Integrated online HILIC-ESI-HRMS and ICP-MS/MS for chemical species profiling in transgenic soybean callus exposed to copper nanoparticles Authors: Raimundo Rafael Gamela, Elisânia Kelly Barbosa Fonseca, Vinnícius Henrique Cerqueira da Silva, Cristiane Renata Schmitt, Marco Aurélio Zezzi Arruda Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Soybean calluses constitute a robust in vitro model for investigating biochemical and elemental responses to external stressors. In this study, transgenic soybean calluses (Glycine max) were exposed to increasing concentrations of copper nanoparticles (CuNPs; 10, 50, and 100 µg L⁻1), and their chemical responses were investigated using an integrated online HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS platform. This hyphenated analytical approach enabled the simultaneous chromatographic separation, molecular characterization, and elemental detection of co-eluting chemical species, providing complementary metabolomic and speciation information within a single analytical workflow. The online coupling revealed marked concentration-dependent effects, with calluses exposed to 10 and 50 µg L−1 CuNPs exhibiting reduced chemical diversity compared with those exposed to 100 µg L−1. Multivariate and pathway-level analyses indicated that CuNP exposure progressively reshaped the metabolic landscape, with the most pronounced alterations observed at the highest concentration. These changes were primarily associated with cellular defense responses, redox imbalance, and membrane remodeling, as evidenced by the increased accumulation of oxylipins and lysophospholipids, including 12(13)-Ep-9-KODE, (9Z,12Z)-7,8,16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9,12-dienoic acid, and LysoPC(16:0/0:0). Importantly, the integrated speciomics strategy afforded by the online HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS platform enabled the putative annotation of metal- and heteroatom-containing species, suggesting homeostatic adjustments involving essential elements such as Mn, Mg, Zn, P, and S associated with organic ligands. These findings highlight the central role of elemental redistribution and coordination chemistry in shaping the biochemical response of soybean calluses to nanoparticle-induced stress and demonstrate the analytical potential of integrated molecular and elemental detection for investigating complex biological systems.Graphical abstract Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00216-026-06596-x. Introduction Modern agriculture increasingly relies on technological innovations to balance productivity with environmental stress mitigation, particularly in high-input cropping systems such as soybean cultivation [1]. In this context, plant biotechnology and in vitro culture systems have emerged as powerful experimental platforms for investigating cellular responses to environmental stimuli and advancing precision agriculture strategies [2]. Soybean (Glycine max) is one of the most economically important crops worldwide and is characterized by a highly dynamic metabolism that plays a central role in stress tolerance, redox regulation, and productivity [3, 4]. Its well-established transformation protocols and adaptability to in vitro cultivation make soybean an excellent model for biotechnological studies, particularly those involving callus tissues [5–7]. In transgenic soybean calluses, the genetically modified metabolic background introduces an additional layer of complexity, providing a valuable system for investigating how altered plant metabolism responds to external perturbations at the molecular level [8]. In recent years, agricultural research has shown growing interest in nanotechnology, particularly in the application of metallic nanoparticles as antimicrobial agents, growth regulators, and modulators of plant stress responses. Among these materials, copper nanoparticles (CuNPs) have attracted particular attention because of the essential role of copper in plant metabolism, redox homeostasis, and enzymatic activity [7–10]. Despite their promising applications, the behavior, transformation, and biological effects of nanoparticles in plant systems remain insufficiently understood, especially with respect to their chemical speciation and interactions with endogenous biomolecules. Callus cultures represent a robust in vitro model for investigating stress-induced metabolic reprogramming, including alterations in oxidative balance, nutrient regulation, hormone signaling, and secondary metabolism. In systems exposed to metallic nanoparticles, cellular responses are intrinsically linked to the chemical species present, which ultimately determine bioavailability, reactivity, and biological effects [5, 9, 10]. However, studies explicitly combining plant callus cultures with metallic nanoparticle exposure while simultaneously addressing chemical speciation and molecular-level transformations remain scarce. This knowledge gap highlights the need for integrative analytical strategies capable of resolving both molecular and elemental information within complex biological matrices. Most current studies still rely on either molecular or elemental analyses in isolation, limiting the interpretation of nanoparticle-induced biochemical responses. Classical approaches such as high-performance liquid chromatography coupled to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (HPLC-ICP-MS) provide excellent sensitivity and elemental selectivity and have been widely applied in targeted speciation studies when the analytes of interest are known and appropriate standards are available. However, these approaches provide limited molecular information and are inherently restricted when unknown species or highly complex biological matrices are involved, since conventional ICP-MS does not provide structural or compositional information [11, 12]. To overcome these limitations, liquid chromatography has increasingly been coupled with electrospray ionization high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-ESI-HRMS) and ICP-MS/MS using both offline and online multimodal strategies. Although offline approaches have been successfully applied in speciation studies, uncertainties regarding the stability of metal- and metalloid-containing complexes during fractionation, storage, and reanalysis remain a significant limitation [13]. In contrast, online hyphenation enables simultaneous chromatographic separation with parallel molecular and elemental detection, a prerequisite for comprehensive speciomics investigations integrating chemical speciation with metabolomics. This approach improves confidence in metabolite annotation through retention time alignment and enhances coverage of metal- and heteroatom-associated metabolites compared with conventional offline workflows. Here, the term speciomics refers to the integrated study of molecular speciation and elemental distribution within biological systems. This analytical framework opens new opportunities for identifying intact molecular forms of elements, including metal-organic complexes, metallobiomolecules, and heteroatom-containing species [11, 14–16]. Within this context, the online coupling of HILIC-ESI-HRMS and ICP-MS/MS [14, 17] provides a powerful multidimensional platform for investigating complex biological systems. High-resolution mass spectrometry enables broad and sensitive coverage of polar and semi-polar metabolites, while ICP-MS/MS allows selective and qualitative detection of metals and non-metals potentially associated with these biomolecules. Together, these complementary techniques support a more robust interpretation of chemical speciation and elemental redistribution, allowing discrimination among ionic, complexed, and biomolecule-associated forms within plant tissues [18]. By leveraging this integrated analytical strategy, stress-induced metabolic reprogramming can be directly correlated with changes in chemical species distribution, providing new insights into how different concentrations of metallic nanoparticles influence cellular homeostasis and coordination chemistry. Therefore, the present study aimed to investigate the effects of CuNPs on transgenic soybean calluses using an integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS speciomics approach. By combining comprehensive molecular profiling with simultaneous elemental detection and speciation analysis, this work provides new insights into CuNP-plant interactions and contributes to the rational evaluation of nanoparticle-based strategies for precision agriculture. Materials and methods Metallic copper nanoparticles The metallic CuNPs used in the present study were previously developed and characterized by Schmitt et al. [19]. Their biosynthesis was performed using residual soybean callus tissues as the biological reducing matrix. Physicochemical characterization was carried out using ultraviolet–visible spectroscopy (UV–Vis), dynamic light scattering (DLS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), revealing an average