Levels of additive genetic variation vary substantially between species Authors: Lillith C. Zijmers, Katie L. Abson, Jarrod D. Hadfield, Adam Eyre-Walker, Roland Roberts, Roland Roberts, Roland Roberts Published: 2026 ABSTRACT A population’s ability to adapt is determined by its levels of additive genetic variance (VA), and while it is agreed that most organisms have genetic variation for most traits, the extent to which it varies between species is poorly characterized. Here, we investigate this question by compiling 3,209 and 1,852 estimates of heritability and evolvability (the additive genetic variance divided by the square of the mean), respectively, for a variety of traits from 220 and 172 multicellular eukaryotic species. Using phylogenetic generalized linear mixed models, we find substantial and highly significant interspecific variation in evolvability. Much of the variation is explained by phylogenetic relatedness, with plants in our data having substantially higher evolvability than animals. While heritability also varies between species, the differences are more subtle, and plants are not exceptional. We investigate whether the variation in evolvability and heritability between species is due to variation in the mutation rate, effective population size, genome size, ploidy, and recombination rate, but find little evidence of any factor being important. However, the confidence intervals are large suggesting that we have little power to detect any associations between these factors and our estimates of VA. Introduction A population’s ability to respond to selection depends on its levels of quantitative genetic variation or more specifically the additive genetic variation (VA) underlying key traits. It is well known that most traits have at least some underlying additive genetic variation [1,2] with substantial variation between published estimates. However, not much is known about whether levels vary systematically between species, or about the factors influencing the observed variation in levels of quantitative genetic variation. Understanding this is key to understanding the genetic architecture underlying complex traits and their evolution. Estimates of VA are not generally comparable between traits and species because they are measured on different scales. Consequently, VA is typically standardized by dividing the estimate by the phenotypic variance (VP), yielding the narrow-sense heritability (h2) [2]. Historically, the primary focus on heritability arose from the use of the breeder’s equation in predicting the response to selection [2,3]. However, relying solely on heritability has some disadvantages for understanding the forces affecting quantitative genetic variance (QGV) because the additive genetic variance appears in both the numerator and the denominator: h2 = VA/(VA + VNA + VE), where VNA is the non-additive genetic variance and VE is the environmental variance. Furthermore, some of the other variance components in the denominator are likely to be correlated with VA [4]. Therefore, an increase in VA may not lead to a proportional increase in h2. In light of these issues and to better understand the additive genetic variance and thereby the adaptive potential of a population, the evolvability (IA), quantified as VA divided by the square of the mean, was first proposed by Charlesworth [5] and later developed by Houle [6]; note that in some analyses the square root of the evolvability is taken to yield the coefficient of additive genetic variance (CVA). Although DNA sequence diversity is known to vary substantially between species [7], there is little evidence of variation in VA [8]. A recent large-scale analysis across birds and mammals found significant variation among species in heritability but not CVA [9] a pattern the authors suggested might be due to variation between species in the level of non-additive genetic or environmental variance, rather than VA. Previous comparative studies examining relationships between measures of additive genetic (IA and h2) and microsatellite diversity, census population size, or ecological specialization also found no clear associations which would be indicative of variation in VA [8,10,11]. However, there are some cases in which VA has been shown to vary between species for particular traits—for example, desiccation and cold resistance, but not wing size, across Drosophila species [12]. Here, we compile estimates of IA and h2 from a much broader range of multicellular eukaryotes than has been analyzed before and investigate whether there is significant variation between species. We also investigate whether IA and h2 are correlated with various factors expected to influence the level of additive genetic variance. Most models for the maintenance of quantitative genetic variation predict that VA should depend on the mutational input VM [13]. Although there is no evidence that estimates of VM differ significantly between species, such estimates are relatively few and subject to substantial measurement error [14]. Therefore, in this study, we examine whether VA is correlated with the nucleotide mutation rate and with the product of the mutation rate and proteome size, which represents the expected rate of mutations that might affect quantitative genetic variation by capturing the total number of nucleotides contained in protein-coding regions (including alternatively spliced exons) [15]. We use these as proxies for mutational input given the limited number of VM estimates. We also investigate the effects of genome size, ploidy levels, and the number of genes, as these factors may influence the effective mutational target size—the total number of sites at which mutations can alter quantitative traits—beyond what is captured by proteome size alone and thus the mutational input contributing to additive genetic variation [13,16]. Levels of VA are also expected to depend on the effective population size when the trait is neutral ([17]; [18]) or selection on the trait is weak [13,19,20]. Wood and colleagues [10] found no significant correlation between heritability (h²) and the census population size, however, h2 may be a poor comparative measure of VA and census and effective population sizes are thought to be only moderately correlated [21,22]. We test whether VA is correlated to long-term estimates of Ne, estimated by dividing the nucleotide diversity by a direct measure of the mutation rate. Additionally, we might expect VA to be influenced by the rate of recombination because recombination mediates the buildup and breakdown of linkage disequilibrium underlying the Bulmer effect [23], mitigates the reduction of variation caused by Hill–Robertson interference among linked selected sites [24,25], and limits the formation of pseudo-overdominance due to linked recessive alleles [26,27]. We explore this by correlating estimates of VA against the recombination rate per nucleotide, along with whether the species is obligately sexual, or engages in asexual reproduction for some parts of its lifecycle. We also examine whether additional biological variables—such as body mass, body length, longevity, and generation time—are correlated with our measures of additive genetic variance. Methodology Literature search and QGV compilation Heritability and evolvability estimates were compiled from the peer-reviewed literature indexed in the Web of Science for the period between 1992 and 2022. Searches were conducted using “Heritability” or “Evolvability” as topic keywords, with the aim of capturing estimates from a diverse range of species and from natural populations. Therefore, journals focusing on domesticated, crop species, or human populations were excluded. The search was further filtered by only selecting journals with over 200 papers meeting the search criteria and then scanning the first 50 articles by titles when sorted by relevance. This resulted in the choice of four journals: “Journal of Evolutionary Biology,” “Evolution,” “Heredity,” and “Proceedings of the Royal Society B.” When multiple estimates were available for the same trait within a population, we selected a single value based on a standardized evaluation of reliability. Preference was given to estimates derived from larger sample sizes and model structures minimizing potential biases. When estimates were otherwise comparable in these respects, we applied a hierarchy based on the relatedness structure used to estimate additive genetic variation. Animal models were preferred, as they utilize information from all known relationships and are generally the least biased and most precise [28]. When animal model estimates were unavailable, we selected those from parent-offspring regressions, which are less affected by dominance or common environmental effects than sibling-based designs ([29]). The resulting dataset was then merged with the datasets of Mittell and colleagues [8] and Young and Postma [9]. We additionally conducted a targeted search for estimates from species that would increase overlap with our predictor variables. We estimate that we have captured approximately 19% of all relevant heritability and evolvability estimates in our data (S1 Appendix). All recorded estimates of evolvability and heritability were numerically checked where possible and recalculated if sufficient raw data were available. Each estimate was also evaluated for suitability in terms of the trait scale and transformation, as evolvability is only meaningful for traits measured on ratio or log-interval scales, where proportional differences are interpretable [ 4,6]. Heritability estimates were likewise checked for compatibility with the underlying trait scale, as h2 is interpretable for interval and ratio-scale traits, but not for ordinal or nominal traits unless modeled and interpreted appropriately ([2]; [29]). If an evolvability estimate was not given, this was calculated if the necessary data were provided. We removed estimates where artificial selection had been performed on the focal trait, along with estimates from inbred lines, since inbreeding inflates VA. However, estimates were retained from species that are naturally clonal or selfing. We log10-transformed estimates of IA because the estimates are not normally distributed. Consequently, 146 negative and zero evolvability values were removed, as these are undefined under log transformation. Removing these