Effectiveness of Physical Activity Interventions Using Wearables and Smartphone Applications for Individuals With Cardiovascular Diseases and Stroke: A Systematic Review and Meta‐Analysis Authors: Ajith Kumar Vemuri, Yasaman Rahimi, Alireza Vafaei Sadr, Seyyed Sina Hejazian, Shouhao Zhou, Jonathan Hakun, Christopher Sciamanna, Vida Abedi, Ramin Zand Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundLack of physical activity is a major risk factor for cardiovascular diseases. Wearables and smartphones offer potential advantages in cost, accessibility, and scale to change physical activity. This systematic review aims to determine if interventions comprising smartphones and wearables are effective in enhancing physical activity among individuals with cardiovascular disease.MethodsPubMed, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were searched for randomized controlled trials, published since January 2000, on wearables and smartphone applications to enhance physical activity among patients with cardiovascular disease. Nonrandomized trials and interventions without a smartphone/wearable component were excluded. Risk of bias was assessed by the Cochrane Collaboration tool. Meta‐analyses were performed to assess the pooled effect on steps per day, distance, oxygen consumption, and (moderate‐to‐vigorous) physical activity in minutes per day.ResultsFourteen randomized controlled trials were included. Interventions comprising smartphones and wearables resulted in a mean difference of 1097.4 (95% CI, 409.2–1785.6; P=0.0018) steps per day, and 3.9 (95% CI, 0.2–7.6; P=0.0413) minutes of moderate‐vigorous physical activity per day compared with control groups.ConclusionThis meta‐analysis showed that interventions comprising smartphones and wearable devices are effective at increasing physical activity among patients with cardiovascular disease. Wearables and smartphones could provide accessible and tailored interventions to enhance physical activity. Nonstandard Abbreviations and Acronyms behavior change techniques Clinical PerspectiveWhat Is New? Interventions that use smartphones and wearable activity trackers have been shown to increase objectively measured physical activity in individuals with cardiovascular diseases.Participants who received digital interventions showed significant gains in daily steps and minutes spent in moderate to vigorous physical activity compared with those who received usual care.The review also shows that most interventions rely on behavior change techniques such as self‐monitoring and feedback, whereas very few explicitly apply established behavioral theories or adaptive intervention strategies. What Are the Clinical Implications? Increasing physical activity is essential for secondary prevention in cardiovascular disease, yet many patients do not engage in traditional cardiac rehabilitation due to time, distance, or financial barriers.Smartphones and wearable activity trackers offer an accessible and scalable approach to extend physical activity support beyond clinical settings.The observed increase of >1000 steps each day and additional minutes of moderate‐to‐vigorous activity suggest that wearables and smartphones can meaningfully complement routine clinical care.It is important to note that device accuracy may be reduced in patients with impaired gait, such as survivors of stroke, and long‐term adherence to digital interventions remains insufficiently studied.Future clinical implementation should emphasize evidence‐supported behavioral strategies and personalization to enhance engagement and sustain improvements in physical activity. Clinical Perspective What Is New? Interventions that use smartphones and wearable activity trackers have been shown to increase objectively measured physical activity in individuals with cardiovascular diseases.Participants who received digital interventions showed significant gains in daily steps and minutes spent in moderate to vigorous physical activity compared with those who received usual care.The review also shows that most interventions rely on behavior change techniques such as self‐monitoring and feedback, whereas very few explicitly apply established behavioral theories or adaptive intervention strategies. Interventions that use smartphones and wearable activity trackers have been shown to increase objectively measured physical activity in individuals with cardiovascular diseases. Interventions that use smartphones and wearable activity trackers have been shown to increase objectively measured physical activity in individuals with cardiovascular diseases. Participants who received digital interventions showed significant gains in daily steps and minutes spent in moderate to vigorous physical activity compared with those who received usual care. Participants who received digital interventions showed significant gains in daily steps and minutes spent in moderate to vigorous physical activity compared with those who received usual care. The review also shows that most interventions rely on behavior change techniques such as self‐monitoring and feedback, whereas very few explicitly apply established behavioral theories or adaptive intervention strategies. The review also shows that most interventions rely on behavior change techniques such as self‐monitoring and feedback, whereas very few explicitly apply established behavioral theories or adaptive intervention strategies. What Are the Clinical Implications? Increasing physical activity is essential for secondary prevention in cardiovascular disease, yet many patients do not engage in