Composite design and property assessment of high and medium entropy layers in TaCHfCZrCTiCVC/HfB₂ZrB₂TiB₂ system Authors: Ekhlas Qays Al-shawway, Zohre Balak Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractThis research investigates the impact of carbonous and metallic additives on the microstructure of high entropy carbide (HEC) and medium entropy in-situ boride (ME-ISB) composite layers. The HEC layer, made from TaCHfCZrCTiCVC with Gr and Si additives, and the ME-ISB layer, composed of HfO2ZrO2TiO2 with nano carbon black (C.Bn) and B4C, were consolidated using spark plasma sintering (SPS) at 2000 °C under 40 MPa for 10 min. Bulk density was measured via the Archimedes method, and microstructural analysis was conducted using field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) and X-ray diffraction (XRD). The findings revealed that the HEC layer has a higher sinterability (99.7%) compared to the ME-ISB layer (78.4%). Hardness tests showed the HEC layer (≈ 15 GPa) is significantly harder than the ME-ISB layer (≈ 1.2 GPa), with average grain sizes of 430 ± 150 nm for HEC and 200 ± 100 nm for ME-ISB.Keywords: Two-layer composite, Carbide, Boride, Microstructure, Fracture toughness, High and medium entropy, SPSSubject terms: Engineering, Materials science Introduction Ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) are a class of advanced structural materials known for their exceptional thermal, mechanical, and chemical stability at temperatures exceeding 2000 ℃, along with strong resistance to oxidation, corrosion, and thermal shock1–3. Due to these superior characteristics, UHTCs are widely used in aerospace, nuclear systems, and high‑temperature structural components1,4–6. Recently, the emergence of high‑entropy ceramics (HECs) has introduced new opportunities for enhancing the performance of UHTCs through multi‑element, near‑equimolar compositions that generate high configurationally entropy and lattice distortion7. Several studies4,8–10 have investigated synthesis routes for HECs—including mechanical alloying, chemical methods, and particularly SPS4,8,11,12 to achieve dense, homogeneous microstructures. HECs typically exhibit superior hardness, strength, and fracture toughness compared to conventional ceramics, attributed to entropy‑induced lattice distortion and hindered crack propagation4,10,13. Moreover, previous research indicates that carbon and metallic additives can significantly promote single‑phase formation and improve sinterability in HEC systems8,14,15. J. Gild and co-workers7 synthesized (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂ and (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)C via RFSPS, demonstrating that 3 wt% carbon facilitates rapid single‑phase formation and yields > 99% relative density without extensive mechanical alloying8. In another study, three HEB compositions—(Hf₀.₂V₀.₂Ta₀.₂Ti₀.₂Nb₀.₂)B₂, (Zr₀.₂V₀.₂Ta₀.₂Ti₀.₂Nb₀.₂)B₂, and (Cr₀.₂V₀.₂Ta₀.₂Ti₀.₂Nb₀.₂)B₂—were synthesized via boro/carbothermal reduction, where the HEB‑Zr sample exhibited the highest hardness (24.2 ± 0.6 GPa) and fracture toughness (9.2 ± 0.3 MPa·m1/2)15. Additionally, Cf/HEC composites produced by RMI showed high bending strength (612.6 MPa) and low ablation rates, with XRD confirming single‑phase (TiZrHfNbTa)C formation16. Studies on medium‑entropy carbides (MECs) such as (MoTaW)C and (NbTaW)C have shown that carbon‑induced lattice distortion enhances charge transfer and strengthens covalent bonding, resulting in improved mechanical properties compared to HEAs17. Hot‑pressed (TiZrHf)C exhibited high relative density (99.2%), fine grain size (1.9 μm), and strong flexural performance at both room and elevated temperatures18. Similarly, SPS‑sintered (TaTiZr)C showed flexural strength of 700 MPa, while higher temperatures led to partial phase degradation and increased fracture toughness19. A recent advancement in this field is the development of dual‑phase high‑entropy UHTCs (DPHE‑UHTCs), combining HEC and HEB phases to achieve fine‑grained, chemically homogeneous, and mechanically robust structures suitable for extreme environments4. For example, (Ti‑Zr‑Nb‑Ta‑Hf)C/(Ti‑Zr‑Nb‑Ta‑Hf)B₂ composites produced via in‑situ boro/carbothermal reactions exhibit nano‑hardness values of 37–43 GPa and high phase stability4. An empirical rule with 93.33% accuracy has also been proposed for predicting single‑phase HEB formation, where < 3.66 indicates single‑phase stability14. This work tackles the persistent lack of phase stability and oxidation resistance of conventional ultra‑high‑temperature ceramics (UHTCs) above 2000 °C in aerospace and hypersonic environments by introducing a dual‑layer, entropy‑engineered composite. The design couples a high‑entropy carbide layer (TaC–HfC–ZrC–TiC–VC), comprising five FCC‑compatible carbides that form a stable single‑phase solid solution with melting points exceeding 3500 °C, with a medium‑entropy boride layer (HfB₂–ZrB₂–TiB₂) of AlB₂‑type structure. Constituent selection was guided by thermodynamic