undefined values could, in principle, bias the results by truncating the lower tail of the IA distribution, so we also ran a censored model that retained these. The results were qualitatively similar, but the censored model fit the data substantially worse, so we report only the log-transformed analysis Because IA was log-transformed while h2 was modeled on its natural [0,1] scale, the two response variables are not directly comparable across analyses. Results are therefore interpreted separately. The bounded nature of h2 additionally reduces total variance available to be explained, likely reducing statistical power relative to the IA analyses. For cases in which both IA and h2 have been estimated, we can calculate the residual variance, the sum of the non-additive and environmental variances, which we normalized by dividing it by the square of the mean: IR = IA(1 − h2)/h2 [4]. Interspecific variation models To partition the variation in recorded estimates of VA, a phylogenetic generalized linear mixed model (PGLMM) was fitted using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) implemented in MCMCglmm [30] in R [31]. Weakly informative priors were used throughout. Random-effect variances were modeled using scaled F1,1 priors (scale √1,000), while the residual variance followed an inverse-gamma prior with shape and scale set to 0.001. Fixed effects were assigned normal priors with a mean 0 and variance 108. The MCMC chains were run for 780,000 iterations, with a burn-in of 180,000 and thinning every 250 iterations. Model convergence was assessed through visual inspection of chain mixing. Additionally, we used posterior predictive checks to visually assess model fit. We included a number of fixed and random effects in our model which aim to capture the likely major sources of variation in VA (Table 1). Critical to our analysis are two species-level random effects that capture the variation in VA among species, one associated with phylogenetic inertia (“Phylogeny” in Table 1) and one which is independent of this (“Non-Phylogenetic” in Table 1). The phylogenetic term takes into account that closely related species may covary in their levels of VA; the tree was estimated using Time Tree [32]. 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003819.t001Table 1Summary of the fixed and random effects included in all MCMCglmm models, with the levels of the categorical fixed effects and the rationale for inclusion. For the random effects the number of levels differ between the models for evolvability and heritability and these are separated by | (IA|h2).LevelsExplanation Fixed effects Method 7Estimates of VA can differ across estimation methods because study designs and statistical models can vary in how they partition genetic and environmental sources of variation, and because they rely on different types of relative [9,29] Trait Type 4Estimates of VA depend on trait type (e.g., morphological, life-history) [4,8,9] Dimension 6Assigned based on the mathematical properties of the focal trait. Evolvabilities depend on trait dimension [4] Environment 3Estimates vary between Lab and Wild populations [3] Covariates Number of fixed effects ContinuousIncluded to reflect potential systematic variation in QGV due to model complexity Number of random effects Continuous Random effects Publication ID 269|415Indexes the publications contributing data. Each estimate is assigned a study ID corresponding to the publication it originated from, accounting for non-independence among estimates reported within the same paper Trait 652|1,036Categorical variable representing conceptually similar traits. Trait names vary across studies—and some measures captured slightly different aspects of the same underlying phenotype—we standardized trait labels across the dataset. Phylogeny 172|220Accounts for variation in VA that is due to shared evolutionary history among species Non-Phylogenetic 172|220Captures species—specific variation in VA that is not explained by phylogenetic relatedness Summary of the fixed and random effects included in all MCMCglmm models, with the levels of the categorical fixed effects and the rationale for inclusion. For the random effects the number of levels differ between the models for evolvability and heritability and these are separated by | (IA|h2). The model was fitted to evolvability and heritability estimates separately. Model predictions for the log evolvability and heritability of each species was calculated by extracting the intercept, phylogeny, and species estimates for the ith species at the jth sampling of the chain where X is either log (IA) or h2. These were then averaged across samples of the chain to yield the posterior mean evolvability and heritability for a linear morphological trait estimated with an animal model in a wild population (these are the reference categories in our analysis), along with the 95% credible intervals. To test whether there is significant variation between specific phylogenetic groups represented in our dataset, we averaged the species estimates within each taxonomic subgroup for each sampling of the MCMC. We then calculated pairwise differences between these group means (e.g., plants versus animals, arthropods versus mammals, etc.). From these contrasts, we derived the posterior distribution of the difference in means, quantifying the variation among the phylogenetic groups sampled in our data. To further investigate whether phylogenetic groups differ in their average evolvability or heritability, we estimated the evolvabilities and heritabilities for the internal nodes (n) of our phylogeny, providing posterior estimates for ancestral nodes. These node-level estimates were then used to calculate pairwise differences among major clades, following the same procedure as above. Finally, we extended our original interspecific variation models by including taxonomic groups as fixed effects, allowing us to formally test whether differences in log (IA) or h2 between groups deviate more than expected under the null model of Brownian evolution (the phylogenetic term) with added independent and identically distributed species effects (the non-phylogenetic term). To quantify the amount of variation between our species in terms of evolvability and heritability we took the estimated variance associated with the phylogenetic (Vphylogenetic) and non-phylogenetic (Vnon-phylogenetic) species terms and then assuming the terms are normally distributed, we derived the quartiles of the distribution of the combined distribution. We quantify the variation in terms of the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles. This allows us to state, for example, that the top 25% of species have an evolvability that is at least x-fold greater than the bottom 25% of species. The 95% credible intervals on these ratios were derived from the samples of the chain. Correlation analysis We investigated whether our estimates of IA and h2 could be predicted by a number of factors: the point mutation rate, the point mutation rate multiplied by the number of protein coding sites in the genome, genome size, number of genes, ploidy levels, the effective population size, the rate of recombination per nucleotide, the mode of reproduction, body mass, body length, longevity, and generation time. Body length was defined as the longest linear dimension; we restricted this analysis to animals since body length is hard to assess in plants because of the root system. Data on the predictors were taken from various databases, including Amniote [33], Pantheria [34], Animal Diversity Web [35] as well as some meta-analytic studies such as Wang and Obbard [36], Lynch and colleagues [15], Stapley and colleagues [37], Lewin and Eyre-Walker [38], and the broader literature (see S1 Table for details). All predictors were log10-transformed prior to analysis. To assess the predictive power of each of our predictors, we used the same fixed and random effect structure, prior, and iteration settings as for the interspecific variation models. Since we did not have estimates of each predictor for every species, we ran the analysis for each predictor separately with heritability and evolvability, respectively, as the response variable. The amount of between-species variance explained by each predictor was quantified using a signed R2 [8]. where V(x) is the variance in the focal predictor and β is the regression coefficient. The product β2V(x) represents the between-species variation in the respective measure of VA that is attributable to variation in the predictor, with the sign of R2 taken from the sign of β. The denominator quantifies the total between-species variation, including phylogenetic and species-level components. pMCMC values were used to assess the degree to which coefficients overlapped zero [39], and for multi-level factors, we used the logic of the Wald test to perform an omnibus test of the factor’s overall effect. The Wald statistic was calculated from the posterior mean vector and covariance matrix [8]. Evolvability versus heritability To investigate the relationship between heritability and evolvability, we fitted a bivariate PGLMM with the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic terms as random effects (Table 1) in which h2 and IA were modeled jointly. The phylogenetic effects, non-phylogenetic effects, and residuals were each allowed to covary across response variables and priors were placed on the resulting covariance matrices such that the marginal prior for the variances was identical to that in the univariate models. All MCMC settings were identical to those of the univariate models. There is an expectation for VA to be positively correlated with the non-additive genetic variance and the environmental variance [4]. The sum of these two components is the residual variance (VR), which we scale by dividing by the square of the mean to yield IR. To test whether IA and h2 are correlated to IR we ran bivariate PGLMMs under the same conditions as the h2 and IA model. Results To assess whether additive genetic variance varies systematically between species, we compiled a dataset of evolvability (IA), and heritability (h2) estimates from the literature. Our dataset comprises 1,852 evolvability estimates from 172 species and 3,209 heritability estimates from 220 species, spanning a broad range of multicellular eukaryotes (Figs 1 and 