Selective isotope separation of 169Er for medical applications Authors: M. V. Suryanarayana, Dipjyoti Balo Majumder, M. Sankari Published: 2026 ABSTRACT We have theoretically investigated the three-step laser isotope separation (LIS) of the 169Er isotope from naturally occurring erbium, irradiated in a medium-flux nuclear reactor for 20 days. The LIS process was analyzed using the density matrix formalism to examine the influence of atomic, laser, and atomic beam source parameters, aiming to optimize the performance of the separation process. This method can be employed to produce 30 to 300 doses equivalent of 169Er / day, each with an activity of 7.4 GBq. The results demonstrate the potential to produce 169Er with high specific activity (1.3 × 10¹⁵ Bq/g), which could enhance the targeting of cancer cells with greater efficacy. This method offers a viable alternative for producing high-specific-activity 169Er without the need for high-flux reactors. Introduction 177Lu, a radioactive isotope of Lutetium, is a critical component in targeted radionuclide therapy (TRT) for cancer treatment1–3. Widely utilized in theranostic applications, 177Lu serves both diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. It has a half-life of 6.6443 days, which is ideal for therapeutic use, offering sufficient time for tumor targeting. The isotope primarily decays by β⁻ emission with a mean energy of 148.8 keV (79.44% of decays), which enables effective tumor cell irradiation along with minimizing radiation exposure to healthy tissues. Additionally, 177Lu emits γ-rays at energies of 112.9 keV (6.23%) and 208.4 keV (10.41%), which are valuable for imaging purposes in single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) scans. Due to its effectiveness in treating non-endocrine tumors (NETs), the demand for 177Lu is high, contributing to significant supply shortages. The primary cause of the 177Lu supply shortage is the limited availability of its enriched parent isotopes, namely,176Lu and 176Yb. Availability of either of these enriched isotopes is critical for the production of 177Lu through neutron activation in nuclear reactors. However, the production of enriched 176Lu and 176Yb is technically challenging and resource-intensive4–18, leading to a constrained supply chain. On the other hand, 169Eris an isotope with decay characteristics that closely resemble those of 177Lu. A comparison of the properties of 169Erand 177Lu is presented in Table 1. An additional advantage of 169Er is its relatively long half-life, which enables the isotope to be transported over long distances, including to remote locations, without significant loss of activity. Recently19, we have studied enrichment of 168Er through atomic vapor laser isotope separation for the production 169Er isotope. Table 1A comparison of the production and decay characteristics of the therapeutic radionuclides ¹⁷⁷Lu and ¹⁶⁹Er isotopes.Property177Lu169ErHalf-life of the radioisotope (days)6.6443(9)9.392(18)Thermal neutron capture cross-section of the parent isotope (barns)2057 b (176Lu)2.85 b (176Yb)2.74 b (168Er)Natural abundance of the parent isotope (%)2.599% (176Lu)12.995% (176Yb)26.978% (168Er)Mean / maximum energies of β− radiation (keV) and intensities148.8 / 496.8 (79.44%)111.2 / 383.8 (8.89%)47.23 / 175.5 (11.66%)98.3 / 342.9 (45%)101.0 / 351.3 (55%)Energies of γ-rays release and intensities112.9 (6.23%)208.4 (10.41%)109.8 (1.3 × 10− 3%)118.2 (1.4 × 10− 4%) Table 1A comparison of the production and decay characteristics of the therapeutic radionuclides ¹⁷⁷Lu and ¹⁶⁹Er isotopes.Property177Lu169ErHalf-life of the radioisotope (days)6.6443(9)9.392(18)Thermal neutron capture cross-section of the parent isotope (barns)2057 b (176Lu)2.85 b (176Yb)2.74 b (168Er)Natural abundance of the parent isotope (%)2.599% (176Lu)12.995% (176Yb)26.978% (168Er)Mean / maximum energies of β− radiation (keV) and intensities148.8 / 496.8 (79.44%)111.2 / 383.8 (8.89%)47.23 / 175.5 (11.66%)98.3 / 342.9 (45%)101.0 / 351.3 (55%)Energies of γ-rays release and intensities112.9 (6.23%)208.4 (10.41%)109.8 (1.3 × 10− 3%)118.2 (1.4 × 10− 4%) A comparison of the production and decay characteristics of the therapeutic radionuclides ¹⁷⁷Lu and ¹⁶⁹Er isotopes. 2057 b (176Lu) 2.85 b (176Yb) 2.599% (176Lu) 12.995% (176Yb) 148.8 / 496.8 (79.44%) 111.2 / 383.8 (8.89%) 47.23 / 175.5 (11.66%) 98.3 / 342.9 (45%) 101.0 / 351.3 (55%) 112.9 (6.23%) 208.4 (10.41%) 109.8 (1.3 × 10− 3%) 118.2 (1.4 × 10− 4%) Previously, Formento-Cavaier et al.20 have investigated the production of 169Er with very high specific activity through mass separation by irradiating enriched 168Er in a high-flux nuclear reactor (a neutron flux of 1.2 × 10¹⁵ n/cm²/s). They achieved a specific activity of approximately 2.40 × 10¹⁴ Bq/g (theoretical no-carrier-added specific activity of 3.044 × 10¹⁵ Bq/g) for 169Er, corresponding to an isotopic purity of ~ 8%.In a similar approach, Zeynep Talip et al.21. employed laser ionization to achieve a separation efficiency of 0.5%.Both methods require two stages of isotope separation. The first stage involves the enrichment of 168Er from natural erbium, typically carried out by the commercial suppliers. In the second stage, mass separation of the 169Er isotope is carried out on the irradiated enriched 168Er. This dual-stage isotope separation process substantially increases the overall cost. Further, irradiation of enriched ¹⁶⁸Er in a high-flux reactor is essential for the production of high-specific activity ¹⁶⁹Er. As per the research reactor database 2025 data published by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), only five high-flux reactors are currently operational globally for the production of isotopes. These reactors are all located in Western nations. Consequently, this approach is unlikely to meet the growing worldwide demand for the production of high-specific activity medical isotopes for cancer therapy. In contrast, there are 42 reactors worldwide capable of producing isotopes with a neutron flux of less than 1 × 10¹⁴ n/cm²/s. Therefore, developing an alternative method for the production of high-specific activity ¹⁶⁹Erusing low to medium flux reactors would significantly enhance global production capacity, thereby meeting the increasing demand for such crucial therapeutic isotopes. In the present work, we have theoretically investigated the feasibility of employing single-stage isotope separation for the production of high-specific-activity 169Er from natural erbium irradiated in a medium-flux reactor (1 × 1014 n/cm²/s) and evaluate its suitability for medical applications. Specifically, we explore the atomic vapor laser isotope separation (AVLIS) of 169Er from irradiated natural erbium, using the density matrix formalism22, thereby eliminating the need for the enriched 168Er isotope. Irradiation of natural erbium Erbium has five natural isotopes namely 162Er (0.139%), 164Er (1.601%), 166Er (33.503%) 167Er (22.869%) 168Er (26.978%) and 170Er (14.910%). When one gram of natural erbium is irradiated in a low-flux (1 × 1013 n/cm2/s), medium-flux (1 × 1014 n/cm2/s) and high-flux (1 × 1015 n/cm2/s) reactors for 20 days(with no cooling), the amount of 169Er producedis6.7 µg, 70.5 µg and 940 µg respectively (Fig. 1A). Concurrently, it also produces other short lived isotopes namely 163Er (T1/2 = 73 min), 165Er (T1/2 = 10.36 h) and 171Er (T1/2 = 7.516 h) in relatively small quantities. Under the same irradiation parameters mentioned above; for the medium-flux reactor irradiation, the resulting quantities of these short-lived isotopes produced are 17.1 ng, 1.1 µg, and 5.1 µg, respectively (Fig. 1B), which are significantly smaller than the 70.5 µg of 169Er generated. Due to the small quantities produced and the relatively short half-lives of these isotopes, they decay rapidly. As a result, these isotopes have been excluded from studies on the laser isotope separation of 