Within-Day Dynamics of Self-Efficacy and Smoking Attitudes: Ecological Momentary Assessment Study of Motivation to Quit and Forgoing Behavior Authors: Amanda L Rebar, Liyan Xiong, Chih-Hsiang Yang, Dèsirée Vidaña-Pérez, James Hardin, Minji Kim, James F Thrasher, Alicia Stone Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundMotivation to quit smoking and decisions to smoke or forgo smoking vary throughout the day. However, little is known about how within-day patterns of psychological states such as self-efficacy and attitudes toward smoking relate to these determinants of smoking cessation attempts. Identifying these dynamic processes can inform the development of more precisely timed and tailored digital interventions.ObjectiveThis study aimed to identify distinct within-day trajectories of self-efficacy for cutting down on cigarettes smoked and attitudes toward smoking, and to examine how these trajectories predicted end-of-day motivation to quit and same-day cigarette forgoing (ie, choosing not to smoke cigarettes that one would normally smoke).MethodsPeople who smoked at least 10 cigarettes a day at baseline (N=348, mean age 44.6, SD 12.1 years; n=212, 60.9% female) received smartphone surveys about 4‐5 times a day after logging each cigarette, producing 15,614 surveys over 2561 days. Trajectories of self-efficacy and smoking attitudes were modeled at the person-day level using smooth functions, and 6 daily parameters of change (overall level, range of change, volatility, overall trend, acceleration of change, and trajectory shape [trend×acceleration]) were extracted. These parameters were then entered as predictors of (1) end-of-day motivation to quit (linear mixed models) and (2) whether participants forwent cigarettes that day (binomial generalized linear mixed models).ResultsHigher overall self-efficacy consistently predicted both greater end-of-day motivation and greater odds of forgoing. Upward trends and acceleration in self-efficacy further predicted greater odds of forgoing, indicating that days when confidence not only increased but did so quicker were most strongly associated with forgoing cigarettes that day. Less favorable attitudes toward smoking predicted greater motivation to quit and increased likelihood of forgoing cigarettes. Broader ranges of daily change in attitudes were linked with stronger motivation to quit and greater odds of forgoing, while more moment-to-moment volatility was associated with reduced odds of forgoing cigarettes that day.ConclusionsDynamic features of self-efficacy and smoking attitudes, such as overall level, trend, and acceleration, were robust predictors of daily motivation to quit and cigarette forgoing. These findings highlight that the way self-efficacy and attitudes shift across the day is meaningful beyond their overall levels. Just-in-time adaptive interventions may be more effective if they monitor and respond to varying trajectory features rather than focusing on static states, supporting a shift toward dynamically aware intervention strategies in digital health. Introduction Background Smoking cigarettes severely impacts the quality and longevity of a person’s life [1]. Tobacco causes systemic harms on the body and mind, leading to a wide assortment of diseases, including cancers, heart disease, lung diseases, and type 2 diabetes [1], that result in the premature deaths of more than 8 million people each year globally [2]. As the most common method of tobacco consumption, smoking cigarettes remains the primary target of most public health measures to prevent tobacco-related deaths [3]. Although not all harms of smoking are reversible, quitting before the age of 40 years can reduce early mortality risk by about 90% [4]. To reduce the massive burden of smoking, there is a need to better understand the dynamics of modifiable predictors of motivation to quit and cessation behaviors. Motivation to quit smoking plays a pivotal role in initiating quit attempts and is a predictor of eventual cessation success [5,6]. When a person reports motivation to quit smoking, it reflects their readiness to change and serves as a crucial psychological trigger that shifts them from contemplation to action [7,8]. Research consistently shows that people with stronger motivation to quit smoking are significantly more likely to initiate serious quit attempts. For example, estimates from the International Tobacco Control Four Country Survey found that people who smoke and reported strong motivation to quit were more than twice as likely to attempt quitting within 6 months compared with those with low motivation [5,9], and a large longitudinal study of US people who smoke showed that those expressing strong motivation to quit had over a 2.5-fold increased likelihood of making a quit attempt [8]. Successful smoking cessation is influenced not only by a person’s motivation to quit but also by engagement in specific preparatory behaviors (sometimes referred to as microbehaviors), such as stubbing out or forgoing smoking cigarettes in situations when one craves a cigarette or would normally smoke [10]. Forgoing cigarettes can signal readiness to quit and consistently and independently predicts subsequent quit attempts [11-14], although the evidence is mixed on whether forgoing leads to successful cessation, which is primarily determined by one’s level of nicotine dependence [9,10,15]. Nevertheless, forgoing cigarettes moves people toward cessation attempts, even if they are not motivated to quit, and, as such, could serve as an intervention target to promote, reinforce, and expand upon. Motivation to quit smoking and microbehaviors of cessation, such as forgoing cigarettes, are reliably predicted by a person’s attitudes toward smoking and their beliefs that they can cut down on smoking (ie, self-efficacy) [15-17]. Positive attitudes about smoking indicate a pleasant valuation of smoking and anticipated pleasure from the act, which can have a strong hedonic motivational sway on behavior [18,19], making it less likely that a person will be motivated to quit or forgo smoking. Alternatively, when people have strong self-efficacy to cut down on smoking, they enjoy an increased likelihood to overcome barriers and maintain control over smoking urges [20]. This self-confidence increases the likelihood of being motivated to quit smoking and engaging in cessation-related microbehaviors such as forgoing cigarettes when tempted [17]. Meta-analytic findings show that the association between self-efficacy and quit attempts or short-term abstinence