Evaluation of the implementation process of a new emergency triage system: West coast system for triage (WEST) Authors: Samah Habbouche, Eric Carlström, Per-Arne Svensson, Carl Magnusson, Lina Dahlen Holmqvist, Suzanne Rose, Suzanne Rose, Suzanne Rose Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundEmergency Department (ED) crowding has escalated globally and has been associated with delayed treatment and increased short-term mortality. In western Sweden, several EDs transitioned from the Rapid Emergency Triage and Treatment System (RETTS©) to the West coast system for triage (WEST), based on principles of the South African Triage Scale. While WEST was introduced and spread rapidly and may have potential benefits, reports suggested challenges during its implementation.ObjectiveThis study examined the implementation of WEST at the first two EDs (ED1 and ED2) and identified barriers and facilitators. The study focused on the transition from RETTS© to WEST and explored staff experiences across implementation stages.MethodsThe study used a qualitative descriptive design with a mixed-methods approach and included semi-structured individual interviews with 36 triage nurses from two hospitals (ED1 n = 17; ED2 n = 19). Interviews explored experiences with WEST, implementation challenges, and comparisons with RETTS©, using Rogers’ “Diffusion of Innovations” as a sensitizing framework and treating each ED as a distinct social system. A deductive qualitative content analysis guided by Rogers’ Diffusion of Innovations was conducted, with inductive coding of unexpected themes from the final open question. Descriptive analyses of Likert-scale items complemented the qualitative analysis. The study received ethical approval, and written informed consent was obtained from all participants before interviews.ResultsED1 participants expressed great enthusiasm and perceived WEST as a notable improvement. ED2 responses were more varied, with reservations commonly targeting the implementation process and concurrent organizational changes. Across both sites, most nurses (30/36) perceived WEST as more accurate than RETTS© in identifying critically ill patients.ConclusionsImplementing WEST was feasible but context dependent. Information, motivation, and consensus-building, education, and organizational readiness emerged as important factors in the implementation process. Viewing each ED as a distinct social system, with its own culture and readiness for change, helped explain why adoption of WEST varied between sites. Background Emergency Department (ED) crowding is a persistent global public health challenge [1]. Rising attendances and suboptimal use of hospital resources mean that demand often exceeds capacity, with crowding linked to delays in life-saving treatments, increased complications, and higher 30-day mortality [2–5]. In Sweden, where the data for this study was collected, waiting times have increased over the past three decades [1]. Improvement efforts have therefore targeted ED flow, including patient prioritization systems [6,7]. This study examined the early implementation of a new triage system at two EDs. The new triage system was designed to alleviate a severe ED crowding situation. By capturing the experiences of triage nurses during the transition from the old triage system to the new one, the study identified organizational facilitators and barriers that can inform future system changes in similar contexts. Rapid Emergency Triage and Treatment System (RETTS©) is a widely used triage system in Sweden. The methodology and structure of RETTS© is described in detail elsewhere [8,9]. However, concerns have been raised regarding its reliability, particularly in the assignment of acuity levels [10]. Acuity refers to the severity or urgency of a patient’s condition and determines how quickly they need medical attention. Sometimes over-triage occurs, defined as assignment of a higher acuity level than clinically warranted, which increases monitoring burdens and risks diverting attention from truly high-risk patients [11]. In an educational evaluation, inter-rater agreement among RETTS© users was moderate, particularly in assessments requiring clinical judgment, indicating gaps in training and consistency [12]. In response to perceived over-triage, a hospital in western Sweden reviewed its triage procedures and developed West coast system for triage (WEST), drawing on principles from the South African Triage Scale [13,14]. WEST, outlined in detail in earlier work [14], considered four domains: (i) vital parameters summarized via National Early Warning Score 2 (NEWS2), (ii) predefined warning signs and symptoms, (iii) additional care needs (e.g., frailty), and (iv) structured clinical judgment [14,15]. Unlike RETTS©, where a single abnormal parameter could escalate acuity level, WEST emphasized patterns of abnormality and integrated clinical judgment. Prior work on WEST yielded the anticipated reduction in over-triage [14]. While the rationale for developing WEST was grounded in concerns about over-triage and consistency in RETTS, introducing a new triage system requires substantial changes to workflows, roles, and shared clinical judgment. Accordingly, the success of WEST depends not only on its design but also on how it is implemented and adopted in everyday ED practice. Organizational changes in healthcare often fail due to limited planning, weak motivation, and change fatigue [16,17]. Subcultures can resist new systems, underscoring the importance of deliberate strategies for change [18]. However, few studies provide in-depth assessment of health professionals’ reactions to implementation in an ED context and to the best of our knowledge no previous studies have investigated health professionals’ responses to introducing a new triage system in Sweden [17,19]. One study from a Danish ED found that implementation was non-linear and context-dependent, with staff primarily focused on ensuring the best possible acute patient pathway for their own patients [17]. Process improvement approaches in ED operations identified three main barriers 1) difficulties to generalize results from other areas, 2) medical staff resistance to change and 3) increase in costs [20]. These findings collectively underscore the complexity of implementation in ED settings and resonate with the present study’s focus on how local context and staff perceptions shape adoption outcomes. Theoretical framework In this study, “Diffusion of Innovations” based on Rogers served as a sensitizing framework to structure inquiry and interpretation. “Diffusion of Innovations” describes how innovations spread over time through communication channels within a social system, influenced by innovation attributes and adopter categories [21]. Rogers describes five adopter categories along a bell-shaped curve: innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards, each reflecting different degrees of innovativeness and willingness to embrace change [21]. Rogers’ concepts of early and late adopters have been applied across a range of healthcare change contexts, from studying how financial rewards influence whether hospitals adopt new practices early or late, to challenge and refine the traditional adopter categories in the context of health technology and to assess whether clinical teams are organizationally ready to implement new care programs [22–24]. Rogers’ concepts are particularly useful in EDs because EDs function as unique social systems and operate within their own specific contextual factors, including staff dynamics, leadership styles, patient demographics, and resource availability. As distinct social systems, EDs experience rapid changes in protocols and practices based on evolving patient needs, staffing, and technology [25]. Furthermore, Rogers’ “Diffusion of Innovations” offers concepts for understanding adoption within a social system [21,26]. As with many implementation efforts in emergency care, progressing from initial uptake to broad and sustained routine use can be challenging, particularly during the transition from early adopters to the early majority, which Moore describes as “Crossing the Chasm” (Fig 1) [27]. “Crossing the Chasm” highlights the crucial divide between these two essential groups in the implementation life cycle: the early adopters and the early majority. Those in the early adopter category are often visionaries who are eager to embrace new technologies, due to their recognition of potential benefits. In contrast, the early majority tend to adopt a more cautious approach, seeking evidence of reliability before making a commitment [21,27,28]. Together, these frameworks shaped the study design and guided data collection and interpretation, with a particular focus on nurses’ perceptions, organizational readiness, and early adoption dynamics during WEST implementation. Conceptual illustration adapted from Moore’s Crossing the Chasm (1991). Adoption curve adapted from Rogers’ “Diffusion of Innovations” and Moore’s concept of “crossing the chasm,” illustrating the challenge of moving from early adopters to the early majority. Bridging this gap is essential for innovations to achieve mainstream adoption. Aim The study had two aims: (i) to explore how triage nurses experienced the transition from RETTS© to WEST, and (ii) to describe perceived benefits and drawbacks of WEST relative to RETTS© regarding flexibility, clarity, and perceived accuracy. A secondary aim was to compare the implementation processes between ED1 and ED2. Materials and methods Study design and methodology This study employed a qualitative descriptive design with a mixed‑methods approach, integrating semi-structured interviews with Likert‑scale summation to capture both narrative insights and structured assessments [29,30]. The interview guide drew on a literature review, “Diffusion of Innovations” theory and previous implementation research. It included items targeting key components of the implementation process, information, motivation and consensus, education, and organizational factors following Janssen et al. [31]. Additional components assessed perceived performance of triage systems, focusing on flexibility, clarity, perceived accuracy and innovation attributes like relative advantage, compatibility, and complexity [21]. Face validity was assessed by two individuals who met the same inclusion criteria as the study participants, ensuring that the interview guide was understandable and relevant for the target group. Interviews strictly followed the guide; clarifications were provided when needed. The final item invited open reflections, allowing unexpected themes to emerge and be coded separately before thematic grouping. The final interview guide is provided as a supplement (S1 File). Study context Sahlgrenska University Hospital, one of Europe’s largest hospitals and the largest in Sweden, employs approximately 17,000 staff and has about 2,300 beds across three hospital sites [32]. It provides emergency and basic care for about 700,000 inhabitants in the Gothenburg region, as well as highly specialized care for approximately 1.7 million residents in western Sweden. ED1 was situated on the tertiary-care campus, whereas ED2 was located on the level 1 trauma center campus. Both EDs managed approximately 55,000 attendances annually. Due to a prolonged problem with ED crowding at the EDs included in this study, a Health Technology Assessment (HTA) of triage systems was initiated. The HTA aimed to identify triage systems effective in