stability and lattice compatibility, and the formation was mediated by C.Bn, B₄C, and selected metal additives. Entropy effects suppress grain growth and bolster phase and oxidation stability, yielding a multifunctional composite with enhanced thermal endurance, mechanical strength, and environmental resilience. These attributes position the material as a strong candidate for thermal protection systems, rocket nozzles, and other high‑temperature structural components in extreme service conditions. This work further investigates the roles of C.Bn and B4C in promoting in‑situ medium‑entropy boride formation from ZrO₂–TiO₂–HfO₂ precursors, as well as the synergistic effects of graphite and Si on enhancing single‑phase HEC formation and sinterability in the carbide layer. SPS was selected due to its high efficiency in consolidating entropy‑engineered ceramics. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, no prior study has reported HEC/ME‑ISB layered composites incorporating the combined effects of C.Bn, B4C, and metallic additives using SPS, highlighting the novelty of this research. Experimental To conduct this research, TiC, ZrC, HfC, TaC, VC, Gr, Si, ZrO2, HfO2, TiO2, and C.Bn and B4C powders were prepared. The characteristics of primary powders (including particle size, purity, and manufacturer) are given in Table 1. SEM/FESEM images and XRD patterns of TiC, ZrC, HfC, TaC, VC, Gr, Si, and C.Bn and B4C powders are given in our previous studies20–26. However, FESEM image and XRD patterns of HfO2, TiO2 and XRD pattern of ZrO2 are presented in Fig. 1. To fabricate a two-layer HEC/ME-ISB composite, the powders of each layer (see Table 2) were weighed in specific proportions and mixed by a high-energy mill at a speed of 200 rpm for 3 h in zirconia cup and ball with powder to ball ratio of 1:5 to obtain the homogeneous powders. Table 1The characteristics of primary powders (including particle size, purity, and manufacturer).TypeParticle sizeCompany and purityTiC< 10 μmXuzhou Hongwu Nanometer Material Co., China, > 98.5%ZrC20 μmAlfa acer, > 99.5%HfC< 10 μmCHEM, Xinglu chemical, china, 99.3%,VC< 2Huhan Haiyun Metallurgical Materials Co., Ltd., China, > 99%TaC< 0.5Huhan Haiyun Metallurgical Materials Co., Ltd., China, > 99%Grplatelet diameter of 5–10 μmUS Research Nanomaterials, Inc., > 99.9%Si0–200 mmRW silicium GmbH, Wöhlerstraße 30, 94,060 Pocking, Germany, > 97.5%HfO2< 1 μmPishrocramicmehr, Iran, > 99.5%TiO2< 5 μmSigmaaldrich, ≥ 99.9%ZrO2D50No. 32, Arash Building, South of Mesbah Intersection, Karaj, Alborz, Iran, Afaghceramic, Grade AF110C.Bn50 nmUS Research Nanomaterials, Inc., C > 95%B4C75 μmSigmaaldrich, > 98% The characteristics of primary powders (including particle size, purity, and manufacturer). (a) FESEM image and XRD of (a) and (b) HfO2, (c) and (d) TiO2, (f) XRD of ZrO2 initial powders. Table 2Chemical composition of each layer and conditions applied to sinter samples.CodeChemical composition of initial powdersTemperature (°C)Time(min)Pressure(MPa)Layer ITaCHfCZrCTiCVC/Si, Gr20001040Layer IITiO2HfO2ZrO2/C.Bn B4C20001040 Chemical composition of each layer and conditions applied to sinter samples. The powders were sintered via SPS (SPS-20T-10, China) at the condition of 2000 °C, 10 min, and 40 MPa in the graphite mold with the inner diameter of 15 mm. Then both surfaces of the sintered tablet were polished using sandpaper up to 2000. To characterize each layer, the sample is cut using a wire cut. For microstructural evaluation, an FE-SEM (TESCAN-Vega II, with a voltage of 20 kV) which was equipped with an energy-dispersive spectroscope (EDS) was applied. Phase identification was investigated by an X-ray diffractometer (Philips, Xpert, TW1800), with CuKα radiation, a step size of 0.04 degrees, and a 1 s detecting time. The Macro-Hardness test was conducted by a Vickers diamond indenter (Zwick Roell, ZHV 10, Germany) with a 20 kg load for 20 s on the polished sections as an average of 5 indentations. The fracture toughness was estimated based on crack lengths generated by Vickers indentation, using the Antis formula. This method is widely applied for brittle ceramics and relies on the radial cracks that emanate from the corners of the indentation imprint. The fracture toughness (KIC) was calculated using the following expression proposed by Antis et al.27: Where: KIC is the fracture toughness (MPa·m1/2). E is Young’s modulus (GPa). H is Vickers hardness (GPa). P is the applied load (N). C is the half-length of the crack measured from the center of the indent to the crack tip (m). Vickers indentation was performed using a microhardness tester under a load of 20 kg. The diagonal length of the indent and the radial crack lengths were measured using a calibrated optical microscope. The average crack length (c) was determined by measuring all four cracks and calculating the mean value. The Young’s modulus was calculated by Nielsen formula (Eq. 2). The Nielsen model provides a semi-empirical approach to estimate the effective elastic modulus of a porous