traditional cardiac rehabilitation due to time, distance, or financial barriers.Smartphones and wearable activity trackers offer an accessible and scalable approach to extend physical activity support beyond clinical settings.The observed increase of >1000 steps each day and additional minutes of moderate‐to‐vigorous activity suggest that wearables and smartphones can meaningfully complement routine clinical care.It is important to note that device accuracy may be reduced in patients with impaired gait, such as survivors of stroke, and long‐term adherence to digital interventions remains insufficiently studied.Future clinical implementation should emphasize evidence‐supported behavioral strategies and personalization to enhance engagement and sustain improvements in physical activity. Increasing physical activity is essential for secondary prevention in cardiovascular disease, yet many patients do not engage in traditional cardiac rehabilitation due to time, distance, or financial barriers. Increasing physical activity is essential for secondary prevention in cardiovascular disease, yet many patients do not engage in traditional cardiac rehabilitation due to time, distance, or financial barriers. Smartphones and wearable activity trackers offer an accessible and scalable approach to extend physical activity support beyond clinical settings. Smartphones and wearable activity trackers offer an accessible and scalable approach to extend physical activity support beyond clinical settings. The observed increase of >1000 steps each day and additional minutes of moderate‐to‐vigorous activity suggest that wearables and smartphones can meaningfully complement routine clinical care. The observed increase of >1000 steps each day and additional minutes of moderate‐to‐vigorous activity suggest that wearables and smartphones can meaningfully complement routine clinical care. It is important to note that device accuracy may be reduced in patients with impaired gait, such as survivors of stroke, and long‐term adherence to digital interventions remains insufficiently studied. It is important to note that device accuracy may be reduced in patients with impaired gait, such as survivors of stroke, and long‐term adherence to digital interventions remains insufficiently studied. Future clinical implementation should emphasize evidence‐supported behavioral strategies and personalization to enhance engagement and sustain improvements in physical activity. Future clinical implementation should emphasize evidence‐supported behavioral strategies and personalization to enhance engagement and sustain improvements in physical activity. Recent evidence highlights a decade‐long rise in cardiovascular disease (CVD) burden, the leading cause of mortality globally, especially in low and middle‐income countries, 1 , 2 , 3 underscoring the need to develop cost‐effective and accessible interventions. 2 , 4 Over the years, an abundance of research has firmly established a lack of physical activity as a major risk factor for CVD and the health benefits of light, moderate, and vigorous physical activity. 1 , 5 , 6 , 7 Although effective physical activity interventions exist for CVD patients, their implementation is limited by high costs, potentially reaching $60 000 per quality‐adjusted life year gained. 8 Smartphones and wearable trackers offer potential advantages in accessibility, cost, scale, and the ability to deliver interventions. Although smartphones and wearable trackers generally provide reliable measurements of physical‐activity metrics (eg, steps, heart rate) in cardiac populations, in certain subgroups with impaired gait (eg, after stroke or when using assistive devices), measurement accuracy may decline and should therefore be interpreted with caution. 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 Additionally, the efficacy of smartphones and wearable trackers in improving physical activity remains unclear. Multiple studies have tried to address this question. Pfaeffli et al.'s systematic review in 2016 addressed the use of mobile health (mHealth) interventions for CVD self‐management; however, the review included only 2 studies on physical activity. 14 In 2018, Coorey et al.'s meta‐analysis concluded that larger, controlled studies of longer duration are required to establish the effectiveness of smartphone applications for CVD self‐management. 15 Kacie et al.'s 2021 systematic review and meta‐analysis of smartphone applications' effectiveness to improve physical activity in patients with CVD provided initial evidence on this question. 16 However, their study included individuals with hypertension in the cohort with CVD and omitted trials using wearable trackers. This systematic review and meta‐analysis aim to explore the recent evidence and determine Using the Participants, Interventions, Comparator, Outcomes, Timing, and Setting framework, this review aimed to determine whether, among adults with CVDs, digital interventions using smartphones and wearable activity trackers, compared with usual care or controls, increase objectively measured physical activity outcomes, steps per day, minutes per day of moderate‐to‐vigorous physical activity, 6‐minute walk distance, or peak oxygen consumption (VO2) at the end of the intervention period in randomized controlled trials. Additionally, this study seeks to identify the behavioral theories and techniques used in these interventions. METHODS Search Strategy The authors declare that all supporting data are available within the article. This systematic review is reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‐Analyses statement 17 and the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. 