The impact of telemedicine on the efficiency and accuracy of emergency department triage: a staff perspective Authors: Muhammad Nauman Qureshi, Hamad Aldukhayl, Abdullah Alnatheer, Irteza Neyaz Ahmad, Amjad Alshehry Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundIn the field of healthcare, telemedicine has emerged as a crucial tool for enhancing the effectiveness and precision of emergency department (ED) triage. Tele-triage is a term used to describe a technology in which a patient’s health record is evaluated over the phone or via another means of communication and treatments or suitable referrals in the EDs are suggested. We assessed emergency department healthcare workers’ familiarity, perceptions, and attitudes toward the use of telemedicine for triage.MethodsThis cross-sectional study assessed 131 healthcare workers in the ED in one of the largest hospitals in Riyadh. The questionnaire included various measures to evaluate the perception of ED staff about the impact of telemedicine in the ED.ResultsPhysicians accounted for the highest proportion of the survey respondents (62.6%, n = 82), followed by nurses (32.8%, n = 43) and then paramedics (4.6%, n = 6). Physicians demonstrated greater familiarity with telemedicine (70.7%) than nonphysicians (38.8%) (p < 0.001). Majority of the participants agreed that telemedicine could be used as a tool for initial assessment. The most frequently used technology was AI-based triage systems, as perceived by ED staff (43.1%, n = 56). The challenges faced in telemedicine implementation for triage included resistance by staff (30.5%, n = 40), privacy concerns (11.5%, n = 15), and lack of training (8.4%, n = 11).ConclusionIn summary, the findings indicate an overall positive perception of ED staff towards using telemedicine in triage within ED, with notable concerns regarding staff resistance, privacy, and training. Despite these challenges, nearly half of the respondents expected an increase in its use, highlighting the need for specific training, alongside technological advancements and equity to enable its widespread adoption.Clinical trial numberNot applicable.Keywords: Emergency, Triage, Telemedicine, Telephone, Remote Introduction In recent years, the integration of telemedicine into emergency care has attracted considerable attention owing to its potential impact on triage effectiveness and accuracy. Telemedicine and telehealth are used interchangeably; however, they differ in meaning [1]. The Health Resources and Services Administration defines telehealth as a subset of e-health and refers to the use of telecommunications and technology in healthcare delivery, information, and education. Telemedicine is under the umbrella of telehealth but specifically refers to clinical services [1]. Meanwhile, the American Academy of Family Physicians defines telemedicine as the use of telecommunications technologies by physicians or other medical practitioners to deliver care. In contrast, telehealth encompasses a wider variety of remote healthcare services beyond clinical services, such as provider training, continuing medical education, public health education, and administrative meetings [2]. With the constant development and advancement of technology, telemedicine has become increasingly popular and more accessible. Consequently, it is being incorporated into several specialties, such as family medicine, ophthalmology, dermatology, and emergency medicine. Although the original concept of telehealth was to provide basic care to rural and underserved patients, it is currently being adopted and implemented as an efficient and cost-effective means to deliver and access quality healthcare services and outcomes for various patient groups. This study aimed to examine ED healthcare personnel’s perceptions, familiarity, and perceived advantages and challenges of using telemedicine for emergency department triage. Across the different studies and reviews, only patient outcomes and patient satisfaction remained constant. Patients who had undergone remote triage reported outcomes consistent with those who had undergone onsite triage [3, 4]; furthermore, patient safety was comparable between the two groups [5]. In addition, patients who have undergone triage remotely expressed high levels of satisfaction with the service provided [5, 6]. One