supporting patient prioritization and ED flow under crowded conditions [13]. In the present study, RETTS© was compared with WEST. Both systems used five color-coded levels (red, orange, yellow, green, blue). Based on the HTA findings, WEST was selected as a promising system to support patient flow at ED1 and ED2 under crowded conditions by combining a broader assessment framework with explicit room for clinical judgment. In addition, WEST incorporates structured neurological assessment tools, including the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) and the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS). WEST was implemented at ED1 from September to November 2019. ED2 implemented WEST in September 2020, between the first and second waves of COVID-19. The educational intervention was designed to be identical at both sites and was delivered in the same manner at both EDs, as confirmed by department managers. At the time of the study, WEST was available in a pocket-sized reference card, allowing triage nurses to keep the material readily accessible during triage. Baseline performance differed somewhat between the two sites: ED2 had longer length-of-stay and time-to-physician than ED1, as recorded in the patient administrative systems. Study population Triage nurses from both EDs were interviewed during a two‑week period between April 16 and April 30, 2021. At the time of the interviews, WEST had been implemented for approximately six months at ED2 and for seventeen months at ED1. Inclusion criteria were ≥1 year of triage experience and ≥3 months of WEST use. All registered nurses working in triage at ED1 (N = 34) and ED2 (N = 44) who met the inclusion criteria were invited to participate through consecutive sampling, using e-mail invitations and announcements at workplace meetings. Interested nurses contacted the interviewer directly by email or in person, and written informed consent was obtained prior to each interview (S2 File). Data collection All interviews were conducted face-to-face during work hours in quiet rooms (30–45 minutes) by the first author. A structured field‑note template aligned with the interview guide was used to document responses in real-time in a consistent and systematic manner. Responses were documented in writing in a near-verbatim style as participants spoke; when needed, participants were asked to pause briefly to ensure accuracy. Tone, pauses, and manner of speaking were not recorded. Following each interview, the notes were returned to participants for confirmation through member checking within two weeks, ensuring that their answers had been accurately captured. Once confirmed, the notes were compiled into a dataset for analysis, from which illustrative quotes reflecting the diversity of participants’ perspectives were selected to support interpretation [33,34]. Data saturation was monitored throughout data collection. As interviews progressed, differences between participants’ responses decreased while similarities increased with recurring themes related to information dissemination, training quality, and organizational adjustments converging consistently after approximately 20–25 interviews. Data collection continued beyond this point to ensure all willing participants could contribute and to minimize the risk of overlooking subgroup perspectives, resulting in 36 interviews in total. Reporting follows the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) (S3 File) [35]. Reflexivity and interviewer positionality All interviews were conducted by the first author, a resident physician in emergency medicine at ED2 at the time of data collection, with clinical experience but no formal leadership responsibilities at either site. Several strategies were employed to reduce potential influence on participant responses. Recruitment was self-selected, with nurses approaching the researcher voluntarily, which minimized the risk of participation being shaped by hierarchical pressure or role expectations. A standardized interview guide was followed strictly across both sites, with probing limited to necessary clarifications, and a structured note-taking format was applied to minimize selective capture of responses. Throughout the study, reflexive attention to the interviewer’s positionality was maintained, and potential role-related influences were considered during analysis. To further balance interpretive bias, investigator triangulation and collaborative coding were employed, and negative cases were considered during theme development. Data analysis Demographic data were analyzed descriptively. Likert-scale responses were summarized using proportions of high ratings, defined as scores of 4–5 on a five-point scale. Missing responses were rare and occurred only sporadically, most notably for items related to organizational change; proportions were therefore calculated based on the number of valid responses for each item. No inferential statistical testing was planned or performed given the study design and sample size. A deductive qualitative content analysis was conducted using “Diffusion of Innovations” as a sensitizing framework [36]. Initially, data were coded within each ED, then compared across sites. Two researchers independently coded an initial subset, reconciled discrepancies to refine a codebook, and subsequently recoded the remaining interview notes. Credibility was strengthened through this independent coding process, followed by dialogue to reconcile discrepancies and establish a final coding scheme [37]. No quantitative inter-rater reliability measure was calculated as the analysis aimed to capture the participants’ perspectives and nuances rather than classify discrete units. As interviews were not audio-recorded, analysis was based on near-verbatim field notes as described above. Ethical considerations Participation was voluntary and written informed consent was obtained prior to each interview (S2 File). Only the interviewer had access to raw data, ensuring participant confidentiality throughout the study. The study followed the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Regional Ethical Review Board in Gothenburg (approval number for the initial pilot study on WEST: Dnr1078-18; approval number for the amendment covering the present study: Dnr2020–06571). Results Study population In total, 36 of 78 eligible nurses participated (response rate 46%; ED1: 17/34, ED2: 19/44). Participants from ED2 were older (median 43, interquartile range (IQR 31–51) vs median 33, IQR 27–38) and reported longer professional experience (median 10 years, IQR 6–23 vs median 5 years, IQR 3–8). Gender distribution (female/male) was similar between ED1 (12/5) and ED2 (14/5) (Table 1). 10.1371/journal.pone.0350323.t001Table 1Characteristics of the study population.ED1ED2Participants, n/N (%)17/34 (50%)19/44 (43%)Age, median (IQR)33(27-38)43(31-51)Years in profession, median (IQR)5(3-8)10(6-23)Female/male12/514/5*IQR= Interquartile range Characteristics of the study population. *IQR= Interquartile range Overall response Descriptive summaries of Likert-scale responses showed that ED1 respondents generally reported positive perceptions of WEST as a working tool, reflected by high agreement or strong agreement across ratings. Responses from ED2 tended to be more variable across participants; however, when evaluating perceived accuracy most participants across both sites agreed or strongly agreed that WEST was more accurate than RETTS© in identifying severely ill patients. The change (implementation of WEST) Differences in the process of implementing WEST were observed across all implementation domains at the two EDs, including information, motivation, education, and organization (Fig 2). ED1 respondents tended to report higher Likert-scale ratings than ED2 respondents. Responses related to the implementation of WEST. Distribution of Likert-scale responses (1–5) to questions related to the implementation of WEST at ED1 and ED2. Percentages may not sum to 100% due to rounding. Information strategies A majority of participants at ED1 (76%) agreed or strongly agreed that the information provided about the new triage system was sufficient, compared with 37% at ED2 (Fig 2). “We were informed months before the implementation on many different occasions, via e-mail and verbally.” (Nurse, ED1) Criticism from ED2 focused on the perception that the implementation team did not adequately communicate information. Rumors circulated that ED1 had already introduced WEST, and that ED2 would be next. “There was a situation of non-existent information that nurtured rumors at the ED.” (Nurse, ED2) ED2 participants expressed a need for clear information and requested briefings and platforms to voice concerns. Participants also reported that information was lacking for physicians within the ED and in connected units. Motivational strategies In ED1, 76% of participants agreed or strongly agreed that they were motivated by perceived limitations of RETTS©, particularly its tendency to over-prioritize patients, compared with 47% in ED2. “We have a lot of over-prioritizations, and the WEST system reduces the number of patients prioritized at the orange triage level. It would facilitate the identification of the most severely ill individuals.” (Nurse, ED2) Nurses at ED2 reported that the implementation was perceived as poorly received by staff, which they felt resulted in low motivation to adopt the new system. They described insufficient background information regarding the rationale for change. The simultaneous introduction of new laboratory routines, also perceived as poorly communicated, further reduced motivation and left staff feeling unprepared. “The reduction in laboratory services, driven by cost-saving measures, along with the introduction of new routines without consulting the ED staff, is not very motivating.” (Nurse, ED2) Educational strategies Participants’ perceptions of education differed substantially between sites. At ED1, 76% of nurses agreed or strongly agreed that they had sufficient time for training and appreciated opportunities to provide feedback, compared with 32% at ED2. “The WEST education included seminars and discussion. We got the opportunity to get help in the triaging process with a supervisor during the first weeks of implementation. We had the opportunity to comment on the pros and cons of the new way of working.” (Nurse, ED1) “The education was limited to some basic information about the new triage system and a review of the warning signs in the WEST handbook.” (Nurse, ED2) “We had a PowerPoint presentation lasting a maximum of one hour. Terrible! Those who were going to train us afterwards did not know the system themselves; if you had questions, there were no answers. You had to learn the system by yourself.” (Nurse, ED2) Educational shortcomings identified by ED2 staff included the lack of interactive, team-based formats such as simulation and tabletop exercises, as well as practical study materials. Participants requested case-based workshops, structured debriefings, joint sessions with physicians, bedside supervision during the initial phase, and systematic feedback. Although NIHSS and GCS were introduced within WEST, no dedicated training on these instruments was provided, leaving several nurses unfamiliar with their application. Organizational strategies A majority of participants at ED1 agreed or strongly agreed that they felt prepared for the implementation of the new triage system compared with approximately one-third of participants