material based on its porosity level. The Nielsen formula is expressed as: Where: E is the effective Young’s modulus of the porous material (GPa). E0 is the Young’s modulus of the fully dense (non-porous) material (GPa). P is the porosity. is an empirical constant related to pore geometry and distribution (commonly (0.4) for spherical pores)28. Grain size was measured using the linear intercept method on multiple FESEM images with different magnification. Image analysis was conducted using ImageJ software, and at least 100 grains were evaluated per sample to ensure statistical reliability. The average grain size values reported in the manuscript reflect this detailed analysis. Result and discussion Microstructure Figure 2 displays FESEM images of the interface between the two-layer HEC/ME-ISB composite, which was sintered at 2000 °C, 40 MPa, for 10 min, shown at magnifications of 90 and 1000. As shown in Figs. 2a and b, the up layer is a five-component carbide layer (I) and the low one is a three-component ISB layer (II). To investigate the microstructure, FESEM images were taken from both layers in the higher magnifications (Fig. 3); It can be seen that layer I has a denser microstructure than layer II. Since the calculations of the initial charging of both layers were done to reach a thickness of about 5 mm, the measurement and comparison of the final thickness obtained for both layers after the sintering process is in complete agreement with the FESEM images; Because according to Fig. 1a, both layers of I and II have a final thickness of 4.8 and 7.6 mm, respectively. In other words, it seems that layer I is completely condensed, while layer II has large amounts of porosity. To investigate this issue more closely, the relative density of both layers was measured. Its results as well as grain size measurement by Image Tools software are given in Table 3. FESEM images of the interface of the HEC/ME-ISB two-layer composite at different magnifications. FESEM images of the polished cross-section of the HEC layer at magnifications (a) kx10 and (b) kx25 and ME-ISB layer (c) kx10 and (d) kx25. Table 3Values of relative density, grain size, hardness, and fracture toughness of two-layer HEC/ME-ISB composite.Layer typeRelative density, %Grain size,nmHardness, HvFracture ToughnessMPa m1/2Layer I99.7 ± 0.3430 ± 150≈ 15 ± 0.56.2 ± 0.4Layer II78.4 ± 3.7200 ± 100≈ 1.2 ± 0.2- Values of relative density, grain size, hardness, and fracture toughness of two-layer HEC/ME-ISB composite. Table 3 shows that, despite the higher melting points of compounds in layer I compared to those in layer II, the relative density of the carbide layer is approximately 100%, significantly exceeding the 78.4% density of the oxide layer. This difference in density can be attributed to the simultaneous presence of metal and carbonaceous additives (Si and Gr) in the carbide layer, whereas the oxide layer contains only carbonaceous (C.Bn) and carbide (B4C) additives. Layer I (five-component carbide) is created from the sintering of TaC, HfC, ZrC, TiC, and VC in the presence of silicon and graphite additives; While layer II is created from the in-situ sintering of HfB2, ZrB2, TiB2 from the oxide compounds (HfO2, TiO2, ZrO2) in the presence of C.Bn and B4C. In other words, in layer I, the sintering mechanism is liquid phase sintering plus the reactive agent, while in layer II, the sintering mechanism is only through the reactive agent. In layer I, Si reacts with carbide compounds through Eq. (3) and creates a silicide phase (MSi2) which is feasible thermodynamically. The melting points of all silicide compounds TiSi2, ZrSi2, HfSi2 and VSi2 (respectively equal to 1470, 1620, 1680, and 1677 °C) except for TaSi2 (2200 °C) are lower than the sintering temperature (2000 °C). So, they present in the liquid phase in the microstructure and improve sinterability. In addition, Gr can facilitate removing oxide impurities through the reaction with oxide impurities on the surface of primary powder particles (Eqs. 4 and 5), thereby improving the sinterability. To investigate the possibility of reactions (4) and (5) happening, thermodynamic calculations were conducted using HSC 5.1 software. For this purpose, the enthalpy and entropy values of the reactions as a function of temperature were obtained using thermodynamic HSC 5.1 software. In addition to the software calculations, the thermodynamic quantities were cross-checked using the data provided in the thermochemical handbook29. Then, based on the standard thermodynamic relation, ΔG = ΔH − TΔS, the ΔG vs. temperature plots were generated for each reaction and presented in Fig. 4. Diagram of free energy changes in terms of temperature for reactions 4–6, and 12. According to what is explained about layer I, thermodynamic investigations show the possibility of Gr reaction with oxide impurities and their reduction to carbide compounds during reactions (4) and (5) at the temperature of 2000 °C (Fig. 3). Therefore, considering it, in this layer, besides the initial