study reported reduced frequency of over-triage and unnecessary referrals [7]. Some studies observed cost reduction as another positive factor [8]. Meanwhile, the levels of ED visits and hospital admissions varied between the two groups from one study to the other. While some studies reported reduced patient visits/admissions in the remotely triaged group [9, 10], others did not find any remarkable difference [11], with some even recording an increase [7, 12]. Length of stay is another factor that differed among the studies. Moreover, concerns were raised regarding the difficulty of remotely conducting comprehensive physical exams [3]. Each study came with its own set of limitations. Generally, a considerable variation was observed in the analyzed variables, sample size, study design, and triage algorithms among the studies, and data on some of the outcomes were not reported by all the included studies [4, 11, 12]. Materials and methods A survey was conducted in the King Faisal Specialist Hospital Emergency Department to assess the knowledge and perception of paramedics, nurses, and physicians regarding the use of remote triage in the ED. A survey of 10 questions aimed to assess their understanding, perception, if it is currently being used for triage, and how it can be improved in the future. The questionnaire was adapted from previously published telemedicine assessment surveys and reviewed by three emergency medicine experts to ensure content relevance. A pilot test was conducted with 10 staff to refine clarity. Although the instrument demonstrated face validity, no formal psychometric validation was performed. Statistical considerations All statistical analyses were conducted using Stata version 18.0. Texas, USA Descriptive statistics were employed to summarize the data. Categorical variables were expressed as frequencies and percentages. Group comparisons were performed using the chi-squared test to evaluate the associations between categorical responses. To investigate the association between the survey items, a pairwise Pearson correlation analysis was conducted. This method was selected to evaluate the strength and direction of linear associations between variables measured on Likert-type scales, which are commonly treated as interval-level data. The pairwise approach enabled the inclusion of all available data for each variable pair, and p-values were reported to determine statistical significance. Ethical considerations Ethical approval was obtained from the King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center (KFSHRC). The study protocol complied with the Declaration of Helsinki and KFSHRC guidelines. Results A total of 131 health professionals participated in the survey, of which the majority were physicians (62.6%, n = 82), followed by nurses (32.8%, n = 43) and then paramedics (4.6%, n = 6) (Table 1). Table 1Overall cohortVariablesN = 131Professional distribution Nurse43 (32.8%) Paramedic6 (4.6%) Physician82 (62.6%)Familiarity with telemedicine in the ED Neutral32 (24.4%) Not familiar at all2 (1.5%) Not very familiar20 (15.3%) Somewhat familiar60 (45.8%) Very familiar17 (13.0%)Telemedicine methods used in the triage AI-assisted triage systems56 (43.1%) Mobile applications23 (17.7%) Remote monitoring devices48 (36.9%) Video consults3 (2.3%)Telemedicine in triage is economical and reduces ED visits Agree51 (38.9%) Disagree21 (16.0%) Neutral27 (20.6%) Strongly agree17 (13.0%) Strongly disagree15 (11.5%)Telemedicine improves patient satisfaction Agree65 (49.6%) Disagree12 (9.2%) Neutral42 (32.1%) Strongly agree12 (9.2%)Telemedicine in triage saves time for patients and doctors Agree63 (48.1%) Disagree7 (5.3%) Neutral25 (19.1%) Strongly disagree1 (0.8%) Strongly agree35 (26.7%)Telemedicine in triage can be used for initial assessment Agree78 (59.5%) Disagree12 (9.2%) Neutral41 (31.3%)Challenges in the implementation of telemedicine in emergency department triage Resistance from the staff40 (30.5%) Privacy concerns15 (11.5%) Lack of training11 (8.4%) Privacy concerns and lack of training10 (7.6%) Resistance from staff, privacy concerns23 (17.6%) Resistance from staff and lack of training22 (16.8%) All three (resistance from staff, privacy concerns, lack of training)9 (6.9%) Other (unable to perform a direct visual head-to-toe assessment, other symptoms may