The Effect of N‑Donor Ligands on Activation of [Ru(tpy)(L–py)(AcCN)]2+ Precatalysts in CO2 Reduction Reaction Electrocatalysis Authors: Maurício Portiolli Franco, Giovana Vitiello Teixeira, André Luiz Barboza Formiga Published: 2026 ABSTRACT The electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO in anhydrous media requires the formation of the M–CO2 bond. Using [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­S]2+ as a model, and substituting a pyridine of bipyridine­(bpy) for L = 123-triazole­(123-trz), oxazole­(oz), pyrrole­(pyrr), pyrazole­(pr z), or NHC was computationally studied using TPPSh/def2-svp for geometries, SP correction with def2-tzvp, and implicit acetonitrile solvation. Complexes with pyrr, prz, and NHC undergo both reductions on the tpy ligand, shifting the second reduction to more negative potentials compared to bpy, 123-trz, and oz (which are at least 0.15 V more positive). For the latter, the second reduction occurs on the bidentate ligand generating [Ru­(tpy·)­(py-L·)­AcCN]0. The general reaction path features two reductions, solvent dissociation to a pentacoordinated complex, and CO2 association, except for NHC, where theoretical and experimental data suggest dissociation after the first reduction. Dissociation barriers varied from 19.0 (oz) to 12.9 kcal/mol (prz), while association barriers ranged from 9.0 (NHC) to 3.8 kcal/mol (oz). Finally, the cis/trans product ratio from CO2 association is directly influenced by the τ5 distortion parameter, serving as a qualitative indicator of selectivity. Introduction Carbon dioxide emissions arise from the most diverse human activities and present a serious environmental issue given it is the most common greenhouse gas with emissions of over 37 billion tons in 2021. Aiming to lessen the impact of CO2 emissions, one solution is to transform this low industrial value feedstock into products of greater added value, such as carbon monoxide, formate, carbonate, and other C2 products, for example, ethanol, , through its reduction. , The problem of the CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) to produce valuable chemicals is the high stability of the linear triatomic molecule, which requires a potential of −2.14 V versus SCE, pH 7.0, for a one-electron reduction. , However, ruthenium polypyridine complexes, such as [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­(AcCN)]2+, can act as electrocatalysts, facilitating the electron transfer to CO2. The first report of CO2RR with [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­(AcCN)]2+ was presented by Nagao et al. in 1994, and later, its kinetics were studied by Meyer and collaborators, suggesting a rate constant of 2–3 s–1 with CO as the major product. Substitution of one pyridine ring in bpy for 1-methyl-benzimidazolium (Mebim) to enhance a stronger t rans-effect increased the rate constant to 19 s–1. The proposed initial step to CO2RR is an EEC mechanism (E = electron transfer step and C = chemical step), which means that two reductions take place before a chemical reaction occurs (Figure ). The first reduction is centered on the terpyridine ligand and the second reduction depends on the bidentate ligand, as described experimentally for bpy and Mebim. In the former ligand, the second electron resides in the bidentate ligand, and the latter ones resides in the terpyridine once again. Proposed catalytic cycle to CO2 reduction reaction in an anhydrous medium. Adapted with permission from ref . One crucial intermediate in CO2RR to produce CO is the metallocarboxylate species, which contains the M–C bond and undergoes dehydration in the presence of water or abstraction of O2– to reach the carbonyl complex. The metallocarboxylate intermediate is formed by the dissociation of acetonitrile (eq ) in the doubly reduced complex followed by CO2 association (eq ). Queyriaux et al. and Meyer and co-workers separately reported that solvent dissociation is the rate-determining step for CO2RR to CO by [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­(AcCN)]2+ in an anhydrous medium. [Ru(tpy)(py‐L)(AcCN)]0⇌k−DkD[Ru(tpy)(py‐L)]0+AcCN 1 [Ru(tpy)(py‐L)]0+CO2→kA[Ru(tpy)(py‐L)(CO2··)]0 