Understanding the underuse: Barriers to vacuum-assisted birth among clinicians in Tanzania: An exploratory qualitative study Authors: Lydia S. Massae, Rashidi Heri Kiangi, Victor Zeno Chikwala, Ally Abdul Lyimo, Stella Emmanuel Mushy, Lilian Teddy Mselle, Hannah Tappis, Hannah Tappis, Hannah Tappis Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundVacuum-assisted birth (VAB) is a critical obstetric intervention for saving the lives of the mothers and newborns, particularly in cases of prolonged second-stage labor, maternal exhaustion, or fetal distress. Despite its proven benefits, VAB remains underutilized, contributing to an increased rate of unnecessary cesarean sections, some of which could be avoided with timely vacuum extraction. This study aimed to explore the barriers to the use of VAB among clinicians at a tertiary hospital in Tanzania.Materials and MethodsAn exploratory qualitative study using in-depth interviews (IDIs) was employed. Twelve clinicians with relevant experience in vacuum-assisted birth were recruited purposively into the study. A semi-structured IDI guide was used to facilitate the interviews. Data were analyzed inductively using thematic analysis to identify key patterns and categories related to barriers in the use of VAB.ResultsOrganizational and individual barriers were identified as key challenges to the use of VAB. Organizational barriers included insufficient availability of VAB equipment, ineffectiveness of the available devices, and poor team dynamics that hindered collaborative decision-making regarding VAB use. Individual barriers centered on clinicians’ apprehension about potential adverse outcomes, along with limited skills and practical experience in performing VAB procedures.ConclusionThe utilization of VAB by clinicians is hindered by both organizational and individual barriers. Addressing these challenges through improved availability of functional equipment, enhanced training to build clinicians’ skills, and improving working conditions has the potential to increase the use of VAB. Strengthening these areas could help reduce the rate of unnecessary caesarean deliveries. Introduction Vacuum-assisted birth (VAB) plays a critical role in improving maternal and newborn outcomes, particularly during complicated deliveries, by reducing the need for cesarean sections (CS). The procedure involves applying a suction device to the infant’s head to facilitate its passage through the birth canal [1,2]. VAB is especially important in settings with limited access to surgical interventions, offering a safe and effective alternative to CS when performed by skilled healthcare providers [1,3]. Clinical indications for VAB include prolonged second stage of labor, maternal exhaustion, or signs of fetal distress [4]. When used appropriately, it can mitigate the risks associated with unnecessary cesarean deliveries, especially in low-resource settings where CS-related complications are harder to manage [4,5]. Recent data indicate a considerable rise in the prevalence of caesarean sections (CS) in Tanzania over the past two decades. The 2022 Tanzania Demographic and Health Survey (TDHS) reported a nationwide cesarean section prevalence of 10.4%, up from about 4% in 2004/05, indicating a significant upward trend in surgical deliveries [6]. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis of 26 studies, encompassing over 600,000 women in Eastern Africa, reported a pooled regional prevalence of cesarean sections (CS) of 24.0%, with significant variability across nations and healthcare facility tiers [7]. Although caesarean section rates have steadily increased in Tanzania, VAB remains rarely performed. In 2020, at Muhimbili National Hospital, vaginal assisted births (VAB) constituted merely 0.8% of deliveries, whereas 54% were performed via cesarean section, highlighting a significant disparity in the utilization of operative birth procedures [8]. Evidence from implementation studies demonstrates that this low utilization is not inevitable. Studies indicate that up to 52% of clinicians lack sufficient knowledge and confidence to perform VAB, which significantly hinders its integration into routine obstetric care [9–12]. However, following provider training and equipment support in 15 health facilities in Tanzania, VAB increased from almost zero to 2%, while caesarean section rates remained stable at 10–11%, suggesting that improved capacity can increase the appropriate use of VAB [13]. These findings highlight an important gap between the increasing use of caesarean section and persistently low use of VAB in Tanzania, underscoring the need to understand clinician-level barriers to VAB utilization. Despite its benefits, evidence of complications associated with VAB may contribute to its limited use by many clinicians. Both maternal and neonatal risks are documented, including cephalhematoma, scalp lacerations, and postpartum haemorrhage [14,15]. These potential complications may influence clinicians to avoid VAB in favor of other delivery methods. Tanzania has included VAB in its national maternal, reproductive, and child health guidelines as a recommended intervention for skilled healthcare providers [3,16–18]. Nevertheless, VAB use continues to decline despite the availability of clear guidelines and supportive evidence [19–21]. This underutilization may be contributing to the increasing rates of CS deliveries in the country. There is limited data on the specific barriers to VAB use at the tertiary facility level in Tanzania. Understanding these barriers is essential to designing targeted interventions that could promote the safe and appropriate use of VAB. Therefore, this study aimed to gain an in-depth understanding of why clinicians opt not to use VAB even when it is clinically indicated and instead prefer CS. Materials and methods Study design and setting We conducted an exploratory qualitative study to analyze the barriers to VAB use among clinicians at Tanzania’s tertiary maternity hospital. The hospital manages approximately 9,000 deliveries annually and serves as a referral center, with 60% of patients arriving from other facilities. Notably, 75% of all deliveries are performed through emergency CS [22]. Despite the hospital’s high delivery volume and capacity for specialized obstetric care, data from the District Health Information System (DHIS2) show consistently low VAB utilization: 2.0% in 2020, 2.2% in 2021, and 2.1% in 2022. The exploratory design of this study enabled an in-depth understanding of clinicians’ experiences and the contextual factors influencing the limited use of VAB in this setting. During the study period, VAB at the study site was performed using reusable rigid stainless steel vacuum cups connected via tubing to an external hand-operated vacuum pump that generated the negative pressure required for assisted vaginal birth. The reusable metal cups were sterilized between uses in accordance with the hospital’s infection prevention and control protocols. Participants and recruitment We purposively recruited 12 clinicians, comprising obstetricians and residents working in the labor ward [23], with assistance from the ward in charge. Obstetricians who participated in the study were required to possess a minimum of six months of experience in the labour ward following their specialist training. Residents enlisted in the study were those who had completed a minimum of one year of residency training and were acquiring specialist training in obstetrics. The ward in charge initially identified potential participants, after which the researcher approached them in person during or after their clinical shifts. The purpose and procedures of the study were clearly explained, and those who expressed interest were provided with review details and invited to schedule sessions at their convenient times and locations. All approached participants agreed to participate in the study. Participants