at ED2 (82% vs. 32%). “In fact, the organization didn’t need to adapt, despite the absence of WEST in other hospitals and the ambulance services. We just transitioned from using RETTS© to WEST in our medical journals.” (Nurse, ED1) “Perhaps it might not be ideal for nurses to be immediately thrown into triage duties. However, given the current circumstances, there may be no alternative.” (Nurse, ED2) The system (performance of WEST) Most participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was perceived as more flexible and more accurate than RETTS© in identifying severely ill patients (Fig 3). Despite these perceived advantages, a majority also agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was perceived as requiring greater clinical experience and was at times seen as more complex and less clear than RETTS©. Overall, participants at ED2 expressed less positive perceptions, reflected by consistently lower Likert ratings compared with ED1. Responses related to performance of WEST. Distribution of Likert-scale responses (1–5) to questions related to the perceived performance of WEST at ED1 and ED2. Percentages may not sum to 100% due to rounding. Flexibility A majority of participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was perceived as more flexible than RETTS©, with higher agreement at ED1 (76%) compared with ED2 (47%). “For me, the flexibility of the system is advantageous, especially with the pocket version, which is convenient to use bedside. However, it can pose challenges for new nurses, particularly those lacking experience in triage, as certain aspects of the process require clinical training. In contrast, RETTS© was foolproof-if you followed it mechanically, mistakes were unlikely.” (Nurse, ED1) “Without prior experience, there are potential pitfalls when using WEST, making it potentially dangerous. However, with experienced staff who have undergone extensive training, WEST offers a simpler and more flexible alternative compared to RETTS©” (Nurse, ED2) While the flexibility enabled by clinical judgment was generally seen as an advantage, some participants noted that it placed higher demands on nurses with less clinical experience. Participants also highlighted the absence of an online version, gaps in the handbook, and lack of clarity regarding when to perform blood sampling. Clarity Regarding clarity, approximately 40% of participants at each site perceived the new triage system to be at least as clear as RETTS©. At ED1, 35% agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was clearer, compared with 26% at ED2. “Being a new or recently graduated nurse and working in triage is not particularly easy. RETTS© proves to be simpler than WEST, especially for inexperienced individuals. The RETTS© binder served as a comprehensive guide, like a Bible, containing all the necessary information, including referrals.” (Nurse, ED1) “At times, only a single word is used to describe a condition, like ‘ongoing bleeding,’ which lacks clarity. It becomes crucial to have additional support from the system, especially when you find yourself alone, to ensure clarity and understanding in such situations.” (Nurse, ED2) Participants also noted that WEST sometimes grouped conditions too broadly, for example, neurological symptoms, creating uncertainty. Unlike RETTS©, WEST did not provide a referral system, requiring nurses to rely on memory of parameters and risk factors. Accuracy Of the 36 participants, 30 agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was perceived as more accurate than RETTS© in identifying severely ill patients, with complete agreement (100%) among ED1 respondents and 68% agreement at ED2. “When used correctly, WEST is more accurate compared to RETTS©. RETTS© tended to over-prioritize, whereas with WEST, patients categorized as red or orange were genuinely ill. The system’s reliability simplifies teamwork in the ED. Furthermore, WEST demonstrates improved prioritization for frail elderly individuals. While RETTS© may be more convenient for inexperienced nurses, WEST’s accuracy makes it a preferred choice for reliable patient assessments.” (Nurse, ED1) However, six participants disagreed, arguing that WEST was less precise. “WEST is less accurate, and you need experience to prioritize patients correctly. This lack of precision leads triage nurses to rely on their intuition rather than purely observational data. In contrast to RETTS©, where the orange triage level required monitoring, WEST extends monitoring to yellow and green priority levels. This results in an increased number of patients requiring monitoring, making it progressively challenging to maintain an overall overview.” (Nurse, ED2) Driving forces (advantages of WEST) Overall, participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system performed well in terms of relative advantage, compatibility, and ease of use, though agreement rates at ED2 were consistently lower (Fig 4). Responses related to driving forces for adoption of WEST. Distribution of Likert-scale responses related to perceived advantages and driving forces for adoption of WEST at ED1 and ED2. Percentages may not sum to 100% due to rounding. Relative advantage Most participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system had a perceived relative advantage over RETTS©, primarily attributed to a perceived reduction in assignment to the orange priority level and fewer unnecessary laboratory investigations. This perception was reported by 94% of participants at ED1 and 53% at ED2. “Fewer orange-prioritized patients result in fewer unnecessary blood samples (which is more cost-effective) and facilitate more accurate and easier identification of seriously ill patients.” (Nurse, ED2) Yet, participants also pointed to shortcomings, including vague descriptions of some warning symptoms and inconsistencies in blood sampling routines. They requested a more comprehensive handbook, including clearer referral guidance. Some noted that the provisional printed handbook was difficult to use in practice. “The pages of the pocket-version keep falling out, and I hope for improved quality.” (Nurse, ED1) Compatibility At ED1, 71% of participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was compatible with existing routines, compared with 37% at ED2. “The blood sampling routine in triage became more scaled down. Initially, this change led to longer waiting times due to inadequate guidelines recommending a minimum number of blood tests. However, presently, I find myself collecting more samples than WEST recommends.” (Nurse, ED1) Concerns were raised about WEST’s compatibility with established routines, particularly blood sampling for conditions such as deep vein thrombosis and subarachnoid hemorrhage. Ease of use A majority of participants agreed or strongly agreed that the new triage system was easy to use, with higher agreement at ED1 (88%) compared with ED2 (68%). Nevertheless, several participants perceived that effective use of WEST required substantial clinical experience. “The system is straightforward and not difficult to follow, but it requires a lot from the nurse. There are no cheat sheets provided by the system, so it is crucial to have experienced personnel in triage.” (Nurse, ED2) Participants requested more detailed guidance, an online version for training, and improvements to the printed handbook to make it easier to navigate in practice. Overall comments Across both sites, participant responses highlighted recurring themes related to training adequacy, laboratory routine compatibility, experience requirements, organizational readiness, and feedback mechanisms, all of which appeared to influence the adoption and clinical use of the new triage system. Several participants noted that the implementation coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic, which was described as contributing to limited training opportunities and increased workload during the transition period. Participants consistently described the new system as more demanding and experience-dependent than RETTS©. Compatibility issues extended to patient handover and the transitional period during which ambulance services and neighboring EDs continued using RETTS©. Trialability was limited by simultaneous transition, and observability was weak, with insufficient feedback and debriefing reported. One individual involved in the implementation was specifically mentioned as accessible and responsive to feedback throughout the process. “With the new system, the majority of patients in the teams are green, creating a calmer atmosphere. It allows us to focus more on the yellow and orange priority levels. With RETTS©, the focus was on everyone, making it difficult to identify those who stood out.” (Nurse, ED2) “Performing triage with WEST demands more from the individual due to the system’s lack of comprehensiveness. In some cases, additional explanations are necessary, requiring medical expertise to fully understand the process. Therefore, more experience is essential for effectively utilizing WEST.” (Nurse, ED2) “Triage education becomes crucial, especially during system transitions. We need an online version for accessibility. Additionally, continuous education is essential, covering topics like chest pain with vegetative symptoms, NIHSS, NEWS2, and GCS.” (Nurse, ED1) “If the new triage system had been introduced without changing the laboratory sampling routines at the same time, it would have been much easier to accept.” (Nurse, ED2) “This new system requires anticipating what will be required; you have to think creatively. It demands experience but has significant potential.” (Nurse, ED2) Overall, WEST was perceived as promising but requiring further development, particularly regarding training, procedural adjustments, and educational support. Adoption-related attitude patterns Adoption-related attitude patterns varied both within and between sites. ED1 showed a tentative tendency toward earlier adoption orientations, reflected in higher agreement across most Likert items and more frequently expressed confidence in the system. ED2 displayed a broader spread of responses, with more participants emphasizing the need for additional support and clearer guidelines before feeling fully confident. These patterns are interpretive rather than definitive, and individual variation was present at both sites. Selected quotes illustrating attitudes consistent with different adoption orientations are presented below. Innovators “I got what I needed to use the system. I was a superuser in the pilot study, which gave me practical training. Patients who are critically ill will be critically ill regardless of which triage system you use.” (Nurse, ED1) Early adopters “Now, with NEWS and clinical judgment taken more seriously, when a patient is triaged as orange it truly means something.” (Nurse, ED1) Early majority “I was hesitant at first. But we now differentiate patient priority more effectively with WEST, fewer patients are assigned to the orange level, and I experience that to be the case in practice. I can also make my own assessments and justify them in a different way.” (Nurse, ED2) Late majority “They did not give good reasons. It was not implemented in consultation with those who work most in the emergency department.” (Nurse, ED2) Laggard “I cannot see the advantages. The risks of missing patients due to insufficient experienced staff are real. Everything in healthcare should be clear and straightforward, WEST is not foolproof. Also, the reduction