be overlooked)1 (0.8%)Increased utilization of telemedicine in emergency departments EDs is anticipated No36 (27.5%) Unsure32 (24.4%) Yes63 (48.1%)Improvements or advancements anticipated, n = 63 Enhanced connectivity11 (17.7%) Improved technology20 (32.3%) Enhanced staff training31 (50.0%) Overall cohort As regards familiarity with telemedicine in ED triage, the participants had a wide range of opinions: 45.8% (n = 60) were somewhat familiar, 13.0% (n = 17) were very familiar, 24.4% (n = 32) showed neutrality, 15.3% (n = 20) were not very familiar, and 1.5% (n = 2) were not familiar at all (Fig. 1). Profession distribution by familiarity with telemedicine in the emergency department The most frequently used technology was AI-based triage systems (43.1%, n = 56), followed by remote monitoring devices (36.9%, n = 48) and then mobile apps (17.7%, n = 23). Video consultation was the least used (2.3%, n = 3). As regards the perception that telemedicine in triage is cost-effective and reduces ED visits, 38.9% (n = 51) agreed, 13.0% (n = 17) strongly agreed, 20.6% (n = 27) were neutral, 16.0% (n = 21) disagreed, and 11.5% (n = 15) strongly disagreed. As regards the perception that telemedicine improves patient satisfaction, 49.6% (n = 65) agreed, 9.2% (n = 12) strongly agreed, 32.1% (n = 42) were neutral, and 9.2% (n = 12) disagreed. None of the participants strongly disagreed. As regards the perception that telemedicine is time-efficient for both patients and doctors, 48.1% (n = 63) agreed, 26.7% (n = 35) strongly agreed, 19.1% (n = 25) were neutral, 5.3% (n = 7) disagreed, and 0.8% (n = 1) strongly disagreed. As regards the perception that telemedicine could be used as a tool for initial assessment, 59.5% (n = 78) agreed, 9.2% (n = 12) disagreed, and 31.3% (n = 41) were neutral. The frequently mentioned barriers to the implementation of telemedicine for triage were resistance by staff (30.5%, n = 40), privacy concerns (11.5%, n = 15), lack of training (8.4%, n = 11), both resistance and privacy concerns (17.6%, n = 23), both resistance and lack of training (16.8%, n = 22), and all three barriers (6.9%, n = 9). Another barrier was the inability to conduct direct visual assessments (0.8%, n = 1). When asked regarding the expected increase in the utilization of telemedicine in EDs, 48.1% (n = 63) answered yes, 24.4% (n = 32) were unsure, and 27.5% (n = 36) did not foresee an increase. Of the 63 respondents who anticipated an increase, the suggested areas for improvement were enhanced staff training (50.0%, n = 31), improved technology (32.3%, n = 20), and better connectivity (17.7%, n = 11) Chi-squared analysis was conducted to compare the responses among the groups. Physicians demonstrated greater familiarity with telemedicine (70.7%) than nonphysicians (38.8%) (p < 0.001). Agreement on the economic benefits of telemedicine was not markedly different across the groups (p = 0.513). Patient satisfaction, time-saving, and feasibility for the initial assessment were perceived differently but with no significant statistical differences. The main challenges in the implementation were consistent for all professional groups (p > 0.05) (Tables 2 and 3). Table 2Comparative analysis healthcare professional’s insights on telemedicine in emergency settingProfessional DistributionNurse(n = 43)Paramedic(n = 6)Physician(n = 82)Total(n = 131)P-valueFamiliarity with telemedicine in the ED Neutral12 (27.9%)4 (66.7%)16 (19.5%)32 (24.4%)<0.0 Not familiar14 (32.6%)0 (0.0%)8 (9.8%)22 (16.8%) Familiar17 (39.5%)2 (33.3%)58 (70.7%)77 (58.8%)Telemedicine methods used in the triage AI-assisted triage systems18 (42.9%)1 (16.7%)37 (45.1%)56 (43.1%)0.41 Mobile applications11 (26.2%)1 (16.7%)11 (13.4%)23 (17.7%) Remote monitoring devices12 (28.6%)4 (66.7%)32 (39.0%)48 (36.9%) Video consults1 (2.4%)0 (0.0%)2 (2.4%)3 (2.3%)Telemedicine in triage is economical and reduces ED visits Agree20 (46.5%)3 (50.0%)45 (54.9%)68 (51.9%)0.51 Disagree11 (25.6%)1 (16.7%)24 (29.3%)36 (27.5%) Neutral12 (27.9%)2 (33.3%)13 (15.9%)27 (20.6%)Telemedicine improves patient satisfaction Agree22 (51.2%)5 (83.3%)50 (61.0%)77 (58.8%)0.25 Disagree7 (16.3%)0 (0.0%)5 (6.1%)12 (9.2%) Neutral14 (32.6%)1 (16.7%)27 (32.9%)42 (32.1%)Telemedicine in triage saves time for patients and doctors Agree30 (69.8%)4 (66.7%)64 (78.0%)98 (74.8%)0.69 Disagree3 (7.0%)0 (0.0%)5 (6.1%)8 (6.1%) Neutral10 (23.3%)2 (33.3%)13 (15.9%)25 (19.1%)Telemedicine in triage can be used for initial assessment Agree31 (72.1%)5 (83.3%)42 (51.2%)78 (59.5%)0.08 Disagree2 (4.7%)1 (16.7%)9 (11.0%)12 (9.2%) Neutral10 (23.3%)0 (0.0%)31 (37.8%)41 (31.3%)Increased utilization of telemedicine in EDs is anticipated No11 (25.6%)2 (33.3%)23 (28.0%)36 (27.5%)0.65 Unsure14 (32.6%)1 (16.7%)17 (20.7%)32 (24.4%) Yes18 (41.9%)3 (50.0%)42 (51.2%)63 (48.1%)Challenges in the implementation of telemedicine in ED triage Resistance from staff13 (30.2%)1 (16.7%)26 (31.7%)40 (30.5%)0.48 Privacy concerns4 (9.3%)1 (16.7%)10 (12.2%)15 (11.5%) Lack of training4 (9.3%)2 (33.3%)5 (6.1%)11 (8.4%) Privacy concerns and lack of training4 (9.3%)1 (16.7%)5 (6.1%)10 (7.6%) Resistance from staff, privacy concerns7 (16.3%)0 (0.0%)16 (19.5%)23 (17.6%) Resistance from staff and lack of training5 (11.6%)1 (16.7%)16 (19.5%)22 (16.8%) Other1 (2.3%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)1 (0.8%)All three (resistance from staff, privacy Concerns, lack of training)5 (11.6%)0 (0.0%)4 (4.9%)9 (6.9%)Statistical methods: categorical variables were compared by chi-square test Comparative analysis healthcare professional’s insights on telemedicine in emergency setting Statistical methods: categorical variables were compared by chi-square test Table 3Comparative analysis of healthcare professionals’ insights on telemedicine in the EDProfessional DistributionNon-Physician(n = 49)Physician(n = 82)Total(n = 131)p-valueFamiliarity with telemedicine in the ED Neutral16 (32.7%)16 (19.5%)32 (24.4%)<0.001 Not familiar14 (28.6%)8 (9.8%)22 (16.8%) Familiar19 (38.8%)58 (70.7%)77 (58.8%)Telemedicine methods used in triage AI-assisted triage systems19 (39.6%)37 (45.1%)56 (43.1%)0.424 Mobile applications12 (25.0%)11 (13.4%)23 (17.7%) Remote monitoring devices16 (33.3%)32 (39.0%)48 (36.9%) Video consults1 (2.1%)2 (2.4%)3 (2.3%)Telemedicine in triage is economical and reduces ED visits Agree23 (46.9%)45 (54.9%)68 (51.9%)0.219 Disagree12 (24.5%)24 (29.3%)36 (27.5%) Neutral14 (28.6%)13 (15.9%)27 (20.6%)Telemedicine improves patient satisfaction Agree27 (55.1%)50 (61.0%)77 (58.8%)0.290 Disagree7 (14.3%)5 (6.1%)12 (9.2%) Neutral15 (30.6%)27 (32.9%)42 (32.1%)Telemedicine in triage saves time for patients and doctors Agree34 (69.4%)64 (78.0%)98 (74.8%)0.471 Disagree3 (6.1%)5 (6.1%)8 (6.1%) Neutral12 (24.5%)13 (15.9%)25 (19.1%)Telemedicine in triage can be used for initial assessment Agree36 (73.5%)42 (51.2%)78 (59.5%)0.043 Disagree3 (6.1%)9 (11.0%)12 (9.2%) Neutral10 (20.4%)31 (37.8%)41 (31.3%)Increased utilization of telemedicine in EDs is anticipated No13 (26.5%)23 (28.0%)36 (27.5%)0.428 Unsure15 (30.6%)17 (20.7%)32 (24.4%) Yes21 (42.9%)42 (51.2%)63 (48.1%)Challenges in the implementation of telemedicine in ED triage Resistance from the staff14 (28.6%)26 (31.7%)40 (30.5%)0.467 Privacy concerns5 (10.2%)10 (12.2%)15 (11.5%) Lack of training6 (12.2%)5 (6.1%)11 (8.4%) Privacy concerns and lack of training5 (10.2%)5 (6.1%)10 (7.6%) Resistance from staff, privacy concerns7 (14.3%)16 (19.5%)23 (17.6%) Resistance from staff and lack of training6 (12.2%)16 (19.5%)22 (16.8%) Other1 (2.0%)0 (0.0%)1 (0.8%)All three (resistance from staff, privacy concerns, lack of training)5 (10.2%)4 (4.9%)9 (6.9%)Statistical methods: categorical variables were compared using the chi-squared test Comparative analysis of healthcare professionals’ insights on telemedicine in the ED Statistical methods: categorical variables were compared using the chi-squared test Correlation analysis Correlation matrices for physicians and nonphysicians are presented in Tables 4 and 5, respectively. Table 4Correlation matrix for physiciansQuestionQ2Q4Q5Q6Q7Q2: Familiarity with the concept oftelemedicine in emergency department triage1.00000.12630.14430.11100.1033Q4: Belief that telemedicine in triage is economical and reduces emergency department visits0.12631.00000.17240.13090.1919Q5: Opinion on whether telemedicine improves patient satisfaction in the emergency department0.14430.17241.00000.26580.0371Q6: Belief that telemedicine in triage saves both the patient’s and doctor’s time0.11100.13090.26581.00000.2523QuestionQ2Q4Q5Q6Q7Q7: Belief that telemedicine in triage can be used for the initial assessment of individuals0.10330.19190.03710.25231.0000Q5 (patient satisfaction) and Q6 (saves time) demonstrated the highest correlation, with a value of 0.2658, indicating a moderate positive relationship. Meanwhile, Q5 (patient satisfaction) and Q7 (initial assessment) exhibited the lowest correlation, with a value of 0.0371, indicating a very weak relationship Correlation matrix for physicians Q2: Familiarity with the concept of telemedicine in emergency department triage Q5 (patient satisfaction) and Q6 (saves time) demonstrated the highest correlation, with a value of 0.2658, indicating a moderate positive relationship. Meanwhile, Q5 (patient satisfaction) and Q7 (initial assessment) exhibited the lowest correlation, with a value of 0.0371, indicating a very weak relationship Table 5Correlation matrix for nonphysicians (paramedic-nurse)QuestionQ2Q4Q5Q6Q7Q2: Familiarity with the concept of telemedicine in emergency department triage1.00000.10550.2004−0.12830.5153Q4: Belief that telemedicine in triage is economical and reduces emergency department visits0.10551.0000−0.0084−0.00330.1302QuestionQ2Q4Q5Q6Q7Q5: Opinion on whether telemedicineimproves patient satisfaction in the emergency department0.2004−0.00841.00000.27630.1426Q6: Belief that telemedicine in triage saves both the patient’s and doctor’s time−0.1283−0.00330.27631.00000.2124Q7: Belief that telemedicine in triage can be used for the initial assessment of individuals0.51530.13020.14260.21241.0000Q2 (familiarity) and Q7 (initial assessment) exhibited the highest correlation, with a value of 0.5153, indicating a moderate positive relationship. Meanwhile, Q4 (economical) and Q5 (patient satisfaction) exhibited the lowest correlation, with a value of −0.0084, indicating no significant relationship. However, a negative correlation was observed between Q2 (familiarity) and Q6 (saves time), with a value of −0.1283, indicating a weak inverse relationship Correlation matrix for nonphysicians (paramedic-nurse) Q5: Opinion on whether telemedicine improves patient satisfaction in the emergency department Q2 (familiarity) and Q7 (initial assessment) exhibited the highest correlation, with a value of 0.5153, indicating a moderate positive relationship. Meanwhile, Q4 (economical) and Q5 (patient satisfaction) exhibited the lowest correlation, with a value of −0.0084, indicating no significant relationship. However, a negative correlation was observed between Q2 (familiarity) and Q6 (saves time), with a value of −0.1283, indicating a weak inverse relationship Overall, the correlations varied more widely compared with the physician group, with some moderate positive relationships and weak or no relationships. Discussion This study aimed to determine the ED staff perception as to how telemedicine impacts the efficiency and accuracy of ED triage in comparison with traditional onsite triage. The key takeaway is that healthcare professionals generally view telemedicine as a beneficial adjunct for emergency triage, particularly in enhancing time efficiency and patient satisfaction. Nearly 75% of the respondents agreed that telemedicine triage saves time, and 59.5% agreed that it can be effectively used for initial assessments. Although only 51.9% supported its contribution to the reduction of unnecessary visits, these results suggest strong support for the utility of telemedicine in the operational aspects of emergency care. These results are consistent with those of the existing literature demonstrating that telemedicine enhances workflow and reduces patient wait times in acute care settings [6, 13]. Consistent with our study particpants perception, previous studies found high levels of patient satisfaction with tele-triage systems, particularly when standardized protocols were applied [3, 4]. However, our study cohort indicated that the belief in the ability of telemedicine to lower cost and reduce ED visits is not uniformly held, aligning with mixed outcomes from recent reviews [9, 11, 12]. These insights confirm the importance of the implementation context and the variability of outcomes in tele-triage studies. An unexpected result was the stark difference in perception between partcipating physicians and non-physicians. Although physicians were significantly more familiar with telemedicine (70.7%), nonphysicians exhibited a stronger association between familiarity and belief in the