2). We have estimates from roughly equal numbers of birds, mammals, arthropods, and plants, with a small number of estimates from fish, arachnids, amphibians, and reptiles. Many of our estimates were for linear morphological traits estimated using an animal model (493 IA and 572 h2 estimates). For all variables aside from heritability, we perform the analysis on the logarithm of the value, however, we refer to the variable by its name—e.g., all analyses are performed on log10(IA), but we refer to IA and evolvability throughout the text. The predicted evolvability from our model for a linear, morphological trait estimated with an animal model from a wild population for each species, plotted across the phylogeny with their 95% credible intervals. Organism silhouettes were obtained from PhyloPic (https://www.phylopic.org) and are in the public domain (CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication or Public Domain Mark 1.0). The data underlying this figure can be found in the data repository accompanying this paper under the DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20021814. The difference in mean evolvability between groups of animals and plants. Each point represents the posterior mean difference between group means, back transformed to the original data scale. Horizontal bars indicate the 95% credible intervals. The dashed line at 1 indicates no difference between groups. Differences greater than 1 indicate that the first node (first-mentioned group in the y-axis) has a x-fold higher predicted evolvability than the second node. All comparisons are plotted so that the means are positive. The data underlying this figure can be found in the data repository accompanying this paper under the DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20021814. Evolvability (IA) To investigate whether IA varies between species, we fitted a phylogenetic GLMM with two species terms—one capturing differences due to phylogenetic relatedness and another capturing species-specific deviations independent of phylogeny; the total effect due to species is the sum of these terms. The fit of the model to the data was adequate, although the model predicted a deficit of small values and an excess of large values compared to that observed (Fig A in S2 Appendix). We find that IA varies significantly between species (Fig 1), with 39% [95% credible intervals: 16%–58%] of the total variance in the random effects (including the residual variance) in the model attributable to interspecific differences (Table 2). The magnitude of this variation is substantial: the top 25% of species exhibit 9.3-fold [3.5, 23] greater evolvability than the bottom 25% (note that we have transformed evolvability back to the natural, rather than log scales, when discussing fold-differences in evolvability). Most of the interspecific variation reflects phylogenetic structure, with phylogeny accounting for 38% [15%, 58%] (Table 2) of the random effect variance. 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003819.t002Table 2The proportion of the random effects variance explained by the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species variances for evolvability. Also given is the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles of the combined phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species effects on the data scale where 1 indicates no difference; estimates are given to two significant figures unless the value is <0.01, in which case it is listed as 0.Species#species#estimatesPhyloNon-phyloPhylo+non-phyloRatio of quartiles All 172185238%[15, 58]1.0%[0, 3.9]39%[17, 58]9.3[3.5, 23] Animalia 1351,39522%[4.7, 40]1.4%[0, 5.4]24%[6.6, 40]5.0[2.5, 12] Arthropods 3846017%[0, 40]6%[0, 21]23%[3.3, 48]5.8[1.9, 20] Birds 343604.7%[0, 17]3.7%[0, 13]8.4%[0, 24]2.5[1.1, 6.3] Birds and Mammals 6869812%[0, 35]1.8%[0, 7.0]14%[0.01, 36]2.9[1.2, 8.9] Fish 1513322%[0, 68]22%[0, 60]44%[1.4, 83]7.2[1.3, 63] Mammals 3433819%[0, 43]3.3%[0, 13]22%[1.6, 46]3.1[1.5, 6.8] Plants 3542513%[0, 40]8.1%[0, 22]21%[0.16, 46]2.9[1.2, 7.6] The proportion of the random effects variance explained by the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species variances for evolvability. Also given is the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles of the combined phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species effects on the data scale where 1 indicates no difference; estimates are given to two significant figures unless the value is <0.01, in which case it is listed as 0. A substantial part of this phylogenetic effect appears to be a difference between plants and animals, with plants having 4.7-fold [2.7, 8.3] higher IA than animals. Plants also have significantly higher evolvability than each of the individual animal subgroups (Fig 2). This difference between plants and animals, and individual animal groups is also evident in the estimated ancestral values for each group; the ancestor to our sample of plants is estimated to have had 4.3-fold [1.1, 18] higher evolvability than the ancestor of the sample of animals (Fig B in S2 Appendix). However, the difference between plants and animals is consistent with the phylogenetic model. When group identity (plant versus animal) is included as a fixed effect alongside the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species effects in the model, the fixed effect coefficient was not significantly different from zero (mean effect = 0.73 [−1.46, 2.52]; Table B in S2 Appendix); i.e., plants are no more divergent from animals than we might expect given the time that has elapsed since the groups diverged and the rate at which evolvability changes. However, the variation in evolvability between species is not simply due to the difference between plants and animals. If we restrict our interspecific variation model to animals only, we still find significant variation between species, with 24% [7%, 40%] of the variance attributable to species differences (Table 2). We also find significant variation in IA between species within plants, mammals, arthropods, and fish individually (Table 2). In each of these cases, however, the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic effects are not individually significant. This indicates that while there is a significant species effect, the data lack sufficient power to partition the species effect between the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic effects. Given the complexity of the full interspecific variation model, which includes many fixed and random effects, and an assumption that log (IA) is linearly related to the predictors in our model, we performed a simplified analysis using only linear morphological traits estimated with an animal model. This results in 493 estimates from 63 species. Results were qualitatively unchanged: interspecific variation accounted for 58% [32%, 81%], and the phylogeny for 56% [28%, 80%] of the random effect variance. Moreover, if we simply plot the species’ mean IA values for this data the phylogenetic effect remains evident (Fig C in S2 Appendix). Although, our principal focus is whether evolvability varies between species, a number of other fixed effects are significant in our model. We observe substantial differences in evolvability among different trait types (Omnibus test, P(>x2) < 0.001), with behavioral traits exhibiting substantially greater IA than other traits. We also find a significant effect of dimension (P(>x2) < 0.001; Table C in S2 Appendix), where traits that scale quadratically (e.g., area) and cubically (e.g., mass) show 1.7 [0.83, 3.5] and 3.5 [2.2, 5.5] times greater evolvability than those that scale linearly (Fig D in S2 Appendix). Counts exhibit 3.4 [1.9–5.9] times greater evolvability than linear traits. The method of estimation also has a significant effect (P(>x2) = 0.012; Table C in S2 Appendix), with full-sib designs yielding higher estimates that are 4.0 [1.6, 9.8] times greater on average than animal models, and midparent-offspring regression yielding the lowest values that are 0.40 [0.17, 0.92] of the values from the animal model (Fig D in S2 Appendix). Estimates of IA also depend on the environment (P(>x2) = 0.003) in which the estimation was made. However, no individual level differed significantly from the reference level, and direct comparisons between laboratory and wild estimates were not significant (Table C in S2 Appendix; Fig D in S2 Appendix). This indicated that the overall significance arises from moderate differences across multiple environment categories rather than a single strong pairwise contrast. Although these fixed effects account for some of the observed variation in IA, they primarily serve to control for differences in methodology and trait choice across publications, and do not explain the interspecific variation in IA that we detect. To investigate what might be causing this variation, we conducted PGLMMs including a suite of predictors: nucleotide mutation rate, estimated total point mutation rate of the proteome, genome size, number of genes, ploidy level, recombination rate per site, mode of reproduction, and estimates of effective population size. In addition, we assessed associations between evolvability and life-history traits such as body mass, body length, longevity, and generation time. Among all variables tested, only body length (which we have only assessed for animals) exhibited a statistically significant association with evolvability after applying a Bonferroni correction for multiple testing. Body length accounted for approximately 46% [4.9%, 94%] of the between-species variance in evolvability, and the model predicts that doubling body size increases IA by 1.3-fold [1.1, 1.5]. No other predictors were significant predictors of evolvability after correction for multiple tests; however, the credible intervals are broad, indicating we have little power to detect associations (Table 3). 