carbide grain, new TaC, HfC, ZrC, TiC, and VC grains as well as CO gases are formed which the CO gases can escape during the sintering process. In layer II, the initial oxide powders can react with C.Bn and in-situ synthesis to the carbide phases through a carbothermal reaction (Equs. 4, 5 and 12) or react with C.Bn and B4C via boro/carbothermal reaction (Equ. 6) and create boride phases which all of them are feasible thermodynamically. Importantly, transition metal diborides exhibit extremely high thermodynamic stability, with more negative formation energies compared to the corresponding oxides under reducing conditions. Therefore, once reduction is initiated, boride formation is strongly favored (Fig. 4). At the carbide/boride interface, chemical potential gradients of boron and carbon generate an additional driving force for interdiffusion. Therefore, the interfacial layer growth is governed by coupled reaction–diffusion processes that are thermodynamically favored at 2000 °C. Although the thermodynamic driving force for boride formation is strong, the dominant pathway is kinetically controlled. Diffusion coefficients follow the Arrhenius relation: For refractory systems, boron diffusion in transition metal borides/carbides typically exhibits activation energies QB in the range of 200–350 kJ/mol. Refractory metal cations (Hf, Zr, Ta) exhibit much higher activation energies, often exceeding 400–600 kJ/mol30–32. As a result: . Furthermore, boron has a smaller atomic radius and it can diffuse via interstitial or mixed mechanisms, while heavy cations diffuse primarily through vacancy-controlled lattice diffusion, which is significantly slower31,32. Considering the short dwell time (10 min), bulk lattice diffusion distances can be estimated from: For typical lattice diffusion of refractory metals, Dmetal≈10− 15 to 10− 14 m2/s, Xmetal≈2–3 μm; Whereas grain-boundary diffusion coefficients are several orders of magnitude higher, Dgb≈10− 11 to 10− 9 m2/s, yielding significantly larger effective transport distances during SPS. Therefore, Long-range lattice diffusion of refractory cations is kinetically limited and grain-boundary/short-circuit diffusion dominates. Boron transport controls the interfacial growth rate. Also, under SPS conditions, pulsed DC current enhances defect concentration. Localized Joule heating at particle contacts increases atomic mobility. Applied pressure (40 MPa) increases contact area and short-circuit diffusion paths. Thus, the effective diffusion coefficient during SPS can be significantly higher than under conventional sintering, especially along particle contacts. However, even under these enhanced conditions, relative mobility hierarchy remains: Therefore, boron diffusion is the dominant kinetic pathway controlling interfacial layer growth33. Linear analysis and XRD were used in addition to thermodynamic calculations to identify layers’ chemical composition, possibility of solid solution formation, the reaction between the primary powders, along the possibility or impossibility of in situ synthesis in each layer. Figure 5 shows the linear analysis of the HEC/ME-ISB two-layer composite on both sides of the interface. According to the obtained results, the presence of elements Ta, V, C, Si, Zr, Ti, Hf, and oxygen in the upper layer (I) and elements C, Zr, Ti, and Hf in the lower layer (II) is evident. It is interesting that while the initial chemical composition of layer II consists of oxide powders (HfO2, ZrO2, and TiO2), no oxygen element is detected and the contrary, in layer I, which consists of no oxide phases, an oxygen element is identified. For layer I, the presence of oxygen can be associated with oxide impurities that exist on the surface of initial powders or are created through reactions (4) and (5) during the milling process. FESEM image of the polished cross-section along with its linear analysis on both sides of the interface. In layer II, no oxygen element identification is indicated; the initial oxide powders were in-situ synthesized to the boride or carbide phases as well as CO gases through reactions (3) and (5). Since CO gases exit from the microstructure, no oxygen element has remained. Figure 6 shows the XRD analysis of both HEC and ME-ISB layers. In layer I, although its initial chemical composition consists of five carbide phases (TaC, HfC, TiC, ZrC, and VC), only the TaC peaks could be detected. In Fig. 6a, the XRD pattern of this layer, as well as five carbide phases, is shown; obviously, it is seen that no peaks of carbide phases except TaC are matched with the XRD pattern. In other words, their intensity has been eliminated so that their peaks cannot be detected by X-ray diffraction patterns (Fig. 7b). This issue possibility originated from the diffusion of Hf, Zr, Ti, and V elements to the crystal lattice of TaC and therefore dissolution and creation of (TaHfZrTiV) C solid solution. Also, a comparison of the pure TaC peaks with the XRD pattern (Fig. 6a) indicates that some TaC peaks (three peaks) were replaced