169Er. For the present investigations, we consider that the natural erbium is irradiated in a medium-flux reactor for 20 days with no cooling. Fig. 1Production efficiency of (A) ¹⁶⁹Er isotope and (B) ¹⁶³Er, ¹⁶⁵Er, and ¹⁷¹Er isotopes as a function of irradiation time. Cooling time is assumed to be zero days. Production efficiency of (A) ¹⁶⁹Er isotope and (B) ¹⁶³Er, ¹⁶⁵Er, and ¹⁷¹Er isotopes as a function of irradiation time. Cooling time is assumed to be zero days. Laser photoionization of erbium Erbium has a melting point of 1529 °C and a boiling point of 2868 °C. Heating the erbium metal to 1200 °C is required to produce a number density of 4 × 1013atoms/cm3at the oven orifice; during effusion, the density is reduced according to the source geometry. At this temperature, 99.2% of the population lies in the ground state 4f126s23H6 (0.0 cm− 1). Therefore, it is necessary to establish the photoionization schemes originating from the 4f126s23H6 (0.0 cm− 1) ground state. We have considered the following photoionization scheme for the laser isotope separation of erbium19,23. Photoionization scheme \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\begin{aligned} & 4f^{{12}} 6s^{2} {}_{{}}^{3} H_{6}^{{}} \left( {0.0~cm^{{ - 1}} } \right) \\ & \quad \xrightarrow{{631.052~nm}}4f^{{11}} 5d6s^{2} \left[ {\frac{{13}}{2},\frac{3}{2}} \right]_{7} \left( {15846.549~cm^{{ - 1}} } \right) \\ & \quad \xrightarrow{{586.912~nm}}4f^{{11}} 5d^{2} 6s~~J = 8~\left( {32884.867~cm^{{ - 1}} } \right) \\ & \quad \xrightarrow{{566.003~nm}}~J = 9~\left( {50552.6~cm^{{ - 1}} } \right)~\xrightarrow{{Autoioization}}Er~^{ + } \\ \end{aligned}$$\end{document} The corresponding isotope shifts and the hyperfine structure constants of the 167Er23 relevant to the photoionization scheme have been shown in Tables 2 and 3 respectively. The relevant Rabi frequencies of transitions along with the decay rates have been published previously19. Table 2Isotope shifts of erbium isotope with reference to the 169Er isotope. Data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23.TransitionIsotope shift with reference to 169Er$ 162Er$ 164Er 166Er 167Er 168Er 170Er631.052 nm-5252.3-3482.4-2102.4-1710.4-706.4728.6586.912 nm4630.23117.81873.81448.8628.8-639.2566.004 nm-350.1-235.7-141.7-109.7-48.748.3$ - 162Er and 169Er isotope shifts have been calculated from King’s plot analysis. Table 2Isotope shifts of erbium isotope with reference to the 169Er isotope. Data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23.TransitionIsotope shift with reference to 169Er$ 162Er$ 164Er 166Er 167Er 168Er 170Er631.052 nm-5252.3-3482.4-2102.4-1710.4-706.4728.6586.912 nm4630.23117.81873.81448.8628.8-639.2566.004 nm-350.1-235.7-141.7-109.7-48.748.3$ - 162Er and 169Er isotope shifts have been calculated from King’s plot analysis. Isotope shifts of erbium isotope with reference to the 169Er isotope. Data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23. $ - 162Er and 169Er isotope shifts have been calculated from King’s plot analysis. Table 3Hyperfine structure constants of 167Er and 169Er isotopes.LevelHFS Constants of 167Er (MHz)I = 7/2HFS Constants of 169Er (MHz) *I = 1/2ABA4f126s23H6 (0.0 cm− 1)-120.487-4552.984724.1654f115d6s2 J = 7 (15846.549 cm− 1)-140.4-2505843.84f115d26s J = 8 (32884.86 cm− 1)-159.3-1915957.4J = 9 (50552.6 cm− 1)-111-2263667* - Calculated HFS constants data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23. Table 3Hyperfine structure constants of 167Er and 169Er isotopes.LevelHFS Constants of 167Er (MHz)I = 7/2HFS Constants of 169Er (MHz) *I = 1/2ABA4f126s23H6 (0.0 cm− 1)-120.487-4552.984724.1654f115d6s2 J = 7 (15846.549 cm− 1)-140.4-2505843.84f115d26s J = 8 (32884.86 cm− 1)-159.3-1915957.4J = 9 (50552.6 cm− 1)-111-2263667* - Calculated HFS constants data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23. Hyperfine structure constants of 167Er and 169Er isotopes. * - Calculated HFS constants data from Christopher A Haynam & Earl F. Worden23. Laser separation of 169Er In the three-step photoionization process under investigation, erbium atoms in the 4f¹²6s² ³H₆ (0.0 cm⁻¹) ground state are initially excited to the 4f¹¹5d6s², J = 7 (15,846.549 cm⁻¹) excited state by a laser tuned to the 631.052 nm transition. Atoms reaching this first excited state are then further excited to the 4f¹¹5d6s², J = 8 (32,884.867 cm⁻¹) level using a second laser, which is tuned to a 586.912 nm wavelength. In the final step, these excited atoms undergo ionization by being promoted to an auto-ionizing state at 50,552.6 cm⁻¹, induced by a third laser set to a 566.003 nm wavelength. For the purposes of this study, all lasers are assumed to have a Gaussian pulse width of 30 ns and a pulse repetition frequency (PRF) of 10 kHz. The lasers are considered to be co-propagating. The laser-atom interaction dynamics in the three-step photoionization scheme can be accurately described by the density matrix elements, which have been previously reported by us14. These elements are numerically integrated over the entire pulse duration using standard numerical integration techniques. The laser pulses are considered to be having Gaussian temporal profiles, and it is further assumed that there is no temporal delay between the pulses. At the end of the laser-atom interaction, atoms in the auto-ionization state undergo ionization. The population in this auto-ionization state is thus considered a measure of the ionization efficiency. Using the ionization efficiencies of the individual isotopes, the degree of enrichment of the target isotope is subsequently determined using the following Eq. 1\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\mathrm{D}\mathrm{e}\mathrm{g}\mathrm{r}\mathrm{e}\mathrm{e}\:\mathrm{o}\mathrm{f}\:\mathrm{e}\mathrm{n}\mathrm{r}\mathrm{i}\mathrm{c}\mathrm{h}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{e}\mathrm{n}\mathrm{t}\:\left(\mathrm{\%}\right)\:\mathrm{o}\mathrm{f}\:\:{}^{169}\mathrm{E}\mathrm{r}\:=\left\{\frac{{{\upeta\:}}_{{169}_{\mathrm{E}\mathrm{r}}}{\mathrm{*}\mathrm{A}}_{{169}_{\mathrm{E}\mathrm{r}}}}{\sum\:_{x}^{all\:isotopes}{{\upeta\:}}_{{\mathrm{x}}_{\mathrm{E}\mathrm{r}}}{\mathrm{*}\mathrm{A}}_{{\mathrm{x}}_{\mathrm{E}\mathrm{r}}}}\right\}\mathrm{*}100$$\end{document} where, η is the ionization efficiency of an isotope and A is its fractional abundance. Ionization efficiency contours To achieve selective ionization of the target isotope, the lasers must be precisely tuned to the resonant transitions specific to that isotope at each excitation step. For odd-mass isotopes, which exhibit hyperfine structure, the lasers should ideally be tuned to the strongest hyperfine component in each step to maximize the ionization efficiency. In the three-step photoionization of erbium via the 631 nm → 587 nm → 566 nm photoionization scheme; the five even-mass isotopes are ionized through J = 6 → 7 → 8 → 9 excitation pathway. In contrast, 167Er (nuclear spin I = 7/2) has 135 possible hyperfine pathways, while 169Er (I = 1/2) has 5 such pathways (Table 4). The most intense hyperfine pathway for 169Er, corresponding to the F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2, has resonance frequency coordinates of (+ 781.0 MHz, + 876.3 MHz, − 827.6 MHz) in the three photon reference frame relative to its centroid frequencies of the three transitions.This hyperfine pathway is identified as serial number 136 in Table 4. Table 4Three photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity.S NOIsotopeJ1J2J3J4IntensityRelative frequencyfirstexcitation transitionsecond excitation transitionthird excitation transitionfirstexcitation transitionsecond excitation transitionthird excitation