Facilitators of, barriers to and strategies for health-system guidance implementation: a critical interpretive synthesis Authors: Qi Wang, Junjie Ren, Xinyu Huang, Kehu Yang, Yaolong Chen, Michael G Wilson, Holger J Schünemann, John N Lavis Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractThis study aims to develop a theoretical framework to support the implementation of health-system guidance, contributing to broader efforts to promote evidence-informed policymaking in health systems. A critical interpretive synthesis was conducted to identify relevant literature from 11 databases and gray literature sources. The documents were assessed for relevance and quality, and data were extracted and synthesized using an interpretive analytic method. Based on the synthesized data, the framework was developed and subsequently refined by the authors. A total of 21 documents published from 2004 to 2024 were included, with 15 (71%) empirical studies and six (29%) non-empirical. The resulting theoretical framework for supporting health-system guidance implementation identified 10 facilitators, 10 barriers, nine combined facilitators and barriers, and 11 strategies across six levels: political system, health system, community, organizational, providers and patients/public. This framework offers a structured approach to comprehensively understanding the various factors and levels involved in health-system guidance implementation. With further development into a practical tool, it may help inform implementation efforts across diverse topics and contexts.Subject terms: Health care, Mathematics and computing Introduction Health systems are defined as “the governance, financial and delivery arrangements for health care and public health services, implementation considerations for reforming or strengthening these arrangements, and broader economic, legal, political and social contexts in which these arrangements are negotiated and operate”1. Over the past decades, substantial improvements in global health have been achieved, including increased life expectancy and reduced neonatal mortality2. Persistent disparities in health outcomes, access, and quality of care underscore the need to further optimize health-system arrangements to achieve the healthcare quadruple aim—enhancing patient experience, improving population health, reducing per capita healthcare costs, and enhancing provider well-being3. Addressing these challenges requires strong stewardship from policymakers, supported by collaboration with health providers, researchers, and other relevant actors, to ensure the delivery of safe, effective, and cost-effective health interventions. Yet, weaknesses within existing arrangements continue to limit their reach and impacts4,5, underlining the need for robust health system strengthening. Health-system guidance (HSG) serves as a crucial tool in this context, by providing systematically developed statements, generally produced at global levels, to offer options and supporting evidence that assists with decision-making in addressing health system challenges. It facilitates the implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of these options, primarily supporting policy development and reform at national or sub-national levels and within international organizations, thereby contributing to the strengthening of health systems6–8. For example, World Health Organization (WHO) produces HSG for use by its Member States and staff, as it has done on topics such as supporting the optimization of community health worker roles in 20189. Bosch-Capblanch et al. highlight key conceptual, methodological, and practical challenges in HSG, arising from the complexity of health systems, the diversity of evidence, and the context-sensitive and multifactorial nature of policymaking process6–8,10,11. To address these challenges, WHO commissioned an expert panel to produce a handbook for HSG development10, and other scholars have developed approaches and tools to support quality in development, appraisal and contextualization12,13. The implementation context for HSG is inherently more complex and multi-level, yet most existing frameworks focus primarily on clinical practice guidelines14–20. Policymakers and other actors involved in the implementation of global HSG at national and sub-national levels therefore require a comprehensive and well-organized theoretical framework to support this process. We aim to develop a theoretical framework that identifies facilitators of, barriers to and strategies for HSG implementation across various levels, guided by two compass questions: (1) What factors – at system, community, organizational and individual levels – facilitate or hinder HSG implementation processes and outcomes? (2) What strategies at these levels can leverage facilitators of and address barriers to HSG implementation processes and outcomes? Results Search results and article selection Our search across nine electronic databases yielded 159,983 records, with 90,597 remaining after duplicates were removed. After screening titles and abstracts, 325 records were selected for full-text review. A random sample of 50 records (approximately 15%) was reviewed by four pairs of independent reviewers, with an average Kappa value of 0.77 (Range: 0.49–1.00), indicating substantial agreement. Following the full-text screening, 314 records were excluded, leaving 11 documents from the database search. An additional ten documents were included from supplementary sources (including gray literature, websites, citation screening, and research team identification), yielding a total of 21 documents for analysis (Fig. 1). PRISMA flow diagram of the inclusion and exclusion process. The diagram shows the identification, screening, eligibility, and inclusion of records from databases and other sources. General observations The 21 included documents7,10,13,16,17,21–36 published between 2004 and 2024 (Table 1), consisted of 15 empirical studies (71%) (e.g., case studies, interviews) and six non-empirical studies (29%) such as methodology handbooks and theory papers. Nine studies focused on low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), two on high-income countries (HICs), one on both LMICs and HICs, and nine did not specify a region. Detailed characteristics are provided in Supplementary Table 1, and no document was deemed fatally flawed (Supplementary Table 2). Table 1Characteristics of included documents (N = 21) (listed alphabetically by authors’ last name)Author and publication year [Reference]Study designStudy aimCountry/region of focusAllegranzi 201323Empirical, before-after studyTo assess the effect of implementation of WHO’s hand-hygiene strategyLMIC and HIC: Costa Rica, Italy, Mali, Pakistan, and Saudi ArabiaAlvarez 201613Empirical, case studies and critical interpretive synthesisTo investigate the development and use of the workbook for contextualizing health systems guidanceLMIC: Peru and UgandaAmoakoh-Coleman 201624Empirical, cross-sectional studyTo explore the impact of public health facility resource on provider adherence to antenatal guidelinesLMIC: GhanaBaker 201525Empirical, systematic reviewTo assess the effectiveness of tailored intervention strategies in improving professional practice and healthcare patient outcomesNo country/region focusBitta 202026Empirical, mixed-methods studyTo describe the contextualization and pilot testing of the guide in Kilifi, KenyaLMIC: KenyaBorggreve 201527Empirical, interviewsTo identify the barriers of policy guideline implementation among Dutch hospital professionalsHIC: NetherlandsBosch-Capblanch 201110Non-empirical, gray literature (methodology handbook)To describe the processes and approaches for developing health system guidance, including guidance dissemination and implementationNo country/region focusBreneol 202222Empirical, scoping reviewTo assess evidence related to the adaptation and implementation of health system guidelines in low- and middle-income countriesLMIC: generalEvans 201228Empirical, interviewsTo identify barriers and facilitators to implementation of recommendationsHIC: United StatesFretheim 200929Non-empirical, theory/discussion paperTo describe considerations and approaches of policy implementationNo country/region focusGrimshaw 200416Empirical, systematic reviewTo review the effectiveness and costs of different guideline dissemination and implementation strategiesNo country/region focusKiplagat 201430Empirical, mixed-methods studyTo identify factors influencing the implementation of integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) in the health facilitiesLMIC: TanzaniaLavis 20127Non-empirical, theory/discussion paperTo explore the links between health systems guidance development and policy development at global and national levelsNo country/region focusMoberg 201817Empirical, mixed-methods studyTo describe a framework for making and using evidence-informed health system and public health recommendations