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003819.t003Table 3The regression of evolvability on various variables. Given is the number of estimates and the number of species from which those estimates come from for each analysis, along with the posterior means with their CIs and pMCMC (twice the posterior probability that the effect lies on the opposite site of zero from its estimated direction) as well as the signed R2 for all IA indicating the proportion of the between-species variance explained. For the categorical predictors, the p-value of the omnibus test are denoted as P(>X2). For the categorical predictors, the posterior means are the deviation from the reference levels (Diploid and Sexual, respectively). An * in the pMCMC or P(>χ2) column indicates a significant effect after Bonferroni correction. Continuous predictors were log10-transformed.Predictor of IAN estimatesN speciesPost. mean p MCMC R 2 Mutation Rate 51142−0.366[−0.776, 0.053]0.073−0.101[−0.342, 0.013] Protein Coding Mutation Rate 41331−0.432[−0.902, 0.009]0.064−0.251[−0.754, 0.020] Genome Size 90061−0.101[−0.541, 0.300]0.641−0.024[−0.171, 0.103] Number of Genes 1,223104−0.020[−0.972, 0.901]0.817−0.001[−0.102, 0.988] Rate of Recombination 618330.182[−0.278, 0.681]0.4480.053[−0.097, 0.278] Effective Population Size 403320.213[−0.286, 0.744]0.4210.038[−0.050, 0.191] Generation Time 44337−0.100[−0.386, 0.173]0.455−0.112[−0.580, 0.182] Longevity 1,318104−0.065[−0.244, 0.115]0.454−0.021[−0.109, 0.037] Body Length 868790.358[0.131, 0.568]0.003*0.456[0.049, 0.943] Body Mass 751710.106[−0.002, 0.227]0.0720.358[−0.020, 0.885] Categorical Predictors N estimates N species Post. mean P(>χ2) R 2 Haplodiploid 1,6451270.074[−0.444, 0.593]0.670.029[0.001, 0.105] Polyploid −0.035[−0.431, 0.381] Mixed Reproduction 1,7841590.208[−0.107, 0.533]0.130.077[0.002, 0.240] Asexual Reproduction 0.146[−1.553, 1.806] The regression of evolvability on various variables. Given is the number of estimates and the number of species from which those estimates come from for each analysis, along with the posterior means with their CIs and pMCMC (twice the posterior probability that the effect lies on the opposite site of zero from its estimated direction) as well as the signed R2 for all IA indicating the proportion of the between-species variance explained. For the categorical predictors, the p-value of the omnibus test are denoted as P(>X2). For the categorical predictors, the posterior means are the deviation from the reference levels (Diploid and Sexual, respectively). An * in the pMCMC or P(>χ2) column indicates a significant effect after Bonferroni correction. Continuous predictors were log10-transformed. Heritability When we run our model on heritability, we find that the model fits the data reasonably well except that there is a large excess of h2 estimates at zero compared to what the model predicts (Fig E in S2 Appendix). This excess of zero estimates is almost certainly methodological, arising because many of the analyses return zero estimates of VA when relatives exhibit negatively correlated trait values. As with evolvability, we find evidence of significant variation between species—the proportion of the random effects variance explained by between-species differences is 24% [4.9%, 52%], though these proportions are not directly comparable because we have log-transformed IA and the two statistics have different bounds. However, this variation cannot be clearly attributed to either phylogenetic or non-phylogenetic components when considered separately (Table 4). The lack of a clear phylogenetic signal is evident when the predicted h2 from our model for each species are plotted on a phylogeny (Fig 3). We also find significant variation in h2 within plants and animals, respectively; however, the smaller taxonomic subgroups as mammals and fish only harbor marginally significant interspecific variation, while the remaining groups tested do not show significant differences (Table 4). Overall, we find that h2 varies quite substantially between species; the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles is 1.8-fold [1.3, 2.6]. 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003819.t004Table 4The proportion of the random effects variance explained by the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species variances for heritability. Also given is the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles of the combined phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species effects on the data scale where 1 indicates no difference; estimates are given to two significant figures unless the value is <0.01, in which case it is listed as 0.Species#species#estimatesPhyloNon-phyloPhylo+non-phyloRatio of quartiles All 2223,20928%[0.35, 57]4.4%[0, 12]32%[11, 60]1.8[1.3, 2.6] Animalia 1732,49712%[0.67, 26]1.9%[0,6.3]14%[2.1, 27]1.4[1.2, 1.7] Arthropods 498843.1[0, 13]2.5%[0, 9.7]5.6%[0, 17]1.2[1.0, 1.5] Birds 446063.5[0, 14]2.1%[0, 7.8]5.6%[0, 18]1.2[1.0, 1.5] Birds and Mammals 821,1186.7%[0, 25]1.4%[0, 5.4]8.2%[0, 26]1.2[1.0, 1.6] Fish 1722521%[0, 62]15%[0, 44]36%[0.01, 70]1.9[1.1, 3.4] Mammals 3851219%[0, 50]6.6%[0, 25]25%[0.15, 55]1.5[1.1, 2.1] Plants 4159929%[0, 67]10%[0, 33]40%[9.3, 71]2.1[1.3, 3.6] The proportion of the random effects variance explained by the phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species variances for heritability. Also given is the ratio of the upper and lower quartiles of the combined phylogenetic and non-phylogenetic species effects on the data scale where 1 indicates no difference; estimates are given to two significant figures unless the value is <0.01, in which case it is listed as 0. The predicted heritability from our model for a linear, morphological trait estimated with an animal model from a wild population for each species, plotted across the phylogeny with their 95% credible intervals. Organism silhouettes were obtained from PhyloPic (https://www.phylopic.org) and are in the public domain (CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication or Public Domain Mark 1.0). The data underlying this figure can be found in the data repository accompanying this paper under the DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20021814. All the fixed effects (Table 1) in our interspecific variation model (i.e., the model without any predictors such as the nucleotide mutation rate) are significant, with the exception of the number of fixed effects (pMCMC = 0.118; Table D in S2 Appendix). Consistent with previous research, h2 varies significantly between trait types (Omnibus test, P(>x2) < 0.001) with morphological traits having the highest h2 and fitness traits the lowest (the average difference in heritability between morphological and fitness traits is 0.15 [0.013, 0.28] (Table D in S2 Appendix; Fig F in S2 Appendix). We also find that the method of estimation has a significant effect (pMCMC < 0.001, Table D in S2 Appendix; Fig F in S2 Appendix) with full-sib designs yielding estimates of heritability that are 0.21 [0.11, 0.30] higher than animal models, which yield similar estimates to other methods. We also find a weak but significant effect of dimension (P(>x2) = 0.012; Table D in S2 Appendix; Fig F in S2 Appendix) and the environment (P(>x2) = 0.002, Table D in S2 Appendix; Fig F in S2 Appendix). The effect of the environment seems to largely reflect higher heritability estimates from laboratory studies compared to those from natural populations (pMCMC = 0.003, Table D in S2 Appendix; Fig F in S2 Appendix). Although we observe significant variation in narrow-sense heritability (h²) across species, most predictors tested do not exhibit statistically significant associations after Bonferroni correction (Table 5). The exception is ploidy level (P(>x2) = 0.004), with polyploids showing lower heritability than diploids. 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003819.t005Table 5The regression of heritability on various variables. Given is the number of estimates and the number of species from which those estimates come from for each analysis, along with the posterior means with their CIs and pMCMC (twice the posterior probability that the effect lies on the opposite site of zero from its estimated direction) as well as the signed R2 for all h2 indicating the proportion of the between-species variance explained. For the categorical predictors the p-value of the omnibus test are denoted as P(>X2). For the categorical predictors, the posterior means are the deviation from the reference levels (Diploid and Sexual, respectively). An * in the pMCMC or P(>χ2) column indicates a significant correlation after Bonferroni correction. Continuous predictors were log10-transformed.Predictor of h2N estimatesN speciesPost. mean p MCMC R 2 Mutation Rate 83646−0.024[−0.167, 0.098]0.693−0.021[−0.149, 0.081] Protein Coding Mutation Rate 70234−0.119[−0.237,0.002]0.056−0.229[−0.654, 0.008] Genome Size 1,514700.025[−0.085, 0.140]0.6620.021[−0.075, 0.146] Number of Genes 2052103−0.150[−0.391, 0.108]0.249−0.055[−0.215, 0.034] Rate of Recombination 1,02139−0.021[−0.157, 0.120]0.738−0.024[−0.233, 0.147] Effective Population Size 681350.006[−0.126, 0.141]0.957−0.002[−0.143, 0.131] Generation Time 72140−0.010[−0.081, 0.064]0.790−0.028[−0.297, 0.215] Longevity 2,249135−0.046[−0.093, 0.002]0.045−0.057[−0.165, 0.002] Body Length 1,4891030.019[−0.040, 0.083]0.5190.042[−0.071, 0.231] Body Mass 1,276950.004[−0.026, 0.033]0.8040.010[−0.242, 0.294] Categorical predictors N estimates N species Post. mean P(>χ2) R 2 Haplodiploid 2,6821680.003[−0.134, 0.149]0.004*−0.190[−0.375, −0.043] Polyploid −0.192[−0.314, −0.089] Mixed Reproduction 3,1012100.272[−0.125, 0.675]0.1570.095[0.007, 0.275] Asexual Reproduction 0.097[−0.044, 0.223] The regression of heritability on various variables. Given is the number of estimates and the number of species from which those estimates come from for each analysis, along with the posterior means with their CIs and pMCMC (twice the posterior probability that the effect lies on the opposite site of zero from its estimated direction) as well as the signed R2 for all h2 indicating the proportion of the between-species variance explained. For the categorical predictors the p-value of the omnibus test are denoted as P(>X2). For the categorical predictors, the posterior means are the deviation from the reference levels (Diploid and Sexual, respectively). An * in the pMCMC or P(>χ2) column indicates a significant correlation after Bonferroni correction. Continuous predictors were log10-transformed. Evolvability versus heritability Although estimates of IA and h2 are significantly correlated across individual estimates, the correlation is weak (r = 0.24 [0.20, 0.29]; Fig G in S2 Appendix), and there is no significant correlation between IA and h2 across species (r = 0.13 [−0.13, 