transition1169Er13/213/215/217/20.5146.6747.06-5547.9-933.1972.82162Er6789100.0100.0100.0-5252.34630.2-350.13164Er6789100.0100.0100.0-3482.43117.8-235.74167Er17/219/221/223/215.7915.5015.26-2518.0718.2406.45167Er17/219/221/221/215.7915.500.90-2518.0718.22010.96167Er17/219/221/219/215.7915.500.02-2518.0718.23231.97167Er17/219/219/221/215.791.1413.56-2518.02666.163.08167Er17/219/219/219/215.791.141.12-2518.02666.11283.99167Er17/219/219/217/215.791.140.03-2518.02666.12187.910167Er17/219/217/219/215.790.0312.02-2518.04211.9-261.911167Er17/219/217/217/215.790.031.18-2518.04211.9642.112167Er17/219/217/215/215.790.030.03-2518.04211.91289.213167Er15/217/219/221/213.5113.5613.56-2481.7977.463.014167Er15/217/219/219/213.5113.561.12-2481.7977.41283.915167Er15/217/219/217/213.5113.560.03-2481.7977.42187.916167Er15/217/217/219/213.511.4012.02-2481.72523.2-261.917167Er15/217/217/217/213.511.401.18-2481.72523.2642.118167Er15/217/217/215/213.511.400.03-2481.72523.21289.219167Er15/217/215/217/213.510.0410.63-2481.73731.9-566.720167Er15/217/215/215/213.510.041.11-2481.73731.980.521167Er15/217/215/213/213.510.040.03-2481.73731.9524.722167Er13/215/217/219/211.4811.8112.02-2138.31313.1-261.923167Er13/215/217/217/211.4811.811.18-2138.31313.1642.124167Er13/215/217/215/211.4811.810.03-2138.31313.11289.225167Er13/215/215/217/211.481.4810.63-2138.32521.8-566.726167Er13/215/215/215/211.481.481.11-2138.32521.880.527167Er13/215/215/213/211.481.480.03-2138.32521.8524.728167Er13/215/213/211/211.480.050.01-2138.33451.6-116.129167Er13/215/213/213/211.480.050.89-2138.33451.6-405.030167Er13/215/213/215/211.480.059.39-2138.33451.6-849.231167Er19/221/223/225/218.3317.6517.11-2108.0575.7767.232167Er19/221/223/223/218.3317.650.53-2108.0575.72828.233167Er19/221/223/221/218.3317.650.01-2108.0575.74432.834167Er19/221/221/223/218.330.6715.26-2108.02997.5406.435167Er19/221/221/221/218.330.670.90-2108.02997.52010.936167Er19/221/221/219/218.330.670.02-2108.02997.53231.937167Er19/221/219/221/218.330.0113.56-2108.04945.563.038167Er19/221/219/219/218.330.011.12-2108.04945.51283.939167Er19/221/219/217/218.330.010.03-2108.04945.52187.940166Er6789100.0100.0100.0-2102.41873.8-141.741167Er11/213/215/217/29.7010.2510.63-1609.21690.0-566.742167Er11/213/215/215/29.7010.251.11-1609.21690.080.543167Er11/213/215/213/29.7010.250.03-1609.21690.0524.744167Er11/213/213/215/29.701.389.39-1609.22619.8-849.245167Er11/213/213/213/29.701.380.89-1609.22619.8-405.046167Er11/213/213/211/29.701.380.01-1609.22619.8-116.147167Er11/213/211/213/29.700.048.30-1609.23321.8-1107.048167Er11/213/211/211/29.700.040.53-1609.23321.8-818.249167Er13/213/215/217/21.8910.2510.63-1306.51690.0-566.750167Er13/213/215/215/21.8910.251.11-1306.51690.080.551167Er13/213/215/213/21.8910.250.03-1306.51690.0524.752167Er13/213/213/215/21.891.389.39-1306.52619.8-849.253167Er13/213/213/213/21.891.380.89-1306.52619.8-405.054167Er13/213/213/211/21.891.380.01-1306.52619.8-116.155167Er13/213/211/213/21.890.048.30-1306.53321.8-1107.056167Er13/213/211/211/21.890.040.53-1306.53321.8-818.257167Er15/215/217/219/21.8011.8112.02-1271.61313.1-261.958167Er15/215/217/217/21.8011.811.18-1271.61313.1642.159167Er15/215/217/215/21.8011.810.03-1271.61313.11289.260167Er15/215/215/217/21.801.4810.63-1271.62521.8-566.761167Er15/215/215/215/21.801.481.11-1271.62521.880.562167Er15/215/215/213/21.801.480.03-1271.62521.8524.763167Er15/215/213/215/21.800.059.39-1271.63451.6-849.264167Er15/215/213/213/21.800.050.89-1271.63451.6-405.065167Er15/215/213/211/21.800.050.01-1271.63451.6-116.166167Er11/211/213/215/21.768.879.39-1067.22077.8-849.267167Er11/211/213/213/21.768.870.89-1067.22077.8-405.068167Er11/211/213/211/21.768.870.01-1067.22077.8-116.169167Er11/211/211/213/21.761.118.30-1067.22779.8-1107.070167Er11/211/211/211/21.761.110.53-1067.22779.8-818.271167Er11/211/29/211/21.760.027.35-1067.23298.6-1337.072167Er9/211/211/213/28.151.118.30-998.22779.8-1107.073167Er9/211/213/215/28.158.879.39-998.22077.8-849.274167Er9/211/211/211/28.151.110.53-998.22779.8-818.275167Er9/211/213/213/28.158.870.89-998.22077.8-405.076167Er9/211/213/211/28.158.870.01-998.22077.8-116.177167Er9/211/29/211/28.150.027.35-998.23298.6-1337.078169Er11/213/215/217/246.1546.6747.06-840.8-933.1972.879167Er17/217/219/221/21.4713.5613.56-829.3977.463.080167Er17/217/219/219/21.4713.561.12-829.3977.41283.981167Er17/217/219/217/21.4713.560.03-829.3977.42187.982167Er17/217/217/219/21.471.4012.02-829.32523.2-261.983167Er17/217/217/217/21.471.401.18-829.32523.2642.184167Er17/217/217/215/21.471.400.03-829.32523.21289.285167Er17/217/215/217/21.470.0410.63-829.33731.9-566.786167Er17/217/215/215/21.470.041.11-829.33731.980.587167Er17/217/215/213/21.470.040.03-829.33731.9524.788167Er13/211/213/215/20.098.879.39-764.52077.8-849.289167Er13/211/213/213/20.098.870.89-764.52077.8-405.090167Er13/211/213/211/20.098.870.01-764.52077.8-116.191167Er13/211/211/211/20.091.110.53-764.52779.8-818.292167Er13/211/211/213/20.091.118.30-764.52779.8-1107.093167Er13/211/29/211/20.090.027.35-764.53298.6-1337.094167Er11/29/211/213/20.087.678.30-738.42451.0-1107.095167Er11/29/211/211/20.087.670.53-738.42451.0-818.296167Er11/29/29/211/20.080.667.35-738.42969.8-1337.097168Er6789100.0100.0100.0-706.4628.8-48.798167Er9/29/211/213/21.427.678.30-669.42451.0-1107.099167Er9/29/211/211/21.427.670.53-669.42451.0-818.2100167Er9/29/29/211/21.420.667.35-669.42969.8-1337.0101167Er9/27/29/211/20.046.677.35-488.82789.3-1337.0102167Er15/213/215/217/20.0710.2510.63-439.81690.0-566.7103167Er15/213/215/215/20.0710.251.11-439.81690.080.5104167Er15/213/215/213/20.0710.250.03-439.81690.0524.7105167Er15/213/213/215/20.071.389.39-439.82619.8-849.2106167Er15/213/213/213/20.071.380.89-439.82619.8-405.0107167Er15/213/213/211/20.071.380.01-439.82619.8-116.1108167Er15/213/211/213/20.070.048.30-439.83321.8-1107.0109167Er15/213/211/211/20.070.040.53-439.83321.8-818.2110167Er7/29/211/213/26.847.678.30-391.12451.0-1107.0111167Er7/29/211/211/26.847.670.53-391.12451.0-818.2112167Er7/29/29/211/26.840.667.35-391.12969.8-1337.0113167Er7/27/29/211/20.866.677.35-210.62789.3-1337.0114167Er5/27/29/211/25.776.677.35143.82789.3-1337.0115167Er19/219/221/223/20.8815.5015.26171.4718.2406.4116167Er19/219/221/221/20.8815.500.90171.4718.22010.9117167Er19/219/221/219/20.8815.500.02171.4718.23231.9118167Er19/219/219/221/20.881.1413.56171.42666.163.0119167Er19/219/219/219/20.881.141.12171.42666.11283.9120167Er19/219/219/217/20.881.140.03171.42666.12187.9121167Er19/219/217/219/20.880.0312.02171.44211.9-261.9122167Er19/219/217/217/20.880.031.18171.44211.9642.1123167Er19/219/217/215/20.880.030.03171.44211.91289.2124167Er17/215/217/219/20.0511.8112.02380.81313.1-261.9125167Er17/215/217/217/20.0511.811.18380.81313.1642.1126167Er17/215/217/215/20.0511.810.03380.81313.11289.2127167Er17/215/215/217/20.051.4810.63380.82521.8-566.7128167Er17/215/215/215/20.051.481.11380.82521.880.5129167Er17/215/215/213/20.051.480.03380.82521.8524.7130167Er17/215/213/215/20.050.059.39380.83451.6-849.2131167Er17/215/213/213/20.050.050.89380.83451.6-405.0132167Er17/215/213/211/20.050.050.01380.83451.6-116.1133170Er6789100.0100.0100.0728.6-639.248.3134169Er13/215/215/217/253.330.3947.06781.0-7262.0972.8135169Er13/215/217/217/253.3352.940.31781.0876.3-7165.5136169Er13/215/217/219/253.3352.9452.63781.0876.3-827.6137167Er19/217/219/221/20.0213.5613.561860.1977.463.0138167Er19/217/219/219/20.0213.561.121860.1977.41283.9139167Er19/217/219/217/20.0213.560.031860.1977.42187.9140167Er19/217/217/219/20.021.4012.021860.12523.2-261.9141167Er19/217/217/217/20.021.401.181860.12523.2642.1142167Er19/217/217/215/20.021.400.031860.12523.21289.2143167Er19/217/215/217/20.020.0410.631860.13731.9-566.7144167Er19/217/215/215/20.020.041.111860.13731.980.5145167Er19/217/215/213/20.020.040.031860.13731.9524.7 Table 4Three photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity.S NOIsotopeJ1J2J3J4IntensityRelative frequencyfirstexcitation transitionsecond excitation transitionthird excitation transitionfirstexcitation transitionsecond excitation transitionthird excitation