18 A systematic literature search was conducted to identify relevant studies published from 2000 up to February 2025. The search encompassed 3 electronic databases: PubMed, the CENTRAL (Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials), and Web of Science. The search aimed to find randomized controlled trials evaluating the effectiveness of physical activity interventions using wearables or smartphone applications to promote physical activity in cardiovascular populations, compared with a control group. Search terms included relevant Medical Subject Headings terms (eg, Mobile Applications, Wearable Devices, Exercise, Cardiovascular Diseases, Randomized Controlled Trial) combined with keywords and text words searched in titles and abstracts. The initial search yielded 556 results from PubMed, 1536 from CENTRAL, and 625 from Web of Science. Additionally, the reference lists of included studies and relevant systematic reviews were manually screened to identify any potentially eligible trials not captured by the database search. The full detailed search strategies used for each database are available in Appendix S1. Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria Studies were included in this meta‐review if they met specific criteria based on the Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, and Study Design 19 framework. Eligible studies were randomized controlled trials published in English between January 2000 and February 2025. The study population consisted of both adults (aged 18 years or older) and adolescents with established CVD (such as coronary heart disease, stroke, or heart failure). Interventions were required to focus on promoting physical activity, using wearable technology (eg, activity trackers, smartwatches) or smartphone or tablet‐based mHealth applications as a core component, either alone or as part of a multicomponent program. The comparison group could be any control condition, including usual care, attention control, waitlist, or an active control. Finally, studies needed to report at least 1 postintervention measure of physical activity, assessed either objectively or via self‐report. Studies were excluded if they were nonrandomized designs, published before 2000, or those without cardiovascular disease. Interventions relying solely on video conferencing or phone calls without a core wearable/smartphone application element were also excluded. Furthermore, studies that did not report physical activity outcomes were ineligible. Study protocols, conference abstracts, and other non‐peer‐reviewed publications were not included. Screening and Selection Process The study selection process involved 2 stages (Figure 1). Initially, titles and abstracts retrieved from the database searches were independently screened by 2 review authors against the eligibility criteria. Subsequently, the full texts of potentially relevant articles were obtained and independently assessed for final inclusion by 2 review authors. Any disagreements encountered during the title/abstract screening or full‐text review stages were resolved through discussion and consensus between the 2 reviewers. If consensus could not be reached, a third review author was consulted for a final decision. PRISMA flow diagram demonstrating the flow of studies through the review. PRISMA indicates Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‐Analyses. Data Extraction The extracted information covered several key areas. Study characteristics included the study identifier (eg, first author and year), publication year, location, stated aims, trial type (randomized controlled trial), and intervention duration. Population details encompassed sample size, baseline demographics, and the study's inclusion and exclusion criteria. Detailed information on the intervention was extracted, including the type of wearable devices or smartphones used, the specific components and delivery mode of the intervention, and the nature of the control group comparison. Outcome measures were documented, including primary and secondary outcomes reported by the study authors, specific physical activity metrics used (eg, steps, moderate‐to‐vigorous physical activity), the timing of outcome measurements, and the study's main conclusions regarding intervention effects. Furthermore, information on the behavioral theory explicitly cited by the authors was recorded, if available. The specific behavior change techniques (BCTs) implemented within each intervention were identified and coded by the review authors based on intervention descriptions, using the BCT Taxonomy v1. 20 For studies featuring multiple relevant intervention arms, data were extracted for the arm that used the wearable or smartphone application with the most additional components compared with the control condition. If essential data were missing or unclear in the published report, supplementary materials were reviewed. Risk of Bias Assessment The methodological quality and risk of bias for each included study were assessed independently by 2 review authors using the Cochrane risk of bias tool, which evaluates 6 key domains. Disagreements between the 2 reviewers regarding the risk of bias ratings were resolved through discussion and consensus or by consulting a third review author if necessary. Each domain was judged as having a low risk, unclear risk, or high risk of bias based on criteria adapted from the Cochrane Handbook. The following domains were assessed. (1) Random