is moderate to strong, with effect sizes typically ranging from r=0.30 to 0.50 [17]. Attitudes similarly demonstrate moderate effects on motivation and behavior, often in the range of r=0.20-0.40 [15]. These effects highlight that, while neither factor alone guarantees quitting, their combined influence plays a substantial role in driving cessation-related motivation and behavior. For decades, public health efforts have promoted smoking cessation through persuasive campaigns aimed at motivating people to quit smoking. Although these campaigns effectively raise awareness about the harms of smoking and can be effective in promoting cessation [21,22], for many people who smoke, campaigns often fall short in translating awareness and cessation attempts into sustained cessation [23,24]. Despite the widespread knowledge of the harms of smoking [4], more than 1 in 5 adults around the world still smoke cigarettes regularly [3]. One reason that these static intervention approaches have limited effectiveness is that smoking behaviors and the motivational factors that influence them fluctuate throughout the day, changing in line with a person’s affective and cognitive states, external demands, responsibilities, environment, and social contexts [25,26]. Prior work has documented these momentary fluctuations but has largely focused on levels of experience or discrete events. Less is known about how these processes unfold over time within a day, including patterns of change such as whether they improve or worsen (ie, direction), how much they fluctuate (ie, variability), and how patterns of change unfold over time (ie, dynamics). To be more effective, smoking cessation interventions may need to align not only with the presence of these fluctuations but also with their underlying temporal patterns [27,28]. The Present Study This study examined within-day dynamics of 2 key constructs relevant to smoking behavior: attitudes toward smoking (ie, momentary evaluations of smoking as good or bad) and self-efficacy for forgoing cigarettes (ie, confidence in one’s ability to resist smoking in the moment). We focused on how these constructs change across the course of a day, including their levels and patterns of change. We addressed 2 primary research questions: (1) What distinct within-day trajectory patterns characterize changes in attitudes toward smoking and self-efficacy for forgoing cigarettes? and (2) Are features of these trajectories (eg, overall level, variability, and direction of change) associated with end-of-day motivation to quit smoking and the likelihood of forgoing a cigarette on that day? Methods Study Procedures Data were from a longitudinal clinical trial using ecological momentary assessment (EMA) [29-31]. Recruitment occurred in central New York and central South Carolina from June 2019 to June 2021, with interruptions during the initial COVID-19 outbreak and closures [29]. Prior to the pandemic, the New York site recruited locally at smoke shops in 6 urban and rural areas selected to capture areas of low household income. Research staff stationed outside the shops invited adults to participate, screened interested individuals for eligibility, and, if eligible, provided participants with study materials and baseline measures on site. In South Carolina, recruitment was conducted through online advertisements and flyers that directed interested individuals to a web-based eligibility screener. Adults (ie, those older than 18 years) were eligible to participate if they had smoked at least 100 cigarettes in their lifetime and at least 10 cigarettes a day in the prior month, with smoking confirmed via exhaled CO (Covita) of at least 8 ppm. Eligible respondents were then contacted to confirm eligibility and schedule an in-person orientation and materials pickup. After the onset of COVID-19, both sites shifted to recruitment through social media advertisements, orientations were conducted virtually, and study materials were provided during scheduled in-person visits to a university or other central location. For the intervention, participants attended a 45-minute orientation session and were provided with a 14-day supply of their preferred cigarette brand, with cigarette packs modified to reflect their randomized labeling condition: control (standard text-only health warnings), insert-only (packs containing paper inserts with efficacy messages), graphic-only (packs displaying pictorial health warnings), or insert plus graphic (packs including both pictorial warnings and efficacy message inserts). Data from all participants across the 4 labeling conditions were included in the present analyses, with study condition statistically controlled in all models. Across all conditions, participants logged each cigarette smoked using the study app. Additionally, participants completed a 1‐ to 3-minute survey following approximately 4 or 5 of the logged cigarettes (randomly sampled each day, with sampling frequency matched to baseline smoking rate), as well as following the first cigarette from each new pack. Data from all participants across the 4 labeling conditions were included in the present analyses, with study condition statistically controlled in all models. Omitting data from days with fewer than 4 smoking survey completions resulted in exclusion of 3429 assessments (18%) for 363 days from 344 participants. This resulted in data of 15,614 assessments of 2561 individual days from 348 individuals for this study. Ethical Considerations The study was approved by the University of South Carolina Institutional Review Board (Pro00083728). Written informed consent was obtained from all participants after eligibility screening. Participant confidentiality was protected by separating identifying information from study data and assigning each participant a unique study ID. Participants received a 2-week supply of their preferred cigarette packs modified with the randomized warning labels and an additional US $150 upon completion of the study. Measures Demographic Characteristics Participants self-reported their age (in years), sex at birth (male and female), race or ethnicity (White/Black or African American, Latino/Latina/Latinx, Asian, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, American Indian or Alaska Native, and Not Listed [Please Specify]), educational attainment (grade school or some high school; completed high school; technical/trade school or community college; some university, no degree; completed university degree; and postgraduate degree), and annual household income (