transition1169Er13/213/215/217/20.5146.6747.06-5547.9-933.1972.82162Er6789100.0100.0100.0-5252.34630.2-350.13164Er6789100.0100.0100.0-3482.43117.8-235.74167Er17/219/221/223/215.7915.5015.26-2518.0718.2406.45167Er17/219/221/221/215.7915.500.90-2518.0718.22010.96167Er17/219/221/219/215.7915.500.02-2518.0718.23231.97167Er17/219/219/221/215.791.1413.56-2518.02666.163.08167Er17/219/219/219/215.791.141.12-2518.02666.11283.99167Er17/219/219/217/215.791.140.03-2518.02666.12187.910167Er17/219/217/219/215.790.0312.02-2518.04211.9-261.911167Er17/219/217/217/215.790.031.18-2518.04211.9642.112167Er17/219/217/215/215.790.030.03-2518.04211.91289.213167Er15/217/219/221/213.5113.5613.56-2481.7977.463.014167Er15/217/219/219/213.5113.561.12-2481.7977.41283.915167Er15/217/219/217/213.5113.560.03-2481.7977.42187.916167Er15/217/217/219/213.511.4012.02-2481.72523.2-261.917167Er15/217/217/217/213.511.401.18-2481.72523.2642.118167Er15/217/217/215/213.511.400.03-2481.72523.21289.219167Er15/217/215/217/213.510.0410.63-2481.73731.9-566.720167Er15/217/215/215/213.510.041.11-2481.73731.980.521167Er15/217/215/213/213.510.040.03-2481.73731.9524.722167Er13/215/217/219/211.4811.8112.02-2138.31313.1-261.923167Er13/215/217/217/211.4811.811.18-2138.31313.1642.124167Er13/215/217/215/211.4811.810.03-2138.31313.11289.225167Er13/215/215/217/211.481.4810.63-2138.32521.8-566.726167Er13/215/215/215/211.481.481.11-2138.32521.880.527167Er13/215/215/213/211.481.480.03-2138.32521.8524.728167Er13/215/213/211/211.480.050.01-2138.33451.6-116.129167Er13/215/213/213/211.480.050.89-2138.33451.6-405.030167Er13/215/213/215/211.480.059.39-2138.33451.6-849.231167Er19/221/223/225/218.3317.6517.11-2108.0575.7767.232167Er19/221/223/223/218.3317.650.53-2108.0575.72828.233167Er19/221/223/221/218.3317.650.01-2108.0575.74432.834167Er19/221/221/223/218.330.6715.26-2108.02997.5406.435167Er19/221/221/221/218.330.670.90-2108.02997.52010.936167Er19/221/221/219/218.330.670.02-2108.02997.53231.937167Er19/221/219/221/218.330.0113.56-2108.04945.563.038167Er19/221/219/219/218.330.011.12-2108.04945.51283.939167Er19/221/219/217/218.330.010.03-2108.04945.52187.940166Er6789100.0100.0100.0-2102.41873.8-141.741167Er11/213/215/217/29.7010.2510.63-1609.21690.0-566.742167Er11/213/215/215/29.7010.251.11-1609.21690.080.543167Er11/213/215/213/29.7010.250.03-1609.21690.0524.744167Er11/213/213/215/29.701.389.39-1609.22619.8-849.245167Er11/213/213/213/29.701.380.89-1609.22619.8-405.046167Er11/213/213/211/29.701.380.01-1609.22619.8-116.147167Er11/213/211/213/29.700.048.30-1609.23321.8-1107.048167Er11/213/211/211/29.700.040.53-1609.23321.8-818.249167Er13/213/215/217/21.8910.2510.63-1306.51690.0-566.750167Er13/213/215/215/21.8910.251.11-1306.51690.080.551167Er13/213/215/213/21.8910.250.03-1306.51690.0524.752167Er13/213/213/215/21.891.389.39-1306.52619.8-849.253167Er13/213/213/213/21.891.380.89-1306.52619.8-405.054167Er13/213/213/211/21.891.380.01-1306.52619.8-116.155167Er13/213/211/213/21.890.048.30-1306.53321.8-1107.056167Er13/213/211/211/21.890.040.53-1306.53321.8-818.257167Er15/215/217/219/21.8011.8112.02-1271.61313.1-261.958167Er15/215/217/217/21.8011.811.18-1271.61313.1642.159167Er15/215/217/215/21.8011.810.03-1271.61313.11289.260167Er15/215/215/217/21.801.4810.63-1271.62521.8-566.761167Er15/215/215/215/21.801.481.11-1271.62521.880.562167Er15/215/215/213/21.801.480.03-1271.62521.8524.763167Er15/215/213/215/21.800.059.39-1271.63451.6-849.264167Er15/215/213/213/21.800.050.89-1271.63451.6-405.065167Er15/215/213/211/21.800.050.01-1271.63451.6-116.166167Er11/211/213/215/21.768.879.39-1067.22077.8-849.267167Er11/211/213/213/21.768.870.89-1067.22077.8-405.068167Er11/211/213/211/21.768.870.01-1067.22077.8-116.169167Er11/211/211/213/21.761.118.30-1067.22779.8-1107.070167Er11/211/211/211/21.761.110.53-1067.22779.8-818.271167Er11/211/29/211/21.760.027.35-1067.23298.6-1337.072167Er9/211/211/213/28.151.118.30-998.22779.8-1107.073167Er9/211/213/215/28.158.879.39-998.22077.8-849.274167Er9/211/211/211/28.151.110.53-998.22779.8-818.275167Er9/211/213/213/28.158.870.89-998.22077.8-405.076167Er9/211/213/211/28.158.870.01-998.22077.8-116.177167Er9/211/29/211/28.150.027.35-998.23298.6-1337.078169Er11/213/215/217/246.1546.6747.06-840.8-933.1972.879167Er17/217/219/221/21.4713.5613.56-829.3977.463.080167Er17/217/219/219/21.4713.561.12-829.3977.41283.981167Er17/217/219/217/21.4713.560.03-829.3977.42187.982167Er17/217/217/219/21.471.4012.02-829.32523.2-261.983167Er17/217/217/217/21.471.401.18-829.32523.2642.184167Er17/217/217/215/21.471.400.03-829.32523.21289.285167Er17/217/215/217/21.470.0410.63-829.33731.9-566.786167Er17/217/215/215/21.470.041.11-829.33731.980.587167Er17/217/215/213/21.470.040.03-829.33731.9524.788167Er13/211/213/215/20.098.879.39-764.52077.8-849.289167Er13/211/213/213/20.098.870.89-764.52077.8-405.090167Er13/211/213/211/20.098.870.01-764.52077.8-116.191167Er13/211/211/211/20.091.110.53-764.52779.8-818.292167Er13/211/211/213/20.091.118.30-764.52779.8-1107.093167Er13/211/29/211/20.090.027.35-764.53298.6-1337.094167Er11/29/211/213/20.087.678.30-738.42451.0-1107.095167Er11/29/211/211/20.087.670.53-738.42451.0-818.296167Er11/29/29/211/20.080.667.35-738.42969.8-1337.097168Er6789100.0100.0100.0-706.4628.8-48.798167Er9/29/211/213/21.427.678.30-669.42451.0-1107.099167Er9/29/211/211/21.427.670.53-669.42451.0-818.2100167Er9/29/29/211/21.420.667.35-669.42969.8-1337.0101167Er9/27/29/211/20.046.677.35-488.82789.3-1337.0102167Er15/213/215/217/20.0710.2510.63-439.81690.0-566.7103167Er15/213/215/215/20.0710.251.11-439.81690.080.5104167Er15/213/215/213/20.0710.250.03-439.81690.0524.7105167Er15/213/213/215/20.071.389.39-439.82619.8-849.2106167Er15/213/213/213/20.071.380.89-439.82619.8-405.0107167Er15/213/213/211/20.071.380.01-439.82619.8-116.1108167Er15/213/211/213/20.070.048.30-439.83321.8-1107.0109167Er15/213/211/211/20.070.040.53-439.83321.8-818.2110167Er7/29/211/213/26.847.678.30-391.12451.0-1107.0111167Er7/29/211/211/26.847.670.53-391.12451.0-818.2112167Er7/29/29/211/26.840.667.35-391.12969.8-1337.0113167Er7/27/29/211/20.866.677.35-210.62789.3-1337.0114167Er5/27/29/211/25.776.677.35143.82789.3-1337.0115167Er19/219/221/223/20.8815.5015.26171.4718.2406.4116167Er19/219/221/221/20.8815.500.90171.4718.22010.9117167Er19/219/221/219/20.8815.500.02171.4718.23231.9118167Er19/219/219/221/20.881.1413.56171.42666.163.0119167Er19/219/219/219/20.881.141.12171.42666.11283.9120167Er19/219/219/217/20.881.140.03171.42666.12187.9121167Er19/219/217/219/20.880.0312.02171.44211.9-261.9122167Er19/219/217/217/20.880.031.18171.44211.9642.1123167Er19/219/217/215/20.880.030.03171.44211.91289.2124167Er17/215/217/219/20.0511.8112.02380.81313.1-261.9125167Er17/215/217/217/20.0511.811.18380.81313.1642.1126167Er17/215/217/215/20.0511.810.03380.81313.11289.2127167Er17/215/215/217/20.051.4810.63380.82521.8-566.7128167Er17/215/215/215/20.051.481.11380.82521.880.5129167Er17/215/215/213/20.051.480.03380.82521.8524.7130167Er17/215/213/215/20.050.059.39380.83451.6-849.2131167Er17/215/213/213/20.050.050.89380.83451.6-405.0132167Er17/215/213/211/20.050.050.01380.83451.6-116.1133170Er6789100.0100.0100.0728.6-639.248.3134169Er13/215/215/217/253.330.3947.06781.0-7262.0972.8135169Er13/215/217/217/253.3352.940.31781.0876.3-7165.5136169Er13/215/217/219/253.3352.9452.63781.0876.3-827.6137167Er19/217/219/221/20.0213.5613.561860.1977.463.0138167Er19/217/219/219/20.0213.561.121860.1977.41283.9139167Er19/217/219/217/20.0213.560.031860.1977.42187.9140167Er19/217/217/219/20.021.4012.021860.12523.2-261.9141167Er19/217/217/217/20.021.401.181860.12523.2642.1142167Er19/217/217/215/20.021.400.031860.12523.21289.2143167Er19/217/215/217/20.020.0410.631860.13731.9-566.7144167Er19/217/215/215/20.020.041.111860.13731.980.5145167Er19/217/215/213/20.020.040.031860.13731.9524.7 Three photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The ionization efficiency of constituent isotopes, under resonant or off-resonant excitation, is governed by a complex interplay of atomic, laser, and source parameters. Atomic properties include Einstein coefficients, decay rates to trapped states, ionization cross-sections, isotope shifts, and hyperfine