0.38]; Fig G in S2 Appendix). There are several reasons why IA and h2 might be weakly correlated. In particular, it has previously been shown that the residual variance—the sum of the non-additive genetic and environmental variances—is positively correlated to VA across individual estimates [4]. Consistent with this, we find a strong positive correlation between residual variance (mean-scaled, IR) and IA across individual estimates (r = 0.73 [0.70, 0.75]; Fig H in S2 Appendix) and species (r = 0.69 [0.47, 0.89]; Fig H in S2 Appendix). Similarly, we find a significantly negative relationship between h2 and IR across individual estimates (r = −0.33 [−0.36, −0.29]; Fig I in S2 Appendix) and species (r = −0.51 [−0.68, −0.28]; Fig I in S2 Appendix). In addition to the correlations, we also analyzed the interspecific variation in IR itself using an interspecific variation model and find that the variation in IR follows a similar pattern to IA; there is a strong phylogenetic component (interspecific variation = 29% [8.3%, 53%]) (Table E in S2 Appendix) with plants having substantially more residual variance than other phylogenetic groups (Fig J in S2 Appendix). Discussion We find significant interspecific variation for two measures of additive genetic variance, the evolvability (IA), the additive genetic variance divided by the square of the mean, and the heritability (h2). For evolvability, a substantial portion of the observed variation can be attributed to phylogenetic relatedness—closely related species tend to exhibit more similar evolvabilities than distantly related species. Much of this phylogenetic signal appears to be driven by plants, which exhibit markedly higher evolvability than animals. Despite this broad taxonomic trend, we also observe substantial variation within major clades, including within both plants and animals, and within most taxonomic groups for which we have sufficient data—birds being the notable exception (Table 2). The variation in evolvability is substantial; we estimate that the top 25% of species have more than 9-fold [3.5, 23] more evolvability than the bottom 25% of species. An important question is whether the variation we observe in our analysis is due to variation between studies and populations, rather than between species, given that measures of VA can vary between populations of the same species [40–42]. Several lines of evidence suggest that there is genuine variation between species. In particular, there is a substantial phylogenetic effect for IA that cannot be explained by population-level variation. Moreover, our overall model structure—including study-level and other random effects—effectively accounts for variation among populations within species. Previously, Young and Postma [9] found significant variation in h2 across mammalian and avian species, without a detectable phylogenetic signal, but no evidence of variation in CVA, the square root of IA. We performed a comparable analysis using our database of estimates from mammals and birds. Their original dataset had 1822 heritabilities for 68 species and only 378 CVA estimates for 23 species, we compiled 1,118 heritabilities for 82 species and 698 estimates of IA for 68 species, for mammals and birds. We find interspecific variation in evolvability but not in heritability for this dataset. Biologically, our results are broadly concordant with those of Young and Postma [9], and the apparent differences in findings likely reflect methodological rather than biological factors. Why does evolvability vary between species? Although we find substantial variation in evolvability, we do not find that it is predicted by any variable that we have tested except body length. Particularly surprising is the lack of a correlation between evolvability and the mutation rate since most models of the maintenance of the additive genetic variance predict that it should depend on the mutational variance [13]. There are several reasons why we might not have detected an effect. First, available proxies for mutational input are relatively crude. We assessed whether evolvability correlates with the nucleotide mutation rate alone, as well as with the mutation rate scaled by proteome size; for these variables, we have few estimates. We also considered the number of protein-coding genes (without multiplying this by the mutation rate, which is only known for a limited number of species). However, the number of genes likely represents a limited proxy for the genomic regions in which mutations can generate phenotypic effects. It does not account for the amount of regulatory DNA, which is likely to vary among species and indeed, most GWAS hits fall in non-coding regions [43,44], meaning that proxies based on proteome size or gene number likely miss much of the mutational target relevant for quantitative traits. Moreover, under most models of quantitative genetic variation maintenance, mutational variance is influenced not only by mutation rate but also by the distribution of effect sizes, which is also known to vary across species [45,46]. Unfortunately, we have very few estimates for the distribution of effect sizes. However, possibly the biggest omission in our estimate of the mutation rate are structural variants (SVs) including transposable element (TE) insertions. There is evidence from Drosophila [47,48] and yeast [49] that SVs can contribute substantially to additive genetic variation. Unfortunately, estimates for the rate at which SVs occur have been estimated for very few species. It is also possible that IA is not correlated to our estimates of the mutational variance because it does not differ substantially between species, in which case it could not account for the variation in IA we observe. We also find no correlation between evolvability and the effective population size. This might be due to a lack of power; both our estimates of Ne and species mean IA are subject to reasonable levels of error. However, in the light of current theory, a strong IA ~ Ne relationship is not generally expected. Classical models show that VA scales with Ne under neutrality [50] and that under mutation-selection-drift balance, VA becomes sensitive to Ne only when drift is strong relative to selection [19,51]. Under stabilizing selection, most mutational input is deleterious and removed by selection before drift can act, making VA largely insensitive to Ne except at very small Ne [20,52]. Moreover, the effective neutral mutational input (Neu) does not necessarily increase with Ne: as Ne increases, the fraction of mutations that are effectively neutral declines, reducing the effective mutational heritability [13]. Recent work reframing these results in terms of nucleotide diversity similarly emphasizes that strong VA ~ Ne scaling is expected only when traits behave neutrally or when Ne is sufficiently small that drift dominates selection [18]. The absence of a detectable IA ~ Ne correlation in our analysis is therefore consistent with theoretical expectations. The one significant correlation we detect is a positive relationship between evolvability and body size in animals (measured as the maximum linear dimension), which remains statistically significant after correcting for multiple tests (p = 0.003, multiple‐test–corrected significance threshold = 0.004). This might arise because larger-bodied species tend to have longer generation times, and species with long generation times have higher mutation rates per generation [36,53] although we tested for a correlation between evolvability and the mutation rate, we had few estimates in our analysis and hence low power. There is also some evidence that larger-bodied species have larger ranges [54,55] and might therefore be exposed to different environments, leading to maintenance of locally adaptive genetic variation. Finally, the observed positive correlation may also be influenced by trait scaling. If the additive genetic variance does not increase linearly with the square of the trait mean, IA will tend to increase with larger trait values. While this could in principle be tested by excluding size traits, the majority of our dataset consists of such traits, and removing them would result in a severe loss of power, preventing reliable inference. Although this study explored a range of factors that could explain interspecific variation in quantitative genetic parameters, there are additional important forces we have not explored. One such factor is selection, which is expected to affect levels of additive genetic variance (though not always under directional selection—see [56]). However, the extent to which selection varies among species is largely unknown, because meta-analyses of selection gradients rarely account for species identity or phylogenetic relatedness [57]. Finally, population structure—such as sub-division and migration—could influence VA, but we have little information on these for the species we have analyzed. Why is evolvability higher in plants? We find that plants have significantly higher evolvability than animals. Although our analysis suggests that the difference between plants and animals is no more than we might expect under a simple phylogenetic model of trait evolution, the difference is substantial, with plants estimated to have ~4.7-fold [2.7, 8.3] more evolvability than animals. Unfortunately, understanding why plants and animals differ is challenging because there are many fundamental differences between plants and animals, and both groups are monophyletic; as a result, we have limited statistical power to test hypotheses. For example, plants generally have many more genes than animals (in our dataset, the mean number of genes is 2.3-fold greater than in animals), but because there is relatively little variation in gene number within plants and animals, we have few independent contrasts to detect an association. We find no evidence that this pattern might be attributable to differences in the mutation rate, effective population size, mating system, genome size, or ploidy. However, there are two conspicuous differences between plants and animals that might contribute to the difference in evolvability between the groups. First, plants have an additional genome, in the chloroplast. While both plastid and mitochondrial genomes are small relative to the nuclear genome, studies have shown that genetic variation in the mitochondrial