2 The effect of the substituent on bpy can change the mechanism to ECE as observed when utilizing 2-methyl-bipyridine and the tBu-tpy ligand. This study utilizes density functional theory (DFT) calculations to comprehensively evaluate five bidentate ligands, each comprising a pyridine ring and a five-membered heterocycle. We will determine their reduction potentials and corresponding assignments, as well as investigate the stability and formation of their possible geometric isomers (cis and trans). These investigations will provide the necessary thermochemistry and kinetic theoretical data required for the formation of the critical target complex [Ru II (tpy)­(py-L)­(CO2 2–)]0. To understand the effect of bidentate ligands with properties distinct from those of the bpy complex such as negatively charged donor atoms and the effect of the position or type of heteroatoms in dissociation activation, the rate-determining step, five 5-membered heterocyclic rings bonded to pyridine ligands were evaluated toward the formation of metallocarboxylate and are presented in Figure . Bipyridine ,, and N-heterocyclic carbene , are well-described complexes in the literature. To the best of our knowledge, the other four complexes investigated in this work have not been previously reported. The oxazoline ligand has only been reported in its benzo analogue. Pyrrole ligands have been described with substituents on the five-membered ring. Pyrazole ligands have been reported mainly as pincer systems with ring substituents. , Finally, 1,2,3-triazole ligands have been reported only in the [Ru­(bpy)2] motif. , 2D structures of bidentate ligands and their generic complexes, trans- and cis-[Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­S]2+. Computational Details Optimizations were performed using the ORCA 5.0.3 quantum package employing the functional TPPSh and the basis set def2-svp, and single-point energy correction calculations were performed using the basis set def2-tzvp, its associated pseudopotential for the ruthenium atom, and the set of auxiliary bases def2/J. The TPPSh functional was selected because it has been shown to reproduce the correct spin-state ordering in spin-crossover systems. In addition, it has been reported to provide reliable molecular geometries when used with the chosen basis set. Dispersion effects were included through the D3BJ , scheme, and implicit acetonitrile solvation was included by the CPCM model. The optimizations of intermediates and transition states were confirmed by Hessian calculations with no imaginary frequencies or only one imaginary frequency, respectively. The intrinsic reaction coordinates for all transition states were calculated to connect them to their reactants and products. The correction from the 1 atm standard (G*) Gibbs free energy to the 1 mol/L standard (G o) Gibbs free energy was made by adding 1.89 kcal/mol to the G* of each molecular species. Gsolvo=Gsolv*+ΔG1atm→1mol/L 3 The dissociation (eq ) and association (eq ) reactions were simulated by microkinetics considering that reduction events do not have an activation barrier; i.e., the reaction equation starts from the doubly reduced complex. The rate constants were calculated using the Eyring equation (eq ), with ΔG solv ‡ obtained by DFT calculations and used as input in microkinetic simulation of the reactions from eqs and in COPASI 4.44. The initial concentrations of [CO2] = 0.28 mol/L, [Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­S]0 = 1.0 mmol/L, and the solvent were treated as being in its standard state, i.e., [CH3CN] = 19.15 mol/L. All of these concentrations were selected to reproduce the CO2RR experiment reported by Chen et al. k=kBThexp(−ΔGsolv‡RT) 4 For a reduction reaction, ΔG solv * is obtained fromeq Asolvx+ne−→ΔGsolv*Asolvx−n 5 where A solv x and A solv x–n are the oxidized and reduced species, respectively, ne – is the number of electrons in the reduction process, and ΔG solv * is calculated as ΔGsolv*=ΔGsolv*(Ax−n)−ΔGsolv*(Ax)−Ggaso(e−) 6 where ΔG solv * is the Gibbs free energy of the reduction reaction under standard conditions and G gas o(e –) is the gas Gibbs free energy of an electron