How hospital-based violence prevention professionals work: a qualitative study Authors: Lars Erik Almquist, Ellen A Ahlness, Ali Rowhani-Rahbar, Sarah Cusworth Walker, Christian D Helfrich Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundHospital-based violence intervention programs (HVIP) hinge on the ability of violence prevention professionals to assist the recovery of intentionally injured patients to prevent further spread of violence. Yet, we know little about the tactics these professionals use or whether the tactics developed by one violence prevention professional transfer to another. To address these gaps, this research catalogs the tactics frontline professionals use to meet the recovery needs of violently injured patients.MethodsSemi-structured interviews were conducted with 23 hospital-based violence prevention professionals to identify tactics used in everyday work. Interviews were organized around 10 “hinge points” on the patient’s recovery continuum deemed integral to program success, identified a priori. The Action Actor Context Target Time (AACTT) rubric helped ascertain essential information about each tactic identified via inductive thematic analysis.ResultsWe identified 214 tactics used by violence prevention professionals. Tactics addressing the initial patient encounter (n=49), trustbuilding efforts with patients (n=44), and service navigation (n=39) represented the largest and most diverse share of tactics identified. Comparably few tactics engaged patient retention (n=11) or aftercare as patients exited the program (n=3).SignificanceDissemination of these tactics will strengthen the skillsets of current HVIP professionals, while enhancing the training of future violence prevention personnel. Findings may support the creation of practical, readily deployable toolkits to translate tactical insight to diverse contexts where HVIPs operate, including HVIPs not yet established.Level of evidenceVI: Evidence from a single descriptive or qualitative study. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC Hospital-based violence intervention programs hinge on the work of violence prevention professionals. Hospital-based violence intervention programs hinge on the work of violence prevention professionals. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS To our knowledge, this is the first study detailing the specific tactics deployed by these professionals during their day-to-day work. To our knowledge, this is the first study detailing the specific tactics deployed by these professionals during their day-to-day work. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE, OR POLICY Findings from this study provide a foundation on which future research may test the effectiveness of individual and/or sets of tactics. Tactics deemed most effective may then be translated to contexts across the country and included in training for future generations of hospital-based violence prevention professionals. Findings from this study provide a foundation on which future research may test the effectiveness of individual and/or sets of tactics. Tactics deemed most effective may then be translated to contexts across the country and included in training for future generations of hospital-based violence prevention professionals. Background Community-level violence operates as a social contagion, with exposure transmitting from person-to-person to form networks of individuals exposed to violence.1–3 In many cities, small proportions of the population are vectors for overwhelming shares of violence.4 5 During the peak of the American homicide epidemic in the 1980s-1990s, as little as 0.2% of Boston residents were responsible for half of the city’s murders and three-quarters of firearm-involved assaults.6 Currently, in Chicago, 70% of the city’s non-fatal firearm offenses may be attributed to a network representing six percent of the population.4 Yet, even within these dense networks, violence is not distributed equally. A one percentage point increase in the proportion of friends who are shot increases one’s own probability of being shot by 144%.5 Once violently injured, a substantial risk of re-injury7–9 and death10 remains. Violence also spreads via retaliation. Adolescents subjected to firearm violence are 2.5 times more likely to perpetrate serious violence within 2 years of that incident than adolescents unexposed to violence.7 This reciprocal relationship between violence exposure and retaliatory response may transform an initial violent act into a cascade of violence extending throughout the network,1 much like the spread of an infectious disease.3 4 11 One solution to community-level violence is to treat it like a social contagion and directly engage individuals “infected”1 by violence with treatment and support to disrupt the contagion’s spread. Hospital-based violence intervention programs (HVIP) represent one mechanism to treat violence as a contagion. Violently injured patients are almost always treated within hospital emergency departments and trauma centers.12 13 Consequently, hospitals serve as rare venues where violently injured individuals can be reliably identified and contacted at a moment of urgent need. The shock of physical violence affords a temporary window of time when individuals may be receptive to help, extracting themselves from circumstances where they face an elevated risk of further violence exposure or of committing violence against others.14 15 HVIPs harness these moments by connecting intentionally injured patients to violence prevention professionals,16 17 frequently referred to as “credible messengers”18 due to their own lived experience of violence. Violence prevention professionals leverage this credibility to enroll violently injured patients into intensive case management services designed to address the social determinants of health and modifiable risk factors that exacerbate health disparities19 20 and influence a patient’s risk of future violence exposure.21–24 HVIPs hinge on the work of the violence prevention professional. Reaching a patient at the hospital bedside means connecting with someone likely situated within a violent network. This is a rare opportunity to shape the life trajectory of someone traditionally difficult to reach outside of punitive law enforcement intervention.25 26 The American College of Surgeons’ Committee on Trauma, whose members are leaders in HVIP program development, published a blueprint for hospitals interested in starting a program.27 A core principle of HVIP operation is that “Case managers develop an almost instant rapport with victims.”28 The blueprint does not state how to achieve this. Gaining the trust of violently injured patients requires social capital. Patients are in pain, terrified of death, feeling trapped without agency over their bodies, and worried about law enforcement interrogations. The linchpin of the HVIP model is the violence prevention professional’s ability to develop a trusting relationship with these patients to prevent violent re-injury while simultaneously supporting their recovery. Little is known about the specific tactics that explain how hospital-based violence prevention professionals accomplish their work. By tactics, we mean the specific activities undertaken within a strategy to achieve a particular goal;29 in this case, the goal of preventing further violence exposure. Violence prevention professionals serve as “credible messengers,”18 community members with lived experiences of violence that generate instant social capital with patients. This status affords a unique authority to speak with patients about the origins and aftermath of their injuries, topics traditionally inaccessible to hospital personnel or law enforcement. Emerging research also engages the gendered experiences of women in violence prevention work.30 Yet, gender and credible messenger status are identities, not tactics. We do not know, for example, what tactics violence prevention professionals use to build trust, de-escalate conflict, navigate social service bureaucracy, or ensure the long-term safety of patients on their caseloads. Nor do we know what tactics are uniquely used by women working in hospital-based violence prevention. Further, we do not know the extent to which violence prevention professionals deploy similar tactics across institutions or whether tactics are largely unique to their local environment. This study seeks to identify and describe the specific tactics hospital-based violence prevention professionals use to support the recovery of violently injured patients. Methods Participant identification and recruitment The population included a nationwide sample of hospital-based violence prevention professionals. Professionals were defined as staff responsible for engaging patients from the hospital bedside through post-discharge recovery efforts. HVIP leadership and hospital medical staff were excluded. Recruitment occurred via a multi-pronged, purposive sample. First, recruitment efforts prioritized professionals honored for their outstanding work at the annual conferences of the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention (HAVI), the leading training and technical assistance agency for HVIPs across the country. Second, individuals were directly recruited by the principal investigator at the HAVI’s 2023 annual conference. Third, HVIP supervisors nominated staff members. Fourth, snowball sampling after interviews helped identify potential participants. Finally, the social media platform LinkedIn was used. Messages with study information and eligibility criteria were sent to relevant profiles of