who consented to take part were given a written informed consent form, which they signed to verify their participation. Recruitment continued until data saturation was achieved [24], which occurred after 10 interviews, with the final 2 confirming no new insights were generated. Data collection tools and procedures A semi-structured interview guide was developed and used as the primary data collection tool to understand barriers to VAB use among clinicians. The interview guide was created following a structured literature review that analyzed obstacles to VAB utilization. Qualitative and mixed-methods research were examined to discover recurring domains affecting VAB use. The domains discovered from the literature were aligned with the socioecological model, which informed the organization of the interview guide. At the individual level, the inquiry examined doctors’ knowledge, skills, training exposure, confidence in executing VAB, perceived competence, and risk perception. At the organizational level, inquiries focused on the availability of functional equipment, guidelines and protocols, workload, staffing levels, and the facility culture about operative vaginal birth. The study involved native Kiswahili speakers, necessitating the translation of a tool initially developed in English to ensure comprehension and clarity in the local clinical context. Bilingual research team members, skilled in obstetrics, rigorously reviewed the translated tool, focusing on terminology related to vacuum-assisted birth and hospital procedures to maintain consistency with the language used in Tanzanian hospitals. When direct translations were absent, adjustments were made to use locally understood expressions. The Kiswahili version was validated by clinicians similar to study participants, with feedback emphasizing clarity, cultural relevance, and vocabulary appropriateness. Minor modifications were made to align questions with local clinical practices and communication styles. The data collection process was conducted from March 10 to May 24, 2023. In-depth interviews took place in a private setting within the hospital, chosen by each participant to ensure confidentiality and minimize interruptions. Each interview lasted between 40 and 50 minutes. A trained research assistant (RA), holding a professional background in nursing and midwifery, fluent in Kiswahili, and experienced in health-related research, supported the data collection. Before data collection, the RA participated in a one-day training session that covered study objectives, ethical research practices, effective interviewing techniques, and the use of the interview guide. Moreover, the researcher (LSM) spearheaded data collection procedures, including obtaining consent from participants, setting appointments, and conducting interviews. During the interviews, both the principal investigator and the RA employed active listening skills and neutral probing skills to encourage participants to elaborate on their responses. All interviews were audio-recorded with participants’ consent and supplemented with field notes to capture non-verbal cues and contextual details. This rigorous data collection process ensured the credibility and depth of qualitative data gathered for the study. Data analysis The interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. We employed thematic analysis guided by the socio-ecological model (SEM) [25,26]. We conducted the analysis manually in Microsoft Excel for systematic data management. The multidisciplinary research team performed iterative coding, with senior researchers verifying the accuracy of codes [27]. To provide early insights and guide the focus of subsequent in-depth interviews, data collection and analysis were conducted simultaneously. This approach ensured that the identified themes were closely linked to the data and revealed barriers to the use of VAB, as generated from the interviews. Transcripts were read repeatedly to properly understand the information on VAB use. The researchers coded one transcript, generated codes that were discussed and agreed upon, and then developed the codebook. Researchers coded independently by using the codebook and letter discussed to agree on the generated codes. Agreed codes were examined and grouped based on their similarities and differences to form subthemes and then themes regarding barriers to performing VAB. The analysis used Kiswahili transcripts to maintain participants’ meaning, with translation to English occurring only during reporting. Ethical considerations Ethical clearance for this study was obtained from the Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences Institutional Review Board with Ref. No. DA.282/298/01.C/2065. Permission for data collection was obtained from the Clinical Research, Training, and Consultancy Unit at MNH with a ref. No. MNH/CRTCU/Perm/2023/119. Written informed consent was obtained from the participants before commencing the interview. Participants were informed of the benefits, possible risks, procedures, and voluntary participation in the study. Permission for audio recording was obtained from the participants before conducting the interview. To ensure confidentiality, the interviews were conducted in a comfortable place identified by the participants themselves. All participants were assigned unique identifiers for concealment of identity. Results Demographic characteristics of the study participants A total of twelve participants were purposefully included in the study, comprising medical specialists and seven resident doctors working in the labor ward. The participants’ professional experience ranged from six months to over thirty years. A summary of participants’ demographic and professional characteristics is presented in S1 Table. Thematic analysis yielded two overarching themes: organizational and individual barriers to the utilization of VAB among clinicians. These themes, along with their corresponding subthemes, are outlined in S2 Table and elaborated in the subsequent sections. Organizational barriers This theme encompasses the systemic obstacles within the healthcare facility that impede the effective implementation and adoption of VAB. Three subthemes emerged under this category: malfunctioning and inaccessible medical equipment, team dynamics in deciding when to use VAB, and limited accessibility and utilization of VAB guidelines and SOP. Malfunctioning and inaccessible medical equipment Participants reported that during the second stage of labor, when indications for VAB use were present, necessary equipment was often unavailable or missing at the critical moment. Moreover, the limited supply of available equipment was cited as a contributing factor to the underutilization of VAB within the ward. Reflecting on this issue, one interviewee said; “Here in the labor ward, we don’t have many tools. However, I believe that we would benefit from having much of this equipment available to us if we approach these situations positively. As it currently stands, we only have one tool.” (Resident, 6 years of experience IDI 2) Participants also pointed out that not regularly checking the functional equipment in the ward is a major barrier to the effective use of VAB. This led to the presence of defective and inappropriate equipment, which later malfunctioned at a critical moment. These were narrated as follows. “The availability of equipment has been a persistent challenge in [hospital], especially in the labor ward. The vacuum cups often fail to grasp the baby’s head properly, and the pumps are damaged. However, the process of locating and replacing this equipment is ineffective. Sometimes, the items are simply unavailable in the ward, and replacement depends on the hospital’s procurement system, which can be slow and unreliable.” (Specialist, 18 years of experience, IDI 8) “…Additionally, because of the poor condition of our equipment, the cup tends to fall out when we take out the baby.” (Specialist, 21 years of experience, IDI 6) Clinicians also revealed that the emergency tray lacked the complete set of VAB equipment necessary for the procedure. This unavailability was attributed to improper assembly and storage of the equipment, which in turn discouraged the use of VAB. One participant stated that; “… For instance, when you are using a vacuum to deliver a baby and need to change the cup, you discover that it is too small for the baby’s head and that it may take a while to find a larger one and might never find the proper size” (Resident, 9 years of experience IDI 3) Unfamiliarity with the type of VAB equipment was mentioned to be another barrier to the utilization of VAB. This was a concern when the clinician was not used to the VAB equipment, which is available in the ward. The participant said; "I can say that these vacuum devices vary quite a bit, so sometimes you may come across a device that you’re not used to using for assisting with delivery. At times, you find that the cup is too small. Therefore, I would suggest that they provide a wider range of sizes to enable us to perform the procedure more effectively."