobium strain and pea genotypes NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Field pea varieties also affected the total soil nitrogen after harvest. Variety ‘Wayitu’ (0.15%N) contributed significantly higher amount of N to soil as compared with ‘Dadimos’ and local. The high fixing ability of this crop may allow it to contribute more nitrogen to the succeeding crop. Effect on biological nitrogen fixation Under field conditions, it is clear that cultivar-strain interaction produces a significant proportion of fixed N2 [9]. In the present study the amount of nitrogen fixed due to the interaction effect of field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strain was determined by following the nitrogen difference method. It was observed (Table 23) that inoculation of rhizobial strains affected the nitrogen fixed considerably. The non-fixing reference crop, barley, reported for its uptake of N for the determination of N2-fixed as a result of symbiotic nitrogen fixation. The detailed laboratory result supported for the determination of N2-fixed interms of uptake of N by the reference crop in grain and straw as well as post-harvest soil N from reference crop field is presented in Table 24. Table 23Amount of symbiotically fixed N (kg/ha) contributed by rhizobium strains in pea varietiesVarietiesRhizobium strainsMeanUninoculatedEAL 300EAL 302EAL 300+302Local111.9796.34153.87118.31120.12Wayitu113.39105.8146.91112.45119.64Dadimos120.9385.13104116.83106.72Mean115.4395.76 134.93115.86 115.49 StrainVarietyInteractionSE (+)5.795.0110.03LSD (0.05%)16.98NSNSCV (%)15.04* Total N uptake in reference crop, barley = 34.8 kg/haNS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Amount of symbiotically fixed N (kg/ha) contributed by rhizobium strains in pea varieties * Total N uptake in reference crop, barley = 34.8 kg/ha NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Table 24Nitrogen uptake by the reference crop (barley) and post-harvest N from reference crop fieldParametersValue (kg/ha)Uptake of N in grain19.8Uptake of N in straw15Total N uptake34.8Total N (after harvest)111.1 Nitrogen uptake by the reference crop (barley) and post-harvest N from reference crop field Thus, the total nitrogen fixed symbiotically derived by legume crop as well as the one left in the soil was calculated using the following Eq [3] : From the results obtained, except EAL 300 all other inocula contributed the fixation of nitrogen Maximum fixed nitrogen was indicated due to inoculation with EAL 302 (242 kg N/ha) though it was at par with strain combination and uninoculated control. Variations among field pea genotypes for the fixed nitrogen were also observed. As shown in Table 25 variety ‘Wayitu’ fixed 19% of nitrogen over local variety which indicated the potential of improved varieties for nitrogen fixation [11]., publication briefly discussed the variability that exists among pulse crops to the amount of N2 fixed [20]., also reported the tremendous potential for the contribution of fixed N in soil exists among the legumes. Table 25Amount of N-fixed as affected by rhizobium strain and field pea genotypesTreatmentN in legume (kg/ha)N in soil (kg/ha)N yield (kg/ha)Uninoculated115.4383.71199.1EAL 30095.7635.5131.2EAL 302134.93107.1242.0EAL 300+ EAL 302115.8673.46189.3LSD (5%)16.9830.7137.04SE (+)5.7910.4712.6Local120.1260.61180.7Wayitu119.64102.04221.7Dadimos106.7262.18168.9LSD (5%)NS26.632.08SE (+)5.019.0610.9CV (%)15.0414.9219.89NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Amount of N-fixed as affected by rhizobium strain and field pea genotypes NS= statistically non-significant difference between treatments Legume-rhizobium symbioses in south-eastern Australia typically acquire in excess of 60% of their total nitrogen (N) from N2 fixation [14] and similarly in south-western Australia reported up to 80%. Likewise, the present study showed an increment of the fixed nitrogen by 46% and 18% over EAL 300 and uninoculated control respectively from nitrogen fixation due to rhizobial strain EAL 302 indicating the necessity of efficient nitrogen fixing rhizobium strains and sound inoculation practice in pulse production. Production guides also suggested that field pea’s N demand can be met as a result of biological fixation somewhere between 30% and 80% [19]. Conclusion The present study investigated the interaction effects of field pea genotypes and Rhizobium leguminosarum strains on nodulation, growth performance, yield, and biological nitrogen fixation based on the agro-ecological conditions of Sinana District, Ethiopia. The results obtained showed that the interaction effects of genotype-strain combinations significantly affect the efficiency of biological nitrogen fixation and crop productivity. Laboratory and greenhouse studies showed that there were significant variations among rhizobial strains with respect to survival on