Towards a unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics Authors: Mathieu Hénault, Lisa M. Wood, Lydia R. Heasley, Kent W. Hunter, Soni Lacefield, Kent W. Hunter, Soni Lacefield, Kent W. Hunter, Soni Lacefield Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Aneuploidies—whole-chromosome copy number imbalances arising from nondisjunction—underlie numerous congenital and somatic disorders, but unlike many other disease-causing variants, they can revert back to euploidy through subsequent errors of the same type. The extent to which this inherent plasticity impacts the stability and persistence of aneuploid karyotypes in populations remains poorly understood, a gap in knowledge that continues to limit our understanding of aneuploidy-driven disease incidence, penetrance, and progression. To assess how reversion shapes aneuploid population dynamics, we developed a budding yeast system to systematically measure the rates at which aneuploidies arise and revert and quantify the relative fitness differences between these karyotypic states. We integrated these data into a computational framework encompassing the broad physiological range of aneuploid karyotype dynamics captured in our experiments. The resulting models reveal that canonical reversion (i.e., subsequent secondary nondisjunction) occurs rarely, conferring a negligible effect on the population dynamics of most chromosomal aneuploidies. However, our models also identified that the reversion dynamics of some chromosomes—those displaying extremely high apparent rates of reversion—were more consistent with a coupled mutational process involving a transient aneuploid state. Whole-genome sequencing and live-cell microscopy demonstrates one such mechanism is facilitated by unresolved intermolecular linkages that disrupt chromosome segregation, leading to chromosome breakage and recombination-mediated repair over subsequent cell divisions. Collectively, this work advances a model of aneuploid population genetics and expands our perspective of the diverse, and chromosome-specific, mutational mechanisms shaping genome architecture. Introduction The functional relevance of any novel genetic variation depends not only on the phenotypic effect it induces, but on its capacity to persist in the population. For most variants, persistence is primarily determined by the rates at which they arise (μ) and their relative fitness (ω). Yet the variants most likely to exert the strongest phenotypic effects—whole-chromosome copy number variations (i.e., aneuploidies)—are additionally constrained by a third factor: reversion. Arising through mitotic or meiotic nondisjunction events, aneuploidies can impart profound physiological changes to cells by simultaneously altering the dosage of hundreds to thousands of genes. Aneuploidies underlie numerous pathological states and adaptive processes, ranging from constitutional conditions like Down syndrome [1], to tumorigenesis [2,3], to the emergence of antimicrobial drug resistance [4]. But these aneuploid states are inherently unstable in dividing populations; each subsequent mitotic cell division carries an intrinsic risk of nondisjunction, providing aneuploid cells with opportunities to revert to euploidy or adopt new aneuploid karyotypes [5–11]. As such, and irrespective of any advantageous effects conferred by an aneuploid state, the associated phenotypes are ultimately only as stable as the underlying aneuploid genotype. Aneuploidy reversion has been documented in numerous experimental systems [7,9,12,13] and is generally described by a two-step sequential mutational framework predicated on the assumptions that a cell must first become aneuploid (step 1, A) before reverting (step 2, R), and that both aneuploid formation and reversion occur stochastically. Within this framework, models differ in their assertions about the likelihood of reversion. Since A and R both constitute nondisjunction of the same chromosome, the probability of R occurring could be expected to equal that of A (i.e., μA = μR), referred to here as the equal-likelihood model. By contrast, if A alters basal genome stability [14,15], the probability of subsequent nondisjunction events including R occurring may be increased or decreased (i.e., μA ≠ μR), referred to here as the unequal-likelihood model. Yet, which of these models most accurately captures observed dynamics of reversion, and the extent to which this relationship shapes population-level karyotypic diversity remains poorly understood. Empirically disentangling the effects of μA, μR, and ω on the observed frequency of an aneuploid karyotype has proven particularly challenging, since each determinant influences estimation of the others. Even studies using experimental approaches like mutation accumulation assays and fluctuation tests, which minimize the influence of ω on mutation rate estimates as compared to adaptive experimental evolution-type studies, have not explicitly accounted for the effects of ω and μR on the aneuploid cell counts observed, potentially confounding the derived estimates of μA [12,15–17]. Likewise, since the relative fitness (ω) of aneuploid cells is often lower than euploids, estimates of aneuploidy-associated fitness effects may be substantially distorted if the emergence of revertants (μR) is not considered [18–24]. Most recently, μR for three chromosomal aneuploidies in yeast was estimated with a system that accounted for fitness differences between the aneuploid and revertant states, but precluded parallel estimation of μA for the aneuploidies tested [9]. As it stands, a unified model incorporating the inherent ephemerality of aneuploid karyotypes into the complex interplay of factors governing their persistence in populations has not been established. Thus, our ability to anticipate the occurrence, stability, and functional implications of these important mutations remains fundamentally limited. To address this gap in knowledge, we systematically investigated aneuploidy reversion with an experimental system capable of integrating all major determinants of aneuploid frequency (μA, ω, μR). This approach allowed us to construct a comprehensive, quantitative model of aneuploid population dynamics and in doing so to identify and characterize a previously unidentified, non-canonical mutational mechanism that directly links the nondisjunction and rapid reversion of specific chromosomal aneuploidies. Results A genetic system to investigate aneuploidy dynamics in populations Although chromosome loss is typically lethal in haploids, it can be tolerated in diploids [12,15,25,26]. The resulting aneuploid state—called monosomy—can produce diverse effects on cellular physiology and fitness [2,10–12,14,15], and once established, can persist for many generations. However, monosomic cells can also revert to euploidy by acquiring a second copy of the remaining homologous chromosome, generating a genotype known as uniparental disomy (UPD) or whole chromosome loss of heterozygosity [12,13,27–29]. Although UPDs restore a balanced chromosomal copy number, they result in whole-chromosome homozygosis and are, themselves, associated with numerous recessive genetic disorders [13,15,27,30]. Given the important physiological implications of both monosomy and UPD, we focused our systematic analysis of aneuploidy frequency on this aneuploid-reversion pair using a tractable budding yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) system. To facilitate selective recovery and high-resolution mutational analyses of cells harboring monosomy or revertant UPD of each of the 16 yeast chromosomes, heterozygous diploid yeast strains were engineered as follows: for each pair of homologous chromosomes, two CAN1 gene cassettes were inserted at loci on each arm of one homolog and a violacein pigment operon [31] was inserted into the other homolog at a position allelic to one of the CAN1 cassettes (Fig 1A). Loss of CAN1 expression confers resistance to the toxic arginine analog canavanine (CANR), and this double-cassette architecture enriches for recovery of CANR clones arising from complete chromosome loss while reducing those that result from copy-neutral loss of heterozygosity (LOH), segmental deletion, or point mutation [15,26]. When populations of these parental strains were pregrown in nonselective conditions and then plated onto canavanine-containing media, spontaneously arising CANR colonies developed and resolved into two major phenotypic classes—light purple (parental-like) or dark purple—reflecting the copy number difference of the pigment operon between monosomic and revertant UPD clones. In most backgrounds, dark CANR colonies were also larger, a phenotype consistent with euploid revertants having higher predicted ω than monosomes (Fig 1B) [9]. A genetic reporter system clarifies variations in reversion frequency across chromosomes. A. A schematic describing the genotypic and phenotypic outcomes reported by the CAN1-VIO selectable yeast system. B. A representative image of light and dark CANR colonies derived from the Chr10 strain. C. WGS data signatures associated with the parental (diploid) strain, light CANR (monosomic) colonies, and dark CANR (revertant UPD) colonies. Each dot denotes a heterozygous allelic position; colors denote normalized depth of coverage (brown), and the allele frequencies of the CAN1-marked chromosome (light green) and VIO-marked chromosome (dark green). D. Per-chromosome quantifications of the normalized copy number estimates inferred from WGS analysis of light CANR clones (brown diamonds) and the revertant frequency derived from the monosome replating tests (green circles). E. A representative image of the sectoring phenotype displayed by the CANR derivatives of the chromosome strains that display higher levels of revertant mosaicism, in this case, Chr10. Black arrowhead denotes a revertant colony identified at day 2 of the test, white arrowheads denote sectors that emerged within light colonies later in the experimental timecourse. The high degree of heterozygosity existing between the homologs in these strains enabled us to use whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of independent light and dark CANᴿ clones to confirm the accuracy of this selectable system (S1 Fig and Table B in S1 Appendix). Light CANᴿ clones predominantly showed a monosomic signature of the expected chromosome—evidenced by whole-chromosome homozygosity and reduced read coverage—and dark CANᴿ clones primarily exhibited a UPD signature—evidenced by whole-chromosome homozygosity and diploid-level coverage (Fig 1C). This analysis also revealed recurrent, chromosome-specific, reversion patterns: whereas the affected chromosome in monosomic clones of Chr1, Chr2, Chr3, Chr5, Chr8, Chr9, Chr14, and Chr16 usually had the expected normalized copy number near 1 copy, all monosomic clones of Chr4, Chr10, Chr11, Chr12, Chr13, and Chr15 had a normalized copy number nearer to 2 copies (Fig 1D, brown diamonds). This suggested that, despite displaying the light colony color phenotype, the clones of this latter group were mosaic, with sizable revertant subpopulations already present at the time of sequencing. We validated the variable revertant mosaicism inferred from WGS by directly measuring the frequency of revertant cells in monosomic populations on a per-chromosome basis. Light monosomic CANR colonies isolated from independent canavanine plates were resuspended completely in water and diluted to single-cell density on rich media plates. After 2 days, dark revertant colonies were counted; total colony counts were quantified after 2 additional days, to accommodate the slower growth of monosomes (Fig 1E). Sequencing confirmed that the dark colonies recovered from these monosome-replating tests harbored the predicted revertant UPD genotype. In agreement with the WGS analysis, revertants were absent or very rare in populations of Chr1, Chr2, Chr3, Chr5, Chr8, Chr9, Chr10, Chr14, Chr15, and Chr16, but prevalent in populations of Chr4, Chr12, and Chr13 (Fig 1D, green circles). In both assessments of revertant frequency, Chr12 was a striking outlier: every sequenced light CANR clone showed a penetrant signature of UPD, and every replated population was almost entirely fixed by revertants (average revertant frequency, 99%). At the experimental endpoint of these replating tests, we noted variations in colony appearance further reflecting the diverse reversion dynamics of different chromosomes: though dark colonies quantified after 2 days were large and fully purple (Fig 1E, black arrowhead), many smaller monosomic colonies developed dark-purple sectors, indicating that reversions had occurred post-plating (Fig 1E, white arrowheads). This sectored morphology was most pronounced in CANR colonies from the Chr4, Chr10, Chr13, and Chr15 strains. A per-chromosome assessment of the fitness costs associated with monosomy The frequency of revertants in a monosome-derived population is determined by both the rate of reversion (μR) and the relative growth rates (ω) of monosomic and revertant cells. For example, the high frequency of revertants in Chr4 and Chr12 monosomic populations could reflect a high rate of reversion or the high relative fitness of revertants compared to their slower-growing monosomic predecessors. Conversely, the low frequency of revertants in Chr2 monosomic populations could result from a low rate of reversion or the similar fitness of monosomic and revertant cells. To distinguish between these possibilities on a per-chromosome basis, we measured ω of monosomic and euploid cells using two orthogonal liquid growth assays. In the first assay, light CANR populations were inoculated in replicate microwell rich media cultures and growth kinetics were assessed by optical density (OD). Because revertant subpopulations would distort estimates of ω, this approach was restricted to monosomes that consistently exhibited undetectable revertant frequencies by both WGS and monosome replating tests (Fig 2A, preselected monosomes). For the second assay, we engineered a new suite of strains that enabled measurement of ω immediately after monosomic cell formation. Hemizygous insertions of the inducible GAL1 promoter (GAL1p) were introduced adjacent to one centromere of each respective homologous pair (GAL1p-CEN)(Fig 2B) [13,32]. This cassette also encoded a URA3 gene, rendering cells prototrophic for uracil (URA+) but sensitive to the drug 5-FOA (FOAS) [33]. In dextrose-containing media, GAL1p is repressed, allowing the centromere to function normally to facilitate accurate spindle-mediated disjunction of the sister chromatid pair in mitosis. Induction of GAL1p in galactose-containing media disrupts centromere activity via constitutive transcription, specifically impairing kinetochore assembly and spindle-mediated disjunction of the URA3-GAL1p-CEN chromatid pair [34]. Consequently, the mother cell retains both copies, becoming a trisomic URA + /FOAS cell and producing a monosomic URA-/FOAR bud cell; the latter cell type can be enriched by selection in 5-FOA containing-media (Fig 2B). To eliminate pre-existing FOAR cells that could confound fitness measurements, populations were pregrown in media lacking uracil prior to induction with galactose. Induced cultures were then transferred into microwell cultures with dextrose- and 5-FOA-containing media to counterselect against the trisomic population and any residual uninduced disomic cells. The growth kinetics of the FOAR subpopulation generated was monitored by OD. For both assays, OD measurements were used to determine the average maximum slope of the logarithmic growth phase for each monosomic replicate and a euploid control, and ω was defined as the quotient of these values, respectively. Fitness costs associated with monosomy vary markedly across chromosomes. A. The ω values derived