sequence generation: This risk was judged based on whether the method used (eg, computer‐generated numbers) was appropriate to produce comparable groups. Studies not describing the method adequately were rated as unclear risk, whereas methods like sequential allocation were rated high risk. (2) Allocation concealment: Assessment focused on whether the method used (eg, central randomization, sealed opaque envelopes) was sufficient to prevent foreknowledge of group assignment before or during participant enrolment. Studies not describing the concealment method were rated as unclear risk. (3) Blinding of outcome assessment: This was evaluated considering the methods used to measure the primary physical activity outcomes. Studies using primarily objective measures (eg, accelerometers) assessed by blinded personnel were generally rated low risk. Studies relying heavily on subjective self‐report outcomes without clear assessor blinding were considered at a higher or unclear risk of detection bias. Blinding of participants and personnel delivering the interventions was noted as generally infeasible in these types of behavioral studies. (4) Incomplete outcome data: This domain assessed whether attrition and exclusions were adequately reported and addressed. Low risk was assigned if attrition was low (<15%) and balanced, reasons were reported, and appropriate analyses (eg, intention‐to‐treat) were used. Higher or differential attrition led to unclear or high‐risk ratings. (5) Selective reporting: Risk was assessed by comparing reported outcomes against those listed in trial registrations or protocols. Studies reporting outcomes as prespecified were rated low risk. (6) Other bias: This domain considered other potential sources of bias, such as significant baseline imbalances between groups that were not adjusted for. Statistical Analysis All meta‐analyses were performed using random‐effects models (DerSimonian–Laird and restricted maximum likelihood estimators) implemented in the “meta” and “metaphor” R packages. Each study‐specific mean difference (MD) was treated as a random effect assumed to vary around an overall pooled MD, with between‐study variance (τ 2 ) estimated using restricted maximum likelihood. This approach accounts for expected heterogeneity in interventions, devices, and populations and yields more conservative pooled estimates than fixed‐effects models. The primary outcomes synthesized quantitatively were changes in physical activity levels, specifically steps per day, minutes of moderate‐to‐vigorous physical activity per day, distance [meters], and VO2 peak [mL/kg/min]. Change‐from‐baseline scores (mean±SD) were calculated or extracted for the intervention and control groups for each study. Where necessary, data reported in weekly units were converted to daily averages (eg, dividing minutes per week by 7). A random‐effects model was employed for all meta‐analyses to account for expected heterogeneity between studies. The overall treatment effect was calculated as the pooled MD with corresponding 95% CIs comparing the change in the intervention group to the change in the control group for each outcome. Statistical heterogeneity across studies was quantified using the I 2 statistic. Values of I 2 were interpreted according to standard thresholds (<25% indicating low, 25%–50% moderate, and >50% high heterogeneity). Visual inspection of forest plots also contributed to the assessment of heterogeneity. Potential publication bias was assessed by visual examination of funnel plot asymmetry for each outcome analysis. Formal testing for funnel plot asymmetry was conducted using Egger's regression test. RESULTS Title and abstract screening of 2717 unique articles led to the full‐text assessment of 110 articles, with 14 studies 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 ultimately included in this review (Figure 1). Population and Intervention Characteristics The characteristics of the included studies and interventions involved 1057 participants with cardiovascular diseases from various populations. Coronary heart disease or myocardial infarction was the most frequently studied population, encompassing 8 of the 14 studies included in this review. These studies investigated various specific populations within this category, including patients diagnosed with myocardial infarction or postacute myocardial infarction (3 studies), patients broadly defined with coronary heart disease or coronary artery disease (3 studies), and individuals with coronary heart disease/acute coronary syndrome (1 study). Additionally, specific subgroups were targeted, such as a cohort comprised exclusively of women with coronary heart disease (1 study). Two studies included participants with stroke. Additionally, 2 studies included patients with broader CVD diagnoses and 1 study adolescents (12–18 years) with moderate‐to‐complex congenital heart disease (Table 1). In all studies, physical activity was promoted through a smartphone or wearable device. In most studies, the application was supported by a pedometer or accelerometer. Table 1Characteristics of Included StudiesStudyIDMean age, y/N (randomized)Intervention durationFollow‐up timeMeasurement typeControlInterventionBehavioral theoryPopulationType of deviceMitropoulos 202453.8/3026 wk24 wkObjectiveSupervised gym‐based resistance training and aerobic exerciseOnline home based resistance training combined with aerobic exercise[Goals and planning: goal setting (outcome), action planning], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior, self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior, feedback