(Resident, 12 years of experience IDI 10) Team dynamics in deciding when to use VAB Clinicians reported that the existence of different viewpoints from members of the team, the minimal consensus in team decisions, and delays in decision-making prohibit VAB use. Several participants noted that differing viewpoints within the team regarding the use of VAB during the second stage of labor were largely driven by fears of negative outcomes, such as cephalhematoma and low Apgar score, for which clinicians might be held accountable. Talking about this issue, an interviewee said; “There are conflicting ideas among ourselves; for example, you may decide to help the client by using the vacuum, but another person may say, “No, let’s not help her.” Fearing that the child’s outcome will be poor and that you will be held responsible, you may be asked why you did not send her for a caesarian section sooner…” (Specialist, 18 years of experience, IDI 8) Another participant added that; “There may be a few differences between the doctor and the nurse while exchanging ideas and their views because each has unique experiences and knowledge, but the doctor makes the final decision” (Resident, 9 years of experience, IDI 11) Participants revealed that within the team, there is an existence of minimal consensus decisions in performing VAB. It was evident that this was because of low practice among clinicians and the absence of clear, standardized protocols within the labor ward. One participant commented that: “Several SOPs have been posted, such as one for eclampsia. If we post for vacuum delivery, we will all be aware very well that when I see this mother needs this service one hundred percent, and our decision becomes uniform, we know what to do better than waiting for another person to come and make decisions, which in turn delays the provision of services” (Resident, 6 years of experience, IDI 2) Some participants raised concerns about delays in decision-making by clinicians, especially the residents. Participants have shown to be reluctant to act quickly when the need arises from a fear of making the wrong call due to a lack of approval from supervisors and more experienced clinicians. An experienced resident with 6 years of experience shared the following: “…There may be a vacuum case, but they tend to call in special persons so and so to attend to the client; as a result, you realize that the same individuals are managing the issue over and over, leaving others to be observers rather than take action.” (Resident, 6 years of experience, IDI 2) Limited accessibility and utilization of VAB guidelines and SOPs This subtheme highlights systemic challenges related to the limited availability, visibility, and use of clinical guidelines and standard operating procedures for VAB. Participants reported that existing guidelines were not consistently accessible within the ward, making it difficult for clinicians, especially those with less clinical experience, to refer to them during clinical decision-making. Several participants noted that the available VAB guidelines appeared to be designed with more experienced practitioners in mind, often lacking practical clarity for those still building competency. One participant said “It is simple for you to grasp the guidelines if you are an expert in the field and read them because of your knowledge. However, other people you may come across may not have had the opportunity to access certain resources.” (Resident, 9 years of experience, IDI 11). In addition, an expert obstetrician echoed. “There are guidelines, but very few people adhere to them, especially those who are capable of this vacuum delivery, because many clients would otherwise have to undergo caesarian sections.” (Specialist, 15 years of experience, IDI 5) This perceived complexity may discourage use among junior clinicians, reducing adherence and undermining confidence in guideline-based practice. In addition to content challenges, participants also emphasized the physical inaccessibility of the guidelines. SoPs and protocols were often not displayed in delivery areas or easily retrievable when needed. This absence of visual reinforcement and practical guidance in the clinical environment further weakened their role in routine practice. Participants explained: “…as far as I can tell, there are no posted instructions or standard operating procedures (SOPs) in the ward on when and how to perform a vacuum delivery.” (Specialist, 15 years of experience, IDI 5) Moreover, there appeared to be a broader organizational gap in the promotion and reinforcement of VAB SOPs. Clinicians reported minimal emphasis on the importance of following protocols, both in supervision and ongoing training. This lack of institutional encouragement contributed to inadequate use and a general undervaluing of guidelines in day-to-day obstetric care. Emphasizing the importance of displaying SoPs. The participant stated: “The existing SOPs should be posted; they are not too many. Right now, they’re just on paper, but if we display them, even someone who has forgotten can refer to them—just like we display guidelines for eclampsia and other conditions. So, in cases where someone needs assistance during delivery, it should show where to place the cup, how many times to pull, and so on. These should also be displayed in the maternity ward.” (Specialist, 16 years of experience, IDI 9) Overall, the limited accessibility and utilization of clinical guidelines reflected a broader organizational shortfall, hindering the standardization and safe implementation of VAB across clinical teams. Individual barriers Under this theme, apprehension regarding adverse outcomes and inadequate skills and experience in performing VAB resulted in the nonuse of VAB among clinicians in the second stage of labor. The subthemes are described below. Apprehension regarding adverse outcomes following VAB This subtheme reflects clinicians’ diminished confidence and lack of enthusiasm to participate in VAB, frequently influenced by prior poor experiences and apprehension regarding adverse outcomes. Participants articulated ongoing apprehensions about the potential hazards linked to the procedure, especially about the welfare of both the mother and the infant. This fear often led to reluctance to commence VAB, despite clinical indications for its necessity. As one specialist explained: “…[Clinicians] are hesitant to use VAB because, if used incorrectly, it could tear the woman’s cervix, causing severe bleeding (PPH) and other serious medical conditions...” (Specialist, 15 years of experience, IDI 5) Participants noted that anxiety concerning the client’s condition has contributed to the development of a team culture that discourages the use of VAB even