and decisionsNo country/region focusMoore 201631Empirical, focus groups and interviewsTo evaluate progress, barriers, facilitators, and proposed solutions of implementing a WHO postpartum haemorrhage guidelineLMIC: KosovoOkot-Chono 200932Empirical, focus groups and interviewsTo assess barriers to implementation of TB-HIV collaborative servicesLMIC: UgandaOmotayo 201821Empirical, trials of improved practicesTo explore factors that influence adoption and acceptability of calcium supplementation recommendationsLMIC: KenyaVogel 201633Empirical, mixed-methods studyTo identify barriers and facilitators to implementation of WHO maternal health recommendationsLMIC: Myanmar, Uganda, Tanzania and EthiopiaWHO 201434Non-empirical, gray literature (methodology handbook)To provide the technical and procedural guidance of WHO guideline developmentNo country/region focusWHO 202336Non-empirical, gray literature (methodology handbook)To support the practical process of guideline adaptation and the technical content used in capacity-building workshops for Member StatesNo country/region focusWHO 202435Non-empirical, grey literature (methodology handbook)To provide the key steps and methods that should be followed for the adaptation of a guideline developed in one country (or at the multinational level) to the specific context of another countryNo country/region focus Characteristics of included documents (N = 21) (listed alphabetically by authors’ last name) Six levels of the framework Our analysis resulted in a conceptual framework (Fig. 2) that identifies HSG implementation barriers, facilitators and strategies across six levels: political system, health system, community, organization, providers, and patients/public. For each level, the framework identifies relevant barriers and facilitators (or concerns/realities, capabilities/opportunities/motivations) and suggests actionable strategies. The detailed findings are presented in Tables 2–7, and interpretation and examples of HSG implementation at each level are discussed below. Framework about barriers, facilitators and strategies for supporting the health-system guidance implementation. The figure presents barriers, facilitators, and strategies related to health-system guidance (HSG) implementation across six levels: political system, health system, community, organization, providers, and patients/public. The central component represents HSG implementation. Green-shaded elements (+) indicate facilitators, red-shaded elements (−) indicate barriers, yellow-shaded elements (±) indicate neutral factors, and blue-shaded elements (✓) indicate strategies. An asterisk (*) denotes findings applicable across health system, public health, and clinical practice guidelines, rather than those specific to HSG. Table 2Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the political-system levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(+) Political support or commitment related to HSG+ Political commitment to HSG through supportive legislation, policies and capacity-building initiatives+ Leadership from designated organizations or champions to guide and sustain implementation+ Commitment to evidence-informed policymaking aligned with government priorities+ Alignment of HSG with widely recognized national or international policy agendasExample 1: Active support from senior policy leaders for workforce training initiatives strengthens implementation capacity.Example 2: Linking HSG recommendations to ongoing health reforms or new legislation facilitates policy uptake and implementation.(+) Stakeholder support and buy-in for HSG*+ Stakeholder advocacy for policy change, participation in government-led implementation activities, and collaboration across health-system levels+ Involvement of key stakeholders in HSG development to enhance implementability, dissemination, and uptake+ Engagement with media to increase visibility of HSG recommendations and inform public understandingExample 1: A committee comprising government and professional representatives develops recommendations that may inform or support subsequent legislative or policy actions.Example 2: Consumer representatives mobilize public narratives to advocate for policy change.(+) Robust evidence infrastructures for supporting HSG implementation*+ Established systems and institutional capacities to generate, synthesize, and use evidence (e.g., systematic reviews, implementation and operational research, and evaluation) to inform HSG implementation and related policy decisions+ Integration of monitoring and evaluation within implementation plans, including process and outcome assessments, to track progress, assess implementation outcomes, and inform scale-up or policy refinement+ Use of context-specific research and data to identify implementation challenges, guide adaptation, and support continuous improvementExample 1: Systematic reviews and other synthesized research evidence are used to inform implementation strategies and justify adoption of specific HSG recommendations.Example 2: Routine data systems and periodic evaluations are used to monitor implementation progress and provide feedback to policymakers and implementers, supporting timely adjustment of strategies and resource allocation.(-) Staff turnover involving key policymakers who are supportive for HSG− Departure or replacement of policymakers who previously endorsed or championed HSG implementation− Resulting shifts in leadership priorities, reduced institutional memory, or weakened commitment that may disrupt implementation continuityExample 1: A newly appointed administration revises national health priorities, reducing explicit policy support for previously endorsed HSG initiatives.Example 2: Implementation plans developed under earlier leadership require re-approval or renegotiation after leadership changes, delaying progress.(-) Interest groups that mobilize when faced with the potential for concentrated costs (and benefits)*− Organized interest groups may actively influence or resist HSG implementation when specific recommendations create concentrated costs or benefits for particular actors− Divergent interests and competing priorities among stakeholders across system levels may shape agenda-setting, decision-making, and implementation processesExample 1: Industry groups likely to incur financial losses from a recommended policy option mobilize quickly to lobby against its implementation.Example 2: Stakeholder groups whose interests align with specific policy priorities advocate for particular HSG topics or recommendations to be prioritized within the policy agenda.(±) Stable (or unstable) political environment+ Stable governance structures and predictable policy environments that enable continuity of implementation+ Clear concentration or delegation of decision-making authority within defined levels of government, facilitating timely policy and implementation decisions− Political instability, shifting power structures, or unclear authority that disrupt policy continuity− Complex administrative procedures and bureaucratic systems (e.g., rigid civil service rules)− Weak governance or accountability mechanisms that undermine coordinated implementation and oversightExample 1 (+): When health responsibilities are clearly delegated to sub-national governments, provincial health authorities can make timely decisions to support HSG implementation.Example 2 (-): Weak coordination between national and sub-national governments delays approval and rollout of HSG-related initiatives.Example 3 (-): Highly centralized planning and administrative procedures prolong approval processes and hinder timely implementation.(✓) Obtain policymaker buy-in and push for policy changes to support HSG implementation*✓ Secure and sustain leadership support and embed evidence-informed policymaking within routine decision-making processes✓ Prioritize HSG recommendations for implementation based on local needs and policy relevance✓ Engage key policy actors in planning and implementing system or policy changesExample 1: Following a change in leadership, the implementation team prepares concise policy briefs and holds targeted briefings to secure endorsement for continuing HSG-related initiatives.Example 2: A formal policy launch convenes senior health officials and system leaders to endorse implementation plans and assign responsibilities across institutions.(✓) Develop policy briefs based on HSG for evidence-informed policymaking✓ Develop national policy briefs incorporating local research evidence to contextualize health-system problems, present context-appropriate policy options, and outline implementation considerations for evidence-informed policymaking and HSG uptakeExample 1: A government-supported Evidence-Informed Policy Network (EVIPNet) adapts global HSG into a country-specific policy brief and convenes a policy dialogue, with outputs used to inform national policy decisions. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the political-system level + Political commitment to HSG through supportive legislation, policies and capacity-building initiatives + Leadership from designated organizations or champions to guide and sustain implementation + Commitment to evidence-informed policymaking aligned with government priorities + Alignment of HSG with widely recognized national or international policy agendas Example 1: Active support from senior policy leaders for workforce training initiatives strengthens implementation capacity. Example 2: Linking HSG recommendations to ongoing health reforms or new legislation facilitates policy uptake and implementation. + Stakeholder advocacy for policy change, participation in government-led implementation activities, and collaboration across health-system levels + Involvement of key stakeholders in HSG development to enhance implementability, dissemination, and uptake + Engagement with media to increase visibility of HSG recommendations and inform public understanding Example 1: A committee comprising government and professional representatives develops recommendations that may inform or support subsequent legislative or policy actions. Example 2: Consumer representatives mobilize public narratives to advocate for policy change. + Established systems and institutional capacities to generate, synthesize, and use evidence (e.g., systematic reviews, implementation and operational research, and evaluation) to inform HSG implementation and related policy decisions + Integration of monitoring and evaluation within implementation plans, including process and outcome assessments, to track progress, assess implementation outcomes, and inform scale-up or policy refinement + Use of context-specific research and data to identify implementation challenges, guide adaptation, and support continuous improvement Example 1: Systematic reviews and other synthesized research evidence are used to inform implementation strategies and justify adoption of specific HSG recommendations. Example 2: Routine data systems and periodic evaluations are used to monitor implementation progress and provide feedback to policymakers and implementers, supporting timely adjustment of strategies and resource allocation. − Departure or replacement of policymakers who previously endorsed or championed HSG implementation − Resulting shifts in leadership priorities, reduced institutional memory, or weakened commitment that may disrupt implementation continuity Example 1: A newly appointed administration revises national health priorities, reducing explicit policy support for previously endorsed HSG initiatives. Example 2: Implementation plans developed under earlier leadership require re-approval or renegotiation after leadership changes, delaying progress. − Organized interest groups may actively influence or resist HSG implementation when specific recommendations create concentrated costs or benefits for particular actors − Divergent interests and competing priorities among stakeholders across system levels may shape agenda-setting, decision-making, and implementation processes Example 1: Industry groups likely to incur financial losses from a recommended policy option mobilize quickly to lobby against its implementation. Example 2: Stakeholder groups whose interests align with specific policy priorities advocate for particular HSG topics or recommendations to be prioritized within the policy agenda. + Stable governance structures and predictable policy environments that enable continuity of implementation + Clear concentration or delegation of decision-making authority within defined levels of government, facilitating timely policy and implementation decisions − Political instability, shifting power structures, or unclear authority that disrupt policy continuity − Complex administrative procedures and bureaucratic systems (e.g., rigid civil service rules) − Weak governance or accountability mechanisms that undermine coordinated implementation and oversight Example 1 (+): When health responsibilities are clearly delegated to sub-national governments, provincial health authorities can make timely decisions to support HSG implementation. Example 2 (-): Weak coordination between national and sub-national governments delays approval and rollout of HSG-related initiatives. Example 3 (-): Highly centralized planning and administrative procedures prolong approval processes and hinder timely implementation. ✓ Secure and sustain leadership support and embed evidence-informed policymaking within routine decision-making processes ✓ Prioritize HSG recommendations for implementation based on local needs and policy relevance ✓ Engage key policy actors in planning and implementing system or policy changes Example 1: Following a change in leadership, the implementation team prepares concise policy briefs and holds targeted briefings to secure endorsement for continuing HSG-related initiatives. Example 2: A formal policy launch convenes senior health officials and system leaders to endorse implementation plans and assign responsibilities across institutions. Table 7Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the patient/public levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(+) Family support*+ Emotional and practical support from family members that help patients follow HSG recommendations (e.g., attending appointments, taking medication, or maintaining recommended behaviors)Example 1: Family members accompany patients to appointments or remind them to follow recommended treatment or lifestyle changes.(+) Perceived or experienced benefits of HSG*+ Anticipated or experienced improvements in health status, functional capacity, or quality of life that increase the perceived value and relevance of recommended interventions for patientExample 1: Patients who perceive that recommended treatment or lifestyle modifications lead to better symptom control or daily functioning become more willing to sustain long-term engagement with care.(+) Incentives for adhering to HSG*+ Provision of patient-level incentives to encourage uptake of HSG-recommended interventions and adherence to recommended care, primarily through financial incentives (e.g., cash transfers, vouchers, or subsidies), with non-financial incentives (e.g., free medications, screening services, or reminder systems) used where appropriate to support adherence and service utilization.Example 1: Conditional cash transfer (CCT) programs that link financial incentives to the use of recommended preventive services have been shown to increase service uptake among women and children.(-) Socioeconomic disadvantages*− Financial hardship, competing livelihood demands, and limited resources constrain patients’ ability to seek, access, and adhere to HSG-recommended servicesExample 1: In Tanzania, women who faced financial constraints accessing services experienced poor continuity of antenatal and postnatal care.(±) Patients’ knowledge about HSG*± Patients’ baseline knowledge and understanding of HSG recommendations, including their purpose, benefits, and potential risks, influence willingness and ability to adhere to recommended interventions− Insufficient or inaccurate knowledge of recommendations (e.g., expected benefits or possible side effects) may reduce adherence or lead to inappropriate useExample 1 (+): Greater patient awareness of the potential benefits and harms of recommended interventions can facilitate informed adherence.Example 2 (-): Lack of understanding of potential side effects or expected outcomes may result in non-adherence to recommended treatments.(✓) Provide education and support activities*✓ Implement structured education and support interventions to improve patients’ understanding of HSG recommendations and to address knowledge gaps that hinder adherenceExample 1: Providing structured counseling, educational materials, or follow-up support can help patients better understand the risks and benefits of recommended interventions and improve adherence. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the patient/public level ± Patients’ baseline knowledge and understanding of HSG recommendations, including their purpose, benefits, and potential risks, influence willingness and ability to adhere to recommended interventions − Insufficient or inaccurate knowledge of recommendations (e.g., expected benefits or possible side effects) may reduce adherence or lead to inappropriate use Example 1 (+): Greater patient awareness of the potential benefits and harms of recommended interventions can facilitate informed adherence. Example 2 (-): Lack of understanding of potential side effects or expected outcomes may result in non-adherence to recommended treatments. Facilitators, barriers and strategies at the political-system level At the political-system level (Table 2), political stability and a predictable governance environment7,13,22,26 are important for successful HSG implementation. Additional facilitators include sustained political commitment13,17,22,28,30,33–35, support and buy-in from key actors7,13,17,22,33,34, and robust evidence infrastructures to support HSG implementation7,13,28,33,34. These infrastructures include established evidence-support systems that institutionalize the use of research evidence and implementation feedback in policy and decision-making processes. In several settings, systematic reviews and other synthesized evidence have been used alongside routine monitoring data to guide adjustments to HSG implementation over time. However, several political and institutional challenges may hinder implementation. Political instability22,29,31, staff turnover among supportive policymakers7,13,28,31,33, and pressure from competitive interest groups7,13,28 may disrupt policy continuity and weaken support for HSG implementation. For example, leadership transitions or shifting policy priorities following elections may delay or deprioritize ongoing initiatives. Addressing these barriers requires strategic political engagement, including securing policymaker buy-in and advocating for supportive policy changes10,13,22,23,33, and developing HSG-informed policy briefs to support evidence-informed decision-making and facilitate uptake7,17,31,33. Facilitators, barriers and strategies at the health-system level At the health-system level (Table 3), strong networks and multisectoral collaboration10,22,26,28,33 facilitate HSG implementation by enabling coordinated planning, clearly defined roles, and shared accountability across sectors, while adequate resources—including sustained financing, workforce capacity, infrastructure, and functional monitoring systems—support implementation feasibility and continuity7,10,13,16,22,23,28,30,31,33,34,36. For example, the establishment of cross-sector partnerships has been used to coordinate implementation activities and strengthen system-wide collaboration, and integrated monitoring systems can support performance tracking and continuous improvement. In contrast, financial constraints and resource limitations7,13,22,24,26–30,32,33, together with the need for substantial adjustments to existing health-system structures and processes7, may disrupt service delivery and hinder implementation. Strategies such as establishing robust HSG implementation networks10,22,31, ensuring sufficient and well-planned resource allocation10,22,31, and engaging diverse health-system actors throughout implementation7,13,17,22,23,26,31,33–36 have been reported to strengthen coordination, enhance implementation capacity, and improve the acceptability and sustainability of HSG implementation. Table 3Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the health-system levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(+) Strong networks and multisectoral collaboration+ Coordinated collaboration across relevant sectors and organizations to support HSG implementation, characterized by proactive leadership, clearly defined roles and responsibilities, accountability mechanisms, and implementation preparedness+ Engagement of government agencies, advocacy groups, and community coalitions supports comprehensive planning and delivery, while media involvement enhances public awareness and acceptance of recommendationsExample 1: New coordination structures or systems are established to support local adaptation and implementation of HSG recommendations.Example 2: A longstanding partnership between a county government and a research institute, with clearly defined roles and responsibilities, strengthens coordination and supports implementation.(-) Require significant adjustments to the health systems− Implementation of new interventions may require substantial modifications to existing health system structures, processes, or resources. When these adjustments are extensive or unanticipated, they can disrupt current service arrangements, create additional workload, or necessitate complementary system changes to enable effective implementationExample 1: A new pay-for-performance financing model may function effectively in settings with established performance monitoring systems, but in contexts where such data are not routinely collected, substantial system adjustments or additional support interventions are required before implementation can proceed.(±) Adequate (or inadequate) resources, including financial budgets (constraints), workforce, facilities, equipment, and ICT-based monitoring and evaluation system*− Adequate and sustained financial resources, including appropriate incentives and flexible funding arrangements, enable planning, coordination, and sustained delivery of HSG implementation activities+ Well-developed information and communication technology (ICT)–based monitoring and evaluation systems, particularly when integrated with electronic health record systems, support systematic data collection and analysis, performance monitoring, and timely feedback, enabling tracking of implementation progress− Workforce shortages, weak recruitment and retention mechanisms, inadequate skill mix, and excessive workload constrain implementation capacity− Limited availability of facilities, equipment, medicines, and medical supplies, together with inefficient procurement, distribution, and supply management systems, restrict service delivery and disrupt integration of recommended interventionsExample 1 (+): Dedicated grant funding is introduced to support implementation rollout, workforce training, and evaluation of HSG-related initiatives.Example 2 (+): Well-functioning monitoring systems, supported by mobile and digital technologies, are used to track implementation performance and inform ongoing improvement.Example 3 (-): Overloaded clinics, shortages of trained staff and testing kits, and limited consultation space reduce the capacity to deliver HSG-recommended services.Example 4 (-): Local plans fail to prioritize funding for implementation activities, resulting in insufficient resources for training, supervision, and follow-up.(✓) Establish an HSG implementation network✓ Establish and strengthen multilateral implementation networks by forming coalitions, advisory groups, or task teams and fostering partnerships across relevant organizations and sectors✓ Clarify roles, coordination mechanisms, and accountability arrangements within these networks to support joint planning, decision-making, and sustained implementationExample 1: Dedicated task teams and inter-organizational partnerships are formed to coordinate and oversee HSG implementation.Example 2: Public–private partnerships with not-for-profit organizations are leveraged to expand service delivery and support implementation at scale.(✓) Provide sufficient resources*✓ Secure adequate and sustained financial and material resources during strategic planning to support implementation activities, considering contextual factors such as governance structures, workforce capacity, and available infrastructure✓ Plan for deployment and efficient use of health workers, infrastructure, equipment, and supplies, including resource-sharing where appropriateExample 1: A multi-year strategic implementation plan incorporates dedicated budgeting, workforce planning, and allocation of equipment and infrastructure to support rollout.(✓) Engage diverse health-system stakeholders in HSG implementation✓ Engage diverse stakeholders throughout implementation—from planning and adaptation to evaluation—to improve relevance, feasibility, and acceptance of HSG recommendations✓ Establish ongoing mechanisms for collaboration and experience-sharing among stakeholders, including policymakers, health workers, professional bodies, community organizations, and implementation partnersExample 1: A multidisciplinary working group is established to gather feedback and guide iterative refinement during implementation.Example 2: Representatives from non-governmental organizations and professional bodies participate in ministry-led planning and coordination meetings. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the health-system level + Coordinated collaboration across relevant sectors and organizations to support HSG implementation, characterized by proactive leadership, clearly defined roles and responsibilities, accountability mechanisms, and implementation preparedness + Engagement of government agencies, advocacy groups, and community coalitions supports comprehensive planning and delivery, while media involvement enhances public awareness and acceptance of recommendations Example 1: New coordination structures or systems are established to support local adaptation and implementation of HSG recommendations. Example 2: A longstanding partnership between a county government and a research institute, with clearly defined roles and responsibilities, strengthens coordination and supports implementation. − Adequate and sustained financial resources, including appropriate incentives and flexible funding arrangements, enable planning, coordination, and sustained delivery of HSG implementation activities + Well-developed information and communication technology (ICT)–based monitoring and evaluation systems, particularly when integrated with electronic health record systems, support systematic data collection and analysis, performance monitoring, and timely feedback, enabling tracking of implementation progress − Workforce shortages, weak recruitment and retention mechanisms, inadequate skill mix, and excessive workload constrain implementation capacity − Limited availability of facilities, equipment, medicines, and medical supplies, together with inefficient procurement, distribution, and supply management systems, restrict service delivery and disrupt integration of recommended interventions Example 1 (+): Dedicated grant funding is introduced to support implementation rollout, workforce training, and evaluation of HSG-related initiatives. Example 2 (+): Well-functioning monitoring systems, supported by mobile and digital technologies, are used to track implementation performance and inform ongoing improvement. Example 3 (-): Overloaded clinics, shortages of trained staff and testing kits, and limited consultation space reduce the capacity to deliver HSG-recommended services. Example 4 (-): Local plans fail to prioritize funding for implementation activities, resulting in insufficient resources for training, supervision, and follow-up. ✓ Establish and strengthen multilateral implementation networks by forming coalitions, advisory groups, or task teams and fostering partnerships across relevant organizations and sectors ✓ Clarify roles, coordination mechanisms, and accountability arrangements within these networks to support joint planning, decision-making, and sustained implementation Example 1: Dedicated task teams and inter-organizational partnerships are formed to coordinate and oversee HSG implementation. Example 2: Public–private partnerships with not-for-profit organizations are leveraged to expand service delivery and support implementation at scale. ✓ Secure adequate and sustained financial and material resources during strategic planning to support implementation activities, considering contextual factors such as governance structures, workforce capacity, and available infrastructure ✓ Plan for deployment and efficient use of health workers, infrastructure, equipment, and supplies, including resource-sharing where appropriate ✓ Engage diverse stakeholders throughout implementation—from planning and adaptation to evaluation—to improve relevance, feasibility, and acceptance of HSG recommendations ✓ Establish ongoing mechanisms for collaboration and experience-sharing among stakeholders, including policymakers, health workers, professional bodies, community organizations, and implementation partners Example 1: A multidisciplinary working group is established to gather feedback and guide iterative refinement during implementation. Example 2: Representatives from non-governmental organizations and professional bodies participate in ministry-led planning and coordination meetings. Concerns, realities and strategies at the community level When considering the community level, three key concerns and realities may function as either facilitators or barriers to HSG implementation (Table 4): (1) prevailing social norms and values within local communities that influence acceptance of HSG recommendations and related services7,17,22,33; (2) community-level facilities and infrastructure, referring to the availability, accessibility, and functioning of local healthcare facilities, service providers, supply mechanisms, and referral or information systems required to support implementation7,13,23; (3) the nature and extent of community engagement in mobilizing support and resources for HSG implementation13,22,23,28,29,32,33. Depending on context, these factors may support implementation when aligned with local needs, or constrain implementation when insufficient or poorly coordinated. One approach to addressing these contextual dynamics is the use of phased implementation with periodic review to inform subsequent scale-up17,22,26,35,36. Table 4Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the community levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(±) Social norms and values in local communities regarding HSG-informed decisions± Acceptance and uptake of HSG recommendations may be shaped by prevailing community norms and values. Shared beliefs about benefits and harms, equity, and the relevance of recommended services may support or hinder implementation. Norms aligned with HSG objectives can facilitate uptake, whereas traditional beliefs, cultural expectations, or misconceptions may reduce adherence to recommended servicesExample 1 (+): Widely held community values supporting equity in health systems facilitate acceptance of HSG promoting equitable access.Example 2 (-): Local cultural beliefs and misconceptions may limit demand for certain recommended programs and services.(±) Community-level facilities and infrastructure*+ Availability of locally accessible production or supply mechanisms (e.g., essential medicines, equipment, or consumables) that enable timely and affordable implementation of HSG recommendations− Geographical or socioeconomic disparities in the distribution of healthcare facilities and providers limit equitable access to HSG-recommended interventions− Weak or fragmented referral pathways, communication systems, or information infrastructure that hinder coordination and continuity of care across service levelsExample 1 (+): A local manufacturer produces WHO-compliant alcohol-based hand rub to support infection prevention guidelines, improving the availability of essential supplies and reducing reliance on costly commercial products.Example 2 (-): Rural communities have limited access to primary care facilities capable of delivering guideline-recommended screening and treatment services.(±) Community engagement*+ Community dialogues and targeted advocacy can help obtain community support for HSG implementation+ Established community networks may help mobilize local resources and facilitate implementation− Limited community involvement in implementation planning and evaluation may reduce the relevance, acceptability, and sustainability of HSG-related interventionsExample 1 (+): Community participatory approaches, such as community mobilization and support groups, have been shown to improve maternal and neonatal outcomes and may facilitate implementation of community-based recommendations.Example 2 (-): Community activities were planned and implemented without meaningful community involvement, resulting in limited sustainability.(✓) Conduct pilot and multi-phased HSG implementation*✓ Implement HSG in a staged manner, beginning with pilot implementation to assess feasibility and contextual fit, followed by reflective evaluation and iterative refinement to inform scale-up✓ Develop a structured dissemination and implementation plan, including stakeholder mapping, defined implementation roles, and a monitoring and evaluation framework to guide phased expansionExample 1: At the end of an initial implementation phase, feedback workshops are conducted to synthesize early implementation experience and inform subsequent scale-up planning.Example 2: HSG recommendations are introduced progressively across settings through staged implementation, with each phase informing refinement and broader rollout. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the community level Example 1 (+): Widely held community values supporting equity in health systems facilitate acceptance of HSG promoting equitable access. Example 2 (-): Local cultural beliefs and misconceptions may limit demand for certain recommended programs and services. + Availability of locally accessible production or supply mechanisms (e.g., essential medicines, equipment, or consumables) that enable timely and affordable implementation of HSG recommendations − Geographical or socioeconomic disparities in the distribution of healthcare facilities and providers limit equitable access to HSG-recommended interventions − Weak or fragmented referral pathways, communication systems, or information infrastructure that hinder coordination and continuity of care across service levels Example 1 (+): A local manufacturer produces WHO-compliant alcohol-based hand rub to support infection prevention guidelines, improving the availability of essential supplies and reducing reliance on costly commercial products. Example 2 (-): Rural communities have limited access to primary care facilities capable of delivering guideline-recommended screening and treatment services. + Community dialogues and targeted advocacy can help obtain community support for HSG implementation + Established community networks may help mobilize local resources and facilitate implementation − Limited community involvement in implementation planning and