Well-being initiatives for hospital employees provided by the Dutch University Medical Centres: an exploratory study Authors: Amber Boskma, Leontien Sturms, Arie Franx, Maarten van der Laan Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundHealthcare professionals (HCPs) face a range of sources of stress and dissatisfaction. Decreased well-being among HCPs is one of the causes of the caregivers’ shortage and relates to poor patient outcomes. To improve well-being in the workplace, a variety of initiatives are offered. This inventory aims to give an overview of well-being initiatives provided by the university medical centres (UMCs) in the Netherlands.MethodsWe conducted semi-structured video call interviews with all UMCs in 2021, employing a purposive sampling approach. An interview guide was used to ensure similar types of data from all informants were collected.Results31 interviews were conducted among nurses, doctors, human resource personnel and occupational health department members. 203 initiatives were reported by the seven UMCs to improve or sustain employees’ well-being. Initiatives concerned coaching, training, programmes, studies, apps and tools. The initiatives aim to improve physical fitness, mental fitness, personal development and balance, team collaboration, equip managers and function/context. Most of the initiatives are aimed at individual employees, and only a few focus on teams, organisations or the healthcare system. We also found that it is not evaluated if initiatives are effective to improve employees’ well-being. Furthermore, HCPs’ needs do not seem to be routinely evaluated upfront in the design of initiatives.ConclusionThe urgency of supporting the well-being of HCPs is recognised, given the extensive amount of provided initiatives. However, this collection of initiatives must be critically reviewed in order to have a balanced offer that is effective and fits the wishes of HCPs. These results should be taken into consideration when creating, implementing and coordinating well-being initiatives for employees in the healthcare field.Keywords: continuous improvement, mental health, physical health, nurse, doctor WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC Literature about interventions for healthcare professionals (HCPs) is growing; however, limited insight is available on how the offered well-being initiatives in the Dutch university hospitals relate to this. Individual-directed interventions, team-based interventions, organisational-directed interventions and multi-model interventions are studied. Interventions are developed for diverse settings, orientations (proactive/prevention, reactive/promotion) and populations. Literature about interventions for healthcare professionals (HCPs) is growing; however, limited insight is available on how the offered well-being initiatives in the Dutch university hospitals relate to this. Individual-directed interventions, team-based interventions, organisational-directed interventions and multi-model interventions are studied. Interventions are developed for diverse settings, orientations (proactive/prevention, reactive/promotion) and populations. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS In our study overviewing well-being initiatives for HCPs in the seven university medical centres of the Netherlands, the 31 semi-structured interviews provided insight into the current situation of ongoing well-being initiatives. Despite this, there is still room for improvement in contributing to the well-being of HCPs. In our study overviewing well-being initiatives for HCPs in the seven university medical centres of the Netherlands, the 31 semi-structured interviews provided insight into the current situation of ongoing well-being initiatives. Despite this, there is still room for improvement in contributing to the well-being of HCPs. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY Understanding the content and focus of ongoing well-being initiatives will contribute to identifying the gap in knowledge, defining further scientific delineation and objectives and ultimately developing appropriate strategies for improving quality of care and patient safety, healthcare worker retention as well as environmental sustainability. Understanding the content and focus of ongoing well-being initiatives will contribute to identifying the gap in knowledge, defining further scientific delineation and objectives and ultimately developing appropriate strategies for improving quality of care and patient safety, healthcare worker retention as well as environmental sustainability. Introduction Healthcare professionals (HCPs) face a range of occupational risks associated with biological, chemical, physical, ergonomic and psychosocial hazards affecting the safety of both HCPs and patients.1 The most common occupational hazards for HCPs are ergonomic hazards (heavy lifting, unsafe patient handling), psychosocial hazards (time pressure, lack of control, shift work and lack of support) and violence and harassment (physical, sexual and psychological).2 Globally, there are 136 million HCPs,1 and across diverse healthcare worker types, the prevalence rates of decreased well-being and increased retention are high.3–5 Poor well-being and occupational burnout among HCPs are associated with poor quality of care and negative patient safety outcomes such as medical errors.2 Therefore, there is great importance for long-term sustainable investments in the health workforce in order to ensure that enough HCPs are employed and retained, deployed where needed, and that they have the skills and equipment to perform their jobs safely and well.5 6 This is essential for ensuring the accessibility of high-quality healthcare. Worldwide, a lot of effort is being put into initiatives for maintaining or improving HCPs’ well-being.7 Literature about interventions for HCPs’ well-being is increasing at an extremely fast pace.7 8 A large variety of different interventions are initiated: individual-directed interventions, team-based interventions, organisational-directed interventions and multi-model interventions.7 9 Interventions are developed for diverse settings, orientations (proactive/prevention, reactive/promotion) and aimed at different populations (for all employees, employees at risk, employees in need).7 8 However, there is currently a lack of a comprehensive overview of interventions provided to Dutch HCPs. Hence, this study investigates the current situation in the Dutch University Medical Centres (UMCs). Herewith, the focus of initiatives, whether they are evidence-based and the involvement of professionals is investigated. This study is part of a programme of the Dutch Federation of University Medical Centres (NFU) about searching for ways to improve and monitor HCPs’ well-being. Investigating the current situation regarding available interventions contributes to an understanding of and getting insight into processes, gaps, problems, opportunities and inefficiencies. Understanding the content and focus of ongoing well-being initiatives will contribute to identifying the gap in knowledge, defining further scientific delineation and objectives and ultimately developing appropriate strategies for improving quality of care and patient safety, healthcare worker retention as well as environmental sustainability. This study aims to get insight and an overview of the current provided/available well-being initiatives for the HCPs in the UMCs of the Netherlands. Methods Design The study approach was explorative and qualitative in design. This approach was chosen because it allows follow-up questions, enabling a better understanding of the context and setting in which (complex) initiatives are offered.10 The consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative studies (COREQ) are used to facilitate reporting of the results.11 Population The study population consisted of various employees of the UMCs of the Netherlands. The sampling strategy was purposive, enabling access to people who could provide rich data.12 Education staff nurses, doctors, human resource (HR) staff members and staff members of the occupational health department were approached since it was expected that they could provide substantial information about which initiatives were offered within the organisations. A maximum variation within this purposive sample was tried to be achieved by approaching participants of (a) each hospital and (b) different wards. In such a manner, access to diverse perspectives was accomplished, and the credibility of the data was enhanced.10 Procedures Employees were contacted by email from July 2021 to October 2021. A few contacts were approached via the network of the NFU colleagues. Through snowballing, extra contacts were gathered and approached. Ultimately, 89 contacts were approached by email. Information about the project and an appointment request were sent.13 Data collection Information about available well-being initiatives was collected by AB conducting semi-structured interviews from August 2021 to December 2021. Due to COVID-19 measures, interviews took place through video calls (Microsoft Teams©), which are considered to be a proper alternative since differences in quality are sufficiently modest compared with face-to-face interviews.14–18 An interview guide was used to ensure similar types of data from all informants were collected.12 From the various suitable questions for qualitative research (experience, feeling, knowledge and follow-up questions), the current study used so-called ‘knowledge questions’ to find answers to the aim.12 The open nature of the questions provided flexibility in the conversation for both the respondent and the researcher.12 Each conversation started with the questions: ‘Which current initiatives/projects/studies are available for the employees within your organisation to prevent/treat/monitor reduced well-being?’ and ‘Which current initiatives/projects/studies are available for the employees within your organisation to optimise personal or contextual factors?’. Hereafter, the following information was asked out per initiative/project/study: (a) content of initiatives; (b) purpose of initiatives; (c) target group; (d) effectiveness/evaluation (eg, results, do’s and don’ts, particularities) and (e) implementation (eg, adjustments, needs assessments, barriers, facilitators). An audit trail was used to write down and link thoughts and methodological choices. Moreover, after analysis, a member check was performed to enhance confirmability. Per the medical centre, an overview of collected initiatives and corresponding features was sent to participants. This was in the form of a table in Word. Feedback was requested via email to confirm assumptions and to check missing initiatives/projects/studies. Of every medical centre, a reaction was received. Based on the responses, the overviews for each UMC were adjusted and completed. Data analysis The data analysis was inductive. During interviews, notes were made in an Excel spreadsheet, and afterwards, the information was organised and written out related to the subthemes by the first author (content, purpose, target group, effects, implementation). Interviews were not recorded or transcribed regarding the feasibility of the study. By taking notes, the data were reduced and delays in analysis were prevented.19 Moreover, this approach was supportive in sharpening the focus and bringing the essence to the forefront,19 since during interviews, a distinction was immediately made between main and secondary issues. While taking systematic notes, initiatives were placed on rows, and information about the hospital and the initiatives were organised in columns. Afterwards, initiatives were categorised independently