particle size of approximately 10 nm, uniform morphology, and high colloidal stability (zeta potential: + 60 mV). Complementary Raman and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy analyses further confirmed the metallic copper structure (Cu⁰). Soybean callus cultivation Transgenic Roundup Ready soybean seeds (carrying the cp4-EPSPS transgene) were surface-disinfected and subsequently transferred to Murashige and Skoog (MS) culture medium (pH 5.8) containing basal salts supplemented with thiamine, myo-inositol, sucrose, and agar. After 10 days of cultivation, leaf and cotyledonary nodes were excised and used as explants for callus induction. The explants were then transferred to MS medium supplemented with vitamins and the plant growth regulators benzylaminopurine (BAP) and thidiazuron (TDZ) [5]. To evaluate the effects of copper nanoparticles on callus development, three CuNP concentrations (10, 50, and 100 µg L−1) were tested. The calluses were maintained in a growth chamber under a 12-h photoperiod at 27 °C for 30 days, after which they were harvested for further analysis. Sample preparation The samples were ground to a fine, homogeneous powder under liquid nitrogen. A subsample of approximately 200 mg was weighed and subjected to extraction with 1.5 mL of acetonitrile/water (50:50, v/v). The mixture was vortexed for 1 min and subsequently sonicated using a Qsonica ultrasonic processor (Newtown, USA) for 90 s using a 10-s on/off pulse cycle. The extracts were then centrifuged at 8500 rpm for 10 min, and the resulting supernatants were filtered through a 0.22-µm membrane filter and transferred to amber vials for analysis. To minimize experimental variability, all calluses were cultivated under identical environmental conditions, and samples were processed using a standardized extraction and analytical workflow. Despite these precautions, variations in extraction efficiency and ionization response, particularly for metal-associated chemical species, may influence signal intensity. Therefore, the present study emphasizes the reproducibility of metabolic trends and pathway-level modulation rather than absolute quantitative reproducibility. Species separation Chromatographic separation was performed using a Thermo Scientific Ultimate 3000 system (Waltham, MA, USA) equipped with a cooled autosampler. Separation was achieved using an Accucore Amide-HILIC column (250 × 2.1 mm, 2.6 µm; Thermo Scientific) operated under gradient elution at a flow rate of 0.750 mL min−1. The mobile phases consisted of (A) acetonitrile and (B) 5 mM ammonium formate containing 0.1% (v/v) formic acid (pH 5.5). The gradient program was as follows: 0–2.5 min, 10% B; 2.5–22.5 min, linear increase to 50% B; 22.5–25.0 min, 50% B; 25.0–26.0 min, increase to 65% B; 26.0–27.5 min, 65% B; and 27.5–30.0 min, return to 10% B for column re-equilibration. A 15-µL aliquot of each extract was injected onto the HILIC column, which was maintained at 35 °C. After chromatographic separation, the column effluent was directed through a Series 600 flow splitter (ASI Company, USA), splitting the flow such that 30% was directed to the ICP-MS/MS and 70% to the ESI-HRMS. Identification of chemical species using HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS An iCAP TQ ICP-MS/MS (Thermo Scientific, Bremen, Germany) was used for the determination of the monitored elements, including iron (Fe), copper (Cu), zinc (Zn), molybdenum (Mo), nickel (Ni), magnesium (Mg), manganese (Mn), calcium (Ca), sulfur (S), and phosphorus (P). Oxygen (O2; 30%, 0.3 mL min−1) and hydrogen (H2; 1.1 mL min−1) were used as reaction gases in MS/MS mode. The ICP-MS/MS was operated in organic mode using platinum cones (Pt cones), and the sample introduction system consisted of a micro-PFA nebulizer with supplemental oxygen/argon (15:85, v/v) added to the nebulizer gas. The influence of the acetonitrile gradient on the ICP-MS/MS signal was monitored as previously described by Kato et al. [14]. The instrument was operated using 99.999% argon (White Martins-Praxair, São Paulo, Brazil), with an RF power of 1500 W, plasma gas flow of 14 L min−1, and nebulizer gas flow of 0.99 mL min−1. Because an organic interface was employed, the spray chamber temperature was maintained at −2 °C. An Orbitrap Q Exactive HRMS (Thermo Scientific, Bremen, Germany), equipped with a heated electrospray ionization (HESI) source, was used for molecular identification of eluting compounds in parallel with the ICP-MS/MS system. The instrument was operated in both positive and negative ionization modes with a spray voltage of 3.5 kV and a resolving power of 70,000 (at m/z 200), over a scan range of m/z 70–1050. Data acquisition consisted of full-scan MS followed by MS/MS analysis in data-dependent acquisition (DDA) mode, targeting the five most intense precursor ions detected in the HRMS signal. Stepped normalized collision energies of 20, 30, and 50 eV were applied. Arsenobetaine (m/z 179.004) was used as an internal standard because it allowed simultaneous detection of arsenic by ICP-MS/MS (m/z 91, monitored as 75As16O in mass-shift mode) and its corresponding molecular ion (C5H12AsO2, m/z 179.004) by HRMS at the same retention time. Each analytical sequence began with blank injections (mobile phase and extraction solvent only), followed by sample analysis. Compound identification and confirmation of fragmentation patterns were performed using Compound Discoverer (Thermo Scientific), with ChemSpider, mzCloud, and MassBank as reference databases. The following adducts were considered during data processing: [M+H]⁺, [M+Na]⁺, [M+K]⁺, [M+NH₄]⁺, [M+CH₃OH+H]⁺, [M+ACN+H]⁺, and [M+H−H₂O]⁺ in positive mode; and [M−H]⁻, [M+Cl]⁻, [M−H₂O−H]⁻, [M+Na−2H]⁻, [M+K−2H]⁻, and [M+FA−H]⁻ in negative mode. Chemometric analysis, including principal component analysis (PCA), was performed using the MetaboAnalyst 6.0 platform. Results and discussions Assessment of transgenic soybean callus after cultivation Figure 1 shows representative transgenic soybean calluses derived from Roundup Ready soybean and cultivated for 30 days under the different experimental conditions. As the objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of CuNPs on callus tissues during this period, only macroscopic physiological parameters, including callus development, oxidation status, and coloration, were assessed.Fig. 1Transgenic soybean calluses cultured after 30 days under control conditions and exposed to CuNPs (10, 50 and 100 µg L−1) Transgenic soybean calluses cultured after 30 days under control conditions and exposed to CuNPs (10, 50 and 100 µg L−1) Regarding callus development, normal growth was observed under all experimental conditions, including exposure to 10, 50, and 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs, as well as in the control treatment (absence of CuNPs). All calluses exhibited a healthy green color, indicating tissue viability and the absence of visible oxidative stress symptoms, consistent with previous observations reported by da Silva and Arruda [6]. No visible growth inhibition was observed in any of the treatments. Importantly, the absence of macroscopic physiological alterations suggests that CuNP-induced responses occur primarily at the molecular and metabolic levels. This finding reinforces the relevance of the integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS approach employed in this study, which enables the detection of early and subtle biochemical reprogramming events that are not detectable by visual inspection. Chemical species profile and comparative analysis of transgenic soybean calluses Multivariate analysis of chemical species To obtain an overview of the chemical species variation induced by CuNP exposure, an unsupervised principal component analysis (PCA) was applied to the dataset generated by the integrated online HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS platform. PCA was used as an exploratory multivariate approach to evaluate global similarities and differences among samples and to identify the main sources of variability within the chemical species dataset [20]. The PCA model showed that the first two principal components captured a substantial proportion of the total variance, with PC1 explaining 40.2% and PC2 accounting for 37.2%, together representing 77.4% of the overall dataset variability. This high cumulative variance indicates that the two-dimensional PCA model provides a robust overview of the main metabolic alterations induced by CuNP exposure in soybean calluses. The PCA score plot (Fig. 2) revealed a clear separation among the experimental groups, indicating a concentration-dependent metabolic reorganization. Control calluses were distinctly positioned in the negative region of both PC1 and PC2, reflecting the basal metabolic profile characteristic of unstressed tissues. In contrast, all CuNP-treated samples shifted toward positive PC1 values, indicating that this component primarily captured the global metabolic response associated with nanoparticle