structure. Laser parameters such as pulse width, pulse shape, inter-pulse delay, intensity, and spectral bandwidth, along with source characteristics including temperature, velocity distribution, Doppler broadening, and collimation, play a critical role. Systematic optimization of these parameters is essential to maximize ionization efficiency and isotopic enrichment of the target isotope. To investigate the impact of off-resonant ionization of non-target isotopes when the lasers are tuned to the strongest hyperfine pathway (F = 13/2→15/2→17/2→19/2) of the target isotope 169Er, the ionization efficiencies of all constituent erbium isotopes were calculated under Doppler-free (i.e., disregarding the velocity distribution of atoms)excitation. These calculations involved systematically varying the frequencies of the first and second excitation lasers while fixing the third excitation laser to the frequency of F = 17/2→19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er. The resulting ionization efficiency contour for irradiated erbium was obtained by summing the abundance-weighted ionization efficiencies of the constituent isotopes (Fig. 2).The resonance positions in Fig. 2have been identified according to the serial numbers in the two-photon framework (Table 5). The intensity of the strongest hyperfine transition pathway, F = 13/2→15/2→17/2→19/2, for the target isotope 169Er (denoted as 60 in two-photon reference frame), is relatively low owing to its low abundance. The resonance frequency positions observed for all even isotopes align with the expected values. In the ionization contour, the horizontal ridges correspond to the spectral lineshape of the first excitation step, while the vertical ridges represent the spectral lineshape of the second excitation transition. The diagonal ridges arise from coherent two-photon excitation, which occurs when the detunings of the two transitions are equal in magnitude but opposite in sign (Δ₁ = –Δ₂). The probability of coherent two-photon excitation decreases as the absolute value of the detuning (|Δ|) increases. A detailed discussion on the two-dimensional ionization efficiency contours can be found in Ref14,17,18. Fig. 2Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of irradiated natural erbium under Doppler free excitation. The natural erbium is considered to be irradiated in a low-flux reactor for 20 days with zero cooling period. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of the169Er isotope. The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. Resonance frequency positions of the isotopes have been marked as per Table 5. The resonance frequency position of the most intensetwo-photon hyperfine pathway 13/2–15/2–17/2at a frequency coordinate of (781 MHz, 876.3 MHz) is marked with 60. The additional resonances of even isotopes are marked with *. Please see the main text for the discussion. Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of irradiated natural erbium under Doppler free excitation. The natural erbium is considered to be irradiated in a low-flux reactor for 20 days with zero cooling period. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of the169Er isotope. The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. Resonance frequency positions of the isotopes have been marked as per Table 5. The resonance frequency position of the most intensetwo-photon hyperfine pathway 13/2–15/2–17/2at a frequency coordinate of (781 MHz, 876.3 MHz) is marked with 60. The additional resonances of even isotopes are marked with *. Please see the main text for the discussion. Table 5Two photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity.S NOIsotopeJ1J2J3IntensityRelative frequencyInt1Int2Freq1Freq21169Er13/213/215/20.5146.67-5547.9-933.12162Er678100100-5252.34630.23164Er678100100-3482.43117.84167Er17/219/221/215.7915.50-2517.7718.25167Er17/219/219/215.791.14-2517.72666.16167Er17/219/217/215.790.03-2517.74211.97167Er15/217/219/213.5113.56-2481.4977.48167Er15/217/217/213.511.40-2481.42523.29167Er15/217/215/213.510.04-2481.43731.910167Er13/215/217/211.4811.81-2138.01313.111167Er13/215/215/211.481.48-2138.02521.812167Er13/215/213/211.480.05-2138.03451.613167Er19/221/223/218.3317.65-2107.7575.714167Er19/221/221/218.330.67-2107.72997.515167Er19/221/219/218.330.01-2107.74945.516166Er678100100-2102.41873.817167Er11/213/215/29.7010.25-1608.91690.018167Er11/213/213/29.701.38-1608.92619.819167Er11/213/211/29.700.04-1608.93321.820167Er13/213/215/21.8910.25-1306.21690.021167Er13/213/213/21.891.38-1306.22619.822167Er13/213/211/21.890.04-1306.23321.823167Er15/215/217/21.8011.81-1271.31313.124167Er15/215/215/21.801.48-1271.32521.825167Er15/215/213/21.800.05-1271.33451.626167Er11/211/213/21.768.87-1067.02077.827167Er11/211/211/21.761.11-1067.02779.828167Er11/211/29/21.760.02-1067.03298.629167Er9/211/213/28.158.87-997.92077.830167Er9/211/211/28.151.11-997.92779.831167Er9/211/29/28.150.02-997.93298.632169Er11/213/215/246.1546.67-840.8-933.133167Er17/217/219/21.4713.56-829.0977.434167Er17/217/217/21.471.40-829.02523.235167Er17/217/215/21.470.04-829.03731.936167Er13/211/213/20.098.87-764.22077.837167Er13/211/211/20.091.11-764.22779.838167Er13/211/29/20.090.02-764.23298.639167Er11/29/211/20.087.67-738.22451.040167Er11/29/29/20.080.66-738.22969.841168Er678100100-706.4628.842167Er9/29/211/21.427.67-669.12451.043167Er9/29/29/21.420.66-669.12969.844167Er9/27/29/20.046.67-488.62789.345167Er15/213/215/20.0710.25-439.51690.046167Er15/213/213/20.071.38-439.52619.847167Er15/213/211/20.070.04-439.53321.848167Er7/29/211/26.847.67-390.92451.049167Er7/29/29/26.840.66-390.92969.850167Er7/27/29/20.866.67-210.32789.351167Er5/27/29/25.776.67144.02789.352167Er19/219/221/20.8815.50171.7718.253167Er19/219/219/20.881.14171.72666.154167Er19/219/217/20.880.03171.74211.955167Er17/215/217/20.0511.81381.11313.156167Er17/215/215/20.051.48381.12521.857167Er17/215/213/20.050.05381.13451.658170Er678100100728.6-639.259169Er13/215/215/253.330.39781.0-7262.060169Er13/215/217/253.3352.94781.0876.361167Er19/217/219/20.0213.561860.4977.462167Er19/217/217/20.021.401860.42523.263167Er19/217/215/20.020.041860.43731.9 Table 5Two photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity.S NOIsotopeJ1J2J3IntensityRelative frequencyInt1Int2Freq1Freq21169Er13/213/215/20.5146.67-5547.9-933.12162Er678100100-5252.34630.23164Er678100100-3482.43117.84167Er17/219/221/215.7915.50-2517.7718.25167Er17/219/219/215.791.14-2517.72666.16167Er17/219/217/215.790.03-2517.74211.97167Er15/217/219/213.5113.56-2481.4977.48167Er15/217/217/213.511.40-2481.42523.29167Er15/217/215/213.510.04-2481.43731.910167Er13/215/217/211.4811.81-2138.01313.111167Er13/215/215/211.481.48-2138.02521.812167Er13/215/213/211.480.05-2138.03451.613167Er19/221/223/218.3317.65-2107.7575.714167Er19/221/221/218.330.67-2107.72997.515167Er19/221/219/218.330.01-2107.74945.516166Er678100100-2102.41873.817167Er11/213/215/29.7010.25-1608.91690.018167Er11/213/213/29.701.38-1608.92619.819167Er11/213/211/29.700.04-1608.93321.820167Er13/213/215/21.8910.25-1306.21690.021167Er13/213/213/21.891.38-1306.22619.822167Er13/213/211/21.890.04-1306.23321.823167Er15/215/217/21.8011.81-1271.31313.124167Er15/215/215/21.801.48-1271.32521.825167Er15/215/213/21.800.05-1271.33451.626167Er11/211/213/21.768.87-1067.02077.827167Er11/211/211/21.761.11-1067.02779.828167Er11/211/29/21.760.02-1067.03298.629167Er9/211/213/28.158.87-997.92077.830167Er9/211/211/28.151.11-997.92779.831167Er9/211/29/28.150.02-997.93298.632169Er11/213/215/246.1546.67-840.8-933.133167Er17/217/219/21.4713.56-829.0977.434167Er17/217/217/21.471.40-829.02523.235167Er17/217/215/21.470.04-829.03731.936167Er13/211/213/20.098.87-764.22077.837167Er13/211/211/20.091.11-764.22779.838167Er13/211/29/20.090.02-764.23298.639167Er11/29/211/20.087.67-738.22451.040167Er11/29/29/20.080.66-738.22969.841168Er678100100-706.4628.842167Er9/29/211/21.427.67-669.12451.043167Er9/29/29/21.420.66-669.12969.844167Er9/27/29/20.046.67-488.62789.345167Er15/213/215/20.0710.25-439.51690.046167Er15/213/213/20.071.38-439.52619.847167Er15/213/211/20.070.04-439.53321.848167Er7/29/211/26.847.67-390.92451.049167Er7/29/29/26.840.66-390.92969.850167Er7/27/29/20.866.67-210.32789.351167Er5/27/29/25.776.67144.02789.352167Er19/219/221/20.8815.50171.7718.253167Er19/219/219/20.881.14171.72666.154167Er19/219/217/20.880.03171.74211.955167Er17/215/217/20.0511.81381.11313.156167Er17/215/215/20.051.48381.12521.857167Er17/215/213/20.050.05381.13451.658170Er678100100728.6-639.259169Er13/215/215/253.330.39781.0-7262.060169Er13/215/217/253.3352.94781.0876.361167Er19/217/219/20.0213.561860.4977.462167Er19/217/217/20.021.401860.42523.263167Er19/217/215/20.020.041860.43731.9 