in laboratory sampling is negative. It causes delays in patient management in many cases, particularly for frail elderly patients with diffuse symptoms. I want to go back to RETTS©.” (Nurse, ED2) Discussion This study examined the early implementation of WEST in two EDs and demonstrated how local context shaped adoption. ED1, which served as the pilot site, reported more positive responses, while ED2 expressed mixed and sometimes critical views. Despite these differences, most participants across both sites perceived WEST as more accurate than RETTS© in identifying critically ill patients, with a perceived reduction in patients assigned to the orange priority level. Diffusion of Innovations as a sensitizing framework Even though adopter categories cannot be definitively assigned, they can be interpreted tentatively based on patterns consistent with Rogers’ framework. From this perspective, there was a higher degree of attitudes resembling early adopters in ED1, while ED2 responses were more heterogeneous and included more cautious views resembling those associated with the early or late majority categories. Importantly, this does not imply that entire EDs can be assigned to a single category, rather, the data suggest relative tendencies within each local context. Building on Rogers’ concepts of “Diffusion of Innovations” [21], the process of change can be understood as influenced by the norms, communication patterns, and structural characteristics of each social system. These contextual features appeared to shape how quickly and widely WEST was adopted in the two EDs. Differences in organizational culture and readiness likely contributed to this variation, though implementation maturity and timing may also have played a role. Furthermore, Moore’s notion of “crossing the chasm” illustrates the gap between enthusiastic early adopters (as observed in ED1) and more cautious groups who require evidence of clear benefits before embracing a new system (as seen in ED2) [27]. Contextual explanations for site differences Differences between ED1 and ED2 may reflect several interrelated contextual factors rather than fundamental differences in adopter characteristics. First, staff composition varied between sites: nurses at ED2 had, on average, more years in the profession, which may have shaped how they evaluated WEST. More experienced staff may have been more familiar with RETTS© and therefore more inclined to compare WEST against long-standing routines, or more accustomed to repeated organizational change. In contrast, the relatively less experienced cohort at ED1 may have perceived WEST as less disruptive and been more open to adoption, potentially reflecting novelty effects or differing baseline expectations. These experience-related factors could partly explain site variation in perceived clarity, ease of use, and reliance on clinical judgment. Second, although training structure, staffing, and coverage were broadly similar across sites, differences in perceived preparedness and available support may reflect variation in local management engagement. At ED1, managers had been working actively to foster readiness for change and prepare staff for transition, which may have contributed to higher ratings of training sufficiency and perceived preparedness. At ED2, the shorter interval between implementation and data collection may have meant that managerial involvement was less visible to staff, influencing their perceptions of support. Third, ED2 implemented WEST during the COVID-19 pandemic, a period marked by unusually high workloads and concurrent organizational changes. These pressures may plausibly have reduced staff capacity to absorb new routines, so-called change fatigue, affecting how WEST was adopted during this critical period. ED1, as the pilot site, implemented WEST under comparatively stable conditions a year earlier. Fourth, the response rate of 46% and self-selected participation introduce a risk of self-selection bias, nurses with strong views toward the implementation may have been more likely to participate. However, participants represented a mix of senior and junior nurses across varying experience levels, suggesting the sample was not systematically skewed. In the absence of data on non-participants, we cannot fully exclude the possibility that the most engaged or most critical nurses were overrepresented. Nevertheless, data saturation was reached after approximately 20–25 interviews, with no major new themes emerging in the remaining interviews (n = 36), supporting the adequacy and depth of the data. Finally, site differences in the data may partly reflect interviewer positionality. The first author was a resident physician at ED2 at the time of data collection, and participants at that site may have responded differently given familiarity with the interviewer, despite the voluntary and self-selected nature of recruitment. Several measures were taken to mitigate this influence, including strict adherence to a standardized interview guide, structured field notetaking, and investigator triangulation during analysis, as described in the Methods. Nevertheless, the potential for site-differential response bias cannot be fully excluded and should be considered when interpreting differences between sites. Direct comparison of ED1 and ED2 is therefore problematic, as a ceteris paribus condition (“all else equal”) could not be assumed. The findings should be understood as descriptive, focusing on ‌‌how local contexts shaped adoption at different stages of implementation. Clinical judgment and novice usability A defining feature of WEST is its reliance on nurses’ clinical judgment alongside structured parameters. Participants generally valued this flexibility, particularly for identifying frail elderly patients, but several expressed concern that the new system may be more challenging for less experienced nurses. In contrast to RETTS©, which provided more prescriptive protocols, WEST placed greater demands on prior knowledge and contextual experience. These views should be understood primarily as perceptions reported by participants rather than conclusions directly linked to measured experience levels in the dataset. Prior literature suggests that clinical judgment can both enhance acuity discrimination and introduce variability, among novice practitioners, and that senior nurses may under-triage while junior nurses may over-triage, complicating staffing strategies [38,39]. This aligns with prior implementation research showing that innovations placing greater demands on individual judgment tend to be more challenging to adopt in settings where staff experience varies widely [17,19]. In addition, perceptions of preparedness and competence may be influenced by cognitive mechanisms such as overconfidence among less experienced staff or reduced feedback loops during early implementation. This represents a potential limitation of self‑reported data, as responses may partly reflect subjective confidence rather than objective performance. These findings therefore highlight the perceived need for structured support, mentorship and feedback opportunities to ensure that the flexibility of WEST is balanced with consistency and safety. Educational and organizational implications Although the educational interventions were designed and delivered similarly at both sites, participants’ perceptions differed markedly. Nurses at ED1 described the education as sufficient, interactive, and supported by supervision, while those at ED2 perceived it as brief, superficial, and lacking practical guidance. This discrepancy highlights how staff perceptions of preparedness may diverge even when formal training structures are equivalent. Participants consistently emphasized that WEST required more than short information sessions for safe and effective use. They called for simulation-based training, bedside supervision, structured case reviews with physicians, and explicit instruction in NIHSS and GCS. The lack of a comprehensive handbook and the absence of a digital version were identified as barriers. These findings align with prior literature recommending experiential learning, continuous feedback, and accessible educational tools for complex system changes [40]. Organizational readiness also proved critical. ED2’s experience in the present study may reflect a pattern identified in prior research, whereby subcultures within healthcare settings tend to resist change when implementation strategies do not align with existing cultural norms [18]. ED2’s experience illustrated how simultaneous reforms, such as pandemic-related adaptations, undermined implementation even when staff acknowledged WEST’s clinical advantages. Aligning the timing of major changes with organizational capacity is therefore essential to minimize disruption. Timeliness Although data for this study were collected in 2021, the implementation of the WEST triage system across the Western region occurred gradually between 2019 and 2023, and the system is currently being prepared for adoption in additional regions. While time-sensitive aspects relate primarily to the system’s clinical performance, the determinants examined here, such as organizational readiness, education and training, and staff motivation, represent fundamental components of implementation processes that remain relevant regardless of when implementation occurs. Summary of implications Taken together, these findings suggest that successful implementation of WEST was shaped less by the intrinsic qualities of the triage system than by the organizational context in which it was introduced. Adoption appears to be influenced by communication, motivation, and training strategies, as well as the ability of each ED to manage competing changes. While WEST was widely perceived as improving triage accuracy, challenges with clarity, novice usability, and contextual readiness underscore the need for carefully staged and well-supported rollouts. Viewed through Rogers’ diffusion framework, these contextual differences highlight how social system characteristics shape diffusion, while Moore’s “chasm” reminds us that enthusiasm among early adopters does not automatically translate into broader uptake without demonstrable advantages for more cautious groups [27]. In this case, WEST has since expanded substantially across Swedish EDs, yet this study underscores that innovations face risks during their initial phases of dissemination. While these findings are grounded in the Swedish emergency care context, several implementation determinants, including organizational readiness, management engagement, and training quality are likely transferable to other settings. However, Sweden’s tax-funded healthcare system, in which EDs receive both referred and self-presenting patients, alongside the specific transition from RETTS© and pandemic timing, may limit direct comparability with healthcare systems operating under different funding models or referral structures. Limitations This two-site design, with ED1 as the pilot and asynchronous implementation at ED2 during COVID-19 limited comparability and precluded causal inference. The interval between implementation and data collection differed substantially across sites, interviews were conducted 17 months after implementation of WEST at ED1 and 6 months after implementation at ED2. This discrepancy reflects real-world conditions rather than a planned design choice, as these were the only EDs in the region using WEST at the time, and the region chose to review