when clinically indicated. This reluctance stems from fears that attempting VAB might lead to complications or delays in delivering the baby. This concern is illustrated in the following quote. “…Even when it’s necessary, our team rarely utilizes the vacuum too frequently, and I believe this is because we’re scared of the potential consequences for the mother and the child…” (Resident, 8 years of experience, IDI 4) Participants expressed fear of the negative outcomes related to VAB use, which was attributed to a prevailing culture of blame within the clinical environment. Clinicians reported that this culture discourages the use of VAB, as individuals fear being held personally accountable in the event of an adverse outcome. As a result, the procedure is rarely preferred or utilized in the ward. A participant stated that; “…When using a vacuum, there’s a risk of being held accountable. This blame culture has made doctors reluctant to utilize vacuums or engage in any related practices since they are unaware of them, which makes them dislike performing VABs as time passes.” (Resident, 10 years in experience, IDI 12) It was pointed out that many clinicians tend to avoid using VAB due to the belief that the equipment is unreliable. The anticipation that the vacuum extractor might fail to function effectively contributes to a lack of confidence in the procedure, ultimately discouraging clinicians from considering VAB as a viable option during delivery. A participant said; “To be honest, doctors feel that this method will not work and hence prefer not to use a vacuum in assisting the mother since their experience in frequently fails; as a result, rather than performing the procedure, you will find that they immediately prepare the patient for surgery” (Resident, 12 years in experience, IDI 10) Participants reported that the requirement to document and justify negative outcomes following failed VAB procedures acts as a deterrent to its use. The fear of having to provide detailed explanations in the event of an unsuccessful attempt often leads clinicians to opt for alternative modes of delivery. As one resident stated: “Any adverse outcome must be documented in a report explaining why the mother died, why the baby died, or why the baby had a low Apgar score. Consequently, clinicians fear being questioned or blamed later for why the baby did not thrive or why the delivery had a poor outcome. This fear of blame is particularly strong among private patients, who constitute the majority of cases here. This culture of blame has led to widespread reluctance to perform vacuum-assisted births.” (Residents, 8 years’ experience, IDI 1) Insufficient skills and experience in performing VAB Many participants indicated that limited clinical experience among junior professionals, few numbers of clinicians proficient in VAB, and the infrequency of VAB-indicated cases in the labor ward collectively contribute to its underutilization. Inadequate preparation and doubts about performing the procedure further discourage its use. A participant said: “I feel the primary issue might be decision-making—whether to use a vacuum or not. Beyond the decision itself, it also involves the clinician’s knowledge and confidence in performing the procedure. You find that someone knows they should perform it, but they are not comfortable doing so, possibly because they are not fully familiar with the technique or they fear the potential outcomes” (Specialist, 16 years of experience, IDI 9) Participants emphasized that VAB requires specific technical competencies, which are typically acquired through hands-on experience and mentorship. These skills are more commonly found among experienced clinicians who are familiar with established protocols and adhere to best practices. As a result, clinicians who lack adequate training, clinical experience, and exposure to the procedure are more likely to underutilize VAB. This was echoed by a participant who said; “…our experience is limited in the first place because of the limited time we spend in the labor ward and the few period sessions we get while at university” (Resident, 6 years’ experience, IDI 12) Participants indicated that only a limited number of personnel in the labor ward have sufficient competence with VAB. It was observed that most clients are overseen by specialists and midwives with extensive experience in the ward, resulting in more proficiency in the procedure. Conversely, some clinicians, especially junior personnel, have restricted practical opportunities to perform VAB, which impedes their capacity to develop proficiency and assurance in its application. This was narrated as follows. “I can say that there are two main reasons why a clinician might not be able to use a vacuum: either they have never used it before or they lack the confidence to use it, which could result in them being unable to use it even if all the indicators are present” (Specialist, 21 years’ experience, IDI 7) Participants reported that the occurrence of a few cases in the labor that need VAB has resulted in low VAB usage. Most cases that arrive at the hospital tend to end in emergency procedures, including the caesarean section. “…although there aren’t many cases, I believe that we should provide time for practice by utilizing manikins; we might schedule time, perhaps once a month, to gather clinicians, go to simulation rooms, and demonstrate with Mankins, and by doing this periodically, we can develop our skills and improve as a team” (Resident, 8 years of experience, IDI 4). Participants noted that individual motivation to engage in VAB practice was generally low, often requiring clinicians to invest additional personal time. Furthermore, the short duration allocated to ward rounds and educational sessions was identified as a contributing factor to the low frequency of VAB performance. This was narrated as follows: “What is required is a personal effort from the clinicians themselves and must be able to set aside extra time to read through the guidelines and find time to come into labor ward to learn what is going on and acquire more experience” (Resident, 12 years experience, IDI 10) “… as doctors, we have many duties in the ward and elsewhere, and we have very little time in labor. As a result, you don’t have a lot of opportunity to practice in real life because there isn’t much equipment available.” (Specialist, 21 years of experience, IDI 6) These findings collectively demonstrate how past negative experiences, whether personally experienced or institutionally recorded, cultivate a cycle of doubt and disengagement, obstructing the development of confidence and motivation essential for effective VAB practice. Discussion This study highlighted both organizational and individual barriers that prevent clinicians from effectively using VAB, an important procedure for managing certain cases of the prolonged second stage of labor. These challenges not only delay timely and appropriate care but also lead to an increased number of CS. The findings point to critical areas within the healthcare system that require focused attention and improvement to support safer and more effective childbirth practices. Organizational-related factors affecting VAB use Clinicians frequently reported that malfunctioning equipment, lack of regular maintenance, and the general unavailability of VAB devices significantly hindered their ability to offer this critical intervention. In some instances, inappropriate sizes of vacuum extractor cups have resulted in slippage during procedures, undermining clinicians’ confidence in the use of VAB. These constraints often required a shift to CS, even though a vaginal-assisted birth would have been safer and more appropriate. Such equipment-related constraints may contribute to increased risks of fetal injury, maternal infections, postpartum hemorrhage, and prolonged hospitalization for both mother and infant due to delayed or