by the first and second authors. Finally, through discussion, a consensus was reached about the final categories. The first author is a nurse with intrinsic motivations in the topic of the current study due to her own experiences and career choices. Being recognisable to participants can offer rapport and familiarity but can also lead to coloured perspectives. The first author was aware of this, and she deliberately aimed to interview with an open, curious view. Furthermore, during analysis, the second author was a good sparring partner to discuss interpretations. Results Participants To get a snapshot of initiatives in 2021, 31 semi-structured interviews were conducted among education staff, nurses, doctors, HR staff members and staff members of the occupational health department (see table 1). Of the 89 approached contacts, some suggested other, more suitable persons, and some did not respond for unknown reasons. Interviews lasted approximately 60 min. Table 1Overview of initiatives gathered and characteristics of interviewees per university medical hospitalUniversity medical centreAmount of initiatives gatheredBackground of interviewees (n=31)Amsterdam UMC30HR staff/occupational health staff (2)Physician (2)UMC Utrecht27HR staff/occupational health staff (1)Researcher (1)Radboud UMC28HR staff/occupational health staff (2)Nurse scientist (3)Physician (1)Erasmus UMC23Education staff (1)HR staff/occupational health staff (2)Nurse scientist (1)Physician (1)Maastricht UMC45Education staff (1)HR staff/occupational health staff (3)Nurse (1)UMC Groningen39HR staff/occupational health staff (2)Nurse (1)Physician (1)Other (3)Leiden UMC11HR staff/occupational health staff (1)Nurse scientist (1)UMC, University Medical Centre. Overview of initiatives gathered and characteristics of interviewees per university medical hospital UMC, University Medical Centre. Initiatives categorised In total, 203 initiatives were identified by the seven UMCs. Based on the detailed description of notes, the following categories were inductively identified by AB and LS: (a) physical fitness; (b) mental fitness; (c) personal development and balance; (d) team collaboration; (e) equipping managers; (f) function and context (eg, roles, tasks, work environment). Some initiatives were suitable for several categories. Results will be further described by category. Physical fitness The category ‘physical fitness’ included initiatives to support physical health. All participants mentioned the organisational attention for healthy food and exercise/sports. For example, for all employees, fruits and protein snacks are offered, and lunch walks, sport lessons and physiotherapist consults are organised, rewarded and promoted. Besides, workshops and health checks are possible to participate in as an individual worker/employee. Mental fitness The category ‘mental fitness’ included initiatives to support mental health. Of the 203 initiatives, most initiatives on mental health were pointed out (43%). Lots of education options (workshops, courses, lectures, e-learning) were described targeting fatigue, coping with stress, mindfulness and sustainable work. Moreover, professional coaching and peer support were remarked as available at all of the UMCs. Participants indicated most of the coaching initiatives are aimed at individuals; however, some initiatives, such as debriefing and intervision sessions, are eligible for teams. Finally, apps are highlighted as being used to track, for instance, symptoms of stress. Personal development and balance Participants of all UMCs indicated personal coaching purposing career development. Moreover, courses and e-learning about this topic are described. According to interviewees, education within this theme is, for example, about leadership, time management and improving resilience. Team collaboration Some interviewees described initiatives focusing on teams. Likewise, in some UMCs, training and coaching are possible for teams. Many participants indicated that training and coaching are targeting improving communication, culture or practising simulated clinical cases interdisciplinarily. One interviewee mentioned an intervention that challenges teams using an app to stimulate healthy patterns (eg, sleep, exercise). Lastly, in all seven hospitals, teambuilding and festivity are organised as indicated by participants. Equipping managers A few courses were revealed during interviews, especially for (direct) managers. Participants highlighted that these initiatives are organised to improve employee support from managers in the context of job resources. Interviewees mentioned these courses are targeting remarking problems, providing advice about how to discuss these problems with employees and applying appropriate actions. Function and context Together with the theme ‘equipping managers’, this is the smallest category, with only 11 initiatives as indicated by participants. A few participants described examples of initiatives changing functions or the context. Examples remarked are assistance for nurses, working in pairs, self-scheduling, combining jobs and projects to support taking the stairs/making work spaces attractive. Highlighting some features Some features emerged from the conducted interviews that need to be considered. Strikingly, participants described most of the initiatives as aimed at individual professionals rather than teams and work context (eg, education options, coaching). Moreover, according to participants, more than half of the offered initiatives are not evaluated. Lastly, some interviewees noted HCPs’ wishes and needs do not seem to be evaluated upfront as a routine in the design of initiatives. Discussion In our study overviewing well-being initiatives for HCPs in the seven Dutch UMCs, the semi-structured interviews provided insight into the current situation and understanding of ongoing well-being