the first 100 search results returned from each query of known HVIP job titles, including “violence prevention professional,” “hospital responder,” and “violence intervention specialist.” Initial contact messages in each strategy were followed by two follow-up messages sent at 1-week intervals after initial contact. Data collection Invitations included links to enrollment forms that gathered information about the professional’s HVIP and optional self-reported demographic information. Semi-structured interviews were conducted between December 2023 and March 2025 using the Zoom videoconferencing platform. Audit trail memos of interviews were maintained throughout the study. The Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research (SRQR) checklist31 was used while drafting the manuscript. Interview guide development Interviews asked about tactics they use at 10 points on a patient’s recovery continuum. These points, which we refer to as “hinge points,” were developed through consultation with HAVI leadership, conversations with HVIP personnel, and a review of the literature. Hinge points represent areas along the recovery continuum where the professional’s successful engagement of one stage of a patient’s recovery opens a door to the next. For example, meeting a patient’s recovery goals hinges on navigating complex social services bureaucracies. Knowing which services to navigate in which order hinges on the prioritization of patient needs. Effective prioritization hinges on the cultivation of sufficient trust for a patient to articulate acutely vulnerable needs amidst profound trauma. This trust hinges on effective rapport-building at the hospital bedside. A senior-level HAVI director and a HAVI working group of violence prevention professionals (anonymous to the authors) vetted the initial interview guide, provided critical edits, and approved the final instrument. Hinge point descriptions are in table 1. The interview guide is in online supplemental appendix A. Table 1Hinge points on the patient recovery continuumHinge pointDescription1Information gathering and hospital relationshipsObtaining patient information from clinical staff, emergency medical services (EMS), electronic health records (EHR), etc; informs strategies for initial patient (and/or family) encounter2Initial patient encounterFirst meeting with patient, typically at bedside; may involve family/friends3TrustbuildingInitial and ongoing cultivation of trust, rapport, and goodwill with patient4Retaliation de-escalationEfforts to diffuse retaliatory violence (often conducted with family/friends)5Program recruitmentPatient recruitment and enrollment into intensive case management services6Assessment and recovery planningDevelopment of patient-specific, needs-based goals to guide recovery7Prioritization of recovery needsPrioritization of recovery needs to achieve patient goals with limited resources8Referrals and service navigationIntensive case management and support navigating wraparound services9Program retentionEfforts to ensure patient continually progresses toward recovery goals10Program exit and aftercareCreation of long-term patient safety plan; patient exit from program Hinge points on the patient recovery continuum The Action Actor Context Target Time (AACTT)32 rubric consists of five elements for describing an evidence-based practice in an actionable manner. The AACTT was used during the interviews to ascertain essential information about each tactic. Grounded prompts were used to ensure that participants included details related to the five AACTT components when describing each tactic. AACTT components with examples from the original text are in table 2. Table 2AACTT definitions and examples*DomainDefinitionExamplesActionA discrete observable behaviorPrescribing antihypertensives, providing a referral to a specialist, washing hands, setting a policyActorThe individual or group of individuals who perform (or should/could) the actionPrimary care physician, pharmacist, social worker, resident, administrator, middle manager, head of unit, policymakerContextThe physical, emotional, or social setting in which the actor performs (or should/could) the actionExamination room, doctor’s office, outside a patient room, in a boardroom, stressful vs calm situation, if patients’ relatives are present or notTargetThe individual or group of individuals for/with/on behalf of whom the actor performs the actionPatient with diabetes and blood pressure above 140/80 mm Hg, patient wanting to quit smokingTimeThe time period and duration that the actor performs the action in the context with/for the targetAt annual review, next time a patient visits, every week, over the next 6 months*From Presseau et al.32 AACTT definitions and examples* *From Presseau et al.32 Analysis Interview transcription occurred in two stages. First, Rev artificial intelligence software transcribed the recordings. Second, transcripts were manually compared with the recordings and revised to ensure accuracy, as needed. Inductive thematic coding33–35 helped identify tactics reported by participants at each hinge point and capture themes in the use of tactics across the recovery continuum. Human subjects Informed consent was obtained to record all interviews. Participants were compensated with a $50 gift card. The University of Washington Institutional Review Board deemed this study exempt. Results Participant characteristics Twenty-three violence prevention professionals (hereafter referred to as participants or interviewees) completed interviews. Participants were majority Black (56.5%) and Latinx (30.4%) and evenly split between women (52.2%) and men (47.8%). More than half (56.5%) of interviewees were age 40 or younger, with one-quarter (26.1%) of participants age 30 or younger. Experience ranged from 2 to 22 years (mean, 7.3; SD, 7.5). Geographic distribution over-represented participants from coastal states (American Hospital Association Regions 2 and 9) and under-represented HVIPs from the Great Lakes (Region 5). All but one interviewee (96.3%) reported a lived experience of violence (table 3). Table 3Participant characteristicsN (%)Age 26–306 (26.1) 31–353 (13.0) 36–404 (17.4) 41–452 (8.7) 46–501 (4.3) 50+4 (17.4)Gender Female12 (52.2) Male11 (47.8)Ethnicity Black/African American13 (56.5) Latinx/Hispanic7 (30.4) Multi-racial2 (8.7) White/Caucasian1 (4.3)Lived experience of violence Yes22 (95.7) No1 (4.3)Geography (American Hospital Association Region) Region 1 (CT, MA, ME, NH, RI, VT)1 (4.3) Region 2 (NJ, NY, PA)7 (30.4) Region 3 (DC, DE, KY, MD, NC, VA, WV)4 (17.4) Region 4 (AL, FL, GA, MS, PR, SC, TN)2 (8.7) Region 5 (IL, IN, MI, OH, WI)1 (4.3) Region 6 (IA, KS, MN, MO, ND, NE, SD)0 (0.0) Region 7 (AR, LA, OK, TX)0 (0.0) Region 8 (AZ, CO, ID, MT, NM, UT, WY)0 (0.0) Region 9 (AK, CA, HI, NV, OR, WA)8 (34.8)Employment experience. Years (SD) Years in hospital-based violence prevention7.3 (7.5) Participant characteristics Prevalence of tactics across hinge points We identified 214 tactics used by interviewees across the patient recovery continuum. Tactics addressing the initial patient encounter (n=49), trustbuilding efforts with patients (n=44), and service navigation (n=39) represented the largest and most diverse share of tactics identified. Comparably few tactics focused on de-escalating retaliation (n=14), recruitment (n=5), retention (n=11), or recovery aftercare (n=3). Tactics engaging a patient’s social networks were virtually absent across all hinge points. A full list of tactics is found in table 4. Select tactics related to (i) establishing interviewee legitimacy within the hospital, (ii) trustbuilding with patients, (iii) meeting patient recovery needs, and (iv) de-escalation are discussed below. Tactics are highlighted for (a) their repetition across interviews or (b) unique engagement of an issue or challenge broadly expressed by interviewees. Table 4Tactics used by hospital-based violence prevention professionalsIDTacticDescription/SignificanceHinge point #1: information gathering and hospital relationships1.1Dress for work in street clothesSignals violence prevention professional’s (VPP) legitimacy to patient; indicates that VPP is not a clinician or law enforcement1.2Dress for work in office attireSignals VPP’s legitimacy to clinical and administrative staff, security, law enforcement, etc.; indicates VPP is bonafide hospital employee1.3Prominently wear hospital ID badgeSignals VPP’s legitimacy to clinical and administrative staff, security, law enforcement, etc.; indicates VPP is bonafide hospital employee1.4Wear hospital-branded attireSignals VPP’s legitimacy to clinical and administrative staff, security, law enforcement, etc.; indicates VPP is bonafide hospital employee1.5Dress for work in scrubsSignals legitimacy to all parties; bypasses discrimination for wearing street clothes and patient skepticism that office attire represents law enforcement affiliation1.6Create “open office” design for HVIP teamAll HVIP staff share communal office space; facilitates instant communication, idea sharing, debriefing opportunities, and referrals1.7Embed open office and HVIP team within emergency departmentStation all VPPs and HVIP staff in emergency department office space to facilitate immediate communication with clinicians regarding patient updates1.8Embed social services and mental health professionals within open officeWorkforce specialists, therapists, etc. share space with HVIP team; facilitates warm handoffs from VPPs1.9Identify high-level hospital champions in every departmentFacilitates strategic relationship-building with influential leadership at the department level; links