on outcome(s) of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal, graded tasks]Patients with MICommercialVarnfield 201455.7/946 wk24 wkObjectiveStandard ardiac rehabilitationThe Care Assessment platform used a smartphone for health and exercise monitoring, and delivery of motivational and educational materials to participants via text messages and preinstalled audio and video files (including understanding cardiovascular disease, symptoms and management)[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), action planning, review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, Self‐monitoring of behavior, Self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Regulation: reduce negative emotions]Patients with MICommercialYudi 202056.8/1688 wk8 wkObjectiveStandard cardiac rehabilitationA multifaceted intervention through a smartphone application. It incorporates all core aspects of cardiac rehabilitation; namely exercise prescription, dynamic tracking of cardiovascular risk factors, assessment of dietary habits, heart health education, education on secondary prevention pharmacotherapy as well[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior, self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior], [Natural consequences: Information about health consequences], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Identity: framing/reframing]CHD, acute coronary syndromeCommercialBeckie 202461.2/4712 wk12 wkObjectiveStandard cardiac rehabilitationApp that displayed progress, education videos, interaction with a health coach, peer support[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support (emotional)], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]Women with CHDCommercialBernal‐Jiménez 202459.4/12836 wk36 wkSubjectiveStandard cardiac rehabilitationmHealth intervention through an app on mobile or tablet. App established aims to achieve physical activity, food consumption, blood pressure, smoking and therapeutic adherence and provided education BT: phases of change theory; [Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior, self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal, habit formation]CADCommercialPatel 202158/19624 wkObjectiveIndividualized, self‐set goals and preset goalsGamification: the game included points and levels that were run automatically (participants did not have to actively play the game—just strive for step goals) and provided daily feedback via text message on their progress.[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution:graded tasks], [Reward and threat: nonspecific reward], [Scheduled consequences: behavior cost]ASCVD or a 10‐y ASCVD risk score ≥7.5%CommercialWillinger 202315.1/9712 wk12 wkObjectiveWearable without receiving further instructionsStudy participants received brief and informative text and video messages on their smartphone daily over a period of 12 wk BT: Bandura's social cognitive; [Goals and planning: review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: self‐monitoring of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]All patients at an age of 12 to 18 y, with moderate‐to‐complex CHDCommercialGrau‐Pellicer 201962.9/3412 wkObjectiveConventional rehabilitationTo have bidirectional feedback: participants could visualize results and exchange messages with the researchers[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support (emotional)], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal, graded tasks], [Identity: identity associated with changed behavior], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]Ischemic or hemorrhagic strokeCommercialDuscha 201859.9/2512 wk12 wkObjectiveUsual caremHealth + human coach[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), Review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support (unspecified)], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution: graded tasks], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]Patients with cardiovascular diseaseCommercialXu 202253.7/7212 wk24 wkObjectivePersonalized daily step goals were set in the WeChat applet backstage based on patients' baseline daily step counts and the goals increased gradually from the baseline by 15% each week during the first 6 wk and then remained constant during the past 6 wkPatients in the individual group received 140 points every Monday (20 points per d), and if they met their daily step goal, no points were deducted; if they did not, 20 points were deducted.[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), Review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: Feedback on behavior, Self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support (unspecified), social support (emotional)], [Comparison of behavior: social comparison], [Repetition and substitution: graded tasks], [Reward and threat: material reward (behavior), nonspecific reward, social incentive], [Scheduled consequences: behavior cost], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]CHD (including acute MI and unstable angina)CommercialPaul 201656.3/236 wk6 wkObjectiveUsual careIndividual and group rewards for achieving goals were provided. As the participant reached their target number of steps, their fish's fins and tail grew. If all 4 members reached their step count target on at least 5 d of the wk then the group was rewarded by another sea creature being added to their fish tank, eg, sea horse or crab[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support (unspecified)], [Comparison of behavior: social comparison], [Repetition and substitution: graded tasks], [Reward and threat: nonspecific reward, social reward]StrokeCommercialJo 202457/416 wk6 wkObjectiveStandard cardiac rehabilitationThe application included exercise modes for warmup, aerobic, stretching, and resistance exercises, and it provided exercise records and a diary[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal]Patients post acute MICommercialLunde 202059/10254 wk54 wkObjectiveUsual careThe app provided automatic reminders and evaluations of tasks and weekly goal achievement. The patients received short, tailored, individualized motivational feedback directly through the app 1–3 times/wk. Additionally, they received comprehensive individual feedback via email once a week for the first 12 wk and every fourth wk for the rest of the y.