seeds, competitiveness, and nodulation efficiency. Strain EAL 302 was found to have better survival on inoculated seeds, higher inherent competitiveness, and higher occupancy than EAL 300. In both sterilized and unsterilized soils, EAL 302 had higher nodule number, nodule dry weight, and plant dry matter, showing its higher symbiotic efficiency. The field study also supported these observations. Significant interaction effects between pea genotypes and rhizobial strains were found for nodulation parameters and straw yield. Inoculation with EAL 302 showed a significant increase in nodule dry weight, nodule volume, plant dry matter, grain yield, straw yield, and nitrogen uptake over the control and EAL 300. Inoculation with EAL 302 significantly increased grain yield compared with the uninoculated control. However, moisture stress during the growing season may have limited the full expression of the yield response. Among the genotypes used for testing, the improved variety ‘Wayitu’ was found to be the best performer for nodulation, plant dry matter, grain yield, and nitrogen uptake. The interaction of ‘Wayitu’ with EAL 302 was found to be the most effective symbiotic treatment, which increased nodulation and straw yield. This result emphasizes the significance of identifying compatible host-strain interactions instead of depending upon improved varieties or inoculation alone. Despite the important findings of this study, some limitations should be acknowledged. The field experiment was carried out during a single cropping season and at one location, which may limit the wider applicability of the results across different environments and years. The occurrence of low rainfall and moisture stress during the cropping season may also have affected nodulation, nitrogen fixation, and yield performance of field pea. Therefore, further multi-location and multi-season studies are recommended to validate the present findings. Recommendation ✓ Based on the results of this study, the following recommendations are made to improve field pea productivity and biological nitrogen fixation in Sinana District and other similar agro-ecological zones: ✓ Based on the results of this study, the following recommendations are made to improve field pea productivity and biological nitrogen fixation in Sinana District and other similar agro-ecological zones: ✓ Rhizobium leguminosarum strain EAL 302 is highly recommended for use in field pea production in the study area. ✓ Rhizobium leguminosarum strain EAL 302 is highly recommended for use in field pea production in the study area. ✓ The improved field pea variety ‘Wayitu’ should be promoted together with strain EAL 302, since this combination showed the best overall performance in terms of nodulation, dry matter, nitrogen fixation, and yield. ✓ The improved field pea variety ‘Wayitu’ should be promoted together with strain EAL 302, since this combination showed the best overall performance in terms of nodulation, dry matter, nitrogen fixation, and yield. ✓ Integrated soil fertility management practices such as crop rotation with cereals, crop residues, and conservation agriculture should be promoted to maintain soil fertility. ✓ Integrated soil fertility management practices such as crop rotation with cereals, crop residues, and conservation agriculture should be promoted to maintain soil fertility. ✓ Further multi-location and multi-season trials are recommended to confirm the superiority of EAL 302 and the ‘Wayitu’ × EAL 302 combination under different climatic conditions. ✓ Further multi-location and multi-season trials are recommended to confirm the superiority of EAL 302 and the ‘Wayitu’ × EAL 302 combination under different climatic conditions. ✓ Future research should concentrate on the long-term residual effects of inoculation on subsequent cereal crops. ✓ Future research should concentrate on the long-term residual effects of inoculation on subsequent cereal crops. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Authors’ contributions TK: Made significant contributions to the research, which included conceiving and designing the experiments, conducting hands-on experimentation, analyzing data, providing interpretations, and writing the paper. HA: Played a pivotal role in shaping the research by contributing to the conceptualization and experiment design, conducting in depth data analysis and interpretation, actively participating in the paper-writing process. Contributed in writing, drafting the manuscript, revising it critically for important intellectual content. Funding The authors declare that no funds or grants were received from this research. Data availability the datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Not applicable. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Data Availability Statement the datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.