exposure.Fig. 2PCA score plot of chemical species profiles obtained from transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations (control, 10, 50, and 100 µg L−1) of CuNPs PCA score plot of chemical species profiles obtained from transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations (control, 10, 50, and 100 µg L−1) of CuNPs Among the treated groups, calluses exposed to 10 µg L−1 CuNPs were mainly distributed along positive PC2 values while remaining close to the PC1 origin, suggesting early adaptive metabolic adjustments rather than extensive metabolic reprogramming. The 50 µg L−1 treatment occupied an intermediate position, displaced toward positive PC1 and moderately positive PC2 values, consistent with a progressive intensification of stress-related metabolic responses. Notably, calluses exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs formed a clearly distinct cluster characterized by strongly positive PC1 and negative PC2 scores, indicating a pronounced and qualitatively different metabolic state at the highest nanoparticle concentration. To identify the chemical species contributing to these separations, the PCA biplot was further examined (Fig. 3). Positive PC1 loadings were predominantly associated with stress- and defense-related metabolites, including γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA), dipeptides such as Glu–Gln and Glu–Asp, deoxynucleosides, flavanone derivatives, and phenylpropanoid-related compounds such as 4-O-β-D-glucosyl-4-coumaric acid. Their close alignment with CuNP-treated samples indicates a major contribution to the observed nanoparticle-induced metabolic shift.Fig. 3PCA loading plot highlights chemical species contributing to sample discrimination in soybean calluses exposed to CuNPs PCA loading plot highlights chemical species contributing to sample discrimination in soybean calluses exposed to CuNPs In contrast, negative PC1 loadings were mainly associated with metabolites involved in primary metabolism and nitrogen assimilation, particularly L-glutamic acid, which was closely aligned with the control group, reinforcing its role as a marker of the basal metabolic state. PC2 provided additional discrimination among CuNP concentrations. Positive PC2 loadings were associated with amino acid–related metabolites and compounds involved in adaptive and buffering responses, contributing to the positioning of the 10 and 50 µg L−1 treatments. In contrast, strong negative PC2 loadings were dominated by 12-oxo-phytodienoic acid, an oxylipin precursor involved in jasmonate signaling and oxidative stress responses. Its close association with the 100 µg L⁻1 treatment suggests enhanced activation of lipid-derived signaling pathways and a more severe oxidative stress condition at the highest CuNP concentration. Despite the clear separation observed in both the PCA scores and biplot, it is important to recognize that PCA primarily captures global variance patterns driven by the most abundant and co-varying metabolites. Consequently, some chemical species detected exclusively in calluses exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs did not contribute substantially to group separation, as PCA inherently emphasizes variables explaining the largest proportion of total variance, while condition-specific or low-abundance metabolites may exert limited influence on the principal components. Overall, the combined interpretation of PCA scores and loadings indicates a transition from basal metabolism in control calluses to adaptive metabolic reorganization at low and intermediate CuNP concentrations, culminating in pronounced stress-driven metabolic reprogramming at 100 µg L−1. It should be emphasized that PCA was applied exclusively as an unsupervised exploratory tool to visualize global metabolic trends and major sources of variability. No supervised classification or predictive modeling was performed, and the PCA results are presented solely to support the pathway-level interpretations discussed in the following sections. Trends in chemical species diversity and chemical classes composition When comparing the chemical species profiles across the four experimental conditions, a total of 118 species were identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured in the absence of CuNPs (control). In contrast, exposure to CuNPs resulted in a reduction in the number of detected species at lower concentrations, with 96 and 94 species identified at 10 and 50 µg L−1, respectively. Overall, a non-linear, concentration-dependent pattern was observed. Calluses exposed to 10 µg L−1 CuNPs exhibited an approximately 18% reduction in detectable chemical species relative to the control, indicating decreased metabolic complexity. At 50 µg L−1, the number of detected species remained similar to that observed at the lower concentration, suggesting maintenance of a restricted metabolic profile rather than metabolic expansion. In contrast, calluses exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs showed a clear increase in chemical diversity, reaching 122 detected species—exceeding the number observed in the control group. This increase indicates a marked metabolic shift relative to the lower CuNP concentrations. With respect to chemical classes (Fig. 4), amino acids represented the most abundant class across all treatments, followed by carbohydrates and shikimate-related compounds. These three classes showed reduced representation at 10 and 50 µg L−1 and increased abundance at 100 µg L−1. Isoflavones, organic acids, nucleosides, and nucleotides were detected at intermediate levels, whereas lipids and saponins were less abundant and exhibited only modest variation among treatments.Fig. 4Chemical species classes identified in transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations of CuNPs Chemical species classes identified in transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations of CuNPs Importantly, most of the identified metabolite classes have been previously reported in soybean tissues and are associated with central metabolic pathways, including carbon, nitrogen, carbohydrate, amino acid, and organic acid metabolism, reinforcing the biological relevance of the detected chemical profiles [21–27]. Chemical species response and metabolic pathway induced by CuNPs in transgenic soybean calluses cultivation Table 1 summarizes the chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs, based on annotation using the ChemSpider, mzCloud, and MassBank databases. Additional information on the chemical species identified under control conditions (absence of CuNPs) and after exposure to 10 and 50 µg L−1 CuNPs is provided in Supplementary Tables S1, S2, and S3, respectively. Table 1Chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MSChemical speciesFormulaeAnnot. DeltaMass (ppm)Calc. MWm/zReference ionRT (min)IndoleC8 H7 N−0.08117.0578118.0651[M+H]+12.45Trans-3-indoleacrylic acidC11 H9 N O2−0.5187.0632188.0705[M+H]+14.28TrigonellineC7 H7 N O2−0.61137.0476138.0549[M+H]+19.88y-Aminobutyric acid (GABA)C4 H9 N O2−0.5103.063386.06001[M+H−H2O]+119.81y-Glu-AlaC8 H14 N2 O5−1.41218.09217.0827[M−H]−17.232-UreidoglycineC3 H7 N3 O3−0.48133.0487134.056[M+H]+115.373-HydroxynorvalineC5 H11 N O3−0.64133.0738134.0811[M+H]+123.194-Guanidinobutyric acidC5 H11 N3 O2−0.29145.0851146.0924[M+H]+118.29Allantoic acidC4 H8 N4 O4−1.17176.0544215.0175[M+K]+115.38AllantoinC4 H6 N4 O3−0.2158.044157.0367[M−H]−12.07Aminoadipic acidC6 H11 N O4−0.24161.0688160.0615[M−H]−12.73Asn-Ile-LeuC16 H30 N4 O5−11.62358.2175339.1996[M−H−H2O]−10.66Asn-Thr-TyrC17 H24 N4 O7−4.44396.1627435.1259[M+K]+12.67Asp-GluC9 H14 N2 O7−1.53262.0797263.087[M+H]+123.35Cys-proC8 H14 N2 O3 S−1.41218.0722219.0795[M+H]+11.56L-ProlineC5 H9 N O2−0.16115.0633116.0706[M+H]+110.54D-a-Aminobutyric acid (PABA)C4 H9 N O20.38103.0634102.0561[M−H]−121.47L-GlutamineC5 H10 N2 O3−0.22146.0691145.0618[M−H]−17.43DL-Pyroglutamic acidC5 H7 N O3−0.06129.0426128.0353[M−H]−12.13Gamma-Glutamyl-2-aminobutyric acidC9 H16 N2 O5−1.68232.1055233.1128[M+H]+123.53Gamma-GlutamylisoleucineC11 H20 N2 O5−1.98260.1367261.144[M+H]+123.15Gamma-GlutamyltyrosineC14 H18 N2 O60.26310.1166291.0987[M−H−H2O]−12.54Gln-GlnC10 H18 N4 O5−1.17274.1274275.1347[M+H]+124.17Gln-GluC10 H17 N3 O60.08275.1118274.1045[M−H]−124.52Glu-AlaC8 H14 N2 O5−1.81218.0899219.0972[M+H]+123.34Glu-aspC9 H14 N2 O7−0.33262.08261.0728[M−H]−123.66Glu-GlnC10 H17 N3 O6−1.51275.1113258.108[M+H−H2O]+123.60GlycylprolineC7 H12 N2 O3−0.09172.0848171.0775[M−H]−119.24Glycyl-prolyl-glutamic acidC12 H19 N3 O6−1.28301.127302.1343[M+H]+17.03IsoleucylprolineC11 H20 N2 O3−1.36228.1471229.1544[M+H]+116.55L-AsparagineC4 H8 N2 O3−1.1132.0534133.0606[M+H]+123.33L-Aspartic acidC4 H7 N O4−0.18133.0375132.0302[M−H]−122.94Leu-ValC11 H22 N2 O3−1.25230.1628231.17[M+H]+15.27L-Glutamic acidC5 H9 N O41.26147.0533146.0461[M−H]−113.44L-Pyroglutamic acidC5 H7 N O3−0.18129.0426128.0353[M−H]−11.15L-ThreonineC4 H9 N O3−0.31119.0582120.0655[M+H]+123.35N-a-Acetyl-L-arginineC8 H16 N4 O3−1.48216.1219217.1292[M+H]+119.39N-Acetylglutamic