[Goals and planning: goal setting (behavior), problem‐solving, action planning, review behavior goal(s)], [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior], [Social support: social support], [Shaping knowledge: \instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Associations: prompts/cues], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability]CAD and valve surgeryCommercialGallagher 202361.2/39032 wk32 wkSubjectiveUsual careGamification centered on a cartoon heart avatar as a virtual representation of the user's health. Users could maintain their own health by completing the active behavior change components and, by doing so, earn coins to purchase and provide healthy food, exercise, medications, and relaxation items [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior, self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Comparison of behavior: social comparison] [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal, graded tasks], [Reward and threat: nonspecific reward, social reward], [Identity: framing/reframing], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability] CHDCommercialCAD indicates coronary artery disease; CHD, coronary heart disease; mHealth, mobile health; and MI, myocardial infarction. Characteristics of Included Studies [Feedback and monitoring: feedback on behavior, self‐monitoring of behavior, self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior], [Shaping knowledge: instruction on how to perform a behavior], [Natural consequences: information about health consequences], [Comparison of behavior: social comparison] [Associations: prompts/cues], [Repetition and substitution: behavioral practice/rehearsal, graded tasks], [Reward and threat: nonspecific reward, social reward], [Identity: framing/reframing], [Self‐belief: verbal persuasion about capability] CAD indicates coronary artery disease; CHD, coronary heart disease; mHealth, mobile health; and MI, myocardial infarction. Analysis of the 14 studies identified 27 unique BCTs used across the interventions, as shown in Table 2, with a total of 130 BCT instances recorded. The most frequently employed BCTs centered on monitoring and feedback, with self‐monitoring of behavior present in all 14 studies and feedback on behavior in 13. Goal‐setting techniques were also highly prevalent: Goal setting (behavior) and review behavior goal(s) were each identified in 11 studies. ‘Instruction on how to perform a behavior was also very common, found in 10 studies. Other frequently used techniques included prompts/cues (9 studies), graded tasks (7 studies), and verbal persuasion about capability (7 studies). A broader range of BCTs addressing areas such as social support, other reward/threat techniques, natural consequences, and identity were employed less frequently across the included studies. Control groups differed across studies, varying from usual care to some form of education through a presentation, booklet, or education visit. Table 2Distribution of Behavioral Change TechniquesBCT nameCountSelf‐monitoring of behavior14Feedback on behavior13Goal setting (behavior)11Review behavior goal(s)11Instruction on how to perform a behavior10Prompts/cues9Graded tasks7Verbal persuasion about capability7Information about health consequences6Behavioral practice/rehearsal6Self‐monitoring of outcome(s) of behavior5Nonspecific reward4Social support (unspecified)4Action planning3Social support (emotional)3Social comparison3Framing/reframing2Social reward2Behavior cost2Social incentive1Material reward (behavior)1Goal setting (outcome)1Reduce negative emotions1Identity associated with changed behavior1Habit formation1Feedback on outcome(s) of behavior1Problem solving1BCT indicates behavior change technique. Distribution of Behavioral Change Techniques BCT indicates behavior change technique. Outcome Measures Most studies measured physical activity objectively with an external accelerometer or pedometer, or with a smartphone's built‐in accelerometer or pedometer. One study subjectively measured physical activity using a questionnaire. Most studies reported their results in mean minutes of physical activity per day or daily step count. Other reported outcomes were mean hours of physical activity per week, mean minutes of physical activity per week, kilocalories per day, and metabolic equivalent of task per day. Eleven studies reported a change in physical activity levels between the baseline and the end of the intervention, and seven studies reported posttreatment physical activity levels. Risk of Bias of Included Studies The risk of bias assessment for the 14 included studies revealed variability in methodological quality across different domains. Regarding random sequence generation, the majority of studies (12 out of 14) were rated