initiatives. A variety of activities is offered. The number of different initiatives is a reflection of the perceived need. Despite this, there is room for improvement in contributing to the well-being of HCPs. Strikingly, most of the initiatives aimed at changing individual professionals rather than teams and work context. Moreover, it remains unknown whether these initiatives are effective in order to improve employees’ well-being since the effects of the majority are not evaluated. Lastly, HCPs’ wishes and needs do not seem to be evaluated upfront as a routine in the design of initiatives. Findings in context First, most of the initiatives aim at changing the individual professional. On one hand, strengthening individuals mediates the relationship between job resources and engagement/exhaustion.20 On the other hand, personal resources cannot offset job demands.20 So, when the context and system are sickening, we are not solving the right problem. This is in a way only addressing the symptoms but not the underlying disease. Altogether, since well-being is a multidimensional concept, organisations should not focus mainly on changing individuals but also on changing teams and work environments, such as in multi-model interventions.9 21 This often neglected focus on preventive organisational-level interventions and the need for a more shared responsibility is highlighted in previous (literature review) research,22 23 making our findings more probable. Second, up to now, there is no structural evaluation of the effectiveness of well-being initiatives. Evaluations of about half of the initiatives are predominantly targeted at experiences and improving the initiatives rather than on the effectiveness of the initiatives. Insight into the cost-effectiveness of initiatives on retaining staff and optimising well-being can be substantially improved24 and is urgently needed. Currently, the revealed initiatives are context-dependent. Despite the fact that testing health promotion initiatives is challenging (many factors influence the effect (eg, personal factors and organisational factors)),24–26 initiatives will benefit from continuous learning and improvement processes, such as action research or PDCA cycles. Thorough evaluation and insight into outcomes will contribute to understanding of what does and does not work and how initiatives work in practice and will provide evidence that informs policy and practice.2 24 27 Moreover, initiatives should better fit and be tailored to professionals’ needs to improve their professional performance.28 29 Strikingly, there is often a mismatch between organisations’ perceptions of health and the interventions they offer employers.30 To bridge this gap, organisations can make informed choices by timely querying and monitoring wants and needs. The primary objective should be creating an intervention that effectively tackles a specific problem while being cost-efficient, feasible, replicable and responsive to the needs of its users.31 Therefore, investigating the needs and perceptions of the recipients and providers regarding the identified problem, on one hand, and the preferences and capacities with regard to the proposed solution, on the other hand, is crucial.31 Lastly, as mentioned, a variety of activities are offered. These initiatives were divided into several categories. Based on the initiative description, the categorisation was made. However, despite the categorisation being done independently and consensus being reached on it, it was sometimes difficult to classify initiatives, and some initiatives were suitable for multiple categories. One example is coaching and intervision, which is sometimes described as support for mental issues, but at the same time, it is also about learning and therefore fits into personal development and balance. Another example is a platform for e-learning. The platform features various types of e-learning, making it possible to categorise them into multiple categories. Programmes have also been included, containing various elements or modules (coaching, webinars, team sessions in one programme), resulting in them being suitable for multiple categories. Finally, there are sessions included that operate on demand. This means that depending on the team’s needs, support from HR is used. Consequently, the classification of the initiative into categories is also dependent on the team’s request. These are examples and a possible explanation for why most initiatives were linked to mental fitness. Methodological considerations The study approach was qualitative, which was considered appropriate for the aim of the current study. A quantitative cross-sectional survey study could also have been considered, as it is suitable for describing the status, prevalence and distribution of a phenomenon at a fixed point in time.32 However, the goal of this study was not to investigate associations in relation to certain well-being outcomes, for example. Additionally, questionnaires rely on responses, validating the constructed questionnaire is necessary, and it is common practice to ask short questions such as yes/no and always/sometimes/never,32 which can be limiting in this case. Despite the fact that a questionnaire has the advantage of potentially reaching a large group and allowing for anonymity,32 the research group supports a qualitative approach. The qualitative research supports an iterative, exploratory approach. This means that insights from data collection (first interviews) can inform subsequent data gathering for further interviews, contributing to a more comprehensive understanding.32 Additionally, the qualitative approach made it possible to build a relationship with participants, resulting in an open environment where rich data was shared. Moreover, this rapport facilitated referrals to key contacts and helped in gathering accurate information from