to the right and some others (two peaks) to the left which can confirm this issue (solid solution formation) to some extent. These replacements (for specified region with brown color dashed line in Fig. 7a) are shown in higher magnification in Fig. 6b in the range of 34 to 44 degree. It is well known when the diffraction pattern peaks of a phase are replaced with the right position, it indicates that its crystal lattice has been contracted; This happens because an atom with a smaller radius has diffused and dissolved into its crystal structure. On the contrary, when the diffraction pattern shifts to the left position, it means the diffusion of an element with a larger atomic radius occurs and results in an expansion in the crystal lattice. Here, V (1.34 Å), has a smaller atomic radius than Ta (1.46 Å) and Hf (1.58 Å), and Zr (1.6 Å) has a higher atomic radius. It means that V resulted in the TaC crystal lattice being contracted and adversely, Hf, Zr, and Ti resulted in it being expanded. So, the two peaks diffracted at 2 degree of 34.92 and 40.50 which replaced to the left position shows that the expansion effect of Hf, Zr, and Ti is more than the contraction effect of V. This issue is inverse for three other peaks diffracted at 58.64, 70.11 and 98.12. Also, this issue is completely following the mismatch factor () between two elements which is calculated through Eq. (9). XRD analysis of the both I and II layers of HEC/ME-ISB two-layer composite. XRD analysis of (a) HEC layer as well as pure TaC (00–019-1292), HfC, ZrC, TiC, and VC pattern, (b) in higher magnification in 34 to 44 degrees specified with dashed brown color in a and (c) TaC peaks with replacement to the right and left position specified with dashed black color in a and b (regions 1, 2 and 3). In which, ai is the lattice parameter of diffused element and a is the lattice parameter of the host element; considering the lattice parameters of Ti, 0.3276, V, 0.3024, Hf, 0.352, Zr, 0.3589 and Ta, 0.3301334, the of each Ti, V, Hf, and Zr with Ta was obtained − 7.66%, −8.39%, 6.62%, and 8.71% respectively. Finally, the total mismatch factor, was obtained 7.67% as a result of the dissolution of three Hf, Zr, and Ti elements in TaC. The positive sign indicates the expansion of the TaC lattice crystal, which is completely consistent with its XRD pattern for the two peaks shifted to the left position (regions 1 and 2 specified with dashed black color in Fig. 7b and higher magnification in the Fig. 7c). However, the replacement of the three other TaC peaks to the right position, indicates that V is a dominant dissolution element in TaC rather than Hf, Zr, and Ti due to it having a smaller atomic radius than Ta. To analyze the displacement of TaC peaks, the strain in these peaks is calculated using the Scherrer and Williamson-Hall methods for peaks shifted to the right and left. The results, including the crystallite sizes, are presented in Table 4. The strain values created in the HEC layer (for TaCL) were obtained by Sc and W-H methods as 0.35 ± 0.08 and 2.02 ± 0.21, respectively, which can confirm the possibility of solid solution formation. As seen, the strain obtained by W-H is ≈ 1.67 higher than the Sc method; the higher strain in W-H compared to Sc also confirms that the strain created in the TaC lattice crystal is tension, or in other words, the TaC lattice has been expanded. The strain obtained in the Sc method is only due to the strain created in the crystallite size, but in W-H, it is caused by the total strain created in the crystallite size and crystal lattice. In addition, the lattice parameter of TaC was calculated by MAUD software equal to 4.468 Å which is higher than pure TaC (4.446 Å) and confirms this issue. The strain obtained 0.49% using lattice parameter obtained by MAUD software. Table 4The strain along with the crystallite of two layers according to Sc and W-H methods.Layer typeStrain, %ScStrain, % W-HCrystallite, nm, ScCrystallite, nm, W-HHEC layer0.35 ± 0.082.02 ± 0.21250 ± 34311 ± 36ME-ISB layer0.54 ± 0.150.40 ± 0.13150 ± 28230 ± 28 The strain along with the crystallite of two layers according to Sc and W-H methods. In addition to the formed solid solution, carbon, and TiSi2 phases have also been detected in this layer. The carbon phase can be related to the primary Gr that did not react with the primary materials during reactions (3) to (4) or due to the release of carbon during reactions (2) and (7). It was reported that a TaC tends to decompose to Ta4C3 and C through reaction (7)35. As mentioned before, TiSi2 identified in the diffraction pattern is formed during reaction (2) and improves sinterability through the liquid phase sintering mechanism. The XRD results of layer II show that no peaks associated with the initial powders of HfO2, ZrO2, and TiO2 can be detected. It means the initial oxide powders are consumed through reactions (3) and (5) and synthesized into the carbide or boride phases. This issue is completely consistent with the thermodynamic prediction presented in