HVIP to all relevant hospital departments1.10Invite hospital champions to HVIP team meetingsProvides department leadership with concrete knowledge of HVIP activities and needs; supports advocacy efforts; supports champion’s ownership of HVIP relationship1.11Establish liaison relationships with every hospital departmentFacilitates strategic relationship-building with frontline staff and middle management department interfacing with HVIP; supports knowledge sharing and warm handoffs1.12Establish consult relationship with doctors and nursesVPPs block off time in schedules to review cases with clinical staff; facilitates information sharing, troubleshooting, and coordinated patient engagement1.13Attend emergency department rounds: clinical updatesVPP accompanies clinicians on patient rounds to obtain clinical information on patient status, recovery, updates1.14Attend emergency department rounds: promote HVIP servicesVPP accompanies clinicians on patient rounds to provide information about how HVIP services may benefit specific patients; clinician may act as advocate for program1.15Conduct HVIP rounds: patient-focusedVPP team collectively makes rounds to touch base with all admitted patients on entire HVIP caseload; provides opportunities to see how other VPPs interact with patients1.16Conduct HVIP rounds: clinical staff-focusedVPP team collectively makes rounds to check-ins with department liaisons, managers, and leaders; provides facetime and opportunities to discuss cases ad hoc, as needed1.17Conduct HVIP rounds: collective debriefingVPP team collectively debriefs after holding rounds; VPPs have more context to provide feedback, suggestions, solutions regarding individual cases1.18Create list of patients cases shared with medical social workersWork with medical social workers to identify overlap in caseloads, collaborate on patient recovery, and avoid duplication of recovery efforts1.19Organize presentations and teaching opportunities for hospital staff to advertise programVPPs participate in hospital trainings and speaking events to introduce HVIP; teach about trauma-informed care and unique trauma injured patients are undergoing1.20Rotate weekend shifts across entire staffDistributes busiest shifts across staff to balance caseload numbers and intensity of individual cases1.21Assign weekend shifts to select VPPsHighly skilled and senior VPPs work only weekend shifts to receive highest volume of severe cases1.22VPPs with weekend shifts take mandated time off during workweekVPPs working the most intensive shifts mandated to take days off each week for self-care; remaining weekday work is administrative1.23Receive EMS notifications in advance of patient arrivalProtocols established to immediately page VPP when patient is in transit via EMS or admitted to emergency department; VPPs 'on call’ return to hospital1.24Enter trauma bay or emergency department before or as patient is admittedHVIP establishes relationship with emergency and trauma departments to give VPP access to meet with and observe patients immediately after admission1.25Obtain identifying information from patient while in emergency department/trauma bayVPP collects as much information as possible from alert patient (e.g., age and caregiver names); VPP prepares for family engagement and initial bedside visit.1.26Obtain identifying information from patient's belongings or personObtaining identifying information from incapacitated patient's belongings (e.g., ID in wallet) or physical presentation (e.g., tattoos) may help confirm relationship to caregivers1.27Obtain injury information from Emergency Medical Technician (EMT)/EMS transport teamGather information from EMT/EMS regarding injury, condition, and conversations with patient ASAP (i.e., before EMT/EMS receives next discharge call)1.28Inform hospital security of caregiver’s names and connection to patientHospitals with tight security heavily screen visitors; VPP can expedite process for caregivers who can establish relationship to injured patient1.29Screen for patient’s HVIP eligibility in advance of first encounterVPP uses EMT report and chart notes to confirm type of injury, age, and other metrics to determine HVIP eligibility; minimizes need for screening at bedside1.30Obtain patient background information from electronic health recordVPP uses patient identification to prepare for first encounter (e.g., using address to identify potential connections based on where patient lives in the community)1.31Obtain patient background information from nursing chart notesChart notes often contain information and context not entered into health record; VPP uses notes to fill in gaps in knowledge of patient's condition, background, etc.1.32Obtain patient current information from nurse(s) regarding information left out of notesConsultation with nurse(s) to obtain contextual information about the patient that did not make the formal chart notes (e.g., emotional state, affect, and conflicts)1.33Receive list of patients discharged straight from emergency department (for follow-up)Provides VPP with contact information for patients treated and discharged without admission (or while VPP off duty); list sent at weekly intervals for cold call follow-ups1.34Establish informal relationships with emergency department leadershipCreating informal relationships “outside of work” with key leadership may facilitate VPP access to emergency department, help identify hospital champions, etc.1.35Create “clinician coffee cart”Uses snacks and caffeine to introduce program and VPP's work; particularly helpful with clinicians who are difficult to work with or dismiss the program1.36Serve as go-between when loved ones and patient can't contact one anotherThe VPP serves as a liaison to communicate information (e.g., messages from patient) when loved ones are prohibited from seeing patient. Occurs when the hospital goes into lock-down, patient goes into surgery, etc.1.37Hold moment of silence with trauma team after patient passes away in trauma baySolidifies unity between VPPs and trauma surgeons and nurses; shared grief strengthens relationships for downstream work with patients who surviveHinge point #2: initial patient encounter2.1Initiate first contact in the emergency department or trauma bayVPP meets patient in emergency department or trauma bay (may be dependent on notification from EMS)2.2Initiate first contact at patient’s bedsideVPP meets patient at their bedside after admission postemergency department/trauma bay2.3Knock before enteringKnocking notifies patient someone is entering; signals respect for patient's space2.4Do not knock before enteringKnocking sounds like gunshots to some patients with severe post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD); VPP may alternatively enter slowly and identify their presence2.5Ask permission to enter patient’s roomAllows patient to establish a relationship with VPP on their terms2.6Ask caregiver consent to enter room if patient <18 years oldVPP builds rapport with caregivers by seeking permission to engage patient who is a minor; establishes relationship on caregiver’s terms2.7Offer to return another time if patient desiresAllows patient to establish relationship with VPP on their terms2.8Conduct rapid scan of patient’s room: to assess general atmosphereVPP quickly discerns the atmosphere of the room (e.g., sorrow, anger, shock, tension, and calm)2.9Conduct rapid scan of patient’s room: identify individuals present (general)VPP quickly assesses the number and general characteristics of people in the room (e.g., age, and emotional state)2.10Conduct rapid scan of patient’s room: identify caregivers (specific)VPP quickly assesses room to identify immediate caregivers; this is typically a mother or maternal caregiver2.11Conduct rapid scan of patient’s room: assess patient demeanorVPP quickly assesses patient’s alertness, body language, and emotional state to inform initial introduction and approach2.12Code-switch (general)VPP adjusts language, posture, and approach depending on who is present; conveys same information in a dialect the listener readily understands2.13Ask visitors to identify relationship to patientAllows visitor to define association with patient; necessary when patient is asleep or in too much pain to respond to direct conversation with VPP2.14Adjust engagement with patient: patient is aloneVPP creates space for more honest conversation; may mention own lived experience of violence2.15Adjust engagement with patient: loved ones are presentVPP speaks to patient and entire room simultaneously if caregivers are present, describes program options for both patient and families (e.g., Victims of Crime Act [VOCA] services)2.16Adjust engagement with patient: single caregiver presentVPP directly engages caregiver in conversation with tone of respect, as if they are partners receiving information or updates2.17Adjust engagement with patient: multiple caregivers presentVPP directly engages caregiver in conversation in tone of respect used to recognize elders (e.g., using “ma’am” and “sir” when directly addressing caregivers)2.18Adjust engagement with patient: romantic partner is presentVPP reassures partner of visitation rights and the importance of the romantic partner's presence to patient recovery2.19Adjust engagement with patient: friends or extended family presentVPP speaks in more informal tone, often adopts street language2.20Maintain constant engagement approach in all circumstancesVPP treats all circumstances the same regardless of who is present (i.e., no adjustments)2.21Adjust tone of voice: younger patientVPP speaks in a more comforting and reassuring tone to younger