diagnostic value (r = 0.5153). This contrast may reflect varying degrees of reliance on structured protocols compared with direct clinical assessment, revealing a potentially overlooked dimension in user training. Moreover, the minimal use of video consultations (2.3%) was surprising given their availability, suggesting usability or workflow concerns in high-pressure environments. This study has significant limitations. First, the data relies on self-reported perceptions rather than objective clinical metrics, such as diagnostic accuracy and treatment time. Second, the survey was conducted at a single center and among a physician-dominant sample (62.6%), potentially limiting its generalizability. Third, no multivariable analysis was conducted to adjust for confounders, such as clinical experience or institutional familiarity with digital tools. In addition, the absence of patient-level outcome data limits our ability to evaluate the true clinical impact of tele-triage. Future research should prioritize prospective or randomized studies comparing tele-triage with onsite triage in category 3–5 emergency cases using objective clinical outcomes, such as time to provider, diagnostic accuracy, and admission rates. Studies investigating hybrid models—integrating AI-assisted triage with clinician oversight—may facilitate the identification of scalable and safe systems. Moreover, structured training programs and usability evaluations are warranted to enhance their adoption across diverse clinical roles. In summary,the evidence from ED staff perceptions in our study indicates telemedicine can enhance emergency triage, particularly by enhancing efficiency and patient satisfaction. While its impact on cost savings and diagnostic accuracy remains unclear, the positive perception among healthcare providers indicates readiness for broader integration. Future success depends on targeted investments in training, infrastructure, and clinical outcome validation. These findings support telemedicine not as a replacement but as a complementary strategy to enhance triage efficiency and resource utilization in EDs. Conclusion In conclusion, participants expressed generally positive perceptions regarding the potential role of telemedicine in ED triage; however, these perspectives do not provide direct evidence of clinical effectiveness. Future controlled studies are required to objectively evaluate triage accuracy, efficiency, and patient outcomes.The findings of our study indicate an overall positive perception toward telemedicine in triage within EDs, with notable concerns regarding staff resistance, privacy, and training. Despite these challenges, nearly half of the respondents anticipated an increase in its use, highlighting the need for specific training, along with technological advancements and equity to enable widespread adoption. However, further research is warranted to evaluate its effectiveness in high-acuity emergency settings and to address the technological and logistical challenges associated with its implementation. Acknowledgements We hereby extend our sincere appreciation to Ms. Reem Saad Almutairi, Epidemiologist at King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Center, for her invaluable expertise, dedication, and significant contributions to this work. Author contributions Muhammad, Hamad, Abdullah, Irteza, and Amjad contributed equally to this work. All authors were involved in the study design, data collection, analysis, and manuscript preparation. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript. Funding This research was conducted without any external funding. Data availability The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors on request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Human Ethics and Consent to Participate Informed consent was obtained and ethically approved from King Faisal hospital and research center Consent for publication The paper has been approved by an appropriate King Faisal hospital and research center ethics committee. Human ethics and consent to participate Approval to conduct the study was obtained from King Faisal hospital Research Center (Approval No. RAC 2241034). All participants provided informed consent prior to completing the questionnaire. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors on request.