at 298 K (G gas o(e –) = 0.867 kcal/mol). Then, standard reduction potentials (Eo ) were calculated using the Nernst equation (eq ). Eo(V)=−ΔGsolv*nF−SHE 7 Here, n is the number of electrons in the reduction process, F is the Faraday constant as 1 eV/V, and SHE is the absolute potential of the standard hydrogen electrode value (4.281 V). Results and Discussion Our calculations are in agreement with reduction potentials and reduction assignments reported in the literature using cyclic voltammetry (CV) experiments for the standard complex [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­S]2+. Theoretical values for 2E1 and 3E2, where the superscript denotes the spin multiplicity of the electronic state and the subscript denotes the first or second reduction, were −1.03 and −1.47 V compared to the experimental values of −1.00 and −1.30 V. In addition, the assignments obtained from DFT and CV were identical for the first and second reductions and were assigned to terpyridine and bipyridine ligands, respectively. For the bpy complex, the dissociation occurs in the second reduction with a ΔG D ‡ = 17.2 kcal/mol and ΔR G D = 8.0 kcal/mol. These values were obtained considering the product as a closed-shell singlet rather than a triplet state, with a triplet–singlet gap (ΔT–S) higher than zero, where positive values indicate singlet states and negative values indicate triplet states; the [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)]0 bipyramidal complex has ΔT–S of 0.27 eV. For this reason, dissociation energies (ΔR G D) were calculated considering the forbidden spin-transition. The forbidden spin-transition type of reaction was also described in water oxidation catalysis with ruthenium complexes. A relevant change in the electronic structure of the dissociation product 1[Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)]0 compared to its predecessor is the reduction of Ru II →Ru0. This is expected for this geometry, as exemplified by the examples [Fe0(CO)5], [Ru0(PPh3)3(CO)2], and [Os0(CO)4(η2-C2H4)]. This charge transfer from the reduced bpy and tpy ligands to a molecular orbital with a Ru–N­(tpy) π character (Figure S1a) shows the reduction of the metallic center to zero. Considering the closed-shell state and geometry of the product, the ruthenium(0) species is the cause for the fast association step and the attack on the carbon atom in CO2. The orbitals involved in the electronic transfer from the doubly reduced solvatocomplex to the metallocarboxylate are presented in Figure S1a–f for the bpy ligand system, as well as for the other ligands studied in this work. The interchange mechanism was also evaluated. The structure of the interchange TS occurs in the triplet state and has both monodentate ligands distant from the metallic center, with Ru–O from CO2 at 3.00 Å and Ru–N from acetonitrile at 4.49 Å, indicating a dissociative interchange mechanism (Id) (Figure ). The simultaneous dissociation of AcCN and the approximation of CO2 occurs with a barrier height of 22.4 kcal/mol, producing a complex with Ru–OCO in the triplet state instead of the metallocarboxylate. Although the activation barrier is not prohibitive, the distance between the metallic center and the solvent indicates that dissociation should occur before CO2 association. Considering that the interchange mechanism has a barrier 5.2 kcal·mol–1 higher than that of the dissociative mechanism, this difference would translate into kDkId=6.81×103 . Furthermore, the Ru–AcCN distance of 4.49 Å is sufficiently long to neglect any long-range interaction, indicating that this interchange transition state is not truly concerted. For these reasons, we considered only the dissociative pathway throughout this work. Transition state structures for the dissociative path (top) and for the interchange mechanism (bottom). Microkinetics simulation of [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­(AcCN)]0 was carried out to evaluate the time evolution of concentrations of the species involved in metallocarboxylate formation (Figure ). Since the equilibrium of acetonitrile dissociation is strongly shifted toward the reactants (k D < k –D) and the