patient2.22Adjust tone of voice: older patientVPP speaks in a more respectful adult-to-adult tone if patient is older2.23Adjust tone of voice: sedated/heavily medicated patientVPP limits engagement and reassures patient they will return later; follow-up conducted when patient may more clearly engage VPP2.24Adjust tone of voice: alert/awake patientVPP engages patient in direct conversation; adjusts tone and posture as necessary2.25Adjust tone of voice: engaged patientVPP directly engages patient in conversation; may inquire more about how patient is doing, what patient's needs are, or to sit and talk with patient2.26Adjust tone of voice: avoidant patientVPP speaks plainly to patient, offers to leave basic information (e.g., flyer) with HVIP information, and asks permission to follow-up another time2.27Adopt motherly tone with patient (female VPPs)Female VPPs adopt tone of concern and comfort when speaking to patient, as if they are a parent speaking to a sick or wounded child2.28Adopt grandmotherly tone with patient (female VPPs)Older female VPPs adopt tone of comfort and reassurance that patient is loved, as if they are a doting grandmother2.29Adopt posture of “casual indifference”; engaging VPP is up to patient (i.e., voluntary)Male VPPs make first encounter simple, do not force program on patient; takes posture that they are here to help but patient can choose to accept or not; no mandates2.30Sit instead of stand; get on patient’s level (male VPPs)Male VPPs may sit in or pull up chair next to patient when speaking to get to patient’s eye level; clinicians speak down to patients, VPP gets on patient's level2.31Bring “goodie bag” to patientInitial gift builds trust; bag also doubles as resource for holding miscellaneous patient items when they are moved between rooms and hospital floors2.32Express gratitude that patient is aliveVPP tells patient they are happy patient survived so they can help support patient's recovery2.33Provide flyer with HVIP information to patientCreates exchange between VPP and patient; sets up VPP’s introduction; presents HVIP as source for recovery needs postdischarge2.34Create YouTube video introducing the HVIP teamHVIP and VPP give context to themselves they can’t always communicate quickly in person; YouTube link provided on flyer or QR code2.35Frame introduction: VPP explains their role by what they are notVPP leads introduction by articulating what they are not, instead of what they are; assuages patient skepticism of motives of yet one more authority figure showing up2.36Frame introduction: VPP is not clinicianVPP distinguishes self from clinical authorities whose medical advice may be interpreted as mandates of what the patient can/can’t do, can/can’t eat, etc.2.37Frame introduction: VPP is not with the policeVPP distinguishes self from punitive law authority who may interrogate patient2.38Frame introduction: VPP will not report any information to policeVPP promises confidentiality and reassures patient they are here to support recovery, not cooperate with police2.39Frame introduction: VPP establishes connection to the communityIndicates credibility to patient that the VPP personally understands patient's life and neighborhood context; immediately establishes commonalities with patient2.40Frame introduction: VPP mentions personal experience of violence (as applicable)Establishes “credible messenger” identity based on experience with violence2.41First question after introduction asks if patient feels safe returning to their communityShows patient VPP is concerned about their whole being, not just their body; assesses risk post-discharge risk factors; answers inform future recovery planning2.42Ask patient if VPP can meet any immediate needsVPP offers to meet basic needs; initial interaction is one of VPP offering to serve patient, not command action or demand information2.43Sitting with patientClinicians and medical staff speak down to patient from standing position at all times; sitting with the patient frames VPP as a peer offering support2.44Speak to patient even if patient remains silent; ask questions about basic needsSpeaking to unengaged patients allows the VPP to introduce themselves and the program in a way that sets up a follow-up visit; patients are often more engaging on VPP return2.45Offer to follow-up laterVPP asks permission to follow-up; if no, patient leaves flyer about HVIP services; if yes, VPP returns up to three times to see if patient is willing to engage2.46Inform patient that declining services at first does not prevent obtaining future supportPatients immediately uninterested in HVIP services are informed that the offer of support remains open well after discharge from hospital (typically 12 months)2.47Ask caregivers if VPP can meet any immediate needsVPP places self in serving position, not authority, to meet needs and build trust2.48Ask silent or unengaged friends to leave the roomToo many people surrounding patient may be overwhelming; VPP encourages least “helpful” members present to step away2.49Follow-up with silent or unengaged friendsVPP speaks with silent or unengaged friends separately; makes sure they are involved, but does so separate from patient bedsideHinge point #3: trustbuilding3.1Conduct daily check-insVPP continually makes presence known; may be full conversation, or may be stopping by just to say hi and then leaving3.2Conduct intermittent check-insVPP avoids overwhelming patients in more critical condition; these patients will have long stays, more opportunities for VPP to visit; check-in intervals reduced (e.g., 2x/week)3.3Progressively introduce more information about the program with each visitIncremental introduction of program avoids overwhelming patient with information; VPP sets up next visit by leaving each conversation with an offer for patient to think about3.4Ask if patient is comfortableIndicates concern for patients most basic needs; sets up ability for VPP to satisfy basic needs3.5Offer to adjust patient's pillows or beddingPatients with severe injuries often do not have the mobility to adjust their positions in hospital bed; small gesture indicates VPP’s attention to patient’s quality of life3.6Offer to obtain extra bedding or items of comfortSignals that VPP “has pull” with the nursing or facilities departments; small gesture indicates to patient that VPP is someone who can get things done3.7Ask if patient is boredIndicates concern for patients felt need to experience joy or satisfaction; sets up ability for VPP to satisfy patient's boredom3.8Offer for patient to borrow iPad or tabletProvides high-quality source of entertainment with unlimited ways to satisfy boredom; offering expensive item indicates patient’s well-being is valuable3.9Ask if patient is satisfied with television channel optionsVPP knows hospital televisions have limited channels and minimal on-demand entertainment; sets up ability for VPP to satisfy entertainment desires of patient3.10Offer for patient to borrow gaming consoleMeets patient desire for entertainment; gaming console is interpreted as a unique privilege for the patient (i.e., patient is treated as special, not every patient receives this)3.11Teach challenging concept to spark engagementEngages patient with a challenging task that patient may never have attempted before (e.g., solving a Rubik's cube); provides opportunity to strategize together3.12Invite patient to play card gameExtends invitation for patient to jointly participate in an activity; card games such as Uno are familiar to patient, indicating shared interests with VPP3.13Play competitive games with patientInitiates collaborative competition to create shared experience; e.g., Rubik's cube speed competition, playing card games, playing Uno, creating video game competitions.3.14Invite patient to participate in creative hospital/program offeringsBreaks routine and boredom of hospital stay; may introduce patient to new experience (e.g., university hospitals may have access to atypical resources, such as 3D printers)3.15Ask about quality of hospital foodVPP knows patient is not satisfied with hospital food; sets up ability for VPP to satisfy nutritional needs with something patient enjoys3.16Ask about patient’s specific craving in the momentPatients may have specific desires that cannot be met by hospital food service departments; (e.g., patient's favorite ice cream to soothe sore throat after intubation)3.17Ask about patient’s favorite foodShows VPP cares about patient preferences and likes or dislikes; provides VPP an opportunity to discuss patient's favorite food and context around it (e.g., childhood favorite)3.18Offer to bring the patient food same day or next encounterProvides an opportunity for the VPP to follow-through on their offer and commitment; builds patient trust that VPP will be loyal in the future3.19Purchase food from location where patient would eat; bypass cafeteriaIndicates patient is valued and worthy of more than the cheapest or most convenient option available.3.20Purchase meal for yourself in addition to patient mealPatients are more likely to engage difficult aspects of their trauma over a shared meal; comes across as two people talking, not patient being questioned3.21Listen to patient’s storyAllows patient to recount their version of events, current feelings, fears, etc., on their own terms instead of always responding to questions (i.e., from clinical staff)3.22Sit beside patient while they tell their storySitting removes power dynamic imposed by clinicians and others standing over patient; sitting at eye level indicates conversation, not transaction3.23Sit in silence togetherBeing present while watching television or