from the induced (light green) and preselected (dark green) growth assays for each chromosome B. A schematic describing the URA3-GAL1p-CEN monosome generation and enrichment approach. C. The deduced ω values measured from the induced (light green) and preselected (dark green) growth assays for each chromosome plotted according to chromosome size. Brown curve depicts the 95% confidence intervals produced from the simple linear regression of ω vs. chromosome size. Most monosomes, even those displaying severe growth defects, showed consistent cross-replicate growth kinetics throughout the experiment and uniform cell distributions at the bottom of the wells at the experimental endpoint (S2 Fig). In contrast, replicate cultures of monosomes of Chr4, Chr10, Chr12, Chr13, and Chr15 initially grew similarly, but became variable at later timepoints. Cell distributions within these wells were heterogeneous at the experiment’s end, reflecting a mixture of slow-growing and faster-growing subpopulations. Suspecting that these subpopulations consisted of revertants that had emerged soon after induction of monosomy and subsequently swept the population, we limited quantification of ω to the first 3–4 divisions of growth (S2 Fig, white area). Nonetheless, we cannot dismiss the possibility that high frequency reversion events compromised the accuracy of ω calculated for these specific chromosomes. In both assays, monosomy universally reduced relative fitness, though the costs incurred depended greatly on the chromosome affected (Fig 2A). These findings provide additional support for the widely accepted model that aneuploidies disrupt essential biosynthetic and metabolic pathways through gene dosage imbalances [4,18,19,22–24,35,36]. Consistent with the work of others, we identified a statistically significant correlation between ω and chromosome size (Fig 2C)(R2 = 0.42, p = 0.0175). We did not investigate the biological basis of this relationship in the present study, since it has been reported elsewhere [22]. The results of these experiments provided insight into the reversion patterns observed in our earlier experiments by establishing two central principles: 1) fitness influences aneuploid frequency, and 2) reversion probability differs across chromosomes. For example, monosomy of Chr2 confers a severe fitness defect (ω = 0.246) yet replated monosomic clones yielded almost no revertants (Fig 1D), indicating that μR is very low. In contrast, monosomes of Chr4, Chr12, and Chr13—despite displaying similarly severe fitness costs—produced high frequencies of revertants, indicating that they revert at markedly higher rates. Establishing an integrated framework of aneuploid karyotype population dynamics We proceeded to estimate per-chromosome rates of monosome formation (μA) and reversion (μR) using fluctuation assays [37,38]. For each CAN1-VIO strain, replicate populations were seeded into microwells containing rich media and expanded to saturation. The culture was then fully mixed and a fraction of each replicate was plated on canavanine-containing selective media to quantify CANR colonies, and a diluted fraction was plated on non-selective media to estimate total population size. Dark CANR revertants and light CANR monosomes were counted and scored after 2 and 4 days, respectively. To estimate mutation rates from the extant colony counts while also accounting for relative fitness differences between monosomic and euploid cells (both parental or revertant), we used the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) program mlemur [39]. Light CANR colony counts were used to estimate μA (Fig 3A). The resulting ω-adjusted μA values varied >10-fold—ranging from 1.20✕10-6 cell-1 gen-1 (Chr7) to 1.33✕10-5 cell-1 gen-1 (Chr12) (Fig 3A)—suggesting that yeast chromosomes are differentially subjected to processes which influence their individual rates of nondisjunction. Similar values were also obtained from orthologous fluctuation tests using populations pregrown on solid media (Tables G and H in S1 Appendix). Although chromosome size has been correlated with nondisjunction frequency in humans [40], no significant relationships between μA and chromosome size, chromosome arm length, genic-, or non-genic element content were identified (S3 Fig) [22]. Rates of aneuploidy and reversion generally conform to an unequal likelihood model. A. Per-chromosome rates of monosomy (μA) estimated from light CANR colony counts. B. Per-chromosome rates of reversion (μR) estimated from the monosome replating test revertant count data. C. Comparison between μA and μR. Horizontal and vertical bars indicate 95% confidence intervals of rate estimates. Dot color represents the average extant frequency of revertant cells in the replating tests from which μR values were computed. Dotted diagonal represents identity. D. Heatmaps showing the average extant frequency of revertant cells in 50 replicate simulated population expansions for each combination of input parameter values (μR and ωA). For each chromosome, simulated final population sizes were set to the average from the empirical replating tests. Outlined circles represent the empirical values for μR and ωA, and the circle fill color represents the empirically observed mean frequency of revertant cells. Horizontal lines denote the 95% confidence interval of the empirical μR. Solid and dotted curves denote the estimated 95% confidence interval for μR, respectively, fitted on empirical colony counts across the variable range of ω shown on the Y axis, representing the value computed for μR if there were an experimental error in the estimate of ωA. E. Comparison of the distributions of revertant frequencies across replicates of the simulated and empirical monosome replating tests. Individual circles denote outliers. Data are also presented as cumulative distribution curves in S6A Fig. Estimating μR required additional consideration. Since a cell must first become monosomic before reverting to form a dark CANR colony, the rate estimated from dark CANᴿ colony counts would typically be interpreted as the compound rate (μC) of these two sequential mutations: Additionally, because the populations subjected to the canavanine fluctuation tests were founded by diploid cells, dark CANᴿ revertant colonies could arise from two parallel mechanisms: reversion from monosomy or from trisomy (S4 Fig and S2 Appendix). Monosomic and trisomic karyotypic states form as reciprocal products of the same nondisjunction event; therefore, the rate of trisome formation is equivalent to μA. However, neither the relative fitness of trisomes (ωT) nor their rates of reversion (μT)—both of which would influence the frequency of extant dark CANR colonies—could be directly measured with this selectable-genetic system, precluding accurate estimation of μR. To circumvent these confounding issues, we instead estimated μR using the revertant colony counts quantified from the monosome replating tests. Because the populations subjected to the replating tests started with monosomic founders, the dynamics of reversion could be directly assessed without having to account for the parallel dynamics of trisomy. The resultant μR values varied 89-fold between chromosomes (4.02✕10-7(Chr2) to 3.58✕10-5 (Chr1)) (Fig 3B). For most chromosomes, reversion probability best fits an unequal likelihood model (μA ≠ μR): Chr2 and Chr10 had lower μR than μA (8.75-fold and 8.63-fold respectively), while Chr1, Chr9, Chr11, Chr13, Chr14, and Chr16 had higher μR than μA (2.74-fold to 25.03-fold). Only Chr3, Chr4, Chr8, and Chr15 show similar μA and μR values more indicative of an equal likelihood model of reversion (Fig 3C). In general, the consistently low values of μR indicate that chromosome loss does not substantially perturb genome stability in this organism, clarifying a central facet of aneuploid population dynamics: across the physiologically relevant range of μA, μR, and ω values measured in these experiments, reversion is a minor determinant of monosomic karyotype stability in populations. Estimation of μR for Chr12 was confounded by the near-complete sweep of revertants in all replicate monosomic populations. Revertant fixation violates an integral requirement of fluctuation assay-derived rate estimation: mutants must be rare enough that independent mutant lineages remain distinguishable within each population. This high revertant frequency permits at least two alternative interpretations: reversion from monosomy could occur through a single mechanism operating at an exceptionally high rate, or reflect the combined output of multiple parallel mechanisms. To distinguish between these possibilities, we developed fflucsim, a forward simulator of population mutational dynamics. fflucsim performs in silico fluctuation tests parameterized by user-specified values for all relevant variables (namely μA, μR, μT, ωA, ωT, and final population size) and explicitly tracks mutation events, mutant frequencies, and population genealogies. We validated that fflucsim accurately recapitulates standard mutational models by simulating population expansion across a broad range of mutation rate and relative fitness values, then benchmarking the known input rates against those estimated from output mutant counts using rSalvador [41] (S5 Fig). We used fflucsim to investigate whether the frequency of revertants observed in the monosome replating tests reflected one or multiple mechanisms. If revertants had emerged via a single mechanism, then fflucsim models parameterized solely by ω and μR should be sufficient to reproduce the observed frequencies. If multiple reversion mechanisms had contributed to the emergence of revertants, even models permitting very high μR values would fail to recapitulate the observed revertant abundance. We simulated replicate monosomic population expansions across the experimentally derived parameter space of ω and μR for each chromosome tested, then directly compared the simulated and observed revertant frequencies across the full range of input values. For most chromosomes (Chr1, Chr2, Chr3, Chr5, Chr8, Chr9, Chr10, Chr11, Chr14, Chr15, and Chr16), simulations parameterized with their empirically-derived μR and ω values produced revertant count distributions that closely matched the observed data; any deviations were fully attributable to minor errors in our empirical estimates of ω or μR (Fig 3D). In contrast, no combination of ω and μR—even μR values close to 1, which would constitute an essentially deterministic event—was sufficient to recapitulate the high frequency of revertants observed in the replated populations of Chr12 monosomes. In addition, the observed revertant frequency distributions for Chr4, Chr10, and Chr13 also differed from the simulated results (Fig 3E and S6 Fig), indicating that the reversion dynamics of Chr4, Chr10, Chr12, and Chr13 do not conform to the predictions of standard mutational models. Instead, they better support the interpretation that for these chromosomes, reversion occurs through multiple parallel mutational routes. Before investigating the molecular basis of these predicted alternative reversion pathways, we re-examined the canavanine fluctuation test results to evaluate the contribution of monosomic cell-derived reversion to the observed frequencies of dark CANR colonies. If dark CANR colonies arise solely from the reversion of monosomic and trisomic cells, then the compound rate of formation (μC) would be the sum of rates describing both two-step mutational processes (S4 Fig): With chromosome-specific μA and μR values determined, we inferred the per-chromosome compound rates of monosomic cell-derived reversion (μA+R = μA ✕ μR) and compared the resulting values to the rates estimated directly from the dark CANR colony counts (μC) (Fig 4A). The resulting μA+R values were ~2–5 orders of magnitude lower than μC, indicating that reversion from monosomy had contributed minimally to the occurrence of dark CANR colonies in the tested populations. This result suggested that the majority of observed revertants derived from trisomic cells, reflecting either their increased relative fitness (ωT) or higher reversion rates (μT). Higher ωT values would result in greater expansion of trisomic subpopulations, thereby increasing the opportunity for reversion events to occur. Alternatively, if trisomic karyotypes are more genetically unstable, reversion could occur at higher rates than in monosomic cells (μT ≫ μR). To explore these possibilities quantitatively, we again used fflucsim, this time simulating the expansion of populations founded by diploid ancestors. These simulations incorporated 5 parameters: empirically determined values of ωA, μA and μR, and a broad range of hypothetical values of ωT and μT. We compared the frequency of revertant CANR cells produced by these simulations to the actual values observed in the CANR fluctuation tests (Fig 4B). These results demonstrate that for most chromosomes, μT values in the range of 10-3-10-1 cell-1 gen-1 would be necessary to produce frequencies of dark CANR cells compatible with our experimental results (Fig 4B, white cells). However, the limited experimental data available indicate that trisomic cells are less fit than euploids (ωT < 1) [16,24], meaning that μT values approaching 1 would often be required to reconcile our observations with model outputs. To our knowledge, such values of μT would be orders of magnitude higher than any aneuploidy rate yet reported and incompatible with previous observations demonstrating the prevalence and long-term stability of trisomic karyotypes in wild populations of yeast [12,20,25,42]. Instead, these results provide additional support for the existence of one or more alternative mechanisms that generate revertant UPD karyotypes. Crucially, both our experimental data and forward simulations indicate that these mechanisms 1) need not proceed through a stable aneuploid intermediate (monosomic or trisomic) and 2) may operate at effective rates or with mutational dynamics which render them poorly described by the constant-rate assumptions underlying standard mutational models. Empirical revertant frequencies are not fully described by reversion from intermediate aneuploid states. A. Trisomic cells are produced as reciprocal products of the same aneuploidy event. Monosomic cells can revert to a disomic karyotype at rate μR, while trisomic cells revert to a disomic karyotype at rate μT. B. Heatmaps show the fits of the revertant CANR cell frequencies derived from the experimental and simulated fluctuation assays. Cell color corresponds to the ratio of the mean revertant CANR cell frequency in 50 replicate simulated populations and the empirical frequency for each combination of input parameter values (μT and ωT); see heatmap legend at bottom right. The empirical estimates were specified for the parameters: μA, μR and ωA. For each chromosome, simulated final population sizes were set to the average from the CANR fluctuation assays. Dots mark parameter combinations for which no viable revertant cell was produced across all 50 simulated replicates, and were substituted by a lower bound frequency corresponding to a single viable revertant cell in a single replicate. Alternative mutational mechanisms facilitate generation of revertant karyotypes To better understand the alternative reversion mechanisms implicated by our rate analyses, we performed a focused molecular characterization of reversion events guided by several observations from the WGS analysis of light and dark CANR clones. Unlike most light CANR colonies—in which only the copy number of the expected chromosome was affected—each clone from the Chr6 and Chr7 strains carried 1–13 additional unselected karyotypic alterations, many of which were mosaic within the sequenced population (Fig 5A and Table B in S1 Appendix). This