association of CO2 is faster than k –D, the concentration of [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)]0 is extremely low, with the highest concentration equal to 3.9 × 10–12 mmol/L, immediately after the start of the simulation because it did not start from chemical equilibrium. These results are in agreement with the conclusion of Meyer and collaborators, although their conclusion was for the full CO2RR and not just for the formation of the metallocarboxylate. Kinetic simulation of precatalysis for the complex [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­(AcCN)]0. Since the symmetry of bipyridine is broken due to the substitution of one of its rings, two position isomers are expected, one with the five-membered ring trans to acetonitrile and another with the ring in the cis position. In the particular case of the NHC ligand, we used a model with N–H instead of N–R to ensure the same steric bulk toward all ligands; yet, we also calculated the real N–Me system, and the results are provided in the Supporting Information. All complexes have the first reduction located on terpyridine, and almost all potentials occur near −1.05 V versus SHE, except for the only negatively charged ligand, pyrrole, with 2E1 = −1.29 V (Table ), as expected for the electrochemical ligand series reported by Lever. For the NHC and oz that have a benzo analogue as reported in the literature, the 2E1 values are in good agreement with both potential values. 1Reduction Potentials in Volts (V) for Cis and Trans Isomers of [Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­S]2+ Calculated with TPSSh/def2-tzvp//TPSSh/def2-svp, D3BJ Dispersion Corrections, and Acetonitrile as the Implicit Solvent NHCpyrrprz123-trzozligands isomersbpy cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans 2E1 –1.03–1.07–1.11–1.29–1.29–1.04–1.06–0.98–1.02–1.02–1.04 3E2 –1.47–1.76–1.79–1.93–1.96–1.73–1.81–1.58–1.58–1.45–1.49 1E2 –1.74–1.932.02–2.17–2.23–1.92–1.94–1.74–1.82–1.74–1.76 Reduction Potentials in Volts (V) for Cis and Trans Isomers of [Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­S]2+ Calculated with TPSSh/def2-tzvp//TPSSh/def2-svp, D3BJ Dispersion Corrections, and Acetonitrile as the Implicit Solvent With an increase of two electrons in the complex due to the second reduction, two possible spin states need to be evaluated: the triplet and the closed-shell singlet. For all reduced solvato complexes, the most stable spin state is the triplet, as shown by the less negative potentials for E2. Also, an important difference between the open-shell and closed-shell states is that, for all complexes in the closed-shell singlet state, both reductions occur at the terpyridine ligand. The oxazole and 1,2,3-triazole rings exhibit electrochemical behavior similar to that of bipyridine, with the second reduction localized on the bidentate ligand, occurring at approximately −1.47 and −1.58 V, respectively. In contrast, NHC, pyrrole, and pyrazole show more negative 3E2 values, which can be attributed to a subsequent reduction centered on the tridentate ligand rather than on the bipyridine fragment. Figure presents the spin-density distribution upon sequential reduction and illustrates representative examples of both behaviors. Spin-density plot of sequential reductions for trans-[Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­AcCN]2+ with L = NHC (top) and oz (bottom). In the benzo-oxazole analogue reported in the literature, the second reduction is experimentally assigned to a double reduction of the terpyridine unit at −1.38 V versus NHE. However, our theoretical calculations, supported by the spin-density map, clearly show that the added electron is localized on the bidentate oxazole ligand rather than on the terpyridine moiety. Therefore, this provides a more reliable assignment of the second reduction process. A small difference in reduction potentials was observed when geometric isomers were compared, especially for those groups where terpyridine is doubly reduced. The position of the five-membered ring causes a shift of tens of mV to a lower potential for the trans isomer when the pyridine ring is on the opposite side of the central terpyridine Ru–N bond. When evaluating the dissociation reaction, at 2E1, the dissociation energies (D E1 ) are considerably larger than those at 3E2(D E2 ) (Table ), suggesting that dissociation is more likely to occur in the doubly reduced complex [Ru­(tpy)­(py–L)­(AcCN)]0. The highest D E2 value was found for the bipyridine and oxazole complexes, with energies of approximately 8 kcal/mol (Table ). All ΔT–S are positive (Table S1), indicating a forbidden spin-transition reaction, as observed before for the bpy complex. 