sitting in silence reassures patient that VPP cares about relationship with patient; patient not just another stop on hospital rounds3.24Offer to talk about how patient was injuredExpresses interest in patient’s story; patients may not feel believed when they recount events; VPP allows patient to tell story on their own terms3.25Avoid discussion of how patient was injuredPatients may not want to talk about injury out of trauma or lack of trust that VPP will not communicate with law enforcement; allows patient to communicate on their terms3.26Speak about perpetrator of patient’s injuryPatients may want to speak about perpetrator, knowing VPP will not relay information to police; this is a fundamental part of the patient’s story3.27Look up perpetrator on social media togetherPatients may want to speak about perpetrator; social media connection offers a way for VPP to share vulnerable experience with patient3.28Process emotions with patientCreates safe space for patient to process emotions they may feel the need to cover up in the presence of family or friends; mitigates the perceived need to “be strong”3.29Validate patient’s feelings and emotionsVPP reassures patient that feeling strong emotions is normal in their condition; the patient is responding as a normal person should3.30Reassure patient that crying is okayCommunicates that crying is a natural, often uncontrollable response to trauma; it does not mean the patient is weak (or, for male patients, “less of a man”)3.31Reassure patient that being scared is okayCommunicates that fear is a natural response to trauma; it does not mean the patient is weak (or, for male patients, “less of a man” or a “coward”)3.32Discuss experience of PTSDProvides context for what patient is feeling and why; helps explain to patient why they are feeling certain symptoms;3.33Discuss therapy and mental health treatment for PTSDVPP builds on discussion of PTSD symptoms to explain importance of mental healthcare; introduces therapy options, ideally on-site at hospital for long patient stays3.34Establish non-traditional mental health and therapy treatment optionsPatients often opposed to traditional therapy; creating alternative treatment options (e.g., “barber shop therapy”) may increase patient's likelihood of processing trauma3.35Assure patient the focus is on the “here and now”Shifts patient focus from reliving trauma to plans for the future and hope for recovery; VPP directs conversations to immediate next steps to help patient move forward3.36Provide comforting physical touch (female VPPs holding patient's hand)Physical touch is powerful for patients and may lead patients to “break down” with VPP; physical touch is likely better received from female over male VPPs3.37Identify additional outlets for emotional supportCommunicates to patient that there are multiple resources to help provide support; indicates to patient that they are not alone, that others need support as well3.38Recognize cues in patient speech that indicate specific emotionsOffer to support patient based on cues; patients often speak in terms of regret, VPP may tap into those feelings in the present3.39Use cues to inform next steps in supporting patient’s recoveryVerbal cues may indicate felt needs patients feel they can’t or do not know how to operationalize; e.g., “I wish I'd finished school”; sets up VPP offer to help patient obtain General Education Development (GED) diploma3.40Tap into childhood memories and vision patient had for when they grew upAsking what the patient wanted to do when they grew up may trigger memories that the VPP can leverage to build trust; e.g., working to restore a dream a patient abandoned3.41Request support from community partners to engage patient's “childhood innocence”Leveraging community connections to creatively tap into lost patient hope for their life; e.g., getting a violin donated for a patient who gave up on playing classical music3.42Avoid interactions with police while inside hospitalMaintains patient trust that VPP is not a liaison to law enforcement or using relationship to obtain information that will be turned over to police3.43Inform patient it is their decision to engage with police or notGives patient agency over engagement with law enforcement3.44Advocate for patient if police attempt to pressure patient into talkingVPP serves as barrier between police and patient; may request officer to physically leave the room; indicates that you're standing up for the patientHinge point #4: retaliation de-escalation4.1Refer patient to monthly peer support meetings at hospitalLinks patient to third-party conflict specialists on site; not run by the HVIP or VPP team, so patient may feel more comfortable speaking honestly about their situation4.2Refer entire caseload to peer support meetings at hospitalReferring an entire caseload reduces stigma for patients who would otherwise be singled out as needing peer support; classes framed as standard procedure for HVIP services4.3Redirect patient’s concern with perpetrator back to immediate recoveryBrings focus back to “here and now” and enables VPP to pivot patient toward back to own recovery needs and goals4.4Redirect patient’s concern with perpetrator back to dreams for the futureShifts focus to patient’s postrecovery goals; provides VPP an opportunity to point out how these will be lost if patient retaliates or focuses extensively on perpetrator4.5Speak with patient about things they wouldn’t want to risk losing if they retaliateHelps frame consequences of retaliation for patient; having patient list these items slows down automatic desire for retaliation4.6Reassure patients with nothing to lose of their worth and their dreams for the futureSome patients may not be persuaded by appeals to family or risk of loss if they retaliate; VPP makes direct appeal to worth of patient's life and purpose in the world4.7Identify the loudest person in the roomThe loudest person in the room is often the agitator, not the most likely to retaliate4.8Isolate the loudest person in the roomSeparating the loudest person turns down the tension in the room, minimizes the reach of their words and actions instigating action in others4.9Identify the quietest person in the roomThe quietest person in the room may be the most likely to retaliate4.10Isolate the quietest person in the roomSeparating the quietest person enables the VPP to assess their demeanor up close, ask questions, and probe to see if they are contemplating retaliation or are just calm4.11Talk potential retaliator down from retaliating in while patient in surgery or treatmentEfforts to get loved ones to de-escalate often include appeals to how the patient would want to loved one to stay nearby for when they get out of the emergency room/trauma bay4.12Invoke potential retaliator’s incarceration (if known/applicable)Appeals to possible re-incarceration may force potential retaliator to take stock of consequences of retaliation; taking stock slows individual down, minimizes urgency4.13Invoke potential retaliator’s status as parent (if known/applicable)Appeals to children's well-being if retaliation results in individual's incarceration, death, or becoming future target of retaliation; slows down urgency to retaliate4.14Help potential retaliator with nothing to lose process emotions in the momentPotential retaliators may not be persuaded by various appeals; VPP slows down perceived urgency of retaliation by asking what individual is feeling, what’s on their mind, etc.Hinge point #5: program recruitment5.1Explain HVIP case management services available to patientVPP explains suite of support offerings in varying levels of detail (i.e., depending on extent of prior conversations, age and comprehension level of patient, etc.)5.2Extend invitation to highly engaged patients during initial encounterCapitalizes on relational connection already made; immediately links patient to HVIP5.3Delay program recruitment if patient is unengaged or shutting downHonors patient preference to not be rushed; VPP allows patient to dictate enrollment decisions and timeline5.4Establish HVIP team protocols for timing and frequency of postdischarge follow-upEach VPP contacts all patients on caseload at least once every set interval (e.g., 2 weeks) postdischarge; 2 weeks gives patient time to transition and acclimate back home5.5follow-up with patients who declined services at regular intervals after dischargeContact patients who did not accept services at 30-, 60-, and 90-day intervals to re-introduce program and HVIP services (note: exclude ”hard” refusals in follow-up attempts)Hinge point #6: assessment and recovery planning6.1Create standardized digital assessmentVPP helps HVIP leadership decide which indicators need to be collected from patient; attempts to standardize data collection across HVIP6.2Administer intake assessment form at bedsideVPP facilitates intake assessment with patient; establishes baseline for assessing patient progress in meeting recovery goals6.3Administer intake assessment in private locationIntake assessment may feel sensitive to patient; wait to complete assessment until visitors and clinicians are absent6.4Complete goal-setting formVPP takes intake form and guides patient through goal-setting for postdischarge recovery6.5Establish patient safety planVPP has patient assess own safety postdischarge; VPP probes for indicators of risk for retaliation against/by patient6.6Allow participant to identify recovery needsHaving patient identify recovery needs gives ownership over the process; VPP can help adjust expectations and communicate what is feasible, as needed6.7Establish goal-specific indicators to measure