acidC7 H11 N O5−0.94189.0635172.0603[M+H-H2O]+17.48N-Acetyl-L-asparagineC6 H10 N2 O4−0.33174.064155.0462[M−H−H2O]−18.39N-Acetyl-L-aspartic acidC6 H9 N O5−0.84175.0479174.0407[M−H]−19.72N-Acetyl-L-histidineC8 H11 N3 O3−0.59197.0799196.0727[M−H]−115.81O-AcetylserineC5 H9 N O4−0.19147.0531146.0459[M−H]−15.10Pro-Lys-SerC14 H26 N4 O5−11.72330.1865311.1686[M−H−H2O]−10.66S-Methyl-L-cysteine-S-oxideC4 H9 N O3 S−0.76151.0302152.0375[M+H]+15.39D-FructoseC6 H12 O6−0.33180.0633179.05613.99D-Raffinose pentahydrateC18 H32 O16−0.62504.1687543.1318[M+K]+121.29D-XyluloseC5 H10 O5−1.11150.0527149.0454[M−H]−13.86GalactitolC6 H14 O6−0.86182.0789181.0717[M−H]−15.46I-InositolC6 H12 O6−0.18180.0634179.0561[M−H]−116.90L-ArabinitolC5 H12 O5−0.02152.0685133.0506[M−H−H2O]−12.17MaltotrioseC18 H32 O16−0.76504.1687503.1614[M−H]−125.37PhosphohexoseC6 H11 O8 P−0.78242.019241.0117[M−H]−119.77ß-D-Glucopyranuronic acidC6 H10 O70.05194.0427193.0354[M−H]−117.72SucroseC12 H22 O11−0.66342.116377.0854[M+Cl]−120.62(9Z.12Z)−7.8.16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9.12-dienoic acidC18 H32 O5−0.22328.2249309.2071[M−H−H2O]−10.8413(S)-HOTrEC18 H30 O30.08294.2195293.2123[M−H]−10.7913-OxoODEC18 H30 O3−1.12294.2192295.2264[M+H]+10.868-{3-Oxo-2-[(2E)−2-penten-1-yl]−1-cyclopenten-1-yl}octanoic acidC18 H28 O3−1.46292.2034293.2107[M+H]+10.91Tetradecanedioic acidC14 H26 O40.41258.1832259.1905[M+H]+10.75(-)-Epigallocatechin 3-(4-methyl-gallate)C23 H20 O11−0.69472.1002471.093[M−H]−17.165.7-Dihydroxy-6-[3.4.5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-oneC15 H16 O9−1.37340.079363.0682[M+Na]+16.053′,4′,5,7-TetrahydroxyisoflavanoneC15 H12 O6−1.22288.063289.0703[M+H]+13.593′,4′,7-TrihydroxyflavanoneC15 H12 O5−1.14272.0682273.0754[M+H]+14.405-DeoxycajaninC16 H12 O5−1.31284.0681285.0754[M+H]+10.857-Hydroxy-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)−4-oxo-3.4-dihydro-2H-chromen-5-yl ß-D-glucopyranosideC21 H22 O10−0.25434.1212433.1139[M−H]−11.26CoumestrolC15 H8 O5−0.42268.0371267.0298[M−H]−11.58DaidzeinC15 H10 O4−1.5254.0575255.0648[M+H]+117.50Daidzein-4′-glucosideC21 H20 O9−1.46416.1101417.1174[M+H]+11.04GenisteinC15 H10 O50.29270.0529269.0456[M−H]−12.36MalonyldaidzinC24 H22 O12−0.96502.1106503.1179[M+H]+117.95MalonylgenistinC24 H22 O13−1.53518.1053519.1125[M+H]+11.483-O-ß-D-galactosyl-sn-glycerolC9 H18 O8−0.9254.0999253.0928[M−H]−17.50LysoPC(16:0/0:0)C24 H50 N O7 P−0.95495.332496.3393[M+H]+14.36PC(20:0/P-18:0)C46 H92 N O7 P−3.11801.6586800.6514[M−H]−114.91PhytosphingosineC18 H39 N O3−1.66317.2925318.2997[M+H]+13.532′-DeoxyadenosineC10 H13 N5 O3−2.01251.1013252.1086[M+H]+11.44AdenosineC10 H13 N5 O4−1.01267.0965268.1038[M+H]+11.60GuanosineC10 H13 N5 O5−1.68283.0912322.0544[M+K]+13.83InosineC10 H12 N4 O50.32268.0809267.0736[M−H]−12.36Cyclic ADP-riboseC15 H21 N5 O13 P2−0.11541.0611540.0538[M−H]−124.52FADC27 H33 N9 O15 P20.37785.1574784.1502[M−H]−121.50UDP-GlcNAcC17 H27 N3 O17 P2−0.22607.0814606.0742[M−H]−123.18UridineC9 H12 N2 O6−0.14244.0695243.0622[M−H]−11.662-Hydroxyadipic acidC6 H10 O5−1.34162.0526325.1125[2M+H]+17.70Citric acidC6 H8 O70.02192.027191.0197[M−H]−123.02Dehydroascorbic acidC6 H6 O6−0.86174.0163173.009[M−H]−11.51Gluconic acidC6 H12 O7−0.86196.0581195.0509[M−H]−118.88Pyruvic acidC3 H4 O30.0788.0160587.00877[M−H]−13.94Succinic acid semialdehydeC4 H6 O3−0.03102.0317101.0244[M−H]−15.441-(sn-glycero-3-phospho)−1D-myo-inositolC9 H19 O11 P−0.32334.0664333.0591[M−H]−123.011-MethyladenineC6 H7 N5−0.61149.0701150.0773[M+H]+17.28AdenineC5 H5 N5−0.67135.0544136.0617[M+H]+11.55GuanineC5 H5 N5 O−0.63151.0493152.0566[M+H]+12.771-MethylcytosineC5 H7 N3 O−0.21125.0589126.0662[M+H]+16.02CytosineC4 H5 N3 O−0.01111.0433112.0505[M+H]+13.131,2,3-TrihydroxybenzeneC6 H6 O3−0.04126.0317127.039[M+H]+12.661,2,4-TrihydroxybenzeneC6 H6 O3−0.27126.0317125.0244[M−H]−13.972,3-Dihydro-1-benzofuran-2-carboxylic acidC9 H8 O30.11164.0474163.0401[M−H]−11.932-hydroxy-5-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidC13 H16 O90.06316.0795315.0722[M−H]−12.543-[2-[3,4,5-Trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxyphenyl]prop-2-enoic acidC15 H18 O8−0.15326.1001361.0695[M+Cl]−12.833-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidC14 H18 O9−1.34330.0946353.0839[M+Na]+19.794-(beta-D-Glucopyranosyloxy)phenylacetic acidC14 H18 O8−1.66314.0997337.0889[M+Na]+16.174-Aminobenzoic acid (PABA)C7 H7 N O2−0.73137.0476138.0549[M+H]+11.114-Hydroxycinnamic acidC9 H8 O3−0.13164.0473163.04[M−H]−12.784−MethylcatecholC7 H8 O2−0.1124.0524142.0862[M+NH4]+12.45Homogentisic acidC8 H8 O4−0.58168.0422169.0494[M+H]+13.35Shikimic acidC7 H10 O50.79174.053173.0457[M−H]−18.25D-Pantothenic acidC9 H17 N O5−1.61219.1103220.1175[M+H]+12.23NicotinamideC6 H6 N2 O−0.18122.048123.0553[M+H]+118.03PyridoxalC8 H9 N O3−0.27167.0582150.0549[M+H−H2O]+12.90 Table 1Chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MSChemical speciesFormulaeAnnot. DeltaMass (ppm)Calc. MWm/zReference ionRT (min)IndoleC8 H7 N−0.08117.0578118.0651[M+H]+12.45Trans-3-indoleacrylic acidC11 H9 N O2−0.5187.0632188.0705[M+H]+14.28TrigonellineC7 H7 N O2−0.61137.0476138.0549[M+H]+19.88y-Aminobutyric acid (GABA)C4 H9 N O2−0.5103.063386.06001[M+H−H2O]+119.81y-Glu-AlaC8 H14 N2 O5−1.41218.09217.0827[M−H]−17.232-UreidoglycineC3 H7 N3 O3−0.48133.0487134.056[M+H]+115.373-HydroxynorvalineC5 H11 N O3−0.64133.0738134.0811[M+H]+123.194-Guanidinobutyric acidC5 H11 N3 O2−0.29145.0851146.0924[M+H]+118.29Allantoic acidC4 H8 N4 O4−1.17176.0544215.0175[M+K]+115.38AllantoinC4 H6 N4 O3−0.2158.044157.0367[M−H]−12.07Aminoadipic acidC6 H11 N O4−0.24161.0688160.0615[M−H]−12.73Asn-Ile-LeuC16 H30 N4 O5−11.62358.2175339.1996[M−H−H2O]−10.66Asn-Thr-TyrC17 H24 N4 O7−4.44396.1627435.1259[M+K]+12.67Asp-GluC9 H14 N2 O7−1.53262.0797263.087[M+H]+123.35Cys-proC8 H14 N2 O3 S−1.41218.0722219.0795[M+H]+11.56L-ProlineC5 H9 N O2−0.16115.0633116.0706[M+H]+110.54D-a-Aminobutyric acid (PABA)C4 H9 N O20.38103.0634102.0561[M−H]−121.47L-GlutamineC5 H10 N2 O3−0.22146.0691145.0618[M−H]−17.43DL-Pyroglutamic acidC5 H7 N O3−0.06129.0426128.0353[M−H]−12.13Gamma-Glutamyl-2-aminobutyric acidC9 H16 N2 O5−1.68232.1055233.1128[M+H]+123.53Gamma-GlutamylisoleucineC11 H20 N2 O5−1.98260.1367261.144[M+H]+123.15Gamma-GlutamyltyrosineC14 H18 N2 O60.26310.1166291.0987[M−H−H2O]−12.54Gln-GlnC10 H18 N4 O5−1.17274.1274275.1347[M+H]+124.17Gln-GluC10 H17 N3 O60.08275.1118274.1045[M−H]−124.52Glu-AlaC8 H14 N2 O5−1.81218.0899219.0972[M+H]+123.34Glu-aspC9 H14 N2 O7−0.33262.08261.0728[M−H]−123.66Glu-GlnC10 H17 N3 O6−1.51275.1113258.108[M+H−H2O]+123.60GlycylprolineC7 H12 N2 O3−0.09172.0848171.0775[M−H]−119.24Glycyl-prolyl-glutamic acidC12 H19 N3 O6−1.28301.127302.1343[M+H]+17.03IsoleucylprolineC11 H20 N2 O3−1.36228.1471229.1544[M+H]+116.55L-AsparagineC4 H8 N2 O3−1.1132.0534133.0606[M+H]+123.33L-Aspartic acidC4 H7 N O4−0.18133.0375132.0302[M−H]−122.94Leu-ValC11 H22 N2 O3−1.25230.1628231.17[M+H]+15.27L-Glutamic acidC5 H9 N O41.26147.0533146.0461[M−H]−113.44L-Pyroglutamic acidC5 H7 N O3−0.18129.0426128.0353[M−H]−11.15L-ThreonineC4 H9 N O3−0.31119.0582120.0655[M+H]+123.35N-a-Acetyl-L-arginineC8 H16 N4 O3−1.48216.1219217.1292[M+H]+119.39N-Acetylglutamic acidC7 H11 N O5−0.94189.0635172.0603[M+H-H2O]+17.48N-Acetyl-L-asparagineC6 H10 N2 O4−0.33174.064155.0462[M−H−H2O]−18.39N-Acetyl-L-aspartic acidC6 H9 N O5−0.84175.0479174.0407[M−H]−19.72N-Acetyl-L-histidineC8 H11 N3 O3−0.59197.0799196.0727[M−H]−115.81O-AcetylserineC5 H9 N O4−0.19147.0531146.0459[M−H]−15.10Pro-Lys-SerC14 H26 N4 O5−11.72330.1865311.1686[M−H−H2O]−10.66S-Methyl-L-cysteine-S-oxideC4 H9 N O3 S−0.76151.0302152.0375[M+H]+15.39D-FructoseC6 H12 O6−0.33180.0633179.05613.99D-Raffinose pentahydrateC18 H32 O16−0.62504.1687543.1318[M+K]+121.29D-XyluloseC5 H10 O5−1.11150.0527149.0454[M−H]−13.86GalactitolC6 H14 O6−0.86182.0789181.0717[M−H]−15.46I-InositolC6 H12 O6−0.18180.0634179.0561[M−H]−116.90L-ArabinitolC5 H12 O5−0.02152.0685133.0506[M−H−H2O]−12.17MaltotrioseC18 H32 O16−0.76504.1687503.1614[M−H]−125.37PhosphohexoseC6 H11 O8 P−0.78242.019241.0117[M−H]−119.77ß-D-Glucopyranuronic acidC6 H10 O70.05194.0427193.0354[M−H]−117.72SucroseC12 H22 O11−0.66342.116377.0854[M+Cl]−120.62(9Z.12Z)−7.8.16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9.12-dienoic acidC18 H32 O5−0.22328.2249309.2071[M−H−H2O]−10.8413(S)-HOTrEC18 H30 O30.08294.2195293.2123[M−H]−10.7913-OxoODEC18 H30 O3−1.12294.2192295.2264[M+H]+10.868-{3-Oxo-2-[(2E)−2-penten-1-yl]−1-cyclopenten-1-yl}octanoic acidC18 H28 O3−1.46292.2034293.2107[M+H]+10.91Tetradecanedioic acidC14 H26 O40.41258.1832259.1905[M+H]+10.75(-)-Epigallocatechin 3-(4-methyl-gallate)C23 H20 O11−0.69472.1002471.093[M−H]−17.165.7-Dihydroxy-6-[3.4.5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-oneC15 H16 O9−1.37340.079363.0682[M+Na]+16.053′,4′,5,7-TetrahydroxyisoflavanoneC15 H12 O6−1.22288.063289.0703[M+H]+13.593′,4′,7-TrihydroxyflavanoneC15 H12 O5−1.14272.0682273.0754[M+H]+14.405-DeoxycajaninC16 H12 O5−1.31284.0681285.0754[M+H]+10.857-Hydroxy-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)−4-oxo-3.4-dihydro-2H-chromen-5-yl ß-D-glucopyranosideC21 H22 O10−0.25434.1212433.1139[M−H]−11.26CoumestrolC15 