precluded accurate assessments of both monosome fitness and reversion dynamics, and instead typified a mutational signature called chromosomal instability (CIN)—a mutator phenotype defined by the constitutive, high frequency accumulation of aneuploidies and other structural variations [21,43,44]. Indeed, aneuploidies of Chr6 are known to induce CIN because copy number imbalances of Chr6 resident genes ACT1 (actin) and TUB2 (beta-tubulin) disrupt spindle assembly and positioning, increasing nondisjunction rates [14,21,45–47] (S2 Appendix). In contrast, the dark CANR clones recovered from the same cultures had acquired only the predicted UPD, with none of the additional karyotypic alterations harbored by their matched light counterparts (Fig 5B). Given the high aneuploid burden and ongoing instability present in the light clones, it is improbable that they were the direct predecessors of the dark clones, particularly within the generational limits of our experiments. Rather, these genotypic patterns imply that revertant UPDs can also arise by mechanisms that bypass a stable aneuploid intermediate state. One proposed mechanism, called reciprocal UPD, posits that intermolecular DNA- or protein-based linkages persisting between homologs in mitosis may facilitate their simultaneous nondisjunction, producing daughter cells each carrying a UPD of one homolog [30]. Yet, direct evidence demonstrating that intermolecular linkages are sufficient to drive cooperative missegregation of multiple chromosomes has remained limited. Disomic revertant karyotypes develop independent of a stable aneuploid intermediate state. A. and B. Representative WGS mappings of light and dark CANR clones derived from the Chr6 CAN1-VIO strain. Each dot denotes a heterozygous allelic position; colors denote normalized depth of coverage (brown), and the allele frequencies of the CAN1-marked chromosome (light green) and VIO-marked chromosome (dark green). Vertical dashed lines delineate centromeric positions. Trisomy of Chr1, denoted with the asterisk, is a preexisting aneuploidy present in the parental Chr6. C. A heatmap of allele frequency at each parental heterozygous position to illustrate the pericentromere-biased breakpoint positions observed in recombinant dark CANR clones. D. A representative Chr4-specific WGS mapping of a dark CANR colony recovered from the Chr4 CAN1-VIO strain displaying the characteristic pericentromeric breakpoints and heterozygosity. Each dot denotes a heterozygous position; color denotes the CAN1-marked chromosome (light green) and VIO-marked chromosome (dark green). E. A schematic illustrating the predicted mechanism and outcomes of a sister-sister intermolecular linkage mediated missegregation event. F. A schematic of the single CAN1-VIO cassette Chr12 strain. G. Quantification of the karyotypic spectra harbored by CANR clones derived from the single-cassette strain. H. Chr12-specific whole-chromosome or centromere-proximal WGS mappings of a recovered trisomic CANR colony. Another karyotypic pattern captured in the WGS analysis provided insight into the plausibility of such a linkage-driven model of aneuploidy generation: while most dark CANR clones harbored a typical UPD, ~ 10% harbored a disomic genotype defined by a short heterozygous tract spanning the centromere and bounded by pericentromeric breakpoints (Fig 5C). Dark CANR clones from the Chr4 strain exhibited a pronounced enrichment for this genotype (8/10 sequenced clones) (Fig 5D), a finding that was particularly surprising given that the CAN1 markers on Chr4 were separated by more than 750kb and positioned at least 300kb from the centromere in either direction. In principle, such molecules could form via independent, sequential recombination events on each arm, but this mechanism would not explain the pericentromeric breakpoint clustering we observed. Similarly, although centromeric gene conversion—in which breaks in one homolog’s centromere are repaired using sequence from the other [48]—can generate recombinant molecules, the resulting breakpoint patterns are distinct from those observed in dark CANR clones. Instead, their breakpoint bias more closely resembles the mutational signature generated by the break–fusion–bridge cycles of dicentric chromosomes [49–51]. Previous studies have shown that when dicentric chromosomes are engaged by microtubules emanating from opposite spindle poles in mitosis, they are broken during cytokinesis, typically at positions near one of the centromeres [49,52,53]. Although neither WGS nor the visible phenotypes of these recombinant clones indicated the presence of dicentric molecules undergoing iterative cycles of breakage and repair, the similarity in breakpoint distribution suggested the existence of alternative molecular scenarios in which two centromeres would behave as though physically linked. We reasoned that sister chromatids, homologs, or even nonhomologous chromosomes connected by persistent intermolecular linkages during mitosis could mimic the missegregation dynamics of a dicentric molecule and result in the formation of the recombinant products recovered in the CANR clones [49,51,54–60]. One variation of this model—in which such linkages persist between sister chromatids—is illustrated in Fig 5E. If intermolecularly linked sisters segregate to opposite spindle poles during mitosis, the persistent linkages between them will form DNA bridges during anaphase. Left unresolved, this bridged DNA will be severed during cytokinesis [49,54,56,61]. The resulting daughter cells will inherit complementary fragments of the linked pair: one retaining only the centromeric fragment, the other retaining the distal arm fragments together with the intact sister chromatid (Fig 5E). In the next cell cycle, homology-templated repair of these fragments would generate recombinant chromosomes [56]. Repair of the centromere-containing fragment using the homolog as the template would yield a homologous pair that retains heterozygosity near the centromere but is homozygous along the arms—precisely the signature displayed by the recombinant CANR clones (Fig 5C-D). Oppositely, repair of the arm fragments using either the sister chromatid or the homolog as a template would result in trisomy or tetrasomy, with at least one molecule potentially containing sequences derived from both homologs. Under this model, and constrained by the positioning of the dual CAN1 cassettes in our system, clones that inherited the centromeric fragment were more likely to be recovered by CANR selection than the reciprocal trisomic or tetrasomic products, since these latter products would likely retain at least one CAN1 cassette and fail to form colonies on canavanine-containing media. Indeed, in the > 500 CANR clones sequenced in this study, only a few recombinant trisomes displayed the allelic pattern predicted in Fig 5C. Thus, to more rigorously test this model, we engineered a new strain in which the homologs of Chr12 harbored either a single CAN1 or pigment cassette ~131kb from the centromere and 19kb from the left telomere (Fig 5F). This positioning increased the likelihood of recovering recombinant trisomic products, although most dark CANR clones were expected to harbor simple copy-neutral LOH tracts that eliminated the CAN1 cassette and duplicated the pigment operon. Indeed, 77.7% (35/45) of dark CANR clones recovered harbored short terminal tracts of LOH near the chromosome end (Fig 5G). However, the other 22.2% harbored aneuploidies of Chr12—both UPD and trisomy. Consistent with the predictions of the intermolecular linkage model, every trisomic clone contained at least one recombinant molecule with pericentromeric breakpoints (Fig 5H and S7 Fig). In addition, many displayed complex recombination patterns including LOH across all three molecules or intermediate allele frequencies reflecting mosaicism within the sequenced populations. Both suggest that generation of the recombinant trisome may have involved multiple broken molecules or repair templates, or the production of unstable recombinant products [62,63]. The recombinant patterns exhibited by the disomic and trisomic CANR clones are consistent with a model in which intermolecular linkages between molecules can coordinate their missegregation, leading to breakage and subsequent repair by homologous recombination. Yet, these results did not formally exclude alternative mechanisms such as sequential recombination or centromeric gene conversion. Nor could these CANR systems directly test a central assumption of the model: that bipolar mitotic attachment is necessary to orient linked molecules in a way that drives their breakage and subsequent recombinant product formation. We used the URA3-GAL1p-CEN strains to test this assumption. In yeast, forces generated by the elongating anaphase spindle are required to drive chromosome translocation through the bud neck constriction into the bud cell [64–66]. Conditional centromere inactivation—via GAL1p induction—prevents kinetochore assembly and thus coupling of these segregation forces to the specific pair of sister molecules harboring the URA3-GAL1p-CEN cassette, resulting in their retention in the mother cell. In this controlled context, only monosomic bud cells arising from divisions in which the URA3-GAL1p-CEN sister pair remained unsegregated in the mother cell would be predicted to manifest a FOAR phenotype (Fig 2A). Alternatively, recovery of FOAR cells harboring a recombinant product of the inactivated chromosome would indicate that its formation occurs independently of direct spindle-mediated segregation, but coincident with segregation of the remaining chromosomes. We assessed these possibilities by plating galactose induced populations of URA3-GAL1p-CEN strains to solid 5-FOA containing media, allowing FOAR colonies to develop, and isolating individual clones for characterization by WGS (Fig 6A). Recombinant chromosome generation coincides with chromosome segregation. A. Schematic of the centromere inactivation assay. B. A representative Chr4-specific WGS mapping of a FOAR colony recovered from the URA3-GAL1p-CEN4 strain that displays pericentromeric breakpoints. C. A heatmap of allele frequency at each parental heterozygous position illustrating the pericentromere-biased breakpoint positions observed in FOAR clones. D. A schematic illustrating the predicted mechanism and outcomes of an intermolecular linkage event that generates an FOAR daughter cell bearing the recombinant genotypes shown in B. and C. Consistent with our previous results (Fig 1D), most sequenced FOAR clones exhibited stable monosomic or revertant mosaic signatures. Yet, 19% displayed a recombinant disomic signature typified by centromere-proximal breakpoints, with Chr4 again overrepresented among this group (4/10 sequenced clones)(Fig 6B and 6C). This recombinant genotype resembled the one displayed by the CANR clones, with one key difference: whereas CANR recombinant chromosome pairs retained heterozygosity only near the centromere, FOAR recombinant pairs were homozygous in the pericentromeric region but retained heterozygosity along the length of the chromosome arms (Fig 6B and 6C). Such products could only arise if the arm segments of an inactivated chromatid were segregated into the bud cell—a process that, to our knowledge, cannot occur in the absence of spindle-generated force. Rather, this result implies that bipolar spindle-generated forces were transmitted to the inactivated chromatid by an indirect mechanism, the most parsimonious being via linkage to actively segregating chromosomes (Fig 6D). As illustrated in Fig 6D, a possible outcome of this type of event would be the breakage and partial inheritance of the inactivated chromatid. The daughter cell inheriting the arm fragments would become FOAR if those fragments were repaired using the homolog as a template, generating a pair of chromosomes precisely displaying the recombinant signature observed in the FOAR clones. This result refines a central principle of the intermolecular linkage model: while mitotic chromosome segregation is necessary for recombinant molecule formation, the direct segregation of linked partners is not. Intermolecular linkages can sufficiently transfer the forces necessary to establish a chromosomal architecture that will result in breakage and asymmetric inheritance of the linked molecules. 22% of sequenced FOAR Chr12 clones were typified not by pericentromeric breakpoints, but by a breakpoint within the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) array on the right arm instead (S8 Fig). Due to the homotypic and repetitive architecture of the rDNA array, we were unable to define the precise location of these breakpoints. Like the Chr12 trisomic clones (Fig 5F-G), these clones usually displayed mosaic coverage and allele frequencies, indicating the existence of multiple distinct molecules of Chr12. Such patterns are consistent with a model in which intermolecular linkages within the rDNA lead to chromosome breakage during mitosis [56], and that repair of these fragments may occur through a process yielding diverse molecular outcomes. Notably, in addition to the selected chromosomal aneuploidy, 19% of FOAR clones derived from the other URA3-GAL1p-CEN strains also harbored terminal tracts of LOH originating in the rDNA and extending to the right telomere. Elevated incidence of LOH distal to the rDNA has been widely observed in yeast [28,42,67–69] The coincidence of this independent mutation with the recombinant reversion of other chromosomes suggests that the rDNA may be a hotspot for persistent linkage formation (S8 Fig). Although the URA3-GAL1p-CEN system generates a mitotic scenario that would rarely occur in wild-type cells—because an unattached chromatid pair typically results in a mitotic checkpoint-mediated cell cycle arrest until attachment is achieved [70,71]—it constituted a valuable tool to further probe the validity of the intermolecular linkage model. Next, we used time-lapse fluorescence microscopy to visualize the segregation dynamics of CEN4 throughout mitosis in dextrose- and galactose-containing media [72,73]. Into the URA3-GAL1p-CEN4 strain, a multicopy tetO array was introduced adjacent to the GAL1p-CEN4 cassette, along with fluorescently-tagged alleles of the tetO-binding protein (TetR-GFP) and alpha tubulin (mRuby-Tub1). Proliferating populations were imaged over time and the CEN4 disjunction dynamics in mitosis were assessed in each condition. As expected, 100% of observed CEN4 disjunction events (59/59) occurred normally in dextrose-containing media: the duplicated tetO loci localized between the spindle poles in prometaphase and, at anaphase onset, remained closely associated with the spindle poles as they separated into the mother and bud cells (Fig 7A and S1 Movie). In galactose-containing media, we expected to see two disjunction phenotypes: 1) normal disjunction in cells that had not sufficiently inactivated CEN4 [74], and 2) inactivation-mediated nondisjunction, in which both tetO loci dissociated from the spindle throughout mitosis and remained unsegregated within the mother cell (Fig 7B and S2 Movie). Indeed, we observed these behaviors in 28.3% (17/60) and 55% (33/60) of dividing cells, respectively. However, we also observed alternative segregation events affecting tetO pairs that were clearly dissociated from the spindle at the time of anaphase onset (Fig 7C-D and S3 and S4 Movies). In 6.6% of dividing cells, both tetO loci segregated into the bud cell (Fig 7C, Alternative Type 1). Unlike normal disjunction—in which the centromeres remain closely juxtaposed to the poles as the spindle elongates—the tetO loci in these cells showed no directed poleward movement at anaphase onset. Only late in anaphase, when the spindle reached its maximum length, did the two tetO loci abruptly translocate into the bud cell (Fig 7C). Chromosome missegregation occurs independently of direct spindle attachments. A.