evaluation may reduce the relevance, acceptability, and sustainability of HSG-related interventions Example 1 (+): Community participatory approaches, such as community mobilization and support groups, have been shown to improve maternal and neonatal outcomes and may facilitate implementation of community-based recommendations. Example 2 (-): Community activities were planned and implemented without meaningful community involvement, resulting in limited sustainability. ✓ Implement HSG in a staged manner, beginning with pilot implementation to assess feasibility and contextual fit, followed by reflective evaluation and iterative refinement to inform scale-up ✓ Develop a structured dissemination and implementation plan, including stakeholder mapping, defined implementation roles, and a monitoring and evaluation framework to guide phased expansion Example 1: At the end of an initial implementation phase, feedback workshops are conducted to synthesize early implementation experience and inform subsequent scale-up planning. Example 2: HSG recommendations are introduced progressively across settings through staged implementation, with each phase informing refinement and broader rollout. Facilitators, barriers and strategies at the organizational level At the organizational level (Table 5), physically and intellectually supportive environments7,10,22,24,29 and alignment of HSG recommendations with organizational culture and priorities10,22,27,28,31 facilitate implementation by enabling the integration of recommendations into routine workflows and institutional decision-making. However, limited organizational capacities—such as weak leadership engagement, resistant cultures, and insufficient resources7,24,27,29,32,33—together with limited inter-organizational collaboration across facilities or service levels24,33, can constrain coordinated and sustained implementation. For example, in some settings, existing staffing structures and workflows cannot accommodate additional activities required for new guidance, while weak coordination between service levels may lead to inconsistent adoption across facilities. To address these challenges, strategies such as providing structured on-site supervision and clear operational guidance22,29,33, and linking HSG implementation to ongoing organizational improvement programs with defined indicators and monitoring processes10,22,29,33, can help support and sustain implementation process. Table 5Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the organizational levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(+) Physically and intellectually supportive environments*+ Physically supportive environments provide sufficient human resources, infrastructure, equipment, and logistical capacity to facilitate the delivery of HSG-recommended activities within existing organizational workflows+ Intellectually supportive environments reflect an organizational culture and governance structure that recognize, prioritize, and actively promote the use of research evidence and HSG recommendations in decision-making and practiceExample 1: Urban hospitals with high-quality infrastructure, sufficient staffing, and reliable equipment are better able to integrate HSG-recommended services into routine clinical workflows without major operational disruption.Example 2: Institutions with appropriate management systems and governance structures, such as designated leadership and internal monitoring mechanisms, are better positioned to support HSG-related initiatives.(+) Alignment of HSG recommendations with organizational culture and priorities+ Alignment of HSG recommendations with an organization’s culture, values, and strategic priorities fosters shared responsibility among teams and facilitates their integration into institutional plans, routines, and decision-making processes, thereby strengthening organizational commitment to implementationExample 1: When HSG recommendations are endorsed by senior management and incorporated into institutional strategic plans and internal performance priorities, departments are more likely to coordinate their activities and allocate resources, facilitating consistent implementation across services.(-) Limited organizational capacities*− Weak leadership engagement, resistant organizational cultures, and insufficient physical resources can constrain an organization’s capacity to implement HSGExample 1: In some organizations, existing workflows cannot support the implementation of new HSG recommendations.(-) Limited inter-organizational collaboration*− Limited collaboration across districts, facilities, or service levels can hinder coordination, continuity, and standardization of HSG implementationExample 1: Weak coordination between primary, secondary, and tertiary facilities can result in inconsistent referral practices and uneven adoption of HSG recommendations across service levels.(✓) Provide on-site supervision and guidance for HSG implementation*✓ Provide structured on-site supervision, ongoing consultation, and clear operational protocols to support staff in implementing HSG recommendations within routine organizational practiceExample 1: A facility establishes an implementation working group that conducts regular supervisory visits and distributes simplified protocols to guide staff in applying new HSG recommendations.(✓) Link HSG implementation to organizational improvement programs✓ Integrate HSG implementation into existing organizational improvement initiatives, with defined indicators, targets, and monitoring processes to support sustained implementationExample 1: HSG recommendations are incorporated into routine quality improvement programs, with progress tracked through existing performance indicators and review meetings. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the organizational level + Physically supportive environments provide sufficient human resources, infrastructure, equipment, and logistical capacity to facilitate the delivery of HSG-recommended activities within existing organizational workflows + Intellectually supportive environments reflect an organizational culture and governance structure that recognize, prioritize, and actively promote the use of research evidence and HSG recommendations in decision-making and practice Example 1: Urban hospitals with high-quality infrastructure, sufficient staffing, and reliable equipment are better able to integrate HSG-recommended services into routine clinical workflows without major operational disruption. Example 2: Institutions with appropriate management systems and governance structures, such as designated leadership and internal monitoring mechanisms, are better positioned to support HSG-related initiatives. Capabilities, opportunities, motivations and strategies at the provider level At the provider level (Table 6), implementation of HSG is influenced by providers’ capabilities, opportunities, and motivations as conceptualized in the COM-B model. Capability may be constrained by training challenges10,22,27,30,33, limited HSG knowledge10,22,27,30,33, and persistence of established clinical routines22,29, while opportunity is affected by workload pressures22 and by HSG features perceived as unclear or weakly supported by evidence16,26,34, although support from opinion leaders can reinforce professional norms and confidence in HSG29. Motivation is shaped by providers’ perceptions and experiences of HSG implementation, including perceived benefits, recognition or incentives7,29,31,33,34 as well as their positive or negative feelings towards the relevance of recommendations in practice22,33. Corresponding strategies focus on strengthening capability and motivation through structured training to enhance knowledge, attitudes, and skills10,13,16,22,23,29–31,33,36, and on creating supportive opportunities through audit and feedback mechanisms that enable performance monitoring and quality improvement16,22,23. Table 6Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the provider levelThemesSubthemes/Detailed explanationExamples(+) Opinion leader support*+ Support from respected clinical or professional opinion leaders who provide supervision or advocacy for HSG implementationExample 1: Senior clinicians or professional association leaders actively endorse HSG and encourage frontline providers to adopt it.(-) Training challenges*− Training challenges, such as limited or poorly coordinated training, insufficient practical preparation, and lack of follow-up supervision for using HSGExample 1: Providers who receive one-off training without ongoing supervision may still lack skills to implement HSG recommendations.(-) Inertia of previous practice*− Persistence of established clinical routines and familiarity with previous practicesExample 1: Established clinical habits persist despite new HSG recommendations.