H8 O5−0.42268.0371267.0298[M−H]−11.58DaidzeinC15 H10 O4−1.5254.0575255.0648[M+H]+117.50Daidzein-4′-glucosideC21 H20 O9−1.46416.1101417.1174[M+H]+11.04GenisteinC15 H10 O50.29270.0529269.0456[M−H]−12.36MalonyldaidzinC24 H22 O12−0.96502.1106503.1179[M+H]+117.95MalonylgenistinC24 H22 O13−1.53518.1053519.1125[M+H]+11.483-O-ß-D-galactosyl-sn-glycerolC9 H18 O8−0.9254.0999253.0928[M−H]−17.50LysoPC(16:0/0:0)C24 H50 N O7 P−0.95495.332496.3393[M+H]+14.36PC(20:0/P-18:0)C46 H92 N O7 P−3.11801.6586800.6514[M−H]−114.91PhytosphingosineC18 H39 N O3−1.66317.2925318.2997[M+H]+13.532′-DeoxyadenosineC10 H13 N5 O3−2.01251.1013252.1086[M+H]+11.44AdenosineC10 H13 N5 O4−1.01267.0965268.1038[M+H]+11.60GuanosineC10 H13 N5 O5−1.68283.0912322.0544[M+K]+13.83InosineC10 H12 N4 O50.32268.0809267.0736[M−H]−12.36Cyclic ADP-riboseC15 H21 N5 O13 P2−0.11541.0611540.0538[M−H]−124.52FADC27 H33 N9 O15 P20.37785.1574784.1502[M−H]−121.50UDP-GlcNAcC17 H27 N3 O17 P2−0.22607.0814606.0742[M−H]−123.18UridineC9 H12 N2 O6−0.14244.0695243.0622[M−H]−11.662-Hydroxyadipic acidC6 H10 O5−1.34162.0526325.1125[2M+H]+17.70Citric acidC6 H8 O70.02192.027191.0197[M−H]−123.02Dehydroascorbic acidC6 H6 O6−0.86174.0163173.009[M−H]−11.51Gluconic acidC6 H12 O7−0.86196.0581195.0509[M−H]−118.88Pyruvic acidC3 H4 O30.0788.0160587.00877[M−H]−13.94Succinic acid semialdehydeC4 H6 O3−0.03102.0317101.0244[M−H]−15.441-(sn-glycero-3-phospho)−1D-myo-inositolC9 H19 O11 P−0.32334.0664333.0591[M−H]−123.011-MethyladenineC6 H7 N5−0.61149.0701150.0773[M+H]+17.28AdenineC5 H5 N5−0.67135.0544136.0617[M+H]+11.55GuanineC5 H5 N5 O−0.63151.0493152.0566[M+H]+12.771-MethylcytosineC5 H7 N3 O−0.21125.0589126.0662[M+H]+16.02CytosineC4 H5 N3 O−0.01111.0433112.0505[M+H]+13.131,2,3-TrihydroxybenzeneC6 H6 O3−0.04126.0317127.039[M+H]+12.661,2,4-TrihydroxybenzeneC6 H6 O3−0.27126.0317125.0244[M−H]−13.972,3-Dihydro-1-benzofuran-2-carboxylic acidC9 H8 O30.11164.0474163.0401[M−H]−11.932-hydroxy-5-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidC13 H16 O90.06316.0795315.0722[M−H]−12.543-[2-[3,4,5-Trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxyphenyl]prop-2-enoic acidC15 H18 O8−0.15326.1001361.0695[M+Cl]−12.833-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidC14 H18 O9−1.34330.0946353.0839[M+Na]+19.794-(beta-D-Glucopyranosyloxy)phenylacetic acidC14 H18 O8−1.66314.0997337.0889[M+Na]+16.174-Aminobenzoic acid (PABA)C7 H7 N O2−0.73137.0476138.0549[M+H]+11.114-Hydroxycinnamic acidC9 H8 O3−0.13164.0473163.04[M−H]−12.784−MethylcatecholC7 H8 O2−0.1124.0524142.0862[M+NH4]+12.45Homogentisic acidC8 H8 O4−0.58168.0422169.0494[M+H]+13.35Shikimic acidC7 H10 O50.79174.053173.0457[M−H]−18.25D-Pantothenic acidC9 H17 N O5−1.61219.1103220.1175[M+H]+12.23NicotinamideC6 H6 N2 O−0.18122.048123.0553[M+H]+118.03PyridoxalC8 H9 N O3−0.27167.0582150.0549[M+H−H2O]+12.90 Chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS To better understand the biochemical impact of CuNP exposure, the metabolic responses of soybean calluses were interpreted by grouping altered metabolites into major functional pathways, with particular emphasis on the comparison between control samples and those exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs. Overall, comparative analysis across all experimental conditions (Table 2) revealed pronounced metabolic alterations, demonstrating that soybean calluses exhibit distinct concentration-dependent biochemical responses to CuNP exposure. Table 2Comparative analysis of chemical species in transgenic soybean calluses under different CuNPs concentrations based on HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS dataChemical speciesCuNPsControl10 µg L−150 µg L−1100 µg L−1y-Aminobutyric acid (GABA)✓✓✓✓Pyruvic acid✓✓✓✓Lactic acid✓XxXL-Valine✓XxXSuccinic acid semialdehydexXx✓D-a-Aminobutyric acid (PABA)xXx✓D-Glyceric acid✓✓✓XCytosine✓✓✓✓Xilose✓XxXL-Isoleucine✓Xx✓N-Acetylglycine✓XxXIndole✓✓✓✓Betaine✓XxXL-ThreonineXXx✓Nicotinamide✓Xx✓1.2.4-TrihydroxybenzeneXXx✓1-MethylcytosineXX✓✓1.2.3-TrihydroxybenzeneXXx✓L-Pyroglutamic acid✓✓x✓DihydrothymineXX✓XDL-Pyroglutamic acidx✓✓✓L-Glutamic acid✓✓✓✓D-Ribose✓✓✓XD-Asparagine✓XxXL-Aspartic acid✓✓✓✓L-ArabinitolxXx✓L-AsparaginexXx✓2-UreidoglycinexXx✓3-HydroxynorvalinexXx✓Adenine✓✓✓✓4-Aminobenzoic acid (PABA)xX✓✓Trigonellinex✓✓✓4-MethylcatecholxXx✓Aminoadipic acid✓X✓✓L-Glutamine✓✓✓✓O-Acetylserine✓✓✓✓4-Guanidinobutyric acidxXx✓3-Hydroxycinnamic acid✓✓✓✓Mevalonic acid✓✓xXD-XylulosexXx✓Pyridoxal✓X✓✓1-MethyladeninexXx✓5-Hydroxybenzofuran-2(3H)-onexX✓XS-Methyl-L-cysteine-S-oxidexXx✓Guanine✓✓✓✓Protocatehuic acid✓XxXL-Histidine✓XxXAllantoinxXx✓Pimelic acidx✓xXCitrullinex✓xX4-Hydroxycinnamic acidxX✓✓2,3-Dihydro-1-benzofuran-2-carboxylic acidxXx✓2-Hydroxycinnamic acidx✓✓XHomogentisic acidx✓x✓GlycylprolinexXx✓N-Acetylglutamic acid✓✓✓✓Dehydroascorbic acidx✓✓✓Cis-Aconitic acid✓X✓XGluconic acid✓Xx✓Shikimic acid✓Xx✓N-Acetyl-L-asparagine✓✓✓✓N-Acetylornithine✓XxXN2-Acetylornithinex✓xXN-Acetyl-L-aspartic acid✓✓x✓Ascorbic acid✓✓xX2-Isopropylmalic acid✓X✓XArginine✓XxXGluconolactone✓Xx✓D-Fructose✓Xx✓I-Inositol✓Xx✓Galactitol✓✓✓✓Ala-Asp✓XxxN6-Acetyl-L-lysine✓XxxTrans-3-Indoleacrylic acidxXx✓Citric acid✓✓✓✓N-Acetyl-L-histidine✓✓✓✓L-Arginine✓XxxO-PhosphothreoninexXx✓4-Pyridoxic acidx✓xxAla-Ilex✓xxL-Tryptophanx✓xx2-Methylcitric acidxX✓xGlu-Gly✓✓✓xN-Acetyl-L-phenylalanine✓✓xxGlycerophosphoethanolaminex✓✓xAllantoic acidxXx✓D-GlucosexX✓xy-Glu-Alax✓✓✓N-a-Acetyl-L-argininexX✓✓Glutamyl pyruvatex✓xxO-Succinyl-L-homoserine✓XxxD-Pantothenic acid✓Xx✓Cys-proxX✓✓Glu-Ala✓X✓✓Thr-Glu-Gln✓XxxTraumatic acidxX✓xIsoleucylprolinexXx✓Leu-Valx✓x✓Val-Asp✓✓xxLeu-Thrx✓xxVal-Ilex✓✓xAla-Ala-Ala✓Xxxgamma-Glutamyl-2-aminobutyric acidx✓✓✓Phosphohexose✓Xx✓Cytidine✓XxxPseudouridine✓X✓xUridine✓✓✓✓Pro-gln✓XxxGlycerophosphoglycerol✓X✓xN-Acetyltryptophanx✓✓xIle-Asp✓XxxVal-Glu✓✓xxL-?-Glutamyl-L-valinexX✓xVal-Metx✓xx2′-Deoxyinosine✓✓✓✓Deoxyinosinex✓xx2′-Deoxyadenosinex✓✓✓Daidzeinx✓✓✓Glu-Glnx✓✓✓Ile-Glux✓xxTetradecanedioic acidxXx✓Glu-Asn✓✓xxGlu-asp✓✓✓✓Gamma-GlutamylisoleucinexXx✓Asp-GluxX✓✓Î3-Glutamylaspartic acidx✓xxMethionylleucinexX✓xThiamine✓XxxInosine✓Xx✓Adenosine✓✓✓✓Coumestrol✓✓xxGenistein✓✓✓✓Butein✓XxxPalmitic acid✓Xxx3′-Hydroxy-O-desmethylangolensin✓XxxGln-Gln✓✓✓✓12-Oxo phytodienoic acid✓✓✓✓Gln-Glux✓✓xa-Linolenic acidxXx✓Leu-Phex✓xxLinoleic acidxX✓xCalycosin✓✓✓x5-DeoxycajaninxXx✓Ophthalmic acid✓✓✓xLeu-Argx✓xxCatechinx✓xxGamma-Glutamyltyrosine✓✓✓✓Argininosuccinic acid✓Xxx13(S)-HOTrExXx✓8-{3-Oxo-2-[(2E)−2-penten-1-yl]−1-cyclopenten-1-yl}octanoic acidxXx✓13-OxoODE✓Xx✓Glycyl-prolyl-glutamic acid✓X✓✓His-Glu✓Xxx(9Z.12Z)−7.8.16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9.12-dienoic acidxXx✓Pro-Lys-SerxXx✓Glycerol monopalmitatex✓xxMonopalmitin✓XxxIsorhamnetinx✓xxLeucyltryptophanx✓xxPhytosphingosinexXx✓Guanosine✓✓✓✓4-Hydroxybenzoic acid glucoside✓✓✓x2-Hydroxyadipic acidxXx✓Cyclic AMP✓XxxcIMP✓✓xx1-(sn-glycero-3-phospho)−1D-myo-inositol✓Xx✓4-(beta-D-Glucopyranosyloxy)phenylacetic acidxX✓✓1-Linoleoyl glycerol✓XxxAsn-Ile-LeuxX✓✓Sucrose✓✓✓✓Cyclic GMP✓Xxx4-O-beta-D-glucosyl-4-coumaric acid✓✓✓✓3-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓Cellobiose✓Xxx3-[2-[3,4,5-Trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxyphenyl]prop-2-enoic acidxXx✓4′-O-beta-D-glucosyl-cis-p-coumaric acidxX✓x5.7-Dihydroxy-6-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-onexXx✓3-Ketosucrose✓XxxD-Maltose✓XxxS-Adenosylmethioninex✓xxUridine 5′-diphosphate✓✓xxDaidzein-4′-glucosidex✓x✓Daidzin✓✓xxSucrose phosphate✓XxxAsn-Thr-Tyr✓✓✓✓Oleanolic acid✓X✓xGln-Leu-TyrxXx✓Luteolin 8-glucoside✓Xxx(-)-Epigallocatechin 3-(4-methyl-gallate)xXx✓ACETYLGLYCITINx✓xxLysoPC(16:0/0:0)✓Xx✓Malonyldaidzin✓✓✓✓Maltotriosex✓x✓D-Raffinose pentahydratexX✓xMalonylgenistin✓✓✓✓Cyclic ADP-ribosexX✓✓Uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose✓XxxUDP-GlcNAcxXx✓UDP-N-acetylglucosamine✓X✓xSoyasaponin A1✓Xxx(-)-Epigallocatechinx✓xxNicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)✓✓✓xFAD✓Xx✓PC(20:0/P-18:0)xX✓✓Sulfoquinovosyl diglyceride✓XxxSoyasapogenol B 3-O-[a-L-rhamnosyl-(1->4)-b-D-galactosyl-(1->4)-b-D-glucuronide]✓XxxIndolelactic acid✓XxxL-proline✓Xx✓ß-D-Glucopyranuronic acid✓Xx✓5(E),9(Z),12(Z)-OCTADECATRIENOIC ACID✓Xxx7-Hydroxy-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)−4-oxo-3,4-dihydro-2H-chromen-5-yl ß-D-glucopyranoside✓Xxx5,6-Dihydrouridine✓Xxx3′,4′,7-Trihydroxyflavanonex✓x✓3′,4′,5,7-Tetrahydroxyisoflavanonex✓x✓Daidzosidex✓xx2′-Deoxyadenosinex✓x✓Trans-aconitic acidx✓xx1-O-(4-Hydroxybenzoyl)-ß-D-glucopyranosex✓xx1,3-dilinolenoylglycerolxX✓x3-O-ß-D-galactosyl-sn-glycerolxX✓✓Ethylmalonic acidxX✓xGlucaric acidxX✓x2-hydroxy-5-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓3-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓PhloroglucinolxX✓x(6E,8E)−5,10-dioxooctadeca-6,8-dienoic acidxXx✓1,16-Hexadecanedioic acidxXX✓5,7-Dihydroxy-6-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-onexXX✓ Table 2Comparative analysis of chemical species in transgenic soybean calluses under different CuNPs concentrations based on HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS dataChemical speciesCuNPsControl10 µg