early outcomes before wider rollout. While this temporal difference may have influenced recall, it also provided complementary insight by capturing both early and more established implementation phases. Baseline performance differences between sites may further have influenced staff perceptions, and external validity was constrained by the regional, two-site design. A key methodological limitation concerns data collection. The interviews were documented through detailed real‑time notes rather than audio recordings, which may have limited the capture of nuance, potentially introduced selective recording, and increased the risk that reconstructed quotes do not fully reflect participants’ exact phrasing. Without audio recordings, subtle features such as hesitation, uncertainty, contradiction, emotional tone, and self-correction were not available for analysis. These qualities may be particularly relevant in a study where attitudes toward implementation are central, as responses that were uncertain or conflicted may carry different meaning than their written form suggests. Given that the present study primarily aimed to explore attitudes shaping the adoption and diffusion of the implementation, structured field notes were considered appropriate for capturing the relevant content. To mitigate potential limitations associated with this approach, data collection involved detailed systematic note-taking procedures and participant verification through member checking, but the absence of verbatim transcripts may still affect analytic depth and qualitative rigor. Finally, assessments of triage outcomes, including reductions in over-triage, were based on participants’ perceptions rather than objective measurements. Future studies should incorporate quantitative outcome data to validate these findings. Interviewer positionality and reflexivity All interviews were conducted by the first author, a resident physician in emergency medicine at ED2 at the time of data collection, with clinical experience but no formal leadership responsibilities at either site. This dual position as both clinician and researcher may have influenced how openly some participants responded, particularly at ED2, where an established working context existed. Participants at ED1 did not share this relationship with the interviewer, though awareness of the interviewer’s role within the regional emergency care system may still have shaped interactions to some extent. Several measures were taken to minimize potential bias. Recruitment was entirely self-selected, with nurses initiating contact voluntarily, reducing the likelihood of perceived hierarchical pressure. A standardized interview guide was followed strictly across both sites, and a structured note-taking approach ensured consistency. During analysis, rigor was strengthened through investigator triangulation, collaborative coding, member checking, and the use of an explicit codebook, with within-site analyses conducted prior to cross-case comparison. Nevertheless, some degree of positionality-related influence on data generation and interpretation cannot be fully excluded. Conclusions Most nurses perceived WEST as more accurate than RETTS© for identifying critically ill patients and reducing over-triage. The implementation process, however, highlighted how adoption was shaped by local context, particularly communication, motivation, education, and organizational readiness. Treating each ED as a distinct social system and applying “Diffusion of Innovations” as a conceptual lens helped explain variation in adoption patterns. These findings suggest that future implementations of new triage systems may benefit from being carefully staged, adequately resourced, and aligned with other organizational changes to minimize disruption. Supporting information Interview guide. Questions as they were asked by the questioner. (PDF) Informed consent. English translation of the informed consent. (DOCX) COREQ Checklist. COnsolidated criteria for REporting Qualitative research (COREQ) completed checklist. (PDF) 4 Mar 2026 -->PONE-D-26-01867-->-->Evaluation of the implementation process of a new emergency triage system: WEst coast System for Triage (WEST)-->-->PLOS One Dear Dr. Habbouche, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Apr 18 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:--> A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. -->If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Suzanne Rose, MS, PhD Academic Editor PLOS One Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. The ethical approval number(s) listed in the manuscript and/or submission metadata does not match the approval number on the ethical approval document you provided. Please ensure that all approval numbers are correct. 3. Thank you for stating the following financial disclosure: “Sahlgrenska University Hospital funded the study through the Emergency Development Center and the Gothenburg Emergency Medicine Research Group.” Please state what role the funders took in the study. If the funders had no role, please state: "The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript." If this statement is not correct you must amend it as needed. Please include this amended Role of Funder statement in your cover letter; we will change the online submission form on your behalf. 4. Please note that funding information should not appear in the Acknowledgments section or other areas of your manuscript. We will only publish funding information present in the Funding Statement section of the online submission form. Please remove any funding-related text from the manuscript. 5. For studies involving third-party data, we encourage authors to share any data specific to their analyses that they can legally distribute. PLOS recognizes, however, that authors may be using third-party data they do not have the rights to share. When third-party data cannot be publicly shared, authors must provide all information necessary for interested researchers to apply to gain access to the data. (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/data-availability#loc-acceptable-data-access-restrictions) For any third-party data that the authors cannot legally distribute, they should include the following information in their Data Availability Statement upon submission: 1) A description of the data set and the third-party source 2) If applicable, verification of permission to use the data set 3) Confirmation of whether the authors received any special privileges in accessing the data that other researchers would not have 4) All necessary contact information others would need to apply to gain access to the data 6. Your ethics statement should only appear in the Methods section of your manuscript. If your ethics statement is written in any section besides the Methods, please delete it from any other section. 7. We note you have included a table to which you do not refer in the text of your manuscript. Please ensure that you refer to Table 1 in your text; if accepted, production will need this reference to link the reader to the Table. 8. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. 9. Please review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the rebuttal letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. If you need to cite a retracted article, indicate the article’s retracted status in the References list and also include a citation and full reference for the retraction notice. Additional Editor Comments: Thank you for submitting the manuscript to PLOS ONE for review. The article is well written and several excellent comments are available from the reviewers to help guide the revision and resubmission. I had an astoundingly robust response for reviews of this manuscript and therefore, you will see eight different reviewer comments, some of which overlap and can be addressed jointly. I greatly look forward to receiving the revised manuscript. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions -->Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. --> Reviewer #1: Partly Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #6: Partly Reviewer #7: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? --> Reviewer #1: N/A Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: N/A Reviewer #4: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #6: Yes Reviewer #7: Yes Reviewer #8: No ********** -->3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified.--> Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #6: Yes Reviewer #7: No Reviewer #8: No ********** -->4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes Reviewer #5: No Reviewer #6: Yes Reviewer #7: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->5. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters)--> Reviewer #1: Thank you for the opportunity to review this manuscript. The topic—staff experiences and contextual factors during implementation of a new triage system—has practical relevance for emergency care operations and implementation science. The cross-site design is a strength in principle; however, the manuscript currently overreaches in several interpretations and requires substantially improved methodological transparency to support the conclusions. Below I outline major and minor issues that should be addressed to improve credibility, clarity, and alignment between data and claims. Major comments 1) Timeliness / novelty given the age of the dataset The interviews were conducted April 16–30, 2021, which is now nearly five years ago. Please justify why these findings remain novel and relevant to current practice (e.g., ongoing implementation of WEST, stable implementation barriers), or present the work more explicitly as an implementation case study with enduring lessons rather than contemporary evidence. Suggested action: Add a short paragraph in the Discussion on the continued relevance of the findings despite the time gap, and clearly delimit which claims are intended to be timeless (e.g., training, leadership engagement, readiness) versus time-sensitive. 2) No audio recordings: major threat to credibility and quotation integrity A central methodological limitation is the decision not to audio-record interviews. The manuscript indicates that responses were written down “in detail,” later “cleaned” (e.g., removing pauses/fillers), and returned to participants. This approach introduces substantial risk of: selective capture during note-taking, reconstruction bias during “cleaning,” and overconfidence in quotations that may appear verbatim but are reconstructed. Suggested action (required): Use precise terminology (e.g., “detailed interview notes” rather than “transcripts” if not verbatim). Describe how notes were taken (real-time vs post hoc expansion; whether near-verbatim phrasing was captured; who took notes). Clarify what “cleaning” entailed and how it could have affected meaning. Temper the evidentiary weight of quotations accordingly and add a stronger limitations paragraph. 3) Interviewer positionality: risk of social desirability bias and analytic bias The interviewer was employed as a resident physician at one of the participating EDs. Even without formal managerial authority, this positionality can affect participant openness and the content/tone of responses. It also raises the possibility of differential rapport across sites and potential bias in interpretation. Required action: Add a dedicated reflexivity subsection: relationship to participants, potential power dynamics, and mitigation steps (e.g., standardized interview conduct; independent coding/analysis; negative case analysis; external reviewer involvement). Explicitly acknowledge that differences between ED1 and ED2 may partially reflect interviewer-site effects. 