2Dissociation Energies (D) in ΔG and Dissociation Activation Barrier (ΔG D ‡) in kcal/mol for Both Isomers and Distortion Parameter τ5 for the Pentacoordinate Complex NHCpyrrprz123-trzozligands isomersbpy cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans D E 1 14.815.59.615.114.915.015.714.715.215.415.9D E 2 8.0–1.4–1.33.43.91.4–0.63.93.08.97.7ΔG D ‡(E2)17.214.87.916.615.914.412.915.914.919.019.0τ5 0.430.220.480.350.300.28aτ5 values vary from zero to one, where zero defines a perfect square pyramidal geometry and 1.00 is a perfect trigonal bipyramidal. Dissociation Energies (D) in ΔG and Dissociation Activation Barrier (ΔG D ‡) in kcal/mol for Both Isomers and Distortion Parameter τ5 for the Pentacoordinate Complex τ5 values vary from zero to one, where zero defines a perfect square pyramidal geometry and 1.00 is a perfect trigonal bipyramidal. CV experiments reported the second reduction at −1.31 V versus NHE for the solvato benzo analogue of NHC (MeBim), which shows a 0.5 V more positive 3E2 value than that of its model. However, reduction of trans-[Ru­(tpy)­(py–NHC)]+ (dissociation product in 2E1) has a theoretical potential of −1.32 V versus SHE (Table S2) and diverges from the experimental value by only 10 mV, while the optimization attempt of the singlet square pyramidal cis-[Ru­(tpy)­(py–NHC)]0 always leads to the trans position isomer. These potentials suggest that AcCN dissociates before 3E2 for the NHC complex and cis-[Ru­(tpy)­(py–NHC)]+ isomerizes into the trans configuration with ΔG = −7.4 kcal/mol, which favors NHC trans to the vacant position (Figure ). Reaction scheme for the dissociation and isomerization of trans- (upper scheme) and cis- (lower scheme) NHC complexes, where potentials are reported vs NHE, and the values in parentheses are experimental values reported for MeBim complexes. Attempts to find the dissociation TS for 2[Ru­(tpy·)­(py–NHC)­(AcCN)]+ were unsuccessful. However, considering AcCN dissociation from the NHC complex at 2E1 followed by reduction provides a better fit to the experimental report, and we predict that this pattern will occur for prz and pyrr since they have similar reduction potentials and are located on the terpyridine ligand. All transition states of the dissociation step were found in the closed-shell singlet state and showed plausible activation barriers at room temperature. They are very similar to the structure of the bpy ligand and are presented in the Supporting Information. Attempts to obtain dissociation TS in the triplet state for all complexes led to very high gradients (nonconverged structures) compared to the standard convergence parameters. When comparing trans complexes, a trans-effect series can be drawn using the ΔG D ‡(E 2) values. The ascending order of the ligand series is oz < bpy < pyrr < 123-trz < prz ≪ NHC. Also, the smaller cis-effect is noticeable and it is not negligible, with oz as the only ligand slower than [Ru­(tpy·)­(bpy·)­AcCN]0. The activation barriers for the NHC and prz ligands are ∼3 kcal/mol smaller than that for bpy. Nagao et al. also described carbon–carbon coupling with the [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­CO]2+ catalyst at −20 °C for electrocatalysis and stoichiometric reactions with BH4 –. They claimed that the formation of highly reduced CO2 products, such as MeOH and C2, depends on the thermal lability of Ru–CO dissociation. This statement suggests that a ligand with a higher dissociation barrier, for example, the 2-pyridine-oxazole­(oz), which has a smaller trans-effect than bpy, could enable the formation of multiple reduction products. After acetonitrile