genome can significantly contribute to phenotypic variation in animals [58,59]. A meta-analysis of studies in which mtDNA was introgressed between nuclear backgrounds in animals suggested the effects can be substantial, with nearly 50% of cases changing the mean up or down by >10% [60] although this is likely to be an overestimate due to sampling error [61]. Similarly, the limited number of studies that have considered the effect of the organellar DNA on phenotypic variation in plants have found substantial effects [62–65]. The second major difference between plants and animals is the potential for transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (TEI) [66]. There are examples of TEI in both plants and animals [67], but no comparative study of how much epigenetic variation is inherited in the two groups of organisms. However, there are some reasons for believing that inherited epigenetic variation might be greater in plants than animals. There are several pathways by which TEI can be propagated [67], but the simplest is through DNA methylation, and most methylation marks are not removed during gametogenesis in plants, whereas extensive remodeling occurs in animals [66,67]. Experiments using epigenetic recombinant inbred lines (epiRILs) of Arabidopsis thaliana suggest that heritable differences in methylation can generate substantial phenotypic variation [68,69] comparable in magnitude to differences observed among natural accessions. Broad sense heritability amongst epiRILs can be as high as 90% for some traits, such as flowering time, but essentially absent for others [64,69]. However, an epiRIL experiment gives an upper estimate for the variation induced by heritable methylation since it involves crossing methylated and largely unmethylated parental strains, hence generating more diversity in methylation than would be seen in a natural population. The fact that largely unmethylated strains are viable suggests that DNA methylation might not play an essential or widespread role in generating large amounts of additive genetic variance, even if it can influence particular phenotypes. Although natural populations do contain epigenetic variation in methylation [70,71], much of this appears to be genetically determined [71]. It therefore seems unlikely that epigenetic variation is why plants have higher evolvability than animals. Evolvability—Other effects Hansen and colleagues [4] reported that the evolvability of cubic traits was roughly nine times that of linear traits, implying strong genetic correlations among trait dimensions (e.g., between height and width). In contrast, our analysis finds that the ratio of linear, quadratic, and cubic traits is closer to 1:2:3, consistent with variation in different dimensions being largely independent. The difference between our study and that of Hansen and colleagues [4] might be due to our larger sample size and the fact that we have modeled many effects they did not, including the method of estimation, trait type and the relatedness of the species in our sample; if we simply take the median estimates of the observed IA values we find a pattern closer to that originally reported by Hansen and colleagues [4]. An additional difference is that our analyses are based on log-transformed IA values, whereas Hansen and colleagues [23] used raw IA, which might also contribute to the differences we observe. Biologically, one might have expected an intermediate scaling between the different dimensions, given that our dataset is extremely heterogeneous spanning diverse species and traits that likely vary in their degree of dimensional integration. However, a more robust test of these scaling relationships will require a dataset with a greater representation of higher-dimensional traits. We also show, for the first time, that count traits exhibit significantly higher evolvability (IA) and lower heritability (h²) compared to linear traits. While Hansen and colleagues [4] did consider counts they did so only for size traits. The relatively high IA of count traits may reflect a combination of biological and statistical factors. Biologically, count traits often arise from modular or discrete developmental processes, where variation among semi-independent units (e.g., number of leaves or offspring) can accumulate additively. Methodologically, the scaling of variance by the mean may contribute to elevated IA values when counts are low or distributions are skewed, as we might expect under a Poisson distribution, overdispersion or zero-inflated distributions, although not all count traits conform to such distributions. Interestingly, when we examine evolvability across different trait types, we find no significant difference between life-history and morphological traits, contrary to previous analyses [4,9]. Our analysis, however, varies from previous studies in several ways. Firstly, we separate fitness and life-history, yet neither is significantly different from morphological traits in IA. We also include a random effect grouping traits that, although labeled differently across publications, measure the same underlying property (e.g., body size). Lastly, we explicitly account for trait dimensions across all trait types. If we remove trait dimension from our analysis, we find that life-history traits have higher evolvability than morphology traits. This result is particularly interesting when considering the distribution of trait dimensions across the different trait types. Morphological traits are predominantly linear (65%), with smaller proportions being quadratic (5.3%) or cubic (21%). In contrast, life-history traits are mostly durations (46%) and counts (51%). These distributions suggest that apparent differences between life-history and morphological traits may reflect underlying differences in trait dimensionality rather than intrinsic differences in evolvability. Hansen and colleagues [4] demonstrated that the residual variance (the sum of the environmental and non-additive genetic variance) is positively correlated with the additive genetic variance across individual estimates of these quantities, a pattern we replicate. They argue that the relationship exists because increases in allele frequencies are expected to increase the additive and epistatic variances [72]. Furthermore, the additive, epistatic, and dominance variances all depend on the number of loci underlying a trait. Houle [6] has also argued that the environmental variance should increase with the additive genetic variance across trait types because complex traits are probably more sensitive to both genetic and environmental perturbation. Extending these findings, we find a strong and significant relationship between IR and IA across species, demonstrating that the positive relationship observed at the level of individual estimates also holds at the species level. This is consistent with our observation that interspecific variation in IR follows the same trend as IA—phylogenetic signal with higher estimates in plants. This suggests that factors linking the additive and residual variances operate not only within species but also across species. Heritability We find significant variation in heritability across species, with the upper and lower quartiles varying by nearly 2-fold. This variation could reflect differences in additive, non-additive, or environmental variance. Across species, we find no evidence of a relationship between IA and h2, suggesting that the interspecific variation in h2 is unlikely to be driven primarily by differences in the additive genetic variance. In contrast, the mean-scaled residual variance (IR) varies significantly between species and is strongly positively correlated with IA and negatively correlated with h2 across both estimates and species. This pattern suggests, as proposed by Young and Postma [9], that the observed between-species variation in h2 is likely influenced more by differences in residual variance than by differences in the additive genetic variance. As with evolvability, we find only one variable that explains some of the variation in h2, this is ploidy level. Polyploids exhibit significantly lower h2 than diploids, which may reflect increased opportunities for epistasis and other non-additive genetic interactions in polyploids. Some of this epistatic variance may contribute to the additive genetic variance depending on the experimental design, but overall, it is consistent with the idea that higher levels of non-additive variation obscure the relationship between IA and h2 at the species level. We find evidence that estimates of h2 are generally higher in the lab than in natural populations contrary to a previous meta-analysis [73]. However, we have many more estimates and probably increased power because we have modeled many fixed effects that influence h2. The difference between lab and wild estimates is not likely to be due to higher VA in lab populations, as IA is not significantly elevated in lab populations. A commonly invoked explanation is that laboratory conditions reduce environmental variance, thereby inflating heritability estimates. However, we find no significant difference between lab and natural populations in IR. This suggests that the higher heritabilities observed in laboratory studies cannot be attributed simply to reduced residual variance under controlled environments and may reflect more subtle differences between laboratory and natural settings that affect how genetic and environmental variation contribute to phenotypic variance. Consistent with previous literature, we find that morphological traits have higher heritability than other trait types [9,4]. In contrast, count traits exhibit lower h2 despite having high IA. This pattern mirrors our findings that count traits have significantly higher IR (Table E in S2 Appendix). Because heritability is sensitive to the residual variance whereas IA is not, elevated IR in count traits can lead to reduced h2 even when evolvability is high. Summary We find substantial interspecific variation in evolvability (IA), with clear phylogenetic signal indicating that closely related species tend to have more similar levels of evolvability, with plants standing out with particularly high levels. While we also find significant interspecific variation in heritability (h2), and the absence of a correlation with IA suggests that this variation