-D. Representative time-lapse image series (left) and interpretive schematic and quantitation (right) of URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cells expressing TetR-GFP and Tub1-mRuby2: A. a cell in dextrose-containing media progressing normally through mitosis, B.-D. cells in galactose-containing media displaying (B.) the expected nondisjunction of the inactivated chromosome pair encoding, (C.) Alternative Type 1 missegregation in which both inactivated chromosomes segregate into the bud cell (D.), or Alternative Type 2 missegregation in which the inactivated molecules migrate into the budneck region prior to cytokinesis. The red budneck delineation denotes the completion of mother-bud cell separation by cytokinesis as assessed by brightfield imaging. Scale bars, 2μM. In approximately 10% of cells, one or both tetO loci migrated to the bud neck region before moving either into the bud cell or back into the mother cell (Fig 7D, Alternative Type 2). Two distinct behaviors were observed at this stage. In some cases, bud neck localization was transient and culminated in rapid movement of a tetO locus into either compartment at the time of cytokinesis, resembling the dynamics of dicentric chromosome severing [49]. In other cases, tetO loci remained at the bud neck for extended periods and drifted slowly back into the cell interior only after cytokinesis had occurred (Fig 7D). TetO pairs displaying these alternative segregation patterns lacked any detectable colocalized Nuf2, an outer kinetochore protein required for microtubule binding (S9 Fig), again demonstrating that their bud-cell directed movements occurred independently of direct spindle attachment but concurrent with chromosome segregation. To determine whether intermolecular linkages with actively segregating chromosomes facilitated these alternative tetO segregation behaviors, we repeated this experiment using a strain expressing a fluorescently tagged histone (Htb2-TdTomato) and analyzed the chromatin dynamics in Alternative Type 2 cells. Consistent with the intermolecular linkage model, 100% displayed chromatinized DNA bridges spanning the dividing nuclei and encompassing at least one tetO locus for variable durations—this was never observed in cells exhibiting normal segregation dynamics (Fig 8A). Transient, rapid movement of tetO loci into the bud neck coincided with bridge resolution (Fig 8B and S5 Movie), indicating that these bridges consisted of chromatin linking at least one unattached tetO-bearing chromatid to a chromosome that had segregated into the bud cell. As is shown in Fig 8B, only after the abrupt, late-stage translocation of one tetO locus through the bud neck does the chromatin bridge which spanned the dividing nuclei for the duration of anaphase finally resolve (Fig 8B, black arrowhead, 18’). Prolonged localization of tetO loci at the bud neck reflected a distinct chromatin architecture and mode of bridge resolution, which occurred only at cytokinesis through the apparent severing of chromatin proximal to the bud neck. In 38% of cases, this process generated a chromatin fragment containing at least one tetO locus; this fragment was never reincorporated into the primary nuclear compartment of the inheriting daughter cell but instead remained cytoplasmically separated throughout the subsequent cell cycle. In the example shown in Fig 8C, both tetO loci are encompassed within the chromatin bridge, although their relative positions with respect to the bud neck differ. In this instance, the orientation of the tetO loci and the Htb2 signal suggests that the unattached tetO-bearing chromatids may be linked both to one another and to chromosomes that have segregated into each cell. Following cytokinesis, the tetO locus positioned closest to the bud neck resolves into a new, chromatinized compartment in the mother cell, leaving the bud cell devoid of this CEN4-adjacent DNA fragment (Fig 8C and S6 Movie). Together, these observations demonstrate that intermolecular linkages promote centromere-proximal breakage and loss of centromere-bearing DNA, leading to daughter cells with incomplete or damaged chromosomes. These findings directly support our proposed mechanism of recombinant CANR and FOAR clone formation (Fig 8D). Chromatin bridges and chromosome fragmentation coincide with alternative missegregation events. A.-C. Representative time-lapse image series of URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cells expressing TetR-GFP and Htb2-tdTomato that exhibit: A. normal segregation of the CEN4-tetO locus and resolution of the dividing nuclei, B., alternative CEN4-tetO segregation and persistence of a long-lived chromatin bridge that resolves only after the rapid translocation of one tetO locus into the bud cell, and C., alternative CEN4-tetO segregation and persistence of a chromatin bridge that resolves to form a tetO-containing chromosome fragment. Time-stamps (in minutes) are relative to the first frame of the displayed series. Arrowheads denote the two tetO loci. D. A schematic illustrating the observed chromatin dynamics and predicted molecular outcomes of the alternative missegregation even displayed in C. Scale bars, 2μM. Discussion The inherent reversibility of aneuploid karyotypes has long been recognized, yet the impacts on population-level dynamics have remained difficult to discern. Here we empirically quantified the occurrence, associated fitness effects, and reversibility of monosomic karyotypes. We developed new mutational models with which to integrate these data, yielding a unified framework of the determinants of aneuploid karyotype diversity and stability in populations. Because we evaluated monosomies of multiple different chromosomes, this framework encompasses the physiologically relevant range of rates and fitness coefficients associated with aneuploidy in S. cerevisiae, enabling us to articulate general principles of aneuploidy dynamics and to resolve additional mutational mechanisms that impact the basal stability and inheritance of chromosomes in unperturbed conditions. A primary goal of this study was to define how reversion constrains aneuploid karyotype stability. We find that the dynamics of canonical 2-step reversion are generally explained by an unequal likelihood mutational model: a cell loses a chromosome and then, via a subsequent random nondisjunction event, reverts to a disomic state. Reversion rates varied across chromosomes but were uniformly low (<10-4 per cell per generation), indicating that 2-step reversion contributes minimally to the stability of aneuploid subpopulations under conditions where populations expand from euploid precursors in permissive, nearly static environments (S2 Appendix). In such scenarios, the relative fitness of aneuploid cells is the primary determinant of karyotype frequencies, suggesting that selection, rather than reversion, dominates the maintenance and diversity of aneuploid lineages. The fitness costs and mutation rates derived in the growth conditions used in this study are likely to differ across stressful or fluctuating environments. Consequently, and in line with a growing body of work, the extent to which natural selection shapes karyotypic diversity within populations is strongly dependent on the environment [75]. However, reversion may become a more influential determinant of karyotype stability in populations that are already highly karyotypically diverse [76–80], or in those undergoing major shifts in effective size or structure—such as bottlenecks, founder events, or selective sweeps. Indeed, reversion had a markedly greater impact on the karyotypic diversification of populations derived from aneuploid founders than from euploids. Moving forward, the influence of specific environmental or population characteristics, and how they alter the primary determinants of aneuploid karyotype stability, can be systematically interrogated using the experimental systems and computational models presented in this work. A second objective of this study was to investigate aneuploidy dynamics across a broad chromosomal context. We find substantial variation in nondisjunction incidence across the different yeast chromosomes. Discerning the underlying basis for this variance warrants further study, as doing so is likely to clarify central principles of genome and chromosomal stability and refine current paradigms of aneuploidy-driven disease risk. Perhaps variations in centromeric sequences, which are highly variant and fast-evolving [48,81–86], may underlie chromosome-specific differences in kinetochore assembly and disjunction fidelity. Alternatively, the spatial organization of chromosomes within the nucleus may impact the likelihood of nondisjunction [87–89]. Our work presents an additional possibility: for certain chromosomes—particularly those exhibiting the highest rates of loss—nondisjunction may more frequently occur through a coupled mechanism defined by intermolecular linkage-mediated missegregation, chromosome breakage, and homologous repair. DNA bridges arise in mitosis from intermolecular linkages with diverse molecular origins, including incomplete DNA replication [60,90,91], defective cohesion or condensin degradation [92,93], residual catenanes [54,90,92,94], and unresolved recombination intermediates [61,95].The molecular features of these bridges elicit distinct cellular responses that differentially affect chromosome stability. For example, wild type mammalian cells form catenane-driven ultrafine centromeric DNA bridges each cell cycle, but these are efficiently recognized and resolved by the BLM/PICH/FANC complex within the normal timeframe of mitosis [54,96]. Other bridge types are not resolved within mitosis but instead trigger a delay in cytokinesis via the NoCut checkpoint [97,98], allowing lagging chromatin to complete segregation before cytokinetic abscission. Bridges that evade recognition, repair, or resolution result in chromosome fragmentation, micronucleus formation, or cytokinetic failure—outcomes collectively associated with genomic instability [96]. While these catastrophic outcomes are hallmarks of genetically unstable cell types including cancer cells and DNA stability mutants [99], their observed incidence in wild type cells is rare [61,90,98]. Our data indicate that damage-inducing linkages form stochastically in wild type cells and that chromosome-specific propensities to form such linkages—perhaps due to the presence of hyper-recombinant loci, the enrichment of cohesin and condensin complexes, etc.—are an important, yet understudied contributor to the observed diversity in nondisjunction rate in wild type populations. Although we have endeavored to define a unified framework of aneuploid karyotype dynamics that can be explored in silico, the genetic systems used in this study allowed empirical detection of but a subset of outcomes predicted by our models of linkage-mediated missegregation, suggesting that we have substantially underestimated the true incidence of this mutational mechanism in populations. For example, recombinant products formed when linked molecules are severed in repetitive regions—such as the rDNA [56], subtelomeric arrays, telomeric repeats, or dispersed repeats—may not resolve with detectable breakpoints or heterozygous tracts displayed by the recombinant clones characterized in this study. Instead, these events would resolve as typical UPDs, making them indiscernible from the revertant karyotype formed through the canonical 2-step reversion pathway. This possibility is particularly salient when interpreting the reversion dynamics of Chr12, which displayed an exceptionally high reversion rate and penetrant revertant WGS signature consistent with a typical UPD. Genetic and chemical perturbations affecting rDNA transcriptional regulation, condensation, and decatenation have been shown to promote the formation of intermolecular rDNA linkages and chromosome severing in cytokinesis [56,100–102]. Our work prompts the hypothesis that even in unperturbed wild type cells, persistent linkages existing within the ~ 1Mb rDNA array facilitate high-frequency chromosome nondisjunction events capable of resolving into a simple UPD karyotype through a complex mechanism of templated repair [42,56]. Our future studies will seek to define the positional and architectural features of such molecular linkages within the rDNA and genome-wide, to determine why some chromosomes appear subject to this mode of genomic instability more than others, and to discern the molecular mechanisms by which repair of severed chromosomes occurs subsequent to nondisjunction. Methods Strains and media Strains and plasmids used in this study are listed in Table A in S1 Appendix. Strain construction was performed using standard transformation, crossing, and sporulation procedures. Directed insertions of selectable cassettes and reporter constructs were validated using PCR and WGS. Depending on the experiment, yeast cells were grown in one of the following media: rich nonselective media (10g/L yeast extract, 20 g/L Peptone, 20 g/L bacteriological agar, and 20g/L glucose (2.0%)), synthetic-defined complete media (20g/L glucose or 20g/L galactose, 5g/L ammonium sulfate, 1.7g/L yeast nitrogen base without amino acids, 1.4g/L complete drop-out mix, 20g/L bacteriological agar), canavanine-containing media (20g/L glucose, 5g/L ammonium sulfate, 1.7g/L yeast nitrogen base without amino acids, 1.4g/L arginine dropout mix, 20g/L bacteriological agar, 0.06g/L canavanine sulfate), uracil drop-out media (20g/L glucose or 20g/L raffinose, 5g/L ammonium sulfate, 1.7g/L yeast nitrogen base without amino acids, 1.4g/L uracil dropout mix), 5-FOA containing media (20g/L glucose, 5g/L ammonium sulfate, 1.7g/L yeast nitrogen base without amino acids, 1.4g/L complete drop-out mix, 20g/L bacteriological agar, g/L 5-Fluoroorotic Acid). Canavanine fluctuation tests Liquid media pregrowth: For each CAN1-marked strain, replicate ~500-cell populations were seeded into microwells containing YPD and expanded for 48hrs (median population size = 7.3x106, median number of generations = 13.8). Solid media pregrowth: Each CAN1-marked strain was streaked onto YPD plates to single cell density and independent colonies were allowed to develop for 48hrs before isolating each and resuspending in 200uL of sterile water. Plating: A fraction (20–40%; average 3-7x106 cells) of each replicate was plated on canavanine-containing media, and a diluted fraction plated on YPD. Plates were incubated at 30°C for 96 hrs; both dark CANR and YPD-plated colonies were counted after 48hrs, the light CANR colonies at 96hrs. Data availability: Raw colony counts, frequency calculations, and inferred population sizes are presented in Table G in S1 Appendix. For strains LRH587, LRH585, Chr684, and LRH588, we were unable to successfully integrate the complete VIO cassette, even after multiple attempts. Therefore, revertant phenotypes were deduced on the basis of colony size at 48hrs. WGS demonstrated that revertant genotype identification by colony size was accurate. Monosome replating tests Plating: Small (48–72hr) light CANR colonies isolated from independent canavanine plates were resuspended and diluted to single-cell density on synthetic defined complete media plates and incubated at 30°C for 48hrs. After 48hrs, dark revertant colonies were quantified; after 96hrs, light monosomic colonies were quantified. Data availability: Raw colony counts, frequency calculations, and inferred population sizes are presented in Table E in S1 Appendix. Visualization: The frequency of revertant clones in each replicate monosomic population assessed are presented in Fig 1D in a plot created in Graphpad Prism 10. Rate estimation using mlemur