Fig. 4. As seen in Fig. 4, the reduction of oxide phases to the carbides or borides is feasible thermodynamically through reactions (3) and (5), at a temperature of 2000 °C. However, no carbide phases are identified in the XRD pattern of layer II. In addition, it can be seen that only the peaks of ZrB2 with some replacement are detected and no peaks related to the HfB2, and TiB2 can be identified in the diffraction pattern (Fig. 6); Hence, according to the XRD result (Fig. 6) and linear analysis (Fig. 5), it can be deduced, firstly, the initial oxide phases were synthesized to the boride phase via reaction (5) and secondly, Hf and Ti diffused and dissolved into ZrB2 crystal lattice and the formed a solid solution of (Zr1−2xHfxTix) B2 through reaction (11). In addition, regarding Fig. 4, the reduction of the oxide phases to the carbides is feasible thermodynamically through the reaction of (12). In other words, both boro/carbothermal and carbothermal reactions (4), (6) and (12) can occur in layer II thermodynamically but according to the XRD result (no carbide phases distinguished), only reaction (6) is happened. This issue can be associated with the lower starting temperature (1330 ◦C) and more negative ∆G (−153.4 kcal/mole) of reaction (6) rather than reaction (12) (TS=1560 ◦C, ∆G= −104.2 kcal/mole). Although the formation of (TiHfZr)B2 (reaction 6) is thermodynamically more favorable than reaction 12, kinetic factors and local reaction conditions play a critical role. If B₄C is not uniformly distributed or C.Bn is locally in excess, oxide powders may preferentially react with carbon to form carbide phases. The reaction between oxides and C.Bn proceeds with faster kinetics due to its simpler mechanism and lower activation barrier compared to reaction 5 and may occur as an intermediate pathway. If the temperature or holding time is insufficient, oxides phases may not fully convert to boride phases and could remain as a residual phase in the final product. Considering the high temperature selected in this study (2000 °C), the sufficient reaction time, and the XRD results (Fig. 5), it appears that reaction (12) either did not occur or, if it did, its extent was so minimal (less than 2%) that it could not be detected by XRD analysis. The evolution of CO gas during reductions 6 and 12 significantly influences reaction kinetics and microstructure. In the reaction 12, CO release occurs more uniformly due to the simpler reaction pathway, minimizing porosity and maintaining effective particle contact. In contrast, the more complex reaction 6 may lead to localized CO accumulation, increased porosity, and reduced interparticle connectivity, thereby slowing reaction progress. For a detailed examination of layer II (ME-ISB), the peaks with the diffraction pattern of pure compounds HfB2, ZrB2, and TiB2 as well as the XRD pattern of layer II, were investigated (Fig. 7a). As seen, TiB2 peaks are approximately removed and no peaks have remained in the diffraction pattern (shown with the red point in Fig. 7d). It was found through twelve identified peaks (possibility for solid solution), ten peaks belong to the ZrB2 with some replacement which eight of them were shifted to the right position and two remained were shifted to the left position (2 angles of 25.66 and 33.03); The 8 peaks shifting to the right position, indicate that the Hf and Ti with lower atomic radius than Hf were diffused and dissolved in Zr crystal lattice and resulted to contract it and finally replaced its peaks to the right position (Fig. 7b). However, with careful investigation of the two remaining peaks diffracted at 2 angles of 25.66 and 33.03 (Figure c), it was found that it is not reasonable that they belong to the ZrB2 due to their shifting to the left position based on the mentioned atomic radius of Hf, Zr, and Ti. Since the XRD patterns of HfB2 and ZrB2 are very close to each other and they are overlapped, their identification from each other is difficult. Here, based on the replacement direction, we can conclude that these two peaks belong to the HfB2 phase (not ZrB2) with some replacement (one of them to the left position, 25.66, and another to the right position, 33.03). Shifting to the left position originates from the Zr and Ti diffusion into the HfB2 lattice, (with dominant Zr diffusion) because Zr has a higher atomic radius than Hf. Finally, for HfB2 peaks shifted to the right position, it can be deduced that the Zr and Ti diffused into the HfB2 lattice (with dominant Ti diffusion a lower atomic radius and resulted in contracting its crystal lattice and shifting to the right position (Fig. 8c). So, it may be concluded that the solid solution formed in the eight peaks belonging to ZrB2 is with (Zr1−2xHfxTix) B2, and for the two remaining peaks belonging to HfB2 is (Hf1−2xZrxTix) B2. The XRD patterns of (a) ME-ISB layer as well as pure HfB2, ZrB2, and TiB2, magnification in (b) 58–66 degrees, (c) 32–42 degrees, and (d) 25–45 degree. As reported in Table 4, it is seen the crystallite size