might be due to variation in the residual variance. Although we find significant variation in the additive genetic variance between species, we are unable to explain this. Nevertheless, our results suggest that some species have a substantially greater capacity to evolve. Supporting information Predictor variables used in the study and their corresponding data sources. (CSV) Analysis quantifying the proportion of QGV estimates represented in our dataset. (PDF) Supplementary figures and tables. (PDF) 20 Feb 2026 Dear Dr Zijmers, Thank you for submitting your manuscript entitled "Levels of additive genetic variation vary substantially between species" for consideration as a Research Article by PLOS Biology. Your Appeal of our previous decision to decline your manuscript has now been evaluated by the PLOS Biology editorial staff, as well as by an academic editor with relevant expertise, and I'm writing to let you know that we would like to send your submission out for external peer review. However, before we can send your manuscript to reviewers, we need you to complete your submission by providing the metadata that is required for full assessment. To this end, please login to Editorial Manager where you will find the paper in the 'Submissions Needing Revisions' folder on your homepage. Please click 'Revise Submission' from the Action Links and complete all additional questions in the submission questionnaire. Once your full submission is complete, your paper will undergo a series of checks in preparation for peer review. After your manuscript has passed the checks it will be sent out for review. To provide the metadata for your submission, please Login to Editorial Manager (https://www.editorialmanager.com/pbiology) within two working days, i.e. by Feb 24 2026 11:59PM. If your manuscript has been previously peer-reviewed at another journal, PLOS Biology is willing to work with those reviews in order to avoid re-starting the process. Submission of the previous reviews is entirely optional and our ability to use them effectively will depend on the willingness of the previous journal to confirm the content of the reports and share the reviewer identities. Please note that we reserve the right to invite additional reviewers if we consider that additional/independent reviewers are needed, although we aim to avoid this as far as possible. In our experience, working with previous reviews does save time. If you would like us to consider previous reviewer reports, please edit your cover letter to let us know and include the name of the journal where the work was previously considered and the manuscript ID it was given. In addition, please upload a response to the reviews as a 'Prior Peer Review' file type, which should include the reports in full and a point-by-point reply detailing how you have or plan to address the reviewers' concerns. During the process of completing your manuscript submission, you will be invited to opt-in to posting your pre-review manuscript as a bioRxiv preprint. Visit http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/s/preprints for full details. If you consent to posting your current manuscript as a preprint, please upload a single Preprint PDF. Feel free to email us at plosbiology@plos.org if you have any queries relating to your submission. Kind regards, Roli Roberts Roland Roberts, PhD Senior Editor PLOS Biology rroberts@plos.org 21 Mar 2026 Dear Dr Zijmers, Thank you for your patience while your manuscript "Levels of additive genetic variation vary substantially between species" was peer-reviewed at PLOS Biology. It has now been evaluated by the PLOS Biology editors, an Academic Editor with relevant expertise, and by two independent reviewers. Based on the reviews, we are likely to accept this manuscript for publication, provided you satisfactorily address the remaining points raised by the reviewers and the following data and other policy-related requests. IMPORTANT - please attend to the following: a) Please address the requests from the reviewers. You'll see that Reviewer #1 is very positive, but wants you to estimate the proportion of studies which your search strategy captures, and has a short list of minor points. Reviewer #2 doesn’t assess the overall advance, but sounds positive, and has a somewhat longer list of relatively minor points, one of which involves further (minor) analysis. b) Please address my Data Policy requests below; specifically, we need you to supply the numerical values underlying Figs 1, 2, 3, S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, S6, S7, S8, S9, S10, either as a supplementary data file or as a permanent DOI’d deposition. I note that you have stated intention to deposit these in Zenodo. Please can you now do so (I will need to check data policy compliance before accepting), and confirm whether the data and code in this deposition are sufficient to recreate the Figures? c) Please cite the location of the data clearly in all relevant main and supplementary Figure legends, e.g. “The data and code needed to generate this Figure can be found in https://zenodo.org/records/XXXXXXXX" and update your Data Availability statement accordingly. d) Please include the URL of your funder in the Financial Disclosure statement. As you address these items, please take this last chance to review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the cover letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. In addition to these revisions, you may need to complete some formatting changes, which you will receive in a follow up email. A member of our team will be in touch with a set of requests shortly. If you do not receive a separate email within a few days, please assume that checks have been completed, and no additional changes are required. We expect to receive your revised manuscript within two weeks. To submit your revision, please go to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pbiology/ and log in as an Author. Click the link labelled 'Submissions Needing Revision' to find your submission record. Your revised submission must include the following: - a cover letter that should detail your responses to any editorial requests, if applicable, and whether changes have been made to the reference list - a Response to Reviewers file that provides a detailed response to the reviewers' comments (if applicable, if not applicable please do not delete your existing 'Response to Reviewers' file.) - a track-changes file indicating any changes that you have made to the manuscript. NOTE: If Supporting Information files are included with your article, note that these are not copyedited and will be published as they are submitted. Please ensure that these files are legible and of high quality (at least 300 dpi) in an easily accessible file format. For this reason, please be aware that any references listed in an SI file will not be indexed. For more information, see our Supporting Information guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/s/supporting-information *Published Peer Review History* Please note that you may have the opportunity to make the peer review history publicly available. The record will include editor decision letters (with reviews) and your responses to reviewer comments. If eligible, we will contact you to opt in or out. Please see here for more details: https://plos.org/published-peer-review-history/ *Press* Should you, your institution's press office or the journal office choose to press release your paper, please ensure you have opted out of Early Article Posting on the submission form. We ask that you notify us as soon as possible if you or your institution is planning to press release the article. *Protocols deposition* To enhance the reproducibility of your results, we recommend that if applicable you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io, where a protocol can be assigned its own identifier (DOI) such that it can be cited independently in the future. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions. Sincerely, Roli Roberts Roland Roberts, PhD Senior Editor rroberts@plos.org PLOS Biology ------------------------------------------------------------------------ DATA POLICY: You may be aware of the PLOS Data Policy, which requires that all data be made available without restriction: http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/s/data-availability. For more information, please also see this editorial: http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001797 Note that we do not require all raw data. Rather, we ask that all individual quantitative observations that underlie the data summarized in the figures and results of your paper be made available in one of the following forms: 1) Supplementary files (e.g., excel). Please ensure that all data files are uploaded as 'Supporting Information' and are invariably referred to (in the manuscript, figure legends, and the Description field when uploading your files) using the following format verbatim: S1 Data, S2 Data, etc. Multiple panels of a single or even several figures can be included as multiple sheets in one excel file that is saved using exactly the following convention: S1_Data.xlsx (using an underscore). 2) Deposition in a publicly available repository. Please also provide the accession code or a reviewer link so that we may view your data before publication. Regardless of the method selected, please ensure that you provide the individual numerical values that underlie the summary data displayed in the following figure panels as they are essential for readers to assess your analysis and to reproduce it: Figs 1, 2, 3, S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, S6, S7, S8, S9, S10. NOTE: the numerical data provided should include all replicates AND the way in which the plotted mean and errors were derived (it should not present only the mean/average values). IMPORTANT: Please also ensure that figure legends in your manuscript include information on where the underlying data can be found, and ensure your supplemental data file/s has a legend. Please ensure that your Data Statement in the submission system accurately describes where your data can be found. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ CODE POLICY Per journal policy, if you have generated any custom code during the course of this investigation, please make it available without restrictions. Please ensure that the code is sufficiently well documented and reusable, and that your Data Statement in the Editorial Manager submission system accurately describes where your code can be found. More information on our Code Policy, what and how to share can be found here: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/s/code-availability Please note that we cannot accept sole deposition of code in GitHub, as this could be changed after publication. However, you can archive this version of your publicly available GitHub code to Zenodo. Once you do this, it will generate a DOI number, which you will need to provide in the Data Accessibility Statement (you are welcome to also provide the GitHub access information). See the process for doing this here: https://docs.github.com/en/repositories/archiving-a-github-repository/referencing-and-citing-content ------------------------------------------------------------------------ DATA NOT SHOWN? - Please note that per journal policy, we do not allow the mention of "data not shown", "personal communication", "manuscript in preparation" or other references to data that is not publicly available or contained within this manuscript. Please either remove mention of these data or provide figures presenting the results and the data underlying the figure(s). ------------------------------------------------------------------------ REVIEWERS' COMMENTS: Reviewer #1: This manuscript describes an impressive survey of the heritability and evolvability of quantitative traits in wild populations. The authors collect a comprehensive dataset, and then show that these fundamental quantitative genetic parameters vary between species, in a way that is explained by phylogeny; plants have especially high evolvability. They then go on to test whether various features that might be expected to affect additive genetic variation, such as mutation rate, genome size, and recombination rate influence h² and IA. They don't find evidence for any of these features being important, but discuss these findings in a thoughtful and balanced way. I greatly enjoyed reading this manuscript. It's exceptionally clearly written and explained, and it tackles some big questions in evolutionary genetics. It seems almost certain to be very widely cited, and I think it would be a really good PLoS Biology paper. I have some suggestions (below), but they are really very minor. Main Comments The literature search is very well described and I can see why you took the decision to restrict the dataset to papers published in those four journals (JEB, Evolution, Heredity, Proc R Soc. B). However, given that one of the conclusions is that the sample sizes might be too small to detect the influence of, say, mutation rate, on h² and IA, that got me wondering what proportion of suitable studies had been captured by those four journals? It should be possible to crudely estimate this, even from the initial filtering of possible papers. It might be useful to discuss briefly what proportion of suitable studies you've sampled. Minor comments and typos Lines 69. 74. Is there a strong justification for choosing proteome size over exome size? Line 183 suggests you mean exome size anyway? I tend to think of the proteome as including all splice variants, whereas the exome refers to all coding parts of the genome. i.e. the former would count some sites multiple times, if they contribute to different splice variants, but the latter would count each site only one. Lines125-126. Does removing the values that had zero or negative evolvability introduce a bias. i.e. by pruning the lowest values from the dataset. Page 229 - on the logarithm, not of the logarithm? Page 233 - we fitted? Reviewer #2: This is a rather densely-packed ms that took a couple of reads. In large part, this is not because of poor writing/presentation, but rather that the meta-analysis attempts to examine so many features that there are a lot of moving parts to follow. The key features are both the size/scale of the dataset and the use of a phylogenetic mixed-model to allow for correlations between taxa (based on the inverse of their branch lengths). The ms attempts to model both narrow-sense heritability (h2) and evolvability (basically, differences in how the additive variance is scaled), and finds that there is little correlation between the two measures. Further, evolvability shows much greater variance than heritability. Most of my issues with the ms are minor, but one point of concern that needs to be addressed by the authors is that log(evolvability) was parameter modeled while heritability was modeled as unscaled. Further, heritability is constrained to lie within [0,1], resulting in compression and hence the potential for lower power. Hence, I think a few comments on this are in order in the final (and minor) revision. Comments/minor points Ln 47: Houle indeed has been the driving force behind evolvability, but Brian Charlesworth was the first to suggest this scaling (Charlesworth, B. 1984. The evolutionary genetics of life histories. In B. Shorrocks (ed.), Evolutionary ecology, pp. 117-133. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford, UK.) ln 68: mutation rate* proteome size. The GWAS data seems to show that almost all GWAS hits are outside of coding regions (see Chapter 21 Walsh/Visscher/Lynch 2025) ln 80: nice estimate of Ne (diversity/mutation rate)! ln 109: Akesson seems to be missing from the ref list ln 107: I would use "mixed model" here (and elsewhere; ln 228) in place of "animal model" to avoid confusion for some ln 148 (top right cell in Table 1). Walsh & Lynch (1998) should either be Lynch & Walsh (1998) or Walsh et al. (2025), see below. ln 324-325: On negative estimates of h2, LS forces these to zero, while REML often avoids this. Might be interested to redo the heritability just using REML estimates. Another issue with REML is that which fixed factors are incorporated is important, as these can shrink the residual variance used to estimate h2 (sum of the variance components makes up the denominator, not the phenotypic variance). This can inflate estimates of h2 over those based on LS where these fixed-effect differences (e.g., sex differences) generating variation are folded into the phenotypic variance. ln 411: additive variance scaling with Ne. A little tricky (e.g. WL pg 438), a point made by the senior author in earlier papers: The mutational variance is typically estimated with inbred lines, so that Ne is very small, and hence selection (s) against new mutations has to be large for them to be non-neutral. As Ne increases, Neu*, where u* is the effective neutral mutation rate, may not increase, as u* decreases with Ne (as 4Ne|s| increases, making fewer mutations neutral). Ln 431—437: Same comment as for ln 411 Ln 465-505: The work on crops typically finds only very small amounts of trait variation associated with cpDNA. I would argue that the plant feature a lot of evolutionary biologists overlook is meristematic tissues. Somatic mutations have no impact on offspring in animals, but a mutation occurring in a plant stem could impact its phenotype, such as flowers or leaf mass, (and hence be selected) with the gene tissue being downstream of that mutation, so there is some exposure to selection of new mutations before they are expressed in the offspring. Ln 735 some confusion, largely due to me! Lynch & Walsh (1998) is correctly sited in the ms, but this is listed as Walsh & Lynch (1998) in the reference list. For L&W, the publisher is Sinauer, not Oxford. We just released Part I of the revision of the 1998 book, which is now Walsh, Visscher, and Lynch. 2025. Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits: Foundations. Oxford. This part of the revision only covers the first part of the 1998 book. Hence the Ln 111 and 120 refs is correct (this maternal is not in Part I of the revision), but the ln 148 refs (above) could be either the 1998 or the 2025. Sorry for the confusion, there was just too much new stuff to fit the revision into a single volume. Bruce Walsh (in case you had not guessed) 12 Mar 2026 7 May 2026 Submitted filename: Response to Reviewers.docx 8 May 2026 Dear Lillith, Thank you for the submission of your revised Research Article "Levels of additive genetic variation vary substantially between species" for publication in PLOS Biology. On behalf of my colleagues and the Academic Editor, Nick Barton, I'm pleased to say that we can in principle accept your manuscript for publication, provided you address any remaining formatting and reporting issues. These will be detailed in an email you should receive within 2-3 business days from our colleagues in the journal operations team; no action is required from you until then. Please note that we will not be able to formally accept your manuscript and schedule it for publication until you have completed any requested changes. Please take a minute to log into Editorial Manager at http://www.editorialmanager.com/pbiology/, click the "Update My Information" link at the top of the page, and update your user information to ensure an efficient production process. PRESS: We frequently collaborate with press offices. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper at this point, to enable them to help maximise its impact. If the press office is planning to promote your findings, we would be grateful if they could coordinate with biologypress@plos.org. If you have previously opted in to the early version process, we ask that you notify us immediately of any press plans so that we may opt out on your behalf. We also ask that you take this opportunity to read our Embargo Policy regarding the discussion, promotion and media coverage of work that is yet to be published by PLOS. As your manuscript is not yet published, it is bound by the conditions of our Embargo Policy. Please be aware that this policy is in place both to ensure that any press coverage of your article is fully substantiated and to provide a direct link between such coverage and the published work. For full details of our Embargo Policy, please visit http://www.plos.org/about/media-inquiries/embargo-policy/. Thank you again for choosing PLOS Biology for publication and supporting Open Access publishing. We look forward to publishing your study. Sincerely, Roli Roland G Roberts, PhD, PhD Senior Editor PLOS Biology rroberts@plos.org