(-) HSG-related negative features− Characteristics of HSG that hinder implementation, such as unclear recommendations and unconvincing evidence underpinning recommendationsExample 1: Providers may be reluctant to follow HSG when recommendations are perceived as unclear or not well supported by evidence.(-) Workload*− Excessive workload and competing clinical demands limit providers’ engagement in HSG implementationExample 1: Limited time constrains application of HSG in routine practice.(±) Providers’ knowledge about HSG and its implementation*+ Adequate knowledge of HSG recommendations and their potential benefits and harms supports implementation− Limited understanding of HSG content or how to apply recommendations in practiceExample 1 (+): Campaign and promotional activities, such as posters, banners, brochures, leaflets, and educational materials, are widely used to disseminate HSG and related information.(±) Perceived or experienced outcomes related to HSG implementation*+Incentives or professional development opportunities that reinforce engagement in HSG implementation− Lack of tangible benefits or recognition that may weaken motivation to implement HSGExample 1 (+): Financial or workload compensation for additional time required to deliver HSG-recommended services.(±) Providers’ positive or negative feelings about HSG*+ Positive attitudes towards HSG, including trust in recommendations and willingness to implement them− Negative perceptions or skepticism about HSGExample 1 (-): Providers express limited confidence in the relevance of HSG to their routine practice.(✓) Provide training to enhance knowledge, attitude and skills about HSG and its implementation*✓ Provide structured education and training to strengthen providers’ knowledge, attitudes, and practical skills for implementing HSGExample 1: Develop and disseminate HSG-focused training materials, such as self-learning resources, educational aids, and instructional videos.(✓) Provide audit and feedback on professional practice*✓ Develop and utilize a surveillance or health information system for evaluating providers’ performance and quality improvementExample 1: Establish technical working groups to monitor the HSG implementation processes, manage unexpected changes, and ensure flexibility. Thematic explanations and illustrative examples for HSG implementation at the provider level + Adequate knowledge of HSG recommendations and their potential benefits and harms supports implementation − Limited understanding of HSG content or how to apply recommendations in practice +Incentives or professional development opportunities that reinforce engagement in HSG implementation − Lack of tangible benefits or recognition that may weaken motivation to implement HSG + Positive attitudes towards HSG, including trust in recommendations and willingness to implement them − Negative perceptions or skepticism about HSG Capabilities, opportunities, motivations and strategies at the patient/public level At the patient and public level (Table 7), behavioral conditions affecting engagement with HSG relate to capability, opportunity, and motivation. Patients’ capability largely depends on their understanding of HSG recommendations and their perceived benefits and risks16,21,29,30,33. Opportunity may be constrained by socioeconomic disadvantages such as financial and time limitations7,33, while support from family members can facilitate adherence to recommended care21,33. Motivation is shaped by the perceived value of recommended interventions21,33 and by incentives that reinforce adherence7,29. To address these factors, providing structured education and supportive activities16,21,33 is identified as a key strategy to improve understanding of HSG and support informed adherence. Discussion The theoretical framework for supporting HSG implementation identified 10 facilitators, 10 barriers, nine combined facilitators and barriers, and 11 strategies across six levels, with 28 general (versus 12 specific). This framework offers a structured approach to comprehensively understanding the various factors and levels involved in HSG implementation. By examining the political system, health system, and organizational levels, as well as the community, provider, and patient perspectives, the framework provides a holistic view of the HSG implementation. Our framework, developed specifically for HSG implementation, differs from existing frameworks and tools for clinical practice guidelines14–20, although some common considerations such as resource availability and engagement of key actors are shared6,7,8,10,12,13,22. Unlike clinical practice guideline implementation, which typically operates within established health system arrangements including governance, financial and service delivery, HSG implementation often involves changes to these arrangements to support policy decisions about health systems. Such changes may range from incremental adjustments to broader system reforms and generally require longer timeframes, negotiation across multiple actors, and substantial system-wide resources. These processes may also be influenced by political considerations, particularly for high-visibility decisions or those affecting powerful groups. In this context, the framework reflects the multi-level and context-sensitive nature of HSG implementation. In the HSG field, several tools have been developed to support different phases, ranging from development and appraisal to reporting and contextualization6–8,10,12,13. Our HSG implementation framework complements these tools by synthesizing key implementation-related elements across them. While the contextualization workbook13 includes a step for identifying implementation barriers and strategies, our framework provides a more comprehensive categorization of facilitators, barriers, and strategies across six levels, from macro-level political and health system contexts to micro-level individual actors. It also reflects the complexity of HSG implementation, in which micro-level decisions are embedded within broader macro-level contexts and shaped by influences operating across multiple levels rather than a single level. Furthermore, our framework introduces a perspective on the roles of providers, patients, and the public in HSG implementation. These groups are viewed not merely as passive recipients of health-system changes resulting from HSG implementation but as integral contributors who can share insights and values to strengthen health systems7,10,17. Consistent with other implementation studies37,38, we provide examples of potentially effective strategies by aligning the facilitators and barriers categorized within the COM-B model39 with the most relevant TDF domains40. This approach broadens the range of factors and strategies that can be considered and enriches understanding of HSG implementation from an individual-level perspective. Our study has several strengths. First, the CIS approach enabled rigorous development of a theoretical framework from a diverse and complex body of literature. Second, independent reviewers, strong inter-rater agreement and team discussions supported reliable article selection and interpretation. Third, our synthesis identified facilitators, barriers, and strategies across multiple levels and provided a structured framework specifically designed to support understanding of HSG implementation. The framework also offers a basis for developing a practical tool to further support implementation efforts. However, not all identified facilitators, barriers, and strategies were specific to the complexity and context sensitivity of HSG, although 79% of included documents were directly relevant. We mitigated this by incorporating input from our interdisciplinary research team. In addition, implementation strategies were often poorly reported, with limited detail on their key components and outcomes. We addressed this by summarizing them using key dimensions (actors, actions, and targets) to improve clarity. This framework provides a structured synthesis of factors and strategies influencing HSG implementation across multiple levels and may serve as an analytical resource for those involved in planning or supporting implementation. By highlighting context-specific influences and potential strategies, it may help implementation teams and decision-makers consider relevant actions within their own settings. It may also inform guideline developers during HSG development by encouraging explicit consideration of implementation influences when formulating recommendations. While not all strategies can be adopted immediately, the framework may therefore serve as a reference to consider implementation influences and potential strategies across contexts. Building on this work, we plan to develop a practical tool to facilitate application of the framework in real-world settings. Future research could apply and refine the framework across different HSG topics and contexts to examine how implementation influences and strategies vary in practice. Methods We used a critical interpretive synthesis (CIS) approach