4) Cross-site comparison is heavily confounded (implementation timing, maturity, COVID, concurrent reforms) ED1 and ED2 differ substantially in timing of implementation, time-since-implementation at the time of interviews, and pandemic context. This makes site comparisons vulnerable to confounding and undermines interpretations framed as differences in “adopter” characteristics. Required action: Reframe ED1 vs ED2 differences as context-dependent and exploratory, not as strong evidence of adopter-category differences. Strengthen the Discussion by explicitly treating “implementation maturity” (time since go-live) and COVID-related instability as plausible primary drivers. 5) Table 1: professional experience differences are plausible explanatory variables but are not integrated Table 1 suggests differences in years in profession across sites. This could plausibly explain perceptions of preparedness, ease-of-use, clarity, and reliance on clinical judgment—yet the manuscript does not use this information in interpretation. Required action: Incorporate staff experience into the analytic narrative as a candidate explanation for site differences. At minimum, add a sensitivity-style interpretation: “differences may reflect experience mix rather than adopter orientation.” 6) “Accuracy” claims are not supported by objective evidence (e.g., Lines ~190 and ~300) You report that most participants rated WEST as more accurate than RETTS© in identifying severely ill patients. However, “accuracy” is an outcome term that typically implies comparison against a reference standard (clinical outcomes, deterioration, ICU admission, etc.). In this manuscript, the evidence appears to be perception-based. Suggested action: Reword throughout to “perceived accuracy” unless objective performance measures are presented. Clarify how participants operationalized “accuracy” (e.g., subjective clinical fit, workflow effects, fewer orange categorizations). Ensure the Discussion does not imply validated superiority without outcomes data. 7) ED1 higher Likert ratings than ED2: consider staff mix and novice/seniority as alternative explanations (Line ~195) You note that ED1 respondents tended to report higher Likert ratings than ED2 respondents. Please consider that site differences might reflect differences in staff composition (age/experience), novelty effects, or local implementation maturity rather than adopter category per se. Suggested action: Explicitly discuss whether ED1 respondents represented a younger/more novice cohort and how this might influence perceptions (including possible optimism bias or different expectations). 8) Training, feedback opportunities, and preparedness: large site differences need deeper explanation (Lines ~232 and ~252) You report substantial differences between sites regarding time for training, feedback opportunities, and preparedness (e.g., 76% vs 32%; 82% vs 32%). The manuscript currently reports these differences but does not adequately investigate why they exist. Required action: Provide contextual detail: Were training modalities genuinely different? Was staffing/coverage different? Was management engagement different? Avoid interpreting this primarily as “late adopters” vs “early adopters” unless you have direct evidence. 9) Management involvement and organizational readiness: consider more suitable theory or stronger justification (Lines ~228, ~398, ~432) Several quotations and themes appear to align more strongly with organizational readiness, leadership engagement, implementation climate, and change management rather than diffusion attributes alone. Additionally, at least one section juxtaposes manager reports (“training was organized similarly”) with nurse perceptions (“superficial”), without clear triangulation. Required action: Explain how discrepancies between manager and staff accounts were handled analytically. Either strengthen your mapping to Rogers (with clear logic and evidence) or justify/augment with a complementary implementation framework (e.g., CFIR, NPT, or organizational readiness theory). If you retain Rogers, explicitly show how your themes align with its constructs and what your data suggests about sequencing (i.e., how X precedes Y), rather than asserting adopter categories. 10) Clinical judgment demands, experience, and possible cognitive bias (Lines 281, 347, 357) You report that WEST places higher demands on nurses with less clinical experience. Please clarify whether experience level was linked to respondents in a way that supports this conclusion analytically, or whether it is a perception expressed by participants. In addition, perceived preparedness or competence can be affected by cognitive bias (e.g., overconfidence among novices, limited feedback loops). Suggested action: Present this primarily as a perceived risk unless you have analytic linkage to experience. Consider acknowledging cognitive bias as a limitation affecting self-reported preparedness. 11) Incomplete Likert reporting (Line 287 and similar instances) Some results report only a subset of response categories (e.g., “clearer” and “equally clear”) without stating what the remaining respondents selected. Suggested action (required): Report complete distributions for each Likert item (either in text, a table, or supplementary material). If you collapse categories, justify the approach and provide the full distribution elsewhere. 12) “Over-triage” language is potentially misleading (Line ~325) The manuscript implies reduced “over-triage” based on fewer orange categorizations. Without objective outcomes or a reference standard, a reduction in orange assignments is not necessarily true “over-triage reduction”; it may reflect different calibration/thresholds between systems. Suggested action (required): Replace “over-triage” with more precise process language (e.g., “reduced assignment to orange” or “shift in triage category distribution”), unless validated outcomes are presented. If you have prior pilot data, ensure you clearly distinguish what is measured externally versus perceived here. 13) Practical implication: experience-dependent triage may be a real operational risk (Lines 347 and 357) If effective use of WEST requires substantial clinical experience, this may be a significant operational issue in EDs with high turnover or less experienced staff. The Discussion should address whether the system is appropriate across staffing contexts and what safeguards (training, supervision, decision support) are needed. Minor comments Ethics identifiers: Please ensure ethical approval identifiers are consistent throughout the manuscript. Data availability statement: For qualitative interview notes, clarify restrictions in terms of confidentiality/re-identification risk and provide a clear access pathway (e.g., data access committee), rather than broad “licensing” phrasing unless applicable. Mixed-methods clarity: The Likert component reads as add-on/descriptive. Either integrate it more formally (e.g., joint displays, explicit mixing rationale) or clearly position it as supportive descriptive context. Coding transparency: Provide clearer detail on coding procedures (portion double-coded, codebook development, handling disagreements, negative cases). Concluding recommendation to the authors I understand that reading this review and seeing the number of suggested changes might feel discouraging. Please know that I took the time to read your work carefully, and my feedback is intended to support you and help strengthen the study. However, the manuscript will require substantial revision. In particular, greater methodological transparency is needed given the absence of recordings; the suitability of the chosen theoretical framework should be reconsidered or supplemented with additional theories to strengthen the analysis and conclusions; and the sections on reflexivity/positionality, potential confounding in cross-site comparisons, and the framing of “accuracy” and “over-triage” as perceptions all need further development. With these revisions, the manuscript has the potential to offer valuable implementation insights. As it stands, however, the strength of the conclusions exceeds what the data can support from my perspective. I wish you the best with your revisions and hope you find this feedback helpful. Reviewer #2: I would like to congratulate the authors for the study performed and also for the clarity and comprehensiveness of the presentation of the results, analyses, limitations and conclusions. Would be beneficial to broaden the study among greater audience. Reviewer #3: Overall The manuscript presents a clear rationale for revising triage practices in light of ED crowding, a well-described two-site implementation context with transparent qualitative methods, and coherent results that link cross-site differences to concrete implementation domains. These findings are brought together in a discussion that draws effectively on foundational theory to interpret heterogeneous uptake and generate practical recommendations. Success of clinical decision support tools such as triage systems relies on moving from abstract theory to routine clinical practice. Successful implementation and sustained adoption are shaped by staff perceptions of value, trust in the tool’s reliability, and usability within real-world workflows. A particular strength of this study is its focus on frontline staff perspectives, which provides actionable insights to strengthen future implementations. The feedback below is offered to further strengthen this important work by clarifying key claims, reinforcing the links between theory and findings, and sharpening the implementation lessons to be as clear and actionable as possible. Background 1. Overall, you do a nice job of outlining the problem statement and relevance and tying that to your aims 2. You move from concerns about RETTS assignment of acuity to over-triage in the next sentence. It would help to add a linkage between these two concepts – how does the acuity relate to the over-triage? 3. Also there is an abrupt change between RETTS/WEST and organizational culture. Would recommend adding a transitional sentence or two – something like “While the rationale for developing WEST was grounded in concerns about over-triage and consistency in RETTS, introducing a new triage system requires substantial changes to workflows, roles, and shared clinical judgment. Accordingly, the success of WEST depends not only on its design but also on how it is implemented and adopted in everyday ED practice.” 4. Line 88 and 89 the wording is a little confusing – would revise to something like “Rogers’ concepts are particularly useful in EDs because EDs function as unique social….” 5. At lines 96/97 you transition from Rogers to Moore, however this is not clear in the text if you are not familiar with these works. Would recommend: a. End this sentence after the references. Furthermore, Rogers’ “Diffusion of Innovations” offer concepts for understanding adoption within a social system (28, 33, 34). b. Add a sentence that discusses how moving from initial uptake into broad routine use is often difficult, particularly at the transition from early adopters to the early majority and note that Moore terms this challenge “Crossing the Chasm” c. Here is an example – “A recurring implementation challenge is the shift from early adopters to the early majority, which Moore describes as “Crossing the Chasm”. 