at low risk, typically employing computer‐generated sequences often managed by independent personnel or services. One study was rated unclear risk due to insufficient description, and 1 pilot study using sequential allocation was rated high risk. For allocation concealment, 8 studies achieved a low‐risk rating through methods like sealed opaque envelopes or central randomization. However, the risk was unclear in 5 studies due to inadequate reporting of the concealment mechanism, and 1 pilot study (Paul, 2016) 30 using sequential allocation was rated high risk. Blinding of outcome assessment was rated low risk in 9 studies, which generally cited blinding of assessors and often used objective primary outcomes. The remaining 5 studies were rated unclear risk, because blinding status was not mentioned. The risk of bias from incomplete outcome data was judged low in 10 studies, characterized by low (<15%), balanced attrition and the use of intention‐to‐treat analyses. Three studies presented an unclear risk due to attrition rates around 15% or slight imbalances, whereas 1 study was rated high risk because of high (>20%) and differential attrition. The risk of selective reporting bias was deemed low for all 14 studies; trials were generally preregistered, and reporting aligned with stated methods and outcomes. Concerns regarding other potential biases were common, with 7 studies rated as unclear risk, frequently arising from comparisons between technology‐based interventions and less intensive usual care controls, raising possibilities of performance bias or Hawthorne effects. Three studies were assessed as high risk due to combined factors such as pilot study limitations, nonrandom allocation, or significant differential attrition (Figure 2). Bias plot of 14 studies in meta‐analysis. Effect on Physical Activity Effect on Steps Four studies (k=4) 21 , 26 , 28 , 29 , 30 reported changes in daily steps from baseline to post intervention. A total of 321 participants (166 in the intervention group and 155 in the control group) were included in these studies. Random effects models revealed a statistically significant improvement in steps in the intervention groups compared with the control group (MD, 1097.38 [95% CI, 409.17–1785.60]; z=3.13, P=0.0018). The analysis indicated no statistically significant heterogeneity among the included studies (I2=0.0% [95% CI, 0.0%–84.7%]; Cochran's Q=1.03, df=3, P=0.7930) (Figure 3). Meta‐analysis of steps per day. Effect on Distance This meta‐analysis included 4 studies (k=4), 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 encompassing 334 participants (175 in the intervention group and 159 in the control group), that reported on changes in distance (meters). Three studies measured the distance as 6‐minute walk tests, whereas 1 study reported the daily distance walked. The results from random effects models indicated no statistically significant difference in distance between the intervention and control groups (MD, 20.04 [95% CI, −8.25 to 48.32]; z=1.39, P=0.1650). The heterogeneity analysis revealed moderate heterogeneity across the studies (I2=39.6% [95% CI, 0.0%–79.5%]; Cochran's Q=4.97, df=3, P=0.1742) (Figure 4). Meta‐analysis of distance. Effect on Moderate and Vigorous Activity The meta‐analysis of light, moderate to vigorous physical activity included 5 studies (k=5), 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 33 comprising 480 participants (252 in the intervention group and 228 in the control group). The random effects models demonstrated a statistically significant improvement in moderate to vigorous physical activity in the intervention groups compared with the control group (MD, 3.88 [95% CI, 0.15–7.60]; z=2.04, P=0.0413). The heterogeneity analysis indicated low heterogeneity across the studies (I2=3.9% [95% CI, 0.0%–80.0%]; Cochran's Q=4.16, df=4, P=0.3845) (Figure 5). Meta‐analysis of minutes in light, moderate, and vigorous physical activity. Effect on VO2 (Maximal Oxygen Consumption) This meta‐analysis of VO2 involved 4 studies (k=4) 21 , 28 , 31 , 34 with a total of 198 participants (99 in the intervention group and 99 in the control group). The results from random effects models showed no statistically significant difference in VO2 between the intervention and control groups (MD, 0.51 [95% CI, −1.71 to 2.73]; z=0.45, P=0.6519). The heterogeneity analysis indicated no statistically significant heterogeneity across the studies (I2=0.0% [95% CI, 0.0%–84.7%]; Cochran's Q=1.40, df=3, P=0.7063) (Figure 6). Meta‐analysis of VO2. VO2 indicates oxygen consumption. DISCUSSION This meta‐analysis suggests that interventions comprising smartphones and wearable devices are effective at increasing physical activity among patients with CVD. Specifically, both steps per day and minutes in moderate‐to‐vigorous physical activity significantly increased compared with controls. No significant effect was found in increasing VO2 and distance walked. Self‐monitoring of behavior and feedback on behavior were the most commonly used behavior techniques in the interventions. Only 2 interventions explicitly mentioned the underlying behavioral theories—phases of change theory and Bandura's social cognitive theory in their interventions. A significant MD of 1097 steps per day was found between the intervention and control groups. This finding is comparable to previous meta‐analyses measuring steps per day in various other chronic disease populations, including CVD. 16 , 35 , 36 Although there is no established evidence of the clinical significance of this increase in steps per day among CVD patients, a similar increase in 350 to 1100 steps among obstructive pulmonary disease patients is reported to have resulted in a reduction of hospital admissions. 