to develop a theoretical framework, which involves an inductive, interpretive, and iterative process to develop concepts and theories from diverse and complex literature, focusing on conceptual insights rather than data aggregation41–43. Since its introduction by Dixon-Woods et al. for healthcare access for vulnerable populations42, CIS has been widely used to generate or refine theories and frameworks12,44,45, including Ako-Arrey et al.’s identification of 30 key concepts related to HSG appraisal12. CIS is particularly appropriate for our study because it synthesizes diverse, complex literature, which suits the heterogeneous nature of HSG research10,12,13. Following our published protocol46, the CIS was conducted and reported using the PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR) [Supplementary Table 3]47. The study was registered with PROSPERO (registration number: CRD42020214072). Identifying relevant articles We conducted a phased literature search guided by the two compass questions, using a strategy developed with librarians. Search terms included “health system,” “guidance,” and “implementation” and their synonyms (Supplementary Table 4) were applied across 11 databases (e.g., CNKI, PubMed, Web of Science) and relevant grey literature sources (Supplementary Table 5). Additional papers were identified through reference screening and targeted identification by senior members of the research team to address conceptual gaps45. To ensure coverage of recent and conceptually relevant literature, an updated targeted search was conducted by the first author, screening 100 results each from Google Scholar and Google using combinations of the terms “implementation,” “guideline,” and “health system” up to December 2024. Selecting eligible articles All reviewers participated in online training to ensure consensus on inclusion criteria. A total of 24 reviewers independently screened titles and abstracts using Covidence, with each record assessed by two reviewers and disagreements resolved by the lead author (QW). Full-text screening was conducted by QW and three graduate students, with each record independently assessed by two reviewers using Kappa statistics48 to assess agreement and refine eligibility criteria. We included both empirical and non-empirical studies addressing implementation facilitators, barriers, and strategies for HSG recommendations, specifically related to health-system arrangements49 at any level. Studies on clinical practice guidelines or health interventions were excluded. There were no restrictions on time frame, context, study design, or language. An asterisk (*) was used to denote findings applicable across health system, public health, and clinical practice guidelines rather than those specific to HSG. Assessing relevant articles Paired reviewers independently assessed relevant articles, resolving disagreements through discussion. While CIS does not typically include formal quality assessments, we applied one relevance criterion and five quality criteria. Relevance was defined as a paper’s ability to contribute concepts or insights addressing the compass questions42. For quality, we excluded fatally flawed empirical papers based on modified NHS National Electronic Library for Health criteria, focusing on research aims, design, data support, and analysis appropriateness42. Extracting data and information The lead author (QW) extracted data, with a randomly selected sample checked by other reviewers for consistency. A standardized form (Supplementary Table 6) was used to extract details such as title, author, publication year, study design, country focus, and implementation object, along with key findings. Facilitators, barriers, and strategies were identified when explicitly mentioned in the text. Facilitators are factors that drive motivation or prompt action to implement HSG, such as enablers, motivators, or opportunities, while barriers are factors that obstruct implementation, including challenges, obstacles, or limitations21. Some factors may function as both, depending on the context. Implementation strategies are methods to enhance adoption and sustainability, including approaches, actions or tools50, and are defined as actions directly controlled by HSG implementers when overlapping with facilitators7. These elements were categorized based on four frameworks39,40,49,51 and labeled in theme tables with symbols: facilitators (+), barriers (-), neutral factors (±), and strategies (✓). At the system level, we applied the 3I + E framework (institutions, interests, ideas, and external factors) to examine political system influences on HSG implementation (Supplementary Table 7)7,11,51, and used the HSE framework to organize governance, financial, and delivery arrangements within health systems (Supplementary Table 8)49. At the community level, defined as local healthcare delivery contexts, the HSE framework49 was used to extract key concerns, contextual realities, and potential strategies relevant to implementation across community-based settings (e.g., retirement homes, and hospices)52. For the organizational level, the HSE framework49 was also applied to identify implementation facilitators, barriers and strategies within health-related organizations including hospitals, clinics and international bodies such as WHO. At the individual level, identified facilitators and barriers were first mapped to the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) (Supplementary Table 9)39 and Behavior Change Wheel (BCW) (Supplementary Fig. 1)40 and then organized using the COM-B model40. This approach enabled examination of capability-, opportunity-, and motivation-related determinants of behavior among healthcare providers and intended recipients of HSG (patients/public), and informed corresponding implementation strategies. In this study, capability refers to the knowledge and skills required to understand and apply HSG; opportunity refers to external conditions such as workload and social support that enable or constrain implementation; and motivation refers to attitudes, beliefs, and perceived or experienced outcomes that influence willingness to adopt HSG-informed practices. Synthesizing and integrating findings We used an interpretive analytic approach with a constant comparative method53 to synthesize findings from the included documents. A 3 × 6 matrix (facilitators, barriers, strategies across six levels: patients/public, providers, organizational, community, health-system and political-system) was used to map and categorize the literature, identify gaps, and guide further sampling54. Iterative discussions within the research team supported refinement of the analytic process. Findings were organized using established frameworks and the analysis followed these steps: (1) identifying common themes, (2) developing theoretical constructs, (3) refining constructs to address gaps, (4) conducting additional sampling until theoretical saturation was reached, and (5) integrating constructs into a theoretical framework for HSG implementation54. The lead author developed the framework, which was then reviewed and revised by the team. Supplementary information Supplementary information Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank the following graduate students from McMaster University and Lanzhou University for their help in conducting the literature screening (listed alphabetically by last name): Nan Chen, Xiajing Chu, Fenfen E, Lufang Feng, Kangle Guo, Qiangqiang Guo, Yue Hu, Ruixue Huang, Xu Hui, Jing Li, Jingwen Li, Yanfei Li, Mina Ma, Yan Ma, Yu Qin, Xue Shang, Yan Wang, Chaoqun Yang, Minyan Yang, Na Zhang, Haitong Zhao, Ying Zhu. Author contributions Q.W. and J.N.L. conceptualized the study, with Q.W. leading the protocol design, literature screening, data extraction, analysis, and manuscript preparation. The study protocol was approved by J.N.L., M.G.W., and H.J.S. J.R. and X.H. contributed to literature screening and data extraction. J.N.L. played a key role in the analysis, contributing to the iterative process of interpretation and synthesis. K.Y., Y.C., M.G.W., and H.J.S. provided essential insights and substantial feedback on the manuscript. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript. Data availability The data supporting the findings of this study are available within the manuscript and its supplementary files. The minimal dataset required to replicate the study’s findings is available upon reasonable request from the corresponding author. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Supplementary information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s44401-026-00094-z. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary information Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available within the manuscript and its supplementary files. The minimal dataset required to replicate the study’s findings is available upon reasonable request from the corresponding author.