Rate estimation: We used mlemur v0.9.6.5 [39] to estimate the mutation rates for all the experimental fluctuation test data. The batch mode in the graphical user interface was used to input selective and non-selective colony counts, culture volumes, dilution factors and relative mutant fitness. Data availability: The colony count input and rate outputs for the monosome replating assay and canavanine fluctuation tests are presented in Tables F and H in S1 Appendix, respectively. Visualization: The rates of reversion estimated from the canavanine fluctuation tests and monosome replating tests are presented in Fig 3A and 3B with plots created in Graphpad Prism. The comparative plot in Fig 3C was made with a custom plotting script (see Data Availability). Relative fitness quantification Preselected monosome assay: For monosomes of Chr1, Chr2, Chr3, Chr8, Chr9, Chr14, and Chr16, 3 independent 72hr grown light CANR clones were isolated and inoculated in 1mL of liquid rich YPD media. A diploid control strain constructed in the same hybrid genetic background was also inoculated in triplicate and all cultures were grown overnight at room temperature to saturation. Saturated cultures were then diluted 20-fold into fresh YPD and dispensed in duplicate into microwell dishes. Induced monosome assay: The pGAL1-CEN strains were grown overnight in 1mL cultures of liquid uracil drop-out media containing 2% raffinose. These cultures were then diluted 3-fold into synthetic defined complete media containing 2% galactose and grown for 2.5hrs to induce centromere inactivation. At least 5 replicate 100-fold dilutions were seeded into 384-well microplates (Corning cat. 3680; Corning, New York) containing synthetic defined complete media containing 2% glucose and 1mg/L 5-FOA, in a total volume of 80 μL per well. Optical density measurements: Growth kinetics were tracked over 36 hrs by measuring the optical density (OD600) of each microwell every 20 min in a Cytation3 (BioTek) plate reader heated to 30°C without shaking. Growth curve analysis: For each replicate growth curve, the maximum growth rate was estimated using custom Python v3.10 [103] scripts. Linear regressions of OD600 values against time were fitted for overlapping sliding windows of 20 timepoints (6.67 hrs) using scipy v1.14 [104], and the maximum slope value was used. Determination of fitness coefficients: The average maximum slope values calculated from each replicate monosomic population of a given strain or isolate was divided by the average maximum slope value calculated from the replicate growth curves of the appropriate diploid control strain. Data availability: Raw slope values and fitness coefficients are presented in D in S1 Appendix. Visualization: The plot of inferred relative fitness coefficients and simple linear regression analysis presented in Fig 2B was generated using Graphpad Prism 10. Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS) library preparation The information for all clones sequenced in this study is deposited in Table I in S1 Appendix. WGS of selected clones was performed as described previously [12,15]. Briefly, candidate colonies were isolated using sterile toothpicks, repatched to rich media plates, and expanded for one day. The entire patch of cells was then used to isolate genomic DNA using the Yeastar Genomic Kit from Zymo Research (cat. D2002; Irvine, CA). DNA quantity and quality was assessed using a Qubit fluorometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Pooled, barcoded libraries of 96–384 individual genomes were generated using a Seqwell plexWell-384 kit. The final barcoded libraries were sequenced at Novogene Corp. using an Illumina Novaseq sequencer. WGS data analysis Read processing and trimming: Reads were trimmed using fastp v0.23.4 [105] with default options. Read mapping: Reads were mapped to the S. cerevisiae reference genome vR64 (http://sgd-archive.yeastgenome.org/sequence/S288C_reference/genome_releases/) using bwa-mem2 v2.3 [106] with default options. Secondary alignments were filtered out using samtools v1.21 [107]. Picard v3.1.1 (http://broadinstitute.github.io/picard) was used to mark and remove duplicates (MarkDuplicates) and add read groups to the BAM files (AddOrReplaceReadGroups). Variant detection: Variants were called using bcftools v1.21 [108], first generating pileups (mpileup) and subsequently calling the variants (call) with options -m -v. Biallelic single nucleotide variants were kept for the genome analyses. Data availability: Per chromosome assessment of the total clones sequenced and the percentage of which harbor defined karyotypic variations is presented in Table B in S1 Appendix. Raw sequencing data are deposited at NCBI under Bioproject PRJNA1414607.Visualization: Figs 1C, 5A, 5B, 5G, 5H, 6B, 6C, and 6E were made with custom scripts deposited on this study’s Github page. Monosome copy number analysis Genomic analysis: The WGS data derived from each of the light CANR clones which harbored only a monosome of the marked chromosome were remapped to a repeat masked reference assembly. The use of a masked reference eliminated the possibility that mismapping to repetitive regions of the genome (i.e., the rDNA array, subtelomeric repeats, mobile elements) would distort coverage analyses and allowed us to more precisely calculate the normalized copy number of the marked chromosome relative to the rest of the genome. The average depth of coverage of the respective marked chromosome was divided by the mean coverage of the other 15 chromosomes and normalized to relate a copy number value. Data Availability: Per clone normalized copy number values are presented in Table C in S1 Appendix. Visualization: The deduced copy numbers of each monosome analyzed are presented in Fig 1D in a plot created in Graphpad Prism 10. Forward simulation of fluctuation assays We developed fflucsim, a forward simulation tool to generate in silico populations expanding from a single diploid cell ancestor. fflucsim is a Python library that includes objects and functions to generate cells and expand them into large populations under adjustable parameters dictating the population dynamics that generate monosomic karyotypes and the mutational events immediately following that revert to disomic karyotypes. Briefly, founder cells are initiated with user-specified values for aneuploidy rates and relative fitness of aneuploid karyotypes. Cells divide synchronously [109] using relative fitness and mutation rates as probabilities of karyotype change and generation of a daughter cell, respectively, until a user-specified target population size is reached. Cells implement two distinct homologs, one carrying a counter-selectable marker, which enables the selection of surviving cells at the end of the population expansion (mimicking the CAN1 cassettes in our experimental fluctuation assays). Importantly, fflucsim keeps full records of the parameters, mutation events and full genealogy in cell and population objects, making it a uniquely powerful framework to track the dynamics of complex mutations with alternative paths to back-mutation. The source code and the Snakemake v9.15 [110] scripts used for all simulations presented in this study are available at GitHub (see Data accessibility section). Microscopy Growth conditions: Cells were pregrown to log phase in synthetic-defined complete media containing 2% raffinose, before dilution into complete media containing either 2% glucose or 2% galactose. After 90 min of growth, cells were prepared for imaging. Slide preparation: Cells were concentrated, spotted on a 1.5% agarose pad containing the same respective media, covered with a coverslip and sealed with paraffin. Imaging procedures: Images were collected on a Nikon Ti-E microscope equipped with a 1.45NA100 × CFIPlan Apo objective, piezo electric stage (Physik Instrumente; Auburn, MA), spinning disk confocal scanner unit (CSU10; Yokogawa), 488-nm and 561-nm lasers (Agilent Technologies; Santa Clara, CA), and an EMCCDcamera (iXonUltra 897;AndorTechnology, Belfast, UK) using NIS Elements software (Nikon). Z-series spanning 7–9 μm with 0.5 μm steps were acquired every 3min for 2 hours. Data Availability: Raw image files will be provided upon request. Visualization: Image files were imported as hyperstacks and processed using Fiji [111]. Maximum projections of z-series for each channel were generated. Intensity and color adjustments, cropping, and merging was performed with tools in either Fiji or Adobe Photoshop. Supporting information Karyotypic alterations associated with the light and dark CANR phenotype on a per- chromosome basis. A., B. Quantification of the percentage of light CANR (A) and dark CANR (B) clones that harbored the denoted karyotypic states affecting the predicted chromosome (Selected) as well as any additional unselected events (Unselected). (TIF) Divergent late-stage growth dynamics suggest the sweep of revertant karyotypes. OD600 growth curve data and end point microwell images of representative strains subjected to the induced monosome generation fitness assays. Black arrowheads point to late-stage, rapid, increases in growth rate indicative of emergent revertant subpopulations. Grey boxes in each plot denote the growth kinetics data that were excluded from our estimate of growth rate to eliminate revertant emergence as a confounding factor. (TIF) Mutation rates are not correlated with chromosomal features. Log-transformed per-chromosome estimates of the rates of monosomy and reversion plotted by chromosome size (A.) or the length of each chromosome arm (B.). Vertical error bars denote the 95% confidence intervals associated with each per-chromosome estimate of μA or μR. Brown and green areas depict the 95% confidence intervals produced from the simple linear regression of μA (brown) μR (green) or vs. chromosome size. (TIF) Parallel mutational routes can generate revertant UPDs. A schematic illustrating genotypes, phenotypes, and rates associated with nondisjunction events that result in the formation and subsequent reversion of monosomic and trisomic daughter cell pairs. Symbols are the same as in Fig 1. Only the derivatives outlined with a solid line would be recoverable in the canavanine fluctuation tests. (TIF) Validation of fflucsim using back-calculation of mutation rates from simulated mutant counts. Mutation rates (dots) and 95% confidence intervals (vertical lines) were estimated from simulated mutant counts using rSalvador [41]. We performed 245 simulations across all combinations of seven μA values (10-7–10-4), seven μR values (10-7–10-1) and five ωA values (10-2–100). For these validation simulations, we ignored reversion that occurs via the trisomic counterparts of monosomy events, setting μT=0 and ωT=1. We performed 50 replicates for each parameter combination. Two models were fitted on simulated mutant counts, the standard Luria-Delbrück model (Lea-Coulson, open dots) and the model accounting for variable mutant fitness (Mandelbrot-Koch, closed dots). The rate values expected from the input parameters are shown as thin background lines. Input parameters are summarized as heatmaps below each plot. Monosome rates (μA) were estimated from combined counts of monosomic and revertant mutants (A), and compound rates (μC = μA × μR) were estimated from revertant mutant counts alone (B). (TIF) Empirical revertant frequencies deviate substantially from the expected value for a subset of chromosomes. A. Cumulative distributions of revertant cell (R) frequency for the monosome replating tests (dark green) and simulated populations generated by fflucsim (light green). The fflucsim distributions correspond to the 50 replicates of the single simulated assay parameterized with the pair of μR and ωA values closest to the empirical estimates for the corresponding chromosome. B. Heatmaps showing the same data as Fig 3D with revertant frequency mapped on a logarithmic scale. Insets highlight the set of input parameters closest to the empirical estimates. (TIF) Pericentromeric recombination patterns suggest an intermolecular linkage-mediated mechanism of chromosome nondisjunction. Chr12-specific whole-chromosome or centromere-proximal WGS mappings of the recovered trisomic CANR colonies. Black arrowheads denote the position of CEN12. (TIF) Breaks within the ribosomal DNA coincide with FOAR karyotype formation. A. Representative Chr12-specific WGS mappings from recombinant FOAR colonies derived from the URA3-GAL1p-CEN12 strain displaying a breakpoint within the rDNA locus. B. A schematic illustrating the predicted mechanism and outcomes of a nondisjunction event resulting from intermolecular linkages arising in the rDNA. C. A representative WGS mapping and corresponding Chr12-specific WGS mapping of a FOAR clone recovered from the URA3-GAL1p-CEN10 strain. As shown in the top mapping, this clone is monosomic for Chr10 and also harbors a mosaic structural variation involving the right arm of Chr12 beginning at a breakpoint in the rDNA. The bottom mapping more clearly illustrates the rDNA breakpoint and mosaic allele frequency on Chr12. (TIF) Alternative missegregation occurs in the absence of intact kinetochores. A. and C. Representative images of a normal disjunction event (A.) and an alternative Type 2 missegregation event (C.) occurring in URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cells expressing TetR-GFP and Nuf2-tdTomato, a kinetochore protein required for spindle microtubule attachment. B. and D. Corresponding line scan analysis illustrating the degree of TetR and Nuf2 signal overlap in A. and C.; Line scan analysis was performed by determining the pixel intensity across the distance spanning all four fluorescent foci for both detection channels using Fiji. (TIF) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Tub1-mRuby2 displaying typical chromosome segregation dynamics in glucose-containing media. (AVI) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Tub1-mRuby2 displaying the expected centromere inactivation nondisjunction dynamics in galactose-containing media. (AVI) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Tub1-mRuby2 displaying Type 1 nondisjunction dynamics in galactose-containing media. (AVI) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Tub1-mRuby2 displaying Type 2 nondisjunction dynamics in galactose-containing media. (AVI) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Htb2-tdTomato displaying Type 2 nondisjunction dynamics of the CEN4-tetO loci and persistence of a long-lived chromatin bridge that resolves only after the rapid translocation of one tetO locus into the bud cell. (AVI) Representative time-lapse image series of a URA3-GAL1p-CEN4-tetO cell expressing TetR-GFP and Htb2-tdTomato displaying Type 2 nondisjunction dynamics of the CEN4-tetO loci and alternative CEN4-tetO segregation and persistence of a chromatin bridge that resolves to form a tetO-containing chromosome fragment. (AVI) Table A. Yeast strains and plasmids used in this study. Table B. Karyotypic variant analysis of sequenced clones. Table C. Per-chromosome monosome depth of coverage analysis. Table D. Data used to calculate relative fitness coefficients. Table E. Monosome replating test count data. Table F. Monosome replating test rate analysis. Table G. Canavanine fluctuation test colony count data. Table H. Canavanine fluctuation test rate analysis. Table I. WGS sample information. (XLSX) Extended Discussion. Additional discussion points regarding the biological contexts for modeling aneuploidy dynamics. (DOCX) 30 Apr 2026 PGENETICS-D-26-00199 A unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics PLOS Genetics Dear Dr. Heasley, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS Genetics. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS Genetics's publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Jun 28 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosgenetics@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pgenetics/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript: * A letter that responds to each point raised by the editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. This file does not need to include responses to any formatting updates and technical items listed in the 'Journal Requirements' section below. * A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. * An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, competing interests statement, or data availability statement, please make these updates within the submission form at the time of resubmission. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Soni Lacefield, PhD Academic Editor PLOS Genetics Kent Hunter Section Editor PLOS Genetics Aimée Dudley Editor-in-Chief PLOS Genetics Anne Goriely Editor-in-Chief PLOS Genetics Additional Editor Comments: Overall, the reviewers agree that this is an interesting study that will contribute to our understanding of aneuploidy. However, the reviewers have made several comments to improve the manuscript with some new experiments and additional discussion points, clarifications, and reference to other studies through writing and analysis. Please try to address these concerns where possible. Journal Requirements: 1) We ask that a manuscript source file is provided at Revision. Please upload your manuscript file as a .doc, .docx, .rtf or .tex. If you are providing a .tex file, please upload it under the item type u2018LaTeX Source Fileu2019 and leave your .pdf version as the item type u2018Manuscriptu2019. 2) Please provide an Author Summary. This should appear in your manuscript between the Abstract (if applicable) and the Introduction, and should be 150-200 words long. The aim should be to make your findings accessible to a wide audience that includes both scientists and non-scientists. Sample summaries can be found on our website under Submission Guidelines:https://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/s/submission-guidelines#loc-parts-of-a-submission 3) Please upload all main figures as separate Figure files in .tif or .eps format. For more information about how to convert and format your figure files please see our guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/s/figures 4) We have noticed that you have uploaded Supporting Information files, but you have not included a complete list of legends. Please add a full list of legends for your Supporting Information files (Supplemental movies) after the references list. 5) We notice that your supplementary Figures, and Tables are included in the manuscript file. Please remove them and upload them with the file type 'Supporting Information'. Please ensure that each Supporting Information file has a legend listed in the manuscript after the references list. 6) Your current Financial Disclosure states, "The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.". However, your funding information on the submission form indicates receiving funds.Please ensure that the funders and grant numbers match between the Financial Disclosure field and the Funding Information tab in your submission form. Note that the funders must be provided in the same order in both places as well. Please amend your detailed Financial Disclosure statement. This is published with the article. It must therefore be completed in full sentences and contain the exact wording you wish to be published.1) Please clarify all sources of financial support for your study. List the grants, grant numbers, and organizations that funded your study, including funding received from your institution. Please note that suppliers of material support, including research materials, should be recognized in the Acknowledgements section rather than in the Financial Disclosure2) State the initials, alongside each funding source, of each author to receive each grant. For example: "This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (####### to AM; ###### to CJ) and the National Science Foundation (###### to AM)."3) State what role the funders took in the study. If the funders had no role in your study, please state: "The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript."4) If any authors received a salary from any of your funders, please state which authors and which funders. 7) Some material included in your submission may be copyrighted. According to PLOS’s copyright policy, authors who use figures or other material (e.g., graphics, clipart, maps) from another author or copyright holder must demonstrate or obtain permission to publish this material under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) License used by PLOS journals. Please closely review the details of PLOS’s copyright requirements here: PLOS Licenses and Copyright. If you need to request permissions from a copyright holder, you may use PLOS's Copyright Content Permission form. Please respond directly to this email and provide any known details concerning your material's license terms and permissions required for reuse, even if you have not yet obtained copyright permissions or are unsure of your material's copyright compatibility. Once you have responded and addressed all other outstanding technical requirements, you may resubmit your manuscript within Editorial Manager. Potential Copyright Issues: Figures 1B, and 1E. Please confirm (a) that you are the photographer; or (b) provide written permission from the photographer to publish the photo(s) under our CC BY 4.0 license.. Note: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Reviewer #1: This manuscript describes a series of experiments that both confirm some suspected patterns of karyotype evolution in yeast and reveal some new patterns using novel methods. 1. In the introduction, it might be helpful to clarify that many of the studies cited used empirical approaches designed to minimize the influence of selection on the detection of aneuploidy and other mutants (as they should). For instance, in mutation accumulation (MA) experiments, it’s certainly true that the possibility of aneuploidy reversion is generally not accounted for, and that differences in fitness could potentially confound rate estimates; however, even with these caveats, MA or fluctuation test style experiments will be a much more useful approaches than other types of experimental evolution where karyotypes evolve under selection, assuming our goal is to understand intrinsic mutation properties. The authors know all this, but in my experience many geneticists are not used to thinking about this distinction, and may assume that the karyotypic changes in question are under strong selection in these experiments. 2. It is known that classical nondisjunction, where a chromosome gain in one daughter cell is coupled with a chromosome loss in the other daughter cell, is not the only means through which aneuploidy might arise. In particular, chromosome loss could occur through “anaphase lag”, where there is a loss without a corresponding gain. If this is happening in yeast, we might expect the rate of mutation to monosomy (which can occur through nondisjunction or chromosome lag) to exceed the rate of reversion, which can only occur through nondisjunction, all else being equal. I’d ask the authors to consider how the anaphase lag model might apply to their observations. 3. As we move towards unbiased quantification of karyotype mutations, I wonder if the authors have considered whether the probability of nondisjunction in a given cell division ought to scale with the current number of chromosome copies. For example, all else being equal, the probability of segregation error occurring in a tetraploid should be twice that of a diploid, since tetraploids have to manage twice as many chromosomes overall. When thinking about aneuploidy reversion in diploids, this would suggest that reversion from trisomy to euploidy is more likely than reversion from monosomy to euploidy. 4. The authors use the term “uniparental disomy” (UPD) to refer to cells that are euploid diploids but have two identical copies of a given chromosome due to chromosome loss and subsequent reversion. I think it’s good to link yeast aneuploidy data with the UPD concept to highlight the health relevance and compare across species, but I’m a bit concerned about applying the term equivalently to these systems. In obligate sexuals like humans, we don’t normally expect cells with two chromosome copies from the same parent, and UPD may be a good term for the exceptions. But in asexual populations of diploid yeast, both homologs always come from the same parental cell, though they are usually distinct copies. I wonder if the emerging literature could be clearer if we started calling these events chromosome-wide LOH or uni-homolog disomy or chromosome loss revertants or something of that nature, since asexual yeast cells only have one parent. 5. Elevated LOH distal to the rDNA locus on Chr12 has been seen repeatedly, e.g., PMID: 37847861, PMID: 28369610, PMID: 29799840, PMID: 31371407, PMID: 32727920; it would be good to comment on the relationship between the current results and these previous observations––I’m not sure if the authors would say the elevated LOH in this region could be partly attributable to the chromosome attachment models they discuss, or if other mechanisms are more likely, like standard break induced replication. I might also note that increased UPD with respect to Chr12 (or even just the rDNA region) could help maintain similar rDNA copy number across the homologs. 6. I came across a likely case of “uniparental disomy” in the following study, where the evidence is a chromosome-wide LOH in a “hybrid” strain that started mutation accumulation with high heterozygosity. PMID: 32727920. 7. I gather that the relatively high degree of initial genome wide heterozygosity in the diploids studied here is intentional, making it easier to see LOH and karyotype change, but if this strategy was stated explicitly, I missed it. 8. Could mutations at the violacein insertion site conceivably affect colony color? 9. Line 308. A pretty strong fitness cost of trisomy was also observed in PMID: 29760081. 10. Line 380. “…since these would likely retain at least one CAN1 cassette and fail to form colonies on canavanine-containing media.” Sounds backwards, is this an error? 11. In Table S1. LRH316 is derived from LRH307 and LRH303, but I don’t see the latter strain listed elsewhere. Maybe it’s meant to be LRH330? LRH556 also seems to appear just once. Reviewer #2: When a chromosome is lost (typically through nondisjunction), how stable is that loss in a population, and what determines its persistence? Key factors include the fitness of the resulting aneuploid cells and the likelihood of reversion to a euploid state, often through a second nondisjunction event. These parameters are likely to vary across organisms and cell types, but according to the authors, a comprehensive characterization within a single system has been lacking. This study addresses this question using diploid budding yeast, examining how aneuploidy persistence is shaped by the rates of chromosome loss, the fitness of the resulting cells, and reversion to euploidy. The authors employ a well-designed experimental system to quantify these variables on a per-chromosome basis, with particular emphasis on reversion. The manuscript first establishes a quantitative framework describing aneuploid formation, fitness, and reversion across all chromosomes. It then shows that, for a subset of chromosomes, the observed “reversion” dynamics cannot be explained by canonical sequential nondisjunction. In the second part, the authors propose and support an alternative mechanism (linkage-mediated missegregation followed by chromosome breakage and recombination) that produces disomic outcomes without a stable aneuploid intermediate. In the first part of the study (Figures 1–3), the authors develop an elegant experimental framework to quantify spontaneous aneuploidy formation, reversion, and fitness. Aneuploidy formation is measured using selection for loss of a CAN1 marker inserted on both arms of each chromosome, followed by whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of selected clones. Reversion frequency is inferred from a shift from heterozygosity to homozygosity at a linked marker encoding a pigment-producing gene (resulting in a dark colony phenotype) followed by WGS. Fitness is assessed using population doubling times in liquid culture. These measurements are then integrated into a computational model. Using this approach, the authors show that the fitness of aneuploid strains is chromosome-dependent, as expected. They further find that, for most chromosomes, reversion rates differ substantially from aneuploidy formation rates, consistent with an unequal likelihood model. A key conclusion from this analysis is that classical two-step reversion via nondisjunction is rare and contributes minimally to population dynamics. In the second part of the study (Figures 4–8), the authors report that a subset of chromosomes (Chr4, 10, 12, and 13) exhibit unusually high apparent reversion rates that cannot be explained by standard models. They interpret these cases as arising from a non-canonical pathway: intermolecular linkage leads to missegregation, chromosome breakage and recombination, effectively coupling “formation” and “reversion.” In this framework, the data are better explained by a model in which chromosome loss is accompanied by partial gains, suggestive of chromosome breakage events, potentially occurring during late mitosis or cytokinesis in the presence of incompletely segregated chromosomes. To support this model, the authors analyze cells in which nondisjunction is artificially induced and observe features consistent with this mechanism, including characteristic patterns in whole-genome sequencing and direct visualization of chromosome segregation defects by live-cell imaging. Based in part on these time-lapse experiments, they propose that a subset of chromosome-specific aneuploidies arise from “intermolecular linkage-mediated missegregation,” in which unresolved linkages between sister chromatids lead to chromatin bridges that are subsequently damaged during mitosis or cytokinesis, resulting in chromosome fragmentation and rearrangement. The first part of the paper is clear and well presented, and the conclusions appear well supported by the data. The second part is more challenging to follow but also more conceptually interesting, as it provides, to my knowledge, one of the first quantitative analyses of partial chromosome missegregation in unperturbed yeast populations. Some sections would benefit from improved clarity and more precise definitions. The mechanistic model proposed (linkage-mediated missegregation followed by chromosome breakage and recombination) is well grounded in prior work on anaphase bridges (which is not always cited). While its application to explain the observed reversion dynamics is compelling, the manuscript would benefit from a clearer distinction between what is conceptually new (notably the quantitative integration with population genetics and the chromosome-specific effects) and what is already established in the literature. As written, the manuscript occasionally gives the impression that this represents a previously unrecognized mechanism. However, the underlying processes are well documented; the novelty here lies more in demonstrating their contribution under unperturbed conditions and linking them to apparent reversion rates. Specific comments 1. In the abstract and main text, the phrase “alternative mechanism in which nondisjunction and reversion are directly coupled” is somewhat confusing. It may be clearer to describe this instead as a single composite mutational process that produces disomic outcomes without a stable aneuploid intermediate. 