dissociation, either cis or trans isomers produce the same pentacoordinated species from the IRC calculations, with most structures closer to square pyramidal (SP) than trigonal bipyramidal (TBP), as identified by the τ5 distortion parameter (Figure ). The τ5 values were obtained by assuming that the angle between terminal pyridines of tpy is 180°, since in either geometry these nitrogen atoms must be in an axial position in TBP or in the equatorial plane in SP geometry, and by using the highest angle N-Rû-L between the nitrogen atom of terpyridine’s central ring and the donor atom of the five-membered ring (ϕL) or pyridine­(ϕpy). 2D structures for the pentacoordinated intermediate [Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)]0 with both ϕL and ϕpy. Calculations of CO2 association barriers in Gibbs free energy (ΔG A ‡) are presented in Table , and the structures are presented in the Supporting Information. The activation barrier indicates a faster reaction than the dissociation step, with ΔG A ‡ ≤ 9.0 kcal/mol, consuming the dissociation product and shifting the equilibrium toward the forward reaction, as observed in the microkinetics for the bpy complex. The pentacoordinate complex reacts with carbon dioxide, reducing it to afford 1[Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­(CO2 ··)]0. The transition structure of CO2 association occurs via an approximation of the carbon toward ruthenium from the terpyridine side. 3Association Reaction Energies (ΔR G A) and Activation Barriers (ΔG A ‡), in kcal/mol, for Both Isomers, and the Cis:Trans Proportion of Metallocarboxylate Isomers NHCpyrrprz123-trzozLigands isomersbpy cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans cis trans ΔR G A –14.6–16.0–7.8–17.6–17.3–16.0–14.8–13.8–14.4–17.7–16.3ΔG A ‡ 5.09.06.67.16.54.95.54.35.43.85.4 cis:trans 1:57.41:2.82.8:16.4:114.9:1 Association Reaction Energies (ΔR G A) and Activation Barriers (ΔG A ‡), in kcal/mol, for Both Isomers, and the Cis:Trans Proportion of Metallocarboxylate Isomers This step can lead to cis and trans isomers, depending on which terpyridine’s side the CO2 associates with the ruthenium center. Gonell et al. described this isomerization for the complex [Ru­(tpy)­(MeBim-py)­AcCN]2+ with MeBim-py, where the precatalyst cis-[Ru­(tpy)­(MeBim-py)­CO2]0 is used to reduce CO2 and it isomerizes to trans-[Ru­(tpy)­(MeBim-py)­CO2]0. The authors attributed this isomerization to the lower angle of the MeBim-Rû-N than the counterpart with pyridine in the pentacoordinate complex. This correlation was also observed when comparing ϕ for the same ligand, and this can be used to qualitatively predict which isomer will form in excess during catalysis. Microkinetic modeling for the py-L complexes closely resembles that of the bpy system, even in the occurrence of competing cis and trans CO2 addition pathways (Figure S4), because the kinetic and thermodynamic products are identical. In contrast, for the NHC system, the kinetic and thermodynamic products differ: the trans isomer is formed first due to a lower activation barrier, whereas the cis isomer is the most thermodynamically stable species (Table ). To obtain quantitative information on isomer distribution, the ratio ΔGAtrans‡ΔGAcis‡ was calculated and is presented in Table as cis:trans proportion. The NHC and pyrr ligands produce a trans excess compared to the other ligands. Plotting the correlation between the isomer excess and the geometric index τ5 (Figure a) shows how available the ruthenium(0) center is for CO2 association from one side rather than the other, i.e., how close the pentacoordinate is to the SP geometry. The exponential correlation between the geometric distortion parameter τ5 and cis:trans proportion (Figure ) arises from the Eyring equation (eq ) when ktranskcis is obtained. (a) Plot of τ5 against excess isomer ratio for the five-membered ring complexes, (b) 2D drawing showing the Φ­(N–Ru-L) angle, (c) plot of ϕ­(N–Ru-py) against ΔG A ‡, and (d) plot of ϕ­(N–Ru-L) against ΔΔG A ‡(cis–trans). A plot of Φ­(N–Ru–L) (Figure b) versus ΔG A ‡ (Figure c) reveals that higher activation barriers correlate with increased negative charge on