inappropriate delivery methods. These findings point to the urgent need for routine equipment inspections, preventive maintenance protocols, and policies that guarantee the availability of functioning vacuum devices in all delivery rooms. These results are consistent with reports from Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa, and Asia, where a lack of functional equipment has been linked to underuse of VAB and increased rates of CS [21]. Similar patterns have been observed in Tanzania, where residents expressed low confidence in using vacuum extractors, largely due to frequent equipment failures and inadequate maintenance [28,29]. In addition, defective devices were reported to negatively influence healthcare providers’ expectations and hands-on experience with vacuum delivery [20,22]. Individual-related barriers affecting VAB use A notable finding from this study was the influence of team dynamics on decision-making regarding VAB in the labor ward. Hierarchical structures often left junior staff feeling disempowered or hesitant to suggest or advocate for VAB, leading to missed opportunities for timely interventions. Effective VAB use requires collaborative decision-making to ensure safe and timely delivery. In the absence of a clear consensus among team members, critical decisions may be delayed, prolonging the second stage of labor and increasing the risk of fetal compromise. To improve this, clinicians emphasized the importance of fostering professional collaboration, developing clear clinical decision-making protocols, and empowering all qualified team members, regardless of rank, to recommend or initiate VAB when clinically appropriate. Participants also stressed the need for accessible standard operating procedures (SOPs), regular practice alongside experienced colleagues, and unambiguous communication to reduce uncertainty and delays. These findings align with those documented in Italy [30], which noted that even experienced specialists often rely on intuitive decision-making rather than formal guidelines, especially in time-sensitive clinical scenarios. Clinicians also expressed deep concerns about potential complications associated with VAB, Such as neonatal trauma or failed procedures. These fears were often reinforced by a workplace culture that assigns blame in the event of adverse outcomes, further discouraging the use of VAB. This apprehension contributes to a tendency toward excessive caution, resulting in increased reliance on CS even when VAB would be a suitable option. Similar concerns have been reported by other researchers in Tanzania and South Africa, where fear of failure and professional repercussions associated with unsuccessful VAB attempts have negatively impacted clinicians’ confidence and career progression [20,22]. Such hesitations can delay necessary interventions and increase maternal morbidity due to avoidable surgical deliveries. To address these issues, the study suggests a shift toward non-punitive clinical governance that includes supportive supervision, regular case reviews, and debriefing sessions. These practices can help staff reflect on adverse events constructively, promote shared learning, and build confidence in using VAB without fear of blame. Inadequate skills and experience were predominantly observed among younger professionals. The execution of VAB during the second stage of labor requires proficiency, confidence, and clinical experience to ensure a favorable outcome. Clinicians reported limited opportunities to practice VAB in the ward due to the infrequent occurrence of eligible cases, which resulted in insufficient hands-on experience. This challenge is further compounded by inadequate training for clinicians in the labor ward and a lack of structured monitoring of VAB use. Another issue identified was the absence of experienced clinicians available to attend to clients requiring VAB and to provide supervision or conduct assessments when needed. Studies from Tanzania and findings from a systematic review support these observations, revealing that many young professionals lack the confidence, competence, and expertise needed to perform VAB, often due to previous adverse outcomes associated with the procedure [21,22,29]. These factors contribute to uncertainty and delays in decision-making, potentially compromising the safety of both the mother and the infant. Addressing these gaps requires individual commitment to ongoing practices, as well as a strong understanding of established protocols and clinical guidelines for safe and effective VAB. Overall, the findings underscore that the safe use of VAB depends on accurate case selection and assessment, strict adherence to standard procedures, proficiency in equipment handling, and consistent application of clinical expertise. These elements should be emphasized in routine ward practices and incorporated into continuous professional development initiatives. Study strengths and limitations This study provides valuable insights into the key challenges that make it difficult to use VAB. By using a qualitative approach, we were able to hear directly from health workers about their real-life experiences with the limited use of VAB in clinical settings, which made the findings more meaningful and grounded However, the study had several limitations. First, it involved a small number of participants from selected health facilities, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other regions or health systems. To address this, participants were purposefully selected to represent diverse professional roles and levels of experience to enhance the richness of the data. Second, social desirability bias may have influenced responses, as participants might have shared views they believed were expected. To mitigate this, interviews were conducted in a private setting, and confidentiality was assured to encourage honest responses. Finally, the qualitative design captures in-depth perceptions but does not provide measurable outcomes. Future studies could use surveys or other tools to measure how common these challenges are in larger populations. Conclusion Both organizational and personal-related challenges made it difficult for health workers to use VAB. Health centers lacked proper equipment or had nonfunctional tools, and weak teamwork affected decision-making. On an individual level, some health workers were worried about possible complications, while others lacked the training and experience needed to feel confident using the procedure. Addressing these issues is essential to improve the safe and effective use of this important treatment. Supporting information Demographic and professional characteristics of participants. (TIF) Themes and subthemes on barriers to the use of VAB. (TIF) Excerpts. (PDF) Transfer Alert This paper was transferred from another journal. As a result, its full editorial history (including decision letters, peer reviews and author responses) may not be present. 16 Aug 2025 18 Jan 2026 -->PONE-D-25-41107-->-->Understanding the Underuse: Barriers to Vacuum-Assisted Birth Among Clinicians in Tanzania: An Exploratory Qualitative Study-->-->PLOS One Dear Dr. Chikwala, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Mar 04 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:--> A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Hannah Tappis, DrPH, MPH Academic Editor PLOS One Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1.Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. Your ethics statement should only appear in the Methods section of your manuscript. If your ethics statement is written in any section besides the Methods, please move it to the Methods section and delete it from any other section. Please ensure that your ethics statement is included in your manuscript, as the ethics statement entered into the online submission form will not be published alongside your manuscript. 