L−150 µg L−1100 µg L−1y-Aminobutyric acid (GABA)✓✓✓✓Pyruvic acid✓✓✓✓Lactic acid✓XxXL-Valine✓XxXSuccinic acid semialdehydexXx✓D-a-Aminobutyric acid (PABA)xXx✓D-Glyceric acid✓✓✓XCytosine✓✓✓✓Xilose✓XxXL-Isoleucine✓Xx✓N-Acetylglycine✓XxXIndole✓✓✓✓Betaine✓XxXL-ThreonineXXx✓Nicotinamide✓Xx✓1.2.4-TrihydroxybenzeneXXx✓1-MethylcytosineXX✓✓1.2.3-TrihydroxybenzeneXXx✓L-Pyroglutamic acid✓✓x✓DihydrothymineXX✓XDL-Pyroglutamic acidx✓✓✓L-Glutamic acid✓✓✓✓D-Ribose✓✓✓XD-Asparagine✓XxXL-Aspartic acid✓✓✓✓L-ArabinitolxXx✓L-AsparaginexXx✓2-UreidoglycinexXx✓3-HydroxynorvalinexXx✓Adenine✓✓✓✓4-Aminobenzoic acid (PABA)xX✓✓Trigonellinex✓✓✓4-MethylcatecholxXx✓Aminoadipic acid✓X✓✓L-Glutamine✓✓✓✓O-Acetylserine✓✓✓✓4-Guanidinobutyric acidxXx✓3-Hydroxycinnamic acid✓✓✓✓Mevalonic acid✓✓xXD-XylulosexXx✓Pyridoxal✓X✓✓1-MethyladeninexXx✓5-Hydroxybenzofuran-2(3H)-onexX✓XS-Methyl-L-cysteine-S-oxidexXx✓Guanine✓✓✓✓Protocatehuic acid✓XxXL-Histidine✓XxXAllantoinxXx✓Pimelic acidx✓xXCitrullinex✓xX4-Hydroxycinnamic acidxX✓✓2,3-Dihydro-1-benzofuran-2-carboxylic acidxXx✓2-Hydroxycinnamic acidx✓✓XHomogentisic acidx✓x✓GlycylprolinexXx✓N-Acetylglutamic acid✓✓✓✓Dehydroascorbic acidx✓✓✓Cis-Aconitic acid✓X✓XGluconic acid✓Xx✓Shikimic acid✓Xx✓N-Acetyl-L-asparagine✓✓✓✓N-Acetylornithine✓XxXN2-Acetylornithinex✓xXN-Acetyl-L-aspartic acid✓✓x✓Ascorbic acid✓✓xX2-Isopropylmalic acid✓X✓XArginine✓XxXGluconolactone✓Xx✓D-Fructose✓Xx✓I-Inositol✓Xx✓Galactitol✓✓✓✓Ala-Asp✓XxxN6-Acetyl-L-lysine✓XxxTrans-3-Indoleacrylic acidxXx✓Citric acid✓✓✓✓N-Acetyl-L-histidine✓✓✓✓L-Arginine✓XxxO-PhosphothreoninexXx✓4-Pyridoxic acidx✓xxAla-Ilex✓xxL-Tryptophanx✓xx2-Methylcitric acidxX✓xGlu-Gly✓✓✓xN-Acetyl-L-phenylalanine✓✓xxGlycerophosphoethanolaminex✓✓xAllantoic acidxXx✓D-GlucosexX✓xy-Glu-Alax✓✓✓N-a-Acetyl-L-argininexX✓✓Glutamyl pyruvatex✓xxO-Succinyl-L-homoserine✓XxxD-Pantothenic acid✓Xx✓Cys-proxX✓✓Glu-Ala✓X✓✓Thr-Glu-Gln✓XxxTraumatic acidxX✓xIsoleucylprolinexXx✓Leu-Valx✓x✓Val-Asp✓✓xxLeu-Thrx✓xxVal-Ilex✓✓xAla-Ala-Ala✓Xxxgamma-Glutamyl-2-aminobutyric acidx✓✓✓Phosphohexose✓Xx✓Cytidine✓XxxPseudouridine✓X✓xUridine✓✓✓✓Pro-gln✓XxxGlycerophosphoglycerol✓X✓xN-Acetyltryptophanx✓✓xIle-Asp✓XxxVal-Glu✓✓xxL-?-Glutamyl-L-valinexX✓xVal-Metx✓xx2′-Deoxyinosine✓✓✓✓Deoxyinosinex✓xx2′-Deoxyadenosinex✓✓✓Daidzeinx✓✓✓Glu-Glnx✓✓✓Ile-Glux✓xxTetradecanedioic acidxXx✓Glu-Asn✓✓xxGlu-asp✓✓✓✓Gamma-GlutamylisoleucinexXx✓Asp-GluxX✓✓Î3-Glutamylaspartic acidx✓xxMethionylleucinexX✓xThiamine✓XxxInosine✓Xx✓Adenosine✓✓✓✓Coumestrol✓✓xxGenistein✓✓✓✓Butein✓XxxPalmitic acid✓Xxx3′-Hydroxy-O-desmethylangolensin✓XxxGln-Gln✓✓✓✓12-Oxo phytodienoic acid✓✓✓✓Gln-Glux✓✓xa-Linolenic acidxXx✓Leu-Phex✓xxLinoleic acidxX✓xCalycosin✓✓✓x5-DeoxycajaninxXx✓Ophthalmic acid✓✓✓xLeu-Argx✓xxCatechinx✓xxGamma-Glutamyltyrosine✓✓✓✓Argininosuccinic acid✓Xxx13(S)-HOTrExXx✓8-{3-Oxo-2-[(2E)−2-penten-1-yl]−1-cyclopenten-1-yl}octanoic acidxXx✓13-OxoODE✓Xx✓Glycyl-prolyl-glutamic acid✓X✓✓His-Glu✓Xxx(9Z.12Z)−7.8.16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9.12-dienoic acidxXx✓Pro-Lys-SerxXx✓Glycerol monopalmitatex✓xxMonopalmitin✓XxxIsorhamnetinx✓xxLeucyltryptophanx✓xxPhytosphingosinexXx✓Guanosine✓✓✓✓4-Hydroxybenzoic acid glucoside✓✓✓x2-Hydroxyadipic acidxXx✓Cyclic AMP✓XxxcIMP✓✓xx1-(sn-glycero-3-phospho)−1D-myo-inositol✓Xx✓4-(beta-D-Glucopyranosyloxy)phenylacetic acidxX✓✓1-Linoleoyl glycerol✓XxxAsn-Ile-LeuxX✓✓Sucrose✓✓✓✓Cyclic GMP✓Xxx4-O-beta-D-glucosyl-4-coumaric acid✓✓✓✓3-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓Cellobiose✓Xxx3-[2-[3,4,5-Trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxyphenyl]prop-2-enoic acidxXx✓4′-O-beta-D-glucosyl-cis-p-coumaric acidxX✓x5.7-Dihydroxy-6-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-onexXx✓3-Ketosucrose✓XxxD-Maltose✓XxxS-Adenosylmethioninex✓xxUridine 5′-diphosphate✓✓xxDaidzein-4′-glucosidex✓x✓Daidzin✓✓xxSucrose phosphate✓XxxAsn-Thr-Tyr✓✓✓✓Oleanolic acid✓X✓xGln-Leu-TyrxXx✓Luteolin 8-glucoside✓Xxx(-)-Epigallocatechin 3-(4-methyl-gallate)xXx✓ACETYLGLYCITINx✓xxLysoPC(16:0/0:0)✓Xx✓Malonyldaidzin✓✓✓✓Maltotriosex✓x✓D-Raffinose pentahydratexX✓xMalonylgenistin✓✓✓✓Cyclic ADP-ribosexX✓✓Uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose✓XxxUDP-GlcNAcxXx✓UDP-N-acetylglucosamine✓X✓xSoyasaponin A1✓Xxx(-)-Epigallocatechinx✓xxNicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)✓✓✓xFAD✓Xx✓PC(20:0/P-18:0)xX✓✓Sulfoquinovosyl diglyceride✓XxxSoyasapogenol B 3-O-[a-L-rhamnosyl-(1->4)-b-D-galactosyl-(1->4)-b-D-glucuronide]✓XxxIndolelactic acid✓XxxL-proline✓Xx✓ß-D-Glucopyranuronic acid✓Xx✓5(E),9(Z),12(Z)-OCTADECATRIENOIC ACID✓Xxx7-Hydroxy-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)−4-oxo-3,4-dihydro-2H-chromen-5-yl ß-D-glucopyranoside✓Xxx5,6-Dihydrouridine✓Xxx3′,4′,7-Trihydroxyflavanonex✓x✓3′,4′,5,7-Tetrahydroxyisoflavanonex✓x✓Daidzosidex✓xx2′-Deoxyadenosinex✓x✓Trans-aconitic acidx✓xx1-O-(4-Hydroxybenzoyl)-ß-D-glucopyranosex✓xx1,3-dilinolenoylglycerolxX✓x3-O-ß-D-galactosyl-sn-glycerolxX✓✓Ethylmalonic acidxX✓xGlucaric acidxX✓x2-hydroxy-5-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓3-Methoxy-4-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]oxybenzoic acidxX✓✓PhloroglucinolxX✓x(6E,8E)−5,10-dioxooctadeca-6,8-dienoic acidxXx✓1,16-Hexadecanedioic acidxXX✓5,7-Dihydroxy-6-[3,4,5-trihydroxy-6-(hydroxymethyl)oxan-2-yl]chromen-4-onexXX✓ Comparative analysis of chemical species in transgenic soybean calluses under different CuNPs concentrations based on HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS data Calluses exposed to intermediate CuNP concentrations (10 and 50 µg L−1) showed marked changes in chemical composition, indicating that nanoparticle-induced stress affected multiple biochemical pathways. As discussed above, reduced chemical diversity was observed at these concentrations, with several metabolites detected in the control group no longer observed after CuNP exposure. For example, 2-isopropylmalic acid, LysoPC(16:0/0:0), 13-OxoODE, aminoadipic acid, and cyclic ADP-ribose, compounds associated with amino acid metabolism, nucleotide turnover, and stress signaling, were absent under these conditions. This reduction suggests an early metabolic suppression accompanied by reallocation of cellular resources, likely driven by mild oxidative stress and the redirection of energy toward maintaining redox balance and cellular homeostasis [28]. At 50 µg L−1, the detection of vanillic acid, coumaric acid, and several glycosylated phenolic compounds suggests activation of compensatory responses, potentially related to reinforcement of antioxidant capacity and stabilization of cellular redox status. This non-linear, dose-dependent response, where intermediate stress levels promote metabolic readjustment, is consistent with previous studies on plant-nanoparticle interactions [29–31]. In contrast, the exclusive detection of multiple metabolites in soybean calluses exposed to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs suggests coordinated perturbation of several interconnected pathways, indicating a transition from metabolic homeostasis toward stress-driven reprogramming. One of the most strongly affected pathways was lipid metabolism, particularly oxylipin biosynthesis and fatty acid oxidation, as evidenced by the appearance of highly oxygenated fatty acid derivatives such as 13(S)-HOTrE, (6E,8E)−5,10-dioxooctadeca-6,8-dienoic acid, and (9Z,12Z)−7,8,16-trihydroxyoctadeca-9,12-dienoic acid [32, 33]. These metabolites are well-recognized markers of lipid peroxidation and membrane oxidation, suggesting that high CuNP exposure promotes a shift in lipid-derived signaling toward oxidative damage. Their absence in control calluses supports the interpretation that basal conditions do not generate sufficient oxidative pressure to trigger membrane lipid oxidation. Although these findings strongly support stress-driven metabolic reprogramming, it cannot be excluded that part of the observed metabolic response reflects adaptive remodeling rather than irreversible cellular damage. In parallel, redox homeostasis and glutathione-dependent metabolism appeared strongly perturbed at 100 µg L−1, as evidenced by the accumulation of metabolites associated with antioxidant turnover, including ophthalmic acid, γ-glutamylisoleucine, DL-pyroglutamic acid, dehydroascorbic acid, and S-methyl-L-cysteine-S-oxide [34]. Ophthalmic acid, in particular, is widely recognized as an indicator of glutathione depletion [35], suggesting that antioxidant buffering capacity may be exceeded under severe copper-induced stress. Secondary metabolism derived from the phenylpropanoid and flavonoid pathways also emerged as a major stress-responsive route [36, 37]. This was supported by the exclusive detection of phenolic and flavonoid metabolites such as (–)-epigallocatechin 3-(4-methyl-gallate), 3′,4′,5,7-tetrahydroxyisoflavanone, daidzein, daidzein-4′-glucoside, licoflavone A, ginnalin B, and 4-hydroxycinnamic acid [38, 39]. These compounds likely contribute to antioxidant defense through radical scavenging and metal-chelating activities. High CuNP exposure also reprogrammed amino acid metabolism, nitrogen remobilization, and the γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) shunt [40], as indicated by the accumulation of GABA, D-α-aminobutyric acid, L-asparagine, L-threonine, and related metabolites. Additionally, the detection of ureide-related compounds such as allantoin, allantoic acid, and 2-ureidoglycine [41] suggests increased nitrogen storage and redistribution, a typical stress response in soybean. Alterations in nucleotide metabolism and cofactor turnover were also evident, with exclusive detection of 1-methyladenine, 2′-deoxyadenosine, FAD, and UDP-GlcNAc, suggesting enhanced nucleotide recycling, possible DNA repair responses, and increased demand for redox-active cofactors [42–44]. Finally, high CuNP exposure affected membrane remodeling and carbohydrate metabolism associated with osmoprotection and carbon reallocation. This was reflected by the presence of membrane-associated species such as PC(20:0/P-18:0), phytosphingosine, and 3-O-β-D-galactosyl-sn-glycerol, together with carbohydrate-related metabolites including D-xylulose and maltotriose [45, 46]. Taken together, these findings indicate that exposure to 100 µg L−1 CuNPs triggers coordinated alterations in lipid metabolism, redox regulation, phenolic metabolism, amino acid and nitrogen metabolism, nucleotide turnover, and carbohydrate metabolism—pathways that remain comparatively stable under basal conditions. To provide an integrated visualization of these stress-associated responses, a heatmap was constructed using selected metabolites associated with oxidative stress, redox imbalance, membrane remodeling, and secondary defense pathways (Fig. 5). The heatmap revealed clear concentration-dependent clustering and pronounced induction of stress-related metabolites at 100 µg L−1 CuNPs, whereas samples exposed to 10 and 50 µg L−1 exhibited lower abundance or suppression of these compounds, consistent with more adaptive metabolic states. These findings are consistent with recent integrated physiological, transcriptomic, and metabolomic studies showing that Cu-based nanoparticles can extensively remodel plant metabolic networks under stress conditions [47].Fig. 5Heatmap of stress-responsive chemical species in transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations of CuNPs Heatmap of stress-responsive chemical species in transgenic soybean calluses exposed to different concentrations of CuNPs Identification of known and putatively annotated heteroatom and metal-containing biomolecules in transgenic soybean calluses The cultivation of soybean calluses exposed to CuNPs indicates that the cells undergo dynamic adjustments in both metal and non-metal homeostasis. These changes likely involve the formation and redistribution of diverse elemental complexes within the cellular environment, although detailed information regarding their chemical speciation in plant tissues remains limited. In soybean calluses, these elements may interact with a wide range of biomolecules, including metalloenzymes, metalloproteins, and low molecular weight ligands, thereby influencing numerous biological processes. Such interactions play essential roles in metabolic regulation, redox homeostasis, stress adaptation, and cellular development, highlighting the complexity of elemental dynamics in soybean calluses exposed to CuNPs [36, 37]. Table 3 summarizes the putatively annotated metal- and heteroatom-containing chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured under 100 µg L−1 CuNPs. Detailed information regarding the species detected under the other experimental conditions is provided in Supplementary Tables S4–S6. Several amino acids, organic acids, phospholipids, and glycopeptide-like ligands were putatively associated with metal ions such as magnesium (Mg2+), manganese (Mn2+), and zinc (Zn2+), as well as with heteroatoms including sulfur (S) and phosphorus (P). These observations suggest that CuNP exposure may induce broader homeostatic adjustments involving redistribution of essential elements and their coordination with endogenous biomolecules. Table 3Putatively annotated chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MSChemical speciesAnnot. ∆Mass (ppm)Calc. MWm/zReference ionRT (min)PolarityMS2 purity (%)C29 H43 O4 P−0.81486.2895485.2822[M−H]−10.661Negative100C32 H64 N8 O4 P2−0.25686.4524685.4451[M−H]−10.982Negative100C37 H67 O10 P0.13702.4473701.44[M−H]−10.99Negative100C24 H23 N O16−0.08581.1016580.0944[M−H]−11.046Negative100C23 H30 Mn N2 O8 P20.07579.0858578.0786[M−H]−11.05Negative100C21 H22 N6 O4 P2 S−0.5516.0896517.0969[M+H]+11.054Positive100C23 H32 Mn N2 O7 P2−0.33565.1063564.0991[M−H]−11.093Negative100C15 H19 N4 O9 P1.54430.0896429.0824[M−H]−11.225Both100C28 H24 O5 P20.82502.1103503.1176[M+H]+11.475Positive100C18 H21 N4 O12 P0.56516.0897517.0969[M+H]+11.58Positive100C17 H14 N8 O12 S0.13554.0453555.0526[M+H]+11.581Positive100C21 H16 O9−1.09412.079471.0928[M−H+HAc]−11.603Negative100C19 H23 N4 O13 P0.29546.1001547.1074[M+H]+11.608Positive100C24 H20 Mn N2 O6−0.21487.0701486.0628[M−H]−11.76Negative100C15 H35 Mn N7 P2 S−0.8462.1527463.1599[M+H]+11.778Positive100C19 H41 Mn N6 O15 P S0.08711.1469710.1397[M−H]−11.806Negative100C29 H44 Mn N2 O8 P2 S0.12697.1675696.1602[M−H]−11.84Negative100C13 H12 N4 O5−4.94304.0793303.072[M−H]−110.802Negative100C12 H23 N O14−0.74405.1116404.1043[M−H]−113.221Negative100C14 H14 N6 O3 S2−2.77378.0558379.0631[M+H]+113.298Positive100C21 H35 N O6 P22.38459.1951458.1878[M−H]−113.52Negative100C7 H19 N7 O9−2.63345.1235344.1162[M−H]−114.408Negative100C16 H25 N5 O9−3.94431.1635430.1563[M−H]−115.404Negative100C8 H20 Mn N4 O7 S2.31371.0442372.0515[M+H]+116.747Positive100C9 H19 N O80.12269.1111268.1038[M−H]−116.866Negative100C6 H19 N5 O3 S22.94273.0937272.0865[M−H]−118.885Negative100C9 H23 N4 O3 P S2−2.76330.094329.0867[M−H]−118.931Negative100C17 H32 N2 O14−0.45488.1851487.1779[M−H]−119.021Negative100C17 H30 N2 O14−0.28486.1696485.1623[M−H]−119.388Negative100C12 H17 Mn N7 O2 S3.55378.0558379.0631[M+H]+119.404Positive100C20 H28 N6 O8−1.22480.1963481.2036[M+H]+119.628Positive100C18 H29 N3 O101.76447.1861448.1934[M+H]+120.927Positive100C19 H27 N O5 P2 S2.04443.1094442.1023[M−H]−121.369Both100C3 H N2 O3 P S0.25175.9446174.9373[M−H]−123.451Negative100C4 H3 N2 O5 P S2−0.71253.9219252.9146[M−H]−123.582Negative100C20 H33 N O17−0.63559.1745558.1674[M−H]−126.628Both100C12 H21 N O11−0.54355.1113354.104[M−H]−128.788Both100C27 H38 Mn N2 O5 P2−0.35587.1634588.1707[M+H]+13.729Positive100C26 H39 Mn N O6 P2−0.31578.1631579.1704[M+H]+14.168Positive100C10 H11 N8 O2 P−1.96306.0737635.1365[2M+Na]+14.417Positive100C20 H23 N O3 P22.66387.1164386.1091[M−H]−14.889Negative100C14 H14 N6 O3 S2−2.77378.0558379.0631[M+H]+16.03Positive100C11 H23 N O13−0.6377.1167376.1094[M−H]−19.783Negative100C11 H20 O6−0.16248.126307.1397[M−H+HAc]−12.717Negative91.93C15 H11 Mg N3 O52.46337.0557338.063[M+H]+11.232Positive92.61C3 H8 Mn O6−1.63194.9698195.9771[M+H]+116.888Positive92.70C10 H5 N5 O50.01275.0291293.0629[M+NH4] 16.582Positive93.21C11 H25 Mn N O3 S3.65306.0947307.102[M+H]+12.692Positive93.27C4 H8 N8 O21.01200.0772199.07[M−H]−116.639Negative94.58C10 H20 N8 O6 S2−1.01412.0943413.1015[M+H]+12.082Both94.62C10 H24 Mg N8 O3 P2−3.48390.1283391.1356[M+H]+12.442Positive94.68C6 H11 Mn N O7−1.3263.9913264.9985[M+H]+17.452Positive94.79C18 H29 N4 O5 P S20.64476.132475.1247[M−H]−11.046Negative96.58C22 H46 N7 O5 P4.73519.3323520.3395[M+H]+14.268Positive96.88C13 H16 N4 O8−3.94356.0954355.0881[M−H]−123.818Negative97.12C7 H3 N9−0.03213.0511214.0584[M+H]+121.405Positive97.33C5 H10 N8 O30.52230.0877229.0804[M−H]−116.976Negative97.43C4 H3 N2 O5 P S2−0.17253.9221252.9148[M−H]−123.068Negative97.47C16 H13 N6 O4 P−3.81384.0721383.0649[M−H]−13.84Negative97.48C11 H22 O10−0.64314.1211349.0905[M+Cl]−19.803Both97.64C16 H26 O3 S−0.42298.1601297.1529[M−H]−10.657Negative97.65C7 H12 O7−0.66208.0582207.0509[M−H]−16.099Negative97.92C22 H44 N7 O5 P4.09517.3163518.3236[M+H]+14.372Positive97.93C6 H18 N5 O6 P2.57287.1002288.1075[M+H]+12.662Positive98.52C17 H31 Mn N O6 S2.92432.1265413.1088[M−H−H2O]−12.734Both98.57C7 H12 O8−0.47224.0531223.0458[M−H]−123.667Negative99.70 Table 3Putatively annotated chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MSChemical speciesAnnot. ∆Mass (ppm)Calc. MWm/zReference ionRT (min)PolarityMS2 purity (%)C29 H43 O4 P−0.81486.2895485.2822[M−H]−10.661Negative100C32 H64 N8 O4 P2−0.25686.4524685.4451[M−H]−10.982Negative100C37 H67 O10 P0.13702.4473701.44[M−H]−10.99Negative100C24 H23 N O16−0.08581.1016580.0944[M−H]−11.046Negative100C23 H30 Mn N2 O8 P20.07579.0858578.0786[M−H]−11.05Negative100C21 H22 N6 O4 P2 S−0.5516.0896517.0969[M+H]+11.054Positive100C23 H32 Mn N2 O7 P2−0.33565.1063564.0991[M−H]−11.093Negative100C15 H19 N4 O9 P1.54430.0896429.0824[M−H]−11.225Both100C28 H24 O5 P20.82502.1103503.1176[M+H]+11.475Positive100C18 H21 N4 O12 P0.56516.0897517.0969[M+H]+11.58Positive100C17 H14 N8 O12 S0.13554.0453555.0526[M+H]+11.581Positive100C21 H16 O9−1.09412.079471.0928[M−H+HAc]−11.603Negative100C19 H23 N4 O13 P0.29546.1001547.1074[M+H]+11.608Positive100C24 H20 Mn N2 O6−0.21487.0701486.0628[M−H]−11.76Negative100C15 