patient progressPatients may need benchmarks to stay motivated; agree on tangible actions that indicate if patient is making progress (e.g., number of job applications submitted per week, etc.)6.8Require patient to sign recovery planTreats recovery plan as a contract between patient and VPP; VPP signs as well, indicating commitment to support patient6.9Conduct 90-day check-in assessments of recovery plan progressMany patient goals take time to meet; conduct check-ins at quarterly intervals to give patient enough time to make progress, but not too long that patient loses motivationHinge point #7: prioritization of recovery needs7.1Inform patient of likely recovery needs based on patient’s situationBeing up front with patient about recovery challenges sets healthy expectations7.2Allow participant to prioritize recovery needsAllowing the patient to prioritize their needs gives agency over the process; cultivates patient ownership of their own recovery7.3Help patient process order of operations in satisfying recovery needsPatients may not be able to see all of the small requirements that must be met to satisfy large needs; VPP may help patient understand order of operations for meeting needsHinge point #8: referrals and service navigation8.1VPP lives in the community served by the hospitalResiding in the community served cultivates trust and comes with intimate knowledge of existing community assets and gaps in resources8.2Leverage existing community connectionsIf VPP lives in the community served, maintain regular connections so they are available when needed; mitigates need to build new relationships8.3Stay up to date about community coalition meetings and trainingsIdentifies referral offerings available and potential referral partners with resources to help patient recovery8.4Attend networking events and coalition meetings to identify potential partnersMeetings give VPP opportunity to network and discuss opportunities with other agency representatives in person instead of navigating phone tree options to identify correct point of contact8.5Introduce HVIP services at community events, coalition meetings, and trainingsVPP attends coalition meetings to introduce program and services8.6Establish relationships with county social service agencies used by patientsCounty social service tracking systems centralize communication and enable VPPs to see if patient has applied for and/or obtained various services (e.g., Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits)8.7Work behind the scenes with service agenciesConnect with agencies to obtain information about service availability to ensure VPP is not referring patient to resource with false hopes that services are available8.8Identify community champion(s)VPP and HVIP identify and work with key influencers in the community who can help identify needs, serve as ears on the ground, etc.8.9Identify champion(s) with lived experience of violence in the communityCommunity champions with lived experience may provide unique advocacy and support of VPP and HVIP vs residents without such experience8.10Use HVIP funds to meet patient’s basic needsUsing HVIP funds to meet basic needs (e.g., groceries, diapers, etc.) maintains trust and enables patient to focus on recovery priorities8.11Inquire about consequences of injury and/or extended hospital stayAsking patient about fallout from their injury helps VPP know the extent to which certain needs may be present (e.g., if patient has dependent children)8.12Offer to contact employer to communicate employee isn't delinquent on purposeContacting employer (without violating the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act [HIPAA]) regarding the patient having an emergency may preserve patient's employment; explains why patient did not show up to work8.13Offer to contact workforce advocate to help patient get back to workBeginning service navigation with employment inquiries engages patient priorities while allowing VPP to help patient meet immediate recovery needs8.14Offer to contact referral services on behalf of patientCalling on behalf of patient mitigates patient anxiety; gives VPP an opportunity to show they have connections and are able to get things done8.15Help patient secure safe housingVPP helps patient identify opportunities to find safe, affordable housing (e.g., Section 8 and links to housing agencies)8.16Help patient secure gainful employmentVPP helps patient identify employment opportunities; links to job resources; identifies patient hobbies and passions that may be linked to future employment8.17Help patient secure government identificationVPP informs patient of need for government ID; makes plan for patient to apply and obtain government ID8.18Host “ID Clinic”HVIP organizes periodic events for patients and relevant contacts (e.g., buddy system partners) to assist with applications for government IDs as a group8.19Help patient secure Social Security cardVPP informs patient of need for Social Security card; makes plan for patient to apply and obtain card8.20Help patient secure birth certificateVPP informs patient of need for birth certificate; makes plan for patient to apply and obtain birth certificate8.21Follow-through on commitment (general)VPP follows through on any commitment to patient; demonstrates loyalty and trustworthiness to patient8.22Jointly conduct taskVPP accompanies patient to appointment or task (generally)8.23Sit in silenceVPP sits in silence with patient, does not feel obligated to initiate conversation; may lead to patient opening up or may simply reassure patient VPP is still present8.24Discuss next steps while satisfying current needVPP uses interim time between appointments or while waiting to help patient identify next steps to meeting their recovery needs8.25Accompany patient to court/legal appointmentsVPP attends court visits involving patient, whether to meet lawyers, attend hearings, seek victims services (contextualized to patient situation)8.26Link patient to patient-specific legal resourcesVPP provides patient links to legal services; warm handoffs conducted to legal representatives, if available8.27Provide VOCA application supportVPP offers to help patient and/or family apply for VOCA funding for recovery services, funeral costs, etc.8.28Host “Expungement Clinic”HVIP works with legal partners to host an event where individuals with low-level offenses may receive support to expunge their criminal records8.29Establish ongoing partnerships with legal stakeholders for ongoing needsHVIP creates partnerships with bar-certified lawyers who may provide fre legal advice to patients, help review rejected VOCA applications, etc.8.30Drive patient to appointmentsVPP personally drives patient to appointments; uses time together to build rapport, obtain status updates, solve challenges8.31Follow-up after patient attends appointment or obtains servicesHolds patient accountable to recovery goals; immediate follow-up allows VPP to call social service agency to troubleshoot any issues that arose8.32Organize transportation for patientVPP ensures patient has transportation to appointments; calls rideshare (e.g., Lyft) for patient, as needed (i.e., if HVIP policy forbids driving patient)8.33Establish HVIP rideshare fund for program useHVIP establishes a business account with a rideshare company (e.g., Lyft); VPP uses funds to organize rides for patient to make appointments, have safe transportation options8.34Create “buddy system” to involve patient's trusted friends in the recovery processVPP asks patient to suggest their closest confidant who can serve as “buddy” to support patient during their recovery8.35Help buddy understand what patient is going throughPatient may be acting differently (e.g., easily angered, scared, etc.) after trauma; VPP explains to buddy what to expect and look for in patient mood, behaviors, etc.8.36Allow patient to invite buddy to any meeting with VPPVPP lets patient know that their buddy is able to join any meetup with VPP at any point and at any location; links buddy to long-term recovery8.37Allow patient to invite buddy to referral servicesVPP lets patient know that their buddy is able to accompany patient to their service referral appointments; links buddy to long-term recovery8.38Refer patient to services VPP knows buddy may benefit from as wellMany services or referrals will benefit the buddy as well (e.g., job fairs, alternative therapy options, etc.); VPP intentionally refers to services that will benefit both parties8.39Work with buddy to tag-team difficult recommendations for services or referralsPatients are often opposed to certain services (e.g., therapy); VPP separately invites buddy to encourage patient to engage alternative recovery services (e.g., barbershop therapy)Hinge point #9: retention of patient in program9.1Maintain open door policy for patient to return to the programCommunicate that patient is welcome to reach out for support for a set interval (e.g., 12 months), pending specific HVIP policy9.2follow-up with patient at regular intervalsBegin following up on a weekly basis, then biweekly, then each 30 days until HVIP policy requires closure of the case9.3Contact patient via textMaintain regular texting contact with patient; follow-up via text if patient has not responded in a while or have missed appointments9.4Contact patient via phone callMaintain regular phone contact with patient; follow-up via text if patient has not responded in a while or have missed appointments9.5Offer to put minutes on patient's prepaid phonesOffer to add phone time to patient's prepaid phones9.6Condition phone minutes on in-person meeting with VPPIncentivize patient to meet up