calculated with both Sc and W-H is smaller in the ME-ISB layer in comparison with HEC. This result is completely compatible with the grain size obtained for them (430 ± 150 nm for HEC and 200 ± 100 nm for ME-ISB, Table 3). Also, FESEM images of these layers confirm this issue clearly (Fig. 3). Figures 9 and 10 show the images of the element distribution map in the first and second layers of the two-layer composite. It can be seen that in both layers, the distribution of elements (except carbon) in the microstructure is almost uniform, which indicates their diffusion into each other and the possibility of the solid solution formation. Element distribution map of the first layer (five components) of carbide/oxide double-layer composite. X-ray mapping for element distribution of the second layer (tri-component) of the carbide/oxide double-layer composite. Hardness The hardness values of both layers are reported in Table 3. It can be seen that the carbide layer has a much higher hardness (≈ 15 GPa) than the oxide layer (≈ 1.2 GPa). FESEM images (Fig. 3) of both layers, relative density values (Table 3) plus the created indentation effect (Fig. 10) confirms this issue. The carbide layer has an almost complete relative density, while the oxide layer contains about 23% porosity, and since the porosity has no resistance against the applied force, it has caused a significant reduction in the hardness of the oxide layer. This is also clear in Fig. 11. The indents are created in both layers under the same applying force, while the average diameter of their effect created in the carbide layer (about 200 microns) is much smaller than the oxide layer (about 500 microns), which indicates the oxide layer has a lower hardness in compared to the carbide layer. FESEM images of the indented effect created in (a) HEC and (b) ME-ISB layers. High-entropy ceramics composed of (Hf, Zr, Ti, Ta, Nb) C were successfully synthesized via hot pressing (HP) at temperatures as low as 1850 °C, utilizing powders prepared through a two-step high-energy ball milling (HEBM) and chemical treatment route (CTR). The Vickers hardness, evaluated under a 4.9 N load, rose from 23.7 ± 0.3 GPa to 24.8 ± 0.8 GPa as the sintering temperature increased from 1750 °C to 1900 °C, likely as a result of enhanced densification and higher relative density at elevated temperatures) from 95% at 1750 °C to 99.3% at 1900 °C36(which is higher than this research. By comparing the results of this study with reference36, it is observed that although the current work exhibits higher relative density and finer grain size than reference36, the resulting hardness is lower. This discrepancy can be attributed to the formation of a secondary titanium disilicide phase in the present study. In contrast, the formation of a single-phase solid solution without any secondary phases in reference36 likely contributed to its higher hardness compared to the current work. Another contributing factor to the reduced hardness observed in this study may be the higher applied load during Vickers hardness testing (20 kg) compared to reference36, where a lower load of 500 g was used; Because the hardness decreases with applied force. In another study37 the hardness of 17.07 ± 0.54 GPa was reported for (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)C single phase synthesized in 1800 °C (15 min) + 2000 °C (0.5 min) which approximately is accordance with present research with hardness of 15 GPa in carbide layer. Seven equimolar, five-component, metal diborides were fabricated via high-energy ball milling and spark plasma sintering. The hardness of samples was obtained in the range of 17.5 ± 1.2 GPa to 23.7 ± 1.7 GPa which higher than this research. This difference is related to the very high amount of porosities (23%) in boride layer in this research rather than reference38( Also in reference39,40, samples (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Mo₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Mo₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, (Hf₀.₂Mo₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, (Mo₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Cr₀.₂Ti₀.₂)B₂, possess virtually one solid-solution boride phase of the hexagonal AlB2 structure while in this research beside the single HEB phase, some carbon was remained which can has negative effect of the hardness. The measured hardness of approximately 1.2 GPa in the boride layer is notably low and can be attributed to several interconnected factors: 1) Complex Multiphase Composition: The boride layer is not a simple monolithic structure but a reactive composite containing various phases, including oxides (HfO₂, ZrO₂, TiO₂-derived), B₄C, C.Bn, and potential reaction products. These diverse components, especially the presence of oxides and carbon, significantly influence the material’s mechanical response compared to pure borides. 