6. It would be nice to conclude the framework section by tying it back to your study. You start by Saying that “Diffusion of Innovations” was a framework. How was the “Crossing the Chasm” incorporated into your design? Did you evaluate perceptions from early adopters separately? If it wasn’t used in your design then I would recommend moving this to the discussion. 7. Your aims are good, but consider whether you’ll truly be able to speak to “accuracy” from nurse perceptions alone. Would recommend saying “perceived accuracy” or speak to “clinical appropriateness” or “nurse confidence” instead. 8. A few minor grammatical recommendations: • “demand often exceeded capacity” change to “demand often exceeds capacity” • “Improvement efforts therefore targeted ED flow” change to “Improvement efforts have therefore targeted ED flow” • “reduction on over-triage” change to “reduction in over-triage” • Remove the extra comma between “ED context” and references (17, 26) • “introducing new triage system” change to “introducing a new triage system” • “In a literature review of process improvements approaches…” change to “process improvement approaches” • “offer concepts” change to “offers concepts” Methods 1. You do a nice job describing the setting and eligibility criteria. Dual coding strengthens credibility of the study and your cross-case logic is well explained. 2. You write the HTA “aimed to identify triage systems effective in preventing ED crowding.” That’s a strong causal claim for triage alone. Consider softening to something like “effective in supporting patient prioritization and ED flow under crowded conditions” 3. You state “ED2 had longer length-of-stay and time-to-physician”, however provide no source for where this was established. Was this observed in the HTA? If so, make this clear and move it to the paragraph discussing the HTA. If not, provide source and context. 4. On line 123 when you state “in this study” are you referring to the HTA study or the present study? 5. Would recommend reframing the paragraph starting at line 125. a. Something like “Based on the HTA findings, WEST was selected as a promising approach to support patient flow at ED1 and ED2 under crowded conditions by combining a broader assessment framework with explicit room for clinical judgment. WEST was implemented….” b. I would remove the stroke scale and coma scale as it doesn’t seem to be relevant. 6. This verbiage is also a little unclear “At the time of the study, WEST was available in a pocket-sized version” – would recommend something like “pocket-sized WEST reference card” that makes it clear what is available. 7. Provide more detail for the transcription – who transcribed, how was it transcribed –typed into a form, handwritten, how were quotes handled? 8. Were there any missing responses? If so, how were they handled? 9. At line 158 you mention unexpected themes emerging from the last question – expand on how you identified and grouped these themes 10. A few minor grammatical recommendations: • “one of Europe’s largest and Sweden’s largest hospital” consider changing to “one of Europe’s largest hospitals and the largest in Sweden” • “cleaned of pauses, overlaps, and fillers” mainly apply to audio transcripts; with notes, it sounds odd. Consider something like “edited for readability while preserving wording.” Results 1. Incorporating direct quotes/perceptions in addition to the Likert scale results is powerful and provides great insight for others who may be interested in rolling out a new triage system. 2. Add a response rate. It appears to be 36 of 72 eligible triage nurses participated (50%). 3. Line 190 refers to Question 7, which does not provide a lot of information to a reader who doesn’t have the questionnaire in front of them. Perhaps reword as “Responses from ED2 tended to be more variable across participants, however, when evaluating perceived accuracy most participants across both sites rated WEST as more accurate than RETTS© in identifying severely ill patients.” 4. Likert results should be more consistent in wording and in alignment with the likert scale. Either label as levels 4 or 5 or agree/strongly agree. Examples include: • “Most participants… considered information sufficient (76%)” – is sufficient a 4 or 5? If so, change to something like “Most participants (76%) agreed or strongly agreed that the education provided on the new triage system was sufficient.” • “30 considered WEST more accurate” change to something like “Of the 36 participants, 30 agreed or strongly agreed that WEST was more accurate than RETTS in identifying severely ill patients…..” 5. Adoption patterns section feels thin given the emphasis in the background. Recommend adding a dedicated Adoption Patterns section. a. who sounded like early adopters/what did early adopter sound like (e.g., expressed enthusiasm, experimentation, advocacy)? b. who sounded like early majority/what did early majority sound like (wanted evidence, clearer guidelines) c. How specifically did these vary by site? 6. Minor grammatical recommendations • “Participants from ED2 were of higher age” use “were older” instead • “reported a longer period of employment” use “reported longer tenure” instead • “Gender distribution was similar (ED1 12/5; ED2 14/5 female/male).” Perhaps replace with “Gender distribution (female/male) was similar between ED1 (12/5) and ED2 (14/5).” for clarity. • “Participants’ perceptions of that education” change to “of the education” • “Most participants perceived WEST as both more flexible and more accurate” replace with “perceived WEST to be…” 7. It would be helpful to add a summary of cross-site differences at the end of each section. For example, after Implementation something like “Across domains, ED1 reported more structured communication, interactive training, and preparedness.” Discussion 1. Overall, well done. Content is appropriate and includes clear summary of results, interpretation of adoption in the context of Rogers/Moore frameworks, and actionable implications. 2. Consider if there is an opportunity to further link your findings to the specific attributes from the Rogers work that you measured: a. Relative advantage: reduced orange over-prioritization / fewer labs (perceived) b. Complexity: harder for novices; lack of comprehensive handbook; no digital tool c. Compatibility: blood sampling routines; integration with other units/physicians d. Communication channels: rumors vs structured briefings 3. Add reference for expansion of WEST at line 446 “In the case of WEST, the innovation not only overcame an early setback but has since expanded across multiple healthcare regions.” Also, what is the early setback that is being referred to? 4. Line 449 make it clear that this study underscores the risks new innovations face during the initial phases of dissemination 5. You say essentially the same “training designed similarly but perceived differently” point twice (lines ~399–403 and ~421–425). Keep it once, and use the other spot to add something new (e.g., presence of champions). 6. In the Limitations be more explicit on the limitations of using written notes rather than audio recordings (e.g., exactness of quotations, ability to capture tone and emphasis) 7. At line 392 “demonstrated faster and more positive adoption” implies you measured adoption speed, recommend changing to “showing more rapid and positive adoption” to soften the language 8. You mentioned the interviewer in ED2 was a resident. Did the participants in ED1 know the interviewer? Is this a potential source of bias in responses (e.g., did ED2 participants share more freely)? Reviewer #4: The manuscript is well prepared, has followed all required research processes and obtained ethical approval, and is acceptable for publication. However, there are minor corrections that need to be addressed by the researchers as outlined in the attached file. Reviewer #5: Thank you for the opportunity to review this important paper. The issues facing the implementation of new triage systems, especially in the dynamic environment of an ED, are complex and multifactorial. This paper has the potential of offering important insights into concrete staff experiences. Further, the qualitative methodology is a useful but under-utilized tool in Emergency Medicine. Overall, the methodology, results and conclusions of the paper are sound. However, there are a number of issues, principally relating to the language and layout of the paper, that need to be worked on before it can be considered ready for publication. The text is at times unnecessarily convoluted and cumbersome to read. This distracts from the content and makes the manuscript less accessible. Examples include the following sentence “Rogers' concepts of early and late adopters in healthcare change have been applied in studies on social system levels on a large scale (29), in selected diagnosis groups (30), as well as in smaller units and populations within healthcare (31). Some reasons to use Rogers' concepts on EDs exclusive include the fact that EDs are unique social systems and operates within its own specific contextual factors, including staff dynamics, leadership styles, patient demographics, and resource availability. Further, the sentence “Participants’ perceptions of that education differed substantially between sites.” Is unintelligible. It is essential that a native English speaker reviews the manuscript for readability and grammar so that the important messages of this study are presented in correct academic English. Further, I would question the utility of Roger’s Diffusion of Innovations (DoI) in this case. The stated aims of the study are “(i) to explore how triage nurses experienced the transition from RETTS© to WEST, and (ii) to describe perceived benefits and drawbacks of WEST relative to RETTS© regarding flexibility, clarity, and accuracy. We also compared implementation processes between ED1 and ED2.” No mention is made of identifying late adopters etc, which is then mentioned in the Discussion (but not results). While this is not make-or-break for acceptance, I think removing the parts about DoI makes for a leaner and more succinct paper. A few additional points below: Line 49: What is a “frontline nurse”? Line 61: Spell out NEWS2 Lines 67-70 (and rest of manuscript): Put references at end of sentence throughout. Please state study design and type of study as a first sentence in the methods. Line 149: avoid personal pronouns Consider filling out the COREQ guidelines for qualitative studies and include as an appendix. Table 1: Interquartile range, not “range”. 