the donor atom. Ligands featuring strongly donating atoms, such as the amide nitrogen in pyrrole and the carbene carbon in NHCs, exhibit larger ΔG A ‡ values compared to ligands containing imine nitrogen donors, which display lower barriers. For the cis series, steric effects dominate the observed trend. In this configuration, the ligand trans to the CO2 addition site is consistently pyridine, rendering the electronic contribution effectively constant across the bidentate ligands. Consequently, variations in ΔG A ‡ primarily reflect steric hindrance. In contrast, for the trans series, electronic effects become more pronounced because different donor rings occupy the position trans to the reaction site. This variability enhances the electronic influence on the activation barrier, resulting in a steeper slope relative to the cis trend. Compared to the cis series, this behavior is reflected directly in the trans correlation, where NHC and pyrrole derivatives occupy the low-ΔG A ‡ region, while oxazole, pyrazole, and 1,2,3-triazole cluster at higher activation barriers, indicative of slower trans addition. A second way to correlate the data is to plot Φ­(N–Ru–L) versus ΔΔG A ‡(cis–trans). This representation leads to the same conclusion as the correlation shown in Figure c, but the trend is more clearly visualized. Negative values indicate preferential formation of the cis isomer, positive values favor the trans isomer, and values close to zero correspond to nonselective formation. The major isomer can be qualitatively determined by identifying the Φ­(N–Ru-L) angle in 1[Ru0(tpy)­(py-L)]0. Also, a higher proportion of one isomer relative to the other can be expected for lower values of τ5 for new ligands with similar steric effects. Conclusions In this study, we computationally described the formation of the metallocarboxylated ruthenium complex 1[Ru II (tpy)­(py-L)­(CO2 2–)]0 in anhydrous media electrocatalysis for a series of bidentate ligands with rings of 2-pyridine-5 members and well-studied [Ru­(tpy)­(bpy)­S]2+. All complexes undergo a slow dissociation step followed by fast association through a pentacoordinate complex, which determines the geometric isomer formed before the catalytic cycle. All complexes with two reductions on both ligands in open-shell states have less negative potentials than systems in which both electrons are located on terpyridine. However, experimental data in the literature show a lower catalytic potential, suggesting that dissociation occurs at the first reduction for these ligands. Since all first reductions are localized on the terpyridine ligand, modification of the bidentate ligand, such as extending the π system by adding a benzo group to its backbone, lowers the second reduction potential by stabilizing the nonligand π* molecular orbital energy of the bidentate ligand, bringing it closer to that of the terpyridine ligand. Association activation barriers are necessary to quantitatively discuss isomer distribution instead of only using association thermodynamics for this type of complex. From a kinetic perspective, since the dissociation step activates the precatalyst (3[Ru­(tpy)­(py-L)­(AcCN)]0) and its backward reaction leads to an off-side species, a ligand with a higher ΔG D ‡ (i.e., slower dissociation) may still display a higher TOF than a complex with faster dissociation, provided that this activation/deactivation step is not rate-limiting. To test this hypothesis, the full catalytic cycle for CO2 reduction to CO under anhydrous conditions must be evaluated. Carbon dioxide addition selectivity in Ru(0)-py-L complexes is controlled by geometric distortion and ligand-dependent steric and electronic effects. The cis : trans ratio follows an exponential dependence on the pentacoordinate distortion parameter τ5, consistent with Eyring kinetics. For the small ligand set studied, strongly donating ligands such as NHC and pyrrole favor trans addition, while weaker donors lead to higher barriers and reduced selectivity. The Φ­(N–Ru–L) angle provides a simple and intuitive descriptor for predicting the preferred isomer and relative selectivity in related systems. Supplementary Material