2) Residual Porosity: Despite high-pressure, high-temperature sintering, a porosity of about 23% was quantified. This residual porosity, likely due to short processing times and exothermic reactions, substantially softens the material. Using an empirical model (H = H0 exp(-bP))41, where H is measured hardness (1.2 GPa), P is porosity (0.23), and b is a sensitivity parameter (typically 4–7), the intrinsic hardness (H0) of a fully dense composite is estimated to be between 3.0 and 6.0 GPa. However, this estimated H0 is still considerably lower than the typical hardness of monolithic borides (18–30 GPa), indicating porosity is not the sole cause of softening. 3) Amorphous or Soft Phases: The high processing temperature (2000 °C) combined with the reactant mixture could lead to the formation of soft, amorphous intergranular phases (e.g., borosilicates). Such phases can drastically lower hardness by enabling grain boundary sliding. Additionally, the presence of C.Bn, which has an intrinsic low hardness of ~ 0.5–1 GPa, acts as a soft constituent, further reducing the composite’s overall measured hardness26. 4) Indentation Effects: The indentation process on a multi-layered composite can be complex. If the indentation depth was significant or approached interfaces, it might induce cracking or delamination, especially given the presence of weak interfaces or porosity. This could lead to an artificially reduced apparent hardness measurement. Fracture toughness To investigate the fracture toughness of both layers, the crack length measurement method was used. According to Fig. 12b, it is clear that there are no cracks in the oxide layer, which is due to the very low hardness of this layer and its high porosity amount. This issue is consistent with the results reported in a previous study42 about composites with low hardness and high porosity amount. Therefore, no value is reported for the fracture toughness of the oxide layer in this research. The value of fracture toughness in the carbide layer was 6.2 MPam1/2. To investigate the hardening mechanism in this layer, FESEM images of crack propagation paths are presented in Fig. 12. By examining the path of crack propagation in the carbide layer, it was found that the activation of toughening mechanisms such as crack deflection, bridging, and grain breakage (Trasgranular fracture) is the reason for improving the toughness of the layer compared to the oxide layer. All of these mechanisms are indicated in Figs. 12a and b. FESEM images of two different crack propagation paths in the carbide layer. High-entropy ceramics (HEC) with the composition (Hf₀.₂Zr₀.₂Ta₀.₂Nb₀.₂Ti₀.₂)C submicron grain sizes 0.578 ± 0.217 m was synthesized via SPS using a two-stage sintering approach. Structural analysis through X-ray and neutron diffraction confirmed the formation of a single-phase material with a rock salt crystal structure. The fracture toughness of 5.9 ± 0.7 MPa m1/2 was obtained which is slightly lower than present study (6.2 MPa m1/2). This issue can be attributed to the smaller grain size of carbide layer in the present study rather than reference submicron37. Also, the only toughening mechanism was reported in reference37 was crack deflection while here, more toughening mechanisms were activated (crack bridging and crack deflection) which can explain the higher fracture toughness obtained in this research rather than37. Conclusion 1- Two-layer composite consisting HEC layer with the chemical composition of (TaHfZrTiV)C in the presence of Gr and Si additives and an ME-ISB with the chemical composition of (HfZrTi)B2 in the presence of C.Bn and B4C was successfully sintered by SPS at 2000 ◦C, holding time of 10 and under a pressure of 40 MPa. 2- Phase identification with XRD and elements distribution map using FESEM showed that a solid solution is formed in both layers. 3- The HEC layer with a relative density of 99.7% has better sinterability than the ME-ISB layer with a 78.4% relative density. 4- The HEC layer (≈ 15GPa) has a higher hardness than the ME-ISB layer (≈ 1.2 GPa). 5- By examining the path of crack propagation in the HEC layer, it was found that the activation of toughening mechanisms such as crack deflection, branching, and grain breakage is the reason for improving its toughness. Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the laboratory support provided by Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz Branch, throughout the experimental phase of this research. Author contributions Zohre Balak conducted the conception, measurements, manuscript composition, and writing, revised the manuscript and validated the data. Ekhlas Qays Al-shawway conducted the experimental design and measurement. The authors gratefully acknowledge the laboratory support provided by Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz Branch, throughout the experimental phase of this research. Data availability The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request (Corresponding Author’s Email address: zbalak@iau.ac.ir). Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request (Corresponding Author’s Email address: zbalak@iau.ac.ir).