with VPP in exchange for phone minutes; VPP uses the opportunity to obtain updates about the patient9.7Contact patient via social mediaMaintain contact with patient via social media platforms (e.g., Instagram) to keep track of patient's posts and continue the conversation9.8Conduct house visitsVisit patient’s house to see if patient is present and willing to meet in person9.9Contact patient’s mother if patient is unreachableContact patient’s mother about patient’s whereabouts, ask about recent updates, request mom to have patient reach out9.10Contact patient’s grandmother if patient unreachableContact patient's grandmother about patient’s whereabouts, ask about recent updates, request mom to have patient reach out9.11Contact street-level intervention professionals if patient unreachableContact violence prevention professionals who have knowledge of what is happening in the community; see if they have knowledge regarding patientHinge point #10: program exit and aftercare10.1Throw graduation party for patient completing programHVIP hosts formal “graduation” celebration to recognize and honor patient who meets recovery goals and exits HVIP program; patient receives “certificate,” etc.10.2Provide patient with aftercare recovery resourcesPatient given list of community resources that may be useful in the future, even if they were not needed during recovery period10.3Remind patient of “open door” policyAssure patient they may contact VPP or HVIP in the future; this is not the end of the relationship, simply the end of formal case management servicesED, emergency department; HVIP, hospital-based violence intervention programs; ID, identification; VOCA, Victims of Crime Act. Tactics used by hospital-based violence prevention professionals ED, emergency department; HVIP, hospital-based violence intervention programs; ID, identification; VOCA, Victims of Crime Act. Establishing legitimacy among hospital personnel Interviewees described tactics to establish their legitimacy within the hospital separate from any patient encounters. Specifically, Black participants reported that the need to justify their presence was rooted in experiences of racism and judgment of their physical appearance. Clinical and nursing staff, hospital security, and law enforcement regularly confront interviewees over their identities, assuming they are private citizens accessing restricted areas, rather than hospital employees conducting their jobs. One repeatedly articulated flashpoint centered around the clothing worn by interviewees. Clothing and first impressions Choosing work attire invokes a dilemma for interviewees. Intentionally dressing in street clothes (table 4; tactic code 1.1) builds rapport with patients, signaling the interviewee’s connection to a shared community and culture. It also signals they are not affiliated with law enforcement. Yet, adopting street attire elevates the likelihood of conflict with hospital staff and security regarding the interviewee’s appearance. To overcome this, interviewees prominently display their hospital ID badge [1.3] or adopt other indicators of hospital employment, such as a jacket with hospital branding [1.4]. These tactics yield mixed results. Dressing in traditional office attire [1.2] largely eliminates judgment of the interviewee. However, patients often associate office attire with law enforcement. One team sidestepped this dilemma by wearing hospital scrubs [1.5]. Scrubs signal legitimacy to hospital staff and security, who recognize the attire as a marker of patient-facing hospital personnel. They simultaneously signal legitimacy to patients, who implicitly distinguish the violence prevention professional from law enforcement. Trustbuilding The “trustbuilding two-step” One set of tactics we are calling the “trustbuilding two-step” emerged throughout interviews. In the first step, participants intentionally ask patients a question they know will elicit a negative response and trigger a felt need. This sets up step two, where the interviewee offers to personally meet that need. Interviewees ask patients if they are comfortable [3.4], knowing the answer will be no. They then offer to adjust the patient’s pillows or request an extra blanket from the nurse’s station [3.5,3.6]. Interviewees ask patients if they are satisfied with the selection of television channels available [3.9]. This sets up an offer to bring patients an iPad to use during their stay, courtesy of the HVIP [3.8]. Participants inquire if patients are bored, setting up opportunities to procure video game consoles [3.10], teach patients how to solve a Rubik’s Cube [3.11], or play card games like Uno [3.12]. Turning these activities into competitions [3.13] is particularly effective at winning over patients. Interviewees also rely on their connections to community resources. One interviewee at a university hospital follows up inquiries about boredom by inviting patients to a campus engineering lab to experiment with a 3D printer for the first time [3.14]. Another intentionally taps into the childhood innocence and dreams of patients [3.40]. After learning a patient abandoned a childhood passion for playing the violin, the interviewee leveraged their standing in the community [3.41] to acquire a violin from a local music academy. They surprised the patient with the gift at an ensuing rehabilitation appointment. The most frequently reported trustbuilding two-step involved food. Interviewees across the country ask about the quality of the hospital food [3.15]; confident patients want to eat virtually anything else. They then ask what patients desire in the moment [3.16] or what their favorite foods are overall [3.17]. Examples of the former include patient cravings for ice cream to soothe sore throats after being intubated. In the latter case, patients injured in a different part of the country from their upbringing might be nostalgic for a specific regional dish. In virtually every case where food was mentioned, the interviewee bypasses the hospital cafeteria [3.19] and returns with the patient’s desired item(s) either the same day or during their next hospital shift [3.18]. One participant maintains a personal commitment to purchasing a second meal for themselves, so they may eat together with patients [3.20]. This interviewee notes that patients are noticeably more comfortable speaking about the most traumatic experience of their life in the context of a shared meal, even with someone they have just met. Trust earned through mundane acts, even a fast-food meal shared at the hospital bedside, set the foundation for patients to trust the interviewee through the remainder of their recovery. The initial bedside encounter Participants deploy a greater diversity of tactics at the bedside compared with other hinge points. Bedside tactics were often described in general terms. For example, participants report rapidly scanning the room [2.8], intuitively adapting how they communicate based on who is present [2.14–2.19]. Interviewees refer to this as code-switching [2.12], a linguistic tactic of changing manners of speech and social engagement based on the immediate context.36 37 Interviewees address caregivers as “ma’am” or “sir,” then adopt street slang such as “homie” when speaking to patients alone [2.16–2.17]. Participants discuss de-escalation with caregivers using terms like “payback” and “retaliation.” This language converts to “spinning the block” and “pulling out the strap” with patients and friends [2.19]. Participants adjust their tone of voice if patients are younger [2.21] or older [2.22], sedated [2.23] or alert [2.24], engaged [2.25] or avoidant [2.26]. Female interviewees report adopting motherly [2.27] or grandmotherly [2.28] approaches, including gently touching a patient’s hand or forearm [3.36]. Male participants noted they must often signal to patients that no power dynamic is at play [2.29], frequently choosing to sit rather than stand over patients[2.30]. Certain interviewees adjust their approach if patients are alone [2.14] or loved ones are present [2.15]. They recalibrate their approach if a single caregiver [2.16], multiple caregivers [2.17], romantic partners [2.18], or others, such as siblings, cousins, or friends, are present [2.19]. However, other interviewees report maintaining the same approach for all visits regardless of the context [2.20]. Prioritizing recovery needs and navigating services Tactics prioritizing recovery needs and service navigation begin with the creation of a recovery care plan [6.2–6.8]. Some interviewees lay out up-front expectations regarding the tremendous post-discharge recovery needs and challenges patients are about to face [7.1]. Others believe this overwhelms patients, preferring to have each patient identify individual needs and recovery priorities [7.2]. In certain states, patients and their families are eligible to receive financial support for recovery services under the federal Victims of Crime Act (VOCA). Interviewees help patients immediately file a VOCA application [8.27] to begin the often-protracted application process as early as possible. Patients disproportionately prioritize obtaining safe housing and gainful employment, which require navigating a drawn-out bureaucratic process. To secure housing, patients need proof of reliable income. Thus, to safely relocate patients [8.15], interviewees must first help them secure stable employment [8.16]. To obtain a reliable job, interviewees help patients obtain government identification [8.17] to prove the patient’s identity. To obtain government identification, participants help patients first secure vital documents, such as Social