H35 Mn N7 P2 S−0.8462.1527463.1599[M+H]+11.778Positive100C19 H41 Mn N6 O15 P S0.08711.1469710.1397[M−H]−11.806Negative100C29 H44 Mn N2 O8 P2 S0.12697.1675696.1602[M−H]−11.84Negative100C13 H12 N4 O5−4.94304.0793303.072[M−H]−110.802Negative100C12 H23 N O14−0.74405.1116404.1043[M−H]−113.221Negative100C14 H14 N6 O3 S2−2.77378.0558379.0631[M+H]+113.298Positive100C21 H35 N O6 P22.38459.1951458.1878[M−H]−113.52Negative100C7 H19 N7 O9−2.63345.1235344.1162[M−H]−114.408Negative100C16 H25 N5 O9−3.94431.1635430.1563[M−H]−115.404Negative100C8 H20 Mn N4 O7 S2.31371.0442372.0515[M+H]+116.747Positive100C9 H19 N O80.12269.1111268.1038[M−H]−116.866Negative100C6 H19 N5 O3 S22.94273.0937272.0865[M−H]−118.885Negative100C9 H23 N4 O3 P S2−2.76330.094329.0867[M−H]−118.931Negative100C17 H32 N2 O14−0.45488.1851487.1779[M−H]−119.021Negative100C17 H30 N2 O14−0.28486.1696485.1623[M−H]−119.388Negative100C12 H17 Mn N7 O2 S3.55378.0558379.0631[M+H]+119.404Positive100C20 H28 N6 O8−1.22480.1963481.2036[M+H]+119.628Positive100C18 H29 N3 O101.76447.1861448.1934[M+H]+120.927Positive100C19 H27 N O5 P2 S2.04443.1094442.1023[M−H]−121.369Both100C3 H N2 O3 P S0.25175.9446174.9373[M−H]−123.451Negative100C4 H3 N2 O5 P S2−0.71253.9219252.9146[M−H]−123.582Negative100C20 H33 N O17−0.63559.1745558.1674[M−H]−126.628Both100C12 H21 N O11−0.54355.1113354.104[M−H]−128.788Both100C27 H38 Mn N2 O5 P2−0.35587.1634588.1707[M+H]+13.729Positive100C26 H39 Mn N O6 P2−0.31578.1631579.1704[M+H]+14.168Positive100C10 H11 N8 O2 P−1.96306.0737635.1365[2M+Na]+14.417Positive100C20 H23 N O3 P22.66387.1164386.1091[M−H]−14.889Negative100C14 H14 N6 O3 S2−2.77378.0558379.0631[M+H]+16.03Positive100C11 H23 N O13−0.6377.1167376.1094[M−H]−19.783Negative100C11 H20 O6−0.16248.126307.1397[M−H+HAc]−12.717Negative91.93C15 H11 Mg N3 O52.46337.0557338.063[M+H]+11.232Positive92.61C3 H8 Mn O6−1.63194.9698195.9771[M+H]+116.888Positive92.70C10 H5 N5 O50.01275.0291293.0629[M+NH4] 16.582Positive93.21C11 H25 Mn N O3 S3.65306.0947307.102[M+H]+12.692Positive93.27C4 H8 N8 O21.01200.0772199.07[M−H]−116.639Negative94.58C10 H20 N8 O6 S2−1.01412.0943413.1015[M+H]+12.082Both94.62C10 H24 Mg N8 O3 P2−3.48390.1283391.1356[M+H]+12.442Positive94.68C6 H11 Mn N O7−1.3263.9913264.9985[M+H]+17.452Positive94.79C18 H29 N4 O5 P S20.64476.132475.1247[M−H]−11.046Negative96.58C22 H46 N7 O5 P4.73519.3323520.3395[M+H]+14.268Positive96.88C13 H16 N4 O8−3.94356.0954355.0881[M−H]−123.818Negative97.12C7 H3 N9−0.03213.0511214.0584[M+H]+121.405Positive97.33C5 H10 N8 O30.52230.0877229.0804[M−H]−116.976Negative97.43C4 H3 N2 O5 P S2−0.17253.9221252.9148[M−H]−123.068Negative97.47C16 H13 N6 O4 P−3.81384.0721383.0649[M−H]−13.84Negative97.48C11 H22 O10−0.64314.1211349.0905[M+Cl]−19.803Both97.64C16 H26 O3 S−0.42298.1601297.1529[M−H]−10.657Negative97.65C7 H12 O7−0.66208.0582207.0509[M−H]−16.099Negative97.92C22 H44 N7 O5 P4.09517.3163518.3236[M+H]+14.372Positive97.93C6 H18 N5 O6 P2.57287.1002288.1075[M+H]+12.662Positive98.52C17 H31 Mn N O6 S2.92432.1265413.1088[M−H−H2O]−12.734Both98.57C7 H12 O8−0.47224.0531223.0458[M−H]−123.667Negative99.70 Putatively annotated chemical species identified in transgenic soybean calluses cultured at 100 µg L−1 of CuNPs using online integrated HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS Notably, different metals exhibit distinct coordination preferences depending on ligand structure and chemical environment [17]. For example, the putative detection of a Mn-histidine complex suggests that CuNP-induced disruption of metal homeostasis may promote intracellular redistribution of manganese, potentially enabling its association with small biomolecules and the formation of organometallic-like complexes. Although these assignments remain putative, they provide valuable insights into possible elemental redistribution mechanisms triggered by nanoparticle exposure. In general, the annotation of metal- and heteroatom-containing species was based on multiple complementary criteria, including accurate mass determination (< 5 ppm mass error), isotopic pattern matching, and MS/MS fragmentation analysis, combined with chromatographic co-elution between the elemental signal detected by ICP-MS/MS and the corresponding molecular ion detected by HRMS. Specifically, retention time agreement between the elemental/heteroatom trace and the associated molecular feature was verified for representative compounds, strengthening confidence in the proposed assignments [14, 17]. Figure 6 illustrates a representative example of this workflow for the identification of the phosphorus-containing metabolite uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose (C15H24N2O17P2). Confirmation was based on accurate mass agreement (−0.03 ppm), isotopic distribution, and MS/MS fragmentation, including the precursor ion and characteristic product ions shown in Fig. 7, which support the proposed structural assignment. Additional representative examples of species containing Mg, Mn, S, and Zn are provided in Figs. S1–S4 in the Supplementary Material, demonstrating the applicability of this analytical strategy across different elemental classes.Fig. 6Example of the identification of the known P-containing metabolite uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose (C₁₅H₂₄N₂O₁₇P₂) in transgenic soybean calluses using HILIC-MS-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MSFig. 7Fragmentation spectra for MS2 fragmentation, which shows the characteristics product ions used for structural confirmation of uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose (C₁₅H₂₄N₂O₁₇P₂) Example of the identification of the known P-containing metabolite uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose (C₁₅H₂₄N₂O₁₇P₂) in transgenic soybean calluses using HILIC-MS-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS Fragmentation spectra for MS2 fragmentation, which shows the characteristics product ions used for structural confirmation of uridine 5′-diphosphogalactose (C₁₅H₂₄N₂O₁₇P₂) Overall, these results reinforce the reliability of the integrated analytical workflow and demonstrate how online HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS can be used to annotate metal- and heteroatom-containing biomolecules in complex plant matrices. Beyond structural characterization, this approach provides important mechanistic insights into how elemental species participate in the cellular adjustments triggered by nanoparticle-induced stress. Conclusions In this study, the integrated online HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS platform proved to be a robust and highly informative analytical strategy for the simultaneous molecular and elemental characterization of transgenic soybean calluses exposed to increasing concentrations of copper nanoparticles (CuNPs). The online coupling enabled the chromatographic co-detection of organic compounds together with metal- and heteroatom-containing species, providing complementary metabolomic and speciation information within a single analytical workflow. Exposure to increasing CuNP concentrations resulted in a broader and more diverse chemical profile, particularly at the highest dose, where metabolites associated with cellular defense, oxidative stress, and membrane remodeling were markedly enriched. This concentration-dependent response highlights the capability of the integrated platform to capture stress-induced metabolic reprogramming that would be difficult to resolve using conventional single-detector approaches. Importantly, the speciomics framework enabled by HILIC-ESI-HRMS-ICP-MS/MS allowed the putative annotation of metal-associated metabolites and heteroatom-containing complexes, revealing evidence of elemental redistribution involving essential elements and suggesting coordination-driven homeostatic adjustments at the cellular level. From a biological perspective, the observed metabolic alterations indicate that CuNP exposure induces oxidative stress and triggers coordinated adaptive responses, including membrane remodeling, activation of antioxidant defense pathways, and reprogramming of amino acid and nitrogen metabolism. The accumulation of lipid-derived metabolites and oxylipins suggests enhanced lipid peroxidation and stress signaling, while the increased abundance of phenolic and related compounds reflects activation of protective biochemical mechanisms aimed at preserving cellular redox homeostasis. Overall, this study advances the understanding of nanoparticle-plant interactions by demonstrating how CuNP exposure modulates both the molecular composition and elemental organization of soybean calluses. Beyond its biological relevance, this work highlights the analytical potential of integrated molecular and elemental coupling as a powerful platform for investigating complex biological systems and provides a valuable framework for future studies on nanoparticle-induced biochemical responses in the context of precision agriculture. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.Supplementary file1 (DOCX 1.58 MB) Supplementary file1 (DOCX 1.58 MB)