37 In populations with cardiac conditions, however, the clinical relevance of such a change remains uncertain, particularly given that device accuracy can vary with gait characteristics and mobility status. Nevertheless, these results indicate that smartphone/wearable‐based interventions show promise in promoting physical activity and may achieve greater benefits with continued advances in sensor accuracy and more comprehensive intervention designs that integrate behavioral‐change strategies and personalized feedback. A significant MD of 3.88 minutes per day in moderate to vigorous physical activity was found between intervention and control groups. This finding slightly differs from the existing meta‐review on patients with CVD, where the difference was 5.8 minutes per day. 16 No significant increases were found in distance and VO2. We could not find any pool analysis measuring the change in distance and VO2 among CVD patients. This is due to the fact that most of the studies are recent (after 2020). Although the increase in distance measured in the 6‐minute walk test is not significant, a 20‐m increase was observed between the intervention and control groups. There is evidence that small improvements in 6‐minute walk test negatively predict cardiovascular events. 38 Analysis of the 14 studies identified 27 unique BCTs used across the interventions, as shown in Table 2, with a total of 130 BCT instances recorded. The most frequently employed BCTs centered on monitoring and feedback, with self‐monitoring of behavior present in all 14 studies and feedback on behavior in 13. Goal‐setting techniques were also highly prevalent: Goal setting (behavior) and review behavior goal(s) were each identified in 11 studies. Instruction on how to perform a behavior was also very common, found in 10 studies. Other frequently used techniques included prompts/cues (9 studies), graded tasks (7 studies), and verbal persuasion about capability (7 studies). A broader range of BCTs addressing areas such as social support, other reward/threat techniques, natural consequences, and identity were employed less frequently across the included studies. Control groups differed across studies, varying from usual care to some form of education through a presentation, booklet, or education visit. Self‐monitoring of behavior and feedback on behavior were highly prevalent in the interventions. These behavioral techniques are known to be associated with increased physical activity among patients with CVD. However, the lack of details on how these interventions are designed and why certain components of the interventions are included, and the content of the intervention messages not being publicly available, restricts the replicability of these interventions. Additionally, action and coping planning, 39 , 40 , 41 which are proven to have moderating effects on sustaining physical activity, are rarely present in the analyzed interventions. Use of these proven behavioral techniques, along with emerging techniques such as Just‐in‐Time‐Adaptive interventions, 42 , 43 , 44 could further help improve physical activity among individuals with CVD. Our study has the following limitations: Most studies in this review focused on results directly post intervention. Therefore, we could not obtain an insight into the sustainability of increased physical activity levels. Further research should include long‐term follow‐up assessments. Furthermore, step‐count accuracy and reliability vary across devices and populations. Research indicates that wearable and smartphone step‐count accuracy can decline at slow walking speeds or in individuals with atypical gait patterns, such as those recovering from stroke or using assistive devices. Accordingly, the pooled step‐count increase observed in this meta‐analysis should be interpreted with caution in such subgroups, as measurement error may attenuate or inflate true changes in physical activity. Also, it would be interesting to obtain more insight into adherence to the use of wearables and smartphone applications and factors influencing adherence, for example, personal preferences for apps and behavior change techniques. Greater adherence may mediate the effect of the intervention on physical activity. With more information on sustainability, adherence, and long‐term effectiveness, wearables and smartphone apps could be designed that are most effective in promoting physical activity to optimize impact on public health. In this review, it was not possible to study the effectiveness of each behavior change technique since they co‐occur with other intervention characteristics and behavior change techniques. Lastly, the population with CVD was predominantly composed of patients with heart disease, restricting generalization to other patients with CVD, such as survivors of stroke. CONCLUSIONS Smartphone and wearable interventions were effective in increasing physical activity for those with CVD. The results indicate a potential benefit of smartphone apps in patients with CVD, although caution is warranted due to the low number of trials and most being in coronary heart disease. Larger‐scale research is needed to investigate the effect of smartphone and wearable applications across CVD diagnoses to be able to determine the ideal length and components of successful interventions. Sources of Funding None. Disclosures None. Supporting information Appendix S1