Two photon frequency positions of erbium isotopes. Frequency scale is reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. An additional distinct resonance was observed for each even isotope (denoted with * in Fig. 2) at a detuned position within the second excitation transition. This can be explained as following. When all three excitation lasers are tuned to their respective resonances, ionization proceeds via the Type-1 pathway (Fig. 3), as exemplified for the F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2 transition of ¹⁶⁹Er (denoted as 60 as per Table 5). When the third laser frequency is fixed to the 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine transition of ¹⁶⁹Er; all the remaining constituent isotopes experience detuned frequency from their respective resonances. Under these conditions, tuning the first and second lasers to the resonance frequencies of the even isotopes (marked 2, 3, 16, 41, and 58) results in a Type-2 ionization process (Fig. 3). The additional resonance (*) occurs at a frequency where detuning of second excitation laser is equivalent to the detuning of the third excitation laser but opposite in sign (i.e., Δ₂ = –Δ₃). This process corresponding to coherent two-photon ionization from the first excited level, as described in the Type-3 process (Fig. 3). The observed resonance positions for even isotopes (Fig. 2) agree well with predicted values (Table 6). Since the third laser is detuned from all isotopes (except 169Er), the ionization efficiency cannot be directly correlated with the abundance. Fig. 3The types of photoionization processes involved three-step photoionization of atoms. The types of photoionization processes involved three-step photoionization of atoms. Table 6Frequency positions of the expected frequency positions of the additional resonances of the even isotopes.S NO@IsotopeExcitation pathwayRelative frequency (MHz)Detuning of the third laser relative to the 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er (MHz)YExpected position of the additional resonance at second excitation transition(MHz)(Z = X-Y)First excitation transitionSecond excitation transitionXThird excitation transition2162ErJ = 6 → 7 → 8 → 9-5252.34630.2-350.1-477.55107.73164Er-3482.43117.8-235.7-591.93709.740166Er-2102.41873.8-141.7-685.92559.797168Er-706.4628.8-48.7-778.91407.7133170Er728.6-639.248.3-875.9236.7@ - S NO as per Table 4. Table 6Frequency positions of the expected frequency positions of the additional resonances of the even isotopes.S NO@IsotopeExcitation pathwayRelative frequency (MHz)Detuning of the third laser relative to the 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er (MHz)YExpected position of the additional resonance at second excitation transition(MHz)(Z = X-Y)First excitation transitionSecond excitation transitionXThird excitation transition2162ErJ = 6 → 7 → 8 → 9-5252.34630.2-350.1-477.55107.73164Er-3482.43117.8-235.7-591.93709.740166Er-2102.41873.8-141.7-685.92559.797168Er-706.4628.8-48.7-778.91407.7133170Er728.6-639.248.3-875.9236.7@ - S NO as per Table 4. Frequency positions of the expected frequency positions of the additional resonances of the even isotopes. @ - S NO as per Table 4. The abundance-normalized ionization efficiency contour of ¹⁶⁹Er is shown separately in Fig. 4, where the F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine pathway of ¹⁶⁹Er (denoted as 60 as per Table 5) is clearly observed. Other ionization channels, F = 13/2 → 13/2 → 15/2 and F = 11/2 → 13/2 → 15/2 (marked as 1 and 32, respectively), exhibit lower efficiencies. It should be noted that the third excitation laser is tuned to a different hyperfine transition (17/2 → 19/2) of ¹⁶⁹Er, rather than the required 15/2 → X transition for these channels. Thus, the ionization of 169Er at the resonance frequencies marked as 1 and 32 can be classified as Type-2 process (as described Fig. 3). Additional resonances (marked as *) correspond to the coherent two-photon ionization directly from the first excited hyperfine level of 169Er. These resonances lie on the Δ₂ = +827.6 MHz line as the third excitation laser tuned to the Δ3 = − 827.6 MHz (corresponding to the 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine transition) from the centre of gravity of 169Er resonance. Fig. 4Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of 169Er under Doppler free excitation. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er. The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. The resonance frequency position of the most intense two-photon hyperfine pathway 13/2–15/2–17/2 at a frequency coordinate of (781 MHz, 876.3 MHz) is marked with 60 (as per Table 5). Please see the discussion about the additional resonance (marked as *) in the main text. Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of 169Er under Doppler free excitation. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er. The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. The resonance frequency position of the most intense two-photon hyperfine pathway 13/2–15/2–17/2 at a frequency coordinate of (781 MHz, 876.3 MHz) is marked with 60 (as per Table 5). Please see the discussion about the additional resonance (marked as *) in the main text. In the case of ¹⁶⁷Er, the larger nuclear spin (I = 7/2) gives rise to 135 possible three-photon hyperfine pathways (Table 4). When the third excitation laser is fixed to the 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine transition of ¹⁶⁹Er, the number of hyperfine pathways in a two-photon framework is reduced to 54 (Table 5). All these hyperfine pathways are densely packed within a small frequency range as shown in Fig. 5. Under the conditions illustrated, the pathways marked as 18, 26, and 29 represent the most efficient ionization channels, and their coherent two-photon ionization (diagonal ridge) occurs in close proximity to the ¹⁶⁹Er hyperfine pathway (marked as 60). Fig. 5Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of 167Er under Doppler free excitation. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er. The F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine pathway of ¹⁶⁹E (marked as 60 as per Table 5). The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. Two dimensional ionization efficiency contour of 167Er under Doppler free excitation. Frequency is scale reference to the 169Er centre of gravity. The third excitation laser is tuned to the 17/2–19/2 hyperfine transition of 169Er. The F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine pathway of ¹⁶⁹E (marked as 60 as per Table 5). The bandwidth of the excitation laser is set to 100 MHz and the intensity of the lasers is set to 10 W/cm2. Tuning the excitation lasers to the F = 13/2 → 15/2 → 17/2 → 19/2 hyperfine pathway of the ¹⁶⁹Er target isotope also results in the ionization of non-target isotopes, though with reduced efficiency.The extent of ionization for both target and non-target isotopes depends on several system parameters, including the laser intensity and bandwidth, as well as the velocity distribution of the atoms effusing from the atomic ensemble. The influence of these parameters on isotope-selective ionization, and consequently on the degree of enrichment, is discussed in the following sections. Intensity of the excitation lasers Intensity of the lasers is detrimental to the efficiency of the laser isotope separation process. Low laser intensity leads to reduced ionization efficiency of the target isotope, resulting in a lower production rate. Conversely, at high laser intensity, the ionization efficiency of both target and non-target isotopes increases, leading to a reduced degree of enrichment. There exists an optimal range of laser intensities in which the production rate of the target isotope is sufficiently high without a significant reduction in the degree of enrichment. In order to find such optimalrange of laser intensities, a series calculations have been carried varying the intensity of all the lasers under the Doppler free excitation. From the ionization efficiency of all constituent isotopes, degree of enrichment has been calculated using Eq [1]. The obtained results are tabulated in Table 7. Table 7Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers for achieving a degree of enrichment exceeding 95% at different laser bandwidths under Doppler-free excitation.Laser bandwidth (MHz)Intensity of the excitation lasers (W/cm2)Ionization efficiency of 169ErDegree of enrichment of 169Er (%)FirstSecondThird101001001000.22100.0252002001000.16100.0504005002000.1499.5753003002000.1199.11003003002000.0897.7 Table 7Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers for achieving a degree of enrichment exceeding 95% at different laser bandwidths under Doppler-free excitation.Laser bandwidth (MHz)Intensity of the excitation lasers (W/cm2)Ionization efficiency of 169ErDegree of enrichment of 169Er (%)FirstSecondThird101001001000.22100.0252002001000.16100.0504005002000.1499.5753003002000.1199.11003003002000.0897.7 Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers for achieving a degree of enrichment exceeding 95% at different laser bandwidths under Doppler-free excitation. As anticipated, both the ionization efficiency and the degree of enrichment decrease with increasing excitation laser bandwidth. Taking into account the constraints of commercially available laser systems, a bandwidth of 100 MHz is considered as an optimal value. With these parameters, an ionization efficiency of 0.08 is obtained with a corresponding degree of enrichment of 97.7%. It should be noted that Doppler broadening of the atomic transitions is neglected in these calculations; therefore, the reported ionization efficiency and selectivity represent upper-limits for the specified laser bandwidths. Influence doppler broadening of the atomic ensemble When the atom source is heated to temperature T (˚K), the evaporated atoms have a most probable velocity determined by the expression\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{v}_{mp}=\:\sqrt{\frac{2{K}_{B}T}{m}}$$\end{document}; where KB is the Boltzmann constant (1.380649 × 10− 23m2.kg.s− 2.K− 1) and m is the atomic mass (kg). If the source temperature is 1200˚ C; the erbium most probable atomic velocity is 383 m/sec. The Doppler shift of the transition frequency due to the atomic velocity can be calculated using the expression\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\varDelta\:\nu\:=\:{\nu\:}_{0}\left(\frac{{v}_{mp}}{c}\right)$$\end{document}, where ν0 is the rest frame transition frequency (Hz) and c is the velocity of the light (m/sec). For the 631.052 nm, 586.912 nm and 566.003 nm transitions, the maximum Doppler shift for the counter-propagating configuration of laser-atom interaction can be calculated to be 429 MHz, 462 MHz and 478 MHz respectively. Therefore, in the laser isotope separation process, when the tunable lasers are tuned the resonance transition of the target isotope, velocity induced Doppler shifts of the atoms of the ensemble cause reduction in the ionization of the target isotope. On the other hand, the non-target isotopes experience enhanced ionization due to velocity induced Doppler shift. As a result, the degree of enrichment of the target isotope decreases. Therefore, the Doppler broadening of the atomic transitions need to be controlled to obtain optimum ionization efficiency and the degree of the enrichment. In AVLIS experiments, Doppler broadening of atomic transitions is minimized by optimizing the effusion geometry of the atomic source. This is achieved through precise control of the atomic beam’s flow dynamics, as well as the incorporation of additional collimators concentrically oriented in a plane perpendicular to the effusion axis. These modifications effectively narrow the velocity distribution of the atomic ensemble, reducing the Doppler shift and thereby improving the degree of enrichment. The effect of Doppler broadening of the atomic ensemble can be incorporated into the calculations using the flux-velocity distribution. The atomic flux-velocity distribution can be expressed as2\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\phi\:\left(v\right)=2\left(\frac{{v}^{3}}{{\alpha\:}^{4}}\right).{e}^{-\left(\frac{{v}^{2}}{{\alpha\:}^{2}}\right)}dv$$\end{document} Here, α denotes the most probable velocity. In the present calculations, the integration is performed up to 4α velocity, where the relative flux decreases to approximately 10− 7 of its peak value.To account for Doppler broadening in the atomic ensemble, the full-angle divergence is first segmented into no fewer than 30 angular segments, and each angular segment is subsequently segmented into at least 30 velocity segments. A series of calculations was carried out by varying the intensities of the three excitation lasers over a range of angular divergence values while fixing the excitation laser bandwidth at 100 MHz. The optimal excitation laser intensities, ionization efficiency, and degree of enrichment of the target isotope are summarized in Table 8.As shown in Table 8, the ionization efficiency of 169Er gradually decreases with varying full-angle atomic divergence. This behaviour can be attributed to the larger velocity-induced Doppler shifts associated with increased angular divergence. The degree of enrichment, however, does not degrade significantly up to an angular divergence of 10°, beyond which it decreases sharply. Therefore, a full-angle divergence of 10° can be considered the limiting value, with corresponding optimal laser intensities of 550, 300, and 100 W/cm². Table 8Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers, along with the resulting ionization efficiencies and degrees of enrichment, for varying full-angle divergence. All excitation lasers have a linewidth of 100 MHz.Full angle divergence (degrees)Intensity of the excitation lasers (W/cm2)Ionization efficiency of 169ErDegree of enrichment of 169Er (%)FirstSecondThird0(Doppler free)3003002008.0 × 10− 297.755503001007.1 × 10− 298.2105503001006.2 × 10− 297.7155503001005.0 × 10− 296.4205503001004.0 × 10− 276.0305503001002.8 × 10− 263.9455503001001.98 × 10− 224.5 Table 8Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers, along with the resulting ionization efficiencies and degrees of enrichment, for varying full-angle divergence. All excitation lasers have a linewidth of 100 MHz.Full angle divergence (degrees)Intensity of the excitation lasers (W/cm2)Ionization efficiency of 169ErDegree of enrichment of 169Er (%)FirstSecondThird0(Doppler free)3003002008.0 × 10− 297.755503001007.1 × 10− 298.2105503001006.2 × 10− 297.7155503001005.0 × 10− 296.4205503001004.0 × 10− 276.0305503001002.8 × 10− 263.9455503001001.98 × 10− 224.5 Optimal intensities of the three excitation lasers, along with the resulting ionization efficiencies and degrees of enrichment, for varying full-angle divergence. All excitation lasers have a linewidth of 100 MHz. 0 (Doppler free) Effect of bandwidth of excitation lasers Thus far, calculations have been carried out by varying the excitation laser