3. Please include captions for your Supporting Information files at the end of your manuscript, and update any in-text citations to match accordingly. Please see our Supporting Information guidelines for more information: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/supporting-information. 4. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewer's Responses to Questions -->Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. --> Reviewer #1: Partly Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** -->2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? --> Reviewer #1: N/A Reviewer #2: N/A Reviewer #3: N/A ********** -->3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified.--> Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** -->4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** -->5. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters)--> Reviewer #1: Dear Author, This is a relevant and fairly good methodological study to explore the maternal health in-depth regarding VAB in LIMC. Here are few suggestions and queries that I think needs to be cleared before the publication. Strengthen the introduction and discussion. Clarify and deepen the thematic analysis. The details of comments and queries are attached as a separate file. Thank you Reviewer #2: Thank you for the opportunity to review this manuscript. This manuscript addresses an important and underexplored issue in maternal health by examining the barriers to the use of vacuum-assisted birth among clinicians in Tanzania. Given the continued burden of prolonged labor and preventable maternal and neonatal complications in low-resource settings, understanding factors influencing the underuse of evidence-based obstetric interventions is highly relevant. The study’s focus on clinicians’ perspectives and its use of an exploratory qualitative design are appropriate for capturing contextual, system-level, and experiential barriers. The topic aligns well with the scope of PLOS ONE and has the potential to contribute valuable insights to obstetric practice, health systems strengthening, and policy discussions in similar settings. Below are some comments that, when addressed, could improve the quality of the manuscript: 1. Line 52: (Despite its known benefits, VAB the utilization of VAB remains…) This sentence will have to be checked to avoid repetition of terms. 2. Line 64: (This utilization may be contributing) This could be changed to “This underutilization may…” 3. Lines 397-401: (In some instances, the use of inappropriate sizes of vacuum extracted cups…) and (Inappropriate sizes of vacuum extractor cups have resulted in slippage during procedures…). These two sentences appear to be communicating the same point. It will benefit the manuscript if the authors can make a single statement from both or keep one. 4. Lines 408-409: (These results are consistent with studies conducted in other LMICs…). It would be more appropriate to be more specific with the names of these LMICs. 5. Lines 433-435: (Similar concerns have been reported in other African countries…). It would be more appropriate to be more specific with the names of these African countries. 6. Additionally, including the data collection tool as a supplementary file would benefit both the readers of the manuscript and improve its perspective. 7. The study makes a good contribution to the field and would benefit from proofreading to correct some grammatical errors. Reviewer #3: Comments to author This is a worthwhile study, particularly in a low resource setting to determine what barriers exist to using a safe alternative to avoid C/S which carry significant risks (especially in a setting with a 75% C/S rate). In understanding the context of the research (which relates to transferability), it would be helpful to describe for the international readership the type (e.g. Kiwi, Silc-cup) and composition (e.g. metal, silicone) of the vacuum systems (e.g. piped or hand-pump operated compressed air) available. Clarifications • Please clarify and define early in the article the clinical specialists included in this study. There is frequent generic reference made to skilled health care providers, and later on (line 248-54) mention is made of nurses, midwives, and nurse attendants. It is unclear why these categories of health care providers are mentioned when the focus appears to be on the barriers experienced by medical clinicians. Are midwives or nurses taught and licensed to undertake vacuum deliveries? • Please clarify what is meant by clinical experience. Does this include clinical experience as an undergraduate medical student or only after qualification. Alternatively does this relate specifically to obstetric clinical experience? As this is a qualitative study it would be prudent to disclose the authors’ experience / perspective of this clinical situation as this is germane to their research conduct and interpretation. • The article would be strengthened by including information about the development of the semi-structured interview guide. It is unclear what informed the questions, i.e. what was the theoretical or conceptual base? This level of detail is relevant for the credibility aspect of trustworthiness. What is mentioned in lines 95/6 is “The tool was informed by a review of existing signatures (include references) to ensure relevant themes on barriers to VAB use”. It is not clear what is meant by a review of existing signatures (include references)”. • Research rigour / Trustworthiness. It would strengthen the article to explicitly include “transferability” and to mention if member checking was done to enhance confirmability. Discussion. This is well founded on the information gathered (data). However, • There is no mention of the knowledge foundation of the participants (to address lack of confidence in decision-making). • While it is understood that the context (equipment availability and functionality, and clinical skills) is not conducive to successful VAB, it appears that some of the participants believed that VAB was harmful per se, despite long standing evidence to the contrary. • While mention is made of lack of agreed clinical guidelines and SOPs, and challenging interpersonal relationships among the labour ward staff, the article is silent on the apparent lack of clinical leadership which is required to manage such dynamics and processes. Ethics. While confidentiality is clearly described there are other ethical concerns • Participants were identified by the ward “incharge”, after which the researcher approached them in person. Did the “incharge” ask the potential participants if the researchers could approach them? This distinction is important in terms of the autonomy of the individuals concerned who were in the employ of the hospital. • What was the employment relationship between the participants and the researchers? Given that the participants were employees in the hospital where the study was being conducted, was there a sense of obligation to participate (undue coercion?), what was the power dynamic between the participants and the employer and/or the researcher? Was there a possibility that they might feel that their participation was necessary to ensure that their employment status was not jeopardised? References. A thorough check of the reference list required to ensure that references are complete and correct, specifically 1, 4, 5, 7, 12, 18, 24, 26 Author contributions. Please clarify which of the authors conducted the interviews. The article indicates that a midwife was a co-facilitator, but it is not clear who was the lead interviewer. It is not clear if the midwife co-facilitator (information gatherer / data collector) is included in the authorship or acknowledgements. Please clarify this contribution. I wish you well in any follow-up quality improvement initiative to strengthen this aspect of clinical practice for the benefit of mothers and babies in your setting. ********** -->6. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy.--> Reviewer #1: Yes: Dr. Sailesh Bhattarai Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. Submitted filename: PONE-D-25-41107_SB.docx Submitted filename: PONE-D-25-41107 Vacuum deliveries-Reviewer report-20260110.docx 7 Jul 2026 Comments from Reviewer 1 1 Introduction Inclusion of recent Tanzanian or East African data on CS and VAB rates to contextualize the problem to make the rationale stronger. Authors’ Response Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We have strengthened the Introduction by incorporating recent evidence on caesarean section and vacuum-assisted birth rates from Tanzania and East Africa. These data highlight the increasing use of caesarean section alongside the persistently low utilization of vacuum-assisted birth, thereby providing a stronger regional context and reinforcing the rationale for investigating the underuse of vacuum-assisted birth among clinicians in Tanzania (Introduction, pages 3–4, lines 52–70). 2 Data collection tools and procedure Are the experiences of residents and experts considered from the time participants had undertaken their medical profession or since they started their medical study? It would be fair to make it clear to the readers. Authors’ Response Thank you for asking. We have improved the description of participants recruited into the study to include their experience as medical specialists, as well as those who had completed one year of residency and are pursuing specialist training in obstetrics. 3 Page no 5 line 96, ‘existing signatures (include references)’ meaning not clear. Authors’ Response Thank you for your observation. We have reviewed the statement and included the appropriate words “existing literature.” 4 If the review of the past study ensures relevant themes, then it was a deductive approach. You did not use data driven theme then. Is this what you mean? Please mention what approach was used. Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. The review of the past literature was done to identify domains related to VAB use and hence structure interview questions rather than an analysis of data. Themes were developed inductively from data. 5 Mention how were the cultural relevance ensured? What changes were made in the English version to adapt the local culture? Authors’ Response The tool was developed in the English language; however, researchers and participants are native Swahili speakers. Translation of the tool to the Kiswahili language and adjustment of the terms to the local clinical environment ensured that the tool aligns with the communication culture. This section has been improved by adding more context. 6 Provide more detail on how the guide was developed, piloted, and refined. Include sample questions in supplementary materials. Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. More details have been provided to clarify the development of the tool. Results 7 The author should make clear who is the person directly involved in VAB in this study. If it is residents or obs/gynecologists, it’s ok. If it is done by trained nursing staff, then this study tells only half part of the story. Author reports nursing attendant should also be exposed to VAB guidelines. If they are not directly involved in the procedure, in what way they can influence the use of VAB should be clearly mentioned. Authors’ Response We agree that attendants are not directly involved in performing vacuum-assisted birth (VAB). They were mentioned alongside nurses by a resident during the interview in the context of comparing their understanding of the guideline. As attendants and nurses were not part of the study population, we have revised this section by replacing the quotation with more appropriate excerpts that pertain exclusively to clinicians. 8 Theme ‘Limited accessibility’ Page no 240 It is known that guidelines for VAB were not available in the ward which made the decision making difficult for the residents. Are not they oriented to all birthing procedure during their medical study or at least before working in the gyne/obs department? Has this been explored? In this study whether if in any form they get orientation regarding the procedures. Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. Clinicians are typically introduced to all major birthing procedures during their formal medical training. However, within the context of this study, participants, particularly those with limited clinical experience, expressed that the availability of clinical guidelines in the labour ward would have supported decision-making and enhanced their confidence in performing vacuum-assisted birth (VAB) successfully. 9 Page no 251-254, attendants might not be exposed to information such as how to access or implement the guidelines. How does patient attendant help in VAB even if the attendant have access to guidelines. Does this attendant mean someone from the birthing crew? Who are these nurse attendants? Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. Attendants are not directly involved in performing vacuum-assisted birth (VAB) and therefore do not influence guideline implementation. Their role is limited to supportive tasks, such as transporting and cleaning equipment. As they were not part of the study population, references to them have been omitted from the manuscript. 10 Page 349, 350, meaning not clear in the quote. Authors’ Response The quotation has been replaced with a clearer excerpt, and additional explanation has been incorporated to enhance clarity and contextual understanding. 11 Some of the subthemes can be merged, which have been repeated in multiple sections, such as fear of blame, etc. to avoid repetition. Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. We have checked and rectified Discussion 12 Discussion regarding how Tanzanian barriers are similar to or different from those in other settings is limited. Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. We note that our findings have been compared with those from other studies (page 21, lines 425–427; page 22, lines 442-445; and page 23, lines 465-468). Comments from Reviewer 2 1 Line 52: (Despite its known benefits, VAB the utilization of VAB remains…) This sentence will have to be checked to avoid repetition of terms. Authors’ Response This sentence has been revised to remove the repeating word ‘VAB’ and improve clarity. 2 Line 64: (This utilization may be contributing) This could be changed to “This underutilization may…” Authors’ Response We appreciate your suggestion. The statement has been changed to “This underutilization may be contributing to the increasing rates of CS deliveries in the country.” 3 Lines 397-401: (In some instances, the use of inappropriate sizes of vacuum extracted cups…) and (Inappropriate sizes of vacuum extractor cups have resulted in slippage during procedures…). These two sentences appear to be communicating the same point. It will benefit the manuscript if the authors can make a single statement from both or keep one Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. We agree with you and have therefore retained only one statement to avoid redundancy and ensure clarity. 4 Lines 408-409: (These results are consistent with studies conducted in other LMICs…). It would be more appropriate to be more specific with the names of these LMICs. Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. The LMICs referred to in this section are those represented in the secondary data, which were analyzed and reported in aggregate (Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa, and Asia). These regions have now been explicitly specified in the manuscript for clarity. 5 Lines 433-435: (Similar concerns have been reported in other African countries…). It would be more appropriate to be more specific with the names of these African countries. Authors’ Response The statement has been revised, and specific countries have been highlighted. 