Security cards [8.19] and birth certificates [8.20]. Thus, helping patients rebuild their lives in safe housing with gainful employment frequently begins well upstream—filling out paperwork to literally acknowledge the patient’s birth. Navigating these administrative hurdles provides opportunities for interviewees to maintain trust with patients. For example, simply sitting together in silence [8.23] is a powerful trust-maintaining tactic. Discussing timelines for achieving the next recovery goal [8.24] in a Department of Motor Vehicles lobby or accompanying patients to the courthouse for appointments [8.25] are simple tactics that participants report pay substantial dividends in a long, often frustrating process of rebuilding a patient’s life. Patients interpret an interviewee’s follow-through on a commitment to accompany them through these hurdles as an act of loyalty. Interviewees at HVIPs with greater resources can streamline components of the recovery process for patients. One university-based HVIP links patients to various legal resources at the campus law school [8.26], including help appealing VOCA applications denied on technicalities [8.29]. Another program holds periodic “ID Clinics” [8.18] to help patients fill out applications for driver’s licenses and government identification. They also host “expungement clinics” [8.28] to help individuals remove offenses from criminal records, thus increasing the probability that patients will satisfy their priorities of obtaining housing or employment. De-escalation Retaliation frequently occurred after loved ones arrived to find patients in comas, intubated, or surrounded by medical devices signaling a spinal injury. Interviewees appealed to a prospective retaliator’s risk of going to prison [4.12] and the impact of incarceration on their families [4.13]. Others petitioned restraint so the retaliator could be present when the patient regained consciousness [4.11]. Other interviewees unequivocally described a counterintuitive tactic—identify [4.9] and isolate [4.10] the quietest person amidst a chaotic situation. Discussion Trustbuilding Cultivating patient trust is not restricted to one hinge point on the recovery continuum. Patients engage clinical staff because there is no viable alternative. The patient-clinician relationship is fundamentally transactional, with decision-making power and agency largely stripped from patients. Patients are poked, prodded, told what they can and cannot do, what they can and cannot eat, when they can and cannot leave their bed, among other mandates. In contrast, the patient-violence prevention professional relationship is akin to a recovery partnership. Patients articulate their recovery goals and priorities, so the violence prevention professional may play a supportive role in meeting them. Sitting with patients in a government administrative building months after discharge maintains trust earned during the initial bedside encounter. On the surface, these actions target immediate patient needs. Yet, articulating a shared experience of violence, dressing in a non-threatening manner, procuring a favorite meal, and honoring commitments to navigate bureaucracy generates trust greater than the sum of these tactical parts. They demonstrate legitimacy and credibility to patients in the most vulnerable moment of their life. Shared experience Interviewees deploy sets of tactics rooted in shared experience with patients. Examples range from sharing the patient’s favorite food to playing card games at the bedside. These actions lay the foundation for sitting in shared silence inside a government administrative building as patients request basic vital documents that, over the ensuing weeks and months, may be leveraged into government identification cards, gainful employment, and even relocation into housing safely away from the immediate risk of re-exposure to violence. These tactics are mundane and easily conducted in the abstract. People play cards and video games all the time. They reluctantly wait in government administrative buildings and fill out paperwork. What sets the work of the violence prevention professional apart is the nature of completing these actions in solidarity with a violently injured patient. Through shared experiences of past violence exposure and current displays of solidarity, patients become uniquely receptive to the violence prevention professional’s tactics mitigating their future exposure to violence. Absence of tactics engaging Patient social networks Tactics engaging a patient’s social networks were virtually absent. This is notable given the influence social networks have on cycles of violence. “Reduc[ing] the risks of retaliation and re-injury” is a core aim of HVIP operation outlined by the HAVI’s Standards and Indicators.38 To achieve this, expectations exist that, “HVIP staff assess the acute, ongoing, and long-term risks of violence for the individual and their social network”38 (emphasis ours). New strategies to ensure violence prevention professionals meet this expectation may be needed. For example, asking patients to list their five closest associates would facilitate intervention opportunities with those at elevated risk of exposure to or perpetration of violence. Assuredly, violence prevention professionals cannot be all things to all people all the time. Tracking down a patient’s peers may not be feasible for understaffed and under-resourced HVIPs, particularly those operating in areas without complementary community-based violence intervention services. However, violence prevention professionals have privileged, direct access to hard-to-reach individuals with high likelihoods of being embedded in violent, contagious social networks. These professionals also have preternatural social intuition and elite trustbuilding skills. They are uniquely positioned to quickly identify vectors of future violence related to injured patients. Investigating the factors helping or hindering an HVIP’s engagement of the social networks of violently injured patients is a critical area for future research. Utility of the AACTT This study used the AACTT rubric to ensure essential information was collected for each tactic about the action, the actor, the context, the target of the action, and the timing in which the action is conducted. The AACTT was helpful in linking the particular action (ie, tactic) to its immediate context. It was less important for the actor and target, almost always the violence prevention professional and patient, respectively. This is somewhat ironic, as the AACTT elaborates on an earlier rubric that omitted the actor. Limitations First, important tactics may be omitted or poorly documented because they involve skills and knowledge that interviewees did not have a means of explaining. Research on how experts perform reveals that individuals may be unable to explain precisely how they operate at elite levels.39 40 Interviewees often lacked the technical terminology to unpack the suite of tactics they intuitively deploy. They often spoke in metaphors. Instinctively knowing how to diffuse chaotic situations was likened to birdwatching. Preparing mothers to view the bodies of murdered sons meant serving as “the wedding coordinator for the worst fucking wedding in history.” Abstract personal characteristics, such as the ability to “be real,” “just be me,” and “overwhelm you with love,” were self-evident trustbuilding tactics. Operating in the aftermath of violent trauma is the air violence prevention professionals breathe, the water they swim in. It makes them credible. It affords an experience-based dialect imminently understood by patients. However, deconstructing their expertise presents challenges for researchers. Second, the effectiveness of these tactics remains unknown, as the goal of this study was to identify the range of tactics used. Third, whether tactics translate between contexts across the country remains unknown. We do not know if tactics effective in Philadelphia and Baltimore translate to Phoenix and Birmingham. Certain tactics may broadly translate. Others may not. Finally, we did not have national data on violence prevention professional demographics and do not know how representative our sample was overall. Areas for future research One option for overcoming the interviewee-researcher language gap is direct observation of violence prevention professionals conducting their work. Another may involve professionals narrating tactics they deployed immediately after patient encounters. Second, evaluation of individual or sets of tactics should build on these findings to identify the degree to which tactics work for other professionals in similar contexts, or if they are idiosyncratic to the personalities and skillsets of individual professionals. Third, future research could determine which tactics are unique to a single hinge point; or at which hinge points a given tactic is most often and/or most effectively used. Conclusion Successful hospital-based violence intervention hinges on the work of frontline violence prevention professionals. Yet, we know relatively little about how they conduct their work. This study represents the first attempt to systematically identify the tactics used by these professionals. Obtaining these previously uncollected data may lay the groundwork for the translation and adaptation of tactics to other HVIP contexts. Cataloging these tactics may facilitate their testing in the field. The most effective tactics may then be disseminated to strengthen the skillsets of current HVIP professionals, while enhancing the training of future violence prevention personnel.