participants with the relevant knowledge, leading to a more complete perspective and fostering positive collaboration in future projects and research in the field. Strengths and limitations The heterogeneous participant group with different backgrounds provided very diverse information and perspectives about the initiatives within the different UMCs. This contributed to achieving a very complete impression and inventory of the current situation. Moreover, intersubjectivity agreement was enhanced by the independent analysis/labelling of categorising the initiatives by the first author and second author.33 Consensus was reached after discussion within the research team. Likewise, memos, assumptions, methodological choices and thoughts were logged. Lastly, member checking was conducted to optimise confirmability.33 Some study limitations need to be discussed. First, interviews were not recorded and transcribed. This could result in missed information or incorrect interpretations. However, careful attention was paid to this by writing down memos during interviews. Additionally, due to the absence of transcripts, it was not possible to add quotes to the results section. The use of quotes can support the interpretation of the results.34 However, quotes are mostly used to provide a better understanding of the language, reactions and behaviour of the participants,34 which is considered less relevant in our study. Second, it was complicated to determine data saturation. Finding participants who were able to provide comprehensive information was challenging sometimes, which resulted in an incomplete overview eventually. To address this inconvenience, participants were asked for other key contacts and a member check. Lastly, this study is a snapshot of a fluctuating set of initiatives offered by UMCs in 2021. This needs to be taken into account during the interpretation of the data, and causal relationships could not be established.35 However, the current study aims to generate an overview, and the outlined results are suitable for informing future directions.35 Implications for clinical practice and future research Caring for and protecting HCPs should be a fundamental part of the health sector.2 It is the shared responsibility of healthcare organisations to facilitate adequate occupational health services and to provide and equip HCPs with the needed skills, knowledge and capacity to protect themselves.2 These study outcomes indicate direction for future research and can be used by researchers, leaders, policy makers and staff. Outlined results should be taken into consideration when creating, implementing and coordinating well-being initiatives for employees in the field of healthcare. Understanding the content and focus of ongoing/available well-being initiatives will contribute to identifying the gap in knowledge, defining further scientific delineation and objectives and ultimately developing appropriate strategies for improving quality of care and patient safety, healthcare worker retention as well as healthcare system sustainability.2 Effective ways to improve well-being among HCPs will not only contribute to reduced absenteeism, lower turnover and satisfied HCPs but will also indirectly enhance the quality and safety of care. Individual level Individuals should communicate their wishes and needs so these can be addressed. Demonstrating leadership and empowerment in this process is crucial. Participating in surveys to achieve the highest possible response rate, as well as expressing wishes and needs during other opportunities such as annual meetings with the manager or team meetings, can help facilitate this. Leadership level Actions tweaking the work environment of healthcare workers to improve well-being must be conducted according to quality cycles, since this supports evidence-based working. Actions must be evaluated to ensure efficient and meaningful care. Leaders have a role in ensuring safe, supportive and welcoming teams and work contexts and facilitating and creating coherence within the organisation and between organisations. The challenge must be taken up to care for healthcare workers with healthcare workers. Future research is recommended to investigate which organisational initiatives are matching the wants and needs of HCPs. Furthermore, studies about well-being initiatives' effectiveness are favourable to being able to constructively improve the well-being of HCPs (teams) in a supportive work environment.7 Conclusion Interviews revealed an overview of 203 initiatives. The study provides insight into initiative types, fragmentation and shortcomings. In conclusion, initiatives should focus on predetermined needs and problems and should be based on evidence. Opportunities for togetherness and collaboration appeared by discovering the overlap in comparable initiatives among hospitals. The more specific initiatives and the differences between provided initiatives among hospitals lead to opportunities to learn from each other’s best practices. The future needs to offer evidence-based initiatives in collaboration with professionals in a context-adaptive fashion, like action research. Footnotes Funding: This research is carried out within the healthcare worker resilience and well-being programprogramme of the Consortium Quality of Care of the Netherlands Federation of University Medical Centres (NFU). Patient consent for publication: Not applicable. Ethics approval: This study does not involve experiences or data of humans, posing no ethical, legal or security issues. Participation was voluntary. Informed consent was not obtained since gathering personal data was not the aim of the study in accordance with the Medical Research Involving Human Subjects Act (WMO). Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed. Data availability statement All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information.