2. In Fig. S2, the authors test for a correlation between μA and total chromosome size and find none. Given the mechanistic model proposed later in the manuscript, it may be more informative to assess whether μA correlates with the length of the longest chromosome arm rather than total chromosome size per se. If bridge formation, delayed arm resolution, or linkage-mediated breakage contribute to the observed chromosome-specific instability, arm length may be a more relevant structural parameter. This analysis seems particularly pertinent, as the manuscript ultimately argues that, for some chromosomes, instability reflects linkage-mediated missegregation and breakage rather than canonical nondisjunction alone. In this context, the length of the longest arm may be a better predictor of the likelihood that chromatin becomes trapped in the bud neck during mitotic exit. 3. Figure 3B-C reveals substantial chromosome-specific variation in μR, including cases where μR exceeds μA, suggesting that reversion dynamics are heterogeneous. In the Discussion, this complexity is somewhat condensed into a general statement that canonical reversion is rare and largely negligible. While this is broadly supported, the manuscript would benefit from a clearer acknowledgment of the chromosome-specific differences and the contexts in which reversion may be more significant. 4. The interpretation that bipolar segregation is required for recombinant formation is somewhat unclear (lines 396–413). Do the authors propose that chromosome breakage arises from spindle-dependent tension during anaphase, from cytokinesis-associated forces during mitotic exit, or from another mechanism? One possibility not made explicit in the text, but consistent with chromatin bridge literature, is that breakage occurs when DNA persists within the bud neck during cytokinesis, independent of whether this positioning results from direct spindle attachment or indirect linkage-mediated displacement. The data presented (e.g. chromatin bridges and bud neck-associated DNA) appear equally consistent with a model in which spatial positioning at cytokinesis, rather than bipolar spindle forces per se, is the primary determinant of chromosome breakage. This interpretation is supported by prior work on dicentric chromosomes (PMID: 25644606, cited by the authors) and - perhaps even more relevant - on chromosomes with intermolecular linkages (PMID: 24286828, 27111841). This point would benefit from further clarification and discussion. 5. The proposed mechanism of linkage-mediated chromosome breakage is highly reminiscent of prior work showing that late-replicating regions (e.g. subtelomeres or rDNA) can remain unresolved into anaphase and incur damage upon cytokinesis in otherwise unperturbed cells. Notably, cytokinesis induces subtelomeric mutations in these cases (PMID: 32385287). This raises the possibility that the phenomena described here represent a chromosome-scale manifestation of previously described locus-specific replication/segregation defects. The manuscript would benefit from a more explicit integration of this literature, and clarification of what aspects of the mechanism are genuinely novel versus extensions of these established observations. In this context, the novelty appears to lie less in identifying cytokinesis-associated damage per se, and more in extending its consequences to chromosome-scale aneuploidy dynamics. Reviewer #3: The manuscript "A unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics" addresses an important question in chromosome biology: how do aneuploidy formation rates, reversion rates, and fitness consequences interact to determine karyotypic stability in dividing populations? The authors develop a sophisticated dual-reporter system in budding yeast that enables systematic measurement of μA, μR, and ω across all 16 chromosomes in a unified genetic background, integrate these measurements into a forward simulation framework, and identify a subset of chromosomes whose reversion dynamics cannot be explained by canonical mutational models. The paper further proposes and provides evidence for an intermolecular linkage mechanism to explain these non-canonical dynamics, supported by whole-genome sequencing of recombinant clones and live-cell fluorescence microscopy. The work represents a great technical achievement and makes genuine contributions to the comprehension of aneuploid population dynamics. The CAN1-VIO dual reporter system is elegant, the orthogonal fitness assays provide important cross-validation, and the live-cell microscopy directly visualizing chromatin bridges and chromosome fragmentation is the most compelling mechanistic data in the paper. The primary conclusion — that canonical reversion contributes negligibly to karyotypic stability for most chromosomes and that fitness is the dominant determinant of aneuploid population dynamics — is well supported by multiple independent measurement approaches. However, some major and minor concerns must be addressed before the manuscript can be accepted. These range from an unacknowledged structural assumption in the computational framework, to the correlative rather than causal nature of the evidence for the intermolecular linkage mechanism, to the framing of the paper's scope and novelty. These concerns are detailed below. MAJOR CONCERNS 1. The fflucsim Structural Assumptions The authors present a thorough exploration of parameter space within fflucsim, pushing μR to values approaching 1 and demonstrating that even this extreme cannot recapitulate Chr12 dynamics. This is a genuinely strong result within the model's framework. However, a structural assumption of the simulator warrants explicit acknowledgment that is currently absent from the paper. To my understand the fflucsim models population expansion as a well-mixed system, yet the monosome replating assay — from which the revertant frequency distributions being modeled are derived — is performed on solid agar medium where spatially clustered progeny from a single early reversion event remain physically grouped. For chromosomes with extreme fitness costs such as Chr12 (ω≈0.25), a single reversion event occurring within the first few divisions of a slow-growing monosomic colony could generate a spatially expanding revertant subclone that dominates the countable colony area by day 2 through fitness-driven spatial expansion rather than through genuinely elevated μR. No combination of μR and ω within a well-mixed population model can reproduce this dynamic because the model is structurally incapable of representing spatial heterogeneity, regardless of what parameter values are explored. The directly testing this concern is non-trivial given the constraints of the violacein-based detection system. Performing the assay in liquid culture would eliminate spatial structure but destroy the pigment-based readout, and a time course approach on solid medium might be confounded by the inherent lag between reversion event occurrence and sufficient violacein accumulation for visual detection. The paper's existing data provides partial mitigation — the liquid-grown fluctuation test populations and the WGS characterization of individual clones are both independent of solid medium geometry and broadly consistent with the replating assay results. Nevertheless, the well-mixed assumption represents an unacknowledged limitation of the analytical framework that should be explicitly discussed. The authors should address this limitation in the Discussion and note that fully resolving it would require development of a detection system that does not depend on pigment accumulation on solid medium. Until such a system is developed, the conclusion that Chr12 dynamics are incompatible with any canonical parameter combination must be framed with the caveat that the assay geometry itself introduces spatial heterogeneity that the model cannot capture. 2. Molecular identity of the linkages (Chr4 and Chr12) No experiment demonstrates that disrupting linkage formation specifically reduces recombinant clone frequency for Chr4 and Chr12 while leaving stable chromosomes unaffected. The molecular species constituting the linkages — topological catenation, cohesin entrapment, unresolved recombination intermediates — is never identified, which limits the mechanistic conclusions and prevents connecting the proposed mechanism to specific molecular perturbations. Deleting FOB1 in the CAN1-VIO Chr12 strain and repeat the monosome replating assay and WGS characterization would directly tests whether rDNA recombination intermediates are the linkage species driving Chr12 non-canonical reversion. Fob1 deletion specifically reduces rDNA recombination without affecting transcription or copy number. The prediction is falsifiable: fob1Δ should reduce recombinant clone frequency for Chr12 — particularly the rDNA breakpoint class in Figure S7 — without affecting Chr1 or Chr2 reversion dynamics. This would be a more direct test for one of the main hypothesis generated from this work data. Another direct assay would be to engineer a truncated rDNA array of defined size inserted at a defined locus on Chr3, a chromosome showing clean canonical monosomic behavior. Introduce this modified Chr3 into the CAN1-VIO system and measure μR, recombinant clone frequency, and breakpoint patterns by WGS, comparing to unmodified Chr3. This experiment directly tests sufficiency — whether rDNA presence alone is sufficient to convert a stable chromosome into a non-canonical reverter — completely decoupled from Chr12 identity, centromere sequence, and gene content. A positive result would also have significant broader implications for understanding instability of any chromosome bearing large repetitive arrays, including human acrocentric chromosomes. 3. The GAL1p-CEN Checkpoint Issue The authors explicitly acknowledge the artificial biology: "Although the URA3-GAL1p-CEN system generates a mitotic scenario that would rarely occur in wild-type cells—because an unattached chromatid pair typically activates a mitotic checkpoint-mediated cell cycle arrest—it constituted a valuable tool to further probe the validity of the intermolecular linkage model." This acknowledgment is appropriate but the checkpoint escape mechanism is never characterized. In Figure 7, 28.3% of cells show normal disjunction, 55% show induced nondisjunction, and approximately 17% show alternative segregation — meaning a substantial fraction of cells with inactivated centromeres escape checkpoint arrest and complete division. Whether checkpoint escape rates vary across chromosomes, which would bias which chromosomes produce recombinant FOA resistant clones, is never addressed. Additionally the uracil starvation pregrowth required by the experimental design could independently influence chromosome segregation fidelity through replication stress, a confound that is not discussed. An assay to measure checkpoint activation duration and/or escape frequency per chromosome would be important to strength further statements. If checkpoint escape rates differ significantly across chromosomes — particularly if Chr12 and Chr4 show higher escape rates than Chr1 and Chr3 — this would indicate that differential checkpoint biology contributes to the observed differences in recombinant clone recovery, requiring reinterpretation of the GAL1p-CEN results. 4. Fitness Measurement Discordance Between Assays Figure 2A shows systematic differences between induced and preselected ω values. The exclusion criterion for the preselected assay is stated: "this approach was restricted to monosomes that consistently exhibited undetectable revertant frequencies." This justification is reasonable — preselected monosomes cannot be measured for fast-reverting chromosomes because the populations are already contaminated with revertants by the time of measurement.However, the paper uses induced ω values for these fast-reverting chromosomes in the fflucsim modeling without validating that the induced assay accurately captures true monosomic fitness for chromosomes like Chr12 where alternative segregation events occur at high rates during the induction period. Cells surviving galactose induction and 5-FOA selection for fast-reverting chromosomes may not be representative monosomes but rather cells that underwent alternative segregation events, potentially reporting fitness values that reflect a mixed population rather than pure monosomes. 5. Replating Assay Temporal Asymmetry The Methods state: "After 48hrs, dark revertant colonies were quantified; after 96hrs, light monosomic colonies were quantified." The fitness correction applied through mlemur is described but the specific appropriateness of mlemur's correction for solid-medium colony counting — as opposed to the liquid culture fluctuation tests for which it was designed — is never discussed. Looking at Supplemental Table 5, individual replicate revertant frequencies for Chr4 range from 0% to 97%, and for Chr13 show enormous variance. This variance itself suggests that the fitness correction may be insufficient for the solid-medium geometry, where spatial structure creates non-linear expansion dynamics that the population-level correction cannot capture. The temporal asymmetry and fitness correction appropriateness for solid-medium colony counting are not addressed, and the high variance in replicate revertant frequencies for intermediate chromosomes suggests the correction may be insufficient. The Methods section should explicitly acknowledge that mlemur's fitness correction assumes well-mixed population dynamics and discuss whether this assumption holds for the solid-medium replating assay geometry. The Discussion should acknowledge that high variance in revertant frequencies across replicates for chromosomes like Chr4 and Chr13 could reflect either genuine Luria-Delbrück jackpot dynamics or spatial expansion artifacts, and that these explanations are not fully distinguishable with the current experimental system. 6. WGS Sample Sizes Supplemental Table 2 reveals that for several chromosomes, as few as 5 light CAN^R clones were sequenced. The core Chr4 finding — 8/10 dark CANr clones showing pericentromeric breakpoints — is presented without confidence intervals or statistical comparison to other chromosomes. The paper never calculates whether this sample size provides sufficient power to detect the claimed frequency difference from other chromosomes or from what would be expected by chance. The authors do provide a larger dataset for Chr12 specifically through the single-cassette strain experiment in Figure 5F-H, sequencing 45 dark CAN^R clones, which is more reassuring for that specific claim. But the generalization to other chromosomes remains statistically underpowered. 7. The rDNA Linkage Hypothesis The rDNA hypothesis is introduced as an observation — 22% of Chr12 FOAR clones show rDNA breakpoints — and elevated to a general mechanism in the Discussion. The authors acknowledge this is a hypothesis: "Our work prompts the hypothesis that even in unperturbed wild type cells, persistent linkages existing within the ~1Mb rDNA array facilitate high-frequency chromosome nondisjunction events." The fact that 78% of Chr12 FOAR clones did not show rDNA breakpoints is never explicitly addressed as a challenge to the rDNA linkage model being general for Chr12. The authors propose that rDNA-mediated events resolving through repetitive region breakage would appear as typical UPDs indistinguishable from canonical reversion — which is a reasonable explanation but is not tested. The proximity of the GAL1p-CEN12 cassette to the rDNA in the strain construction raises the possibility that rDNA breakpoints are an assay architecture artifact, which is also never formally excluded. 