intensities and the angular divergence of the atomic ensemble, while maintaining the bandwidths of all three lasers constant. In practice, however, the optimal bandwidth for each excitation is determined by the isotope shifts, hyperfine structure, and oscillator strength of the corresponding transition. Therefore, additional calculations were performed by varying the bandwidths of all three excitation lasers independently, while keeping the full-angle divergence fixed at 10° and the excitation laser intensities at 550, 300, and 100 W/cm², respectively. Under the conditions described above, setting the bandwidth of all excitation lasers to 20 MHz resulted in an ionization efficiency of 5 × 10− 2 and a degree of enrichment of 99.9%. Both values decreased to 2 × 10− 2 and 47.5%, respectively, when the laser bandwidths were increased to 240 MHz. Although the ionization efficiency of the target isotope remains largely unaffected, the co-enrichment of stable 168Er (20.9%) and 170Er (31.4%) isotopes significantly reduces the overall degree of enrichment. Consequently, the excitation laser bandwidths should be limited to 100 MHz, yielding a degree of enrichment of 98.1% with an ionization efficiency of 6.2 × 10− 2. Production rate of target isotope The production rate of the enriched radioisotope determines the number of doses of medicine that can be produced per day. The production rate can be determined using the following equation:3\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:P\:\left(\frac{g}{hour}\right)=2.827\times\:{10}^{3}\times\:\left({b}^{2}\:p\:l\:d\:A\:{\eta\:}_{i}\frac{M}{{N}_{A}}PRF\:\right)$$\end{document} Where b is the laser beam diameter (cm), pis the fractional population of the ground level, l is the length of the laser-atom interaction region (cm), d is the number density of atoms in the interaction region (atoms/ cm3),A is the fractional abundance of the target isotope, ηιis the ionization efficiency (derived from the density matrix calculations), M is the atomic mass of the target isotope (AMU), NA is the Avogadro number (6.02214076 × 1023)and PRF is the pulse repetition frequency of the lasers (Hz). For the dimensions of the laser–atom interaction cell and the given laser parameters, the production rate is determined by the atomic number density in the interaction region and the ionization efficiency. Operating the atomic source at the highest feasible density is therefore desirable; however, at higheratomic number densities, photoions are increasingly susceptible to charge-exchange collisions prior to extraction. The probability of such collisions can be estimated using the following expression: 4\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\text{Probability of charge exchange}}\,p = 1 - e^{{ - \sigma dN}}$$\end{document} Where, σ is the resonant charge exchange cross-section (cm2), d is the distance traversed by photoions prior to collection at the ion collector (cm) and N is the number density of the atoms (atoms / cm3). The resonant charge-exchange cross section can be determined24 from the following expression:5\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\sigma\:\left(v\right)=\left(1.81\times\:{10}^{-14}-2.12\times\:{10}^{-15}{.log}_{10}v\right).{\left(\frac{IP}{13.6}\right)}^{-1.5}$$\end{document} where v is the velocity of the ion in cm/sec and IP is the ionization potential of the element in eV. Based on the above formula, the resonant charge-exchange cross section corresponding to the most probable velocity of 383 m/s is calculated to be 4.2 × 10− 14 cm2. This value is good agreement with reported value of 2.8 × 10− 14 cm225. As discussed earlier, in AVLIS experiments, it is desirable to operate the atomic source at the highest feasible number density in order to maximize the production rate of the target isotope. However, increasing the atomic number density and the laser beam diameter () adversely affects the achievable degree of enrichment due to charge exchange collisions. Therefore, it is necessary to identify an optimal operating regime in which the number density is sufficiently high while the degree of enrichment is not significantly degraded. Calculations were performed by varying the laser beam diameter () and the atomic number density (), and the results are presented in Fig. 6. It should be noted that increasing the laser beam diameter also necessitates operation of the lasers at higher average powers to maintain the required laser intensities. Considering these constraints, a laser beam diameter of 50 mm and an atomic number density of 4 × 1012 atoms/cm3 are identified as optimal operating conditions, yielding a degree of enrichment of 42.4% for 169Er isotope. Fig. 6Variation of the degree of enrichment (%) with laser beam diameter (cm) and atomic number density (atoms/cm³) in the laser–atom interaction region. All excitation lasers have a bandwidth of 100 MHz, and their intensities are fixed at 550, 300, and 100 W/cm², respectively. Variation of the degree of enrichment (%) with laser beam diameter (cm) and atomic number density (atoms/cm³) in the laser–atom interaction region. All excitation lasers have a bandwidth of 100 MHz, and their intensities are fixed at 550, 300, and 100 W/cm², respectively. The production rates of the target isotope were calculated using Eq [3]. by varying the laser beam diameter and the atomic number density (Fig. 7). For a laser beam diameter of 50 mm and an atomic number density of 4 × 1012 atoms/cm3, the production rate was found to be 83.2 µg/day. Fig. 7Variation of the production rate (µg/day) with laser beam diameter (cm) and atomic number density (atoms/cm³) in the laser–atom interaction region. All excitation lasers have a bandwidth of 100 MHz, and their intensities are fixed at 550, 300, and 100 W/cm², respectively. Variation of the production rate (µg/day) with laser beam diameter (cm) and atomic number density (atoms/cm³) in the laser–atom interaction region. All excitation lasers have a bandwidth of 100 MHz, and their intensities are fixed at 550, 300, and 100 W/cm², respectively. From the no-carried added specific activity of 3.044 × 10¹⁵ Bq/g; one can calculate the amount of 169Er required for the single of 7.4 GBq which was found to be 2.43 µg. Consequently, the system is capable of producing more than 30 dose equivalent of 169Er/ day / cell. By designing the setup with multiple cells—approximately 10 with one set of lasers — It is feasible to produce around 300 doses equivalent of 169Er/ day. Conclusions We have theoretically investigated the three-step laser isotope separation (LIS) of the 169Er isotope from naturally occurring erbium, irradiated in a medium-flux nuclear reactor for 20 days. The LIS process was analyzed using the density matrix formalism to examine the influence of atomic, laser, and atomic beam source parameters, aiming to optimize the performance of the separation process. It has been shown that the present method can be employed to produce 30 to 300 doses equivalent of 169Er/ day, each with an activity of 7.4 GBq. The results demonstrate the potential to produce 169Er with high specific activity (1.3 × 10¹⁵ Bq/g), which could enhance the targeting of cancer cells with greater efficacy. This method offers a viable alternative for producing high-specific-activity 169Er without the need for high-flux reactors. It is anticipated that this approach will contribute to the increased availability of 169Er for the treatment of non-endocrine tumors. The optimum conditions derived in the present work are contingent upon the atomic parameters reported by the research groups cited herein. Errors in the reported atomic parameter values could potentially alter the derived optimum system parameters. Consequently, experimental validation of the photoionization process may be a prerequisite for the design and implementation of a large-scale isotope separation system based on the current work.