162-163: Likert-scale responses were summarized using proportions of high ratings, defined as scores of 4-5 on a five-point scale: please put the %s in the figure in addition to mentioning them in the text. Again, a very good paper, appropriate for publication pending the above revisions. Looking forward to reading a new draft. Reviewer #6: DearAuthor This manuscript evaluates the implementation of a new emergency triage system (WEST) in two Swedish emergency departments using Rogers' "Diffusion of Innovations" as a theoretical framework. The study is methodologically strong with a clear comparative design, appropriate mixed-methods approach, and rich qualitative data from 36 nurses. The findings that implementation success depends on context, communication, education, and organizational readiness are well-supported and practically valuable. The methodological limitations require more prominent discussion, including the absence of audio recording during interviews, the interviewer's dual role as a clinician at one study site, and the substantial difference in implementation-to-interview timing between sites. According to the manuscript , ED1 was interviewed 17 months post-implementation while ED2 was interviewed only 6 months post-implementation, which may have influenced responses and limits direct comparability. Additionally, the quality of figures included at the end of the manuscript is very poor and must be re-uploaded with higher resolution. Despite these concerns, the theoretical framework is well-applied, the qualitative analysis is rigorous, and the practical implications are significant. Reviewer #7: Dear Authors, This manuscript presents a well-conducted qualitative study exploring the implementation of the WEST triage system in two emergency departments. The topic is relevant to emergency medicine and implementation science, and the use of a theoretical framework (Diffusion of Innovations) provides a structured lens for interpretation. The study design aligns with the stated aims, and the conclusions are cautious and generally supported by the data presented. The qualitative methodology is appropriate for examining implementation processes. The sample size (n=36) is reasonable for this type of inquiry, and the use of independent coding and member checking strengthens analytic credibility. The integration of descriptive Likert-scale data with qualitative findings is consistent with the exploratory design. However, several issues should be addressed to strengthen methodological transparency and compliance with journal policy: 1. Qualitative Data Collection and Rigor Interviews were not audio-recorded; instead, detailed written notes were taken and returned to participants for confirmation. While member checking is a strength, the absence of verbatim transcription may limit analytic depth and transparency. Please clarify: • How completeness and accuracy of note-taking were ensured; • How potential loss of nuance was mitigated; • Whether any structured approach was used to standardize documentation. This limitation should also be discussed explicitly in relation to qualitative rigor. In addition, the manuscript would benefit from explicit reference to established qualitative reporting standards (e.g., COREQ), including a clearer discussion of reflexivity and the interviewer’s positionality. 2. Statistical Component The quantitative component consists of descriptive summaries of Likert-scale responses. This approach is appropriate given the exploratory and primarily qualitative design. However, the Methods section should explicitly state that no inferential statistical testing was planned or performed due to the study design and sample size, in order to avoid potential misinterpretation. 3. Data Availability The current Data Availability Statement indicates that supporting data are not publicly available due to licensing restrictions and may be shared upon reasonable request and additional ethics approval. Under the PLOS Data Policy, “available upon request” is generally insufficient unless a formal and transparent access mechanism is clearly specified. The manuscript should clarify: • The legal or ethical basis for restricting public access; • The identity of the data controller; • The formal process through which qualified researchers may request access; • Whether de-identified qualitative data could be shared in a repository. Revision of the Data Availability Statement will be necessary to ensure compliance with journal requirements. 4. Transferability and Context The discussion appropriately emphasizes contextual differences between ED1 and ED2. It would further strengthen the manuscript to briefly elaborate on which contextual features are likely specific to the Swedish healthcare system and which may be transferable to other emergency care settings internationally. Overall, this is a thoughtful and methodologically appropriate study addressing an important operational issue in emergency care. With clarification of qualitative rigor and data availability procedures, the manuscript would meet the publication criteria of PLOS ONE. Reviewer #8: The current manuscript addresses a very important and relevant study addressing implementation of triage innovation in the context of emergency department. The research question is clinically relevant, the two-site comparison is a strength mixed approach is appropriate. Minor revisions and clarifications have to be justifies and is been uploaded ********** -->6. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy.--> Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: Yes: Professor Rostislav Kostadinov MD, PhD, DSc Reviewer #3: No Reviewer #4: Yes: Dr. Fatuma Aden Affey Reviewer #5: No Reviewer #6: Yes: Hamidreza Aghababaeian Reviewer #7: Yes: NINELL KADYROVA Reviewer #8: Yes: Dr.Manju Avinash Nair ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. --> Submitted filename: Evaluation of of WEEST coast System.docx Submitted filename: Reviewer suggestions.docx 17 Apr 2026 Response to reviewers Dear Editor, We would like to express our sincere gratitude to the Academic Editor and the eight reviewers for the opportunity to revise our manuscript. Your comments were thoughtful and constructive and have meaningfully strengthened the work. Although we have not repeated our appreciation in each individual response, we are grateful for every comment received. Also, we have organized our responses thematically rather than addressing each comment individually. We hope this approach is acceptable and remain happy to address any further questions or comments. Sincerely, The Authors Please see attached file "Response to reviewers" for details Submitted filename: Response_to_reviewers.docx 13 May 2026 Evaluation of the implementation process of a new emergency triage system: West coast system for triage (WEST) PONE-D-26-01867R1 Dear Dr. Habboush, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Suzanne Rose, MS, PhD Academic Editor PLOS One Additional Editor Comments (optional): Thank you for your thoughtful revisions - when submitting the final document, please see a few additional modifications requested from the reviewers below. Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions -->Comments to the Author 1. If the authors have adequately addressed your comments raised in a previous round of review and you feel that this manuscript is now acceptable for publication, you may indicate that here to bypass the “Comments to the Author” section, enter your conflict of interest statement in the “Confidential to Editor” section, and submit your "Accept" recommendation.--> Reviewer #1: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #2: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #3: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #5: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #8: All comments have been addressed ********** -->2. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. --> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? --> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes Reviewer #8: Yes ********** -->6. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters)--> Reviewer #1: (No Response) Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #3: I appreciate the authors’ careful attention to the reviewers’ feedback. This is a technically sound descriptive study that focuses on capturing insights from frontline staff for operationalizing the WEST clinical decision-support tool for ED triage. My previous concerns have been addressed in the latest draft. I have outlined a few minor suggestions and grammar edits to further polish the manuscript for publication. Line 333-334 “Information was also lacking for physicians” sounds like a claim from your results. Would suggest modifying to something like “Participants also reported that information…” Line 545: Would recommend saying “while ED2 responses were more heterogeneous and included more cautious views resembling those associated with the early or late majority categories.” Would recommend adding to the “Contextual explanations for site differences” section a statement on potential self-selection bias. The response rate was 46%, with self-selected participation. This introduces a plausible risk that respondents were more engaged, more critical, or more motivated than non-respondents. Since attitudes toward implementation are central to the paper, the manuscript could benefit from a short discussion of how self-selection may have influenced findings. For example, nurses with strong positive or negative views may have been more likely to participate. The authors should also clarify whether participants differed from nonparticipants in seniority if that information is known. If there is any further information on the education component as a Supplemental document as that information may be helpful to others deploying WEST. A few nitpicky edits for spelling/grammar as well as suggestions to improve clarity and flow. Line 52/53: "Rising attendances and suboptimal use of hospital resources means" should be "Rising attendances and suboptimal use of hospital resources mean" Line 55: "data was collected" should be "data were collected" Line 76: Would suggest modifying to be "where a single abnormal parameter could escalate the acuity level" to be more precise. Line 83: "Organizational changes in healthcare often fails" should be "Organizational changes in healthcare often fail." Line 84: "Subcultures could resist new systems" should be "Subcultures can resist new systems" Line 97: would recommend rephrasing as "difficulty generalizing results from other areas" Line 109: "how financial rewards influences" should be "how financial rewards influence" Line 187: would recommend clarifying as "The educational intervention was designed to be identical at both sites" Line 306: “On Likert-scale summaries” would recommend to rephrase as “Descriptive summaries of Likert-scale responses showed ED….” Line 471: “At ED1 71%” should be “At ED1, 71%” Line 565: would suggest changing “more years in the profession” to “more years of professional experience” Line 675: “Sweden's tax-funded system” would be more clear to say “Sweden's tax-funded healthcare system” although it is implied. Reviewer #5: Well done addressing comments from a large amount of reviewers. The manuscript is much clearer. Happy to accept for publication. Reviewer #8: Minor modifications as per the attachment to be caried out to further strengthen what is already a useful and timely study. ********** -->7. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy.--> Reviewer #1: Yes: Daniel Wittrock Reviewer #2: Yes: Rostislav Kostadinov, MD, PhD, DMS Reviewer #3: No Reviewer #5: Yes: Maximilian P. Nerlander Reviewer #8: Yes: Dr.Manju Avinash Nair ********** Submitted filename: Peer Review Report -PLOS.docx PONE-D-26-01867R1 PLOS One Dear Dr. Habbouche, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS One. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset You will receive further instructions from the production team, including instructions on how to review your proof when it is ready. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few days to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. You will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Suzanne Rose Academic Editor PLOS One