8- Chr6 and Chr7 Exclusion Requires Explicit Justification The paper claims to provide a systematic analysis of aneuploidy dynamics across all 16 yeast chromosomes, yet Chr6 and Chr7 are effectively excluded from the quantitative rate analysis without explicit criteria stated in the main text. The authors correctly identify that these chromosomes induce chromosomal instability through ACT1/TUB2 dosage imbalance, which violates the stable mutation rate assumption of fluctuation analysis. However, this exclusion justification appears only implicitly through the mechanistic discussion of CIN, never as an explicit statement of scope limitation. More importantly, the Methods note that VIO cassette integration failed repeatedly for several strains including those used for Chr6 and Chr7 — a significant technical limitation mentioned only in a footnote without connection to the main results narrative. The paper should explicitly state in the Results which chromosomes are excluded from which analyses and why, rather than allowing readers to piece this together from scattered statements across Methods and supplementary materials. I also noted that whether the CIN phenotype of Chr6 and Chr7 is mechanistically related to the non-canonical reversion observed in Chr4 and Chr12 is an interesting question the paper raises but does not address. Given the authors' proposed intermolecular linkage mechanism, it is worth considering whether the elevated nondisjunction rates induced by Chr6 aneuploidy could themselves generate linkage-mediated events on other chromosomes — a possibility that would have implications for interpreting the unselected aneuploidy burden observed in Figure S1. Without the need to perform a new experiment the author could perform a lower-resolution analysis that might be achievable with the existing deposited sequencing data to specifically, test whether the midpoints of unselected LOH events in Chr6 and Chr7 light CANr clones show statistically significant enrichment near centromeres relative to random chromosomal positions. This analysis would either provide preliminary support for linkage-mediated events in a CIN context or appropriately conclude that the existing data lacks sufficient resolution to address the question. Either outcome is informative and should be reported as a supplementary analysis. Additionally, the Discussion should include a brief paragraph acknowledging that whether Chr6-induced CIN generates linkage-mediated events as a mechanistic consequence of spindle disruption remains an open question, identifying it as an important direction for future work. This would substantially improve the paper's mechanistic coherence and honestly situate the Chr6/Chr7 observations within the broader intermolecular linkage framework the paper proposes. MINOR CONCERNS 1.Yeast-to-Human Extrapolation The Abstract states the work "expands our perspective of the diverse, and chromosome-specific mutational mechanisms shaping genome architecture" in a context framed around human disease. In the discussion section we can see the following statement "Discerning the underlying basis for this variance warrants further study, as doing so is certain to clarify central principles of genome stability and refine current paradigms of aneuploidy-driven disease risk". But I believe it is important to address in the paper that there are fundamental difference between S. cerevisiae point centromeres (~125bp, single CENP-A nucleosome) and human regional centromeres (megabases, complex chromatin) acknowledged as a limitation on extrapolation. The intermolecular linkage mechanism proposed here specifically involves rDNA on Chr12 and centromere-proximal recombination — both features that are organized entirely differently in humans. The word "certain" in "certain to clarify" is an overstatement that no data in the paper supports. 2. Genetic Background Effects Supplemental Table 1 shows Chr5 diploid strain is constructed as "(LRH279 x LRH202)" where LRH279 is in JAY291 background while most other strains are S288c. Several strains also show mixed parentage. The Methods state only: "Strain construction was performed using standard transformation, crossing, and sporulation procedures" with no discussion of background standardization. What is missing: The paper never discusses whether the JAY291 vs S288c background difference for Chr5 could contribute to its apparently distinct behavior in the fitness and rate analyses. JAY291 is a Brazilian bioethanol strain with substantially different genome content, ploidy history, and stress response compared to S288c. Given that Chr5 shows one of the higher μA values (Figure 3A) and relatively normal reversion dynamics, the possibility that background effects contribute to this pattern is never considered. 3. The "Unified Model" Framing: The title claims "A unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics" and the author states: "Collectively, this work establishes a unified model of aneuploid population genetics" But the author also acknowledges: "The genetic systems used in this study allowed detection of but a subset of outcomes predicted by our models of linkage-mediated missegregation, suggesting that we have substantially underestimated the true incidence of this mutational mechanism" And: "Discerning the underlying basis for this variance warrants further study" regarding why some chromosomes are subject to linkage-mediated instability more than others. A truly unified model would provide quantitative criteria to predict which chromosomes undergo canonical versus non-canonical reversion. Instead, the classification is entirely post-hoc — chromosomes are labeled non-canonical because their empirical data deviates from model predictions, not because any feature of the chromosome predicts non-canonical behavior prospectively. The Discussion speculates about centromere sequence variation, nuclear organization, and rDNA content as potential predictors, but none of these are tested. The model describes two classes of chromosome behavior but cannot predict class membership from first principles, which substantially limits its utility as a "unified" framework. So please re-consider the use of "unified framework". ********** Have all data underlying the figures and results presented in the manuscript been provided? Large-scale datasets should be made available via a public repository as described in the PLOS Genetics data availability policy, and numerical data that underlies graphs or summary statistics should be provided in spreadsheet form as supporting information. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy. Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] Figure resubmission: While revising your submission, we strongly recommend that you use PLOS’s NAAS tool (https://ngplosjournals.pagemajik.ai/artanalysis) to test your figure files. NAAS can convert your figure files to the TIFF file type and meet basic requirements (such as print size, resolution), or provide you with a report on issues that do not meet our requirements and that NAAS cannot fix. After uploading your figures to PLOS’s NAAS tool - https://ngplosjournals.pagemajik.ai/artanalysis, NAAS will process the files provided and display the results in the "Uploaded Files" section of the page as the processing is complete. If the uploaded figures meet our requirements (or NAAS is able to fix the files to meet our requirements), the figure will be marked as "fixed" above. If NAAS is unable to fix the files, a red "failed" label will appear above. When NAAS has confirmed that the figure files meet our requirements, please download the file via the download option, and include these NAAS processed figure files when submitting your revised manuscript. Reproducibility: To enhance the reproducibility of your results, we recommend that authors of applicable studies deposit laboratory protocols in protocols.io, where a protocol can be assigned its own identifier (DOI) such that it can be cited independently in the future. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option to publish peer-reviewed clinical study protocols. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols 14 May 2026 Submitted filename: Response to Reviewers.pdf 8 Jun 2026 Dear Dr Heasley, We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript entitled "Towards a unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics" has been editorially accepted for publication in PLOS Genetics. Congratulations! Before your submission can be formally accepted and sent to production you will need to complete our formatting changes, which you will receive in a follow up email. Please be aware that it may take several days for you to receive this email; during this time no action is required by you. Please note: the accept date on your published article will reflect the date of this provisional acceptance, but your manuscript will not be scheduled for publication until the required changes have been made. Once your paper is formally accepted, an uncorrected proof of your manuscript will be published online ahead of the final version, unless you’ve already opted out via the online submission form. If, for any reason, you do not want an earlier version of your manuscript published online or are unsure if you have already indicated as such, please let the journal staff know immediately at plosgenetics@plos.org. In the meantime, please log into Editorial Manager at https://www.editorialmanager.com/pgenetics/, click the "Update My Information" link at the top of the page, and update your user information to ensure an efficient production and billing process. Note that PLOS requires an ORCID iD for all corresponding authors. Therefore, please ensure that you have an ORCID iD and that it is validated in Editorial Manager. To do this, go to ‘Update my Information’ (in the upper left-hand corner of the main menu), and click on the Fetch/Validate link next to the ORCID field. This will take you to the ORCID site and allow you to create a new iD or authenticate a pre-existing iD in Editorial Manager. If you have a press-related query, or would like to know about making your underlying data available (as you will be aware, this is required for publication), please see the end of this email. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming article at this point, to enable them to help maximise its impact. Inform journal staff as soon as possible if you are preparing a press release for your article and need a publication date. Thank you again for supporting open-access publishing; we are looking forward to publishing your work in PLOS Genetics! Yours sincerely, Soni Lacefield, PhD Academic Editor PLOS Genetics Kent Hunter Section Editor PLOS Genetics Aimée Dudley Editor-in-Chief PLOS Genetics Anne Goriely Editor-in-Chief PLOS Genetics www.plosgenetics.org BlueSky: @plos.bsky.social ---------------------------------------------------- Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Authors: Please note here if the review is uploaded as an attachment. Reviewer #1: I think the authors have thoughtfully addressed the reviewers' comments, and the revised manuscript is an excellent contribution. Reviewer #2: The authors have satisfactorily addressed my comments and have improved the manuscript accordingly. In particular, they performed the additional chromosome-arm-length analysis, expanded the discussion of chromosome-specific reversion dynamics, and better integrated their findings with the existing literature on chromatin bridges and cytokinesis-associated chromosome breakage. I appreciate the authors’ careful revisions and would like to congratulate them on a very interesting and thoughtfully executed study. ********** Have all data underlying the figures and results presented in the manuscript been provided? Large-scale datasets should be made available via a public repository as described in the PLOS Genetics data availability policy, and numerical data that underlies graphs or summary statistics should be provided in spreadsheet form as supporting information. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes ********** PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy. Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: No ---------------------------------------------------- Data Deposition If you have submitted a Research Article or Front Matter that has associated data that are not suitable for deposition in a subject-specific public repository (such as GenBank or ArrayExpress), one way to make that data available is to deposit it in the Dryad Digital Repository. As you may recall, we ask all authors to agree to make data available; this is one way to achieve that. A full list of recommended repositories can be found on our website. The following link will take you to the Dryad record for your article, so you won't have to re‐enter its bibliographic information, and can upload your files directly: http://datadryad.org/submit?journalID=pgenetics&manu=PGENETICS-D-26-00199R1 More information about depositing data in Dryad is available at http://www.datadryad.org/depositing. If you experience any difficulties in submitting your data, please contact help@datadryad.org for support. Additionally, please be aware that our data availability policy requires that all numerical data underlying display items are included with the submission, and you will need to provide this before we can formally accept your manuscript, if not already present. ---------------------------------------------------- Press Queries If you or your institution will be preparing press materials for this manuscript, or if you need to know your paper's publication date for media purposes, please inform the journal staff as soon as possible so that your submission can be scheduled accordingly. Your manuscript will remain under a strict press embargo until the publication date and time. This means an early version of your manuscript will not be published ahead of your final version. PLOS Genetics may also choose to issue a press release for your article. If there's anything the journal should know or you'd like more information, please get in touch via plosgenetics@plos.org. PGENETICS-D-26-00199R1 Towards a unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics Dear Dr Heasley, We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript entitled " Towards a unified model of aneuploid karyotype dynamics" has been formally accepted for publication in PLOS Genetics! Your manuscript is now with our production department and you will be notified of the publication date in due course. The corresponding author will soon be receiving a typeset proof for review, to ensure errors have not been introduced during production. Please review the PDF proof of your manuscript carefully, as this is the last chance to correct any errors. Please note that major changes, or those which affect the scientific understanding of the work, will likely cause delays to the publication date of your manuscript. Soon after your final files are uploaded, unless you have opted out or your manuscript is a front-matter piece, the early version of your manuscript will be published online. The date of the early version will be your article's publication date. The final article will be published to the same URL, and all versions of the paper will be accessible to readers. For Research Articles, you will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. Thank you again for supporting PLOS Genetics and open-access publishing. We are looking forward to publishing your work! With kind regards, Anita Estes PLOS Genetics On behalf of: The PLOS Genetics Team Carlyle House, Carlyle Road, Cambridge CB4 3DN | United Kingdom plosgenetics@plos.org | +44 (0) 1223-442823 plosgenetics.org | Twitter: @PLOSGenetics