6 Additionally, including the data collection tool as a supplementary file would benefit both the readers of the manuscript and improve its perspective. Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. The in-depth interview guide has been added as a supplementary file. 7 The study makes a good contribution to the field and would benefit from proofreading to correct some grammatical errors. 8 Authors’ Response Proofreading has been done to correct grammatical errors. Comments from Reviewer 3 1 In understanding the context of the research (which relates to transferability), it would be helpful to describe for the international readership the type (e.g. Kiwi, Silc-cup) and composition (e.g. metal, silicone) of the vacuum systems (e.g. piped or hand-pump operated compressed air) available. Authors’ Response Thank you for this helpful suggestion. The Methods section has been amended to include details regarding the vacuum extraction apparatus utilized at the study site. We have detailed the type and substance of the vacuum cup and the vacuum generation mechanism utilized in the hospital. This supplementary information offers crucial clinical context for international readers who may lack familiarity with the instruments utilized for vacuum-assisted delivery in this setting. 2 Clarifications Please clarify and define early in the article the clinical specialists included in this study. There is frequent generic reference made to skilled health care providers, and later on (line 248-54) mention is made of nurses, midwives, and nurse attendants. It is unclear why these categories of health care providers are mentioned when the focus appears to be on the barriers experienced by medical clinicians. Are midwives or nurses taught and licensed to undertake vacuum deliveries? Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. We have added explicit descriptions about the participants of this study. Nurses and midwives are not part of this study, regardless of being trained to perform VAB. Therefore, any information in reference to health care providers has been reviewed and clarified. 3 Please clarify what is meant by clinical experience. Does this include clinical experience as an undergraduate medical student or only after qualification. Alternatively, does this relate specifically to obstetric clinical experience? Authors’ Response Clinical experience in this study refers to working experience after qualification. Undergraduate medical training was not explored in this study. We have clarified this in the participant and recruitment section. 4 As this is a qualitative study it would be prudent to disclose the authors’ experience / perspective of this clinical situation as this is germane to their research conduct and interpretation. • The article would be strengthened by including information about the development of the semi-structured interview guide. It is unclear what informed the questions, i.e., what was the theoretical or conceptual base? This level of detail is relevant for the credibility aspect of trustworthiness. What is mentioned in lines 95/6 is “The tool was informed by a review of existing signatures (include references) to ensure relevant themes on barriers to VAB use”. It is not clear what is meant by a review of existing signatures (include references)”. Authors’ Response Thank you very much for your comment. The development of the interview guide has been further explained. The guide was designed through a structured literature review, and the socioecological model guided the structure and organization of questions. Moreover, line 95/6 has been reviewed and the appropriate terms incorporated. 5 Research rigour / Trustworthiness. It would strengthen the article to explicitly include “transferability” and to mention if member checking was done to enhance confirmability. Authors’ Response Thank you for your comment. To improve transferability, we have elucidated the contextual attributes of the study environment, encompassing facility level, delivery volume, VAB rates, and organizational context. We also supplied comprehensive participant characteristics, including professional cadre (expert obstetricians versus residents), job experience, and additional recruitment criteria. These descriptions enable readers to evaluate the relevance of findings to analogous clinical settings. Formal member checking was not conducted due to logistical limitations and the restricted availability of clinicians. Confirmability was improved through methodological triangulation within the study team, and independent coding by various researchers, followed by consensus discussions. 6 Ethics While confidentiality is clearly described there are other ethical concerns • Participants were identified by the ward “incharge”, after which the researcher approached them in person. Did the “incharge” ask the potential participants if the researchers could approach them? This distinction is important in terms of the autonomy of the individuals concerned who were in the employ of the hospital. Authors’ Response Thank you for your observation. In this study, the role of the in-charge was to identify potential participants and produce a list, which was given to the researchers. Then the researcher was the one who obtained consent from participants, and all participants were free to choose whether to participate or not. The in-charge did not ask participants anything about being approached by the researcher. 6 What was the employment relationship between the participants and the researchers? Given that the participants were employees in the hospital where the study was being conducted, was there a sense of obligation to participate (undue coercion?)? What was the power dynamic between the participants and the employer and/or the researcher? Was there a possibility that they might feel that their participation was necessary to ensure that their employment status was not jeopardised? 7 Authors’ Response OThe relationship between the researchers and participants was limited strictly to the conduct of the study. All researchers were affiliated with Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences, while participants were employees of Muhimbili National Hospital. Although both institutions share the name “Muhimbili,” they operate independently under distinct management structures, despite being located adjacent to one another. 8 Author contributions. Please clarify which of the authors conducted the interviews. The article indicates that a midwife was a co-facilitator, but it is not clear who was the lead interviewer. It is not clear if the midwife co-facilitator (information gatherer/data collector) is included in the authorship or acknowledgements. Please clarify this contribution. 9 Authors’ Response Thank you for the comment. We have updated the author's contribution. The RA has also been included as a co-author because he participated in curating data and creating the initial draft of the manuscript, which warrants authorship. Submitted filename: Response to Reviewewers.docx 12 Jul 2026 Understanding the Underuse: Barriers to Vacuum-Assisted Birth Among Clinicians in Tanzania: An Exploratory Qualitative Study PONE-D-25-41107R1 Dear Dr. Chikwala, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Hannah Tappis, DrPH, MPH Academic Editor PLOS One Additional Editor Comments (optional): Reviewers' comments: PONE-D-25-41107R1 PLOS One Dear Dr. Chikwala, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS One. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset You will receive further instructions from the production team, including instructions on how to review your proof when it is ready. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few days to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. You will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Hannah Tappis Academic Editor PLOS One